interagency visitor use management council - keith brown, kerri cahill
TRANSCRIPT
Presentation Overview
• History and mission of the Interagency Visitor Use Management Council (the Council)
• Update on the council’s activities
• Overview of the council’s position paper and visitor use management framework
2
• History and mission of the Interagency Visitor Use Management Council (the Council)
• Update on the council’s activities
• Overview of the council’s position paper and visitor use management framework
3
4 THE IMPORTANCE OF AND CHALLENGES WITH VISITOR USE MANAGEMENT AND VISITOR CAPACITY
The Challenge of Litigation
Inconsistent and inadequate implementation of VUM and capacity methodologies across the agencies:
• Not meeting agencies’ missions
• Reduced accountability
• Confusion in the field
• Inability to demonstrate success
• Litigation
5
The Challenge of Implementation
Proactively planning for visitor use maximizes the ability of agencies to encourage access and protect resources and values
Importance of Visitor Use Management
6
The Interagency Visitor Use Management Council
Mission: Provide guidance on long-term visitor use management policies and give direction on the most pressing needs by building technical competencies and improving interagency coordination.
8
• Consistent guidance across agencies
• Elevate the professional and scientific approach to managing visitor use
• Increased communication and collaboration
• Cost savings and improved efficiency
• More defensible decision-making
Expected Outcomes
• History and mission of the Interagency Visitor Use Management Council (the Council)
• Update on the council’s activities
• Overview of the council’s position paper and visitor use management framework
9
10
1. Establish guidance directives 2. Develop tools 3. Conduct training 4. Communicate effectively 5. Build institutional capacity
Work Plan
11
• Developed a visitor use management framework for agency planning and decision-making processes, includes common definitions for key terms
• Compiled and analyzed agency policies on visitor use management
• Developing separate “how-to” guidebooks for: — visitor capacity — indicators and thresholds
• Collaborated with the Interagency Wild and Scenic Rivers Coordinating Council on their guidebook for “Addressing User Capacities in Comprehensive River Management Plans”
Highlights for Recent Council Activities
12
• Developed council operating procedures and recruited over 15 volunteers to support the council’s work
• Prepared a communications plan and organized an outreach team
• Developing a council website for council products and a clearinghouse of existing visitor use management information
• Coordinating with the Federal Interagency Council on Outdoor Recreation
• Coordinating with related agency programs and councils
Highlights for Recent Council Activities (Continued)
• History and mission of the Interagency Visitor Use Management Council (the Council)
• Update on the council’s activities
• Overview of the council’s position paper and visitor use management framework
13
14
• Shift focus from narrow concept of visitor capacity to the broader concept of visitor use management
• Key terms are consistently defined across agencies • Presents a visitor use management framework to be integrated into
agency decision making processes -- using a sliding scale approach • Specific guidance for applicable legal requirements re: capacity
— Wild and Scenic Rivers — NPS General Management Plans — National Scenic and National Historic Trails
Council Position Paper
15
Process for managing all characteristics of visitor use and settings • Sustain resource conditions and visitor
experiences • Variety of strategies and tools
— Education — Site Management — Regulation — Enforcement — Rationing/allocation
Visitor Use Management
16
• Subcomponent of visitor use management
• Maximum amounts and types of visitor use that an area can accommodate
• While sustaining desired resource conditions and visitor experiences
Visitor Capacity
17
Visitor Use Management Framework
Purpose:
• Make decisions about VUM
• Analytical thought process
• Apply to all VUM issues/concerns
• Not a stand-alone process
• Flexibility - Sliding scale of analysis
18
Visitor Use Management Framework
Criteria:
• Unified guidance (multi-agency) • Defensible, transparent process, agency accountability • Desired conditions defined • Proactive response to changes in resource and social conditions • Clarify role of visitor capacity • Compatible with existing planning processes • Executable by field-level staff • Incorporate the sliding scale of analysis
19
Visitor Use Management Framework
1) Clarify project purpose and need. 2) Review the area’s purpose,
legislation, policy and management direction.
3) Assess existing information and current conditions.
4) Develop project planning strategy.
Element 1 – Build the Foundation
20
Visitor Use Management Framework
5) Define desired conditions
(resources, recreation opportunities, visitor experiences).
6) Define suitable visitor uses, facilities, and services based on desired conditions.
7) Determine acceptable levels of impact.
Element 2 - Define Visitor Use Management Direction
21
Visitor Use Management Framework
8) Compare and document the differences between existing and desired conditions and, for visitor related impacts, clarify the specific links to visitor use characteristics.
9) Identify visitor use management strategies and actions to achieve desired conditions.
10) Where necessary, identify visitor capacities and strategies to manage use levels within capacities.
11) Develop monitoring strategies.
Element 3 - Identify Management Strategies
22
Visitor Use Management Framework
12) Implement management actions. 13) Conduct and document ongoing
monitoring and evaluate the effectiveness of management actions in achieving desired conditions.
14) Adjust management actions if needed to achieve desired conditions and document rationale.
Element 4-Implement, monitor, evaluate, and adjust