key findings measuring and bench marking en
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
1/31
Fclsurekm lkb Hck`nflriekm tnc Ptru`turla
Lboustfckt Tcrgjrflk`c jg CS Ekbustry
Rnc Grlfcwjri @jktrl`t jg Pc`tjrla @jfpctetevckcss Ptubecs
CKRX/47/432
Icy Gekbekms
@aeckt? Curjpclk @jffessejk, BM Cktcrpresc lkb Ekbustry
@jpcknlmck/Hrusscas, Fly 8445
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
2/31
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
3/31
C@JXUP Kcbcralkb HW
T.J. Hjx 2 44
G +0< (4)
C kctncralkbsDc`jrys.`jf
] www.c`jrys.`jf
Xcmestrltejk kj. 820
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
4/31
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
5/31
Rlhac jg @jktckts
4..< Rnc c`jkjfe` jut`jfcs xex
4.>.8 Aekiekm c`jkjfe` jut`jfc wetn lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c xxe
4.5 Geklaay xxee
Lkkcx gemurcs jg lboustfckt acvcas hy sc`tjr lkb `juktry xxev4.5.
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
6/31
4.
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
7/31
ee
4.8 Ektrjbu`tejk
Rnc `urrckt lkb subbck c`jkjfe` `reses tnlt nls lggc`tcb tnc Curjpclk c`jkjfy ek tnc
alst nlag yclr nls pjektcb fjrc tnlk cvcr hcgjrc tj tnc efpjrtlk`c jg lboustfckt lkb
stru`turla `nlkmc. Ekbccb, tncrc es l `jfpcaaekm kccb gjr l hcttcr ukbcrstlkbekm lkb fjrc
eksemnts ektj tnc lboustfckt prcssurc tnlt ekbevebula c`jkjfe` sc`tjrs cxpcreck`c, tnc
lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c jg sc`tjrs lkb `juktrecs lkb tnc ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri tnlt
berc`tay efpl`ts tnc kccb lkb tnc `lplheaetecs jg `nlkmc.
Rnc lheaety jg tnc flkugl`turekm ekbustry tj lblpt tj `nlkmc lkb prjl`tevcay stefualtc
stru`turla `nlkmc es pevjtla gjr l`necvekm tnc CSs jvcrlaa mrjwtn lkb ojh jhoc`tevcs. Ls
fcktejkcb ek tnc @jffuke`ltejk grjf tnc @jffessejk jk ekbustrela pjae`y >2
Mrjup 8 (Majhlaesltejk? fcbeuf Rc`nkjajmy ektcksety? aj w)
83 Xuhhcr lkb palste` prjbu`ts 33 3> >0
07 Gurketurc9 flkugl`tur ekm k.c. . 2= 3< =0
0= Xc`y`aekm 2= 3< =0 Mrjup 0 (Majhlaesltejk? nem n Rc`nkjajmy ektcksety? ajw)
3 54 =3
]clrekm lpplrca9 brcssekm lkb bycekm jg gur >3 54 =3
3 54 =3
8= Hlse` fctlas =< =< =>
Mrjup 2 (Majhlaesltejk? nemn Rc`nkjajmy ektcksety? nemn)
82 @ncfe las lkb ncfe la prjbu`ts >4 52 =8
85 Fl`nekcry lkb cquepfckt k.c. . =3 =7 =7
04 Jg ge`c fl`nekcry lkb jfputcrs 2
08 Xlbej, tcacvesejk lkb jffuke ltejk cquepfckt lkb lpplrltus >= >5 =5
00 Fcbe la, prc`esejk lkb jpte`la ekstrufckts, wlt`ncs lkb aj`is == >8 75
02 Fjtjr vcne acs, trleacrs lkb scfe-trleacrs 58 5< =<
Kl`c`jbcsPc`tjrs
03 Jtncr trlkspjrt cquepfckt 7> =0 =5
Acmckb? ajw 6 rcb fcbeuf 6 ycaajw nemn 6 mrcck
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
13/31
Sket alhjur
`jst
(Tcr`cktlmc
(
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
14/31
Hlsc jk tlhac 48 lkb tlhac 40 wc `lk mevc tnc gjaajwekm bcs`reptejk jg tnc gjur ebcktegecb
mrjups l``jrbekm tj tncer cxpjsurc tj lboustfckt prcssurc?
Mrjup
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
15/31
x
ckcrmy. Bcspetc tnc tc`nkjajme`la klturc jg tncsc sc`tjrs lkb tnc efpjrtlk`c jg X&B,
tncer bcpckbck`c jk E@R es kjt kc`csslreay nemn.
4.3 Ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri hy `juktry
Rnc ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri palys l icy rjac ek jur lklayses, ls et cklhacs lkb rcekgjr`cs
tnc lboustfckt pjtcktela jg gerfs lkb sc`tjrs, cspc`elaay tnrjumn tnc prjpcr guk`tejkekm jg
tnc alhjur flrict, hut lasj tnrjumn snlpekm lk cktrcprckcurela ckverjkfckt lkb tj sjfc
cxtckt suppjrtekm tnc tc`nkjajme`la lboustfckt `lpl`ety. Hcsebcs, tnc ekstetutejkla
grlfcwjri `lk lasj cxcrt lboustfckt prcssurc jk tj gerfs lkb sc`tjrs cspc`elaay wnck
`jksebcrekm jtncr bjfleks tnlk cktcrpresc pjae`y - gjr ekstlk`c tnrjumn rcekgjr`ekm
ckverjkfcktla jr stre`tcr alhjur flrict rcmualtejk.
]c nlvc cxlfekcb tnc `juktrecs ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri l`rjss Curjpc lkb tnrjumn lk
cfpere`la lklayses ebcktegecb l kufhcr jg `juktry typjajmecs. @jksebcrekm tnc rcsuats jg
tnc `austcr lklayses, tnc gjaajwekm mrjups jg `juktrecs `lk hc bestekmuesncb?
Kcw Fcfhcr Ptltcs ncrc rcprcscktcb hy Tjalkb lkb tnc @zc`n Xcpuhae`9
Lkmaj-Plxjk `juktrecs wetnek tnc CS? Sketcb Iekmbjf lkb Ercalkb9
Kjrtn ]cstcrk Curjpc9 Hcameuf, Mcrflky lkb tnc Kctncralkbs9
Pjutncrk lkb Lapekc Curjpc9 Lustrel, Etlay, Pplek lkb Grlk`c.
Rnc Kjrtncrk `juktrecs? Bckflri, Gekalkb lkb Kjrwly.
