impact of surrogate advertising on liquor sales

117
SUMMER TRAINING PROJECT REPORT ON “impact of surrogate advertisment on liquor sales” SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE MASTER’S DEGREE IN INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS (MIB) OF H. N. B. GARHWAL UNIVERSITY, DEHRADUN SUBMITTED TO: INTERNAL GUIDE EXTERNAL GUIDE Richa sinha ranvijay singh Asst. professor IMS ub group Dehradun dehradun

Upload: chunan-sharma

Post on 30-Oct-2014

203 views

Category:

Documents


5 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

SUMMER TRAINING PROJECT REPORT

ON

“impact of surrogate advertisment on liquor sales”

SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS

FOR THE MASTER’S DEGREE IN INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS (MIB)

OF

H. N. B. GARHWAL UNIVERSITY, DEHRADUN

SUBMITTED TO:

INTERNAL GUIDE EXTERNAL GUIDERicha sinha ranvijay singhAsst. professorIMS ub groupDehradun dehradun

SUBMITTED BY:

Chunan kumar

(MIB 11A20)

INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES, DEHRADUN

BATCH 2011-13

Page 2: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

The completion of a project is never a unilateral effort. Through this

sentence I wish to make a modest effort to thank and express my

gratitude to all those who extended their co-operation and assistance

for this project.

I am highly indebted to professor richa sinha, our internal guide ims

dehradun, for her inspiration, guidance and encouragement during the

course of this Research work assigned to me. She was our guiding

force right from the inception of the research till its completion.

Chunan kumar

MIB 11A20 (2011-2013)

Ims dehradun

2

Page 3: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

CERTIFICATE

I have the pleasure in certifying that Mr. /Ms. ...…………..

…………………………..is a bonafide student of IInd Semester of the Master’s

Degree in International Business (MIB), Batch 2011-13, of Institute of

Management Studies, Dehradun under H.N.B.Garhwal University Roll No.

………..……. .

He/She has completed his/her project work entitled

……………………………………

…………………………………………………………….. under my guidance.

I certify that this is his/her original effort & has not been copied from any other

source. This project has also not been submitted in any other Institute /

University for the purpose of award of any Degree.

This project fulfils the requirement of the curriculum prescribed by this

Institute for the said course. I recommend this project work for evaluation &

consideration for the award of Degree to the student.

3

Page 4: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Signature : ……………………………………

Name of the Guide : ……………………………………

Designation : ……………………………………

Date : ……………………………………

4

Page 5: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

(To be made on Company Letter Head)

CERTIFICATE

This is to certify that Mr. / Ms. ________________________ (Mention your ID),

S/o. / D/o. Shri ______________________________, student of Master’s Degree

in International Business (MIB), Batch 2011-13, at Institute of Management

Studies, Dehradun has successfully completed his / her compulsory Summer

Training with us, as part of his / her Course Curriculum.

The duration of his / her training was from _____________ to _____________

on the project _______________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________

*under the supervision of Mr. / Ms.………………………, Designation …………….

During the training we found him / her quite sincere, hard working and his / her

conduct & behavior was good.

We wish him / her all success in his / her academic endeavours and in life.

Signature : ____________________

** (HR Manager)

Name : ____________________

5

Page 6: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Designation : ____________________

*, ** : To be used only when the certificate is given by HR Department.

6

Page 7: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Contents

Topic Page No

Rationale of the study ----------------------------------------------------6

Introduction-----------------------------------------------------------------7

Industry Structure and developments----------------------------------8

Opportunities and Threats -----------------------------------------------10

Future Outlook ------------------------------------------------------------ 12

DEFINING SURROGATE ADVERTISING ---------------------------13

LIQUOR ADS ON TV -----------------------------------------------------16

-KABHI WHISKY, KABHI RUM---------------------------------------20

Allowing socially responsible ads by Liquor Company------------------ 22

Advertising in the Liquor category on Televisio-------------------------23

Surrogate advertising — Needed, a spirited attack -------------------26

Liquor Company’s uses overseas series to Circumvent ad ban: -----------30

Kingfisher, Wills spared from surrogate ad ban: ---------------------- 32

Surrogate liquor ads flow into FM radio: -----------------------------------34

I & B Ministry’s Slashing of Surrogate Ads ------------------------------35

7

Page 8: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Foul Cry by Major Liquor------------------------------------------------------39

Bacardi origins ------------------------------------------------------------------40

BACARDI’S WAY OF SURROGATE ADVERTISING--------------------46

UB Group…………………………………………………………….…48

PROMOTIONAL MOVES OF UB GROUP FROM TIME

TO TIME……………………………………………………………….53

Methodology……………………………………………………………..59

Questionnaire……………………………………………………………60

Analysis and Graphs…………………………………………………….62

Conclusion………………………………………………………………..70

Bibliography -----------------------------------------------------------------------72

8

Page 9: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Rationale of the study

Liquor Industry has one of the fastest growing markets in India. The

liquor industry does make campaign to entire customer, therefore the

assurance of the customer are increasing day by day.

In an industry where change is the only constant, survival depends on

the quickest reaction time. When technology advances happen at the

blink of the eye, one has to keep pace or else get left behind. To

achieve this, the Co’s have to lay emphasis on total customer

satisfaction through improvements by their own capabilities and

teamwork, for this products should be backed by strong R & D,

9

Page 10: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

continuous up gradation of technology, customer oriented marketing

and unique background integration process in manufacturing.

10

Page 11: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY

My research objective is to find out that “How successful has

Surrogate Advertising been in promoting the liquor Brand”

Is surrogate advertising actually for launching a new product or is it

for manipulation of the existing liquor brands for sales? We get a

100% recall value for the actual liquor products even though

surrogate versions were being mentioned on T.V.

11

Page 12: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

INTRODUCTION

Liquor Industry has one of the most lately growing market values in

India. The liquor industry does make about by campaign to entire

customer. Therefore the assurance of the customer is increasing day

by day this is mainly due to the advertising.

In an industry where change is the only constant, survival depends on

the quickest reaction time. When technology advances happen at the

blink of the eye, one has to keep pace or get left behind. To achieve

this, the companies have to lay emphasis on total consumer

satisfaction through continuous improvements by their own

capabilities and teamwork. For this products should be backed by

strong R & D, continuous up gradation of technology, customer

oriented marketing and unique background integration process in

manufacturing.

12

Page 13: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

There is a surrogate approach towards liquor advertising in India.

There is not much that they can do except market themselves through

promotions with the latest celebrity. Hollywood films like “Scent of a

Woman” have helped in brand endorsement.

13

Page 14: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

14

Page 15: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Industry Structure and developments

The Indian Made Foreign Liquor (IMFL) market consists of Whisky,

gin, rum and vodka. The all important whisky market is further

segmented into low priced, regular, and deluxe, semi premium,

premium and Scotch. The most competitive segment in the IMFL

category is the regular segment whisky. This segment has more than

30 brands competing with each other.

The size of the organized IMFL industry stands close to Rs.200

billion and comprises of approximately 25 IMFL manufactures. The

low price IMFL and country liquor segment accounts for approx.

Rs.120billion. Now low priced IMFL is a distinct category as opposed

to country liquor, with products in the latter category typically sold at

lower prices.

The total IMFL market today’s stands at around 70 million cases per

annum which is been growing at a rate of 10% to 12% over the past 5

years. India is one of the very few liquor markets in the world where

the growth rates are positive. Particularly, the cheap liquor segment

has shown a growth of more than 25% over the past 5 years. Also,

15

Page 16: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

which is estimated to be more than the size of the IMFL market? The

market is heavily skewed in favor of whisky, accounting for around

60% - 65% of the IMFL market.

There also exists a huge unorganized sector (estimated to be as large

as the organized sector) involved in the production and safe of cheap

liquor (which is distinctly different from excise duty paid country

liquor). This trend is witnessed most in the rural areas of the country.

