kimberlin v. nbc (ii) amend compl redacted

8/20/2019 Kimberlin v. NBC (II) Amend Compl Redacted

1/60

!" $%& '!(')!$ '*)($ +*( ,*"$-*,&(. '*)"$. ,/(.0/"1

!"#$$ &'(!#")'*+

2344 56678 $966 (:; 56; ,1 ?423@AB>CD76; +


2/60

/#0-*7 ,(#*7#7 0-(2),'*$ 3-" 7,(,.#/

'*$"-710$'-*

3G AB>CD


3/60

EH9 WH96 D 9=G $86=6 CDB

8>9W >D: 6WHB :C=D: bH9 79CW6 H77T996: >< ::96== >==H7C> B>9J6 VHBC76 96=VHD=6G

MG 16E6D:>D:6 B=6; =B>D:69HT= >D: :6E>W>= bT9C=:C796 >BB

,>9SB>D: =X <

AB>CDD: JHF69DW6D< HEEC7C>B= >D: D:G ,>DS

HE DF6 7HDD: =S=D: >D: EECBC>D: >:F699SB>D:G ,>DS HE D9SB>D:G


4/60

@G Q6DT6 C= V9HV69 CD < AB>CD9SB>D:; W>DS HE 7D9SB>D:; 9SB>D:; >D: >

=T[=DB VH9JS C= > [BHJJ69 X8H 96=C:6= >< 34 PT==6Z 'JSG

3?G 5HD8>D >D: ">JS X9C J9HTV BH7>< 3OR PHT99CDJB=H BH7>< 233I %69CJ6 AB>76 19CF6; +


5/60

3OG 16E6D:>D< -B6DD 567Y C= > 9>:CH >D: BC::96== C= 3?@4 /F6DT6 HE =; RBYCD C= > [BHJJ69 >D: +*L "6X= 7HWW6D::96== C= OON' &G '86S6DD6 ,HTDCD 5BF:G U34O; 'HBH9>:H PV9CDJ=;

'HBH9>:H 24R4IG

3IG 16E6D:>D< A> [BHJJ69 X8H 96=C:6= >< MNO@ P6>JB6D

19CF6; (>D78H A>BH= Q69:6=; '>BCEH9DC> R4?@NG %6 C= 6WVBHS6: >= >D /==C=D<

PBYCD D (H=> (H>: '>W>9CBBH; '/ RM43?G

32G 16E6D:>D< $86 -B6DD 567Y A9HJ9>Wd,697T9S (>:CH /9 W6:C>

7HWV>DS 796>f6 !D7; != > W6:C> 7HWV>DS HXD6: [S 16E6D:>D<

-B6DD 567Y >D: 796>D: C=

BH7>< 33MM /F6DT6 HE =; MOD< 15 '>VCX EC9W BH7>< @3@ ]CDJ

P ??M3O; >D: C= 86>:6: [S /D< 1>D 5>7Y69; BH7>< W6 >::96==G


6/60

/$,$#(#*$ -3 3,0$/

?3G !D ?44R; B>D =6796< J9HTV 7>BB6: _$6>W $86WC=` D: BE HE 7H9VH9>B

>J6D7C6=; CD7BT:CDJ 7DCf>W[69 >D: Q6BF6< (6FHBTB>D9S 2; ?44R 6W>CB 9S 6WVBHS66 />9HD 5>99

:6=79C[6= D9HDG5>99i>>9HDj8[J>9SG7HWk 1>B W6:C> D:

C:6DFCH9 HE 6WVBHS66=G m!< C= B= < 8>F6 > BC[69>B [6D9HD 5>99 CD +6[9T>9S ?434 [9>JJ6:


7/60

/DHDSWHT= 96=VHD:6: [S VT[BC=8CDJ WH96 D N4;444 HE %5 ->9S 6W>CB= <

6ZVH=6: B HE CB=

=8HX6: > WTB9 HV69>7W[69 >D: $6>W $86WC=G $6>W $86WC= J>==CF6 >WHTD >[HT<

AB>CD= =8>96: XCXS69= >< %TDW= >D: FC76 F69=>G $6>W

$86WC= CBB6J>BBS =79>V6: =H7C>B W6:C> =C==H7C>76[HHY; >D: V96V>96: :H==C69= HD AB>CDD: 8C= +>76[HHY E9C6D:= >D: H96 HD 7HWVTWV>CJD; B=6 :H7TW6DD: 9: PDHX:6D CD

+6[9T>9S ?43O >D: 96VH9B:;


