inclusive insurance: going beyond the mandate?ifmrlead.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/inclusive...

2
Need to Expand Insurance 88% workers in India belong to the informal sector, and have limited social security nets. 2 Between 2000 and 2050, the population in the 60-80 years, and the above 80-year age brackets has been projected to grow by 326% and 700% respectively. 3 Inclusive Insurance: Going Beyond the Mandate? Priyadarshini G and Safa M. Khan, IFMR LEAD Insurance penetration in India stands at 3.4% , as compared to the emerging market average of 2.9%. The annual premium growth has been 7.9% in 2015 against the global growth of 3.8% 1 . While rising incomes have contributed to the slow and steady rise of insurance take up in India, a large section of society still remains uncovered. This is due to threefold challenges faced by all stakeholders, i.e., the uninsured target client, distribution intermediary and the insurance company. Innovative product design that incorporates simplicity, flexibility and certainty can help overcome the initial behavioural hurdles to take-up by the uninsured. At the same time, distribution channels need to be customized to suit the economic and geographic needs of the target clients for the business model of the insurance company to remain sustainable. While India is currently deemed to have the window of opportunity in terms of its demographic profile, its ageing population will be a huge burden after this phase of transition. It is therefore necessary for today’s productive workforce to adequately insure against future eventualities. Microinsurance in India Microinsurance is the protection offered to low-income clients in exchange for regular premiums, which are proportional to likelihood and costs of risk involved. These products aim to provide clients with appropriately priced insurance covers to manage their risks. Microinsurance is a low price- high volume business and its viability largely depends on minimizing distribution and transaction costs. In terms of claims disbursement both private and public sector insurance schemes seem to be performing efficiently (Figure 1). Technology enabled distribution of micro-insurance schemes could help reduce such costs even further. With technology and mobile money-based micro-insurance having contributed significantly to health insurance take ups in Kenya and elsewhere 4 , this field is seen as the most fertile ground for future innovation in the insurance sector in India as well. Micro-insurance that offers life/pension/health benefits can have a maximum cover of Rs.2,00,000 without the annual premium exceeding Rs.6,000. The government also has introduced two key low premium insurance schemes that are linked to its broader vision of ensuring financial inclusion under the Jan Dhan Yojana. Also, IRDA 5 has permitted crop insurances to be distributed by micro-insurance agents irrespective of sum assured. This is expected 1 All figures from Swiss Re Sigma Report, 2015 2 66th round of NSSO survey, 2011-12 3 PRS Report 4 Emerging Practices in Mobile Microinsurance, Camilo Tellez (2012) 5 Product Types -Life -Crop -Health -Disaster -Property -Unemployment -Disability -Reinsurance Delivery Models Partner agent model : Scheme assigns an agent like insurance company/hospital Full service model: Scheme designs, delivers and manages the products Provider driven model: Healthcare providers takes over full service Community based/mutual models: Clients manage operations and avail service

Upload: others

Post on 21-Feb-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Inclusive Insurance: Going Beyond the Mandate?ifmrlead.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Inclusive Insurance.pdf · ERGO, ICICI Lombard, and SBI GIC. Way Forward Improving efficiencyin

NeedtoExpandInsurance

• 88% workers in India belong to the informalsector,andhavelimitedsocialsecuritynets.2

• Between2000 and 2050, thepopulation in the60-80years,andtheabove80-yearagebracketshasbeenprojected togrowby326%and700%respectively.3

InclusiveInsurance:GoingBeyondtheMandate?PriyadarshiniGandSafaM.Khan,IFMRLEAD

InsurancepenetrationinIndiastandsat3.4%,ascomparedto the emerging market average of 2.9%. The annualpremiumgrowthhasbeen7.9%in2015againsttheglobalgrowthof3.8%1.Whilerisingincomeshavecontributedtothe slow and steady rise of insurance take up in India, alargesectionofsocietystillremainsuncovered.Thisisdueto threefoldchallenges facedbyall stakeholders, i.e., theuninsured target client, distribution intermediary and theinsurance company. Innovative product design thatincorporates simplicity, flexibility and certainty can helpovercometheinitialbehaviouralhurdlestotake-upbytheuninsured.Atthesametime,distributionchannelsneedto be customized to suit the economic and geographic needs of the target clients for the businessmodel of theinsurance company to remain sustainable.While India is currentlydeemed tohave thewindowofopportunity interms of its demographic profile, its ageing populationwill be a huge burden after this phase of transition. It isthereforenecessaryfortoday’sproductiveworkforcetoadequatelyinsureagainstfutureeventualities.

MicroinsuranceinIndiaMicroinsurance is the protection offered to low-income clients in exchange for regular premiums, which areproportionaltolikelihoodandcostsofriskinvolved.Theseproductsaimtoprovideclientswithappropriatelypricedinsurancecoverstomanagetheirrisks.

Microinsurance is a low price- high volume businessand its viability largely depends on minimizingdistribution and transaction costs. In terms of claimsdisbursementbothprivateandpublicsectorinsuranceschemes seem to be performing efficiently (Figure 1).Technology enabled distribution of micro-insuranceschemes could help reduce such costs evenfurther.With technology and mobile money-basedmicro-insurance having contributed significantly tohealthinsurancetakeupsinKenyaandelsewhere4,thisfield is seen as the most fertile ground for futureinnovationintheinsurancesectorinIndiaaswell.