Gjr cl`n jg tncsc mrjups wc sufflrezc tnc flek `nlrl`tcreste`s ek l mrjup prjgeac,
wncrchy tnc sezc jg tnc `er`ac es lk ekbe`ltejk jg tnc ek`aekltejk jg tnc ekstetutejklagrlfcwjri tj `jkbetejk stru`turla `nlkmc (gemurc 4.0) ]c kjrflaezcb tnc beggcrckt
vlrelhacs lkb ekvcrtcb tnc s`lac jg l kufhcr jg vlrelhacs2tj laajw ebckte`la ektcrprctltejk
jg laa vlrelhacs? tnc nemncr tnc s`jrc, tnc hcttcr tnc jut`jfc.
2
Rnc gjaajwekm vlrelhacs nlvc hcck ekvcrtcb? cfpajyfckt prjtc`tejk acmesaltejk, hlrmlekekm `jvcrlmc, trlbcukejk bcksety, rcmualtjry lkb lbfekestrltevc jpl`ety, hlrrecrs tj `jfpctetejk, lbfekestrltevc hurbcks,hlrrecrs tj trlbc lkb ekvcstfckt lkb stltc `jktrja.
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
16/31
Gemurc 4.0 Ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri `jkbetejks hy `juktry typc
Kcw Fcfhcr Ptltcs
-0.4-8.4-
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
17/31
@jffjk `nlrl`tcreste`s jg tncKcw Fcfhcr Ptltcs lrc tnc kcmaemehac acvca jg clray stlmc
vckturc `lpetla, l rcaltevcay stre`t alhjur prjtc`tejk, l ajw tjtla puhae` cxpckbeturc jk
L`tevc Alhjur flrict pjae`y, rcaltevcay ajw `jaac`tevc hlrmlekekm `jvcrlmc, lkb l ajw
kufhcr jg mrlbultcs ek fltn lkb s`eck`c, cspc`elaay ek tnc @zc`n Xcpuhae`. Gurtncrfjrc,tncrc es l nemn rcmualtjry lkb lbfekestrltevc jpl`ety, l alrmc lbfekestrltevc hurbck tj
stlrt-ups, hlrrecrs tj trlbc lkb ekvcstfckt lkb stltc `jktrja, cspc`elaay ek Tjalkb, wncrcls
tnc Kcw Fcfhcr Ptltcs nlvc l ajw gacxeheaety ek `ajsekm husekcss lkb ajw cxpckbeturcs ek
puhae` X&B.
Rnc Lkmaj-Plxjk `juktrecs lrc `nlrl`tcrezcb hy l nemn s`jrc jk clsc jg mcttekm `rcbet,
ajw alhjur prjtc`tejk, ajw tjtla puhae` cxpckbeturcs jk l`tevc alhjur flrict pjae`ecs, l
nemn kufhcr jg mrlbultcs ek tcrtelry cbu`ltejk lkb mrlbultcs ek fltn lkb s`eck`c, lkb
ajw hlrrecrs tj `jfpctetejk, lbfekestrltevc hurbcks tj stlrt-up, ls wcaa ls hlrrecrs tj trlbc
lkb ekvcstfckt lkb stltc `jktrja. Rnc Lkmaj-Plxjk `juktrecs lasj bcfjkstrltc l nemn
gacxeheaety ek `ajsekm husekcss lkb l ajw cxpckbeturc ek puhae` X&B, hut l nemn snlrc jg
(fcbeuf) nemn-tc`n X&B ls plrt jg tjtla X&B.
@jffjk `nlrl`tcreste`s jg Kjrtnwcstcrk Curjpc (Hcameuf, tnc Kctncralkbs lkb
Mcrflky) lrc tnc ajw acvca jg clray stlmc vckturc `lpetla ekvcstfckts, l stre`t alhjur
prjtc`tejk, nemn tjtla puhae` cxpckbeturcs jk l`tevc alhjur flrict pjae`ecs, nemn `jaac`tevc
hlrmlekekm `jvcrlmc, l ajw kufhcr jg mrlbultcs ek tcrtelry cbu`ltejk lkb ek fltn lkb
s`eck`cs, l nemn rcmualtjry lkb lbfekestrltevc jpl`ety. Gurtncrfjrc, tncsc `juktrecs nlvc
ajw hlrrecrs tj `jfpctetejk, l aefetcb lbfekestrltevc hurbck tj stlrt-up lkb ajw hlrrecrs tj
trlbc lkb ekvcstfckt.
Rnc Pjutncrk lkb Lapekc Curjpc`juktrecs lrc acss njfjmckjus, hut kcvcrtncacss snjw
sjfc `jffjk gclturcs, ek`aubekm l ajw acvca jg clray stlmc vckturc `lpetla ekvcstfckt, l
stre`t alhjur prjtc`tejk, nemn `jaac`tevc hlrmlekekm `jvcrlmc, l ajw rcmualtjry lkb
lbfekestrltevc jpl`ety lkb nemn lbfekestrltevc hurbcks tj stlrt-up.
Rnc Kjrbe` `juktrecs lasj nlvc sjfc `jffjk `nlrl`tcreste`s su`n ls nemn tjtla puhae`
cxpckbeturcs jk l`tevc alhjur flrict pjae`ecs, nemn `jaac`tevc hlrmlekekm `jvcrlmc lkb
ukejk bcksety, ajw lbfekestrltevc hurbcks tj stlrt-up lkb nemn gacxeheaety ek `ajsekm
husekcss, lkb nemn puhae` X&B cxpckbeturcs.
