impect of global recession on kse
TRANSCRIPT
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY
Impact of Global Rescission on Karachi Stock
Exchange
Final Project/Thesis
Course Code : MKT-606MBA (Banking and Finance)
FACULTY OFMANAGEMENT AND SOCIAL SCIENCES
SPRING - 2011
Institute of Business and Technology1
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all we would like to thank Almighty ALLAH who has guided us the way
for a bright future. We would like to express my gratitude to our teacher and
those who gave me the possibility to complete this thesis.
We are deeply indebted to our teacher Dr. Noor Ahmed Memon whose help,
stimulating suggestions and encouragement helped us in all the time of
research for and writing of this thesis.
We are also thankful to our parents who accommodated us during those long
hours of work in writing Synopsis for Dissertation and all the friends and
colleagues especially our UBL treasury member’s who equally encouraged
us.
We would also like to appreciate the co-operation we got from our classmates
at the institute, which boosted our morale and encouraged us to strive for
better results.
Lastly, we offer my regards and blessings to all of those who supported me in
any respect during the completion of the project.
Mohammad Farhan Shaikh Muhammad Sufyan
Institute of Business and Technology2
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEGEMENT 1ABSTRACT 4
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction 61.2 Purpose of Study 71.3 Research Objectives 71.4 Research Methodology 8
CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Literature Review 11 CHAPTER 3: STOCK EXCHANGE
3.1 History 16 3.2 Mobilizing Savings for Investment 17 3.3 Facilitating Company Growth 17 3.4 Redistribution of Wealth 17 3.5 Corporate Governance 18 3.6 Creating Investment Opportunities for Small Investors 18 3.7 Major Stock Exchange 18 3.8 Contribution to GNP 22 CHAPTER4:KARACHI STOCK EXCHANGE
4.1 Karachi Stock Exchange 234.2 KSE 100 Index 254.3 KSE 30 Index 284.4 KMI 30 324.5 Progress 37
CHAPTER 5: IMPACT OF GLOBAL RECESSION ON KSE
5.1 Global Recession 385.2 Attributes of Recession 395.3 Karachi Stock Market & Recession 395.4 Causes & Effects of recession 445.5 Global Impact on KSE 455.6 Recession & Politics 475.7 Consequences of KSE Recession 52
Institute of Business and Technology3
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
CHAPTER 6: CONCLUSION & RECOMMENDATIONS
6.1 Conclusion 556.2 Recommendations 55
REFERENCES 57
Institute of Business and Technology4
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS AND
TECHNOLOGY
ABSTRACT SUBMITTED BY: Mohammad Farhan
Shaikh Muhammad Sufyan
DISCIPLINE: MBA (Executive)
TITLE OF PROJECT REPORT: Impact of Global Rescission on
Karachi Stock Exchange
MONTH OF SUBMISSION: April, 2011
NAME OF PROJECT SUPERVISOR: Dr. Noor Ahmed Memon
Abstract
This report is covered the information related to the global stock exchange
recession and its overall functions and working procedure. The main influence
of this report is on Karachi Stock Exchange recession, its procedure of
affecting recession on stock and its role that he played in an economy and all
the related aspects are also covered of this report.
The global stock recession that started in the fourth quarter of 2008 is
expected to continue till mid-2010. It has affected almost all countries and
Pakistan as well.
In economics, the term ‘recession’ means "The reduction of a country’s (GDP)
for at least two quarters; or in normal terms, it is a period of reduced economic
activity" The International Monetary Fund regards periods when global growth
is less than 3% to be global recession. On the October 8, 2008, IMF released
its World Economic Outlook, according to which the world economy was
predicted to experience an all time low. While many economists and brokers
alike panicked; some shock their heads in dismay; some just planned on
waiting to see what twisted and interesting things might reap. We in Pakistan,
however, just laughed at the naivety of the IMF, for this prediction did not use
Institute of Business and Technology5
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
to us at all – we were already in the bottom and going to back to worst in it,
and had been so for over a year! Such predictions barely held any ground for
the once 26th largest economy in the world, and 47th largest in terms of the
dollar. It is sad to see our economy like this now, for Pakistan is actually a
very economically diverse country, growing industries of textiles, agriculture,
sports goods, chemicals, food processing, and fishing, to name a few etc. We
were, at one time, one of the top exporters of fish and shrimps to Europe. In
2005, the World Bank said Pakistan as the top reformer in the region; and by
2006 we had managed to decrease our poverty level by 21 %.
Unfortunately, now all these are a thing of the past, for right now is no better
than that of any other under-developed country. The main reason for this
downfall has largely been the political instability over the past few years; there
is no proper economic policies were implemented; at least none that
succeeded. This caused a very high rate of inflation, which, in 2008, had
increased to a whopping 25% as compared to a 7.9% of 2006. In addition to
this, we already had a negative balance of payments, with the quantity of
imports outstripping the quantity of exports. The result was that our main
stock exchange, the Karachi Stock Exchange, became stagnant for the first
time and then declined drastically, and on top of that, Pakistan’s Gross
Domestic Product (GDP) dropped to 4.9% in Pakistan after this declining.
What occurred afterwards is what we call the domino effect. The value of the
Pak Rupee crashed from 60-1 USD to 80-1 USD in only a month, the prices of
commodities soared through the roof, the majority number of people living
below poverty line increased from 60 million to 77 million, and consequently,
the working class layman became virtually deprived from basic necessities
like water, wheat, electricity, natural gas, and cooking oil; add to all this, the
preposterous amounts of load-shedding, and what we get is a nation in
shambles. This is the main reason for declining economy of Pakistan. So are
main influence of this study is that what is the impending of global recession
on Karachi stock exchange? The purpose of this study is to discuss the
various factors impacting negatively or positively in the global recession on
Karachi stock exchange in Pakistan.
Institute of Business and Technology6
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction
A stock exchange, formerly a securities exchange share market or bourse is a
corporation or mutual organization which provides facilities for stock brokers
and trader s, to trade company stocks and other security in stock market.
Stock exchanges also provide facilities for the issue and redemption of
securities as well other financial instruments and capital events including the
payment of income and dividends. The securities traded on a stock exchange
include: shares issued by companies, unit trusts, derivatives, pooled
investment products and bonds. To be able to trade a security on a certain
stock exchange, it has to be listed there. Usually there is a central place at
least for recordkeeping, but trade is less and less linked to such a physical
place, as advance markets are electronic networks, which gives them benefits
of speed and cost of transactions. Trade on an exchange is by members only.
The initial offering of stocks and bonds to investors is by definition done in the
primary market and subsequent trading is done in the secondary market. A
stock exchange is often the most important element of a stock market. Supply
and demand in stock markets are driven by different factors which, as in all
free markets, affect the price of stocks.
There is usually no problem to issue stock via the stock exchange itself, nor
must stock be subsequently traded on the exchange. Such trading is said to
be off exchange or over-the-counter. This is the usual way that derivatives
and bonds are traded. Increasingly, stock exchanges are part of a global
market for securities.1
1.2 Purpose of Study
The main purpose of this study that we work with investments, so we are
particularly concerned with recessions because they can have a very negative
impact on investment account values. We are going to look at the global
recession on KSE with particular focus on how recession affected KSE on
1 Karachi stock exchange2 Theory and evidence from the Karachi stock exchange
Institute of Business and Technology7
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
2008 The main purpose of this study is to highlight the shortcomings present
in different aspects of KSE and suggest the steps to overcome them to
accelerate the development process. As it is discussed above that the current
progress of Karachi Stock Exchange is the result of improvement in the
numbers of factor which are affecting the KSE directly or indirectly, like
political condition of country, regional issues, economical growth, GDP,
inflation rate, financial policies, financial reformation etc. In these factors some
are controllable but some are not or very difficult to control for a developing
country. In this study only three factors or aspects are considered
Which are highly involved in the development of any exchange and also
controllable for the authorities and can be changed according to the situation?
Organizational structure of the Karachi Stock Exchange
Recession on Karachi stock exchange
Impact of global recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
So what is the impact of global recession on Karachi stock exchange? The
purpose of this study is to discuss the various factors impacting negatively or
positively in the global recession on Karachi stock exchange in Pakistan.
1.3 Research Objectives
Through this research we would focus on the following area.
To know about Recession occurred in KSE
To know about impact of recession on KSE
To understand the causes of recession
To know how to measure or control over recession
To know about what has hit KSE during the time of recession
To understand various problems faced by KSE during the time of
recession
To understand the customer attitudes at the time of recession
To understand how Pakistan is hurt because of recession in 2008
1.4 Research Methodology
Institute of Business and Technology8
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
This research study is based on recession and the data taken from KSE
website, and other resources available on internet, The Karachi Stock
Exchange recession study is an explanatory study which is aimed at
explaining the impact of Global crisis and recession on Karachi stock
exchange and what affect it will have on the financial institutions of developing
countries. For this purpose content analysis was technique was used and
several website, research papers and articles related to stock exchange and
development economics were examined. This research initially included
impact of global recession and how stock market was hurt because of
recession in 2008.
As in conceptual analysis, a concept is chosen for examination, and the
analysis involves quantifying and tallying its presence, also known as thematic
analysis. A specific number and set of concepts were examined such as
“effects of global recession on stock and financial crisis”, its “contagion effect”
on “financial institutions” of “developing countries”. In this content analysis the
existence of a concept was examined. Set of rules were defined in this
research regarding the existence of concepts and the linkages between these
concepts.
Data Collection: Research reports, which have already been developed on
global recession and Karachi stock recession, have immense significance and
they will form an integral part of data.
International Review of Business Research Papers Vol. 5 No. 5
September 2009
2nd International conference on business and economic research 2nd
ICBER 2011
International Journal of Business and Social Science Vol. 2 No. 6; April
2011
World applied sciences journal 10 (5): 590-596, 2010
International Research Journal of Finance and Economics ISSN 1450-
2887 Issue 35 (2010) Euro Journals Publishing, Inc. 2010
Institute of Business and Technology9
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
European Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Sciences
ISSN 1450-2275 Issue 14 (2008) Euro Journals, Inc. 2008
Instruments: For collection of primary data, I decided that following
instruments will be used:
1. Questionnaire
2. Interview
3. Observation
Questionnaire: Questionnaires are very flexible as there are many ways to
ask the same questions from different respondents. So, I planned to prepare
questionnaire for
a. People work with investments
b. Treasurers’
c. Stock broker’s
d. People work with stock exchange
Since the focus of the study is to find the factors affecting having the most
significant impact on Karachi stock exchange recession in Pakistan, so, I
decided that the multiple choice questions will be asked from entire set of
respondents. 2
Interview: Personal Interviews are the most reliable source of getting
information from respondents. For this purpose, I shall interview the people
having the most knowledge about stock exchange. Following people will be
contacted on some future time.
a. Stock holders
b. Stock broker’s
c. Economists
2 Theory and evidence on Research Methodology
Institute of Business and Technology10
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
d. Government Officials
Observation: Another instrument that will be used in my study is the
observation. People will be observed thoroughly while conducting interviews
and getting questionnaires filled.
