irac organization - florida coastal school of law - ira… · · 2016-08-19irac organization...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
IRACORGANIZATION
EXAMPLES
1
![Page 2: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
IRAC
• IRAC(Issue,Rule,Analysis,andConclusion)formsthefundamentalbuildingblocksoflegalanalysis.Itistheprocessbywhichalllawyersthinkaboutanylegalproblem.ThebeautyofIRACisthatitallowsyoutoreducethecomplexiLesofthelawtoasimpleequaLon.
• ISSUE‐>WhatfactsandcircumstancesbroughttheseparLestocourt?
• RULE‐>Whatisthegoverninglawfortheissue?• ANALYSIS‐>Doestheruleapplytotheseuniquefacts?• CONCLUSION‐>Howdoesthecourt'sholdingmodifythe
ruleoflaw?
2
![Page 3: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
ISSUESPOTTING:STEPONE• "ThefactsofacasesuggestanIssue."• ThekeytoissuespoXngisbeingabletoidenLfywhichfactsraise
whichissues.Becauseofthecomplexityofthelaw,theeliminaLonoraddiLonofonefact(suchasLmeofdayorwhethersomeonewasdrinking)caneliminateoraddissuestoacasetherebyraisinganenLrelydifferentruleoflaw.
• Inlawschoolcasebooks,theeasiestwaytoisolatetheissueistomerelylookatthechapterheadingsofthecases,suchas"PersonalJurisdicLon"inCivilProcedureor"OfferandAcceptance"inContracts.Thecasesyoureadwillalsocontainlanguagethatsignalstheimportantissue.Forinstance,thejudgewillsimplystate:
• "Thecaseturnsupontheques?onwhether...."OR"Wecomethentothebasicissueinthecase."
3
![Page 4: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
ISSUESPOTTINGCON’T
• Ques)onstoaskwhenreadingacase:• WhatfactsandcircumstancesbroughttheseparLestocourt?
• Aretherebuzzwordsinthefactsthatsuggestanissue?
• Isthecourtdecidingaques?onoffact‐i.e.theparLesareindisputeoverwhathappened‐orisitaques?onoflaw‐i.e.thecourtisunsurewhichruletoapplytothesefacts?
• Whatarethenon‐issues?
4
![Page 5: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
RULE
• Rule‐WhatistheLaw?• "TheissueiscoveredbyaRuleoflaw."• Simplyput,theruleisthelaw.Therulecouldbecommonlawthatwasdevelopedbythecourtsoralawthatwaspassedbythelegislature.
5
![Page 6: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
RULECON’T
• Ques)onstoaskwhenreadingacase:• Whataretheelementsthatprovetherule?
• Whataretheexcep?onstotherule?
• Fromwhatauthoritydoesitcome?Commonlaw,statute,newrule?
• What'stheunderlyingpublicpolicybehindtherule?
• Aretheresocialconsidera?ons?6
![Page 7: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
ANALYSIS‐THEARTOFLAWYERING
• "ComparethefactstotheruletoformtheAnalysis."• ThisimportantareaisreallyrelaLvelysimple.Foreveryrelevantfact,youneedtoaskwhetherthefacthelpstoproveordisprovetherule.Ifarulerequiresthatacertaincircumstanceispresentinorderfortheruletoapply,thentheabsenceofthatcircumstancehelpsyoureachtheconclusionthattheruledoesnotapply.Forinstance,allcontractsforthesaleofgoodsover$500havetobeinwriLng.Consequently,inanalyzingacontractforthesaleofgoods,youapplythepresenceorabsenceoftwofacts‐worthofgoodandwhetherthere'sawriiencontract‐inordertoseewhethertheruleholdstrue.
7
![Page 8: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
AnalysisCon’t
• Ques)onstoaskwhenreadingacase:• Whichfactshelpprovewhichelementsoftherule?
• Whyarecertainfactsrelevant?• HowdothesefactssaLsfythisrule?• Whattypesoffactsareappliedtotherule?• Howdothesefactsfurtherthepublicpolicyunderlyingthisrule?
• What'sthecounter‐argumentforanothersoluLon?
8
![Page 9: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
CONCLUSION–TAKINGAPOSITION
• "FromtheanalysisyoucometoaConclusionastowhethertheruleappliestothefacts."
• TheconclusionistheshortestpartoftheequaLon.Itcanbeasimple"yes"or"no"astowhethertheruleappliestoasetoffacts.Aprofessorwillonengiveyouasetoffactsthatcouldgoeitherwayinordertoseehowwellyouanalyzeadifficultissue.ThemistakemanystudentsmakeistonevertakeaposiLononewayortheotheronanissue.MostprofessorswantyoutotakeaposiLonandsupportitinordertoseehowwellyouanalyze.
9
![Page 10: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
CONCLUSION–TAKINGAPOSITION
• Ques)onstoaskwhenreadingacase:• What'stheholdingofthecase?• Hastheholdingmodifiedtheexis?ngruleoflaw?• Whatistheproceduraleffectoftheholding?Isthecaseoverturned,upheldorremandedforretrial?
• Doestheholdingfurthertheunderlyingpolicyoftherule?
• Doyouagreewiththeoutcomeofthecase?
