incessant power supply in nigeria and the need for … … · for fault evaluation and reliability...
TRANSCRIPT
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1554 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
TITLE: INCESSANT POWER SUPPLY IN NIGERIA AND THE NEED FOR THE
DESIGN AND PRODUCTION OF 100,000MW POWER PLANT
NAME OF AUTOR: OSHIN OLA AUSTIN, Adanikin Ariyo, Fakorede Ebenezer, Joseph Ojotu
AUTO BIOGRAPHY My name is Oshin Ola Austin. I hold a Bachelor Degree and a Master Degree in Electrical and
Electronics Engineering, Power system Engineering Options, from the Federal University of
Technology, Akure, Nigeria with an excellent Eight years experience both in the field of power
System Engineering and in classroom teaching. My excellent working attitudes, hardworking
and good relationship with both staff, students and clients have been found to be an outstanding
tracks of good records. A team player, effective, dynamic and result oriented; very apt to learn and working to achieve desired
results. I am Christian from Ondo State
Telephone: 23480 6013 7969 Email: [email protected]
Email: [email protected],
FEBRUARY, 2018
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1555 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
ABSTRACT
The present unreliable and erratic power supply is a pointer to the fact that there is a great need
for fault evaluation and reliability studies of electric power system in Nigeria. The recent
blackout in the country has grounded many activities and has destroyed many industrial
processes. Also, the power industries face a lot of problems. Some of the highest priority issues
being generation of sufficient power, urgent clearance of faults, adequate protection and increase
reliability of the system, that is, bringing a steady uninterrupted power supply to the consumers.
The Nigerian power problem resulted to incessant planned, forced and unplanned outages. In
addition, it has resulted to erratic and unreliable supply of electricity in the country. It has
reduced productivity and has increased unemployment rate in the country to over 40million (this
figure is over 70% of Nigerian youths. It has led many of the youths in the country to crime. It
has led many of the deaths of many innocent people in the country. Hence, an analytical method
is developed to assess the dynamic- reliability of the distribution system, as well as optimizes the
occurrence of faults along each of the individual consumer point in a feeder in order to improve
the performance of the system. This research publication therefore evaluates the occurrence of
faults which is about 856 occurrences during a period of 8 years and outages which range
between 1118 to 3785 hours per annum along the distribution lines, also the failure rates of each
of the feeders were analyzed in order to improve on the supply of electricity in the distribution
network. The reliability of the system which ranges between 8.57*10-12 to 9.548*10-5 were
analyzed; and fault clearing techniques were carried out. Efforts were made to adequately assess
the failure rates of the feeders which range between 0.003 and 0.001 and reliability of the
distribution system. Efforts were also made to improve the performance of the system. As a
result, it was possible to establish improvement techniques which ensure adequate and constant
supply of electricity to all the consumers for industrial growth and employment: a basic solution
to increasing crime rate in the country.
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1556 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
KEY WORDS Fault Evaluation, Improvement of Electric Power Distribution Network, Reliability, Occurrence
of Faults, Failure Rates, Outages, Reliability, Fault Clearing, Improvement Techniques, Supply
of Electricity, Productivity, Load Flow Analysis
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction An electric power system consists of three major components: Generation, Transmission
and Distribution. A Generating station generally employs the action of a prime mover coupled to
an alternator and at least an external exciter for the production of electric power. The prime
mover may be a steam turbine, a wind mill or a water turbine which converts energy from other
sources into mechanical energy. The external exciter produces the magnetic field. In many cases,
the field will be electro-magnetic, and field coils carrying the field current will be wound on a
magnetic structure. The iron forming structure will be laminated. This is to reduce field iron
losses. Then the field coils are concentrated and wound around protruding poles called salient
poles, or distributed in slots cut into a cylindrical magnetic structure commonly used for AC
generators. With this arrangement, a DC current is applied to the field winding (rotor winding)
which produces a magnetic field (a rotor magnetic field). The rotor of the generator is then
turned by a prime mover producing a rotating magnetic field within the machine. The rotating
magnetic fields induces a three phase set of voltages within the stator winding from which output
voltage ranging between 11kV and 25kV can be obtained. This is in accordance to Faraday’s
laws of electromagnetic induction. The electrical energy produced by the generating station is
then transmitted over long distance and distributed with the help of transmission lines and
distributors to various consumers. In view of the insufficient electric power generation capacity
and coupled with power losses and constant outages many industries and consumers faced with
unreliable power supply in the country. Hence the focus of this research work is based on Fault
Evaluation and Improvement of Electricity in Power Distribution Network: Ikorodu in Lagos
State, Nigeria as a case study.
