iza institute of labor economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · ()...

40

Upload: others

Post on 29-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

������������� ������ �������������������������������� ��!"����#������%$��&�� ' ����!"���(�)��*+#,�(� ��-.'/��0�������1*2������3

��4657518:9;<(464657=?>A@ BC57DE>GFH�%;I�J@EFK4657FG5'�FGLM4651NPOQFKRSN�T6U(��>GTVRETVOQWX>G= '�FKLM4Y5?NPOQFKRSN�T6U(��>KTVRTVOZW[>K=

\�REW^]VFK5?=7W^N_8`T6U��_TbaC4 \�REW[]6FK57=?W[NJcFH-.4d]Y46egf46REh2!C� ��#i��� !C� �� c���)f%!C� ��#i����46Rhj�1kl#

�_TmaC4n!CW[N_86fE�_Tma"4 oVpVpYqSpbrAsmt6tVt u DvcFKwIFK>6f%u�DvcFGw%FG>yxzsm��{6�q\H;|�%;}#y; !C#���#i'�#

~�S�����J�6�E���V�M���b��Y�l�V�Y����g���S� ���V�I�6���1�Y�E���V��V���V�<�b�"����J�V��J���_���#iLE5?WXe.pYtVtSo

�n�(� �m¡b¢M£6��¤F�46RM46e^8J=?F�hM4YNA4�U¥5?TVO¦4�§MFGeXh¨F ©JLIFK57W[OZFGRSNvhFK=7W[ªVREFGhQN7T«OQFd4Y=7DE5?F�N7@EF�WXRE>GFKRSNPW^]VF�FG¬%FK> N

T6U�4Q>A@M46REª6F­WXR®NP@EFHLEWXFG>KFy574YNPFY;��)@EF­F ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNiaC46=i>GTVREhED>GNPFGh¯a�W[N7@EWXR24QNP5?FKF°r_LEeX46RSNPWXRª§M5?O±TVL%FG5P4YN7WXREª²W[R³BC5?W[N7WX=7@³!CTVe[DEO­wEWX4fv!"46RM46hM4J;��)@EWX=¨§M5?O´N_8JLWX>d4YeXe[8µLM4d8�=¶W[N7=zaCTV5?·6FG57=LEW[FK>KFH5P4YN7FK=GfIa�W^NP@jN7@EF«5P4YN7FHLM4YWXh2wIFKW[REªQhEFGN7FK57OQWXRFKh2wS8®LEeX46RSNPWXRªZ>GTVREhEW^NPWXT6RE=K;�'�DE5?WXREª¨NP@FF ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNdf�U¥TV5z4¸ªVW^]VFKR¹=7F NQT6U�LEeº46RSN7WXREª¸>GTVREhEW^NPWXT6RE=Kf�avTV57·YFK57=¨avFK57F:TVw=7FK51]VFGh³LEeX46RSNPWXRªDEREhFK5�NP@EF�5?FKªVDEeX465�»¥>KTVRSNP5?TVe½¼(LWXFK>GF)5P4YN7F�LM46WXh¨4YREh¶4 @EW[ªV@EFG5�»¥N757Fd4¾NPOQFKRSN°¼�5P4¾NPF6;��µF�DE=?F)NP@EW[=F ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46e<>A@M4YREªVFiW[RZN7@EFiLEW[FK>GF�574YNPF�NPTHWXhEFGR�N7W[U½8zN7@EFiFGeº46=1NPWX>GW[N_8zTYU¿aCT657·6FG5CLE5?TJhDE>GN7W[]�W[N_846REhZFG¬%TV5?N�DE=?WXREªHhEW[¬%FK5?FKRSN�=?NP4YNPW[=?NPW[>d46e<4YLELE57TV46>A@EFK=G;��(WX5?=?NKf�avFi>GTVRE=?WXhEFG5v#i����&�#ÀOZF NP@ET�hE=K;��FKªV5?FK=7=?WXTVR=(T6UMhE46WXe^8 LE57T�hEDE> NPW^]JW^N_8�TVRyN7@EFvLWXFK>GFC574YNPF�8JW[FKe[hy46RyFK=?N7WXOZ4YNPF�T6UNP@EFvFKeº4Y=?NPW[>KW^N_8 T6UTVDN7LEDNva�W[NP@Z57FG=7LIFK>GNCNPT­>A@M4YREªVFK=CWXRZN7@EFiLWXFK>GFi574YNPF�T6U.tÁÃÂVÄ;(��@WXeXF)N7@EF�#��i��&�#�OQFGN7@ETJh=@M4d]VF¨NP@FZ4Yh]Y46RSNA46ªVF¨T6UvLEeX46>KW[REª`OZW[REWXOZ46e�57FG=?NP5?WX> NPWXT6RE= TVR²NP@EF¨hM4YNP4fÅNP@EF 8²465?FQe[WXOQW[N7FKh¯W[RNP@FKWX5(46wEW[eXW[N_8iNPT�LE5?FKhEW[>GN�NP@EF"F ¬lFG>GN7=�T6UI46e[N7FK5?RM4YNPW^]VFi»�DERTVwE=7FG5?]6FKh<¼�>KT6R�N75P46> NP=G;��)@EFK5?FGU¥TV5?F6fVavFNPD57R²NPT:=?N757DE> NPDE5746e�FK=?N7WXOZ4YNPW[TVR¯DE=?WXREª:NP@FQF°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSNP46e�hM4YNP4;Z��DE5 =?N757DE> NPDE5746e�FK=?N7WXOZ4YNPFT6U)N7@EF¶FGeº46=1NPWX>GW[N_8²W[=ytÁÃÂS{Jf�]VFK518µ>GeXTV=?FZN7T2NP@EFZ#��i��&�#ÆFK=1NPWXOZ4YN7F6;:�µFnFG=?N7WXOZ4YNPF¨NP@M4¾NyNP@FWXRSN757T�hEDE>GN7WXTVRHT6U<4iwE46=7FCaC46ªVFvWXRSNPT�NP@EFv>KTVRSNP5746>GN�ªVW[]6FKRyavTV57·YFK5?=�aCTVDeXh­W[RE>K5?Fd46=?Fv§M5?O,L57T6§EN7=wIFGN_avFKFKR¸{¨4YREh¤sd¨LIFK5?>KFGR�NK;

3�Ç¿ÈbÉ�Ê ËmÌÍÈbÎGÏgпÊGÑÓÒKÔ¾ÎAÕÅÖÃÉ7×mØ É�ÏÍÉ7Ð�É7Ê°ÏÓÑÓÈ�ÐÍËbÙbÙ6ΠÏÍÌlÚÛÏgΠÜÝÌÍÈbÉ�ÞbÞbß�à.á�â¾ÞdÈbÉ7Ê°ÏgÉ1ÏÅÊ ÑÓÒdÔbÎAÕÅÖ|É?×mØGÉ?ÐlÐ�˾ÙbÙYÎGÏ�Ì¿ÚÛÏgΠÜãä à�Þ¾á:Ê Ô¾×�ÌÍÈbÉ"álÊ°Ô¾ÊG×bÊ"àÅÉ?ÐÍÉ?Ê ÏgÑÓÈ�á%Ⱦʰå|ÏÅå|Ô«ÞdÎmÑ åæÊ°Ö�çEÎGÖÃåæÑ å|É?пʰÔY×iß�ËbÜ)Ê°Ô�àÅÉ7Ð�ÎGËbÏÓÑ É?ÐÅÊ°ÌÅÌÍÈbÉvè.Ôbå|é É?ÏgÐÍå}ÌbêÉë ÊPéAÊ Ö[â�ìyÉCÌÍȾʠÔbÒHá%ȾʰÏgÖ|É?Ð(í%É?ÖÃÖ|É1Ü)Ê ÏÍÉvÚÛΠÏ(ÈbÉ1Ö|ÙmÚÛËbÖ<Ñ1ΠÜ"Ü"É1ÔKÌgÐ?â�ìyÉ)Ê°ÖæÐ�Î�ÌÍȾʠÔbÒ�Ð�É?Ü"åÃԾʠÏ�پʰÏÍÌÍåæÑ å|پʰÔKÌÓÐ�Ê°ÌÌÍȾÉ.è.Ôbå|é É?ÏgÐÍå}Ì¥î�ΰÚSï.ΠÏÍÌÍÈ�álÊ ÏÍÎGÖÃå|Ô¾ÊbðPÌgÈbÉ.ß�ñ¿á¨ò�ΠÔKÌÍÏbêÉ?Ê ÖKÊ Ô¾×vÌÍÈbÉ.è�Ôbå|é É1ÏÓÐÍå}ÌbêÉ ë ÊPéAÊ°ÖbÊ ÐEÕlÉ1Ö|Ö¾ÊGÐEپʰÏÍÌÍåæÑ å|پʰÔKÌÓÐÊAÌ¿ÌgÈbÉ�ó ÎGËbÏgÔlêÉ1É7п×mË«á%ô¥à.ç êñ%ñZÊ Ô¾×�ÌgÈbÉ�õlÌÍÉ?ÖÃå|É1Ï�É1Ô êñIÑ ÎGÔbΠÜ"å|É�×mË Ç�ÏÓÊPéAÊ°å|ÖVÊ°Ì.è ä õ�ò¨â

Page 2: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

��� ��� �m¡�����£6� ��� � ¢ � �����M�����¢����� �

�)@EF¯W[RE>KFGRSNPW[]6F2F ¬lFG>GNP=¶T6U >KT6R�N75P46> NP=ZLEeº4d8 4¤>GFKRSNP5746ei5?TVeXF:WXR¹NP@EFjOZT�hEFG57R N7@EFKT65?8¹T6U NP@F§M5?Oj;���>KT6RETVOQWX>�N7@EFKT657WX=1NP=)@M4d]6F«OQT�hEFKe[eXFKhZNP@EF�46wWXeXW^N_8¨T6U�>KTVRSN75P46> NP=)NPT¨46e[WXªVRZNP@EF W[R�N7FK5?FK=?N7=T6U�aCTV5?·6FG57= 46Rhj§M5?OZ=y»Í��465?Ni46REh2��TVe[OZ=1NP5 �T6O+»1smÄ��S{V¼ f<��TVeXOQ=?N75 �TVOÆ46REh¸*®WXeXª657TVO »1smÄVÄ6tS¼ f*jW[eXªV5?TVO 4YREhµ��TVwIFK51NP=Z»1smÄ6ÄSpV¼ f�B"4Y·6FK5¶»1sdÄVÄSpV¼?¼ ;z�_R²NP@EFQ57FGeº4YN7FKh 46REh 57FG>KFKRSN7e[8Sr_hEF ]VFGeXTVLIFKh§MFGeXh¹T6U LIFK57=?TVREREFGe�FK>KT6RETVOQWX>K=2»Í-.4��GFd465j» smÄVÄ��S¼?¼­>KTVOQL%FGRE=P4¾NPWXT6R¹=18�=?NPFGOZ=¶4657F®>KT6RE=7W[hEFK5?FKhLITVeXW[>G8¹WXRE=1NP5?DEOZFGRSNP=`T6U«NP@EF¯§E57O a�@WX>A@�>d46R�wIF¸DE=7FGhÀN7T WXOQLE57Tm]6F¯NP@EF¸LIFK51U¥TV57OZ46RE>GF¯T6UavTV57·YFK57=G;­��FK>GFKRSNPe^8VfÅhM4YNP4¶U¥57TVO LM4d8�57TVe[e(5?FK>KT657hE= @M4d]6Fzw%FGFKR²DE=7FGh N7T`FK=1NPWXOZ4YN7FHNP@FzFG¬%FK>GN7=T6U�>KT6R�N75P46> NP=zTVR�avTV5?·6FK5¨4YREh §M57O L%FG5?U¥TV5?O¶4YRE>KFY; �)@F`TVwE=7FG5?]6FKhÝ]64Y57Wº4¾NPWXT6RµWXRµ>KTVRSNP5746>GN7=WX=�57FGeº4YN7FKh:NPTZTVwE=7FG5?]6FKh¸OQFd46=?DE57FG=iT6U(L%FG5?U¥TV5?O¶46R>KF«WXR®TV57hEFG5�N7T¶FG=?NPW[O¶4¾NPF�WXRE>GFKRSNPW^]VFHFG¬%FK>GN7=46REh:NPTQOQFd46=?DE57F�NP@EF�W[OZLITV5?NP46RE>GF T6U�46=18�OZOQFGN757WX> W[RU¥TV5?O¶4YN7WXTVR��JF°©E4YOZLEe[FK=�WXRE>GeXDEhF��<FG575746eXe46REhj�J@Fd465?FK5H»1smÄ6ÄVÄS¼ f(4V4Y57=7>A@246REhj�J@EFK4657FG5H»1smÄVÄ6ÄfMp6t6tVtS¼ fE-�4��KFd4Y5«»gp6tVt6tS¼ fE!CTVL%FGeº46Rhj4YREh*jTVRFGNy»gp6t6tSpV¼ fE�i46e[FG8²»Íp6tVtVÂV¼"46="aCFGeXe.46=�B"4YREhEWXFG5P4fEB"465P4YRE·¾4m86f<46REhj��4Y=7DEe�»Íp6tVt6qS¼ ;

��REF�L%TYNPFKRSN7Wº46eSLE5?TVwEe[FKO�a�W^NP@yLE4m8�5?TVeXeShM4¾NA4�WX=ÅNP@M4¾N�N7@EFvT6wE=7FG5?]VFGh­>A@M46RªVFK=�WXR«>KTVRSNP5746>GN7=OZ4m8:wIF«FKREhET6ªVFKRET6DE=iwIFK>K46DE=7FHNP@EF«>KTVRSN75P46> N�WX=�4Q>A@ETVWX>GF«]Y465?Wº46weXF TVR®NP@EFHLM465?N�T6U�NP@EF«§M57O»Í�5?FKREhEFG57ªS4Y=?N¶»1smÄ6ÄVÄS¼ fÅ!C@EWº46LL%TV5?W�46Rhµ�J46eº46RW cF`»Íp6tVtVÂV¼7¼ ;«�ÓU�§M57OQ= =7FGeXFK> N«4`>KTVOQL%FGRE=P4¾NPWXT6R=7>A@FKOQF­wM46=?FKh¸TVR®U�46>GN7TV57=�DERETVwE=?FK51]VFKh²wS8®NP@EFHFK>KT6RETVOQFGNP5?WX>GWº46R¿fMwDNia�@EW[>A@²4Y¬%FK>GN�avTV57·YFK5LE5?TJhED>GNPW^]�W[N_8VfvNP@EFGR�57FKª657FK=?=7W[TVR�OQFGNP@TJhE=¨a�WXe[e)U�46WXe"N7TµLE5?Tb]�W[hEF¯4µ>GTVRE=?WX=?N7FKRSN`FG=?NPW[O¶4¾NPF:T6UNP@F«W[RE>KFGRSNPW[]6FHF ¬lFG>GNK;��®�)@EF«TVwE=?FK5?]6FKh¯>GTm]64Y57Wº4¾NPWXT6R`w%F N_aCFGFKR2avTV57·YFK5�LE57T�hEDE> NPW^]JW^N_8:46REh:NP@FLM4d8�OZFGRSN�=18�=?NPFGO >KTVRU¥T6DEREhE=�WXR>KFKRSN7W[]VFG=�a�W^NP@`]Y4657WX4YNPW[TVRnW[R®DRETVwE=?FK5?]Y46weXFK=G;

�(©JL%FG57W[OZFGR�N7=nLE5?Tb]�W[hEF¸4µ=?WXOQLEeXFYfC8VF N`L%TmavFK51U¥DEegf)aC4m8 WXR a�@EWX>A@�N7T�=7TVe^]VF®NP@EFG=7F¸FKR�rhETVª6FKREFGW[N_8²LE5?TVwEeXFGOZ=G;¨�)@EFZF°©JTVªVFKRTVDE=H]Y465?Wº4YN7WXTVR2WXR L%TVe[WX>GWXFK=iL%FG57OQW[NP=�N7@EFZ46LELEe[WX>d4¾NPWXT6R¯T6UeXFG=7=�57FK=1NP5?WX>GN7W[]6FH=1NA4YN7WX=?N7WX>K46eÅOZF NP@ET�hE=�NPTZOZFK46=7DE5?FHN7@EFyF ¬lFG>GNP=�T6U�LITVeXW[>G8`>A@E46REªVFG=¨»ÍBCD5?NPe[FK=?=»1sdÄVÄSoV¼?¼ ;�#"N�NP@F�§E57OÆe[FG]VFGegfEF ]Y46eXDM4¾NPWXRªz>A@M46REªVFG=�W[R:L%FG57=7T6REREFKeÅLITVe[WX>KW[FK="D=7WXRª¨§EFKeXh:F°©LIFK5 rWXOQFKRSN7=H@M4Y=z4je[TVREª2@WX=?N7TV5?86f(hM4¾NPWXRª2wM46>A·²NPT®NP@EFn�i4da)NP@ET657REFnF°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSN7=yWXR NP@EFjsmÄSp6tY=46REh�sdÄVÂVt�»Íx�W[eXe[FK=7LWXFj»1smÄ6Äsb¼ f�96TVREFK=`»1smÄVÄVpV¼7¼°;¸�(WXFGeXh¤F ©JL%FG57W[OZFGR�N7=­>KT6O­wEWXRF¶NP@EF¶w%FGREFG§EN7=

� çMÊ Ê ÏgÐgÑÓÈHÊ Ô¾×zÞdÈbÉ?Ê ÏÍÉ?Ï�� �! " " $# ð�ß�Ê°Ö|É1î%�'&)(�("* # ÊGÐ�ÕlÉ1Ö|ÖIÊ Ð�í¿Ê°ÔY×måÃÉ?ÏgʾðJí¿Ê°ÏÓÊ°Ô¾ÒPÊPîGð�Ê°Ô¾×­à.ÊGÐ�˾Ö��'&"("()+ #ȾÊPé É(å|ÔKéGÉ?Ð�ÌÍå|ØGÊ°ÌÍÉ?×�ÌÍÈbÉ�ÐÍÉ ÌÍÌÍå|ÔbØ"ΰÚJÙ¾åÃÉ7Ñ É�ÏgÊ°ÌÍÉ7Ð%å|Ô�ÌÍÈbÏgÉ1É�ÐÍÉ1پʠÏgÊ°ÌÍÉ�å|Ô¾×mËYÐ¥ÌgÏÍå|É?Ð-,ÌÍÏgÉ1É�ÙbÖæÊ°ÔKÌÍå|ÔbؾðmÖ|ΠØGØ å|ÔbØÌÍå|Ü/.6É1Ï7ð.Ê°Ô¾×ZÚÛÏgËbåÃÌ�Ùbå|ÑÓÒdå|Ôbؾâjô½Ô`Ê°Ö|Ö�Ñ1ÊGÐ�É7Ð1ð%ÌÍÈbÉ«ÙbåÃÉ7Ñ É ÏÓÊAÌgÉ å|Ð�ÑÓȾÎGÐÍÉ1ÔnÊ Ð�ÊyÚÛËbÔYÑ_ÌÍå|ΠÔ`ΠÚ(É10mÙYÉ7Ñ_ÌÍÉ7×ÙbÏgÎd×b˾Ñ_ÌgåÃédåÃÌ¥î â

s

Page 3: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

T6Uv57FK46e^rgaCTV5?eXh¿f%§M57Ozr_e[FG]VFGe�hM4YNP4:a�W^NP@²>KT6R�]�W[RE>KW[REª:F ©JTVªVFGRETVDE=�]Y4657WX4YNPW[TVR¯WXR²LITVeXW[>G8�»Í�M57FGRE>A@»1sdÄSoYq�¼?¼ ;

�_R®NP@EW[=�LM4YL%FG5KfMaCFy46RM46e^8�=7F«hM4YNA4¨U¥57TVOÆ4Q§MFGeXh®F ©JL%FG57W[OZFGR�N�hEFG=7WXª6REFKh2N7TZOQFd4Y=7DE5?FHNP@FWXR>KFKRSN7W[]VF`F ¬lFG>GNzTYU�LWXFK>GF rÓ5P4YN7Fn>KTVOQLIFKRE=74YNPW[TVR¿;¸�)@EFnF°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSNzaC46=z>KT6REhEDE> NPFKh a�W^NP@EW[R4 N757FGF r_Leº46RSNPW[REª¤§E57O TVLIFK5P4¾NPWXRª¤W[R NP@F2LE5?Tb]�W[RE>KFjT6U�BC5?W[NPW[=7@³!CTVeXDO­wEWº4Jf)!"46RM4YhM4;À�)@EFavTV57·YFK57= W[RjN7@EWX=�§M57O 465?FHN_8�LEWX>K46eXe^8`LM46W[h2LEW[FK>GF­5P4YN7FK=��¿46R¯W[REhEW^]JW[hEDM46e��Ã=�hM4YWXe[8nFd465?REWXREª6=�465?F=?N757W[>GNPe^8�LE5?TVLITV5?N7WXTVRM4Ye�N7T²N7@EF:R�DEO­wIFK5zT6U�NP5?FKFK=¨@EF:TV5z=?@EF:LEeº4YR�N7FKhÝhEDE5?WXREª 4¸ªVW^]VFKRÝhM4d86;�eº46RSN7WXREªZWX=iLIFK51U¥TV57OQFKh2TVR¯eº4Y57ªVF«NP5P4Y>GNP=�T6U�eº4YREh¯>d4YeXeXFGh��������� ;i\�REhEFG5�RETVR�r_F ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46e>KT6REhEW[N7WXTVR=KfÅNP@EF¨LEW[FK>GFZ574YNPFzU¥TV5«4:LM465?N7WX>GDEeº465iwEeXT�>A·¯WX=�>A@ET6=7FKRµw�8¸N7@EF¨§M57O 4Y=y4nU¥DERE> NPW[TVRT6UCLEeº46RSN7WXREª:>KT6REhEW[N7WXTVR=� N7@EFZ=?eXTVLIF¨T6UCN7@EF¨NPFK5?5P46W[R¸NPT2wIF¨LEeº4YR�N7FKh¿f�NP@EF¨=?T6U½NPREFG=7=HT6U"NP@F=7T6WXegfJ46REh:=?T¨U¥T65?NP@l;���@EFKR®>KTVRhEW[N7WXTVRE=C57FKRhEFK5�LEeX46RSNPWXRª­hEW��Q>GDEe[NKf57FGhEDE>GWXREªzNP@F R�DO­w%FG5)T6UNP5?FKFG="NP@M4YNC>d46R`wIF�LEeX46RSNPFGh`TVR:4yªVW^]VFKR`hE4m86fNP@Fi§M57O WXRE>G57FK46=7FG=CNP@EF LWXFK>GF�5P4¾NPFiW[RnTV5?hEFK5CN7T=P4¾NPWX=1U½8¸4`eº4Yw%TVD51r_=?DELELEe^8®>KTVRE=1NP5746WXRSNd;z�JWXRE>GFzLEeº4YR�N7WXREª¶>KTVREhW[NPW[TVRE= 4Y57FzDERET6wE=7FG5?]VFGh�wS8¯NP@FFK>GTVRETVOQFGN757W[>KWº4YR¿fIN7@EFz>KT65757FGeº4YN7WXTVRjw%F N_aCFGFKR LEeº4YR�N7WXREª¶>KTVREhW[NPW[TVRE=i46REh¸LEW[FK>KFz574YNPFG=�WXRhEDE>KFG=FKRhETVªVFGREFKW^N_8V;��_R2U�46>GNKfI4Z57FGªV57FG=7=?WXTVR¯TYU�TVwE=?FK5?]6FKh¸LE5?TJhDE>GN7W[]�W[N_8:TVR2LEWXFG>KF«5P4YN7FK=iD=7WXRª¶RETVR�rF ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46eÅhE4YNA4­8�WXFGeXhE=�4zREFGªS4YNPW^]VF�57FGeº4YN7WXTVR=7@EW[L¿;

�)@EF:F°©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSNzNPT�TV·¤LEeº46>GFnTVR NP@57FKF:hEW^¬lFG57FGR�N¨weXT�>A·�=zhDE57W[REª¯NP@EFjp6t6tVÂ2LEeX46RSNPWXRª=7FK46=7T6R¿;�'�DE57W[REª­NP@EF�F°©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSNdfFd46>A@®@ETVOQTVªVFGREFKTVD=)wEeXT�>A·ZaC46=�hEW[]�W[hEFKh:WXRSN7T­N_aCTQLM4651NP=KfTVREFQLM4651N�NPT®w%FQLEeº4YR�N7FKh¤4YN�NP@EFQ57FGªVDEeX465 LEWXFG>KFQ5P4YN7Fj»Í46=«hEFGN7FK5?OZW[REFKh wS8²>KTVREhW[NPW[TVRE=P¼�4YREhNP@FnT6NP@FK5HN7T¯wIF¶LEeX46RSNPFKhÝ4¾N­46R F°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSNP46e�»½NP5?Fd4YN7OZFGR�NA¼«LEW[FK>GF¶5P4¾NPF6;2�)@EF¶NP5?Fd4YN7OZFGRSNLEW[FK>KF¸574YNPF257FKL57FK=?FKRSNPFGh�46R�W[RE>K5?Fd46=?F¸T6U«DEL�NPT�N_avFKRSN_8�LIFK5?>KFKRSN®Tm]VFG5nNP@EF¸5?FKªVDEeX465nLEW[FK>GF5P4¾NPF6;+�465?N7WX>GWXLM46RSN7=2WXR NP@EF�F°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSN¯avFK5?F TVwE=?FK5?]6FKh DEREhFK5¸wIT6NP@�N7@EF�5?FKªVDEeX465¯4YREhNP@F:N757FK4YNPOQFKRSN¨LEW[FK>KF:574YNPFnU¥TV5¨4¸ªVW^]VFGR wEe[TJ>A·<; �_RÝNPT6NP46egf�N7@EF:F ©JLIFK57W[OZFGRSNZL57Tm]�WXhEFGh smÄV{TVwE=?FK51]64¾NPWXT6RE=zTVR¹hM46WXe^8 LE57T�hEDE> NPW[]�W^N_8Vf�smtVĸ4YN¨5?FKªVDEeX465zLEW[FK>KF`574YNPFG=Q46REh ���²4YNzNP5?Fd4YN7OZFGRSNLEW[FK>KF�574YNPFG=K;

