injury-2003-trauma care systems in belgium

Upload: everybodylies419

Post on 04-Jun-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    1/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 1 (version 11-06-2003)

    Trauma care in Belgium.

    Stefaan J.B. Nijs, MD and Paul L.O. Broos, MD, PhD, FRCS

    (Dpt. of Traumatology, U.Z. Gasthuisberg, K.U. Leuven)

    Corresponding author:

    Dr. Stefaan Nijs

    Dpt. Of Traumatology

    U.Z. Gasthuisberg

    Herestraat 49

    3000 Leuven (Belgium)

    Phone: +32 16 34 46 66

    Fax: +32 16 34 46 14

    e-mail: [email protected]

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    2/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 2 (version 11-06-2003)

    Geography and demography

    Belgium is situated in the west of Europe, bordered to the north by the

    Netherlands, to the east by Germany and the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg

    and to the south and the west by France. Although its surface area of 32,545

    km2makes it a small country, its location has made it the economic and

    urban nerve centre of Europe. "Belgium, heart of Europe" is not just a catch

    phrase: the geographical centre of the 15 countries of the European Union is

    actually located in Belgium and more precisely in Oignies-en-Thirache

    (Viroinval), in the province of Namur .[1]

    The Belgian state has a federal structure. The decision-making power in

    Belgium is no longer exclusively in the hands of the Federal Government

    and the Federal Parliament. Nowadays, the management of the country falls

    into several partners, which exercise their competences independently in

    different fields. The state is divided in three communities based on linguistic

    and cultural issues: the Flemish-, the French- and the German-speaking

    community. Furthermore, the country is divided in three regions on a more

    historical and economical base: the Flemish region, the Brussels capital

    region and the Walloon region. The federal state retains important areas of

    competence including: foreign affairs, defence, justice, finances, social

    security, important sectors of public health and domestic affairs, etc. The

    regions and communities are entitled to run foreign relations themselves in

    those areas where they have competence. The public health and social

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    3/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 3 (version 11-06-2003)

    security competence are not only shared by the federal and regional

    governments, but they are within each structure also shared by different

    ministries. This partition of competences in different persons and levels

    makes it often difficult to interact with the government.

    On 1st January 2001, Belgium had 10.263.414 inhabitants. This means a

    population density of 336 inhabitants/km2 which makes Belgium one of the

    most crowded countries of Europe. Flanders has 5.952.552 inhabitants (440

    inhabitants/km2), the Walloon Region 3.346.457 (198 inhabitants/km2) and

    the Brussels Capital Region 964.405 (5953 inhabitants/km2) [1]. These

    differences reflect on the development of the regions. Flanders is

    characterized by a spread of the population over the entire surface. Even in

    the more rural regions, the streets are bordered by houses, which are not

    concentrated in villages alone. This makes that there is a close interaction

    between traffic and living space over the entire surface. Wallonia has a more

    rural aspect. Its population lives more concentrated in towns and villages.

    On the other hand, it traditionally has the heavier industries, which are

    related to a relatively higher number of and more serious labour accidents.

    The Brussels Capital Region is a typical city region with a dense interaction

    between the living space and traffic at a lower speed, but also by relatively

    more criminality. This means that the need for trauma care is relatively

    different in the three regions.

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    4/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 4 (version 11-06-2003)

    Traditionally the French-speaking community is oriented on the French

    culture, the Flemish more on the Anglo-American and German culture. This

    is also reflected in the scientific - including the medical - world, where

    Flemish medicine is based on an Anglo-American and German (Central-

    European) and Walloon medicine on a French (Southern-European)

    tradition.

    Pre-hospital care

    Before 1956, there was no organized medical field support. The local doctor

    tried to give some support to the trauma victim. Although some local

    hospitals offered transportation using their own ambulances, the most often

    used means of transportation were taxis and private cars. In 1956, the first

    governmental organisation of medical transport was founded, creating the

    national rescue service for transportation of poliomyelitis patients. The

    law of 8th April 1958 obliged the municipalities to provide transportation to

    all persons in need of urgent medical care caused by accidents or illness on

    a public road or public space. A public space was defined as all places that

    cannot be considered as a private home [2].

