information retrieval for hta 2nd part search strategies ......databases retrieval tools (or troops)...

22
Information Retrieval for HTA 2 nd part Planning Strategies for HTA Searching Bibl. Daniel Comandé [email protected]

Upload: others

Post on 28-Jul-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Information Retrieval for HTA

2nd part Planning Strategies for

HTA Searching

Bibl. Daniel Comandé [email protected]

Page 2: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Anatomy of HTA

1.- QUESTION

• IS BOTULINUM TOXINE USEFUL TO COMBAT MIGRAINES?

2.- TRANSLATION (Technology / Health Matters)

• Botulinum Toxine AND Migraines

3.- Search Strategy

• (Botulinum Toxine AND Migraines) AND Evidence Filters

Page 3: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Planning Search Strategies

Page 4: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Convergent Assault

Infantry

Cavalry & Siege

Machines

Page 5: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Components of HTA Search Strategy

HTA

Technology Terms

Health Subject Terms

Evidence Filters

Page 6: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Databases retrieval tools (or Troops)

Thesaurus Terms

Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT)

Truncation

Field and cross-field searching (title, abstract, title & abstract, etc.)

Phrase searching

Shared references

Page 7: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

In Example: “Induced Hypothermia in Brain

Ischemia Prevention in Newborns”

Induced Hypothermia

Brain Hypoxia Ischemia

Search Results

Page 8: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Technology Terms Construction (Induced Hypothermia MeSH)

Page 9: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Technology Terms Construction (Induced Hypothermia Entry Terms)

Page 10: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Induced Hypothermia simplification

(Hypothermia, Induced[Mesh] OR hypothermi*[tiab)

(Hypothermia, Induced[Mesh] OR Mild hypothermia[tiab] OR Moderate hypothermia[tiab] OR Induced hypothermia[tiab])

(Hypothermia, Induced[Mesh] OR hypothermia[tiab] OR Moderate hypothermia[tiab] OR Induced hypothermia[tiab])

(Hypothermia, Induced[Mesh] OR hypothermia[tiab])

(Hypothermia, Induced[Mesh] OR hypothermia[tiab])

Page 11: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Health Subject Terms Construction (Brain Hypoxia-Ischemia MeSH)

Hypoxia-Ischemia, Brain[Mesh]

Page 12: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Health Subject Terms Construction (Brain Hypoxia-Ischemia Entry terms)

Brain Hypoxia Hypoxia Ischemia

Ischemic Encephalopathy

Ischemic-Hypoxic

Cerebral Hypoxia

Page 13: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Brain Hypoxia-Ischemia simplification

(Hypoxia-Ischemia, Brain[Mesh] OR Brain Hypoxia Ischemia[tiab] OR Brain Hypoxia ischemia[tiab] OR Ischemic Hypoxic Encephalopathy[tiab] OR Cerebral Hypoxia Ischemia[tiab] OR Brain Hypoxia ischemia[tiab])

(Hypoxia-Ischemia, Brain[Mesh] OR Brain Hypoxia ischemia[tiab] OR Brain ischemia hypoxia[tiab] OR Ischemic Hypoxic Encephalopathy[tiab] OR Cerebral Hypoxia Ischemia[tiab] OR Brain Hypoxia ischemia[tiab])

(Hypoxia-Ischemia, Brain[Mesh] OR Brain Hypoxi*[tiab] OR Brain ischemi*[tiab] OR Ischemic Hypoxic[tiab] OR Hypoxic Encephalopath*[tiab] OR Cerebral Hypoxi*[tiab] OR Cerebral ischemi*[tiab] OR Ischemic Encephalopath*[tiab])

Page 14: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

(Hypothermia, Induced[Mesh] OR hypotherm*[tiab]) AND (Hypoxia-Ischemia, Brain[Mesh] OR Brain Hypoxi*[tiab] OR Brain ischemi*[tiab] OR Ischemic Hypoxic[tiab] OR Hypoxic Encephalopath*[tiab] OR Cerebral Hypoxi*[tiab] OR Cerebral ischemi*[tiab] OR Ischemic Encephalopath*[tiab])

Hypothermia, Induced[Mesh] OR

hypotherm*[tiab]

Hypoxia-Ischemia, Brain[Mesh] OR Brain Hypoxi*[tiab] OR Brain

ischemi*[tiab] OR Ischemic Hypoxic[tiab]

OR Hypoxic Encephalopath*[tiab]

OR Cerebral Hypoxi*[tiab] OR

Cerebral ischemi*[tiab] OR Ischemic

Encephalopath*[tiab]

Search Results

Page 15: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Thesaurus Term

Title & Abstract terms

Spelling

Other Terms (substances)

Other Terms (Trademarks)

Other Terms (Trials names)

The “wedge battle formation”

Page 16: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Evidence Filters (Limits)

Page 17: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Evidence providing studies

Randomized Controlled Clinical Trials

Practice Guidelines

Heath Technology Assessments

Meta-Analysis

Systematic Reviews

Page 18: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Observational Studies

Narrative Reviews

Case Series

Systematic Reviews

Practice Guidelines

Randomized Controlled Trials

Page 19: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

The “envolving pincer”

Limits reduces the “enemy”results

Page 20: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Without Limits

With Limits

Search with and without LIMITS

Page 21: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

The “enemy” sourrenders

Useful Evidence for HTA

Page 22: Information Retrieval for HTA 2nd part Search Strategies ......Databases retrieval tools (or Troops) Thesaurus Terms Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) Truncation Field and cross-field

Thank you for your attention Brigado!

Bibl. Daniel Comandé [email protected]