Data Analysis: This section of the report describes the descriptive and
quantitative analysis. Firstly, we provide an analysis of global market
recession under different aspects of recession on Karachi stock exchange
and Appling different models in various odd days as discussed in
methodology part. Secondly, we measure and discuss sector-wise
performance of IPOs under Normal, Boom & Recession period of economy.
Finally, the analysis of this recession is discussed on yearly base.
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
Institute of Business and Technology11
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
2.1 Literature Review
The Karachi Stock Exchange or KSE Situated in Karachi, Sindh, Pakistan. Founded
in 1947, it is Pakistan's largest and oldest stock exchange, with many Pakistani as
well as overseas listings. It is current premises are situated on Karachi Stock
Exchange Road, in the heart of Karachi's Business District.
Karachi Stock Exchange is the biggest and most liquidity exchange in Pakistan. It
was declared the "Best Performing Stock Market of the World for the year 2002". As
of Dec 8, 2009, 654 companies were listed with a market capitalization of Rs. 8.561
trillion (US$ 120.5 billion) having listed capital of Rs. 2805.873 billion (US$ 40.615
billion). The KSE 100TM Index closed at 9645.71 on June 19, 2010.By 30 July total
market capitalization of the KSE reached Rs2.95 trillion, approximately 350 billion
dollars.
The exchange has pre-market sessions from 09:15am to 09:30am and normal
trading sessions from 09:30am to 03:30pm. The Karachi stock exchange has
undergone a considerable deal of downturn partly due to global financial crisis and
partly on account of domestic troubles. It remained suspended in excess of 4 months
and resumed normal trading only on December 15, 2008. The KSE 100 Index and
KSE 30 Index after hitting the low around mid January has now rebounded and
recovered 20-25% till March 12, 2009. By 30 July 2010 total market capitalization of
the KSE reached Rs2.95 trillion, approximately 35 billion dollars. It was newly
appointed in 18th September 1948.
The KSE is the biggest and most liquid exchange in Pakistan and in 2002 it was
Foreign buying interest had been very active on the KSE in 2006 and continued in
2007. According to estimates from the State Bank of Pakistan, foreign investment in
capital markets total about US$523 Million. According to a research analyst in
Pakistan, around 20pc of the total free float in KSE-30 Index is held by foreign
participants.
Institute of Business and Technology12
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
KSE has seen some fluctuations since the start of 2008.KSE Board of Directors has
recently (2007) announced plans to construct a forty story high rise KSE building, as
a new direction for future investment.
Disputes between investors and members of the Exchange are resolved through
deliberations of the Arbitration Committee of the Stock Exchange.
Karachi Stock Exchange began with a 50 shares index. As the market grew a
representative index was needed. On November 1, 91 the KSE-100 was introduced
and remains to this day the most generally accepted measure of the Exchange.
Karachi Stock Exchange 100 Index (KSE-100 Index) is a benchmark used to
compare prices overtime, companies with the highest market capitalization are
selected. To ensure full market representation, the company with the highest market
capitalization from each sector is also included.
In 1995 the need was felt for an all share index to reconfirm the KSE-100 and also to
provide the basis of index trading in future. On August the 29th, 1995 the KSE all
share index was constructed and introduced on September 18, 1995.
World announced the Karachi Stock Exchange is the best performing world stock
market in 2002. Since then the KSE keep on maintaining the reputation as one of the
best performing markets in the world.
Since 1991, foreign investors have an equal opportunity together with local investors
to operate in the secondary capital market on the Karachi Stock Exchange. The
establishment of the new policy for foreign investors and initiated privatization in
Pakistan has accelerated the development of the KSE, which had even 663
companies listed in 2006. In addition, companies have a choice to be listed on one of
the two markets - the ready market and the over-the-counter (OTC) market, which
has lesser listing requirements. While the ready market requires listing companies to
have minimum paid up capital of Rs 200 million (about UK 1.8 m), the companies
with minimum of Rs 100 million can be listed on the OTC market.
The Karachi Stock Exchange trades the KSE-100 Index. It is a highly-diversified
index of 100 largest capitalization companies' stocks from all sectors of Pakistan
Institute of Business and Technology13
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
economy. A constantly revised index is a good indicator of the overall Exchange
performance over a period of time. In 2005, 88% of the KSE total market
capitalization was represented by the KSE-100 Index.
The membership in the Karachi Stock Exchange is limited. Only 200 individual and
corporate entities can register as members in the KSE. In 2005, 162 members
traded actively on the Exchange. In addition, foreign corporate entities may also
become the members of the KSE with the condition that the nominee member of the
company is a citizen of Pakistan.
Its been for some time that the Karachi Stock Exchange has been ‘frozen’ for official
trading when on 28th August fearing a massive flight of capital the movers and
shakers of KSE set a Floor-Price-Level at 9144.93 points which was the KSE index
as of the last trading session on August 27th. The one month embargo was
extended even further.
Its been widely reported that many of the stalwarts of our stock market are practically
on their knees pleading the government for a bailout plan. As an outsider with little
insights on the specifics of this lucrative industry I feel there are two sides to the
argument. The investor with some stake in the stock market vehemently advocates
the implementation of the bailout package arguing that its geared up confidence
building measure trying to prevent the flight of the hefty foreign investor.
While the other side of the argument, advocated mostly by the layperson is to urge
the government to focus their attention towards other pressing issues in the country,
as they see these stock market goons as gamblers, who enjoyed the rewards in the
last three years, and suddenly when the gambling gave way are coming back to ask
for more money to help them resume
Admittedly my arguments may only represent a cursory analysis of a very complex
problem but I would like to use this opportunity to open this blog for the experts who
may help shed light on what is the best solution out of this mess, more along the
lines of what’s best for Pakistan and not making the rich richer
Institute of Business and Technology14
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
In economics, the term ‘recession’ means "The reduction of a country’s Gross
Domestic Product (GDP) for at least two quarters; or in normal terms, it is a period of
reduced economic activity".
Capitalism and Interest Based financial System are the root causes of world financial
system’s failure. It is going to convert into economic crisis. If it is not going to handle
properly, its results may be more adverse than Great Depression. Pakistan was in
crisis right from the beginning but financial crisis is increasing its rate of knots.
Financial crisis is one of the major challenges of 21st century. It is not only parting
negative impact on US but several rich countries' financial systems are also
trembling under its weight. Economies of major world including Pakistan are at high
level of risk. This crisis is also pointing fingers on the capitalistic companies and
banks, which somehow are bigger than many countries.
Pakistan was in crisis from the beginning of year 2007, but financial crisis triggered
this crisis and situation is going to worst. Pakistan is passing from crucial phase of its
life. Crisis in Pakistan was started when former President Pervez Musharraf
suspended Supreme Court Chief Justice. Later on Lal Masjid incident took place
which throughout Pakistan created huge tension because after this incident chain of
suicide attacks started in the country, which has not been ended as yet.
In large part due to fuel subsidies and other economic obligations, Pakistan's budget
deficit of $21 billion is the highest in a decade, and the current account deficit is 8.4
percent of GDP. In all of Asia, Pakistan has the highest interest rates, least valuable
currency, and riskiest financial obligations. As a result, Pakistani government debt is
considered one of the riskiest in the world.
Pakistan's currency, the rupee, has lost 20 percent against the falling dollar and is
now near record lows. The Karachi Stock Exchange—Pakistan's oldest and largest
stock exchange—has lost 40 percent of its value since April 2008. Just last August,
the KSE put a floor on the index to keep shares from falling even further.
Pakistan foreign currency reserves have dropped significantly due to the unstable
political and security situation. In less than a year, Pakistan's foreign reserves have
Institute of Business and Technology15
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
dropped from an all-time high of $14 billion last November to just under $6 billion
today. Pakistan has taken loan from International Monetary Fund (IMF) on harsh
terms and conditions to meet crisis. But financial crisis will be adverse due to this aid
because terms are directing Pakistan, not to support their financial sector.
Aid from USA and foreign remittance are one of the main contributions towards
current account balance of Pakistan. But after the financial crisis, American aid
stopped and foreign remittances to Pakistan also showing steep decline.
All the bailouts and nationalizations are not the permanent solutions to this financial
crunch. It may be possible that we will get rid of this crisis in few months or few
years, but it will again come and hit the economies and challenge the financial
systems of the world. We have to address the roots of this crisis. Basically all the
financial systems of the world revolve around "Capitalism" and "Interest", which will
somehow always invite such big recessions in the days to come.The basic economic
statistics paint a dire picture. Two-thirds of the Pakistani population lives on less than
$2 a day, with one-third of the population living below the poverty line. While the
Pakistani economy expanded 5.8 percent in the last fiscal year, this rate of economic
growth was the slowest since 2003 and is expected to fall to 4.6 percent this year.
But the benefits of this economic growth have not reached the vast majority of
Pakistanis.
The newly elected government faces interlinked challenges: tackling emboldened
militant groups and terrorist organizations, advancing political reform, and stabilizing
the economy. If Pakistan's economy experiences further collapse, the government
could lose further support of the people. Experts are saying that Karachi Stock
Exchange, one of the worst hit Stock Exchanges of the world in the financial
recession, has finally pulled through and that 3investors will make millions. Let us all
hope that this proves to be true and the now 'broke' stock-'Brokers’ finally recover
from this nightmare.
3 International Review of Business Research Papers Vol. 5 No. 5 September 2009
2nd International conference on business and economic research 2nd ICBER 2011
European Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Sciences
Institute of Business and Technology16
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
3. STOCK EXCHANGE
3.1 History
The Karachi Stock Exchange, the oldest exchange in Pakistan, KSE was
established in 1947 and became a registered company limited after a few
years later. Since then it has been experienced a remarkable progress with
only 5 companies listed and 90 members on the Exchange in the 1950s and
663 listed companies and 200 members in 2006.
