key differences

Upload: nilesh-parkar

Post on 10-Apr-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    1/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    KKKeeeyyy DDDiiiffffffeeerrreeennnccceeesss

    IIInnndddiiiaaannn GGGAAAAAAPPP VVVsss IIIFFFRRRSSS

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    2/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    Preface

    India, in 2011, joins the global accounting revolution: International Financial Reporting

    Standards.ConvergencewithIFRSisnotjustaboutswitchingoverfromonesetofaccounting&

    reporting standards to another. It takes the description of a revolution because conceptualdifferencesareexpected,asevidencedinthispublication.

    Convergence ismore about a complete business and financial strategy to adopt international

    standards which is expected to be a long drawn process involving investment of time andresources.WebelievethatnowistherighttimetogearupforIFRS.

    ThisBDOIndiapublicationisanendeavortoprovideaconcisesummaryofthemeasurementdifferences that exist between IFRSand IndianGAAP.Weadvise readers to consult all the

    relevantaccountingstandardsandapplicableregulations.

    WeatBDOIndiaarecommittedtohelpyoumigratetoIFRSassmoothlyaspossible,andlookforwardtoteamingwithyouonthischallengingbutexcitingjourney.

    GlobalKnowledgeServices

    BDOIndia

    701, Leela Business Park,Andheri Kurla Road, Andheri (East),Mumbai 400059

    [email protected]: 6672 9999 / 6639 1101D: 6672 9606 / 6672 9617

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    3/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    Thispublicationcontainsinformationinsummaryformandisthereforeintendedforgeneralguidanceonly.Itisnot

    intendedtobeasubstitutefordetailedresearchortheexerciseofprofessionaljudgement.NeitherBDOIndianor

    anymemberoftheorganisationcanacceptanyresponsibilityforlossoccasionedtoanypersonactingorrefraining

    fromaction asa result ofanymaterial inthispublication.We recommend you seek professional advice before

    takingactionsonspecificissues.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    4/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    CostV/sFairValue

    Generally uses historical cost, but intangible

    assets, property, plant and equipment (PPE)

    andinvestmentpropertymaybemeasuredat

    fairvalue.Derivatives, certain other financial

    instruments and biological assets must be

    revalued.

    Uses historical cost, but Fixed Assets may be

    revalued.

    Certain derivatives are carried at fair value. No

    comprehensive guidance on derivatives and

    biologicalassets.

    PresentationofFinancialStatements

    ComponentsofFinancialStatements

    IAS 1 provides overall requirements for the

    presentationoffinancialstatements,guidanceon their structure, and the minimum

    requirements for their content. Although it

    does not prescribe a particular format, itprescribes the components of the financial

    statementsthat togetherwouldbeconsidered

    asacompletesetoffinancialstatements.

    1. StatementofFinancialPosition(Balance

    sheet),

    2. Statement of Comprehensive Income /Income Statement (Profit and Loss

    Account),

    3. StatementofChangesinEquity(SOCIE),4. StatementofCashFlows,5. Notes comprising a summary of

    significantaccounting policiesand otherexplanatoryinformation,and

    6. StatementofFinancialPositionasatthebeginning of the earliest comparativeperiod when an entity applies an

    accounting policy retrospectively or

    makes a retrospective restatement of

    itemsinitsfinancialstatements,orwhenit reclassifies items in its Financial

    Statements

    CompaniesActrequirespreparationof:

    1. BalanceSheet,2. ProfitandLossAccount,and3. NotestoAccounts

    As per AS 3 Cash Flow Statements Level 1enterprises are required to prepare a Cash Flow

    Statementusingthedirectorindirectmethod.

    SEBImandatestheuseofindirectmethodforlistedcompanies.

    The insurance regulator IRDA requires insurancecompanies to prepare the Cash Flow Statement

    usingthedirectmethod.

    The conceptofSOCIEdoesnotprevail;however,

    they are represented by the captions share capital

    andreservesandsurplusinthebalancesheet.

    StatementofFinancialPosition(BalanceSheet)Format

    A current/non-current presentation of assets

    and liability is used, unless a liquiditypresentation provides more relevant and

    reliable information. Certainminimum items

    arepresentedonthefaceofthebalancesheet.

    Accountingstandardsdonotprescribea particular

    format;certainitemsmustbepresentedonthefaceofthebalancesheet.Formatsareprescribedbythe

    CompaniesActandotherregulationslikeBanking

    Regulation Act, Insurance Regulatory and

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    5/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    DevelopmentAuthorityActetc.

    StatementofComprehensiveIncome(ProfitandLossAccount)Format

    Presentedinoneoftwoformats(functionornature).Certainminimumitemsarepresented

    onthefaceoftheincomestatement.

    Underthenatureofexpensemethodexpenses

    are aggregated in the income statement

    according to their nature, (for example

    depreciation,purchasesofmaterials,transportcosts,wages and salaries, advertising costs),

    and are not reallocated amongst various

    functionswithintheenterprise.

    The function of expense or cost of sales

    methodclassifiesexpensesaccordingtotheirfunction aspart ofcost of sales, distribution

    oradministrativeactivities.

    Does not prescribe a standard format; but certainincome and expenditure items are disclosed in

    accordance with accounting standards and the

    CompaniesAct.

    Industry-specificformatsareprescribedbyindustry

    regulations.

    StatementofComprehensiveIncome-Structure

    Entitieshavetheoptiontopresenteither:

    1. Single Statement of ComprehensiveIncomeor

    2. Twoseparatestatements-a. An Income Statement displaying

    componentsofprofitorloss;and

    b. AStatementofComprehensiveIncomebeginning with profit or loss anddisplaying components of other

    comprehensiveincome.

    ComponentsofOtherComprehensiveIncome

    include:

    a. Changesinrevaluationsurplusb. Actuarial gains and losses on defined

    benefitplans

    c. Gainsorlossesarisingfromtranslatingthe financial statements of foreignoperations

    d. Gains and losses on remeasuringavailable-for-salefinancialassets

    e. The effective portion of gains andlossesonhedginginstrumentsinacash

    flowhedge.

    No comprehensive income statement is prepared.

    OnlyaProfitandLossAccountisprepared.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    6/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    StatementofChangesinEquity(SoCIE)

    Statementshowscapitaltransactionswiththe

    owners, the movement in accumulated

    profit/loss and a reconciliation of all other

    componentsofequity.

    Noseparatestatementisrequired.

    CashFlowStatements-BankOverdraft

    Bank Overdraft repayable on demand istreatedasCashandCashEquivalentsifthey

    form an integral part of the entitys Cash

    Management

    AS3CashFlowStatementsdoesnotprovideanyguidance on Bank Overdrafts. However, Bank

    overdraft are treated as FinancingActivities as a

    normalpractice

    CashFlowStatements-Dividend/Interest

    There is no guidance for classifying cash

    flows arising due to Dividend & Interest.

