impact of fuel cell technology

11
IMPACT OF FUEL CELL TECHNOLOGY on the automotive and supplier industry

Upload: others

Post on 14-Nov-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

IMPACT OFFUEL CELL TECHNOLOGY

on the automotive and supplier industry

3

1 Global Market DevelopmentZero Emission Vehicle Index

MARKETFORECAST

2 Value CreationManufacturing Process Analysis

BUSINESS POTENTIAL

3 Supply Chain AnalysisSupply Chain Strategies Economic Impact

IMPACT ON GER & EU

Facts & FiguresContact4FEV AT

A GLANCE

CONTENTS

The information in this study was gathered from diligent research and analysis. Nevertheless, the information is not part of giving advice to any party. The information may not be current and the authors have no obligation to provide updates or changes. Neither is there any warranty as to the ac-curacy or completeness of information in this study and any liability therefore is disclaimed. The study contains intellectual property. All scenarios of future developments are subject to their assumptions and may not be realized. Unforeseen events may occur. Developments from the past do not indi-cate future developments. Any use which a third party makes of this document, or any reliance on it, or decisions to be made based on it, are the responsibility of such third party. FEV Consulting accepts no duty of care or liability of any kind whatsoever to any such third party, and no responsibi-lity for damages, if any, suffered by any third party as a result of decisions made, or not made, or actions taken, or not taken, based on this document. ©2020 FEV Consulting GmbH. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

Dear readers,

The mobility transformation is in full swing. Along with battery electric vehicles, fuel cells will also play a key role in the mobility of the future. In order to assess the effects and potential for mechanical and plant engineering at an early stage, we have launched a second round of the „Drive Systems in Transition“ study, this time focusing on fuel cell technology.

Once again, FEV Consulting GmbH was our part-ner in this undertaking. We hope the results of this study will help the members of the VDMA to gain transparency and provide orientation in times of change. As with the previous study, we analyzed the effects on value creation - this time based on recent developments in the field of fuel cell techno-logy. We examined the development of important markets through 2040, with a focus on passenger cars, commercial vehicles, and mobile machinery.

The VDMA is heavily engaged in shaping the mo-bility of the future: from the „Fuel Cell“ and „Po-wer-to-X for Applications“ working groups, through collective industrial research in the world‘s leading Research Associations for Drive Technology (FVA) and Combustion Engines (FVV), to the „Future Business“ process. These numerous activities are coordinated in the VDMA‘s #XMOTIVE forum.

I hope you find this interesting reading and look forward to further discussions in the future. Let us continue to work together to drive the change in mobility forward, and to put the many opportuni-ties for the mechanical and plant engineering in-dustry into practice!

Hartmut RauenStellvertretender Hauptgeschäftsführer des VDMA

5FEV CONSULTING | Impact of Fuel Cell Technology

GLOBAL LIGHT-DUTY1) VEHICLES SALES FORECAST

Global passenger car markets are ex-pected to shift towards electrified po-wertrains in the next years. Starting from 2030, electrification will also be supported by the introduction of over 60 million fuel cell vehicles. Japan and South Korea are expected to be the first movers towards fuel cell vehicles sho-wing already significant market shares by 2030.

The three major passenger car market regions China, USA and Europe are ex-pected to follow the first mover markets from the late 2020s onwards. This is also indicated by our Zero Emission Ve-hicle Index for Fuel Cell Passenger Car vehicles. It reaches 100 index points, i.e. a comparable level of attractiveness to conventional powertrain, in the early

2030s.The combined market share of these five key market regions will reach 12% by 2040, however with different regional market shares:

Japan should achieve 6% fuel cell market share in 2030. Continued growth in popularity results in over 20% by 2040.A strong govern mental and societal push towards a hydrogen society is also supported by stringent well-to-wheel CO2 emission regulation South Korea is expected to have a

market share of 3% by 2030 which will rise to 14% in 2040, also mainly driven by governmental push

China is expected to show a market share below 2% in 2030 as currently especially battery electric vehicles are subsidized. However, the market share will rise to 14% until 2040 displacing plug-in hybrid vehicles and conventional powertrains

