incorporating environmental elements in property marketing ... · incorporating environmental...

64
INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR MD AMANAT ULLAH The thesis submitted to fulfill the requirement for the award of the Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) Faculty of Technology Management and Business University Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia AUGUST 2016

Upload: vuxuyen

Post on 23-Apr-2019

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY

MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR

MD AMANAT ULLAH

The thesis submitted to

fulfill the requirement for the award of the

Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)

Faculty of Technology Management and Business

University Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia

AUGUST 2016

Page 2: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

v

DEDICATION

In the name of most merciful and loving Allah S.W.T and highest appreciations be upon

Him. This thesis is dedicated to almighty of Allah S.W.T and my admire parents, Haji

Mawlana Mohammed Ismail Bin Mohammed Sakahwat Hussein and Hajjah Rowshon

Ara Binti Mawlana Noor Mohammed, and my maternal uncle Dr, Ma’sum Billah Bin

Mawlana Noor Mohammed, who have supported me to start the journey of education in

my life. It is also dedicated to my beloved wife Mrs, Sadia Binti Mawlan Azizur

Rahaman Siddiqui, younger brother Mohoammed Zahidul Islam, sister Mrs, Romiza

Akter Hawoah and Mrs, Salma, nieces, nephews and my children who have makes me

happy in the way of my PhD research in Malaysia.

Page 3: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

vi

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

This research would not be a success without many people; they contribute a lot to touch

the success point. Such as one of the most admire and highest distinguished Associate

Professor Dr. Seow Ta Wee, supervise me always on the right track with best

approaches as a friendly, uncountable thanks for him until the end of the day of my life.

It is mentionable that, there are two kinds of people existing in the world they always do

the best wishes to others more than him / herself. The first category is an ideal teacher

they want his or her student would be better than him or herself in the academic career

and spiritual character and many aspects. The following type of people is the most

honorable parents they want their children would be better than themselves in all aspects

of life. I have to declare strongly that, I am the luckiest Ph.D. student to get that

supervisor / teacher and parents. That is why the greatest thankful to almighty of Allah

Suba-Hanahu-Ta’lah and the University Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia UTHM.

Also thankful for my internal examiners in the faculty of Technology management and

Business UTHM, they had correct me to set up the framework, theories, questioners and

sampling. I would grateful to them for valuable advice, research instruction and valuable

time that was very important for my study of PhD.

And thanks to all of the admin staff of Department of Construction Management and at

Faculty of Technology Management and Business, they did not forget me to inform the

most important seminar, conference, workshop etc. It has to mention the moral support

that I have got from my colleagues at University Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia.

Finally, Dean and Head of Department who has always offered guidance and support. I

have to be grateful to the University Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia for the financial support

to pay the tuition fees and other support. The International Office of UTHM Staff they

support me for the visa and other legal issues during my study in Malaysia.

Page 4: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

vii

ABSTRACT

Half of the world population all over the countries reside in the cities. By 2050, the

world proportion is likely to reach 75%. Malaysia is an urban society with majority

people of the country approximately 70% living in the cities. The high demand of

accommodation in the cities, and many developers supply the housing unit through

condominium complex to fulfil the requirement of accommodation. Every day the

number of condominium is increasing in Kuala Lumpur city. The natural green

environment is decreasing with destructive impact on physical, mental illness and many

problems among the people reside in the city compare to the rural. The modern

developers in Kuala Lumpur facing difficulties to influence the target customers due to

the lack of green environmental elements in a housing project and marketing strategy are

one of the great problems to achieve the high performance of sales. Therefore,

incorporate of important environmental elements in a housing project and marketing

strategy to achieve the high performance of sales. The level of importance evaluates

through quantitative research method with five (5) points Likert types scale. The data

collected from Kuala Lumpur city area among condominium users, tenant, owner,

management team and developers employees including marketing staff, managers, sales

staff, and sales agents altogether 509 respondent. More than 85% respondents are agreed

the environmental elements are very important at the condominium complex to have a

healthy city life, and it strongly influences customers to buy or rent the apartment units.

The green marketing is acting as a mediation to contribute the high performance of sales.

As a result, less or no difficulty to reach the high performance of sales. In conclusion,

those project has the most demanding environmental elements are more successful

projects, compare to less or non-existing environmental facilities projects in Kuala

Lumpur, Malaysia.

Page 5: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

viii

ABSTRAK

Setengah daripada populasi dunia direkodkan telah menetap di kawasan bandar.

Menjelang tahun 2050, populasi dunia yang bermastautin di bandar dijangka akan

mencecah 75%. Majoriti masyarakat Malaysia iaitu 70% daripada jumlah populasi

penduduknya tinggal di bandar. Hasil daripada permintaan penempatan di bandar, ramai

pemaju membekalkan kondominium untuk memenuhi keperluan penginapan tersebut.

Setiap hari bilangan kondominium semakin meningkat di bandar Kuala Lumpur.

Persekitaran semula jadi yang hijau semakin berkurangan dan ini memberi kesan besar

kepada kesihatan mental dan fizikal masyarakat yang berada di persekitaran bandar.

Pemaju moden di Kuala Lumpur menghadapi kesukaran untuk mempengaruhi

pelanggan oleh kerana masalah alam sekitar yang hijau dalam projek perumahan dan

strategi pemasaran merupakan salah satu cara untuk menanganinya bagi mencapai

prestasi yang tinggi dalam jualan. Oleh yang demikian, penggabungan unsur-unsur alam

sekitar penting dalam projek perumahan dan startegi pemasaran untuk mencapai prestasi

jualan yang tinggi. Tingkat kepentingan diperiksa melalui kaedah kuantitatif yang

menggunakan kaedah skala likert berskala lima (5) mata. Pengumpulan data dilakukan

di kawasan perumahan kondomium Kuala Lumpur yang melibatkan 509 responden yang

terdiri daripada pengguna kondominium, penyewa, pemilik rumah, kumpulan

pengurusan kondominium dan pekerja pemaju perumahan termasuk staf pemasaran,

pengurus, staf jualan dan agen jualan. Lebih 85% responden bersetuju bahawa elemen

persekitaram sangat penting di kompleks kondominium untuk kesihatan yang sihat dan

ia secara langsung dapat mempengaruhi pelanggan untuk membeli dan menyewa rumah

tersebut. Pemasaran hijau bertindak sebagai ‘mediation’ yang menyumbang kepada

prestasi jualan yang tinggi. Hasil daripada itu, tiada kesukaran untuk mencapai prestasi

yang tinggi jualan. Kesimpulannya projek yang menitikberatkan elemen alam sekitar

jelas lebih tinggi permintaannya jika dibandingkan dengan projek yang sebaliknya di

Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.