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1557 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
CHAPTER TWO
2.1 Problem Statement:
The incessant electric power supply problems facing the existence of industries in Nigeria
is a pointer to the fact that there is great need for fault evaluation and reliability assessment of
electric power system in the country and provide solutions. As it has been earlier said, this
problem has grounded many activities and has destroyed many industrial processes. In view of
this, a traditional analytical method is developed to access the occurrence of faults and outages
along each of the individual consumer point in a feeder, as well as optimizes the reliability of the
generation, transmission and distribution system.
In view of this, it will be possible to improve on the performance of the system. It will
also assist in the generation and transmission of sufficient power, clearing of faults, ensuring
adequate protection and reliability of the distribution system, that is, bringing a steady
uninterrupted power supply to consumers within the distribution area and the entire country.
2.2 Existing generation capabilities in Nigeria
The generation capabilities in Nigeria are shown in Table 1.1
Table 1.1: Generation capabilities in Nigeria
S/N NAMES OF GENERATING
STATIONS
RAW
MATERIALS
MW
1 Egbin Thermal Power Plant Gas, coal 1080
2 Kainji Hydro Power Plant Hydro(water) 480
3 Jebba Hydro Power Plant Hydro (water) 360
4 Shiroro Hydro Power Plant Hydro (water) 450
5 Sapele Thermal Power Plant Gas Turbine 170
6 Afam Thermal Power Plant Gas Turbine 72
7 Delta Thermal Power Plant Gas 329
8 Geregu Gas Power Plant Gas 414
9 Omotosho Gas Power Plant Gas 300
10 Papalanto Gas Power Plant Gas 300
11 Alaoji Gas Power Plant Gas 346 MW
Total 4301MW
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1558 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
Source: Power Holding Company of Nigeria Plc, Ikorodu , Lagos State
2.3 EXISTING NATIONAL INDEPENDENT POWER PROJECT (IPP) IN NIGERIA
The National Independent Power Projects are shown in table 1.2
Source : Source : Power Holding Company of Nigeria Plc, Ikorodu ,Lagos State
Though the total installed generating capacity is 5,746MW, the country is only able to
genera
te
3,500
MW
becaus
e most
faciliti
es
have
been
poorly
manag
ed and the reliability of the generating, transmission and distribution system being very low due
to high failure rates of equipment, large energy losses and poor protection system. In addition,
Electricity in Nigeria is facing a lot of problems ranging from financial misappropriation, to
inadequacy of facilities and non-commitment of PHCN staff. Therefore, the condition has
remained pathetic with failures, power failure and non-reliability of the system on daily basis, the
effects has grounded many activities and destroyed many industrial processes, and has open
ways for mass unemployment, crimes, slow economic and poor national development.
Since the management of continuous, reliable and constant power supply in Nigeria is a
difficult task, there is a need for the reliability assessment of the power system network. This
evaluation will reveal the prevalence and frequency of faults and outages on the distribution
system. It will also reveal their effects on the supply of electric power to various consumers.
Also, it will be possible to analyze the causes of faults along the transmission and distribution
Serial
Number
Name/Location Capacity
1 AES 288MW
2 Okpai 480 MW
3 Afam 300MW
4 Omokun 75MW
5 Afam VI 300MW
6 Ibom Power 188MW
7 Omokun 75 MW
8 ALSCON 360MW
Total 2066 MW IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1559 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
lines. Then adequate system techniques for improving the performance of the system will be
achievable.