USA and Europe and will only show limited market shares of fuel cell vehicles in 2030 of below 1%, which are expected to rise to 10% until 2040 due to further tightened emission regulation also mainly displacing plug- in hybrid and conventional powertrains

GLOBAL MARKET DEVELOPMENT

2019 2025 2030 2035 20400

50

100

150

Vehicle with ICE

Battery electric vehicle

Fuel cell vehicle

86 91 88 85 81

Year

Abschnitt 1.1

7 18 26 361

5 11

8899

107117 128

1) including passenger cars and light commercial vehicles up to 3.5t gross vehicle weight

Sales in million units

Within other industries, fuel cell applications are expected to be introduced by 2030 and rolled-out towards 2040. Regarding on-road commercial vehicles, the heavy-duty vehicle segment will be a key driver, for example in Europe, due to the implemented stringent CO2 emission regulations, but also in Japan and South Korea. Due to the comparably high energy throughput by com-mercial vehicles in general and heavy-duty vehicles in particular, the build-up of hydrogen filling stations is driven by the commer-cial vehicle segments.

Amongst non-road applications especially forklifts, rail and marine applications have a high likelihood of larger fuel cell sales shares. Already today, forklifts are equipped with fuel cells to extend ope-rating time. Until 2030, we expected a further roll-out within the forklift market segments, also in higher power segments above 19 kW.

However, because of the limited total market size for these applica-tions, sales volumes of fuel cell variants are expected to be smaller than those in the passenger car market by an order of magnitude.

OTHER INDUSTRIES

#MarketForecast

Europe USA China Japan SouthKorea

Global

1.5 1.6 5.2 1.00.2

1.61.6

5.2

1.00.1

0.25.3

0.20.2

Light-duty vehicles 2)

Heavy-duty vehicles 3)

NRMM 4)

Sales in million units84 millionapplications

12%Fuel cellapplications

1) Market in scope are EU, USA, China, Japan and South Korea // 2) Passenger cars and light commercial vehicles // 3) Medium and heavy commercial vehicles & bus // 4) Agricultural tractors, excavators, forklifts, commercial vessels, pleasure crafts, locomotives and railcars within power segments in scope

GLOBAL MARKETS1) FUEL CELL SALES IN 2040

2019 2025 2030 2035 20400

50

100

150

Vehicle with ICE

Battery electric vehicle

Fuel cell vehicle

86 91 88 85 81

Year

Abschnitt 1.1

7 18 26 361

5 11

8899

107117 128

1) including passenger cars and light commercial vehicles up to 3.5t gross vehicle weight

Sales in million units

PASSENGER CAR MARKET

ZERO EMISSIONNO POLLUTANT AND CO2 EMISSIONWITHOUT RANGE ANXIETY FOR CUSTOMERS

H2O

7FEV CONSULTING | Impact of Fuel Cell Technology

ZERO EMISSION VEHICLE INDEX

The Zero Emission Vehicle (ZEV) Index is our multidi-mensional framework to determine the competitive-ness of alternative powertrains in comparison with conventional ones.

Currently, battery electric vehicles are gaining attrac-tiveness and should be very competitive in Europe and China within next two years. The market USA shows some improvement space for electric ve-hicles on a country average level. Hence, the equal competitiveness status is achieved in the late 2020s.

By the early 2030s, fuel cell electric vehicles will be a viable alternative and attractive option. Their popula-rity should increase particularly in vehicle segments where consumers require longer driving range and fast refuelling.

100 ZEV index points indicate that the market and in-dustry boundary conditions as well as the consumer attractiveness are on a similar level as for conventio-nal powertrain. The evaluation is based on over 40 key indicators covering the six dimensions: regula-tion & policies, technology, infrastructure, industry, economics and social.