Page 6: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

ix

TABLE OF CONTENTS

TITLE i

DECLARATION ii

DEDICATION iii

ACKNOWLEDGMENT iv

ABSTRACT v

ABSTRAK vi

TABLE OF CONTENTS vii

LIST OF FIGURES xiv

LIST OF TABLES xviii

LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS xx

LIST OF APPENDICES xiv

CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION 1

1.1 Introduction 1

1.2 Research Background 2

1.3 Research Problem 5

1.4 Research Purpose 7

1.5 Research Questions 8

1.6 Resesarch Objectives 8

1.7 Aim of the study 9

1.8 Scope of the study 9

1.9 Significance of the study 10

1.10 Conclusion 11

Page 7: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

x

CHAPTER 2 LITERATURE REVIEW 12

2.1 Introduction 12

2.2 Definition of Marketing 13

2.3 Definition of Strategic Marketing 15

2.4 Elements of Strategic Marketing 16

2.4.1 Product (Condominium Complex) 18

2.4.1.1 Production Model 19

2.4.1.2 New Product (Project) Development 19

2.4.1.3 Variety of Product (House) 20

2.4.1.4 The Quality & Design of Condominium 21

2.4.1.5 Packaging and Decoration 21

2.4.1.6 Brand Name of the Product 22

2.4.2 Price (Value of Unit) 22

2.4.2.1 Base price 24

2.4.2.2 Promotional Price 25

2.4.2.3 Discount Pricing 25

2.4.2.4 The Pricing Model 26

2.4.3 Place of housing complex (Location) 27

2.4.3.1 Distribution of Product 29

2.4.3.2 Public Relation 31

2.4.4 Promotional Activities 32

2.4.4.1 Promotional Planning 33

2.4.4.2 Advertising 34

2.4.4.3 Pre Product Advertising 35

2.4.4.4 Post Product Advertising 36

2.4.4.5 Green Advertising 36

2.5 Influence of Strategic Marketing on sales 37

2.5.1 Beauty of Project Influence to Buy 38

2.5.1.1 The project design and layout Influence to Buy 39

2.5.1.2 Green Environment Influence to Purchase 40

Page 8: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

xi

2.5.1.3 Internal Quality of Housing Influence to Buy 40

2.5.1.4 Internal Facilities Influence to Buy 41

2.5.2 Strategic Pricing Influence to Buy 42

2.5.2.1 Mortgage Facilities from the Bank 43

2.5.3 Strategic Location Influence to Buy 43

2.5.4 Strategic Promotion Influence to Buy 44

2.5.4.1 Push Selling 44

2.5.4.2 Pull Selling 45

2.6 Green Marketing for Housing 45

2.6.1 Owner / Vendor of Property 47

2.6.2 Green Product in Marketing Strategy 47

2.6.3 Green Environmental Elements in Marketing Strategy 48

2.6.4 Property with Green Environment 49

2.6.5 Purchase Power (Pricing) 50

2.6.6 Target Customers 51

2.6.7 Total Processing of Dealings 53

2.6.8 Purchaser 54

2.7 Definition of Environment 54

2.7.1 Definition of Green Environment 55

2.7.2 Definition of Housing Environment 56

2.7.3 Environmental Architect of Housing 57

2.7.4 Environmental Architect of Housing in Commercial View 59

2.8 The Environmental Elements at Condominium Complex 60

2.8.1 Classification of Environmental Elements 61

2.8.1.1 Natural Green Environmental Elements 61

2.8.1.1.1 The Green Trees and Grass 62

2.8.1.1.2 The Natural Viewpoint and Sky View 63

2.8.1.1.3 The Parkland and Garden 63

2.8.1.1.4 The Lake 63

2.8.1.2 Entertainment Environmental Elements 64

2.8.1.2.1 The Swimming Pool and Children Pool 64

Page 9: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

xii

2.8.1.2.2 The Children Playground 65

2.8.1.2.3 Tennis Court and Squash Court 65

2.8.1.2.4 Function Room and Barbecue Pit Facilities 66

2.8.1.3 Health & Safety Environmental Elements 66

2.8.1.3.1 24-hour security and CC TV 67

2.8.1.3.2 Gymnasium Facility 67

2.8.1.3.3 Smoke detector and Alarm system 68

2.8.1.3.4 Care Park Building 68

2.9 Influence of Environmental Elements in Marketing Strategy for

Performance of Sells 69

2.9.1 Natural Environment Influence Marketing Strategy for

Performance of Sells 70

2.9.1.1 Natural Environment Influence Product and

Performance of Sells 70

2.9.1.2 Natural Environment influence Price and

Performance of Sells 71

2.9.1.3 Natural Environment influence Place and

Performance of Sells 71

2.9.1.4 Natural Environment influence Promotion and

Performance of Sells 72

2.9.2 Entertainment Facilities influence Marketing Strategy for

Performance of Sells 72

2.9.2.1 Entertainment Facilities influence Products and

Performance of Sells 73

2.9.2.2 Entertainment Facilities influence Price and

Performance of Sells 73

2.9.2.3 Entertainment Facilities Influence Place and

Performance of Sells 74

2.9.2.4 Entertainment Facilities influence Promotion and

Performance of Sells 74

Page 10: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

xiii

2.9.3 Health and Safety influence Marketing Strategy for Performance

of Sells 75

2.9.3.1 Health and Safety influence Products and

Performance of Sells 76

2.9.3.2 Health and Safety influence Price and Performance

of Sells 77

2.9.3.3 Health and Safety influence Place and Performance

of Sells 77

2.9.3.4 Health and Safety influence Promotion and

Performance of Sells 78

2.10 Theoretical Framework 78

2.10.1 Environmental Element in Project and Impact on Sells 80

2.10.2 Lack of Environmental Element in Project and Impact on Sells81

2.10.3 Lack of Environmental Element in Marketing Strategy and Impact

on Sells 82

2.11 Property Marketing Model 83

2.11.1 Solution 84

2.11.2 Information 85

2.11.3 Value 86

2.11.4 Access 88

2.11.5 SIVA Marketing and Impact on Target Sales 89

2.12 Property Valuation Theory 89

2.12.1 Natural Environmental Elements 90

2.12.2 Entertainment Environmental Element 90

2.12.3 Health and Safety Environment Elements 90

2.13 Deification of Success 91

2.13.1 Better Performance of Sells for Few Projects 91

2.14 Key Success Factors for Housing Project 92

Page 11: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

xiv

2.15 Theoretical Problems and Strategic Solution 97

2.15.1 The Problems for SIVA Marketing Model 97

2.15.2 The Problems for Property Valuation Theory 97

2.15.3 The Problems for Success Theory 98

2.15.4 The Solution for the Gaps of theories 98

2.16 Conclusion 99

CHAPTER 3 RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY 100

3.1 Introduction 100

3.2 Research Philosophy 100

3.2.1 Ontology 102

3.2.2 Objectivism 102

3.2.3 Subjectivism 102

3.3 Research Design 103

3.3 .1 The Research Flow 104

3.3.2 Selection of Respondents 106

3.3.3 Research Instrument 106

3.4 Research Methods 107

3.4.1 Quantitative Research Approach 107

3.4.2 The Validation of Quantitative Research Approach 108

3.5 Methods of Data Collection 108

3.5.1 The Survey Method 109

3.6 Instrument of Data Collection 109

3.6.1 Closed-Ended Question 109

3.6.2 Development of Questioner 110

3.7 Identify the Population and Sampling 111

3.7.1 Selection of Sample and Sample Size 112

3.7.2 Simple Random Sampling 113

Page 12: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

xv

3.8 Pilot Study 114

3.8.1 The Reliability Test 115

3.9 Respondents of the Research 116

3.10 Normality Test 119

3.11 Data Analysis 120

3.11.1 Descriptive Analysis 120

3.11.2 Regression Process Analysis 121

3.11.3 The Sobel Test 121

3.11.4 The ANOVA Analysis 122

3.12 Conclusion 123

CHAPTER 4 THE MOST SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS

AT COMPLEX CONDOMINIUM AND THE INFLUENCE IN

MARKETING STRATEGY WITH DISCUSSION 124

4.1 Introduction 124

4.2 The Demographic Analysis 124

4.2.1 The Ethnic Group Analysis 125

4.2.2 The Education Level of Respondent 126

4.2.3 Household Monthly Income of Respondent 128

4.3 Important Environmental Elements at Apartment Complex 129

4.4 The Groups of Environmental Elements at

Condominium Complex 130

4.4.1 Natural Environmental Elements 130

4.4.2 Entertainment Elements 132

4.4.3 Health & Safety Elements 134

4.4.4 Overall Environmental Elements 136

4.4.5 The Discussion for Objective One 139

Page 13: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

xvi

4.5 Influence of the Environmental Elements in Marketing Strategy 140

4.5.1 Influence of Natural Environmental Elements in

Marketing Strategy 140

4.5.2 Influence of Entertainment Elements in

Marketing Strategy 142

4.5.3 Influence of Health & Safety Elements in

Marketing Strategy 144

4.5.4 Influence Level of All Environmental

Elements in Marketing Strategy 146

4.5.5 The Discussion for Objective Two 149

4.6 Conclusion 151

CHAPTER 5 THE INFLUENCE OF GREEN MARKETING ON

PERFORMANCE OF SALES AND DEVELOPMENT

OF FRAMEWORK WITH DISCUSSION 152

5.1 Introduction 152

5.2 The Influence of Green Marketing Strategy on Target Sales 153

5.2.1 Product Influence by Green Environment on Target Sale 153

5.2.2 Price and Promotion Influence by

Green Facilities on Target Sale 156

5.2.3 Place Influence by Green Environment on Target Sale 158

5.2.4 Influences of Green Marketing on Target Sales 160

5.2.5 The Discussion for Objective Three 163

Page 14: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

xvii

5.3 Influence of Environment & Marketing

Strategy on Performance of Sales 167

5.3.1 The Outcome of Model Summary in

Between (X) EE and (M1,2,&3) MS 169

5.3.2 The Outcome of Sales Performance by

Both (X) EE and (M) MS (4Ps) 171

5.3.3 Outcome of Sales Performance (PRSL) by

Environmental Elements (EE) 172

5.3.4 The Total Performance of Sales (PRSL) by

Environmental Element (EE) 173

5.3.5 Outcome of Model Tests for Indirect Effect 174

5.3.6 Outcome of the Confidence on Theory 176

5.3.7 The Regression Analysis for Performance of

Sale with Mediator 177

5.3.8 The Discussion for Objective Four 178

5.3.8.1 Influence of Environmental Elements and

Marketing Strategy on Sales 179

5.3.8.2 The Performance of Sales (PRSL) by

Environmental Elements (EE) 180

5.3.8.3 The Performance of Sales (PRSL) by

Green Marketing Strategy (MS) 181

5.4 Framework Development of the Housing Property Business 182

5.4.1 The Developed a Property Marketing

Framework of this Study 183

5.4.2 The First Stage of Framework Development

in Environmental Elements 185

5.4.3 The Second Stage of Framework Development

in Marketing Strategy 186

5.4.4 The Third Stage of Framework Development

in Success of Target Sales 187

5.5 The city of Kuala Lumpur 187

5.6 Conclusion 189

Page 15: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

xviii

CHAPTER 6 SUMMARY IMPLICATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS 191

6.1 Introduction 191

6.2 Summary 191

6.3 Implications 194

6.3.1 Suggestions for the Developers 194

6.3.2 Suggestions for the Sales and Marketing Team 196

6.4 Theoretical Implications 196

6.4.1 Implications for Practice 197

6.5 Research Contribution 199

6.5.1 Contribution to the Housing Industry 199

6.6 Areas for Further Research 200

6.7 Conclusion 200

REFERENCES 202

LIST OF FIGURES

1.1 The average daily temperature in Kuala Lumpur

1.2 A: The Natural Environment to Attract the Clientele Green Environmental

1.2.B: The natural environment elements using at the housing complex

2.4: Elements of marketing strategy

2.4.1.5 Packing and decorating of the product.1, who does enter water 2, the report of

damages 3, the solution

Page 16: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

xix

2.4.2: The housing price since 2001 to 2012

2.4.3: The Project location and Marketplace to Sales

2.4.3.A The Marketplace for Property Sales and Individual Effect.

2.4.4: Promotion and distribution of property

2.4.3: Pre product advertising

2.5: Housing Loan 2009 to 2011

2.5.1: External and Internal Facilities

2.5.1: External Natural Green Environment

2.5.2: Internal Design of an Apartment

2.5.4.2: Promotional Strategy and Planning

2.6: Green Marketing for Property

2.6.3: Natural Green Projects in KL

2.6.5: Housing Price

2.6.6: International Target Customer

2.6.6 A: Number of Foreign Customers by MM2H

2.7.3 Environmental Architect of housing

2.8.1.1 Natural Green Environmental Elements

2.8.1.2 Sky Swimming Pool

2.8.1.3: Health & Safety Facility at Complex

2.9: Influence of Environment Elements in Marketing Strategy and Performance of Sells

2.9.3: Crime Cases in Malaysia 2000 – 2009

2.9: Theoretical Framework.

2.10.A: Independent variable Mediator and dependent variable

2.9.1: Total Percent of sells

Page 17: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

xx

2.13: The Success Theory

2.13.1 Quick Sold Project in KL

2.14: Key Success Factors and Market Context

2.14: Parkland 121,968 sf including the Lake, Swimming pool

3.1: Research Philosophy in onion shape (Saunders et al, 2008)

3.3: Research Design Process (Author)

4.4.1 Level of important in percentage (Natural environmental elements)

4.4.2 Level of important in percentage (Entertainment elements)

4.4.3 Level of important in percentage (health & safety elements)

4.4.4 Overall important of environmental elements in percentage

4.5.1 Level of influence on sales in percentage (Natural Environment)

4.5.2 Level of influence on sales in percentage (Entertainment elements)

4.5.3 Level of influence on sales in percentage (Health & safety elements)

4.5.4 Overall influence of environmental elements in property sales in percentage

4.5.5 Environmental Facilities Influence on Sales.

4.5.5. A. The condominium user in Kuala Lumpur

5.2.1 Environment of project (Product) influence on sales in percentage

5.2.2 Strategic price influence on property sales in percentage

5.2.3 Strategic location influence on sales in percentage

5.2.4 The influence level of green marketing elements on sales in percentage

5.3 Model mediation between environmental element and performance of sales

5.3.1 Significant between EE and MS

5.3.3 The strong significant (EE) = X on (PRSL) = Y

5.3.6 Sobel test of mediator impact of IV on DV

Page 18: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

xxi

5.3.8.1 Model Summary for performance of sales

5.4.1 Developed framework of the study

5.5 The map of Kuala Lumpur

LIST OF TABLES

1.3 Absence of Environmental Elements at Housing Project and it’s Impact

1.3. A. Absence of Environmental Element in Marketing Strategy and it’s Impact

2.4 Strategic Marketing Elements in Housing Industries

2.9.2.4 Condominium price based on location

2.10.2 Lack of Environmental Element at Housing Project and it’s Impact

2.10.3: Lack of Environmental Element in Marketing Strategy and it’s Impact

2.11 Siva Marketing Model

2.11. A. SIVA Marketing Model in Customers and Developers Views

3.3.2 Objectives Related Respondents and Methods

3.7.1 Sample Size Generation System

3.9.a. (A) Category projects list for data collection

3.9.b. (B) Category projects list for data collection

3.9.c. (C) Category projects list for data collection

3.9.d. Developers and Projects List of Collected Data.

3.10 The values of skewness and kurtosis

Page 19: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

xxii

4.2: Number of Respondent

4.2.1: Respondent of Ethnic Groups

4.2.2: Education Level of Respondent

4.2.2.1: The Relations between Education and Four Objectives

4.2.3: Household Monthly Income

4.2.3.1: The Relations between Income and Four Objectives

4.4.1 Ranking Summary of natural environmental elements

4.4.2 Ranking summary of entertainment elements

4.4.3 Ranking summary of health & safety elements

4.4.4 Overall ranking summary of environmental elements

4.5.1: Influence of natural environmental elements in marketing strategy

4.5.2: Influence of entertainment elements in marketing strategy

4.5.3: Influence of health & safety elements in marketing strategy

4.5.4 The influence of environmental elements in marketing strategy

5.2.1: Environment of project (Product) influence on target sales

5.2.2: Strategic price influence on target sales

5.2.3: Strategic location and unit position influence on target sales

5.2.4: Overall influence ranking of green marketing on target sales.

5.2.5: Absence of Environmental Elements at Housing Project and it’s Impact on sales

5.2.5.A: Absence of Environmental Element in Marketing Strategy and it’s Impact on sales

5.3 Model mediation between environmental element and performance of sales

5.3.1 Level of significant between (IV) X = EE and (DV) M1 = Product

5.3.1a Level of significant between (IV) X = EE and (DV) M2 = Price

5.3.1b Level of significant between (IV) X = EE and (DV) M3 = Place/Promotion

Page 20: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

xxiii

5.3.2 Finding the sales performance by both (X) EE and (M1,2&3) MS

5.3.3 Finding the sales performance (PRSL) by environmental elements (EE)

5.3.4 Finding total, direct and indirect effects (MS/EE) = X on (PRSL) = Y

5.3.5 Finding the theory tests for many effects

5.3.6 Finding the confidence on theory in percentage

6.3.1 Compare between existing & non-environmental facilities at project

6.4 The level of confidence on theory in practices

LIST OF ABBREVIATION

°C Celsius (Temperature in Degrees)

RM Ringgit Malaysia (Currency)

PSF Par Square Feet

SQ FT Square Feet

4Ps Product, Price, Place and Promotion

CCTV Closed Circuit Television

NPD New Product Development

R&D Research and Development

SWOT Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats

US $ United States Dollars

$ Dollars

TV Television

UK United Kingdom

KLCC Kuala Lumpur City Centre

MM2H Malaysia My 2nd Home

PWTC Putra World Trade Centre

Page 21: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

xxiv

LRT Light Rail Transit

KL Kuala Lumpur

SIVA Solution, Information, Value and Access (model)

QC Quality Check

EFA Exploratory Factor Analysis

SPSS Statistical Package for Social Science

REHDAM Real Estate and Housing Developers Association in Malaysia

SS Sum of Squares

MS Mean Square

SD Std. Deviation

WiFi Wireless Internet for Frequent Interface

GST Goods and Services Tax

PRSL Performance of Sales

EE Environmental Elements

MS Marketing Strategy

IV Independent Variable

DV Dependent Variable

DB KL Dewan Bandaraya Kuala Lumpur

Page 22: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

xxv

LIST OF APPENDIX

APPENDIX TITLE

A. Table of reliability test

B. Q-Plot charts

C. Request Letter to customers

D. Questionnaire for condominium user / customers

E. Request Letter to sales and marketing team

F. Questionnaire for Developers sales and marketing team

G. List of publication

H. List of conferences

Page 23: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

1

CHAPTER 1

INTRODUCTION

1.1 Introduction

In the perspective of psychology, the safety or housing is the most basic needs of all

human being (Maslow 1943). The safety or housing is an important dream for every

sagacious person in the world. Currently, the number of wise learnt people, high-level,

mid-level income group and foreign people with Malaysia My Second Home (MM2H)

program are increasing in Kuala Lumpur city (Tarmiji et, al,. 2012). Therefore, the

housing demand is rapidly increasing, and the developers are continuously developing

more condominium in the city to supply the demand for accommodation. As a

consequence, the natural environment is decreasing, and it has the primary adverse

impacts on public health in many aspects such as warming, air pollution, water

pollution, etc (Muhammad et, al,. 2013). The secondary impact on property sales

within the specific time frame (product lifecycle). A number of researchers suggested

developers to, incorporate the most demandable environmental facilities at the

condominium complex. It influences target customers to achieve the target sales within

the product lifecycle timeframe. The reason is wise educated, high-level, mid-level

income group of people would not like to buy the apartment complex without natural

environmental facilities (Bendre et, al,. 2000; Norhaslina. 2009). Therefore, this study

will discover the most important environmental elements and it’s influence on sales to

achieve the developers goals through green marketing strategy.