    The same year, an investigation researching the needs and conditions to start

    up a national service for urgent medical support was initiated. The process

    was urged after some painful experiences, such as the disaster in the mari pit

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    5/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 5 (version 11-06-2003)

    Roosberg in Zichem-Zussen-Bolder. On 23rdDecember 1958, the pit

    collapsed and seventeen workers got isolated. It took a long time before any

    rescue operation was initiated, all workers died and only four corpses could

    be retrieved. The event was considered as a national disaster and the King

    and the minister of public health, Paul Meyers, did visit the area. On his way

    back to Brussels, the minister witnessed a serious accident in which a

    female pedestrian was hit by a car. Again, it took a long time before any

    rescue service reached the scene. Some sources mention that the Minister

    would have stated that such thing should not happen again and that he

    ordered his administration to give the development of a national service for

    urgent medical support highest priority [3].

    In 1959, the first help centre 900 became active in Antwerp. Nationwide,

    15 extra centres were installed between 1959 and 1963. It was recognized

    that the municipalities didnt have the possibilities to organise the urgent

    medical support and the transportation of injured and acute ill persons did

    become a task of the Department of Home Affairs starting from 1stJuly

    1965. A central telephone number, 900, could be used nationwide to

    activate the rescue system. In that way, one of sixteen help centres, located

    in fire stations and manned by firemen was reached. Although the 900

    help centres were legally only responsible for the evacuation of ill or injured

    persons on public spaces, they soon started giving support to all medical

    emergencies. In 1986, 50% of all interventions in the region of Hasselt were

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    6/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 6 (version 11-06-2003)

    interventions in private homes. Only in 1998, this situation was recognised

    in a changed law. Starting from 1st

    January 1998, all emergency

    interventions are legally the domain of the 100 intervention teams. In

    November 1987, the number 900 changed into the number 100 because

    of technical reasons. Beside the number 100, the European rescue

    number 112 is in use since 1996 [4].

    At the moment, 10 help centres 100 are active in Belgium, one per

    province. They are almost all localised in a fire station. This means that six

    of the initial sixteen centres have been closed in 1997. This has been an

    issue of intense debate and still is discussed by some officials. The

    Department of Home Affairs is - as already mentioned - responsible for the

    arrangement and the functioning of the help centres. The Ministry of Public

    Health and Environment is responsible for the organisation, the medical

    equipment and the teaching of the EMTs (Emergency Medical Trainee).

    All calls to the 100 or 112 centres are recorded on tape, mentioning

    hour and date. All the 100 centres are connected and deal with the calls

    making an intervention of the fire-brigade, EMTs and the Civil Protection

    necessary. They are also a pivot in the provincial disaster management

    planning. When one calls the 100, the telephone operator will send all

    necessary help to the scene: EMTs, MUG (Mobile Emergency Team), fire

    brigade, . The help centre will also inform the police over a direct line

    when estimated necessary. Operators are firemen, most of them lacking a

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    7/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 7 (version 11-06-2003)

    specific training. They use a standard protocol gathering the necessary

    information [5].

    In case of accident or illness, the operator can send an ambulance with at

    least a driver and an helper on board. Both are trained EMTs. This means

    they need to have a basic EMT training (120 hours, of which 18 hours

    dedicated to the treatment of the injured patient) and to follow additional

    trainings (24 hours/year) in recognised provincial training centres on a

    regular base. Every five year, the EMT has to prove his theoretical and

    practical skills in a test. Law has defined the external characteristics of the

    ambulance. The equipment is not defined, because the European Standard

    for Medical vehicles and their equipment which was introduced in 2000

    got no legal character yet. Until recently, the Ministry of Public Health

    provided the different 100 services with ambulances. This policy has been

    abandoned because of budgetary reasons. Now, every 100 service has to

    buy its own ambulances, according to its financial possibilities. Ambulances

    are managed and manned by hospitals, private enterprises, the Red Cross

    and in the first place by the fire brigades. Both professionals and volunteers

    man the ambulances. In Brussels, an ambulance and MUG team of the army

    intervene in those cases where severe burns are expected since the burn unit

    is located in the military hospital [6].

