jstenzel-sptg presentation-with korean.pdf
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
1/39
1 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
Presentation of the Sakya Paแนแธita Translation Groupof the International Buddhist Academy, Kathmandu, Nepal
and their Translation of the Mahฤyฤna ฤkฤลagarbha Sลซtra
This paper was presented at the International Conference โTranslation of Buddhist Scriptur esfrom around the World,โ organized by the Research Center for the Tibetan Buddhist Canon,Dongguk University, Gyeongju, South Korea, November 28-29, 2014. I wish to express my
gratitude to Dr. Khenpo Ngawang Jorden, director of the International Buddhist Academy,
Kathmandu, for his thoughtful guidance of our translation work, as well as to my translation
colleagues, Ven. Ngawang Tenzin, Ven. Jampa Tenzin, and especially Christian Bernert whose
comments to this paper were of great help. I would like to thank Mr. Dai Sung Han fortranslating the paper into Korean.
Introduction
In February 2014, coinciding with the Tibetan New Year, the โ84000-Translating the Words ofthe Buddhaโ published online the Mahฤyฤna ฤkฤลagarbha Sลซtra (โphags pa nam mkhaโi snying
po zhes bya ba theg pa chen poโi mdo) as part of their ongoing translation project of translatingthe entire Tibetan Canon within one hundred years. The Sakya Pandita Translation Group whoaccomplished this translation has worked with the 84000 from the initial stages of its online
publications, providing the first pilot translations for the website. The purpose of my presentation
is to provide some background information on the translation work of the Sakya Pa แนแธitaTranslation Group within the larger context of the 84000, drawing on our most recent experience
with the ฤkฤลagarbha Sลซtra. In the first part of my presentation, I wish to give the necessary background information to our translation work, and to discuss the main features of the editorial
policy of the 84000 which served as our guideline. The second part will focus on specific details
of our translation process. I will discuss some of the challenges that we faced in translating the
ฤkฤลagarbha Sลซtra, and explain the various solutions we found.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
2/39
2 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
I. โ84000 โ Translating the Words of the Buddhaโ
History
A translation conference at Deer Park Institute in Bir, India, in 2009, was the first step of an
initiative that culminated in the founding of the โ84000 โ Translating the Words of the Buddha.โAt this conference, more than fifty senior translators of Tibetan scriptures, headed by the Tibetan
teacher Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche, discussed the importance of translating the Tibetan
Buddhist Canons. They recognized the importance of international cooperation. Translating
Tibetan scriptures had been largely left up to individual translators and translation groups, who
often had to struggle to find the financial and material support for their work. The conference in
Bir resulted first of all in founding the โBuddhist Literary Heritage Projectโ which was later, in2011, renamed โ84000 โ Translating the Words of the Buddha.โ The project was thus initiated by Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche and funded by the Khyentse Foundation.
1The foundation is a
registered global non-profit initiative that โaims to translate all of the Buddhaโs words into
modern languages, and to make them available to everyone, free of charge.โ The participants of the Bir conference also resolved to invite the participation of the masters and
holders of all lineages. Today, the list of 153 translators and 23 translator teams that have
participated so far in the 84000 project2 demonstrate that all major schools of Tibetan Buddhism
(Nyingma, Kagyรผ, Sakya, Gelug) are represented, thus making it a non-sectarian, unified
enterprise.
In their published vision statement, the 84000 explains its motives:3
It is said that the Buddha taught more than 84,000 methods to attain true peace and
freedom from suffering. Of these teachings, only 5% have been translated into modernlanguages. Due to the rapid decline in knowledge of classical languages and in the
number of qualified scholars, we are in danger of losing this cultural heritage andspiritual legacy.
Therefore, the 84000โs declared goal is to translate the entire treasury of Tibetan Buddhistliterature within one hundred years. The interim goals of five, ten, and twenty-five years
determine the order in which this goal is to be accomplished. For now, the 84000 focuses on
translating the more important texts of the Kangyur (bkaโ โgyur ), and, to a lesser degree, of theTengyur (bstan โ gyur ).
1http://84000.co/about/origin/2โTranslators,โ accessed Oct 30, 2014. http://84000.co/about/translators/.3โVision,โ accessed Oct 30, 2014. http://84000.co/about/vision/.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
3/39
3 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
The long and short-term goals are specified in the following chart:
100 years To provide universal access to the Buddhist literary heritage
translated into modern languages.
25 years To make all of the Kangyur and related volumes of the
Tengyur available in English, and provide widespread
accessibility in multiple platforms.
10 years To make a significant portion of the Kangyur and
complementary Tengyur texts available in English, and easily
accessible in multiple platforms.
5 years To make a representative sample of the Kangyur and
Tengyur available in English, and establish the infrastructure
and resources necessary to accomplish the long-term vision.
To realize its vision of translating the entire Tibetan Buddhist literary heritage, the 84000 works
simultaneously in five domains. These are:
1. Translation grants: The 84000 organizes the translations of important texts - mostly
sลซtras so far - in the form of grant applications.2. Publication: The editorial board of the 84000 accompanies and supervises the editing
process of the translated texts until their online publication on the website of the 84000.
3. Fundraising: The 84000 undertakes the necessary efforts to raise the funds for the
ongoing and future translation projects.4. Translation Tools: The 84000 has started to provide information that is relevant to
pursuing its long-term goal by providing links to existing translation programs, to
translation tools, and other relevant information.
5. Dharma Events: The 84000 organizes dharma events in which the translated sลซtras areused for dharma practice, such as the โResounding of the Buddhaโs Wordโ in Bodhgaya (2012, 2014) or New York (2012, 2013). Apart from the meritorious aspect of such
practices, these events certainly serve the purpose of publicizing the importance of
sponsoring the translation projects.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
4/39
4 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
Some Facts: Works Published and in Progress
Translations in Progress and Published Online4
Pages Commissioned for Translation
Pages Published
4http://84000.co/about/progress/. Accessed Oct 10, 2014.
http://84000.co/about/progress/http://84000.co/about/progress/http://84000.co/about/progress/
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
5/39
5 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
Translators Supported
Translators
Translatorsโ Affiliations
Impact of the 84000โsWork The table below provides an overview of how often the translations provided by the 84000 have
been viewed.5
Reading Room Hits:
4.4 million hits
Text Downloads: 110,898 times
5โImpact,โ accessed Oct 30, 2014. http://84000.co/about/impact/ Information updated on: January 1, 2014.
http://84000.co/about/progress/?share=facebook&nb=1
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
6/39
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
7/39
7 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
khang ) of the China Tibetology Research Center (krung goโi bod rig pa zhi โjug ste gnas).6 Translators use the Pedurma Kangyur to trace variations of the different editions. Only changes
that affect the meaning significantly should be marked in footnotes.
Research
In addition to translating sลซtras, translators are required to do a certain amount of research and tocompose brief introductions, notes, bibliographies, glossaries and other reference material. These
are published along with the translations. All publications are online, free of charge.
Standards and Standardization
In their editorial policy, the 84000 has formulated the guiding principles for the translation work.
Generally speaking, the translations should possess the following qualities: โAccuracy ofmeaning, clarity, consensuality, consistency and flexibility.โ7 What these principles entail, theeditorial committee of the 84000 explains in the Guidelines for Translators. In the second part of
my presentation, I will elaborate on some of these details. Generally speaking, one can say that
all rules aim at producing a text of easy readability. As translators, we should think to โ be kind toour readers.โ8
Setting standards naturally leads to the question of standardization, i.e. to the idea that all
translators use the same vocabulary for recurrent technical terms. The editorial board of the
84000 has expressed the wish to develop such translation standardization, similar to the
Mahฤvyutpatti project in Tibet. Standardization, however, is not possible at the moment, and it isnot clear to which degree it will be in the future. The guidelines of the 84000 give rules as to the
spelling, capitalization, use of italics and punctuation, but leave the vocabulary to the discretion
of the translators. They demand however, that each translation team develops a glossary
alongside their translation. This is done in an excel sheet in which the Tibetan, Sanskrit, andEnglish terms are listed, as well as a short English definition. In the final publication, the English
word is hyperlinked so that the reader can easily access the glossary entries.
The challenge of, and resistance to, standardization are problems that are better understood when
we compare the historical contexts of the translation endeavours now with the translations of
Sanskrit Buddhist literature into Tibetan. Therefore I would like to deviate for a short moment
into the history of the translation of the Tibetan Buddhist Canon. In the second part of my
presentation, I will then return to a few concrete examples of the editorial guidelines of the
84000.
6 Dpe sdur ma, Krung go'i bod rig pa'i dpe skrun khang /, pe cin/. 2006-2009. par gzhi dang po, 109 volumes,
accessed Oct 10, 2014. http://www.tbrc.org/#!rid=W1PD96682. 7โ84000 Editor ial Policy v8.0,โ IV A, 7, accessed Oct 30, 2014, http://84000.co/resources/grants/.8This expression is borrowed from Dr David Bellos, Translation and Transmission Conference, Oct 2014.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
8/39
8 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
Translations of the Buddhist Canons into Tibetan
The Tibetan Buddhist Canon is a translation of mainly the Sanskrit Canon, of which many texts
have been destroyed or lost over the centuries. Other translations were done from texts in
Chinese, Khotanese, Socdian, or other languages of that time, when these were believed to have
had a Sanskrit original that got lost.
Whereas the Pฤli Canon could be preserved, or rather reconstructed, in its entirety thanks to theefforts of generation after generation copying individual manuscripts in neighbouring countries,
such as Sri Lanka, Burma, and Thailand -this is, unfortunately, not the case for the Sanskrit
teachings. Many Sanskrit texts have only survived in Tibetan or Chinese translation.
As for the translations to Tibetan, there were two clearly distinguishable phases of Sanskrit-
Tibetan translation, corresponding to the periods of uptake in Buddhism known to Tibetan
historians as the โearly propagationโ ( snga dar ) and โlater propagationโ ( phyi dar ).The first, aโtop-downโ movement, lasted from the 7th to the mid-9th century and was an initiative based on
royal initiative and support. In the 7thcentury CE, the newly united kingdom of Tibet was stillrelatively young when its ruler, Songtsen Gampo (srong btsan sgam po, 569 โ 649?/605 โ 649?),decided to sponsor Buddhism and with it the translation of important texts from India. Two and a
half centuries of prosperity were followed by a time of political collapse and religious crisis. The
second, โnew translation periodโ ( gsar โgyur ) - also called the โlater dissemination of theteachingsโ ( phyi dar ) - between the 11th and 14th centuries was a fragmented movement thatsprung from the grassroots, fuelled by teachers and adepts. It was a period of great individual
achievements, though less consistent in following uniform standards. Such individuals were, for
example, Bari Lotsawa,9 Drogmi Lotsawa,
10and Rinchen Zangpo
11 - three translators that are
revered in the Sakya School, with which the Sakya Paแนแธita Translation Group is affiliated.
After the 14th
century, Buddhism had mostly disappeared from the Indian subcontinent, and no
further Sanskrit texts were translated into Tibetan. In total, 5250 texts 230,000 folio sides were
translated from Sanskrit to Tibetan. Over 870 translators and scholars were involved and their
translations have been praised by modern historians as a masterpiece of teamwork, terminology
and consistency.12
Characteristic Features of the Translation into Tibetan
Translating from Sanskrit into Tibetan had a unique feature because the Tibetans created a
Tibetan linguistic system that was modelled upon Sanskrit, even though the two languages share
no direct linguistic relation, Tibetan belonging to the Tibeto-Burmese language group. However,Sanskrit was chosen as a benchmark in order to be able to translate Buddhist scriptures into
9 Ba ri lo tsA, also called Rinchen Drak (rin chen grags) (1040-1111).10 Brog mi shakya ye shes (994-1078).11 Rin chen bzang po (958-1055).12 http://www.thlib.org/encyclopedias/literary/canons/about/wiki/tibetan%20canons%20introduction.html. See also
Roberta Paine, โThe Translator in Tibetan History: Identity and Influence.โ Forum 8.2 (2010): 133-161.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
9/39
9 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
Tibetan.13
Not only did grammarians attempt to conceptualize Tibetan through the lens of
Sanskrit noun cases, syntax, and verbal conjugation (albeit simplified), moreover, by royal
commission the vocabulary and style of translations were highly regularized. Standardization
became maybe the most important feature of translation; and the fabricated similarity of Tibetan
to Sanskrit facilitated translation, and made it possible to produce texts of high precision.14
Lotsawa-Paแนแธita
As we know from colophons, the translations were mostly carried out by a collaboration of
Indian scholars and Tibetan translators, a model that received the name lotsawa-paแนแธ ita. TheSanskrit title paแนแธ ita designated mastery of the five sciences: grammar, logic, medicine, artisticcrafts, and philosophy. The title lotsawa was an honorific term for the native Tibetans involved
in the translations of Sanskrit texts into Tibetan. Some of them had travelled to India or a
Himalayan borderland, had accompanied Indian paแนแธ itas back to Tibet, had invested health andwealth, effort and sacrifice, to make translations happen. Since the collaborative effort of people
with two different skill sets has proven highly successful, many translators today, including my
own translation group, try to emulate the lotsawa-paแนแธ ita model when translating Tibetanscriptures into English.