8/60

,)-#. /0* %-1* +*&23"4*#/"2"*4 5615-+*+ -2 7(89: $1* /;- /$%/"%+< =>? /- "#@*%/

$&& +-1/+ -2 2$&+* )$/*1"$& -#/- /0* "#/*1#*/ "# -14*1 /- 4*+/1-A /0* 1*56/$/"-#

-2 "/+ /$1.*/+B $#4 =C? /- 6+* +-%"$& +%"*#%*+ $#4 -/0*1 /*%0#"D6*+ /-

)$#"56&$/* -#&"#* 4"+%-61+* $#4 $%/"E"+) /- .*#*1$/* -6/%-)*+ "/ %-#+"4*1+

4*+"1$F&*G (- +** 0-; *H/1*)"+/ /0*+* 51-.1$)+ $1*I @6+/ %-#+"4*1 /0* /$%/"%+

/0*A F-$+/ -2 6+"#. /- $%0"*E* /0-+* *#4+< J2$&+* 2&$. -5*1$/"-#+K =5-+/"#.

)$/*1"$& /- /0* "#/*1#*/ $#4 2$&+*&A $//1"F6/"#. "/ /- +-)*-#* *&+*?I 2$L* E"%/")

F&-. 5-+/+ =51*/*#4"#. /- F* $ E"%/") -2 /0* "#4"E"46$& ;0-+* 1*56/$/"-# /0*A

;$#/ /- 4*+/1-A?I $#4 5-+/"#. J#*.$/"E* "#2-1)$/"-#K -# E$1"-6+ 2-16)+G

q8D< 596C9<

%HB:CDJ=; :67C:6: V>9>BB6B 7>WV>CJD =9W $86WC= = JHCDJ Y6 AB>CD==H7C>: +9C6:W>Dc= _BCE6 > BH<

WH96 :CEEC7TB=6

EH9 8C= EHBBHX69= J6 CD


9/60

>D: 78H=6 8CW [67>T=6 HE 8C= VH=C= > 0H= /DJ6B6= /==C=D< 1C=D:G *D "HF6W[69

3I; ?433; D: C==T6: >D

CDbTD7J>CD=< ,9G /BB6DG !D < 7>=6; ,9G /BB6D ECB6: > WHBY69 X>= 7Hg8H=D< +96Sc= A>==>=; QC9JCDC>G

16E6D:>D< +96S =TV69FC=6: 16E6D:>D< K>BY69 CD < 7>V>7C[HT< /TJT=< 3@; ?433; P6D 6W>CB DBY69; +96S >D: ">JS DDCDJ

D: >D: _WT9:69` AB>CDD< +96S; >D /==C=D< 1C=


10/60

D< ">JS :C: 7HD7< T= >996=B ECBCDJ= >J>CD=< AB>CDVV6>9 H:CHT=h

_"H; .HT 8>F6 S bH9 W6:C> =D: [S

VT[BC=86: 7HT9< :67C=CHD=G $86D =>S 86 H[CD6: D V9HF6 C


11/60

MMG !D >D 6W>CB E9HW 16E6D:>D< +96S D< K>BY69 HD 1676W[69

??; ?433; 16E6D:>D< +96S 7HWVBCW6DBY69 HD > VB6>:CDJ >D: C:; _$8C=

YC7Y= >==G $86S >96 JHCDJ V6=8C V=S78HV>=C= >::6:aG AB>CDDSHD6 < 16E6D:>D< +96S; >D: D6F69 6F6D VT[BC=86: HDBCD6 > =CDJB6 XH9: H9 [HT<

16E6D:>D< +96SG

MNG !D HCB= D< K>BY69 >D: =HW6 HE


12/60

=8HTBB CB :>DT>9S ?N; ?43?; 16E6D:>D< +96S D<

K>BY69 X8CB6 X>C bT9S CD > 7>=6 86 X>= FCDJ ETDG $8C= C= X8><

! :Hh V9HF6 F6 > bT9S HT< =H ! 8>F6 > BCCB= HD 1676W[69 ?3; ?433; 16E6D:>D< +96S :C=7T==6: 8C=

VB>DD6: W66= V>9<

HE > WHDC9S N; ?43?; 16E6D:>D< +96S >=Y6: 16E6D:>D< K>BY69

B6CD


13/60

O?G *D H9 >[HT< \>DT>9S N; ?43?; AB>CDCD=< ,9G

/BB6D; 16E6D:>D< K>BY69 >VV6>96: TDCDFCD: CDCD: C:6D= />9HD K>BY69; >D: 6F69SHD6 XHTB: YDHX < 86 X>= BY69 EHBBHX6: AB>CD= 6F>BT>B

