imports to ostia 1-5c

Upload: cassandra-iliou

Post on 28-Feb-2018

222 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/25/2019 Imports to Ostia 1-5C

    1/15

    American Academy in Rome, University of Michigan Press and American Academy in Rome and University of

    Michigan Press are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Memoirs of the American Academy in

    Rome. Supplementary Volumes.

    http://www.jstor.org

    merican cademy in Rome and University of Michigan Press

    Imports at Ostia in the Imperial Period and Late Antiquity: The Amphora Evidence from theDai-Aar ExcavationsAuthor(s): Archer MartinSource: Memoirs of the American Academy in Rome. Supplementary Volumes, Vol. 6, TheMaritime World of Ancient Rome (2008), pp. 105-118Published by: for theUniversity of Michigan Press American Academy in RomeStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/40379300Accessed: 01-01-2016 01:45 UTC

    Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

    JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of contentin a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship.For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Fri, 01 Jan 2016 01:45:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/http://www.jstor.org/publisher/umphttp://www.jstor.org/publisher/aaromehttp://www.jstor.org/stable/40379300http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/40379300http://www.jstor.org/publisher/aaromehttp://www.jstor.org/publisher/umphttp://www.jstor.org/
  • 7/25/2019 Imports to Ostia 1-5C

    2/15

    IMPORTSATOSTIA IN THE IMPERIALPERIOD AND

    LATE

    ANTIQUITY:

    THE

    AMPHORA

    EVIDENCE

    FROM THE DAI-AAR

    XCAVATIONS

    Archer

    artin

    1.

    ntroduction

    this aper wish o examine rendsn themportationf mphora-borneoodstuffsessentially

    wine,

    il,

    and

    fish

    auces)

    to Ostia from

    hefirst

    entury

    .d.

    to thefifth. should

    tress t the

    outset hat

    willbe

    discussing

    he um

    ofthese

    oods

    mported

    n

    amphorae

    nd

    not

    necessarily

    the ntire

    upply

    f hem o Ostia.

    That

    s,

    ppropriately

    or conferenceedicated o

    ports,

    will

    be concerned

    nly

    with

    hat

    art

    f he

    upply

    mported hrough

    he

    port

    acilitiesfOstia.

    Thisdiscussion

    s

    based on

    the

    preliminary

    lassification

    under

    my

    irection

    nd

    with

    he

    help

    ofEricDe Sena

    of he

    AAR's

    Archaeology

    aboratory

    nd

    a

    team f

    talian, erman,

    nd

    American

    students)

    f

    hematerial

    rom elected

    ontexts

    xcavated

    n nDAI-AAR

    project

    etween

    998

    nd

    2001. The37

    sondages

    xcavated

    ere

    esigned

    o

    provide

    maximumf

    nformation,

    articularly

    with

    egard

    o

    dating,

    or lements

    dentified

    hrough

    on-invasive

    urveying

    nthe

    previously

    nex-

    cavated

    reas

    f he

    ity.

    ecause

    of heir

    urpose,

    hey

    ended

    more

    o

    depth

    han

    readth,

    hich

    means

    hat

    ften he

    ingle tratigraphic

    nitswere

    of

    imited ize.

    However,

    y putting ogether

    several nits f imilarate,wewere bleto create umulativeroups or range fchronological

    horizons.2

    deally

    ne

    wouldwant o have

    continuous

    eries

    fhorizons f he

    ame

    ength

    f ime

    with

    imilarmounts

    f

    material

    n

    eachone.

    n

    practice

    e

    have hree

    roups

    f ontexts

    f

    roughly

    similar

    ize

    one

    for

    he econd

    half f he

    first

    entury

    .D.

    nd two

    ess

    closely

    efined

    roups

    or

    the

    years

    rom

    80 to

    350

    and

    from

    50

    to

    475)

    and

    a

    larger

    ne

    for

    he irst alf f he econd en-

    tury),

    ith

    gap

    between 50

    nd

    280. Of

    course,

    s the

    tudy

    f he

    pottery

    rogresses,

    e

    hope

    to

    approximate

    ore

    losely

    he

    deal,

    ut

    even

    now

    we feel hat

    urresultsre

    worthy

    f

    note.

    A

    particular

    trength

    f he

    resent

    tudy

    s ts

    methodological

    asis.