Page 24: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

2

1.2 Research Background

In the modern era half of the world population all over the countries reside in the

cities. By 2030, 60% of the world population will reside in the urban areas and by

2050, the world proportion is likely to reach 75% (Seetharam & Yuen 2010). In

Peninsular Malaysia average of 11.1% percent increasing in every year

Consequently, the rapid growth of urbanization with bulk accommodation.

Therefore, the Malaysia is likely to be a society of urban with (over all 70% percent)

majority people of the country is living in the cities (Norhaslina 2009; Tarmiji et, al,.

2012). Everyday the natural green environment is reducing, due to the developing

new condominium in urban. As an effect, on warming, air pollution, water pollution,

sound pollution, physical and mental illness among the people reside in the city

compare to the rural (Seetharam & Yuen 2010; Muhammad et, al,. 2013). That is

why, the green environment is very important issue to get a healthy city life. The

modern developers can bring back the natural green environment at the housing

complex to minimize the warming, air pollution, water pollution, sound pollution,

physical and mental illness among the people reside in the city. Therefore, it would

be a great responsibility to build up housing complex with natural green

environmental elements. Similarly, the condominium developers will able to achieve

the target sale through using the natural green environmental elements in marketing

strategy, known as green marketing. The environmental facilities increasing the

beauty of housing complex and it influence the target customers to involve to buy or

rent the property.

It is a great responsibility for the property business organizations to save both

property business and natural environment. The natural green environment at

surrounding of the housing can protect the indoor air quality to create a healthy

residence. It is well known that the lack of green produce warming at the

surrounding, due to this reason the environmentalist are suggested urban people lives

with a natural green environment to protect from warming and pollution. Figure 1.1

shows the average daily temperature in Malaysia Kuala Lumpur, recorded maximum

36.°C and minimum 20.°C (Meng et, al,. 2007). Therefore, the modern developers

must keep the green environment at the surrounding of the housing to minimize the

urban temperature to achieve both healthy environment and property business.

Page 25: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

3

Figure 1.1 The average daily temperature in Kuala Lumpur (Meng et, al,. 2007).

On the one hand, most of the current educated and high level of income group

know the advantage of the green environment at the surrounding of housing, on the

contrary, they know the disadvantages of non-existed of green environment.

Therefore, almost all the property developers using the green environmental element

at surrounding of housing properties to achieve the business goals and a better

lifestyle in the urban. Scientifically it was proved that the natural green trees, grass

can keep cooling and improve the air quality from the interrupting of air pollutants

and warmness. The green elements also reduce the risk of physical and mental illness

in urban people. Therefore, combine the environmental elements in property

marketing strategy (Lisa & Jackson 2013).

For example, there is no minimum green environmental element in the Dhaka city

especially most of the commercial area, and there is much brick kiln surrounding the

city. As a consequence, polluted air and high temperature the people having a lot of

physical and mental illness. Only the green environment can reduce the warming and

level of pollution in Dhaka city (Motalib, et, al,. 2015). One the other hand, Singapore

is known as a garden city, a much natural environment exists as an outcome is a

minimum of pollution level and healthy city. The housing developers in Singapore

developed the house with the eco-friendly environment which can magnify the target

customers to achieve the target sales (Seetharam & Yuen 2010).

The natural green environmental element can provide a green marketing strategy

to meet the target sales for housing properties business. In the modern days, many

Page 26: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

4

people are well educated, and most of them are living in the cities because of job

opportunities and better-earning facilities, etc. Due to the job or income facility, they

must need to stay in the towns with a healthy environment. Many developers in Kuala

Lumpur try to develop the condominium with the green environment to achieve the

business goals. For example; figure 1.2.A displays the green environment at the Seri

Riana Residence 2013 project. The green marketing strategic displaying the green

environmental elements to magnetize the educated and high level of income people to

buy the project.

Figure 1.2 A: The Natural Environment to Attract the Clientele Green

Environmental Project: (Seri Riana Residence 2013)

The Seri Riana Residence is a successful project because of the reasonable

price with environmental facilities, and the per square feet is RM 542.57 compare to

the Oval, City Center RM 820.00 per square feet (sq ft) the agent posted the price

(iProperty). Now the property business organization planned about the healthy and

natural environment and most of the property developers are practicing to keep the

natural environment in the surrounding of the project. As a result, this types of

properties becoming more expensive and a successful project. Currently, the 90% of

high rise building in Malaysia is using for residence and the residential building

having the natural environment to make beauty and the healthy environment. Mostly

they have a swimming pool, playground, grassland and so on. Most of the modern

condominium have had this green environment on top of the car park building that is

more attractive to the customers. (Seetharam & Yuen 2010; Eric 2012; Abdul & Mar

2012).

So, the natural environmental elements can provide a high security of strategic

marketing for housing properties to magnetize the clientele and it has been partly

proved at the project of Seri Riana Residence and Riana Green East developed by

Page 27: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

5

IJM Land Berhad. Most of the researcher are agreed for adding the green

environmental element in the housing complex to get the better customers to gain the

target goals. Therefore, the majority of housing complex are incorporated the natural

green environmental element at the surrounding of the project, and these natural

environmental elements are mostly highlighted in the marketing policy to draw the

targeted customers. (Abdul & Mar 2012; Khairil et, al,. 2008).

Figure 1.2.B: The natural environment elements using at the housing complex

(Lake Front Cyberjaya – Part ll, 2013).

1.3 Research Problem

The housing industry in Kuala Lumpur facing difficulties to influence the target

customers due to the lack of green environmental elements in the condominium project

and marketing strategy is one of the enormous problem to achieve the high

performance of sales (Muhammad et, al,. 2013; Eric 2012; Anne 2003; Elforgani &

Rahmat 2011; Ezanee et, al,. 2013; Woei et, al,. 2015). The issue is lacking

environmental elements at the surrounding of condominium complex as concern the

project is mislaying the high demand as a direct impact on poor sales. Table 1.3

explain many researchers found there is a lot of unkind impact on property business

when the environmental elements are absence at the condominium complex.

Page 28: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

6

Table: 1.3 Absence of Environmental Elements at Housing Project and it’s Impact

Authors

Yea

r

Natural

Environment

Entertainme

nt Element

Health &

Safety

Project

Location Impact on Sales

Khairil, et, al,. 2008

Environmental

Beauty - Car Park - Less Demand

Eric 2012

Green

Environment

Swimming

Pool Security

Less

Accessible Less Buyers

Abdul & Iman 2012 - - Security Non-Popular Poor Sales

Mitchell 2012

No Natural

Environment

No

Playground

No

Security - No Human

Activity

Mariana 2008

No Green

Environment

No

Playground -

Less

Important Lower Income

Group

Muhammad

et, al,. 2013

No Natural

Environment - -

Non-Green

Area Air, Water &

Sound Pollution

Woei et, al,. 2015 - - location 33.4% No Profite

Ezanee et, al,. 2013

Natural

Environment - Security - Global Warming

U.S

Consumer

Commission 2010 -

Perfect Size

Playground - - Children

Suffering

Seetharam

& Yuen 2010

Green Trees And

Grass Playground - - Physical and

Mental Illness

Similarly, lacking environmental elements in property marketing strategy as a

concern on product, price, location and promotional activities are not perfect as a

direct impact on poor sales. Table 1.3.A: explain several researchers established

there is the much unkind impact on property business when the environmental

elements are absence in marketing strategy.

Table:1.3.A: Absence of Environmental Element in Marketing Strategy and it’s Impact

Authors Year Product Price

Place /

Location Promotion

Impact on

Sales

Elforgan

&

Rahmat 2011 Minimum Green High

Not Settable

For Reside

No Discount

Price Less Buyer

Said et,

al, 2008

Environmental

sustainability - Accessibility

No Green

Advertising Less Sales

Abdul et,

al,. 2012

Expensive Non-Popular - Poor Sales

Ezanee

et, al,. 2013

No Environmental

Quality

Resalable

Price -

Promotional

Price No, / Less

Profit

Laurie 2008 Natural Beauty - Noise Location - Less Buyer

Anirban 2012 No Green Product - Warming - Slow Sales

Activities

John 2008 - Hedonic Urban Location - Less

Clients

Woei et, al 2015 - - Unit location 33.4% No Profite

Anne 2013

Less Green

Product (House) - -

No Promotional

Price Less

Choose

Page 29: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

7

The problems occur when the environmental elements are absence in both

housing complex and marketing strategy. As a result, the apartment complex is not

high demand among the wise learnt people, high-level, mid-level income group and

foreign people (Khairil, et, al,. 2008; Eric 2012; Abdul & Iman 2012; Bender 2012).

The issue is lacking environmental location and apartments position in the

complex is the most barrier to sales the property. Finally the developers was waiting

since the period 2009–2014 for sales but they was dynamism to 33.4% discount to

auction the property for the target customers (Woei et, al; 2015). In ths case the

developers in Kuala Lumpur faced the most deficalty to sales the propery due to the

lack of property location finally they sold the property wit high discount price that

may be considered as a not profitable project.

The direct impact on property business such as, difficulty to meet the target

sales, less demand among target customers, and less or no profit due to less number

of sales activity. As a result, the property business in great danger and the people in

the city will live in a harmful environment (Muhammad et, al, 2013; Anirban 2012).

Therefore, the healthy environment is absolutely essential to integrate the natural

green environmental elements, entertainment facilities and health and safety

elements in the housing project and property marketing strategy to achieve a

sustainable property business and green city.

1.4 Research Purpose

The purpose of this study to discover the environmental elements which will carry the

success of the modern housing industry through green marketing strategy. It will able

to show the level of impacts on the performance of sales while incorporating

environmental elements in marketing strategy and without environmental elements in

marketing strategy.

Page 30: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

8

1.5 Research Questions

Overall this research able to provide the answer to the below-mentioned questions and

it can guide the right direction to achieve the target goals.

i. Which environmental elements are most important at condominium complex?

ii. What is the influence level of environmental elements in marketing strategy?

iii. What is the influence level of green marketing strategy on property sales?

iv. How does the environmental elements and marketing strategy influence

performance of sales?

v. How to develop a property marketing framework with environmental elements

to achieve the target sales?

1.6 Research Objectives

This study will concentrate on the research question to precisely present a logical

answer to the modern property business organizations to achieve the target goals

through the below-mentioned research objectives.

i. To identify the most important environmental elements at condominium complex

ii. To examine the influence level of environmental elements in marketing strategy

iii. To investigate the influence level of green marketing strategy on target sales

iv. To evaluate the influence of environmental elements and marketing strategy on

performance of sales

v. To develop a property marketing framework with environmental elements to

achieve the target sales

Page 31: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

9

1.7 Aim of the Study

The aim of this research is to produce modern instructions of a dynamic property

business and novel solution to reach the target sale to achieve the property business

goals. The natural green environmental elements is a key to success factors for

housing industries. It is also a very essential for the healthy life of customers which

can create a perfect solution for global warming. Many developers are able to sell the

housing units to the target customers and the potential customers due to the

incorporating environmental elements at the condominium complex. Therefore, most

of the developers shall be benefited from this research at the same times the user of

property will get a healthy, cold, harmony natural green environmental and peaceful

life in the cities for current and next generation in each country in the modern world.

1.8 Scope of the Study

This research will strongly focus on the modern condominium developer’s strategic

marketing with the external environmental elements in Kuala Lumpur city area.

Which will able to show the level of success in the specific time frame. It will bring

the cleared picture of the negative and positive impact on property business when the

natural green environmental elements are absence or present in the strategic

marketing. Therefore, the modern developer will able to take a decision, what need

to do in strategic marketing, based on the level of customers demand on natural

environmental elements at the housing complex. Finally, this study will ultimately

show the degree of successes through incorporate if environmental elements in

property marketing strategy.

Page 32: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

10

1.9 Significance of the Study

This research will be very important for modern developers because it will able to

show the way how to achieve the target goals within specific time frame. Secondly,

the marketing strategy will strongly focus on target sales to reach the success of

condominium complex. Finally, how to incorporate environmental elements at the

surrounding of the housing complex and that environmental element is most

demanding by customers to drown the satisfaction of the client at the top level.

