kathryn horn, [email protected] dr. carole emberton ... · “the roots of tourism at gettysburg:...

1
www.buffalo.edu Research Questions •What purpose can the site serve now? Can contemporary issues of race and war be addressed? •How can visitors be better educated when they visit? In his 1863 “Gettysburg Address,” President Abraham Lincoln stated, “The brave men, living and dead, who struggled here, have consecrated it, far above our poor power to add or detract. The world will little note, nor long remember what we say here, but it can never forget what they did here.”[1] President Lincoln envisioned the Gettysburg battlefield becoming a sacred place where American citizens could reflect on the importance of the American Civil War, and never forget the blood sacrifice that 51,000 men made there. Instead, Gettysburg has evolved from sanctified ground, into a place for amusement, entertainment, and commercial opportunities. People visit Gettysburg as tourists seeking an amusing and entertaining experience, not necessarily to learn the comprehensive history of the Civil War or reflect on the sacrifices the nation made to end the bondage of African Americans. It is the tension between history, education, and entertainment that my project seeks to explore. My research has focused on the transformation of the Gettysburg battlefield into a tourist destination. In order to have a better understanding of what the battlefield has become, I traveled to Gettysburg. At the Gettysburg National Military Park, I conducted research at the research center and also explored the well know battlefield. From my research I can conclude that Gettysburg transformed into a tourist site during the late 19th century. [1] Abraham Lincoln, “The Gettysburg Address,” in Abraham Lincoln, Slavery, and the Civil War, ed. Michael P. Johnson (Boston: Bedford/ St. Martin’s, 2011), 161. The Roots of Tourism at Gettysburg: 1863- 1913” Kathryn Horn, [email protected] Dr. Carole Emberton, Faculty Mentor, Department of History Future Research Questions Tipton Image 4231: Trolley Devils Den 1896, courtesy of Gettysburg National Military Park Abstract When did the Gettysburg battlefield become a place where people visit? When did the tension between preservationists and those who supported commercial endeavors develop at Gettysburg? Timeline of Gettysburg Battlefield: 1863- 1913 Methods This project could not have been completed with out the support of CURCA. I would like to thank the history department, and my advisor Dr. Emberton. I also want to thank the National Park Service’s employees and volunteers for their assistance at the GNMP. Further research questions developed from a conference I attended, “The Future of Civil War History: Looking Beyond the 150 th ,” held at Gettysburg College March 14 th - 16 th , 2013. July 1- 3, 1863: Battle of Gettysburg November 19, 1863:Gettysburg National Cemetery dedicated by President Abraham Lincoln April 1864- February 1895: Early preservation efforts by the Gettysburg Battlefield Memorial Association, Veterans create a heroic rhetoric on the battlefield February 1895: Creation of Gettysburg National Military Park, Federal Government in charge of preservation July 1-3, 1913: 50 th Anniversary, Grand Reunion “Gettysburg Cyclorama” For my project, I analyzed both primary and secondary documents. At the Gettysburg National Military Park research center, I looked at unpublished documents that related to the creation of the park, early visitor accounts, and amusements found on the site in the late nineteenth century. People began to visit the battlefield after the battle concluded. These people came to pay their respect to the men who died there, but as reconciliation between northerners and southerners began, the battlefield become more than just a place to remember those who perished there. Veterans held reunions, and brought their families. The battle itself interested people, and many came to explore and learn about Gettysburg. The town profited from these visitors and many businesses capitalized on the increase in visitation. For example, the Gettysburg Battlefield Trolley and the Gettysburg Cyclorama were amusements that private companies founded in the late nineteenth century. Image of Kathryn Horn, March 2013 “Battlefield Trolley Lines” Tipton Image 3242: courtesy of Gettysburg National Military Park “Battlefield Trolley” Image of Kathryn Horn, March 2013 Literature Linenthal, Edward Tabor. Sacred Ground: Americans and Their Battlefields. Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 1993. Weeks, Jim. Gettysburg: Memory, Market, and an American Shrine. United States: Princeton University Press, 2003. Image Copied from Gettysburg National Military Park, Vertical File 9-RR8 Advertisement for the battlefield trolley. For fifteen cents more a visitor could be given a guided tour of the battlefield. A ticket for the Gettysburg Cyclorama. There were four cycloramas that traveled to U.S. cities in the late 19 th century. One can still view an original at the Gettysburg National Military Park Museum and Visitor Center. Image Copied from Gettysburg National Military Park, Vertical File 11-46-A Conclusions President Lincoln imagined Gettysburg becoming a sanctified ground, where no one could create a new meaning of the battle. However, Civil War veterans did alter the remembrance of Gettysburg and of the war. They understood that their memories would become what would be remembered, and could choose what would not be remembered on the site. The appealing memories constructed by veterans transformed the Gettysburg battlefield from a place of blood ridden ground, into a site of valor and amusement. In the post war years, Gettysburg did not become a place to reflect on the important implications of the American Civil War. These constructed memories made the site more than just a place for memorialization, but also a place for consumption by the general population.

Upload: phungtuyen

Post on 17-Jul-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Kathryn Horn, kdhorn@buffalo.edu Dr. Carole Emberton ... · “The Roots of Tourism at Gettysburg: 1863- 1913” Kathryn Horn, kdhorn@buffalo.edu Dr. Carole Emberton, Faculty Mentor,

www.buffalo.edu

About this template Abstract Text Sizes Research Questions Importing Photographs

•What purpose can the site serve now? Can

contemporary issues of race and war be addressed?

