instrumental city_ the view from hudson yards
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
1/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/
S H A N N O N M A T T E R N A P R I L 2 0 1 6
I n s t r u m e n t a l C i t y : T h e V i e w f r o m H u d s o n Y a r d s ,
c i r c a 2 0 1 9
The worlds most ambitious smart city project is here.
Should we worry that New York City is becoming an
experimental lab?
The first tower at Hudson Yards opens in May 2016, with Alphabets Sidewalk Labs as a premier
tenant. View east from the High Line across the West Rail Yard, Manhattan. [Shannon
https://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-3.jpghttps://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-3.jpghttps://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-3.jpghttps://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-3.jpghttps://placesjournal.org/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
2/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 2
Mattern]
The observation deckwont be finished for a few years yet. If you want to
see the future of New York, walk north along the High Line, round the
curve at the rail yards, and turn your back to the river. Amid the highway
ramps and industrial hash of far-west Manhattan, a herd of cranes hoists
I-beams into the sky. This is Hudson Yards, the largest private real-estate
development in United States history and the test ground for the worlds
most ambitious experiment in smart city urbanism.
H u d s o n Y a r d s w i l l b e t h e n a t i o n s f i r s t q u a n t i f i e d
c o m m u n i t y , a t e s t i n g g r o u n d f o r a p p l i e d u r b a n d a t a
s c i e n c e .
Over the next decade, the $20-billion project spanning seven blocks
from 30th to 34th Street, between 10th and 12th Avenues will add 17
million square feet of commercial, residential, and civic space, much of it
housed in signature architecture by the likes of Skidmore, Owings &
Merrill; Diller Scofidio + Renfro; and Bjarke Ingels Group. But you dont
have to wait that long to see where this is headed. The first office tower,
Kohn Pedersen Foxs 10 Hudson Yards, opens next month, with directaccess to the High Line. The new subway stop is already in business (and
has already sprung a few leaks); an extension of the 7 train line connects
the diverse, middle-class neighborhood of Flushing, Queens, with this
emerging island of oligarchs.
Its a major transformation for the grim streetscape of the Far West Side. A
decade ago, The New YorkersJohn Cassidy described the neighborhoods
notable architectural features:
The Port Authority Bus Terminal, the entrance to the Lincoln Tunnel,
the cavernous Jacob K. Javits Convention Center, which blocks access
to the river and the Manhattan tow pound. The M.T.A. rail yard,
which is hidden behind concrete walls. a Greyhound-bus parking
depot, a Sanitation Department refueling station, and several vacant
lots.
1
2
3
http://www.kpf.com/projects/10-30-hudson-yardshttp://ny.curbed.com/2015/8/14/9930774/see-hudson-yards-towering-open-air-observation-deck -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
3/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 3
The terminals and tunnels and tracks are still there, but now someone has
flipped a switch, and a whole new section of the city is coming online.
(Stick with me for a few thousand words, and youll understand thats not
a metaphor.) New Yorkers havent seen anything like this since the
construction of Rockefeller Center transformed Midtown in the 1930s.
Hudson Yards is even more impressive, as it rises atop two massive steel-
and-concrete platforms that span a working rail yard. [PDF]
Its also rising on a bed of data. Reports say it will be the nations first
quantified community, a fully instrumented testing ground for
applied urban data science. If youve read my work forPlaces, you know
Im not about to let that claim pass unnoticed. To understand what
Hudson Yards portends for smart citiesand smart urban citizens around
the world, it is crucial that we examine the ground on which this
experiment is taking place the people and powers that converge here,
and the epistemologies and methodologies and urban fantasies they are
enacting.
The rail yards, 1929. View west from a building on 31st Street. [Ewing Galloway, NYPL Digital
Collection]
T h e L o n g - U n p r o g r a m m a b l e T e r r a i n
4
https://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-2.jpghttp://digitalcollections.nypl.org/items/510d47dd-8bea-a3d9-e040-e00a18064a99https://placesjournal.org/article/smart-cities/https://placesjournal.org/author/shannon-mattern/http://content.related.com/HYImages/2015-07/Platform-Graphic-Horizontal-Hi-Res.pdf -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
4/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 4
T h e L o n g - U n p r o g r a m m a b l e T e r r a i n
For nearly a century, this forlorn if frenetic infrastructural terrain has
invited and impeded repair. The 1929 Regional Plan proposed to
relocate New York Citys shipping facilities to Newark and open the
waterfront to improvement. A generation later, the John Lindsay
administrationhad a go at it, but developers were stymied by the tracksand tunnels and blocked by opponents in Hells Kitchen, who won Special
District status that preserved the neighborhoods low-rise, residential,
affordable character. Lindsays allies pushed through only one major
project on their punchlist, the Javits Center, and concessions left little
room for future development on the Far West Side.
Yet real estate always finds a way. In the early 1970s, Richard Ravitch,
developer and head of the Metropolitan Transit Authority, demonstratedthe untapped potential of the MTAs Caemmerer Hudson Rail Yards 26
below-grade acres that served as parking for Long Island Railroad trains
by ordering the construction of columns that could support a deck above
the tracks. Once it was possible to build over the yards without disrupting
their transportation functions, writes anthropologist Julian Brash,
development proposals quickly emerged. In the mid-80s, Olympia and
York, a Canadian development firm that had worked on the
London Docklands, offered to raze Madison Square Garden (itself a
symbol of destruction, standing on the rubble of McKim, Mead and
Whites glorious Penn Station) and build a new arena, office towers, and
retail complex atop the rail yards.
H e r e o u r s t o r y c r a s h e s i n t o D a n i e l D o c t o r o f f , t h e m a n
w h o g a v e H u d s o n Y a r d s i t s n a m e . H e h e a d s a s t a r t u p
c o m p a n y o w n e d b y A l p h a b e t t h a t w a n t s t o b u i l d a f u t u r i s t i c
c i t y f r o m s c r a t c h .
Those plans were killed by the 1987 stock market crash, but a half mile
south, organic growth was happening among the warehouses, garages,
fringe nightclubs, and auto-repair shops of West Chelsea. The Kitchen, a
legendary performance-art venue, had relocated from SoHo to West 19th
5
6
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pennsylvania_Station_(1910%E2%80%9363)https://placesjournal.org/article/john-lindsay-adventure-playground-new-york/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
5/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 5
in 1986, followed by the Dia Art Foundation, and then by trailblazing
gallerists like Matthew Marks, Barbara Gladstone, Andrea Rosen, and
Lawrence Luhring. As Chelsea emerged as the citys new contemporary
art hub, entrepreneurs toyed with the idea of building a new Yankee
stadium above the rail yards. Then came the economic boom of the
1990s and the growth of the Silicon Alley tech corridor. A collective of
business, labor, and academic leaders known as the Group of 35 saw a need
for more office space in Midtown and planned to annex the Far West Side.
Here our story crashes into Daniel Doctoroff, the man who gave Hudson
Yards its name. Youll be seeing a lot of him in 2016. Hes the head of
Sidewalk Labs, a startup company owned by Alphabet (ne Google) that
reportedly wants to build a futuristic city from scratch, as a test ground
for experimental technologies. Back in the 90s, he was a private equity
investor who pitched the idea of rebuilding far-west Manhattan around a
Stadium of Dreams that could attract the Olympic Games and later
house the Jets football team. Incoming mayor Michael Bloomberg
recruited Doctoroff as his deputy for economic development, and the
two pushed the sports complex and surrounding development as
probably the single most important economic project that New York City
has undertaken in decades.
7
8
9
http://nymag.com/nymetro/realestate/urbandev/features/9307/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
6/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 6
Failed proposal for the NYC 2012 Olympics stadium at Hudson Yards. [Kohn Pedersen Fox]
That dream burst in 2004, when the Regional Plan Association and local
community board rejected the stadium. New York lost the Olympics bid to
London, and concurrent proposals to expand the Javits Center and
relocate Penn Station also failed. Yet the core vision of a redeveloped
waterfront survived. As New York City weathered the Great Recession and
its popular mayor was elected to a third term, Bloombergian urbanism
was ascendant from Times Square to the White House. Hudson Yards was,
Brash observes, the capstone of the Bloomberg administrations urban
and economic development strategy and a microcosm of the strategy
itself. Setting aside the Olympics stadium, the mayor promised to build
the citys next great high-end office district.