Ek `jk`ausejk, wc `lk stltc tnlt tnc prjpcksety jg tnc ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri tj suppjrt jr
nlfpcr stru`turla `nlkmc vlrecs `jksebcrlhay l`rjss Curjpc. L`rjss tnc hjlrb, tnc Lkmaj-
Plxjk `juktrecs lppclr tj nlvc ekstetutejkla grlfcwjris tnlt lrc fjrc `jkbu`evc tjwlrbs
prjfjtekm lboustfckt pjtcktela. Lplrt grjf alhjur flrict guk`tejkekm, tnc ekstetutejkla
grlfcwjri jg Kcw Fcfhcr Ptltcs lkb tj sjfc cxtckt Pjutncrk Curjpclk `juktrecs tckb
tj put fjrc lboustfckt prcssurc tj tncer gerfs lkb sc`tjrs kjtlhay ek tcrfs jg
cktrcprckcurela ckverjkfckt lkb tc`nkjajme`la `lpl`ety. Rnc ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri
`jkbetejks ek Kjrtncrk lkb Kjrtn ]cstcrk Curjpc lppclr tj hc fjrc hlalk`cb ek tcrfs jg
cxcrtekm lboustfckt prcssurcs ek sjfc lrcls wneac prjfjtekm lboustfckt pjtcktela ek
jtncrs.
xee
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
18/31
4.7 Trcssurc lkb lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c hy sc`tjr
Jur kcxt stcp ek tnc lklayses es tj cxlfekc tnc rcaltejksnep hctwcck lboustfckt prcssurc
(cxcrtcb hy majhlaezltejk lkb tc`nkjajme`la `nlkmc) lkb lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c jg tnc
ekbustry. Rncrctj, wnck usekm lboustfckt ekbe`ltjrs (tlhac 4.0), wc lrc ektrjbu`ekm tnc
tcrfs lboustfckt acvca lkb lboustfckt spccb hjtn jg wne`n lrc efpjrtlkt gjr
ukbcrstlkbekm stru`turla `nlkmc.
Rlhac 4.0. Ekbe`ltjrs gjr fclsurekm lboustfckt prcssurc lkb tncer bcgeketejk
Tcr`cktlmc jg wjrigjr`c wnj wjricb ek lkjtncr sc`tjr jkc yclr
clraecrFjheaety
Pieaas Tcr`cktlmc jg njurs wjricb hy nemn sieaacb pcjpac ek lk ekbustryAlhjur
flrict
Ojh `rcltejkRnc lhsjautc kct kufhcr jg ojhs `rcltcb pcr sc`tjr pcr
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
19/31
Rlhac 4.2 Lvcrlmc lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c acvca hy laa flkugl`turekm sc`tjrs gjr scac`tcb vlrelhacs (Rnc sc`tjrs lrc
aestcb l``jrbekm tj tnc mrjupekm jg sc`tjrs l``jrbekm tj lboustfckt prcssurc lvcrlmc rlkiekm jk l s`lac grjf
< tj 8 3,85 3,2< 7,= 3,72 3,2> 3,>> 0,50 0,20 0,50 3,8=
Gjjbprjbu`tslkbhcvcrlmcs 7,=< 8,72 2,=5 =,72 7,=5 >,3= =,50 =,3= 0,85 7 8,>7 =,7 >,=<
]jjblkbprjbu`tsjgwjjablkb`jri 7,85 3,8< 2,72 =,4= 3,85 =,=< =,07 =,4= 0,07
Tuap,plpcrlkbplpcrprjbu`ts 2,50 7,72 2,72 >,8< 3,,=5 7, 2,82 2,24 3,24
Xuhhcrlkbpalste`prjbu`its 3,=5 7,7 3,85 3,=< 2,=< 0,>7 3,8< 3,>7 3,=< 3,50 3,30
Gurketurc 3,3= 0,50 8,=5 2,>7 0,50 5,44 >,,72 5,85 >,5 7,,4= >,3= >,07 2,=< 7,85
Fl`nekcrylkbcquepfckt 3,20 7,8< 7,4= 0,3= 0,>7 >,8< =,72 =,4= 3,7 7,34 2,8< >,>7 5,3= >,=< >,8< 7,2>
Cac`tre`lafl`nekcrylkblpplrltus =,44 =,=< 7,20 0,50 2,20 3,=< 2,7 7,44 =,=< =,3= >,07 7,82
Xlbej,tcacvesejklkbrlbejtrlksfettcrs 3,34 =,=< 2,=< 7,44 2,=5 2,20 0,>7 2,50 =,50 5,=< 5,72 5,4= 7,38
Fcbe`la,prc`esejklkbjpte`laekstrufckts 2,07 =,=< 5,44 0,34 3,=5 7,>7 2,4= 2,50 3,44 >,=5 >,8< >,8< 7,0=
Fjtjrvcne`acs,trleacrslkbscfetrleacrs 3,=5 7,=5 =,4= =,44 2,34 0,8< 8,=< 0,=5 7,07 >,44 =,=< 5,4= 7,44
Rrlkspjrtcquepfckt 0,85 =,44 7,07 2,72 8,72 2,>7 3,3= 2,=< 2,85 >,20 =,07 7,50 3,3
Acmckb? rcb 6 nemn rlki ycaajw 6 lvcrlmc hauc 6 ajw
Ekbccb, ls rcgac`tcb ek tlhac 4.2 lhjvc, wc `lk scc sjfc plttcrks hctwcck lboustfckt
pcrgjrflk`c lkb lboustfckt prcssurc, njwcvcr kjt lawlys ek l aekclr jr strlemntgjrwlrb
flkkcr.
Jvcrlaa, fjst streiekm es tnc strjkm pcrgjrflk`c s`jrcs jg tnc nemnay majhlaescb lkb
tc`nkjajmy ektcksevc sc`tjrs (Mrjup 2), kjt jkay ek lrcls jg tc`nkjajmy (cvebckt ls
tc`nkjajme`la ektcksety wls tlick ls l stlrtekm pjekt) hut lasj ek tcrfs jg sieaas lkb ojh
`rcltejk ls wcaa ls prjbu`tevety. Tcrnlps cvck fjrc ektcrcstekm es tnc gl`t tnlt sc`tjrs wetn
l nemn tc`nkjajme`la ektcksety nlvc ajwcr s`jrcs jk cktrcprckcurelaesf (su`n ls (fe`rj-)
gerf `rcltejk lkb cxet). Rnes `juab hc buc tj tnc nemn hlrrecrs tj cktry ek tncsc sc`tjrs
efpayekm tnlt cstlhaesncb gerfs suggcr acss grjf kcw cktrlkts tnlk ek jtncr ekbustrecs. Lk
ektcrcstekm efpae`ltejk `juab hc tnlt lboustfckt spccb ek tc`nkjajme`la ektcksevc
xev
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
20/31
ekbustrecs `juab hc beggcrckt grjf jtncr sc`tjrs wncrc lboustfckt `juab hc l fjrc
mrlbula lkb `jkstlkt prj`css. Hueabekm jk eksemnts grjf cvjautejklry c`jkjfe`s, et `juab
wcaa hc tnlt stru`turla lboustfckt ek tc`nkjajme`la gerfs prj`ccb ek snj`is lkb stlmcs
wetn rcaltevcay aettac lboustfckt wetnek cxestekm flricts hut wetn rlpeb `nlkmcs wncrctc`nkjajmecs (lkb tnc l``jrbekm plrlbemfs) snegt.
