IntelWiki: Recommending Resources to Help Users Contribute to Wikipedia 

Mohammad Noor Nawaz and Andrea BuntUniversity of Manitoba

1

2

User Generated Content

Voluntary Contribution

3

Image Courtesy: Wikimedia Commons

Typical Contribution Rates

4

Stuckman et al., WikiSym 2009Nielsen

Contributors(9%)

Consumers(90%)

Creators (1%)

Increasing Contribution Rates

Make it easier!

5

Wilkinson, EC 2008Hoffmann et al., CHI 2009

Nielsen

State of the Art

6

Our Contributions

Novel approach to facilitating Wikipedia contributions to free-form text

─ resource recommendations

Prototype illustrating approach

Proof-of-concept empirical evaluation

7

8

Our Approach

IntelWiki Prototype: Framework

ResourceRanker

ResourceFetcher

ResourcePresenter

9

IntelWiki

IntelWiki - Demo

10

• For demonstration video see:

http://hci.cs.umanitoba.ca/projects-and-research/details/intelwiki

EvaluationConditions

1. IntelWiki 2. Default

16 participantsWithin subjects

11

12

Tasks

13

Perceived Workload (NASA TLX)

IntelWiki Default0

20

40

60

80

Mea

n O

vera

ll W

orkl

oad

F1,14 = 11.653; p = 0.004

14

Word Count

F1,14 = 5.302; p = 0.037 IntelWiki Default

185190195200205210215220225230235

Mea

n N

umbe

r of

Wor

ds

15

Fact Count

F1,14 = 7.304; p = 0.017

IntelWiki Default12

16

20

Mea

n Fa

ct C

ount

16

Fact Count

IntelWiki_First IntelWiki_Second12

14

16

18

20IntelWikiDefault

Mea

n Fa

ct C

ount

17

Preference

IntelWiki Default0

4

8

12

16

# P

artic

ipan

ts

Integrated Editing

[I preferred IntelWiki] because it gives me everything in one window.

18

Easier Resource Inspection

The keywords in the tooltip helped me understand which article will be more suitable for geography.

[Keyword highlighting] was very helpful; didn't have to read the whole page, or even the paragraph, only the lines containing the highlighted words.

19

Replacing Manual Search

[IntelWiki] eliminated any need for [additional searches] because, virtually anything that's needed I think was provided in the [recommended resources]

20

Lack of Trust

I don't usually trust the highlight and these things. I prefer to study by myself.

I preferred the [Default interface] because I can get more facts -- I don't really have to base my knowledge on a limited set of resources. It makes me more elaborate in my research. - P10

21

Summary

Resource recommendations as an way to facilitate Wikipedia contributions

IntelWiki prototype

Improved editing quantity and quality, and cognitive load

22

23

Future Work

24

IntelWiki: Recommending Resources to Help Users Contribute to Wikipedia Mohammad Noor Nawaz and Andrea BuntUniversity of Manitobabunt@cs.umanitoba.cahci.cs.umanitoba.ca