isic2015_full paper - 8 - dhenny yuartha junifta - aji nur afifatul hasna - meirna puspita...

Upload: meirna

Post on 01-Mar-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/26/2019 ISIC2015_Full Paper - 8 - Dhenny Yuartha Junifta - Aji Nur Afifatul Hasna - Meirna Puspita Permatasari.doc

    1/10

    15thIndonesian Scholars International Convention

    London, 3 - 4 October 2015

    TRADITIONAL VILLAGES INVOLVEMENT: A REFLECTION OF TRI HITA KARANA

    FOR TOURISM STRATEGY IN BALI

    DHENNY YUARTHA JUNIFTA

    Department of Economics Development

    AJI N. AFIFATUL HASNA, !EIRNA ".

    "ER!ATASARI

    Department of Acco#ntin$

    %ra&i'a(a Universit( %ra&i'a(a Universit(

    !alan$, !T Har(ono )*+ !alan$, !T Har(ono )*+

    INDNESIA

    -enn(.(#arta.)/0$mail.com

    INDNESIA

    a'in#rafifa0$mail.com

    meirna.p#spita0$mail.com

    ABSTRACT

    To#rism -evelopment, in te lon$ term, &ill potentiall( $ive ne$ative impact an- remove local val#es.

    In or-er to protect te e1istence of local val#es, %ali partic#larl( possesses tra-itional villa$es

    f#nctione- to preserve te e2#alit( of 3o-, #man, an- nat#re as &ell as 4ein$ reflecte- in Tri Hita

    Karanaconcept. Tis researc aims to o4serve te pro4lems in s(ner$i5in$ local val#es an- to#rism

    -evelopment in %ali. A-optin$ 2#alitative approac, tere &ere primar( an- secon-ar( -ata o4taine-

    tro#$ literat#re revie&s. Te res#lt of tis researc so&s tat %ali is still lac6 of tra-itional villa$es

    involvement in creatin$ to#rism -evelopment plan. Economical rationalit( remains as te 4asic of all

    performe- to#rism -evelopment activities. Hence, Tri Hita Karana concept m#st imme-iatel( 4e

    revive- 4( involvin$ tra-itional villa$es in constr#ctin$ s#staina4le to#rism -evelopment strate$(.

    Keywords7 To#rism, Tra-itional 8illa$es, Tri Hita Karana

    1. INTRODUCTION

    As te main to#rism -estination in In-onesia, it is inevita4le for %ali to -eal &it vario#s to#rism

    iss#es. Several literat#res a$ree tat to#rism as 4een lar$el( contri4#tin$ to s#pport economic $ro&t

    9An-ra5, Nelia, an- Norte, :;)+< =atircio$l#, :;;>< =im, ?en, an- Jan$, :;;*< Lee an- ?an$,

    :;;/@ as te catal(st to re-#cin$ povert( an- provi-in$ 4enefits for p#4lic 4( #pscalin$ pro-#ctivit(

    an- emplo(ment 9St(li-is an- !atina, :;)< An-ra5, Nelia, an- H#$o, :;)+< Beinali, et.al, :;)+@. It

    is visi4le tat te n#m4er of to#rism sector contri4#tion to raisin$ Re$ional 3ross Domestic "ro-#ct

    9R3D"@ of %ali &ic is al&a(s a4ove C; from te total amo#nt. Te si$nificant n#m4er is lifte- #p

    4( te ten-enc( of te n#m4er of to#rists an- o& te( allocate teir mone( for spen-in$ eac -a(

    9%"S, :;)@.