    In those cases where the operator expects that urgent medical support is

    needed, he can send a doctor at the scene. The operator has the right to send

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    8/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 8 (version 11-06-2003)

    no matter what physician at the scene to provide first medical support, but

    he will preferentially send one of the recognized MUGs (mobile emergency

    team). These MUG teams are linked to a recognized emergency department

    of a hospital [7]. It consists at least of an in emergency medicine trained

    medical doctor and a trained (male) nurse. Apart from criteria for the

    external characteristics, the equipment is also legally defined. The mission

    of these MUG services was designated by the Order in Council of 10 th April

    1995 stating: the MUG is a hospital function, the aim of a MUG is the

    reduction of the therapy free interval by going at the scene on the demand of

    the 100 operator, the execution of all necessary medical and nursing care at

    the scene and the supervision during hospital transport [8]. The function of

    the MUG is further organised according to the Order in Council of 10th

    August 1998 stating that the recognition of a MUG service can only be

    awarded to an hospital with a recognised specialized emergency department

    [9]. The medical head of the department must be a medical specialist in

    emergency medicine. To becomea medical specialist in emergency

    medicine, one must follow an additional training of 2 years after a

    successfully completed training in internal medicine, anaesthesia or surgery.

    The head nurse responsible for the nursing tasks must have a postgraduate

    training in emergency and intensive care medicine. The medical doctor

    leading an intervention must be a medical specialist in emergency medicine,

    a specialist in training to become specialist in the emergency medicine or at

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    9/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 9 (version 11-06-2003)

    least to have obtained the certificate acute medicine. This is an additional

    training consisting of a theoretical training of 120 hours and a practical on-

    site training of 240 hours, including at least 10 potentially life saving pre-

    hospital interventions.(Ministerial Council of 12th November 1993). The

    nurse must have a postgraduate training in emergency and intensive care

    nursing or have at least five years of experience (gained before 1998) in an

    emergency department. The personnel in active MUG service should be

    immediately available and although they may have active duties in the

    emergency department they should immediately be replaceable in these

    duties by equally trained personnel. At the moment, 79 MUG services are

    active. According to the programmation legacy, this number should be

    reduced to 72, but the current minister of Public Health declared he couldnt

    accept this reduction and wanted to augment the number to 81 [10]. The

    programmation of MUG services according to the Order in Council of 10th

    August 1998 foresees 1 MUG per administrational district and an additional

    1 per 150.000 citizen.

    According to the Order in Council of 10th August 1998, the victim has to be

    transported to the nearest hospital with a recognized emergency department

    [9]. The medical doctor of the MUG can ask the 100 operator to make an

    exception on this rule in case of:

    1. a disaster leading to an overwhelming of the caring capacities of thenearest hospital.

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    10/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 10 (version 11-06-2003)

    2. when the victim or ill is - because of his/her medical condition - inneed of specific diagnostic and/or therapeutic means as mentioned in

    the protocol (article 4, 6, Order in Council 10th August 1998)

    3. when the treating physician, present by the ill, confirms that the illhas a medical record concerning the specific pathology of which

    he/she actually suffers, in a hospital of the intervention region and

    this hospital has a recognised emergency department.

    This exception should be granted by the 100 operator according to the

    protocol and according to the available means [11]. The nearest hospital is

    meant in time as stated in the Order of Council of 08 th July 1999. The

    protocols mentioned have to be drawn up by the provincial commissions on

    urgent medical help. These commissions were founded in 2000 and started

    functioning in 2001. The form HA 01 of the provincial commission for

    emergency medical help in the province of Antwerp which is in use since

    05thNovember 2001 mentions as reasons for exception: CO-intoxication,

    Neurosurgery, Invasive Cardiology, Burns, Obstetrics and Paediatrics[12].

    Notice that neither polytrauma nor any other trauma related causes (except

    neurosurgery) are mentioned in the list! The physician of the MUG service

    does not have to use this form and can ask for further exceptions.