In 2002, the Karachi Stock Exchange was recognized internationally by the
magazine 'Business Week' as one of the best performing stock exchange in
the world.
The Karachi Stock Exchange has started trading through the computerized
trading system KATS (Karachi Automated Trading System) since 1997. As
the need for Trading Workstations installation has been significant during the
consecutive years, today over 1000 KATS workstations are already installed.
In 2005, trading in the Internet was also started.
Since 1990, corporate entities can become members on the Karachi Stock
Exchange. However, they have to face stringent requirements of the Board of
Directors and own a minimum capital of Rs. 20 million (approximately UK
181,000).At the beginning of 2006, 120 corporate members were registered in
Stock Exchange.
The Karachi Stock Exchange introduced KSE-50 Index at the end of the 20th
century. However, just because of the growth in the stock market, the Index
did not represent the stock market performance anymore. Thus, in 1991 a
capital weighted KSE 100 Index launched. At the moment, the Exchange
successfully trades two world-famous indices KSE 100 Index and KSE All
Share Index, which was introduced in 1995. Karachi Stock Exchange is the
biggest and most liquid exchange and has been declared as the “Best
Performing Stock Market of the World for the year 2002”. As on May 30, 2008,
654 companies were listed with a market capitalization of Rs. 3,746.203 billion
Institute of Business and Technology17
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
(US$ 56.334 billion) having listed capital of Rs. 705.873 billion (US$ 10.615
billion).
History Graph of KSE 100 Index
Source Karachi stock exchange history
3.2 Mobilizing Savings for Investment
When people draw their savings and invest in shares, it leads to a more
rational allocation of resources because funds, which could have been
consumed, or kept in idle deposits with banks, are mobilized and redirected to
promote business activity with benefits for several economic sectors such as
agriculture, commerce and industry, resulting in stronger economic growth
and higher productivity levels and firms.
3.3 Facilitating Company Growth
Companies view acquisitions as an opportunity to expand product lines,
increase distribution channels, hedge against volatility, increase its market
share, or acquire other necessary business assets. A takeover bid or a
merger agreement through the stock market is one of the simplest and most
common ways for a company to grow by acquisition or fusion.
Institute of Business and Technology18
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
3.4 Redistribution of Wealth
Stock exchanges do not exist to redistribute wealth. However, both casual
and professional stock investors, through dividends and stock price increases
that may result in capital gains, will share in the wealth of profitable
businesses.
3.5 Corporate Governance
By having a wide and varied scope of owners, companies generally tend to
improve on their management standards and efficiency in order to satisfy the
demands of these shareholders and the more stringent rules for public
corporations imposed by public stock exchanges and the government.
Consequently, it is alleged that public companies (companies that are owned
by shareholders who are members of the general public and trade shares on
public exchanges) tend to have better management records than privately-
held companies (those companies where shares are not publicly traded, often
owned by the company founders and/or their families and heirs, or otherwise
by a small group of investors). However, some well-documented cases are
known where it is alleged that there has been considerable slippage in
corporate governance on the part of some public companies. The dot-com
bubble in the early 2000s, and the subprime mortgage crisis in 2007-08, are
classical examples of corporate mishandled. Companies like Pets.com
(2000), Enron Corporation (2001), One.Tel (2001), Sunbeam (2001), Web van
(2001), Adelphia (2002), MCI WorldCom (2002), Parmalat (2003), American
International Group (2008), Lehman Brothers (2008), and Satyam Computer
Services (2009) were among the most widely scrutinized by the media.
3.6 Creating Investment Opportunities for Small investor
As opposed to other businesses that need huge capital outlay, investing in
shares is open to both the large and small stock investors because a person
buys the number of shares they can easily afford. Therefore the Stock
Exchange gives the opportunity for small investors to own shares of the same
companies as large investors
Institute of Business and Technology19
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
3.7 Contribution to GNP
To assess the relationship between stock markets’ development, and
economic growth in a small developing economy like Pakistan, we used the
log-linear model as follows:
(1)
Where; =Log of real Gross national product per capita, = Market
Capitalization (the amount of capital as share of GDP proxies by stock market
development) = Log of Financial Development (proxies by credit to
private sector as share of GDP), = Log of Financial Instability
(measured by standard deviation of the inflation rates), = Log of Inflation
Rate, = Log of Foreign Direct Investment (in millions of dollars) as share
of GDP, = Log of Literacy Rate (the ratio of the number of people
completing primary education to total population). The reason for taking log is
that taking the natural logarithm of a series effectively laniaries the
exponential trend (if any) in the time series data since the log function is the
inverse of an exponential function (Asteroid and Price, 2007).
Table-1: Theory Intuition and Expected Signs
Variable Theory intuition Expected sign
Market Capitalization
Improvement in the efficiency and
size of stock markets will circulate as
cholesterol in the process of
economic growth positively.
+
Financial Development
The expected sign of increase in
credit to private sector spurs the
economic activity in the economy
through their causal channels.
+
Financial Instability
Financial instability induces to decline
the investment activities directly and
indirectly that deters the economic
growth
-
Institute of Business and Technology20
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Inflation Rate Inflation measures the monetary
instability that affects the economic
performance through its detrimental
impacts.
-
Foreign Direct Investment
Economic growth is expected to be
influenced positively by FDI along
with spillover effects through
employment generating process.
+
Literacy Rate
Higher literacy rate improves the
efficiency of an economy by
providing more productive labor
force.
+
Annual data of all variables have been collected from World Development
Indicators database (WDI, 2006), World Bank, Economic Survey of Pakistan
in (2006), and International Financial Statistics (IFS, 2006).
Descriptive statistics and correlation matrix of the variables of our selected
model are expressed in Table 2a and 2b respectively.
Table-2a
Descriptive Statistics
VariablesReal GNP Per
Capita
Market Capitaliz
ation
Credit-Private
FDI Financial
Instability
Inflation
Literacy Rate
Observations 36 36 36 36 36 36 36 Std. Dev. 0.356 4.226 0.128 0.942 1.264 0.549 0.236 Skewness -0.150 2.684 -0.559 -0.649 -0.319 0.192 -0.188 Kurtosis 3.259 10.697 3.687 2.605 2.308 2.653 1.912 Sum 332.880 88.462 115.192 -32.151 131.818 71.733 123.360 Sum Sq. Dev. 4.319 607.466 0.562 30.179 54.395 10.250 1.901
Institute of Business and Technology21
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Table 2b
Correlation matrix
Real GNP per capita
1.000Market Capitalization
0.7303 1.000Credit-Private 0.7718 0.4207 1.000FDI 0.8397 0.5518 0.6083 1.000
Financial Instability -0.5058 -0.3936 -0.3458 -0.4959 1.000Inflation -0.5194 -0.1804 -0.5228 -0.2538 0.1444 1.000Literacy Rate 0.9252 0.6873 0.7100 0.8673 -0.3781 -0.4090 1.000
*The data has been collected from international monetary financial statistics
database (IFS) for Pakistan4
4 Theory and history about of Karachi stock exchange
Institute of Business and Technology22
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
3.8 Major Stock Exchange in the World
Region Stock Exchange Market Value(millions USD)
Total Share Turnover (millions USD)
AfricaJohannesburg Securities Exchange
432,422.1 17,999.7
Americas NASDAQ 2,203,759.6 2,325,238.3
Americas São Paulo Stock Exchange 611,695.0 30,748.5
Americas Toronto Stock Exchange 997,997.4 84,323.0
Americas New York Stock Exchange 9,363,074.0 1,517,615.7
Asia-Pacific
Australian Securities Exchange 587,602.7 37,400.1
Asia-Pacific
Bombay Stock Exchange 613,187.6 14,425.0
Asia-Pacific
Hong Kong Stock Exchange 1,237,999.5 80,696.8
Asia-Pacific
Korea Exchange 470,417.3 81,755.0
Asia-Pacific
National Stock Exchange of India 572,566.8 39,057.1
Asia-Pacific
Shanghai Stock Exchange 1,557,161.3 142,144.2
Asia-Pacific
Shenzhen Stock Exchange 389,248.3 75,365.5
Asia-Pacific
Tokyo Stock Exchange 2,922,616.3 301,781.5
Europe Euro next 1,862,930.9 146,173.3
EuropeFrankfurt Stock Exchange (Deutsche Borse)
937,452.9 264,970.3
Europe London Stock Exchange 1,758,157.7 241,151.1
EuropeMadrid Stock Exchange (Bolsas y Mercados Españoles)
871,061.4 114,994.0
EuropeMilan Stock Exchange (Borsa Italiana)
456,206.7 48,094.8
EuropeNordic Stock Exchange Group OMX1 503,725.8 55,299.9
Europe Swiss Exchange 761,896.1 63,435.6
Institute of Business and Technology23
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
4. KARACHI STOCK EXCHANGE
4.1 Karachi Stock Exchange
The Karachi Stock Exchange (KSE) is the largest and most liquid of the three
stock exchanges in Pakistan. The KSE was established on 18th September
1947. It became a Limited Company by Guarantee on 10th March 1949.
There were initially 09 members and only five companies were listed with a
paid up capital of Rs. 37 million. The scale of operations has grown
substantially over the years. As of June 30, 2006 there were 652 listed
companies with a listed capital of Rs. 517,904.11 million (US$ 8,511.16
million) and a market capitalization of Rs. 2,942,739.59 million (US$
48,360.55 million). The daily turnover on average is 270.50 million shares with
average daily trade value being Rs. 32,869.61 million (US$ 540.17 million).
Membership strength has gone to 200. The representation index for the
market is the KSE 100 index, a capital weighted index initiated on November
1, 1991 which represents about 90% of the market capitalization of the Stock
Exchange. In 1995 the need was felt for an all share index to reconfirm the
KSE-100 and also to provide the basis of index trading in future. On August
29, 1995 the KSE all share index was constructed and introduced on
September18, 1995. (Table 1)
Some major sectors of the economy contributed extraordinary to the
performance of the stock exchange market during 2007-08. These sectors
include fuel and energy, banks and financial institutions, transport and
communication, and chemicals and pharmaceuticals (Table 2).