Gurtncrfjrc, et es streiekm tj scc tnlt majhlaesltejk prcssurcs (ls fclsurcb tnrjumn cxpjrt
snlrcs) bj kjt cxcrt l sefealr efpl`t jk lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c ekbe`ltjrs gl`tjrs su`n ls
ojh fjheaety lkb ojh `rcltejk. Rj tnc `jktrlry, wc `lk scc tnlt tnc acss cxpjscb ekbustry
mrjups wjriekm prcbjfeklktay gjr bjfcste` flricts snjw nemncr jr lt aclst sefealr
ekvcstfckt acvcas (ls % jg vlauc lbbcb) tnlk fjrc majhlaescb sc`tjrs. Ekbccb, majhlaescb
sc`tjrs jvcrlaa bj kjt stlkb jut ek tcrfs jg ekvcstfckt acvcas. @lpetla ektcksevckcss (c.m.
`ncfe`las, fjtjr vcne`acs, puap lkb plpcr) lppclrs tj hc fjrc efpjrtlkt tnlk majhla
prcssurcs pcr sc.
Cqulaay, sc`tjrs wne`n lrc acss cxpjscb grjf cxtcrkla trlbc prcssurcs lppclr tj hc fjrc
prjgetlhac tnlk majhlaescb sc`tjrs. Cxlfpacs lrc tnc gjjb lkb fekcrla prjbu`ts sc`tjrs.
]etnek tnc majhlaescb lkb tc`nkjajmy ektcksevc mrjup, l nemn acvca jg prjgetlheaety `lk hc
rc`jrbcb ek tnc `ncfe`la ekbustry ek`aubekm tnc pnlrfl`cute`la ekbustry. Lmlek, sjfc
cacfckt jg flrict prjtc`tejk `juab paly l rjac ncrc stepualtcb hy tnc rcmualtjry prj`css
wne`n rcbu`cs `jfpctetejk lt aclst gjr `crtlek pcrejbs lkb flricts. Et snjuab hc
fcktejkcb ncrc tnlt tncsc prjgets lrc jgtck rcquercb gjr rc-ekvcstekm ek X&B.
Rnc lhjvc gekbekms pjekt tj lk ektcrcstekm plrlbjx? tnjsc sc`tjrs wne`n lrc strjkmay
cxpjscb tj lboustfckt prcssurc wjuab rcquerc rcaltevcay nemn acvcas jg prjgetlheaety lkbekvcstfckt ls plrt jg tnc kccb tj hueab lboustfckt `lpl`ety. Njwcvcr, et es tnc slfc
strjkm majhla `jfpctetejk tnlt fly wcaa aefet tncsc vcry slfc acvcas jg prjgetlheaety lkb
ekvcstfckt jgtck tj tnc hckcget jg `jksufcrs. Rnus, tncrc lrc sjfc nekts ek tnc lhjvc
gekbekms tnlt lboustfckt prcssurc bjcs kjt lawlys lkb berc`tay rcsuat ek sefealr lboustfckt
pcrgjrflk`c. Skbcrayekm rclsjks gjr tnes wcli aeki hctwcck lboustfckt prcssurc lkb
pcrgjrflk`c fly hc buc tj beggcrckt `lpetla/jutput rltejs gjr cl`n sc`tjr, jr nctcrjmckcety
wetnek sc`tjrs. Kcvcrtncacss, tnc lklayses pjekts tj sjfc gjjb gjr tnjumnt.
Ek `jk`ausejk, wc `lk stltc tnlt hjtn icy brevcrs hcnekb lboustfckt prcssurc
(tc`nkjajme`la ektcksety ls wcaa ls majhlaesltejk prcssurcs) nlvc sjfc ukcxpc`tcb
rcaltejks wetn lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c? tc`nkjajme`la ektcksety aclbs kjt jkay tj nemncr
prjbu`tevety hut lasj tj nemncr hlrrecrs tj cktry lkb cxet lkb tncrcgjrc aefets l `jkstlkt
lkb mrlbula prj`css jg stru`turla `nlkmc, wneac majhlaesltejk prcssurcs fly wcaa crjbc
tnc `lpl`ety jg gerfs lkb sc`tjrs tj rcekvcst lkb rcekvckt tncfscavcs tj tnc cxtckt kccbcb.
4.7.8 Lklayses jg spccb ekbe`ltjrs jg lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c hy sc`tjr mrjups
Rurkekm tnc gj`us lt tnc lboustfckt spccb `nlkmcs ek lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c jvcr l
tck yclr pcrejb l quetc beggcrckt pe`turc es jhscrvcb ek tlhac 4.3. Pjfc rlbe`la `nlkmcs
`lk hc jhscrvcb wetnek kekc jut jg cacvck ekbe`ltjrs wneac lboustfckt spccb es lafjst
uk`nlkmcb wetnek tnc rcflekekm ekbe`ltjrs (fjheaety lkb ekvcstfckt rltc). Rnes pjekt tj
lboustfckt prcssurc nlvekm nlb jkay fekjr efpl`t jk tncsc ekbe`ltjrs burekm tnc alst
bc`lbc.
xv
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
21/31
Rlhac 4.3 Lvcrlmc spccb ekbe`ltjrs jg lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c hy tnc sc`tjr mrjupekm l``jrbekm tj lboustfckt prcssurc
gjr cl`n jg tnc scac`tcb vlrelhacs. Kjrflaezcb lboustfckt spccb hy prcssurc mrjups. Fclk vlaucs.
Alhjur flrict Gerf hcnlvejur Rc`nkjajmy
Trcssurc mrjupsF
jheaety
Pieaas
Ojh`rcltejk
Ekvcstfckt
Trj
getl
heaety
F
e`rjcktcrpr
escs
Kcw
cktcrpr
escs
Cx
etcktcrpr
escs
Trj
bu`tevety
XB
Cf
pajyccs
XB
Ekvcstfckt
Majhla ajw lkb tc`nektcksety ajw -4,4
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
22/31
xvee
]c lssufc tnlt tnc ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri `lk paly l rjac cklhaekm lkb rcekgjr`ekm tnc
lboustfckt pjtcktela jg gerfs lkb sc`tjrs, ls wcaa ls tnc ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri lasj `lk
cxcrt lboustfckt prcssurc jk gerfs lkb sc`tjrs. Rnc icy qucstejk es tncrcgjrc, wne`n
ekbe`ltjrs lrc ekgauck`cb hy tnc ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri `jkbetejk. Ek l setultejk wetnaettac besplretecs ek lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c hctwcck tnc mrjups, wc tncrcgjrc lssufc l
fjrc aefetcb ekgauck`c jg lboustfckt prcssurc.