    All

    he herds ere

    etained

    and

    examined

    or ttribution

    o

    fabric

    roups.

    his

    has allowed s to

    proceed

    with

    uantification

    n

    various

    ways:

    otal herd

    ount

    nd total

    herd

    weight;

    heminimum

    umber f

    vessels

    epresented

    by

    he

    rim herds nd

    a maximum

    epresented

    y

    thenumber

    f ll

    diagnostic

    herds

    minus

    oins;

    and

    finally

    he

    stimated

    essel

    quivalent

    alculated

    n the

    basisof he

    percentage

    f

    he

    rims

    re-

    served.

    ndeed,

    he

    omparison

    f he

    esultsf

    he

    different

    uantifications

    orms

    ne of he eatures

    ofa paper hatwaspresentedta conferencetBarcelona n ateantique ottery.3erewe have

    used

    an

    average

    fresults

    xpressed

    n

    percentages

    f

    all the

    quantifications.

    hat s

    significant

    s

    that

    his

    material

    as

    collected

    nd

    processed

    with

    he ntention

    f

    undertaking

    tatistical

    nalysis

    1

    For

    the

    project

    nd

    previous

    ibliography,

    ee

    Martin t

    al.

    2002.

    2

    At

    the ime he

    election

    as made he xcavators

    ad not

    yet

    upplied

    he

    hasing

    f

    he

    tratigraphies.

    herefore,

    e

    were ble to

    base t

    only pon

    the

    eramic ate f he

    ingle

    stratigraphic

    nits,

    whichwill

    nevitably

    e

    superseded

    n

    some

    cases

    by

    other

    ating

    vidence.

    3

    Martin nd

    De Sena 2005.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Fri, 01 Jan 2016 01:45:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Imports to Ostia 1-5C

    3/15

    106

    ARCHER

    MARTIN

    Fig.

    1.

    Provenience

    f

    mports

    t Ostia:

    horizon

    50-100).

    Fig.

    3. Provenience

    f

    mported

    ine t Ostia:

    horizon

    50-100).

    Fig.

    2. Products

    mported

    t Ostia:

    horizon

    50-100).

    Fig.

    4.

    Provenience

    f

    mported

    il/

    ish

    auce t Ostia:

    horizon

    50-100).

    of entire

    ssemblages,

    nlike hematerial rom lder xcavations

    hat re still

    eference

    oints

    n

    the iteratureutwere

    ubjected

    o statistical

    nalysis nly

    s an

    afterthought

    ncemost

    f he

    body

    sherds nd

    possibly

    thers ad beendiscarded ithout

    ecording.

    e

    expect

    he

    DAI-AAR

    ontexts

    to

    constitutehefirst

    ajor

    ublication

    fmaterialt Ostia

    to be

    processed

    n

    this

    way.

    For each horizon

    present

    our

    raphs.

    irst show he

    percentages

    f

    amphorae

    f

    any

    ort

    arriving

    rom hevarious

    egions

    n

    order

    o

    give

    n dea of heir elativeommercial

    eight

    t

    Os-

    tia at the imenquestion. he secondgraph s ntended opoint ut what heOstianmarket as

    interested

    n

    mportingybreaking

    own he

    mphorae

    ccording

    o their

    ontents:

    ine;

    il and

    fish

    auces

    grouped ogether

    because

    ne cannot

    lways

    e certain

    f he

    ontent,

    s some

    regions

    exported

    oth);

    unknown. or the

    purposes

    fthese

    raphs

    take

    nto onsideration

    he

    primary

    contents f

    the

    amphorae,

    s there s no immediate

    ay

    to

    identifyossible

    econdary

    ontents

    deriving

    rom hereuse f

    vessels,

    which

    may

    nothavebeen

    mportant

    n

    any

    ase at

    such

    major

    port

    s

    Ostia. The third

    raph

    llustrateshe

    proveniences

    f thewine

    mphorae,

    nd the

    fourth

    does the amefor he

    ontainers or il and fish auce.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Fri, 01 Jan 2016 01:45:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Imports to Ostia 1-5C

    4/15

    IMPORTS

    AT

    OSTIA IN

    THE

    IMPERIAL

    PERIOD

    AND LATE

    ANTIQUITY

    107

    Fig.

    . Provenience

    f

    mports

    t Ostia:

    horizon

    (100-150).

    Fig.

    7.

    Provenience

    f

    mported

    ine t Ostia:

    horizon

    (100-150).

    Fig.

    6. Products

    mported

    t Ostia:

    horizon

    (100-150).

    Fig.

    8.

    Provenience

    f

    mported

    il/

    ish

    auce

    t Ostia:

    horizon

    (100-150).

    2.

    The

    Horizons

    The first orizon

    figs.

    -4),

    attested

    y

    3,367

    herds

    weighing

    1.7

    kg,

    overs hehalf

    entury

    rom

    a.d.

    50

    to 100.Then

    taly rovides

    ust

    ver

    quarter

    f he

    mphora-borneroducts

    t Ostia

    and

    Iberia

    omething

    ore han

    third,

    ith outhern aul and NorthAfrica

    xporting

    esser mounts

    and the astern

    Mediterraneaness

    yet fig.

    ).

    Whenwe turn o the

    products,

    e see that here s a

    somewhattrongernterestn mportingine han il or fish auce fig. ). Italys theprovenience

    of the

    argest

    ercentage

    f wine

    amphorae fig.

    ).