    A function specialised emergency department was created by the order of

    Council of 27th April 1998 [13]. In this order, a number of structural,

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    11/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 11 (version 11-06-2003)

    functional and organisational requirements are listed. One of the aims was

    to limit the number of recognised - and thus in the 100-system functioning -

    emergency departments. This should lead to improved care by concentrating

    patients, experience and means, and should economize because of the same

    reasons. Discussing the structural and functional requirements goes beyond

    the scope of this article. Mentionable are the necessity of an ICU-unit of at

    least 3 beds, a polyvalent operation theatre, a radiography department and

    clinical biology. The head of the department should be, as for the MUG

    function, a medical specialist in emergency medicine. Both functions (head

    of the specialized emergency department and head of the MUG) can be

    gathered in one person. A specialist in emergency medicine, a trainee in

    emergency medicine or a physician having obtained the certificate acute

    medicine should secure the medical supervision of the department 24 hours

    a day. The physician supervising the function specialised emergency care

    cannot supervise any other function at the same time with the exception of

    the supervision of the MUG, when he can be replaced by a physician on

    call, having the same qualifications, within 15 minutes after leaving the

    emergency department. As long as this physician on call does not replace

    him, the physician supervising the ICU should replace him. The supervision

    should be guaranteed 24 hours a day. The supervising physician should

    always be able to call a physician in one of the listed specialities:

    internal medicine

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    12/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 12 (version 11-06-2003)

    surgery

    anaesthesiology

    radiology paediatrics orthopaedic surgery gynaecology obstetrics otorhinolaryngeology

    ophthalmology

    psychiatry neurology

    The physicians mentioned in this list should be available on call. It is

    nowhere mentioned that they should be only on call for one hospital! In the

    praxis, they often are on call for more than one emergency department.

    Concerning the nursing staff, it is stipulated that the head nurse should have

    a postgraduate training in emergency and intensive care nursing or should

    be head of the emergency nursing staff for more than five years. Every

    moment, at least two nurses should be present, one of them having a

    postgraduate training in the emergency and intensive care nursing or having

    an experience of at least 5 years in one of these departments on the moment

    of the Order in Council. Although it was the aim to limit the number of

    specialised emergency departments to 70 100 departments nationwide,

    actually 148 departments got recognised.

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    13/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 13 (version 11-06-2003)

    Intra-hospital care

    Apart from the above-mentioned recognition criteria for the specialized

    emergency department no legislation whatever on intra-hospital triage,

    treatment and/or inter-hospital transfer of the injured exists. It is left to the

    sole judgement of the physician what he should or should not treat.

    Concerning this judgement, one should notice the fact that the Belgian

    medical rewarding system is strictly act-related and that the technical act is

    rewarded far more than the intellectual one .

    No specific trauma-surgery is legally recognised or protected. In most

    hospitals an ad hoc formatted group of physicians treats the injured. The

    formation of this group passes too often ad random or at least unstructured.

    Only some hospitals have a specific trauma surgery unit or a trauma team.

    Even a structural trauma protocol fails to exist in most hospitals.

    After the hospital stay, specific revalidation possibilities are scarce. Some

    hospitals do have a specific revalidation unit, but in this unit cardio

    revalidation, stroke revalidation, orthopaedic and trauma revalidation all get

    mixed. The therapy is guided depending on the available place and the

    interests of the leading physicians and physiotherapists.

    Results

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    14/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 14 (version 11-06-2003)

    Only partial information on incidence, treatment and outcome of trauma in

    Belgium is available. The best source of information are the statistics of the

    Belgian Institute of Traffic Safety (BIVV) [14]. Data on home, work and

    sports related trauma are completely lacking. No national trauma

    registration exists. Medical insurance information is distributed over a lot of

    participants and not available for research.