The Indian Liquor industry is also characterized by the presence of

immense competition amongst the major domestic liquor companies.

Regulation

The liquor business is among the last few industries that are still

under the licensing policies of the Central Government and will likely

see the most significant growth over the next 2/3 years on account of

more progressive regulation.

Liquor, in India, is a state subject, not a central one, in that each state

controls the excise duty structure and also the distribution of liquor.

The event, liquor manufactured in one state is sold in another state,

the incidence of import duty and export duty results in high product

16

Page 17: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

prices at the consumer end. It is this non uniformity of the duty

structure coupled with different types of distribution arrangements

dictated by the state governments that makes manufacturing and

marketing of liquor a very challenging task for Indian companies.

Distribution while unregulated in some states such as Maharashtra

and West Bengal is regulated in some others such as through auctions

(Haryana & Rajasthan, Bihar, Jharkhand) or through government

controlled procurement agencies (such as Tamil Nadu and Andhra

Pradesh). There are around 100,000-110,000 licensed liquor outlets in

India, with another 10, 0000 outlets such as bars and restaurants.

Advertising is also regulated by the Central government and liquor

players are not freely allowed to advertise on electronic and print

media.

Market Size (IMFL)

17

Page 18: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

o Market: 95 million cases 

o Past growth 15 % @ per annum

o Brown spirits - particularly whisky, rum & brandy account

for   over 75 % of this market

o South and North share 60% of market 

Industry Structure

o Industry in the organized sector - an industrial license is

required to start manufacture

Major brands (manufacturers): Signature, Blue Riband (UB Group),

Aristocrat (Jagjit Industries), Smirnoff, Gilbeys Green Label, Malibu,

Archer’s Peach Schnapps (International Distilleries India), Passport

(Seagrams), VAT 69, Black & White, Black Dog (United Distillers

India)

18

Page 19: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

19

Page 20: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Opportunities and Threats

On April 1, 2001, India, under commitment to the WTO, removed

quantitative restrictions (QR) on bottled in origin (BIO) liquor

imports and placed them under the OGL (Open General License)

category. Further, it is expected that the important duty of foreign

liquor would also be brought down to a committed level of 150%, the

WTO bound rate over the next 2/3 years.

This would lead to the entry of large Liquor Multinationals companies

in the country. These Multinationals will make strong inroads in the

higher priced categories of the market such as super premium and

premium end of the whisky market consisting of price levels of

Rs.450 and above per bottle of 750 ml. It is believed that these

segments are those where the Indian liquor industry will face

maximum competition over the next 3 to 4 years. Already, domestic

brands are losing substantial market share top India specific brands of

Multi nationals companies. The competition in this segment is bound

to intensify still further.

20

Page 21: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

With duties coming down over a period of time and imported liquor

coming under the purview of OGL, there have emerged excellent

opportunities for their trading in the domestic market products like

imported, wines, beer, breezers and coolers etc. should have good

opportunities for an aggressive player.

Taking advantage of this opportunity, Radico has already entered into

exclusive marketing distribution arrangements with earnest and Julio

Gallo, California, USA, the owners of the largest winery in the world

distribution of their wines in India and also with Interbrew, of

Germany for the distribution of Beck’s beer in India.

The company is also planning to introduce Ready to drink products

like Bacardi breezers and coolers through a tie up with major foreign

players. This segment is likely to see good growth in future as

consumers get acquainted with the product gradually.

Future Outlook

It is believed that the Indian liquor industry is set to grow

exponentially over the next 4 to 5 years on the back of a major

21

Page 22: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

unshackling of the regulatory structure governing it. In the last 2

years, at the State level, the Delhi Government has thrown open retail

distribution to private parties, the Uttar Pradesh government’s new

excise policy has substantially increased the contribution per case of

country liquor for most distillers in the state, the Tamil Nadu

Government’s decision to allow 100 ml packs of IMFL to wean

indications towards this direction. At the central government level,

there is a proposal to charge a uniform excise duty as opposed to state

specific excise duties.

22

Page 23: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

DEFINING SURROGATE ADVERTISING

Surrogate advertising can be defined as advertisement of a brand

extension in such a way that brings clear recalled of the core product

in the mind of the consumer. The concept of surrogate advertising in

India emerged due to certain regulations enforced on the promotion of

certain products mainly liquor and tobacco (products). Here the

companies are producing these products in order to avoid legal

complications, and also in order to remain in the minds of the

consumers, use reminder adverting by way of resorting to surrogate

advertising. These companies advertise their brand extensions for the

promotion of the core brand.

An advertisement of any thing whether it is product, service

or event in the name of core brand by which the actual product is

recalled is surrogate advertisement. Cigarette companies have used

the vehicle of surrogate advertising to reach the minds of consumers

from time to time giving for example Gold Flake which produces gold

Flake expression greeting cards, Red and White which sponsors

bravery awards, and wills which advertises wills cigarettes on the

sports wear which we have witnessed time and again on the T-shorts

23

Page 24: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

worn by the Indian cricket team. Wills lifestyle is also an example of

surrogate advertising.

Moving ahead the liquor companies have successfully used the name

of the core brand with some other products like Royal Challenge.

Similarly, Bacardi extends its brand name by producing Bacardi

cassettes, Teacher’s advertises in the name of Teacher’s Achievement

Awards, McDowell’s in the name of the Soda, Aristocrat, 8 PM,

Contessa and AC Black go ahead in the name apple juice, and Gilbeys

and Kingfisher in the name of water etc.

He also talked of an advertisement (surrogate in nature) in which a

small line of 6-/8 front size statement reading CDs and Cassettes of

the 100pipers pure music series are available in select outlets whereas

no CD, cassette or music system is shown. Above all, a Seagrams 100

piper (which is a wine) is written in a manner that it is creating an

image of bottle sticker, i.e. round folded sticker.

In INDIA there are no specific laws to control the activities relating

to surrogate advertisement. However the government issues certain

directives from time to time which are based on various laws and

codes like the Code for commercial Advertising on Doordarshan and

24

Page 25: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

The cable Television networks (Regulation) Act, 1995, Press Council

of India Act 1978 and the Cinematography Act 1952.

However the regulation is not going to affect surrogate advertising

because TV channels are free to air ads of kingfishers mineral water

and other products like Aristocrat apple juice though it is clear that

these products have been produced by the liquor companies only for

surrogate advertising. Secondly, the consumers of liquor and tobacco

companies are mostly habitual of their brands and they are not

much affected by the advertisement.

25

Page 26: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

26

Page 27: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

LIQUOR ADS ON TV

Scenario 1: The handsome young guy celebrates his corporate victory in his office. Pulls out a bottle of Aristocrat from one of his desk drawers and savors the brownish looking fluid. Cut to the next scene: in the hazy background which looks like a poolside party going on, our hero again is shown dancing with a pretty girl. Drinking Aristrocrat APPLE juice.

Scenario 2: A few young men out on a trek. They finally reach their destination to celebrate while their adventure gear is prominently displayed beside them. The adventure gear is from Four Square, a brand of cigarettes.

Scenario 3: A gang of boys and girls is seen dancing in the rain. Obviously they are having a good time, courtesy MINERAL WATER, from the `King of Good Times' aka as Kingfisher

27

Page 28: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Such TV commercials have been flowing like beer on tap on various

television channels despite the Indian government frowning down

upon the practice though informally. No more. The authorities have

started talking tough and ordered in no uncertain terms that satellite

channels stop airing surrogate advertising involving liquor.

Some channels have complied while others are likely to follow suit.

Figures about how much television advertising spends by the booze

go glug-glug courtesy the governments are hard to come by one

estimate placed it at a giddying Rs 2700-3000 million. Phew! Enough

to make even a teetotaler hit the bottle.

But media planners and buyers believe they won't have to do that.

Liquor advertisers will find an out. Already Bacardi has invested in

Bacardi blast night parties, which serve as a very effective branding

vehicle.