Translation Tools - The Mahฤvyutpatti and Madhyavyutpatti
The Tibetan translations of Sanskrit sลซtras show a high degree of conformity in vocabulary. Thisis the result of an invested effort of standardizing terminology. It is documented in the
Mahฤvyutpatti, the Madhyavyutpatti, and similar texts. The Mahฤvyutpatti (bye brag tu rtogs pachen po) or โThe Great Volume of Precise Understanding or Essential Etymologyโ is a Sanskrit-Tibetan lexicographical reference work with nearly 10,000 entries, which is still used by scholars
today. The related Madhyavyutpatti ( sgra sbyor bam po gynis pa) provides a detailed account of
translation technique. These two volumes were created c. 814 at the order of King Tride
Songtsen (khri lde srong btsan, r. 799-815), i.e. during the first translation period in Tibet, with
the intention to standardize the translation of Buddhist texts into Tibetan. These texts settled
issues of orthography, grammar, and translation rules, and thus played a central role in achieving
a largely consistent standardized language for translating Buddhist scripture. Students of Tibetan
language still refer to this compendium today.15
In an address to the recent Tsadra Foundation
conference on โTranslation and Transmissionโ in October 2014, the scholar Peter Skillings
13 It is believed that the Tibetan script and texts on grammar date to the 7 th century. Under the rule of king Songtsen
Gampo ( srong btsan sgam po) the scholar and grammarian Tonmi Sambhota ( thon mi sam bho ta) is credited by the
tradition to have created a script and composed the Root Verses on Grammar, the so-called sum cu pa, and the
Guide to the Signs (rtags kyi โjug pa)14 For a detailed account, see Stephan Beyer, The Classical Tibetan Language, (New York: State University of New
York, 1992/ Delhi: Sri Satguru Publications, 1993).15 David Weldon, โGuardians of the Sacred Word,โ accessed Oct 10, 2014.http://www.asianart.com/exhibitions/covers/intro. html.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
10/39
10 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
advised translators to study the Mahฤvyutpatti attentively. He even suggests that these texts betaught in university seminars.
16
Apart from the royal supervision of the early translations in Tibet, another factor facilitated the
creation of a standardized language: Tibet, unlike China, did not have a well-developed
philosophical tradition prior to the arrival of Buddhism. Therefore, translators coined technicalterms that were assigned to Sanskrit expressions with little danger of being misunderstood in the
light of some other context. Thus the Tibetan translations, though literal and somewhat dense
and unnatural are considered relatively reliable in representing the Sanskrit originals. They have
proven to be an invaluable source for the reconstruction of lost Sanskrit texts.17
Language reforms
During the two translation phases, three major language reforms ( skad gsar bcad ) took place.
During these reforms numerous words were labeled โold signsโ (brda rnying ) and were replacedwith new terms. These revisions were instrumental in establishing standardized spelling,
vocabulary, and grammar. The last reform dates to the 10th
century CE. The literary language has been more or less frozen since this time.
18 During each of these revisions, older, existing
translations were updated to reflect the new standards.
Translation from Tibetan to English
Jumping forward in time now for about half a millennium, the situation for translators looks very
different. The first thing to note is that the translation of Tibetan Buddhist Texts into English (or
other European languages) does not have a very long history. At the Tsadra conference in
Keystone, Colorado, Tsadra founder Eric Colombel, shared his experience as a young student in
Paris, France, where the only books in French available numbered two, and were very difficult to
understand. However, the interest in Indo-Tibetan Buddhism in the Western world progressedvery quickly from being the reserve of a few Indologists and Tibetologists in the 19
thcentury to
an accepted mainstream phenomenon 150 years later. Older translations of texts often exhibited
some influence from the particular groups that were cultivating contact with Buddhist cultures,
be it colonialists, Christian missionaries, or followers of Jungian psychology.19
At present, with the social and political situation in Tibet and in Tibetan exile communities,
leading Tibetan masters have recognised the very real risk that in one or two generationsโ timethere will simply be too few people with sufficient understanding of the language or contents.
16 Peter Skillings, โDr. Peter Skillingโs address to the conference,โ http://translationandtransmission.org/videos.html.17 Roberta Raine, โTranslating the Tibetan Buddhist Canon: Past Strategies, Future Prospects,โ Forum 9.2 (2011):157-186.18Jamgon Kongtrul ('jam mgon kong sprul blo gros mtha' yas), Treasury of Knowledge, Buddhism's Journey to
Tibet , (Ithaca, NY: Snow Lion Publication, 2010), 220.19 Roberta Paine mentions H. Kernโs translation as an example for Christian influence in translation (in โTheTranslator in Tibetan History: Identity and Influence.โ Forum 8.2 (2010): 133-161). Jungian influence can be foundfor example in Evans-Wentz, W. Y., Tibetan Book of the Dead: or, The After-Death Experiences on the Bardo
Plane, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1927. It contains a "Psychological commentary" by Carl Jung.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W._Y._Evans-Wentzhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Junghttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Junghttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W._Y._Evans-Wentz
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
11/39
11 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
The growing awareness of this risk has not only led to the founding of the 84000, but to a few
similar events that are concerned with the preservation of the Tibetan Buddhist literary legacy:
2008 Light of Berotsana, Colorado, USA: http://www.berotsana.org/conference-of-translators/
2009 BLHP/ 84000, Bir, India: http://84000.co/about/origin/ , previously mentioned
2011 Tengyur Translation, Sarnath, India: http://www.aibs.columbia.edu/conference.html
2014 June: Translation Conference and Workshop at University of Vienna, Austria:http://buddhism.tibetan-translation.com/2014/05/translating-and-transferring-buddhist.html
2014 October: Translation and Transmission Conference in Keystone, Colorado, USA:http://translationandtransmission.org/index.html
Translator Types
Who are the people, who participates in these events? Apart from a few Tibetan teachers
committed to translating, they are men and women mainly from Europe and America, who have
a particular connection to Tibetan Buddhism, culture and language. During the latest conference,
which I attended along with 200 other participants, senior translator Wulstan Fletcher and others
discussed the distinction between two types of translators:
1. Dharma practitioners who become translators and interpreters โ they are often self-professedor designated by a Tibetan teacher. Often not subject to professional oversight, their focus is
on the religious significance of a text, the accessibility for the target audience of
practitioners, and/or the use of a text as practice liturgy. As practitioners they are sometimes
bound by religious rules of samaya (dam tshig ) and secrecy.
2. Academics whose fields of expertise often include philology, buddhology, philosophy,
anthropology, religious studies, etc. - they are not necessarily trained as interpreters orlanguage experts. The oversight of their translation work comes from within academia in the
form of peer-review. Their focus in translating is on accuracy, comparison of editions,historical and philosophical contextualization and significance. Academics are not bound by
the traditionโs norms of secrecy, but follow the code of critical investigation and unrestrainedcuriosity.
Both types of translators often work as individuals, seeking occasional help from advisors or
colleagues. A peculiar fact is that many translators that work with text translations cannot
necessarily speak colloquial Tibetan. Both groups generally consider the literary language to be a
classical Tibetan which is distinct and separate from spoken Tibetan. However, the more
experienced translators, and particularly those who have been immersed in Tibetan communities
for some time, emphasize the importance of the oral tradition. Spoken Tibetan is not only
important for the collaboration with Tibetan scholars, but also allows a richer understanding of
the subtleties of the language.
Concluding Remarks
These glimpses into the history of the translation of Buddhist scriptures, however brief and over-
simplified they may be, show sufficiently the different contexts in which translation has taken
http://www.berotsana.org/conference-of-translators/http://www.berotsana.org/conference-of-translators/http://84000.co/about/origin/http://www.aibs.columbia.edu/conference.htmlhttp://buddhism.tibetan-translation.com/2014/05/translating-and-transferring-buddhist.htmlhttp://translationandtransmission.org/index.htmlhttp://translationandtransmission.org/index.htmlhttp://buddhism.tibetan-translation.com/2014/05/translating-and-transferring-buddhist.htmlhttp://www.aibs.columbia.edu/conference.htmlhttp://84000.co/about/origin/http://www.berotsana.org/conference-of-translators/http://www.berotsana.org/conference-of-translators/
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
12/39
12 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
place in the past and is taking place today. The most important difference in my view is the fact
that translation started as a state-supported endeavour in Tibet which entailed a strong
centralizing and standardizing power right from the beginning. In comparison, todayโstranslation projects do not enjoy royal or state support, and only a few efforts to centralize a
translation effort. The 84000 is probably the most important of them. The short but successful
story of the 84000 shows the importance of concerted efforts in this field. The recent surge in
Tibetan Buddhist translation conferences worldwide is most likely another outcome of a shift in
thinking about translation, a shift moving away from the individual achiever towards mutual
support and team efforts.
There is another significant difference in the translation context then and now - a difference on
which I do not elaborate in this presentation because of time restrictions - and that is the
immense supply of translation tools available today. Starting with digitized dictionaries, digitized
and searchable texts, online resources such as the TBRC, ACIP or AIBS data bases, cloud
search, etc., translators are able to benefit from the accumulated and recorded knowledge of
Buddhist scholarship like never before in history.
In the second part of my presentations, I would like to present and reflect upon my personal
experience as translator of the 84000 within the context that I have outlined so far.
II.
The Translation of the ฤkฤลagarbha Sลซtra In the summer of 2011, the Sakya Pandita Translation Group signed a contract with the 84000
for the translation of several sลซtras, among them the ฤkฤลagarbha Sลซtra. This sลซtra is a text of 20folios in the Dege Edition,
20 or 44 pages in the Pedurma edition. Its complete name is
ฤ k ฤลagarbha-nฤma-mahฤ yฤna-sลซtra ('Phags pa nam mkha'i snying po zhes bya ba theg pa chen po'i mdo). In the Catalogue of the Tibetan Buddhist Canons [Tokyo: Tลhoku University, 1934],it is Tลh. no. 260. It was translated into Tibetan by the scholars ลฤkyaprabha and Ratnarak แนฃita.
In the following I will present our translation work of this sutra. I will briefly introduce the text
and our translation team, and then focus on the challenges we encountered in the work process,
as well as the solutions we found.
Introducing the SลซtraThis sลซtra is named after the Bodhisattva ฤkฤลagarbha, in Tibetan Namkhe Nyingpo, which
means โessence of spaceโ or โmatrix of space.โ The sutra tells of a situation in which Buddhaลฤkyamuni resides in the Khalatika Mountains, which refers probably to the Barabar mountainsnear Bodhgaya. Buddha ลฤkyamuni and his retinue are joined by the bodhisattva ฤkฤลagarbha,who arrives displaying his magical powers. At first, a bright ray of light, coming from the jewel
on top of his head, transforms the whole of the world into a pure land. Thereupon the bodhisattva
Maitreya requests Buddha ลฤkyamuni to give a teaching on the powers and capacities of
20Degรฉ Kangyur, vol. ZA, folios 264r.4-283v.2.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
13/39
13 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
Bodhisattva ฤkฤลagarbha. The answer of Buddha ลฤkyamuni forms the major part of the sลซtra.The Buddha explained the qualities and the powers of ฤkฤลagarbha. His particular power is hisability to help practitioners purify their wrongdoings, in the sutra called โdownfalls.โ TheBuddha explains each of the twenty-three downfalls, or transgressions, separately, in more or
less detail. They include general unwholesome actions such as killing and stealing, and also the
eight transgressions of bodhisattvas which are deeds like teaching emptiness to disciples that are
not mature enough for comprehending it; or trying to convince somebody that the Mahฤyฤna path is not the right path to practice; or trying to deter somebody who wants to take the monastic
vows of self-liberation. The Buddha also explains various methods of purification of these
negative deeds and transgressions, such as praying to ฤkฤลagarbha, giving special offerings,reciting dharaแนis, and so forth. A special emphasis is on a dream incubation type of practice. The person invites ฤkฤลagarbha to appear in her or his dream and to listen to the confession ofwrongdoings, and it is in the dream that ฤkฤลagarbha purification will take place. The sutra endswith the Buddha giving a teaching on the emptiness of phenomena.
Because of its systematic presentation of the twenty-three transgressions this sลซtra has gainedspecial importance among Mahฤyฤna sลซtras and is mentioned as reference work for Bodhisattvaethics by masters such as ลฤntideva, Sakya Paแนแธita or Jamgon Kongtrul.21 The famous Bodhicaryฤvatฤra (translated as The Way of the Bodhisattva) by ลฤntideva recommends the ฤkฤลagarbha Sลซtra as the first reference text to study for bodhisattva training.
This sutra was translated by four members of the Sakya International Buddhist Academy, which
I will briefly introduce before turning to the work process of our translation group.