    Within

    taly, ampania representedy

    the

    typical

    lack-sand

    abric)

    nd therest f

    Tyrrhenian

    entral

    taly

    ach account or bout

    half,

    hile

    a

    slight

    ontribution

    omesfrom heAdriatic. outhern aul

    supplies significantroportion

    f

    thewine

    mphorae,

    ith beria nd

    the asternMediterranean/Blackea area

    exporting

    ess and

    NorthAfrica ext o

    nothing.

    il and fish auce s much ess

    variegated

    n

    ts

    provenience:

    bout

    three-quarters

    rom he berian

    eninsula

    nd

    one-quarter

    rom orthAfrica

    fig.

    ).

    The

    secondhorizon

    figs.

    -8),

    with

    ,991

    herds

    weighing

    04.8

    kg,

    ates othe irst alf f he

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Fri, 01 Jan 2016 01:45:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Imports to Ostia 1-5C

    5/15

    108

    ARCHER MARTIN

    Fig.

    9. Provenience

    f

    mports

    t Ostia:

    horizon

    (280-350).

    Fig.

    11.

    Provenience

    f

    mported

    ine t Ostia:

    horizon

    (280-350).

    Fig.

    10. Products

    mported

    t Ostia:

    horizon

    (280-350).

    Fig.

    12.

    Provenience

    f

    mported

    il/fish

    auce t Ostia:

    horizon

    (280-350).

    second

    entury.y

    now

    beriahas

    gained

    ignificantly

    nd North frica o a lesser xtent s

    suppliers

    of

    mphora-borne

    roducts,

    hile

    taly

    nd southern aul

    bothhavedeclined

    fig.

    ).

    The

    change

    in

    the

    productsmported

    s

    striking:

    ine tands t

    only

    third,

    nd oil and fish auce reach

    nearly

    60

    percent

    fig.

    ).

    Looking

    t the

    proveniences

    fwine

    mphorae,

    e see ittle

    hange,

    owever,

    essentially

    nly

    decline

    n

    winefrom beria ndan increasenthat rom he asternMediterra-

    nean/Black ea area

    fig.

    ).

    The datafor

    taly

    ide

    n

    mportant

    hift: ow

    Campanian

    ontainers

    are rare tOstia,undoubtedlyecauseofthedestructionausedby he ruptionfVesuvius. he

    provenience

    f theoil and

    fish-sauce

    ontainers emains he ame as

    in

    the

    previous

    orizon:

    a.

    three-quarters

    rom he berian

    eninsula

    nd

    one-quarter

    rom orthAfrica

    fig.

    ).

    The third

    orizon

    figs.

    -12)

    picks

    p

    the

    tory

    etween 80 and

    350,

    fter

    gap

    ofmore han

    a

    century.

    ere

    2,610

    sherds

    weighing

    69

    kg

    wererecovered. he

    proveniences

    f the

    mphora-

    borne

    products

    re

    quite

    different

    fig.

    ).

    Now NorthAfrica ccounts orhalf f

    them,

    hile he

    formerly

    ominant

    berian

    eninsula

    eclines o 16

    percent.

    he

    percentages

    or

    taly

    nd southern

    Gaul

    continue o decrease.

    hose for he astern

    Mediterranean,owever,

    ise

    ignificantly.

    hat

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Fri, 01 Jan 2016 01:45:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Imports to Ostia 1-5C

    6/15

    IMPORTS

    AT

    OSTIA

    IN THE IMPERIAL

    PERIOD

    AND

    LATE

    ANTIQUITY

    109

    Fig.

    13.

    Provenience

    f

    mports

    t Ostia:

    orizon

    (350-475).

    Fig.

    15. Provenience

    f

    mported

    ine t Ostia:

    horizon

    (350-475).

    Fig.

    14.

    Products

    mported

    t Ostia:

    horizon

    (350-475).

    Fig.

    16. Provenience

    f

    mported

    il/

    ish

    auce t Ostia:

    horizon

    (350-475).

    does

    not

    hange

    with

    espect

    o the

    irst

    alf

    f he econd

    entury

    s the

    trong

    nterest

    n

    mporting

    oil and

    fish

    auce,

    ontainersorwhichmake

    up

    two-thirdsf he

    ample fig.

    0).

    Now the astern

    Mediterranean/Blackea area s

    by

    far

    hemost

    mportantupplier

    fwine

    n

    amphorae,argely

    ith

    Kapitan

    and

    I

    amphorae

    f unknown ut

    probably egean

    r Pontic

    rigin fig.

    1).

    taly

    tself

    accounts

    or

    he econd

    argest ercentage

    fwine

    ontainers,

    ostly

    mall

    lat-bottomed

    mphorae

    from yrrhenianentraltaly. mphorae rom outhern aul stillmakeup a significantart f the

    sample,

    lthoughhey

    re

    ssentially

    esidual,

    s their

    roduction

    nds t he

    eginning

    f his orizon.