�¤FZD=7F¨NP@EFG=7F¶hE4YNA4`NPT®FK=1NPWXOZ4YN7F­NP@EFQ57FG=7LITVRE=7FZT6U�aCTV5?·6FG57=yN7Tj>A@M4YREªVFK=«WXR²NP@FZLEW[FK>GF5P4¾NPF�DE=7W[REªzN_aCTZhEW[¬%FK5?FKRSN�=?NP4YNPW[=?NPW[>d46e¿46LELE5?TS46>A@EFG=K;"��WX57=1NdfavFH46LELEe^8nDERE5?FK=1NP57W[>GN7FKh¯4YRM46e[8�=?WX=1rT6Uºrg]64Y57Wº4YRE>KF�»�#��i��&�# ¼QN7FK>A@ERW���DEFK=G;��)@EFG=7F²OQFGNP@TJhE=n46eXe[TbaÆDE=nNPT hEFG>KTVOQLITV=7F¸4d]6FK5P4YªVFLE5?TJhED>GNPW^]�W[N_8®WXRSNPT¶wEeXT�>A·Vr_=7LIFK>GW[§M>yFG¬%FK>GN7=KfÅW[REhEW[]�W[hEDM46eÛr_=7LIFK>GW[§M>�F ¬lFG>GNP=Gf.46REh¯N7@EFyNP5?Fd4YN7OZFGRSN

p

Page 4: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

FG¬%FK> N2TYU­>A@M46RªVWXREª¹NP@EF²LEW[FK>GF¤574YNPFY;Æ#i=®=7DE>A@lfH4YR #i����&�# LE57Tm]�WXhEFG=¯46RÀDERE5?FK=1NP57W[>GN7FKhFK=1NPW[O¶4YN7FZTYU"NP@EFZ>A@M46REª6FnWXR¤LE57T�hEDE> NPW[]�W^N_8¤hDE57W[REªjN7@EF¶F°©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSNd;2��DE5y5?FK=?DEe[N7=y=7DªVªVFK=1NNP@E4YN�46RjW[RE>K5?Fd46=?F�WXR`NP@EF«LEW[FK>KF�574YNPF aC46=i4Y>K>KT6OZLM4YREWXFGh®wS8®46R®WXR>K57FK46=7F�W[R:avTV5?·6FK5�TVDN7LEDN �NP@F"FKeX46=?N7WX>KW^N_8«T6U<aCTV5?·6FG5�LE57T�hEDE> NPW[]�W^N_8Ha�W^NP@z57FG=7LIFK> N�NPT F ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46eJ>A@M46REª6FK=�WXRHNP@EF)LEW[FK>GF5P4¾NPF�WX=�FK=1NPWXOZ4YN7FKh`NPTZw%F«tÁÃÂVÄ;��µF«>KTVR=7WXhFK5�NP@EF«WXOQL%T65?NA4YRE>KF T6U(L%TYNPFKRSN7Wº46e[e[8Z>KTVRU¥T6DEREhEW[REªU�46> NPTV5?=�=7DE>A@ 46=�aCFK4YNP@EFG5Kf¿U�4YN7WXªVDF6f%46REh¸FKRhETVªVFGRETVDE= LM4Y5?NPW[>KW[LM4YNPW[TVR¿f<wEDNi§MREh¯NP@FKO NPT`wIFDEREW[OZLITV51NA46RSN)wIT6NP@:FG>KTVRET6OZW[>d46e[e[8¶46REh:=?NP4YNPW[=?NPW[>d46e[e[86;

�)@EFz#i���)&(# FG=?NPW[O¶4¾NPFK=�@M4d]VF¨RETnhWX57FG>GN W[RSNPFK5?LE57F NA4YN7WXTVR2WXR2N7FK57OQ=�T6U�FG>KTVRTVOZW[>HU¥DER�rhM46OQFKRSNP46eX=G;���@M4YNvWX=�OQTV5?F6fSNP@EF�#i����&�#ÀOZF NP@ET�hE=�4657F�e[WXOQW[NPFGh­WXR¨NP@FKWX5�4YwEWXe[W[N_8«NPT«LE57FGhEWX> NwIFK@M4d]�WXTVD5CDEREhFK5"4Ye[NPFG57RM4¾NPW[]6F�>GTVRSNP5746>GN7=KfEDERTVwE=7FG5?]6FKh:WXRQNP@EF�F ©JL%FG57W[OZFGR�N »¥�¤TVeXLWXR¿f<smÄVÄVoV¼ ;�¤FZDE=?F¶=1NP57D>GNPD5P46e�FK>GTVRETVOQFGN757WX>¨OQFGN7@ETJh=Kf�4YLELEeXW[FKh¸NPT®NP@EFQF ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46e�hM4¾NA4f�NPT®FG]Y46e^rDM4YN7FZ>GTVRSNP5746>GN7DM46e�L%FG5?U¥TV5?O¶4YRE>KFY;`\�=?WXREª:NP@EFZ=?N757DE> NPDE5746e�OZT�hEFKeÍfÅaCFZFK=?N7WXOZ4YNPFzN7@EFZT6DNPLEDJNFKeX46=?N7WX>GW[N_8nN7T¶wIF­tÁÃÂS{Jf<]VFG5?8j>KeXT6=7F�NPTZN7@EFy#i���)&(#/FK=?N7WXOZ4YNPFY;�B"46=7FGh¯TVR2N7@EFK=?Fy5?FK=7De[NP=Gf%avFFK=1NPW[O¶4YN7FHN7@M4YN�N7@EFzWXRSNP5?TJhDE>GN7WXTVRjT6Uv4nwM46=7F­aC46ªVFyWXRSNPTnN7@EF­>KT6R�N75P46> N aCT6DEeXh¸W[RE>K5?Fd46=?F­§M57OLE5?T6§ENP=�wIFGN_avFKFGR²{z46REh smÂzL%FG57>KFGRSNd;

�)@EFjLM46LIFK5ZWX=¨TV57ªV46REW �GFKh³46=QU¥T6eXeXTma�=G$2�_R N7@EF2RF ©�Nn=?FK>GN7WXTVRlfCaCFjhEFK=?>K5?WXwIFjNP@FjNP5?FKF°rLEeX46RSNPWXRªµWXRhEDE=?N75?8 WXR�Bv57W[N7WX=?@�!CTVe[DEO­wEWX4µ46=¶avFKe[e�46=QNP@EF2>KTVOQL%FGRE=P4¾NPWXT6R�=?8�=?N7FKO W[R³NP@F§M5?Oj;��_R¶=7FG>GN7WXTVRZÂfSaCF�hEFK=?>K5?WXwIF�T6DE5vF°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSN��Ã=�hEFK=?WXªVRlf�a�@WXeXF)W[RZ=?FK> NPWXT6RZq�aCF�hEFG=7>K5?WXwIFNP@F¤=746OZLeXF¸hM4YNP4 4YREh L57FK=?FKRSN2N7@EF²#��i��&�# 5?FK=7De[NP=G; �_R =7FG>GNPW[TVR�oJfiavF¤>GTVRE=7W[hEFK5:NP@FLIT6NPFGR�N7Wº46e(>KTVRU¥T6DEREhEW[REª:FG¬%FK>GN7=�T6UvU�4¾NPWXª6DEF¨46REh¸avFd4YN7@EFK5Gf�a�@EW[eXFzW[R¸=7FK> NPW[TVR��navFZ>GTVRE=?WXhEFG5F ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46e�4YREh²=?NP5?DE>GN7DE5P4Ye�W[hEFKRSN7W[§M>K4YNPW[TVR¸T6UvFG¬%TV5?N1r_FKeX46=?N7WX>GW[N_8jLM465P4YOZF NPFK5?=K;¨�_R =7FK> NPW[TVR{JfavF«L%FG5?U¥TV5?OÆL%T6eXWX> 8n4YRM46e[8�=?WX=�46REh:W[R®=?FK> NPWXT6R �­avFH>GTVRE>Ke[DEhEFY;

� � � ¡������¥¢ � ��� ��� � �� ¡ �¥��������� �����²� �¥¢

��@EW[eXF2N7WXO­wIFK5nW[=`4 57FGREFGaC46wEe[F¸57FK=?TVDE5?>KF6f�46>GN7W[]VF²5?FGU¥TV5?FK=?NP4YNPW[TVR�>d4YRÀW[RE>K5?Fd46=?F¯NP@EF²=?L%FGFKh4YN­a�@WX>A@ U¥TV57FG=?N7=Q5?FKªVFGREFK574YNPF:4YREh¹46eX=?T²46eXe[Tba�=HTVREFnN7T >GTVRSNP5?TVeCU¥TV5­=?L%FG>KW[FK=z>KT6OZLITV=7W^NPW[TVR¿f=7T6OZF NP@EW[REªjN7@M4YN­W[=yhEW �Q>KDEe^NHN7T¯hET¯W[R¤NP@Fn>d46=?FnT6U�RM4¾NPDE5746ev5?FKªVFGREFK574YNPW[TVR¿;2��F U¥TV57FG=?NA4¾NPWXT6RWX=y>KFKRSN75P46eCN7T²4¯=?N7Fd46h8µ=7DELLEe[8µT6U�NPWXOyw%FG5HNPT¯N7@EF`��TV5?N7@¹#�OZFG57W[>d46R�OZ465?·6FGNK;¤�_RÝBv57W[N7WX=?@!CTVe[DEO­wEWX4fF°©JN7FKRE=?W[]6Fy57F U¥TV57FG=?NP4YNPW[TVRjW[=)DEREhEFG5?NP46·6FGR¯wS8:w%T6N7@®N7@EFH*jWXRWX=?N75?8`TYU��MTV5?FK=?N7=i4YREh

Â

Page 5: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

NP@F«OZ4��?TV5"N7WXO­wIFK5 r_@M4Y5?]VFG=?N7WXREª­§M5?OZ=G;�)@EFQ=?N7FKLE=�DERhEFK51NA46·YFKRµN7T®>GTVOQLEeXF NPFyN7@EWX= 5?FGU¥TV5?FK=?NP4YNPW[TVR 4657Fz=1NP5746WXªV@SN?U¥TV5?aC4657hl;¨�5?WXTV5

NPTZNP@EFH@M465?]6FK=1N�T6U�46RS8:NP5P4Y>GN�TYU�>KTVREW^U¥FK5?TVDE=�N7WXO­wIFK5Gf%5746REhET6O =746OQLEeXFG=iT6U�>GTVREFK=�4657F«NA46·YFKRU¥57T6O/NP@F�N757FKFG=�TVRQN7@EF)NP5746>GNKfJ4YREh¨=7FKFGhEeXW[REªV=�465?F�ª657Tma�RQU¥5?TVO/N7@EF�=7FGFKhE=v>KTVRSNA4YWXREFGhZW[R¨N7@EFK=?F>KT6REFK=G;)�)@EWX=�FKRE=?DE57FG=iNP@E4YN�NP@EF«=7FGFKhEe[WXREªV=�NPTQwIFH5?FKLEeX46RSNPFKh24657F«>KT6OZLM4¾NPWXweXF�a�W[N7@®N7@EF«eXT�>d46eOQWX>K5?TYr_>GeXW[O¶4YN7FK=(46REh¶=?TVWXe<4Y=�avFKe[eI46=v5?FKLE5?FK=?FKRSNA4YN7W[]6FiT6U%NP@EF�@EWX=1NPTV5?WX>K46eM=7LIFK>GWXFK=�>KT6OZLITV=7W^NPW[TVR¿;

��57FGFzLEeº46RSN7WXREªZWX=�4n=?WXOQLEeXFYfI86FGN�LE@S8�=7W[>d46e[e[8®F ©J@M4YDE=?N7WXREªEf%NA46=?·I; �ÓN�WXRS]VTVe^]VFG= hEWXªVª6WXREªZ4@ETVe[Fia�W[N7@:4z=7LIFK>KWX46e¿=?@ETm]VFKeÍfELEeX46>KW[REª¨4­=7FGFKhEe[WXREªzW[RnNP@EW[=)@ETVeXFYfE46Rh:N7@EFKR:>GTb]6FK5?WXREª¨W[N7="57T�T6N7=a�W[N7@j=?TVWXeÍfEFKR=7DE5?WXREª¨NP@M4¾N�N7@EF NP57FGFHW[=�DELE57W[ªV@SN�46REh:NP@M4YN�N7@EFH5?TJTYNP=�4657F U¥DEe[e[8¶>KTm]VFG57FKhl;)�)@EF46OQTVDERSN«T6UvFG¬%TV5?N«57F ��DEWX5?FKh¤N7TjLIFK51U¥TV57O NP@EF¨NA46=?·¸hEFKLIFKRhE=HT6R¤NP@F¨N7FK5?5P46W[R¤TVR²a�@EW[>A@¤NP@FLEeX46RSNPWXRª`WX=�hETVREFY;Z�_R ªVFGREFK5746egfÅNP@F¨N7FK5?5P46W[R >K46R¤]Y46518²4`ªV57FK4YN«hEFd4Ye�U¥57TVO =?W[N7F¨N7T:=7W[N7F6;Q�_R=7T6OZF`>K46=7FG=Kf"4¾U½NPFK5¨4¯N75P46> N¨@M46=zwIFKFKR¹@M4651]VFG=?NPFGh¿fCN7@EF:eº46REh W[=zLE57FGLM465?FKhÝU¥TV5­LEeX46RSNPWXRª¸w�857FGOZTm]�WXRªyNP@EFiRM4YNPD5P46eIwEDEW[eXhJrÓDEL¶T6U.T657ªS46RWX>iOZ4YN?NPFK5�TVRnN7@EFiU¥TV5?FK=?N��MTJT65v=?T­NP@M4YNCNP@EF�=7TVW[e%W[=F ©JLITV=7FGh¿f�46eX=?T`·�RTba�R¤46= ����������� 6;z��>K57FGFG§MRªjOZ46·6FG=�LEeº46RSN7WXREª`FK46=7W[FK5 wIFK>d4YDE=7F¨=7FGFKhEe[WXREª6=O­DE=1N�w%FyLEeº46RSN7FKh²hEWX5?FK> NPe[8jWXR¯N7@EFz=7T6WXeg;H�JW^NPFG=iNP@M4¾N�4657Fz5?FKeX4YNPW^]VFKe^8��<4YN�TV5iN7@M4YN @E4m]6F¨w%FGFKRLE5?FKLM465?FKh¹465?FnO­DE>A@ÝFd4Y=7WXFG5yNPT¸Leº46RSN­N7@M46R =7W^NPFG=yNP@M4¾N¨4657Fn]6FK518�=?N7FKFGL TV5y@M4d]VF`RET6N­w%FGFKRLE5?FKLM465?FKh¿;��)@F�N_8�LEWX>K46e<OZW[REWXOyDEO�hEFGRE=7W^N_8QT6UÅ=7FGFKhEe[WXREª6=vW[=C46wITVDN�s �6tVt«=1NPFGOZ=vL%FG5v@EFG>GNP4657FYfTV5H46RµW[RSNPFK5 rÓN757FKFQ=7LE46>KW[REª2T6U)46w%T6DNzp�ÁÃqjOZF NP57FG=Kf(46e[N7@ETVDEªV@ NP@EW[=�>d46Rµ]Y46518 =7DEwE=1NA46RSN7Wº46e[e[8V; &'�FKLIFKRhEWXREª²TVRÝNP@F®>GTVREhEW^NPW[TVRE=Kf�46R 4d]VFG5P46ªVF®LEeX46RSNPFK5z>K46R¹LEeº46RSN¨wIFGN_avFKFGR�{6tVt²46REhÀsVsmt6tNP5?FKFG=�LIFK5)hM4d86f%4Yw%TVDJN�@M46e[U�46R:@EFG>GNP4657FY;

��8�LEWX>K46eXe^8VfÅNP5?FKF rÓLEeº4YR�N7WXREª`§M5?OZ=«465?F¨>A@ETV=7FGR¤N7TjLEeX46RSN«=7FKFGhEeXW[REªV=�TVR @M4651]VFK=1NPFGhµNP5746>GN7=NP@57TVDEª6@y4)LE5?TJ>GFK=7=�T6UJ>KTVOQL%F NPW^NPW[]6F�wEWXhhEWXREª;�'�FGL%FGREhEW[REª�TVR«N7@EF�eº46RhJrÓN7FKR�DE57F�465?5P46RªVFKOQFKRSNdfFKW^NP@EFG5®4ÝN7WXO­wIFK5 r_@M4651]VFG=?NPW[REª §M57O TV5`NP@EFµ*jWXRWX=?N75?8�TYU­�MTV5?FK=?N7=®a�W[eXe�>K46eXe�U¥TV5:=7Fd4YeXFKh�r_wEW[hNPFGREhEFG57=i>GTVRE>GFK57RWXREªQNP@EF«>KTV=1NiLIFK5�NP5?FKF«LEeº4YR�N7FKh¿fMa�W^NP@:NP@EF«eXTmavFK=?N�wEW[hEhEFK5 �Ã=�wIFKWXRªZ=?FKeXFG>GN7FKhNPTyL%FG5?U¥TV5?O N7@EFiavTV57·<;��)@EFiLE57W[>KFi5?FK>GFKW[]6FKh:wS8ZN7@EFi§M5?O L%FG5vNP5?FKF�Leº46RSNPFGhnWX=v>d46e[eXFGhZNP@F �����

� ��� ��� ;�BCWXhhEWXREª¨TVR:>GTVRSNP5P4Y>GNP=�NA4Y·6FK=�LEeX46>KF W[R:N7@EF�eº4YN7F�46DN7DEOZR®T6U�NP@EF 86Fd465�LE5?FK>KFGhEWXRªZNP@FLEeX46RSNPWXRªj=?Fd46=?TVR¿f�a�@EW[>A@�57DER=HU¥57T6O Fd465?e[8 =7LE5?WXREª®NP@E5?TVDEªV@ NPT¯eX4YNPFQ=7DOZOQFK5G;jBvFGU¥TV5?FZNP@F

&�� ÔbÉ ÈbÉ7Ñ_ÌgÊ ÏÍÉ�åæÐ�Ê°Ô`Ê ÏÍÉ7Ê � ("(yÜ"É ÌÍÏgÉ?Ð�Ð��K˾ʠÏÍÉGðIÎ Ï � (bð ("(�(HÐ��K˾ʰÏgÉ�Ü"É1ÌÍÏgÉ?Ð?â®Ç¿Èd˾Ð1ðlÎ Ô¾É ÈbÉ?Ñ ÌgÊ°ÏgÉ�å|ÐÊ°ÙbÙ¾ÏÍÎ 0må|Ü"Ê°ÌÍÉ?ÖÃî &bâ +�� �"� Ê Ñ1ÏÍÉ7Ð1â

q

Page 6: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

wEW[hEhEWXRªZNA4Y·6FK=iLEeº46>GF6fINP@EF­L57WXR>KWXLE46eX=�T6U�N7@EFyNP5?FKF°r_LEeX46RSNPWXRªZ§M5?OZ=�N_8JLWX>d4YeXe[8`]�W[FGa NP@F­eº46RhNPT`wIFzLEeX46RSNPFKh²4YREh²FK=?N7WXOZ4YNPF«NP@EFz>GTV=?N«4¾N�a�@EWX>A@¸N7@EFG8¸>K46R¸>KT6OZLEe[FGN7FyNP@EFz>GTVRSNP5746>GNK;y�)@EW[=FK=1NPW[O¶4YN7FKh¸>GTV=?N hFKLIFKREhE=�TVR¯N7@EFzF ©JLIFK> NPFKh R�DEO­wIFK5 T6U�N757FGFK=�NP@E4YN�4nLEeX46RSNPFK5�a�WXeXe�wIF¨46wEeXFNPT¨LEeX46RSN)WXR®4­hM4d8na�@WX>A@¿fMW[RnNPDE5?R¿fMhEFKLIFKRhE=�T6R:N7@EF ªVFGREFK5746eÅ>KTVRhEW[N7WXTVRE=CT6U�N7@EF�465?Fd4­NPT¨wIFLEeX46RSNPFKhl;

�eº4YR�N7FK5?=�4657F�L57FKhTVOZW[RM46RSNPe^8QLM46WXh¶DE=7W[REªzLEWXFG>KF°r_5P4¾NPF�>GTVRSNP5P4Y>GNP=Gf<46e[N7@ETVDEª6@¶§©JFKhJrga"4YªVF>KT6R�N75P46> NP=�4Y57F"=?TVOZF NPW[OZFG=�DE=?FKh¨WXR=?NPFK46h¿;(\�REhEFG5�LEW[FK>KF°r_574YNPFv>KTVRSNP5746>GN7=KfSLEeX46RSNPFG57=�465?FCLM4YWXh­W[RLE5?TVL%T65?NPW[TVR`NPTQNP@EFGWX5�TVDN7LEDNd;)x�FGREFK5746eXe^8VfMRETZF ©JLEeXW[>KW^N�wM46=7F«a"4YªVFHT65�L57T�hEDE>GN7WXTVRj=?NP46REhM465?hF ©JW[=?NP=Gf«46e[N7@ETVDEªV@À§M57OQ=j4657F ªVTm]VFG57REFGh w�8ÀOQWXREW[O­DEOzrÓaC46ªVF¯eX4da�=K; ��DNPLEDJN2W[=®N_8�LEW[>d46e[e[8OQFd46=?DE57FGhj4Y=CNP@EFiR�DO­w%FG5)T6UÅNP5?FKFG=)LEeº46RSN7FKh`LIFK5"hM4d86fM46e[N7@ETVDEª6@n=7TVOQF 465?Fd4¾rÓwM46=?FKh`=7>A@FKOQFK=465?F¯DE=7FGh�4Y=¶aCFGeXeÍ; #iRÀ4657FK4¾r_wE46=7FGh�=7>A@EFGOZF²WX=¶TVREF¯DERhEFK5na�@EW[>A@�LEeº46RSN7FK57=n4657F¯LE46WXh�W[RLE5?TVL%T65?NPW[TVR NPT�NP@EFv4657FK4�T6UEeº46REh�NP@FG8«LEeº4YR�N�W[Ry4�ªVW[]6FKRyhE4m86fV46=?=7DEOQWXRª�4�LM465?N7WX>GDEeº465Å=?FKFGhEeXW[REªhEFGRE=7W^N_8V;

� � ����� ��¡ � ��� � �m¢ �� �J�$� � �

��DE5zhM4YNP4¯aCFG57F:>KTVe[eXFG>GNPFGh¹4YN¨4¸OZFGhEWXDO¨rÓ=7W �GFKh¿f�N757FGF r_Leº46RSNPW[REª2§M5?Oj;µ�)@EWX=­§M5?O LM4d8�=¨W[N7=LEeX46RSNPFK5?=�LEWXFG>KF¨5P4YN7FK=�F ©J>GeXDE=?W[]VFGe[86;¶' 46W[e[8jFd465?REWXRªV= U¥TV5�4®Leº46RSNPFG5�4657F¨hEF NPFG57OQWXREFGh¤wS8¸NP@FLE5?TJhED>GN�T6U.NP@F LEWXFG>KF 5P4¾NPF 46Rh:N7@EF R�DEO­wIFK5)T6U.N757FKFG="NP@EF�avTV5?·6FK5�LEeX46RSNPFGh®T6R:4¨LE465?N7WX>KDeº465hM4d8 �%RT¶wM46=?F«aC46ªVFHWX=�WXR>KeXDhEFKh®WXR:NP@EF«>KT6R�N75P46> Nd;�BCe[TJ>A·�=�NPTQw%F«LEeX46RSNPFKh24657F�hEW^]�WXhEFGh2WXRSN7T� ���� ��N7THwIF�LEeº46RSN7FKhQw�8¨W[REhEW^]JW[hEDM46eLEeº46RSN7FK57=G;��MTV5�Fd46>A@ZwEeXT�>A·<fSNP@EF�§M57O hFK>KW[hEFK=�TVR¶4«LEW[FK>GF5P4¾NPF6;¨�)@EW[=�5P4YN7F¨NP46·6FG=HW[RSNPT®46>K>GTVDERSN«NP@EF¨F ©JLIFK> NPFKhµR�DO­w%FG5�T6UvN757FGFK=�NP@M4YNH4`LEeX46RSNPFK5�>K46RLEeX46RSN�W[R®4QhM4d8®46Rh®N7@EFHF°©JL%FG>GNPFGh2aC46ªVF NP@EF�§M5?OÆa"46RSN7=�N7TZLM4d86;C�ÓN�WX=�WXOQLITV5?NP46RSN"NPTQRET6N7FNP@E4YN�DEREhEFG5�RET6RJr_F°©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA4YeÅ>KTVREhW[NPW[TVRE=)NP@F«LWXFK>GFH574YNPF�W[=�N7@EF«=P46OQF U¥TV5�46eXe¿LeXT6N7=)WXRj46RFKRSN7WX57F¨wEe[TJ>A·<;¨��T®OZ4YN7>A@EWXREª:T6UvLEeX46RSNPFK5?= NPT:LEeº4YR�N7WXREª`>GTVREhEW^NPW[TVRE=�T�>K>GDE57=«WXR¸NP@WX=�§M5?O =7TEfFG]6FKRnN7@ETVDEªV@ZLEeº4YR�N7FK5?=vOZ4d8¨w%F�@EFGN7FK5?TVªVFKRFKTVDE=GfNP@F�LEW[FK>GFi5P4¾NPF�57FK>GFKW^]VFKh¶WX=�WXREhEFGL%FGREhEFGR�NCT6ULEeX46RSNPFK5)>A@E465P46> NPFG57WX=1NPW[>K=K;

'�DE5?WXREª¸N7@EFjF°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSNKf"Fd46>A@³wEeXT�>A·µaC46=¶hEW^]�WXhEFGh W[R�N7T N_avTµLE465?N7=K;���REF®T6UiN7@EFK=?FLM4651NP=�a"4Y=CNP@EFGRn5P4YREhETVOQe[8y>A@ETV=7FGRnNPTHw%F�LEeº46RSN7FKh¶DREhEFK5�NP@EF�57FGªVDEeX465vLWXFK>GF�574YNPFYf�N7@EFiTYNP@EFG5NPT¶LEeº46RSN7FKh¯DERhEFK5�NP@EFyN757FK4YNPOQFKRSN�LWXFK>GFy574YNPFY;i�)@EF«NP57FK4YNPOQFKRSNiLEWXFG>KF­574YNPFH57FKL57FK=?FKRSNPFGh 46R

o

Page 7: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

WXR>K57FK46=7F�T6U�wIFGN_avFKFKR2FKWXª6@�N�4YREh®N_avFKRSN_8®LIFK57>GFKRSNi46w%Tm]6F�N7@EF�57FGªVDEeº4Y5)LEWXFG>KF 5P4¾NPF6;�"avT¤e[WXOQW[NP4YNPW[TVRE=�WXR�N7@EF`hEFK=?WXªVRÝT6U�N7@EF`F ©JLIFK57W[OZFGRSNza"465?5P46RSNQhEW[=7>KD=7=7W[TVR¿;µ�(WX5?=?Ndf�W[R

TV5?hEFK5�N7T�4m]6TVWXhQ46RS8yL%TV=?=7W[wEeXF���4ma)N7@ETV5?REF)FG¬%FK> NP=Kf * aCT657·6FG57=�aCFG57F�·6FGLN�WXªVRTV5P46RSN�TYUIN7@EF"U�46> NNP@E4YNiN7@EFG8jaCFG57FzLM4651NPW[>KWXLE4YNPW[REªZW[R¸46R¯F°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSNK; ��T:46>G>KTVOQLEe[WX=7@®NP@EW[=KfINP@EFy§E57O REFKFGhEFKh4¤5?Fd46=?TVRM46weXF2F°©JLEeº46RE4YNPW[TVR¹U¥T65Qa�@S8¹NP@EFjLEWXFG>KF2574YNPF:aC46=n>A@M46RªVWXREª¤TVR³=?WXOQWXeX465­LEeX46RSNPWXRª>KT6REhEW[N7WXTVR=K;)�µT657·6FG57=iavFK5?FyNPT6eXh:NP@M4YN�>KT6REhEW[N7WXTVR=�TVRjNP@EF«NP57FK4YNPOQFKRSN�wEeXT�>A·�=i@M4Yh¯>A@M46REª6FKh=7W[RE>KFQNP@EFZTV57W[ªVWXRE46e�wEW[hE=y@M4YhµwIFKFKR�N7FKREhFK57FGhÝ46REh NP@M4YNHNP@EFZTV57W[ªVWXRE46e�wEW[hµLE5?WX>KFZ@M46h¤w%FGFKR@EW[ªV@¿; + ��@EWXe[FZNP@WX=yaC46=z>KT6R�]�W[RE>KW[REª¯NPT¯N7@EF`LEeº4YR�N7FK5?=Kf�W[N­57F���DEW[57FGh =7LM4YN7Wº46ev=7FGLM465P4¾NPWXT6R�T6UNP@F LEeXT6N7="NPTzwIF�LEeº46RSN7FKh`DEREhFK5�Fd46>A@®LEW[FK>KF 574YNPFY;�#i=)=7D>A@¿f<WXREhEW^]�WXhEDM4Ye%LEe[T6NP=C>KTVDEe[h:RET6N�wIF5P4YREhETVOQe[8n46=7=?WXªVREFGh®N7TZ5?FKªVDeº465�46RhjNP5?Fd4YN7OZFGRSN�LWXFK>GF�5P4YN7FK=Kf<wEDJNi574YNP@EFG5�@M46e[U�T6U�NP@EF«wEe[TJ>A·aC46=�5746REhET6OZe^8n46=?=7W[ªVREFKh:NPT¨5?FKªVDEeX465)46Rhj@M4Ye[U�NPTzNP5?Fd4YN7OZFGR�N�LWXFK>GF�5P4YN7FK=K;