10
https://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-4.jpg -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
7/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 7
B l o o m b e r g i a n u r b a n i s m w a s a s c e n d a n t f r o m T i m e s S q u a r e t o
t h e W h i t e H o u s e .
Many of the same people have been committed to the redevelopment of
the rail yards, in one form or another, since the Lindsay years. Despite the
obstinacy of the site, the failed projects blazed the way for future
development, as first the eastern blocks and then the western blocks were
rezoned from manufacturing to commercial and residential use. In 2008,
after yet another development deal fell through, the MTA awarded a
contract to the partners who now control the site, Related Companies and
Oxford Properties. They invested $400 million to build platforms over
the tracks, and, in late 2010, broke ground on the first building: 10 Hudson
Yards, the 52-story commercial office tower now ready to open its doors at
30th Street and 10th Avenue.
Throughout the decades of negotiations, the urban context has changed
dramatically, with the flourishing of Hudson River Park, the renovation of
the Javits Center, and the transformation of an elevated rail line into the
wildly popular High Line Park. Early developers sought to demolish the
northern section of the elevated track to make way for their own
interventions, but the Friends of the High Line lobbied to save it, and we
all know what happened next. When 10 Hudson Yards opens next
month, it will be filled with tenants who see the park as an essential
amenity. The tower was built directly on top of the High Line and
designed to accommodate it, with a grand pedestrian passageway running
through the base.
11
12
https://placesjournal.org/article/above-grade-on-the-high-line/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
8/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 8
Hudson Yards redevelopment plan. [Kohn Pedersen Fox]
E m b e d d e d S m a r t S y s t e m s
Kohn Pedersen Fox, the architecture firm that master-planned thedevelopment and designed the towers at 10 & 30 Hudson Yards, has
worked with Related and Oxford to incorporate multiple intelligences
in the project. The plan itself reflects a calculus that balances profit with
physics and geology. Because the complex topology of tracks and tunnels
limits where engineers can embed caissons into the bedrock, only 38
percent of the site can support construction, so developers have to
maximize the usable area by building as high-density, and high-profit, as
possible.
C i r c u i t s a r e t h e n e w t o p o l o g y o f t h i s t e r r a i n , o n c e d o m i n a t e d
b y t u n n e l s a n d t r a c k s .
That calculus also includes public responsibility. One fourth of the
residential units are designated for affordable housing (although skeptics
13
https://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-5.jpg -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
9/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 9
fret that affordable means studios and other housing unsuitable for
families). Sustainable features include an efficient, Cogen-powered, on-
site power-generation plant; energy management systems that calibrate
use across the grid; household meters that provide real-time readings; and
a thermal loop that ties together each buildings central plant, enabling
them to exchange heat and chilled water. Environmental righteousness
brings cost savings, too. The power plant is supposed to keep building
services running through any disruption, whether brownout or
superstorm.
Circuits are the new topology of this terrain, once dominated by tunnels
and tracks. Yet another mechanical loop a pneumatic-tube trash
removal system by the Swedish company Envac will have separate
circuits for recyclables, food waste (converted to fertilizer), and trash (fed
into a central dehydrator). While such systems are environmentally
smart they eliminate noisy, polluting garbage trucks; minimize
landfill waste; and reduce offensive smells they also cultivate an out-of-
sight, out-of-mind public consciousness. With disposal chutes on each
floor of every building, garbage becomes more of a domestic aesthetic
problem than an ecological concern. Perhaps the designers could
provide a peek into the trash-collection system so that visitors can both
marvel at its efficiency andreflect on their own contributions to thechallenges of waste management.
14
15
-
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
10/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 10
Hudson Yards: Engineered City, promotional material from Related Companies. [PDF]
The master plan also calls for a contextual intelligence that acknowledges
Hudson Yardss relation to the city. The site, while marginal, should feel
connected to the rest of Manhattan, and the buildings, while monolithic,
should be deferential. The projects enormous physical presence will
feel threatening, explained KPF principal William Pedersen, unless it is
https://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-6.jpghttp://content.related.com/HYImages/2015-07/Engineered-City-Hi-Res.pdf -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
11/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 1
sculpted and creates responses that are very specific to context. Some
of the buildings taper as they ascend; some lean toward one another;
some, with lopped-off crowns, seem to tip their hats; some smooth their
envelopes sharp angles into soft curves. Yet the renderings still
demonstrate a great deal of luminous bravado.
O n t h i s a r t i f i c i a l g r o u n d , e v e n t h e s o i l i s e n g i n e e r e d i t s
t h e s m a r t e s t s o i l i n t o w n .
Rather than pursuing a singular architectural vision, Related recruited a
team of prominent designers, each charged with infusing his or her
sensibility. As architecture critic Justin Davidson wrote in 2012, That
approach emulates a sped-up version of New Yorks gradual, lot-by-lot
evolution; the danger is that it can produce a jumble. Landscape
designer Thomas Woltz faces an extraordinary challenge: his Public
Square, the central plaza for the Eastern Yards, must knit together the
buildings and negotiate vast disparities in scale. In an open space next to
1,000-foot-towers, our tallest tree is going to be like an ant next to a tall
mans shoe, Woltz said. Public Square will feature an entry garden, a
canopying Pavilion Grove, a water feature, a massive interactive artwork
by Thomas Heatherwick, and, according to the developers, a stonework
installation recalling Manhattan geology the schist foundation upon
which the complex floats, and into which its caissons are anchored. On
this artificial ground, even the soil is engineered. The smartest soil in
town is designed to drain efficiently and collect stormwater in a 60,000-
gallon storage tank, which will be protected from the heat of subterranean
trains by a network of tubes that circulate chilled liquid. Public Square is
thus charged with calibrating a proper climate for plants, people, and
buildings. As Davidson put it: its the node where the sites conflictingforces reveal themselves: the tension between public and private, between
city and campus, between democratic space and commercial real estate.
16
17
18
19
20
http://www.nbwla.com/projects/boards/hudson-yards -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
12/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 12
Public Square, scheduled for completion in 2018. View south toward Culture Shed. [Nelson
Byrd Woltz]
The Public Square: The Smartest Park in Town, promotional material from Related
Companies. [PDF]
https://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-8.jpghttps://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-7.jpghttp://content.related.com/HYImages/2015-07/Landscape-Graphic-Horizontal.pdf -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
13/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 13
Culture Shed, scheduled for completion in 2019. [Diller Scofidio + Renfro / Rockwell Group]
Cedric Prices unbuilt Fun Palace, 1961.
Yet another mediating structure sits just south of the Square, adjacent to
the High Line. Culture Shed, a 200,000-square-foot venue by DS+R and
Rockwell Group, will serve as aKunsthallefor public and private exhibits,
concerts, screenings, fashion shows, and trade events. The signature
design element is a telescoping outer shell that can be extended over the
https://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-10.jpghttps://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-9.jpghttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Culture_Shed -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
14/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 14
adjacent lot, doubling the venues footprint for larger events. When the
building is compacted, the side lot will be free for open-air programming
and public use. Architect Elizabeth Diller has called it an open
infrastructure that could take on any form of creative expression, at any
time, at any scale. Its flexibility and openness and readiness to
accommodate an array of electro-mechanical demands, Diller says,
constitute myriad forms of intelligence. In that respect, it was inspired
by Cedric Prices hypothetical Fun Palace(1961), a data-driven
architectural machine that would calculate its users preferences and
reconfigure itself to accommodate them. Though never built, Prices
Palace, like the Shed, represents an experimental platform where data
determines form.
N e w Y o r k i n t h e A g e o f I n f o r m a t i c s
Hudson Yards is thus marked by intersections: merging infrastructures,
political-economic interests, operational logics, publics (ideally) and
urban imaginaries. According to Brash, the Bloomberg Way embraced
two distinct imaginaries: a corporate city, with the mayor as CEO and the
city as a unified corporate entity, a brand; and the city as a luxury
product, an elite, meritocratic realm. The Yards embodies both.