PLANNED TO BE IN OPERATION IN CALIFORNIA & GERMANY IN 2030

STATIONS1.000

ANNUALLY R&D INVESTMENTS

5 billion

3-4 Minutes

GLOBALLY OVER

IN THE NEXT YEARS

3-4 Minutes A HYDROGEN FUEL CELL CAR NEEDS NEARLY THE SAME AMOUNT OF TIME AS A CONVENTIONAL CAR TO REFUEL

REFUELING TIME

11x MORE ENERGY THAN BEV

HIGHER HYDROGEN GRAVIMETRIC ENERGY DENSITY COMPARED TO BATTERY1) FITS BETTER FOR APPLICATIONS WITH HIGH ENERGY DEMAND

EU

Fuel cell push

Increasing BEV attractiveness

Balanced

Combustion engines Battery push

Increasing FCEV attractiveness

Development over time

2020

2040

ZEV INDEX DEVELOPMENT

#VehicleIndex

2020 2022 20302024 20402026 20382036203420322028

Battery electric vehicles

Fuel cell electric vehicles

COMPETITIVENESS OF ALTERNATIVE POWERTRAINS OVER TIME

9FEV CONSULTING | Impact of Fuel Cell Technology

On the one hand, fuel cell powertrains comprise sub-systems and components which are new in automotive applica-tions. On the other hand, well-known parts and components are also applied.

Especially the fuel cell stack, mainly consisting out of the bipolar plates and membrane electrode assemblies, will require new manufacturing techno-logies to be implemented. However, to operate the fuel cell stack, additio-nal components are required that are

VALUE CREATION

#ValueCreation

Fuel cell system

Hydrogenstorage

Batterystorage EDU

Abschnitt 2.1

Total business in billion Euro per year

Passenger cars

35.2

23.0

10.916.7

2030 2040

39%8

58

17%

43%

2040

28%

42%

30%

58

Balance of plant

Fuel Cell Stack

Hydrogen Storage

OH & Profit

Material

ManufacturingTotal business in billion Euro per year

41% Fuel cell system

27%

13%

19%

86 billion EUR

Hydrogen storage

Battery storage

Electric drive unit2)

2040 – Global MarketsPassenger Car Fuel Cell Vehicle Split1)

1) Markets in scope are EU, USA, China, Japan and South Korea2) LCV: Light Commercial Vehicles | Heavy Duty Vehicles: Medium &

Heavy Commercial Vehicles incl. City Busses

summarized as Balance of Plant. These components in principle show higher similarities with existing components, like turbochargers, cooling systems or pipes, fittings and valves. For the hyd-rogen storage system, high manufactu-ring capacities of carbon fiber reinforced plastic will be required. In addition, each fuel cell electric vehicle also requires a (larger) battery and an electric drive unit, similar to the ones used within hybrid and electric vehicles.

For the considered market regions, the total business potential is expected to rise to nearly 86 billion Euro per annum for passenger cars by 2040. 32% of the business potential are generated by the electric powertrain, including the battery and the electric drive unit. Further 68% of the business potential is generated by the fuel cell and hydrogen system components reaching 58 billion Euro by 2040. Thereof 28% or 16 billion Euro per year is manufacturing value creation. Major drivers for the value creation are:

BUSINESS POTENTIAL BY POWERTRAIN IN 2040

FUEL CELL POWERTRAIN SYSTEM

Processes for forming, coating and changing material properties especially to produce the fuel cell stack components, with a total of 2.6 billion Euro per year

Machining, especially for the compressor and expander modules used in the air system and the hydro- gen guiding components and valves, with a total of 5 billion Euro per year

Composite processing to produce hydrogen tank systems with a total of 1 billion Euro per year

11FEV CONSULTING | Impact of Fuel Cell Technology

Primary Shaping Coating

Forming

MACHINING

Machining processes generate over 6 billion Euro of manufacturing value crea-tion in 2040. Major contributors are the balance of plant components (e.g. com-pressor-expander-motor unit) and the hydrogen feeding parts (e.g. manifolds, valves, lines) required in the balance of plant and hydrogen tank.

PRIMARY SHAPING

Primary shaping processes generate over 2 billion Euro of manufacturing va-lue creation in 2040. Most of the value creation happens within the production of balance of plant components. Fur-ther value is created by housing com-ponents within the electric powertrain, for example the housings of the electric drive unit or the battery housing.