    The

    supply

    foil

    and fish auce s nverted ith

    espect

    o the

    previous

    orizon: ow

    three-quarters

    of he ontainers

    omefrom orthAfrica nd

    one-quarter

    rom

    he berian

    eninsulafig.

    2).

    Horizon

    (figs.

    3-16)

    goes

    from

    50

    to

    475,

    with

    ,165

    sherds

    weighing

    0

    kg.

    Here North

    Africas evenmore

    mportant

    s a

    provenience

    han

    n

    the

    previous

    orizon

    fig.

    3).

    The eastern

    Mediterranean/Blackea area sthenextmost

    mportant,lthough

    thas ost

    ground

    with

    espect

    to

    horizon

    .

    Italy,

    n the

    ther

    and,

    has ncreased omewhat. he berian

    eninsula

    as declined

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Fri, 01 Jan 2016 01:45:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Imports to Ostia 1-5C

    7/15

    110

    ARCHER MARTIN

    and outhern

    aul

    disappeared

    rom he

    icture.

    il and

    fish

    auce

    till ccount or

    y

    far

    he

    argest

    percentage

    f he

    mphora-borneroducts

    fig.

    4).

    Somewhatmore han alf hewine

    mported

    n

    amphorae

    omes rom

    he astern editerraneannd ratheress han alf rom

    taly,

    ith

    minimal

    amount

    rom he berian

    eninsula

    fig.

    5).

    The

    easternMediterranean/Black

    ea area

    no

    onger

    has one

    major upplier

    ut rather

    range

    f

    amphorae

    f different

    rigins,

    fwhich

    alestinian

    Carthage

    RA

    5-6

    are the

    most

    mportant,

    ollowed

    yKapitan

    and I

    amphorae

    nd

    Carthage

    LRA

    3

    fromwestern

    sia Minor.

    n

    this asthorizonNorthAfrica

    upplies

    lmost ll

    the

    oil

    and

    fish auce

    mported

    n

    amphorae

    fig.

    6).

    The

    only xception

    s a small

    uantity

    rom

    usitania.

    3.

    Comparisons

    The

    publications

    f

    the

    mphorae

    rom heTerme

    el

    Nuotatore

    orm

    he

    tandard

    oint

    f ref-

    erence or heclassat Ostia.4AlthoughheTerme el Nuotatore xcavations erenotdesigned

    for

    uantification

    f the

    ceramic

    material,

    ubsequent uantification

    f the

    diagnostic ieces

    has

    provided

    nsight

    nto he rends

    n the

    upply

    f

    amphora-borne

    oods

    at Ostia. This evidence s

    particularly

    elcome ecause

    t heds

    ight

    n the

    period

    hat

    s

    acking

    n ourevidence. or

    ayers

    between

    he

    Flavian nd Severan

    eriods

    he

    Terme

    el Nuotatore

    material as been

    presented

    n

    various

    yntheses.

    here s

    no

    equivalent

    ynthetic

    reatmentor he

    mphorae

    rom

    he

    main

    ay-

    ers

    documenting

    he

    econd

    half f

    he hird

    nd thefourth

    enturies

    t theTerme

    el

    Nuotatore,

    although

    ull etails

    ave

    ppeared.

    The

    provenience

    f he

    mphorae

    ttestedt the

    Terme

    el Nuotatore

    as been calculated

    y

    geographic

    egions

    imilar

    o

    this

    tudy

    ith imilar

    esults.5

    or the

    Flavian

    eriod

    he hreemost

    important

    ources

    f

    amphorae

    re

    n

    rising

    mportance

    taly,

    Gaul,

    andthe berian

    peninsula,

    eachwith

    bout

    one-quarter,

    ith heNorth

    African

    ources

    n

    a

    decidedly

    econdary osition.

    n

    theHadrianic eriod here re wo mportantroveniences:

    aul andthe

    berian

    eninsula,

    hile

    the

    Africanources

    ise o

    the hird

    osition

    nd

    taly

    alls

    ack to

    fourth,

    ith

    Aegean

    mphorae

    making

    heir

    irst

    ignificant

    ppearance.

    y

    he ate

    Antonine

    eriod

    he

    berian

    eninsula

    nd

    the

    North

    African

    ources

    re he

    wo

    major roups,

    ith

    taly

    nd

    Gaul

    still

    mportant

    econdary

    nes

    and

    the

    Aegean

    remaining

    s

    a lesser

    resence.

    he ate Severan

    eriod

    hows

    he

    NorthAfrican

    dominating

    y

    far,

    with he

    Aegean

    n

    a clear

    econd

    place

    and all

    other

    roveniences

    f minor

    importance.

    n thefourth

    entury

    he

    North

    African

    ources

    re

    evenmore

    mportant,

    hile he

    Aegean

    ontinues

    s

    a

    decidedly

    ess

    mportant

    econd

    nd

    the

    ther

    roveniences

    re

    nsignificant.

