lamberto 2001
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/4/2019 Lamberto 2001
1/13
Chemical Engineering Science 56 (2001) 4887}4899
Computational analysis of regular and chaotic mixingin a stirred tank reactor
D. J. Lamberto, M. M. Alvarez, F. J. Muzzio*
Department of Chemical and Biochemical Engineering, Rutgers University, P.O. Box 909, Piscataway, NJ 08855-0909, USA
Received 9 October 1998; received in revised form 29 November 1999; accepted 10 December 1999
Abstract
Mixing in an unba%ed stirred tank equipped with a 6-blade radial#ow impeller is examined computationally. Results demonstrate
that the #ow generated by constant impeller speed is partially chaotic. Under these conditions, the stretching experienced by #uidelements located within segregated toroidal regions of the #ow increases slowly at a linear rate characteristic of regular (non-chaotic)
#ows. Within the bulk #ow region, since the #ow is chaotic, stretching increases at the expected exponential rate. The use of dynamic
#ow perturbations enhances mixing; when time-dependent RPM are applied, a globally chaotic #ow is generated. We investigate
computationally the e!ect on mixing performance of protocols in which the agitation speed oscillates between two steady values.
Di!erent frequencies of speed change and several RPM settings are compared. Under variable RPM schemes, the segregated torii are
periodically relocated and #uid elements have the opportunity to abandon the regular regions. Under these conditions stretching
increases exponentially throughout the entire #ow domain. In general, mixing protocols with higher frequency of speed #uctuation
produce the largest increase in stretching rates. Counter-intuitively, at a given RPM #uctuation frequency, stretching rates were
higher for the lower RPM settings, either per revolutions or per unit of energy spent. 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Laminar mixing; Stirred tank; Chaos; CFD
1. Introduction and background
The development of e$cient laminar mixing techno-
logy continues to be critical to many industrial opera-
tions. For the processing of low-viscosity liquids, e$cient
mixing is frequently achieved by operating under turbu-
lent conditions. However, turbulence is precluded when
high-viscosity #uids are mixed, or must be avoided in
order to protect delicate shear-sensitive materials sus-
pended in the #ow (Sefton, Dawson, Broughton, Blys-
niuk, & Sugamori, 1987; Backer, Metzger, Slaber, Nevitt,
& Boder 1988; Cherry & Papoutsakis, 1998; Croughan,
Hamel, & Wang, 1987, 1988; Beck, Stiefel, & Stinnett,
1987; Papoutsakis, 1993; Tanaka, Semba, Jitsufuchi,
& Harada, 1988; Blynsniuk & Sefton, 1991; Omurtag,
Stickel, & Chevray, 1996). In such cases chaotic laminar
#ows can provide a practical alternative. Chaotic mixing
* Corresponding author. Tel.:#1-732-445-3357; fax:#1-732-445-
2421.
E-mail address: [email protected] (F. J. Muzzio).
has been found to occur in completely deterministic
systems devoid of any #uctuations of the #ow "eld.
Extensive work has been performed for several two-
dimensional chaotic #ows (e.g. the blinking vortex, the
cavity #ow, the journal bearing, the sine #ow), and both
computational and experimental techniques have been
rigorously developed for the quantitative characteriza-
tion of mixing processes in such systems (Aref, 1984;
Swanson & Ottino, 1990; Muzzio, Swanson, & Ottino,
1991; Muzzio & Liu, 1996; Alvarez, Muzzio, Cerbelli,
Adrover, & Giona, 1998; Muzzio et al., 2000). Unfortu-
nately, we are still far from achieving the same level of
detail in the analysis of 3-D #ows. In fact, only a few 3-D
relevant industrial systems have been analyzed numer-
ically using dynamical systems tools (e.g. Hobbs & Muz-
zio, 1998a,b,c; Rauline, Tanguy, Le BleHvec, & Bousquet
1997).
Mixing in a stirred tank is chosen as a case study
because although this is the most widely used type of
mixing equipment used for large-scale industrial opera-
tions, laminar mixing in stirred tanks is poorly under-
stood. Scaling correlations and mixing characterizations
have fallen short of accurately representing these systems
0009-2509/01/$- see front matter 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 0 0 9 -2 5 0 9 (0 0 ) 0 0 4 0 7 - 3
-
8/4/2019 Lamberto 2001
2/13
Table 1
System dimensions and #uid properties
Tank
Tank diameter, DR
20.0 cm
Fluid depth, H 22.0 cm
Impeller radius, rG
3.81 cm
Impeller height, xG 7.08 cmBlade height, H@
1.46 cm
Blade width, =@
0.07 cm
Shaft diameter, DQ
0.79 cm
Fluid (glycerin)
Density, 1.26 g/cm
Viscosity, 707 cP
due in part to complex geometry and di$culty in
measuring speci"c parameters inside most stirred tanks,
and in part to an overall lack of understanding of mixing
processes in 3-D #ows.