    Traffic related mortality in Belgium is high. During the year 2000, 1470

    people died on the Belgian roads. This averages 4 a day! It means that

    13.9/100000 citizens/year die on the road. When we compare this to our

    neighbouring countries Belgium scores badly (table 1). When we look at the

    trend since 1972 (last year before the global energy crisis and important

    safety measures), we see that the number of deaths halves although the

    number of vehicles doubles and the number of vehicle-kilometres almost

    triples.(table 2) Important measures in the reduction of trauma deaths were

    the safety belt obligation, speed reduction, alcohol testing, airbags, EBS, car

    safety improvement and structural traffic changes resulting in speed

    reduction. Intense sensitisation campaigns (fig. 1) have made the public

    aware of the problem of traffic related trauma and may have contributed to

    the reduction of traffic related mortality and morbidity. Recently, the

    government made the reduction of traffic related mortality and morbidity

    one of its main topics. They want to increase traffic control and - by

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    15/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 15 (version 11-06-2003)

    augmenting the detecting chance and the penalties - reduce the driver

    induced traffic risks.

    The lack of drivers responsibility is one of the main causes of traffic related

    mortality and morbidity. In 4168 out of 49065 accidents (i.e. 8.5%) in 2000,

    ethanol intoxication was one of the contributing factors. When we look at

    the accidents with at least one fatality or severely injured victim, we see that

    in 949 out of 9346 (i.e. 10.2%) accident ethanol intoxication in one of the

    drivers was recorded. Ethanol intoxication as a cause of an accident causing

    fatality or severe injuries is time dependent. On week days it is only

    recorded in 5.1%, on weekend days in 10.8%, on week nights in 18.5% and

    on weekend nights even in 23.8%. These figures underestimate the situation

    as in many fatal accidents no blood probe could be obtained. Apart from

    ethanol intoxication, narcotic drug abuse plays an increasingly important

    part in traffic accidents [15]. Surprisingly, the highest percentages of

    ethanol intoxications in fatality or severely injury related accidents are not

    seen in the younger age groups, but in the group 30-39 years. Even the

    group 50-59 years scores as high as the group 25-29 years and higher than

    in the group 18-25 years.(table 3)

    Speeding with secondary loss of control is the cause of 642 out of 1356 (i.e.

    47.3%) fatality related accidents in which the cause could be detected. Not

    giving priority is the second most frequent cause in 16.8% of cases [14].

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    16/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 16 (version 11-06-2003)

    Looking at the ascertained traffic infractions, we notice that speeding leads

    with 346501 infractions followed by parking infractions (32236), not

    wearing the safety belt (42033 infractions), ethanol intoxication (15030

    infractions), neglecting traffic lights (14059 infractions) [14].

    Discussion

    Looking at the available data, one could be pleased with the Belgian

    situation. Although the number of driven kilometres almost tripled since

    1972, the number of traffic deaths halved. Of course this is not a bad

    statistic. When looking over the borders of our country, statistics are

    however not so positive anymore. In the year 1999, traffic related mortality

    was 13.7 deaths pro 100000 citizens. Looking at our neighbours Germany

    scored 9.5/100000, the Netherlands 6.9, Luxembourg 13.7 and France 14.4

    [14].

    Of course progression is made due to structural changes on car safety

    (safety belt obligation, car safety, ABS, air bags, ) and on speed reducing-

    safety augmenting structural changes (traffic islands, refuges, rotundas, ).

    The influence of organisation of the pre-hospital care cannot be detected in

    the available data yet.

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    17/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 17 (version 11-06-2003)

    However, one cannot neglect the fact that reducing traffic related mortality

    and morbidity has to be based on three pillars: reducing the accident risk,

    reducing the impact forces and amelioration of the care for the victim.

    Reducing the accident risk can be accomplished by sensitisation of the

    driver resulting in decreased risk-behaviour. Beside this sensitisation one

    should implement structural changes making traffic safer for all participants

    (traffic islands, separated biking roads, rotundas, ) and augment

    repression by intense controlling. This is in the first place a governmental

    duty. Structural changes reducing impact forces and protection of all

    participants in traffic are an industrial challenge. The medical part of the

    challenge is to improve the care for the injured. A well-organised pre-

    hospital care is crucial in this care for the injured. Although the initial goals

    of structural organisation could not be reached, whether or not influenced by

    lobbying groups, Belgium has a fairly good organisation of the pre-hospital

    care. A slight reduction of the recognised emergency departments could

    reduce costs and improve the experience through a broader exposure.