�)@EF RFKFKhnN7T­LE5?FK=7FGRSN)NP@EF�F°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSNva�W[NP@WXR¶N7@EFiRM4¾NPDE5746e%avTV57·�W[REªV=CTYUÅNP@EFi§E57O 46eX=?T57FG=?N757WX> [email protected]=7W[ªVR2T6U�N7@EFyF°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSNK;i�)@EF«§M57O >KTVOQOQW[NP=)N7T¶LEeX46RSNPFK5?=iRETYNNPTQ57FGhEDE>GFHNP@F«LWXFK>GFH574YNPFY;C#�eX=7TfENP@EF §M5?O hETJFG=�RT6N�LM4d8:hEW[¬%FK5?FKRSNiLWXFK>GF�5P4YN7FK=�NPT¨aCTV5?·6FG57=LEeX46RSNPWXRª�WXR�>GeXTV=?F¯LE5?Tm©JW[OZW^N_8¹N7T�TVREF²4YRET6NP@FK5Kf�TVR�=?WXOQWXeX465¨ªV57TVDREh¿f�4YNnN7@EF¯=P4YOZF2N7WXOQF6;!CTVRE=?F���DEFGR�N7e[86f�N7@EF2Leº46RSNPW[REª DEREhEFG5ZNP@F257FGªVDEeX465¨LEWXFG>KF2574YNPF:aC46=n>KT6OZLEe[FGN7FKh ����� � ���jNP@FLEeX46RSNPWXRªzDEREhEFG5�N7@EF�@EWXª6@EFK5)NP5?Fd4YN7OZFGRSN�LEWXFG>KF�5P4YN7F6;

� � � ¢ � � � �`¢�m¢ ¢ � � � � � � � � � � �¥��� �H¡��<� � ���

��DE5�hM4YNA4�=7F NC>GTVRSNA46W[RE=�WXRU¥TV5?O¶4¾NPWXT6RzTVRQN7@EF�LEWXFG>KF�5P4YN7F�=?FGN�U¥TV5�Fd46>A@nweXT�>A·IfSa�@EW[>A@¶avF�=?@M46eXehEFGRET6NPF wS8��Jf46REhnNP@F�LEWXFG>KF 574YNPF�5?FK>GFKW[]6FKh:wS8nFK46>A@:LEeº46RSN7FK5Kf�a�@EWX>A@`avF =7@M4YeXeIhEFKRETYNPF wS8�Åf46=)avFKeXe.4Y="NP@M4YN�LEeX46RSNPFG5��}=�hE46WXe^8¶LE5?TJhDE>GN7W[]�W[N_86fa�@EWX>A@:avFH=?@M46eXelhEFKRETYNPF�wS8�Z;

�_R¸��46wEe[F¶sVf<aCFyLE57FG=7FKRSN�=?DEOZOZ46518j=1NA4YN7WX=1NPWX>G=�>GTVRE>GFK57RWXREª:46e[e�smÄS{QT6wE=7FG5?]Y4YNPW[TVRE=�U¥57TVONP@FiF ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNd;�#ÀNPT6NP46e<T6U�pJs�aCT657·6FG57=CavFK5?F�TVwE=?FK51]VFKh`hDE57W[REªHN7@EFiF°©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSNdf�LEeX46RSNPWXRª

* ìHÎGÏÍÒGÉ1ÏÓÐ�ÕÅÈbΫÒKÔ¾ÎAÕ¤ÌgÈbÉ1îzÊ ÏÍÉ)ÌÓÊ°Òdå|ÔbØ�پʠÏ�ÌCåÃÔQÊ Ô¨É 0mÙ6É1ÏgåÃÜ"É?ÔGÌvÜ"ÊPîzÊ Ö}ÌgÉ1Ï�ÌgÈbÉ1å|Ï .YÉ?ȾÊPédåÃÎGËbÏ?ðå|Ô¾×mÉ �ÙYÉ?Ô¾×mÉ?ÔGÌ.ΠÚ�ÌgÈbÉ�É 0mÙ6É1ÏgåÃÜ"É1ÔKÌÓÊ°ÖVÌÍÏgÉ?Ê°ÌÍÜ"É1ÔKÌ7âô½Ô�Ê"Ð�É?ÏÍå|É?ÐlΠÚJÉ 0mÙ6É1ÏgåÃÜ"É?ÔGÌÓÐÅ×mÉ?ÐÍå|Ø ÔbÉ7×�ÌgÎCå|Ôdé É7Ð¥ÌgåÃØKÊAÌÍÉ�ÌÍȾÉÉ �VÉ?Ñ ÌgÐlΰÚ�å|ÖÃÖ|ËbÜ"å|Ô¾ÊAÌgåÃÎGÔ�ΠÔ�Ù¾ÏÍÎm×mË¾Ñ ÌÍå|édå}Ì¥î)ÊAÌ%ÌÍÈbÉ(ß�ÊPÕ¿ÌgÈbΠÏgÔbÉ.ÙbÖæÊ°ÔKÌlΰÚ��(É1Ô¾É1ÏÓÊ°ÖYñIÖÃÉ7Ñ_ÌgÏÍåæÑ°ðKÏÍÉ7Ð�É7Ê°ÏÓÑÓÈbÉ1ÏÓÐÊ°Ö|ÖÃÉ?Ø É7×mÖÃî"ÚÛÎGËbÔ¾×iÐ�ËYÑÓÈ�ÏgÉ?ÐÍËbÖÃÌgÐ?âôºÌÅåæпÔbΰÌgÉ1ÕlΠÏÍÌÍÈdî ðdÈbÎAÕlÉ1éGÉ1Ï7ð ÌgȾÊAÌÅå|ÔiÊvÏgÉ �ºÉ 0bÊ°Ü"å|Ô¾ÊAÌgåÃÎGÔ�ΰÚE×bÊAÌÓÊ�ÚÛÏgΠÜÌÍÈbÉ�ß�ÊPÕ¿ÌÍÈbÎGÏÍÔ¾É(Ù¾Ö|Ê ÔGÌ.óGΠÔbÉ7Ð � �! " & # ÚÛÎGËbÔ¾×iÔbÎ)É?éKåæ×mÉ?Ô¾Ñ É�ΰÚMÐÍ˾ÑÓÈ�É��6É7Ñ_ÌÓÐ1â

+ Ç¿ÈbåæÐ�ȾʠÙbÙ6É1Ô¾ÐCÐ�ÎGÜ"É ÌÍå|Ü"É?ÐvÕÅÈbÉ1Ô­ÌgÈbÉ .bÖÃÎmÑÓÒyȾʠÐ/.YÉ?É1Ԩ˾ÔbÉ 0mÙ6É?Ñ_ÌgÉ?×mÖ|îzÙbÏgÉ1پʠÏÍÉ7× �^ÐgÑ ÏgÉ1É ÚÛÉ7× # .dîyÌÍȾÉò å|Ôbå|Ð�ÌÍÏgî�Î Ú ã ΠÏgÉ?Ð�ÌgÐ?â

Page 8: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� ¢E� � ���������� �� � � � ����� ��� ���� � � � � ����� � � ����������� � ������� � ��� � � �

&�465?Wº46wEe[F *jFK46R ��NK;|'�F ]I; *®WXREW[O­DEO *24b©W[O­DEO��DO­w%FG5�T6U(��57FGFK= Ä6q6qE;|t6 Â6qsV;|ÄVp ÂS{6o smÄ �Vo��FKªVDEeX465)�WXFG>KF«��4YNPF t;æp�s t;|tVp t;[s � t;æpYÂ�WXFG>KF«��4¾NPF�(4YWXh t;æpY t;|t6 t;[s � t;æp��' 46W[e[8Z��4657REW[REªV=H»��6!ChER<¼ pJsKqE;æ{6{ �6Ä;æp6o �6Ä;æ{Yt q�o�sV;|ÄVo

TVRyN7@E57FGFChEW^¬lFG57FGR�N(wEeXT�>A·�=KfVTm]6FK5�4�NP@E5?FKF rÓOZT6R�N7@­LIFK57W[TJh«WXR«NP@EFv=7LE5?WXREª�46REhy=?DEOQOZFG5(T6UIpYtVtVÂfsmtVÄ�TVR«>KTVRSN757TVeSLEe[T6NP=�46Rh ����TVR�NP5?Fd4YN7OZFGR�N�LEe[T6NP=G;��)@FCLEW[FK>KF�574YNPFG=�LM4YWXh NPT�LEeº4YR�N7FK5?=�hED57WXRªNP@F F ©JL%FG57W[OZFGR�N�5746REªVFGh:U¥5?TVO s �yNPTZp��­>KFGRSNP=�L%FG5)=7FKFGhEeXW[REªEfa�W^NP@:46R®4d]VFG5P46ª6F«TYU�p6­>GFKRSNP=G;�)@EF�57FGªVDEeX465�»�T65)>KTVRSNP5?TVe½¼CLWXFK>GF 5P4YN7FK=�5P4YREªVFKh`U¥5?TVO s �­N7T¶pY­>KFKRSN7=�LIFK5)=?FKFKheXWXRªEfa�W[N7@®46R4d]VFG5P46ªVF¨T6UCpJs¨>GFKRSNP=G;Q� R 4d]VFG5P46ª6F6fÅaCT657·6FG57=«LEeº4YR�N7FKh Ä6qVq`=?FKFGhEeXW[REªV= LIFK5 hM4d8²46Rh FK4657RFKh�VpJsmo®»Í!"46RM46hWº46R<¼�L%FG5�hE4m86;

��TZ@WXªV@Ee[WXªV@SNvNP@EF«FKREhTVªVFKRFKW[N_8nLE57TVweXFKO WXR��?RETVR�r_F ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46e! zhM4YNP4favFH5?FKªV5?FK=7=?FKhNP@F`eXTVªS4Y57W[N7@EO T6U)N757FKFG=zLEeº4YR�N7FKhÝFd4Y>A@¹hE4m8¤TVR NP@FneXTVªV4657W^NP@EO T6U�N7@EFn57FGªVDEeX465­LEW[FK>KF¶5P4YN7FLM46W[h D=7WXRª N7@EF¤sdtVÄ >GTVRSNP5?TVe^rÓªV57TVDL¹T6wE=7FG5?]Y4YNPW[TVRE=G;³�_R³��46wEe[FjpJfvavFjL57FK=?FKRSNnN7@EFj5?FK=?DEe[N7=U¥57T6O FK=1NPW[O¶4YN7WXREª­N7@EF U¥TVeXe[Tma�WXREª­5?FKªV5?FK=?=7WXT6RjOQTJhFKeg$

eXTVª #"%$ &('*),+�$ ".-�)0/IeXTVª ��&1-32,"4$ & »¥qE;[sm¼

a�@EFG57F #"%$ &z57FGLE57FG=7FGR�N7= NP57FGFK= LEeX46RSNPFGh¯wS8¯WXRhEW[]�WXhDM46e65CTVR¸LeXT6N87Mf ��&z57FGLE57FG=7FKRSN7=�N7@EF­LEW[FK>GF5P4¾NPFn5?FK>KFGW[]6FKh¹L%FG5­NP57FGF`LEeº4YR�N7FKh TVRÝLEe[T6N97Mf�46REh:)6+$ " W[=z4f�LITV=7=?WXwEe^8µW[REhEW^]JW[hEDM46eÛr_=?L%FG>KW[§E>6fWXRSN7FK57>GFKLNK;���@EFKR`W[REhEW^]JW[hEDM46eÛr_=?L%FG>KW[§E>)@EFGN7FK57T6ªVFKREFGW[N_8ZWX=vWXªVRET657FKhlf�N7@EF�FG=?NPW[O¶4¾NPFK=�WXRZ>KTVe[DEOQR»Í4V¼lT6U��(46weXF�p"=7DEª6ªVFK=1NÅ[email protected][RE>K5?Fd46=?WXREª"N7@EF�LEWXFG>KF�574YNPF�hEFG>K5?Fd46=?FK=�4m]6FK5746ªVF�LE57T�hEDE> NPW^]JW^N_8 �YNP@FFK=1NPW[O¶4YN7FKh«FKeX46=?N7WX>KW^N_8�T6ULE57T�hEDE> NPW^]JW^N_8�a�W[N7@H5?FK=?L%FG>GN(N7T�LWXFK>GFv574YNPF�WX=<;ipJÁ}q ��4YREhH=1NA4YN7WX=1NPWX>K46eXe^8=7W[ªVREW^§M>d46RSNK;�#�hEOZW^N7N7WXREª�WXRhEW[]�WXhDM46e^rÓ=7LIFK>GW[§M>�@EF NPFG57TVªVFGREFKW^N_8yW[RHN7@EFCW[R�N7FK5?>KFKLJN ´>KTVe[DEOZR¶»�wM¼T6U<��46wEe[F)p ±57FK=?DEe[N7=�WXR­46R­WXR>K57FK46=7FGhzFK=1NPWXOZ4YN7FKh­FGeº46=1NPWX>GW[N_86f6wEDN(W[N(WX=(=1NPW[eXe�REFKªV4YNPW^]VF6f=;HsVÁ|{V{Jf46REh®=?NP4YNPW[=?N7WX>d4YeXe[8Q=?WXªVREW^§M>d4YR�NK;

�)@EF¤REFKªV4YNPW^]VF >KT�F �Q>KW[FKRSN2FG=?N7WXOZ4YNPF²TVRÀNP@EF eXTVªV4657W^NP@EO T6UyN7@EF¤LWXFK>GFµ574YNPF²LM46W[hÀN7T{

Page 9: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� ¢E� � �� � � � � ��� �� ��������� � ��� ��� � � � �� � � ��� ����� ��� � ��� � ��� ���� � � ��� �� � � �� � � � ��� � ��� � � ��� � ������ � � � � �� ��� �����

�_REhEFGL%FGREhEFGR�N�&�4657WX46wEe[F »Í4V¼ »�wM¼!CTVRE=1NA46RSN pJÁÃÄVts ÂÁ �6q�p

»Ít;|p6ÄVtS¼ »Ít;ÃÂVÄ6q�¼-ÅTVªS465?W[N7@EO TYU��WXFG>KF«��4YNPF«(4YWXh ;ipJÁ}q �s ;«sVÁ|{V{Yq

»Ít;^s � �S¼ »Ít;|p �SoV¼*24¾©JW[O­DEO �_RhEW[]�WXhDM46eÅ��¬%FK>GN tÁ|oV{Vp

»Ít;^smÂS{V¼*jW[REWXO­DO �_REhW[]�WXhEDE46eÅ��¬lFG>GN ;�tÁ|p��s

»Ít;Ãt��sb¼��� tÁ �Sp6t tÁ � �VÂ

LEeX46RSNPFK5?=jW[=nNP5?TVDEwEe[WXREª U¥57T6O NP@EF LIFK57=?L%FG>GN7W[]VF T6UyWXRE>GFKRSNPW^]VF²NP@EFGTV5?86; ��46·6FGR�eXW^NPFK5746eXe^8Vf�W[N=7DªVªVFK=1NP=�NP@M4¾N�a�@FKRZN7@EF�LEWXFG>KF�5P4YN7F�WX=�@EW[ªV@¨LEeº46RSN7FK57=�avTV57·ze[FK=?=�W[RSNPFKR=7W[]6FKe^8­NP@M4YRQa�@EFGR¶NP@FLEW[FK>KF�5P4¾NPF�WX=.eXTma�;�#iR­4Ye[NPFG57RM4¾NPW[]6F�F ©JLEeº4YRM4YNPW[TVR�WX=ÅNP@E4YN�N7@EF�LEWXFG>KF�5P4YN7F�W[=.FKREhET6ªVFKRET6DE=�N7T�NP@F=?NP4YNPW[=?N7WX>d4YeÅOZT�hEFKeÍ;"�_R2LE465?N7WX>KDeº465GfMW[U�LWXFK>GFH574YNPFG=�465?FH>GTV575?FKeX4YNPFGhja�W[N7@jDRETVwE=?FK5?]6FKh¸U�46> NPTV5?=NP@E4YN�46e[=7T`4Y¬%FK> N�LEeº4YR�N7FK5�LE57T�hEDE> NPW[]�W^N_8VflN7@EFKR¸NP@F­TVwE=?FK5?]6FKh¤LEWXFG>KF­574YNPFya�W[eXe�w%Fy>KTV5?57FKeX4YNPFGha�W[N7@2NP@FyFK5?57TV5�NPFG57O 2 "4$ ��W[R »�q;[sb¼°;��Ý�)@EW[=�>KTV5?57FGeº4YN7WXTVR:a�WXe[e�5?FK=?DEe[NiWXR2wWº46=?FKh¸FK=1NPW[O¶4YN7FK=�T6UNP@FCFKeX46=?N7WX>GW[N_8�T6UML57T�hEDE>GN7W[]�W[N_8�a�W^NP@y5?FK=?L%FG>GN�N7T�LEWXFG>KFv5P4YN7FK=(wIFK>K46DE=?F"TVREFvT6UMNP@EFvO¶4YWXRSNA46W[REFKh46=?=7DEOQLNPW[TVRE=)T6U(eXFK46=?N1r_= ��DM4Y57FK=�FG=?NPW[O¶4¾NPWXT6Rn@M46=�wIFKFKR®]�WXTVeX4YNPFGh¿;

��4m]�W[REªjF°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSNP46e�hM4YNP4j4d]6TVWXhE=�N7@EFQFKREhET6ªVFKREFGW[N_8¸L57TVwEe[FKO wS8¸L57Tm]�WXhEW[REª:F ©JTVªVF°rRETVD=H]Y4657WX4YNPW[TVR WXR¤N7@EF¶LWXFK>GF¶574YNPFQU¥TV5­4®ªVW[]6FKR�=?FGNzT6U"LEeº46RSN7WXREªj>KTVREhW[NPW[TVRE=G;®�_Rµ�(46weXFK=yÂ46REh2qEf%avFzLE57FG=7FGR�N N7@EFy=?DEOQO¶46518®=?NA4¾NPWX=1NPW[>K=�U¥T65�NP@F­57FGªVDEeº4Y5­»¥TV5i>GTVRSNP57T6e½¼�4YREh2NP5?Fd4YN7OZFGRSNhM4YNP4«=?FGN7=va�@EW[>A@n>KTVRSNP46WXR®smtVÄ«46REh%���«T6wE=7FG5?]Y4YNPW[TVRE=GfJ5?FK=7LIFK> NPW^]VFKe^8V;��)@EFi4d]VFK5746ªVF�LEWXFG>KF�5P4YN7F57FG>KFGW[]VFGh�wS8²LEeº4YR�N7FK5?=HW[R N7@EFZ>GTVRSNP5?TVe�ªV57TVDL¤aC46=y4Yw%TVDJN­p�sZ>GFKRSNP=HL%FG5«N757FKFYf�a�@EW[eXF¨WXR²NP@FNP5?Fd4YN7OZFGRSN�ªV5?TVDELyW^N�aC46=�4Yw%TVDJN�p ��>KFGR�N7=�L%FG5�N757FKFY;���Rz4d]VFG5P46ª6F6f6N7@EFC>GTVRSNP57T6eJªV5?TVDEL­Leº46RSNPFGh

� Ç¿ÈbÉ�Ü)Ê°Ô¾ÔbÉ1Ï)å|Ô`ÕÅÈbåæÑÓÈZÌgÈbÉ��¾ÏgÜ/ÑÓȾÎKÎKÐ�É7ÐvÌÍÈbÉ�Ù¾åÃÉ7Ñ É ÏÓÊAÌÍÉ�ÊGÐ)ÊyÚÛËbÔ¾Ñ ÌÍå|ΠÔ`ΰÚ�ÙbÖæÊ°ÔKÌÍå|ÔbبÑ1ΠԾ×måÃÌÍå|ΠÔYÐØ É?ÔbÉ1ÏÓÊAÌgÉ?ÐlÌÍȾå|ÐÅÑ1ΠÏgÏÍÉ?Ö|Ê°ÌÍå|ΠÔ�â

Page 10: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� ¢E� � ���������� �� � � � ����� ��� ������ � � ����� � ����� � � ���<����� � � ������� � ��� � � �

&�465?Wº46wEe[F *jFK46R ��NK;|'�F ]I; *®WXREW[O­DEO *24b©W[O­DEO��DO­w%FG5�T6U(��57FGFK= �����; �Vo ÂSp6oJ;Ãq � ÂVÄ6t sb{ �Vo�WXFG>KF«��4¾NPF t;æp�s t;æp6o t;[s � t;æpYÂ' 46W[e[8Z��4657REW[REªV= s �VpJ; �Vo oYt;ÃqVt �6Ä;æ{Yt Âsm{J;æ{Yt*24¾©JW[O­DEOÆ' 4YWXe[8 sdÂ;æ{ � qE;ÃqVt �;|t6t p�sV;[sdt��FKOQL%FG5P4YN7DE57FZ»g!CFGeX=?WXDE=P¼' 46W[e[8Z�57FK>GWXLEW^NA4YN7WXTVR oJ;æpY {J;æo¾q t;|t6t p �;ÃqVt»g*®WXeXe[WXOQFGN757FK=P¼!CDEO­Deº4YN7W[]VF�' 4d8�=)�µT657·6FGh t;|Ä6Ä t;|Ä�� t Â

� ¢E� � ���������� �� � � � ����� ��� ������ ��� � � � ��� � ����� � � ������� � � ������� � ��� � � �

&�465?Wº46wEe[F *jFK46R ��NK;|'�F ]I; *®WXREW[O­DEO *24b©W[O­DEO��DO­w%FG5�T6U(��57FGFK= smtsbp�;|Â��Vo ÂSo�sV;æpY ÂS{6o smÄ �Vo�WXFG>KF«��4¾NPF�(4YWXh t;æp � t;|tVp t;æpY t;æp��' 46W[e[8Z��4657REW[REªV= pVo¾qE;æo � ���;|Ä�� smtVoJ;|t6t q�o�sV;|ÄVo*24¾©JW[O­DEOÆ' 4YWXe[8 s��;[s6s {J;|t�� �;ÃqVt p6oJ; �6t��FKOQL%FG5P4YN7DE57FZ»g!CFGeX=?WXDE=P¼' 46W[e[8Z�57FK>GWXLEW^NA4YN7WXTVR Â;|t6Ä qE;|ÂJs t;|t6t sdÂ;ÃqVt»g*®WXeXe[WXOQFGN757FK=P¼!CDEO­Deº4YN7W[]VF�' 4d8�=)�µT657·6FGh sV;æo6p sV;|t6 t Â

�����z=?FKFKheXWXRªV=)L%FG5�hM4d8VfEa�@EW[eXF�NP@F�N757FK4YNPOQFKRSN�ªV57T6DEL:LEeº46RSN7FKh smtsbpy=?FKFKheXWXRªV=K;��Ty>GTVRE=7W[hEFK5�NP@F�=1NA4YN7WX=?N7WX>K46eM=7W[ªVREW[§E>d46RE>GF�TYU¿TVDE5�5?FK=7De[NP=�U¥DE5?N7@EFK5Gf�avF�46DEªVOQFKRSNPFGh¸»¥qE;[sm¼

NPT®WXR>KTV5?L%TV574YNPFzF°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSNP46e�]Y4657WX4YNPW[TVR¸WXR¸NP@FZhM4¾NA4;Q�_R¤LE465?N7WX>KDeº465Gf¿aCFQ>KTVR=7WXhFK57FGhµNP@FU¥TVe[eXTma�WXREªy57FKª657FK=?=7W[TVR¿$

e[TVª �"4$ &9'��#+$ " & -� /Ie[TVª�� & - 2 "4$ & »¥qE;æp6¼Ä

Page 11: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� ¢E� ���� ��� � � � ��� ��� � � � ��� � � � �� ��������� � ��� ��� � � � �� � � ��� ����� ��� � ��� � ��� ���� � � ��� �� � � �� � � � ��� � ��� � � ��� � ������ � � � � �� ��� �����

�_REhEFGL%FGREhEFGR�N�&�4657WX46wEe[F!CTVRE=1NA46RSN {JÁ|oV{V{

»Ít;^sbo6ÂS¼-ÅTVªS465?W[N7@EO TYU � tÁÃÂVÄVÂ

»Ít;Ãt��VÄS¼*24¾©JW[O­DEO �_RhEW[]�WXhDM46eÅ��¬%FK>GN tÁ|oVpV{

»Ít;Ãt��VÂS¼*jW[REWXO­DO �_REhW[]�WXhEDE46eÅ��¬lFG>GN ;�tÁÃÂsdq

»Ít;ÃtSo �S¼*24¾©JW[O­DEO ��W[NPF���¬%FK> N ;�tÁ}qEsmÂ

»Ít;Ãt6q �S¼*jW[REWXO­DOÆ�JW^NPF���¬%FK>GN ;�tÁ|oYq�o

»Ít;Ãt6q �S¼��� tÁ ���s

a�@EFG57F � &H5?FKLE5?FK=7FGRSNP=�N7@EF�LEWXFG>KF�5P4¾NPF LM46W[h:TVR24zLM4Y5?NPW[>KDEeX465"LEe[T6Ndf �������Xf� &('�� � & U¥T65"NP57FK4YNPOQFKRSN�ªV5?TVDEL®TVwE=?FK5?]Y4YN7WXTVR=

��& U¥T65)>KTVRSNP5?TVeŪV5?TVDEL:TVwE=?FK5?]Y4YN7WXTVR=Kf46REh �#+�$ " &�57FGLE57FG=7FKRSN7=v4�>GTVRE=1NA46RSN�NPFG57O NP@M4¾N�WX=�WXREhEW^]�WXhEDM4Ye46RhzLEeXT6N(=7LIFK>GW[§M>Y;���T6N7FCNP@E4YN�NP@FF ©JTVª6FKRETVD=i]Y4657WX4YNPW[TVR`WXR®NP@EFHLEWXFG>KF«5P4YN7FyhEW[57FK> NPe^8`WXhEFGRSNPW[§EFK=�N7@EF«FKeº4Y=?NPW[>KW^N_8:T6U�LE5?TJhDE>GN7W[]�W[N_8a�W[N7@:57FK=?L%FG>GN�NPT¨LEWXFG>KF�5P4¾NPFK=G;v�)@FH5?FK=7De[NP=)U¥5?TVO FG=?NPW[O¶4¾NPWXRª®»�qE;|pV¼"465?F«L57FK=?FKRSNPFGh¯WXR:��46wEe[FoJ;

�)@EF)FG=?N7WXOZ4YNPFGh­FKeX46=?N7WX>KW^N_8«WX=(LITV=?W[NPW^]VFYfStÁÃÂVÄfV4YREhz=?NP4YNPW[=?NPW[>d46e[e[8 =?WXªVRW[§M>K46RSNdfVwEDJN�=7OZ46eXe[FK5NP@E46RnLE5?FG]�WXTVD=CFK=1NPW[O¶4YN7FK=G;�(4V465?=7>A@:46Rh:�J@EFK4657FG5�»1smÄ6ÄVÄS¼�FK=?N7WXOZ4YNPFGhn4ye[TmaCFG5CwITVDEREh¶N7TyNP@FFKeX46=?N7WX>GW[N_8QNPTQw%F Tm]VFG5itJÁæ{V{�fa�@EWXe[F��i46e[FG8¸»gp6tVt6ÂS¼CFK=1NPWXOZ4YN7FKh:W[N"N7T¨w%F«tÁ}qEsV;