10
![Page 11: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
IRACTRIAD
• IRACisagoodmodel.However,inthepressureoftheexam,manystudentsleaveoutthemostimportantpartoftheequaLon‐theanalysis.Inordertoillustratetheimportantoftheanalysis,I'vemodifiedthetradiLonalmodelintowhatIcalltheIRACTriad.
•
11
![Page 12: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
IRACTRIADCON’T
• TheIRACTriademphasizestheAnalysisbyusingtheFacts,IssueandRuleasbuildingblocks.TheAnalysisistheendproductandprimarygoaloftheIRACTriad,buttherolethatfactsplayinformingtheanalysisishighlighted.
• Step1:ThefactsofacasesuggestanIssue.• Thelegalissuewouldnotexistunlesssomeeventoccurred.• Step2:TheissueisgovernedbyaRuleoflaw.• Theissuemechanicallydetermineswhatruleisapplied.• Step3:ComparethefactstotheruletoformtheAnalysis.• DothefactssaLsfytherequirementsoftherule?• TheTriadisactuallyjustasimpleflowchartinwhichthe
factscanbepigeonholedintoaConclusion.
12
![Page 13: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
ContractsHypotheLcal:FACTS
• Facts:• Anoldmanwhoisveryillandneardeathmakesanoralcontractwithhisnephew.Thetermsofthecontractarethattheunclewillimmediatelygivehisnephewallofhislifesavings‐$100,000‐inreturnforthenephew'spromisetoprovidefoodandshelterfortheoldmanunLlthemandies.Thenephewtakesthemoneyandsupportstheoldmanatacostof$10,000ayear.TheoldmanliveslongerthanexpectedandissLllaliveanerfineenyears,atwhichpointthenephewcutstheoldmanoffwithoutfurthersupport.
13
![Page 14: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
ISSUE?
14
![Page 15: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Issue
Is an oral contract valid after fifteen years? Note that the issue is stated in the form of a question and uses key facts to illustrate the problem. Don't be alarmed if you didn't see the issue right away. By reading case law in contracts, you will learn that these sorts of factual situations give rise to issues surrounding whether a contract is valid.
15
![Page 16: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
RULE?
16
![Page 17: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Rule
A contract must be in writing if it is not possible to perform the contract within one year. - Statute of Frauds The issue immediately triggers the appropriate rule. Again, the appropriate rules are something that you will learn in your first year of contract law.
17
![Page 18: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
ANALYSIS?
18
![Page 19: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Analysis
The Statute of Frauds does not state that the contract must be performed within one year. It only states that it must be possible to complete the contract within a year. Since a very ill, old man could have died within one year, it is possible that the contract could have been completed. This analysis shows how closely you must pay attention to the wording of a rule. The words "not possible" indicate that a remote possibility of being able to complete the contract means the rule does not apply. 19
![Page 20: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
CONCLUSION?
20
![Page 21: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Conclusion
• TheStatuteofFraudsprobablydoesnotapplyinthesecircumstances,andtheoralcontractisnotinvalideventhoughitwasnotcompletedwithinoneyear.
• Conclusionsshouldbeshortandputintermsofaprobability.
21
![Page 22: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
CivilProcedureHypothe)calFacts:
• 1.PatriciasuesDanielinfederaldistrictcourtovermoneythatshesaysheowesher.
• 2.Shewinshercase.• 3.Danielappealsthedecisioninthefederalappellatecourt,whichoverturnsthelowercourt'sdecisiononatechnicalerror.
• 4.PatriciaappealstotheU.S.SupremeCourt,andthecourtrefusestohearthecase.
• 5.PatriciaaiemptstosueDanielasecondLmeinthestatecourtsystemoverthesameissueofthemoneyshesaysheowesher.
22
![Page 23: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
ISSUE?
23
![Page 24: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Issue
• DoesthefactthatPatriciatookhercasetothehighestfederalcourtandlostpreventherfromstarLngthesamecaseinastatecourt?
• CivilProcedureques?onsquitenaturallyfocusonwhetheraplain?ffordefendanthascorrectlyfollowedtherulesinbringingacasetocourt.CivilProceduregenerallydoesnotfocusonthesubstanceofthedispute‐i.e.whethertheplain?ffordefendantwins.
24
![Page 25: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
RULE?
25
![Page 26: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Rule
• TheprincipleofresjudicatastatesthatonceafinaljudgmentonthemeritshasbeenmadeonaparLcularcase,theplainLffisbarredfrombringingthatsamecaseagainstthesamedefendantinthesameordifferentcourt.
26
![Page 27: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
ANALYSIS?
27
![Page 28: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Analysis
• SincePatriciaappealedthecasetothehighestcourt,afinaljudgmentisconsideredtohavebeenmadeonthemaier.ShehasexhaustedallofthepotenLalappealsbygoingtothehighestcourtwhichhasruledonhercase.IfsheaiemptstobringthesamecauseofacLon(i.e.thesameparLcularfactsandcontroversy)instatecourt,thenDanielcanarguetohavethecasethrownoutofcourtusingtheprincipleofresjudicata.
28
![Page 29: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
CONCLUSION?
29
![Page 30: IRAC ORGANIZATION - Florida Coastal School of Law - IRA… · · 2016-08-19IRAC ORGANIZATION EXAMPLES 1 ... product and primary goal of the IRAC Triad, but the role that](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022051800/5acdd24c7f8b9aad468e6051/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Conclusion
• Patriciacannotbringthecaseinstatecourt.
30