First significant, this study is a guideline for property business organizations

because it will able to guide the marketing strategy with environmental elements and

the degree of success level in sales and profit margin. At the same times, it will able

to show the level of negative impact on property business when the absence of a

natural environmental element in marketing strategy. Therefore, the modern

developer will able to take a perfect decision which environmental elements are most

important to attract the customers in relations to draw the target sales and target

profit for the success of property business in the high competition market. Elias

Oikarinen (2007) mentioned the natural environmental elements bring the better

value of housing property and it typically increasing the value of the property. The

eco-friendly environment is most demandable among everyone especially the

educated and high level of income people in Japan, Korea, Hong Kong as a

consequence the property price become double. The double price habitually brings

the more profit and success of the modern developers (Glindro et al., 2011).

Second significant of this study is marketing strategy, there are four elements

Product, Price, Place / Location and Promotion are in a group works as a mediator to

bring the success of condominium project from the property market. It will briefly

discuss the important role of mediator that is acting between environmental elements

and the success of apartment project. Baron & Kenny (1986) it is important to use

the mediator to maintain the relationship between independent and dependent

variable. Therefore, this research will able to show the modern developers, the

marketing strategy plays an important role to achieve the target profit margin within

the specific timeframe.

Finally, this research will able to identify the most demandable environmental

elements which actively magnify the target customer to achieve the target sales

Page 33: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

11

within the particular time. Hamid (2012) found the environmental element such as

natural green environment, playground, swimming pool, and security are most

demandable for the customers for health and safety purpose. That is why the

environmental elements able to increase both price and sale. As a result, the modern

developers can achieve target profit successfully. This investigation will show the

level of demand among the current customers and which environmental element is

most important for what purpose. Therefore, this study is a very important guideline

for housing property business organizations to set up the environmental element of

the housing project (Doole & Lowe 2008).

1.10 Conclusion

In the current warming world is demanding the cold natural green environment to

achieve the healthy city life. The current educated and high levels of income people

want the health and safety residence in the modern city. Only the modern developers

can supply the health and safety environmental residence in the cities. The modern

developers also incorporate the natural green environmental element in the housing

complex to create cold and beautiful green natural environment to attract the target

customers with target profit margin. Each natural environmental elements are

increasing the housing price, but it douses not effect on the sale quantity because of

high demand among the customers. Currently, most of the customers are demanding

in internal design and external green park, swimming pool, security, mini market,

gymnasium etc. Normally these types of facilities are most necessary for daily life to

be a healthy and these are the basic need for the modern customer. So, this study will

able to show the most important environmental elements which will help to achieve

the developers target goals within the precise timeline through marketing strategy.

Page 34: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

12

CHAPTER 2

LITERATURE REVIEW

2.1 Introduction

This chapter will express the current practice of incorporating environmental elements

in property marketing strategy among modern developers in Malaysia. The natural

environmental elements are include the natural green trees, grass, playground,

swimming pool, tennis court, squash court, gymnasium, natural viewpoint, care park,

parkland, security, etc (Suhaida, et, al,. 2011; Wong 2001; Chau et, al,. 2002; Chau et,

al,. 2004). The marketing strategy will bring the target profit margin from the current

property market. The elements of marketing strategies are included as a product (house

building or condominium), price (value of housing unit), place (project location), and

promotion (advertising) are the basic elements call four Ps (Reed 2005). The product

refers to this study is the condominium or a housing complex. The price or value of

housing units can bring the profit margin, which is very important for customers and

the developer. The place is the location of condominium complex and external

environment and accessibility. The promotion is a kind of advertising for quick sale

and convey the property information to the target customers through using the print

media, property agent and electronic media such as television , internet, radio and so

on (Maarit 2011; Marcia 2010). It logically proved that the human could be healthy

when they associated with a natural green environment. Currently, the modern housing

industries are developing housing project with the green and healthy environment to

fulfill the needs of customers as much as they can in the cities area to achieve the

target goals (Blythe 2005).

Page 35: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

13

2.2 Definition of Marketing

The marketing refers to an organizational occupation and a set of processes of

creating, communication and supply the value to target customers and managing the

customer relationships between organization and customers in relation to benefit the

its stakeholders of the organization (Gregory 2007). Marketing is an administrative

and managerial process by which groups, organizations or individuals to get what they

requirement and want by detecting, identifying, providing, advertising or

communicating and delivering value to customers (Yuriy 2012; Kotler et, al,. 2003).

The basic concepts that marketing applies are the needs and desires of consumers, the

creation, products and services, by the exchange between parties through selected

value (Ramin & Ali 2013; Marina, 2012). A strategic communication deals through

managing for long-term business activities started through the organization in order to

further competitive advantage. The organization allocates and uses its resources in a

continuously changing marketing environment aimed at meeting consumer needs

constantly while trying to rise to the expectations of different categories of

“stakeholders”. The strategic approach involves using a strategy, which allows the

organization to compete, to identify new market opportunities, develop and trade new

products and services, to guide allocation of resources among the main activities of

the market and to guide the development of organizational structure that helps to

achieve predetermined performance levels (Kotler, 2003).

Generally, marketing is a set of communication between organization and the

targeted customers to achieve the organizational goals and the customer satisfaction.

Marketing is the process of commercial communicating with a value of a product or

service to the clienteles, for the purpose of selling the goods or service. It is a critical

business function to attract the target customers. It is a common view, which the

marketing is a strong connection between a member of societies they highly require

of the goods or services and the organization who can fulfill the requirement in the

society. The marketing these needs and wants through exchange processes and

building long-term business dealings. It is a process of collaborating with the

commercial value of a product or service through positioning to customers (Karna

2001 Giese & Cote 2002).

Page 36: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

14

Marketing can look at a managerial occupation that set of processes to create a way to

communication with valuable customers to build strong relations with them in the

ways to have commercial benefit for the industries and shareholders of that

organization. The advertising and marketing are the knowledge of selecting a target

group by analysis of market and the segmentation of the marketing, as well as an

understanding of the consumer, buying behavior and providing higher customer value

(Marina 2012). There are five competing concepts under which organizations can

choose to operate their business; the manufactured idea, the notion of a product, the

selling perception at the marketing, and the holistic marketing concept. There ar four

components in the holistic marketing such as marketing relationship, internal

marketing, integrated marketing, and socially responsive marketing. The set of

engagements necessary for successful marketing management includes capturing

marketing insights, connecting with customers, building strong brands, shaping the

market offerings, delivering and communicating value, creating long-term growth,

and developing marketing strategies and plans (Kotler, 2003; Karna 2013). The

marketing is the product information that essential to convey the targeted customers

to influence to buy and the organization will achieve the target goals (William et, al,.

2007) Marketing is a societal process by which individuals and groups obtain what

they need and want through creating, offering, and freely exchanging products and

services of value with others (Kotler, 2003).

William and Elizabeth (2007) mentioned the American Marketing Association

(AMA) defined the marketing in 1935 modified in 1985 and again in 2004. “Marketing

is the performance of business activities that direct the flow of goods and services

from producers to consumers.” (1935) “Marketing is the process of planning and

executing the conception pricing, promotion, and distribution of ideas, goods, and

services to create exchanges that satisfy individual and Organizational objectives.”

(1985) “Marketing is an organizational function and a set of processes For creating,

communicating and delivering value to customers And for managing customer

relationships in ways that benefit The organization and its stakeholders.” (2004).

Page 37: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

15

2.3 Definition of Strategic Marketing

The strategic marketing is a planning between a vendor and a purchaser in a way to

the vendor shall be agreed to supply the goods service to buyer and the honorable

buyer must agree to pay the value of property or services to the vendor (Ramin & Ali

2013). The strategic marketing is a plan of art to influence the target customer and a

direction of controlling the customers choose. The sales person have must apply to the

buyer with special skill or knowledge to perform the sales. The strategic marketing

plan or policy of sales design commonly practice in the modern strategic marketing

(Tom 2010; Ramin & Ali 2013). For example McDonald, they are the success to

achieved the target goal in the market. Exactly the property business can follow the

same strategic marketing that follows McDonald to success their business, but the

product and customers are not exactly same. Therefore, for the property marketing

strategic must be customized the strategic marketing plan to success. So, what is the

marketing strategy for property business? The strategic marketing for property

business has to be analytical, fact finding, reach to target goals, development of

management and sustainable strategic marketing. The strategic marketing is a process

consists of analyzing the environment, competitive market and business factors

affecting the Corporation and its business units. It also identifies the market

opportunities, forecasting future trends, and threats in business areas of interest for the

industry. It is also to participate in setting objectives and formulating corporate and

business unit strategies. To select target marketing strategies for the product markets

in each business unit is to establish marketing target goals, to implement and manage

the marketing strategies to meet the target market needs (Clark 2002; Jim & Peter

2005).

The strategic marketing is a prosperous art to win the objective of an adherent

organization with the specification of the product to catch the target customers buy

particular information and providing the absolute need for a client. The most important

purpose of a marketing strategy is to assign efficiently and coordinate marketing

resources and activities to achieve the firm’s goal within a particular product market

(Isobel & Robin 2008; Jari 2013 Karna et, al,. 2001). As a result, the decisions about

the scope of a marketing strategy involves the specification of the target market

segment(s) to be pursued and the product line to be offered. Then, firms look for a

Page 38: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

16

competitive gain and working together environment, planning a well-integrated

program of marketing mix elements.

The strategic marketing also refers to look at the overall of a company’s

portfolio of products and managing and markets the portfolio to achieve the

organization’s overall goals. A marketing strategy consists of an internationally

integrated but externally focused set of choices about the company addresses its

consumers in the context of a competitive environment (Roger et, al,. 2012).

2.4 Elements of Strategic Marketing

Strategic Marketing is the set of strategic tools for marketing that the business

organization uses to achieve the target objectives from the target market. Distributing

the information of goods or services to the customers through marketing variables or

mix into four different categories creates it much easier to formulate a marketing

strategy. The four categories Product, Price, Place, and Promotion are usually called

the 4-Ps (Ramin & Ali 2013; Cole 2012). The term “strategy marketing” reflects to a

company’s best opinion as to how it can most profitably apply its skills and resources

to the marketplace. It is inevitable in a broad scope. The strategies marketing is the

means by which a corporation achieves its marketing goals and are usually concerned

with the 4 P's Product, Price, Place and Promotion (Jim & Peter 2005).

Figure 2.4: Elements of marketing strategy (Ramin & Ali 2013)

Page 39: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

17

Figure 2.4 explain the Product including Variety, Quality, Design, Brand

Name, Features, and Packaging. The Price is including List price, Discount,

Promotional price, Payment period and Credit terms if applicable. The place including

Advertising, Personal Selling, Sales Promotion, Location and Public relation. The

Promotion including Channels, Media Coverage, Promotional area or Location,

Inventory, Transportation and Logistics (Ramin & Ali 2013).

The principle role of marketing strategy is assisting in creating a suite for

fulfilling requirements of targeted customers and meanwhile focus on improving the

efficiency of property sales strategy ( Yuriy 2008).

Table 2.4 Strategic Marketing Elements in Housing Industries (Yuriy 2008)

Product In this challenging era, the strategy of just providing

high-quality products (housing) for increasing sells

has been obsolete because there is no any option left

for low-quality goods to sales. Now there are lot more

things that have to be considered while manufacturing

products like their property, and / or facilities should

fulfill the criteria of targeted customers better than

what others developers offer to the customers.

Purpose,

presentation,

quality,

wrapping,

Durability,

support, service,

and warranty.

Pricing Developers realize how much amount can afford by

clients for a specific unit. It is very essential to analyze

every ins and out of creating a good pricing strategy.

A strategy such as no extra charges for servicing

sometimes results in a loss for the organization instead

of producing good impression among customers. It is

also a mentality of people that expensive products

should be of higher quality. So price beating policy is

not a good approach, but the hedonic pricing model is

more than enough for property business.

Discount offers,

funding, loans,

leasing options,

allowances, Price

listing,

promotional price,

and early booking

discount.

Place The successful property business highly depends on

the selection of area / location where it is setup.

Developers should also consider the right time for

selecting the place for local access. In the past some of

the business boost up due to the selection of area such

as important city location, popular area and so on.

Sites-channel

motivation,

market coverage,

service levels, the

internet, mobile.

Promotion How to well aware targeted customers about the

products and developers itself. Nowadays It is more

than the marketing strategic four P’s. Organizations

have to use every tricks and technic to promote their

housing project and adjust the customer perspective

time to time.

Customer dealing,

Promotion, mass

media, direct

sales, sales, green

advertising.

Page 40: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

18

2.4.1 Product (Condominium Complex)

Armstrong and Kotler describe Product is an anything that could be offered to the

market for attention to purchase for use, or ingesting that influence satisfy a want or

need (Armstrong & Kotler, 2005). The product is the first element of strategic

marketing, which refers to the goods or services that will make available for

customer’s needs or wants. In the case of a physical product, such as a house, a

developer or housing industries will gather raw materials / information about the

features and benefits desired by a target market. Ahead of assembling a house

(product), the strategic marketing management’s role is to communicate with the

target customer to understand the demand of them to create the house by engineering

plan and design. The engineering plan and design must base on customers’ needs and

solution of the current problems of product an expected result in the marketers to find

as many customers as possible to buy this product (Jim & Peter 2005).