    At te oter an-, to#rism also 4rin$s ne$ative infl#ence 9%esc#li-es, !arta, an- "eter :;;:@.Te open an- interactive caracter of to#rism en- #p &it 4oostin$ c#lt#ral assimilations

    9S#r&i(anta, :;;C@. To#rism, at first, $ives positive impact to&ar-s econom( an- #plifts te level of

    participation of societ(, (et it is not $#arantee- to last for an( lon$er perio-. Te fact is tat to#rism

    creates social e1ternalit( &ic apparentl( infl#ences societ( 9"ict#re )@ 9Do1e(, )>*< %#tler )>/;>@. Te interaction patterns #ltimatel( affect te &a( people tin6 an- 4eave so tat it sapes te

    sacre-, socialoriente-, an- localval#e4ase- caracters of te %alinese societ(. In te en-, te

    armon( of tree elements of Tri Hita Karanaol-s important roles in creatin$ a peacef#l life an- a

    p(sical (et spirit#al prosperit(.

    Fi$#re :7 Te role of tra-itional villa$es in %ali

    /.).*ow Be%des# Ad#$ 0er&e"2e T!e"r Roe "% Dr#+$"%' Re'u#$"o%s #%d Cre#$"%' Sus$#"%#,e

    Tour"s( De2eo(e%$ "% B#"

    endesa dat is 4asicall( a lea-er of a societ( &o is responsi4le for te preservation of tra-itional

    val#es. Te perception of endesa datconcernin$ is role in -raftin$ te re$#lation an- creatin$

    to#rism -evelopment plan can 4e seen from te follo&in$ secon-ar( -ata o4taine- 4( previo#s

    researcer. He con-#cte- a researc to some sample o#t of ),+C total pop#lation of te most

    representative endesa dat. Accor-in$ to Saras intervie& res#lt of is -issertation, tere &ere

    appro1imatel( **.* of respon-ents to#$t tat te( &ere not a-e2#atel( involve- in terms of

    re$#lation-raftin$ an- to#rismplannin$ process ); (ears a$o. !ean&ile, te percenta$e of

    #ninvolve-endesa dats perception elevate- to + five (ears a$o.

  • 7/26/2019 ISIC2015_Full Paper - 8 - Dhenny Yuartha Junifta - Aji Nur Afifatul Hasna - Meirna Puspita Permatasari.doc

    5/10

    !ni"ta, Hasna, #er$atasari

    Fi$#re C7 "erception of endesa dat re$ar-in$ to teir involvement in -raftin$ re$#lations an-

    creatin$ to#rism -evelopment plan in %ali

    So!rce. Sara, 2014

    Te fin-in$ a4ove so&s tat tere is still lac6 of s(ner$( amon$ tra-itional villa$es an-

    to#rism -evelopment, &ile in fact, tra-itional villa$es ave 4een 4ein$ important part in societ(. Aste impact of tis con-ition, #nfavora4le conflicts appens in vario#s locations in %ali s#c as lan-

    o&nersip -isp#tes, socioc#lt#ral an- investment licensin$ conflict, an- te -e$ra-ation of

    environment. In te oter &or-s, te to#rism -evelopment in %ali t#rns o#t to 4e lac6 of

    caracteristics.

    . DISCUSSION

    .1.0ro,e(s Resu$ed Due $o T!e A,s&e%&e o+ Sy%er'y ,e$wee% Tr#d"$"o%# V"#'es #%d

    Tour"s( De2eo(e%$ "% B#".

    A caracterise- -evelopment in %ali ma( onl( 4e attaine- if teto#rism sector Kas te ma'or

    contri4#tor of re$ional economic $ro&t is a4le to &or6 in s(ner$( &it tra-itional villa$e as te$#ar-ian of local val#es an- tra-itional caracters. Eac polic( relate- to to#rism -evelopment is

    ma-e 4( te a$reement an- consens#s consists of te $overnment, societ( 9tra-itional villa$e societ(@,

    an- investors 9"arson, :;;+@. Te lac6 of s(ner$( 4e&een tose tree parties ma( res#lt in te

    removal of te -istinctive caracters of to#rism in %ali. Te follo&in$ list are some conflicts referre-

    as te in-icator of te can$in$ circ#mstances s#c as7

    ). ?ommerciali5ation of sacre- c#lt#re elements s#c as reli$io#s rit#als an- &orsip places

    :. Te -e$ra-ation of point of vie& an- te orientation of %alinese societ( from mo-est(, pr#-ence,

    an- sanctit( to profitoriente-. Tere ave 4een man( conflicts appene- #n-er tis circ#mstance.