    They may be classified as Operating,FinancialorInvestingactivities.

    Interest and Dividends paid are classified as cash

    flows from Financing Activities. Interest and

    DividendreceivedareclassifiedascashflowsfromInvesting Activities. Only in case of a financial

    enterprise, interest paid, interest received anddividendreceivedshouldbeclassifiedasoperating

    activities.

    EventsaftertheBalanceSheetDateNonadjustingevents

    IFRS requires disclosure of significant non

    adjusting event in the notes to the Financial

    Statements

    IndianGAAPrequiresdisclosureofsucheventsin

    thereportoftheapprovingauthority.

    DisclosureofcriticaljudgementsIAS 1 requires disclosure of criticaljudgements and estimates made by

    managementinapplyingaccountingpolicies

    ThereisnosuchspecificdisclosurerequirementinAS1orScheduleVI.

    ConsolidatedFinancialStatements

    IFRS considers Consolidated Financial

    Statements as theGeneralPurpose Financial

    Statements.

    It is not mandatory to prepare Consolidated

    Financial Statements underAS 21.SEBI requires

    from listed companies to submit ConsolidatedFinancialStatements.BankingCompaniesarealso

    required to prepare Consolidated Financial

    Statements.

    ExtraordinaryItems

    Disclosure as extraordinary items either on

    the face of the income statement or in thenotesisprohibited.

    Aredefinedasincomeorexpensesthatarisefrom

    eventsortransactionsthatareclearlydistinctfromthe ordinary activities of the enterprise and,

    therefore, are not expected to recur frequently or

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    7/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    regularly.

    The nature and the amount of each extraordinaryitemshouldbeseparatelydisclosedinthestatement

    ofProfitandloss.

    OverrideofTrueandFairView

    In extremely rare circumstances when

    managementconcludes thatcompliancewith

    arequirementofaStandardorInterpretationwould be misleading, and therefore that

    departurefromarequirement isnecessaryto

    achieve a fair presentation, an enterpriseshoulddisclose:

    (a) that management has concluded that the

    financial statements fairly present theenterprises financial position, financial

    performanceandcashflows;

    (b)thatithascompliedinallmaterialrespectswith applicable IAS except that it has

    departedfromaStandardinordertoachievea

    fairpresentation;(c)theStandardfromwhichtheenterprisehas

    departed, the nature of the departure,

    including the treatment that the Standard

    wouldrequire,thereasonwhythattreatmentwouldbemisleadinginthecircumstancesand

    thetreatmentadopted;and(d) the financial impact of the departure onthe enterprises net profit or loss, assets,

    liabilities, equity and cash flows for each

    periodpresented.

    Theoverridedoesnotapplywherethereisa

    conflict between local company law andIFRS; in such a situation, the IFRS

    requirementsmustbeapplied.

    Fair presentation requires compliance with the

    applicable requirements of the Companies Act,

    1956andtheotherregulatoryrequirementsandtheapplication of thequalitativecharacteristicsof the

    AccountingStandardsFramework.

    RestatementofFinancialStatements

    ChangesinAccountingPolicy

    Comparative years information is restatedand theamountoftheadjustmentrelating to

    prior period is adjusted against opening

    balances of retained earnings of the earliest

    prior period presented, unless specificallyexempted.

    Restatementisnotrequired.Theeffectofchangesis included in currentyear incomestatement. The

    impactofchangeisdisclosed.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    8/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    Correctionoferrors

    Theopeningbalancesofassets,liabilitiesand

    equity for theearliest prior period presented

    arerestated.

    Restatement is not required. The effect of

    correction is included in current years income

    statementwithseparatedisclosures.

    Property,PlantandEquipments(PPE)

    ComponentAccounting

    IAS 16 mandates component accounting.

    Under this approach, each major part of an

    item ofpropertyplant andequipmentwith acostthatissignificantinrelationtothetotal

    costoftheitemisdepreciatedseparately.

    AS 10 does not require full adoption of the

    componentapproach. Itnearlyrecognizesthesaid

    approach in one paragraph by stating thataccounting for tangible fixed assets may be

    improved if total cost thereof is allocated to its

    variesparts.

    CostofPPE

    Historicalcostor revaluedamountsareused.Regular valuationsofentireclassesofassetsare required when revaluation option is

    chosen.

    Historicalcostisused.Revaluationsarepermitted,however, no requirements on frequency ofrevaluation. Revaluation for the whole class of

    assetsisnotrequired.

    DepreciationonRevaluationofProperty,PlantandEquipment

    Depreciation on revalued portion cannot be

    recoupedoutofrevaluationreserve

    Depreciation onrevalued portioncanberecouped

    outofrevaluationreserve

    UsefulLifeofPPE

    Depreciationtobecalculatedbasedonuseful

    life.

    Depreciation calculation is based on higher of

    usefullifeoftheAssetsorScheduleXIVrates

    Assetdismantlement,removalandrestorationcosts

    The cost of an item of property, plant and

    equipment includes the present value of thecosts of its dismantling, removal or

    restoration,theobligationforwhichanentity

    incursasaconsequenceofinstallingtheitemand/or using the item during a particular

    period for purposes other than to produce

    inventories during that period. Change in

    decommission or restoration obligations aregenerallyadded/deductedto/fromtherelated

    asset.

    Appendix to AS 29 Provisions, Contingent

    Liabilities andContingentAssets requires any thebest estimate of an obligation being removal and

    restorationcostsaretobeincludedinthecostofthe

    asset and a provision is to be recognised for thesame.Nodiscountingrequired.

    MajorInspectionCost

    Cost of major inspectionsand overhauls are

    recognisedinthecarryingamountofproperty

    Costs of major inspection are expensed when

    incurred.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    9/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    plantandequipment.

    RevaluationReserveofProperty,PlantandEquipment

    RevaluationReserveisdirectlytransferredtoRetainedEarningsonderecognition.

    Revaluation Reserve is transferred to IncomeStatementonderecognition.

    ReviewofUsefulLife,ResidualValue,DepreciationMethod

    IAS 16 mandates review of useful life,residual value and depreciation method at

    eachyearend.

    AS10doesnotspecifyanysuchrequirement.

    BiologicalAssets

    Measuredatfairvaluelessestimatedpointof

    sale costs, with changes in valuation

    recognizedintheIncomeStatement.

    Notspecified.GenerallyHistoricalcostused.

    IntangibleAssetsValuationModels

    Cost Model and Revaluation Model: An

    entity shall choose either the cost model orthe revaluation model as its accounting

    policy.

    Cost Model only: After initial recognition, an

    intangibleassetshouldbecarriedatitscostlessanyaccumulated amortisation and any accumulated

    impairmentlosses.Revaluationofintangibleassets

    isprohibited.

    Activemarket

    Revaluation model is permitted only wherethere is an activemarket for the underlying

    intangibles.