Introducing Sakya IBA and its Translation Team
The International Buddhist Academy (short: IBA) is located in Kathmandu, Nepal, and wasestablished in 2001 by the late Khenchen Appey Rinpoche, an eminent Sakyapa scholar and
teacher, whose students include prominent teachers such as His Holiness the Sakya Trizin, and
Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche.22
In 2009, an intensive translator training program began that educated simultaneously Tibetan and
Western scholars to prepare them for collaborative translation programs in the future. The
Tibetan monastic scholars who were admitted to the IBA all had completed seven to nine years
of philosophical studies at various Sakya monastic colleges, such as Dzongsar Shedra (Bir,
India), Sakya College (Dehradun, India), Rimbik Shedra Sakya Chopelling (Darjeeling, India),
or Sakya Institute (Puruwalla, India). Thus, all of them are highly qualified in Buddhist philosophy and have attained either a Shastri (ka chu pa) degree - equivalent to a Batchelorโs
21 ลฤntideva was an Indian master of Nalanda, lived around the 8th century. Sakya Paแนแธita (chos rje sa skya paN Dita kun dga' rgyal mtshan) (1184-1251), is one of the five founders of the Sakya School. Jamgon Kongtrul ( 'jam
mgon kong sprul blo gros mtha' yas), (1813-1899), is a renowned master of the Rimรฉ (ecumenical) movement.22 โWelcome to the International Buddhist Academy,โ accessed October 10, 2014.http://internationalbuddhistacademy.org/about/
http://www.rigpawiki.org/index.php?title=Rim%C3%A9http://www.rigpawiki.org/index.php?title=Rim%C3%A9http://www.rigpawiki.org/index.php?title=Rim%C3%A9http://www.rigpawiki.org/index.php?title=Rim%C3%A9
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
14/39
14 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
degree - or an Acharya ( slob dpon) degree, equivalent to a Masterโs degree, prior to entering theIBA. Their education at the monastic colleges had included extensive training in logic and
debate. This discipline of philosophical debate has become so ingrained in the monksโ way ofthinking and speaking that, even though not formally on the curriculum at the IBA, debates can
often be witnessed during tea breaks and recreation time. At the IBA, the monksโ trainingfocuses on English language which most of them had received only to a very little degree before
arriving at the IBA.
The non-Tibetan (mostly Western) students of the IBA translator program focused on studying
Tibetan language: classical Tibetan (chos skad ) as well as colloquial Tibetan ( phal skad ). Tibetan
exists as a diglossia, i.e. as two different co-existing language โhabits,โ namely classical, literaryTibetan which has seen very little change since the Buddhist canon itself was translated, and
colloquial Tibetan, spoken dialects, which have continued to evolve into new usages of
vocabulary and grammar. Both aspects of Tibetan intersect in the field of Buddha Dharma. The
monastics at the IBA are familiar with both, and therefore it is deemed necessary also for non-
Tibetan translators to study not only literary language, but also its practical application in
conversations about Buddhist teachings, as well as colloquial Tibetan. At the IBA, Tibetan
scholars also spoke Kham and Amdo dialects but these were not taught to non-Tibetan students.
The non-Tibetan, or Western students at the IBA come from various backgrounds, some hold
academic degrees in Buddhist studies, others have a strong affiliation with a Tibetan lama who
advised them to learn the skill of translation. In a two year program, they receive an education
consisting of three areas: Tibetan grammar, translation of Buddhist scriptures, and conversational
Tibetan. They study Tibetan grammar ( sum chu pa and rtags โjug pa) with Tibetan teachers, i.e.from a Tibetan perspective without the attempt to apprehend Tibetan grammar through western
grammatical concepts. Translation into English is taught in workshop style with experienced
senior translators such as Gavin Kilty (Institute of Tibetan Classics), Dan Martin (PhD,
independent researcher), Khenpo Jorden (PhD Harvard, Director of the Institute), and others.
Tibetan conversation is practised daily in one-on-one modules, and informally during lunch and
tea breaks. According to Gavin Kilty, for translating a classical text you must have knowledge of
spoken Tibetan. You need to discuss it, not only with khenpos and lamas that you might ask, but
with yourself.
At the end of the first two year intensive program in 2011, a small number of students committed
to working in the two translation groups associated with the IBA, the Chodung Karmo
Translation Group which focuses on the translation of specific commentaries of the Sakya
tradition, and the Sakya Pandita Translation Group, which translates sลซtras and is funded bygrants of the 84000.
Team Translation
The ideal model that these translation groups follow is that of the lotsawa-paแนแธ ita as explained previously. Since different text translations demand various ranges of language expertise, the
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
15/39
15 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
translation teams are complemented with Sanskrit experts, English editors and proof readers as
needed. In the case of the ฤkฤลagarbha Sลซtra, the text was translated into English by a teamconsisting of the monastic scholars Jampa Tenzin and Ngawang Tenzin, and the western
academics Christian Bernert and myself. It was edited by Pamela Gayle White and the final
proof reading was done by Vivian Paganuzzi, an English professor at the IBA. Our team was
supervised by Dr Khenpo Ngawang Jorden, the director of the IBA.
Challenges
In the process of translating the sutra, we faced different kinds of challenges. Roughly speaking,
one could group them into four categories: [1] human resource challenges, [2] structural
challenges,[3] textual challenges and [4] challenges of the Tibetan language.
1. Human Resource Challenges
Our first challenge consisted of the fact that we were junior translators. The two Tibetan scholars
had no prior experience; Christian Bernert and I had academic training, both holding a M.A. in
Buddhist Studies, but had each translated only a few shorter texts before embarking on this project. All four of us had studied Tibetan Buddhism for more than a decade, albeit in different
contexts. None of us had, however, focused particularly on the study of sลซtras. We were,therefore, in many respects, in a training process.
The solution for this challenge was that we were very well framed. The head of our translation
team was Khenpo Jorden, the director of the IBA. A student of Khenpo Appey Rinpoche, he is
excellently trained in the Tibetan monastic college system, as well as in the Western academic
System, holding a PhD from Harvard. He helped us with difficult passages and verified the end
result. Moreover, we were well connected via email with translators and editors of the 84000
who helped us with a number of problems. An online community of translators has since starteda Google group, which is regularly used for conversations on translation issues.
2. Structural Challenges
Our second challenge could be called a structural challenge because it had to do with how we
structured our work flow. We decided to divide the text in two parts. Acharya Jampa Tenzin and
myself translated the first half, Acharya Ngawang Tenzin and Christian Bernert translated the
second. Afterwards we exchanged our translations and verified the section of the other party.
The advantage of this work style was that we had a fresh, new reading of our translated text by
two other translators, which we hoped would reduce the amount of errors. The challenge was,evidently, to harmonize two different styles, and to verify that passages that had the same
wording in Tibetan would have the same wording in English. This work style was quite time-
consuming. It elicited numerous discussions between the translators which were helpful for
gaining experience in translating but, generally speaking, we concluded that it would be
reasonable to have one text translated by only one pair of translators in the future.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
16/39
16 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
3. Text Edition Challenges
The translators of the 84000 are requested to research existing versions and editions of the s ลซtrathey are translating. For the ฤkฤลagarbha Sลซtra, no Sanskrit version is available, but there is, inthe Chinese Canon, the Sลซtra on the Bodhisattva ฤkฤลagarbha, translated by Buddhayaลas between 403 and 413 CE. The Chinese version of this text differs, however, significantly from
the Tibetan translation found in the Kangyur . It has been translated into German from the Korean
and Chinese versions by the Korean monk and scholar Sunim Tenzin Tharchin together with
Elisabeth Lindmayer in 2010.23
Christian Bernert and I both read this translation, but decided
that although the basic content of both texts is the same, their structures are very different, i.e.
the Chinese contains numerous passages not found in the Tibetan, and vice versa.
The solution to this challenge was simply to acknowledge that there were two different versions
of the ฤkฤลagarbha sลซtra in the introduction to our translation, but to treat our text as anindependent work. We did not attempt to compare our translation with the translation from the
Korean-Chinese version.
4. Challenges of Translating the Tibetan Language
The fourth and most important challenge in my list is found in the Tibetan language itself.
Unlike the inflectional language of Sanskrit, classical Tibetan is an agglutinating language that
uses particles, or connectors ( phrad ) to express person, number, gender, and case. The particular
challenge in understanding Tibetan texts is due to the โtranscategorical and optional nature of theuse of case markers.โ24 This means that the same particles ( phrad ) may designate different cases,or that particles may be omitted altogether. This elliptical style that overrides rules of syntax was
dubbed โThe Tibetan Telegram Principleโ by Stephan Beyer.25 In order to produce an accuratetranslation, it is therefore indispensable to possess a large contextual understanding. Knowing the
vocabulary and grammar rules alone is not sufficient; the understanding comes from background
knowledge. In a teamwork of paแนแธ ita-lotsawa, it is often the Tibetan scholar who can providesuch a background.
Specific Examples:
4a. Archaic Language
The first challenge that I would like to address among the many linguistic challenges in
translating Tibetan texts, especially sลซtras, is the challenge of archaic language. Even though wedo have wonderful resources โ lexica, dictionaries, data bases and so on โ they are not able to
answer all of the translatorsโ questions. In the process of translating the ฤkฤลagarbha Sลซtra, wehad a few terms that posed a challenge even for learned Tibetan scholars. Living at the
23Tenzin Tharchin and Elisabeth Lindmayer. Das Akashagarbha- Sutra. Allumfassende Liebe und Weisheit: Heilend
und Wunscherfรผllend , (Mรผnchen: Diamant Verlag, 2010).24 Nicolas Tournadre, โThe Classical Tibetan Cases and their Transcategoriality: From sacred grammar to modernlinguistics.โ Himalayan Linguistics 2010, Vol. 9(2): 87-125.25 Stephan Beyer, The Classical Tibetan Language, 195.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
17/39
17 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
International Buddhist Academy, we were surrounded by Tibetan scholars with various fields of
expertise. Still, we had a few expressions that were unfamiliar to all of them. One example is the
term phyag dar ba which occurred in the passage on the seventh and eights bodhisattva
transgressions. The wordโs meaning that was familiar to native Tibetan speakers, and which youfind in dictionaries, is โsweeper,โ phyag dar meaning โdustโ or โrubbishโ. In the ฤkฤลagarbha
Sลซtra, the term occurs in connection with โadvisors, ministers, soldiers and physicians.โ Totranslate the term as โsweeperโ did not seem intelligible in the context of this sลซtra.
To solve this problem we spoke with various experts at the IBA and also consulted other texts on
the bodhisattva transgressions. We read the corresponding Tibetan and Sanskrit passages in
ลฤntidevaโs ลikแนฃฤsamuccaya. This led us on to discover that phyag dar ba is the translation ofcaแนแธฤlฤ in the Sanskrit text, a term that means in general โoutcast, person of lowest value.โAccording to Monier Williams it can also mean โa very low representative of something.โ26 Itseems that the context for this secondary meaning could be found in brahmanical thought, in
particular its hierarchy of pure versus impure occupations and the value judgement associated
with it.
4b. The Tone of a Translation
The second challenge I would like to discuss is the tone, or voice, of a translation. The
ฤkฤลagarbha Sลซtra contains several passages of poetry, which were challenging to translate because they were obscure, and seemed to express several layers of meaning at the same time.
Our translation group discussed the verses several times and finally opted for reading the passage
as describing the realization of Bodhisattva ฤk ฤลagarbha. We decided to keep the translation asliteral as possible. In these verses (below), the Tibetan word kun gzhi means literally โall-ground.โThis term refers in numerous other texts to the ฤlaya, the eighth or so-called storehouseconsciousness in Buddhist psychology, which in some schools of thought is associated with
tathฤ gatagarbha, or Buddha nature. However, after some discussion, we finally opted forignoring a possible philosophical reference and used a literal translation of the โall-ground.โ
The verses of obscure poetry on folio 265b read as follows:
The Bhagavฤn replied:27
โIt is just as you have said. The place where the all-basis is heard,and where, with wisdom, sentient beings are established,
that place is the sphere of activity of meditative concentration.
โIt is the sphere of activity of the Bodhisattva ฤkฤลagarbha, who has demonstrated the meditative concentration free of appearances
26 Monier Williams Sanskrit-English Dictionary, 383/3.27Degรฉ Edition, F.265.b.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
18/39
18 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
and free of proliferations.
โWhoever is attached to the two views will later be in a realm of delusion.
Attachment to permanence o annihilation
is utter delusion about here and there.
โThose who wish to free themselves completely from both of these views
should meditate on that which is inexpressible,
thereby swiftly attaining the grounds.
In Tibetan this passage reads as follows:
Regarding our first translation of these verses, the reviewer of the 84000 - whose identity was
kept anonymous by the editorial committee - pointed out that โthe meanings of the versifiedteachings on the nature of reality in this sutra are often obscure and lend themselves to
ambiguity. However, if the translation is rendered clearly and unambiguously, the reader will
have no idea of the ambiguous nature of the text, and will assume that the clarity of the English
reflects the clarity of the Tibetan. This could lead the reader to believe that the translation isdefinitive, whereas future translations of the same sutra that carry contradictory readings will not
be seen as merely reflecting the obscurities inherent in the text but as either correction to the
original or mistaken readings of the Tibetan.โ
The suggested solution for such problems was to insert a paragraph in the introduction on the
difficulties of translating these kinds of verses on the nature of reality in general, and specifically
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
19/39
19 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
within this sutra. Moreover, specific instances of ambiguity could be annotated with footmarks to
the translation itself. We opted for the first solution suggested here.
4c. Technical Terms and Treatment of Sanskrit
A third challenge concerns the numerous Buddhist technical terms. Many or all of them
encompass meanings that cannot be accurately rendered with one single English term. Whereasthe Tibetan translators in the 7
th century were reluctant to retain Sanskrit loan words in their
translation, and rather translated nearly everything into Tibetan including names of people and
places, English translators often resort to the original Sanskrit terms. Tibetans did not shy away
from creating altogether new words, rendering, for instance, the word โBuddhaโ with โ sangsrgyas,โ two words that both carry new meanings, none of which directly found in the Sanskritโ budh (to awaken). Since many English translators use Sanskrit terms, over time, Englishreaders got accustomed to certain words such as โbuddha, bodhisattva, dharma.โ In accordancewith the 84000 guidelines, we tried to find a middle way between the necessity for, and the
overload of, Sanskrit. Our solution was to use Sanskrit whenever we could not find a satisfying
English term. We tried to reduce the amount of Sanskrit as much as we could. In our first draft
we had also bhik แนฃu, parฤmitฤ, bhลซmi, saแน gha, etc., which you find now as English terms -monk, perfection, ground, assembly, etc. - in the final, published version. The Sanskrit of these terms
can still be found in the online glossary which the reader can access by clicking on highlighted
terms in the translated text.