2.4 Specific objectives of the study: The specific objectives of the research work are to:
(a) study the causes, nature and effects of faults on the distribution network;
(b) evaluate the occurrence of faults and outages on feeders and distribution networks,
and
(c) determine the reliability of the network.
(d) improve electricity supply in Nigeria.
2.5 Expected Contribution to knowledge The study is expected to:
(a) provide the reliability indices for Ikorodu distribution network; and
(b) establish procedure to improve electricity supply to consumers within the
distribution system
(c) establish procedure to improve electricity supply in Nigeria
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 3.1 INTRODUCTION
Power System grounding is very important, particularly since a large majority of faults involve
ground or re caused by thunderstorm/lighting strikes. In order to carry out fault evaluation of
Electric Power Distribution Network, a detail study of Ikorodu 132/33kV substation Network of
the Power Holding Company of Nigeria under which there are about 47,739 customers was
carried out. The results for Lagos Feeder were presented in this research publication. Types and
frequency of faults occurrence were recorded. These data were collated, evaluated and analyzed
both mathematically, graphically and with the use of computer excel software.
The data collected from the Power Holding Company of Nigeria include: Geographical map of
the Distribution Area Network, fault records, causes and duration of outages, feeder-by-feeder
load loss and system downtime, frequency of faults, inventory of distribution transformers on
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1560 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
each feeder, feeder length, transformer capacity and conductor capacity, load demand of
customers, number of customers and their categories. From the collated data obtained for 8 years (2004-2011), the network reliability, failure rate ( λ ), Mean
Time Between Failures (MTBF), Mean Down Time (MDT) and Availability (A) were calculated using
equations (3.1) to (3.5).
Then the failure rate of the system on yearly basis was evaluated which was used to determine
the reliability of the system on yearly basis. Also, feeder-by-feeder load loss and was evaluated
for each year using equations (3.6) to (3.9). The month that fault occurred, the date of fault, the
time the feeder tripped, the time it was restored, duration of fault (downtime), load loss in
megawatts, phase on which fault occurred and nature of faults were recorded and evaluated.
From the data, the failure rates ( λ ) of the feeders were evaluated using equation (3.1)
Failure rate = fault frequency on each feeder
Period of operation of the feeder (hour) ……. ……………….......(3.1)
The results of the failure rates were used to determine the reliability R(t) of the feeders according
to equation (2):
R(t) = e-λt ……………….. .………………………....(3.2)
Where λ is failure rate (failure/hour) and t is time (hour).
Mean Time Between Failures (MTBF) of all the feeders were evaluated using equation (3):
MTBF ………………………………………….………………….(3.3)
Mean Down Time were also estimated on feeder by feeder basis using equation (3.4):
Mean Down Time (MDT) = Total down time of each feeder
Fault frequency ……………...(3.4)
Finally, availability (A) of electricity within the distribution network on yearly and feeder by
feeder basis were evaluated using equation (5):
Availability = operating time of the feeder in a year
total number of hours in a year ……………………(3.5)
In fact, Reliability Indices recovered in section (2.25) to (2.29) and the relevant equations (2.31)
to (2.51) were used for all calculations which are repeated here for clarity as follows:
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1561 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
Reliability customer-oriented indices were obtained using the following equations.