    Revaluationisprohibited.

    LifeofIntangibleAssets

    Anentityshallassesswhethertheusefullife

    ofanintangibleassetisfiniteorindefinite.If

    finite,thelengthof,ornumberofproductionorsimilarunitswouldconstituteusefullife.

    Anintangible asset shall be regarded by theentityashavinganindefiniteusefullifewhen,

    based on an analysis of all of the relevant

    factors, there is no foreseeable limit to the

    period over which the asset is expected togeneratenetcashinflowsfortheentity.

    There is a rebuttable presumption that the useful

    lifeofanintangibleassetwillnotexceedtenyears

    fromthedatewhentheassetisavailableforuse.

    Reviewofresidualvalue

    An entity is required to review the residual

    valueoftheintangibleassetsateachyearend

    Nosuchrequirement.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    10/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    and give the effect accordingly. In case

    revisedresidualvalueexceedscarryingvalue

    nodepreciationwillbechargedagainstthose.

    Intangiblesacquiredasapartofbusinesscombination

    Ifanintangibleassetisacquiredinabusiness

    combination,thecostofthatintangibleassetis its fair value at the acquisition date. The

    intangible is recorded by the acquirer

    irrespective of whether the asset had beenrecognised by the acquiree before the

    businesscombinationornot.

    If an intangible asset is acquired in anamalgamation in thenatureofpurchase, thesame

    should be accounted at cost or fair value if the

    cost/fair value can be reliably measured. If the

    sameisnotreliablymeasurableitisincludedasapartofgoodwill.Intangibleisrecordedevenifthat

    intangible asset had not been recognised in the

    financial statements of the transferor. Intangibleassetsacquiredinanamalgamationinthenatureof

    merger,oracquisitionofa subsidiaryarerecorded

    atbookvalues,whichmeansthatiftheintangibleasset was not recognized by the acquiree, the

    acquirerwouldnotbeabletorecordthesame.

    ImpairmentofAssets

    ReversalofImpairmentLoss

    An impairment loss recognised in prior

    periodsforanassetotherthangoodwillshall

    be reversed if, andonly if, there has been achangeintheestimatesusedtodeterminethe

    assets recoverable amount since the last

    impairmentlosswasrecognised.Ifthisisthecase, the carrying amount of the asset shall,beincreasedtoitsrecoverableamount.That

    increaseisareversalofanimpairmentloss.

    Animpairmentlossrecognisedforanassetinprior

    accountingperiodsshouldbereversediftherehas

    beenachangeintheestimatesofcashinflows,cashoutflows or discount rates used to determine the

    asset's recoverable amount since the last

    impairmentlosswasrecognised.Ifthisis thecase,the carrying amount of the asset should beincreased to its recoverable amount.That increase

    isareversalofanimpairmentloss.

    AllocationofgoodwillincaseofCGU

    For the purpose of impairment testing,

    goodwill acquired inabusiness combinationshall, from theacquisition date, beallocated

    to each of the acquirers cash-generating

    units,orgroupsofcash-generatingunits,that

    areexpectedtobenefitfromthesynergiesofthecombination,irrespectiveofwhetherother

    assets or liabilities of the acquiree are

    assigned to those units or groups of units.Each unit or group of units to which the

    goodwill is so allocated shall represent the

    lowest level within the entity at which thegoodwill is monitored for internal

    GoodwillisallocatedtoCGUbasedonbottom-up

    approach, i.e. identify whether allocated to aparticularCGUonconsistentandreasonablebasis

    and then, compare the recoverable amount of the

    cash-generating unit under review to its carrying

    amountandrecognizeimpairmentloss.

    However, if none of the carrying amount of

    goodwill can be allocated on a reasonable andconsistent basis to the cash-generating unit under

    review;and if, inperforming the 'bottom-up' test,

    the enterprise could not allocate the carryingamountofgoodwillonareasonableandconsistent

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    11/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    managementpurposes;andnotbelargerthan

    asegmentbasedoneithertheentitysprimary

    or the entitys secondary reporting formatdetermined in accordance with IFRS 8

    OperatingSegment.

    basistothecash-generatingunitunderreview,the

    enterprise should also perform a 'top-down' test,

    that is, the enterprise should identify the smallestcash-generating unit that includes the cash-

    generating unit under review and to which the

    carryingamountofgoodwillcanbeallocatedonareasonable and consistent basis (the 'larger' cash-

    generatingunit);andthen,comparetherecoverable

    amount of the larger cash-generating unit to itscarryingamountandrecognizeimpairmentloss.

    InvestmentProperty

    Definition

    IAS 40 defines investment property asproperty (land or a building-or part of a

    building-orboth)held(bytheownerorbythe

    lesseeunderafinancelease)toearnrentalsor

    for capital appreciation or both, rather thanforuse intheproductionor supplyofgoods

    orservicesorforadministrativepurposes;or

    saleintheordinarycourseofbusiness.

    AS 13 defines an investment property as aninvestment in land or buildings that are not

    intendedtobeoccupiedsubstantiallyforuseby,or

    intheoperationsof,theinvestingenterprise.

    SubsequentMeasurement

    Anentity has anoption toapply either costmodelorfairvaluemodel.Iffairvaluemodel

    is adopted, then changes in fair value are

    recognised in P&L A/c. In the fair valuemodel the carrying amount is notdepreciated. In the costmodel, the asset is

    carriedatcostlessdepreciation.

    EAChasopinedthattheinvestmentpropertyneedstobedepreciatedasitisadepreciableasset.Hence,

    depreciated cost model must be applied for

    subsequentmeasurement. Impairment is providedforwhereapplicable,andreversalofimpairmentsispermitted

    Transfersto/fromInvestmentProperty

    When there is a change in use of the

    investment property, the standard providesdetailed guidance for subsequent

    classificationanditsmeasurement.

    NoGuidance

    InventoryNetrealizablevalue

    AnewassessmentofNRV isrequired tobe

    madeineachsubsequentperiod.Writedownofinventoryis reversed ifcircumstancesthat

    previously caused inventories to be written

    down below cost no longer exist or when

    NospecificguidanceinAS2.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    12/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    there is clearevidence of an increase in the

    NRV because of changes in economic

    circumstances.

    Inventoriesofaserviceprovider

    IAS-2 includes provisions relating to the

    work-in-progressofaserviceprovider.Under

    IAS-2 such WIP consists primarily of thelabour and other costs of personnel directly

    engaged in providing the service, including

    supervisory personnel, and attributableoverheads.Labourandothercostsrelatingto

    salesandgeneraladministrativepersonnelare

    notincludedbutarerecognisedasexpensesintheperiodinwhichtheyareincurred.

    AS 2 excludes work in progress arising in the

    ordinary course of business of service providers.

    Hence,thereisnoguidanceforthesame.

