inside the jobs act_ equity crowdfunding - forbes
DESCRIPTION
ForbesTRANSCRIPT
-
5/23/2015 InsideTheJOBSAct:EquityCrowdfundingForbes
http://www.forbes.com/sites/tanyaprive/2012/11/06/insidethejobsactequitycrowdfunding2/print/ 1/5
http://onforb.es/PUssBJ
ENTREPRENEURS 11/06/2012@11:57AM 37,517views
InsideTheJOBSAct:EquityCrowdfunding
CommentNow
Inthespringof2012,PresidentObamapassedanactthatwilldrasticallyalterthelandscapeofcrowdfundingplatforms.UntilApril5,2012,asmallpoolofexistingcrowdfundingsiteswereonlypermittedtooperateonarewardordonationbasis,essentiallyofferingaproduct,discount,orenticementinexchangeformonetaryfunding.WiththelaunchoftheJOBSAct,shortforJumpstartOurBusinessStartups,theabilityforthegeneralpublictoreceivecompanyequityinexchangeforfundingisnowapossibility.
Asoftoday,theSecuritiesActof1933statesthatentitiescannotofferorsellsecuritiestothepublicunless(a)theofferingisregisteredwiththeSEC,or(b)thereisanavailableexemptionfromregistration.Unfortunately,thecrowdfundingexemptionintroducedunderthetittleIIIoftheJOBSActunderSection4(a)(6)oftheSecuritiesActwontbeavailableuntiltheSECissuesitsregulations.
Theissueisentrepreneursfinditverydifficulttoaccessfinancing.Notonlybecausetheirbusinessplansarerejected98%ofthetimebyVentureCapitalswhentheycanmanagetogetanintroduction,butalsobecauseU.S.banksaccordingtotheSmallBusinessAdministration,held$607billioninoutstandingbusinessloansof$1millionorlessduring2011,whichsurprisinglyenough,represents$100billionlessthanin2008.Withthecurrentstateoftherecessionandtherisingnumbersofunemployment,crowdfundingcouldbeagreatassettoourcountryseconomy.Theseportalscouldserveasagreatvehicleforinvestinginsmallbusinesses,whichareaccountableforcreating65%ofthenetnewjobsoverthepast17years.AstheCoFounderofOnevest,theleadingequitycrowdfundingplatformforentrepreneursandsmallbusinesses,Ihaveseenjusthoweffectivethepowerofthecrowdis.
Crowdfundingisessentiallyatoolthatgivesentrepreneurstheopportunitytoattractapoolofpeopleviasocialmediaorsharedinterestsinordertocontributetoafundingtargetthathasbeenpreviouslyestablishedbythe
TanyaPriveContributor
Icoverfundingentrepreneurialventurefromacrowdfundingangle.OpinionsexpressedbyForbesContributorsaretheirown.
-
5/23/2015 InsideTheJOBSAct:EquityCrowdfundingForbes
http://www.forbes.com/sites/tanyaprive/2012/11/06/insidethejobsactequitycrowdfunding2/print/ 2/5
entrepreneur.
Datafrommassolutionresearchindicatesthattotalfundsviatherewardanddonationbasedcrowdfundingaregrowingatarateof524percent,whereplatformsraisedalmost$1.5billion,fundingoveronemillionprojectsin2011.
Withtheadditionofequityasapotentialoptionwithinthecrowdfundingspace,thespotlightoncrowdfundinghasincreasedsubstantially.BusinesssavvyindividualscannowdreamofbeingoneofthefirstseedinvestorsinthenextFacebook,Airbnb,orDropbox.
CrowdfundingCapitalAdvisors,acrowdfundindustryconsultancyfirmwillbereleasingareportinSeptember2013thatshowsthedebtandequitycrowdfundingspacetobeatleast$4.3billioninitsfirstyearofoperation.
Asitalwayshappensinlife,therearepeoplewhoarecontrarytoitsimplementationastheythinkthatequitybasedcrowdfundingisveryriskyfortheaverageAmerican.Onthisnote,IwouldliketomentionthefactthatAmericanspurchase$45billiondollarsworthoflotteryticketseveryyear,withtheaveragehouseholdspending$150annually.Theoddsofwinningthelotteryareonein175millionaccordingtoAaronAbrams,amathematicianatEmoryUniversity.Thestockmarketoddsmightbeabitbrighter.However,totalassetsinvestedinstocks,bonds,mutualfunds,pensionfundsandinsurancefundsequal$30trillionaccordingtotheeconomistMichaelShuman.Forboth,lotteryandstockmarketshavenolimits,anyindividualcouldspendallthemoneytheywantandofcourselose
it.
Ontheotherhand,equitycrowdfundingcomeswithlimits,asthelawpermitsinvestmentsto5percentforindividualswithannualincomeoflessthan$100,000and10percentforthosewhomakeover$100,000.
Sothebigquestionis,whydomostcrowdfundingsitesstillnotofferequityasanoptionyet?NowthattheJOBSActhaspassed,theUSSecuritiesExchangeCommission(SEC)hasbeeninstructedbyCongresstostepinandmonitorthenewchangesbeforetheActcantakeeffectforequitycrowdfunding(regulationsareexpectedonorbeforeJanuary2013).TheSECexiststoregulatefinancialFederallaws,andprotectthepublicfrompotentialfiscalmisuseregardingtheselaws.