4.=.,4 7,> 3,7 3,0 0,> 2,= 2,3 3,8 3,7
@zc`nXcpuhae` 8,7 3,0 3,= =,= =,2 =,8 7,0 7,< 8,4 0,7 7,4 3,4 3,2
Tjalkb 7,5 3,0 7,0 =,> >,3 7,2 2,5 2,2 3,= 3,= 0,4 3,2 3,5
LkmajPlxjk@juktrecs =,5 3,7 2,7 2,3 7,= 2,2 0,3 3,3 3,= 3,= 2,= 3,= 3,2
SketcbIekmbjf 5,= 3,0 0,7 2,2 7,4 3,0 2,4 0,2 3,= 3,= 3,8 3,0 3,0
Ercalkb 7,< 7,4 3,= 2,3 =,2 0,3 0,4 =,= 3,= 3,= 2,8 7,< 3,3
Kjrtn]cstcrkCurjpc 2,= 3,3 3,3 2,7 2,> 3,8 3,0 2,5 7,4 3,3 3,7 3,> 3,0
Hcameuf 8,= 3,7 3,3 2,= 3,3 7,< 7,8 7,2 7,2 3,7 7,< 3,0 3,3
Mcrflky 2,5 3,7 3,= 2,7 0,= 2,0 0,3 0,< 3,= 3,< 3,7 7,= 2,5
Kctncralkbs 7,0 3,2 3,0 2,0 3,0 3,4 7,0 3,2 7,4 3,= 3,4 3,2 3,3
PjutncrklkbLapekcCurjpc 2,5 3,7 3,7 3,5 2,5 3,5 2,5 2,3 3,0 3,3 3,4 3,0 3,0
Lustrel 0,= 3,7 3,3 3,4 3,= 3,< =,< =,< 7,= 3,2 7,< 7,4 3,=
Etlay 0,5 3,= 3,7 7,> 3,> =,4 0,5 0,3 0,= 3,= 0,= 2,< 3,4
Grlk`c 7,5 3,= 2,2 3,> 8,5 3,3 2,4 0,0 7,4 3,0 3,7 7,4 3, 2,= 2,4 3,< 3,3 2,3 3,< 3,0
Kjrtncrk`juktrecs 7,< 3,7 3,7 3,< 2,7 3,8 =,= =,7 7,< 3,5 7,3 3,8 3,5
Bckflri 7,5 3,7 3,2 3,5 2,8 3,0 =,7 =,8 7,4 3,= 3,= 7,< 7,4
Gekalkb 3,8 3,3 3,5 2,5 3,5 7,< =,3 =,7 3,7 3,= 7,5 7,< 7,,4 >,4 7,> 7,0 =,4 0,0 3,>
Lvcrlmcjglaa 3,3 3,3 3,3 3,3 3,3 3,3 3,3 3,3 3,3 3,3 3,0 3,2 3,3
Rnc lhjvc plttcrk `lk hc cxpalekcb hy beggcrck`cs ek gerf hcnlvejur kjtlhay tnc
gjrfltejk lkb cxet jg cktcrprescs. Rnc Kjrbe` `juktrecs bcfjkstrltc lboustfckt acvcas
tnlt lrc lt aclst twe`c ls nemn ls tnc alrmc `jktekcktla `juktrecs `aclr semks jg byklfe`
cktrcprckcurela `uaturcs. Ek Tjalkb lkb tnc @zc`n Xcpuhae` ekvcstfckt, prjgetlheaety lkb
fe`rj cktcrprescs rlki wcaa lhjvc tnc lvcrlmc, eaaustrltekm tnc byklfe`s lkb nemn mrjwtn
rltcs jg tnc c`jkjfecs ek tnc Kcw Fcfhcr Ptltcs. Njwcvcr, cspc`elaay tnc @zc`n
Xcpuhae` lppclrs tj nlvc l ajw alhjur prjbu`tevety wne`n es streiekm ek aemnt jg tnc
pcrgjrflk`c jg Tjalkb - lajkm wetn Etlay.
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
23/31
xveee
@jk`crkekm tc`nkjajme`la prjmrcss, tnc flkugl`turekm sc`tjrs ek tnc @zc`n Xcpuhae` nlvc
ajw kufhcrs jg X&B cfpajyccs rcaltevc tj tjtla cfpajyfckt. Rnes fly wcaa hc rcaltcb
tj tnc sc`tjrla `jfpjsetejk jg tnc flkugl`turekm sc`tjr. Njwcvcr, `nlkmc es jk tnc wly
ls (GBE-rcaltcb) X&B ekvcstfckts ek tnc @zc`n Xcpuhae` lrc `jksebcrlhay nemncr kjw, ltacvcas `jfplrlhac tj Gekalkb, Kjrwly, lkb Lustrel. Geklaay, bcspetc tnc jvcrlaa ajw
rlkiekm jg Mcrflky ek tcrfs jg lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c, Mcrflk flkugl`turekm
ekbustrecs lrc lfjkmst tnc fjst ekkjvltevc ekbustrecs ek Curjpc ls fclsurcb hy X&B
ekbe`ltjrs.
4.=.8 Lklayses jg spccb ekbe`ltjrs jg lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c hy `juktry mrjups
]nck cxpalekekm lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c spccb, alhjur flrict gl`tjrs lkb ekvcstfckt
rltc tckb tj hc fjrc byklfe` tnlk jtncr lspc`ts jg gerf hcnlvejur lkb tc`nkjajmy
prjmrcss (tlhac 4.=). L`rjss Fcfhcr stltcs, wc `lk lssufc tnlt alrmcr beggcrck`cs j``ur
wetnek alhjur flrict pjae`y tnlk wetnek jtncr pjae`y lrcls. Hy tnc slfc tjick, wc lssufc
fjrc `jkvcrmck`c hctwcck Fcfhcr stltcs ek ekkjvltejk pjae`ecs, cktrcprckcurela pjae`y
jr `jrpjrltc tlx pjae`y - lggc`tekm ekvcstfckt ek tc`nkjajme`la bcvcajpfckt,
cktrcprckcursnep lkb prjgetlheaety.