    Inventoriesacquiredondeferredsettlementterms

    IAS 2 specifically requires that where

    inventory is acquired on deferred settlement

    terms, the difference between the purchase

    pricefornormalcredittermsandtheamountpaid is to be accounted as interest expense

    overtheperiodoffinancing.

    There is no express requirement under AS 2

    specifying treatment of inventories acquired on

    deferredsettlementterms.

    Noncurrentassetsheldforsaleanddiscontinuedoperations

    Scope

    IFRS-5 sets out requirements for

    classification, measurement and presentationof Non-current assets held for sale and the

    classificationandpresentationofdiscontinuedoperations.

    There is no specific standard which prescribes

    classification,measurementandpresentationofallnon-currentassetsheldforsale.HoweverasperAS

    10itemsofFixedassetsthathavebeenretiredfromactive use and are held for disposal are stated at

    lower or their net book value and net realizable

    valueandshowninthefinancialstatements.

    As 24 deals with disclosures relating todiscontinuedoperations.

    Classification

    Anentityshallclassifyanon-currentasset(ordisposalgroup)asheldforsaleifitscarrying

    valuewillberecoveredprincipallythroughasale transaction rather than through

    continuinguse

    AS10givesaverylimitedguidance

    Measurement

    Non-current assets held for sale should be

    measured at the lower of carrying value orfair value less cost to sell. After

    Nospecificguidanceexceptabove.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    13/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    reclassification theseassetswillnolongerbe

    subjecttosystematicdepreciation.

    PeriodofdisposalforNon-currentassetsheldforsale

    Completed within a year, with limited

    exceptions.

    Notimeframespecified.

    Definition-DiscontinuedOperations

    Acomponentofanentitythateitherhasbeendisposed of or is classified as held for sale

    and:

    (a) represents a separate major line ofbusinessorgeographicalareaofoperations,

    (b) is part of a single coordinated plan to

    disposeofaseparatemajorlineofbusinessorgeographicalareaofoperationsor

    (c)isasubsidiaryacquiredexclusivelywitha

    viewtoresale.

    A discontinuing operation is a component of anenterprise:

    a. thattheenterprise,pursuanttoasingleplan,is (i) disposing of substantially in itsentirety,suchasbysellingthecomponentin

    asingletransactionorbydemergerorspin

    off of ownership of the component to theenterprises shareholders; (ii) disposing of

    piecemeal, such as by selling off the

    componentsassetsandsettlingitsliabilitiesindividually; or (iii) terminating through

    abandonment;

    b. that represents a separate major line ofbusinessorgeographicalareaofoperations;and

    c. that can bedistinguishedoperationallyandforfinancialreportingpurposes

    Methodofdiscontinuance

    Operations and cash flows that have beendisposedofareclassifiedasheldforsale

    Pursuanttoa singleplan,eithersubstantiallyinitsentirety or piecemeal or terminated through

    abandonment.

    Presentation

    A single amount ispresented on the faceof

    theincomestatementcomprisingtheposttax

    profitor loss ordiscontinued operationsandananalysisofthis amounteitheron theface

    of the income statement or in the notes for

    both current and prior periods. Separateclassificationon the balance sheet for assets

    andliabilitiesforthecurrentperiodonly

    Thefollowingisseparatelydisclosedonthefaceof

    the profit and loss account separately from

    continuingoperations:

    pre-taxprofitorlossandrelatedtaxes pre-taxgainorlossondisposalIncome/expense line items from continuing anddiscontinuing operations are segregated and

    disclosed in the notes toaccount;butispresentedonacombinedbasisintheincomestatement.Noseparatepresentationisrequiredfor

    BalanceSheetitems.

    FinancialInstruments

    Under IndianGAAP therewasnoaccounting standard specifically forfinancial instruments.TheICAI has issued standards for recognition and measurement of financial instruments and their

    presentation and disclosure which are recommendatory from 1.4.2009 and mandatory from

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    14/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    1.4.2011.HencethecomparisongivenbelowiswithoutconsideringtheimpactoftheseStandards.

    Also,itisnecessarytonotethatrecognition,measurement,presentationanddisclosureoffinancial

    instrumentsisgovernedbytherespectiveregulatorsofvariousindustrieslikeRBI,SEBIandIRDA.

    Definition

    A financial instrument is any contract that

    givesrisetoafinancialassetofoneentityanda financial liability or equity instrument of

    anotherentity.

    No specific standard on financial instruments.However, accounting of certain financial

    instrumentsareprovidedinAS13Accountingfor

    InvestmentsandGuidanceNoteonAccountingfor

    EquityIndexandEquityStockFuturesandOptionsissuedbytheICAI.

    FinancialAssetsClassification

    Financialassetisclassifiedinfourcategories:

    1)FinancialAssetatFairValuethroughP&LA/c2)HeldtoMaturity

    3)LoansandReceivables4)AvailableforSale.

    AS 13 classifies investments into long-term and

    currentinvestments.

    Detailed classificationof Investments forbanks isprescribedbyRBIwhichissimilartoIFRS.

    FinancialAssets-Measurement

    1)Initialmeasurementoffinancialassetsisat fair value. Transaction cost is alsoincludedintheinitialcarryingvalueunless

    theyarecarriedatfairvaluethroughprofit

    orloss

    2)Subsequentmeasurementisat:a. amortisedcostusingeffectiveinterest

    method for Loans and Receivables

    andHeld-to-maturityinvestmentsb. fair value for Financial assetsat fair

    value through profit or loss and

    Available-for-salefinancialassets.Changesincarryingamountareaccounted

    in the IncomeStatement for all financial

    assets except for Available-for-salefinancial assets which is accounted

    throughEquity.

    Long term investments are recorded at cost less

    diminution, other than temporary. Currentinvestmentsarerecordedatlowerofcostormarket

    valueinaccordancewithAS13.

    HoweverforBanking,MutualFundandInsurance

    sectors, the respective regulators (i.e. RBI, SEBIandIRDA)prescribeguidelinesformeasurementof

    Investments.

    FinancialLiabilitiesClassification

    Financial Liabilities is classified in two

    categories:

    1) Financial Liabilities at Fair ValuethroughP&LA/c

    2) OtherLiabilities

    NoGuidance.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    15/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    FinancialLiabilitiesMeasurement

    Initialmeasurementoffinancialliabilitiesis

    atfairvalueoftheconsiderationreceived.

    Subsequentmeasurementisat:a. amortisedcostusingeffectiveinterest

    methodforotherliabilities

    b. fairvalueforFinancialLiabilitiesatfairvaluethroughprofitorloss

    NoGuidance.

    FinancialAssets-Reclassification

    1. FVTPL:a. Reclassification into and out FVTPL

    on initial recognition andreclassification of derivatives is

    prohibited Held for trading may be

    reclassifiedintoAFS,HTMandL&R

    incertainrarecircumstances.