JOINING AND ASSEMBLY

Joining and assembly processes are pre-sent within many fuel cell vehicle com-ponents. Major contributors are the ba-lance of plant and the hydrogen system due to the number of parts that are as-sembled. Also, the fuel cell stack genera-tes nearly 1 billion Euro of value creation. The total value creation is expected to be nearly 6 billion Euro in 2040.

FORMING

Major forming processes within fuel cell powertrains are used for the bipolar plates and the hydrogen tank. Also, the air and hydrogen guiding systems wit-hin the balance of plant require forming processes. The total value created is ex-pected to reach nearly 2 billion Euro in 2040.

COATING

Coating processes are primary applied to the fuel cell stack and required for example for the bipolar plates and com-ponents of the membrane-electrode-as-sembly. The total value is expected to reach 0.9 billion Euro in 2040.

OTHER & SPECIAL PROCESSES

Other and special processes also ac-count for nearly 7 billion Euro of value creation in 2040. However, the major contribution is the production of battery cells used within the fuel cell vehicles, followed by electronic components and the composite processing for the car-bon-fiber tanks.

MANUFACTURING PROCESS ANALYSIS

+

Other & Special Processes

2030 2040 2040

12

86

28%

42%

30%

27%

9%

25%

7%

25%

3%

4%

Total business in billion Euro per year

Joining

Change material characteristics

Other & special processes

CoatingForming

Primary shaping

Machining

24

Material

Manufacturing value creation

OH & Profits

Fuel Cell Powertrain Systems

Fuel Cell System

Fuel Cell Stack 67 44 850 273 644 209 340

Balance of Plant 2,378 1,049 2,066 637 145 152 1,105

Hydrogen storage

Tank 335 21 0 0 0 246 760

Others 2,214 463 1,428 320 0 0 612

Electric Powertrain Systems

Battery storage

Battery Cells 0 0 0 0 0 0 1,920

Battery Pack 86 271 506 110 4 0 131

EDU & OtherElectronics

Electric Motor 555 139 353 0 2 233 658

Traction Inverter 204 159 342 34 5 0 243

Transmission 607 64 316 257 26 108 123

Other Electronics 83 53 93 10 1 0 68

Mac

hini

ng

Prim

ary

Sha

ping

Join

ing

&

Ass

embl

y

Form

ing

Coa

ting

Cha

ngin

g m

ater

ial

prop

ertie

s

Oth

er s

peci

al

proc

esse

s

FUELL CELL ELECTRIC VEHICLE POWERTRAIN SYSTEM

MANUFACTURING VALUE CREATION FCEV POWERTRAIN IN 2040

TOTAL BUSINESS86BILLION

EURO

VALUE CREATION24BILLION

EURO

Total business in million Euro per year

#ManufacturingProcessAnalysis

FEV CONSULTING | Impact of Fuel Cell Technology

SUPPLY CHAIN ANALYSIS

#SupplyChainAnalysis

13

The calculated manufacturing value creation is based on the vehicle’s sales destination. For Europe, the number of vehicles sold is equal to the number of vehicles produced. Thus, the vehicle sales are an appropriate proxy to determine the vehicles produced. To further account for the design of a supply chain, two scenarios have been evaluated:

Globally over

5bn EURO annual R&D investments in the next years

DEVELOPMENT

More than 60k jobs generated in the automo-tive industry, over 15k in manufacturing

FUEL CELL STACK COMPONENTS

In 2040 11bn Euro revenue globally from passen-ger car fuel cell powertrain components1)

Over 27bn Euro investments into manufactu-ring equipment required until 2040

SUBSYSTEM SUPPLIER & INTEGRATOR

OEM

BELOW 5 Euro per kilogram hydrogen fuel price from 2030 onwards

INFRASTRUCTURE

More than 95% recycling of platinum used in MEA possible

RECYCLING & AFTERSALES

OVER 8bn EURO INVESTMENTS

IN 2040EURO 11bn

MORE THAN 68k jobs

H2 O2

Globally over

5bn EURO annual R&D investments in the next years

DEVELOPMENT

More than 60k jobs generated in the automo-tive industry, over 15k in manufacturing