Other stakeholders have different hopes for the development: they see it
as the northern anchor of a vibrant cultural district (moored at the south
by the new Whitney Museum); as a workshop for smart, sustainable
construction methods; as a mixed-use neighborhood drawing diverse
publics to its offices, residences, shops, restaurants, and cultural facilities.
The metaphors begin to pile up. Hudson Yards is conceived as an
interface, as a mixing chamber, a test-bed. How will these competing
visions be reconciled on the ground? Not easily is my guess, since they areborn of different ideologies and epistemologies.
H u d s o n Y a r d s i s c o n c e i v e d a s a n i n t e r f a c e , a s a m i x i n g
c h a m b e r , a t e s t - b e d . H o w w i l l t h e s e c o m p e t i n g v i s i o n s b e
r e c o n c i l e d o n t h e g r o u n d ?
21
22
23
http://www.cca.qc.ca/en/collection/283-cedric-price-fun-palace -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
15/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 15
In a recent article, Neil Brenner and Christian Schmid identified three
urban age discourses that shape our current episteme. Urban
triumphalism, as championed by economists like Edward Glaeser, regards
the city as an engine of innovation and civilization and prosperity.
Sustainable urbanismimagines cities as hotbeds of resilience and
environmental consciousness. Finally, technoscientific urbanismreflects a
neopositivist return to postwar systems thinking and centralized
planning; it is especially visible in the discourse around smart cities,
which regards the intelligence generated from spatial sensing and data
analysis as a fix for perennial urban problems.
Bloombergianism draws from all three discourses; in fact, it represents
their greatest synthesis. As Brash explains, the mayors so-called
pragmatism redefined complex urban issues as a set of problems to be
solved via the application of technical knowledge and evaluated via
quantitative measurement. He liked policies with measurable
outcomes. Yet while Bloombergs advocacy for Hudson Yards depended on
numbers cost/benefit analyses, revenue projections, square-footage
counts Brash argues that it was also rooted in fantasy. In selling a vision
of the future city, the mayor asked developers, and New Yorkers at large,
to take a leap of faith.
Bloombergs belief in the power of data shaped his initiatives. In 2010, he
launched theApplied Sciences NYCprogram, inviting top research
institutions to submit proposals to build new applied science and
engineering campuses in New York, with funding and land provided by the
city. The program was designed not only to enhance educational
offerings but also to generate innovative ideas that can be
commercialized, catalyzing hundreds of spinoff companies and increasing
the probability that the next high-growth company a Google, Amazon,or Facebook will emerge in New York City. The city had already
spawned Esty, Tumblr, and Foursquare, but to fully exploit its established
industries finance, media, advertising, real estate it would need to
expand its science and engineering sector.
24
25
26
27
http://www.nycedc.com/project/applied-sciences-nyc -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
16/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 16
Recruitment poster for prospective graduate students, 2013. [Center for Urban Science
and Progress]
The first award, in 2012, went to Cornell University and the Technion-
Israel Institute of Technology for a joint campus on Roosevelt Island. A
few months later, the mayor announced a second award, for New York
Universitys Center for Urban Science and Progress, a research center in
Downtown Brooklyn. Since then, CUSP has become the hub in a large
network of international collaborators that includes universities
(Carnegie Mellon, CUNY, University of Toronto, University of Warwick,
and the Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay); tech, design, utility, and
defense companies (IBM, Microsoft, Xerox, Cisco, Consolidated Edison,
Lutron, National Grid, Siemens, AECOM, Arup, IDEO, and Lockheed
Martin, all of whom provide financial support); and city agencies
28
https://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-12.jpghttp://cusp.nyu.edu/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
17/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 17
(departments of city planning, design and construction, buildings,
environmental production, parks and recreation, and transportation; the
MTA; the Port Authority; fire and police).
C U S P w a n t s t o i n s t r u m e n t N e w Y o r k C i t y a n d t r a n s f o r m t h e
c i t y i n t o a l i v i n g l a b o r a t o r y a n d c l a s s r o o m .
Call it the academy-industry-government complex. CUSPs intermodal
teams use city data urban informatics to address challenges related
to infrastructure, energy use, pollution, noise, transportation, public
safety, public health, and so on, and thereby help cities around the world
become more productive, livable, equitable, and resilient. They start by
focusing on problems close to home and then seek to scale up solutions
that can be applied globally: CUSP will instrument New York City and use
existing data from network agencies to transform the city into a living
laboratory and classroom. Instrument. What a remarkable verb.
I first wrote about CUSPs methodsforPlacesin 2013. Earlier that year,
director Steven Koonin had written, it is now not a fantasy to ask if you
could know anything about a city, what do you want to know and to
ponder what could be done with that information. In the era of Big
Data, nearly everything can be measured, and that data can probably be
used to optimize something. More recently, deputy director Constantine
Kontokosta has insisted that CUSP does not put the data before the horse.
Whereas some scientists adopt the attitude, We have so much data, lets
just correlate it all, analyze it all, and see what interesting patterns we find
and respond to them, he says that CUSP researchers take the opposite
approach: Lets think of the important, interesting questions and then
find the data we need. Those important questions, according to
Kontokosta, are shaped by collaborations with social scientists who focus
on issues such as social equity and justice. On its website, CUSP claims
that its work is ultimately about people, i.e. the customers and operators
of urban systems, and that its mission is to understand them and their
behavior. In this universe, citizens relate to their city by consuming
and administering its systems, and by serving as sources of measurable
behavioral data.
H u d s o n Y a r d s a s O p e n - A i r U r b a n L a b
29
30
31
32
33
34
https://placesjournal.org/article/methodolatry-and-the-art-of-measure/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
18/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 18
H u d s o n Y a r d s a s O p e n - A i r U r b a n L a b
As the Bloomberg administration cultivated these centers of innovation
on Roosevelt Island, in Downtown Brooklyn, and later at Columbia
University and the Brooklyn Navy Yard it was easy to see a role for
Hudson Yards. Here was an unprecedented opportunity to rewire a large
plot of land, to create, tabula rasa, a test-bed of urban intelligence thatwould align the citys new data science industry with its expertise in
finance, real estate, design, and structural and civil engineering. In April
2014, CUSP announced that it would partner with Related and Oxford to
develop Hudson Yards as a unique experimental environment for
testing new physical and informatics technologies and analytics
capabilities. Kontokosta would lead the initiative.
H u d s o n Y a r d s w a s a n u n p r e c e d e n t e d o p p o r t u n i t y t o r e w i r e a
l a r g e p l o t o f l a n d , a l i g n i n g t h e c i t y s n e w d a t a s c i e n c e
i n d u s t r y w i t h i t s e x p e r t i s e i n f i n a n c e , r e a l e s t a t e , d e s i g n ,
a n d s t r u c t u r a l a n d c i v i l e n g i n e e r i n g .
There are many other U.S. cities Austin, San Francisco, Los Angeles, and
Chicago among them that are integrating smart technologies intoexisting architectures in order to improve efficiency, safety, health, and
resilience. New York has other programs, too: a network of sensors,
video cameras, and EZ Pass readers that monitor traffic congestion in
Midtown; water meters that wirelessly report leaks; solar-powered trash
compactors that alert sanitation workers when they are full; rooftop noise
sensors that detect the acoustic signature of gunshots and help agents
geolocate their origins. And theyre making money. The NYPDs Domain
Awareness System, which links surveillance cameras, license plate
readers, radiation and chemical monitors, and police files, has been sold
to other law enforcement agencies and has yielded profit for both New
York and its partner Microsoft. The federal governments Smart Cities
Initiative, launched last fall, aims to fund new programs in the areas of
civic technology, cybersecurity, transportation, broadband infrastructure,
and more.
35
36
37
38
39
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domain_Awareness_System -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
19/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 19
And while other sites around the world Songdo, South Korea; Masdar,
United Arab Emirates; Lavasa, India have purportedly built smart
from the start, Hudson Yards offers the first opportunity in the United
States to build, from the ground up, the most connected, measured, and
technologically advanced digital district in the nation. Its new steel
and concrete structures will serve as scaffolding for the installation of a
future-proofed fiber-optic loop, as well as rooftop satellite, digital
antennae, and wireless responders that provide tenants with super-fast
connectivity without dead zones. The massive platforms and sidewalks
and building facades offer seemingly boundless surface-area for
embedded technology such as environmental sensors, sub-metering and
building data-capture systems, and devices linked to the Internet of
Things. Modeling software will process data on pedestrian flow, traffic,
indoor and outdoor air quality, energy production and consumption,
waste streams, and citizens health and activity levels. Residents and
workers equipped with tracking apps and smartphone sensors will enjoy
an interactive, data-driven experience, and developers can use the
harvested data to improve operational efficiencies, productivity, and
quality of life to build a community thats more livable, equitable, and
resilient. So the story goes.