    2. HTM:a. If significant amount of HTM is

    reclassified or sold, the remaining

    investments inHTM category are to

    be reclassified into AFS and noinvestmentcanbeclassifiedasHTM

    foraperiodof2years(alsoknowas

    tainting).

    3. AFS:a. AFS that would have met the

    definitionofL&R(ifithadnotbeendesignated as AFS) it may be

    transferredintoL&Riftheentityhas

    the intention and ability to hold thefinancial asset for the foreseeable

    futureoruntilmaturity.

    Where long-term investments are reclassified as

    currentinvestments,transfersaremadeatthelower

    ofcostandcarryingamountatthedateoftransfer.

    Whereinvestmentsarereclassifiedfromcurrenttolong-term, transfers aremadeat the lower of cost

    andfairvalueatthedateoftransfer.

    FinancialAssets-Derecognition

    Financial assets are derecognised based on

    risks and rewards first; control is secondarytest.

    There is limited guidance for derecognition.

    Usually,financialassetsarederecognisedbasedontransferofrisksandrewards.

    The ICAI has issued a Guidance Note on

    securitization which requires derecognition based

    oncontrol.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    16/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    Classificationbetweenliabilityandequity

    The issuer of a financial instrument shall

    classify the instrument, or its component

    parts, on initial recognition as a financial

    liability, a financial asset or an equityinstrument in accordancewith the substance

    of the contractual arrangement and the

    definitionsofafinancialliability,afinancialasset and an equity instrument. The

    applicationoftheseprincipalsrequirescertain

    instrumentswhichhavetheformofequitytobe classified as liability. For example

    redeemablepreferenceshareonwhichafixed

    dividendispayableareclassifiedasliability.

    Classification is based on form rather than

    substance.For example preference shares are

    treated as capital, even though in many case insubstanceitmaybealiability.

    CompoundFinancialInstruments

    IAS 32 requires compound financial

    instruments,suchasconvertiblebonds,tobesplit into liability component and equity

    component and each component is recorded

    separately.

    No split accounting required and financial

    statementsareclassifiedeitherasequityorliabilitydependingon their primarynature.Forexamplea

    convertible debenture is generally treated as

    liability.

    Derivatives

    Aderivativeisafinancialinstrumentorother

    contractwithinthescopeofthisIAS39withallthreeofthefollowingcharacteristics:

    1) its value changes in response to thechange in a specified interest rate,financialinstrumentpriceetc.

    2) it requires no or smaller initial netinvestment;and

    3) itissettledatafuturedate.

    There is no specific standard dealing with

    derivatives; though, there are somepronouncementswhichdealwith specific typesof

    derivatives.Consequently,manyderivativesremain

    outsidethebalancesheet.

    EmbeddedDerivatives

    All embedded derivatives are required tobe

    recognizedseparatelyfromhostcontractif:

    1. theeconomiccharacteristicsandrisksofthe embedded derivative are not closelyrelated to the economic characteristicsandrisksofthehostcontract,

    2. aseparateinstrumentwiththesametermsas the embedded derivativewouldmeetthedefinitionofaderivative;and

    3. thehybrid (combined) instrument is not

    Thereisnospecificguidancedealingwithseparate

    recognitionofembeddedderivatives.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    17/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    measured at fair value with changes in

    fairvaluerecognisedinprofitorloss

    Ifanembeddedderivativeisseparated,

    1) the host contract shall be accounted forunder this Standard if it is a financial

    instrument,and

    2) in accordance with other appropriateStandards if it is not a financial

    instrument.

    DeferredTax

    Basis

    IFRSrequiresentities toaccountfortaxation

    using the Balance Sheet liability approachwhich focuses on temporary differencebetween the carrying amount of an asset or

    liability inthestatementoffinancialpositionanditstaxbase.

    Deferred tax is accounted for using the Income

    statement approach, which focuses on timingdifference.

    DeferredtaxonrevaluationofPPEandIntangibleAssets

    Deferredtaxistobecreatedonrevaluationof

    PPE and Intangible assets and the same is

    recognisedinothercomprehensiveincome

    Deferredtaxisnotrecognisedasitisconsideredto

    beapermanentdifference.

    RecognitionofdeferredtaxassetsincaseofbusinesscombinationUnderIFRS,thecostofbusinesscombination

    is allocated to the identifiable assets andliability assumedby reference to fair values.

    However, if no equivalent adjustment is

    allowedfortaxpurpose,itwouldgiverisetoatemporarydifference.

    Under IndianGAAP, businesscombination(other

    thanamalgamation)willnotgiverisetoadeferredtaxadjustment.

    DeferredTaxonConsolidation

    Temporarydifferencearisewhenthecarryingamount of investments in subsidiaries,

    branches or associates or interests in joint

    ventures (namely the parent or investorsshare of the net assets including carrying

    amountofgoodwill) becomesdifferent from

    the tax base (which is often cost) of theinvestment/interest.

    Under Indian GAAP, consolidation will not giverisetoadeferredtaxadjustment.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    18/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    DeferredtaxonunrealisedIntra-groupprofits

    Deferred taxonunrealised intragroupprofit

    isrecognisedatthebuyersrate.

    Deferred tax is not recognised as deferred tax

    expense is an aggregation from separate financial

    statementofeachgroupentityandnoadjustmentis

    madeonconsolidation.

    RecognitionCriteria

    A deferred tax asset is recognised if it is

    probable(morelikelythannot)thatsufficienttaxableprofitwillbeavailableagainstwhich

    the unused tax losses and tax credits canbe

    utilised.

    Deferredtaxassetsisrecognised(a)ifrealisationis

    virtually certain for entities with tax losses carry-forward, whereas (b) if realisation is reasonably

    certainforentitieswithnotaxlossescarry-forward

    Liabilities

    ProvisionsGeneral

    Provision are discounted to Present value

    wheretheeffectofthetimevalueofmoneyismaterial

    Discountingofprovisionsisnotpermitted

    ProposedDividend

    Liabilityfordividendsdeclaredtoholdersofequity instruments are recognised in the

    periodwhendeclared

    Dividendsarerecognisedasanappropriationfromprofitsandrecordedasliabilityatthebalancesheet

    date, if proposed or declared subsequent to the

    reporting period but before approval of the

    financialstatements

    FinancialLiabilitiesversusEquityClassification

    Capital Instruments areclassified,dependingon substance of issuers contractual

    obligations as either liability or equity or

    equityandliability.

    Mandatory redeemable preferenceshares are

    classifiedasliabilities.

    No specific guidance. Inpractice, classification isbasedonlegalformratherthansubstance.

    All preference shares are disclosed separately as

    sharecapitalundershareholdersfunds.