The product itself is the first element. Product must satisfy consumer needs.

The product includes the physical product, product services, branding, packaging,

coloring, standardizing, planning and developing right product, product modification,

product innovation, etc. (Jain, 2007; Jerry 2002). The “Product” refers to the goods or

services that the producer offers to the clients. Apart from a physical production itself,

there are features connected with the product that customers are having high demand

and they attracted on the product such as the way it is packed. Other product attributes

include quality, features, options, brand name and warranties. Therefore, it might think

to offer as a bundle of services or goods. The goods appearance, role, and support

make up what the client is really purchasing. The successful managers immediate

responsiveness to the requirements their goods packages address for clienteles. The

product bundle must meet the demands of a particular target market (Cole 2012).

Page 41: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

19

2.4.1.1 Production Model

The product model is the basic guideline that strategic marketing follows accordingly

to produce a successful product in the modern era are acknowledged the best practice

research and consequential methodology have led to some the most significant

discoveries in product innovation. They were the first identify what distinguish

winning products from losing products, built a perfect product to success predictive

tool, and first to initiate the idea of new product assortment management. Their

combined works are considered to have achieved the greatest impact on performance

in product innovation today. Cooper and Edgett, have stimulated and enabled business

executives and their organizations to create product innovation capability that has

generated millions of dollars in new wealth (Robert et, al,.2013). This model is vital

to create product innovation the housing project to success in the modern days with

the new idea and new fact-finding such as the green environment for better human life

and health. In reality, most of the developer follows the operations system but not

perfectly due to many reasons (Nigel et, al,. 2007; Robert et, al,. 2013).

2.4.1.2 New Product (Project) Development

Marketing is a vital plane to the role a New Product Development (NPD) through

several mechanisms. One is cross the functional communication and collaboration so

that marketing elements are incorporated into the NPD development. In addition it is

a strategic orientation of NPD, that is included in the commercialization strategy

elements such as client orientation and market fit. The marketing investigation plays

a specific character, as it offers the knowledge and information that marketing carries

hooked on its NPD roles. We show that use of marketing study is the most important

to the foundation of higher NPD success in the market of property and development

processing. Many theories of NPD achieve because they incorporate market elements

and strategic elements in the NPD include client orientation or market appropriate.

Implicit in these theories are the hypothesis that businesses must continuously obtain

market information for such adaptation to the market to work. Certainly, some work

Page 42: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

20

specifically on NPD stresses the need for this market orientation (John et, al,. 2007;

Robert et, al,. 2013). Many of the activities discuss are marketing research, and bring

in customer information at many different stages of the NPD process. Display how the

marketing study could use for guide Research and Development (R & D. This role for

marketing study should be improved, if, as noted above, NPD in the Properties

industry is quite market driven. So, Market Research is vital to invest in property

industries to success the property business in the modern market in any part of the

world (Mateja et, al,. 2010; Robert et, al,. 2013).

In this case, the new condominium complex is considered as a new product to

supply the demand of the customer. The new housing complex develops based on the

new design of internal and external according to the current demand in environmental

elements and other facilities that most important to the target customers.

2.4.1.3 Variety of Product (House)

There are several variety of housing in Malaysia developed through many developers

companies as below.

i. Terraced – single, two- or three-storey

ii. Semi-Detached – single, two- or three-storey

iii. Detached

iv. Townhouse

v. Flat

vi. Serviced Apartment and Condominium complex

vii. Low-cost flat

Page 43: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

21

2.4.1.4 The Quality & Design of Condominium

Each product having the quality and design when the industry produces or develop.

The condominium is one of the housing product that is the main product of this study.

The housing value analysis that can be applied to the building in order to minimize the

construction cost and maximize the quality at the same times, without compromising

the building’s efficiency (Farouk 2011). The Condominium complex is known as

high-rise building a high rise building (Tower) is a term that means a tall building

which is more than total height exceeds 36m or 12 floors. The high rise building use

for varies purpose such as administrative, residential, or a hotel. Since the beginning

of the high rise, building developers did not pay the attention to surrounding of the

environment. Day by day the user of the tower demand environment at the surrounding

due the many problems, as a result, the developers develop the environmental design

for the new high rise building (Farouk 2011).

2.4.1.5 Packaging and Decoration

The Packaging is a primary function in the business concentration for the protection

and beauty of the product. Physical damage and chemical deterioration from

mechanical and climatic hazards, as well as changes caused by microorganisms, must

be prevented. The product and packaging materials must be compatible”. In reality,

after construct, the building developers do the packing by beautiful colors not only

outside but also inside to protect the building from rainwater damage and climatic

hazards. So, the outside of the building is most important to create a skin by water

resist materials that looks beautiful, and it is the best packing of the building (Lockhart

& Paine 1996). For instance, complete a high rise building as a product with the

beautiful internal and external design that can attractive the customers. The beautiful

color of the high-rise building can protect from the rain water that usually damage the

building the distemper color use as both for increasing the beauties and packaging

also. The figure 2.4.1.5 shows how to damage the building without the packaging by

Page 44: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

22

distemper color, the rate of damage and how to save the building by using the

distemper color as packing (Cheng 2008)

Figure 2.4.1.5 Packing and decorating of the product.1, who does enter water 2, the

report of damages 3, the solution. (Lockhart & Paine 1996).

2.4.1.6 Brand Name of the Product

Basically each commercial product has the brand name but the property does not have

the brand name however, there is reputation (good or bad) of the developers in the

property market based on the quality of product or condominium building. The

branding can influence the target customers to performance the sales activities in the

property market. The best branding usually guarantees product / property sale (Cheng

2008). For example, there are many well-known housing brand (developers) in

Malaysian property market such as IJM Land, UEM Sunrise Berhad, UDA Holding

Berhad, TTDI Harta Sdn Bhd, Mah Sing Group etc.

2.4.2 Price (Value of Unit)

The second element of strategic marketing is the price of a goods or services, it must

be high enough to cover the costs and make a profit but low enough to attract

customers to buy the product. The price can affect the volume of sales in the market.

Page 45: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

23

It is the high values of the product, which can determine the customer to buy or not to

buy. The reasonable value of the influence product client to purchase. Price mix

includes determining pricing objectives and policies of price fixation, discount policy,

concession policy, profit margin, terms of payment, credit policy, etc (John

et,al,.2008; Eloisa et, al,. 2011).Term “Price” refers to refers how much you can charge

your customers for your product or service and how much is the profit in behind in the

total value of the product. Determining your product’s price should reflect the suitable

locating of your invention in the marketplace and result in value that covers the

production cost per item and includes a profit margin. The result should neither greedy

nor timid. The high price will send out of the market, and the too low price will make

it impossible to grow your business (Cole et, al,. 2012)

The product then comes the price with profit many projects got to lose if they

make the mistake in the stage. Subsequently, the price is most important to get the

target profit from the sales in the challenging market. It is the very careful stage to set

the price of the product that should be approved by the result of customer’s purchasing

behaviors. Marginal theory of costing is that most businesses have a combination of

the two resulting in semi-variable costs. Under this, the whole cost of industrial or

producing products or services can be separated into two different parts: the fixed and

the variable prices. Fixed prices are considered to be the outstanding constant no

matter the variation in the number of products though variable (marginal) costs vary

directly with production quantity. However, difficulties do arise in categorizing some

costs as either fixed or changeable (Sinclair & Talbott 1986).

In the theory, the fixed cost is the land price and very adequate is the quantity

of units for example a condominium is total 25 levels, and another condominium is

total 35 levels with the same measurement of land. In this case, the land is the fixed

cost but total deferment of 10 level is the variable. It means the more ten levels of a

condominium can get the more profit compare to the 25 stories one (Sinclair & Talbott

1986).Price is the value of the product that can show the loss or profit of the business,

Pricing is the process of determining what a company will receive in exchange for its

products. Pricing is the cost of product or services for the manufacturing organization

or companies, it starting up based on competitors, marketplace, and quality of the

product. Pricing is also a key variable in macro-economic the theory of price

allocation. The pricing is a fundamental aspect of strategy marketing it works with

four Ps of the marketing strategy. The other three features are promotion, product, and

Page 46: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

24

place / location. The price carried profit, revenue generating, and the strategic price

strongly influences customers to purchase or rent the housing property (Elias 2007;

John et,al,.2008)

Table 2.4.2 Property Price in Malaysia 2000 to 2012 (Price Index 2012).

The property price is increasing based on increasing building materials, as well

as many foreign demand to buy the property. As a result, the government makes the

rule for them in the pricing is minimum RM 500,000.00 Information by the state

government and practicing by the developers and agent such as Property Guru

iProperty and others The foreign customer have to pay minimum RM 500,000 to

purchase housing apartment / property in Malaysia (Price Index, 2012).

2.4.2.1 Base price

Base price is the original price of the product or services without the additional charge

that might be added on the base price, such as decoration, utility, furnisher handling

or shipping charges, sales tax, optional equipment charges, etc. Many developers is

showing the base price to attract the target customers after booking gradually they

show the additional cost to them. If the total price is showing before purchase might

be the customers should not buy the property because of price (Roger et al,. 2012).

80

90

100

110

120

130

140

150

00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12

RM

-P

sf

Year

Malaysia - House Priceindicators, all Malaysia

Page 47: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

202

REFERENCE

Abdul Hamid Mar Iman, Fu Yek Pieng, Christopher Gan (2012) A Conjoint

Analysis of Buyers’ Preferences for Residential Property, international real

estate review 2012 vol. 15 no. 1: pp. 73 – 105.

Abdul Hamid (1991), Malaysia’s Vision 2020 Kuala Lumpur: Pelanduk

Publication Ltd: 1-2Gree

Abdullah, Abdul Aziz Rahman, Hamzah Abdul (2011) Planning Process of

Development Project in the Malaysian Context: A Crucial Brief Overview,

International Journal of Applied Science and Technology Vol. 1 No. 2;

April 2011,

Aiken, L. S., & West, S. G. (1991). Multiple regression: Testing and interpreting

interactions. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Copyright © 2004 – 2013 Elite

Research LLC

Alaskari. O, Ahmad M.M, N. Dhafr, Pinedo-Cuenca (2012) Critical Successful

Factors (CSFs) for Successful Implementation of Lean Tools and ERP

Systems, Proceedings of the World Congress on Engineering 2012 Vol III ,

WCE 2012, July 4 - 6, 2012, London, U.K.

Andrea Bacova, Paulette Duarte, Aminreza Iranmanesh, Viera Joklova, Leandro

Madrazo, (2011). Housing Concepts, OIKODOMOS October 2011, The

contents of this document are also available in OIKOpedia

www.oikodomos.org/oikopedia.

Andrew F. Hayes (2013) Introduction to Mediation, Moderation, and Conditional

Process Analysis: A Regression-Based Approach

Andrew F. Hayes (2013) Model Templates for PROCESS for SPSS and SAS,

Department of Psychology The Ohio State University Columbus, H 43210,

U.S.A.

Anirban Sarkar (2012). Green Marketing and Sustainable Development

challenges and Opportunities, International Journal of Marketing, Financial

Services & Management Research, Vol.1 Issue 9, September 2012, ISSN

2277 3622

Anne Frej (2003), Green Buildings and Sustainable Development Making the

Business Case ULI–the Urban Land Institute 1025 Thomas Jefferson

Street, N.W. Suite 500 West Washington, D.C. 20007-5201

Page 48: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

203

Aqil S. M, Burney (2008) ‘Inductive & Deductive research approach’ Karachi

University Journal of Science Vol.39 (1) May 2008.

Aqil S. M, Burney and Nadeem Mahmood (2006) “A Brief history of

Mathematical Logic and Applications of Logic in CS/IT” Karachi

University Journal of Science Vol.34 (1) July 2006. 61-75

Aram, J.D. and Salipante, P.F., Jr. (2003) ‘Bridging scholarship in management:

Epistemological reflections ‘British Journal of Management 14, 189–205.

Armstrong, G., & Kotler, P. (2005). Marketing: An introduction (7th ed.). Upper

Saddle River, New Jersey: Pearson Prentice-Hall. UK

Aurimas Dapkevicius, Borisas Melnikas (2009) Influence Of Price and Quality to

Customer Satisfaction Neuro Marketing Approach, Vilniaus Gedimino

Technikos Universitetas, Issn 2029-2341(Print)/Issn 2029-2252 (Online)

Babbie, E., 2010. The Practice of Social Research,12th Ed: 2010 Cengage

Learning Inc.

Barthwal R.R. (2002) Environmental Impact Assessment. New Age International

(P) Ltd, publishers New Dilhi 110002 India.

Bartol, K. M., & Martin, D. C., Management. New York: McGraw Hill, Inc.

(1991) Glass, N. M., Pro-active management: How to improve your

management performance. East Brunswick, NJ: Nichols Publishing.