"With the government cracking the whip on surrogate advertising on

TV, the liquor companies will move to intensify ground events and

explore other such below-the-line avenues for promotion. Outdoors is

also an option.

28

Page 29: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

A lot of that was already happening with booze cash backing musical

concerts, exhibitions and seminars. Royal Challenge, for example,

sponsors golf events.

A clutch of media planners and advertising personalities fells that

there is a going to be a rise in the number of liquor and tobacco

sponsored events in the near future in the effort to neutralize the ban

on ads on TV channels.

Some have even taken the cable TV route working closely with cable

operators to insert ads or "crawlers" during movies that are aired on

home video channels. Some liquor companies going to cable

operators to have their ads aired on the home video channel on which

the government's attention has not been drawn till now is also been

banned. The advantages were two-fold on advertising on cables: cable

operators' charges for ads are just a fraction of what satellite channels

charge and in the short-term this can be an alternative to

Outdoors and direct advertising. What could spoil the party however

is the fact that in some places like Delhi the state government has

banned hoardings?

Below-the-line advertising will increase and hog a bigger share of the

media budget of liquor and tobacco companies.

29

Page 30: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Of late TV channels have seen a sufficient of commercials pegging

aerated water, mineral water, bar accessories by liquor companies. 8

PM Apple juice, Bagpiper soda, Kingfisher water, Aristocrat

Premium apple juice, Hayward’s 5000 dart boards are just a few of

the examples. Johnnie Walker Scotch whisky promotes a series of

successful stories on CNBC India through sound bytes from

prominent Indians like Amitabh Bachchan. Almost every channel has

been party to the surrogate commercial brigade, with the sole

exception being Doordarshan, which by mandate did not carry such

fare.

"What are advertisements for?" It is a method to communicate to and

come in contact with the consumer. TV channels may have been one

such contact point. Whenever and wherever there is an opportunity to

come in contact with the consumer it can be exploited it can be

through his mouse pad or the club he frequents. So, the liquor

companies have options and will go in for that marketing too.

Though liquor companies did not seem to be worried, as the ad

expenditure of liquor companies have not come down with the ban on

TV ads.

Annual revenues from surrogate advertising for the television

industry as a whole is about 4 per cent of total ad spends - between

Rs2000 million and Rs2250 million.

30

Page 31: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

According to one TV channel executive it was niche channels that

would be affected more than general entertainment ones. In the first

place the categories of advertisers were limited as the viewer profile

was either up market or youth-specific. Movie, sports, news and

music channels were the channels that he felt would be impacted

most.

Looking abroad for parallels though, India seems to be working in

reverse direction. In the US for instance, while beer ads have been a

regular feature of the TV advertising milieu, when it comes to hard

liquor, the spirits industry has lived under a voluntary ban on the

placement of ads on TV for the past 50 years. But with declining

revenues over the past two increasingly health-conscious decades, the

industry has begun cautiously testing the regulatory climate by

placing ads on some local TV or cable stations. There is a heated

debate going on in the US over the wisdom of this reversal, especially

after NBC announced towards the end of last year that they would

allow liquor commercials to run during late-evening programming,

making them the first national network to do so.

Coming back to India, as the government tightens the screws and

takes the fizz out of the liquor companies' blast, the affected ones are

re-drawing their strategies. The restriction put by the government can

be termed a non-option because it applies to the competition too.

Hence, all the constituents affected by the liquor crackdown have to

31

Page 32: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

take cognizance of the fact that the tipplers' party is over. If they don't

fall in line they may end up with a hangover. That's if the government

acts on its threat putting its weight behind the liquor ad ban move, it is

quite likely that it is dry days for television channels even for

surrogate ads.

KABHI WHISKY , KABHI RUM

Law prohibits liquor advertisements, however, such restrictions are

circumvented by ads purported to be for products outside the banned

category. All liquor licensees include bars, pubs, restaurants, licensee

retail stores, wineries, breweries and distilleries - are allowed to

advertise their products, but they must comply with Liquor Control

and Licensing regulations.

For example, licensees may put up signs to advertise their

establishments or products. These signs and advertisements may

include liquor prices (including specials), hours of sale and the names

of liquor manufacturers or brands. But they could not place

advertisements in newspapers, magazines and periodicals, or on

television, radio or the Internet, and publish pamphlets and brochures.

They should also not:

32

Page 33: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Encourage people to drink liquor or to drink irresponsibly (ads

that mention price must take this into account; if a licensee's

price advertising encourages or results in drinking excess, the

Liquor Control and Licensing Branch can prevent the licensee

from including liquor prices in future advertising)

Show people drinking liquor, or anyone who is either

intoxicated or behaving irresponsibly or illegally

Associate liquor with driving

Be directed at minors or placed in locations used or visited

mostly by minors, such as theaters and playgrounds

Depict liquor as:

o One of life's necessities

o Key to social acceptance or personal success

o Central to the enjoyment of an activity, or

o A status symbol.

In addition:

Ads for bars and winery lounges may not use

pictures of minors (in BC, that's anyone under the age of 18)

Ads for restaurants must make clear that serving food

is the restaurant's primary purpose

Ads for companies that make beer, wine or spirits

may name a liquor store, bar or restaurant where the product is

sold, and

33

Page 34: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Ads for companies that make beer, wine or spirits are

not to be shown on a theatre screen before a movie.

So, we have Club soda as a stand in for bagpiper whisky, or mineral

water for kingfisher beer. Keeping pace with the I.T. mode, there are

websites for Seagram whisky and Bacardi rum.

A few sips of AC Apple juice in a TV commercial drop the neckline

of a nubile woman by several inches (as imagined by the imbiber).

Guess what would happen if AC juice ferments to Aristocrat whisky

for which the former is surrogate?

Brand stretching has become a lifesaver of the liquor advertising

industry, besieged by regulations, which can be breached with

impunity.

Cheers to soda water with spirit

34

Page 35: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

The latest proposal: allow socially responsible ads by liquor

companies

Faced with a 7 to 11 percent loss in revenues after the ban on direct

and indirect liquor advertising, a group of TV broadcasters has

submitted a proposal to the government to allow them to use socially

responsible ads sponsored by liquor companies.

A committee of broadcasters headed by I&B special secretary Mr.

R.R. Shah, which was set up the government recently to find out what

constitutes surrogate ads, has recommended to the government that

socially useful advertisements sponsored by liquor companies should

be allowed on TV channels according to a top official in a private TV

channel.

Socially useful ads sponsored by liquor companies are a very popular

concept in the US and the UK, and are likely to be well accepted in

India as well, as a member of the committee on surrogate ads. Since

public service endorsement does not lead to promotion of liquor ads,

these cannot be clubbed with direct/indirect or even surrogate

advertising of liquor. The socially useful ads or public service

endorsements, which this committee is referring to, may not

necessarily talk about drunken driving as some liquor companies have

been doing so far. Although the government hasn’t decided whether

to allow liquor whether to allow liquor companies to advertise

35

Page 36: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

socially responsible ads on. TV channels there are feelers that the

government is warm to the idea. In fact, broadcasters are even open to

the idea of the government is warm to the messages can be allowed on

TV channels. For instance, if the government feels that only

medically helpful or crime prevention messages must be beamed on

channels, broadcasters are ready to abide.

Advertising in the Liquor category on Television registers a negligible

dip of 2% in 2011 as compared to 2010

Key Findings:

Advertising in the Liquor category marks a negligible dip of 2%

in 2011 compared to 2010.

Liquor advertising spends on Television varies across the years

2000-11.

Feature Films are the most preferred program genre for Liquor

Advertising in 2011.

A look at the trend of TV advertising in the Liquor category in year 2011 compared to

2010.

36

Page 37: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

We can see that Advertising shows a negligible dip of 2% in year

2011 compared to year 2010. The graph shows the indexed spends of

the Liquor category on Television Advertising since 2010.

Advertising in the Liquor category is expected to be quite seasonal.

Let's check out whether that's actually the case.

37

Page 38: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

The graph shows that Liquor advertising spends on

Television varies every year across 2010-200.