Ç¿ÈbÉyÙYÎGåÃÔKÌ�É7Ð¥ÌgåÃÜ)Ê°ÌÍɫΠÚ�ÌÍÈbÉyÉ1ÖæÊ Ð�ÌÍåæÑ åÃÌ¥înÑ1Ê°ÖæÑ Ë¾Ö|Ê°ÌÍÉ?× .KînçMÊ Ê ÏgÐgÑÓÈ`Ê°Ô¾×jÞdÈbÉ?Ê ÏÍÉ?Ï�Õ¿Ê Ð�ÎAé É1Ï &mð.ÕÅÈbå|Ö|Éß�Ê ÖÃÉ?î�� Ð�Õ¿Ê Ð �� � â�ìHÉi×måæÐÍÑ1˾ÐÍÐ�ÏÍÉ7Ê ÐÍΠԾÐ(ÚÛÎGÏ�ÌgÈbÉ�×må �6É?ÏÍÉ?Ô¾Ñ É7Ð�å|Ô¨É?Ð�ÌÍå|Ü)ÊAÌgÉ?Ð�å|Ô¨ÐÍÉ?Ñ_ÌgåÃÎGÔ â ï.ΠÌÍÉ)ÌgÎdÎÌÍȾʰÌ?ð<ÕÅȾåÃÖ|É�ÌgÈbÉ�É7Ð¥ÌgåÃÜ)ÊAÌgÉ?ÐvΰÚ�çMÊGÊ°ÏÓÐÍÑÓÈzÊ°ÔYרÞdÈbÉ?Ê ÏÍÉ?Ï � �- " � �# ʠԾרß�Ê°Ö|É1î �'&"("("* # Ê°ÏgÉ�É?Ð�ÌÍå|Ü)ÊAÌgÉ?ÐvΰÚÌÍÈbÉ�É �VΠÏÍÌ¿É?Ö|ÊGÐ¥Ìgå|Ñ1å}Ì¥îGðdÌÍÈbÉ�Ñ1ΠÜ"پʠÏÍåæÐ�ÎGÔ�åæÐ.Ð�ÌÍå|ÖÃÖ�éAÊ ÖÃåæ× .YÉ7Ñ1Ê°ËYÐ�É(ÌÍȾÉ1å|ÏÅÜCÎm×mÉ?Ö|Ð.åÃÜ"ÙbÖ|î�É �GËYÊ°Ö|å}Ì¥î�.6É Ì¥ÕlÉ1É?ÔÉ �VΠÏÍÌ�Ê°Ô¾×�ÙbÏgÎm×m˾Ñ_ÌgåÃédåÃÌ¥î�É?Ö|ÊGÐ¥Ìgå|Ñ1å}ÌgåÃÉ7Ð1â

smt

Page 12: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� � � � � �m¡�� �� ����� �<¡ � � ��� � � � � � � ��� ��£6�b�

x W[]VFGR¤N7@EFZwIFGU¥T657F r_4YU½NPFG5HRE4YNPDE5?FZTYUCNP@F¶F ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNdf�W[N«WX=«WXOQLITV5?NP46RSN NPTj46>K>GTVDERSNyU¥TV5�NP@FFG¬%FK> NP=vT6UÅT6N7@EFK5�U�46>GN7TV57=�a�@EW[>A@n>KT6DEeXhQw%F�>A@M46RªVWXREªy4YN�NP@EF�=P4YOZF�NPW[OZF�46=�NP@EF�F ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46eNP5?Fd4YN7OZFGRSN24YREhÀa�@WX>A@�>GTVDEe[h LITV=7=?WXwEe^8�4Y¬%FK> NjL57T�hEDE>GN7W[]�W[N_86; �¤F²>KTVR>KFKRSN75P4YN7FµTVR�N_aCTfavFd4YN7@EFK5�46REh`U�4YN7WXªVDEFY;

� ��� ��� � � � ��� ��¢��� ��¡

��TH>GTVRSNP57T6eEU¥TV5�aCFK4YNP@FK5Kf�avF�>GTVeXe[FK> NPFKhQhM4YNP4 TVR¨hM46WXe^8­5746WXRU�4YeXeJ46REhQO¶4¾©JW[O­DEO NPFKOQLIFK5P4¾NPDE5?FU¥TV5"N7@EF�hM4d8J=�46REh®57FGªVWXT6RE=�WXR`a�@EWX>A@:NP@F«F°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSN�NPT�TV·ZLEeº46>GF6;��¤FH4YDEªVOQFKRSNPFGh®N7@EFHF°©�rLIFK57W[OZFGRSNA46e%57FKª657FK=?=7W[TVRnNPTzW[RE>Ke[DEhEFiN7@EFK=?F�]Y465?Wº46weXFK=GfJ>GTVRE=?WXhEFG57WXRª­NP@EF�U¥TVe[eXTma�WXRªy57FGªV57FG=7=?WXTVR¿$

e[TVª �" &(' �#+$ " & - � /IeXTVª�� &8-� ���� ��" & - ����� � ��� 5 �=" &8-32," & »ÍoJ;[sm¼

�)@EF�57FG=7DEe^NP=.U¥57TVO »ÍoJ;^sb¼¿4657F�LE5?FK=?FKRSNPFGhzWXR��(4YwEeXF �;.�µF�LE5?FK=7FGRSN�N7@E57FGFv=?FGNP=�T6UJ57FK=?DEe[N7=K;��_RHNP@F§M5?=?N�>KTVe[DEOQR¿fVaCF�ªVW^]VF�eXFK46=?N1r_= ��DE4657FG=�»Í��-��E¼(>GTJF �Q>KWXFGRSNvFG=?N7WXOZ4YNPFG=K;��_R¨NP@EF�=?FK>KT6REh¶>GTVeXDEOQR¿favFnLE57FG=7FGR�N¨��-��¤=1NA46RhM4657hµFK575?TV57=­46REh¿f�WXR¤N7@EF¶N7@EWX5?h�46REh¤U¥TVDE5?N7@µ>GTVeXDEOQRE=Gf�avFnLE57FG=7FGR�NKf57FG=7LIFK> NPW[]6FKe^8Vf�@EF NPFG57TV=?>KFKhE46=?N7WX> rÓ>KTVR=7WX=1NPFGR�N¨=1NA46RhM4657hµFK575?TV57=Gf�46Rh�57TVwDE=?Ny@EFGN7FK57T6=7>KFGhM46=1NPWX>°r>KT6RE=7W[=?NPFGRSN�=?NP46REhM4Y57h2FG575?TV57=�NP@M4¾N�46hOZW^N)U¥TV5�RETVRJrÓWXREhEFGL%FGREhEFGR�N�TVwE=?FK51]64¾NPWXT6RE=�hDEFHN7TZ>GTVO¨rOQTVR¿fEDERTVwE=7FG5?]6FKh¿fIhM46W[e[8Z=7@ET�>A·�=K;��)@EFy4Y=7=7T�>KWX4YNPFGh:LJrÓ]Y46e[DEFK=�465?F�ªVW[]6FKR®WXR:LM465?FKRSNP@EFG=7FG=K;

�)@EF«5P4YWXRU�46e[e¿46RhjNPFGOZLIFK574YNPD57F�>KT�F �Q>KW[FKRSNP=�465?FH=1NA4YN7WX=?N7WX>K46eXe^8ZW[RE=7W[ªVREW^§M>d46RSN�46Rh®N7@EFKW[5WXR>KeXD=7WXT6R¸@M46= eXW^N7N7eXFyF ¬lFG>GN«TVR¸NP@FzLE57T�hEDE> NPWXT6R FGeº46=1NPW[>KW[N_8jFK=1NPW[O¶4YN7F6; � �)@WX=�=7DEª6ªVFK=1NP= NP@M4¾NOZ46>K5?TYrÓavFd4YN7@EFK5)=?@ET�>A·�=i4657F RT6N�LEeº4d8�WXREª¨4zOZ4��?TV5)5?TVeXF W[RnNP@EF�F ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46eÅhE4YNA4;

� � �� � � � � � � � ��� ¢J��� � �

#iRT6NP@EFG5zL%TYNPFKRSN7Wº46e�>KTVRJU¥TVDEREhEW[REª¸FKe[FKOQFKRSN­N7@M4YNz>GTVDEeXh W[R �MDEFGRE>KFnN7@EF`#��i��&�# 57FG=7DEe^NP=­W[=avTV57·YFK5�U�4YNPW[ªVDEF6;��JWXRE>GF NP@EF LEW[FK>GF«574YNPF�aC46=�WXR>K57FK46=7FGhjT6REe[8n4YU½NPFG5)LEeº46RSN7WXREª­aC46=�>KTVOQLEe[FGNPFGh4YNHNP@EFZ57FKª6DEeº465«5P4¾NPF6f�aCTV5?·6FG57=zOZ4m86f�WXR¤ªVFKRFK5P4Yegf�wIF¶OQTV57FQNPW[57FKh¤TVRµN757Fd4¾NPOQFKRSN?rÓ5P4YN7F¶hM4d8�=

� õ��¥ÎGåÃÔKÌ�ÌgÉ?Ð�ÌJΠÚmÌÍÈbÉ%ÈKîdÙ6ΰÌgÈbÉ?ÐÍå|Ð�ÌÍȾʰÌ�ÌgÈbÉ%Ñ1ÎKÉ���Ñ å|É1ÔKÌgÐ�ΠÔ�ÏÓÊ°å|ÔmÚ^Ê°Ö|ÖGÊ Ô¾×(ÌÍÉ?Ü"ÙYÉ?ÏgÊ°ÌÍËbÏgÉ%Ê ÏÍÉ��?É1ÏgÎ.ÙbÏgÎd×bË¾Ñ É7ÐÙ �ºéPÊ ÖÃ˾É?ÐEÎ°Ú ( � � � ë ÞCÐ¥ÌÓÊ°Ô¾×bÊ Ïg×�É1ÏgÏÍÎGÏgÐ # ð)( � + �^ÈbÉ ÌgÉ1ÏgÎGÐgÑ É7×bÊ Ð�ÌÍåæÑ �ºÏÍÎ�.b˾Ð�ÌEÐ�ÌgÊ Ô¾×bÊ Ïg×�É1ÏgÏÍÎGÏgÐ # ð°Ê Ô¾× ( � &�ÛÏgÎ".bËYÐ¥Ì.ÈbÉ1ÌÍÉ?ÏÍÎKÐÍÑ1É?×bÊGÐ¥Ìgå|Ñ(Ð¥ÌÓʰԾ׾ʰÏÓ×�É1ÏgÏgΠÏÓÐ%ÕÅåÃÌÍÈ�ÔbÎGÔ �ºåÃÔ¾×bÉ1Ù6É1Ô¾×mÉ?ÔKÌ.Î".¾ÐÍÉ1ÏgéAÊAÌÍå|ΠÔYÐ # â

sVs

Page 13: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� ¢E� ���� ��� � � � ��� ��� � � � ��� � � � �� ��������� � ��� ��� � � � �� � � ��� ����� ��� � ��� � ��� ���� � � ��� �� � � �� � � � ��� � ��� � � ��� � ������ � � � � �� ��� �����

�_REhEFGL%FGREhEFGR�N�&�4657WX46wEe[F !CT�F �Q>KW[FKRSN � -�� ��TVwEDE=1N ��TVwEDE=1N��=?N7WXOZ4YNPF ��NPhj��5757T65 ��NPhj��5757T65 ��NPhj��5757T65

»¥�_REhEFKLIFKRhEFKRE>GFm¼ »g!Ce[DE=?N7FK5?WXREª�¼!CTVRE=1NA46RSN {JÁ|oVoYq t;|pVp6Ä t;|pV{Vo t;|pVpVo

»Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼-ÅTVªS465?W[N7@EO TYU � tÁÃÂVÄ�� t;^smtVt t;^sVsm t;^sVsb{

»Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »1;ÃtVtsb¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVÂS¼*24¾©JW[O­DEO �_RhEW[]�WXhDM46e tÁ|oVpVo t;Ãt��V t;ÃtSoVp t;Ãt6q ���¬lFG>GN »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼*jW[REWXO­DO �_REhW[]�WXhEDE46e ;�tÁÃÂsbo t;ÃtSo � t;ÃtSo�� t;ÃtSoV{��¬lFG>GN »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼*24¾©JW[O­DEO ��W[NPF ;�tÁ}qStSp t;ÃtS{6 t;ÃtS{6Ä t;ÃtSo6t��¬lFG>GN »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼*jW[REWXO­DOÆ�JW^NPF ;�tÁ|oYq�{ t;Ãt��V t;ÃtVÄV t;Ãt �6q��¬lFG>GN »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼*24¾©JW[O­DEOÆ' 4YWXe[8 tÁÃtVts t;ÃtVtSo t;ÃtVtSo t;ÃtVt6q��FKOQL%FG5P4YN7DE57F »Ít;ÃÂVtS{V¼ »Ít;|{V{��S¼ »Ít;|{6Âsb¼��T6NA46e¿' 46WXe^8 tÁÃtVtSp t;ÃtVtSp t;ÃtVtSp t;ÃtVts�57FG>KWXLW[NA4¾NPWXT6R »Ít;|{ �VtS¼ »Ít;|p6ÄS{V¼ »Ít;Ãt ���S¼

��� tÁ ���s

NP@E46R TVRÝ>KTVRSN757TVeÛr_5P4¾NPF¶hE4m8�=G; �¤F`LE57Td©�8µU�4¾NPWXª6DEFnwS8�>GDEO­DEeX4YNPW^]VF¶hE4m8�=zavTV57·YFKh¹=7WXR>KFnNP@Feº4Y=?N hM4d8¸TYUC5?FK=?NK;z�M57TVO �(4YwEeXFG=�®4YREh²qj4d]6FK5P4YªVF¨>KDEO­Deº4YN7W[]VFyhM4d8J= avTV57·YFKh¤WX=�@EW[ªV@EFG5 TVRNP5?Fd4YN7OZFGRSN?r_574YNPF«hM4d8�=z» sVÁæo6pV¼)N7@M46RjTVR2>GTVRSNP57T6e^r_574YNPF�hM4d8�=z»�t;ÃÄVÄS¼ ;)#/�T6WX=7=?TVR¯5?FKªV5?FK=7=?WXTVRjT6UhM4d8�= aCTV5?·6FGhµTVR 4`hEDEOQOy82]Y465?Wº46weXFyW[REhEW[>d4YN7WXREª¶N757FK4YNPOQFKRSN?rÓ5P4YN7FzhM4d8�=«=?DEªVªVFG=?N7=«N7@M4YN NP@FhEW^¬lFG57FKR>KF�WX=)=1NA4YN7WX=?N7WX>K46eXe^8Z=?WXªVRW[§M>K46RSN �N7@EF�LJrÓ]Y46e[DEF�U¥TV5"NP@F«F ��DM46eXW^N_8nT6U(OZFK46RE=)W[=�tÁ|t6tsV;

��T­>KT6R�N757TVeIU¥TV5vU�4¾NPWXª6DEF6fSavF WXRE>GeXDEhEFGh¶LE5?FG]�WXT6DE="hM4d8�=CavTV57·YFKh:hEWX5?FK> NPe[8QW[R�N7THN7@EF�>KT6REhEW^rNPW[TVRM46e.OQFd46RjU¥DERE>GN7WXTVRjU¥TV5iLE5?TJhDE>GN7W[]�W[N_8j46REh¸D=7F­5?FKªV5?FK=7=?WXTVR²4YRM46e[8�=?WX=K;i�)@EFK=?Fz57FK=?DEe[N7= 465?FLE5?FK=7FGRSNPFKh2WXR:�(4YwEeXF«{J;

sbp

Page 14: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� ¢E� ���� �� ��������� � ��� ��� � � � �� � � ��� � �� � � ��� ����� ��� � ��� � ��� ���� � � ��� �� � � �� � � � ��� � ��� � � ��� � ������ � � � � �� ��� �����

�_REhEFGL%FGREhEFGR�N�&�4657WX46wEe[F !CT�F �Q>KW[FKRSN � -�� ��TVwEDE=1N ��TVwEDE=1N��=?N7WXOZ4YNPF ��NPhj��5757T65 ��NPhj��5757T65 ��NPhj��5757T65

»¥�_REhEFKLIFKRhEFKRE>GFm¼ »g!Ce[DE=?N7FK5?WXREª�¼!CTVRE=1NA46RSN {JÁ|oYqEs t;^s �Vt t;^sboV{ t;^sb{V{

»Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼-ÅTVªS465?W[N7@EO TYU � tÁÃÂS{ � t;ÃtVÄSp t;ÃtVÄs t;^smt��

»Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »1;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVÂS¼*24¾©JW[O­DEO �_RhEW[]�WXhDM46e tÁ|o6ÂVt t;Ãt��V t;ÃtSoVp t;Ãt6q�{��¬lFG>GN »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼*jW[REWXO­DO �_REhW[]�WXhEDE46e ;�tÁÃÂsbp t;ÃtSo � t;ÃtSo�� t;ÃtSoYq��¬lFG>GN »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼*24¾©JW[O­DEO ��W[NPF ;�tÁ}qStVÄ t;Ãt6qSÄ t;Ãt6qEs t;ÃtVÂ6q��¬lFG>GN »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼*jW[REWXO­DOÆ�JW^NPF ;�tÁ|oYqS t;Ãt6q � t;Ãt6q�p t;Ãt6qEs��¬lFG>GN »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼ »Ít;ÃtVtVtS¼!CDEO­Deº4YN7W[]VF�' 4d8�= tÁÃtVtS{ t;Ãtsmt t;ÃtsVs t;Ãtsbp�¤TV57·YFKh »Ít;}q�o6ÂS¼ »Ít; � �VtS¼ »Ít; �VtSpV¼

��� tÁ ���s

�57F ]�WXTVDE=�hM4d8�=�avTV5?·6FKhZ@M46=�RET«=?NP4YNPW[=?NPW[>d46e[e[8«=7W[ªVREW^§M>d46RSN�F ¬lFG>GNvTVR¨LE57T�hEDE> NPW[]�W^N_8zWXRzNP@F=P4YOZLEe[F6;)��@M4YNiWX=�OZT657F6fMN7@EFyFG=?NPW[O¶4¾NPF«T6U�NP@FyFKeX46=?N7WX>GW[N_8:T6U�L57T�hEDE>GN7W[]�W[N_8`a�W^NP@j57FK=?L%FG>GN�N7TNP@F«LWXFK>GF�5P4YN7F >A@M46REªVFG=�]6FK518:eXW[N?NPe[F�a�W[N7@jW^NP=)W[RE>Ke[DE=7W[TVR¿;

� � �� � � � � � � � � ��¢E¡m����£ � � ¢����� �

�ÓU�DERETVwE=?FK51]64YwEeXF U�46> NPTV5?=�4YeX=7T¨4¾¬lFG>GN�U�4YNPW[ªVDEF�e[FG]6FKeX=GfENP@EFGRjT6LNPW[O¶46eILM4651NPW[>KWXLE4YNPW[TVRnhEFG>KWX=?WXTVR=OZ4m8 N757DER>d4YN7F�N7@EFvFG575?TV5�N7FK5?O T6UETVw=7FK51]VFGhzLE57T�hEDE> NPW[]�W^N_8V;�(4651NPWX>GWXLM4¾NPWXT6R«hFK>KW[=7W[TVRE=�>d46RHeXFd4YhNPTnN_avTEfÅLITV=7=?WXwEe^82T6LEL%T6=7WXRªEflF ¬lFG>GNP=G;z�(W[57=?NKf%avTV57·YFK5?=�a�@T®LE465?N7WX>KW[LM4YN7FyTVR¯N757Fd4¾NPOQFKRSN?rÓ5P4YN7FhM4d8�=�465?FHe[WX·YFKe[8ZNPTZ@M4d]VFye[TmaCFG51rÓN7@M46RJr_4d]VFK5746ªVF«eXF ]VFKe[=�TYU(U�4YN7WXªVDEFYfMªVW[]�W[REª¨57WX=?F«N7T¶4Q=?NP46REhM465?h=P4YOZLEe[F rÓ=7FKe[FK> NPWXT6RnLE57T6wEeXFGOj;�!CT6DERSNPFK5746>GN7WXREªzN7@EWX=GfNP@EF F°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSNP46e¿WXR>K57FK46=7F W[RnNP@EF�LEW[FK>GF

smÂ

Page 15: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� ¢E� ���� ����� � � ���4� ��� � ���� � � � � � � ��� � � ��� ��� � � ��� � �

(4Y5?NPW[>KW[LM4YNPW[TVR' 4d8�=��¤TV5?·6FKh t s ��T6NA46et p o�� �Vts t � � � �

p s qS qVq s ÂVt Âs��T6NA46e q smÄV{ p6tJs

5P4¾NPF`>d4YR¹hWX57FG>GN7e[8µ4Y¬lFG>GNzavTV57·YFK5QLM4651NPWX>GWXLM4¾NPWXT6R ��NP@EF:@EW[ªV@EFG5­57FGR�N7=¨DEREhEFG5¨N7@EFnNP5?Fd4YN7OZFGRSNLEW[FK>KF²574YNPF¸>GTVDEeXh�W[REhEDE>GF¯aCTV5?·6FG57=:NPTÝ=7@ETma DL�N7T aCTV5?·�4YN`U�4YN7WXªVDF¸eXFG]6FKe[=nNP@M4YN`avTVDEe[hRETV5?O¶4YeXe[8Q>K46DE=7F�NP@FKO N7TQ=1NA4d8:@ETVOQF6;

�_RµN7@EWX=H=7DEw=7FK> NPW[TVR¿f�avFnF ©JLEe[TVW[N�NP@F¶U�46>GN«NP@E4YNz46w=7FKR>KFK=­avFK5?Fn57FG>KTV5?hEFKh hDE57W[REª2NP@FF ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNd; �JW[RE>KFZNP@EFG=7F:46wE=?FKRE>GFK=zT�>K>GDE575?FKhÝTVR�hM4d8�=­U¥TV5«a�@EWX>A@�N7@EF`F ©JLIFK57W[OZFGRSNyNPT�TV·LEeX46>KFYflNP@EF 8¯avFK57Fz]6TVeXDERSNP465?8¯46wE=7FGRE>KFG=�TVR¸NP@EFzLM4Y5?N T6U�N7@EF­aCT657·6FG57=G;z�MDE5?N7@EFK5?OZTV5?F6fÅ=?WXRE>GFFG]6FK518VTVREFyWXRS]VTVe^]VFGh2WXR`N7@EFHF°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSN�57FG>KFKW^]VFGh2NP@EF�=746OZF«LEW[FK>KF�574YNPF«TVRj4QªVW^]VFGR2hM4d8VfMavF·�RETma�a�@M4YN�LEW[FK>GF 5P4YN7F�N7@EF�LEeº4YR�N7FK5"U¥TV51aCFGRSNiwS8`@EW[=�TV5)@EFK5�46w=7FKR>KF6;

��TzWXRS]VFG=?N7WXªS4YN7FiNP@F�WXOQL%T65?NA4YRE>KF�T6U.LM4651NPWX>GWXLM4¾NPWXT6RZhEFG>KW[=7WXT6RE="WXR¶TVDE5"=746OZLeXF6f�avF�NA46wED�reº4¾NPF6fWXR:�(4YwEeXF �fLM465?N7WX>GWXLM4YN7WXTVRn46REh®>KDEO­Deº4YN7W[]VF hE4m8�=)avTV57·YFKh¯hED57WXRª¨N7@EF�F ©JLIFK57W[OZFGRSNd;

�)@EF2LM465?N7WX>GWXLM4YN7WXTVRÝ574YNPFjhEDE57W[REªµN7@EF2F°©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSN¶aC46=nF°©�NP57FGOZFGe[8¹@EW[ªV@¿f)465?TVDEREh�Ä��LIFK57>GFKRSN �EavTV5?·6FK5?=)hEFK>GWXhEFGh`RET6NvNPT­avTV57·QTVRnTVRe[8QqzhM4d8�="hEDE5?WXREªyN7@EF�F°©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSNd;���@E4YN"W[=OQTV57FYf%NP@FK57FzW[=ie[W[N7N7eXF�NPTn=?DEªVªVFG=?N N7@M4YN�U�4YN7WXªVDFy>d4YDE=7FGh²N7@EFK=?FzhEFK>GWX=?WXTVRE=G;��"aCT`T6U�N7@EF­RETVR�rLM4651NPW[>KWXLE4YNPW[TVR¤hE4m8�=¨T�>K>KD5757FGhÝ4YN­N7@EF`w%FGªVWXRREWXREªjT6U�NP@EFZaCFGFK·<fvwIFGU¥T657F:46RS8¤LEeº46RSN7WXREª¯@E46hNA4Y·6FKRjLEeº4Y>KF6;��)@WX=�=7DEª6ªVFK=1NP=�NP@M4YN�=?FKe[FK>GN7WXTVR®WX=)TYU(OQWXRET65"WXOQL%T65?NA4YRE>KF�W[R`NP@EF�F ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46e=P4YOZLEe[F6;

�_R«�(4YwEeXF�ÄfbaCF�hET�>[email protected]>GWXLM4¾NPWXT6R hEFK>GWX=7W[TVRE=�465?F�46eXOQTV=?N.W[hEFKRSN7WX>d4YeVw%F N_aCFGFKRNP5?Fd4YN7OZFGRSN:46REh�>KT6R�N757TVe�ªV57T6DELE=K;/�)@EF¸LM4651NPW[>KWXLE4YNPW[TVR³574YNPFG=`4657F²Ä��Áæp L%FG57>KFGRSN24YREhÀÄS{JÁ �LIFK57>GFKRSNdf�57FG=7LIFK> NPW[]6FKe^8Vf�=7DEªVª6FK=?N7WXREª N7@M4YN�NP@EF�F°©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA4YeE]64Y57Wº4¾NPWXT6R­WXRzNP@F�LWXFK>GF�5P4YN7F�@E46h4zREFKª6eXWXª6WXwEe[FiFG¬%FK> N�TVRjLE465?N7WX>KW[LM4YN7WXTVR¿;

sdq

Page 16: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� ¢E� ���� � � ��� ��� � � ��� � � � � � ��� � � � ��� � � � � � � � ��� � ��� � � � � �

(4Y5?NPW[>KW[LM4YNPW[TVRt s ��T6NA46e

��57Fd4¾NPOQFKRSN p ��� ÄVt!CTVRSNP5?TVe p smt6Ä sVs6s��T6NA46e q smÄV{ p6tJs

#�=y4`§MRM46e�W[REhEW[>d4YN7WXTVR¸T6UvNP@EF¨W[OZLITV5?NP46RE>GFzT6U"LM4Y5?NPW[>KW[LM4YNPW[TVR¯W[R T6DE5�57FK=?DEe[N7=Kf.aCFZFK=1NPW^rOZ4YNPFGh²4`�5?TVwEW^N�OQTJhEFGe(e[WXRE·�WXRª¶LM4651NPW[>KWXLE4YNPW[TVR®N7T`hM4d8�=�aCTV5?·6FGhµ46Rh F°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSNP46e(5?FKRSNP=G;�)@EW[=)46eXe[TmaCFGh`DE="NPTzF°©E4YOZW[REF�a�@EF NP@EFG5�F ©JL%FG57W[OZFGR�NP46e%]Y465?Wº4YN7WXTVRZWXRnN7@EF�LEW[FK>KF 574YNPF�4Y¬lFG>GN7FKhLM4651NPW[>KWXLE4YNPW[TVR¿f¿U¥TV5«4jª6W[]VFGRµR�DEO­wIFK5HT6U"hE4m8�=«aCTV5?·6FGh¿;:�_R�LM4651NPWX>GDEeº4Y5KfÅaCFZ>KTVR=7WXhFK57FGhµNP@FU¥TVe[eXTma�WXREªyOZT�hEFKeÍ$