    Te re$ional a#torit( of %ali as recor-e- )): attac6s too6 place in tra-itional villa$es.

    C. Dissensions a4o#t lan-o&nersip an- investment licensin$

    Te a4scence of s(ner$( is initiall( ca#se- 4( te contra-ictor( feat#res of to#rism a$ainst telocal val#es. Tis iss#e is relate- to te concept of to#rism tat is more mo-ern an- international tan

    tra-itional local c#lt#re. To#rism is even calle- as $lo4al capitalism 9?apra, :;;@ 4eca#se it is in line

    &it te economic rationalit( s#c as $ro&t, e-onism, materialism, in-ivi-#alism, an- te overri-e

    of norms. Tose are o4vio#sl( -ifferent &it te local caracteristics &ic ten- to 4e more sacre-,

    participationoriente-, p(sical an- spirit#al prosperit(oriente- an- to$eterness an- #sef#lness.

  • 7/26/2019 ISIC2015_Full Paper - 8 - Dhenny Yuartha Junifta - Aji Nur Afifatul Hasna - Meirna Puspita Permatasari.doc

    6/10

    !ni"ta, Hasna, #er$atasari

    Fi$#re 7 Te -ifferences amon$ caracteristics of 3lo4al 8al#e an- Local 8al#e

    Alon$s &it te contra-ictor( feat#res of 4ot $lo4al val#es an- local val#es, anoter pro4lem

    tat ma6es tra-itional villa$es 4ecome less involve- in -raftin$ re$#lations an- creatin$ to#rism

    -evelopment plan is tri$$erre- 4( teir o&n internal an- e1ternal factors 9Sara, :;)@. Te

    e1planation of te factors are -etaile- as follo&s7

    ). Internal factor

    Tere are t&o main pro4lems, te( are -iver$ent #n-erstan-in$ of localval#es perception an-

    to#rism -evelopment. Eac tra-itional villa$e as -ifferent vision an- mission of to#rism-evelopment. Some of tem ass#me tat to#rism -evelopment so#l- f#n-amentall( 4e 4ase- on

    te preseverance of local val#es an- c#lt#re, an- te oters ass#me tat te to#rism -evelopment

    is onl( aime- to $ain more economical profit. T#s, it is -iffic#lt to #nite tese -ifferent

    perspectives. Te $overnment ten ass#mes tat it is not efficient for tra-itional villa$es to $et

    involve- in -raftin$ te re$#lation an- te plan of to#rism -evelopment.

    :. E1ternal factor

    Gile te internal factor as ca#se- some comple1 -iffic#lties, te e1ternal factor, in tis case te

    le$islative an- e1ec#tive, someo& ma6e te sit#ation &orse. Te( apparentl( ave lo&

    #n-erstan-in$ a4o#t te to#rim -evelopment strate$( an- te importance of tra-itional villa$es

    involvement.

    Fi$#re +7 Factors tat in-er te s(ner$( 4et&een tra-itional villa$es an- to#rism -evelopment in

    %ali.

    So!rce. Sara, 2014

    .). I("$"o%s $ow#rds C!#r#&$er"sed E&o%o(y #%d Tour"s( De2eo(e%$ S$r#$e'y

    To-a(s to#rism -evelopment in %ali is r#n 4ase- on economic rationalit( an- -espite all te

    commercial s#ccesses, tere is still lac6 of accommo-ation for tra-itional villa$e as a localval#es

    c#sto-ian instit#tion. A co#ntr(, in carr(in$ o#t its o4li$ation on rational f#nction, m#st also perform

  • 7/26/2019 ISIC2015_Full Paper - 8 - Dhenny Yuartha Junifta - Aji Nur Afifatul Hasna - Meirna Puspita Permatasari.doc