Where do we see ads for Liquor?

The graph show that almost 29% of the total advisement on Liquor is on Feature Films. The other program genres, which are favored by Liquor category, are Drama/Soap, News Bulletin, Cricket, Music Shows/songs, and Comedies and so on. 

38

Page 39: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

(Analysis from AdEx India-A Division of TAM Media Research)

Surrogate advertising — Needed, a spirited attack

In India, the trend of surrogate advertisement gathered momentum with the Cable TV

Network Regulation Act, which prohibits tobacco and liquor advertisements on TV

channels. The liquor industry has intentionally blurred the line between products,

advertising `old wine' in a `new bottle,' only this time with a soft-drink label.

"MEIN, AAP AUR Bagpiper". This Bagpiper club soda advertisement, featuring cine

celebrities, is similar to the earlier one for Bagpiper whisky. The advertisement comes

with the same music and punch line as the one for the popular liquor brand telecast

before the ban on liquor advertisements. This phenomenon, known as "surrogate

advertising" (duplicating the brand image of one product extensively to promote

another product of the same brand), has become commonplace.

Surrogate advertisements took off not long ago in the UK, where British housewives

protested strongly against liquor advertisements "luring" away their husbands. The

liquor industry found a way around the ban: Surrogate advertisements for cocktail

mixers, fruit juices and soda water using the brand names of the popular liquors.

In India, the trend of surrogate advertisement gathered momentum with the Cable TV

Network Regulation Act, which prohibits tobacco and liquor advertisements on TV

channels. The liquor industry has intentionally blurred the line between products,

advertising `old wine' in a `new bottle,' only this time with a soft-drink label.

39

Page 40: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

A market survey in 2005 revealed that advertising has a direct influence on the

consumption habits of 481 million people in India and an indirect impact on 300 million

`aspirants' from the lower income group. Considering this and realizing that nearly 50

per cent of the television owners have access to cable channels, there is no doubt that the

hidden call for alcohol consumption behind the surrogate advertisements is not escaping

the eyes of viewers in the world's fourth highest liquor-consuming country. Surrogate

advertising defeats the very purpose of banning liquor advertisements.

Sociological studies have shown that, in India, a significant share of income of a large

section of the population is spent on liquor, potentially leading to financial distress and

health hazards. According to the International Wine and Spirit Board, a liquor industry

publication, there will be a jump in the number of people reaching the legal drinking

age of 25 within the next few years. The implication is that the problem is going to grow.

The motivations of firms look even more suspect when they advertise products that

cannot be bought. In 2010, for example, Jagjit Industries, the maker of Aristrocrat

Whisky, advertised a product called `Aristrocrat Apple Juice.' The company reportedly

confirmed availability of the fruit juice in Delhi, Haryana, Punjab and Rajasthan, yet,

no reputed shop in Delhi had ever seen it, let alone sells it. However you can find it now.

Understanding the gravity of the situation, the Indian Broadcasting Foundation (IBF)

has started to take on the surrogate liquor advertisements. The IBF decided that Jagjit

Industries and other liquor-manufacturing units must get production of the

advertisement approved both at the `storyboard stage' and after the production of the

commercial.

It also ruled that that if liquor companies promote any juice, mineral water or soda,

these should be shown in a proper manner and not as trimmings to liquor

advertisement.

These are welcome steps, but the key point lies in enforcement. If, in a free society,

producers have a legitimate right to let consumers know about their products through

advertisements, consumers have the right to information in adverts that are clear and

honest.

40

Page 41: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Surrogate advertisements are not only misleading, but also false and dishonest in many

cases. With surrogate advertising so widespread, this is the moment to tackle the

problem head-on.

There should be stringent regulatory measures to curb the practice, such as:

Making transparent laws banning surrogate advertisements for different

products under a single brand names, by amending the Trade Marks Act, for

instance;

Providing teeth to the Advertising Standards Council of India to enable it take

action against false and misleading advertisements, and keep a close vigil over

clever evasion of the law;

Asking the electronic and print media to adhere to the advertisement codes and

not to encourage surrogate advertisements;

Consumer awareness programme could be created to help people understand the

negative impact of surrogate advertisements;

Adopting strict laws to penalize those companies featuring surrogate

advertisements without any real existence of the product; and

Requiring advertising agencies to have full knowledge of the products under the

same brand for which they are promoting advertisements, and taking legal

actions against those agencies which design surrogate advertisements.

41

Page 42: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

This is not cricket! - Liquor Company’s uses overseas series to circumvent ad ban:

WITH the Government trying to clamp down on surrogate advertising, liquor

companies seem keen to bat out the ban. Even as liquor brands have traditionally been

associated with up market sporting activities like golf, polo, derby and yachting,

companies are now turning towards the game of the masses - cricket. After the

triangular series at Zimbabwe in 2011 (of which Royal Stag was the associate sponsor),

the India and Zimbabwe Test series will be called the Royal Stag Cup.

Till date Royal Stag has used several international cricketers as brand endorsers. This

is the first time the company has forayed into tournament sponsorship. Similarly, the

ICC World XI Vs Australia series to be held Down Under will be called the Johnnie

Walker Super Series.

As both the series were being held outside India it would be difficult for the

Government to blip out the liquor brands. Since the matches will be beamed into Indian

drawing rooms live, the brands will enjoy good visibility.

Internationally beer brands such as Fosters and Lion have supported cricket in

Australia and Sri Lanka respectively. Meanwhile, Royal Stag has roped in Zimbabwean

Vice-Captain, Heath Streak as their new Royal Stag brand ambassador. Other celebrity

42

Page 43: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Royal Stag cricket endorsers include Australian Cricket captain Ricky Ponting, and

India's ace off spinner Harbhajan Singh.

The Information and Broadcasting (I&B) Ministry's efforts to ban surrogate

advertising of liquor brands has reached a naught. A few months ago, it had sent out

notices to various television channels to withdraw advertisements by liquor companies.

But within a few weeks of the notices being issued, surrogate advertising made a

comeback on television. In fact, a few liquor companies have been advertising during

the ongoing cricket series as well between ENGLAND AND INDIA. However channels

were categorically told that there is a complete ban on advertising by liquor companies.

The Government is also handicapped by procedure wherein it can take action against

channels only after receipt of complaints. "The Government cannot suo motu issue

show-cause notices. It has to first receive complaints," said official sources.

Liquor companies on their part state that their advertising is self-regulated and comply

with the Indian Broadcasting Foundation and the Advertising Standards Council of

India code.

Kingfisher, Wills spared from surrogate ad ban:

43

Page 44: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

In a significant policy shift, the government has in principle decided to permit non-

liquor and non-tobacco advertisements of Kingfisher and Wills brands on TV channels.

This is despite the fact that the Cable TV Act prohibits advertising of liquor and

tobacco.

According to I&B ministry sources, the government will, however, consider granting

similar exemptions on a case-by-case basis to such “genuine” businesses. The Cable TV

Act is also likely to be amended on these lines later.

A committee, comprising representatives from home, health, law, women empowerment

and information & broadcasting ministries, is still examining the objection raised by the

UB Group (Kingfisher water, soda and airline) and ITC (Wills Lifestyle) over the ban.

A government however gave both Kingfisher and Wills a green signal soon. The UB

group and ITC have been successful in convincing the government that they have

“genuine” non-liquor, non-tobacco businesses, though with the same brand names.

According to industry estimates, liquor advertising (surrogate) is worth Rs 250 crore to

300 crore in India. Even as there are several liquor brands indulging in surrogate

advertising on TV, only Kingfisher is likely to be spared for now. ITC, a major tobacco

brand, too would be allowed to beam its Wills Lifestyle ads. For other liquor companies,

decisions will be taken on a case-to-case basis, till the policy is fine tuned, the source

said.

