karl popper, - stanford university · thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is,...

16
eprinted for private circulation from sophy of Karl Popper, ed. Library of Congress Card Number: 76-186983 N Number: Vol. II 0-87548-141-8 pen Court Publishing Co., 0 B974 he Library o

Upload: others

Post on 24-Mar-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,

eprinted for private circulation from sophy of Karl Popper, ed.

Library of Congress Card Number: 76-1 86983 N Number: Vol. II 0-87548-141-8

pen Court Publishing Co., 0 B974 he Library o

Page 2: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,

24

Page 3: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,
Page 4: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,

2

Page 5: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,

ly when very strong princ~ples of

. . . mere possibilities could never give rise to any prediction. I t is possible, , that an earthquake will destroy tomorrow all the houses 3th parallels north and south (and no other houses). Nobo e this possibility, but most people would estimate it as exce

ingly small; and whlle t e sheer possibility as such does not give rise to any prediction, the estimate t at it is exceedingly small may be made the

e event described will not take place ('"in

P

Page 6: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,

Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~ r o b a ~ ~ ~ ~ t y attached to it -has always a predictive function, w we should hardly an event upon being told no more than that event is possible. r words, we do not assume that a possibility as such has any ten o realise itself; but we do interpret probability measures, or “weights” attributed to the possibility, as measenri position, or tendency, or propensity to realise itself; . . .

ere is not a large one. possible GaSeS is a fu

Eet us now ta

Page 7: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,
Page 8: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,
Page 9: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,

physical hypothesis (or perhaps a met hypothesis s f ~ ~ w t o n i a n forces. It is

tal a ~ ~ a ~ g e ~ e ~ t (and therefore every state sf a

Page 10: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,

768

thesis in contrast to

between the relative- frequency and propensity interpretations. Indeed, B have fou to try to infer what formal properties the p ~ o p e n s ~ ~ y inte supposed to have from consideration of the two-slit experiment.

e situation as I see it in three points. Popper says about the use of probability in quan-

tum mechanics and the way he has used t ea of propensity to say these things seem eminently sensible to me.

2. I find the systematic case for the propensity ~n~erpretation ba

equacy of the subjective interpretation stand in sharp contrast, however, to

turn Mechanics a s ' a Statistical Theory *

the general bibliography. H agree with y about q ~ a n t ~ ~ mechanics as a statistic

lattice. It is not the result that is so

Page 11: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,
Page 12: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,

eterminism so

Page 13: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,
Page 14: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,

772

and so by Fourier inversion

As is well known in robability theory not every c aracteristic func- tion determines a pro er probability distribution, and this is the di with (4). (The expre sion given by (4) for the joint density was first proposed by Wigner [ 19321 and the derivation just sketched follows Moya1 [ f9491 .’)

ket us now look at a simple ex harmonic oscillator in the

and the time-indepen ent wave equation is

tion in terms of Hermite polynoarpiahs is familiar lowest energy state

U S

ensity with mean zero an variance u2 = I/2a2

We now apply (4) and ( 5 ) to obtain the joint turn and position. For c venience of cakulatio propagation vector k = p We have at once:

Page 15: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,
Page 16: Karl Popper, - Stanford University · Thus the estimate of the measure of a psssibdity- that is, the estimate of the ~roba~~~~ty attached to it -has always a predictive function,