    7/10

    !ni"ta, Hasna, #er$atasari

    etical f#nction in en$a$in$ all constit#ents to e1perience e2#al mo4ilit( an- pro$ress 9Y#sti6a,

    :;;>@. In a--ition, efforts an- strate$( are re2#ire- to 4#il- s(ner$( 4et&een to#rism an- local val#e

    arran$ements. Te strate$( proposition involves te reflection of Tri Hita Karana pilosop( to

    create a s#staina4le to#rism strate$( for %ali. Te &a( to appl( te Tri Hita Karana in or-er to

    revitali5e te tra-itional instit#tion is 4( creatin$ teams consist of7

    ). Te 3eneral Assem4l( of#a%ra$an8illa$e 93A"8@

    An e1istin$ comm#nication for#m amon$ %alinese societ(. 3A"8 &ill later represent local

    comm#nit( consi-erin$ its 4etter compreension a4o#t socioc#lt#ral con-ition.

    :. 3overnment

    Te polic( ma6er at te level of re$#latin$ an- creatin$ to#rism -evelopment plan in %ali

    C. ?#lt#ral o4server

    An e1pert in socioc#lt#ral o4servation sets to 4e te a-visor of $overnment an- "a6raman

    villa$e relate- to te occ#rence of contin#o#s effects of to#rism an- local val#es.

    Te en$a$ement of tree parties is e1pecte- to a--ress properl( all s#4'ects re$ar-in$ to te

    s(ner$( of to#rism -evelopment an- local val#es. Te main -#t( of te a4ovementione- parties is to

    elp copin$ &it to#rism -evelopment pro4lems tat emer$e internall( or e1ternall( s#c as7

    ). Increasin$ capacit( of %en-esa A-at in terms of econom(, social, c#lt#re, an- or$ani5ation.

    ?onse2#entl(, te e1pecte- o#tp#t &ill 4e te 4etter min-set of tra-itional villa$e in interpretin$c#lt#re an- -evelopment. In a--ition, te constraint of tra-itional villa$e -iverse- -evelopment

    perceptives can 4e solve-.

    :. Up$ra-in$ te role of te 3eneral Assem4l( of #a%ra$an 8illa$e 93A"8@ to te level of

    re$#lator( an- to#rism -evelopment plannin$ an- ali$nin$ te perspective of le$islative an-

    e1ec#tive 4oar- of te re$ion to&ar-s te essence of tra-itional

    8illa$e e1istence. In or-er to ma6e tis strate$( &or6, tere m#st 4e an effort to stren$ten te

    comm#nication for#m 4et&een te $overnment an- tra-itional villa$es.

    C. Investment mappin$ performe- 4( c#lt#ral o4server an- te 3eneral Assem4l( of #a%ra$an

    8illa$e 93A"8@. As so&n in te c#rrent con-ition, investment is te prominent instr#ment to

    4oost #p to#rism -evelopment in %ali. Noneteless, te c#rrent #n-erta6en investments still foc#s

    on te $ro&t aspect. nl( a fe& of tem -eli4eratel( ta6e c#lt#ral aspects into acco#nt.

    Terefore, investment mappin$ 4( c#lt#ral o4server an- 3A"8 is #r$entl( re2#ire- toaccommo-ate 4ot economic an- c#lt#ral interests. In tis case, c#lt#ral o4server an- tra-itional

    villa$e representatives o#$t to con-#ct a st#-( a4o#t pro$ro&t an- proc#lt#re investments as

    &ell as te effects te com4ination ma( carr( o#t &it. Te res#lt of te st#-( &ill 4e te

    recommen-ation for te $overnment to -eci-e an incl#sive investment polic(.