40
41
-
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
20/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 20
Construction of the platforms over the rail yards in 2015. [Patrick Cashin / Metropolitan
Transportation Authority]
T h e P o l i t i c s o f N u m b e r s
But how to operationalize and then quantify and optimize such
fuzzy qualities? What constitutes livability or equity? Why the
unquestioned supremacy of efficiency? Are allthings better when theyrequick and easy? Sustainability (that buzzword-of-yore supplanted in
some circles by the more gritty resilience) has really been a measurement
problem, according to Kontokosta. The solution is to capture a
broader array of measurements, a richer assemblage of data streams
data from the environment, data from physical systems, data about
human behavior in order to better understand urban ecosystems.
CUSP is particularly interested in how physical spaces and environmental
42
43
https://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-17.jpghttps://www.flickr.com/photos/mtaphotos/16992354740/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
21/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 2
conditions shape human activity. How, for example, do noise, air
quality, and social interactions correlate with educational achievement?
At a granular level, how does the use of Public Square relate to measures of
health? Koonin predicts that all this cross-referencing and collation will
produce new disciplines. Well see the rise of human-centered civil
engineering and wider applications of quantitative design.
T h e t r o u b l e w i t h m o d e r n t h e o r i e s o f b e h a v i o r i s m , H a n n a h
A r e n d t w a r n e d , i s n o t t h a t t h e y a r e w r o n g b u t t h a t t h e y c o u l d
b e c o m e t r u e .
While data science itself is an interdisciplinary practice, the translation of
data into built form requires collaboration among an even larger field of
actors, many of whom bring wildly disparate values and preconceptions.
Think of all the earthmoving that has to happen, or the negotiation with
labor unions. These are not activities that can be easily data-fied. And not
everyone in this larger field of actors shares Kontokostas concern with
putting important questions before data collection and analysis. Real-
estate developers and governments focus on measurable outcomes. They
need numbers to inspire confidence in potentially risky investments, and
to systematically guide their planning and implementation. I dont knowwhat the applications might be, admits Relateds Jay Cross, but I do
know that you cant do it without the data. Thats a dangerous
approach, argues sociologist Will Davies, as theoretical presuppositions
and hypotheses can allegedly be abandoned, along with notions of
causality, in favor of blanket surveillance of everyday life. Then its all
about data-capture and pattern-spotting and behaviorist explanations.
Built environments and technical systems are presumed to inform human
behavior, and data about that behavior is fed back into the environment to
alterfuturehuman behavior. Its B. F. Skinner with sensors.
Within this model, people do possess agency, but their actions are framed
by their roles as consumers and generators of data. What about
human activities that cannot be observed? What about all those potential
behaviors that are never enacted, and thus never measured, because the
physical space or its regulation prohibits them or because ones
44
45
46
47
48
-
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
22/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 22
subjectivity proscribes a repertoire of possible behaviors? What about
other modes of action, other means by which people perform their urban
citizenship? How will the new methods of measurement and planning
inform what it means to be a citizen in a quantitative community?
The trouble with modern theories of behaviorism, Hannah Arendt
warned in 1958, is not that they are wrong but that they could becometrue that the very instruments used to measure behavior are indicative
of, and constitutive of, societies of automatism and sterile passivity.
The data we generate, based on determinist assumptions and imperfect
methodologies, could end up shaping populations and building worlds in
their own image.
Pedestrians outside the Hudson Yards subway station? Or automatons in a behavioral
experiment? Jennifer Gabrys critiques the rituals of smart citizenship.
49
https://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-16.jpg -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
23/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 23
Sustainability is a common value in smart urbanism and a selling point for
residents hoping to live mindfully and ethically in their LEED Gold
apartment buildings. But what does that really mean? Media scholar
Jennifer Gabrys argues that people enact their citizenship or
empirically behave like citizens by installing smart thermostats in
their homes, depositing trash in the appropriate chutes, monitoring air
quality and noise levels while they walk the dog, and FitBitting their way
to good health. Through this self-monitoring (and the voluntary provision
of personal data to some central repository), they presumably learn to
make informed and responsible choices, to alter their behavior when
necessary, and to contribute to the collective sustainability effort. Smart
citizenship, Gabrys says, is thus equated with monitoring and managing
ones relationship to the urban environment operationalizing the
cybernetic functions of the smart city rather than with exercising
rights and responsibilities or advancing democratic engagement
through dialogue and debate, as Arendt would prefer.
P e o p l e b e h a v e l i k e c i t i z e n s b y i n s t a l l i n g s m a r t t h e r m o s t a t s
i n t h e i r h o m e s , d e p o s i t i n g t r a s h i n t h e a p p r o p r i a t e c h u t e s ,
a n d F i t B i t t i n g t h e i r w a y t o g o o d h e a l t h .
If we were to measure the behavior of these citizen-sensors as an index of
their engagement with the city, wed find that their actions are limited, as
Arendt foretold, by the instruments that render those actions visible and
worth accounting for. The result is a passive, somewhat egocentric notion
of citizenship even an automatedperformance of citizenship, wherein
self-managing environmental technologies can override citizens if they
do not perform in accordance with the rules which restricts
peoples ideas about civic action, delimits the rights to the city to
which they feel entitled, and shapes their imagination about what a city is
and can be.
Whats more, Gabrys says, the very responsiveness that enables citizens
to gather data often doesnt let them meaningfully act upon the data
gathered, since this would require changing the urban system in which
they have become effective operators. While some models of smart
50
51
-
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
24/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 24
urbanism embrace the tools of e-government report-a-pothole apps,
for example, or community planning software they typically lack any
means of accommodating user input that challenges the underlying
principles and ideologies of the tools. Civic engagement platforms, in
their promotion of transparency and efficiency, tend to obscure the
politics of pervasive surveillance and offer no means for citizens to
question the goals of growth and progress (i.e., neoliberalism), or to
trace the spread of what Shoshanna Zuboff calls surveillance capitalism.
Jathan Sadowski and Frank Pasquale follow this logic to its conclusion:
Anybody who wishes to ask critical questions about the future, let alone
actually constrain and slow down technological development, is de facto
extinguishing an exploding economy and standing in the way of a
(supposedly) democratizing force.
Y o u c a n n o t c o s h a p e a p a i n s t a k i n g l y e n g i n e e r e d , s h r e w d l y
f i n a n c e d , a l g o r i t h m i c a l l y - t u n e d , m a s t e r - p l a n n e d
e n v i r o n m e n t d e s i g n e d t o p r e v e n t y o u f r o m i n f l u e n c i n g i t .
Proponents of values-driven design advocate that citizens be involved in
co-designing the technology that shapes the environments they live in
and structures their everyday lives. Yet, as The New Republics ChristineRosen notes, You cannot coshape an environment particularly a
painstakingly engineered, shrewdly financed, algorithmically-tuned,
master-planned environment designed by others to prevent you from
influencing it. Arethere opportunities for meaningful citizen
participation in creating the smart technologies that will define Hudson
Yards? And what about the visitors? What about the conscientious
objectors? What about the residents who lack the tools for participation
smart devices or technological smarts and who are thus subjected
to the citys monitoring without being able to monitor back?
I posed these questions to Related and CUSP. Representatives from both
organizations indicated that theyre still in the planning phases for the
quantified community, and they cant share concrete details.