We used Sanskrit terms in the following instances: to describe [1] particular types of
practitioners (mahฤsattva, ลrฤvaka, pratyekabuddha), [2] particular types of beings that werementioned as part of the Buddhaโs entourage (deva, nฤga, yakแนฃa, gandharva, asura, garuda,kinnara, mahoraga, kimbhฤแนแธa, preta, piลฤca, pลซtana, kaแนญapลซtana), and [3] for Buddhisttechnical terms that encompassed a spectrum of meaning too vast to capture all meanings. One
example for the latter category is dhฤraแนฤซ . This term is used in various ways. For instance, itrefers to the mental capacity of not forgetting, enabling one in particular to cultivate positive
forces and to ward off negativity. It is also very commonly used as a term for mystical verses
similar to mantras, the usage of which will grant a particular power. There is no English
multivalent term bearing equivalent meanings. Thus, the use of Sanskrit remains a necessity as
long as no satisfying English translations have been determined; and translation decisions have
to be taken in a case-by-case manner.
4d. Repetitions
Another challenge peculiar to translating sลซtras pertains to repetitions. The editorial policiesโ statement of the 84000 reads: โA great deal of repetition, sometimes of stock phrases, is acharacteristic feature of some Kangyur texts, and in most cases it should be reproduced in full in
the translation.โ
To give an example from our particular sutra: We had several passages mentioning fear, or the
absence thereof, for example, in the face of ฤk ฤลagarbhaโs magical displays. In the original,
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
20/39
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
21/39
21 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
In this presentation I have tried to elucidate the editorial policies of the 84000and our personal
experience with it. The challenges that we faced were partly specific to our team of junior
translators, and partly general difficulties that all translators of the Tibetan language encounter.
The solutions that we found have one feature in common: in order to find solutions we had to
expand โ we had to expand our pool of knowledge to include the intelligence and experience ofsenior translators, and we had to expand our focus beyond the limits of the text we were
translating in order to find information and ideas in other texts. Generally speaking I can say that
the English translation of the ฤkฤลagarbha Sลซtra would not have reached its level of qualitywithout the assistance of many scholars, particularly the editors and reviewers of the 84000. In a
collaborative effort, we have attempted to come close to their ideals of โaccuracy of meaning,clarity, consensuality, and consistency.โ The organization of the 84000 demonstrates that in astructured collaborative effort, translations can be produced in quantity and quality that represent
much more than the sum of the individualsโ work.
Bibliography
Tibetan Texts
ฤkฤลagarbha nฤma mahฤyฤna sลซtra ('Phags pa nam mkha'i snying po zhes bya ba theg pa chen po'i mdo). Tลh. 260. Degรฉ Kangyur, vol. 66 ZA, (mdo sde, za), folios 264r.4-283b.
Dpe sdur ma. Krung go'i bod rig pa'i dpe skrun khang /, pe cin/. 2006-2009. par gzhi dang po/.Accessed Oct 10, 2014. http://www.tbrc.org/#!rid=W1PD96682
Secondary Literature
โ84000 Editorial Policy v8.0.โ Accessed Oct 30, 2014. http://84000.co/resources/grants/.
Beyer, Stephan. The Classical Tibetan Language, New York: State University of New York,
1992/ Delhi: Sri Satguru Publications, 1993.
Jamgon Kongtrul ('jam mgon kong sprul blo gros mtha' yas), Treasury of Knowledge,
Buddhism's Journey to Tibet . Ithaka, NY: Snow Lion Publication, 2010.
โOrigin.โ Accessed Oct 30, 2014. http://84000.co/about/origin/.
Raine, Roberta. โTranslating the Tibetan Buddhist Canon: Past Strategies, FutureProspects.โ Forum 9.2 (2011): 157-186
โProgress.โ Accessed Oct 10, 2014. http://84000.co/about/progress/.
Skillings, Peter. โDr. Peter Skillingโs address to the conference,โ http://translationandtransmission.org/videos.html.
Tharchin, Tenzin, and Elisabeth Lindmayer. Das Akashagarbha- Sutra. Allumfassende Liebe und
Weisheit: Heilend und Wunscherfรผllend . Mรผnchen: Diamant Verlag, 2010.
http://84000.co/about/progress/http://84000.co/about/progress/
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
22/39
22 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
Tournadre, Nicolas. โThe Classical Tibetan Cases and their Transcategoriality: From sacredgrammar to modern linguistics.โ Himalayan Linguistics 2010, Vol. 9(2): 87-125.
โWelcome to the International Buddhist Academy,โ accessed October 10, 2014.http://internationalbuddhistacademy.org/about/
Weldon, David. โGuardians of the Sacred Word.โ Accessed Oct 10, 2014.http://www.asianart.com/exhibitions/covers/intro. html.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
23/39
23 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
๊ตญ์ ๋ถ๊ต ํํ ๋คํ) ์ฌ๊บ
28 ๋นค๋๋ฐ ๋ฒ์ญ ๊ทธ๋ฃน์ ํ๋ ์ ํ ์ด์ ๊ณผ
๋์นํ๊ณต์ฅ๋ณด์ด๊ฒฝ ๅคงไน่็ฉบ่่ฉ่ฉ็ถ) ์ญ๊ฒฝ
์์ธ
2014๋ 2์์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ ๋ ์ ๋ง์๊ณผ ๋์์ โ84000-๋ถ์ฒ๋ ๋ง์์ ์ญ๊ฒฝโ ํ๋ก์ ํธ๋ ๋ฐฑ ๋ ๋์
ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋์ฅ๊ฒฝ์ ์์ ํ ์ญ๊ฒฝ ํ๋ ๋ฒ์ญ ํ๋ก์ ํธ์ ์ผํ์ผ๋ก ์จ๋ผ์ธ์์์ ๋์นํ๊ณต์ฅ๋ณด์ด๊ฒฝ
( Mahฤ yฤna ฤ k ฤลagarbha S ลซtra; โ phags pa nam mkhaโ i snying po zhes bya ba theg pa chen poโ i mdo) ์
์ถํํ์๋ค.29
์ด ๊ฒฝ์ ๋ฒ์ญํ ์ฌ๊บ ๋นค๋๋ฐ ์ญ๊ฒฝ ๊ทธ๋ฃน์ 84000ํ๋ก์ ํธ์ ์จ๋ผ์ธ ์ถํ์ ์ด๊ธฐ ๋จ๊ณ๋ถํฐ
๊ฐ์ด ์ผํด ์๊ณ , ๊ทธ ์ฌ์ดํธ๋ฅผ ์ํด ์ฒซ ์ํ ๋ฒ์ญ์ ์ ๊ณตํ์๋ค. ์ด ํ๋ ์ ํ ์ด์ ์ ๋ชฉ์ ์ 84000
ํ๋ก์ ํธ์ ํฐ ์ ํฉ ์์์ ๊ฐ์ฅ ์ต๊ทผ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝํ ํ๊ณต์ฅ๋ณด์ด๊ฒฝ์ ๊ดํ ๊ฒฝํ์ ์ฌ์ฉํ์ฌ ์ฌ๊บ ๋นค๋๋ฐ์
์ญ๊ฒฝ์์ ์ ๊ดํ ๋ฐฐ๊ฒฝ์ ์ง์์ ์ ์ํ๋ ๊ฒ์ด๋ค. ํ๋ ์ ํ ์ด์ ์ฒซ ๋ถ๋ถ์์ ๋๋ ์ฐ๋ฆฌ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ์์ ์
๊ดํ ํ์์ ์ธ ๋ฐฐ๊ฒฝ ์ง์์ ์ ๊ณตํ๊ณ , ์ฐ๋ฆฌ ์์ ์ ์ง์นจ์ธ 84000์ ํธ์ง ์ ์ฑ ์ ์ฃผ์ ํน์ง๋ค์ ๋ ผํ๋ ค
ํ๋ค. ๋์งธ ๋ถ๋ถ์์๋ ์ฐ๋ฆฌ ์ญ๊ฒฝ ๊ณผ์ ์ ๋ํ ํน์ ํ ์ธ๋ถ์ ๋ด์ฉ์ ์ด์ ์ ๋๋ ค ํ๋ค. ์ฌ๊ธฐ์ ๋๋
ํ๊ณต์ฅ๋ณด์ด๊ฒฝ์ ๋ฒ์ญํ๋ฉด์ ์ง๋ฉดํ ๋์ ๋ค์ ๋ํด ๋ ผํ๊ณ , ์ฐ๋ฆฌ๊ฐ ๋ฐ๊ฒฌํ ๋ค์ํ ํด๊ฒฐ์ฑ ์ ์ค๋ช ํ
๊ฒ์ด๋ค.
I.
84000 โ ๋ถ์ฒ๋ ๋ง์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ ํ๋ก์ ํธ
์ญ์ฌ
2009๋ ์ธ๋ ๋น๋ฅด ์ง์ญ์ ์๋ ๋ น์ผ์ ์น์์์ ๊ฐ์ต๋ ํ ๋ฒ์ญ ํ์ ํ์๊ฐ โ84000 โ ๋ถ์ฒ๋ ๋ง์
์ญ๊ฒฝโ์ ์ค๋ฆฝํ๋ ์ญํ ์ ํ ์ฒซ ๊ฑธ์์ด์๋ค. ์ด ํ์ ํ์์์ ์ข ์ฌ๋ฅด ์ผ์ฒด ๋ฆฐํฌ์ฒด์ ์ ๋ ์๋ 50์ฌ๋ช
์ด์์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ๋ค์ด ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋ถ๊ต ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝํ๋ ๊ฒ์ ๋ํ ์ค์์ฑ์ ๋ ผํ์๋ค. ๊ทธ๋ค์
๊ฑฐ๊ธฐ์ ๊ตญ์ ์ ํ๋ ฅ์ ์ค์์ฑ์ ๊นจ๋ซ๊ฒ ๋์๋ค. ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ์ ๊ทธ ์์ ์ ์ํด ๊ธ์ ์ ยท๋ฌผ์ง์
์ง์์ ์ป์ผ๋ ค ๊ณ ์ ํ๊ณ ์๋ ๊ฐ์ธ ๋ฒ์ญ๊ฐ์ ๋ฒ์ญ ๊ทธ๋ฃน์ ๋ ๋๊ฒจ์ ธ์์๋ค. ๋น๋ฅด์์ ๊ฐ์ต๋ ๊ทธ
ํ์ ํ์์ ๊ฒฐ๊ณผ๋ก์ ์ฐ์ ์ ์ผ๋ก โ๋ถ๊ต ๋ฌธํ ์ ์ฐ ํ๋ก์ ํธ Buddhist Literary Heritage Projectโ๊ฐ
์ค๋ฆฝ๋์๊ณ , ๊ทธ๊ฒ์ 2011๋ ์ โ84000 โ ๋ถ์ฒ๋ ๋ง์์ ์ญ๊ฒฝโ์ด๋ผ๊ณ ๊ฐ๋ช ๋์๋ค. ์ด ํ๋ก์ ํธ๋ ์ด๋ ๊ฒ
์ข ์ฌ๋ฅด ์ผ์ฒด ๋ฆฐํฌ์ฒด์ ์ํด ์ฐฝ์๋์๊ณ , ์ผ์ฒด ์ฌ๋จ์ด ์๊ธ์ ์ง์ํ๊ณ ์๋ค.30
์ด ์ฌ๋จ์ โ๋ชจ๋ ๋ถ๋ฒ์
ํ๋ ์ธ์ด๋ก ๋ฒ์ญํ์ฌ ๋ชจ๋ ์ฌ๋๋ค์๊ฒ ๋ฌด์์ผ๋ก ์ ๊ณตํ๋ ๋ชฉ์ โ์ ๊ฐ์ง ๊ณต์ธ ๊ธ๋ก๋ฒ ๋น์๋ฆฌ ์ฌ์ ์ฒด์ด๋ค.
๋น๋ฅด ํํ ์ฐธ์ฌ์๋ค์ ๋ํ ๋ชจ๋ ์ข ๋จ์ ์ ์น์์ ์ค์น์ ์ฐธ์ฌ๋ฅผ ์ ๊ทน ์ ๋ํ๊ธฐ๋ก ๊ฒฐ์ ํ์๋ค. ์ค๋๋ ,์ง๊ธ๊น์ง 84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ์ ์ฐธ์ฌํด์จ 153๋ช ์ ๊ฐ์ธ ๋ฒ์ญ๊ฐ์ 23 ๋ฒ์ญ ํ์ ๋ช ๋จ
31์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ๋ถ๊ต์
๋ชจ๋ ์ฃผ์ ์ข ํ (๋๋ง, ๊น๊ท, ์ฌ๊บ, ๊ฒ๋ฃฉ)๊ฐ ์ฐธ์ํ์๊ณ , ๋ฐ๋ผ์ ๋ฒ์ข ๋จ์ ์ธ ํต์ผ๋ ์ฌ์ ์ฒด๊ฐ
๊ตฌ์ฑ๋์์์ ๋ณด์ฌ์ค๋ค.