Institute of Business and Technology24
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Table 1: Profile of Karachi Stock Exchange
2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08Number of Listed companiesNew Companies listedFund Mobilized (Rs billion)Listed Capital (Rs billion)Turnover of shares (billion)Average Daily Turnover of Shares (million)Average Market Capitalization (Rs billion)
65915
54.0438.588.3
351.9
2068.2
65814
41.4496.0104.7319.6
2801.2
65812
49.7631.168.8
211.0
4019.4
6525
49.2690.156.9
265.7
4622.9
Source: Pakistan Economic Survey 2007-08
Table 2: Scrotal Performance on Karachi Stock Exchange
Sector General Index(%)
Market Capitaliz
ation(%)
(ACM)*
(Rs Billion)
2006-
07
2006-07 2007** 2008**
1.Cotton and other Textiles2.Chemicals and Pharmaceuticals3. Engineering4. Auto and Allied5. Cables and Electrical Goods6. Sugar and Allied7. Papers and Boards8. Cement9. Fuel and Energy10.Transport and Communication11.Banks and Financial Institutions12.Miscellaneous Change
-3.218.949.829.718.23.027.711.09.244.040.97.528.2
38.023.465.945.235.912.348.324.41.435.8
117.362.743.9
103.3241.415.092.020.017.124.0
129.91098.2244.91341.8241.3
----
153.9369.928.6
100.526.520.638.6
156.61267.4241.91965.1286.5------
* Aggregate Market Capitalization; ** End April
Source: Pakistan Economic Survey, 2007-08
Decade wise Progress: The following is a decade wise progress of the
stock index since its incorporation in 1947: Year no: of listed companies
Institute of Business and Technology25
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
listed capital (Rs. in million) Market Capitalizing (Rs. in millions)
(1) 1950 : 15 117.3 -
(2) 1960 : 81 1,007.7 1,871.4
(3) 1970 : 291 3,864.6 5,658.1
(4) 1980 : 314 7,630.2 9,767.3
(5) 1990 : 487 28,056.0 61,750.0
(6) 2000 :762 236,458.5 382,730.5
The KSE is run by a Board of Directors that consists of 10 members including
the Managing Director. Out of these, 5 Directors are elected from the 200
members of the Stock Exchange and 4 non-member Directors are nominated
and appointed by the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan
(SECP) from amongst the professionals belonging to various trades and
professions. The SECP is also the overall regulatory body over the KSE as
well as the rest of the Stock Exchanges in Pakistan. The Chairman of the
Board is elected by the Board from amongst the non-member Directors. The
operational and administrative activities of the Exchange are managed by the
Managing Director who is also the Chief Executive of the Exchange.
4.2 KSE 100 Index
The KSE 100TM Index was introduced in 1991 and comprises of 100
companies selected on the basis of sector representation and highest
market capitalization, which captures over 80% of the total market
capitalization of the companies listed on the Stock Exchange. Out of 35
Sectors, 34 companies are selected i.e., one company from each
Sector (excluding Open-End Mutual Fund) on the basis of the large
market capitalization and the remaining 66 companies are selected on
the basis of highest market capitalization. This is a total return index i.e.
dividend, bonus and rights are adjusted. The same methodology is
applicable in the case of All Share Index, which includes all the listed
companies, (except Open-End Mutual Funds).
Most recognized index of the Karachi Stock Exchange
Institute of Business and Technology26
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Representation from all sectors of the KSE and includes the largest
companies on the basis of their market capitalization
Represents over 85% of the market capitalization of the Exchange.
Objective: The primary objective of the KSE-100 index is to have a
benchmark by which the stock price performance can be compared to over a
period of time. In particular, the KSE-100 is designed to provide investors with
a sense of how the Pakistan equity market is performing. Thus, the KSE100 is
similar to other indicators that track various sectors of the Pakistan economic
activity such as the gross national product, consumer price index, etc.
Brief About KSE-100 Index: The KSE-100 Index was introduced in
November 1999 with base value of 1,000 points. The Index comprises of 100
companies selected on the basis of sector representation and highest market
capitalization, which captures the over 80% of the total market capitalization
of the companies listed on the Stock Exchange. Out of the following 35
Sectors, 34 companies are selected i.e. one company from each sector
(excluding Open-End Mutual Fund Sector) on the basis of the largest market
capitalization and the remaining 66 companies are selected on the basis of
largest market capitalization in descending order. This is a total return index
i.e. dividend, bonus and rights are adjusted.
List of KSE Sectors
1 .Open-end Mutual Funds 19 Oil & Gas Marketing Companies
2 .Close-end Mutual Funds 20 Oil & Gas Exploration Companies
3 .Modarabas 21 Engineering
Institute of Business and Technology27
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
4 .Leasing Companies 22 Automobile Assembler
5 .Investment Banks/Inv. Cos./Securities Cos. 23 Automobile Parts
6 .Commercial Banks 24 Cables & Electric Goods
7 .Insurance 25 Transports
8 .Textile Spinning 26 Technology & Communication
9 .Textiles Weaving 27 Fertilizers
10 .Textile Composite 28 Pharmaceuticals
11 .Woolen 29 Chemical
12 .Synthetic & Rayon 30 Paper & Board
13 .Jute 31 Vanaspati & Allied Industries
14 .Sugar & Allied Industries 32 Leather & Tanneries
15 .Cement 33 Food & Personal Care Products
16 .Tobacco 34 Glass & Ceramics
17 .Refinery 35 Miscellaneous
18 .Power Generation & Distribution
Calculation Methodology: In the simplest form, the KSE-100 index is a
basket of price and the number of shares outstanding. His value of the basket
is regularly compared to a starting point or a base period. In our case, the
period is 1st November, 1991. To make the computation simple, the total
market value of the period has been adjusted to 1000 points.
Thus, the total market value of the base period has even assigned a value of
1000 points. example of how the KSE-100 Index is calculated can be
demonstrated by using a three-stock ample. Table 1 illustrates the process.
First, a starting point is selected and the initial value of the here-stock index
set equal to 1000.
Taking stock As share price of Rs. 20 and multiplying it by its total common
shares outstanding of 50 million in the base period provides a market value of
one billion Rupees. This calculation is repeated for stocks B and Stock C with
the resulting market values of three and six billion Rupees, respectively.
The three market values are added up, or aggregated, and set equal to 1000
to form the base period value. All future market values will be compared to
base period market value in indexed form.
Institute of Business and Technology28
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
4.3 KSE 30 Index
The primary objective of the KSE-30 Index is to have a benchmark by which
the stock price performance can be compared to over a period of time. In
particular, the KSE-30 Index is designed to provide investors with a sense of
how large company’s scrip’s of the Pakistan’s equity market are performing.
Thus, the KSE-30 Index will be similar to other indicators that track various
sectors of country’s economic activity such as the gross national product,
consumer price index, etc.
Globally, the Free-float Methodology of index construction is considered to be
an industry best practice and all major index providers like MSCI, FTSE, S&P,
STOXX and SENSEX have adopted the same. MSCI, a dominating global
index provider, shifted all its indices to the Free-float Methodology in 2002.
KSE-30 Index is calculated using the “Free-Float Market Capitalization”
methodology. In accordance with methodology, the level of index at any point
of time reflects the free-float market value of 30 companies in relation to the
base period. The free-float methodology refers to an index construction
methodology that takes into account only the market capitalization of free float
shares of a company for the purpose of index calculation.
Free-float Methodology improves index flexibility in terms of inclusion any
stock from all the listed stocks. This improves market coverage and sector
coverage of the index. For example, under a Full-Market Capitalization
Methodology, companies with large market capitalization and low free-float
can be included in the stock Index. However, under the Free-float
Methodology, since only the free-float market capitalization of each company
is considered for index calculation, it becomes difficult to include closely held
companies in the stock index during at the same time preventing their undue
influence on the index movement.
Introduced in 2006
Based on the “Free Float Methodology”
Includes only the top 30 most liquid companies listed on the KSE.
Institute of Business and Technology29
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Free - Float Methodology: Free-Float means to say proportion of total
number of shares issued by a company that are readily available for trading at
the Stock Exchange. It generally excludes the shares held by controlling
directors / sponsors / promoters, government and other locked-in shares not
available for trading in the normal course.
Objective and Description: Free-Float calculation can be utilized to
construct stock indices for the betterment of market representation than those
constructed on the basis of total market capitalization of companies.
• It gives weight for constituent companies as per their actual liquidity in the
market and is not unduly influenced by tightly held large-cap companies.
• Free-Float can be used by the Exchange for regulatory purposes such as
risk management and market surveillance.
Determining Free-Float Factor: The listed companies shall be submitted
their pattern of shareholding, in the prescribed manner, to the Stock
Exchange. The Exchange will determine the Free-Float Factor for each such
company. Free-Float Factor is a multiple with which the total market
capitalization of a company is adjusted to arrive at the Free-Float market
capitalization. Once the Free-Float of a company is determined, it is rounded-
off to the top multiple of 5 and each company is categorized into one of the 20
bands given below.
Pre – Requisites to Qualify for Inclusion in KSE-30 Index:
1. The Company which is on the Defaulters’ Counter and/or its trading is
suspended, declared Non-Tradable (i.e. NT) in preceding 6 months
from the date of recomposition will not be considered for inclusion in
KSE-30 Index;
2. The Company will be eligible for KSE-30 Index if its securities are
available in the Central Depository System;
3. The Company should have been formal listing history of at least two
months on KSE;
Institute of Business and Technology30
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
4. The company should have an operational track record of at least one
financial year and it should not be in default(s) of the Listing
Regulations;
5. The Company should have been minimum free-float shares of 5% of
total outstanding shares;
6. The Company should be eligible for KSE-30 Index if its securities are
traded for 75% of the total trading days;
7. The Open-End and Closed-End Mutual Funds will not be eligible for
inclusion in the KSE-30 Index;
Selection Criteria: The companies which qualify the prerequisites will be
selected on the term of highest marks obtained as per the following criteria:
Free-Float Market Capitalization: The scrip should be included in the Top
Companies, ranked on the terms of free-float market capitalization.
The free-float market capitalization for each company is calculated by
multiplying its total outstanding free-float shares with the closing market price
on the day of composition / re-composition.
Liquidity: The scrip included in the top companies should also be
characterized by adequate liquidity i.e. transaction cost and one of the
practical, fact and accurate measures of market liquidity is Impact Cost. It is
defined as the cost of executing a transaction in a given stock for a specific
predefined order size of fixed rupee amount (currently set to Rs. 500,000).
The transaction cost referred here is not the fixed cost typically incurred in
terms of transaction charges or cost arising through CDC; rather it is the cost
attributable to the market liquidity, which comes from buyers and sellers in the
market. Average of the best bid price and the best offer price of a scrip at any
time, called ideal price, is considered as the best price to trade in that
particular scrip at that time. However, every buyer and seller suffers a cost in
excess of this ideal price while actually executing a transaction (buy or sell).
