Eky Fioole & Rudi ClauseAvans University of applied sciences

The Netherlands

Indiana Jones and the crusade for

Large-scale ePortfolios:The forgotten questions

Indiana Jones and the crusade for

Large-scale ePortfolios:The forgotten questions

Download the presentation

http://avans-elearning.blogspot.com/ http://avans-elearning.blogspot.com/

Avans University of applied sciences

20.000 students 2.000 staff & faculty members 20 Schools 60 bachelor degree programs

3 locations (Breda, Tilburg and ‘s Hertogenbosch)

1 VLE (Bb Academic Suite) & ...

20.000 students 2.000 staff & faculty members 20 Schools 60 bachelor degree programs

3 locations (Breda, Tilburg and ‘s Hertogenbosch)

1 VLE (Bb Academic Suite) & ...

Our view on Learning and teaching

• Our main drivers are:

To produce excellent professionals who will continue to further develop themselves and their profession.

For selected businesses and organizations we are their partner for knowledge development and knowledge sharing.

In learning and teaching we opt for people (students, lecturers and professionals) to connect, cooperate and collaborate in acquiring knowledge and becoming competent.

• Our main drivers are:

To produce excellent professionals who will continue to further develop themselves and their profession.

For selected businesses and organizations we are their partner for knowledge development and knowledge sharing.

In learning and teaching we opt for people (students, lecturers and professionals) to connect, cooperate and collaborate in acquiring knowledge and becoming competent.

Implementations of ePortfolio, our approach in the past

School 1 Assessment

School 2 Reflection

School 3 Show Case

School 4

School 5

StudentStudent

School 6 -> 20

Innovative projects with a limited number of schools

Focus on early adaptors / innovators (passionate, opinionated)

Bottom-up approach (parallel processes)

Focus on Learning how to use ePortfolios

Collaborating with students

Very different use of ePortfolios (outcome / output)

Resulting in….

Flexibility, Engagement and Complexity, but also a lot of Learning Experiences!

Innovative projects with a limited number of schools

Focus on early adaptors / innovators (passionate, opinionated)

Bottom-up approach (parallel processes)

Focus on Learning how to use ePortfolios

Collaborating with students

Very different use of ePortfolios (outcome / output)

Resulting in….

Flexibility, Engagement and Complexity, but also a lot of Learning Experiences!

Facing new challenges: scaling up

2006 - 2008:

Large-scale implementation of ePortfolios

The forgotten questions

2006 - 2008:

Large-scale implementation of ePortfolios

The forgotten questions

Scaling up: Facing new challenges, new questions:

How different is scaling up? Can we use the same strategies?

How did we become successfull in our earlier projects?

What are our own opinions and beliefs?

Who are our stakeholders in this?

How complex are the changes we ask our lecturers and students to make?

How can we address both the small and the big issues in change?

And above all …..

• What are those forgotten questions?

How different is scaling up? Can we use the same strategies?

How did we become successfull in our earlier projects?

What are our own opinions and beliefs?

Who are our stakeholders in this?

How complex are the changes we ask our lecturers and students to make?

How can we address both the small and the big issues in change?

And above all …..

• What are those forgotten questions?

Identification of different phases in the implementation of ePortfolios

Phase 1: The start: motivated members, small projects, strong beliefs, opinionated stakeholders, use of portfolios as a tool to enhance and assess student learning on campus.

using ePortfolios off campus (work placements, graduation assignments) and use by facultymembers for their professional development and yearly reviews

Phase 2: The large scale implementation: large scale use of ePortolios, more variety in how ePortfolios are used leading to complexity, larger projects.

Phase 3: New context, new challenges, new tools, the evolution of ePortfolios.

Phase 1: The start: motivated members, small projects, strong beliefs, opinionated stakeholders, use of portfolios as a tool to enhance and assess student learning on campus.

using ePortfolios off campus (work placements, graduation assignments) and use by facultymembers for their professional development and yearly reviews

Phase 2: The large scale implementation: large scale use of ePortolios, more variety in how ePortfolios are used leading to complexity, larger projects.

Phase 3: New context, new challenges, new tools, the evolution of ePortfolios.

What else is new in Phase 2?

Involvement of a much larger group (the majority of users)

Dealing with a higher level of insecurity

A great variety in the use of ICT

Much more diversity in wishes & believes

The stakeholders have less in common

Greater variety in students (full-time and part-time)

Increasing complexity

Different strategies

How to create Engagement?

Involvement of a much larger group (the majority of users)

Dealing with a higher level of insecurity

A great variety in the use of ICT

Much more diversity in wishes & believes

The stakeholders have less in common

Greater variety in students (full-time and part-time)

Increasing complexity

Different strategies

How to create Engagement?