System Average Interruption Frequency Index (SAIFI)
servedcustomer ofnumber Total
year ain on interrupti customers sustained ofnumer TotalSAIFI = …………..(3.6)
System Average Interruption Duration Index (SAIDI)
servedcustomer ofnumber Totalyear ain on interrupti sustained ofduration TotalSAIDI = ……………………(3.7)
Customer Average Interruption Frequency Index (CAIFI)
affected customers ofnumber Total onsinterrupticustomer annual ofnumber TotalCAIFI = ………………..……(3.8)
Customer Average Interruption Duration Index (CAIDI)
(3.9).................................. nsinteruptiocustomer ofnumber Total year ain on interrupti sustained ofDuration TotalCAIDI =
Average Service Availability Index (ASAI)
demnded hourscustomer service availble of hoursCustomer ASAI = …………………...……………(3.10)
Average Service Availability Index (ASUI)
year ain demnded hourscustomer year ain service/ unavailble of hoursCustomer ASUI = …………...………(3.11)
The power losses on the available feeders are calculated on the basis of the monthly maximum
loading on the feeders, the resistance, size of each feeder conductor, route length of each feeder
and maximum current drawn from each feeder conductor using equations (3.12 to 3.15).
Current drawn from feeder
fpV .3 PI 1×
= ……………………………………………….(3.12)
and A lR
=
….……………………………………. (3.13)
where P is power in k Watts
V is voltage in volts
is resistivity in mΩ
R is resistance in ohms; and
A is cross sectional area in m2
Power loss = RI L2 ……………………………………………………………… (3.14)
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1562 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
Power loss = Power received - Power consumed ……………………………….(3.15)
CHAPTER FOUR
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS 4.1 Failure Rate and Reliability Index on Lagos Road Feeder
Failure rate of the feeder for the 8 Years
operation of Period
frequency Fault = …….……………………………………………..(4.2)
53690
92= = 0.00171354failure/hour
4.2 Reliability on Lagos Road Feeder
The reliability system for the period of 8 years (2004-2011) was obtained.
tetR λ−=)( ………………………………………………………(4.1)
)8760)(0017135.0(718.2)( −=tR
810*3143.30)( −=tR
4.3 Mean Time Between Failure (MTBF) for the eight years on Lagos Road Feeder
λ 1
=
0.00171354 1
=
= 583.587hours (average value within the eight years)…(4.3)
4.4 Mean Down Time (MDT) = Mean Time To Repair (MTTR) on Lagos Road Feeder
frequencyFault
down time Total = ……………………(4.4)
92
16,390 =
= 178.152 hours ( average result within the eight years)
4.5 Availability of Electricity on Lagos Road Feeder in Percentage
Availability year ain timeof hours Total
Time Operating = ………(4.5)
70080 53,690
= = 0.76612 or 76.612%
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1563 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
4.6 Cumulative Load Losses of the Feeders in MW (2004 – 2011)
Feeders
Lagos
road
feeder
Ayangburen
feeder
Ijebu
Ode
feeder
Eyita
feeder
Igbogbo
feeder
Ladega
feeder
Agric
feeder
Isawo
feeder
Oriokuta
feeder
Load Loss
(MW) 203 237 204.5 204.32 180.98 200.9 198.3 189.1 175.01
Figure 4.1 Feeder Load losses on the feeders ( 2004-2011)
The total load loss for the nine feeders in 2004-2011 is 1792.73MW
4.7 Table 4.2: Downtime Results for the Feeders in hours (year 2004-2011) Feeders
Cumulative
Lagos
road
feeder
Ayangburen
feeder
Ijebu
Ode
feeder
Eyita
feeder
Igbogbo
feeder
Ladega
feeder
Agric
feeder
Isawo
feeder
Oriokuta
feeder
Downtime
(hours)
16390 21277 18816 17842 20183 19431 17651 18628 18452
Lagos road feeder
Ayangburen feeder
Ijebu Ode feeder
Eyita feeder
Igbogbo feeder
Ladega feeder
Agric feeder
Isawo feeder
Oriokuta feeder
Load
loss
(M
w)
(Year IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1564 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