Bazeley, P. (2007) Qualitative Data Analysis with NVivo. London: Sage.

Bendre, A., Din, A., Hoesli, M., Brocher, S. (2000). Environmental Preferences:

Further Evidence Using the AHP Method, Journal of Property Investment

and Finance, 18(4): 445-455.

Bennett, R. and Barkensio, A. (2005). Relationship quality, relationship

marketing, and client perceptions of the levels of service quality of

charitable organisations, International Journal of Service Industry

Management.

Bevan W and Lu S (2013). Green marketing in housing: reality or rhetoric? In:

Smith, S.D and Ahiaga-Dagbui, D.D (Eds) Procs 29th Annual ARCOM

Conference, 2-4 September 2013, Reading, UK, Association of Researchers

in Construction Management, 1243-1252.

Bowen, H.K., Clark, K.B., Holloway, C. A., and Wheelwright, S. C. (1994)

Development Projects and Pricing: Harvard Business Review UK.

Page 49: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

204

Boyle, Melissa A. and Katherine A. Kiel. (2001) “A Survey of House Price

Hedonic Studies of the Impact of Environmental Externalities,” Journal of

Real Estate Literature, 9, 117– 144.

Boynton, A. C. & Zmud, R. W. (1984). An assessment of critical success factors.

Sloan Management Review,25(3), 17-27.

Brandimarte, P. (2011). Dependence, Correlation, and Conditional Expectation.

In Quantitative Methods. pp. 353–381.

Brian Milani (2005) Building Materials in a Green Economy: Community-Based

Strategies For Dematerialization, Department of Adult Education and

Counselling Psychology and the Institute for Environmental Studies

University of Toronto.

Broom, G.M. (2000) Effective Public Relations: Pearson Education LTD

Singapore.

Bruce Turner, (1994),"The Valuation of Resort Condominium Projects and

Individual Units", Journal of Property Valuation and Investment, Vol. 12

Iss 4 pp. 9 – 36.

Bryman, A. (2006) ‘Integrating quantitative and qualitative research: how is it

done? Qualitative Research, Vol. 6, pp. 97–113.

Bryman, A., 2008. Self-completion Questionnaires. In Social Research Methods.

p. 748.

Burrell and Morgan (1982) Sociological Paradigms and Organisational

Analysis.Reproduced with permission of Ashgate Publishing Company

Buscher, B. and Dressler, W, (2007). Linking new protectionism and

environmental governance:on the rapidly increasing tensions between

actors in the environment-development nexus. Conservation and society, 5

(4), 586–611.

Castree, N., (2008). Neoliberalising nature: the logics of deregulation and re-

regulation. Environment and planning A, 2008.

Chan Wai Seen (2006), The house development aims to be a premier centre for

businesses in Kuala Lumpur, Copyright© 2006 JS Valuers Research &

Consultancy Sdn Bhd (2006).

Chau, K. W. & Chin, T. L. (2002), A Critical Review of the Literature on the

Hedonic Pricing Model and Its Application to the Residential Market in

Penang, The Seventh Asian Real Estate Society Conference. FiI

Chua, L.C., 2006. Sample Size Estimation Using Krejcie And Morgan And

Cohen Statistical Power Analysis: A Comparison. Jurnal Penyelidikan

IPBL, 7, pp.78–86.

Page 50: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

205

Chau, K. W. & Chin, T. L. and Ng, F. F. (2004), The Impact of the Asian

Financial Crisis on the Pricing of Condominiums in Malaysia, Journal of

Real Estate Literature, 12(1): 33-49.

Cheng Fan Fah (2008) Importance of Branding for Property Developers in

Malaysia, Universiti Putra Malaysia 43400 UPM Serdang Selangor Darul

Ehsan.

Chihiro Shimizu Hideoki Takatsuji Hiroya Ono Kiyohiko G. Nishimura,

(2010),"Structural and temporal changes in the housing market and hedonic

housing price indices", International Journal of Housing Markets and

Analysis, Vol. 3 Iss 4 pp. 351 – 368.

Christina Sagala, Mila Destriani, Ulffa Karina Putri, Suresh Kumar (2014).

Influence of Promotional Mix and Price on Customer Buying Decision:

International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications, Volume 4,

Issue 1, January 2014 1 ISSN 2250-3153

Clark, M. (2002) ‘The relationship between employees’ perceptions of

organizational climate and customer retention rates in a major UK retail

bank’, Journal of Strategic Marketing 10: 1, 93–113.

Clement W. Stone, (1985).The Greatest Salesman in the World, Fredeick Fell

Education Publisher. New York 10036 USA.

Cole Ehmke, Joan Fulton, and Jayson Lusk (2012) Marketing’s Four P’s: First

Steps for New Entrepreneurs Purdue University press USA

Collis, J. and Hussey, R. (2003), Business Research: A Practical Guide for

Undergraduate and Postgraduate Students (2nd edn). Basingstoke: Palgrave

Macmillan.

Craig Watkins, (1999),"Property valuation and the structure of urban housing

markets", Journal of Property Investment & Finance, Vol. 17 Iss 2 pp. 157

– 175.

Creswell, J.W., 2003. Chapter One, “A Framework for Design.” Research design

Qualitative quantitative and mixed methods approaches. Retrieved from

http://www.sagepub.com/upm-data/22780_Chapter_1.pdf.

Dadson Awunyo-Vitor1, Edward Kwame Ayimey, & Regina Adzoa Gayibor

(2013). Does Sales Promotion Influence Buyer Behaviour? A Study of PZ

Cussons Limited, British Journal of Economics, Management & Trade

3(2): 141-152, 2013

Dana Frank (1994) Purchasing Power consumer organizing gender and Seattle

labour movement 1919-1929. The press syndicate of the university of

Cambridge, Cambridge, CB2 1RP UK.

Page 51: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

206

Danny Myers, (2011). Economics & Property The Estates Gazette Guide, Third

Edition, Elsevier Ltd, Oxford, OX5 1GB, UK.

David Fredeck Ross, (2004). Distribution Planning and Control Managing in the

Era of Supply Chain Management, Second Edition, Kluwer Academic

Publishers, 101 Philip Drive Assinippi Park 02061 USA.

David Garson (2016). Partial Least Squares: Regression & Structural Equation

Models, Statistical Associates Blue Book Series, (2016 Edition) School of

Public & International Affairs, North Carolina state University.

David Lorenz & Thomas Lutzkendorf (2008) “Sustainability in Property

Valuation: Theory and Practice” Journal of Property Investment & Finance,

Vol. 26 Iss 6 pp. 482 – 521.

Deborah S. Levy, (1995),"Modern marketing research techniques and the

property professional", Property Management, Vol. 13 Iss 3 pp. 33 – 40.

Degtiareva, E. (2001). Minimizing risk by analyzing a lessee’s financial position:

Analysis of the financial situation and projected cash flow. Leasing-Courier

5(17): 1-5.

Dev, Chekitan, S And Schultz, Don, E (2005). A Customer-Focused Approach

Can Bring The Current Marketing Mix Into The 21st Century, Journal Of

Marketing Management; Jan / Feb 2005, Vol. 14 Issue 1, P16, January

2005.

Diae Gow McDilda (2007) The everything green living book. Adams Media

Publications Company USA.

Easterby-Smith, M., Thorpe, R. and Jackson, P.R. (2008) Management Research

(3rd edn) London: Sage.

Eldred, G. (1987). Real estate: analysis and strategy. New York: Harper & Row.

(p. 326)

Elforgani, M.S.A, & Rahmat I Bin. (2011) Green Design Performance of

Malaysian Building Projects – Descriptive Study, Issue 1819-6608, Vol 6,

No 11, November 2011.

Elias Oikarinen (2007) Studies On Housing Price Dynamics. Copyright © Elias

Oikarinen & Turku School of Economics Isb 978-951-564-506-7 (nid.)

978-951-564-507-4 (PDF) Issue No 0357-4652 (nid.) 1459-4870 (PDF)

Eloisa T. Glindro, Tientip Subhanij, Jessica Szeto, & Haibin Zhud (2011),

Determinants of House Prices in Nine Asia-Pacific Economies.

International Journal of Central Banking September 2011 Center for

Monetary and Financial Policy, Bangko Sentral Pilipinas Economic

Research Department, Bank of Thailand 2011.

Page 52: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

207

Eng Dr.Wei Chun (2012) The Asia-Pacific Housing Conference organized by

Orando Holdings Sdn Bhd. 2012. Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

Eric Ooi (2012) High-End Condominium and Gated & Guarded Communities

Market Performance and Outlook. Knight Frank Malaysia 17 January 2012.

Erika Von Mutius, Md Munich, Germany (2002) Environmental Factors

Influencing the Development and Progression of Pediatric Asthma, Journal

of Allergy Clin Immunol Volume 109, Issue Number 6 Von Mutius S527.

Ezanee Md. Elias, Azizi Abu Bakar, Ahmad Yusni Bahaudin, and Fadzil Mohd

Husin (2013) Green Residential Buildings: The Perspective of Potential

Buyers, Proceedings of 3rd Global Accounting, Finance and Economics

Conference 5 - 7 May, 2013, Rydges Melbourne, Australia, ISBN: 978-1-

922069-23-8.

Ezeanya, Andrew C (2004) Malaysian housing policy : Prospects and obstacles

of National Vision 2020, University of Malaya, Department of Social

Administration and Justice, UM, Kuala Lumpur 50603.

Farouk, Akram (2011) High Rise Buildings and How They Affect Countries

Progression Department of Architecture. Ain Shams University Faculty of

Engineering Department of Architecture Cairo, Egypt.

Frank Atkinson (2010) Sales Planning: Ventus Publishing ApS ISBN 978-87-

7681-613-1. eBooks at bookboon.com

Fuat A. Firat & Clifford J. Shultz , (1997)," From segmentation to fragmentation

Markets and marketing strategy in the postmodern era ", European Journal

of Marketing, Vol. 31 Iss 3/4 pp. 183 – 207.

Garrod, Guy and Kenneth G. Willis. (1992) “The Environmental Economic

Impact of Woodland: A Two State Hedonic Price Model of the Amenity

Value of Forestry in Britain,” Applied Economics, 24, 715–728.

Ghauri, P. and Gronhaug, K. (2005) Research Methods in Business Studies: A

Practical Guide(3rd edn). Harlow: Financial Times Prentice Hall.

Giese, J.L. & Cote, J.A (2002). Defining Consumer Satisfaction, Academy of

Marketing Science, journal of Academy of Marketing Science Vol, 2000,

Number 1.

Gillian KaneGeorge HeaneyKen EwartBilly McAlister, (2002),"Developing an

accessibility appraisal model for the external environments of housing

estates", International Journal of Manpower Facilities, Vol. 20 Iss 3/4 pp.

104 – 1132.

Page 53: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

208

Glynis Laing, Michael Lane, Nicci Millington, (2005) Public Relations Guide

For Rural Housing Organizations, Housing Assistance Council 1025

Vermont Avenue, .W. Suite 606 Washington, DC 20005 - 202-842-8600

(voice)

Graeme Newell, (2008),"The strategic significance of environmental

sustainability by Australian-listed property trusts", Journal of Property

Investment & Finance, Vol. 26 Iss 6 pp. 522 - 540 Permanent link to this

document:

Gregory T. Gundlach (2007). Definition of Marketing: Perspectives on Its

Implications for Scholarship and the Role and Responsibility of Marketing

in Society, Journal of American Marketing Association ISSN: 0743-9156

(print), 1547-7207 (electronic) Vol. 26

Grunig, J.E. and Grunig, L.A (2000) “Public Relations in Strategic Management”

journalism Studies 1(2):303-321.

Gupta, Sunil (1988) Impact of sales promotions on when, what, and how much to

buy, Journal of Marketing Research, Issue 4 Volume 25

Hair, J F., Black, W. C., Babin, B. J., Anderson R. E., & Tatham R. L. (2006)

Multivariate data analysis (Sixth Edition ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ;

Pearson Prentice Hall.

Hair, J. F., Black, W. C., Babin, B. J., Anderson, R. E., & Tatham, R. L.

(2010). Multivariate data analysis (Vol. 6). Upper Saddle River, NJ:

Pearson Prentice Hall.

Hair, J.F., Hult, G. T. M., Ringle, C., & Starstedt, M. (2013). A primer on partial

least squares structural equation modelling (PLS-SEM) Sage Pub.

Hakim, C. (2000) Research Design: Successful Designs for Social and Economic

Research (2nd edn). London: Routledge

Hard Timee Ahad (2014) Property Developers in Malaysia. Maybank ib

Research and Development. Issue no: PP16832/01/2013 (031128).

Haslehurst, M. (1980). Manufacturing technology. The English Language Books

Society (ELBS) (Ed.), pp. 4-10. Hodder & Stoughton, Bucks, UK.