This price movement from the real price is known as the transaction cost and
when measured as the percentage of real price is called Impact Cost.
Institute of Business and Technology31
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Under impact cost analysis high liquidity is represented by low impact cost. A
stock with high market capitalization cannot be assumed to be liquid just
because of its sheer size. Some large market capitalization stocks are in
reality very illiquid. Similarly, high trading volumes, in themselves, are not
enough to confirm consistent liquidity of a stock.
Impact cost analysis looks at the order book of each stock market throughout
the whole trading day and based on the bids and offers calculates impact
costs in terms of percentages for each instance of the order book.
The Impact Cost of each security is calculated as described hereunder:
• First the impact of cost is calculated separately for the buy and the sell side
in each order book for past six months.
• The buy side impact cost (or the sell side impact cost) is the simple average
of the buy side impact cost (or the sell side impact cost) computed in the last
six months.
• Impact Cost of reckoned for the purpose of all computation is the mean of
such buy side impact cost and sell side impact cost.
Final Rank: The scrip should include in Top Thirty companies on the basis of
final ranking. The final rank is arrived by assigning 50% weightage on the
basis of free-float market capitalization and 50% weightage to the liquidity
based on Impact Cost of the securities. The security having highest free-float
stock market capitalization and lowest Impact cost is assigned full marks and
the marks for rest of the securities are calculated proportionately.
Selection of 30 companies for inclusion in the KSE-30 Index: The
companies selected for inclusion in the KSE-30 Index are determined on the
basis of "Free-Float Market Capitalization" methodology. As per this
methodology, the level of Index at any point of time reflects the free-float
market value of thirty component stocks related to a base period. The market
capitalization of a company is determined by the multiplying price of its stock
by the number of free float shares determined for the purpose.
4.4 KMI-30
Introduced in September 2008
Institute of Business and Technology32
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
KMI comprises of thirty stock Companies that quality the KMI Shariah
screening criteria and are weighted by float adjusted market
capitalization.
12% cap on weights of individual securities.
Rebalancing of the Index will be done bi-annually.
Shariah Supervisory Board of Meezan Bank chaired by eminent
Shariah scholar Justice (Retd.) Mufti Muhammad Taqi Usmani.
A total return Index based on free float methodology
The objective of KSE-Meezan Index (KMI) is to serve as a gauge for
measuring the performance of Shariah compliant equity investments. It may
also act as a research tool for the Impact Costively of purposes in the
strategic asset allocation process. Besides tracking performance of the
Shariah compliant equities, its construction will increase investor trust and
enhance their participation.
Currently, the three indices being maintained at the Karachi Stock Exchange
are KSE-100 Index, KSE All-Share Index, and KSE-30 Index. The KSE-100
and KSE All Share Indices are market capitalization indices while KSE-30
Index is based on free-float capitalization.
The free-float methodology of index construction is being considered as the
best thing by all major index providers including MSCI, FTSE, S&P, STOXX,
and SENSEX, because it results in a performance measurement of stocks
that are readily accessible and well traded.
KSE-Meezan Index is also calculated using the “Free-Float Market
Capitalization”, wherein, the level of index at any certain point in time reflects
the free-float market value of the selected Shariah compliant shares in relation
to the base period. The free-float methodology refers to an index construction
methodology that takes into account only the market capitalization of free-float
shares of a company for the purposes of index calculation. The free-float
capitalization of the Islamic stock index constituents will be capped in relation
to the overall capitalization of Islamic index at 12% on the first day of
composition. At all subsequent re-compositions dates, any constituent
Institute of Business and Technology33
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
breaching this limit will thus be brought in line with this requirement. Any
surplus free-float capitalization will be distributed to the remaining companies
according to their relative capitalization in the index.
Free Float Methodology: Free-Float of a security is defined as the proportion
of total shares outstanding that are deemed available for buying in the Stock
Exchange. Therefore, it generally excludes the shares held by controlling
directors / sponsors / promoters, government and other locked-in shares is
not issuing for trading in the normal course.
Free-Float methodology reflect the true picture of liquidity present in the
market, hence the index movement is unbiased move towards the closely
held companies, High net-worth individuals, speculators, and hedgers, will
use the free float number for framing trading strategies, while regulatory
bodies may utilize these numbers for effective risk management and market
surveillance to minimize market manipulation incidences.
Not with standing to the above calculations, under no circumstances what so
ever, free-float of scrip shall exceed its book entry shares, available in the
Central Depository System. Share held by investors that would not, under
normal circumstances, be available in the market for trading shall be treated
as “Controlling / Strategic Holdings” and shall under no circumstances
whatsoever, be included in the Free-Float. Shares held by promoters,
directors, acquirers for the purpose of maintaining control, whether or not
related to Government, or held by associated groups in terms of cross-holding
or any shares which precisely cannot be sold in the open market shall
preclude such numbers while determining the free-float.
Determining the Free Float: Listed companies will be submitting their pattern
of shareholding in the prescribed manner to support the Exchange determine
a Free-Float Factor. Free-Float Factor is a multiple with which the overall
market capitalization of a company is adjusted to arrive at its Free-Float
market capitalization. The screened list of Shariah compliant securities will be
provided by the Al Meezan Investment Management Limited to provide its
Shariah screening services. Once the equity is approved by Shariah Board
and is included in the horizon for Islamic Index, its free-float is rounded-off to
Institute of Business and Technology34
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
the higher multiple of five and each company is categorized into one of the 20
bands.
Eligibility Criteria
Screening Filters: The companies whose primary business is related to any
of the following areas or Business Segments will not be eligible for inclusion in
the Islamic Index.
Conventional Banks and other Financial Institutions that are totally
engaged in interest related activities.
Enterprises having gambling or Alcohol also as a part of their concern.
Cable Networks, entertainment channels, advertising and media with
exception to the concerns engaged in the business for the news
dissemination.
Arms Manufacturing
Conventional Insurance both Life and General
Concerns involved in producing or financing concerns, which produce
Non-Halal Food or perform any activity relating to packaging and
processing of such foods items those are Non-Halal.
Determination of financial ratios after its discussion with the Sharia-
board
The Company which is on the Defaulters’ Counter and/or its trading is
suspended, declared Non-Tradable (i.e. NT) in preceding 6 months
from the date of re-composition shall not be considered for inclusion in
KMI-30 Index;
The Company will be eligible for KMI-30 Index if its securities are
available in the Central Depository System;
The Company should have a formal listing history of at least two
months on KSE;
The company must have an operational track record of at least one
financial year and it should not be in default(s) of the Listing
Regulations;
The Company should have minimum free-float shares of 5% of total
outstanding shares;
Institute of Business and Technology35
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
The Company will be eligible for KMI-30 Index if its securities are
traded for 75% of the total trading days;
Mutual Funds (both Open-Ended and Closed-Ended) are ineligible for
inclusion in the KMI-30
Screening - Financial Ratios and International Best Practice: The
companies are examined for compliance in financial ratios, as certain ratios
may violate compliance measurements. Al Meezan observes leverage,
investments, illiquid assets, and revenue as key areas in the following manner
from the prospect of non-compliant activities. All of these are subject to
evaluation on an ongoing basis.
Leverage Compliance: Compliance is measured as Interest bearing debt /
Total Assets < 40 %;
Investment Compliance: Compliance is measured as non-compliant
investment / Total Assets < 33%
Income Compliance: Companies with Revenues from non-compliant
activities are eligible only if they comply with the following threshold: Non-
compliant Income / Total Revenue < 5%
liquid Assets Compliance: Compliance is measured as Illiquid Assets / Total
Assets > 20%
Net Liquid Assets Compliance: Market Price per share should be greater
than Net Liquid Assets per share
Selection Criteria: All the eligible companies for the Islamic Index can be
included up to a maximum of thirty (30) companies. During the selection
process, each company’s financial reports are thoroughly reviewed by
research analysts of Al Meezan to ensure that the company meets
benchmarks or thresholds for Shariah compliance screening. Those that are
found to be non-compliant are screened out. The industries that are
Institute of Business and Technology36
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
considered non-compliant (as defined in the eligibility criteria) are not
considered for inclusion in the Islamic, as these would not be appropriate for
investment from Shariah perspective. From the list of Shariah compliant
companies, securities are selected on the basis of free float and Impact Cost.
While ranking the companies 50% weight is signed to free float capitalization
and the remaining 50% is allocated to Impact Cost such that the companies
with the highest free float and the lowest Impact Cost get the highest rank in
the selection process. Top 30 ranked companies as per above criteria are
included in Islamic Index.
4.5 Progress
Five Years Progress Report
5 YEARS PROGRESS 2007-2011
Upto
29-12-2007Upto
31-12-2008Upto
31-12-2009Upto
31-12-2010Upto
17-05-2011
Total No. of Listed Companies 654 653 651 644 638
Total Listed Capital - Rs. 671,255.82 750,477.55 814,478.74 919,161.26 930,556.69
Total Market Capitalization - Rs. 4,329,909.79 1,858,698.90 2,705,879.83 3,268,948.59 3,166,432.95
KSE-100TM Index 14075.83 5865.01 9386.92 12022.46 11930.24
Institute of Business and Technology37
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
KSE-30TM Index 16717.10 5485.33 9849.92 11588.24 11575.58
KSE All Share Index 9956.76 4400.76 6665.55 8359.31 8294.92
New Companies Listed during the year 14 10 4 6 -
Listed Capital of New Companies - Rs. 57,239.92 15,312.12 8,755.73 33,438.45 -
New Debt Instruments Listed during the year 3 7 1 4 2
Listed Capital of New Debt Instruments - Rs. 6,500.00 26,500.00 3,000.00 5,650.18 5,000.00
Average Daily Turnover - Shares in million 268.23 146.55 179.88 132.64 116.49
Average value of daily turnover - Rs. 25,262.97 14,228.35 7,450.75 4,405.20 4,559.86
Average Daily Turnover (Future TM) YTD 61.69 30.76 1.03 4.58 5.98
Average Value of Daily Turnover - YTD 9,077.61 5,229.97 89.66 396.90 708.71
Foreign Investment in Securities Market
Inflow – Rs - - - - -
Outflow – Rs - - - - -
Net Inflow/(Outflow) – Rs - - - - -
YTD = Year to date
a. The KSE 100 TM Index was introduced in November, 1991
b. The KSE All Share Index was introduced in September, 1995.
c. Listed companies reflected in the relevant year have been stated after 6 companies delisted in 2006, 7 in 2007, 6 in 2008, 2 in 2009, 8 in 2010 and 4 in 2011 and merger of 14 companies in 2006, 4 in 2007, 4 in 2008, 4 in 2009 and 5 in 2010.5
5. IMPACT OF GLOBAL RECESSION ON KSE
5.1 Global Recession
A global recession is a period of global economic slow downfall. The
International Monetary Fund (IMF) takes many steps into account when
defining a global recession, but it states that global economic growth of 3
percent or less is "equivalent to a global recession". By this measure, four
periods since 1985 qualify: 1990–1993, 1998, 2001–2002 and 2008–2009.