FUEL CELL STACK COMPONENTS

In 2040 11bn Euro revenue globally from passen-ger car fuel cell powertrain components1)

Over 27bn Euro investments into manufactu-ring equipment required until 2040

SUBSYSTEM SUPPLIER & INTEGRATOR

OEM

BELOW 5 Euro per kilogram hydrogen fuel price from 2030 onwards

INFRASTRUCTURE

More than 95% recycling of platinum used in MEA possible

RECYCLING & AFTERSALES

OVER 8bn EURO INVESTMENTS

IN 2040EURO 11bn

MORE THAN 68k jobs

H2 O2

FUELL CELL VALUE CHAIN

AUTOMOTIVETRADE FLOW

1.2 Mio

0.2 Mio

0.3 Mio0.2 Mio

0.5 Mio

0.3 Mio

0.6 Mio0.5 MioIMPORT

EXPORT

in Million Vehicles

15FEV CONSULTING | Impact of Fuel Cell Technology

Manufacturing

Material

Overhead & profit

Supplier

OEM

Supplier

OEM

Local

Global

Local

Global

MAKE STRATEGY

BUY STRATEGY

like the compressor-expander-motor unit. Furthermore, the integration and final assembly of the fuel cell system is conducted in-house. Most OEMs in-source the manufacturing of the electric drive units, besides the electric compo-nents within the traction inverter. Also, the battery cell production and the bat-tery module & pack assembly is insour-ced by approximately half of the OEMs.

OEM MAKE SCENARIO

OEM BUY SCENARIO

This scenario assumes a much lower share of in-house production by the OEMs regarding fuel cell powertrain components. OEMs concentrate on the integration of finished fuel cell system components, like the stack or Balance of Plant subsystems. The major value

creation is generated by the suppliers which offer finished system solutions to many OEMs to further leverage produc-tion volumes. The same applies to the electric drive unit and the battery, which is offered as off-the-shelf solution by larger system integrator suppliers.

This scenario is based on a higher share of components, produced by the OEMs in-house. In focus of the OEMs is the integration of the fuel cell stack com-ponents to a stack. In addition, some fuel cell stack sub-components (e.g. bi-polar plates) are manufactured by most OEMs as well as the hydrogen tanks. Partially, also key components of the balance of plant are produced in-house,

#SupplyChainStrategies

creation which also limits the global au-tomotive parts supply market, with has a negative impact on the value creation within Europe, since Europe is a net ex-port region regarding this commodity.

In total, both effects counteract each ot-her partially, such that the total impact on the value creation generated in Euro-pe is below 5%.

The total value creation in Europe dif-fers between the two scenarios of the OEM value creation share.

On the one hand, the OEM make sce-nario leads to a higher share of OEM value creation which is expected to be local value creation. More value crea-tion is being generated in Europe. On the other hand, the OEM make scena-rio reduces the share of supplier value

MAKE STRATEGY

BUY STRATEGY

Fuel cell system

Hydrogenstorage

Batterystorage EDU

1.51.2

0.7 0.8

1.61.2

0.6 0.7

Automotive OEM Exported Supply Local Supply

VALUE CREATION SHARES BY POWERTRAIN SYSTEM IN 2040

MAKE STRATEGY

BUY STRATEGY

Fuel cell system

Hydrogenstorage

Batterystorage EDU

1.51.2

0.7 0.8

1.61.2

0.6 0.7

Automotive OEM Exported Supply Local Supply

The economic impact for Europe is analyzed by evaluating two supply chain scenarios. Within the scenarios we considered a production location, i.e. produced locally in Europe or elsewhere, for each component. Further, we determined whether the component is produced by the OEM or sourced from a supplier.

SUPPLY CHAIN STRATEGIES

SUPPLY CHAIN SCENARIOS

FEV CONSULTING | Impact of Fuel Cell Technology 17

MAKE BUY

2.8 2.7

42%

7%7%

25%

5%6%7%

42%

7%7%

25%

5%6%7%Metal processing

Plastics processingElectricsElectronicsMechatronicsChemical processingComposite processingProcess automation

1% 1%

Manufacturing Value Creation in billion Euro

The manufacturing value creation of po-wertrains for fuel cell passenger cars sold in Europe by 2040 is expected to reach 4.3 billion Euro annually. In both supply chain scenarios, the related ma-nufacturing value creation that occurs in Europe is higher, and is expected to reach up to 4.8 billion Euro annually. This underlines Europe’s position as a net ex-porting region for automotive industry goods.