52
53
54
55
https://placesjournal.org/article/whos-your-data/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
25/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 25
10 Hudson Yards, under construction in 2014. View from the High Line. [Steven Severinghaus]
D a t a S t r e a m s a s U r b a n I n f r a s t r u c t u r e
While much of the data at Hudson Yards will be drawn from building
systems and connected devices, people themselves constitute another
valuable data source. CUSP has repeatedly stated that residents and
visitors will not be tracked unless they opt in to the anonymous collectionof personal data from home sensors and smartphone apps. In 2014, a
senior official at Related proposed that residents might be incented to
opt-in in exchange for services, but when I reached out last month,
the company declined to comment on how that might work. Its not
exactly reassuring to hear CUSP researchers tell The New York Timesthat
the conditions under which people will feel comfortable sharing their
personal information will be another subject for experiment. For
56
57
58
https://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-13.jpghttps://www.flickr.com/photos/horsepunchkid/15012054315/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
26/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 26
most researchers working with human subjects, consent, privacy, and
confidentiality are critical values. Its not clear that the rules of the game
are the same at Hudson Yards. Kontokosta toldFast Companythat todays
urbanites have come to demand services and conveniences that require
they get comfortable with greater surveillance and instrumentalization.
If data collected at Hudson Yards is subject to loosely regulated mining,what about the data as aphysical resource, which will require a material
infrastructure for its storage and management? It seems thats another
test bed. As Kontokosta recently explained toBisnow:
We havent seen this type of comprehensive data effort in an urban
development before. There will be a lot of challenges dealing with
the fire hose of data this is going to unleash, but were hoping this will
eventually become a model for how cities think about this type of
informatics infrastructure going forward.
Thats not much clearer than what we heard two years ago from Relateds
senior vice president of operations. Thad Sheely surmised that the data
would be stored in the cloud (where?) and managed by an outside
information technology company (perhapsHudson Yards tenant SAP?):
Basically, well be the funnel and collect the data so they can put [the
information] though their spin cycle in the cloud, and then provide
an interface for us to be able to access the information. That way,
we wont need to have a big server farm on campus.
Again, neither Related nor CUSP would confirm speculations about that
spin cycle in the cloud. But if an off-site model is realized, the physical
systems that make the development smart its tubes and cables andservers will presumably be hidden away like all the other circuits.
Whats left? A deceptively clean, shallow interface to the Hudson Yards
operating system, whose physical architecture, algorithmic operation,
and security we know very little about.
T h e c o n d i t i o n s u n d e r w h i c h p e o p l e w i l l f e e l c o m f o r t a b l e
59
60
61
https://placesjournal.org/article/interfacing-urban-intelligence/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
27/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 27
s h a r i n g t h e i r p e r s o n a l i n f o r m a t i o n w i l l b e a n o t h e r s u b j e c t
f o r e x p e r i m e n t .
Geographer Rob Kitchin has identified issues that governments and
developers must address in order to ensure the privacy, protection, and
security of data, which he takes to be critical rights in the smart city notsubjects for experimentation. New Yorkers would do well to familiarize
themselves with these recommendations, which include building
privacy-by-design into technologies; offering education about data
security; forming a smart-city oversight committee to monitor
governance, ethics, privacy, and security; empowering a compliance team
that works across city departments and contractor companies; and
charging a cybersecurity emergency response team. Implementing
Kitchins recommendations in New York could enable the benefits of
smart cities and urban big data to be realized, while promoting fairness
and equity, and protecting citizens (and the city itself) from harm.
Ill go a step further than that. The politics of data, and the materiality of
its infrastructure, could be made legible or senseable within the
landscape. Just as I suggested earlier that Hudson Yards designers might
offer a peek into mechanical systems like the trash chute, there could also
be civic education to inform residents and visitors about what makes the
community so smart and about their own potential for managing the
uses of the data they generate. A public library would be an ideal
venue for such public pedagogy, and for providing an interface to and
guiding patrons use of open data provided by Hudson Yards and the
city government. Further, we need to ensure that public institutions and
repositories have the resources to commit to the long-term maintenance
of open, secure information infrastructures. That is especially important
in cities powered by commercial IT and dependent on proprietary
platforms. History shows that commercial partners tend to value
innovation-driven obsolescence, exclusive contracts, and the
monetization of user data; rather than resilience, interoperability,
equitability, and discretion.
62
63
64
https://placesjournal.org/article/library-as-infrastructure/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
28/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 28
A woman admires the Hudson Yards logo on a mobile device in the penthouse at 15 Hudson
Yards, scheduled for completion in 2018. [Diller Scofidio + Renfro / Rockwell Group]
F r o m P e n t h o u s e t o S i d e w a l k ( L a b s )
Lets pause now to consider what we know about the community forming
on the Far West Side. At 10 Hudson Yards, opening soon, tenants will
include the luxury fashion retailer Coach, cosmetics company LOreal,digital marketers VaynerMedia, Boston Consulting Group, and the
software and data analytics company SAP. Next year, a second tower
opens at 55 Hudson Yards, designed by KPF/Kevin Roche; the first
confirmed tenant is the law firm Boies, Schiller & Flexner. Opening in
2018 are a 70-story apartment building by DS+R/Rockwell Group and a
retail center by Elkus Manfredi that will feature more than one hundred
shops, including New Yorks first Neiman Marcus store, and restaurants
65
https://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-15.jpg -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
29/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 29
curated by celebrity chef Thomas Keller. By 2019, Culture Shed will
begin hosting events. David Childs of Skidmore, Owings & Merrill will
unveil a mixed-used building anchored by an Equinox hotel and fitness
club. And KPF will open a 90-story tower with tenants who are moving
from the Time Warner Center at Columbus Circle, including HBO,
CNN, Oxford Properties, and Related Companies; as well as the
investment bank Wells Fargo Securities and at least one private equity
firm. The year 2020 will bring the highly symbolic regime change of a
62-story office tower replacing the McDonalds at 34th Street and 10th
Avenue. After that comes a second phase of development, at the Western
Yards, which will emphasize residential use; among its seven apartment
buildings and one public school, there is one office building.
T h i s i s a l a n d o f l u x u r y a n d l o g i s t i c s , f i t n e s s a n d f i n a n c e ,
m a r k e t i n g a n d m e d i a , c o u t u r e a n d c u r a t i o n , f i n e - d i n i n g a n d
d a t a a l l s i t u a t e d a m i d s t a b u n d a n t o p e n s p a c e .
What does that tell us? This is a land of luxury and logistics, fitness and
finance, marketing and media, couture and curation, fine-dining and data
all situated amidst abundant open space, including not only Public
Square and Culture Shed, but also Hudson Park & Boulevard, a four-acregreen space that will extend past the northern border up to 39th Street.
While some early boosters imagined Hudson Yards as an annex of the
Midtown business district, the current developers have a more specific
image in mind: Silicon Alley West. Relateds agents have aggressively
pursued tech start-ups, figuring that the resilient micro-grid and frontier
location will be a draw. There is even interest in growing a full-time tech
incubator on site.
Any day now, Sidewalk Labs an urban innovation accelerator will
move into the 26th and 27th floors of 10 Hudson Yards. Perhaps they are
already there. Right beside them will be Intersection, a Sidewalk
subsidiary formed last year after the acquisition of Control Group, a tech
and design firm, and Titan, an outdoor advertising company. Intersection
has already made its presence felt around the city by transforming New
Yorks 8,000-plus payphones into Links, ad-supported pylons that
66
-
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
30/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 30
feature super-fast WiFi, free calls, and charging stations. (Among
the crucial questions for privacy and security: will the Links become
nodes in the NYPDs Domain Awareness System?)
LinkNYC kiosks installed last month in Manhattan. [Edward Blake]
Sidewalk Labs, remember, has a deep connection to the once-
unprogrammable terrain of the Far West Side. Chief executive Daniel
Doctoroff is the Bloomberg ally who recoded the territory as Hudson
Yards. Given the neighborhoods many evolutionary phases, whose
histories are carved into the landscape here, it is fitting that Sidewalk now
positions itself as an ambassador of the new infrastructural age. The
company tells its own version of urban history: After the steam
revolution, the electricity revolution, and the automobile revolution, all of
67
https://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-14.jpghttp://www.sidewalklabs.com/https://www.flickr.com/photos/eblake/25539831295/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
31/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 3
which made their marks here, comes a digital revolution characterized by
ubiquitous connectivity, sensors, location-based services, social
networks, advanced computing power, the ability to analyze data, and new
design and fabrication technologies like 3-D printing and robotics that
promise to solve our pressing urban problems, to promote efficiency
and adaptability, to build urban community and give people a greater
sense of personalization. Is that what weve been missing all this time?