Before tobacco advertising was banned, ITC alone had an ad budget, on both television

and print, of Rs 100 crore, as per Lintas Media estimates for 2011. Of this, Rs 76 crore

was only for print. As for Kingfisher, its airline ad budget alone is around Rs 10 crore.

In a recent interview, UB chairman Vijay Mallya had in an interview that I&B minister

S Jaipal Reddy had assured him the ministry couldn’t take a view that Kingfisher ads

are surrogate. “Certainly not with an airline. We already have a very significant

mineral water business Mr. Mallya had said.

The government clampdown on surrogate liquor and tobacco ads had begun during the

National Democratic Alliance (NDA) regime. In fact, former information &

broadcasting minister Sushma Swaraj was in the process of formulating a norm on

brand extension and surrogate advertising based on the volume of non-liquor or non-

tobacco business.

The reasoning, at that point, was that if there’s a standalone genuine business owned by

a liquor/tobacco company, the brand could be advertised.

44

Page 45: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

However, last month, the UPA government issued notices to liquor/tobacco companies

and television channels, stating that there’s a blanket ban on advertising liquor.

Surrogate liquor ads flow into FM radio:

Even as the Information and Broadcasting (I&B) Ministry is clamping down on

surrogate liquor ads appearing on various television channels, these ads seem to have

crept into the various private FM radio channels.

Recently Guinness UDV's Gilbey's Green Label and UB Group's Romanov have been

advertising on some private FM channels in Mumbai and Delhi.

But just as liquor ads are not permitted to advertise on TV, they cannot be heard on

radio. Officials in the Ministry said FM channels would also have to follow the

Broadcasting Code framed for the All India Radio (AIR) and the Doordarshan.

Despite this, FM companies seem to be accepting surrogate liquor ads. The officials at

radio networks refused to comment on the issue calling it "a touchy one". They merely

said that the same guidelines applicable to surrogate advertising on television is

45

Page 46: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

applicable to radio. Also, advertising by liquor companies on radio has been miniscule

compared to television.

B Ministry&I have been looking at the issue of surrogate liquor advertisements and

have been sending out notices to various television channels. "It has been a cat and

mouse game. Once notices are issued the ads go out, but reappear after a while," said

the Ministry official.

And with the revival of radio through FM, the debate over surrogate advertising on TV

is being carried over to radio as well.

I & B Ministry’s Slashing of Surrogate Ads

IBF Flays surrogate liquor ads

The Indian Broadcasting Foundation (IBF) has come down heavily on surrogate

liquor ads. While asking channels to withdraw commercials of close to a dozen

products, it has also sought changes in several other ads.

The ones that have been seen as inappropriate are ads for 8 P.M. Apple Juice

where two generals are seen exchanging drinks, Bagpiper Hero, Bacardi

46

Page 47: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Breezers, Johnnie Walker, McDowell’s Signature and Whitehall Party, among

others.

In some other ads such as the one for Mc Dowell’s Mera No. 1, it has said that

the term spirit should be removed. The words ‘Rare Spirit’ should be removed

from the Royal Channel Golf Accessories while it has suggested a brand new

commercial for Aristocrat Premium Apple Juice.

Recent at a meeting of the IBF sub committee on surrogate advertising, the

apex body comprising all the major broadcasters has categorically said that

members of the Confederation of Indian Alcoholic Beverage Companies

(CIABC). Seagram, Jagjit Industries and all other alcohol companies must get

product of their commercials approved both at the storyboard stage and after

production of the commercial. It also said that liquor companies must provide

authentic data in the form of a letter from the Chairman or Member of the Board

or the auditors giving details of the surrogate products’ manufacturing facilities,

launch date, distribution networks and details of the product category

registration.

The sub committee said that if the commercial promotes an apple juice, mineral

water or soda, it should be presented in a suitable manner and not shown as an

accessory to alcohol drinking. The recent clampdown on surrogate ads will

affect the television channels as the industry spends over Rs. 300 crore on

advertising. According to medial planners, huge amounts of money are spent on

regional channels such as Alpha Punjabi, Marathi and Bangla or ETC Punjabi,

the expenditure is not very high. The rates for spots on these channels are very

low, said a Delhi based media planner.

Meanwhile, the liquor companies continue to claim that these ads were for

genuine products that are available in the market. The companies had, in fact,

some months back, placed samples and other proofs before the Government to

defend their case.

47

Page 48: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

The government, meanwhile, said that the

channels would have to adhere to the

Advertisement Code, which is part of the

Cable Television Networks (Regulation)

Act, 1995 as they can take action against channels violating the code by asking

cable operators to black out the channel.

According to the IBF’s code, if a liquor company does not have an adequate

number of the product that it was trying to project on television available in the

market through sufficient distribution outlets, TV channels do not accept the ads

of that company.

The case of Hayward’s was cited as an example and how the ads were taken off

the air by TV channels when it was found out the market did not have an

adequate number of dart boards the company was advertising on TV, the IBF

source said. Apart from the government, the IBF was in the process of finalizing

its own advertising and programming code, which was an attempt towards

voluntary self-regulation, “he added.

Still, government sources indicate that the I & B ministry list of objectionable

television commercials includes ACP Apple Juice Kuch Bhi Ho Sakta Hai

campaign, Royal Stag (that incidentally features two cricketers), Aristocrat,

Smirnoff, Bagpiper, McDowell’s Gilbey’s Green Label, Whitehall, Imperial

Blue, Macintosh Apple Juice, Royal Challenge and Smirnoff.

48

Page 49: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

49

Page 50: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Surrogate liquor ads that have gone off air

Advertisements for Hayward’s 5000, ACP Black apple juice and Radico

Khaitan’s 8 pm apple juice was pulled out from all major TV channels

immediately, after the Indian Broadcasters Foundation (IBF) has objected in an

act of self discipline regarding surrogate advertising.

The broadcasters, henceforth, will seek details of products, which they believe

promote non – existent products added an IBF official. They met I & B Ministry

officials to convince them of their efforts at self-regulation.

While a decision has been taken to affect this ban immediately, the

implementation is likely to take at least a couple of days since most of the

advertisements are inserted in advance.

After the I & B Ministry banned liquor ads in 2000, most liquor manufacturers

devised ingenious ways of remaining visible even while observing the legalities.

Mostly, the hard liquor ads were replaced with more socially acceptable options

such as apple juice, even if such products did not exist within their portfolio.

Regarding the ACP black apple juiced ad where a woman sheds her clothes as

the drink is consumed, the IBF official said, “While it might be a genuine ad,

the IBF committee has decided to remove it in its present format.”

Foul Cry by Major Liquor

50

Page 51: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Even as the Government gets cracking on surrogate advertising by

liquor firm, Jagjit Industries, whose ad for AC Black apple juice has

been pulled off air from TV channels, alleges that the competition is

obfuscating the entire issue to suit their commercial interests.

Jagjit’s spokesperson said the competition through the Confederation

of Indian Alcoholic beverage Companies (CIABC) has been

canvassing against this ad with the Information and Broadcasting

Ministry and the TV channels.

“There is need for regulation of this sector, but I am against arbitrary

regulation. If the ACP Black ad is surrogate sexist below the line

advertising, so are many others. At least, this product actually exists,”

says Jagjit director Deepankar Barat.

CIABC chairman Vijay Rekhi, on the other hand says we are only

ensuring that the industry behaves responsible in collaboration with

the media and the ministry. He reckons that the TV channels that are

signatories to the voluntary CIABC marketing code need to enforce it

their end.

Many a times though ad may be genuine its content violates all

norms of decency, and hence the ad should be pulled out.

Worldwide, the liquor industry is regulated by a code of conduct,

which includes the hours when such ads can be aired, the content and

a compulsory statutory warning. In India, the Government has been

trying to bring in a sense of regulation.