    The problem of trauma care in Belgium is the total lack of coordinated intra-

    hospital care. Too often ad hoc organisation, leading to unclear procedures

    and loss of crucial time, has to be established. Many reports from all over

    the world have documented the reduction in overall mortality, preventable

    death and morbidity after installation of a regionalized and well-organized

    trauma system [21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26]. Unpublished data demonstrate the

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    18/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 18 (version 11-06-2003)

    fact that trauma care in Belgium can also reach high standards of care for

    the injured if in the setting of an organised Trauma Team, where trauma

    dedicated surgeons work together with specialists in the emergency

    medicine, intensive care and revalidation [16]. Standards comparable to

    those reached in the centres participating in the American and British

    MTOS (Major Trauma Outcome Study) studies [17, 18] and those reported

    by the German DGU (Deutsche Gesellschaft fr Unfallchirurgie) [19].

    Although trauma is the third leading cause of death after malignancies and

    arteriosclerosis and even the leading cause of death in the population under

    40 years of age, it remains the neglected disease [20]. Beside its high

    mortality, it is responsible for a whether or not permanent loss of function in

    an immense group of patients. Adequate trauma care can - as demonstrated

    by many other countries - lead to a decrease in mortality and improved

    outcome. It is no longer acceptable that inappropriate trauma care is

    established because of lacking experience and/or means, because of

    financial reasons (a too large spread of the offered pathology) or because of

    a lack of interest for those institutions where all means are available (lack of

    fashionable).

    When the Belgian politicians want to halve mortality due to traffic accidents

    by 2010, as they stated, Im afraid that sensitisation, repression, structural

    changes and safer cars alone will come short. The implementation of a well-

    organized trauma system, starting from excellent pre- hospital care and

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    19/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 19 (version 11-06-2003)

    ending in excellent revalidation facilities, should be an integral part of this

    policy. The coordination of such teams cannot be born in amateurism or ad

    hoc interest, but should be supported by well-trained, experienced trauma

    specialists (surgeons) working in close relation to the other intra-mural

    cooperates (emergency specialists, ICU (Intensive Care Unit) specialists,

    revalidation physicians, neurosurgeons, ) and to each other in a

    regionalised and echelonised trauma system.

    In my opinion, we should come to a European standard for trauma care,

    where every inhabitant of the European community can get the same well-

    organised care based on the best available experience within the community.

    Mortality should no longer range between 21.1/100000/year (as in Portugal)

    and 6.0/100000/year (as in the UK).

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    20/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 20 (version 11-06-2003)

    Table 1: Evolution of the traffic related mortality/morbidity.

    Year Deaths

    30 days

    Deaths 30 days +

    severely injured

    Victims (deaths 30

    days + injured)

    Motor vehicles (on

    1st

    August)

    Vehicle Kilometres (in

    milliard)

    1972

    1975

    1980

    1985

    1990

    1995

    2000

    3.101

    2.346

    2.396

    1.801

    1.976

    1.449

    1.470

    26.711

    21.735

    22.325

    18.533

    19.455

    14.166

    11.317

    106.538

    84.478

    84.700

    76.315

    88.160

    71.754

    69.431

    2.732.677

    3.136.909

    3.753.745

    3.970.866

    4.594.058

    5.136.342

    5.735.034

    32,69

    38,01

    47,96

    53,64

    70,28

    80,26

    90,04

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    21/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 21 (version 11-06-2003)

    Table 2: Traffic related mortality in Europe (1999)

    Country Number of deaths per 100.000 inhabitants

    Belgium

    Germany

    France

    Luxembourg

    The Netherlands

    United Kingdom

    13.7

    9.5

    14.4

    13.5

    6.9

    6.0

    Source: IRTAD-International Road Traffic and Accident Database (OECD)

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    22/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 22 (version 11-06-2003)

    Table 3: Alcohol intoxication in accidents with deaths/severely injured.

    Age Number of drivers

    involved

    Number of drivers

    involved under the

    influence of alcohol

    %

    18-24

    25-29

    30-39

    40-49

    50-59

    60-69

    70+

    2.287

    1.453

    2.337

    1.676

    987

    597

    537

    170

    118

    216

    145

    79

    22

    12

    7,4

    8,1

    9,2

    8,7

    8,0

    3,7

    2,2

    Total 10.204 787 7,7

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    23/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 23 (version 11-06-2003)

    Figures

    Fig. 1: Example of a sensitisation campaign.