� 3" � '���+1-��#/����� �" ��-�� � »¥eXTVª����; e[TVª �V¼ - 2," ��� »ÍoJ;æp6¼

FK=1NPW[O¶4YN7FKhÝDE=?WXREª²NP@EF:F°©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA4Ye)=P46OQLEeXFY;Ý��FG57F6f��#/¶>K46LN7DE57FG=QN7@EF:FG¬%FK>GNZT6U�>KDEOyDEeº4¾rNPW^]VFnhE4m8�=zavTV57·YFKh������ �" � T6R LM465?N7WX>GWXLM4YN7WXTVR¤hEFK>GWX=?WXTVRE=Gf�a�@EWXe[F� � >d4YLNPDE5?FK=­N7@EFnFG¬%FK> N¨T6UF ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46e�5?FKRSNP=n»�eXT6ª�� ;³eXTVª �6¼ ;®�JW[RE>KF¨aCFZTVwE=?FK5?]6F¶NP@FZW[REhEW[]�W[hEDM46e�46w=7FKR>KFK=yWXR²NP@EW[==P4YOZLEe[Fz46REh²=?WXRE>GF¨avF¨·�RETma�NP@FQLWXFK>GFz5P4YN7F­NP@M4¾N a"46=�LM4YWXh¸TVR 46RS8¸ªVW^]VFGR hE4m86fÅNP@EF­N7FK57O»�e[TVª�� ;`eXTVª �6¼(WX=�hEFG§EREFKhQU¥TV5�FG]6FK5?8QW[REhEW[]�W[hEDM46eJWXRzNP@EF�F ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46e=P46OQLEeXFYfSFG]6FKRnTVRQhM4d8�=NP@FG8`hEW[h:RET6N�aCT657·<;

�)@EF2FK=?N7WXOZ4YNPW[TVR¹57FK=?DEe[N7=`465?F2LE5?FK=7FGRSNPFKhÀWXR �(4YwEeXF¤smt;��)@FK57F2WX=¶RT�FG]�WXhFKRE>GF2NP@M4¾N>KDO­DEeº4¾NPW[]6FihM4d8�="avTV57·YFKh:TV5v]Y465?Wº4YN7WXTVRQWXRZNP@EF�LWXFK>GF�5P4¾NPFi@E46h:46RS8n4¾¬lFG>GN)TVR`LE465?N7WX>KW[LM4YN7WXTVRhEDE5?WXREªzN7@EF�F ©JL%FG57W[OZFGR�NK;

x W[]6FKR¸NP@EFG=7FQ@EWXª6@ LE465?N7WX>KW[LM4YN7WXTVRj5P4YN7FK=Kf�46Rh N7@EFKW[5�=7W[OZW[eº465?W[NPW[FK=�wIFGN_avFKFKR¤NP@EF¨>KT6R�N757TVe46REh­N757FK4YNPOQFKRSN�ªV5?TVDELE=Gf6avF)WXªVRET657FKhyFKREhET6ªVFKRET6DE=�LM4651NPWX>GWXLM4¾NPWXT6RHhEFG>KW[=7WXT6RE=�46=�4YRzWXOQL%TV51NA46RSNU�46> NPTV5�4Y¬%FK> NPW[REª¨TVDE5)#��i��&�#/5?FK=?DEe[N7=K;��� ìHÉ�ȾÊPé É�Ê°ÖæÐ�Î�É7Ð¥ÌgåÃÜ)ÊAÌgÉ?×�Ê�Ñ Î Ü"ÙbÖ|É ÌgÉ�Ð�ÌÍÏg˾Ñ_ÌgËbÏÓÊ°ÖbÜ"Îm×mÉ1Ö6å|Ô¾Ñ ÎGÏÍÙ6ΠÏÓÊAÌgåÃÔbØ�ÙYÊ°ÏÍÌÍåæÑ å|Ù¾ÊAÌgåÃÎGÔ"×bÉ?Ñ åæÐÍåÃÎGÔ¾ÐIÊ Ô¾×

ÙbÏgÎd×b˾Ñ_ÌgåÃédåÃÌ¥îH×mÉ7Ñ åæÐ�å|ΠԾР.¾Ê ÐÍÉ?×HΠԭÎ".YÐ�É?ÏÍéAÊ).¾ÖÃÉ)Ê°ÔY׫ËbÔ¾Î".¾ÐÍÉ1ÏgéAÊ).bÖ|ÉCÚ^Ê Ñ_ÌgΠÏÓÐ1â�Ç¿ÈbÉ)ÏÍÉ7Ð�˾Ö}ÌÓÐ�Õ%É?ÏÍÉ"é É?ÏÍîÐ�å|Ü"åÃÖæÊ°Ï.ÌÍÎ)ÌgÈbÎGÐÍÉ�ÙbÏgÉ?ÐÍÉ1ÔKÌÍÉ7×Sâ �(å|é É?ÔiÙYÊ°ÏÍÌÍåæÑ å|Ù¾ÊAÌgåÃÎGÔ�×bÎKÉ7ÐÅÔbΠÌ�Ð�É?É1Ü ÌÍÎ .6É�ÙbÖæÊPîKå|ÔbØ)Ê)ÐÍåÃØGÔbå �6Ñ1Ê°ÔKÌ.ÏgΠÖ|ÉåÃÔiÌgÈbÉ�É 0mÙ6É1ÏgåÃÜ"É1ÔKÌ7ðbÕ%É�ÎGÜCåÃÌÅÌÍȾÉ?ÐÍÉ(ÏgÉ?ÐÍËbÖÃÌgÐlÚÛÏgΠܹÌÍÈbÉ�پʠÙYÉ?Ï?â

sbo

Page 17: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� ¢E� � ���� ��� � ��� ��� � �� � � � � ������ � ��� ��� � ���� � � � ��� ��� ����� �� � � ��� ����� ��� � ��� � ��� ���� � � ��� ��� � � ��� � �

�_REhEFGL%FGREhEFGR�N�&�4657WX46wEe[F !CT�F �Q>GWXFKRSN ��NPh¿;���575?TV5 LJrg&�46eXDEF!CTVRE=1NA46RSN pJÁ^smtSp tÁÃÂSoYq tJÁ|tVt6t' 4d8�=��¤TV5?·6FKh ;�tÁÃtVts tÁ^smÄs tJÁ|ÄVÄVoeXT6ª���;�e[TVª � ;�tÁ}qVqSt sVÁ �S{6t tJÁ �sKq-ÅTVªE;�-ÅWX·YFKe[WX@ET�TJhn�<DRE>GN7WXTVR ;HsmÄJÁ �Vt6t

� � � � �d¡��£6��.¡b¢ ���� �

��FK=7De[NP=zW[R�LE5?FG]�WXTVD=z=7FK> NPW[TVRE=zLE5?Tb]�W[hEF`FK=1NPWXOZ4YN7FK=­T6U�N7@EF`57FG=7LITVRE=7F:T6U�avTV57·YFK5¨TVDN7LEDN­N7TF ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46e�>A@M4YREªVFK=ZWXR NP@FjLEW[FK>GFj574YNPFY;�FGNQW[NQOZ4d8 w%F®T6UiWXRSNPFG57FK=1NZN7Tµ>GTVRE=7W[hEFK5¨NP@FLE5?T6§EN¯LIFK51U¥TV57OZ46RE>GF¤TYU­NP@EF¤TVwE=?FK5?]6FKh >KT6R�N75P46> N ����� ���� � �����µ46e^NPFK5?RM4YN7W[]VF >KT6R�N75P46> NP=G; �)@EW[=LE5?FK=7FGRSNP=.N_aCT�L%TYNPFKRSN7Wº46eYLE57TVweXFKOQ=K;��(W[57=?NKfmw%FG@M4d]�WXTVDE5ÅOZ4d8�>A@M4YREªVF�46=¿NP@F�>GTVRSNP5746>GN.>A@M4YREªVFK=G;��¬lT65?N�eXF ]VFKe[=C4Y57F�=7FKR=7W[N7W[]6F�N7TH>GTVRSNP5P4Y>GNP=C46REhQO­DE=1NCwIF�L57FKhWX>GN7FKh¶46=�NP@EF�>KTVRSN75P46> NC>A@M4YREªVFK=G;�JFG>KTVREhlfE46RS8Q>KTVOQLM465?WX=?TVRZOyDE=?Nv>KTVR=7WXhFK5�>KTVRSNP5746>GN7=vN7@M4YNC4657F�46>K>GFKLNP46wEe[F�NPT«wIT6NP@QNP@EF�§M57O46REh¸N7@EFzaCTV5?·6FG57=$���������Xf.4:L57TVLITV=7FGh²>KTVRSNP5746>GN«O­D=?N�=P4¾NPWX=1U½8¸F ©JLIFK> NPFKh�r_DN7WXeXW^N_82>GTVRE=1NP5P4YWXRSNP=G;��46·�WXREª�NP@EFG=7FiU�4Y>GNPT657=�WXRSNPTy46>K>GTVDERSNv57F���DEW[57FG=CFK=1NPW[O¶4YN7WXREª«4�=?N757DE> NPDE5746e%OQT�hEFKeMW[RQa�@EW[>A@¶NP@FLM465746OQFGNPFG57=�hEF NPFK5?OZW[REWXRªyaCT657·6FG5iDN7WXe[W[N_8Z46REh®LE57T�hEDE> NPW^]JW^N_8`465?F�WXhEFGR�N7W[§MFGh¿;

�_RQNP@EW[=�=?FK> NPWXT6R¿f�avFihFG]VFGeXTVL¶46REhQFK=1NPWXOZ4YN7F�4�=7W[OZLeXF)=?N757DE> NPDE5746eIOZT�hEFKeMTYUlavTV57·YFK5"4YREh§M5?O wIFK@E4m]�W[TVDE5�DEREhEFG5iNP@EF«TVwE=?FK51]VFKh²LEW[FK>GF r_574YNPF«>KT6R�N75P46> Nd;��µFHF ©JLEe[TVW[N�NP@FyF ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46e]Y4657WX4YNPW[TVR¨WXR¨NP@EF�LEW[FK>KF�5P4YN7F�N7THW[hEFKRSN7W[U½8zNP@F�LM4Y5P46OQFGN7FK57=�T6U¿N7@EF�OZT�hEFKeÍ;(�)@EFG=7F�LE465P46OQFGN7FK5?=465?F¯NP@EFGR DE=?FKh¿fiWXR�=7FG>GN7WXTVR�{Jf�NPTÝ>KTVR=7WXhFK5`NP@EF¸5?FKeX4YNPW^]VF¸LIFK5?U¥T657OZ46RE>KF¸TYU«N7@EF²TVwE=?FK5?]6FKh>KT6R�N75P46> Nd;

� ��� � �H¡�����£6� ��� �½���

�¤FH4Y=7=7DOZF NP@E4YN�hM46W[e[8nL57T�hEDE>GN7W[]�W[N_86f ��EWX=)hEF NPFG57OQWXREFGhjwS8

'����s �

Page 18: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

a�@EFG57F � 5?FKLE5?FK=7FGRSNP=:NP@EF¯avTV57·YFK5 �Ã=:FG¬%TV51N`eXF ]VFKeÍf � W[=n4�LE5?TJhED>GNPW^]�W[N_8 =7@ET�>A·³5?FKLE5?FK=7FGRSN?rWXRª LEeº46RSN7WXREª >GTVREhEW^NPWXT6RE=`w%F 8VTVRhÀN7@EF¸aCTV5?·6FG5��}=j>GTVRSNP57T6eQ»�=7D>A@�46=`N7@EF²@M4657hREFK=?=jT6U«NP@FªV5?TVDEREh<¼°;C�¤Fy46=?=7DEOQF�NP@M4YN � U¥TVe[eXTma�=�4Ze[TVªVRET657OZ46elhEW[=?N757WXwDNPW[TVR`a�W[NP@®LM465746OQFGNPFG57= � 4YREh� �¾;:�eX46RSNPFG57=«@M4d]VFn4®DNPW[eXW^N_82U¥DERE> NPW[TVR 2 hEF §MREFGh�Tm]VFK5HFd465?REWXRªV=��²4YREhµF ¬lTV51N �Q;`�MTV5«4ªVW^]VFKR¤LEWXFG>KFQ5P4YN7F �Jf�Fd465?REWXRªV=��¸F���DM46e � T65 � � �";Z�¤FZ46=7=?DEOZF¨NP@E4YN�NP@EFQ>KTV=1NyTYU"FG¬%TV51NU¥DERE> NPW[TVR`U¥TV5)LEeº4YR�N7FK5 5�WX=)TYU�N7@EF U¥TV57O®$

� » �y¼�'��=" �» � -Àsb¼ ���� ����� �="���t � ����t

a�@EFG57F���"­hEFKRETYNPFK=`N7@EF²LEeº46RSN7FK51rÓ=7LIFK>GW[§M>²>KT6OZLITVREFGR�N:TYUy>GTV=?N7=246Rh���>A@M465P4Y>GNPFG57W'�KFK=:NP@F>KD5?]Y4YNPD57F­T6U � »�� ¼ ;��¤FHU¥DE51NP@EFG5 46=7=?DEOQF­4¶=?FKLM465746wEe[FyDN7WXeXW^N_8nU¥DERE> NPW[TVR2W[R��®46REh � T6U�NP@FU¥TVe[eXTma�WXREªHU¥TV57O®$

2­»�� � �y¼ '���� ; � » �­¼�� '! � ��� ;"�=" �» � -�sb¼ ���� �����$# Á » �;[sm¼

� � � � ���

�MTV5(FK46>A@zwEe[TJ>A·«T6U<eº4YREh¿f 7 �¾NPT�wIF"LEeX46RSNPFGh¿f6NP@FCNPW[OZW[REª�TYU<FG]VFGRSNP=�WXR«NP@EF"OQT�hEFKe�WX=(46=(U¥TVe[eXTma�=K$sV;���4YNPDE5?F�>A@ETJT6=7FK=y» � & � � �& ¼CU¥TV5)weXT�>A· 7M;pJ;)�)@EF�§M5?OÆTVwE=?FK5?]6FK=­» � & � � �& ¼"46REh:NP@FKR®=7FKe[FK> NP=�4¨LWXFK>GF�5P4YN7F � &V;Â;)�)@EF�avTV57·YFK5�TVwE=7FG5?]6FK=C» � &�� � �& ¼%U¥TV5ÅwEe[TJ>A·87<fY46REh«WX=ÅTY¬lFG57FKh�NP@F�>KTVRSNP5746>GN ��&�U¥TV5ÅLEeX46RSNPWXRª

TVR:NP@E4YN�wEeXT�>A· �ENP@EF�LEeX46RSNPFG5)FKW[N7@EFK5�4Y>K>KFGLNP=�TV5)5?F �?FK> NP=�NP@EF�>GTVRSNP5P4Y>GNd;qE;�!CTVRhEW[N7WXTVRM4Ye¿TVRj46>K>GFKLN7WXREª¨NP@EF«>KT6R�N75P46> N�NP@EF�aCT657·6FG5iW[=)5P46REhTVOZe^8`46=?=7W[ªVREFKh®NPTQLEeº4YR�N

TVR²4ZLM465?N7WX>GDEeº465�LEe[T6N�T6U�weXT�>A· 7¤» �������XfINP@EF­Leº46RSNPFG5ihE574da�=�4nLM465?N7WX>GDEeº465�]Y46eXDFyT6U ��¼ ;�)@EF«LEeX46RSNPFK5"N7@EFKR®>A@ET�TV=7FG=i4YRjF ¬lTV51N�eXF ]VFKe � 46RhjLE5?TJhDE>KFG= Z;

oJ;)�)@EF�§M5?OÆTVwE=?FK5?]6FK= 46REh®LM4d8J=�Fd4Y57REW[REªV=%�<;

� � �� � � � �d¡ � '&)(n¡�� ��* ��� ��¡ �E¢� ��� � �

-ÅFGN?NPWXRª � "�hEFKRT6NPFyN7@EFyT6LNPW[O¶46eÅe[FG]6FKe�T6U�FG¬%TV51N�>A@ETV=?FKR¸wS8®aCTV5?·6FG5 57fINP@EFGR¯>KTVRhEW[N7WXTVRM4YeÅTVR �<4zLM465?N7WX>GDEeº465v]64YeXDEF T6U �"fM4­aCT657·6FG5��}=iTVLJNPWXOZ46e%FG¬%TV5?N�W^U(ªVW^]VFGR®wS8

� " ',+ � �=".-0/sb{

Page 19: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

a�@EW[>A@®N7@EFKR:8�WXFKe[hE=)NP@EF U¥TVe[eXTma�WXRªyTVwE=?FK51]VFKh�r_LE5?TJhED>GNPW^]�W[N_8:F���DM4¾NPWXT6R¿$

� " ' � /� / " /��/ Á » �;æp6¼

�_R³T657hEFG5QU¥TV5Q4¸aCT657·6FG5ZN7Tµ46>G>KFGLN¶N7@EFj>GTVRSNP5746>GNZT6¬%FK57FGh¿fCW^NQO­DE=?NZ=P4¾NPWX=1U½8 @EW[=ZF°©LIFK> NPFGhJrDN7WXeXW^N_8�>KTVR=?NP5746WXRSNK; x W[]6FKR�N7@EF�>KT6R�N75P46> N²@M46=¯T6REe[8 TVREF�W[RE=?N757DEOQFKRSN²4YREh�aCT657·6FG57= 465?F@EF NPFK5?TVªVFGREFKTVD=Kf=?TVOQF�avTV57·YFK5?=Ca�WXe[eMFd465?R¶57FGRSNP=K;��¤Fi4Y=7=7DOZF�NP@M4¾NvN7@EFiLEW[FK>GF�574YNPF�WX=�>A@ETV=?FKRNPT2=P4YN7WX=?U½8²N7@EF`46e^NPFK5?RM4YN7W[]VFZDNPW[eXW^N_8¸>KTVR=?NP5746WXRSNzTYU)NP@EFne[TmaCFG=?N?r_46wEW[eXW[N_82aCTV5?·6FG5zWXRµN7@EFZ§M5?Oj;�)@EF�aCT657·6FG5�a�W^NP@:eXTmavFK=1Ni4YwEWXe[W[N_8QeXF ]VFKe.@M4Y=�N7@EF�@EWXª6@EFK=1N�>KTV=1N�LE465P46OQFGN7FK50����� �������Xf

� � 'ÀO¶4¾©l» ��/ � � � �dÁKÁdÁ � ���¼ Á#i=�=?DE>A@¿f �­=7T6e[]VFG=i4YªVFKRSN�� �Ã=�F ©JLIFK> NPFKh�r_DN7WXeXW^N_8n>GTVRE=?N75P46W[RSN

�� /� /�� F ©JL� ^» � -�sb¼ � -¹tÁæo» � -�sb¼ � � ���» ��-Àsb¼ � / � '��� Á » �;|ÂV¼

��46·�WXREª�e[TVªS465?W[N7@EOZ=�46Rh­=7DEw=?NPW^NPDN7WXREª�U¥57TVO » �J;|ÂS¼.WXRSNPT­» �;|pV¼Å8JW[FKe[hE=�N7@EFCU¥TVe[eXTma�WXREª�FKOQLEW[57WX>K46e=7LIFK>GW[§M>K4YNPW[TVR:WXR`NPFG57OQ=)T6U�5P46REhTVO ]Y4657WX46wEe[FK=K$

eXT6ª #" & ' e[TVª<» � -Àsm¼ -¹eXT6ª��� ;�e[TVª ��& - �ie[TVª + � ��=" - ;ÝtÁ|oE» � -Àsm¼ � � �& -���" & » �;ÃqS¼

a�@EFG57F��#" &:F���DM46e[=®» � -,sb¼K»¥eXTVª ��" & ; � &¾¼HW[=­hEWX=1NP5?WXwEDN7FKh RET657OZ46eXe^8 a�W^NP@ OQFd46R �GFK5?T¤4YREh]Y4657WX46RE>GFQ» � -�sb¼ � � �& ;� � �� � ¡���¢J����� � � & (`¡�� � * �(� ��¡ �¢����� � �

\�RhEFK5QTVDE5zF°©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSNdf�NP@EF:LEW[FK>GF®574YNPF:TVRÝwEe[TJ>A· 7µWX=zF°©T6ªVFKRET6DE=7e^8 WXRE>G57FK46=7FGh U¥57T6O ��&NPT � &nU¥TV5HLE465?NyT6U)NP@EFZwEeXT�>A·<f�>A@ETV=?FKR¹4YNy5P46REhTVO 46REh�>GTVOZL57WX=?WXREª®NP@EFQNP5?Fd4YN7OZFGR�NyLEeXTYNP=K;�¤TV57·YFK5iL57T�hEDE>GN7W[]�W[N_8nTVR®N7@EFHN757FK4YNPOQFKRSN�LEeXTYNP=�WX=�NP@EFGR2ªVW^]VFGR2wS8`NP@EF�U¥TVe[eXTma�WXREªzT6wE=7FG5?]VFGhJrLE5?TJhED>GNPW^]�W[N_8nF ��DM4YNPW[TVR¿$

� " & '� /&� / " /�

/ Á » �;æo6¼

s �

Page 20: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

x W[]VFGR`NP@M4YN�>GTVREhEW^NPW[TVRE=)@M4d]VF�RETYN�>A@E46REªVFGh¿f ��&H=1NPW[eXel=74YNPW[=?§MFG=H» �;ÃÂS¼ fJ8JW[FKe[hEWXREª­N7@EF U¥TVeXe[Tma�WXREªFKOQLEW[57WX>K46el=?L%FG>KW^§M>d4YN7WXTVR:W[R:N7FK5?OZ=)T6U�5P4YREhETVO ]Y465?Wº46weXFK=G$

eXT6ª �" &9'�eXTVª<» �6-zsb¼ - eXTVª �� ;ie[TVª ��& - �ieXTVª + � ��=" - ;�tÁ|oE» �6-zsb¼ � � �& - ��eXT6ª + ��&��& - - �#" &�» �; �V¼

� � ��� � � � � ��� � £V¢� ��� � � �J�$ ½�b�

��TZW[hEFKRSNPW^U½8¶N7@EF�LM465P4YOZF NPFK5?=)T6U�NP@EF�OQTJhEFGelavFH>GTVO­wEW[REFQ» �;}q�¼"46Rh�» �; �V¼vNPTz8�WXFKe[h

eXT6ª �" &9'�eXTVª<» �6-zsb¼ - eXTVª �� ;ie[TVª ��& - �ieXTVª + � ��=" - ;�tÁ|oE» �6-zsb¼ � � �& - ��eXT6ª + ��&��& - - �#" &�» �;æ{6¼

TV5

eXTVª #" & ' �+�-¹e[TVª<» ��-Àsb¼,; eXTVª ��&1-�� =/ " ;ÝtJÁæoE» � -�sb¼ � � �& -��ieXTVª + � &��& - -���" & » �; �V¼

a�@EFG57F� &(' � � & U¥T65"NP57FK4YNPOQFKRSN�ªV5?TVDEL®TVwE=?FK5?]Y4YN7WXTVR=

��& U¥T65)>KTVRSNP5?TVeŪV5?TVDEL:TVwE=?FK5?]Y4YN7WXTVR= » �;|ÄV¼

WX="N7@EF�LEWXFG>KF�5P4¾NPF�NP@F�avTV5?·6FK5i46>GN7DM46e[e[8Z57FK>GFKW^]VFKh®U¥TV5)LEeX46RSNPWXRªE;

smÄ

Page 21: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� � � �<¡ � � ��� � � � � ��� � £V¢� ��� �

��¢E¡m���!����� � � � � ��� �� � � � � � � � �4����� ��� � � ��� � � � � � � � � ����� � ��� � � � � ��� � � ��� �� ��� ����� � �������� �� � � � � ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� � � � ����� � � � � � � � � � � ����� � ��� � � � � ��� � � � ������� ��� ��� � � � � � � ��� � � ��� ��

»¥W½¼ ���»�W[W½¼ � & �=7��»¥WXW[W½¼ eXTVªM» ����¼ ;�eXT6ª<» �="Ó¼ � �»�W^]E¼ne[TVª �� ;��¢E¡m���!������� � � � � ��� �� � � � � � � � �4����� �=� � � ��� � �� � � �� � � � � ����� � ��� � � � � ��� � � ��� � � �������� � ������� � �� � � � � ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� � � � ������ � � � � � � � � � � ����� � ��� � � � � ��� � � � ������� ��� ����� � � � � �� ��� � � ��� ��

»¥W½¼ ���»�W[W½¼ � & �=7��»¥WXW[W½¼ eXTVªM» ��/G¼ ; eXT6ª<» �="g¼ � �»�W^]E¼ne[TVª �� -�� eXTVªM» � � ¼ ; eXT6ª<» ��/ ¼ � ;�«¡ ��� � � � � � � �<¡�� � �

��¢E¡m���!���

� � � � � � ����� � ��� � � ��� � � ������� ��� ��� ��������� � & � � ����& � � ����� ��� � ������� ��� ��� � � � �4� ���� ���� � � � ��� � � ��� � ��eXTVª�� � � � �4� ��� � ������������ ��� ��� � �& ��� �4� ��� � � � �4����� �=� � � ���

� � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � �4����� ��� � � � ����� � � ��� � � =/ " � ������� ��� ��� eXTVª<» ����¼ ;Ýe[TVª<» �="g¼ �� � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � ��� � �� ��� ������� ��� ����e[TVª �� �

��¢E¡m���!�����

� � ��� � � � �4����� �=� � � ��� � �� � � �� � � � � ����� � ��� � � � � ��� � � ��� �� � ��� � � � � � � � ��� �������� ��� ���:eXT6ª��� - � e[TVª<» � � ¼ ; eXT6ª<» ��/ ¼ � ��� � ����� � / ��� �� � ����� � � ���� � � � � � �� � � ��� � �� � � � � � �4����� �=� �)s � � � ��� � � �4����� �=� � � � � ����� � � � � ��� � � ����� =/ " � ������� ��� ��� eXTVªM» ��/ ¼ ; e[TVª<» �="g¼ � �

p6t

Page 22: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� ¢E� � � �� ��� � ��� ��� � �� � � � � ������ � ��� ��� � ���� � ��� � � � � � � � � ����� �� � � ��� ����� ��� � ��� � ��� ���� � � ��� �� � � �� � � � ��� � ��� � � ��� � ������ � � � � �� ��� �������NP46REhM465?h2��5?57TV5?=�4Y57F WXR:LM4Y57FKRSN7@EFK=?FK=K;

(4Y5P46OQFGN7FK5 »Í4S¼ »�w<¼ »�>d¼ »�hM¼� tÁ|Â6ÂVt tÁÃq6qS tÁÃÂV � tÁà� �

»�tÁ|t6Äsb¼ »�tÁ^s �S{V¼ »�tÁÃt6qSÂS¼ »ÍtÁ^smt��S¼�+ qEÁæ{YÂSp qEÁæ{6p�� qEÁ|{V{Js qEÁ|{ �6q

»�tÁ|tVoJsb¼ »�tÁÃtSoYq�¼ »�tÁÃtSp6ÄS¼ »ÍtÁÃtS{VpV¼� / tÁ|tV{Yq tÁ|t6 � tÁÃt6qSt tÁÃtsdq»�tÁ|t6t��S¼ »�tÁ^sVsmtS¼ »�tÁÃtS{Jsb¼ »ÍtÁ^smÂsb¼� � tÁ|t��s tÁ|tVoV{ tÁÃt6q�p tÁÃtsdq»�tÁ|tJs �S¼ »�tÁ^sVsbpV¼ »�tÁÃt �VÂS¼ »ÍtÁ^smÂsb¼� � tÁ[sdÂ�� tÁ[sdt6q tÁ^smtV tÁ^smtVt»�tÁ|tJsboV¼ »�tÁ^smtVÄS¼ »�tÁÃtS{VpV¼ »ÍtÁ^s �6q�¼��� tÁ|tYq�o tÁÃtSpYq