Although the OEM value creation is sig-nificantly lower in the “Buy” scenario, this is partially counteracted by increa-sed local supplier value creation. In ad-dition, the total exports of automotive parts are increased, resulting in a net positive effect in European value crea-tion of roughly 50 million Euros annual-ly. The share of exported supply varies between 21% and 24% of the total supplier value creation in the two sce-narios. Major target export regions are China and the USA. In both scenarios, the fuel cell specific powertrain compo-nents (fuel cell stack, balance of plant and the hydrogen storage) account for over 50% of the value creation or over 2.6 billion Euro respectively.

The related business potential (i.e. re-venue) of fuel cell powertrain system components is expected at over 11 billi-on Euros annually in both scenarios. Be-side the manufacturing value creation, this includes material and basic compo-nents costs as well as overheads and profits of the entire supply chain. Based on the analysis of the industry sectors affected, the manufacturing value crea-tion will generate over 60,000 jobs until 2040, of which over 15,000 will be ma-nufacturing jobs. Further, nearly 8 billion Euro of net invested capital into ma-chines and production equipment are required in 2040 to serve the expected market demand.

#EconomicImpact

EUROPE

Germany traditionally has a strong foot-print in the automotive industry. This is valid for the OEM perspective as well as regarding the supplier landscape. The same is true for the chemical indus-try, which certainly plays a role when it comes to fuel cell subcomponents pro-duction.

The overall share of Germany’s value creation of the value creation with origin in Europe is expected to be nearly 40%, which results in 4 billion Euro annual re-venue by 2040 for fuel cell powertrain components assembled in passenger car vehicles. This translates into nearly 1 billion Euro annual manufacturing value creation by 2040.

Regarding the manufacturing value crea-tion mechanisms, there is a clear imba-lance between the countries in Europe. Although Germany generates some 40% of the revenue streams within the European automotive industry, only 22% of manufacturing jobs are located in Germany. This means that the reve-nues and manufacturing value creation in Germany are based rather on capital than on labor. This is underlined by the high degree of automation and the high productivity of Germany as a high-wage country. Due to that, over 12 billion Euro of machine and manufacturing equip-ment investments are required in Ger-many until 2040 for production of fuel cell specific powertrain components, in order to realize the revenue and employ-ment potential given the macroecono-mic boundary conditions .

GERMANY

MAKE BUY MAKE BUY MAKE BUY

63.5 62.12.8 2.7 8.3 8.1

1.8 1.7

1.0 1.0

49.5 48.4

3.6 3.5

3.8 3.6

4.6 4.5

Germany Rest of EU

VALUE CREATION1)

MANUFACTUR-ING LABOR2)

MACHINE INVESTMENTS3)10.4 10.2

Manufacturing Value Creation in billion Euro

Employment in thousand FTEs

Nominal investments in billion Euro

FUEL CELL SYSTEM VALUE CREATION IMPACT

MAKE BUY MAKE BUY MAKE BUY

63.5 62.12.8 2.7 8.3 8.1

1.8 1.7

1.0 1.0

49.5 48.4

3.6 3.5

3.8 3.6

4.6 4.5

Germany Rest of EU

VALUE CREATION1)

MANUFACTUR-ING LABOR2)

MACHINE INVESTMENTS3)10.4 10.2

Manufacturing Value Creation in billion Euro

Employment in thousand FTEs

Nominal investments in billion Euro

MAKE BUY MAKE BUY MAKE BUY

63.5 62.12.8 2.7 8.3 8.1

1.8 1.7

1.0 1.0

49.5 48.4

3.6 3.5

3.8 3.6

4.6 4.5

Germany Rest of EU

VALUE CREATION1)

MANUFACTUR-ING LABOR2)