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    24/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 24 (version 11-06-2003)

    References

    1. www.fgov.be2. http://members.tripod.com/Brandweer_Lommel/klini/klini01.html3. http://limburg.kbbf.be/links/100/hc100_geschiedenis01.htm4. Survey on implementation of 112, document of the European

    Commission, dated 06th January 1999.

    5. http://www.brandweer.org/ambulance/achtergronden/belg_she.html6. Handboek voor de hulpverlener-ambulancier van het Ministerie van

    Sociale Zaken, Volksgezondheid en Leefmilieu, Bestuur van de

    Gezondheidszorgen-Dienst Geneeskundige Hulp aan de

    Burgerbevolking

    7. http://www.emerbel.org/brevet/documenten/Bronselaer K.-WetgevingDMH-.pdf

    8. Belgian Law Gazette, 10th May 19959. Belgian Law Gazette, 2ndSeptember 199810.http://www.agalev.be/code/nl/page.cfm?id_page=193811.http://www.vhp.be/uhak/dmh01.htm12.http://www.vhp.be/uhak/dmhha01.htm

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    25/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 25 (version 11-06-2003)

    13.Belgian Law Gazette 19th June 199814.Jaarverslag 2000 Verkeersveiligheid, Belgisch Instituut voor

    Verkeersveiligheid (BIVV).

    15.Belgian Toxicology and Trauma Study (BTTS): a study by theBelgian Society of Emergency and Disaster Medicine (BeSEDiM),

    the Toxicological Society of Belgium and Luxemburg (BLT) and the

    Belgisch Instituut voor de Verkeersveiligheid (BIVV), 1995-1996.

    16.Van Camp LA, Vanderschot PMJ, Sabbe MB et al. The effect ofhelmets on the incidence and severity of head and cervical spine

    injuries in victims of motorcycle and moped accidents: a prospective

    analysis based on Emergency Department and Trauma Surgery data.

    Eur J Emer Med 1998; 5(2):269-271.

    17.Champion HR, Copes WS, Sacco WJ et al. The Major TraumaOutcome Study: establishing national norms for trauma care. J

    Trauma. 1990 Nov;30(11): 1356-65.

    18.Crawford R. Trauma audit: experience in north-east Scotland.Br J Surg. 1991 Nov; 78(11): 1362-6.

    19.Yates DW, Woodford M, Hollis S. Preliminary analysis of the careof injured patients in 33 British hospitals: first report of the United

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    26/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 26 (version 11-06-2003)

    Kingdom major trauma outcome study. BMJ. 1992 Sep 26; 305

    (6856): 737-40.

    20.Rixen D, Raum M, Bouillon B et al. Predicting the outcome insevere injuries: an analysis of 2069 patients from the trauma register

    of the German Society of Traumatology (DGU)] Unfallchirurg. 2001

    Mar; 104(3): 230-9.

    21.http://www.wvc.vlaanderen.be/gezondheidsindicatoren/22.Mullins RJ, Mann NC. Population-based research assessing the

    effectiveness of trauma systems. J.Trauma.1999; 47: S59-S66

    23.Mann NC, Mullins RJ, MacKenzie EJ, Jurkovich GJ, Mock CN .Systematic review of published evidence regarding trauma system

    effectiveness. J.Trauma.1999; 47: S25-S33.

    24.MacKenzie EJ. Reviw of evidence regarding trauma systemeffectiveness resulting from panel studies. J.Trauma. 1999; 47: 34-

    41.

    25.Jurkovich GJ, MockC. Systematic review of trauma systemeffectiveness based on registry comparisons J.Trauma.1999; 47:

    S46-S55.

  • 8/13/2019 Injury-2003-Trauma Care Systems in Belgium

    27/27

    Trauma care in Belgium 27 (version 11-06-2003)

    26.Jurkovich GJ, Mock C. Systematic review of trauma systemeffectiveness based on registry comparisons. J.Trauma

    .

    1999; 47:

    S46-S55.