A greater sense of personalization?
S i d e w a l k L a b s a i m s t o b r i d g e t h e g a p t h a t t y p i c a l l y d i v i d e s
u r b a n i s t s a n d t e c h n o l o g i s t s , e m b r a c i n g a s e t o f p r i n c i p l e s
a n d u r b a n i m a g i n a r i e s t h a t e x t e n d b e y o n d t h e B l o o m b e r g
c o n s e n s u s .
While established smart-city players like Cisco and IBM peddle top-down,
master-planned solutions, Sidewalk Labs presents itself as a fresh
alternative, offering platforms (theres that ubiquitous, seemingly
innocuous metaphor) that users can plug into. Undergirding those
platforms is the entire Alphabet apparatus: the largest pool of capital in
the world focused on urban innovation; a deep knowledge of how cities
work, informed by the companys vast store of urban data, particularly
regarding urban mobility; a commitment to privacy and world-class
security; the leaders trust-based relationships with city governments
and major companies; and their confidence to work with, through, and
sometimes aroundexisting institutions and regulatory structures in
order to bring its products to market (italics mine). That foundation
rivaling the Yardss two massive platforms in the concentration of
funding, deal-making, and engineering required for its construction
equips Alphabet and Sidewalk Labs to build, deploy, and service any
digital technology in the physical world, which they can then test at
scale and offer on a subscription, fee, or commission model to private
parties or governments anywhere. Are you worried yet? Or thrilled?
Such a wealth of resources, and such hubris, might imply a narrowly
technocratic approach to urban betterment, but Sidewalk Labs aims to
bridge the gap that typically divides urbanists and technologists (a
68
69
70
-
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
32/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 32
chestnut roasted often in company presentations). It embraces a set of
principles and urban imaginaries that overlap with and extend beyond the
Bloomberg consensus. While Sidewalk, like Bloomberg, recognizes cities
as engines of opportunity and actively seeks business opportunities, it
also, like CUSP, asserts that cities are ultimately about people, and that
cities must adapt to the needs (and behaviors) of their citizens. Further,
Sidewalk explicitly addresses the ethical dimensions of urban living and
urban design. Its website highlights the importance of fostering
interactions, planned and spontaneous, among urban citizens; cultivating
shared values and promoting equity, inclusion, and diversity; and
accepting the critical responsibility to facilitate coordination without
control. That last bullet is especially tricky in this new world of
ubiquitous surveillance and algorithmic governance. Doctoroff has
spoken about the need to keep the virtuous cycle going (remember:
dont be evil; do the right thing!) to maintain quality of life, protect our
privacy, keep us safe, and address equity while still maximizing profit.
71
72
https://abc.xyz/investor/other/code-of-conduct.htmlhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don%27t_be_evil -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
33/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 33
App concept from a company presentation. [Sidewalk Labs]
Although committed to a code of ethics that emphasizes local concerns
and citizen empowerment, Sidewalk Labs aims big. Working at an
ambitious scale enables the team to model the interrelationships among
seemingly disparate urban challenges. For example: the availability of
transportation affects where people choose to live, which affects housing
prices, which affects quality of life. Data-capture and pattern-spotting
show potentially actionable correlations. Solving problems is then a
matter of building the right relationships with partners and stakeholders,
and developing the right technologies.
What urban realities could those technologies effect? Sidewalk talks in the
present tense, as if the goals have already been realized:
73
https://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-18.jpg -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
34/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 34
Modern, affordable housing is enabled by performance-based code,
advanced materials, and new and ownership models.
Digital mobility systems can manage limited road space to improve
transportation equity and air quality.
Personalized social services can deliver measurable health outcomes
while maintaining individual privacy.
Distributed energy management uses new business models,
renewable energy, and smarter storage to improve sustainability.
After Doctoroffs own battles with zoning and building codes, its no
surprise that he emphasizes the potential of performance-based codes.
In a world in which we can monitor things like noise or vibrations, he
wonders, why do we need to have these very prescriptive building codes
that only change once every several decades? It inhibits the transfer of
land so we end up having very restrictive uses. He holds that owners
and residents should be allowed to behave as they please in their
apartments and neighborhoods, so long as they dont exceed certain
thresholds, and that a regulatory system built on sensors and automatic
monitoring would produce more vibrant, mixed-use neighborhoods and
enhance the free flow of property, which lowers costs. Of course, suchmodels presume that the key variables that codes and zoning are designed
to regulate peoples health, safety, and welfare; property value, orderly
development, and community character are objectively measurable and
enforceable. Neighborly behavior has a number.
S u c h m o d e l s p r e s u m e t h a t t h e k e y v a r i a b l e s t h a t c o d e s a n d
z o n i n g a r e d e s i g n e d t o r e g u l a t e a r e o b j e c t i v e l y m e a s u r a b l e
a n d e n f o r c e a b l e . N e i g h b o r l y b e h a v i o r h a s a n u m b e r .
And given Alphabets investment in self-driving cars, its no surprise,
either, that Sidewalk is focusing on urban transportation. Last month, the
federal Department of Transportation announced that finalists in its $40-
million Smart City Challenge will partner with Sidewalk Labs to develop a
traffic management system calledFlow, which will use anonymized data
74
75
http://www.citylab.com/housing/2014/08/braving-the-new-world-of-performance-based-zoning/375926/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
35/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 35
from mobile apps like Google Maps and Waze, along with sensors on the
street and eventually (we can assume) in Alphabets cars, to help
commuters and city governments monitor and manage traffic patterns.
Flow will spot areas and sources of congestion, model the impact of
altered or expanded transit routes, coordinate ride shares, and perhaps
even identify zones underserved by public transit. LinkNYC will feed
data into the system, too, directing drivers to available parking,
recommending detours around traffic jams, and routing self-driving cars
through the streets. The kiosks may someday serve as digital
stethoscopes, monitoring flows of people, commercial activity, and
garbage removal, and perhaps inciting service or policy changes; and
as notice boards, flagging table openings at neighborhood restaurants
or warning of service delays at the nearest subway. Well be doing
Developer Days, making APIs, said Intersections chief innovation officer.
The city as platform, finally realized.
The winner of the Smart City Challenge, to be announced in June, will get
not only a Department of Transportation grant but also a license to
Flow and 100 free Links. The result: an ingenious vertically-integrated
system, with Alphabet managing city streets from A to Z from individual
automobiles and commuters navigational systems to transit informatics
and the hardware that enables data-capture and transfer. The onlycommuters out of the loop (and off the map) will be those who arent
plugged into Alphabets platforms and products. And at Hudson Yards, the
street design will make it clear who the intended users are. Justin
Davidson surmises that street activity will be managed via drop-off lanes,
so the limos are taken care of. But how to manage the shopping-cart
pushers and skateboarders and fellow misbehavers? Sidewalk Labs did
not respond to my inquiries.
76
77
78
-
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
36/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 36
Rendering of Hudson Yards towers with Zaha Hadids 520 W. 28th and the High Line. [Related
Companies]
T h e I n s t r u m e n t a l C i t y
If you happen to be in New York next month, stop and look up at the new
building straddling the High Line. Whatevers brewing on the 27th and
28th floors, its going to be big. Sidewalks new leadership, announced inFebruary, includes former heads of key divisions at Google maps,
shopping, machine intelligence as well as Bloomberg allies with deep
experience in planning and development. Joining Doctoroff in the C-suite
are Rit Aggarwala, who designed Bloombergs PlaNYC sustainability
program, and Josh Sirefman, who helped build Cornell Tech on Roosevelt
Island. The company is hiring machine vision and simulation experts as
well as city leads focused on municipal processes like health and human
79
https://placesjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mattern-hudson-yards-11.jpg -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
37/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 37
services, public safety, and criminal justice. Presumably, these are the
urban sectors it aims to optimize. As recently as last month, Sidewalk Labs
was also recruiting a product lead for citizen experiences.
T h e s e - m o d e r n d a y H a u s s m e n n h a v e t a m e d t h e i r w e s t e r n
f r o n t i e r , s u n k m o u n d s o f c a p i t a l i n t o a b u r i e d r a i l b e d ,
f i n e s s e d t h e z o n i n g a t t h e D e p a r t m e n t o f B u i l d i n g s , a n d n o w
i n t e n d t o u s e t h e i r n e w w e a p o n d a t a t o r e v o l u t i o n i z e
t h e o l d u r b a n r e g i m e .