Hasmah Abu Zarin (1999). Factors Influencing Demand For Condominium In

Johor Bahru, Malaysia, International Real Estate Society Conference '99,

Co-sponsors: Pacific Rim Real Estate Society (PRRES) Asian Real Estate

Society (AsRES) Kuala Lumpur, 26-30 January 1999. Faculty of

Geoinformation Science & Engineering Universiti Teknologi Malaysia

81310 UTM Skudai,

Page 54: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

209

Hasmah Abu Zarin and Ahmad Ariffian Bujang (2000). Factors Influence

Demand for Condominium in Johor Bahru, Malaysia. International Real

Estate Society Conference ' 99.

Hayes, Andrew. F. (2013). Introduction to Mediation, Moderation, and

Conditional Process Analysis: A Regression-Based Approach. The Ohio

State University Department of Psychology, Columbus OH 43221 New

York: The Guilford Press. http://www.guilford.com/p/hayes3

Hayes, B. E (1998) Managing Customer Satisfaction: Survey design use and

statistical analysis methods, Wisconsin AS Q quality press.

Healey, M.J. and Rawlinson, M.B. (1994) ‘Interviewing Techniques in Business

and management research’, in V.J. Wass and P.E. Wells (eds) Principles

and Practice in Business and Management Research. Aldershot:

Dartmouth, pp. 123–45.

Hezri, A,A. and Hasan, M.N. (2004) Management framework for sustainable

development indicators in the State of Selangor, Malaysia, Ecological

Indicators, 4, pp. 287–304

Hoffman, D. And Novak, T. (1996) “Marketing In Hypermedia Computer

Mediated Environments: Conceptual Foundations”, Journal Of Marketing,

Vol.60, July,1996, Pp.50-68.

Hox J. (2002). Multi-level Analysis: Environment Techniques and Applications

(Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, London Page no: 110)

Isobel Doole and Robin Lowe (2008) International Marketing Strategy Analysis

development and implementation. Publisher: Dawson-Bowling

Manufacturing UK.

Izudinshah Abd. Wahab, Lokman Hakim Ismail, (2013). Natural Ventilation

Approach in Designing Urban Tropical House, Department of Construction

Engineering and Architecture, Universiti Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia

(UTHM)

Jain T.R. Dr. S.C. Aggarwal Dr. R.K. Rana (2007) Basic Statistics for

Economists. V.K India Enterprises. 4323/3, Ansari Road, Darya Gani. New

Delhi-2 India.

James E. Grunig & Larissa A. Grunig (2010) Public Relations in Strategic

Management and Strategic Management of Public Relations: theory and

evidence from the IABC Excellence project, Journalism Studies Volume

1, Issue 2-2000 Publishing models and article dates explained Published

online: 12 Dec 2010.

James R., Follain, (2010) A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities ©

Research Institute for Housing America December 2010. All rights

reserved.

Page 55: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

210

James Wong (2008) Malaysia Property Market Review 2008. VPC Alliance

Malaysia Sdn, Bhd. March, 2008.

James Wong, Somnul Laohaprasit, John Prawiromaruto (2013). Property Country

Report : Malaysia. VP Asia-Pacific Conversion Singapore 19 April 2013.

Jari Karna (2003) Environmental Marketing Strategy and its Implementation in

Forest Industries, Finnish Forest Research Institute, Vantaa Research

Centre PO Box 18, FIN 01301 Vantaa ISBN 952-10-0963-2 (paperback)

ISBN 952-10-0964-0 (online).

Jen Green, (2012). Ethical Debates Advertising, First Edition, The Rosen

Publishing group, 29 east 21st Street, New York NY 10010 USA.

Jenet Manyi Agbor (2011), The Relationship between Customer Satisfaction and

Service Quality: a study of three service sectors in Umea, School of

Business Spring 2011.

Jerry B, and David Macias (2002) Managing Product Definition in High

Technology Industries: California Management Review Ltd.

Jerry Goolsby (1988), “The Rise and Fall of the Functional Approach to

Marketing: A Paradigm Displacement perspective,”in Historical Perspectives

in Marketing, Terrence Nevett and Ronald A. Fullerton, eds. Lexington, MA:

D.C. Heath and Company, 35–54.

Jim Blythe and Peter Reed (2005) Strategic Marketing. University of Cambridge –

Select Knowledge limited. UK

Jim Suttle (2010) Environmental Element, Omaha Master Plan of Environment

Element. Journal of environmental economy and society 2010.

John J. Toohey, S.J. (2007), Notes on Epistemology, the Starting Point of

Epistemology,Reality and Truth, Georgetown University Washington, D.C.

USA

John R. Hall, (2013) HIGH-RISE BUILDING FIRES, National Fire Protection

Association Fire Analysis and Research Division, September 2013.

John R. Hauser, MIT and Ely Dahan (2007) New Product Development, University

of California at Los Angeles, 110 Westwood Plaza, B-514, Los Angeles, CA

90095, (310) 206- 4170, fax (310) 206-7422,

John. R. Ottensmann, Seth. Payton, Joyce Man (2008) Urban Location and

Housing Prices within a Hedonic Model, The Journal of Regional Analysis

and Policy (2008) Volume: 38, Issue: 1, Pages: 19-35 ISSN: 10904999

Johnson. G., Scholes, K., & Sexty, R.W (1989) Exploring strategic management.

Scarborough, Ontario: Prentice Hall,

Page 56: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

211

Jong-Jin Kim, and Brenda Rigdon, (2007) Sustainable Architecture Module:

Qualities, Use, and Examples of Sustainable Building Materials.

Department of Architecture and Urban lanningThe University of Michigan.

Center for Higher Education, 430 E. University Ave., Ann Arbor, MI

48109-1115.

Joseph I. Uduji (2013) Public Relations for Improving Public Perception of the

Marketing Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development ISSN 2222-

1700 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2855 (Online) Vol.4, No.8, 2013

Joseph I. Uduji (2013) Public Relations for Improving Public Perception of the

Marketing Executives in the Banking Industry in Nigeria, Journal of

Economics and Sustainable Development ISSN 2222-1700 (Paper) ISSN

2222-2855 (Online) Vol.4, No.8, 2013

Justin D. Benefield, (2009),"Neighborhood amenity packages, property price, and

marketing time", Journal of Property Management, Vol. 27 Iss 5 pp. 348 –

370.

Karna, J., Juslin, H., Ahonen, V. and Hansen, E. (2001). Green Advertising:

Greenwash or a True Reflection of Marketing Strategy? Greener

Management International (2001).

Khairil Wahidin Awang, Nor Khomar Ishak, Salleh Mohd Razi and Azni Zarina

Taha (2008) Environmental Variables and Performance: Evidence from the

Hotel Industry in Malaysia, International Journal of Economics and

Management 2(1): 59 – 79 (2008)

Kim Hiang Liow, (1996),"Property companies’ share price discounts and

property market returns The Singapore evidence ", Journal of Property

Finance, Vol. 7 Iss 4 pp. 64 – 77.

Kim Y. (2011) The Pilot Study in Qualitative Inquiry: Identifying Issues and

Learning Lessons for Culturally Competent Research. Qualitative Social

Work, 10, pp.190–206.

Kisho Dr. Kurokawa, (2012) GREEN BUILDING DEVELOPMENT THE

MRCB WAYS, © the green imitative by MRCB 08 may 2012,

Klaus G. Grunert C. Ellegaard (1992) The Concept of Key Success Factors:

Theory and Method. MAPP working paper no 4, October 1992, ISSN 0907

2101.

Kotler Philip (2003), Marketing Management: Analysis, Planning, and Control,

3rd edition Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall. London, UK

Krauss S.E. et al., (2009). Preliminary Investigation and Interview Guide

Development for Studying how Malaysian Farmers ’ Form their Mental

Models of Farming. The Qualitative Report, 14, pp.245–260.

Page 57: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

212

Krejcie & Morgan, (1970) DETERMINING SAMPLE SIZE FOR RESEARCH

ACTIVITIES and Small-Sample Techniques. The NEA Research Bulletin,

Vol. 38 (December, 1960) (p. 99)

Kris Peeters,(2011), Building and construction materials, Published by Minister-

President of the Government of Flanders, May 2011.

Lisa P. Jackson (2013), Creating Equitable Healthy and Sustainable

Communities, Environmental Protection Agency United States of America

(EPA) 2013.

Lockhart H. and F. A. Paine (1996) Packaging of Product and Healthcare:

Chapman & Hall, 2-6 Boundary Row London, UK

Maarit Karppinen (2011) Strategic Marketing Plan for a Hotel and Restaurant

Business, Vaasa University, department of Applied Science and Hospitality

Management, May 2011.

Mahsa Familmaleki, Alireza Aghighi and Kambiz Hamidi (2015). Analyzing the

Influence of Sales Promotion on Customer Purchasing Behavior,

International Journal of Economics & Management Sciences, ISSN: 2162-

6359 IJEMS, an open access, Volume 4 Issue 41000243.

Malpezzi, and S. Mayo. (2005). “Metropolitan-Specific Estimates of the Price

Elasticity of Supply of Housing, and Their Sources.” American Economic

Review Papers and Proceedings.

Maria Teresa Siniscalco and Nadia Auriat (2005) “Quantitative Research

Methods in Educational Planning” Questionnaire Design, International

Institute for Educational Planning / UNESCO 7-9 rue Eugene – Delacroix,

75116 Paris, France, (www.unesco.org/iiep.)

Marcia Nedland (2010). Developing A Basic Marketing Plan To Sell Houses,

Copyright 2010, Fall Creek Consultants, www. Fallcreekconsultants.com

Mariana Mohammed Osman, Noor Suzilawati Bt Rabe, Syahriah Bt Bachok.

(2007) An Investigation of Factors Influencing Communities Decision to

Reside in Gated Development in Kuala Lumpur and Selangor, Department

of Urban and Regional Planning, International Islamic University Malaysia,

Kuala Lumpur 53100 - Malaysia

Marina Vaskovich (2012) Real Property Processes an Explorative Study of

Property Institutions in Belarus, Real Estate Planning and Land Law

Department of Real Estate and Construction Management School of

Architecture and the Built Environment Royal Institute of Technology

(KTH) Stockholm, Sweden 2012

Page 58: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

213

Maslow A. H. (1943) A Theory Of Human Motivation - Classics in the History

Of Psychology, Originally Published In Psychological Review, 50, 370-

396, York University, Toronto, Ontario ISSN 1492-3713 Posted in August

2000.

Mateja Karnicar Senk, Peter Metlikovic, Matjaz Maletic, Bostjan Gomiscek

(2010). Development of New Product/Process Development rocedure for

SMEs, University of Maribor, Faculty of Organizational Sciences,

Laboratory for Quality Management, Kidriceva 55a, Kranj, Slovenia,

Volume 43, Number 2, April 2010.

Matlovicova, K. (2008) PLACE MARKETING PROCESS – THEORETICAL

ASPECTS OF REALIZATION. Act Faculty Studious of Humanity ,

University of Presoviensis, 12 pu presov 2008, s. 195-224.

Maylor, H. and Blackmon, K. (2005), Researching Business and Management.

Basingstoke:Palgrave Macmi Healey, M.J. and Rawlinson, M.B. (1994)

‘Interviewing Techniques in Business and llan.

McGrew, (2013). Mc Grew Real Estate, Online Publications, 1501 Kasold Drive

Lawrence, KS 66047.

Melchert, L. (2007), The Dutch sustainable building policy: A model for

developing countries? Building and Environment. 893–901

Meng, Ng Wai, Alejandro Camerlengo & Ahmad Abdul Wahab (2007). A

STUDY OF GLOBAL WARMING IN MALAYSIA. Jurnal Teknologi,

42(F) Jun. 2007: 1–10 Universiti Teknologi Malaysia.

Michael Burr Tilford (2009), Developing For Demand- An Analysis of Demand

Segmentation Methods and Real Estate Development, Boston University

School of Management & Business (2009).

Michael R. Diamond (2010). The Meaning and Nature of Property:

Homeownership and Shared Equity in the Context of Poverty, Georgetown

Public Law and Legal Theory Research Paper No. 10-50 August 2010

Miles, M.B. and Huberman, A.M. (1994) Qualitative Data Analysis. Thousand

Oaks, CA: Sage. Chapter 11 provides a very useful examination of a range

of ethical issues principally from the perspective of their implications for

data analysis.

Miller, N.G. and Markosyan, S, (2003), The Academic Roots and Evolution of

Real Estate Appraisal, The Appraisal Journal, April 2003,

Mintu, A. T. & H. R. Lozada. (1993). "Green Marketing Education: A Call For

Action," Marketing Education Review, 3 (Fall): 17-23.

Page 59: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

214

Mitchell, R. and Popham, F., (2008) Effect of exposure to natural environment on

health inequalities: an observational population study, The Lancet

(372/9650), 1 655–1 660.

Moore-moore, B Laurie (2008) The key to marketing luxury homes - defining

and targeting the best prospect groups

Morris, T. and Wood, S. (1991) ‘Testing the survey method: continuity and

change in British industrial relations’, Work Employment and Society, Vol.

5, No. 2

Motalib Mohammad Abdul, Rodel D. Lasco, Enrique P. Pacardo, Carmelita M.