Micro-insurance that offers life/pension/health benefits can have a maximum cover of Rs.2,00,000 without theannualpremiumexceedingRs.6,000.Thegovernmentalsohasintroducedtwokeylowpremiuminsuranceschemesthat are linked to its broader vision of ensuring financial inclusion under the Jan Dhan Yojana. Also, IRDA5 haspermittedcropinsurancestobedistributedbymicro-insuranceagentsirrespectiveofsumassured.Thisisexpected

1AllfiguresfromSwissReSigmaReport,2015266throundofNSSOsurvey,2011-123PRSReport4EmergingPracticesinMobileMicroinsurance,CamiloTellez(2012)5InsuranceRegulatoryandDevelopmentAuthority

ProductTypes-Life -Crop-Health -Disaster-Property -Unemployment-Disability -Reinsurance

DeliveryModels• Partneragentmodel:Schemeassignsanagentlikeinsurancecompany/hospital• Fullservicemodel:Schemedesigns,deliversandmanagestheproducts• Providerdrivenmodel:Healthcareproviderstakesoverfullservice• Communitybased/mutualmodels:Clientsmanageoperationsandavailservice

Page 2: Inclusive Insurance: Going Beyond the Mandate?ifmrlead.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Inclusive Insurance.pdf · ERGO, ICICI Lombard, and SBI GIC. Way Forward Improving efficiencyin

tohavepositiveimpactontakeupofcropinsuranceschemessuchasPMFBY.

PradhanMantriJanSurakshaYojana(PMJSY)The PMJSYwas introduced to provide insurance to unorganizedworkers but is open to all savings bank accountholders.Thisschemehastwocomponents,alifeinsurance(PMJJBY)andanaccidentinsurance(PMSBY)component,bothadministeredbytheLifeInsuranceCorporationofIndia(LIC).ItishopedthataccountsopenedundertheJanDhanYojanawillaidinmakingsurethatthisschemeiseasilyandwidelyaccessibletoallsectionsofthesociety.Bothoftheseschemesworkonauto-debitpaymentmodeandpaycompensationtothenomineeassignedbythepolicyholder.

PradhanMantriFasalBimaYojana(PMFBY)

Only 23% of India's total farmer population iscoveredunderexistingcropinsuranceschemes.Thegovernment aims to increase this to 50%by 20186,with the larger aim of doubling famer incomenotwithstanding.The PMFBY- introduced in January2016, replaced the National Agriculture InsuranceScheme (NAIS)andModified National AgricultureInsurance Scheme (MNAIS). The scheme is handledbytheAgricultureInsuranceCompanyof India(AIC)andaselectionofempanelledinsurancecompanies.There is one implementing private company perstate, selected through a bidding process. So far,companies selected include Bajaj Alliance, HDFC-ERGO,ICICILombard,andSBIGIC.

WayForward

Improving efficiencyin the enrollment and disbursement processes is vital for insurance schemes to result inpositive outcomes for the beneficiaries.The average expense ratio of Indian life insurers is 19%7while it isbetween 4% and 12% in developed markets. Digital technology could aid in bringing distribution andadministrativecostsdown.Bundlingmicrofinancewithmicro-insurancetogethercouldalso reapbenefits.For instance,BRACoffers ‘CreditShield Insurance,’ wherein the beneficiary receives life insurance coverage by making a one-time premiumpaymentwhiletakingoutaloan.8SuchamodelimprovesboththeMFI’sbusinesssustainability,butalsomakestheloanmoreaffordablefortheclients.Improvingproductofferingandmarketing-Whilethemandateistoexpandanddeepeninsurancepenetrationin India, the challenge lies inensuring thatappropriate productsareserviced tocustomers.A topdown thrustcould induce the sector to start catering to the low-income segments but firm level innovations are equallyimportanttomakesurethatthebusinessmodelremainssustainableandprofitable.Goingbeyondthemandate–Takeupnumbers,thoughindicativeoftheindustry’sfoothold,donottellushowinclusivethispenetrationhasbeen.Thereisthereforeaneedtogobeyondthesenumberstomakesurethatallsectionsofsocietyarecateredtoandgivenanopportunitytomanagepotentialfuturerisks.

PMFBY-Goingbeyondthemandate?ThePMFBYisanambitiousschemethatseekstobecomeagame-changerinthecropinsurancelandscape:Use of technology: The scheme can be accessed through amobile/online application. Remote sensing drone and GPStechnologiestobeusedtodetermineaccurateyieldlossesandweatherconditions.Lower premium rates: No cap on the premium. A uniformpremium of only 2% to be paid by farmers for Kharif crops,1.5% for Rabi crops, and5% of sum insured/actuarial rate forannualcommercialandhorticulturecrops.Therestofthecostis borne by the state and central governments, and is sharedequally.UnifiedPackageInsuranceScheme(UPIS):Single-windowpilotscheme wherein farmers can opt for at least two otherinsuranceschemes(suchasPMSBY&PMJJBY)inadditiontothePMFBY.

Features PMSBY PMJJBYCover Accidentaldeath/disability/accidentaldeath DeathduetoanyreasonAnnualPremium Rs.12 Rs.330

SumAssured i)Rs.2,00,000foraccidentaldeathii)Rs.1,00,000forpartialdisability Rs.2,00,000fordeathduetoanyreason

Eligibility Savingsbankaccount SavingsbankaccountAgelimit 18-70years 18-50years

Premiumtobepaidtill 70years50years.Optiontocontinuetill55years.

6http://www.pmindia.gov.in/7TowersWatsonCIISurvey20158http://blog.brac.net/2016/01/credit-shield-insurance-piloting-microinsurance-products-in-bangladesh/

Source:IRDAAnnualReport,2014-15