5 Karachi Stock Exchange Five Year Progress Report
Institute of Business and Technology38
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Overview: Informally, as a national recession is a period of declining
productivity. In a 1974 New York Times article, Julius Shiskin suggested
several rules of thumb to identify a recession, which included two successive
quarterly declines in gross domestic product (GDP), a measure of the
nation's output. This two-quarter metric is now a commonly held definition of a
recession. In the United States, the National Bureau of Economic Research
(NBER) is regarded as the authority which identifies a recession and which
takes into account several measures in addition to GDP growth before making
an assessment. In many developed nations other than USA, the two-quarter
rule is also used for identifying a recession.
Where as a national recession is identified by two quarters of decline, defining
a global recession is more difficult, because developing nations are expected
to have a higher GDP growth than developed nations. According to IMF, the
real GDP growth of the emerging and developing countries is on an uptrend
and that of advanced economies is on a downtrend since late 1980s. The
world growth is projected to slow from 5% in 2007 to 3.75% in 2008 and to
just over 2% in 2009. Downward revisions in GDP growth vary across regions.
Among the most affected are commodity exporters, and countries with acute
external financing and liquidity problems. Countries in East Asia (including
China) have suffered smaller declines because their financial situations are
more robust. They have benefited from falling commodity prices and they
have initiated a shift toward macroeconomic policy easing.
The IMF estimates that global recessions seem to occur over a cycle lasting
between 8 and 10 years. During what the IMF terms the past three global
recessions of the last three decades, global per capita output growth was zero
or negative.
5.2 Attributes of Recession
A recession has many attributes that can occur simultaneously and includes
declines in component measures of economic activity (GDP) such as
consumption, investment, government spending, and net export activity.
These summary measures reflect underlying and highlighting drivers such as
Institute of Business and Technology39
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
employment levels and skills, household savings rates, corporate investment
decisions, interest rates, demographics, and government policies.
Economist Richard C. Koo said that under ideal conditions, a country's
economy should have the household sector as net savers and the corporate
sector as net borrowers, with the government budget nearly balanced and net
exports near zero. When these relationships look and become unbalanced,
recession can develop within the country or create pressure for recession in
other country. Policy responses are often designed to drive the economy back
towards this ideal state of balance.
A severe (GDP down by 10%) or prolonged (three or four years) recession is
referred to as an economic depression, although some argue that their
causes and cures can be different. As an informal shorthand, economists
sometimes refer to different recession shapes, such as V-shaped, U-shaped,
L-shaped and W-shaped recessions element.
5.3 Karachi Stock Market & Recession
THE “decoupling” hypothesis that the emerging world of which Pakistan is a
part of no longer so nearly tied to the old industrial world – that whatever
happens in the latter would affect the former – became popular before the
global economy went into what economists have begun to call, the “Great
Recession.”
Karachi Stock Exchange 100 Index
Institute of Business and Technology40
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Source Meta stock data
The down turn started in the United States in the summer of 2007. Initially
there was a consensus between economists that the downturn`s effect would
not be felt by the emerging countries to the extent it would influence the more
linked economies of the industrial world. That was not happened.
We know from Pakistan`s experience that even in an economy that was not
an integral part of the global production system, there were many negative
consequences influence from the economic crisis in the United States and
Europe. Pakistan`s exports were affected by the contraction in the global
stock markets. The Karachi stock market, shaken by the rapid deterioration in
the security situation, suffered as foreign capital flew out and joined the exit
from a number of other emerging stock markets.
KSE-100 Index 3 Years Performance
Institute of Business and Technology41
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Source Karachi Stock Exchange Performance
It is an important thing, therefore, for Pakistan`s policy makers to stay abreast
of the developing situation in the global economy. Today I will explore some of
the current expert thinking on the subject of the Great Recession. I do belief
that there are lessons to be learned for the governments in the merging
markets.
How close was the Great Recession to the Great Depression of the 1930s?
One answer to the question was provided by Christiana Rumor, the head of
President Barack Obama`s Council of Economic Advisers. She is one of the
two senior officials in the new administration who have a good understanding
of the Great Depression. The other, of course, is Ben Bernanke, the Chairman
of the Federal Reserve, America`s central bank. Bernanke studied the subject
as a graduate student and then published a book about it. He is generally
credited with pulling the American economy back from the knee and brink of a
depression.
What is an economic depression? What distinguishes it from a deep
recession is the paralyzing fear of the unknown. That fear leads consumers,
investors and business managers to pull back from the stock market. They
begin to hoard cash by sharply cutting expenditure. According to the students
of economic depression, “a devastating loss of confidence inspires behavior
Institute of Business and Technology42
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
that overwhelms the normal self-correcting mechanisms (lower interest rates,
inventory re-supply, and cheap prices) that normally prevent a recession from
becoming deep and prolonged a depression.” In other words, economic
managers should be try to address the situation by using new tools. As the
US economy got close to a depression, Bernanke, having lowered interest
rates to near zero, went for what is called the “quantitative easing” of money.
This he did by printing enormous amounts of money and got it to the credit
starved sectors of the economy. This was done while hundreds of billion
dollars worth of stimulus was being giving to the economy through the budget
by way of the President Obama`s large stimulus package.
Did the state of the US economy justify these extraordinary moves? A report
issued recently by Ms Rumor finds that the initial impact on the levels of
confidence for all categories of economic actors was much more severe than
was the case at the starting and during the Great Depression.
While it is correct that stock prices fell by one-third from September to
December 1929, the beginning of the downturn, it has to be recognized that
for few people owned stocks then is the case now. The effect on the
economy, therefore, was not as severe as was the case now when the fall in
stock prices affected the levels of wealth for much more people. At this time,
home prices barely dropped then but fell sharply now. From December 1928
to December 1929, households lost three percent of their accumulated
wealth. This time they lost a much larger proportion – as much as 17 percent.
There were some policy take missteps that accelerated the pace of economic
deterioration. Among them that was the decision not to support Lehman
Brothers, the fourth largest US investment bank. The anniversary of the
bank`s collapse inspired much commentary. While there was disagreement
about the wisdom of the decision – some people argued that even if the bank
had not been allowed to fail, some other would have become the victim of the
economic malaise. There is a consensus that the decision accelerated the
deterioration. As Robert J. Samuelson of Newsweek puts it, by “allowing
Lehman to fail almost certainly made the crisis worse. By creating more
unknowns – which companies would be rescued, how much were `toxic`
Institute of Business and Technology43
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
securities worth? It converted normal anxieties into abnormal fears that
triggered panic.” The economy, in other words, was brought near the state of
depression not only by the economy`s own internal dynamics, but by public
policy.
The Lehman decision froze credit markets and resulted in the collapse of the
stock markets. By year end, the Dow Jones industrial average was down 23
per cent from the level reached before the bank`s collapse and 34 per cent
from a year earlier. There was panic situation in the financial markets which
affected and cause an affect of financial markets and general confidence.
In September, the Conference Board`s Consumer Confidence Index was
61.4. By February 2009, it fell to 25.3. Spending on consumer durables fell at
the annual rate of 12 per cent in the first 3 quarters of 2008, accelerating to a
decline of 20 per cent in the fourth. Investment by businesses fell by 39 per
cent in the last quarter of 2008. When Obama administration decided to act.
The most important lesson to be drawn from this episode in recent American
economic history is that public policy plays an important role in the way
economies develop and how they should be steered out of the crises into
which they can given and find themselves as they look forward.
This lesson is particularly important for a country such as Pakistan that has
allowed economic institutions in the public sector to weaken greatly, has lost
the capacity to do some serious analytical work on the state of the economy in
both the public and the private sectors, and has not been developed linkages
between the private and the public sectors to developed. The last is
particularly important since it provides the policymakers advice from analysts
who do not have political axes to grind.
Institute of Business and Technology44
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Recession Period of KSE
Source of KSE causes & effects recession in 2008
5.4 Causes & Effects of Recession
April 20: Karachi Stock Exchange achieved a major milestone when KSE-100
Index crossed the psychological level of 15,000 for the first time in its history
and peaked point 15,737.32 on 20 April, 2008. Moreover, the increase of 7.4
per cent in 2008 made it the best performer among major emerging markets.
May 23: Record high inflation in the month of May, 2008 resulted in the
unexpected increase in the interest rates by State Bank of Pakistan which
eventually resulted in sharp fall in Karachi Stock Exchange.
July 17: Angry investors attacked the Karachi Stock Exchange in protest at
plunging Pakistani share prices
July 16: KSE-100 Index dropped one-third from an all-time high hit in April,
2008 as rising pressure on shaky Pakistan's coalition government to tackle
Taliban militants exacerbates concern about the country's economic woes.
August 18: KSE 100 Index rose more than 4% after the announcement of the
resignation of President Pervez Musharraf but Credit Suisse Group said that
Institute of Business and Technology45
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Pakistan's Post-Musharraf rally in Stock Exchange will be short-lived because
of a rising fiscal deficit and runaway inflation.
August 28: Karachi Stock Exchange set a floor for stock prices to halt a
plunge that has wiped out $36.9 billion of market value since April.
December 15: Trading resumes after the removal of floor on stock prices that
was set on August 28 to halt sharp falls.
5.5 Global Impact on KSE
Financial crisis is one of the major challenges of 21st century. It is not only
parting negative impact on US but several rich countries' financial systems are
also trembling under its weight. Economies of major world including Pakistan
are at high level of risk. This crisis is also pointing fingers on the capitalistic
companies and banks, which somehow are bigger than many countries.