51

Page 52: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Bacardi origins (A)

The most famous of light and Puerto Rican rums is Bacardi. Bacardi

was originally made in Cuba, and notably the first light rum. They

also opened plants in Mexico and Puerto Rico in the 1930’s. The

Puerto Rican plant allowed importation to the US without the import

duty imposed. When Castro took over Cuba and nationalized the rum

industry, Bacardi stopped production there and Puerto Rico became

their main distillery. Though Bacardi is most famous for its light rum,

they also produce other variations. Ron Rico and Don Q are Puerto

Rican rum also.

France imports a lot of Rum from the French West Indies. Once

imported to France, they are often aged. Martinique is the largest

producer. Many of these rums are produced with the addition of

dunder. Dunder is the residue left from the previous batch and can be

compared to the making of sour mash in the States. Haiti also

52

Page 53: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

produces fine sipping Rums. Cachucha is made in Brazil from

sugarcane and often heavily sweetened, as it is naturally dry, this is

the main ingredient in Caiparnha. A clock cousin, Caha is made in

Pragnay, and other South American countries. In Mexico rum is more

popular than tequila. Here it fees by the name of aguardiente.

Flavored runs are gaining in popularity; Capitan more a spiced rum

and Malilum coconut flavor are two examples.

BACARDI’S MARKET SHARE SCENARIO AND

CURRENT MARKET STRATEGY

Bacardi picks up local consumer insights to infuse new spirit into stagnating

sales.

Chilling out on a beach in the middle of the day has a universal appeal. Or does

it not, it appears, In India. Which is why Bacardi is on the verge of releasing a

brand new campaign for the Indian market, which replaces the earlier trademark

global TV commercial?

Sure, the fun, colours and passion are all there because the target group of

tipplers between the ages of 25 and 45 years hasn’t changed. Only, in place of

53

Page 54: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

sun, sea and sand in the afternoon, the setting is an evening bash after a tiring

day’s work. That marks a radical for the Cuban rum maker. This is the first time

any where in its worldwide markets that Bacardi Martini has had to leave its

global communication to local taste. What made Bacardi Martini take such a

significant step?

The answer lays in the way the market for white spirits, and white rum in

particular, has evolved over the last few years. Today, the white spirits market

accounts for less than 5 percent of total liquor sales in India and is dominated by

gin. White rum and vodka make up less than 2 per cent of the total liquor sales.

International Distillers and Vintners (IDV), which launched its Smirnoff Vodka

eight years ago, was joined by Bacardi in 1998 when the latter introduced white

rum, Carta Blanca. The two were expected to expand the market for white

spirits through their marketing blitz. Even today, the segment is a drop in the

Indian liquor ocean.

To be sure, Bacardi had a great start. In the first year, Carta Blanca sold 20,000,

the next year (1999-2000), it achieved the targets of 40,000 cases and the

following year sales surged to peak at a little less than 1,00,000 cases.

What worried the company was that after that, sales leveled off. In fiscal 2010,

Bacardi failed to reach last year’s sales.

Considering many global brands have thought twice about bringing their

international campaign into the. So Bacardi began with its world wide Indian

54

Page 55: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

market, how is it that Bacardi chose this option? Part of the explanation lays in

the fact that Bacardi faced a major challenge in defining consumers in the first

place.

Although rum as a category, primarily dark rum, accounted for 13 to 14 per cent

of the total market in 1998, consumer loyalty was extremely high and hard to

break. So the task before Bacardi was a formidable one.

Price was another barrier since Bacardi came at a premium of over 250 per cent

to local rums and whiskies. Research at the time showed that, at best, Bacardi

could possible pick up rum drinkers on the fringes, who were open to trying out

other types of rum.

But this number was too small and uncertain. Bacardi could hope to draw in

these consumers long as it preserved the strong, macho properties of dark rum.

Most rum drinkers chose the product to make a statement about them and stand

out in the crowd.

“The change we are making in India, while subtle, recognizes the need to

balance the playfulness of Bacardi with more of a work ethic if we are to

connect even more with the Indian consumer” Jeff Macdonald Marketing

director, Bacardi Martini India Limited. Research also should that up market

consumers were more concerned with how a drink enhanced their image rather

than with taste positioning of freedom and passion to get consumer to associate

the drink with youthfulness.

55

Page 56: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

The communication was followed up with elaborate below the line activities.

Such as promos (free glasses with a bottle of Bacardi). To increase trials,

Bacardi launched a miniature 60 ml bottle at Rs. 35 and then a 375 ml print

bottle for Rs. 180. The idea was to rope in consumers who found the drink

expensive.

The last few years saw Bacardi (in common with other liquor companies) hit by

the blanket ban on advertising in the electronic media. In the absence of direct

product advertising, the company was left with no option but to rely on below

the line activities, such as a dance parties and promotions. The standard of

surrogated advertising was taking time since the parent company wasn’t used to

this form of advertising.

Late last year Bacardi kicked off a study to find out what would push sales. The

answer lay in making its surrogate communication more relevant for the Indian

target audience. While Bacardi targeted a wider consumer segment, young

executives dominated its consumption.

The company discovered these people are serious about their careers, which

have higher priority than having fun. Fun follows after work, while its previous

communication was all about fun.

Based on the findings, the company roped in filmmaker Prasoon Pandey to

create a new film under the aegis of its advertising agency McCann – Erickson.

56

Page 57: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

The new advertising is crafted on simple though of transformation that is how

the Bacardi spirit charges up a lazy evening after a hard days work.

Bacardi’s new advertising may have taken a cue from what most other liquor

brand are doing McDowell’s No. 1 Aristocrat and Gilbey’s Green have all tried

to associate themselves with professional success at the work place.

Bacardi is confined that its new initiatives will help bring about a change in

consumer habits, although it admits the process may take time. Its assumptions

are based on its observation in the US and UK which have been showing a clear

move from whisky to white spirits among young up market people driven by a

combination of strong image based marketing initiatives and the fact that white

spirit have a wider potential as cocktail base.

In the US, more than 50 per cent of the market is already white spirits; India

tends to follow global trends, “says Macdonald. So we are very confident we

can grow this segment and take a leading position.

The company is introducing a new pack design that will highlight the brand’s

heritage established in 1862 in Cuba and product quality the world’s smoothest

rum. The company plans to be more aggressive with its Bacardi Blast music

event which attracted over 150, 000 consumers across nine metros, in the year

2004.

57

Page 58: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

“This year BACARDI objective is to make it even bigger and even hotter, with

innovative venues the hottest international DJs and hot, new Bacardi cocktail”

said Mr. Macdonald.

Bacardi Blast compact discs (CDs) will be another thrust area for brand

building. The company is all set to launch the ninth CD in the series, having

already sold over 300,000 copies with four releases reaching number one in the

charts. “We plan to have Bacardi Nightshift events in even more big way,”

says Macdonald. And a new on trade promotion concept that will become the

hottest post work party in town.

Most of these initiatives are in line with Bacardi Martini’s objective to garner

quick volume in the Indian market. Last year, the company acquired a 51 per

cent stakes in erstwhile white and Mackay (now Whytehall India) and spreading

its presence in IMFL whiskies as well.

Apart from this, the company is distributing William Grant’s Scotch whisky

brands and Bacardi Martini’s affiliate John Dewar & Sons Dewars Scotch

Whisky in India. But its experience with white liquor will test whether it’s truly

understood the spirit of the Indian Market.

BACARDI’S WAY OF SURROGATE

ADVERTISING

58

Page 59: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

The, General Manager, marketing BACARDI put it: “any alternative brand has

to fit the original proposition. Both our product and the parties and music we are

promoting allow consumers to release the super – me.

Music can get you in the party mood, just like a peg or two, but apple juice is

just apple juice, despite Aristocrat’s assurances to the contrary on the small

screen.

That could be the difference between alternative brand advertising and surrogate

ads that the committee will be looking for.

The committee, we are told, will look into whether the brands advertised are

legitimate products it may also look into the amount of revenue invested into

promotion of a brand vis a vis the percentage of revenue it brings into a

company. Said Ramesh Narayan, experiment, Advertising Agencies Association

of India.

Though it remains unclear how fat the surrogate ad ban will go, the ASCI

already has a basic guideline.