28 ์ญ) ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ฌ๋ ์ข ๋จ ์ค์ ํ๋. ํ์ ์๊ฐ์ด๋ ๋ป์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ์ด๋ก์ ์ฌ์บฌ๋ฌด๋์ ์ฌ์บฌ์๋ ์ด์์ ์ผ๋ก ๋ค๋ฅด๋ค.29 ์ธํฐ๋ท ์น์ฌ์ดํธ: www.84000.co30 http://84000.co/about/origin/31 โTranslators,โ accessed Oct 30, 2014. http://84000.co/about/translators/.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
24/39
24 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ์ ๋น์ ์ ์ธ๋ฌธ์์ ๊ทธ๋ค์ ๋๊ธฐ๊ฐ ์ค๋ช ๋์ด์๋ค:32
๋ถ๋ค๋ ์ง์ ํ ํํ์ ๊ณ ๋ก๋ถํฐ ํดํ์ ์ํด ํ๋ง ์ฌ์ฒ์ฌ๊ฐ์ง์ ๋ฐฉํธ์ผ๋ก ๊ฐ๋ฅด์ณค๋ค๊ณ ํ๋ค.
์ด ๊ฐ๋ฅด์นจ์ ๋จ์ง 5%๋ง์ด ํ๋์ด๋ก ์ญ๊ฒฝ๋์๋ค. ๊ณ ์ ์ธ์ด์ ๋ํ ์ง์๊ณผ ์ ๋ฌธ์ ์ธ ํ์๋ค์
์๊ฐ ๊ธ๊ฒฉํ ๊ฐ์ํ์ฌ ํ์ฌ ์ฐ๋ฆฌ๋ค์ ์ ์ ์ ์ ์ฐ๊ณผ ๋ฌธํ์ ์ ํต์ ์์ ์๊ธฐ์ ์ฒํด์๋ค.
84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ์ ๊ณต์ธ๋ ๋ชฉํ๋ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ผ์ฅ ์ ์ฒด๋ฅผ ๋ฐฑ๋ ์์ ์ญ๊ฒฝํ๋ ๊ฒ์ด๋ค. 5๋ , 10๋ ๊ทธ๋ฆฌ๊ณ
25๋ ์ ์ค๊ฐ์ ๋ชฉํ๋ ์ด ๋ชฉํ๊ฐ ๋ฌ์ฑ๋์ด์ผ ํ ์ค๊ฐ์ ๋จ๊ณ๋ฅผ ํ์ ํ๋ค. ํ์ฌ 84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ๋ ๊ฒฝ์ฅ์
์ฃผ์ ๋ณธ๋ฌธ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝํ๋ ๋ฐ ์ด์ ์ ๋ง์ถ๊ณ ์์ผ๋ฏ๋ก, ๋ ผ์ฅ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ์ ์๋์ ์ผ๋ก ๋ฐฉ์น๋์ด ์๋ค.
์ฅ ๋จ๊ธฐ์ ๋ชฉํ๋ ๋ค์ ์ฐจํธ์์ ์์ ๋์๋ค:
100 ๋ ํ๋์ด๋ก ๋ฒ์ญ๋ ๋ถ๊ต ๋ฌธํ ์ ์ฐ์ ๋ชจ๋ ์ธ๋ฅ๊ฐ ์ด์ฉํ ์ ์๋๋ก ์ ๊ณตํ๋ค.
25 ๋ ๊ฒฝ์ฅ ์ ์ฒด์ ๊ด๋ จ๋ ๋ ผ์ฅ์ ์์ด๋ก ํ์ฉ๊ฐ๋ฅํ๊ฒ ๋ง๋ค๊ณ , ๋ค์ํ ํ๋ซํผ์์
๊ด๋ฒ์ํ ์ ๊ทผ์ฑ์ ์ ๊ณตํ๋ค.
10 ๋ ์๋นํ ๋ถ๋์ ๊ฒฝ์ฅ๊ณผ ๋ถ์์ ์ธ ๋ ผ์ฅ์ ์์ด๋ก ํ์ฉ๊ฐ๋ฅํ ๋ก ๋ง๋ค๊ณ ๋ค์ํ
ํ๋ซํผ์ผ๋ก ์ฝ๊ฒ ์ ๊ทผํ๊ฒ ๋ง๋ ๋ค.
5 ๋ ๋ํ์ ์ธ ๊ฒฝ์ฅ๊ณผ ๋ ผ์ฅ์ ํ๋ณธ์ ์์ด๋ก ํ์ฉ๊ฐ๋ฅํ๊ฒ ๋ง๋ค๊ณ , ์ฅ๊ธฐ์ ์ธ
๋น์ ์ ๋ฌ์ฑํ๋๋ฐ ํ์์ ์ธ ๊ธฐ๋ฐํ๊ฒฝ๊ณผ ์์์ ์ ์ฐฉ์ํจ๋ค.
ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋ถ๊ต ๋ฌธํ ์ ์ฐ ์ ์ฒด๋ฅผ ๋ฒ์ญํ๋ ๋น์ ์ ํ์คํํ๊ธฐ ์ํด์ 84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ๋ ๋ค์ฏ ์์ญ์
๋์์ ์์ ํ๋ค. ๊ทธ๊ฒ๋ค์ ๋ค์๊ณผ ๊ฐ๋ค:
1.์ญ๊ฒฝ๋น
: 84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ๋ ์ฃผ์ ๋ณธ๋ฌธ ๋ฒ์ญ์ ์ฐ๊ตฌ๊ธ ์ ์ฒญ ํ์์ผ๋ก ํธ์ฑํ๊ณ ์๋ค โ
์ง๊ธ๊น์ง๋ ๋๋ถ๋ถ ๊ฒฝ์ ๋ค์ด๋ค.
2. ์ถํ: 84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ ์ถํ ์์ํ๋ ๋ฒ์ญ๋ ๋ณธ๋ฌธ์ 84000 ์น์ฌ์ดํธ์ ์จ๋ผ์ธ์ผ๋ก ์ถํ๋
๋๊น์ง ํธ์ง ๊ณผ์ ์ ๊ฐ๋ดํ๊ณ ๊ฐ๋ ํ๋ค.
3.๊ธฐ๊ธ์กฐ์ฑ
: 84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ๋ ํ์ฌ ์งํ ์ค์ธ ๊ทธ๋ฆฌ๊ณ ๋ฏธ๋์ ๋ฒ์ญ ์ฌ์ ์ ์ํด ๊ธฐ๊ธ์
์กฐ์ฑํ๋๋ฐ ํ์์ ์ธ ๋ ธ๋ ฅ์ ์ทจํ๋ค.
4. ๋ฒ์ญ
๋๊ตฌ: 84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ๋ ํ์กดํ๋ ๋ฒ์ญ ํ๋ก๊ทธ๋จ๊ณผ ๋ฒ์ญ ๋๊ตฌ, ๊ทธ๋ฆฌ๊ณ ๋ค๋ฅธ ๊ด๋ จ ์ ๋ณด์
๊ดํ ์ฐ๊ณ๋ฅผ ์ ๊ณตํจ์ผ๋ก์จ ์ฅ๊ธฐ์ ๋ชฉํ๋ฅผ ์ถ๊ตฌํ๋ ๋ฐ ๊ด๋ จ๋ ์ ๋ณด๋ฅผ ์ ๊ณตํ๋ค.
๋ถ๊ต ํ์ฌ
: 84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ๋ ๋ณด๋๊ฐ์ผ(2012, 2014)์ ๋ด์ (2012, 2013)์์์ โ๋ถ์ฒ๋์ ๊ฐ๋ฅด์นจ์ด
์ธ๋ คํผ์ง Resounding of the Buddhaโs Wordโ33๊ณผ ๊ฐ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๋ ๊ฒฝ์ ๋ค์ด ๋ถ๋ฒ ์ํ์ ์ฌ์ฉ๋๋ ๋ถ๊ต ํ์ฌ๋ฅผ
์กฐ์งํ๋ค. ์ด๋ฐ ๋ฒํ์์ ์กฐ์งํ๋ ๊ณต๋์ ๊ดํ ๊ณ ๋ ค์๋ ๋ณ๋๋ก, ์ด๋ฐ ํ์ฌ๋ ๋ถ๋ช ํ ๋ฒ์ญ ํ๋ก์ ํธ์
ํ์์ ์ค์์ฑ์ ์ ์ ํ๋ ๋ชฉ์ ์ ๊ณตํํ๋ค.
32 โVision,โ accessed Oct 30, 2014. http://84000.co/about/vision/. 33 ์ญ) ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ฌ๋๋ค์ด ๋ถ๊ต ์ถ์ ์ค์ ์ฌ๋ฌ ๋ค๋ฅธ ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ํฐ ์๋ฆฌ๋ก ๋คํจ๊ป ๋ ์กํ๋ ํ์ฌ.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
25/39
25 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
ํ๋ก์ ํธ
์คํ
:
์ถํ๋์๊ฑฐ๋
์งํ
์ค์ธ
์์
์จ๋ผ์ธ์์์
์ถํ
๋์๊ฑฐ๋
์งํ
์ค์ธ
์ญ๊ฒฝ๋ฌผ
์ญ๊ฒฝ์
์๋ขฐํ
์ชฝ
์
์ถํ๋ ์ชฝ ์
๋ฒ์ญ ์ง์
๋ฒ์ญ ์
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
26/39
26 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
๋ฒ์ญ ์ ์์
โ ๋ค๋ฅด๋ง ์ผํฐ โ ํ์ ๊ธฐ๊ด
84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ ์์ ์ ์ํฅ
์๋ ์ผ๋ํ๋ 84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ์ ์ํด ์ ๊ณต๋ ๋ฒ์ญ๋ฌผ๋ค์ด ์ผ๋ง๋ ์์ฃผ ์ฌ์ฉ๋๊ณ ์๋๊ฐ์ ๋ํ ๊ฐ์๋ฅผ
์ ์ํ๋ค.34
๋์๊ด
์ ์
์
:
4.4 ๋ฐฑ๋ง ๊ฑด
๊ฒฝ์ ๋ค์ด๋ก๋:
110,898 ๋ฒ
์ฌ์ดํธ ๋ฐฉ๋ฌธ์ ์:
151,813 ๋ช
๋์๊ด
๋ฐฉ๋ฌธ์
์
:
81,238 ๋ช
34 โImpact,โ accessed Oct 30, 2014. http://84000.co/about/impact/ Information updated on: January 1, 2014.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
27/39
27 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
๋ ์
์์
๊ตญ
:
135 ๊ฐ๊ตญ
84000
ํ๋ก์ ํธ์
ํธ์ง
์ ์ฑ
84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ๋ ๋ชจ๋ ๋ฒ์ญ๊ฐ๋ค์ด ์ค์ํด์ผํ ํธ์ง ์ ์ฑ ์ ๋ฐ๋ฌ์์ผ์๋ค. ์ผ ๋ ์ ํ ๋ฒ, 84000
ํ๋ก์ ํธ๋ ์ด๋ฏธ ์ ์ ๋ ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ ์ง์์๋ฅผ ์ ์ถํ๋๋ก ๋ฒ์ญ๊ฐ๋ค์๊ฒ ๊ณต์งํ๋ค. ๊ฑฐ๊ธฐ์ ์ง์ํ๊ธฐ
์ํด ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ๋ค์ 5 ์ชฝ์ ํ๋ณธ ๋ฒ์ญ๊ณผ ํจ๊ป ํ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ ์๊ฐ์์ ์์ฐ์ ์ ์ถํด์ผ ํ๋ค. ์ ์ ๋ ํ์
84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ์ ํธ์ง ์์ํ์ ์ํด ์ ์๋ 2010๋ ์ ์์๋๊ณ ๋งค๋ ์ฆ์ฅ๋๋ ํน์ ํ ๊ท์น์ ๊ธฐ๋ฐ์
๋์ด ์ญ๊ฒฝ์ ์์ํ ์ ์๋ค.
์์ ๊ณผ ๋์ ์ธ์ด
์ด๋ฏธ ์ธ๊ธํ๋ฏ์ด, 84000ํ๋ก์ ํธ์ ์ฃผ์ ์ด์ ์ ๊ฒฝ์ฅ๊ณผ ๋ ผ์ฅ์ ์ํด์๋ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ์ด๋ค.
๋ฐ๋ผ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ์ ์ฃผ๋ก ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด๋ก๋ถํฐ ํํด์ง๋ฉฐ, ํ์กดํ๋ ํ๋ฌธ๋ณธ๊ณผ ๋ฒ๋ณธ์ ํด์์ ํฌํจํด์ผ ํ๋ค.
๋์์ธ์ด๋ ์์ด์ด๊ณ , ์ฅ๊ธฐ์ ์ผ๋ก ์์์ด ํ์ฉ๊ฐ๋ฅํ๋ฉด ์ค๊ตญ์ด๋ฅผ ํฌํจํ ๋ค๋ฅธ ํ๋ ์ธ์ด๋ฅผ ํฌํจํ๋ค.
๋์ ๋ ์๋ ๊ต์ ์์ง๋ง ์ ๋ฌธ๊ฐ๋ ์๋ ์ฌ๋๋ค์ด๋ค. ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ๋ ํ์๋ค๊ณผ ์ผ๋ฐ ์ ๋ ์์๊ฐ ์ด์ฉํ ์
์๋ ์ธ์ด๋ฅผ ์ฌ์ฉํ๋๋ก ์๊ตฌ๋๋ค.