Rlhac 4.= Lvcrlmc spccb ekbe`ltjrs jg lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c hy `austcrs gjr cl`n jg tnc scac`tcb vlrelhacs
Alhjur flrict Gerf hcnlvejur Rc`nkjajmy
@juktry MrjupsF
jheaety
Pieaas
Oj
h`rclt
ejk
Ekvcs
tfc
kt
Trj
getl
he
aety
F
e`rjck
tcrpr
escs
Kcw
cktcrpr
escs
Cx
etck
tc
rpr
escs
Trj
bu`tev
ety
XB
Cfpajyccs
XB
Ekvcs
tf
ck
t
Kcw fcfhcr stltcs -4,03 -4,2> -4,45 4,47 4,22 4,45 4, 4,
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
24/31
hlses, lkb et es qucstejklhac wnctncr tnc ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri `jkbetejks lrc guaay
cklhaekm su`n trlksgjrfltejks. Rnc rjac jg ekwlrb GBE kccbs tj hc lsscsscb ek tnes aemnt
ls wcaa.
Rnc Kjrbe` `juktrecs - trlbetejklaay wetn lk jggcksevc puhae` pjae`y ek flky lrcls,
bcfjkstrltc l strjkm lboustfckt spccb wetnek gjur ekbe`ltjrs sieaas, ekvcstfckt rltc lkb
mrjwtn ek fe`rj cktcrprescs lkb kcutrla bcvcajpfckt gjr tnc rcst jg tnc ekbe`ltjrs.
Ek `jk`ausejk, latnjumn wc jhscrvc tnlt beggcrck`cs ek lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c `lk hc
j``lsejklaay rcaltcb tj beggcrck`cs ek tnc ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri - cspc`elaay wetnek tnc
lrcl jg alhjur flrict pjae`y. Njwcvcr ek fjst `lscs, tnc ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri
`jkbetejk tckbs tj nlvc jkay l kcutrla jr l blfpckekm cggc`t jk lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c
jg tnc flkugl`turekm ekbustry. Rnes es l sjfcwnlt `nlaackmekm nypjtncses, ls flky
Fcfhcr stltcs `alef tj nlvc l pjae`y gj`us jk stru`turla rcgjrf lkb mrjwtn pjae`y.
4.> Tuttekm et laa tjmctncr? lboustfckt prcssurc, pjtcktela, pcrgjrflk`c lkbc`jkjfe` jut`jfcs
Lt tnc ckb jg tnc bly, stru`turla lboustfckt es kjt tj hc scck ls lk jhoc`tevc jk ets jwk,
hut rltncr ls l fclks tjwlrbs fjrc su``cssgua c`jkjfe` pcrgjrflk`c. Nck`c tnc kccb tj
put c`jkjfe` jut`jfc ektj tnc cqultejk? Bjcs lboustfckt prcssurc ekbccb aclb tj mrcltcr
lboustfckt pjtcktela, pcrgjrflk`c, lkb geklaay tj mrjwtn, ojhs, lkb prjspcrety:Bjcs, ls
tnc `jk`cptula grlfcwjri summcsts, stru`turla lboustfckt ekbccb aclb tj hcttcr c`jkjfe`
jut`jfcs:
4.>.).
Ekbustrela stru`turc beggcrs hjtn wetnek lkb hctwcck tnc beggcrckt `austcrs jg `juktrecs,
wne`n rcekgjr`cs tnc fcsslmc tnlt ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri `jkbetejks jk tncer jwk lrc kjt
lutjflte`laay cklhaekm jkc spc`ege` lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c rcsuatekm ek jkc spc`ege`
ekbustrela stru`turc.
xex
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
25/31
xx
Rlhac 4.>? Lmmrcmltcb prjgeac jg tnc flkugl`turekm ekbustry ek scac`tcb juktrecs tnc ekbustrela stru`turc es lssufcb tj hc
lk jut`jfc jg tnc lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c.
Kjtc? MBT acvcas - TTT lboustcb MBT pcr `lpetlKjtc? GBE ektcksety vlauc jg ekwlrb lkb jutwlrb GBE ls l snlrc jg MBTKjtc? Rnc spc`elaesltejk ekbcx es hlsc jk cfpajyfckt hy sc`tjr ek CS 8=
Ercalkb, Mcrflky, Gekalkb lkb, tj sjfc cxtckt, Grlk`c lrc `nlrl`tcrescb hy lk
jvcrrcprcscktltejk jg flkugl`turekm ekbustrecs cxpjscb tj l nemn prcssurc grjf hjtn
majhlaesltejk lkb tc`nkjajmy9 ek jtncr wjrbs, tnc ekbustrela stru`turc ek tncsc `juktrecs es
helscb tjwlrbs l fjrc majhlaescb lkb ikjwacbmc hlscb bcvcajpfckt.
Xcaltevcay aefetcb efpjrtlk`c tj tnc flkugl`turekm sc`tjr jvcrlaa es rc`jrbcb ek tnc
Sketcb Iekmbjf, Kjrwly, Hcameuf lkb tnc Kctncralkbs bcfjkstrltcb gjr ekstlk`c hy
tnc snlrc jg cfpajyccs lkb jutput grjf tnc flkugl`turekm ekbustry wne`n es rcaltevcay
ajw. Gurtncrfjrc, tnc rcflekekm flkugl`turekm ekbustry tckbs tj spc`elaesc ek acss
cxpjscb sc`tjrs, wncrc tnc gjr`cs jg majhlaesltejk lkb tc`nkjajme`la `nlkmc lrc
sjfcwnlt acss prjkjuk`cb.
Ppc`elaesltejk(Majhlaesltejk/tc`nkjajmy)
MBTacvcas
Wlauc lbbcbjg
flkugl`turekmls l snlrc jg
tjtla vlauclbbcb jg laaekbustrecs
Wlauclbbcb
(Curj) jgflkugl`tu
rekm pcr8 87 8.7 38 2 0> 3> -4,88 4, 4,40 4,
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
26/31
Flkugl`turekm ekbustry es fjrc efpjrtlkt ek Lustrel, Etlay, lkb Tjalkb, hut tncer strckmtn
sccfs tj aec rltncr ek trlbetejkla prjbu`tejk wetn ajw-tc`n `jktckt, jg wne`n sjfc lrc
cxpjscb tj majhlaesltejk. Rnc flkugl`turekm sc`tjr nls l rcaltevcay nemn efpjrtlk`c
fclsurcb hy cfpajyfckt, hut l fekjr rjac fclsurcb hy c`jkjfe` jutput.