When Doctoroff, surrounded by his old Bloomberg compatriots and new
Alphabet colleagues, looks down upon the construction at Hudson Yards,
he must feel that his Olympic dreams, long deferred, have been fulfilled recast, rebranded for our new age of algorithmic ambition. The developers
and financiers and data-managers will behold the same scene. These-
modern day Haussmenn have tamed their western frontier, sunk mounds
of capital into a buried rail bed, finessed the zoning at the Department of
Buildings, and now intend to use their new weapon data to
revolutionize the old urban regime. Theyll remake the infrastructures
that have been entangled at the Yards; theyll overlay a new topology of
circuits and data flows atop the train tracks and tunnels. These Great Men
this is a latter-day Power Broker story, after all will have successfully
united New Yorks powers in finance, real estate, design, marketing,
engineering, technology, and now data science to construct a floating
empire that blends allthe urban age discourses: triumphalism,
sustainability, technoscientism. Theyll behold the city fully
instrumented and instrumentalized, as an engine of data and profit.
And fantasy. From the observation deck atop 30 Hudson Yards, projected
to be the highest in the city, residents and visitors will look out upon a
dream made manifest: a clean, efficient urban machine; a carefully
curated cultural experience; a Keller-fed, Equinox-toned, Coach-clad
populace; a sustainable urban ecosystem; a harmonious community that
behaves in accordance with the rules; a city that plays by the numbers.
Here, those modern theories of behaviorism, dear Professor Arendt, will
-
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
38/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 38
have become true.
p j pp b .
p bb .
1. For a helpful overview of recent literature on smart cities, see Simon
Marvin, Ands Luque-Ayala, and Colin McFarlane, Eds.,Smart Urbanism:
Utopian Vision or False Dawn? (New York: Routledge, 2016).
2. Technically, BIGs Spiral, on 10th Avenue, between 34th and 35th
Streets, is one block north of the Hudson Yards site.
3. John Cassidy, Bloombergs Game, The New Yorker, April 4, 2005, 56-67.
4. Of course, data-driven urban planning has a long history. See Jennifer
LightsFrom Warfare to Welfare: Defense Intellectuals and Urban
Problems in Cold War America (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University
Press, 2005) and Mark Vallianatos, Uncovering the Early History of Big
Data and Smart City in Los Angeles,Boom, June 2015.
5. Julian Brash,Bloombergs New York: Class and Governance in the Luxury
City (Athens: University of Georgia Press, 2011), 146.
6. Brash, 48.
7. David Halle & Elisabeth Tiso,New Yorks New Edge: Contemporary Art, the
High Line, and Urban Megaprojects on the Far West Side (Chicago:
University of Chicago Press, 2014).
8. After six years in the mayors administration, Doctoroff returned to the
http://www.boomcalifornia.com/2015/06/uncovering-the-early-history-of-big-data-and-the-smart-city-in-la/http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2005/04/04/bloombergs-gamehttps://placesjournal.org/donatehttp://eepurl.com/ZUmrH -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
39/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 39
private sector to lead Bloomberg LP as President (2008-11) and CEO
(2011-14).
9. Quoted in Halle and Tiso, 215.
10. Brash, 123.
11. For more on Hudson Yards financing, which includes public tax
incentives, consult Bridget Fisher, The Myth of Self-Financing: The Trade-
Offs Behind the Hudson Yards Redevelopment Project, Schwartz Center for
Economic Policy Analysis, Working Paper 2015-4 (New York: The New
School, 2015). See also Halle and Tiso; Hudson Yards Development
Corporation, Financial Incentives; and New York City Independent
Budget Office, Citys Spending on Hudson Yards Project Has Exceeded
Initial Estimates (April 2013).
12. Halle and Tiso, 176. For more on the High Line, see Places articles
including Phillip Lopate, Above Grade: On the High Line,Places
Journal, November 2011.
13. Patrick J. Kiger, Hudson Yards Rises Above the Rails, UrbanLand,
October 6, 2014.
14. The developers explain, If on a Sunday, air conditioning is needed for
just a few occupants in an office building, it can come from the already-
active retail center rather than powering-up the entire commercial
towers cooling plant. See Related Companies brochure, Tomorrows
City Today, as well as website pages on Sustainability and
Infrastructure.
15. Juliette Spertus and Benjamin Miller, Pneumatic Tubes for One New
Yorks Trash, Urban Omnibus, August, 26, 2015. For more on pneumaticinfrastructures, see Shannon Mattern, Puffs of Air, in John Knechtel,
Ed.,AIR, Alphabet City #15 (Cambridge: MIT Press, 2010), 42-56.
16. Quoted in Kiger.
17. Heres Pedersen again: We tried to design our buildings to respond to
every aspect of the context around them. That responsiveness, that
http://urbanomnibus.net/2015/08/pneumatic-tubes-for-one-new-yorks-trash/http://www.hudsonyardsnewyork.com/office/infrastructurehttp://www.hudsonyardsnewyork.com/office/sustainabilityhttps://onlinedocs.related.com/HYDocuments/HY_Press_HYPIS_FINAL_4-15-2014_1846.pdfhttp://urbanland.uli.org/planning-design/hudson-yards-rises-rails/https://placesjournal.org/article/above-grade-on-the-high-line/http://www.ibo.nyc.ny.us/iboreports/hudsonyards2013.pdfhttp://www.hydc.org/html/project/financial.shtmlhttp://www.economicpolicyresearch.org/images/docs/research/political_economy/Bridget_Fisher_WP_2015-4_final.pdf -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
40/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 40
gesturing, the sense that there is dialogue between buildings, is really the
essence of what we are trying to do. With 10 Hudson Yards sloping
towards the Hudson River and 30 Hudson Yards gesturing toward the 7-
train subway station, we are creating a type of dance. See David Moin,
Stephen M. Ross Discusses His Vision for Hudson Yards, Womens Wear
Daily, March 10, 2016.
18. Justin Davidson, From 0 to 12 Million Square Feet,New York, October 7,
2012.
19. Quoted in Davidson.
20. Hudson Yards Press Kit, January 27, 2016.
21. Cynthia Davidson, Moving Parts: A Conversation with Elizabeth Diller,
Log 36 (Winter 2016), 52.
22. Brash, 17.
23. For more on urban test beds, see Orit Halpern, Jesse LeCavalier, Nerea
Cavillo, and Wolfgang Pietsch, Test Bed Urbanism,Public Culture25:2
(2013): 272-306.
24. Neil Brenner and Christian Schmid, Towards a New Epistemology of theUrban? City 19 (2015), 151-82. See also Henri Lefebvre, The Urban
Revolution (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2003 [1970]),
191.
25. Brash, 91.
26. Applied Sciences NYC, Overview.
27. For more, see Russell Hughes, The Internet of Politicized Things:
Urbanization, Citizenship, and the Hacking of New York Innovation
City,Interstices 16 (2016), 24-28.
28. According to Michael Manfredi, architect of the Bridge co-location
facility, Its about making connections between someone who might be
working at Microsoft and some doctoral student who is working on ways
of assembling information, and that rarely happens on an academic
http://interstices.aut.ac.nz/ijara/index.php/ijara/article/view/211http://www.nycedc.com/project/applied-sciences-nychttp://content.related.com/Lists/HYNewsAndPress/Attachments/134/Hudson-Yards-Press-Kit-01.27.16.pdfhttp://nymag.com/homedesign/urbanliving/2012/hudson-yards/http://wwd.com/retail-news/retail-features/stephen-ross-hudson-yards-retail-related-cos-10387536/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
41/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 4
campus. See Liz Stinson, Cornell Wants People to Collide on Its New
NYC Tech Campus, Wired, July 1, 2015.
29. CUSP website, About.
30. Shannon Mattern, Methodolatry and the Art of Measure,Places
Journal, November 2013. For a sustained critique of technoscientificurbanism, see also Mattern, Interfacing Urban Intelligence, Places
Journal, April 2014, and Mattern, Mission Control: A History of the
Urban Dashboard, Places Journal, March 2015.