Figure 4.2: Downtime results for the feeders (year 2004-2011)
Total Downtime along all the nine feeders between the 8 years (2004-2011) is equal to 168,670
Hours, out of the total time of 560,640 hours, leaving a total operating time of 391,670 hours
4.8 Table 4.3: Frequency of Faults on 11 kV feeders (frequency of faults on all the three
phases) (2004-2011)
Feeders Lagos
road
feeder
Ayangburen
feeder
Ijebu
Ode
feeder
Eyita
feeder
Igbogbo
feeder
Ladega
feeder
Agric
feeder
Isawo
feeder
Oriokuta
feeder
Frequency 92 106 94 100 95 97 93 90 93
Figure 4.3: Frequency of Faults on 11 kV feeders (frequency of faults on the three
phases) (2004-2011)
4.9 Table 4.4: Failure rate of 11 kV feeders (2004-2011)
Lagos road feeder
Ayangburen feeder
Ijebu Ode feeder
Eyita feeder
Igbogbo feeder
Ladega feeder
Agric feeder
80
85
90
95
100
105
110
2004-2011
Lagos road feeder
Ayangburen feeder
Ijebu Ode feeder
Eyita feeder
Igbogbo feeder
Ladega feeder
Agric feeder
Isawo feeder
Oriokuta feeder
Dow
ntim
e
(Years )
Freq
uenc
y of
(Years )
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1565 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
Feeders Lagos
road
feeder
Ayangburen
feeder
Ijebu Ode
feeder
Eyita
feeder
Igbogbo
feeder
Ladega
feeder
Agric
feeder
Isawo
feeder
Oriokuta
feeder
Failure rate (hr) 0.0017
1
0.00217 0.00183 0.00191 0.00190 0.00192 0.0017
7
0.0017
5
0.00180
Figure 4.4: Failure rate of 11 kV lines feeders (2004-2011)
4.10 Table 4.5 : Reliability of 11 kV Feeders (2004-2011)
Feeders Lagos
road
feeder
Ayangburen
feeder
Ijebu
Ode
feeder
Eyita
feeder
Igbogbo
feeder
Ladega
feeder
Agric
feeder
Isawo
feeder Oriokuta
feeder
Reliability
(*10-8 )
30.314 0.547 10.587 5.223 5.721 5.185 17.878 22.181 14.048
Lagos road feeder
Ayangburen feeder
Ijebu Ode feeder
Eyita feeder
Igbogbo feeder
Ladega feeder
Agric feeder
Isawo feeder
Failu
re ra
te
(hrs
)
(Year ) 2004-2011
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1566 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
Figure 4.5: Reliability of the 11 kV Feeders (Year 2004-2011)
4.11 Resistance of Lagos Road Feeder
i. The length of each of the sections was obtained as shown in equation 3.21 L = S* 50 ………………………………………………. (4.6) Where S = number of spans 50 = Average length span ii. Resistance at 400c ( R400c ) was obtained DC Resistance (Rt)DC per km of any line at temperature t (40.5) can be obtained using Equation (3.22) (Rt)DC = (Rref)DC * t + 288 tref + 288 ……………………..(4.7) Where (Rref)DC = DC Resistance of the line per km at a reference temperature t ref ( 200C ) (Rt)DC = DC Resistance of the line at 40.50c t = 400C tref = 200C The DC Resistance of the line per km at a reference temperature t ref = 200C as stated by the manufacturer is 0.27018 Ω /km. The AC Resistance Rt(AC) /km of the line can then be obtained from Rt(AC) /km = (Rt)DC * 1.05 (4.8)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Year 2004-2011 (*10-8 )
Lagos road feeder
Ayangburen feeder
Ijebu Ode feeder
Eyita feeder
Igbogbo feeder
Ladega feeder
Agric feeder
Isawo feeder
Failu
re ra
te (h
rs)
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1567 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
Where Rt(AC) /km = AC Resistance of the line /km at 400c (Rt)DC = DC Resistance of the line at 400c 1.05 is the factor used to multiply the DC resistance in order to Obtain the AC resistance. It represents the addition resistance Due to skin effects (Mehta and Mehta,2008) The resistance of the line at 40oC were then obtained as follows: (R400C)DC /km = (R20)DC * t + 288 tref + 288 (R40)DC /km = 0.27018 * 40 + 288 20 + 288 (R40)DC/ km = 0.27018 * 328.5 308 (R40)DC /km = 0.288163 (R40)AC /km = 0.288163 * 1.05 (R40)AC /km = 0. 288163 * 1.05 = 0.3025709 Hence, the resistance of the line per kilometer = 0.3025709 ohm.
