justin mezetin and meredith massey nchs questionnaire design research laboratory fedcasic 2014:...

29
THE Q-SUITE: Q- BANK AND Q-NOTES Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Upload: elinor-julianna-thornton

Post on 18-Dec-2015

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

THE Q-SUITE: Q-BANK AND Q-NOTES

Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey

NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory

FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods

March 19, 2014

Page 2: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Outline

Introduction Analytical Framework Q-Notes: Qualitative Analysis software Q-Bank: Question Evaluation library and

resource Next Steps

Page 3: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Introduction

What is cognitive interviewing/question evaluation?

Benefits of Cognitive Interviewing

Validity studies showing all phenomena the question is capturing

Page 4: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Analytical Framework

Page 5: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Background Challenges

Time consuming to conduct a thorough analysis

Larger sample sizes (N > 20)Multiple projects with over 100-150 interviews

CollaborationMultiple Interview LocationsResearchers with varying levels of

experienceTesting in Multiple Languages

Page 6: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Q-NOTES: ANALYSIS

SOFTWARE

Page 7: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Level One: Conducting Interviews Interview guide Consistency Pre-selected

Themes Multiple Languages Raw data storage

Page 8: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Interview Guide

Page 9: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Question Translation

Page 10: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Level Two: Summarizing Interview Notes Synthesizing raw

data Tagged videos Researcher

collaboration Viewing data for a

single respondent

Page 11: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Summarizing Interview Notes

Page 12: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Level Three: Comparing Across Respondents Developing thematic

schema Project level themes Question level

themes Flexibility Consistency across

coders Cross interview

comparison

Page 13: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Viewing one question across all respondents

Page 14: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Level Four: Comparing Across Groups Development of

Advanced Schema Sub-group analysis Comparative

analysis

Page 15: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Subgroup Analysis

Page 16: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Subgroup Analysis Results

Page 17: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Comparative Analysis

Page 18: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Level Five: Drawing Conclusions

Report template Summary tables Thematic schema

Page 19: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Report Template

Page 20: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Q-BANK: DISSEMINATING

FINDINGS

Page 21: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Q-Bank Users

Data Analysts Questionnaire Designers Survey Methodologists Survey Managers

Page 22: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Q-Bank Benefits

Deeper understanding of what survey variables are capturing

Share/view findings from studies conducted at other organizations

Resource to learn more and dialog about Question Evaluation

Mechanism to compare different methods and findings

Page 23: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Searching Q-Bank

Page 24: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Q-Bank Search Results

Page 25: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Question Selection

Page 26: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Question Details

Page 27: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Q-Suite Features

Collaboration Consistency Transparency

Q-Notes: Qualitative Analysis Software Q-Bank:

Library of Evaluation studiesResource on Question Evaluation

Page 28: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Q-Suite Next Steps

Q-NotesRun a public beta test Summer 2014*Export feature to submit into Q-Bank

Q-BankContinue increasing content Inclusion of all methods in Q-BankPilot test with NHIS to link key variables to

Q-Bank testing reports

Page 29: Justin Mezetin and Meredith Massey NCHS Questionnaire Design Research Laboratory FedCASIC 2014: Survey Evaluation Methods March 19, 2014

Questions or Feedback?

Contact Us:[email protected]

Visit:www.cdc.gov/QBankwww.cdc.gov/QNotes