    The

    major

    ifference

    etween

    he

    Terme

    elNuotatore

    vidence

    nd

    the

    omparable

    orizons

    n

    our

    eries

    s

    a

    greater

    mportance

    f

    Gaulish

    mphorae

    t

    the

    Terme

    ntheFlavian

    nd

    Hadrianic

    periods.

    he

    fourth-century

    icture

    or heTerme

    el

    Nuotatore

    verlaps

    n

    part

    with

    ur

    horizon

    to

    which

    t s

    more

    imilar,

    nd

    to a lesser

    xtent

    ith

    ur

    horizon .The

    atter

    hows

    diminished

    importance

    or

    he

    berian

    eninsula

    nd

    an

    increased

    ne

    for

    taly,

    ssentially

    ccounted

    or

    y

    Keay

    LII amphorae, hich egin obe distributeduringhefourthentury.

    The Terme

    el

    Nuotatore

    aterial

    grees

    ith urs

    n

    howing

    n

    ncreasing

    nterest

    n

    mporting

    4

    The

    basic

    bibliography

    s:

    Palma nd

    Panella

    1968;

    Panella

    1970;

    1973a;

    1973b; 1977a;

    1977b;

    Pavolini

    977a;

    1977b.

    For Strato

    in

    Area

    XVI,

    dating

    o the

    fourth

    entury,

    he

    most

    useful

    or

    omparison

    or his

    tudy

    n Ostia

    V,

    see

    the able

    ppended

    o this

    rticle

    ith

    he eelaborated

    ata

    from

    he

    able t

    Manacorda

    977a,

    41-244,

    with he

    ddi-

    tion

    f

    the

    data from avolini

    977a.

    Other onsiderations

    of he

    mphora

    material

    rom

    heTerme

    el Nuotatore

    ill

    be cited

    where

    elevant.

    5

    See Panella

    1986,

    ig.

    ,

    610,

    for

    synthesis.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Fri, 01 Jan 2016 01:45:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Imports to Ostia 1-5C

    8/15

    IMPORTS

    AT

    OSTI

    A IN THE

    IMPERIAL

    PERIOD AND LATE

    ANTIQUITY

    111

    oil.6

    he value or efiniteil

    containersose

    romess han 0

    percent

    n

    the lavian

    eriod,

    o more

    than 0

    percent

    ntheHadrianic

    eriod,

    o almost0

    percent

    ntheAntonine

    eriod,

    omore han

    0

    percent

    n

    the ate

    Severan

    eriod,

    nd to somewhat

    ore han alf t the

    nd of he

    ourth

    entury.

    The Terme

    el

    Nuotatore vidence or he

    provenience

    f the

    wine

    mported

    o Ostiacorre-

    sponds

    o what ur vidence hows.Gaul was

    the

    major

    xporter

    f

    wine o

    Ostia

    n

    the

    Hadrianic

    and Antonine

    eriods,

    with ome

    coming

    rom he

    Aegean.7

    talian

    winewas of

    relatively

    inor

    importance

    nd

    derived

    rom

    egions reviously

    ot

    oncerned

    ith

    he rade

    the

    Tiber

    alley

    nd

    Emilia)

    rather han

    Tyrrhenian

    entral

    taly.8

    n the

    ate Severan

    eriod

    Gaulishwine

    was declin-

    ing

    n

    mportance

    ut tillwell

    represented,

    nd eastern ine

    ontainersontinued

    o be

    attested.9

    In

    fourth-century

    ontexts ine

    mphorae

    rom heEast make

    up

    thebulk of those

    recognized.

    Otherwise orthAfrica

    upplied

    omewine

    n

    containersromMauretania nd

    possibly

    ome

    of

    the eries f

    mall,

    lat-bottomedessels.

    The situation ith

    il

    and

    fish

    auce

    containers rom heTerme el Nuotatore

    lso

    agrees

    n

    general ith urmaterial.he berian eninsulas themain upplier f mportedil and fish auce

    until oward he

    ndof he econd

    entury,lthough

    frican

    roducts

    onstituted

    strongecondary

    presence,

    ith

    NorthAfrica

    aking

    ver hedominant

    osition

    fter

    hat.10

    n

    the

    fourth-century

    contexts orth

    Africas

    practically

    nrivaled.

    The

    early

    ifth

    entury

    ayers

    rom

    elow heCasone

    del

    Sale

    current

    useum

    nd

    office uild-

    ing)

    t the

    enter

    f

    the

    ity elong

    o

    part

    fthe

    range

    overed

    y

    our

    horizon .11North

    Africa

    is the

    provenience

    f ome

    45

    percent,

    hile he

    East

    supplies early ne-quarter.

    he

    only

    ther

    significant

    ontemporary

    ource

    f

    amphorae

    s the rea of the Strait

    f

    Messina,

    with

    omewhat

    lessthan

    percent.

    s the

    African

    mphorae

    robably

    ll

    contained

    il or fish

    roducts

    ndmost

    of he

    astern

    mphorae

    nd those

    rom he trait

    fMessina erved or

    wine,

    herelativenterest

    in

    mporting

    il

    or

    fish

    roducts

    emainedonstant t about60

    percent.