Pakistan was in crisis from the beginning of year 2007, but financial crisis
triggered this crisis and situation is going to worst. Pakistan is passing from
crucial phase of its life. Crisis in Pakistan was started when former President
Pervez Musharraf suspended Supreme Court Chief Justice. Later on Lal
Masjid incident took place which throughout Pakistan created huge tension
because after this incident chain of suicide attacks started in the country,
which has not been ended as yet.
In large part due to fuel subsidies and other economic obligations, Pakistan's
budget deficit of $21 billion is the highest in a decade, and the current account
deficit is 8.4 percent of GDP. In all of Asia, Pakistan has the highest interest
rates, least valuable currency, and riskiest financial obligations. As a result,
Pakistani government debt is considered one of the riskiest in the world.
Pakistan's currency, the rupee, has lost 20 percent against the falling dollar
and is now near record lows. The Karachi Stock Exchange—Pakistan's oldest
and largest stock exchange-has lost 40 percent of its value since April 2008.
Just last August, the KSE put a floor on the index to keep shares from falling
even further.
Institute of Business and Technology46
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Pakistan foreign currency reserves have dropped significantly due to the
unstable political and security situation. In less than a year, Pakistan's foreign
reserves have dropped from an all-time high of $14 billion last November to
just under $6 billion today.
Pakistan has taken loan from International Monetary Fund (IMF) on harsh
terms and conditions to meet crisis. But financial crisis will be adverse due to
this aid because terms are directing Pakistan, not to support their financial
sector.
Aid from USA and foreign remittance are one of the main contributions
towards current account balance of Pakistan. But after the financial crisis,
American aid stopped and foreign remittances to Pakistan also showing steep
decline.
All the bailouts and nationalizations are not the permanent solutions to this
financial crunch. It may be possible that we will get rid of this crisis in few
months or few years, but it will again come and hit the economies and
challenge the financial systems of the world. We have to address the roots of
this crisis. Basically all the financial systems of the world revolve around
"Capitalism" and "Interest", which will somehow always invite such big
recessions in the days to come.
The basic economic statistics paint a dire picture. Two-thirds of the Pakistani
population lives on less than $2 a day, with one-third of the population living
below the poverty line. While the Pakistani economy expanded 5.8 percent in
the last fiscal year, this rate of economic growth was the slowest since 2003
and is expected to fall to 4.6 percent this year. But the benefits of this
economic growth have not reached the vast majority of Pakistanis.
The newly elected government faces interlinked challenges: tackling
emboldened militant groups and terrorist organizations, advancing political
reform, and stabilizing the economy. If Pakistan's economy experiences
further collapse, the government could lose further support of the people.
Institute of Business and Technology47
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Impact on Global Recession on KSE
Source meta stock data
5.6 Recession & Politics
Since inception, Pakistan has been facing complex issues on political and
economic fronts. At the time of creation of Pakistan, there was no education,
no industry, no agriculture, no trade, no commerce, and above all no
infrastructure. However, with the passage of time, the country s economy,
despite various shocks has managed to come out of pressure. The history of
Pakistan can be divided into two distinct struggles of epic proportions; the
struggle for independence and the struggle for survival. The struggle for the
independence of Pakistan culminated in the creation of Pakistan albeit at
great human cost. However, the struggle for survival continues despite the
nation having sacrificed a lot, both in terms of precious human lives and
socio-economic development. The people of Pakistan have lived through
difficult times. The country survived despite many odds and its
dismemberment. Today, the people are facing worst power crisis that is not
only hitting hard to the country s economy but also badly affecting the fellow
citizens. Now, Pakistan s critical issue is still the bad state of its economy. It
has inflation rate in double figure, prices of essential items have been
rocketing high and lack of investment in power generation capacity by the
previous rulers have halted wheels of industry causing unemployment. The
current state of our economy is related to war on terror with horrendous spill
Institute of Business and Technology48
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
over affects on the rest of Pakistan. Americans bomb in the northern areas,
the terrorists react to it by bomb blasting in rest of the country are making
investors insecure and unsafe thereby hitting hard Pakistan s economy.
In the back drop of Pakistan s economic outlook, first we need to understand
that high inflation, surge in oil prices, security concerns, decline in FDI,
widening trade gap and persistent load shedding are hitting hard to the
country s economy. The Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) has always been a
reflection of the success of foreign policy of any country but FDI statistics in
Pakistan are presenting a glomming picture, which is not a good omen for
economy at all. During the financial year 2007-08, the volume of US direct
investment in Pakistan was $ 1,309.3 million, while in FY 2008-09 it was $
875.3 million. Similarly, during FY 2007-08, volume of UK investment in
Pakistan was $ 460.2, UAE $ 589.2, Japan $131.2 million and Hong Kong $
339.8 million which came down to $263 million, $178.2 million, $74.3 million
and $156.1 million respectively during FY 2008-09. There was 31.2%
decrease in FDI during FY 2008-09 as compared to FY08 while 51%
decrease in total foreign investment in FY09 as compared to FY08. Chief
Operating Officer of Abbasi & Company Mohammad Ishaq Abbasi, while
sharing his views about the problems being faced by the country s economy,
said high inflation rate, surge in oil prices, depreciation in Pak rupee, decline
in FDI, security concerns, load shedding are major issues confronted to the
national economy. He said inflation remains the biggest threat to our
economy, jumping over 25% in October 2008 before decelerating this year in
June 2009 to 16 month s low of 13.13%. Depreciation in rupee, which has
fallen from 60-1 USD to over 83-1 USD in a few months, security concerns
resulting from our role in the War on Terror have created great instability,
decline in FDI from a height of approximately $8.4bn to $4.6bn for the current
fiscal year and extending trade gap as import growth exceeds export
expansion causing the current account deficit to growing on Pakistan
economy and Karachi stock exchange market in Pakistan as well.
Talking about Pakistan s Stock Markets, Mr. Ishaq Abbasi said prior 2008
recession leading international magazine Business Week declared KSE-100
Institute of Business and Technology49
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Index as the best-performing stock market index in the world. Post 2008
General Elections, uncertain political environment, and aforementioned
factors resulted in the steep decline of the Karachi Stock Exchange. Now with
the SBP tighter and stable monetary policies in an effort to conserve
economic growth has contributed in reduction of money-market interest rates
and the inflation may drop back to single digits in 2010. Further Pakistani
government is now pursuing an export-driven model of economic growth
successfully implemented by South East Asia and now highly successful in
China. Recent announcement by the Ministry of Water and Power
Development that load shedding will end through employing rental power
units and that the country will be self-sufficient by the year 2011.Mr. Ishaq
Abbasi said Pakistan has a growing upper and upper middle class, estimated
at 6.8 million in 2002 and projected to grow to 17 million people by the year
2010, with relatively high per capita income. Thus middle term, however, may
be less turbulent, depending on the political environment/militants actions and
the GDP may pick up to over 4.5% per annum by 2011-12. This all
contributes to my optimistic view on Pakistan s Stock Markets from medium to
long term. At these levels, Benchmark Karachi Stock Exchange-100 Index
seems to be consolidating itself supported by healthy corporate
announcements. Had not been the uncertain political environment in the
country and Pakistan s participation in war on terror, Karachi stock exchange
100 Index would have been trading above 9500 point s level currently.
According to him, oil, utility, energy, fertilizer and cement stocks are still
trading at discounts and can provide growth and value to investors in medium
to long term. He further said the Securities and Exchange Commission of
Pakistan (SECP) registered 243 companies during the month of July 2009,
bringing the total corporate portfolio of registered companies to 53,424. Of
243 companies incorporated during July 2009, 240 companies were limited by
shares, comprising of 2 public unlisted companies, 224 private companies
and 14 single member companies. In addition, 2 associations not for profit
under section 42 of the Companies Ordinance, 1984 (the Ordinance) and one
foreign company were also registered. Total authorized capital and paid up
capital of 240 limited by shares companies, incorporated during July, 2009
Institute of Business and Technology50
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
amounted to Rs.1,463.9 million and Rs. 451.4 million respectively. During July
2009, number of new incorporation was highest at Lahore, whereby 91
companies have been registered, followed by Islamabad registering 66
companies, Karachi with 59 companies. Peshawar, Quetta, Faisalabad,
Multan, and Sukkur registered 13, 1, 6, 6, and 1 company, respectively. Major
share of new incorporation was witnessed in the trading sector comprising of
44 companies, followed by 26 each in services and construction, 19 in
information technology sector and 14 in tourism sector.
During the month, the Commission granted licenses to 2 associations not for
profit under Section 42 of the Ordinance of which one is for promotion of
education, and other for social services. Commenting on the state of country s
economy in the backdrop of decline in FDI, businessman Mohammad Pervaiz
Malik said foreign investment plays key role in making the economy of any
country stronger, as it helps to initiate new ventures, promotes
industrialization, creates new jobs and enhances government revenue. He
said present regime has failed to convince even countries like USA and UK to
increase their investment and support economy of Pakistan. Pevaiz Malik said
though economic crisis is getting further deepening with every passing day
but instead of evolving efficient policies, government has found an easy way
and put on stake the future of Pakistan by borrowing from IMF and other
financial institutions. He urged upon the government to take steps on war
footing to attract foreign investors otherwise situation would go out of control.
He said government should bind Pakistani diplomats posted abroad to make
extraordinary efforts to improve the Pakistan perception in the eyes of the
developed world. He said Pakistan embassies abroad should keep continuous
liaison with the businesspersons and investors of their respective countries
and strive hard to convince them to make investment in Pakistan. He said that
huge energy crisis is also a major reason to decrease the investment in
Pakistan.
At the time when a large number of industrial units have been closed down
due to more than 12 hours load shedding, how one can expect of any new
foreign project just because of energy crises in Pakistan.
The Vice President of SAARC Chamber of Commerce & Industry Iftikhar Ali
Institute of Business and Technology51
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Malik said that the government would have to evolve a methodology for
cutting the cost of doing business in Pakistan. To achieve the goal, there is a
dire need to cut the rate of markup considerably as on the one hand it would
help make Pakistani merchandise competitive at the global market on the
other it would expedite the process of industrialization in the country. He said
improvement of Pakistan s perception in the eyes of potential foreign
investors should be the cornerstone of all the policies made for the future. As
the law and order situation must be given priority to attract foreign investment.
Human resource availability and its development is an important aspect,
which must not be ignored, he said. The Lahore Chamber of Commerce and
Industry (LCCI) President Mian Muzaffar Ali said that he understands well that
there is no overnight solution of the problems but definitely, there is a dire
need to set a direction in the larger interests of the country. Mian Muzaffar Ali
said, I strongly believe that today, we as a nation hold the utmost
responsibility to deliver.