    Fi$#re *7 Strate$( recommen-ation to perform caracterise- an- s#staina4le to#rism -evelopment

  • 7/26/2019 ISIC2015_Full Paper - 8 - Dhenny Yuartha Junifta - Aji Nur Afifatul Hasna - Meirna Puspita Permatasari.doc

    8/10

    !ni"ta, Hasna, #er$atasari

    Te implementation of te propose- to#rism -evelopment strate$( can $ive positive impacts,

    especiall( in t&o matters. First, te s(ner$( 4et&een tra-itional villa$es, $overnment, an- investors

    9to#rism in-#str(@ as te controller of c#lt#ral an- economic -istri4#tion. Te $overnment an- societ(

    &ill cooperate to s#pervise te investments an- 6eep tem ali$ne- &it local val#es. For economic

    -istri4#tion p#rpose, investors are o4li$e- to $ive 4enefits to te rate of emplo(ment an- Small an-

    !e-i#m Enterprises 9S!Es@. Ne1t, accomo-atin$ economic interests an- local val#e implications is

    te positive impact contri4#te- 4( te s(ner$( 4et&een local societ(, $overnment,an- te investors.

    Fi$#re 7 Te effect of s#staina4le to#rism strate$( implementation to&ar-s te s(ner$( of societ(,

    $overnment, an- investors.

    Te secon- impact namel( to increase te empo&erment of te comm#nit(. Implementation

    of caracterise- -evelopment strate$( enco#ra$es all components of societ(, $overnment, an-

    investors to acieve 4etter learnin$, monitorin$, an- improvements. All components &ill 4e ena4le-

    to -emonstrate critical 4eavio#r in -ealin$ &it can$es. S#c con-ition ma( later tri$$er te

    enancement in or$ani5ational $overnance, capacit( an- more resilient local $eni#ses.

    Fi$#re /7 Te impact of caracterise- -evlopment strate$( implementation to&ar- societ(

    empo&erment

    So!rce. / Siani)ar, etal, di$odi"i%asi, 2013

    3. CONCLUSIONS

    To#rism &it all its open an- interactive caraceristics as asserte- te ris6 of conflicts an- local

    val#es siftin$ in %ali. In or-er to solve te pro4lems, %ali re2#ires a ne& 4etter strate$(. Te term of

    strate$( ere is meant &it caracterise- -evelopment strate$(, a com4ination of to#rism

    -evelopment an- tra-itional villa$es or #a%ra$aninvolvement as te local val#e maintainer. As a

  • 7/26/2019 ISIC2015_Full Paper - 8 - Dhenny Yuartha Junifta - Aji Nur Afifatul Hasna - Meirna Puspita Permatasari.doc

    9/10

    !ni"ta, Hasna, #er$atasari

    &a( to implement te strate$(, tra-itional villa$es m#st 4e involve- in re$#lator( level an- to#rism

    -evelopment plannin$ activities.

    As te 4asis of $overnmental implementation, te tra-itional villa$es, is &ell a&are of te

    concept of Tri Hita Karanaor tree ca#ses of &elfare &ic can 4e ac6no&le-e$e- 4( 6eepin$ te

    e2#alit( of "ara(an$an 93o-@, "a&on$an 9#man@, an- "alemaan 9nat#re@. Tra-itional villa$es

    4ecome important in %ali since teir e1istence are aime- to create sacre-, participative, social

    oriente-, an- p(sicall( (et sprit#all( prospero#s as te main caracteristics of %alinese societ(. Te

    implication of te caracteristics &ill res#lt in S!%erta'a$a9a state of a peacef#l life as te o#tcome

    of reli$io#s practices@ an- Tata Tentra$ Kertarahar*a9a peacef#l an- prospero#s societ(@ in %ali.

    Neverteless, in -ail( practices, tra-itional villa$es are often not 4ein$ involve- in -raftin$

    te to#rism re$#lation or creatin$ to#rism -evelopment plan. T&o factors are 4elieve- to 4e te ca#se

    of tis circ#mstance. Te first is te contra-ictor( feat#res of to#rism a$ainst local val#es an- te

    secon- is certain internal an- e1ternal intricacies &itin te tra-itional villa$es. Referrin$ to te

    pro4lems, te most appropriate strate$( 4ein$ recommen-e- to attain caracterise- to#rism

    -evelopment is to revitali5e te role of tra-itional villa$es in %ali. An instit#tion consists of te

    3eneral Assem4l( of#a%ra$an8illa$e 93A"8@, $overnment, an- investors &ill elp restorin$ te

    role of tra-itional villa$es.