Rebancos, Josefina T. Dizon (2015) Health Impact Of Air Pollution On

Dhaka City By Different Technologies Brick Kilns, International Journal

Of Technology Enhancements And Emerging Engineering Research, Vol 3,

Issue 05 127 Issn 2347-4289

Muhammad Najib Razali Yasmin Mohd Adnan, (2012),"Transparency in

Malaysian property companies", Property Management, Vol. 30 Iss 5 pp.

398 – 415.

Muhammad Roman, Muhammad Idrees, Samiullah (2013) A Sociological Study

of Environmental Pollution and Its Effects on the Public Health Faisalabad

City. Vol. 1 no. Issn: 2201-6740 (online) 6 June 2013. International Journal

of Education and Research. www.ijern.com

Nabeel Hussain & Chris Boyd (2012) Market View Kuala Lumpur Residential

Property, Research & Consultancy CB Richard Ellis (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd 9-

1, Level 9 Menara Millennium Jalan Damanlela Bukit Damansara, Kuala

Lumpur 50490 Malaysia.

Nabila H Zhafira, Junio Andreti, Sheila S Akmal, Suresh Kumar (2013). The

Analysis of Product, Price, Place, Promotion and Service Quality on

Customers’ Buying Decision of Convenience Store: A Survey of Young

Adult in Bekasi, West Java, Indonesia, International Journal of Advances in

Management and Economics Vol. 2, ISSN: 2278-3369. Nov.-Dec. 2013

Neustadtl, A., Robinson, J.P. & Kestnbaum, M., (2002). Doing social science

research online. In The Internet on Everyday Life. pp. 186–211.

Ngai Weng Chan, (1998),"Environmental hazards associated with hill land

development in Penang Island, Malaysia: some recommendations on

effective management", Disaster Prevention and Management: An

International Journal, Vol. 7 Iss 4 pp. 305 – 318.

Nick French, (2004),"The Valuation of Specialised Property", Journal of Property

Investment & Finance, Vol. 22 Iss 6 pp. 533 – 541.

Nigel S. C. Stuart and J Robert (2007). Operations Management fifth edition,

Prentice Hall Pearson Education Ltd. England.

Page 60: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

215

Nik Nazli Nik Ahmad Ahmed Salat Ahmed Haraf, (2013),"Environmental

disclosures of Malaysian property development companies: towards

legitimacy or accountability?", Social Responsibility Journal, Vol. 9 Iss 2

pp. 241 – 258.

Norhaslina Hassan (2009) Issues and challenges of sustainable urban

development in Malaysia, in: Nurhaslina Hassan (ed) Sustainable urban

development issues in Malaysia, Dewana Sdn. Bhd, Selangor.

Nunnally, J. C. (1978) Psychometric Theory, New York, McGraw-Hill

Nwachukwu, C.C.(2004) Management: Theory and practice, pp. 265-7. Africana

First Publishers Limited, Onitsha, Anambra State, Nigeria.

Oliver, R.(1997) A Behavioural Perspective on the Consumer. Boston: McGraw-

Hill, , 43-62, New York:

Onkvisit S. and John J. (2009) International Marketing Strategy and Theory, fifth

edition, Routledge 2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon, OX14

4RN UK.

Ottman, J. 1998. "What Sustainability Means to Consumer Product Marketers,"

The Ottman Report on Environmental Marketing, Vol. 5, No. 1:

Patrick J. Wilson John Okunev, (2001),"Enhancing information use to improve

predictive performance in property markets", Journal of Property

Investment & Finance, Vol. 19 Iss 6 pp. 472 – 497.

Pollack, B. 1995. Break-even analysis: The third leg of the underwriting tool.

Real Estate Review 25: 43-6.

Powers, L. (1987) Break-even analysis with semi-fixed cost. Ind. Market.

Managemt. 67: 35-41.

Prothero, A. (1998), Environmental Marketing Management: Meeting the Green

Challenge by Ken Peattie, 1995. Pitman Publishing, Isbn 0 273 60279 9.

Bus. Strat. Env., 7: 52–53. doi: 10.1002/(SICI)1099-0836(199802).

Qiuxue Luo & Paul TJ James (2012) Influences on the buying behaviour of

purchasing commercial housing in Nanning city of Guangxi province,

China, Journal of Management and Marketing Research, Bangkok

University, Thailand.

Ralf Muller & Kam Jugdev, (2012),"Critical success factors in projects",

International Journal of Managing Projects in Business, Vol. 5 Iss 4 pp. 757

– 775.

Ramin Rahnama and Ali Hossein Beiki (2013) Modern Marketing, Concepts and

Challenges. Islamic Azad University, Rasht.Iran Arabian Journal of Business

and Management Review (OMAN Chapter) Vol. 2, No.6, Jan. 2013

Page 61: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

216

Ratchatakulpat, T., Miller, P., and Marchant, T. (2009). Residential Real Estate

Purchase Decisions in Australia: Is It More Than Location? International

Real Estate Review, 12, 3, 273 – 294.

Rebecca Lai-Har Chiu, (2006) Professional Housing Management Practices in

Hong Kong, Hong Kong University Press, 14/F Hing Wai Center. Hong

Kong.

Reuben M. Baron and David A. Kenny (1986) Moderator-Mediator Variable

Distinction in Social Psychological Research: Conceptual, Strategic, and

Statistical Considerations, Journal of Persnality and Social Psychology

1986, Vol. 51, No. 6, 1173-1182, Copyright 1986 by the American

Psychological Association, Inc 0022-3514/86/$00.75

Richard J. Cebula (2010) The Hedonic Pricing Model Applied to the Housing

Market of the City of Savannah and Its Savannah Historic Landmark

District . Southern Regional Science Association 2010. ISSN 1553-0892

SRSA, 1601 University Avenue, PO Box 6025, Morgantown, West

Virginia 26506-6025, USA.

Robert G. Cooper and Dr. Scott J. Edgett (2013) Best Practices in the Idea-to-

Launch Process and Its Governance. A study of new-product development

practices at 211 businesses provides insights into best practices in both the

idea-to-launch process and its governance.

Robin Johnson, (2011),"Public health and social housing: a natural alliance",

journal of Housing, Care and Support, Vol. 14 Iss 1 pp. 6 - 14 Permanent

link to this document:

Roger A. Kerin, Robert A. Peterson (2012) Strategic marketing problems, cases

and comments. Issn 003447-270 Vol 4, No, 5.

Roinn An Comhshaoil, & Oidhreachta Agus Rialtais (2007) Sustainable Urban

Housing : Design Standards for New Apartments, Department of The

Environment Heritage and Local Government , Sustainable Urban Housing:

Design Standards for New Apartments Guidelines for Planning Authorities

September 2007.

Ruddick, M.E., Sherwood, P.K. & Stevens, R.E. (1983). The marketing research

handbook: A decision-oriented approach. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.

(p. 80)

Said Ilias, Omar Osman, Mohd Wira Mohd Shafiei, Arman Abd Razak, Tee

Kuan Kooi (2008). Sustainability in the Housing Development Among

Construction Industry Players in Malaysia, School of Housing Building

Planning, Universiti Sains Malaysia.

Page 62: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

217

Sanders, A. L., & Magness, K. (2007). Brick Maintenance and Repair for

Historic and Landmark Structures, Issue no: 1 /2007, Volume 24 number 1

Saravanan, R. & Rao, K. S. P. (2007). Measurement of service quality from the

customer’s perspective – An empirical study, Total Quality Management,

Seetharam Kallidaikurichi & Belinada Yuen (2010), Developing Living Cities,

From Analysis to Action, National University of Singapore,

Singapore.World Scientific Publishing Co, Ltd. Singapore.

Silverman, D. (2007) A Very Short, Fairly Interesting and Reasonably Cheap

Book about Qualitative Research. London: Sage.

Sinclair, K.; and Talbott, J. (1986). Using break-even analysis when cost

behavior is unknown. Management. Account. 68: 52-5.

Stephan Anthonisz Chad Perry , (2015),"Effective marketing of high-rise luxury

condominiums in a middle-income country like Sri Lanka", Journal of

Work-Applied Management, Vol. 7 Iss 1 pp. 61 – 83.

Stephen Chung (2002) Real Estate Development, Investment Analysis, Project

Management and Architectural Design Practices in Hong Kong, China,

Asia for Project Management Institute.

Suhaida Mohd Sood, Dr. K. H. Chua, Dr. Leong Yow Peng.(2011) Sustainable

Development in the Building Sector: Green Building Framework in

Malaysia, 1-8.

Syerrina Zakaria And Nuzlinda Abd Rahman (2014) Analyzing The Property

Crime Patterns In Peninsular Malaysia: Esda Approach, Journal of

Business and Social Development, ISSN: 2289-2915, Volume 2 Number 1,

March 2014: 104-113 © Penerbit UMT.

Tan, Y.K. (2011) An Hedonic Model for House Prices in Malaysia. Wong

International Real Estate Society Conference. 15(1), 12-15. ORIC

Publications.

Tarmiji Masron, Usman Yaakob, Norizawati Mohd Ayob, Aimi Shamimi

Mokhtar (2012) Population and spatial distribution of urbanization in

Peninsular Malaysia 1957 – 2000, Malaysia Journal of Society and Space 8

issue 2 (20 – 29) Themed Issue: Malaysian Environment and Society ©

2012, ISSN 2180-2491

Tashakkori, A. and Teddlie, C. (2003) Handbook of Mixed Methods in Social and

BehaviouralResearch. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Teck-Hong Tan (2011) Sustainability and Housing Provision in Malaysia,

Journal of Strategic Innovation and Sustainability vol. 7(1) 2011.

Page 63: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

218

Tom Kauko (2010), Sustainable Urban Property Development and

Neighbourhood Dynamics, The Open Urban Studies Journal, 2010, 3, 103-

111

Tung Chee Kuan, (2009) Facilities Management In Malaysia, © Ministry of

Higher Education, Executive Consultant of Genting Sanyen (M) Sdn Bhd,

Malaysia.

Tze San Ong (2013) Macroeconomic Determinants of Malaysian Housing

Market, Human and Social Science Research Vol. 1, No. 2 (2013), 119-

127.

Ulrich Kriese, (2009),"Business and marketing strategies in responsible property

investment", Journal of Property Investment & Finance, Vol. 27 Iss 5 pp.

447 – 469.

Vries S. de, Verhei, R.A, Groenewegen P.P. (2003), Natural environments

healthy environments: an exploratory analysis of the relationship between

green space and health. Environment and Planning A. Vol. 35, 2003

Wester, K.L., Willse, J.T. & Davis, M.S., 2008. Responsible Conduct of

Research Measure: Initial Development and Pilot Study. Accountability in

Research, 15, pp.87–104.

William L. Wilkie and Elizabeth S. Moore (2007) What Does the Definition of

Marketing Tell Us, Journal of American Marketing Association - 2007 Vol.

26 ISSN: 0743-9156 (print), 1547-7207 (electronic)

William L. Wilkie and Elizabeth S. Moore (2007) What Does the Definition of

Marketing Tell Us About Ourselves? Journal of Public Policy &

Marketing: Fall 2007, Vol. 26, No. 2, pp. 269-276.

Woei Chyuan Wong, Pooi Leng Ng, Janice Y.M. Lee & Md Nasir Daud (2015)

Apartment foreclosure discount in Kuala Lumpur. Pacific Rim Property

Research Journal Volume 21, Issue 2, 2015, Published online: 06 Aug 2015

Wong Wei Sum (2012), Property Developer Cloudy Outlook; organizes by

Maybank Berhad, Property Sector Peer Valuation Summary, and Source:

Maybank IB Stock 2012,

World Business Council, (2013). Marketing and sustainable development.

University of Cambridge, University press, Cambridge, UK.

World Health Organ (1992). WHO Commission Regarding the Health and

Environment, 2001 WHO Bulletin OMS. Vol 70 1992

Page 64: INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING ... · INCORPORATING ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS IN PROPERTY MARKETING STRATEGY IN KUALA LUMPUR . MD AMANAT ULLAH . The thesis

219

Yates, S.J., 2004. Doing Social Science Research. London: SAGE Publication

Ltd. p.293.

Yin, R.K. (2003) Case Study Research: Design and Method (3rd edn). London:

Sage.

Yin, R.K., 2009. Case Study Research: Design and Methods (Vol.5, p.219).

doi:10.1097/FCH.0b013e31822dda9e

Yuriy Moyseyenko (2012). Marketing Mix of Industrial Property in Modern

Conditions. (PhD Project) National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine 9-th

floor, 60 T. Shevchenko blvd. KYIV 01032 UKRAINE (UA) May, 2012.

Yvonne Yoong (2013) Top 10 architectural trends for new Malaysian properties

in 2014, Issue no 55486 Views Home & Living.

Zain-Ul-Abideen (2003) Effective advertising and its influence on consumer

buying behaviour: European Journal of Business and Management ISSN

2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 Vol 3, No.3 (Online)