    The contexts

    ating

    rom

    he irstalf f he

    ifth

    entury

    ntil a.

    450/470

    rom he xtramural

    basilica tPianabella orrespondo the atterart f urhorizon.12 hethreemportantroupsre

    the

    ame.

    Africa

    eads

    y

    arwith

    7

    percent,

    ut he

    ontainers

    romhe trait

    f

    Messina

    re

    n

    econd

    position

    t

    12

    percent,

    hile he astern

    mphorae

    ome o

    4.5

    percent.

    ere

    there

    ppears

    o be

    an

    even

    greater

    nterest

    n

    mporting

    il

    and fish

    roducts

    han

    t the ther

    ate ontextsxamined.

    4.

    Conclusion

    The shifts

    n

    the

    proveniences

    f the

    mphorae

    nthesehorizons

    orrespond

    o

    trends hathave

    becomewellknown

    hrough

    arious

    tudies

    ocumenting

    he

    rigin

    f

    mphorae

    mported

    o

    Ostia.

    6

    See

    the

    data

    presented

    by

    Panella

    1983,

    figs.

    49-50,

    260-261,

    for elected

    il containers

    those

    most

    ecurely

    attributedo that unction,uch sDressel 0) against on-

    tainers

    f other ontents

    i.e.,

    wine nd

    fish

    auces,

    s

    well

    as ess-known

    nes,

    ncluding ossible

    il).

    7

    Carandini

    nd

    Panella

    1981,

    91^92,

    494;

    Panella

    1991,

    290.

    8

    Panella

    1991,

    90.

    9

    Carandini

    nd Panella

    1981,

    98,

    500.

    10

    Carandini

    nd

    Panella

    1981,

    92^94,

    496-497,

    98-499

    seem

    o ndicate

    hatAfrican

    mphorae

    or hese

    roducts

    were ncreasingrom heAntonineeriod hroughhe arly

    Severan

    eriod

    o become

    dominant

    n the ate

    Severan r

    Gordian

    period;

    Panella

    1983,

    figs.

    9-50,

    260-261

    shows

    Baetican

    il as second

    to

    Africann the Antonine

    eriod;

    Panella

    1991,

    90-291

    also

    places

    Baetican il

    n the econd

    position

    ith

    espect

    o African

    n

    theAntonine

    eriod.

    11

    Martin

    993,

    07-208;

    Martin

    005,

    62-63.

    12

    Ciarrocchi 993.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Fri, 01 Jan 2016 01:45:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Imports to Ostia 1-5C

    9/15

    112

    ARCHER MARTIN

    Amphorae

    rom

    yrrhenian

    entral

    taly iveway

    irsto onesfrom he

    berian

    eninsula

    nd then

    to NorthAfrican

    nes,

    with moderate ise neastern ontainersn ate

    ntiquity.

    hus,

    urdata

    offer

    merely

    confirmationith he omfortf

    more

    olid

    quantification.

    The

    change

    n

    emphasis

    rom

    mporting

    ine o

    mporting

    il and

    fish auce has

    perhaps

    ot

    been

    brought

    o

    sharply

    nto ocus s

    in this

    tudy.

    t

    s,however,

    phenomenon

    ith

    nteresting

    implications.

    he time fthe

    change ccording

    o our

    data,

    between

    he econdhalf f

    thefirst

    century

    nd thefirst alf fthe

    econd,

    orrespondspproximately

    o the

    nd of

    the

    production

    of he

    arge

    wine

    mphorae

    f

    Tyrrhenian

    entral

    taly

    ssociated

    with he lave-run

    illas hat

    ad

    flourishedhere or everal

    enturies,

    hich till ominate ur

    first orizon.

    Discarding

    he

    highly nlikely ypothesis

    f

    sudden

    rop

    n

    demand

    orwinewith

    espect

    o

    oil and fish aucebut

    rather

    ssuming

    t

    o haveremained

    elatively

    onstant

    hroughout

    he

    period

    from he irsto the

    ifth

    enturies,

    ne

    s facedwith

    ccounting

    or

    he

    rigin

    f hewine o

    replace

    what

    previously

    as

    supplied y

    the

    villas f

    Tyrrhenian

    entral

    taly.