CDbT9C6=; CD7BT:CDJ 7HDCDG %6 X>=

B>C: HEE E9HW XH9Y EH9 =6F69>B :>S= E==>TB< >D: [>CD776== D< 9S 3?; ?43M; 16E6D:>D< K>BY69 X>= = >D >B


14/60

>I $+ $# *)5&-A** -2 NO89G ,+ 9 )*#/"-#*4 /- A-6 -# !1"4$AI /0* +/$/* -2

A-6 -22"%* "+ $&)-+/ F*A-#4 4*+%1"5/"-#G Q-+/ -2 /0* &*.$& 4-%6)*#/+ "# A-61

-22"%* $1* 5"&*4 0$50$R$14&A "# #- &*++ /0$# 2"E* &*.$& +"H* 5$5*1 F-H*+I

;"/0-6/ 1*.$14 /- $#A L"#4 -2 -1.$#"R$/"-#I 2"&"#.I %01-#-&-.AI */%G (0* 2*;

2"&*+ /0$/ ;*1* $%/6$&&A +/-1*4 "# A-61 2"&* %$F"#*/ $1* #-/ 2"&*4 $&50$F*/"%$&&A-1 +6F@*%/ )$//*1G SE*# /0-+* $55*$1 /- F* "#%-)5&*/* $#4 51-E"4* #- F$+"+

2-1 4*/*1)"#"#. ;0$/ $%/"-#+ ;*1* /$L*# -1 1*)$"# /- F* /$L*# /- %-#%&64*/0* )$//*1G 9/ "+ $&+- -FE"-6+ /0$/ )-+/ -2 /0* ;-1L /0$/ A-6 4"4 "# /0$/ -22"%*I

$+ 1*E*$&*4 FA /0* +/$%L+ -2 4-%6)*#/+ "# /0* /-5 -2 A-61 4*+LI 1*&$/* /-

5*1+-#$& F6+"#*++I "#%&64"#. A-61 E$1"-6+ F&-. $%/"E"/"*+G 9# 2$%/I "/ "+ 4"22"%6&//- 4*/*1)"#* ;0$/ A-6 ;*1* ;-1L"#. -# 2-1 NO89 -E*1 /0* &$+/ 2*; ;**L+I "2

$#A/0"#.G =T-61 %0$1$%/*1"R$/"-# -2 A-61 -22"%* $+ J)*++AK "+ F*&"*4 FA /0*

50-/-.1$50+ /0$/ ;* /--L /- 4-%6)*#/ /0* $%/6$& %-#46%/"-# -2 /0$/ 1--)?G

(0* 2*; 4-%6)*#/+ /0$/ 4"4 1*&$/* /- NO89 F6+"#*++ 4- #-/ "#4"%$/* /0*

%611*#/ +/$/6+ -2 /0* )$//*1+ /- ;0"%0 /0*A 1*&$/*4 $#4 NO89 "+ #-; "# /0*

5-+"/"-# -2 1*/1$%"#. +/*5+ $#4 %-#/$%/"#. #6)*1-6+ /0"14 5$1/"*+ /-

4*/*1)"#* ;0*1* /0"#.+ +/$#4G UFE"-6+&AI /0-+* *22-1/+ ;"&& %-+/ NO89

+".#"2"%$#/ +6)+I "#%&64"#. /0* %-+/ 2-1 -6/+"4* %-6#+*& /- %-))6#"%$/* ;"/0/0"14 5$1/A %-6#+*& $#4 %-#/"#6* 1*51*+*#/$/"-# -2 NO89I $+ #*%*++$1AG :"E*#

/0-+* %"1%6)+/$#%*+I "/ +**)+ %&*$1 /0$/ A-6 2$"&*4 /- 5*12-1) A-61 46/"*+ $+

%-6#+*& /- NO89I "# 2$E-1 -2 561+6"#. A-61 5*1+-#$& "#/*1*+/+I ;0"&* F*"#. 5$"4FA NO89G (06+I NO89 "+ *#/"1*&A @6+/"2"*4 /- /*1)"#$/* A-61 *)5&-A)*#/ 2-1

%$6+* 1*&$/*4 /- A-61 2$"&61* /- 5*12-1) "# $%%-14$#%* ;"/0 /0* *H5*%/$/"-#+$#4 ;"/0 A-61 -F&".$/"-#+ $+ $ )*)F*1 -2 /0* V"1."#"$ W/$/* X$1G UFE"-6+&AI