•How can visitors be better educated when they visit?

Early Amusements Importing Tables & Graphs

In his 1863 “Gettysburg Address,” President Abraham

Lincoln stated, “The brave men, living and dead, who

struggled here, have consecrated it, far above our poor

power to add or detract. The world will little note, nor long

remember what we say here, but it can never forget what

they did here.”[1] President Lincoln envisioned the

Gettysburg battlefield becoming a sacred place where

American citizens could reflect on the importance of the

American Civil War, and never forget the blood sacrifice that

51,000 men made there. Instead, Gettysburg has evolved

from sanctified ground, into a place for amusement,

entertainment, and commercial opportunities. People visit

Gettysburg as tourists seeking an amusing and entertaining

experience, not necessarily to learn the comprehensive

history of the Civil War or reflect on the sacrifices the nation

made to end the bondage of African Americans. It is the

tension between history, education, and entertainment that

my project seeks to explore.

My research has focused on the transformation of the

Gettysburg battlefield into a tourist destination. In order to

have a better understanding of what the battlefield has

become, I traveled to Gettysburg. At the Gettysburg

National Military Park, I conducted research at the research

center and also explored the well know battlefield. From my

research I can conclude that Gettysburg transformed into a

tourist site during the late 19th century.

[1] Abraham Lincoln, “The Gettysburg Address,” in Abraham Lincoln, Slavery,

and the Civil War, ed. Michael P. Johnson (Boston: Bedford/ St. Martin’s,

2011), 161.

“The Roots of Tourism at Gettysburg: 1863- 1913”

Kathryn Horn, [email protected]

Dr. Carole Emberton, Faculty Mentor, Department of History

Future Research Questions

Tipton Image 4231: Trolley Devils Den 1896, courtesy of Gettysburg

National Military Park

Abstract

When did the Gettysburg battlefield

become a place where people visit?

When did the tension between

preservationists and those who supported

commercial endeavors develop at

Gettysburg?

Timeline of Gettysburg Battlefield:

1863- 1913

Methods

This project could not have been completed with out the

support of CURCA. I would like to thank the history

department, and my advisor Dr. Emberton. I also want to

thank the National Park Service’s employees and

volunteers for their assistance at the GNMP. Further

research questions developed from a conference I

attended, “The Future of Civil War History: Looking

Beyond the 150th,” held at Gettysburg College March 14th -

16th, 2013.

July 1- 3, 1863: Battle of Gettysburg

November 19, 1863:Gettysburg National

Cemetery dedicated by President Abraham

Lincoln

April 1864- February 1895: Early preservation

efforts by the Gettysburg Battlefield Memorial

Association, Veterans create a heroic rhetoric on

the battlefield

February 1895: Creation of Gettysburg National

Military Park, Federal Government in charge of

preservation

July 1-3, 1913: 50th Anniversary, Grand Reunion

“Gettysburg Cyclorama”

For my project, I analyzed both primary and

secondary documents. At the Gettysburg National

Military Park research center, I looked at

unpublished documents that related to the creation

of the park, early visitor accounts, and amusements

found on the site in the late nineteenth century.

People began to visit the battlefield after the

battle concluded. These people came to pay their

respect to the men who died there, but as

reconciliation between northerners and southerners

began, the battlefield become more than just a

place to remember those who perished there.

Veterans held reunions, and brought their families.

The battle itself interested people, and many came

to explore and learn about Gettysburg.

The town profited from these visitors and many

businesses capitalized on the increase in visitation.

For example, the Gettysburg Battlefield Trolley and

the Gettysburg Cyclorama were amusements that

private companies founded in the late nineteenth

century.

Image of Kathryn Horn, March 2013

“Battlefield

Trolley Lines”

Tipton Image 3242: courtesy of

Gettysburg National Military Park

“Battlefield Trolley”

Image of Kathryn Horn, March 2013

Literature

Linenthal, Edward Tabor. Sacred Ground:

Americans and Their Battlefields. Urbana and

Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 1993.

Weeks, Jim. Gettysburg: Memory, Market, and

an American Shrine. United States: Princeton

University Press, 2003.

Image Copied from Gettysburg

National Military Park, Vertical File

9-RR8

Advertisement

for the

battlefield

trolley. For

fifteen cents

more a visitor

could be given a

guided tour of

the battlefield.

A ticket for the

Gettysburg Cyclorama.

There were four

cycloramas that traveled

to U.S. cities in the late

19th century. One can

still view an original at

the Gettysburg National

Military Park Museum

and Visitor Center.

Image Copied from

Gettysburg National

Military Park, Vertical

File 11-46-A

Conclusions

President Lincoln imagined Gettysburg becoming

a sanctified ground, where no one could create a

new meaning of the battle. However, Civil War

veterans did alter the remembrance of Gettysburg

and of the war. They understood that their

memories would become what would be

remembered, and could choose what would not be

remembered on the site. The appealing memories

constructed by veterans transformed the Gettysburg

battlefield from a place of blood ridden ground, into

a site of valor and amusement. In the post war

years, Gettysburg did not become a place to reflect

on the important implications of the American Civil

War. These constructed memories made the site

more than just a place for memorialization, but also

a place for consumption by the general population.