»�tÁÃtVÂ6q�¼ »ÍtÁÃtV �S¼��� tÁÃtSo6Ä tÁÃtSo��»ÍtÁÃt6q �S¼

-ÅTVªS465?W[N7@EO TYU�-ÅWX·YFKe[WX@ET�TJh:�MDER>GNPW[TVR p6ÄJÁæpYq � ÂV{JÁ �V{Vo qEsVÁÃt �VÄ qVqEÁÃÂS{6t

�)@EFZO¶4Y57ªVW[RM46e(wIFKRFG§ENyT6U"F°©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA4Ye�hE4YNA4 ����� ���� � �����ZRETVRJrÓF ©JL%FG57W[OZFGR�NP46e�hM4YNP4:U¥T65FK=1NPW[O¶4YN7WXREª�NP@EF)=1NP57D>GNPD5P46eEOQT�hEFKeJWX=�RETma >KeXFK465K;(�(©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA4Ye]Y4657WX4YNPW[TVRyW[R­NP@EF)LEW[FK>GF)5P4YN7FhEW[57FK> NPe^8nWXhFKRSNPW^§MFK=)NP@F«FGeº46=1NPW[>KW[N_8ZT6U�FG¬%TV5?NK; �_R`NP@Fy46w=7FKR>KF«T6U(=?DE>A@j]Y465?Wº4YN7WXTVRlf�� &HF���DM46e[=��&®46REhÝWXhFKRSNPW^U½8JW[REª ��5?F���DEW[57FK=¨4¸OQFd46=?DE57F`TYU�46e^NPFG57RM4YN7W[]6FnDNPW[eXW^N_8Vf �� 46REh NP@F®FG=?N7WXOZ4YNPFGh]Y46eXDF T6U �2a�WXeXe%w%F�=?FKRE=?W[NPW^]VF NPTQ46RS8`=?DE>A@¯4¨OQFd46=?DE57FY; � (

�¤FHFG=?N7WXOZ4YNPFGh�» �;æ{6¼)D=7WXRªQN7@EFHF°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSNP46eÅhM4YNP4;C�)@EF«57FG=7DEe^NP=�4657F�ªVW^]VFGR2WXR:��46wEe[FsVsVf>KTVe[DEOZR¤»�4S¼ ;��)@EF�FG=?NPW[O¶4¾NPF T6U�NP@EF�FGeº46=1NPWX>GW[N_8ZT6U�FG¬%TV5?N�a�W[N7@:57FK=?L%FG>GN�NPTzNP@F«LWXFK>GF�5P4YN7F

ï.ΠÌÍÉ(ÌÍȾʰ̿ÌÍÈbÉ�ÏgÉ?Ð�ÌÍÏgå|Ñ ÌÍå|ΠԾÐlÉ1Ü .YÎm×må|É?×�å|Ô � â � # ÙYÉ?ÏÍÜ"åÃÌlÌgÈbÉ�åÃÔKÌgÉ1ÏgÙbÏÍÉ1ÌgÊ°ÌÍå|ΠÔ�ΠÚ���Ê Ð%ÌgÈbÉ�É1ÖæÊ Ð�ÌÍåæÑ åÃÌ¥î)ΰÚÉ �VΠÏÍÌ%ÕÅåÃÌÍÈ�ÏgÉ?ÐÍÙ6É?Ñ_ÌIÌÍÎ�ÌgÈbÉ�Ù¾åÃÉ7Ñ É.ÏÓÊAÌgÉ âô½Ô)ÌÍÈbÉ(Ê).¾ÐÍÉ1ÔYÑ É.ΠÚSÌÍÈbÉ7Ð�É.ÏgÉ?Ð�ÌÍÏgåæÑ_ÌÍå|ΠÔYÐ1ð ÌÍÈbÉ�پʰÏÓÊ°Ü"É ÌgÉ1Ï<ÎGÔ)ÌÍȾÉÉ 0mÙ6É1ÏgåÃÜ"É1ÔKÌÓÊ°Ö�éAÊ°ÏgåæÊAÌÍå|ΠÔ�åÃÔiÌgÈbÉ�Ùbå|É?Ñ É�ÏÓÊAÌgÉ(åæ×mÉ?ÔGÌgå �YÉ?пÌgÈbÉ�ΠËmÌgÙbËmÌ.É?Ö|ÊGÐ¥Ìgå|Ñ1å}Ì¥îGâ

� ( Ç¿ÈbåæÐÅå|ÐÅÌÍÈbÉ�åæ×mÉ1ÔKÌgå �YÑ?ÊAÌgåÃÎGÔiÐ�ÌÍÏÓÊAÌgÉ1Ø î"ÚÛÎGÖÃÖ|ÎAÕlÉ?× .Kî�çMÊ Ê°ÏÓÐgÑÓÈ�Ê°Ô¾×�ÞdÈbÉ7Ê°ÏgÉ1Ï � �- " � �# Ê°Ô¾×iß�Ê ÖÃÉ?î � &)("($& # âpJs

Page 23: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

�²WX=�t;ÃÂVÂQ46REh2W^NP=�FK=1NPWXOZ4YN7FKh®=?NA4YREhM465?h¯FK5?57TV5�WX=�t;ÃtVÄ;"�)@FH]Y46eXDFHT6U(NP@EF«eXTVªV4657W^NP@EO T6U�NP@FeXW[·6FGeXWX@TJT�hZU¥DER>GNPW[TVR:WX=�p6Ä;|pVoJ; �"�

�)@EF¨F°©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA4Ye�FK=1NPWXOZ4YN7F­T6U���WX=i=?NA4¾NPWX=1NPW[>d46e[e[8®=7W[ªVREW[§E>d46RSNdf%NP@ETVDªV@²=7DEwE=1NA46RSN7Wº46e[e[8=7OZ46e[eXFK5�NP@M4YR¨N7@M4YN�TYU¿�4V4657=?>A@¶4YREhZ�J@EFd4Y57FK5�» smÄVÄVÄS¼�TV5��i4YeXFG8`»gp6t6tSpV¼ ;.��@M4YN�W[=�OZT657F6fYU¥57TVONP@FyFK=1NPW[O¶4YN7FyT6U +­46REh �²avF­>d46R¸5?FK>GTb]6FK5 4YR¯FK=1NPWXOZ4YN7FHT6U��� DERhEFK5�NP@EF­@S8�LIT6NP@EFG=7W[=iNP@M4¾NNP@F«OZ465?ªVWXRM4Ye%W[REhEW[]�W[hEDM46eIa"46=�W[R:N7@EF F ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46eÅ=746OQLEeXFY;��)@EWX=�ªVW^]VFG=�4YR®FG=?N7WXOZ4YNPF T6U ��T6U ���SoJÁÃÂsVfÅ>GTVRE=7W[hEFK5746wEe^8¸eº465?ªVFK5�N7@M46R²NP@M4¾N�WXOQL%TV=?FKh²wS8 (4V4Y57=7>A@�46REhµ�J@EFd4Y57FK5Z» smÄVÄVÄS¼iT65�i4YeXFG82»Íp6tVtSpV¼°;�x W[]VFGRnNP@EFiWXhEFGR�N7W[§M>K4YNPW[TVR¶5?FK=?DEe[N7=KfJN7@EWX=C=7DEªVª6FK=?N7="NP@M4¾NCNP@Fi]Y46eXDEFG="T6U �� DE=?FKhwS8:(464657=?>A@¯46REh2�J@EFK4657FG5�46=)aCFGeXe.46=��i4YeXFG8ZNPT¨WXhFKRSNPW^U½8�¯avFK5?F«N7TJTze[Tba�; � &

� � � � � �<¡b¡�� �¢��� � � ��¢� ����¡ � ���¿£��Å�¨¢ � ��� ��¡¾£ � � ����� � � ¡b¡��<¡Y�

�_RE>G57Fd4Y=7FKh �MF°©JWXwEW[eXW[N_8�>d46R�wIF2TVwJNA46W[REFKh�W[R N7@EF¯=?N757DE> NPDE5746eiOQT�hEFKe�wS8³W[RSNP57T�hEDE>GWXREª¤hM46W[e[8avFd4YN7@EFK5­=?@ET�>A·�=�� 46Rh�L%FG57>GFKLN7WXTVR�FG575?TV57=G;¯�FG57>GFKLN7WXTVR FG5757T657=y>K46LN7DE57F¶N7@EF¶LITV=?=7WXwWXeXW^N_8NP@E4YNHN7@EFZ§E57O+O¶4d8²OQWX= �?DEhEªVFQ46> NPDM46e�LEeX46RSNPWXRªj>GTVREhEW^NPWXT6RE=�TVR�42ª6W[]VFGRµwEe[TJ>A·<;®-ÅFGNHhM46W[e[8TVDN7LEDN�wIF«ª6W[]VFGR:w�8

'���� � » �;^smtS¼

a�@EFG57F � 46REh�� 4657F¤WXREhEFGL%FGREhEFGR�N¯5P46REhTVO ]64Y57Wº4YwEeXFG=Kf�a�W[N7@�eXT6ª � wIFKW[REª³hWX=?N757W[wEDNPFGhRETV5?O¶4YeXe[8 @M4d]�WXREªÝOQFd46R � &¤46REh�]64Y57Wº4YRE>KF � �& 46REhÀeXT6ª�� w%FGWXREªÝhEW[=?N757WXwDNPFGhÀRTV57OZ46eXe^8@M4d]�WXREª®OQFd46R � � & 46REh²]Y4657WX46RE>GF � �� ;�� * �¤FZ4Y=7=7DOZF¨NP@M4¾N NP@EF¨]Y46eXDEFzTYU�� W[= TVwE=?FK5?]6FKh4YU½N7FK5zLM4651NPW[>KWXLE4YNPW[TVRµhEFG>KW[=7WXT6RE=¨4657F`OZ46hEFYf�wEDNQw%F U¥TV57F`F ¬lT65?N¨WX=y>A@ETV=7FGR¿;Ý��T 46>G>KTVDR�NzU¥T65LIFK57>GFKLN7WXTVR2FK575?TV57=�TVR¸4QªVW[]6FKR¯wEe[TJ>A·<fIaCFz4Y=7=7DOZF«NP@M4YN�4YN�NP@EFHw%FGªVWXRERWXREªZT6U�NP@Fy>KT6R�N75P46> N

��� ô½Ô ÇJÊ".bÖÃÉ ��� ðdÕlÉ�ÙbÏÍÎAédåæ×mÉ�Ê°ÔiÉ?Ð�ÌÍå|Ü"Ê°ÌÍÉ�ΠÚ���ΠÏÅÖ|Î Ø ���� ��� Ö|ΠØ������ #�� Ö|ΠØ���� � #�� â� & Ç¿ÈbÉ�ÏgÉ?ÐÍËbÖÃÌ.å|Ð�ÔbΰÌ(Ñ Î Ü"ÙbÖ|É ÌgÉ1Ö|îiÑ1ΠԾÑ1ÖÃËYÐ�å|é É��bÌÍȾÉ�Ú^Ê Ñ Ì.ÌÍȾʰÌ�ÌgÈbÉ�É?Ð�ÌÍå|Ü)ÊAÌgÉ?×�éAÊ°Ö|ËbÉ�ΠÚ��� å|Ð�Èbå|Ø ÈbÉ?ÏÅÌÍȾʠÔÌÍÈbÉ�Ê ÐgÐÍËbÜ"É?×"éAÊ°Ö|ËbÉ�åæÐ%ÔbΰÌ7ðKå|Ô�åÃÌgÐÍÉ1ÖÃÚ¥ðmÉ1édåæ×mÉ1Ô¾Ñ1É.ΰÚ�Ü"åæÐ��½ÐÍÙYÉ7Ñ å �YÑ1Ê°ÌÍå|ΠÔ�âMàÅÉ7Ñ1Ê°Ö|ÖXð ÚÛÏgÎ Ü Ç¿ÈbÉ?ΠÏgÉ1Ü � ÌÍÈYÊAÌ?ðå}ÚVÌgÈbÉ.Ü)Ê°ÏgØ å|ԾʰÖmå|Ô¾×må|édå|×b˾ʰÖYå|ÐMԾΰÌIå|ÔCÌÍÈbÉ�ÐgÊ°Ü"ÙbÖ|É ð ÌÍÈbÉ�É?Ð�ÌÍå|Ü"Ê°ÌÍÉ7×CÑ1ÎdÉ ��Ñ å|É1ÔKÌ<ÚÛÏgÎ Ü ÌÍÈbÉ.É10mÙYÉ?ÏÍå|Ü"É1ÔKÌgÊ ÖÐÍÊ Ü"ÙbÖÃÉHÉ?Ð�ÌÍå|Ü)ÊAÌÍÉ7Ð�� Ö|Î Ø ���� ÖÃÎGØ������ #�� ÖÃÎGØ���� � #�� â¤ìyÉ­Ñ Î ÔYÐ�åæ×mÉ1Ï�Ê ×¾×må}ÌgåÃÎGԾʰÖ(É 0mÙbÖæÊ°ÔYÊAÌÍå|ΠÔYÐ)ÚÛΠÏ�ÌÍȾÉ×må �6É?ÏÍÉ?Ô¾Ñ É7ÐÅåÃÔ�ÏgÉ?ÐÍËbÖÃÌgпå|Ô�ÐÍÉ?Ñ ÌÍå|Î Ô � â

� * ìHÉ�ÐÍË�.¾ÐgÑ Ïgå|ÙmÌ�ÊPé É1ÏÓÊ°ØGÉ�ÕlÉ?ÊAÌgÈbÉ1Ï�ÐÍÈbÎmÑÓÒmÐ�.dî �"!iÌgÎ ×mÉ1ÔbΠÌÍÉCÌÍȾÉvÚ^ÊGÑ_Ì�ÌÍÈYÊAÌ�ÌÍÈbÉ �YÏÍÜ � Ð�É 0mÙYÉ7Ñ_ÌÓÊAÌÍå|ΠÔYÐΰÚ�ÕlÉ?Ê°ÌÍÈbÉ?ÏlÐÍÈbÎmÑÓÒmÐIÜ)ÊPî)×må �6É?ÏÅÊ Ñ ÏgÎGÐgÐ<Ñ1ΠÔKÌÍÏÓÊ Ñ ÌgÐ .YÉ7Ñ1Ê°ËYÐ�É�ÌÍÈbÉ?î"ÌgÊ°ÒGÉ�ÙbÖæÊ Ñ1É�Ê°Ì¿×må �VÉ1ÏgÉ1ÔKÌ%ÌgåÃÜ"É7Ð%ΠÚ�ÌÍȾÉî É7Ê°Ï7â�ìHÉ)×mÎ�ÔbΠÌ�Ê ÖÃÖ|ÎAÕ¸ÌgÈbÉ?ÐÍÉvÉ10mÙYÉ7Ñ_ÌgÊ°ÌÍå|ΠԾÐ(ÌgÎiÑÓÈYÊ°ÔbØGÉC×bÊ åÃÖ|î�ÐÍåÃÔ¾Ñ1ÉvÉ10mÙYÉ7Ñ_ÌÍÉ7׫ÕlÉ?Ê°ÌÍÈbÉ?Ï�ÕÅåÃÖ|Ö<Ê �VÉ?Ñ ÌÌÍÈbÉ�ÐÍÉ ÌÍÌÍå|ÔbØ)ΰÚÌÍȾÉ�ÙbåÃÉ7Ñ É�ÏÓÊAÌÍÉ�Ê Ô¾×�ÌgÈbÉ�Ùbå|É?Ñ1É�ÏgÊ°ÌÍÉ�å|ÐÅÑ1ΠԾÐ�ÌgÊ ÔKÌlÚÛÎGÏ.ÊCØ å|é É1Ô�Ñ ÎGÔKÌÍÏÓÊ Ñ_Ì7â

pVp

Page 24: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

wIT6NP@¨NP@EF�§M57O 4YREhQN7@EF�aCTV5?·6FG5"TVwE=?FK5?]6F � &VfJ46RQDER�wEWº4Y=7FKh¶FK=?N7WXOZ4YNPF�T6U%NP5?DEF�>GTVREhEW^NPW[TVRE=Kf � &���������Xf

� &(' � &1-�� & � &����µ»Ít�� � �� ¼ � �"»�� &� � &b¼ '�tÁ » �;^sVsb¼

��LNPW[O¶4YelFG¬%TV51N�WX=

� ' + �� ��" - / Á�JDEw=?NPW^NPDN7WXREª¨W[R�N7T¨LE57T�hEDE> NPW[]�W^N_8`46REh`NP46·�WXREª¨eXT6ªS4657W^NP@EOQ=v8�W[FKeXh=

e[TVª ' ��e[TVª � ; ��eXTVª �=".-�» � -�sb¼eXTVª�� -�» ��-Àsm¼eXTVª �(Á » �;^sbpV¼

�)@EF«LEWXFG>KF 574YNPF�WX=)>A@TV=7FGRjNPT¨=74YNPW[=?U½8

�� ����� �������������! #"%$& � �('�)+*,���-�. #"�/��102/� �(02/3 "546�����7�����-�. #" &98 � �('�)+*,���:�. #"�/602/8 4���-�! #"<; = >@?A )B�DCFEG 6HI"

�JDEw=?NPW^NPDN7WXREªj» �;[sdÂS¼CWXRSNPT®» �;^sbpV¼v8�WXFGeXhE=

eXT6ª #" � &('²e[TVª �� -ÝeXTVª<» � -�sb¼ ; eXTVª � & -��(»¥eXTVª � � ; eXTVª �="g¼;tÁæo» � -�sb¼ �J � �& - � �� - � ��FK - ��»¥eXTVª�� & ; eXT6ª � &b¼ -ML " & � » �;^sdq�¼

a�@EFG57F

L " & �0'¦» � -�sb¼ J e[TVªN �6; � � & K -�» ��-Àsb¼G»�e[TVª ��" & ; � &b¼ - » � -�sb¼O�&SÁp6Â

Page 25: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

�)@EF«FK5?57TV5)=1NP57D>GNPD57F«WX=)ªVW^]VFKR®wS8

�"» L " & �1¼ '�t

�"» L " � &�L " � &b¼ '¦» � -Àsm¼ � » � �& - � �� - � �� ¼�)»DL " & � L "

�&

�� ¼ '¦» � -Àsm¼ � � ��

�)»DL " & � L "�& �

�¼ '¦» � -Àsm¼ � � ��

�)»DL " & � L " &��

�¼ '�t

�)»DL " & � L "�& � ¼ '¦» � -Àsm¼ � » � �� - � �� ¼

�)»DL " & � L " & ��¼ '¦» � -Àsm¼ � � ��

�)»DL " & � L " &�� ¼ '¦» � -Àsm¼ � � �� Á

» �;^sboV¼

��=?N7WXOZ4YNPFG=�T6UlhW[¬%FK57FGRSN�]6FK5?=7WXT6RE=�T6U�» �;^sdq�¼�465?F)ªVW[]6FKR¨WXR¨��46wEeXF s6s >GTVeXDOZRE=�»¥w<¼ fI»¥>m¼°fJ4YREh»�hM¼ ;«�_R >GTVeXDOZRÝ»¥w<¼ f%aCFQ46e[eXTma U¥TV5iavFd4YN7@EFK5 =?@ET�>A·�=Gf.wEDN�RET`LIFK5?>KFKLJNPWXT6R FG575?TV57=�� �������Xf � �WX=�LITV=7W^NPW^]VF�a�@EW[eXF ��� WX=��KFG57TE;v�)@EFHFG=?N7WXOZ4YNPF T6U �¸WX=�tÁ}qVqZ46REh:NP@EF�]Y46eXDF«TYU�N7@EFHe[TVªS465?W[N7@EOT6U�NP@EF e[WX·YFKeXW[@ET�TJhQU¥DERE>GN7WXTVR`W[RE>K5?Fd46=?FK=)NPTQÂS{�Á �S{6oJ;��_R®>KTVe[DEOZR »¥>m¼°faCF�LE5?FK=?FKRSNiFG=?N7WXOZ4YNPFG="T6UNP@F�OQT�hEFKeEa�W^NP@ETVDJN�aCFK4YNP@EFG5v=?@ET�>A·�=GfwEDJNC4YeXeXTma�W[REª�U¥TV5�LIFK57>GFKLN7WXTVRQFK5?57TV5?=$� �������Xf � � W[= �KFK5?Ta�@EW[eXF ��� W[=�LITV=7W^NPW^]VF6;��)@EFyFK=?N7WXOZ4YNPF«T6U �²W[=itJÁ|Â6q¶46REh2N7@EFH]Y46e[DEF«T6U�NP@FyeXT6ªS4657W^NP@EO T6U�NP@FeXW[·6FGeXWX@TJT�hjW[=iqEs6Á|t �6Ä; �(W[RM46eXe^8Vf<WXR2>KTVe[DEOZR�»�h<¼°flavFzLE57FG=7FKRSN�FG=?NPW[O¶4¾NPFK=iT6U�NP@EFyOZT�hEFKe.a�W[N7@wIT6NP@®L%FG57>GFKLN7WXTVR®FK5?57TV5?=�4YREh®avFd4¾NP@EFG5�=?@ETJ>A·�=�� �������Xf � � 46REh ��� w%TYNP@®L%TV=?W[N7W[]VFY;���FK5?F6fMNP@FFK=1NPW[O¶4YN7F�T6U �:WX=�tÁÃÂS{«46REhZN7@EF�]Y46e[DEF�T6U¿N7@EF�e[TVªS465?W[N7@EO�T6UlNP@EF�eXW[·6FKe[WX@ET�T�h­U¥DERE>GN7WXTVRZWX=�F���DM4YeNPT¨qVqÁ|ÂS{Yt; � +

�_RݪVFGREFK5746egf(N7@EFnW[REhEW[]�W[hEDM46e�]Y4657WX46RE>KFZLM465746OZF NPFG57=z465?FnRET6N­LE57FG>KWX=?FKe^8µFG=?NPW[O¶4¾NPFKhlf�46e^rNP@TVDEªV@ NP@EF¨]Y46eXDEFQT6UvNP@EFQeXTVªV4657W^NP@EO T6U"NP@FZe[WX·6FGeXW[@ETJT�h¯U¥DERE> NPW[TVR¤W[RE>K5?Fd46=?FK=H=7DEwE=1NA46RSN7Wº46e[e[8

� + ÞKÌÍÏgåæÑ_ÌÍÖ|îzÐ�Ù6É?Ê ÒdåÃÔbØYð�ÕlÉ�Ñ1Ê ÔbÔbΠÌ�Ñ Î Ü"پʠÏÍÉ)Ü"Îm×mÉ?Ö|Ð�ÕÅå}ÌgÈzéPÊ ÏÍåæÊ°ÔYÑ É?Ð�Ð�É1Ì�ÌÍÎ��?É1ÏgΠ˾Ð�å|ÔbØ ÌgÈbÉ�Ð�ÌgÊ Ô¾×bÊ°ÏÓ×ÖÃå|Ò É?ÖÃå|ÈbÎdÎm× �ºÏgÊ°ÌÍå|Î�ÌgÉ?Ð�Ì�Ê Ð%ÌÍÈbÉ�éAÊ ÏÍåæÊ°Ô¾Ñ1É�ÙYÊ°ÏÓÊ°Ü"É ÌgÉ1ÏÓÐ1ðdÕÅÈbÉ?Ô�ÐÍÉ Ì¿ÌgÎ �?É1ÏgξðbÊ ÏÍÉ(ΠÔ�ÌÍÈbÉ .6Π˾Ծ×bÊ°Ïgî)ΰÚÌÍȾÉپʰÏÓÊ°Ü"É1ÌÍÉ1ÏÐ�ÙYÊ Ñ ÉGð7ÐÍÎ�Ð�ÌgÊ Ô¾×bÊ°ÏÓ×Sð �¾ÏÓÐ¥Ì �XÎGÏg×mÉ?Ï�Ê ÐÍîdÜ"ÙmÌÍΠÌÍåæÑMÜ"É ÌÍȾÎd×¾ÐJÊ ÏÍÉ<å|ÔdéAÊ°Ö|å|×SâJìHÉl×mÎ�ÐÍÎ.ÈbÉ?ÏÍÉIÐÍå|ÜCÙ¾ÖÃîÌÍÎiÙbÏgÎAéKåæ×mÉ�ÌgÈbÉ�ÏgÉ?ÊG×mÉ1Ï�ÕÅå}ÌgÈHÐÍΠÜ"É�ÚÛÉ?É1Ö|åÃÔbØ�ÚÛΠÏ�ÈbÎAÕ¸Ü�ËYÑÓÈ .YÉ1Ì�ÌgÉ1Ï�ÌÍÈbÉCÜ"Îd×bÉ1ÖæÐ �bÌ�ÕÅÈbÉ?Ô�ÙYÉ?ÏgÑ1É1ÙmÌgåÃÎGÔÉ1ÏgÏÍÎGÏgпʠԾ×�׾ʰå|ÖÃîiÐ�ÈbÎmÑÓÒmпʰÏgÉ�åÃÔ¾Ñ1ÖÃËY×mÉ?×Sâ

pYq

Page 26: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

wS8­NP@FKWX5�W[RE>Ke[DE=7W[TVR¿;�#"N�NP@EF�=746OZF"N7WXOQF6f6N7@EF)FK=1NPW[O¶4YN7F)T6U<NP@EF�F ¬lTV51N�FKeX46=?N7WX>KW^N_8 �¶WX=�LE5?FK>GWX=7FGe[8FK=1NPW[O¶4YN7FKh¿f5P46REª6WXREª­U¥5?TVO tÁÃÂV­NPTQtÁ}qVqE;

� � � � ( � �� � �J�K� � ��� �¥�

�_RyT657hEFG5�NPT�FG]Y46e[DM4YNPF�N7@EFCLIFK51U¥TV57OZ46RE>GFvT6UJNP@EFv=?N757DE> NPDE5746eJOQT�hEFKeÍfbavFC>K46eX>GDEeº4¾NPFKhyÄSobrÓL%FG57>KFGRSN>KT6R§MhEFGRE>KF`W[R�N7FK51]64YeX=�U¥TV5HN7@EF¶LE5?FKhEW[>GN7FKh�]Y46eXDFK=«T6U)NP@EFZeXTVªV4657W^NP@EO TYU�hM46WXe^8¸LE5?TJhED>GNPW^]�W[N_8V;�¤F�>KTVR>KFKRSN75P4YN7F�TVRnNP@F�]VFG57=?WXTVR`T6UÅN7@EF�OQTJhFKe<a�W[NP@ZL%FG57>GFKLN7WXTVR`FG5757T657=)46Rhn5P46RhETVO hM46W[e[8=7@TJ>A·�=K; �_R���WXªVDE5?F¤s6f�avF¯LE5?FK=?FKRSN`NP@EFG=7F¯>GTVR§MhFKRE>GF W[RSNPFK51]Y46eX=Gf)46eXT6REª¤a�W^NP@³N7@EF¸46> NPDM46eTVwE=?FK51]64¾NPWXT6RE=KfEwS8¶WXREhEW^]�WXhEDM4Ye%FGOZLEe[Tm8VFKFY;���TQ4d]VT6WXh`>Ke[DN7N7FK5GfJavF«Leº46>GF�TVwE=?FK5?]Y4YN7WXTVR`R�DEOyw%FG5TVRÝNP@EF®@ETV5?W �GTVRSNA46e)4b©W[=K;¹�)@EF®>KTVR§EhEFKRE>GF¯WXRSN7FK5?]Y46eC>KTV5?57FK=?L%T6REhEWXRª N7T¤FK46>A@³TVw=7FK51]Y4YNPW[TVRWX=zOZ465?·6FKhÝwS8Ý4 � � ¸NPT¸hEFGRET6N7F®>GTVRSNP5?TVe)TVwE=?FK5?]Y4YN7WXTVR=¨46REh¹4 ���� ¯NPT²hEFKRT6NPF`NP5?Fd4YN7OZFGRSNTVwE=?FK51]64¾NPWXT6RE=K;��)@EFz46> NPDM4Ye�TVw=7FK51]Y4YNPW[TVR2W[=i=?8�O­wITVe[W �KFGh2wS8:NP@EFy57FKª6DEeº465�LEW[FK>GFy5P4¾NPFHU¥T65�NP@FLEe[T6N"TVR`a�@EW[>A@`NP@EF�T6wE=7FG5?]Y4YNPW[TVR`T�>K>KD5757FGh¿;��)@EF�eXTVªV4657W^NP@EO T6U�hM4YWXe[8QLE5?TJhDE>GN7W[]�W[N_8ZWX="ª6W[]VFGRTVR`NP@F�]6FK51NPWX>K46e.4¾©JWX=G;