    Te last 4#t not least, tere are positive implications &ic are -escri4e- 4( tree points.First, te implication from caracterise- -evelopment strate$( implementation s#c as7 9)@ te

    s(ner$( of societ(, $overnment, an- to#rism in-#str( to control te c#lt#ral an- economic

    -istri4#tion< an- 9:@ te impact of te increase of societ( empo&erment. Secon-, tis researc can 4e

    #se- 4( te $overnment as te f#n-amental men# of te s#staina4le to#rism polic( preparation in

    %ali. Tir-, te 4enefit in terms of science is propose- 4( provi-in$ $reater insi$ts a4o#t te

    e1istence of c#lt#re in to#rism -evelopment an- its importance. Tere ave 4een a lot of researces

    &ic concern &it to#rism -evelopment recentl(, (et not all of tem clearl( o4serve te

    contra-ictor( feat#res of to#rism a$ainst te local val#es. Te researcers tat notice to#rism onl(

    from te economical rationalit( &ill res#lt in profitoriente- polic( &ic act#all( treaten te local

    val#es. T#s, it 4ecomes important for 4ot aca-emician an- polic( ma6er to see to#rism

    -evelopment from &i-er point of vie&.

    ACKNO4LEDGEMENTS

    Te a#tors &o#l- li6e to $ive sincere tan6s to all people &o $enero#sl( contri4#te- to te &or6

    presente- in tis paper. Special mention $oes to !rs. 8ir$inia N#r Ramanti, SE., !SA, not onl( for

    er tremen-o#s aca-emic s#pport, 4#t also for $ivin$ #s a-vise an- s#$$estion. Similarl(, profo#n-

    $ratit#-e $oes to I !a-e Sara &o $ives #s opport#nit( to 'oin te researc -isertation tat inspires #s

    to &rite tis paper. Anoter special mention $oes to Salsa4ila Sasmi for all er elps. F"%#y5 ,u$ ,y

    %o (e#%s e#s$5 $!#%6s 'o $o A#! S4T #%d our +#("y +or # &o%$"%uous suor$.

    REFERENCES

    Asti6a, =et#t S#-ana. )>>C. Konse)si Tri Hita Karana dala$ Kehid!)an n''ota an*arr diKota$ad&a en)asar. s!at! analisis des%ri)ti" tentan' nilai dan $a%na %esei$ban'an

    dala$ %ehid!)an $as&ara%at %ota. Sosiolo$i, Fa6#ltas Ilm# Sosial -an Ilm# "oliti6,

    Universitas In-onesia

    An-ra5, J.!., N. !. Norte., an- H. 3. 3oncalves. :;)+. ""ect o" To!ris$ on e'ional s&$$etries.

    $)irical evidence "or #ort!'al. Jo#rnal of To#rism !ana$ement +; 9:+:*@

    %a-an p#sat statisti6. :;).ali ala$ n'%a. "rovinsi %ali7 %"S

    %as#6i, S#list(o. :;);./etode #enelitian Ja6arta 7 "ena6#

    %esc#li-es, Antonia., !arta, E. L., "eter, J. !. :;;:.esidents #erce)tions o" the C!lt!ral ene"its

    o" To!ris$. Annals of To#rism Researc, 8ol :>, No. :, pp. C;CC)>

    %#tler, R. G. )>/;. The Conce)t o" To!rist rea C&cle o" evol!tion. I$)lications "or /ana'e$ent o"

    eso!rces. Jo#rnal of ?ana-ian 3eo$raper, I8, I

    ?apra, F. :;;. The Hidden Connections. Strate'i Siste$i% /ela(an Ka)italis$e ar! . Yo$(a6arta7

    Jalas#tra

  • 7/26/2019 ISIC2015_Full Paper - 8 - Dhenny Yuartha Junifta - Aji Nur Afifatul Hasna - Meirna Puspita Permatasari.doc

    10/10

    !ni"ta, Hasna, #er$atasari

    ?ao, ?. ?., %arat R. H., an- "as2#ale !. S. :;;. To!ris$, lobaliation, Social 6ternalities, and

    o$estic 7el"are. Jo#rnal of Researc in International %#siness an- Finance )/ 9)))>@

    Do1e(, 3.8. )>*. 7hen eno!'h is eno!'h. The 8atives are restless in Old 8ia'ara Herita$e

    ?ana-a, No. :, pp. :*:.