Bacardi kicked off the “Blast concept around six years ago which dates

surrogate advertising with music events in the metros in conjunction with

Channel V.

The ad jingle that made Bacardi a household name was switched from sipping

on Bacardi Rum to swinging to Bacardi Blast.

59

Page 60: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

But any one old enough to drink will also surely recalled the old words as soon

as the tune comes on the telly. That is the brand recall and value advertisers will

sorely miss, if the clampdown is complete.

60

Page 61: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

UB Group

One of the leading liquor companies of the country. The UB group has been

successful in maintaining its pole position. Dr. Vijay Mallya, is the face of the

$2 billion UB Group 51 year-old Dr. Mallya took over the reins of the United

Breweries Group in 1983 at the tender age of 28 and has, since then, steered the

UB Group to a multinational conglomerate. Instrumental in shaping the

Kingfisher brand as one of the most popular beers across the globe, Dr. Mallya

has received several awards both in India and overseas. He was conferred a

Doctorate in Philosophy in Business Administration (honoris causa) by the

University of Southern California and nominated as a Global Leader for

Tomorrow by the Geneva-based World Economic Forum (WEF).

In recognition of Dr. Vijay Mallya's contribution to the development of Trade

and Industry in Karnataka, the Federation of Karnataka Chambers of Commerce

and Industry conferred upon him "Sir M. Visvesvaraya Memorial Award" for

the year 2001.

UB Group is 3rd largest spirits marketer in the world. With the sales of over 50

million the spirits business of the group is the 3rd largest spirits marketer of the

world.

61

Page 62: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

The UB Group, with acquisition of Shaw Wallace & Company Limited, offers

140 brands at varying price points - attracting consumers of every taste- and

combined with its unparalleled reach has become an object of envy for the

competition.

Spirits

McDowell & Company Limited

Herbertsons Limited

Shaw Wallace & Company Ltd.

Is the 3rd largest spirits marketer in the world with sales of approx. 50

million cases

The 'Millionaire' Brands belonging to United Spirits has increased to 15

McDowell's No.1 Brandy is the largest selling brandy in the world

McDowell's No. 1 Whisky is one of the fastest growing whisky brands in

the world with sales of over 5.52 million cases

McDowell's No.1 Celebration Rum is one of the fastest growing rum

brands in the world with sales of over 5.04 million cases

62

Page 63: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

McDowell's No.1 Whisky is the 5th largest non-scotch whisky and 8th

largest whisky (including Scotch) in the world.

Offers 140 brands

Bagpiper Whisky is India's Largest selling whisky with sales of 10

million cases last year

McDowell & Company Limited (McD)

McDowell is the major player in the spirits business. The Group's spirits

business sold over 50 million cases .The Division has scaled unprecedented

global heights and now occupies the position of the 3rd largest spirits marketer

in the world .It offers 140 brands at varying price points - attracting consumers

of every taste- and combined with its unparalleled reach has become an object

of envy for the competition. Some of its brands like McDowell's No.1 Whisky,

No.1 Celebration Rum and No.1 Brandy occupy the top rungs in India in terms

of volume. McDowell No.1 Brandy is the largest selling brandy in the world.

McDowell has always powered ahead riding on innovations. A series of

packaging innovations have added value and assurance for the customer. These

include holograms, non-refillable 'guala' caps, and tamper proof tear off caps

63

Page 64: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

based on German technology. Not surprisingly, McDowell occupies the pride of

place in UB Group, contributing to a major chunk of the Group's turnover.

Beer

United Breweries Limited (UBL)

Upon demerger of the beer business from the erstwhile United Breweries

Limited, the newly constituted UBL has become the main brewing company of

the UB Group. The latter has now been renamed as United Breweries

(Holdings) Limited. UBL has been associated with brewing for over five

decades and and commands a domestic market share in excess of 50%. Its

leading brands readily brings cheer all over India and abroad - that include

Kingfisher, UB Export, London Pilsner, Premium Ice and Kalyani Black Label.

The Kingfisher towers over every beer brand not only in India but on foreign

shores too. While Kingfisher Premium has raced to sales of 18.8 million cases,

Kingfisher Strong became the fastest growing brand. Its sales crossed the 10

million cases mark within 5 years of introduction. The brand has also

comfortably outpaced the industry average growth- notching up 29 % growth as

against 3% for the industry.

64

Page 65: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Relentless innovation has played a major part in these achievements. For non-

stop partying, a 5-liter keg of Kingfisher draught beer has been introduced that

blends versatility with economy. A four pack has also been introduced by

London Pilsner -another brand within the fold. An attractive new value pack has

also been introduced for the traditional markets.

To build upon its leadership position, UBL has broken new grounds with a

multi-faceted strategic alliance with Scottish & Newcastle Plc. (S&N). While

allowing UBL to market S&N's international brands in India, it will also

leverage S&N's global network while further globalization the Kingfisher brand.

Commands a domestic market share of over 50%

Leading brands are Kingfisher, UB Export, London Pilsner, Premium Ice

and Kalyani Black Label.

Kingfisher to bring in "international good times" with S & N's brands.

And Kingfisher will also bring cheer abroad.

Kingfisher is the only Indian Beer brand available in 52 countries and

also on international flights.

Every third beer sold in India is Kingfisher.

65

Page 66: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

PROMOTIONAL MOVES OF UB GROUP

FROM TIME TO TIME

KINGFISHER CORPORATE CRICKET

The third kingfisher Corporate Cricket was played from August to November in

the year 2011. Twenty-four corporate participated in this event.

The matches were played over weekends at the indoor stadium at Karnataka

State Cricket Association.

The finalists were Infosys and Max Health Scribe. Infosys emerged the

winner at the end of the highly competitive match.

The prize distribution function was held at the Karnataka Cricket

Association.

Mr. Jawagal Srinath, the pace bowler of Indian Cricket team at that time

was the Chief Guest and Mr. Raghavanda gave away the prizes.

From the board’s room to the pitch, team spirit reigned.

The third kingfisher Cricket concluded with all involved looking forward

for the next cricketing season.

66

Page 67: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

KINGFISHER MAKES A SPASH AT AD-

ASIA IN JAIPUR

The much talked about ad-Asia event was held at Jaipur in the third week

of November 2010.

The seminars, held at the Birla Auditorium, saw participation of nearly

1500 people from all around Asia. Gala dinners were organized at exotic

locales like the City Palace, the ram Bagh Palace, the Jai Mahal Hotel, the

Polo Club and the Gold Palace Resort.

Kingfisher was the exclusive beer brand at this event. Besides having

exclusive bars at each of these venues, it was the most visible brand

through out the event.

All the delegates admired Kingfisher’s ‘Enter the World of Kingfisher’

campaign with Speed Style and Fun.

Kingfisher stole the show in style once again.

KINGFISHER “NO RULES” NIGHT

Pub nights in Delhi on may 6th December just get better with KINGFISHER

BRIGADE adding to the fun. They were nights of interactive fun where the

kingfisher brigade, attractively dressed up in Kingfisher attire entered the

selected pubs in style The Dj’s welcomed the team with the Kingfisher oo-la-la-

67

Page 68: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

jingle. The Kingfisher brigade had its own version of Eric Clapton unplugged,

who obliged the guests with request songs. There were lots of games and

attractive prizes as well.

The event was well supported with regular RJ mentions on RED FM. ‘NO

RULES’ were nights full of fun, frolic, live guitar and Kingfisher.

KINGFISHER COORG TRINGULAR GOLF

TOURNAMENT

The Kingfisher Coorg Triangular Golf Tournament was held at Coorg

from November 15 to 17, 2004.

The USP of the tournament is that it was played at three different

courses-Bittangal, Polibetta and Mercara Downs on three different days.

Over the years this tournament has caught attention of golfers from all

centers of South India.

This year, the tournament showcased 110 participants from Coorg,

Bangalore Mysore, Coimbatore, etc. Each participant enjoyed the game

and had a good time with chilled Kingfisher after the tough game.