    Revenue

    Additionalconditionforrecognitionofrevenuefromsaleofgoodsorrenderingofservices

    IAS18prescribesanadditionalconditionthat

    thecostsincurredortobeincurredinrespect

    ofthetransactioncanbemeasuredreliablytobefulfilledbefore therecognitionofrevenue

    fromsaleofgoods.

    This condition is not required to be fulfilled for

    recognizingrevenueunderAS9.

    BarterTransactions

    Theaccountingtreatmentdependsonwhether

    theexchange transactioninvolves goodsand

    NoSpecificGuidance

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    19/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    services of similar nature and value (for

    example,exchangeofcommoditieslikeoilor

    milk).Exchangesofsimilarassets:1. Carryingamountof theasset received=

    Carryingamountoftheassetsurrendered

    +cashorcashequivalenttransferred.2. Nogainsorlossesarerecognised.Exchangesofdissimilarassets:

    1. Carryingamountof theasset received=Fairvalueoftheasset received+/-cash

    orcashequivalenttransferred

    2. Gainorlosstoberecognised=Fairvalueof the asset received +/- cash or cashequivalent transferred- carrying amount

    oftheassetsurrendered

    Interest

    Interest income is recognised using the

    effectiveinterestmethod.

    Interest is recognised on a time proportion basis

    takingintoaccounttheamountoutstandingandtherateapplicable

    RenderingofServices

    Requires recognition using percentage ofcompletion method. Revenues from

    installation fees and production commission

    are recognised with reference to stages ofcompletion, unless the installation is

    incidentaltosale

    Completed service contract method orproportionatecompletionmethodpermitted

    CustomerLoyaltyPrograms

    Awardcreditsareaccountedforasaseparate

    identifiablecomponentofasalestransaction,

    with theconsideration allocated between theawards credit and the other components of

    sale.

    Nospecificguidance.

    EmployeeBenefits

    Actuarialgainsandlosses

    Actuarialgainsandlossesmaybe: recognisedimmediatelyinprofitorloss; recognised immediately in other

    comprehensiveincome;or

    deferred upto a maximum with anyexcess of 10% of the greater of thedefined benefit obligation or the fair

    valueoftheplanassetsattheendofthe

    Actuarial gains and losses should be recognisedimmediately inthe statementof profit and loss as

    anincomeorexpense.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    20/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    previous reporting period being

    recognised over the expected average

    remaining working lives of theparticipating employees or other

    acceleratedbasis

    EffectsofChangesinForeignExchangeRates

    FunctionalandPresentationCurrency

    Thereisaconceptof3currencies:Functional

    Currency,ForeignCurrencyandPresentation/

    Reporting Currency, which are defined asunder.

    Functional Currency is the currency of theprimary economic environment inwhich the

    entityoperates.

    Foreign currency is a currency other thanfunctionalcurrency.

    PresentationcurrencyisthecurrencyinwhichtheFinancialStatementsarepresented.

    ThereisnoconceptofFunctionalCurrency.

    Foreign currency is a currency other than thereportingcurrencywhich is the currencyinwhich

    FinancialStatementsarepresented.

    TranslationsintheConsolidatedFinancialStatements

    Nodistinction ismadebetween integral and

    non-integralforeignoperationsunderIAS21.

    All entities are required to prepare theirFinancial statements in Functional currency.Any exchange gain/loss to record a

    transaction in its functional currency is

    recognised in the income statement. Intranslating the Financial Statement from

    functionalcurrency topresentation currency,

    thereportingentityshouldusethefollowingprocedures:

    a. Assetsand liabilities,bothmonetaryandnon-monetaryshouldbe translatedat the

    closingrate.b. Income and expenses items should betranslatedatexchangeratesatthedateof

    transactions;andc. Allresultingexchangedifferencesshould

    be accumulated in foreign currency

    translation reserve until the disposal oftheinvestment.

    Translationoffinancialstatementstothereportingcurrency of the parent/investee depends on the

    classification of that operation as integral or nonintegral.

    Inthecaseofanintegraloperation,monetaryassets

    are translated at closing rate; non-monetary itemsaretranslatedathistoricalrateiftheyarevaluedat

    costandatclosingrateiftheyarevaluedonother

    valuationbasisandincomeandexpenseitemsaretranslated at historical/average rate. Exchange

    differencesaretakentothestatementofprofitand

    loss.

    For non-integral operations, closing rate method

    shouldbefollowed(i.e.allassetsandliabilitiesare

    tobetranslatedatclosingratewhileprofitandlossaccountitemsaretranslatedatactual/averagerates).

    The resulting exchange difference is taken to

    reserve and is recycled to profit and loss on thedisposalofthenon-integralforeignoperation.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    21/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    OperatingSegments(IFRS8v/sAS17)

    Applicability

    Thisstandardisapplicableto

    separate or individual financialstatementsofanentitywhosedebtor

    equity instruments are listed or

    proposedtobelisted,and

    Consolidated Financial Statements ofa groupwith a parent whose debt or

    equity instruments are listed or

    proposedtobelisted.

    ThisstandardisapplicabletoalllevelIentities.

    DeterminationofSegments

    IFRS imposesa ManagementApproach totheidentificationofoperatingsegmentswhich

    is to be based on internal reports that areregularly reviewed by the entitys ChiefOperatingDecisionMaker(CODM)inorder

    to allocate resources to the segment and

    assessitsperformance.

    AS17requiresanenterprisetoidentifytwosetsofsegments(businessandgeographical),usingarisks

    andrewardsapproach,withtheenterprisessystemof internal financial reporting tokeymanagementpersonnelservingonlyasthestartingpointforthe

    identificationofsuchsegments.

    Measurement

    Segmentprofitorlossisreportedonthesame

    measurement basisas that used by the chiefoperating decision maker. There is no

    definition of segment revenue, segment

    expense,segmentresult,andsegmentassetorsegmentliability

    Segment information is prepared in conformity

    with theaccountingpoliciesadoptedforpreparingand presenting the financial statements of the

    enterprise as a whole. Segment revenue, segment

    expense,segmentresult,segmentassetandsegmentliabilityhavebeendefined

    Conformitywithaccountingpolicies

    IFRS 8 does not define segments as eitherbusiness or geographical segment and does

    notrequiremeasurement ofsegment amount

    based on entitys accounting policies, anentity must disclose how it determined its

    reportable operating segments and the basison which disclosed amount have been

    measured

    AS17 requires that segment informationmustbepreparedinconformitywiththeaccountingpolicies

    adoptedforpreparingandpresentingtheFinancial

    Statementsoftheconsolidatedgrouporentity.

    Reconciliation

    Requires reconciliation of segment

    performance measures, and segment assetsandliabilitieswiththecorrespondingamounts

    reportedinthefinancialstatements

    Reconciliation is presented between the

    informationdisclosed for reportablesegments andthe aggregated information in the enterprises

    financialstatements.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    22/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    Discretereporting

    IFRS 8 allows for discrete reporting of a

    componentofanentitythatsellsprimarilyor

    exclusivelytootheroperatingsegmentsofan

    entity.