These values were obtained by calculation using Microsoft excel algorithm. The values of the
line resistance, inductance and impedance obtained are presented
4.12 Inductance of Lagos Road Feeder The inductance of conductors per phase per meter can be obtained from equation (4.9)
= r
D log 2 + 0.5 * 10 = L eq
e 7-
o ……………………………(4.9)
Where Deq = 3cabcab D*D*D= ………………………………….. ( 4.10)
And r = Radius of the 100m2 Aluminium conductor The inductance of the 11KV line along Lagos Road feeder was obtained as illustrated below:
1. Radius of the 100mm2 Aluminum conductor = r r = 0.00559m
2. The distances between the pairs of conductors are :
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1568 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
D ab = 0.658 Dbc = 0.658 and Dca = 1.316 The equivalent distance of the conductor Deq is given by Deq = 3√ Dab * Dbc * Dca
Deq = 3√ 0.658 * 0.658 * 1.316 Deq = 3√ 0.5697806 Deq = 0.82902803 meter Inductance/phase/meter of the lines were obtained as follows: Lo = 10-7 * 0.5 + 2 loge Deq . r Lo = 10-7 * 0.5 + 2 loge 0.82908 . 0.00559 Lo = 10-7 * 0.5 + 2 loge 148.31485 Lo/ phase/meter = 0.0010312 Henry These values were obtained by calculation. Microsoft excel algorithm was used to analyze the results and the values of the line inductive reactance obtained were presented in tables 4.1 – 4.3 Reactance of Lagos Road Feeder/phase/kilometer = ofLπ2 (4.11) = 0.32400525 ohm Resistance of Lagos Road Feeder/ phase/kilometer = 0.302570893 ohm 4.13 Impedance of the Lagos Road Feeder The impedance Z, of Lagos Road feeder/kilometer = 0.302570893 + j0.32400525 Therefore impedance Z per kilometer = 0.443 ohm Table 4.6 shows the impedance of Lagos Road 11KV feeder and their measured current values on section by section basis. S/N Sections Location Length (m) Resistance (Ω) Reactance (Ω) Impedance (Ω)
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1569 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
1 Wema Bank 5.6 1.694 1.814 2.439 2 Jiboro 5.8 1.755 1.879 2.527 3 Afri Bank 6.0 1.815 1.944 2.614
4 Unity Bank 6.2 1.876 2.009 2.701
5 ITC 6.4 1.936 2.074 2.788
6 Oceanic Bank 6.4 1.936 2.592 2.788
7 Ragolis 8.0 2.421 2.657 3.485
8 Intercontinental 8.2 2.481 3.305 3.572
9 Oduguwa 10.2 3.086 3.337 4.444
10 First Bank 10.3 3.116 4.374 4.487
11 Fin Land 13.5 4.085 4.374 5.881
12 Amoke Soderu 13.5 4.085 4.374 5.881
S/N Sections Location Length (m) Resistance (Ω) Reactance (Ω) Impedance (Ω)
1 Oke Oriya 10.2 3.086 3.305 4.522
2 Aniyikaye 10.6 3.207 3.434 4.699
3 Bolaji 11.4 3.450 3.694 5.053
4 Econet 11.8 3.570 3.823 5.231
5 Fatai 12.4 3.752 4.018 5.497
6 Ebun 13.5 4.085 4.374 5.985
7 Diamond Bank 7.3 2.209 2.365 3.236
8 Awosere 8.2 2.481 2.657 3.635
9 Lowa 10.2 3.086 3.305 4.522
10 Mabadeje 11.3 3.419 3.661 6.009
11 Arisendo 13.5 4.085 4.374 5.985
S/N Sections Location Length (m) Resistance (Ω) Reactance (Ω) Impedance (Ω)
1 Lagos St Water Works 10.3 3.116 3.337 4.566
2 Etisalat 10 3.027 3.240 4.433
3 Koya 12 3.631 3.888 5.319
4 UBA 9.4 2.844 3.046 4.167
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1570 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
5 GTB 9.6 2.905 3.110 4.256
6 Fun City 9.8 2.965 3.175 4.344
7 Zenith Bank 9.9 2.995 3.208 4.389
8 Sterling Bank 10.0 3.026 3.240 4.433
9 Tanterlizer 10.2 3.086 3.305 4.522
10 Jobi 10.4 3.147 3.370 4.610
11 Ajenifuja 12.1 3.661 3.920 5.364
12 Towolari 11.4 3.449 3.694 5.054
4.14 Load Flow Analysis and Line Parameters along Lagos Road Feeder
The normal operating voltage of Lagos ROAD feeder is 11KV. Its length is 13.52 Km. It