Question ….

• If all this is true …

What does it mean for the approach and strategy in phase 2?

What questions did we ask ourselves?

What did we do?

• What would you do?

• If all this is true …

What does it mean for the approach and strategy in phase 2?

What questions did we ask ourselves?

What did we do?

• What would you do?

What did we do?

• We organized a Community of Practice, supported by a community on Bb

• We made our own ideas on ePortfolios more explicit

• We made active use of our stakeholders (in different roles)

• We developed and used a new model (The Maastricht Model)

• But most of all:

• we used the Avans view on learning and teaching as our starting point

• we really tried to listen to our stakeholders

• we kept the Forgotten Questions in mind.

• We organized a Community of Practice, supported by a community on Bb

• We made our own ideas on ePortfolios more explicit

• We made active use of our stakeholders (in different roles)

• We developed and used a new model (The Maastricht Model)

• But most of all:

• we used the Avans view on learning and teaching as our starting point

• we really tried to listen to our stakeholders

• we kept the Forgotten Questions in mind.

The Maastricht Model

Based on:

Our own beliefs

The Model of Brussels

Our experiences so far and our expectations of the future

Based on:

Our own beliefs

The Model of Brussels

Our experiences so far and our expectations of the future

Assessment

Show Case

StudentStudent

Reflection

StaffStaff

Assessment

Show CaseShow Case

EACEAC

Assessment

Reflection

SchoolSchool

Show Case

School 1 -5

Phase 2a

AssessmentSchool 12

Reflection

Show Case

StudentStudent

School 13 -> 20

Assessment

Reflection

Show Case

StaffStaff

School 6 -11

School 1 -12

Phase 2b

School 14 -> 20

School 13

Reflection

Show Case

StudentStudent

Reflection

StaffStaff

Assessment Assessment

Show Case

Show Case

EACEAC

Assessment

Reflection

School 1 -14

Phase 3

School 17 -> 20

School 15

Assessment

Reflection

Show Case

StudentStudent

Reflection

StaffStaff

Assessment

Show CaseShow Case

EACEAC

Assessment

Reflection

SchoolSchool

Show Case

School 16+ +

The Pitfalls

Copying a ‘blueprint’ for implementation in order to:

Copy earlier successes

Trying to speed up the implementation process

Working with implicit ideas and not making them explicit (our own opinions and beliefs)

Not linking ePortfolio implementations to your view on Learning and Teaching

Making no use of our stakeholders

Expecting a model to have all the answers

Copying a ‘blueprint’ for implementation in order to:

Copy earlier successes

Trying to speed up the implementation process

Working with implicit ideas and not making them explicit (our own opinions and beliefs)

Not linking ePortfolio implementations to your view on Learning and Teaching

Making no use of our stakeholders

Expecting a model to have all the answers

Our Lessons Learned

It’s hard to overcome your own role as an expert.

Copy/paste actions or blueprints don’t work

Allow participants to create and live their own learning process and be patient

Keep an open mind in regard to the expected results

Keep involving students!

It’s hard to overcome your own role as an expert.

Copy/paste actions or blueprints don’t work

Allow participants to create and live their own learning process and be patient

Keep an open mind in regard to the expected results

Keep involving students!

Our Wishes and Challenges for the future

We have started our crusade, but we have no idea what (new) challenges we will have to deal with on our way. We are still facing a lot of (unknown) questions and challenges, such as:

How to achieve that the present Community of Practice will evolve into an active Community of Learners

Will we still be using Bb in a few years from now?

What impact will social software (web 2.0 / 3.0) really have?

How will we collaborate with new stakeholders?

Does the Model of Maastricht really help us?

We have started our crusade, but we have no idea what (new) challenges we will have to deal with on our way. We are still facing a lot of (unknown) questions and challenges, such as:

How to achieve that the present Community of Practice will evolve into an active Community of Learners

Will we still be using Bb in a few years from now?

What impact will social software (web 2.0 / 3.0) really have?

How will we collaborate with new stakeholders?

Does the Model of Maastricht really help us?

Still ….

•We have our maps, we have some of the necessary equipment, we have started the expedition and we are looking forward to new adventures

•We have our maps, we have some of the necessary equipment, we have started the expedition and we are looking forward to new adventures

Questions?Discussions?

Need to share ideas?

Eky Fioole: ey.fioole@avans.nlRudi Clause: rlth.clause@avans.nl

Eky Fioole: ey.fioole@avans.nlRudi Clause: rlth.clause@avans.nl

Community of Practice ePortfolio