    AS 17 requires only those segments which sell

    exclusivelyorprimarilytoexternalcustomerstobe

    deemedreportablesegments.

    ShareBasePayment(GrantDateAccounting)

    Accountingstandard

    There is a detailed standardwith respect to

    sharebasedpayment

    Nospecificstandard.However, ICAI hasissueda

    recommendatory Guidance Note for Employee

    sharebasedpayment.

    Measurement

    Employee share base payment should be

    accountedforusingfairvaluemethod.

    Employee share based payments are accounted

    eitheratintrinsicvalueorfairvalue

    ConsolidatedFinancialStatements(CFS)Applicability

    All entities have to prepare Consolidated

    FinancialStatementsunderIFRS

    Consolidated Financial Statements are mandated

    only by the regulator i.e. Securities ExchangeBoardofIndia(SEBI)forlistedcompanies

    DefinitionofControl

    Control is the power togovern the financialand operating policies of an entity so as to

    obtainbenefitsfromitsactivities.

    Controlis:1. the ownership, directly or indirectly through

    subsidiary(ies), of more than one-half of the

    votingpowerofanenterprise;or2. control of the composition of the board of

    directors in the case of a company or of thecomposition of the corresponding governing

    body incase of any other enterprise so as toobtaineconomicbenefitsfromitsactivities.

    Thereforeamereownershipofmore than 50%of

    equity shares is sufficient to constitute controlunderIndianGAAP,whereasthisisnotnecessarily

    sounderIFRS.

    DualControl

    Onlyoneentitycan have control (as distinct

    from joint control) over another entity.

    Therefore, when two or more entities each

    hold significantvoting rights, certain factorsare reassessed todetermine which partyhas

    control.

    Inararesituation,whenanenterpriseiscontrolled

    bytwoenterprisesonewhichcontrolsbyvirtueof

    ownershipofmajorityofthevotingpowerandthe

    otherwhichcontrols,byvirtueofanagreementorotherwise, the composition of the board of

    directors, the first mentioned enterprise will be

    considered as subsidiary of both the controllingenterprises and therefore,both theenterpriseswill

    needtoconsolidatethefinancialstatementsofthat

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    23/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    enterprise.

    PotentialVotingRights

    The existence and effect of potential voting

    rights that are currently exercisable or

    convertible, including potential voting rights

    held by another entity, are considered whenassessingcontrol.

    As per ASI 18, potential voting rights are not

    consideredfordeterminingsignificant influence in

    thecaseofanassociate.

    Subsidiariesexcludedfromconsolidation

    CFS includes all subsidiaries. A subsidiary

    thatmeets, on acquisition, the criteria to be

    classifiedasheldforsaleinaccordancewithIFRS5,NonCurrentAssetsHeldforSaleand

    Discontinued Operation, applies the

    presentation for assets held for sale (i.e.separate presentation of assets and liabilities

    to be disposed), rather than normal line by

    lineconsolidation.

    Precludeconsolidationofasubsidiarywhencontrol

    over that subsidiary is likely to be temporary.

    Considersasubsidiarytobetemporarilycontrolledwhen it is acquired and held exclusively with a

    viewtoitssubsequentdisposalinthenearfuture.

    Also precludes consolidation of a subsidiary thatoperatesunderseverelongtermrestrictions,which

    significantly impair its ability to transfer funds to

    theparent. IntheCFS, theprecludedsubsidiaries

    areaccountedasperAS-13andthereasonsfornotconsolidatingaredisclosed.

    Reportingperiod

    When financial statements of a subsidiary

    usedinpreparationofCFSarepreparedasof

    a reporting date different from that of the

    parent, adjustments shall be made for theeffects of significant transactions or events

    that occur between that and the date of the

    parents financial statements. In any case thedifference between the reporting dateof the

    subsidiaryand that ofthe parent shallbeno

    morethanthreemonths.

    SimilartoIFRS,exceptthatthedifferencebetween

    the reporting dates should not be more than six

    months.

    Uniformaccountingpolicies

    Compliancewithuniformaccountingpolicies

    ismandatory.

    CFSshouldbepreparedusinguniformaccounting

    policies for like transactions and other events insimilarcircumstances.Ifitisnotpracticabletouse

    uniformaccountingpolicies inpreparing theCFS,that fact should be disclosed together with the

    proportions of the items in the CFS towhich thedifferentaccountingpolicieshavebeenapplied.

    SpecialPurposeEntities

    SIC12statesthataSpecialPurposeEntity

    (SPE) should be consolidated when the

    Nospecificguidance.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    24/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    substance of the relationship between an

    entityand the SPE indicates that the SPE is

    controlledbythatentity.

    AccountingforInvestmentinSubsidiaryinParentsSeparateFinancialStatements

    Parents investment in a subsidiary be

    accounted for in the parents separatefinancial statements (a) at cost, or (b) as

    available-for-salefinancialassetsasdescribed

    inIAS39.

    Investmentsinsubsidiaryshouldbeaccountedforin accordance with AS 13, Accounting for

    Investments, which is cost as adjusted for any

    diminutionother than temporary invalueof those

    investments.

    InvestmentsinJointventures

    If the reporting enterprise does not prepareconsolidated financial statements because it

    has no subsidiaries, its Jointly Controlled

    Entities should be either proportionatelyconsolidatedorequityaccounted.

    At cost less impairment if consolidated financialstatementsarenotprepared.

    BusinessCombinations

    Scope

    Appliestomostbusinesscombinationboth

    amalgamation (where acquiree loses itsidentity)and acquisition (where acquiree

    continues its existence). IFRS 3 does not

    apply to common control transactions,formation of JVs, combinations involving

    mutual entities and combinations throughcontractalone.

    There is no one comprehensive standard. AS-14

    applies only to amalgamation. AS-21, 23, 27applies to accounting for investments in

    subsidiaries, associates and joint ventures

    respectively.AS-10wouldapplywhereademergeddivisionisacquiredonalump-sumbasisbyanother

    entity.

    Acquisitiondate

    The date on which the acquirer effectivelyobtainscontroloftheacquiree.

    The date of amalgamation as defined in

    Amalgamation/ acquisition scheme of High

    Court/RBI.

    ContingentLiabilities

    Contingent Liabilities are to be included in

    NetAssetsatfairvalue.

    ContingentliabilitiesarenotrecordedasLiabilities.

    MethodofAccounting

    All business combinations are accounted

    underPurchaseMethodatfairvalues.PoolingofInterestMethodisprohibited.