๋ณธ๋ฌธ๊ณผ ๋ณธ๋ฌธ ๋น๊ต, ๊ทธ๋ฆฌ๊ณ ๊ต์ ํ
๋๋ถ๋ถ ์ญ๊ฒฝ์ ์์ ์ ๋ฐ๊ฒ ํ์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด ๊ฒฝ์ ์ด๋ค. ์๋นํ ๋ถ๋์ ์์ ๋ค์ ๋ฒ์ด ํ์ด ํ์กดํ์ง
์๊ธฐ ๋๋ฌธ์ ์์ด๋ก ๋ฒ์ญํ ๋ ํ์์ ์ผ๋ก ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋ฒ์ญ๋ณธ์ผ๋ก๋ถํฐ ๋ง๋ค์ด ์ง๋ค. ์ค์ง ์์์ ์์ ๋ค์๋ง
์ ๋ขฐํ ์ ์๋ ๋ฒ์ด ์์ ์ด ํ์ฉ๊ฐ๋ฅํ๋ค. ๊ทธ ๊ฒฝ์ฐ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ๋ ๋ฒ๋ณธ์ ์์ ์ผ๋ก ํํด์ผํ๋ค. ๋ฒ์ญ์
์ด์์ ์ผ๋ก ํ์๋ณธ๊ณผ ๋ฒ๋ณธ, ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ๋ณธ์ด ํ์กดํ ๋ ๋ค๋ฅธ ํ๋ณธ์ ๋ณธ๋ฌธ ๋น๊ต์ ์ฐธ์กฐ๊ฐ ํฌํจ๋์ด์ผ ํ๋ค.
ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ๋ณธ์ ์ดํ์ ๊ดํด์ ์ด ์ ๋ฌด๋ ๋ฒ ์ด์ง์ ์ค๊ตญ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธํ ์ฐ๊ตฌ ์ผํฐ(krung goโ i bod rig pa zhi โ jug ste
gnas)์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ผ์ฅ ๋์กฐ๊ตญ(bkaโ bstan dpe sdur khang )์์ ๋ฐํํ ๊ฒฝ์ฅ๊ณผ ๋ ผ์ฅ์ ์ ๋์กฐํ(dpe bsdur
ma)์ ์ํด ์ฝ๊ฒ ๋น๊ตยท๋ถ์ ํ ์ ์๋ค.35
์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ๋ค์ ์ ๋์กฐํ ๊ฒฝ์ฅ์ ์ฌ์ฉํ์ฌ ๋ค๋ฅธ ํ๋ณธ๋ค์ ์ดํ์
์ถ์ ํ๋๋ฐ ์ฌ์ฉํ๋ค. ํ์ง๋ง ์ค์ง ์๋ฏธ์ ์ค๋ํ ์ํญ์ ๋ผ์น๋ ์ดํ๋ค๋ง์ ๊ฐ์ฃผ์ ํ๊ธฐํด์ผ ํ๋ค.
์ฐ๊ตฌ
๊ฒฝ์ ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝํ๋ ๊ฒ๊ณผ ๋๋ถ์ด ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ๋ค์ ๊ทธ ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ๊ดํด ์ด๋ ์ ๋ ์ฐ๊ตฌํด์ผํ๋ฉฐ, ์๊ฐ๋ฌธ, ๊ฐ์ฃผ,
๋์๋ชฉ๋ก, ๋ถ๋ก๊ณผ ๋ค๋ฅธ ์ฐธ๊ณ ์๋ฃ๋ฅผ ์์ฑํ๋๋ก ๊ท์ ๋์ด์๋ค. ์ด๊ฒ๋ค์ ๊ทธ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๋ฌผ๊ณผ ํจ๊ป ์ถํ๋๋ค.
๋ชจ๋ ์ถํ๋ฌผ์ ์จ๋ผ์ธ์์์ ์ถํ๋๊ณ , ๋ฌด๋ฃ์ด๋ค.
ํ์ค๊ณผ ํ์คํ
84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ๋ ํธ์ง์ ์ฑ ์์ ๋ฒ์ญ์์ ์ ์ํ ์ง๋ ์์น์ ์ธ์ ๋ค. ์ผ๋ฐ์ ์ผ๋ก ๋ฒ์ญ๋ฌผ์ ๋ค์๊ณผ
๊ฐ์ ํน์ฑ์ ๊ฐ์ ธ์ผํ๋ค: โ์๋ฏธ์ ์ ํํจ, ๋ช ๋ฃํจ, ํฉ์์ฑ, ์ผ๊ด์ฑ ๊ทธ๋ฆฌ๊ณ ์ตํต์ฑ.โ
36
84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ์ ํธ์ง ์์ํ๋ ์ด ์์น๋ค์ด ์๋ฐํ๋ ๋ด์ฉ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ์ ๊ฐ์ด๋๋ผ์ธ์์ ์ค๋ช ํ๋ค. ์ 2๋ถ
ํ๋ ์ ํ ์ด์ ์์ ๋๋ ์ด ์ธ๋ถ์ฌํญ๋ค ์ค ์ผ๋ถ๋ฅผ ์์ธํ ๋ ผํ ๊ฒ์ด๋ค. ์ผ๋ฐ์ ์ผ๋ก ๋งํ์๋ฉด, ๋ชจ๋ ๋ฐฉ์นจ์
์ฝ๊ฒ ์ฝ์ ์ ์๋ ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ๋ง๋๋๋ฐ ๋ชฉ์ ์ด ์๋ค๊ณ ๋งํ ์ ์๋ค. ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ๋ก์ ์ฐ๋ฆฌ๋ ๋ ์์๊ฒ ์น์ ํจ ์
ํญ์ ์ผ๋์ ๋์ด์ผ ํ๋ค.
35 Dpe sdur ma, Krung go'i bod rig pa'i dpe skrun khang /, pe cin/. 2006-2009. par gzhi dang po, 109 volumes, accessed Oct 10, 2014.
http://www.tbrc.org/#!rid=W1PD96682.36 โ84000 Editorial Policy v8.0,โ IV A, 7, accessed Oct 30, 2014, http://84000.co/resources/grants/.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
28/39
28 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
ํ์ค์ ์ ํ๋ ๊ฒ์ ์์ฐ์ค๋ฝ๊ฒ ํ์คํ์ ๋ํ ์ง๋ฌธ์ผ๋ก ์ด์ด์ง๋ค. ์ฆ, ๋ชจ๋ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ๋ค์ ๋น๋ฐํ๋ ๋ถ๊ต
์ฉ์ด๋ค์ ๋ํด ๋์ผํ ๋จ์ด๋ฅผ ์ฌ์ฉํด์ผํ๋ค. 84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ์ ํธ์ง์์ํ๋ ๊ณผ๊ฑฐ์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ์์ ํ
Mahฤvyutpatti(้ฃ่ญฏๅ็พฉๅคง้)์ ์ ์ฌํ ๋ฒ์ญ ํ์คํ ํ๋ก์ ํธ๋ฅผ ์ถ์งํ๊ณ ์ถ์ด ํ๋ ์๋ง์ ๊ฐ์ง๊ณ
์์์ ํ๋ช ํ์๋ค. ํ์ง๋ง ๊ทธ๋ฐ ํ์คํ ์ฌ์ ์ ํ์ฌ์๋ ๊ฐ๋ฅํ์ง ์๊ณ , ์ฐจํ ์ธ์ , ์ด๋ค ๋ฒ์๋ก ํ ์ง๋
ํ์ฌ๋ก์ ๋ช ํํ์ง ์๋ค. 84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ์ ์ง์นจ์๋ ์ฒ ์๋ฒ, ๋๋ฌธ์์ฐ๊ธฐ, ๊ธฐ์ธ์๊ณผ ๊ตฌ๋๋ฒ์ ๊ดํ
๊ท์น์ ์ ํด์ฃผ์ง๋ง ๋จ์ด ์ ํ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ๋ค์ ์์ ์ฌ๋์ ๋งก๊ธด๋ค. ํ์ง๋ง ๊ฐ๊ฐ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ ํ์ ๋ฒ์ญํ๋ ์์ค์ ๊ถ๋ง ์ฉ์ด ํด์ค(glossary)์ ๋ง๋ค์ด์ผ ํ๋ค. ์ด๊ฒ์ ์์ ์ํธ์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด, ๋ฒ์ด์ ์์ด๋ฅผ
์๋กํ๊ณ ์งง์ ์์ด ํด์ค์ ์ค์ด์ ๋ง๋ ๋ค. ์ต์ข ์ถํ ๋ณธ์์๋ ์์ด ๋จ์ด๊ฐ ์๋์ ์ผ๋ก ๋งํฌ๋์ด
๋ ์๋ค์ ์ฉ์ดํด์ค์ ์ฝ๊ฒ ๋ณผ ์ ์๋ค.
ํ์คํ์ ๋ํ ๋์ ์ ๊ฑฐ๋ถ๊ฐ์ ๋ํ ๋ฌธ์ ๋ ํ์ฌ์ ๋ฒ์ด ๋ถ๊ต ๋ฌธํ์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด๋ก ๋ฒ์ญํ ๋์ ์ญ์ฌ์
์ ํฉ๊ณผ ๋น๊ตํด ๋ณผ ๋ ๋ ์ฝ๊ฒ ์ดํด๋๋ค. ๋ฐ๋ผ์ ๋๋ ์ ์ ๋์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋ถ๊ต ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ๋ฒ์ญ์ ์ญ์ฌ๋ก ์ฃผ์ ๋ฅผ
๋ฒ์ด๋๋ ค ํ๋ค. ๊ทธ๋ฌ๊ณ ๋์, ํ๋ ์ ํ ์ด์ ์ 2๋ถ์์ 84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ ํธ์ง ์ง์นจ์ ๊ตฌ์ฒด์ ์ธ ์ค๋ก๋ฅผ
๋ค์ ๋ค๋ฃฐ ๊ฒ์ด๋ค.
๋ถ๊ต๊ฒฝ์ ์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด ์ญ๊ฒฝ
ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋ถ๊ต ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ์ง๋ ์์ญ ์ธ๊ธฐ ๋์ ๋๋ถ๋ถ์ ๋ณธ๋ฌธ์ด ํ๊ดด๋๊ณ ์ฌ๋ผ์ ธ๋ฒ๋ฆฐ ๋ฒ์ด์์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๋์๋ค.
๋ค๋ฅธ ๊ฒ๋ค์ ๋ฒ์ด ์๋ณธ์ด ์ฌ๋ผ์ก๋ค๊ณ ์๊ฐ๋ ์๊ธฐ์ ํ์์ ์ ์ฅ ์ง์ญ์ ์ฝํ์ด์ ์์ฝ๋๋์์ด ๋ฑ์
์ธ์ด๋ก๋ถํฐ ํํด์ก๋ค. ๋ฐ๋ฉด์ ๋นจ๋ฆฌ ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ์์ ํ๊ฒ ์ ํด์ ธ์๊ฑฐ๋ ํน์ ์คํ๋ ค ์ฌ๊ฑด๋์๋คโํ๊ตญ,
๋ฏธ์๋ง ๊ทธ๋ฆฌ๊ณ ์ค๋ฆฌ๋์นด์ ๊ฐ์ ์ด์ ๋๋ผ์์ ๊ฐ๊ฐ์ ํ์ฌ๋ณธ์ ์ธ๋์ ๊ฑธ์ณ ํ์ฌํ ๋ ธ๊ณ ๋๋ถ์ด๋ค.
ํ์ง๋ง ๋ถํํ๊ฒ๋ ๋ฒ์ด๊ฒฝ์ ์ ์ด์ ํด๋น๋์ง ์๋๋ค. ์๋ง์ ๋ฒ์ด ๊ฒฝ์ ์ด ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด์ ํ์
๋ฒ์ญ๋ณธ์ผ๋ก๋ง ํ์กดํ๋ค.
ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด ์ญ๊ฒฝ์์๋ ๋ ๊ฐ์ ๋๋ ท์ด ๊ตฌ๋ถ๋๋ ๋ฒ์ด-ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด ์ญ๊ฒฝ ํํ๊ฐ ์๋๋ฐ, ๊ทธ๊ฒ์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ
์ญ์ฌ๊ฐ๋ค์ด ๋งํ๋ โ์ด๊ธฐ ์ ๋ฒ๊ธฐ( snga dar )โ์ โํ๊ธฐ ์ ๋ฒ๊ธฐ( phyi dar )โ์ ์๋นํ๋ค. ์ฒ์์ผ๋ก, โ์์์
์๋๋กโ์ด๋์ 7์ธ๊ธฐ๋ถํฐ 9์ธ๊ธฐ ์ค๋ฐ๊น์ง ์กด์ํ์์ผ๋ฉฐ, ์๊ถ์ ์ง๋์ ๋ณดํธ์ ๊ธฐ๋ฐ์ ๋ ์ฌ์ ์ด์๋ค.
๊ธฐ์ ํ 7์ธ๊ธฐ์ ์๋ก์ด ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ํต์ผ ์๊ตญ์ ์ก์ฉฌ๊ฐ๋ฝ์( srong btsan sgam po, 569 โ 649?/605 โ 649?)์ด
๋ถ๊ต์ ์ธ๋์์ ์ค์์๋ ๋ถ๊ต ๊ฒฝ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ์ ์ง์ํ์ ๋น์์๋ ์ฌ์ ํ ์๋์ ์ผ๋ก ์ ํฅ๊ตญ๊ฐ์๋ค.
