interstate 40 landslide evaluation...project history 1974 - 2003 east-bound lanes opened in 1974...

27
___ Randy Sullivan May 17, 2017 Effects of Drainage on Landslide Movement at Interstate 40 across the Cumberland Plateau Escarpment Courtney Vissman, PE – Golder Associates Randy Sullivan, PE – Golder Associates David Barker, PE – TDOT Lori Fiorentino, PE - TDOT Robert Jowers, PE – TDOT

Upload: others

Post on 23-Sep-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Randy SullivanGolder Associates Inc.Atlanta, Georgia, USA

May 17, 2017

Effects of Drainage on Landslide Movement at Interstate 40 across the Cumberland

Plateau Escarpment Courtney Vissman, PE – Golder Associates

Randy Sullivan, PE – Golder AssociatesDavid Barker, PE – TDOT

Lori Fiorentino, PE - TDOTRobert Jowers, PE – TDOT

Page 2: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Site Location

2

NashvilleKnoxville

Rockwood

UI-40

Page 3: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Site Location

3

Eastern Cumberland Plateau Escarpment separating Valley and Ridge and Cumberland Plateau

City of Rockwood

Page 4: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___April 2017 Aerial Photo looking East at MM342

4

WB I-40

EB I-40

Approx. slide limits

Construction Access Road

Page 5: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Cross-Section through Slide

5

Pennington Fm.

Newnan Limestone

Gizzard Group

Page 6: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Outline of Presentation History of slide

Desktop review & subsurface investigation

Short-term remediation in 2010-2011

Key findings & conclusions

Long term options & recommendations

Selected option and the 2018 geotechnical program

6

Page 7: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Original Construction-1968

3

Page 8: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Other Slides on Rockwood Mountain

3

Pennington Fm.

Page 9: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972,

1974, and 1994 Geomembrane-lined ditches installed in 1990’s Slope inclinometers installed 1974 and 2003

9

Horizontal drain fan

Page 10: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Project History 1976-2009

~0.5 in/yr from 1976-2009

TDOT retained Golder in 2009 for review of files

10

Page 11: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Desk Study and Geologic Mapping Historic headscarps Topographic bulge Colluvial lobes

dissected topographic bulge

Page 12: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___

9

Desk Study and Geologic Mapping

Page 13: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Interpreted Geologic Model

10

Roc

kwoo

d Th

rust

Pennington – slide-prone formation in TN & GA

Gizzard Group

Newnan Limestone

Page 14: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Inclinometer Installation-2010

14

Page 15: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Subsurface & Instrumentation Cross Section A-A

15

Page 16: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Short-Term Remediation - Dewatering

16

All water piped and discharged here

Page 17: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

4.5

5.0

Annu

al P

reci

pita

tion

(inch

es)

Cum

ulat

ive

Incl

inom

eter

Dis

plac

emen

t (in

ches

)

Year

Composite Cumulative Displacement of Inclinometer and Yearly Precipitation

17

Wel

ls c

ompl

eted

Wel

l adj

ustm

ents

st

arte

d

Page 18: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Key Findings & Conclusions Roadway embankment construction in 1968 exacerbated on-going creep landslide

Sliding is within Pennington Shale at depth of more than 70 ft below embankment toe

Movement has slowed to ~0.1 in/yr since April 2014 (when adjustments to pumps started)

Total movement since 2011 has been about 2 inches

Incremental movement has been larger in years with higher annual rainfall

Movement likely to continue indefinitely

Performance to date suggest catastrophic movement is unlikely

Slide has progressed eastward since 1969 & recently northward near Westbound lanes, and may continue

Slide extends downhill below inclinometers

18

Page 19: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Options - EarthworkRe-alignment of I-40

Construct new westbound lanes

Relocate eastbound lanes onto current westbound lanes

High probability of triggering multiple landslides

Toe berm or buttress

Key imported earth into toe of slide

May require relocating local roads below I-40

Additional investigation needed to delineate extent of slide

Risk of new slide daylighting above or below berm or buttress; thus, not considered feasible

19

Page 20: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Options – Drainage

20

Page 21: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Options – Ground Anchors

21

Page 22: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Options: Reticulated Micropiles

22

Page 23: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Options: Status Quo with Risk Mitigation Measures

Delineate extent of slide

Dewatering system

Inclinometers

Remote monitoring

Emergency action plan

Miscellaneous

23

Page 24: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___Summary of Long-Term Options Earthwork

Groundwater drainage

Ground anchors

Reticulated micropiles

Status quo with risk mitigation measures

24

Page 25: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___2018 Geotechnical Program

25

Page 26: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___2018 Geotechnical Program

26

• 14 Boreholes and Inclinometer Casing

• PQ Drilling

• 2.75-inch Casing

• Geologic Mapping

• New Lidar Data Review

• Evaluate Effect of Additional Drains

• Plan for Remote Monitoring

S L I D E D E L I N E AT I O N A N D E VA L U AT I O N

CONTINUED PUMP IMPROVEMENT

CONTINUED INCLINOMETER MONITORING

Page 27: Interstate 40 Landslide Evaluation...Project History 1974 - 2003 East-bound lanes opened in 1974 Horizontal drains, trench drains and dewatering wells installed in 1968, 1972, 1974,

___

275

Thank You