MACHINE INVESTMENTS3)10.4 10.2

Manufacturing Value Creation in billion Euro

Employment in thousand FTEs

Nominal investments in billion Euro

MAKE BUY MAKE BUY MAKE BUY

63.5 62.12.8 2.7 8.3 8.1

1.8 1.7

1.0 1.0

49.5 48.4

3.6 3.5

3.8 3.6

4.6 4.5

Germany Rest of EU

VALUE CREATION1)

MANUFACTUR-ING LABOR2)

MACHINE INVESTMENTS3)10.4 10.2

Manufacturing Value Creation in billion Euro

Employment in thousand FTEs

Nominal investments in billion Euro

1) Based on the revenue within the automotive industry in Germany and the EU2) Based on the manufacturing jobs within the automotive industry in Germany and the EU3) Based on a 10% lower elasticity of labor in Germany compared to the EU assuming standard economic functions

ECONOMIC IMPACT

MAKE BUY MAKE BUY MAKE BUY

63.5 62.12.8 2.7 8.3 8.1

1.8 1.7

1.0 1.0

49.5 48.4

3.6 3.5

3.8 3.6

4.6 4.5

Germany Rest of EU

VALUE CREATION1)

MANUFACTUR-ING LABOR2)

MACHINE INVESTMENTS3)10.4 10.2

Manufacturing Value Creation in billion Euro

Employment in thousand FTEs

Nominal investments in billion Euro

VALUE CREATION BY INDUSTRY IN 2040

19FEV CONSULTING | Impact of Fuel Cell Technology

Hartmut RauenDeputy General Manager

Alexander RaßmannProject management

19FEV CONSULTING | Impact of Fuel Cell Technology

FEV AT A GLANCE WORK WITH

6500+ EXPERTSAROUND THE GLOBE

ANY QUESTIONS?

Dr. Michael WittlerPrincipal

Mobile +49 (175) 9338913 [email protected]

Kai KrügerManager

Mobile +49 (170) 7846439 [email protected]

We welcome your comments, questions and suggestions. Please feel free to get in contact:

FEV CONSULTING OFFICES IN AACHEN

BEIJINGBILBAOCOLOGNE

DUBAIWORLDWIDE FEV GROUP OFFICES IN EUROPE, NORTH AMERICA, SOUTH AMERICA AND ASIA

MUNICH

40+DETROIT

TOKYO

Automotive & Commercial Vehicles Industrial, Off-Highway & MarineRail & AerospaceClean Energy & Power GenerationHighly Engineered Products

INDUSTRIES500+PROJECTS IN 30 COUNTRIES

#Contact

Alexander NaseManaging Director

Mobile +49 (160) 94110987 [email protected]

TOP MANAGEMENT CONSULTANCY

TECHNICAL KNOW-HOW &

TOP MANAGEMENT CONSULTANCY

TECHNICAL KNOW-HOW & VDMA e.V.

Lyoner Str. 1860528 Frankfurt

Postfach 71086460498 Frankfurt

Contact Alexander Raßmann:Phone +49 (69) [email protected]

Internet: www.vdma.org

Aachen Office (Global Headquarter)FEV Consulting GmbHNeuenhofstr. 18152078 AachenGermany

Beijing Office (FEV Powertrain Technology Co., Ltd.)No.168 HuaDa street, Yanjiao High-tech development zone, Sanhe city, Hebei province,065201

Bilbao Office (FEV Iberia Sl.)Calle del Cardenal Gardoqui 1,48008 BilbaoSpain

Cologne OfficeFEV Consulting GmbHNiehler Str. 104 50733 KölnGermany

Detroit Office (FEV Consulting Inc.)4554 Glenmeade Lane Auburn Hills, MI 48326-1766USA

Dubai OfficeFEV Asia GmbH (Branch)P.O.Box No. 112687, Dubai Airport Free Zone, Dubai, U A E.

Munich OfficeFEV Consulting GmbHIngolstädter Str. 2280807 MunichGermany

Tokyo OfficeFEV Japan Co. Ltd.Kjimachi,Chiyoda City, Tokyo 102-0083Japan

How to reach us online:fev-consulting.com