์ ์น์ ์ธ ๋ถ๊ดด์ ๋ถ๊ต์ ์๊ธฐ๊ฐ ๋๋ํ ๋ ๊น์ง ๋ ์ธ๊ธฐ ๋ฐ์ ํฉ๊ธ๊ธฐ๊ฐ ์์๋ค. ๋ ๋ฒ์งธ, โ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ธฐ( gsar
โ gyur )โ๋๋ ํ๊ธฐ ์ ๋ฒ๊ธฐ( phyi dar )๋ผ๊ณ ๋ ๋ถ๋ฆฐ๋คโ๋ 11์ธ๊ธฐ์ 14์ธ๊ธฐ ์ฌ์ด์ ์ผ์ด๋ ์ฐ๋ฐ์ ์ธ
์ด๋์ด๊ณ , ์ค์น๊ณผ ์ ๋ฌธ ํ์๋ค์ ์ํด ๋ถ ์งํด์ง ํ๋ฟ๋ฆฌ ์ด๋์ด๋ค. ์ด๊ฒ์ ์๋ํ ๊ฐ์ธ์
ํ์ฝ์๊ธฐ์ด์ง๋ง, ํต์ผ๋ ํ์คํ๋ฅผ ๋ฐ๋ฅด๋ ๊ฒ์๋ ์๋์ ์ผ๋ก ์ผ๊ด์ฑ์ด ๋ถ์กฑํ๋ค. ์๋ฅผ ๋ค์ด, ๋ฐ๋ฆฌ
์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ37
, ๋๋ก๋ฏธ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ38
, ๊ทธ๋ฆฌ๊ณ ๋ฆฐ์ฒธ ์๋ฝ39
๊ฐ ๊ทธ๋ฐ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ๋ค์ ์ผ๋ถ์๊ณ , ์ฌ๊บ ๋นค๋ํ ๋ฒ์ญ ๊ทธ๋ฃน์ด
์ํด์๋ ์ฌ๊บํ์์ ์ถ์๋๋ ์ธ ๋ช ์ ์๋ํ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ์ด๋ค.
14์ธ๊ธฐ ์ดํ์ ๋ถ๊ต๋ ์ธ๋ ์๋๋ฅ์์ ๋๋ถ๋ถ ์ฌ๋ผ์ก๊ณ , ๋ฒ์ด ๋ณธ๋ฌธ์ด ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด๋ก ๋ ์ด์ ๋ฒ์ญ๋์ง
์์๋ค. ์ด ํฉ 5250 ๋ณธ๋ฌธ๊ณผ 230,000 ๊ฐ์ ๊ฒฝ์ ๋ฑ์ฅ์ด ๋ฒ์ด์์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด๋ก ๋ฒ์ญ๋์๋ค. 870์ฌ๋ช
์ด์์ ๋ฒ์ญ๊ฐ์ ๊ตํ์๋ค์ด ๊ด์ฌํ์๊ณ , ๊ทธ๋ค์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๋ฌผ์ ํ๋ ์ญ์ฌ๊ฐ๋ค์ด ํ์ํธ์ ์ ๋ฌธ์ฉ์ด, ๊ทธ๋ฆฌ๊ณ
์ผ๊ด์ฑ์ ์์ด์ ๊ฑธ์์ด๋ผ๊ณ ์ฐฌํํ๊ณ ์๋ค.40
37 Ba ri lo tsA wa(1040-1111), Rinchen Drak (rin chen grags)์ด๋ผ๊ณ ๋ ๋ถ๋ฆฐ๋ค.38 Brog mi shakya ye shes (994-1078).39 Rin chen bzang po (958-1055).40 http://www.thlib.org/encyclopedias/literary/canons/about/wiki/tibetan%20canons%20introduction.html. Roberta Paine, โThe Translator inTibetan History: Identity and Influence.โ Forum 8.2 (2010): 133-161 ๋ํ ๋ณด๋ผ.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
29/39
29 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ฅ๊ฒฝ ๋ฒ์ญ์ ๋ ํนํ ํน์
๋ฒ์ด์์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด๋ก์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ์, ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด๊ฐ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ-๋ฒ๋ง ์ด์กฑ์ ์ํด ๊ทธ ๋ ๊ฐ์ ์ธ์ด๊ฐ ์ง์ ์ ์ธ
์ธ์ด์ ์ธ ๊ณํต์ ์ํ์ง ์์์๋ ๋ถ๊ตฌํ๊ณ , ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ฌ๋๋ค์ด ๋ฒ์ด์ ๊ธฐ๋ฐ์ ๋ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ธ์ด ์ฒด๊ณ๋ฅผ
๊ตฌ์ถํ์๊ธฐ ๋๋ฌธ์ ๋ ํนํ ํน์์ ๊ฐ์ง๊ณ ์๋ค. ์ด์จ๋ ๋ฒ์ด๋ ๋ถ๊ต ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด๋ก ์ญ๊ฒฝํ๊ธฐ์ํ
์ฒ๋๋ก์ ์ ํ๋์๋ค.41
๋ฌธ๋ฒํ์๋ค์ ๋ฒ์ด์ ๋ช ์ฌ ๊ฒฉ๋ณํ, ํต์ด๋ก , ๊ทธ๋ฆฌ๊ณ ๋์ฌ ํ์ฉโ๋น๋ก
๋จ์ํ๋์์ง๋งโ์ ๋ ์ฆ๋ฅผ ํตํด ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด๋ฅผ ๊ฐ๋ ์ ์ผ๋ก ํด์ํ๋ ค ๋ ธ๋ ฅํ์ ๋ฟ๋ง ์๋๋ผ, ์๋ฆฝ ์์ํ๋ ๋จ์ด ์ ํ๊ณผ ๋ฒ์ญ ๋ฌธ์ฒด๋ฅผ ๊ณ ๋๋ก ์ฒด๊ณํํ์๋ค. ํ์คํ๋ ์๋ง ์ญ๊ฒฝ์ ๊ฐ์ฅ ์ค์ํ ํน์์ด
๋์๊ณ , ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด๊ฐ ๋ฒ์ด์ ์ธ์์ ์ธ ์ ์ฌํจ์ ๊ฐ์ง๊ฒ ๋ ๊ฒ์ ๋ฒ์ญ์ ์ฉ์ดํ๊ฒ ๋ง๋ค๊ณ , ๊ณ ๋์
์ ํ์ฑ์ ๊ฐ์ง ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ๋ฒ์ญํด ๋ผ ์ ์๊ฒ ํ๋ ๋ฐ๊ฑฐ๋ฆ์ด ๋์๋ค.42
๋ก์ง์-๋นค๋๋ฐ
๊ฒฝ์ ์ ํ์ง(ๅ่จ)์์ ์ ์ ์๋ฏ์ด, ๋ฒ์ญ์ ๋๋ถ๋ถ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋ฒ์ญ๊ฐ๋ค๊ณผ ์ธ๋ ํ์์ ํ๋ ฅ์ ์ํด
ํํด์ก๊ณ , ์ด ์์์ ๋ก์ง์-๋นค๋๋ฐ(lotsawa-paแนแธ ita)๋ผ๋ ์ด๋ฆ์ ์ป๊ฒ ๋์๋ค. ๋นค๋๋ฐ๋ผ๋ ๋ฒ์ด๋ ๋ฌธ๋ฒํ,
๋ ผ๋ฆฌํ, ์ํ, ์์ , ๊ทธ๋ฆฌ๊ณ ์ฒ ํ์ด๋ผ๋ ๋ค์ฏ ํ๋ฌธ์ ํต๋ฌํ ์ด๋ฅผ ์ง์ํ๋ค. ๋ก์ง์๋ผ๋ ๋ช ์นญ์ ๋ฒ์ด
๊ฒฝ์ ์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด๋ก ์ญ๊ฒฝํ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋ณธํ ์ธ์ ๋์ฌ ๋ถ๋ฅด๋ ์ฉ์ด์ด๋ค. ๊ทธ๋ค ์ค ์ผ๋ถ๋ ์ธ๋ ํน์ ํ๋ง๋ผ์ผ
๊ตญ๊ฒฝ์ ์ฌํํ๊ณ ์ธ๋ ๋นค๋๋ฐ์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ๋ก ๋์์ ๊ฑด๊ฐ๊ณผ ์ฌ์ฐ, ๋ ธ๊ณ ๋ฅผ ํฌ์ํ์ฌ ์ญ๊ฒฝํ์๋ค. ๋ค๋ฅธ ๋
๊ฐ์ง ๋ฅ๋ ฅ์ ๊ฐ์ง ์ง๋จ์ ํ๋์ ์ธ ๋ ธ๋ ฅ์ด ๋งค์ฐ ์ฑ๊ณต์ ์ด๋ผ๋ ๊ฒ์ด ์ฆ๋ช ๋จ์ ๋ฐ๋ผ, ์ฐ๋ฆฌ ๋ฒ์ญ ํ์
ํฌํจํ ์ค๋๋ ์๋ง์ ๋ฒ์ญ๊ฐ๋ค์ด ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ์์ด๋ก ์ญ๊ฒฝํ ๋ ๋ก์ง์-๋นค๋๋ฐ ์์์ ๋ณธ๋จ๊ณ ์๋ค.
๋ฒ์ญ๋๊ตฌ- hฤvyutp tti ้ฃ่ญฏๅ็พฉๅคง้๊ณผ dhy vyutp tti้ฃ่ญฏๅ็พฉไธญ้
๋ฒ์ด ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋ฒ์ญ์ ์ฉ์ด ์ ํ์ ์์ด ๊ณ ๋์ ์ผ๊ด์ฑ์ ๋ณด์ฌ์ค๋ค. ์ด๊ฒ์ ์ฉ์ด์ ํ์คํ์
ํฌ์ํ ๋ ธ๋ ฅ์ ๊ฒฐ๊ณผ์ด๋ค. ์ด๊ฒ์ ๋ฒ์ญ๋ช ์๋์ง๊ณผ ๋ฒ์ญ๋ช ์์ค์ง, ๊ทธ๋ฆฌ๊ณ ๊ทธ์ ์ ์ฌํ ๋ณธ๋ฌธ์ ์
๋ถ๋ฅยท์ ๋ฆฌ๋์ด ์๋ค. ๋ฒ์ญ๋ช ์๋์ง(bye brag tu rtogs pa chen po)์ ๋ฒ์ด์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด์ ์ฉ์ด๋ฅผ ๋น๊ตยท์ฐธ์กฐํ
์์ ์ผ๋ก ๋ฌด๋ ค 10,000 ํ์ ์ด๊ฐ ์๋ก๋์ด ์์ผ๋ฉฐ, ์ค๋๋ ์ ํ์๋ค๋ ์ฌ์ ํ ์ฌ์ฉํ๊ณ ์๋ค. ๊ทธ๊ฒ๊ณผ
์ฐ๊ด๋ ๋ฒ์ญ๋ช ์์ค์ง(sgra sbyor bam gynis)์ ๋ฒ์ญ๊ธฐ๋ฒ์ ์ธ๋ถ์ ์ธ ๋ด์ฉ์ ์ ๊ณตํ๋ค. ์ด ๋ ๊ถ์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ
์ด๋ก ๋ถ๊ต ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ํ์คํ๋ ๋ฒ์ญ์ ์ํด์ ํฐ๋ฐ ์ก์ฉฌ์( Khri lde srong btsan, ์ฌ์ 799-815๋ )์
๋ช ๋ น์ผ๋ก ์ฝ 814๋ โ์ฆ, ์ฒซ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ธฐ ๋์โ์ ์์ฑ๋์๋ค. ์ด ์ฑ ๋ค์ ์ฒ ์๋ฒ๊ณผ ๋ฌธ๋ฒ, ๊ทธ๋ฆฌ๊ณ ์ญ๊ฒฝ ๊ท์น์ ๋ฌธ์ ๋ค์ ํด๊ฒฐํ์๊ณ , ๋ฐ๋ผ์ ๋ถ๊ต ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝํ๋๋ฐ ์๋นํ ์ผ๊ด์ฑ ์๊ณ ํ์ค์ ์ธ ์ธ์ด๋ฅผ ๊ตฌ์ฌํ๋๋ฐ
์ค์ฌ์ ์ธ ์ญํ ์ ํ์๋ค. ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด ํ์์ ์ค๋๋ ์ฌ์ ํ ์ด ๊ฐ๋ก ์๋ฅผ ์ฐธ์กฐํ๋ค.43
2014๋ 10์์
๊ฐ์ต๋ ์ง๋๋ผ ๋ฒ์ธ์ โ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ณผ ์ ์นTranslation and Transmissionโ์ด๋ผ๋ ํ ์ต๊ทผ์ ํํ์ ์ฐ์ค์์ ํผํฐ
์คํฌ๋ง ๋ฐ์ฌ๋ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ๋ค์๊ฒ ๋ฒ์ญ๋ช ์๋์ง์ ์ฃผ์ ๊น๊ฒ ๊ณต๋ถํ๊ธฐ๋ฅผ ๊ถ์ฅํ์๋ค. ๊ทธ๋ ์ด ์ฑ ๋ค์ ๋ํ
์ธ๋ฏธ๋์์๋ ๊ฐ๋ฅด์น ๊ฒ์ ๊ถ์ฅํ์๋ค.44
ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด๊ธฐ ์ญ๊ฒฝ์ฌ์์ ์์ค์ ๊ฐ๋ ๊ณผ๋ ๋ณ๊ฐ๋ก ํ์คํ๋ ์ธ์ด๋ฅผ ์ฉ์ดํ๊ฒ ๊ณ ์ํ ์ ์์๋ ๋ ๋ค๋ฅธ
์์๋, ์ค๊ตญ๊ณผ๋ ๋ฌ๋ฆฌ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ์์๋ ๋ถ๊ต์ ๋ณด๊ธ ์ด์ ์ ์ ๋ฐ๋ฌ๋ ์ฒ ํ ์ ํต์ด ์์๋ ๊ฒ์ด๋ค. ๋ฐ๋ผ์
๋ฒ์ญ๊ฐ๋ค์ ๋ค๋ฅธ ๋ฌธ๋งฅ์์ ์คํด์ ์ฌ์ง๊ฐ ์ ์ ๋ฒ์ด ํํ์ ํด๋น๋๋ ๊ธฐ์ ์ ์ฉ์ด๋ค์ ๋ง๋ค์ด ๋ผ ์
์์๋ค. ๋ฐ๋ผ์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๊ฒฝ์ ๋ค์ ๋น๋ก ์ง์ญ(้่ช่ญฏ)์ด๊ณ , ์ผ๋ง๊ฐ ์กฐ๋ฐํ๊ณ ๋ถ์์ฐ์ค๋ฝ์ง๋ง, ๋ฒ์ด ์์ ์
41 ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋ฌธ๋ฒ ๊ฒฝ์ ๊ณผ ๋ณธ๋ฌธ๋ค์ 7์ธ๊ธฐ์ ๋ง๋ค์ด์ก๋ค๊ณ ํ๋ค. Songtsen Gampo (srong btsan sgam po)์์ ์ง๋ ์๋ ๋ฌธ๋ฒํ์์ด์
๊ตํ์์ธ Tonmi Sambhota (thon mi sam bho ta)๋ ์จ์ญ๋น ์ ๋ฑ๊ธฐ์ฃฝ๋น (rtags kyi โjug pa)๋ผ๋ ๋ฌธ๋ฒ์ฑ ์ ๋ง๋ ์ ์๋ผ๊ณ ์ ํต์ ์ผ๋ก ์๋ ค์ ธ์๋ค.42 Stephan Beyer, The Classical Tibetan Language, (New York: State University of New York, 1992/ Delhi: Sri Satguru Publications, 1993)์
์ฐธ์กฐํ๋ผ.43 David Weldon, โGuardians of the Sacred Word,โ accessed Oct 10, 2014. http://www.asianart.com/exhibitions/covers/intro. html.44 Peter Skillings, โDr. Peter Skillingโs address to the conference,โ http://translationandtransmission.org/videos.html.