In the evening, the prize distribution function was packed with live music

by a Bangalore band, just 4 you.

The golfers enjoyed the music and danced to the tunes till the wee hours.

68

Page 69: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

“CHIKKA BOTTLE KICK TOTAL”

In the spirit of UB’s consistent effort give value to the customer, another

product donned the limelight with the launch of KINGFISHER MINI 250 ml at

Rs.19.

For the first time, strong beer is being made available at this price point.

KINGFISHER MINI is expected to sweep the small strong beer market in

Bangalore before taking on the rest of Karnataka.

The brand was launched with much fanfare and a well planned marketing mix

in terms of both visibility and reach. POP material, Press ads and Hoarding

were provided in order to create mind share for the product. Baichung Bhutia

endorses the brand.

The punch line” CHIKKA BOTTLE KICK TOTAL” was created so that

potential consumers would be able to relate to the brand. Mr. Ramesh

Vishwananthan addressed the press meet at the Taj West End. This launch was

in congruence with UB’s policy of consistently trying to evolve the market in

the wake of its reputation as an industry leader. KFS MINI is well on its way to

break sales records in Bangalore, after which, it will be rolled out into the other

markers of Karnataka.

69

Page 70: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

DJ-KINGFISHER STRONG REMIX NITE AT

AGRA AND LUCKNOW

Kingfisher believes in having fun and doing it in style. So Kingfisher Strong co

produced the Dj-Kingfisher Strong Remix Nite with Dainik Jagran.

The Remix Nite was a series of two events held on December 12, 2004 at

Lucknow and on December 13,2004 at Agra. Dj’s Jack and Harsh turned tables

with style as the crowd thronged the dance floor.

Beautiful Pooja Mishra (of Zee Music fame) mesmerized the crowd with her

cute.

One-liners. Remix numbers were belted out and Kingfisher pint beer was on the

media partner for this event.

KINGFISHER MAGIC AT CONGO

The magical anticipation was finally over on December 6, 2011. Dr. Vijay

Mallya, kicked off the first Congo season in Goa. Spread over an acre of Goa’s

Candolim strip (opposite Kingfisher Villa), Congo promises to be an

adventurous dining experience. Ace designer, Malini Ramani, put together a

special collection for the event based on “The Elements” fire, air and water.

70

Page 71: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

With all the elements in place, Dr. Vijay Mallya, Congo, Kingfisher, Malini

Ramani, India’s top models, choreographers, dancer and performers; it was a

magical night with a charm that will not be forgotten.

Flamboyant Mallya launches Kingfisher airlines

Few Indian industrialists can compete with flamboyant liquor baron Vijay

Mallya when it comes to throwing flashy parties and the launch of his new

airline division Kingfisher Airlines was no exception.

With foot-tapping music, a laser show, food and drinks, Mallya - hailed as

India's own Richard Branson - announced Saturday night his foray into the

country's rapidly growing aviation sector on a day when his only son Siddhartha

turned 18.

It may have been billed as a birthday gift from a doting father to his London-

based son but the head of the diversified UB Group is rearing to make his mark

in the Indian sky after carving out a niche for himself in the liquor business.

After unveiling the red and white Airbus 320-200 amid the bursting of crackers

and loud music, Mallya, 49, said Kingfisher Airlines would begin commercial

operations from Monday.

"Its to the new India that we offer Kingfisher Airlines," said Mallya, chairman

of the Bangalore-headquartered UB Group that makes the largest-selling

Kingfisher beer.

71

Page 72: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Methodology

1. Primary Data: This data is the data of collected in the form

of market survey which was done with the help of

questionnaire’s

a) Questionnaire: I interviewed 30 people for the purpose of

my questionnaires under the guidance of my guide.

2. Secondary Data: Secondary data was collected by going

through various websites which were:

www.yahoo.com

www.expressindia.com

www.hindustantimes.com

www.bacardi.com

72

Page 73: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Information about the U.B. Group was made qualitative

through the United Breweries Ltd Brochure.

3. Sampling Decisions

a) My sample size was 20

b) Sampling method

Random sampling method was used i.e. people were handpicked and no conscious

effort was made.

Questionnaire for Market Research

Name: _____________ Contact No: ________________

Gender: Male Female

Q1 How old are you? ………………………………….

Q2 Which of these best describes your job?Managerial.......................................................Professional......................................................Clerical..............................................................Skilled Trades..................................................Manual worker................................................Student..............................................................Other PLEASE WRITE IN _______________

Q3. Do you buy, drink liquor or visit any liquor outlet at all?Yes.....................................................................No......................................................................

73

Page 74: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Q4. Have you ever seen advertisement of liquor? Yes.................................................................... No……………………………………………

Yes…………………………………………….No……………………………………………..

Q8. Which liquor advertisement do you see frequently? Please Rank accordingly?Beer...................................................................Whisky..............................................................Rum...................................................................Vodka................................................................Jinn....................................................................Breezers............................................................None of these....................................................

Q9. Which products, are these ads actually promoting? Liquor………………………………………… Beer...................................................................Music CDs........................................................Adventure Holidays.........................................Mineral Water.................................................Sports Accessories...........................................Musical Nights.................................................

Yes…………………………………………….

No……………………………………………..

Q11. Where have you seen these ads?Pubs and Bars……………………………………Shopping malls………………………………….Social Gathering…………………………………Five Star Hotels…………………………………T.V………………………………………………Magazines……………………………………….Sports Kit…………………………………….…

74

Page 75: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Other (PLEASE WRITE IN)_________....... Does surrogate ads stimulate your purchase decision for the alone mentioned

brands?Yes………………………………………………No……………………………………………….

ANALYSIS AND GRAPHS

Population: 50 PeopleSample Size: 30 People

Q1. Do you buy, drink liquor or visit any liquor outlet at all?

75

Page 76: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Q2 Have you ever seen advertisement of liquor?

Q3 Do you frequently see the liquor advertisement?

76

Page 77: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Q4 Which one of them you recall the most? Please Specify

77

Page 78: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Q5 Do you know advertising of liquor is banned in India?

78

Page 79: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Q6 Which products, are these ads actually promoting?

79

Page 80: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Q7 Have you seen the advertisement of other product like cigarette, which Is also banned?

Q8 where have you seen these ads?

80

Page 81: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

81

Page 82: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

Conclusion

According to the survey conducted;

a) 50% of the peopled consume liquor

b) 35% did not consume liquor

c) 15% occasionally as rarely consume liquor

2. Most recall liquor ads were of kingfisher, royal stag and

Bacardi cd.

3. 60% of the people have noticed the Bacardi CD ad more than

Mc Dowell’s club soda and mineral water.

4. There was a 100% recall value for the actual liquor product

looking at the surrogate versions.

5. 60% of people agreed that surrogate adjust stimulates their

purchase decision.

6. More than 90% of the people that liquor advertising are

banned in India.

7.More than 50% of the people have seen the ads on T.V. followed

by magazines, shopping malls and bars and pubs.

8.More than 70% of the people said the ads are actually

promoting liquor.

My research objective was to find out that “how successful has

surrogate adverting been in promoting the liquor brand” 60% of

the people have agreed acc to the alone mentioned data that

82

Page 83: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

surrogate advertising has been successful in promoting the liquor

brand.

To second objective is surrogate advertising actually launching a

new product or is it were manipulation of the existing liquor

brands for sales? We get a 100% recall value for the actual liquor

products even though surrogate versions were being mentioned

on T.V.

Hence, I can conclude by saying that surrogate advertising

stimulates of liquor brand is more of a less than a negative aspect

used.

83

Page 84: Impact of Surrogate Advertising on Liquor Sales

BIBLIOGRAPHY

U B Group Brochure, Jan 2011, Issue No. 5

Links

www.bacardi.com,

www.yahoo.com

www.expressindia.com

www.hindustantimes.com, June 2011

www.theubgroup.com

84