originates from the 33/11kV Distribution Substation Located at Sabo in Ikorodu. However, the
resistance and inductance along the line form series impedance which usually reduces the
voltage at the receiving end. As a result, the output of any of the 11/0.415kV distribution
transformers along the feeder is always less than 220 V on a single phase and less than 415V on
a three phase system. Voltages along the line were recorded using multi meter at interval of 1km.
The results obtained were shown in table 4.6
4.15 Analysis and Calculations of Fault Currents on Lagos Road Feeder
Fault currents were estimated and calculated based on the data collected in Ikorodu
PHCN Distribution office along 11KV Lagos Road and other feeders. From these data,
calculations and analysis were made; the fault currents along the distribution line were also
calculated.
From the results obtained the ratings of the protective devices such as: current
transformers, relays, circuit breakers and fuses that would be required for the protection of the
distribution line and equipment were obtained. Thus the protective devices selected will be able
to withstand the large values of fault current which will occur in the event of faults. With this
development, the protection of lines, equipment, lives and properties can be safeguarded by
proper setting and of choice relays.
Fault currents along the outgoing 11kV Lagos Road feeder were calculated and the
results obtained presented:
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1571 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
At the point of fault, 1/Zpu equivalent = 1/ 0.1903823 = 5.253 (1) 1 . Z p = 1 . 0.1903823 = 5.253pu (2) Since VAfault = 1/Zf.pu × (MVA)base , Then VAfault = 5.253 × 15 = 78.795 MVA (3) If = 1/Zf.pu × (MVA)base KV × √3 = 5.253 × 15 . 11 × √3 = 4.135786 KA Having obtained the fault currents (If ) and the fault voltages (Vf ) from the control room of the Utility Company, one can now develop a programe that will evaluate and determine the values of the impedance (Z) in ohms at the point of fault and the per unit impedance (Zpu) up till the point of fault. Given the per km impedance of the distribution lines, the distance ( that is the length of line ) where repair operations should be carried out can be obtained. This will be useful in fault location, ease the location of the point of faults, speed repair operations and improve the performance of the system.
CHAPTER FIVE CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
5.1 CONCLUSION
The supply of electric power in Ikorodu Distribution network is not reliable. It is
characterized by a large number of faults. Duration of outages or interruption of power supply is
also very high in the area. Load demand kept on increasing on yearly basis. The present demand
for electricity in the country is 9437MW and by the year 2015, this value according to the
Energy Commission of Nigeria will be increasing to 15,730MW. Yet the country could only
generate 3,500MW of electricity out of a total of 6,367 MW power station installed capacity.
Because of these irregular problems, many industrial processes have been unfavourably affected.
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1572 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
The problem has affected economic growths of local and international industries. Thus
production cost and market price of goods and services kept on increasing because the affected
industries seek alternative source of power supply through high cost of generators and fuel.