�)@EFCOZT�hEFKeS§EN7=�N7@EFChM4¾NA4 ��DEW^NPFvavFKe[egfY46e[N7@ETVDEª6@¿fYW[Ry=1NP57W[>GN�NPFK5?OZ=GfYN7@EFCOQTJhFKe�WX=�57F �?FG>GN7FKhwS8 N7@EF2hE4YNA4; �_R�46e[egfCRWXREF N_8³LIFK5?>KFKRSN`TYU NP@EFjTVwE=7FG5?]Y4YN7WXTVRE=QU�46eXe)a�W^NP@EW[R NP@F¸ÄSobrÓL%FG57>KFGRSN>KT6R§MhEFGRE>KF�WXRSNPFG5?]Y46eX=G;(��@M4YN�W[=vOQTV57FYfS=7W[RE>KF�NP@EF�TVDN7LEDNC46REhZFG¬%TV5?N�FKeX46=?N7WX>GW[NPW[FK=�>GTVWXRE>GWXhEF�W[RTVDE5�OQTJhFKegfYaCF�>d46RQ>KT6OZLM4Y57F)NP@EF�FG=?NPW[O¶4¾NPFKhQTVDN7LEDN�FKeX46=?N7WX>GW[N_8yU¥5?TVO/N7@EF�=?NP5?DE>GN7DE5P4YeIOQT�hEFKeNPTzN7@M4YN)U¥57T6O NP@F #����)&(# OQTJhFKeg;��µF�RET6N7F�NP@M4¾N)NP@EFG=7F�LM465746OZF NPFG57=�465?F�]6FK518`>Ke[TV=7FYf<tÁ|ÂV{U¥TV5�NP@EF«=?N757DE> NPDE5746e�OZT�hEFKe.4YREh¯tÁÃÂVĨU¥TV5)NP@EFH#����)&(#/OZT�hEFGe �<46RS8®OZW[=1rÓ=7LIFK>KW^§M>d4¾NPWXT6R`hETJFG=RET6N�@M4d]VF­4Zeº4Y57ªVF�FG¬%FK> N TVR®NP@EFHFK=?N7WXOZ4YNPFGhjLE465P46OQFGN7FK5�T6U�W[R�N7FK5?FK=?NK;�#�=�46e^a"4d8�=Kf<NP@FK57FHWX=�4NP5746hEF°r_T6¬ZWXR«NP@EF)4YLELEeXW[>d4YN7WXTVR«T6UM=1NP5?DE>GN7DE5P46eJOZT�hEFGeX=�N7T�hM4YNP4;��_R�]Y465?Wº46we[8VfY=?N757DE> NPDE5746eOQTJhFKeX=hET¸RETYN­§EN­N7@EFnhM4YNP4¸46=yavFKe[e)46=yN7@EFKW[5yDERE5?FK=1NP57W[>GN7FKhÝ>KTVDR�N7FK5?LM465?N7=K;µ��TmaCF ]VFG5Kf�=?NP5?DE>GN7DE5P4YeOQTJhEFGeX=(46eXe[TbaÝT6REF"NPT�OZ46·6F"wIFK@E4m]�W[TVDE5P4YeEWXRSNPFG57LE5?FGNP4YNPW[TVRE=�T6U<N7@EF)57FG=7DEe^NP=�46REhzN7T WXRS]VFG=?NPW[ªS4YN7F46e^NPFK5?RM4YN7W[]VFHL%T6eXWX>GWXFG=�DERTVwE=7FG5?]6FKh hEDE57W[REª¶N7@EF­F ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNd;��¤F­hEF ]VFKe[TVL¸NP@EW[=ieX4YN7N7FK5iLITVW[R�NWXR`N7@EF�REF ©�N�=7FG>GNPW[TVR¿;

� � � � ��Í£ � � � ¢ �.� ��� � � ½� ��¡ � ¢��� � � � � � �d¡¾¢E£6�b�z¢ � � � �I�G�b�

��=?N7WXOZ4YNPW[REªQN7@EFz=?N757DE> NPDE5746e(OQT�hEFKe�46eXe[Tma�=�DE=�N7TnLE5?FKhEW[>GNiN7@EF­LIFK51U¥TV57OZ46RE>GF­T6U�46e^NPFK5?RM4YN7W[]VFpVo

Page 27: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

>KT6R�N75P46> NP=Gf�RET6NyTVwE=7FG5?]6FKh hEDE5?WXREª®NP@EFZF ©JLIFK57W[OZFGRSNd;:�ÓN­W[=HRETYNPFGavTV51NP@S8¤N7@M4YN«NP@EFZTVwE=?FK5?]6FKh>KT6R�N75P46> N�@M46=�TVREe^8yT6REF)WXRE=1NP5?DEOZFGRSNdfVNP@F)LEWXFG>KF�5P4YN7F6;�x�W^]VFKR¨>A@M4YREªVWXRª LEeº46RSN7WXREª >GTVREhEW^NPWXT6RE=KfNP@F�LEWXFG>KF�5P4YN7F�O­DE=1N)46>G>KTVOQLEeXW[=7@QN_aCT­NP46=7·�=K$�LE5?Tm]JW[hEWXRªyWXR>KFKRSN7W[]VFG=CU¥TV5vFG¬%TV5?N"46REh`ªVDM4Y5P46RJrNPFGFKW[REª eº46wITVDE5�=7DELLEe[86;(#�>KT6R�N75P46> N�NP@E4YN�WXR>KeXDhEFK=�4�wE46=7F"aC46ªVF�46e[eXTma�=�N7@EF"§M5?O,N7T =7FKLE465P4YN7FNP@F­NA46=?·�= TYU�N_avT:WXRE=1NP5?DEOZFGRSNP=Kf¿N7@EF­LEW[FK>GFz5P4YN7F­LE57Tm]�WXhWXREª`W[RE>KFGR�N7W[]6FK=�46REh¸N7@EF­wM46=?F­a"4YªVF=P4¾NPWX=1U½8�WXREªQeº46wITVDE5�=?DELELEe^8V;)�_RjN7@EWX=�=7FG>GN7WXTVR¿f<avFy>KT6RE=7W[hEFK5�@ETma NP@EF«WXRSN757T�hEDE>GN7WXTVR®T6U�4ZwM46=?FaC46ªVF�WXRSNPTzN7@EF�>KTVRSNP5746>GN�avTVDEe[h24Y¬%FK> N)§M57O LE57T6§NP=K;

�)@EF�wM46=?F rga"46ª6Fi>KT6R�N75P46> N�WXRE>GeXDEhEFG=C4�wM46=?F�aC46ªVF��,46REhZ4«LEW[FK>GF�574YNPF ��46RhQNP46·6FG=vNP@FU¥TV5?O � '�� " & - � �Á

��TZ>GTVOZLE4657F >GTVRSNP5P4Y>GNP=GfEaCF«hEFGRET6NPF

�n» �6¼ ' + � �=" - /NP@F«F ¬lT65?N�eXF ]VFGe�DREhEFK5)N7@EF�TVwE=7FG5?]6FKh¯LEW[FK>GF r_574YNPF >GTVRSNP5746>GNKf<46REh

�n»�� � ��¼<' + � �=" - /NP@F«F ¬lT65?N�eXF ]VFGe�DREhEFK5)N7@EF«46e[N7FK57RE4YNPW^]VF wM46=?F rga"46ª6F«>GTVRSNP5746>GNK;

�¤F�=7TVe^]VF)U¥TV5(N7@EF�wM46=7F°rÓaC46ªVF�>KT6R�N75P46> N�NP@M4YN�avTVDEe[h¨ªVW[]6F)Fd46>A@¨aCT657·6FG5�N7@EF�=P46OQF)DN7WXeXW^N_8eXF ]VFGe)@EF:TV5z=7@EF®>KD5757FGRSNPe[8�Fd465?RE=¨DEREhEFG5QN7@EF:TVwE=7FG5?]6FKh³>GTVRSNP5746>GNK; �M5?TVO F ��DE4YNPW[TVR » �;^sb¼ fF ©JLIFK> NPFKhjDNPW[eXW^N_8¶W[=)ªVW[]6FKR®w�8

�"» 2��" & ¼<'� /�� /& F ©JL� ^» � -�sb¼ � &8-¹tÁæo» � -�sb¼ � » � �& - � �� ¼ �� / " » � -�sb¼F ©JL ;y» ��-�sb¼ � � & ; tJÁæoE» � -�sb¼ � � �� � Á

�M57TVO F���DM4YN7WXTVR¤» �;[sdÂS¼ f

� /�� /& F ©JL� ^» �0-:sm¼�� &�-¨tÁæo» �0-:sb¼ � » � �& - � �� ¼ � F ©JL� ^» �0-:sb¼ � � & -¨tÁ|oE» �0-:sm¼ � � �� � '��� » � -`sb¼ � / � Á�JDEw=?NPW^NPDN7WXTVR`8�WXFGeXhE=

�)» 2 �" & ¼<'�+ � ��=" -0/ �� Áp �

Page 28: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

\�RhEFK5)NP@F«wE46=7F°rÓaC46ªVF«>KTVRSNP5746>GNKfMF ©JLIFK>GN7FKhjDNPW[eXW[N_8ZWX=)ª6W[]VFGRjwS8

� 2 ��� $ � �" & � ' � �*- � �n»�� � ��¼ � � ;"��" �� -�s �n»�� � ��¼ ��� ����� #

'�� -� � /� /�� F ©JL� [» � -�sb¼ � &1- tJÁæoE» � -�sb¼ �6» � �& - � �� ¼ �� / " » � -Àsm¼F ©JL� ;y» ��- sb¼ � � & ;ÝtÁ|oE» � -Àsb¼ � � �� �

'�� - � � /�� / �� � /�� / �+ � ���" - / �� Á

�JTVe^]�WXREª­U¥TV5"N7@EF�eXF ]VFKeÅTYU � NP@M4¾N�ªVDM465746RSNPFKFG=�>GDE575?FKRSN�DNPW[eXW[N_8¨8�WXFGeXhE=

� " &�» ��¼ ' + � ���" - / �� s ; � � /�� /��� � /� /�� #Á »Í{J;[sm¼

x W[]VFGR �n» ��¼ 46REh �­f�avFQ>d46R a�57W[N7F¨F ©JL%FG>GN7FKh�LE5?T6§EN7=«LIFK5�avTV57·YFK5«DEREhEFG5y46RS8²wM4Y=7F rga"4YªVF>KT6R�N75P46> N�46=

» � ; ��¼ � / �� +� ��=" - / » ��-Àsb¼

� /�� /; �� + � ��=" - / s ; + � � -0/� / # Á »Í{J;æp6¼

*24¾©JW[OZW'�KWXRª­F���DM4YN7WXTVR¤»Í{J;æp6¼ a�W[N7@:57FK=?L%FG>GN�NPT �,8�W[FKeXh="NP@EF�=?NP46REhM4Y57h®=7TVe[DNPW[TVR

��*' � �

U¥57T6O a�@EW[>A@jW^N)U¥TVeXe[Tba�=�� ' + ����=" -%/ �� s ; � � /�� /��� � /�� /�� #

Á

�(©JL%FG>GNPFGh2LE5?T6§EN7=�LIFK5"avTV57·YFK5�DEREhEFG5�N7@EF�wM46=?F rÓaC46ªVF�>GTVRSNP5P4Y>GN�4657F

� ��� $ � � ' ; �� ' + � ���" - / �� � � /�� / �� � /�� / �;�s # Á

\�RhEFK5)NP@F«LWXFK>GF rÓ5P4YN7F«>GTVRSNP5746>GNKfMF ©JL%FG>GN7FKh2L57T6§EN7=�L%FG5�avTV5?·6FK5�465?F«ª6W[]VFGR:w�8

� � '» � ; �6¼

� + ����=" - / �� » � -Àsm¼ Á »Í{J;|ÂV¼

pV{

Page 29: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� �<¡ � �¢¡ � ���

� � � ��� � � � � ��� � � � ��� � � � ��� � � ����� �� � � � ������ � � � � � � � ��� � � � �� ��� � ��� � � � � � � ����� � � ������ ��� � � � ����� ��� � � ��� ������� ��� � � ��� � � ���� � � � � � � ��� �4� ��� ���

�"» � ������5�%� �V¼ ' �*; �� "A» � -�sb¼

�"» � ������5��%� � � �­¼0' » �*; ��¼� /�� /

� / "P» ��-Àsb¼ ; " s ; + � � - /�� / # »Í{J;ÃqS¼

� � �����

" ��F°©L�» �+m¼F ©JL�» � =/�"_¼ '��� + � ���" - / ��+ '�eXTVª��� - � e[TVª<» � � ¼ ; e[TVª<» � /°¼ � �=/ " ' e[TVª<» ��/G¼ ; e[TVª<» ��"g¼ � Á

�«¡ ��� � � � � �<¡�� ¥¢E¡ � �

� � � � � �� � � � � ��� � � ��� � � � � � � � � � �� � � � ��� � � � ��� � � � � ��� � � � � � � � ������� � ��� ��� � � � ��� ��� ��� � � �� � � ��� � � ��� ��� ��� ��� � ����� ��� � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � ��� ��� � � � � � ��� � � � ��� �� � � � � � � � � ������ �=� � ��� � �� � � �� � � � � ����� � ��� � � � � ��� � � ��� � � �

�+('ÀeXT6ª �� -�� eXTVªM» � � ¼ ;�eXT6ª<» ��/G¼ �=/ " ' e[TVª<» � / ¼ ; eXTVª<» �="Ó¼ � Á

� � � ����� �

" ��F ©JL�» �+d¼F ©JL�» � =/ "Ó¼ '��� + � ��=" -0/ Á��� � � � � � ��� �� � �� � � �+ � =/ " � � � � � � ��� ������� ��� � � ��� � � ���� � ���

�_R �(4YwEeXF`sbp�f.avF¨LE57FG=7FGR�N­4`=7DEOQO¶4Y5?8¯TYUC>GTVRSNP5P4Y>GNPDE46e�L%FG5?U¥TV5?O¶4YRE>KFzTVR Fd4Y>A@¤F°©LIFK5 rWXOQFKRSNP46e(wEe[TJ>A·<fÅF ]64YeXDM4YN7FKh 4YN�N7@EFzFK=1NPW[O¶4YN7FK=�U¥5?TVO ��46wEe[FnsVsj»�h<¼)���������Xf.46eXe[Tba�W[REªZU¥T65�hM46W[e[8=7@TJ>A·�=�46REh:L%FG57>GFKLN7WXTVR®FK5?57TV5?=K;��_R:NP@EF §M5?=?N�>KTVe[DEOQR¿fJavF�LE57FG=7FKRSN�NP@EF�LEW[FK>GF 5P4YN7F«LE46WXh`DER�rhEFG5�N7@EF�46> NPDM4YeI>GTVRSNP5746>GNKf�a�@EW[eXF�WXR¨NP@F�=?FK>KT6REhn>KT6eXDEOQRQavFiL57FK=?FKRSN"N7@EF�T6LNPW[O¶46eLEWXFG>KF�5P4YN7FDEREhFK5�NP@EF�wM46=?F rga"46ª6F�>GTVRSNP5P4Y>GNd;(�_RZNP@F�N7@EWX5?h¨>KTVe[DEOZRlfVaCF�LE57FG=7FGR�NvNP@EF�4d]VFG5P46ª6F�wM4Y=7F rga"4YªVF

p��

Page 30: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� ¢E� � � ��� � ��� � � � �� � � � ��� � � � � � � � �

BCe[TJ>A· ��4YN7F ��LNPW[O¶46e B"46=7F � � � ��� $ � � �FK57>GFKRSN(4YWXh ��4¾NPF �µ46ªVF �_RE>G57Fd4Y=7F

� t;^s �Vt t;ÃÂVÂSp ;«s �VÄÁ^sbo s�� �; �6q s �VÄJ;[sbo smÂ;}q���7� t;|p6ÂVt t;ÃÂ6qSÄ ;«sVsVsVÁÃtV smtSp�;æpVp sVsVs6;|tV �; ����7�?� t;|p6ÂVt t;ÃÂVÂSp ;iÄ6qÁ[sb{ �S{�; �Sp Ä6q;[sb{ {J;|o��

DEREhFK5�N7@EFCwE46=7F°rÓaC46ªVFC>GTVRSNP5746>GN$�SWXR�NP@EF�U¥TVDE5?N7@y>GTVeXDEOQR¿fbaCFvLE57FG=7FGR�N�F ©JL%FG>GN7FKhzLE5?T6§ENP=�DEREhEFG5NP@F�46>GN7DM46e¿LEW[FK>GF r_574YNPFi>KTVRSNP5746>GNKfMWXRnN7@EF�§EU½NP@:>GTVeXDEOQR¿f�aCF�LE5?FK=?FKRSN�F ©JL%FG>GN7FKh2L57T6§EN7=)DEREhEFG5NP@FQwE46=7F°rÓaC46ªVF¨>KTVRSN75P46> Ndf�46REh²WXR¸N7@EFz=7WÛ©JN7@¤>GTVeXDOZR¯avF¨LE57FG=7FKRSN«NP@EFzLIFK5?>KFGR�NHWXR>K57FK46=7F¨W[RF ©JLIFK> NPFKhjLE57TY§EN�w�8n=?a�W[N7>A@EWXRªQN7T¨N7@EF�wM46=?F rÓaC46ªVF«>KT6R�N75P46> Nd;

�¤F�FK=?N7WXOZ4YNPF�NP@EF�LIFK57>GFKRSNA4YªVF�WXRE>G57Fd4Y=7F�WXR:F ©JLIFK> NPFKhjLE57TY§ENP="N7TQwIF�w%F N_aCFGFKR¯{¨4YREh²smÂLIFK57>GFKRSNd;Q��WXRE>GF­NP@EFzwM4Y=7F rga"4YªVF¨>KTVRSNP5746>GN�W[=iNP@FQT6LNPW[O¶46e�>KT6R�N75P46> Ndf¿N7@EWX= ªVW^]VFG=�4:OQFd4Y=7DE5?FT6U�NP@EF�>GTVRSNP5P4Y>GNPDE46eÅWXREF �Q>KWXFGRE>G8`a�W^NP@EW[RnNP@EF §M5?Oj; � �

� � � ���d£ ��K� ��� � ¢ � � � � � £ ��� ��� � �

��>KTVRTVOZW[=?N7=(465?FvW[RE>K5?Fd46=?WXREª6e[8iN7DE57RWXREª�NPT�F ©JL%FG57W[OZFGR�N7=�N7T�ªS4¾NP@EFG5�hM4¾NA4�>GTVRE>GFK57RWXREª�WXREhEW^]�WXhJrDM46eÅwIFK@E4m]�W[TVDE5K;v�(©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSN7=i46e[eXTmaÀU¥TV5"NP@EF«5P4YREhETVO 4YeXeXT�>d4¾NPWXT6RnT6U�NP57FK4YNPOQFKRSN7=Kf<=7W[OZLEe[W[U½8SrWXRªHW[hEFKRSNPW^§M>d4¾NPWXT6RZ4YREhZFG=?N7WXOZ4YNPW[TVR¿;��(WXFGeXh¨F ©JLIFK57W[OZFGRSNP=�F ©�NPFGREhnNP@EF�wIFKREF §ENP=vT6U¿F°©T6ªVFKRET6DE=]Y4657WX4YNPW[TVR2W[R¯NP5?Fd4YN7OZFGR�N7=�NPT`5?Fd46eÛrÓavTV57e[h¯hM4YNP4flU�46>GWXeXW^NA4YN7WXREª¨NP@FzªVFKREFG5P46e[W �K4YNPW[TVR2T6U�=1NA4YN7WX=?N7W^r>d4Ye(57FG=7DEe^NP=G;H��WXFKe[h2F°©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSNP= L57Tm]�WXhEFz4n=?WXOQLEeXFYfI86FGN�LITmaCFG5?U¥DEeÍflNPT�TVe.U¥TV5 46RM4Ye[8�=7W[REª¶NP@FFG¬%FK> NP=�T6U�hEW[¬%FK5?FKRSN�L%FG57=7T6REREFKe.LITVeXW[>KW[FK=va�W^NP@EW[R`NP@EF §M5?Oj;

�¤F @M4d]VF�46RE46e[8�=7FGh`hM4YNP4yU¥57TVO TVREF�=?DE>A@:§MFKe[hnF ©JLIFK57W[OZFGRSNdfEhEFG=7W[ªVREFKhnN7TzOZFK46=7D57F�NP@F57FK46>GN7WXTVRQT6U¿avTV5?·6FK5?=CNPT«>A@M46RªVFK=vWXRQLEWXFG>KF rÓ5P4YN7F�W[RE>KFGRSNPW[]6FK=G;��)@EFiF°©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA4Ye<]Y465?Wº4YN7WXTVR¨W[RNP@F­LEWXFG>KF­574YNPF­46eXe[Tba�=�U¥TV5�NP@EFzhEW[57FG>GN�OQFd4Y=7DE5?FKOQFKRSN T6U�5?Fd46> NPWXT6RE=ia�W[N7@EWXR246R¸DERE5?FK=1NP57W[>GN7FKh

� ��� É7Ð�Ù¾å}ÌgÉ�ÌgÈbÉ�Ú^ÊGÑ_Ì�ÌgȾÊAÌ�ÌÍÈbÉCÙ6É1ÏÓÑ É1ÔKÌ�å|Ô¾Ñ1ÏÍÉ7Ê ÐÍÉ�åÃÔ«ÙbÏÍÎ �bÌgÐ�×mÉ1Ù6É1ÔY×bÐ(ΠÔbÖ|î�ÎGÔ�Î".YÐ�É?ÏÍéAÊ).¾ÖÃÉ7Ð.Ê°Ô¾× �ð6å}Ì(å|ÐÔbΰÌvå|×mÉ?ÔKÌÍå �¾É?×zÊ°Ì�ÌÍÈbÉ�˾ÔbÏÍÉ7Ð¥ÌgÏÍåæÑ_ÌgÉ?×yÉ?Ð�ÌÍå|Ü)ÊAÌgÉ?Ð�ΠÚ%ÌgÈbÉ�õ�ï �� õ Ü"Îm×mÉ?Ö[âiÇ¿Èbå|Ð�ÎmÑ1Ñ Ë¾ÏgÐ .6É?Ñ?ʰ˾ÐÍÉ"ÌÍȾÉÙYÉ?ÏgÑ1É1ÔKÌgÊ Ø ÉlåÃÔYÑ ÏgÉ?Ê ÐÍÉlåÃÔ"ÙbÏgÎ �bÌÓÐM×mÉ1Ù6É1ÔY×bÐEΠÔbÖ|î�ÎGÔ �� ��� ��������������������� �"!#�$��% âEôºÌI×mÎdÉ?ÐÔbΠÌ<ÔbÉ?Ñ1É?ÐgÐÍÊ ÏÍå|Ö|î×mÉ1Ù6É1ÔY×�ÎGÔbÖ|î�Î Ô �ð¾åÃÔiØ É?ÔbÉ1ÏÓÊ°ÖXâǿȾÉ�ÙYÎGÖÃåæÑ î�ʠԾʰÖ|îmÐ�åæÐlå|пÎGÔbÖ|î�éAÊ°Ö|å|×iåÃÚJËbÔ¾×bÉ1ÏÍÌgÊ°ÒGÉ1Ô�ÊAÌ¿ÌÍȾÉ�ÏÍÉ7Ð¥ÌgÏÍåæÑ_ÌgÉ?×É?Ð�ÌÍå|Ü)ÊAÌÍÉ7Ð1â

p6Ä

Page 31: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

U¥5P4YOZF aCTV5?·<;¯��DE5«57FG=7DEe^NP=y=?DEªVªVFG=?N­N7@M4YN«aCT657·6FG57=­hT¯57FK46>GNHNPT2W[RE>KFGRSNPW[]6FK=G;j�¤F¶57FGL%T65?Ny46RTVDN7LEDN�FGeº46=1NPWX>GW[N_8Qa�W[N7@`57FK=?L%FG>GN�NPT¨>A@M4YREªVFK=�W[RnNP@EF�LEW[FK>KF 574YNPF TYU(tJÁ|ÂVÄJ;��)@EWX=�46>G>KTV5?hE="a�W[N7@LE5?FG]�WXTVD=�57FK=?DEe[N7=�TVwNA4YWXREFGhzw�8z(4V465?=7>A@¶46REhZ�J@EFK4657FG5�»1smÄVÄ6ÄS¼(46REhQ��46eXF 8:»gpYtVtVÂS¼°$�LEW[FK>GF)5P4YN7FLM4d8�OZFGRSN"=?8�=1NPFKOQ="hET­4Y¬lFG>GN�aCT657·6FG5"wIFK@M4d]�WXTVD5K;���Rn4«wE57TS4YhEFK5v=7>d4YeXF6f�TVDE5�57FG=7DEe^NP=C4657Fi46eX=?T>KT6RE=7W[=?NPFGRSN�a�W[N7@¯NP@EFHeXW[N7FK574YNPDE5?FHW[RS]VFK=1NPW[ªS4YNPW[REªnW[RE>KFGR�N7W[]6F­FG¬%FK> NP=K;«��L%FG>KW[§E>d46e[e[8Vf%46= �4V465?=7>A@46REh`�J@EFd4Y57FK5�»gp6t6tVtS¼ f�-.4��GFd465i»gp6t6tSpV¼ f�46Rh:�J@EFK4657FG5 »gpYtVt6q�¼�@M4d]VF�46eX=?T«U¥TVDREh¿fW[RE>KFGRSNPW[]6FK=vhETOZ4YN7N7FK5K;