    BothPurchaseMethod(agreedvalues)andPooling

    ofInterestMethod(carryingamount)arepermitted.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    25/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    SubsequentadjustmenttoAssetsandLiabilities

    A12monthwindowperiodisallowedtoget

    theacquisitionaccountingright.Upto the12

    month period, any adjustments to the fair

    value of assets/liabilities taken over arerecognized with a corresponding effect to

    goodwill. After the 12 months period, any

    adjustments to the fair value ofassets/liabilities takenoverarerecognized in

    the income statement. In respect of

    adjustments arising out of contingentconsideration, correction of errors and

    deferred taxes, the 12 months time barring

    periodisnotapplicableandany adjustmentsontheseaccounts,thecorrespondingeffectis

    taken togoodwill, even if the same is made

    after12months.

    Nochangeispermitted

    ContingentConsideration

    Considerationfortheacquisitionincludesthe

    acquisition date fair value of contingentconsideration. Changes in Contingent

    consideration resulting from the events after

    theendofthereportingperiodarerecognisedinprofitorloss.

    Nospecificguidance.

    AccountingforGoodwill

    The acquirer shall, at the acquisition daterecognise goodwill acquired in a businesscombinationasanasset;andinitiallymeasure

    thatgoodwill atits cost, being the excessof

    thecostofthebusinesscombinationovertheacquirersinterestinthenetfairvalueofthe

    identifiable assets, liabilities and contingent

    liabilitiesrecognised.Afterinitialrecognition,theacquirershallmeasuregoodwill acquired

    in a business combination at cost less any

    accumulated impairment losses. Goodwill

    amortizationisprohibited.

    Treatment of goodwill differs in differentaccounting standards. Goodwill arising onamalgamationinnatureofpurchaseisamortisedto

    P&Lover5years.GoodwillunderAS-21,23and

    27 need not be amortised though there is noprohibition. In case of amalgamation innature of

    merger,excessamountovernetassetstakenoveris

    adjusted against revenue reserves.All goodwill istestedforimpairment.

    NegativeGoodwill

    Iftheacquirersinterestinthenetfairvalueof the identifiable assets, liabilities and

    contingent liabilities recognised exceeds the

    costofthebusinesscombination,theacquirershall reassess the identification and

    RecordedasCapitalReserve.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    26/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    IFRS IndianGAAP

    measurement of the acquirees identifiable

    assets,liabilitiesandcontingentliabilitiesand

    the measurement of the cost of thecombination; and recognise immediately in

    profitorlossanyexcessremainingafterthat

    reassessment.

    Acquisitionrelatedcosts

    Acquisitionrelatedcostssuchasfindersfees,

    due diligence fees, legal fees etc, areaccounted for an expenses in the period in

    which the costare incurred and services are

    received.

    Nospecificguidance.

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    27/28

    Forprivatecirculationonly

    Appendix:ListofIFRS

    IFRS

    IFRS1 First-timeAdoptionofInternationalFinancialReportingStandards

    IFRS2 Share-basedPayment

    IFRS3 BusinessCombinations

    IFRS4 InsuranceContracts

    IFRS5 Non-currentAssetsHeldforSaleandDiscontinuedOperations

    IFRS6 ExplorationforandEvaluationofMineralResources

    IFRS7 FinancialInstruments:Disclosures

    IFRS8 OperatingSegments

    IFRS9 FinancialInstruments(replacementofIAS39)

    IAS

    IAS1 PresentationofFinancialStatements

    IAS2 InventoriesIAS7 StatementofCashFlows

    IAS8 AccountingPolicies,ChangesinAccountingEstimatesandErrors

    IAS10 EventsaftertheReportingPeriod

    IAS11 ConstructionContracts

    IAS12 IncomeTaxes

    IAS16 Property,PlantandEquipment

    IAS17 Leases

    IAS18 Revenue

    IAS19 EmployeeBenefits

    IAS20 AccountingforGovernmentGrantsandDisclosureofGovernment

    Assistance

    IAS21 TheEffectsofChangesinForeignExchangeRates

    IAS23 BorrowingCosts

    IAS24 RelatedPartyDisclosures

    IAS26 AccountingandReportingbyRetirementBenefitPlans

    IAS27 ConsolidatedandSeparateFinancialStatements

    IAS28 InvestmentsinAssociates

    IAS29 FinancialReportinginHyperinflationaryEconomies

    IAS31 InterestsinJointVentures

    IAS32 FinancialInstruments:Presentation

    IAS33 EarningsperShareIAS34 InterimFinancialReporting

    IAS36 ImpairmentofAssets

    IAS37 Provisions,ContingentLiabilitiesandContingentAssets

    IAS38 IntangibleAssets

    IAS39 FinancialInstruments:RecognitionandMeasurement

    IAS40 InvestmentProperty

    IAS41 Agriculture

  • 8/8/2019 Key Differences

    28/28

    IFRIC

    IFRIC1 ChangesinExistingDecommissioning,RestorationandSimilarLiabilities

    IFRIC2 MembersSharesinCo-operativeEntitiesandSimilarInstruments

    IFRIC4 DeterminingwhetheranArrangementcontainsaLeaseIFRIC5 RightstoInterestsarisingfromDecommissioning,Restorationand

    EnvironmentalRehabilitationFunds

    IFRIC6 LiabilitiesarisingfromParticipatinginaSpecificMarketWaste

    ElectricalandElectronicEquipment

    IFRIC7 ApplyingtheRestatementApproachunderIAS29FinancialReporting

    inHyperinflationaryEconomies

    IFRIC8 ScopeofIFRS2

    IFRIC9 ReassessmentofEmbeddedDerivatives

    IFRIC10 InterimFinancialReportingandImpairment

    IFRIC11 IFRS2GroupandTreasuryShareTransactions

    IFRIC12 ServiceConcessionArrangementsIFRIC13 CustomerLoyaltyProgrammes

    IFRIC14 IAS19TheLimitonaDefinedBenefitAsset,MinimumFunding

    RequirementsandtheirInteraction

    IFRIC15 AgreementsfortheConstructionofRealEstate

    IFRIC16 HedgesofaNetInvestmentinaForeignOperation

    IFRIC17 DistributionsofNon-cashAssetstoOwners

    IFRIC18 TransfersofAssetsfromCustomers

    SIC

    SIC7 IntroductionoftheEuro

    SIC10 GovernmentAssistanceNoSpecificRelationtoOperatingActivities

    SIC12 ConsolidationSpecialPurposeEntities

    SIC13 JointlyControlledEntitiesNon-MonetaryContributionsbyVenturers

    SIC15 OperatingLeasesIncentives

    SIC21 IncomeTaxesRecoveryofRevaluedNon-DepreciableAssets

    SIC25 IncomeTaxesChangesintheTaxStatusofanEntityoritsShareholders

    SIC27 EvaluatingtheSubstanceofTransactionsInvolvingtheLegalFormof

    SIC29 ServiceConcessionArrangements:Disclosures

    SIC31 RevenueBarterTransactionsInvolvingAdvertisingServices

    SIC32 IntangibleAssetsWebSiteCosts