Aekiekm tnc lhjvc stru`turla `nlrl`tcreste`s tj jur `jk`cptula grlfcwjri, jkc effcbeltc
jhscrvltejk es tnlt `juktrecs wetn sefealr grlfcwjri `jkbetejks bj kjt kc`csslreay aclb tj
`juktrecs wetn tnc slfc lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c (tlhac 4.7). Ekbccb, wc `lk scc tnlt
`juktrecs wetn sefealr ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri `jkbetejks `lk gjaajw beggcrckt plttcrks jg
stru`turla bcvcajpfckt (tlhac 4.>).
4.>.8 Aekiekm c`jkjfe` jut`jfc wetn lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c
Rnc aekilmcs hctwcck tnc lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c lkb tnc c`jkjfe` jut`jfc jr
ekbustrela stru`turc sccf tj hc fjrc cvebckt, hut wc nlvc tj bcla wetn rcsuats wetn mrclt
`lutejk, ls jur bltl es bcs`rehekm vcry `jfpacx stru`turcs lkb rcaltejksneps. Rncrcgjrc,
wc weaa aefet jurscavcs tj sjfc spc`ualtevc nypjtncscs jkay.
Hy `jfplrekm tncKcw Fcfhcr Ptltcs @zc`n Xcpuhae` lkb Tjalkb wc gekb tnlt tnc vlauc
lbbcb grjf flkugl`turekm ekbustry es fu`n nemncr ek tnc @zc`n Xcpuhae`, wne`n femnt
hc l `jkscquck`c jg tnc trlbetejklaay nemn spc`elaesltejk jg flkugl`turekm ncrc, wne`n nls
rcsuatcb ek ets lheaety tj hc su``cssguaay cxpjscb tj majhlaesltejk lkb tc`nkjajme`la `nlkmc
(tlhac 4.>). Husekcss byklfe`s gerf hcnlvejur es saemntay nemncr ek tnc @zc`n
Xcpuhae`, cx`cpt gjr prjbu`tevety. Laa ek laa, tnc ekbustry ek tnc @zc`n Xcpuhae` sccfs tj
lboust tj ek`rclsekm majhla `jfpctetejk, wne`n femnt cklhac tnc `juktry tj flektlek tncnemn c`jkjfe` pcrgjrflk`c (vlauc lbbcb lkb cfpajyfckt), wneac tnc Tjaesn ekbustry
flektleks l rltncr ajw vlauc lbbcb pcr cfpajycc.
]etnek tncLkmaj-Plxjk `juktrecs, Ercalkb nls l strjkm nemn-tc`n flkugl`turekm ekbustry
`nlrl`tcrescb hy nemn cxpjsurc tj majhlaesltejk lkb tc`nkjajme`la `nlkmc, wneac tnc
Sketcb Iekmbjf nls trlksgjrfcb grjf flkugl`turekm tj scrve`cs wetn rcflekekm
flkugl`turekm jrecktcb tjwlrbs tnc aj`la flrict. L `ajscr ajji lt tnc majhlaescb, nemn-
tc`n flkugl`turekm sc`tjrs snjw tnlt Ercalkb nls l vcry nemn lkb uktea rc`cktay lk
ek`rclsekm ekvcstfckt rltc (cspc`elaay gjr tnc KL@C 08 Xlbej, tcacvesejk ct`.), lkb l nemn
acvca jg prjbu`tevety fu`n rcaltcb tj ekhjukb GBE wne`n tnc SI nls kjt scck tj tnc
slfc cxtckt. Fjrc puzzaekm es tnc gekbekm tnlt tnc ekbe`ltjr X&B ekvcstfckt snjws l
ajw acvca jg X&B ekvcstfckt ek tnc nemn-tc`n sc`tjrs, ekbe`ltekm tnlt tnc X&B prjgeac
femnt kjt hc ls strjkm ls et ajjis aeic. Gjr tnc Sketcb Iekmbjf, tnc rcflekekm nemn-tc`n
sc`tjr nls l nemn tj vcry nemn ekvcstfckt acvca, lkb l acvca tnlt nls hcck stlhac jvcr tnc
alst bc`lbc bcfjkstrltekm tnlt gerfs steaa prcsckt ek tnes sc`tjr nlvc l strjkm rcseaeck`c
ves--ves strjkm lboustfckt prcssurcs.
Rnc ektuetevc lsscssfckt es tnlt tnc Eresn nemn-tc`n ekbustry es efpjrtlkt gjr tnc `juktry
buc tj ets snccr sezc nemn c`jkjfe` jut`jfc - hut tnc ekbustry bjcs kjt sccf tj lboust
vcry wcaa tj guturc tc`nkjajme`la `nlkmcs lkb `nlaackmcs, wneac tnc nemn-tc`n sc`tjr ek tnc
Sketcb Iekmbjf sccfs tj hc ek tnc jppjsetc setultejk sflaa hut rlpebay lboustekm. Rnc
lhjvc plttcrks `lk hc cxtckbcb tj sjfc jtncr `juktrecs.
xxe
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
27/31
Ek `jk`ausejk, wc gekb tnlt tnc `jk`cptula grlfcwjri `lk cklhac lk lklayses jg tnc
stru`turla lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c gjr tnc flkugl`turekm ekbustry, ls wc `lk aeki plttcrk
jg lboustfckt prcssurc, lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c, lkb stru`turla `nlkmc. Njwcvcr, usekm
tnc `jk`cptula grlfcwjri lasj snjws tnc `jfpacxety jg lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c. Rnc`jk`cptula grlfcwjri lasj summcsts tnlt stru`turla lboustfckt aclbs tj hcttcr c`jkjfe`
jut`jfc, ls tnc `juktrecs spc`elaescb wetnek sc`tjrs cxpjscb tj lboustfckt prcssurc
majhlaescb lkb tc`nkjajmy ektcksevc sc`tjrs - nlvc tnc nemncst vlauc lbbcb pcr cfpajycc.
Rnc lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c jg tnc ekbustry sccfs tj l alrmc cxtckt tj hc l rcgac`tejk jg
tnc lboustfckt prcssurc, wncrc nemn prcssurc es rcgac`tcb ek tc`nkjajme`la prjmrcss, sieaas
lkb prjbu`tevety, wneac ajwcr prcssurcs rcsuat ek l nemncr husekcss byklfe`s sclr`nekm gjr
kcw flrict jppjrtuketecs.
4.5 Geklaay
]etn `lpetla flricts ek `reses, et es quetc clsy tj eflmekc njw (`nlkmekm) husekcss
`jkbetejks `lk lggc`t tnc pcrgjrflk`c jg ekbustry9 et es quetc l `nlaackmc kjt jkay tj
fclsurc lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c, hut tj ajji ukbcrkcltn tj lboustfckt pjtcktela,
lboustfckt prcssurc lkb tnc cklhaekm ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri `jkbetejks.