#"N¶4¤OQTV57F:hEF NA46W[eXFGh e[FG]VFGegf�NP@EF®OZFK46=7D57FKh F ©JLIFK57W[OZFGRSNA46e�57FK46>GN7WXTVRÝNPT¤WXRE>GFKRSNPW^]VFG=ZW[=eXTmavFK5®NP@M46R�LE57F ]JW[TVDE=GfHRET6RJr_F°©LIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA4Yegf FK=1NPW[O¶4YN7FK=��z=7FKFYf«U¥T652F ©46OQLEe[F6f«(4V4Y57=7>A@ 4YREh�J@EFK4657FG5¸» smÄVÄVÄS¼z46Rh��i46e[FG8 »Íp6tVtVÂS¼°;�# R�DEOyw%FG5¶T6U LITV=?=7WXweXF:F ©JLEeX46RM4YN7WXTVRE=¨U¥TV5¨NP@EW[=ZF°©�rWX=1Nd;���WX57=1Ndf�LE5?FG]�WXTVD=COQTJhEFGeX=�DE=7FGhn=?N757DE> NPDE5746elFG>KTVRTVOZF NP5?WX>�OZF NP@ET�hE=�NPTyW[hEFKRSN7W[U½8zNP@FiFG¬%TV51NFKeX46=?N7WX>GW[N_8V;�#i=vhEFKOQTVRE=1NP5P4¾NPFKh¶WXR¶�)@FKTV5?FKO sVf�N7@EFK=?F�OQTJhEFGeX=�57F ��DWX57FGhnWXhFKRSNPW^U½8JW[REªH46=7=?DEOZL�rNPW[TVRE=�>KTVR>KFK5?REWXRªiNP@EF�]Y46eXDEF�T6U<4Ye[NPFG57RM4¾NPW[]6FvDJNPWXe[W[N_8�4YREhHN7@EF"FK=1NPW[O¶4YN7F�T6UMNP@EFvFG¬%TV5?N�FKeX46=?N7WX>GW[N_8WX=«=7FGRE=7W^NPW^]VF¨NPTjN7@ETV=?Fn46=?=7DEOQLNPW[TVRE=G;`#iRET6N7@EFK5«LIT6NPFGR�N7Wº46e�>GTVRSNP57W[wEDN7WXREª:U�46>GN7TV5 NPT®NP@EFQeXTmaF ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46e<5?FK=7LITVRE=?FiW[=�N7@M4YN�aCT657·6FG5CF ¬lTV51NCOZ4d8zRET6NvwIFi4�>KTVRSN7WXR�DETVDE=�]Y4657WX46wEeXFY;��_R¶LM4651rNPW[>KDEeX465KfDELELIFK5ie[WXOQW[N7=vNPTZFG¬%TV5?N�46Rh2LE5?TJhED>GNPW^]�W[N_8`OZ4d8:F ©JWX=1Nd;"#,=?N757DE> NPDE5746e.OZT�hEFKe¿a�@WX>A@46=?=7DEOQFK= NP@E4YN aCT657·6FG5H5?FK=?L%TVR=7FQWX=�>GTVRSNPWXR�DET6DE= NPT:WXRE>GFKRSNPW^]VFG=HOZ4d8¯Tm]VFG5«FG=?N7WXOZ4YNPF­N7@EFz57F°r=7De[NPW[REªnW[RE>KFGR�N7W[]6FzFG¬%FK>GNKf.LM465?N7WX>GDEeº465?e[8:W^UvhE46WXe^8®avTV5?·6FK5�F ¬lTV51N WX=i=7W[N7DM4YN7FKh²REFd4Y5iNP@EFzDLEL%FG5wITVDEREh¿;y#¦§MRM46e�>GTVRE=7W[hEFK574YNPW[TVR¸WX=�N7@M4YN N7@EFzFG¬%TV5?N�FGeº46=1NPW[>KW[N_8jOZ4m82w%Fz@FGNPFG57TVª6FKREFGTVDE=K;¨��ThM4YN7F6f�57FK=?Fd465?>A@EFK5?=z@M4d]VFZFK=?N7WXOZ4YNPFGhµOQTJhFKeX=�a�W^NP@¤>KTVRE=1NA46RSNyFKeº4Y=?NPW[>KW^NPWXFG=Kf.TV5«@ETVOQTVªVFGREFKTVD=NP5?Fd4YN7OZFGRSNzFG¬%FK> NP=K; �F N­NP@EFZ]64Y5?8�WXREª257FK=?DEe[N7=­OZ4m8 5?F �MFG>GNzNP@F¶U�46>GNHNP@M4¾N­NP5?Fd4YN7OZFGR�N7=z465?F@EF NPFK5?TVªVFGREFKTVD=Kf¿FGW[NP@FK5�4Y>K57T6=7=iLeº46RSNPFG57=�TV5�=?W[N7FK=K;i(4V4Y57=7>A@²4YREh²�J@EFK4657FG5z»Íp6tVt6q�¼)@M4d]VFyLE57F°r=7FGRSNPFKh¶TVREF�4YN7N7FKOQLN�NPT�>KT6RE=7W[hEFK5�=7DE>A@¶4«OQT�hEFKeÍ;(�MDN7DE57F�WXRS]6FK=?N7WXªS4¾NPWXT6RQTYUlNP@FK=7F�WX=?=7DEFG=�a�W[eXeWXR>K57FK46=7F�TVD5)DEREhEFG57=?NP46REhEW[REª¶TYU�N7@EF�F �Q>KW[FKRE> 8:T6U(W[RE>KFGRSNPW[]6F�=?8�=?N7FKOQ=�a�W^NP@EW[Rn§M57OQ=K;

�¤Fi@M4d]6F�46e[=7T«>KTVRE=?WXhEFG57FGhZNP@Fi57FGeº4YN7W[]6F�wIFKRFG§EN7=CT6UÅFG=?N7WXOZ4YNPW[REª =?N757DE> NPDE5746el4YREh¶FG>KTVRET¾rOQFGNP5?WX>zOQTJhFKeX=�DE=?WXREª®F ©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46e�hM4¾NA4;Z�_RµªVFGREFK5746egfÅNP@F¶46wWXeXW^N_8jN7T2ªVFGREFK5746eXW'�KFzF°©LIFK5 rWXOQFKRSNP46e(5?FK=7De[NP=�N7T`FG]Y46e[DM4YNPFzLITVe[WX>KW[FK=�DERETVwE=?FK51]VFKh a�W[N7@EWXR2N7@EF¨F ©JLIFK57W[OZFGRSNA46e�=7FGN?NPW[REª:57FKL�r57FG=7FGR�N7=HN7@EFZOZ4��?TV5�4Yh]Y46RSNA46ªVF¨T6UC=?N757DE> NPDE5746e�FK=?N7WXOZ4YNPW[TVR¿;z�_R²U�46>GNKf�F°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSN7=y465?FQ46eX=?TwIFKREF §M>KWX46e¿NPTQ=?N757DE> NPDE5746eÅFK=1NPWXOZ4YN7WXTVR`OQFGN7@ETJh=KfMLE5?Tb]�W[hEWXREªzF°©JTVªVFKRTVDE=�]64Y57Wº4¾NPWXT6Rna�@EWX>A@®57F°r

ÂVt

Page 32: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

hEDE>GFK=�NP@EF�=?FKRE=?W[NPW^]�W[N_8`T6U�NP@F«5?FK=?DEe[N7=�N7TzU¥DERE>GN7WXTVRE46e^rgU¥TV57O 46=?=7DEOQLNPW[TVRE=G;��DE5�57FG=7DEe^NP=�=7DªVªVFK=1N�NP@M4YNH4`>KT6R�N75P46> N�a�@EWX>A@¤WXRE>GeXDEhEFG=�4®wE46=7FzaC46ªVF6f�WXR²4YhEhEW[N7WXTVR¯N7T

4¤LWXFK>GFj574YNPFYf"a�WXe[e)WXRE>G57Fd4Y=7F:§M57O LE5?T6§ENP=Zw%F N_aCFGFKRÀ{ 46REh�sd¤LIFK57>GFKRSNd;À�ÓNZWX=QWXOQL%TV51NA46RSNNPTµRET6NPFYf)@ETmaCF ]VFG5Kf�NP@M4YN¶=7DE>A@�4¤>KTVRSNP5746>GN¶O¶4d8¹>KT6OZF:a�W[N7@�46hEhEFGh¿f)DEREOQT�hEFKe[eXFKhlf">KTV=1NP=G;�_R�LM4651NPWX>GDEeº4Y5Kf)a�@EFK5?Fd46=`N7@EF²LEWXFG>KF rÓ5P4YN7F¯>KT6R�N75P46> N®WX=nTVRe[8�LeXT6N¶=7LIFK>KW^§M>6f�NP@EF¸wM4Y=7F rga"4YªVF>KT6R�N75P46> N)WX=vWXREhW[]�WXhEDE46e<46REh`LEe[T6Nv=7LIFK>KW^§M>6;��)@F�>KTV=1NP=)T6U.RFKªVT6N7Wº4YN7WXREª«=7D>A@:4y>KTVRSN75P46> N)O¶4d8TVDN_avFKW[ªV@ÝNP@EF®w%FGREFG§NP=QT6U�W^NP=zWXOQLEe[FKOQFKRSNA4YN7WXTVR��C=7FGF6fCU¥T65zF ©46OQLEeXFYfC�MFK5?5P46e[e)46REh³�J@EFK4657FG5»1sdÄVÄVÄS¼«U¥T65¨4²hWX=7>GDE=7=?WXTVRÝT6U�NP@F`57TVe[F`WXOQLEeXFGOZFGR�NP4YNPW[TVRµ>GTV=?N7=¨LEeº4d8�W[R�NP@EF:hEF NPFG57OQWXRM4YN7WXTVRT6U)>GTVRSNP5746>GN7=K;®��T6N7FQN7TJT:NP@E4YNyDREhEFK5«NP@EFZwM46=?F rÓaC46ªVFZ>KTVRSN75P46> N­WXRhEW[]�WXhDM46eX= OZ4d8²@M4d]VF¶46RWXR>KFKRSN7W[]VF«NPTZOZW[=757FGLE57FG=7FGR�NiNP@EFGWX5�46wEWXe[W[N7WXFK=CWXR2T657hEFG5�NPTZF ©�NP5746>GNi57FGR�N7=iU¥57T6OÆNP@EF«§M57O®;�� RFWXRSN7FK57L57FGNP4YNPW[TVR:T6U�T6DE5�57FK=?DEe[N7=�WX=)NPTQLE57Tm]�WXhFH4¨eXTmavFK5�wITVDEREh:NPT¨NP@EF«>KT6=?N�T6U�W[OZLeXFKOQFKRSN7WXREª=7D>A@¯4z>KTVRSN75P46> Nd;

��DE5:57FG=7DEe^NP=®46e[=7TÝ=7DEª6ªVFK=1N¯4ÝR�DEO­wIFK5:T6U­hWX57FG>GN7WXTVRE=nU¥T65nU¥DNPDE5?F¤5?FK=?Fd465?>A@¿; �_RE>GTVOQFFG¬%FK> NP=�OZ4m8n4Y¬%FK>GN�F ¬lTV51N�FKeX46=?N7WX>KW^NPW[FK="4Y="NP@EF 8`hET¨T6NP@FK5)eº4Yw%TVD51r_=?DELELEe^8¶hFK>KW[=7W[TVRE=K;��_RhEFKFGh¿fNPTQNP@EF«F ©�N7FKRSN�NP@E4YNiW[RE>KT6OZF�FG¬%FK> NP=i4657F«WXOQL%T65?NA4YR�NKfMTVDE5�57FG=7DEe^NP=�TVRjN7@EFyW[R�N757T�hEDE> NPWXT6RjT6U�4wM46=?FZaC46ªVFQO¶4d8�wIF¶Tm]VFG57=?NP4YNPFGh¿;:�_R�ªVFGREFK5746egf�W[N«WX=«hEW �Z>GDEe[N�N7T2WXhFKRSNPW^U½8²46RµW[RE>KT6OZFQ46REhµ4=7DwE=?N7W[NPDJNPWXT6R F ¬lFG>GN�U¥57T6O >A@M46RªVFK=�WXR¸N7@EFzLEWXFG>KF¨5P4¾NPF¨46e[TVREF6;­��©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNA46e(OZF NP@ET�hE=�465?F46R:TVwS]�WXTVD=)57FKOQFKhJ8Vf<46e[eXTma�WXREªy57FK=?Fd465?>A@EFK5?=�N7Tz]64Y5?8nwIT6N7@:N7@EF�LEWXFG>KF 574YNPF�46Rh24­wM4Y=7F a"4YªVFWXRhEFKLIFKREhFKRSNPe^8V;"'�W[>A·6FGRE=­» smÄVÄVÄV¼C@M46=�LE57Tm]�WXhEFGh24YRjF°©E4YOZLEe[F a�W[NP@WXR®4QeX46wITV5P4YN7TV5?8Z=7F N7N7WXREª �§MFGeXh³F°©JL%FG57WXOQFKRSN7=¶aCT6DEeXh LE57Tm]�WXhEF®NP@EFjTVLELITV5?N7DEREW^N_8 NPTµ>GTVR§M5?O @WX=Q57FK=?DEe[N7=Za�W^NP@EW[R NP@Feº4Yw%TVD5"O¶4Y57·6F Nd;

�¤F`46e[=7T¯W[ªVRETV5?F¶h8�RM46OQWX>ZFKe[FKOQFKRSNP=­W[R¤N7@EFn>KT6R�N75P46> NPW[REª¸FKRS]�WX5?TVREOQFKRSNd; �F NyavTV57·YFK5FG¬%TV51N:hEFK>GWX=7W[TVRE=:OZ4m8³hEFKLIFKRh�TVR�U�4YN7WXªVDEF2eXFG]6FKe[=µ»¥TV5`FG¬%TV51N:>KTV=1NP=A¼¶N7@M4YNj4657F¯N7@EF²57FG=7DEe^NT6U�LE57F ]�WXTVDE=�FG¬%TV51N�eXFG]6FKe[=K;v\�REhEFG5)NP@EFG=7F«>KWX5?>KDEOQ=?NP46RE>GFK=KfMavTV57·YFK5 r_FG¬%TV51NihEFG>KW[=7WXT6RE=)a�WXeXeINA46·YF46>G>KTVDERSN�T6U<N7@EFKW[5(FG¬%FK> N�TVRzU¥DNPD57F"W[RE>KTVOQFCe[FG]6FKeX=GfSªVW[]�W[REª�57W[=7FCN7T 4�h8�RM46OQWX>COZT�hEFKe�T6UIFG¬%TV51N>A@ETVW[>KFY;�'i8JRE46OZW[>K="OZ4d8Z46eX=?Tzw%F�W[OZLITV51NA46RSNvWXR¶N7@EF >A@ETVW[>KF�T6U.N7@EF >KTVRSN75P46> Nd;��_R:LM4651NPWX>GDEeº4Y5KfNP@FC§M57O,OZ4m8«@M4d]6F)WXRE>GFKRSNPW^]VFCN7T�>A@M46REª6F"NP@EF">GTVRSNP5746>GN�4Y=(WXRJU¥TV57OZ4YNPW[TVRH46w%T6DN�>GTVREhEW^NPWXT6RE=�T65avTV57·YFK5�N_8�LIFHW[=�57FG]6Fd46e[FKh¿;v��@EWXe[F�N7@EF«>KTVRE=?F���DEFGRE>KFG= T6U�4¨eº46>A·¶T6U�>GTVOZOQW[N7OZFGRSN)@M4d]VFHw%FGFKRWXhFKRSNPW^§MFKh¤w�8²N7@EFKTV5?WX=1NP=Kf�FKOQLEWX5?WX>K46e(avTV57·²@M46=�8VF NyN7T2OQFd46=?DE57F¨NP@EFGWX5«WXOQL%T65?NA4YRE>KFY;¶�)@EFG=7F

Âs

Page 33: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

F ©�N7FKRE=?WXTVRE=�57FGO¶4YWXR`WXOQLITV5?NP46RSN�4657FK46=�T6U�U¥DNPDE5?F�57FK=?Fd465?>A@¿;

ÂSp

Page 34: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� � � .¡�� �

ÂVÂ

Page 35: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� � � .¡�� � �?£�� � ��� � �� � �

Â6q

Page 36: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� � � .¡�� � �?£�� � ��� � �� � �

ÂSo

Page 37: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� � � .¡�� � �?£�� � ��� � �� � �

 �

Page 38: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� � � .¡�� � �?£�� � ��� � �� � �

ÂS{

Page 39: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

� � � ��¡�� � £ ���

B"4Y·6FK5Gf¿xz;ÅsmÄVÄVpJ; �1�_RE>KFGR�N7W[]6Fz!CTVRSNP5746>GN7=i4YREh¯�FK5?U¥T657OZ46RE>KFy*jFK46=7DE5?FKOQFKRSNd; �� � � ��� � �� � � � � � ��� � � � � ��� � � � �Yf¿sdtVtM»ÍÂV¼ $�o6Ä���� �sdq;

B"4YREhEWXFG5P4��­;[fb�A;mBC465P46R·Y4d86f646Rh«�A;d��46=?DEe<»Íp6tVt6q�¼°; �?#iwE=?TVeXDJNPF�46REh«��FKeX4YNPW^]VF��_RE>GFKRSNPW^]VFK=G$��]�WXhEFGRE>KF«TVR`�¤TV57·YFK5��5?TJhDE>GN7W[]�W[N_86; µ!"���� '�W[=7>GDE=7=?WXTVR®(4YL%FG5���TE;�qVqSÂs6;

BC5?Tma�R¿f­!i;«smÄVÄ6t; �?�(WX5?OZ= ��!C@ETVWX>GFµT6U¨*jFGN7@ETJh TYU¨(4d8V; � � � � � ����� � � � � � � � � � �� � � � ��� � � ��� ������ ��fEqSÂM»�ÂS¼ $)s �VoY=��Is �SpY=K;

BCD5?NPe[FK=?=Kf�x¨;�smÄ6ÄSoJ; �?�)@EF¸!"4Y=7F2U¥TV5Z��46REhETVOQW �GFKh³�(WXFGeXh¹��5?Wº46e[=ZW[R���>KTVRTVOZW[>24YREh�TVeXW[>G8`��FK=?Fd465?>A@¿; �� � � ��� � � � � � ��� � � � � ��� ��� � � ��� ���4� �����lÄM»ÍpV¼ $ �6Â�� �6qE;

!C@EWX46LELITV57WÍf¿�; rÓ#y;Å46Rh¤B�;.�46eX46REW cF­p6tVtVÂJ; �?��FK=1NPW[REªj!CTVRSNP5P4Y>GN��)@EFGTV5?8I$ # �JDE51]VF 8¸T6U�JT6OZFi��FG>KFKRSN)�¤TV57·<; ²�_R�� ��� � � ����� � � � ��� � � � � ��� � � � � ��� � � � � ����� ���� � � ��� ��� � �� � � � � � � ��� � � ��� � � � �� � � � � � � � �� ������� f�FGh¿;�wS8`* ;'�F a"4YN757W[L%TVRSNKfJ-�;J�i46R=7FKRlf46Rh2�;E��D57RETm]�=7·S8V;C��F a��TV57·<$�!"46OywE57W[hEªVF�\�RW[]VFG57=?W[N_8®�57FG=7=K;

!CTVLIFKeX46REh¿fI#y;%46REh¸!i;Å*jTVRFGN�pYtVtsV; �?�)@EF«�µFGe[U�465?Fy��¬%FK>GN7= T6U��_RE>GFKRSNPW^]VFQ�J>A@FKOQFK=K; ��8�L%FG=7>K5?WXLNKfI'�FKLM4651NPOQFKRSN�T6U(��>KTVRET6OZW[>K=Kf<\�REW[]6FK5?=7W[N_8nT6U�*®WXREREFG=7T6NP4;

'�W[>A·�W[RE=7T6R¿fE'­;%smÄVÄVÄ;9�?#iR:�(©JL%FG57W[OZFGR�NP46eÅ�(©46OQWXRM4YN7WXTVRZT6U�-.46wITV5��JDELLEe[8¶46REh`�¤TV57·�_RSNPFGRE=7W^NPW[FK=K; �� � � ��� � � � ��� � � � � � ��� � � � � ��� f%sb{E»�qS¼ $ �VÂ���� � �VÄ;

��@E5?FKR�w%FG57ªEfi�«;�smÄVÄVtJ; � � � � � � ��� � � ��� � � � � � � ������� � � � � ���� � � � � � ����� � �� � � � � �� � � � ��� � � ��� ������ ��fEqSÂM»�ÂS¼ ;

�MFK5?5P46e[egf�!i;C46REh�Bi;���@EFd465?FK5G; sdÄVÄVÄ; �?�_RE>GFKRSNPW^]VFG=j4YREh���5746RE=746>GN7WXTVRÀ!CTV=1NP=na�W^NP@EW[RN7@EFn�(W[57O®$z��=?N7WXOZ4YNPW[REª24YRµ#iª6FKRE> 8Ý*jT�hEFKev\�=?WXREª¯(4d8�57TVe[eC��FK>GTV57hE=G; � ������ � � �� ��� � � � � � � � � � ����� f � �M»gp6¼ fMÂVt6Ä��JÂ����J;

x WXwEwITVRE=GfV��;JsdÄ��S{J;(�7�WXFG>KF r_��4¾NPF��_RE>KFGR�N7W[]6F��J>A@EFKOQFK=Gf �� � � ��� � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � ��� foE»¥q�¼ fqEsmÂ��pYÄ;

x WXe[eXFK=?LEWXFYf ��;«sdÄVÄsV; � � � � � � � � � ��� �� �� � � � � � �� ����� � ��� � � ��� � � � � ��� � � �� � ��� �� � � ����� � ��� � � ;���FGa �TV57·<$v!"46O­wE5?WXhEª6F \�REW^]VFG57=7W^N_8®�57FK=?=K;

��46eXF 8Vf * ;�p6tVtVÂ; �?�)@EF ��FG=7LITVRE=?F¤T6U«�¤TV57·YFK5®��¬lTV51N`NPT¹�WXFG>KF ��4¾NPFK=G$¹��]�W[hEFKRE>GFU¥5?TVO N7@EF«*jW[haCFG=?N7FK57Rj-ÅTVªVªVW[REª­�_REhDE=?N75?8V; �� � � ��� � � � ��� � ��� ��� ���� � � ����� fMÂ��M»¥q�¼ $���Js�� �VÄVtJ;

��465?NKfC�­;�4YREh¹Bi;���T6eXOQ=?NP5 �TVO®f"smÄ��S{�; �?�)@F`�)@EFKTV518 T6U�!CTVRSNP5746>GN7=K; �_R�� ��� � � ������ � � ��� � � � � � � � ��� ��� ��� � �� � � � � � � � �� ������� fvFKh¿;�wS8¹� ;vBCFGa�e[FG8V;À��FGa �TV5?·I$!"46OywE57W[hEªVF�\�RW[]VFG57=?W[N_8:�57FG=7=G;

��

Page 40: IZA Institute of Labor Economicsconference.iza.org/conference_files/boe2005/shearer_b2056.pdf · () *+#, ( -.'/ 0 1*2 3 4657518:9;< (464657=?>a@ bc57de>gfh%;ij@efk4657fg5

��FK>A·�O¶4YR¿f%9;ÅsmÄS{YqE;9�P�J@M46hTba��57WX>GFK=Gfl*j4657·YFGN���4YªVFK=Gf%4YREh®-�4Yw%TV5���DELELEe^8V; � ��� � � �� � ����� � � �¿q�p�$ �S{6Ä�� �6ÄVÂ;

��FK>A·�O¶4YR¿f.9;%46REh²9;l�JOQW[NP@lf�sdÄVÄSoJ; �?#�=7=7FG=7=?WXREªnN7@EFz!"46=?FyU¥TV5��JTJ>GWº46e.�(©JLIFK57W[OZFGRSNP=K; � � � ��� � � � � � ��� � � � � � � ��� � � ��� ���4� �����lÄM»gpV¼°$ �So��Is6smt;

��TVeXOQ=?N75 �TVO®f�Bi;�46REh �;v*jWXe[ªV57T6Oj;�smÄ6ÄVt; �P*jDEe^NPW[NP46=7·µ�57WXR>KWXLE46e^rÓ#iªVFGR�N¨#�RM46e^8J=?FK=G$�_RE>GFKRSNPW^]VF�!CTVRSNP5P4Y>GNP=Gf #i=?=7FGN¯�ia�REFK5?=7@EW[L¿f�46REh�96TVw '�FK=?WXªVR¿; � � � ��� � � � ��� � � �� ��� � � � � ����� � � �� � � �� � ��� � �MfM{E»¥=7L<¼°$vpYq �oVp�;

96TVRFK=Kfl�%;.smÄVÄVpJ;��1�µ46=��)@EFK5?F­4Q�i4da)NP@TV57REFy��¬lFG>GN �� � ����� � � � � � � ��� � � � � � ���� � � �� ��¾fMÄ��M»�ÂS¼ $�qSoJs���q ���;

-.4��GFd465GfM�);¿smÄVÄ��J; � ��� �� � � � � � ��� � � � � ��� � � � � � � � ������ ;���FGa �TV57·<$�96TV@R:��W[eXF 8 �

�JT6RE=K;-.4��GFd465Gfi�);)pYtVtVt; �?�FK51U¥TV57OZ46RE>GF¸(4d8�46REh��57T�hEDE> NPW[]�W^N_8V; � � ����� � � � � ��� � � � � �� ������ ��fMÄVtE»goV¼°f¿smÂ6q ���Ism �s6;

*jW[eXªV5?TVO®f<�;%46REh 9;%��TVwIFK51NP=G;ysmÄVÄVpJ; � ��� � � � � �����(� �� � � �� � ��� � � � � � � � � � �� � ��� �Í;��REªVe[FGavTJT�hj!CeXW^¬l=GfM��F a 96FK5?=7F 8%$v�57FGR�N7WX>GFy��46eXeÍ;

�4V4657=?>A@¿f"�«;�46REh¹Bi;��J@EFK4657FG5K;�smÄ6ÄVÄ;*�?�)@EF®��FG=7LITVRE=?F®TYU��¤TV5?·6FK5¨��¬%TV5?NzN7T²�WXFK>GF��4YNPFG=K$C��]�W[hEFKRE>GF«U¥5?TVOÆNP@FyBC5?W[N7WX=7@j!CTVe[DEO­wEWX4­��5?FKF°r �eº46RSN7WXREªQ�_REhEDE=1NP518Vf � � � ��� � �� � � ����� � � ���� � � ����� f<Â6q<»¥q�¼ f �6qSÂ�� � �S{J;

�4V4657=?>A@¿f��H;�46REh B�;��J@EFK4657FG5K;²pYtVtVt; �7�WXFG>KFn��4YN7FK=Kf���W^©JFKh ��46ª6FK=Kf�4YREh��_RE>GFKRSNPW^]VF��¬%FK>GN7=K$«��NP4YNPW[=?N7WX>d4Ye(��]�WXhEFGRE>KF­U¥5?TVO �4d8J5?TVeXe(��FG>KTV5?hE=K; � � � ����� � ��� � � � � � ��� � � � � �� ������ ��fEqEsS»1sb¼°f<o6Ä��JÄVpJ;

�4V4657=?>A@¿f �«;"46REh�B�;��J@EFK4657FG5K;�p6tVt6qE; �P*j46eXF°r �MFKOZ46eXFj�57T�hEDE> NPW[]�W^N_8�'�W^¬lFG57FKRSN7Wº46e[=K$�)@EF ��TVeXFjT6U«#iwEW[eXW^N_8³4YREh��_RE>KFGR�N7W[]6FK=K; !"46@EWXFG5`hEF¸57FG>A@EFK5?>A@EFµ!C� �� c���Æt6qYrPsmtf'jcFGLM465?N7FKOQFKRSN�h � c��>GTVRETVOQW���DEFYfM\�RW[]VFG57=?W[NJcF«-.4d]Y46egf<!"4YRM46hM4;

�J@Fd465?FK5KfIBi;.smÄ6Ä �; �7�WXFG>KFH��4YN7FK=Gf<�5?WXRE>GWXLM4Ye^r_#�ªVFKRSN�*jT�hEFGeX=Kf<4YREh2�5?TJhED>GNPW^]�W[N_8:�57T¾r§Me[FK=G; � � � ��� � � � � � � ��� ��� ���� � � ����� f<Âs�»gp6¼ $�pV{6o��JÂVtVÂJ;

�J@Fd465?FK5Kf�Bi;^f�pYtVt6qE; �7�W[FK>KFZ��4YNPFG=Kf��(W^©JFGh �µ46ªVFG=H4YREh¤�_R>KFKRSN7W[]VFY$­��]�WXhEFGRE>KFQU¥57TVO 4�(W[FKe[h:��©JLIFK5?WXOQFKRSNd; � ������ � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � ����� f<{Js�»ÍpV¼ $�oJsdÂ��o6Â6q;

�¤TVeXLWXR¿f��z;"smÄ6ÄSoJ;� � � � ��� � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � ����� � � � ��� � �������FGa �T657·<$��i4651aCT�TJh:#�>d46hEFGOZW[>��DEwEeXW[=7@EFG57=G;

ÂVÄ