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
30/39
30 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
ํํํ๋๋ฐ ์๋์ ์ผ๋ก ์ ๋ขฐ์ฑ์ด ๋๋ค๊ณ ์ฌ๊ฒจ์ง๋ค. ๊ทธ๊ฒ๋ค์ ๋ํ ์ ์ค๋ ๋ฒ์ด ๊ฒฝ์ ๋ค์ ์ฌ๊ตฌ์ฑํ๋๋ฐ
๋งค์ฐ ๊ท์คํ ์๋ฃ์์ด ์ฆ๋ช ๋์๋ค.45
์ธ์ด ๊ฐํ
๋ ์ญ๊ฒฝ ๊ธฐ๊ฐ ๋์์, ์ธ ๋ฒ์ ์ฃผ์ํ ์ธ์ด ๊ฐํ(skad gsar bcad)์ด ์์๋ค. ์ด ๊ฐํ๊ธฐ ๋์ ์๋ง์
์ฉ์ด๋ค์ด โ่่ญฏ(brda rnying )โ์ผ๋ก ๋ถ๋ฅ๋์๊ณ , ์๋ก์ด ์ฉ์ด๋ค์ ์ํด ๊ต์ฒด๋์๋ค. ์ด ๊ฐ์ ๋ค์ ํ์คํ๋ ์ฒ ์๋ฒ๊ณผ ๋จ์ด, ๋ฌธ๋ฒ์ ํ๋ฆฝํ๋ ์๋จ์ด ๋์๋ค. ๋ง์ง๋ง ๊ฐํ์ 10์ธ๊ธฐ์ ํํด์ก๋ค. ๋ฌธ์ด(ๆ่ช)๋ ์ด
์๊ฐ ์ดํ๋ก ๋ค์๊ฐ์ ๊ณ ์ฐฉํ๋์๋ค.46
์ด ๊ฐ์ ๊ฐ๊ฐ์ ๊ธฐ๊ฐ์ ์ค๋๋, ์กด์ํ๋ ๋ฒ์ญ๋ค์ ์๋ก์ด
ํ์ค์ผ๋ก ๊ฐฑ์ ๋์๋ค.
ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ
์ด์์
์์ด๋ก์
์ญ๊ฒฝ
์ง๊ธ์ผ๋ก๋ถํฐ 500์ฌ ๋ ์ ์ ์๊ฐ์ผ๋ก ๊ฑฐ์ฌ๋ฌ ์ฌ๋ผ๊ฐ๋ฉด, ๋ฒ์ญ๊ฐ๋ค์ ์ํฉ์ ์์ฃผ ๋ค๋ฅด๊ฒ ๋ณด์ธ๋ค. ์ฒซ
๋ฒ์งธ๋ก ์ฃผ์งํด์ผํ ์ฌํญ์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋ถ๊ต ๊ฒฝ์ ์ ์์ด(๋๋ ๋ค๋ฅธ ์ ๋ฝ ์ธ์ด)๋ก ์ญ๊ฒฝํ ์ญ์ฌ๋ ์ค๋๋์ง
์์๋ค๋ ๊ฒ์ด๋ค. ์ฝ๋ก๋ผ๋ ํค์คํค์ ์ง๋๋ผ ํํ์์ ์ง๋๋ผ ์ค๋ฆฝ์ ์๋ฆญ ์ฝ๋กฌ๋ฒจ์ ํ๋์ค ํ๋ฆฌ์์
๋ฏธ์ํ ํ์์ผ๋ก์์ ๊ฒฝํ์ ๊ณต์ ํ๋ค. ๊ฑฐ๊ธฐ์๋ ๋ถ์ด๋ก ๋ฒ์ญ๋ ์ฑ ์ด ๋จ์ง ๋๊ฐ ์์๋๋ฐ ์์ฃผ ์ดํดํ๊ธฐ
์ด๋ ค์ ๋ค๊ณ ํ๋ค. ์ด์จ๋ , ์์ ์ธ๊ณ์ ์ธ๋-ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋ถ๊ต์ ๋ํ ๊ด์ฌ์ 19์ธ๊ธฐ์ ๋ช๋ช์ ์ธ๋ํ์์
ํฐ๋ฒ ํธํ์์ ๋น์ถํ์ผ๋ก๋ถํฐ 150๋ ํ ์ผ๋ฐ์ ์ธ ์ฃผ๋ฅ ํ์์ผ๋ก ๊ธ๊ฒฉํ ์ง์ ๋์๋ค. ๊ตฌ์ญ ๊ฒฝ์ ๋ค์
์๋ฏผ์ฃผ์์์ ๊ธฐ๋ ๊ต ์ ๊ต์ฌ ํน์ ์ต ์ฌ๋ฆฌํ์ ์ถ์ข ์์ ๊ฐ์ ๋ถ๊ต๋ฌธํ์ ๊ต๋ฅ๋ฅผ ์ฆ์งํด๊ฐ๋ ํน์
๋จ์ฒด์ ์ํฅ์ ์ข ์ข ๋ณด์ฌ ์๋ค.47
์ ๋์ ์ธ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋ถ๊ต์ ์ค์น๋ค์ ํ์ฌ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ์ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋ง๋ช ์ฌํ์ ์ฌํ์ ์ด๊ณ ์ ์น์ ์ธ ์ํฉ์์
ํ ๋ ์ธ๋์ ์๊ฐ ์์ ์์ ํ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ด์ ๊ทธ ๋ด์ฉ์ ์ถฉ๋ถํ ์ดํดํ ์ ์๋ ์ฌ๋์ด ์์ฃผ ์ ์ด์ง
๊ฒ์ด๋ผ๋ ์ค์ง์ ์ธ ์๊ธฐ๋ฅผ ์ธ์งํ์๋ค.
์ด ์๊ธฐ์ ๋ํ ์ฆ๊ฐ๋๋ ์ธ์์ 84000 ํ๋ก์ ํธ์ ์๊ธ์ง์๋ฟ๋ง ์๋๋ผ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋ถ๊ต ๋ฌธํ ์ ์ฐ์
๋ณธ์กด๊ณผ ๊ด๊ณ๋ ์ฌ์ ์ผ๋ก ์ด์ด์ก๋ค:
2008 Light of Berotsana, Colorado, USA: http://www.berotsana.org/conference-of-translators/
2009 BLHP/ 84000, Bir, India: http://84000.co/about/origin/ , previously mentioned
2011 Tengyur Translation, Sarnath, India: http://www.aibs.columbia.edu/conference.html
2014 June: Translation Conference and Workshop at University of Vienna, Austria: http://buddhism.tibetan-translation.com/2014/05/translating-and-transferring-buddhist.html
2014 October: Translation and Transmission Conference in Keystone, Colorado, USA:http://translationandtransmission.org/index.html
๋ฒ์ญ ์
์ข ๋ฅ
์ด ์ญ๊ฒฝ์ฌ์ ์ ์ฐธ์ฌํ๋ ์ฌ๋๋ค์ ๋๊ตฌ์ธ๊ฐ? ์ญ๊ฒฝ์ ์ข ์ฌํ๋ ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ์ค์น๋ค๊ณผ๋ ๋ณ๊ฐ๋ก, ๊ทธ๋ค์ ์ฃผ๋ก
ํฐ๋ฒ ํธ ๋ถ๊ต์ ๋ฌธํ์ ์ด๊ณ ์ธ์ด์ ์ผ๋ก ํน๋ณํ ๊ด๊ณ๊ฐ ์๋ ์ ๋ฝ๊ณผ ๋ฏธ๊ตญ์ ๋จ์ฑ๊ณผ ์ฌ์ฑ๋ค์ด๋ค.
45 Roberta Raine, โTranslating the Tibetan Buddhist Canon: Past Strategies, Future Prospects,โ Forum 9.2 (2011): 157-186.46 Jamgon Kongtrul ('jam mgon kong sprul blo gros mtha' yas), Treasury of Knowledge, Buddhism's Journey to Tibet, (Ithaca, NY: Snow Lion
Publication, 2010), 220.47 Roberta Paine์ H. Kernโs translation์ ๋ฒ์ญ์ ์์ด์ ์ ํ์ ์ธ ๊ธฐ๋ ๊ต ์ํฅ์ ๋ฐ์ ๊ฒ์ด๋ผ๊ณ ์ธ๊ธํ๋ค (in โThe Translator in TibetanHistory: Identity and Influence.โ Forum 8.2 (2010): 133 -161). ์ตํํ์ ์ํฅ์ ์๋ฅผ ๋ค์ด Evans-Wentz, W. Y., Tibetan Book of the Dead :ํน์, The After-Death Experiences on the Bardo Plane, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1927์์ ๋ณผ ์ ์๋ค. ์ด๊ฒ์ ์นผ ์ต์ ์ฌ๋ฆฌํ์ ์ฃผ์์
ํฌํจํ๊ณ ์๋ค.
http://www.berotsana.org/conference-of-translators/http://84000.co/about/origin/http://www.aibs.columbia.edu/conference.htmlhttp://buddhism.tibetan-translation.com/2014/05/translating-and-transferring-buddhist.htmlhttp://buddhism.tibetan-translation.com/2014/05/translating-and-transferring-buddhist.htmlhttp://translationandtransmission.org/index.htmlhttp://translationandtransmission.org/index.htmlhttp://buddhism.tibetan-translation.com/2014/05/translating-and-transferring-buddhist.htmlhttp://buddhism.tibetan-translation.com/2014/05/translating-and-transferring-buddhist.htmlhttp://www.aibs.columbia.edu/conference.htmlhttp://84000.co/about/origin/http://www.berotsana.org/conference-of-translators/
-
8/9/2019 JStenzel-SPTG presentation-with Korean.pdf
31/39
31 | J u l i a S t e n z e l , T h e S a k y a P a n d i t a T r a n s l a t i o n G r o u p
200์ฌ๋ช ์ ๋ค๋ฅธ ์ฐธ์ฌ์๋ค๊ณผ ํจ๊ป ์ฐธ์ํ ์ต๊ทผ์ ๊ทธ ํํ์์ ์ ์ ๋ฒ์ญ๊ฐ์ธ ์ธ์คํ ํ๋ ์ณ์ ๋ค๋ฅธ
์ด๋ค์ ๋ ๊ฐ์ง ์ข ๋ฅ์ ์ญ๊ฒฝ๊ฐ๋ค์ ๊ตฌ๋ถ์ ๊ดํด ๋ ผ์ํ์๋ค.
๋ถ๊ต ์ํ์ ํต์ญ ์ ๋ฒ์ญ ๏ฟฝ