31. Steven Koonin, The Promise of Urban Informatics(The Center for Urban
Science and Progress: 2013), 2.
32. Quoted in Brian Libby, Quantifying the Livable City, CityLab, October
21, 2014.
33. CUSP website, Disciplines, Domains, and Projects.
34. As the Applied Sciences NYC brief indicates, the city is focused on the
potential commercialization of such knowledge. CUSP projects that its
applied research, including the work of graduate students in its Applied
Urban Sciences and Informatics degree and certificate programs, will
generate $5.5 billion in economic activity, including nearly 200 spin-off
companies and several thousand new job, within the first three decades of
operation. Hughes observes that the recruitment of graduate researchers
into such enterprises reflects the citys commitment to equip its students
as tools for the 21st century digital economy. See Hughes, op cit., 26, and
New York Economic Development Corporation, press release, April 23,
2012.
35. A few months after the CUSP announcement, a third award went to theColumbia Data Science Institute, which, like CUSP, focuses on
informatics, but has a wider purview; their work addresses such topics as
cybersecurity, health and financial analytics, the management of large
data sets, and generalizable formal and mathematical models for data
processing. Later, a fourth award went to Carnegie Mellon, which
proposedto locate its Integrative Media Program in Steiner Studios at the
Brooklyn Navy Yard.
http://www1.nyc.gov/office-of-the-mayor/news/376-13/mayor-bloomberg-carnegie-mellon-university-will-open-fourth-new-applied-sciences/#/0.http://datascience.columbia.edu/http://www.nycedc.com/press-release/mayor-bloomberg-new-york-university-president-sexton-and-mta-chairman-lhota-announcehttp://cusp.nyu.edu/research/http://www.citylab.com/tech/2014/10/quantifying-the-livable-city/381657/http://cusp.nyu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/CUSP-overview-May-30-2013.pdfhttps://placesjournal.org/article/mission-control-a-history-of-the-urban-dashboard/https://placesjournal.org/article/interfacing-urban-intelligence/https://placesjournal.org/article/methodolatry-and-the-art-of-measure/http://cusp.nyu.edu/about/http://www.wired.com/2015/07/cornell-wants-people-collide-new-nyc-tech-campus/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
42/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 42
36. CUSP press release, NYU CUSP, Related Companies, and Oxford
Properties Group Team Up to Create First Quantified Community In
The United States at Hudson Yards, April 14, 2014.
37. On the politics of smaller-scale, more modest, retrofit-oriented smart
city initiatives, see Taylor Shelton, Matthew Zook, and Alan Wiig, The
Actually Existing Smart City, Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economyand Society 8 (2015), 13-25.
38. Robert Lee Holz, As World Crowds In, Cities Become Digital
Laboratories, Wall Street Journal, December 11, 2015.
39. United States press release, Fact Sheet: Administration Announces New
Smart Cities Initiative to Help Communities Tackle Local Challenges
and Improve City Services, September 14, 2015.
40. CUSP press release, April 14, 2014, op cit.
41. CUSP press release, April 14, 2014, op cit.
42. Quoted in Steve Lohr, Huge New York Development Project Becomes a
Data Science Lab, The New York Times, April 14, 2014.
43. Kontokosta, quoted in Lohr. NYPD deputy commissioner of informationtechnology Jessica Tisch likewise explained that the thing that allows
you to do data-driven management is to view all the different sorts of data
at the same time and provide that data to the officers in new ways,
quoted in Holz, op cit.
44. See Kiger, op cit., and Libby, op cit.
45. Quoted in Lohr, op cit.
46. Quoted in Lohr, op cit.
47. William Davies, The Chronic Social: Relations of Control Within and
Without Neoliberalism,New Formations: A Journal of
Culture/Theory/Politics 84-5 (2015), 40-57.
48. For more on the historical relationships between behaviorism,
http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/04/14/huge-new-york-development-project-becomes-a-data-science-lab/https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2015/09/14/fact-sheet-administration-announces-new-smart-cities-initiative-helphttp://www.wsj.com/articles/as-world-crowds-in-cities-become-digital-laboratories-1449850244http://cusp.nyu.edu/press-release/nyu-cusp-related-companies-oxford-properties-group-team-create-first-quantified-community-united-states-hudson-yards/ -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
43/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 43
engineering, and cybernetics, see the work of Orit Halpern. See also Ana
Teixeira, The Pigeon in the Machine: The Concept of Control in
Behaviorism and Cybernetics, inAlleys of Your Mind: Augmented
Intelligences and Its Traumas, Ed. Matteo Pasquinelli (Lneberg: meson
press, 2015), 23-34. For more on behaviorism in urban design, see Eric
Gordon and Stephen Walter, Meaningful Inefficiencies: Resisting the
Logic of Technological Efficiency in the Design of Civic Systems, in CivicMedia: Technology, Design, Practice, Ed. Eric Gordon and Paul Mihaildis
(Cambridge: MIT Press, 2016).
49. Hannah Arendt, The Human Condition (Chicago: University of Chicago
Press, 1958), 322.
50. Jennifer Gabrys, Programming Environments: Environmentality and
Citizen Sensing in the Smart City,Environment and Planning D: Societyand Space 32:1 (2014), 30-48. Halpern, LeCavalier, Cavillo, and Pietsch, op
cit., echo Gabryss claim that sensor-based urban smartness marks a
turn against the faith in liberal subjectivity, denigrates the place of older
political processes in decision making and operates at a level far
beneath consciousness. See also Marcus Foth, Laura Forlano, Christine
Satchell, and Martin Gibbs, Eds.,From Social Butterfly to Engaged Citizen:
Urban Informatics, Social Media, Ubiquitous Computing, and Mobile
Technology to Support Citizen Engagement(Cambridge: MIT Press, 2011).
51. Christine Rosen argues that in outsourcing so many aspects of our daily
lives to technology, we are making a moral choice. With the rise of
ambient intelligence and persuasive technologies, we are replacing
human judgment with programmed algorithms that apply their own
standards and norms to our behavior, usually with the goal of greater
efficiency, productivity, and healthy living. See Rosen, The Machine andthe Ghost, The New Republic, July 12, 2012.
52. Jennifer Light discusses the use of simulation games in communities and
schools in the 1960s to help citizens understand urban systems thinking;
such programs encourag[ed] citizens to maintain the stability of the
system rather than destroy it. Residents were educated to debate the
political choices offered by the game but not to question the models of
https://newrepublic.com/article/104874/rosen-verbeek-technology-morality-intelligence -
7/25/2019 Instrumental City_ the View From Hudson Yards
44/48
4/27/2016 Instrumental City: The View from Hudson Yards
https://placesjournal.org/article/instrumental-city-new-york-hudson-yards/ 44
urban systems themselves. See Urbanizing Military Information
Technology: Interview with Jennifer Light,New Geographies 7 (2015),
139-147; and Light, Taking Games Seriously, Technology and Culture
49:2 (April 2008), 347-75.
53. The goal of surveillance capitalism, Zuboff explains, is to access the
real-time flow of your daily life in order to directly influence andmodify your behavior for profit. Hudson Yardss planners plan to use
behavioral data in developing urban services but its likely that that
same data will be of great interest to local retailers and restaurateurs. See
Shoshanna Zuboff, The Secrets of Surveillance Capitalism,Frankfurter
Allgemeine, March 11, 2016.
54. Jathan Sadowski and Frank Pasquale, The Spectrum of Control: A Social
Theory of the Smart City,First Monday 20: 6-7 (July 2015).
55. Rosen, op cit.
56. See Jessica Leber, Beyond the Quantified Self: The Worlds Largest
Quantified Community,Fast Company, April 22, 2014; and Lohr, op cit.
Rob Kitchin notes that many of the governments and corporations
managing smart cities claim to use anonymous data or metadata, but the
empirical evidence reveals that privacy is being eroded, people are
being predictively profiled and socially sorted and inequalities are
widening. See Grounding Urban Data: Interview with Rob Kitchin,
New Geographies 7 (2015), 109-14.
57. Kiger, op cit.
58. Lohr, op cit.
59. Leber, op cit.
60. Ryan Boysen, Hudson Yards Smart