We need to stop borrowing a few breaths in the form of funding from the
international donor agencies or our debt repayments just so we can go for a
few more steps yet not look for the cure for what we are plagued with. We
understand that interim relief might be absolutely necessary for right now to
continue, we need to start thinking of a long-term solution to our ills.
We must have political stability if we are to industrialize. Political stability can
only come with political maturity. Our politicians must now attempt to raise the
stature and level of their politics from the present day classroom type boyish
squabbles to more constructive criticism of their opponents. They must set
themselves down to the task of nation building, he added. The LCCI President
said that the law and order situation is indeed alarming these days. How can
you expect any investment in this kind of scenario? Where even the local
businessperson is shy to invest, how can you attract foreign investment? We
seem to have lost our sense of direction. There is no discipline or respect for
the Law left in our society. We will have to develop such a political and judicial
system, in which the common citizen must be assured of the safety of his
person and property. He must be confident of being able to obtain justice
Institute of Business and Technology52
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
when wronged. We cannot achieve economic development in a situation
when people cannot properly sleep due to fear of some untoward happening
in the surroundings.
5.7 Consequences of KSE Recession
The fall of once great KSE 100 index from the 15700 level to a meager 4500
was indeed the worst crisis condition that ever hit the Pakistani stock markets.
A lesser dreadful situation occurred in 1971 despite the fall of Dhaka. So far,
there has been no formal inquiry conduct for finding the responsible elements.
As it is always the case with the equity stock markets in Pakistan.
A large number of people believed in hidden elements involved in the events
that lead to the crisis. Fingers are pointed towards the previous and infamous
mythical cartel rumored to having been responsible for disasters like this in
the past as well. None of these accusations can be proven since all the
previous investigations hardly held anyone responsible of those crises.
Certainly, the instability brought on by the scuffle among the former president,
PPP and PML (N) worked as a catalyst in weakening the foundations of
Pakistani financial sector. Apparently, even the cool and calm nature of the
new Prime Minister wasn’t enough to bring a sense of calm in the highly
volatile market. In my view the disaster that hit the Pakistani stock market was
entirely home brewed. It may have intensified in the light of global financial
crisis but it was in no way a result of domino effect set off from stock markets
in the united state or Europe.
The foreign investors pulling out of the Pakistani stocks bazaar was the first
major step blow to the investor confidence in KSE. The departure of foreign
element was not due to the global financial crisis rather it was a result of
sudden devaluation of Pakistani currency. The rising oil prices had lead to a
large trade imbalance. The panic was further intensified by the actions of
State bank of Pakistan. SBP’s lack of refusal in lending stockpiles of money to
the central government needed the consequential rise in interest rate for
cutting down inflation. This hampered progress in industries and services
sector which severely hurt the investor sentiment.
Institute of Business and Technology53
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Later SECP the so-called 'savior' of the common man intervened in the stock
exchanges when the fiasco had just started. By changing the upper and lower
circuit values, KSE rose to its top ever of 960 points in an intraday trade. The
math was very simple, your share could achieve 10% more value on a bullish
day whereas lose only 1% on a bad one. The TV channels were filled with
brokers cheering but critics shouting. The event was analogous to the
notorious ‘double shah’ scam. It was all perfect as long as the money kept
coming in and the outflow was lesser than the inflow. The danger of the latter
happening was foreseen by many with bigger consequences in mind like the
total rupture of confidence in the stock market. That’s exactly what was to
follow in KSE, a series of unprecedented low volume bearish weeks of trade
acting like poison for the investor confidence.
As the Pakistani equities continued to cataclysmically shed their value, the
government got promised a rescue fund which would help stabilize the shares
bazaar. The fund is in the beginning was supposed to be formed from the
capital reserves of NIT and other mutual fund cash dumps. As the days
passed by rescue fund seemed that more and more like a myth due to the
infinite delays caused by the government’s inability to convince fund
managers. NIT refused in the beginning to participate; pleading on the
grounds that they couldn’t be possibly risk gambling the money in their vaults
for a bailout since the deposits were ‘life savings of pensioners & widows’.
Almost all mutual funds including NIT later suspended trading in their units
ironically because of the scenario in KSE. In all likelihood if NIT had used a
small portion of its fund back then, the shares bazaar and the mutual fund
industry wouldn’t have been faced this avoidable crisis.
Afterwards KSE administration selects to freeze the floor. Months of almost
zero trade followed the decision. The act evidently ripped all expectation from
a small investor’s heart. Several shareholders defaulted during the tenure of
the floor freeze. Many were pushed to sell their valuables and property in
order to manage deficits. Was it a series of unfortunate events or a
culmination of unprofessional acts that lead to the paralysis of Pakistan’s
stock exchanges, a process that began in 2008? This is a question which still
requires an answer. Hopefully the restored judiciary will address the issue at
Institute of Business and Technology54
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
anyhow. At least finding the truth and apprehending the people responsible
will to some degree do justice to the thousands who lost their life savings just
because they chose to invest in their motherland.6
6. CONCLUSION & RECOMMENDATIONS6 The Avoidable collapse of Karachi Stock Exchange 2008 – KSE
Article Source: http://ezine.pk/?expert=Ali Hammad Raza
Institute of Business and Technology55
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
6.1Conclusion
Main objective of this study is to cover the whole crisis of Karachi stock
exchange an interest rates on the stock returns and volatility in Karachi stock
exchange for period of 2008. This study confirms that the global financial
crisis has a significant effect on the financial institutions of developing
countries. Our findings about impact of global recession on Karachi stock
exchange 2008 which support the impact of Global crisis and recession on
Karachi stock exchange and what effect it will have on the financial institutions
of developing countries.
The perception that they had broken the links with the larger economies has
been painfully disproved by the hard facts on those crises. Financial markets
of the world are closely interconnected, and the impact of the world financial
collapse on Emerging Economies is a witness to this fact. The government
should introduce programs to recapitalize banks, guarantee bank liabilities,
and provide liquidity to banks by funding markets and in some cases support
troubled asset markets. Asset price inflation should be made under the control
of monetary policy authorities by government. Responses to global crises
must be methodical, inclusive, decisive, and organized. As Global problems
may require global multilateral solutions. If the crisis will continue for long
period, state and local governments may begin to restrict as they try to shore
up new financing arrangements for their operations.
6.2Recommendations
In the current scenario of Pakistan, it was the dire need for the investors to
find the securities having less correlation that can be used to diversify their
portfolios for investments. In the volatile markets like Karachi Stock Exchange
(KSE), keeping in view the findings and conclusion of the current study, it was
proposed and recommended for the investors.
Individual investor should be preparing before investment of any stock
in stock exchange.
Individual always use the dividend stock for save side.
Institute of Business and Technology56
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
Purchase of common stock should be done when a company is up-
grading itself: as it is the time when the company’s share price is lower
and its future earnings will be more.
Investing across the board is a way more important during bear
markets, when your assets can really get hammered by volatility. Make
sure you can manage your risk with a diversified, well-balanced
portfolio.
Decisions for stock purchase should not be made by just considering
the market value of equity: as the company’s other internal and
external factors have high significance in determining stock returns.
If annual sales of a company are high, the wrong decision regarding its
stock purchase should not be made.
A company high variation in the market value of equity should not be
Considered good for investment.
If a Company is having negative correlation of Market Value of Equity
with EPS, it should be avoided for investment, because it may have
bad future prospects.
Technical analysis should be made which would be an easy predictor
of stock returns on the basis of Market Value of Equity and other
economic factors.
REFERENCES
Institute of Business and Technology57
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
History of the Karachi Stock Exchange
http://www.advfn.com/StockExchanges/history/KSE/KarachiStockExch
ange. History.
Karachi Stock Market & Recession.
Http://archives.dawn.com/archives/153612 Karachi stock market &
recession.
Five Year Progress Report on KSE http://www.kse.com.pk/
An Analysis on the performance of IPO- A Study on the Karchi Stock
Exchange of Pakistan by Miss Shama Sadaqat, Muhammad Farhan
Akhtar, Khizer Ali in April 2011 http:
//www.ijbssnet.com/journals/Vol._2_No._6;_April_2011/30.pdf
KSE-100 Index Years Performance
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_RBeSQasZTWY/SYw2S03FkjIAM/2-
mrsbZvDqY/s1600-h/performance_big.gif.
KSE 100 Index http://www.docstoc.com/docs/32242077/KSE-100-
Index.
Karachi Stock Exchange
http://essaysforstudent.com/Business/Karachi-Stock-Exchange/80452.
html.
European Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Sciences.
http://www.eurojournals.com/finance.htm
http://www.forexpk.com/weekly-updates/editors-pick/struggles-for-
survival-independence-characterises-history-of-pakistan.html
Interest Rate Volatility and Stock Return and Volatility by Nosheen
Zafar, Syed Faiza Urooj, Tahir Khan Durrani in 2008
http://www.eurojournals.com/ejefas_14_13.pdf
International Review of Business Research Papers Vol. 5 No. 5
September 2009
Institute of Business and Technology58
Impact of Global Recession on Karachi Stock Exchange
2nd International conference on business and economic research 2nd
ICBER 2011
International Journal of Business and Social Science Vol. 2 No. 6; April
2011
International Research Journal of Finance and Economics ISSN 1450-
2887 Issue 35 (2010) Euro Journals Publishing, Inc. 2010
ISSN 1450-2275 Issue 14 (2008) Euro Journals, Inc. 2008
http://www.nationsencyclopedia.com/economies/Asia-and-the-acific/
Pakistan-MONEY.html
The Impact of Recent Global Financial Crisis On the Financial
Institutions in the Developing Countries by Nida Iqbal Malik Subhan
Ullah Kamran azam Anwar khan in
Year2009http://www.bizresearchpapers.com/8.Nida.pdf
Volatilities Dynamics in Emerging Economies Case of Karachi Stock
Exchange by Mahreen Mahmud and Nawazish Mirza
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karachi_Stock_Exchange
World applied sciences journal 10 (5): 590-596, 2010
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_recession Global Recession
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KSE_100_Index Causes & Effects of
recession
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recession Attributes of Recession
http://karachi.metblogs.com/2008/11/04/karachi-stock-exchange-fiasco/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KSE_100_Index Causes & Effects of
recession
Sufyan Farhan
Institute of Business and Technology59