    3eria, I. G. )>>C.#ari(isata dan ina$i%a Keb!da&aan Lo%al, 8asional, dan lobal. Denpasar7 "T.

    Upa-a Sastra

    Hi-a(at, S(arif#-in, an- Se-arma(anti. :;;:./etode #enelitian %an-#n$ 7 !an-ar !a'#

    =atircio$l#, S. T. :;;>.evisitin' the to!ris$-led-'ro(th h&)othesis "or T!r%e& !sin' the bo!nds test

    and ohansen a))roach "or cointe'ration. To#rism !ana$ement, C;9)@, )e:;.

    =im, H. J., ?en, !., an- Jan$, S. S. :;;*. To!ris$ e6)ansion and econo$ic develo)$ent. the case

    o" Tai(an To!ris$ /ana'e$ent. :9+@, >:+e>CC.

    Lee, ?., an- ?an$, ?. :;;/. To!ris$ develo)$ent and econo$ic 'ro(th. a closer loo% at )anels.

    To#rism !ana$ement, :>9)@, )/;e)>:.

    "arson, Ga(ne. :;;+. #!blic #olic&. #en'antar Teori dan #ra%ti% nalisis Kebi*a%an. Ja6arta7

    "rena-a !e-ia

    "erat#ran Daera "rovinsi %ali Nomor )* Ta#n :;;> Tentan$ Rencana Tata R#an$ Gila(a "rovinsi

    %ali Ta#n :;;>:;:>

    Santosa, E-( Y#s#f N. S. :;;C.#eran esa dat ala$ #e$ban'!nan #ari(isata di ali Apli6asi,J#rnal Apli6asi Ilm#ilm# A$ama, 8ol I8, No. : Desem4er :;;C7 :;::)

    Sara, I !a-e. :;). #eranan esa dat dala$ #e$ban'!nan #ari(isata. Kas!s di ali Seba'ai

    aerah T!*!an 7isata Disertasi Fa6#ltas e6onomi -an %isnis, Universitas %ra&i'a(a. Not

    Yet "#4lise-.

    Sianipar, ?. ". !or$ana., 3. Y#-o6o., A. Ar-i#tama., =. Do&a6i. :;)C. Co$$!nit& $)o(ere$ent

    Thro!'h ))ro)riate Technolo'&. S!stainin' the S!stainable evelo)$ent "roce-ia

    Environmental Science ) );;);)*

    St(li-is, Dimitrios., an- !atina Ter5i-o#. :;). To!ris$ and the cono$ic Crisis in Kavala, reece .

    of Annals of To#rism Researc 9:);::*@

    S#r&ianta, E-i. :;;C.a$)a% #en'e$ban'an #ari(isata Terhada) Kehid!)an Sosial !da&a dan

    %ono$i. !e-ia Gisata 8ol. :, No. )

    Y#sti6a, Ama- Erani. :;;>. %ono$i #oliti%. Ka*ian Teoritis dan nalisis $)iri%. Yo$(a6arta7"#sta6a "ela'ar

    Baenali, %aram., !osen .J., Esllam .., Naser .T., an- So4an . D. :;)+. 7ill To!ris$

    evelo)$ent I$)rove the 9!alit& o" Li"e in Hasht)ar Cit&: n nal&sis o" Local esidents;

    ttit!des International Jo#rnal of Econom(, !ana$ement an- Social Science., 8ol 9@, No

    9C@, pp :>CC;;