    ere one must

    emember,

    aswas said at thebeginning,hat hispaperdealsonlywithproduce arriedn amphorae. he

    difference ust avebeen taken

    p by

    wine

    brought

    o market

    n

    some

    other ashion.13n the ast

    few ecades t has often

    een

    recalled s a

    general

    oteof

    caution hat

    wine nd oil couldbe and

    were

    undoubtedly roduced

    n

    most

    arts

    f theMediterranean orld nd thatnot all

    ended

    up

    transported

    n

    amphorae.

    here s

    iterary

    nd

    conographic

    vidence

    or

    arrels nd skin ontain-

    ers,

    nd wine nd oil

    moving

    short

    istance ithin local market ould

    imply

    avebeen

    placed

    in

    miscellaneous

    ontainers,

    uch

    s vino

    fuso

    till

    s

    today.

    ur statistics

    uggest

    hat rom

    bout

    A.D. 00 a

    greater

    ercentage

    fOstia'swine

    upply

    eached t

    n

    some

    uch

    way.

    13

    See De

    Sena

    2003

    for

    methodological

    onsiderationsnd

    an

    attempt

    o

    estimate

    ow

    much

    ofthe need

    for il

    the

    hinterlandfRome nd

    Ostia could

    upply

    about

    ne-fifth

    on

    average).

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Fri, 01 Jan 2016 01:45:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Imports to Ostia 1-5C

    10/15

    IMPORTS

    AT

    OSTIA

    IN

    THE

    IMPERIAL PERIOD

    AND LATE

    ANTIQUITY

    1

    3

    Appendix:

    trato

    of

    AreaXVI at theTerme elNuotatore

    The tablebelow

    presents

    he data on the

    amphorae

    rom trato of Area

    XVI

    at the

    Terme el

    Nuotatore

    ccording

    o current enominations

    nd

    grouped eographically

    utwithout

    ny

    heck-

    ing

    of

    thematerialtself.14

    14

    It s basedon Manacorda

    977a,

    able

    ,

    pp.

    241-244

    with

    the

    ddition f he nformationontained

    n

    Pavolini

    977

    .

    I

    am

    extremelyrateful

    o Clementina

    anellaforher

    help

    in

    establishing

    he

    quivalences.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Fri, 01 Jan 2016 01:45:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Imports to Ostia 1-5C

    11/15

    114

    ARCHER

    MARTIN

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Fri, 01 Jan 2016 01:45:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Imports to Ostia 1-5C

    12/15

    IMPORTS

    AT

    OSTIA IN THE

    IMPERIAL

    PERIOD

    AND LATE

    ANTIQUITY

    115

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Fri, 01 Jan 2016 01:45:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Imports to Ostia 1-5C

    13/15

    116

    ARCHER

    MARTIN

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Fri, 01 Jan 2016 01:45:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Imports to Ostia 1-5C

    14/15

    IMPORTS

    AT

    OSTIA

    N THE

    IMPERIAL ERIOD AND LATE

    ANTIQUITY

    1

    7

    Works ited

    Carandini,

    .,

    and

    C.

    Panella,

    The

    Trading

    onnections fRome nd

    Central

    taly

    n

    the

    Late Second and

    ThirdCenturies:

    he

    Evidence f

    the

    Terme el Nuotatore

    xcavations, stia,

    n

    The

    RomanWest

    in

    the

    Third

    entury:

    ontributions

    rom

    rchaeology

    nd

    History,

    d. A.

    King

    nd M.

    Henig

    Oxford

    1981)

    487-503.

    Ciarrocchi, .,

    Pianabella

    Ostia antica).

    Area

    3000,

    n

    La Storia conomica iRoma neWalto

    edioevo lia

    lucedei recenticavi

    rcheologici.

    ttidel Seminario

    oma

    2-3

    aprile

    992,

    d. L. Paroli nd P.

    Delogu

    (Florence 993)

    215-219.

    De

    Sena,

    E.

    C,

    Seeing

    heTrees

    nd

    theForest:

    oward More Refined

    nderstanding

    f

    Socio-Cultural

    Systems

    n

    Classical

    Antiquity.

    he Case ofOlive Oil inAncient

    atium,

    Archaeologiae.

    esearch

    y

    Foreign

    issions n

    taly

    (2003)

    11-32.

    Manacorda, ., Anfore,

    n

    StudiMiscellanei

    3,

    Ostia

    V Le

    Terme

    el

    Nuotatore.cavodell

    ambiente

    VI

    e delVarea

    XV

    d.

    A. Carandini nd C. Panella

    Rome

    1977a)

    116-266.

    , Anfore, nStudiMiscellanei3,Ostia V Le Terme elNuotatore.cavo ell mbienteVIedell' rea

    XXV,

    ed. A. Carandinind C. Panella

    Rome1977b)

    359-383.

    Martin, .,

    Ostia ntica Casone

    del

    Sale;

    Porto

    Fiumicino).

    rea

    ,

    n

    La Storia

    conomicaiRomaneWalto

    Medioevo lia

    lucedei recenti

    cavi

    rcheologici.

    ttidel Seminario oma

    2-3

    aprile

    992,

    d. L. Paroli

    andP.

