kendal dearlove music counts. gaps exist in supportive care for young cancer patients. music is...
TRANSCRIPT
Kendal DearloveMUSIC COUNTS
• Gaps exist in supportive care for young cancer patients.
• Music is important to most young people
• Music may be an effective way to help this group of patients cope with their disease and treatment.
Issue:
Studies
• O’Callaghan et al (1)
– 26 paediatric cancer patients and their parents
– Mean age of 5.7y
– Examined their perspectives on music and the role of music therapy in these children’s lives through semi structured interviews.
• O’Callaghan et al (2)
– 12 adolescents and young adults,
– mean age 21y with cancer (AYA)
– Examined their perspectives of music’s role in their lives.
– Patients known to onTrac@PeterMac were recruited and individual semi-structured interviews were used
• Stinson et al (3) – 29 adolescents,
– Mean age 15.1y, with cancer (AWC)
– Examined their needs to inform the development of disease self-management programs.
– Convenience sampling was used to recruit participants including 29 patients mean age 15.1y, 30 parents and 22 healthcare professionals and semi structured individual and focus group interviews were held.
Results
• Stinson et al (3) – Young cancer patients need more information
about their disease and treatment and support services specifically tailored to their needs.
• O’Callaghan et al (1) and O’Callaghan et al (2) – Use of music and music therapy for children,
adolescents and young adults is beneficial in helping them to cope with their disease and treatment.
Limitations
• Results may be influenced by recruitment of participants who had
received music therapy (1) (2).
• Not all studies give the genders of the parents interviewed which may
introduce gender bias in the results (3) (1).
• Ethnicity was not given in any of the studies. The type and use of music
young people are exposed to may be influenced by ethnicity and
socioeconomic status (1) (2) (3).
• Some studies limit their sample to Melbourne which reduces
transferability of findings (1) (2).
• Some focus groups were small or unvaried which may influence the
views expressed (3).
• Not all studies reached data saturation resulting in potential non-
transferability of the findings (1) (2).
Conclusion
• Music therapy was beneficial for the patients who received it.
• As young cancer patients struggle with issues unique to their age group, music therapy may be a beneficial option for this group and should be offered in cancer treatment centres.
Issues within Radiation Therapy Departments
• Music may not be appropriate for all ages, tastes
• Awkward radio ads/ radio chat
• Inappropriate songs
• Radio replay driving staff mad
• Traumatic sounds
Potential Solutions
• Patients bringing CDs
• Follow Digital trend
• Eliminate unnecessary sounds
• Find out about availability of music therapy services in your area
Resources
1. O’Callaghan et al. Support Care Cancer. 2011;19:779–788.
2. O’Callaghan et al. Support Care Cancer. 2012;20:687–697.
3. Stinson et al. J Cancer Surviv. 2012;6:278–286.