*E*# "2 NO89 0$4 $ +*E*1$#%* 5-&"%AI ;0"%0 "/ 4-*+ #-/I A-6 ;-6&4 #-/ F*

*#/"/&*4 /- 1*%*"E* $#A +6%0 %-)5*#+$/"-# 6#4*1 /0* %"1%6)+/$#%*+G 8$/0*1INO89 ;-6&4 F* @6+/"2"*4 "2 "/ +-6.0/ 1*")F61+*)*#/ 21-) A-6 2-1 $)-6#/+ 5$"4

2-1 +*1E"%*+ /0$/ A-6 4"4 #-/ 5*12-1) 461"#. 5*1"-4+ 461"#. ;0"%0 A-6 4"4 #-/

5*12-1) +*1E"%*+G

9# &".0/ -2 $&& /0* $F-E*I $#4 "# /0* %-#/*H/ -2 A-61 $%/"-#+ -6/+"4* /0* +%-5* -2

A-61 *)5&-A)*#/I "2 A-6 )6+/ %-#+"4*1 A-61+*&2 /- F* $ E"%/")I "/ "+ -#&A -2

A-61 -;# "11*+5-#+"F&* $%/"-#+G NO89 4-*+ #-/ 0$E* $ 1*+5-#+"F"&"/A /-

51-E"4* A-6 ;"/0 $ J+-2/ &$#4"#.K 21-) /0-+* $%/"-#+ "# /0* 2-1) -2 6#*$1#*4

%-)5*#+$/"-#G YG


15/60

YG T-6 %0-+* /- 5-L* $/ $ .1-65 /0$/ "+ L#-;# 2-1 E"-&*#/ 1*51"+$&+I

$55$1*#/&A "# /0* #$)* -2 $++*1/"#. 2"1+/ $)*#4)*#/ 1".0/+ =*E*# /0-6.0 /0*

ZGWG :-E*1#)*#/ "+ #-/ "#E-&E*4 "# +6551*++"#. %$1/--#+ -2 Q-0$))*4?G ,#4

A-6 ;*1* 2*$126& *#-6.0 -2 A-61 $4E*1+$1"*+ /- $&*1/ /0* 5-&"%* "# /;-

%-6#/"*+G W- "/ ;-6&4 F* 6#1*$+-#$F&* 2-1 A-6 /- %-#4*)# %-))-# +*#+*

*22-1/+ /- 51-/*%/ /0-+* ;0- 0$E* #-/0"#. /- 4- ;"/0 A-61 $%/"E"/"*+ $+JF*A-#4 $&& 1$/"-#$&"/AG 9# 0"#4+".0/I 4- A-6 +/"&& %-#+"4*1 A-6 JSE*1A-#*

[1$; Q-0$))*4K F&-. /- F* 1$/"-#$&\ 92 +-I 9 ;-6&4 #-/ %-#+"4*1 A-6 /- F* $

%1*4"F&* $551$"+*1 -2 1$/"-#$&"/AG

8=HD=gEH9g[6CDJgDT>9S ?43?; 16E6D:>DBY69; +96S; >D: ">JS; CD 7HD769B=6 D>99>CDT=6: 16E6D:>D< K>BY69c= bH[

= DH< >==>TBD: ^Ma E>B=CEC6: 8C= 8H=VCB 967H9:=G

O@G !D +6[9T>9S ?43?; /D:96X 596C[>9< D< PD>8>D >D:

HD8>D =F>CB>[B6 96=HT976= CD

:67B>9>9 >J>CD=< AB>CDD< PD>8>D X9HF6

[66D > [CJ :6>Bh VTBC=D: > 8TJ6 VB>


16/60

X8C78 16E6D:>D< %HJ6 VT[BC=86:; CD7BT:CDJ B=6 >BB6J>CDS ?N; ?43?

VH== CE

51")$ 2$%"$ =+"%? 7>=6 HE V69bT9S >J>CDG`

ORG !D \>DT>9S ?43?; 16E6D:>D< /Y[>9 CD 7HD=VC9>7S XCDBY69; +96S; ">JS; PD>8>D; >D: HTD786: > D6X 6DB 5BHJJ69= 'BT[ >= > $6Z>= DHDgV9HEC< 7H9VH9>99>B

5BHJJ69= 'BT[ D< /Y[>9 8>= = =TV69FC=H9S VH=C 79CWCD>B 6DJ6: CD CBB6J>B

>7T:6: 7C9= [S 796>B=6 D>99>D:

[S E>B=6BS = N43^7â Ma DHDgV9HEC7= D6F69 ECB6: >DS

96oTC96: [T=CD6== ECBCDJ= H9 !(P RR4= =CD76 C


17/60

N3G $86 E9>T: 7HWWCB 5BHJJ69= 'BT[ HD C9: HE :C967D: T=6: 869 VH=CD: 96VT9:CDJ AB>CDD9; K>BY69; +96S; PD>8>D; ">JS >D: HCDB 5BHJJ69=

'BT[ EH9 > =W6>9 7>WV>CJD [>=6: HD E>B=6 D>99>D: 86 C= J6: CD 7S[69 [TBBSCDJ HE AB>CD J9>D: =7>B6G

NOG

!D ,>S >D: \TD6 ?43?; B 5BHJJ69= 'BT[; >D: E>B=6BS


18/60

< D: 8TD:96: D:

:HBB>9= [>=6: HD T:TB6D< 96V96=6DE=Y6: EH9 V9HHE

< 16E6D:>D< ">B 5BHJJ69= 'BT[ X>= J9>DD<

/Y[>9 E>CB6: DB 5BHJJ69= 'BT[

7HD :HD>J6 =B=6BSh _">B 5BHJJ69= 'BT[;

!D7G C= > N43^7a^Ma gg =T=6

HE CBT96= 9S ?3; ?43O; B 5BHJJ69= 'BT[

796>= > =86BB 7HWV>DS T: WH96 D HD6 8TD:96: D: :HBB>9=

E9HW JTBBC[B6 7CYCDJ TV E>B=6 D>99>[HT< AB>CD


19/60

CDDCf>DS B6JCDD69G $86S

D6F69 7HD:T7DS =CWCB>9 7>WV>CJD= >J>CD=< >DS H7D: /BC /Y[>9 =HBC7CD:

9676CF6: :HD>D: >D: B 5BHJJ69= 'BT[ X>= 6ZVH=6: >= > E9>T:TB6D< N43^7a^Ma DHDg

V9HECD 5>7Y69 8>= > 96VT= > B>XS69 X8H 796>9>WW6: 8TD:96:= HE D:= E9HW $6> A>97A>9= >D H9J>DCf>9D:C:>D< 5>7Y69 8>= 9>C=6: WCBBCHD= HE :HBB>9= VCB S6>9=; >D: 8>: [66D V>SCDJ 16E6D:>D< /Y[>9c= QC76 n QC79CHT=


20/60

NRG /= > 96=TB< HE 9 [BHJ= >D: >9CD9SB>D:; 9676CF6: W>DS D: :6>: >D:

[6BC6F6: B=6 D>99>CB; V8HD6 >D: [BHJ VH=B 96>:69= 7>BB6: >D:dH9 7HD7CDWCBS; 8C= D6CJ8[H9=

>D: 8C= 78CB:96D 9CDJ AB>CDB H:69= 7>W6 CD9SB>D: >D: D: 8C= 78CB:G $8C= 7>T=6: AB>CDD: 8C= E>WCBS 6Z


21/60

EH9 8CW=6BE >D: 8C= E>WCBS [67>T=6 HE D: J>CD=< 8CWG QC9BBS

6F69S CDVV6>9= CD 'HT9DBY69 >D: %HJ6 8>F6 =BY6: 8CW;

>D: AB>CD9= < 16E6D:>D< K>BY69 XCBB >J>CD >==>TB< 8CWG 5HDBY69 >D: %HJ6 7HD=DDSHD6 HDBCD6 X8H oT6==< HD6

96VH9= 9676CF6: W>DS :6>B 78>9J6= >J>CD=< > 96VH99>==W6D< HE AB>CDD9; +96S; %HJ6; >D: K>BY69; 8>F6 7HDD: VT[BC7BS >CDE


22/60

16E6D:>D< %HJ6; >= > =6DCH9 W6W[69 HE JS; PD>8>D >D: HBY69

>D: HDF6 7HD99>TJ86S CD ,HD


23/60


24/60

7HDFC7CB D< K>BY69 HD 1676W[69 33; ?433;

16E6D:>D< +96S =>C: < 86 XHTB: 7>BB [BHJJ69 -B6DD (6SDHB:= >D: CDCD=<

+96S HD6 S6>9 6>9BC69 X696 DH< J6:7>=9SB>D:G $8C= 7HDCD6: W>CD= CDFHBF6: XCW6:

AB>CD= >BB6J6:BS =X>G %6 >D: HD:CH <

AB>CD= 96=VHD=C[B6 EH9 BY69 >VV6>96: HD %TEE AH=


25/60

0CF6; CWVTCDCDD< 567Y >BBHX6: 16E6D:>DBY69 >D:

+96S VV6>9 FC> >T:CH HD 8C= 9>:CHdW >D: CWVTD:

=CDD<

K>BY69 D< +96S = _16VTD: >79H== D< +96S =V67CEC7>BBS =


26/60

@OG *D ,>S ?N; ?43?; 16E6D:>D< $86 5B>f6 VT[BC=86: >D >9DS :T6 :CBCJ6D76 H9 >=Y


27/60

AB>CDYCDJ BC7CHT= =D:

16E6D:>D< 567Y >79: EH9 F>CB>[B6 D:G 8D >9


28/60

16V>9D: E>B=6BS D: J6DD< K>BY69 DD 5>7Y69 >D: 15 '>VCD: J>CD=< < W>BC7CHT= =TC


29/60


30/60


31/60

R4G 16E6D:>D< ,C786BB6 ,>BYCD T=6: 869 [BHJ >D: $XCJS; >D: HF6 T=6:

16E6D:>D< +96Sc= bH[ :6=79CV


32/60


33/60

8G

_A>


34/60

[>D HD _A>


35/60

V9H=67T


36/60

=oT69>:6= >= > B>X >[C:CDJ =B [S :>S;

>D: BB= HD 8C= 96>:69= 9>== 8C= 9J6CDD: 8C= 6WVBHS69 W>CDCD HEEC7C>B VB>T=C[B6 :6DC>[CBC==697BHD6 >D: HEE :T9= =HD=G 567>T=6 BY69 8>= X9C= T=6: 16E6D:>D< +96S }_/==C=D<

1C=D: T9J6: V6HVB6


37/60

34?G 16E6D:>DF6 96V6>CB6:; >D: :6=[CBCD99>[HT< AB>CDBY69gW>D:SgD>JSg>D:gH9; X8C78 CD7BT:6: 16E6D:>DBY69; ">JS >D: PD>8>D X8C78 =D:dH9 CWVTCD=

CDFHBF6: XC: JHBY69 9HD KH9= =X>D: C= > F69S 8CJ8 V9HECB6

FC79 X>= VH=DYBCD '6D: FC6X69=8CV E9HW >79H== S ?N; ?43?; $>[C %>B6 X9HD >9DYBCD

'6D


38/60

X8C78 E>B=6BS =CD 78CB: WHB6===>==CD; X8H 8>= ECB6: HF69

344 E9CFHBHT= B>X=TCD: >DS [BHJJ69 X8H :>96: W6DW6uG`

$86 >9:69=


39/60

334G 16E6D:>D< %HJ6 8>= VT[BC=86: 8TD:96:= HE [BHJ VH=D: CDD: >77T=CDJ 8CW HE 79CW6 >E[T=6 >D: E9>T:G !D E>79>==CDJ AB>CDWCBS >D: >DSHD6

X8H =TVVH9CD[BS

CD7BT:6= =HW6 9>JCDJ >D: BC[6BHT= CDEH9W>D< %HJ6c=

$XC= [66D 96V6>CDD< %HJ6 8>= 96V6>


40/60

6>9D > BCFCDJ; 16E6D:>D< %HJ6 W6< XCDBY69; /Y[>9 >D: H9G $86 >J966W6DD< %HJ6 W>:6 XCCDD: F6 8>9W6:

AB>CDJ966W6D


41/60

8>9>==W6DD: =BYCDJ HE AB>CDD: 8C= E>WCBSG /BB HE 9>==W6D< 8>= [66D :HD6 ==; [TBBS >D:

TV=6< AB>CDD: D< %HJ6 8>= W>:6 TDX>DJ966: XCD< K>BY69 D: 7>T=6 AB>CDF6 8C= E>WCBS

>D: 8CW >BHD6G

333G *D \TD6 @; ?43?; 16E6D:>D< /Y[>9 J>F6 >D CD9>==CDJ

7HD=69F>D< %HJ6 :C=7T==6: D: 7HD=VC96: XC9SB>D:G 897BbgD< %HJ6 >= >

=6DCH9 W6W[69 HE 16E6D:>D< ">B 5BHJJ69= 'BT[ B>TD786: > D6X ETD:9>C=CDJ

7>WV>CJD [>=6: HD B=6 D>99>CDT=6: 16E6D:>D<

K>BY69 V69=HD 7BC7Y= B 5BHJJ69= 'BT[ :HD>9 V96FCHT=BS T=6: C=6 WHD6S [>=6: HD 8C= E>B=6 7B>CW <

AB>CD =X>WV>CJD HE 8>9>==W6D= B6:


42/60

[BHJJ69= BH=CDJ bH[=; D: VHBC76 xPK/$$CDJ=cuG` /< B 5BHJJ69= 'BT[ >D:

7HD=VC96: XCD< /Y[>9 B 5BHJJ69= 'BT[ 96>: >9D; %HJ6 >D: HD:


43/60

33OG 16E6D:>DBY69; +96S; PD>8>D; %HJ6; 15 '>VC9 9>C=6: >D: 7HD[HT< D: 96VT978 @; ?43M; 16E6D:>D< /Y[>9


44/60

+6[9T>9S 2; ?43O >9[HT< 16E6D:>D< ,>BYCD; _$XCVHD HE 78HC76G 5>S= :6FHBF6 CD9=u$>TDD: B6JCHD HE 6D69JCf6: EHBBHX69=G`

8B 5BHJJ69=

'BT[ 7HD=7< HE W>CB E9>T:; XC96 E9>T: H9 WHD6S B>TD:69CDJG

3?4G $86 16E6D:>DB=6 D>99>F6 8>9W6: AB>CD= >D 6:T7>


45/60

$T9Y6S; ]>f>Y8=D; &JSV; P>T:C /9>[C>; $TDC=C>; 5>89>CD; \H9:>D >D:

6B=6X8696 9D >[HT< =H7C>B W6:C>G K86D D9D6: >[HT< BBCDJ AB>CD 79CWCD>B >D: = 6:T7>7D< $86 5B>f6; 7HDDD: ,697T9S (>:CH /9D >9


46/60

_D: C= V96=C:6D9; 8>F6

CDD:dH9 967YB6==BS VT[BC=86:; 96VT[BC=86: >D: :C==6WCD>D: :6E>W>==H7C>D: >7B >D: V9H=V679


47/60

3?IG $86 D>W6: 16E6D:>DW>D: 7HD99>==W6DDB=6 >D: :6E>W>T=6

BB6J6 79CW6= >D: W>Y6 AB>CDVV6>9 H:CHT=; CDE>WHT=; >D:dH9 E9CJ8DD: :6E>W>


48/60

3MOG /BDD:

:6E>W>W>DD: :6E>W>D: XCDD: :6E>W>EE9

XCD: =T=CD6: T=6 W>ZCWTW

8>9W CDW6: 16E6D:>DW>D: E>B=6

=W6: 16E6D:>D7J>CD=< AB>CDDD: W>BC7CHT=; X696 CDCDD: X696 W>:6 XC

7>BBHT= CD:CEE696D76 CD


49/60

3O?G $8T=; CD VT[BC=8CDJ B=6 >D: :6E>W>?@+ 5CFG+ (?E=BD+ $KBALMN+ !GL=+

$MG !E?OG+ (G@LI@N "?PBC ,@AH+ 3@GN+ /A@?D?M?D+ *?FN+ !@GBA>?@A8LCQ+

!?L=G@+ 7! 0?RBACE /A@?AGFBGH+J

3OMG

AB>CDBB6J6= >D: CD7H9VH9>9>J9>V8 >[HF6G

3OOG $86 D>W6: 16E6D:>DD76: AB>CD=HD>[B6 V69=HDG

3O@G $86 D>W6: 16E6D:>D78 7HWVBC7C< CD >D: 96=VHD=C[B6 EH9

7>=CD E>B=6 BCJ8< >D: FCHB>7SG

3O2G

$86 D>W6: 16E6D:>D79H==


50/60

3ORG $86 16E6D:>DJ6: CD HTJ6HT= >D: 6ZB=6BS VT[BC=8CDJ B=6 =D: D6E>9CHT=

7HD:T7D:CDJ < 86 [6 CDF6=996=D: CWV9C=HD6: EH9 =X>X=TCJ>CD=< 8CW;