-
5/23/2015 InsideTheJOBSAct:EquityCrowdfundingForbes
http://www.forbes.com/sites/tanyaprive/2012/11/06/insidethejobsactequitycrowdfunding2/print/ 3/5
Inorderforthegeneralpublictofeelprotectedwhileinvestinginsmallbusinesses,theSECisworkingoncreatingastructuretosafeguardthesenewallowances.Whiledeliberatingthenumerousissuesinvolved,theSECcreatedanonlineforumtoreceivecommentsfromthepublicandaidintheirdecision.Untiltheyfinessethesechanges,crowdfundingplatformswillnotlegallybeabletoexistasequitybasedmodelswithoutoperatingunderthelicenseofabrokerdealer.
EventhoughtheSEChasadeadlineestablishedonJanuary2013,therearefearsconcerningdelaysonthedeliveryoftheregulations.Agoodexampleofthetypeofdelaysfundingportalscouldbefacing,couldperfectlybetheDoddFrankAct,whichbecamethelawinJuly21,2010.ItwasscheduletobeenforcenolaterthanApril15,2011.However,afterayearofitsdeadlinetheenforcementisnowheretobeseen.Note,thattheSECstaffhavesaidpubliclyinanumberofforumsthatJOBSActrulesaretakingprecedenceoverDoddFrankrules.
Forequitycrowdfundingtooperateproperly,fundingportalswillnotonlyneedregulationsinplace,butalsotheappointmentofaselfregulatoryorganizationorSRO.ThisSROismostlikelytobeFINRAasthelasttimeanSROwasintroducedinthemarketwasbackinthe1930s.Thisorganizationwillbeaccountableforoverseeingtheregulationoftheequitycrowdfundingindustry.Unfortunately,FINRAisprivatelyrunwheretheyreceiveannualduesfrombrokersandfirmsinthefinancialindustry.Thisfactcouldextendthedelaysevenfurther.
AgoodstepforwardwasSECsproposalonAugust2012toendtheprohibitionagainstgeneralsolicitationandadvertisementonstartupsandinvestmentfundsunderRules506and144Aofferings.Withthisproposal,essentiallysellerswouldnotberestrictedwhenadvertisinganoffering.Withoutadoubt,socialmediaisakeyelementbehindthesuccessofcrowdfundingandifprojectcreatorsarenotabletotelltheworldaboutitviathesenetworkstheirfundraisingeffortswillmostlikelysuffertosomedegree.
AninterestingfactstatedontheproposedSECRuleseliminatingbanongeneralsolicitationof506offerings,isthatin2011theestimatedamountofcapital(includingbothequityanddebt)raisedinRule506offeringsandRule144Aofferingswas$895billionand$168billioncomparedto$984billionraisedinregisteredofferings.In2010,theamountofcapital(includingbothequityanddebt)raisedinRule506offeringsandRule144Aofferingswas$902billionand$233billion,comparedto$1.07trillionraisedinregisteredofferings.
-
5/23/2015 InsideTheJOBSAct:EquityCrowdfundingForbes
http://www.forbes.com/sites/tanyaprive/2012/11/06/insidethejobsactequitycrowdfunding2/print/ 4/5
Onanothernote,itissurprisinghowtheU.S.startupsfinditsodifficulttoraisemoneyduringtheinitialstageoftheirbusinesswhereonlyaccreditedinvestorsandotherinstitutionalinvestors,representing1%oftheUSpopulation,aretheonlycrowdallowedtoparticipate.IntheUKforexample,notonlyequitycrowdfundingislegal,butalsoundertheEnterpriseInvestmentSchemeanyoneinvestingbetween500and1minaqualifyingbusinesscouldbeeligibleforincometaxrelief,worth30percentoftheamountinvested.
Toconclude,IhavetosaythatIamabigfanofinvestorprotection.However,Idofearthattoomanyrequirementsmaykilltheattractivenessofstartupinvesting.Asthetitle3(concerningcrowdfunding)oftheJOBSActstates,companiesseekingequitycrowdfundingshouldalreadythinkpriortotheirfundraisingeffortsthroughafundingportalaboutfilingwiththeSECandallpotentialinvestordocumentationthatwillinclude:
Registrationandincorporationdocuments.
Nameofdirectors,officerandstockholders.
Descriptionofthebusiness.
Prioryeartaxreturns.
Financialstatements.
Intendeduseofproceeds,targetamountanddeadline.
Shareprice.
Descriptionoftheownership.
Outstandingsecuritiesofthecompany.
-
5/23/2015 InsideTheJOBSAct:EquityCrowdfundingForbes
http://www.forbes.com/sites/tanyaprive/2012/11/06/insidethejobsactequitycrowdfunding2/print/ 5/5
Thisarticleisavailableonlineat:http://onforb.es/PUssBJ 2015Forbes.comLLCAllRightsReserved
Inadditiontothis,intheeventthecompanyisraisingover$500,000itwillneedtheirfinancialstatementstobeaudited,whichcouldbeacostlyprocess.
Fundingportalswillalsobeinvitedtopasscertainrequirements.SomeofthesemightberegistrationfeesorfortheportalmanagementteamtoholdwhateverexamFINRAorotherSROmayrequire.WordonthestreetisthattheremightbeeitheraspecialexamforportaloperatorsorforthemtopasstheexistingSeries7,63,64,66or79.HoldersoftheseexamsmayalsoneedtobesupervisedbyatleastoneholderofaSeries24andanotherwithSeries28.
Whilethefutureofequitybasedcrowdfundingisstillundetermined,enthusiasticentrepreneursandinvestorswaitwithbaitedbreathfortheSECsfinalverdict.Eitherway,thefaceofsmallbusinessinvestingwillbedrasticallyalteredastheJOBSActbeginstotakeeffect.