Again, it was observed that many of the power and distribution transformers are too old. Thus,
making continuous maintenance at high cost, a regular practice in the distribution area.
Fault frequency is also very high. It was observed that this high fault frequency affected
the failure rates and conversely, reduces the reliability of power system in the distribution area.
For example in Lagos Road feeder where the number of consumers is about 4,709, the failure
rate for the eight years is 0.0017135 failure/hour/customer. This is too high because in a normal
circumstance, anywhere in the world, failure rate should be as low as 0.00001459
failure/hour/customer or even lower.
The actual electrical power requirement of customers along Lagos Road feeder is
15.328MW while power supply along the feeder is 6.711MW. This has shown that the quantity
of power supply is inadequate in the area. Load demand kept on increasing in the distribution
network area. As at December, 2011, load demand of the customers in Ikorodu was 120MW.
Beside this increase in load, the network is characterized by the high number of faults and
outages which is over 100 occurrences per annum. All these have made power failure and
outage problems regular events in this distribution area. For instance, the net failure rate between
years 2004-2011 along Lagos Road feeder is 0.001411 failure/hour/customer. It is even worst
along Ayangburen 11kV feeder, over there, the failure rate was at the highest level of 0.002172
failure/hour/customer. And along Ijebu Ode feeder, the failure rate was 0.001834
failure/hour/customer. All these are still on the high side. They are therefore reasons for the
incessant supply of electric power in this distribution area. Also, Mean Time Between Failure
stands at an average of 583.59 hours along Lagos Road feeder. Mean down time along the feeder
is 178.1522 hours. The results show that most of the electrical equipment along this feeder are
prone to failure as a result of overload, losses, damages and decrease in efficiency of
components. Thus, the supply of electricity along all the feeders is not reliable and needs
improvement according to the following recommendations.
This research work revealed that the actual electrical power requirement of customers
along Lagos Road feeder is 15.328MW. The actual electrical power requirement of customers in
Ikorodu Distribution Network is 137.952MW. The actual electrical power requirement of
customers in Lagos State is 2,759.04MW. The actual electrical power requirement of Nigeria
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1573 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
is 106,774.848MW. If Nigeria must overcome the present incessant power outages, poor
power supply which has grounded many activities, destroyed many industrial processes,
reduced productivity, increase unemployment and crime among the youths, this is the
actual electrical power required by the country.
REFERENCES
Adegboyega, G.A, Adu, M.R and Melodi A.O (2010), Power Losses in
Distribution System and Solutions; Akure as a case study, FUTAJET, vol. 6, No.2, page
75-80
Burke James J. (1994), Power Distribution Engineering Fundamental and
Applications, Marce Dekker Inc. New York, page 125-127
Desphande, M.V (1984), Electrical Power System Design, Tata Mc Graw-Hill
Publishing Company Limited, New Delhi, page 56-78
Gupta B.R (2010), Power System Analysis and Design, S.Chand Company Limited
New Delhi pages 593 – 611
Kothari D.P and Nagrath, I .J (2008) Power System Engineering , second edition ,
Mc Graw – Hill , New Delhi, page 1 – 12,146 – 159, 456 – 557
Monterrosa Carlos (2011), Fault Analysis in Electrical works and distribution
Lines, Green and co Ltd, London, page 77
Edward J. Tyler, 2005, National Electric Estimator, Craftman Book Company page
90
Fortesque, C. L (1918), Method of symmetrical coordinate Applied to the solution of
Polyphase networks
Francis, T.G (2001), Electrical installation work, Longmans, Green and co Ltd,
London, page1-3
Gupta J.B.(2006), A Course in power system, S.K Kataria & Sons ,New Delhi, part
1, page 130
IJSER
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 10, Issue 2, February-2019 1574 ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2019 http://www.ijser.org
Pabla, A.S (2004) Electric Power Distribution , 5th Edition , Mc Graw – Hill
Publishing Company , New Delhi , Pages 96,117, 218 and 230 .
IJSER