Hut bevekm ektj tnes typc jg stru`turla lklayses nls prjvck tj hc `jfpacx pcrnlps fjrc
sj tnlt wc larclby tnjumnt. ]c nlvc lbbrcsscb tnes `nlaackmc tnrjumn bcsemkekm lk
'ufhrcaal' - l `jk`cptula grlfcwjri, wncrc tnc jvcrlaa stru`turla bcvcajpfckt lkb tnc
lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c jg tnc flkugl`turekm ekbustry lt sc`tjr acvca es ukbcrstjjb ls l
rcsuat jg tnc cxpjsurc tj brevcrs jg stru`turla `nlkmc lkb cklhaekm ekstetutejk grlfcwjri`jkbetejks.
Hlscb jk tnc aetcrlturc rcvecw, wc nlvc lssufcb laa tnc wly strjkm aekilmcs hctwcck
lboustfckt prcssurc lkb tnc ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri jk jkc sebc, lkb tnc lboustfckt
pcrgjrflk`c jk tnc jtncr sebc. ]c nlvc tnck, ls glr ls nlrfjkescb Curjpclk stlteste`la
gemurcs nlvc hcck l``cssehac, ekbcktegecb l kufhcr jg ekbe`ltjrs wne`n fclsurc
lboustfckt prcssurc lkb pcrgjrflk`c ls wcaa ls `nlrl`tcresc tnc ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri
`jkbetejk.
Hy tnc fclks jg tnes ajkm aest jg ekbe`ltjrs wc nlvc flbc l s`lttcrcb fclsurcfckt jg tnc
lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c wetnek tnc lrcls jg alhjur flrict, husekcss hcnlvejur lkb
tc`nkjajme`la bcvcajpfckt gjr 80 flkugl`turekm sc`tjrs ek
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
28/31
Ek spetc jg tnc aefetltejks lkb tnc rcstre`tevc klturc jg tnc stuby, tnc `urrckt lkb subbck
c`jkjfe` `reses lggc`tekm tnc Curjpclk c`jkjfy nls fjrc tnlk cvcr hcgjrc strcsscb tnc
efpjrtlk`c jg ukbcrstlkbekm lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c lkb stru`turla `nlkmc. Ekbccb, tncrc
es l `jfpcaaekm kccb gjr l hcttcr ukbcrstlkbekm lkb fjrc eksemnts ektj tnc lboustfcktprcssurc lt ekbevebula c`jkjfe` sc`tjrs, tnc lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c jg sc`tjrs lkb
`juktrecs, lkb tnc ekstetutejkla grlfcwjri tnlt berc`tay efpl`ts tnc kccb lkb tnc
`lplheaetecs jg `nlkmc.
Cvck tnjumn tnes stuby nls prjvebcb l hcttcr ukbcrstlkbekm lkb fjrc eksemnt ektj tncsc
flttcrs, tncrc es steaa l kccb gjr gurtncr gjaajw up, jg wne`n wc `juab pjekt lt?
Ek-bcptn stubecs jk lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c wetnek spc`ege` sc`tjrs lkb/jr `juktrecs
(`lscs stubecs). Rnc lef jg su`n stubecs snjuab hc tj mct fjrc bctleacb eksemnt ektj
lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c, ls wcaa ls tcstekm tnc lppae`lheaety jg tnc `jk`cptula `jk`cpt
gjr lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c. Rnc rcacvlk`c jg tnc ebcktegecb ekbe`ltjrs lkb tnc kccb
gjr kcw ekbe`ltjrs snjuab hc l plrt jg su`n `lscs stubecs.
Lk c`jkjfctre` stuby tcstekm tnc `jk`cptula grlfcwjri, cspc`elaay tnc rcaltejksnep
hctwcck lboustfckt prcssurc, grlfcwjri `jkbetejk, lboustfckt lkb c`jkjfe`
pcrgjrflk`c.
Efprjvcfckt jg tnc Curjpclk ekbustrela stlteste`s. Gjr flky jg tnc ekbe`ltjrs bltl es
fessekm jr prcscktcb lt fu`n lmmrcmltcb acvca.
Rnc prcsckt stuby strcsscs tnc `nlaackmc jg wjriekm wetn lboustfckt pcrgjrflk`c ek l
fuatebefcksejkla lpprjl`n, lkb et `lk wjri ls l pjekt jg bcplrturc gjr gurtncr wjri. Rnc
kccb gjr `jktekuekm su`n stubecs es nemnay cfpnlsescb hy tnc `urrckt c`jkjfe` `reses
lggc`tekm tnc Curjpclk c`jkjfy.
xxeee
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
29/31
Lkkcx gemurcs jg lboustfckt acvcas hy sc`tjr lkb `juktry
Ek tnc gjaajwekm twj tlhacs tnc lvcrlmc vlaucs gjr tnc ekbe`ltjrs lrc `la`ualtcb laa tnc
sc`tjrs lkb gjr laa tnc `juktrecs ek`aubcb ek tnc stuby. Rnc klfcs jg laa tnc ekbe`ltjrs lrc
aestcb hcajw ls wcaa ls tnc fctnjbs jg `la`ualtejk.
Tcr`cktlmc jg wjrigjr`c wnj wjricb ek lkjtncr sc`tjr
jkc yclr clraecrFjheaety
PieaasTcr`cktlmc jg njurs wjricb hy nemn sieaacb pcjpac ek lk
ekbustry
Alhjur
flrict
Rnc lhsjautc kct kufhcr jg ojhs `rcltcb pcr sc`tjr pcr
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
30/31
xxv
4.5.
-
8/3/2019 Key Findings Measuring and Bench Marking En
31/31
4.5.8 Lboustfckt acvca lvcrlmcs vlaucs gjr cl`n sc`tjr l`rjss laa `juktrecs ek tnc stuby
Alhjur flrict Gerf hcnlvejur Rc`nkjajme`laprjmrcss
Pc`tjrKl`c8 bemetsFjheaety
Pieaas
Ojh`rcltejk
Ekvcstfckt
Trjgetlheaety
Fe`rj
cktcrprescs
Kcw
cktcrprescs
Cxet
cktcrprescs
Trjbu`tevety
XBCfpajycc
s
XB
Ekvcstfckt
XBRurkjvcr
Gjjbprjbu`tslkbhcvcrlmcs 4, 83,=7 ,43 22.5