=6D:CDJ > E>B=6 B6 :>S JH6= [S X8696 AB>CDBY69 7>W6 7HT9< 86>9CDJ CD


51/60

,HDVCB=6 79CWCD>B >D: 7CFCB >7J>CD=< AB>CD 9 V69CH:; >BB X8C78 8>F6 [66D :C=WC==6: H9 :6DC6:G

16E6D:>DBY69 >D: =HW6 HE CD=< AB>CDD: WH7Y CDD: [HT< AB>CDF6 6F6D >D< K>BY69 8>= 6F6D

CWVT 9676D< [BHJ VH=< < AB>CDTJ8C9 J>W6 EH9

:6=< 8C=

8HW6 >D: HEEC76; >D: Y6 V967>TWCBS < DH SHTDJ 78CB: =8HTB: 8>F6

BSD78 WH[ [>=6: HD

E>B=6 D>99> 7HD=C=G

$8C= 7B6>9BS :6WHD=


52/60

3NMG $86 D>W6: 16E6D:>D


53/60

$5'"7 0),'( 3-" "#)'#3

'DS?HBCD CT 2@BS?LN ,RR@CR@B?ABCD CT *?QG+ 'DA@IHBCD BDAC /GLEIHBCD+ ?DP 1D@G?HCD?>EG

2I>EBLBAN

VC7Y69 8>F6 >VV9HV9C>D: :6: HD AB>CDD: B>=< D>W6= EH9 7HWW697C>B VT9VH=6=; CD7BT:CDJ 9>C=CDJ ETD:=; =6BBCDJ

W6978>D:C=6 >D: 796>T:TB6D< ECD>D7C>B =7>W=G $86S 8>F6 VB>76: AB>CDW6 CD


54/60

D6E>9CHT= >7D: [6B6: S= CD7BT:6 AB>CDW6G

OIG AB>CD= D6F69 JCF6D 16E6D:>DDS W>DD69 >D: 8>= 96V6>=Y6: 16E6D:>D9CHT= F6DT6= F6 8CW

>BHD6G

O@G $86 >7D96 967YB6==; CDD: YDHXCDJ; >D:

:HD6 CD H9:69 T=6 =T[=DB CDbT9S CDCDJ6 >D: J6

/W69C7>D 7CFCBC>D=G

O2G 16E6D:>D796 XCBBETB; X>DD: W>BC7CHT=; >D: :HD6 XCD CWV9HV69 >D: HTJ6HT= WHD: 7>96B6== CD:CEE696D76 CDVC7Y69; K>BY69 >D: ">B 5BHJJ69= 'BT[

W>BC7CHT=BS >D: X9HDJETBBS CD= :C967= >D >J966W6D< D


55/60

HE 79CW6=; =6D:CDJ > :6E>W>BC7CHT= B>X=TC< >J>CD=< AB>CDD: 8C= 6WVBHS69 CD H9:69 X=TC< CDCD= CDFHBF6: XCT=6: < ETD:69 DD:

HW6: 16E6D:>DF6 == DCf>D: HW>J6: [S W6: 16E6D:>DBC7CHT=

>7T=6 HE >7W6: 16E6D:>D7J>CD=< AB>CDDD: W>BC7CHT=; >D: X696 CDCDD7D: HTJ6HT=

WH96B6== CD:CEE696D76 CDDJ6=G

3'3$5 0),'( 3-" "#)'#3

'*$#"3#"#*0# 6'$5 2"-/2#0$';# #0-*-('0 ,7;,*$,.#

CDBB6J6= >D: CD7H9VH9>9>J9>V8 >[HF6G

3I@G 16E6D:>DJ6: CD > 7HD769WV>CJD HE HDBCD6 :6E>W>B=6 BCJ8B=6 D>99>


56/60

T:; B 78>9J6=; 7S[69 [TBBSCDJ

>D: >7XETBBS; CD H9:69 T=6 :>W>J6 CDXETB [T=CD6==6=;

[H= >D 6WVBHS66 HE \T=D: >= > WT=C7C>DG

3I2G 16E6D:>DCD= 6DJ>J6: CD [T=CD6== >D: 6DJ>J6:

CD 7HD:T7< D: :6V9CF6 AB>CDW>J6= >D: BH== CDCD= =TEE696: >7B :>W>J6 >D: BH==G

3@3G $8T=; D7D: HTJ6HT= WH96B6== CD:CEE696D76 CD


57/60

3@NG AB>CD= =TEE696: >7B :>W>J6 >D: BH==G

3@IG $8T=; 16E6D:>D< K>BY69 >7D: HTJ6HT=

WH96B6== CD:CEE696D76 CD


58/60

>7JHG

32?G /= > 96=TB< HE 16E6D:>D7CD= =TEE696: =6F696

6WHB :C=D: W6DB >DJTC=8G

#'.5$5 0),'( 3-" "#)'#3

0-*/2'",04 $- 0-(('$ /$,$# ),6 $-"$/

CDBB6J6= >D: CD7H9VH9>9>J9>V8 >[HF6G

32OG $86 16E6D:>D


59/60

2",4#" 3-" "#)'#3

K%&(&+*(&; AB>CD


60/60

:1"4 7#(,*7

AB>CDD:= > bT9S B HE >BB C==T6= CD 7= HE 9CJ8< [S > bT9SG

(6=V67

kimberlin v. nbc (ii) amend compl redacted

Documents