    Delogu

    Florence

    993)

    206-215.

    ,

    Variation

    n

    Ceramic

    Assemblages

    s an ndicator f

    Openness

    o

    Trade,

    n

    Terra

    Marique:

    tudies

    inHonor

    f

    Anna

    Marguerite

    cCann

    n the

    Receipt

    f

    heGoldMedal

    of

    he

    Archaeological

    nstitute

    f

    America,

    d.

    J.

    Pollini

    Oxford

    005)

    61-76.

    Martin, .,

    and E. C. De

    Sena,

    Agricultural

    nd

    Craft

    upplies

    n

    Late RomanOstia:

    Pottery

    vidence

    rom

    the

    DAI/AAR

    Excavations,

    n

    LCRW 1. Late

    RomanCoarse

    Wares,

    ooking

    Wares nd

    Amphorae

    n

    theMediterranean:

    rchaeology

    nd

    Archaeometry,

    d.

    J.

    Ma

    Gurt

    Esparraguera,.

    Buxeda

    Garrigos,

    M. A. Cau Ontiveros

    Oxford

    005)

    385-393.

    Martin, .,

    M.

    Heinzelmann,

    .

    C. De

    Sena,

    M. G. Granino

    Cecere,

    The

    Urbanistic

    roject

    n thePrevi-

    ouslyUnexcavated reas fOstia DAI-AAR1996-2001),Memoirsf heAmerican cademyn Rome

    47

    (2002)

    259-304.

    Palma, .,

    andC.

    Panella,

    Anfore,

    n

    Studi

    Miscellanei

    3,

    Ostia

    . Le Terme

    el

    Nuotatore.cavo

    ell' mbiente

    IV,

    ed.

    A. Carandini

    nd C.

    Panella

    Rome

    1968)

    97-116.

    Panella,C,

    Anfore,

    n StudiMiscellanei

    6,

    Ostia

    I. Le Terme el Nuotatore.

    cavodell' mbiente

    ,

    ed. A.

    Carandini

    nd C. Panella

    Rome

    1970)

    102-156.

    ,

    Contenitori

    onoansati,

    n StudiMiscellanei

    1,

    Ostia

    II. Le Terme el Nuotatore.

    cavo

    degli

    ambienti

    II,

    VI, VII,

    Le Terme el

    Nuotatore.cavodell' mbiente e

    di un

    saggio

    nell'area

    O,

    ed.

    A.

    Carandini

    ndC. Panella

    Rome1973a)

    460-462.

    ,

    Anfore,

    n

    Studi

    Miscellanei

    1,

    Ostia

    II.

    Le

    Terme el Nuotatore.cavo

    degli

    mbienti

    II,

    VI, VII,

    Le Terme el

    Nuotatore.cavodell mbiente

    e

    di

    un

    aggio

    ell'area

    O,

    ed.

    A.

    Carandini nd

    C.

    Panella

    (Rome1973b)

    463-633.

    ,

    I contenitorileari

    resenti

    d Ostia

    n

    eta antonina:

    nalisi

    ipologica, pigrafica,

    uantitativa,

    n

    Produccion

    comercio

    el aceite n

    a

    antigiiedad.

    egundo ongreso

    nternacional

    Sevilla,

    4-28

    Febrero

    1982) Madrid1983)225-261.

    ,

    Oriente occidente:

    onsiderazioni

    u

    alcune nfore

    egee'

    di

    eta

    mperiale

    Ostia,

    nRecherches

    sur es

    amphores recques,

    d.

    J.-Y. mpereur

    nd

    Y.

    Garland

    Paris 1986)

    609-636.

    Bulletin e corre-

    spondance

    ellenique

    uppl.

    13.

    ,

    Un

    contesto

    i eta antonina alle Terme

    el Nuotatore

    i

    Ostia,

    n

    Studimiscellanei

    8,

    Giornate

    in onore

    i

    AchilleAdriani.

    oma 26-27

    novembre

    984,

    d. S. Stucchi nd M. Bonanno

    Aravantinos

    (Rome

    1991)

    281-297.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Fri, 01 Jan 2016 01:45:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Imports to Ostia 1-5C

    15/15

    118

    ARCHER MARTIN

    Pavolini,

    C,

    Contenitori

    onoansati,

    n

    StudiMiscellanei

    3,

    Ostia

    V. Le Terme el Nuotatore.

    cavo

    dell'ambiente VI e dell'areaXXV,ed. A. Carandini ndC. Panella Rome1977a)113.

    ,

    Contenitori

    onoansati,

    nStudiMiscellanei

    3,

    Ostia V Le Terme

    elNuotatore.cavo

    ell'ambiente

    XVI e

    dellarea

    XXV,

    ed. A. Carandini nd C. Panella

    Rome1977b)

    358.