In the last "ve years, the laminar #ow structure in
stirred tanks has been examined mainly through Eulerian
analysis of experimental and computational velocity"elds. Representative examples are the papers by Harvey
and Rogers (1996), Ranade (1997), Harvey, Wood, and
Leng (1997), and Lamberto, Alvarez, and Muzzio (1999).
However, the Eulerian approach does not tell us much
about mixing performance; indeed, velocity "eld in-
formation is only the starting point to investigate mixing.
While Lagrangian methods provide a much more com-
plete picture, examples of Lagrangian approaches to the
study of mixing in tanks are scarce: short-time computa-
tional tracer dispersion experiments have been used to
reveal #ow circulation patterns (see for example Tanguy,
Thibault, Brito-De La Fuente, Espinosa-Solares,
& Tecante 1998); Lyaponuv exponents have been used as
a gross estimator to assess mixing e$ciency in stirred
tanks (de la VilleHon et al., 1998).
In the laminar regime, a stirred tank agitated at con-
stant speed is characterized by the presence of toroidal
segregated regions that limited mixing performance. In
a previous paper (Lamberto, Muzzio, Swanson, & Ton-
kovich, 1996) we demonstrated experimentally that such
segregated regions were e!ectively destroyed by using
time-dependent impeller speed protocols, greatly enhanc-
ing mixing performance (these experimental results were
later con"rmed and extended by Yao, Sato, Takahashi,
& Koyama (1998)). In a second paper, we showed thatthe location, size, and shape of such segregated regions
could be predicted by CFD calculations (Lamberto et al.,
1999).
In this paper, such computations are considerably ex-
tended using Lagrangian analysis (tracer dispersion
simulations, PoincareH sections, stretching "elds, and
stretching distributions) to characterize in detail laminar
mixing performance in an unba%ed stirred tank reactor
equipped with a single 6-blade radial #ow Rushton im-
peller (the system dimensions are listed in Table 1). To
the best of our knowledge, this paper is the "rst to
address mixing in stirred tank geometries using a detailed
Lagrangian approach (with emphasis on stretching cal-
culations). It is numerically con"rmed that steadily
agitated stirred tanks are partially chaotic systems (as
supported by experimental observations), and that vari-
able RPM protocols improve the mixing performance of
stirred tanks. Computations are used to quantify such
improvements. Section 2 o!ers a description of the
computational #uid dynamic (CFD) techniques used to
determine the #uid velocity and to conduct a Lagrangian
investigation of mixing performance. In Section 3, com-
putations are used to analyze the #ow in the stirred tank
operated at constant impeller speeds, and in Section 4,
the use of dynamic #uctuations in the impeller speed is
analyzed. It is shown that widespread chaos is generated
under such conditions. Quanti"cation of the reduction in
the mixing time as a function of RPM #uctuation ampli-
tude and #uctuation frequency is discussed.
2. Computational methods
As a starting point, the three-dimensional velocity "eld
inside the tank is determined using the CFD software
package FLUENT2+. First, the geometry of the system is
constructed and discretized into cylindrical}polar quad-
rilateral cells. The grid used in the computations present-
ed in this paper contained over 150,000 nodes to describe
one-sixth of the tank geometry. Due to the symmetry ofthe system, for low-inertia #ows, a reasonable starting
point is to model one-sixth of the tank containing one
impeller blade. Once this task is completed, FLUENT2+
solves the conservation equations using a "nite-volume
iterative method to determine the velocity of the #uid at
the centroid of each cell. Velocity data are obtained for
Reynolds numbers in the range 8(Re(70. Speci"c
details about the mesh geometry generation and re"ne-
ment, and an extensive experimental validation of the
computational velocity "elds obtained by this approach,
have been presented elsewhere (Lamberto et al., 1999).
Particle tracking software was developed to perform
a Lagrangian investigation of laminar mixing for the
stirred tank system. Motion of passive tracers (point
particles) was tracked throughout the #ow domain to
simulate the mixing process and to reveal regions of
chaotic and non-chaotic (regular) #ow. The tracking soft-
ware used a directed search algorithm to determine par-
ticle positions within the computational cell domain and
a tri-linear interpolation scheme to determine particle
velocities from the known cell values obtained from CFD
simulations (Lamberto, 1997). Details will not be re-
ported here in the interest of brevity. Particles are placed
in pre-determined locations in the #ow domain and their
4888 D. J. Lamberto et al. / Chemical Engineering Science 56 (2001) 4887}4899
-
8/4/2019 Lamberto 2001
3/13
Fig. 1. Vector plots of the axial and radial components of the velocity
within a vertical plane located at "303: (a) Re"8.64 and (b)
Re"69.12.
positions are tracked by integrating the equation of
motion:
dx(t)/dt"v(x, y, z). (1)
The time-independent Eulerian velocity "eld in a rota-
tional reference frame attached to the impeller was used
in Eq. (1) to yield constant boundary conditions; in otherwords, the tank walls move while the impeller remains
still. The integration of Eq. (1) is not a trivial task. In
chaotic systems the error in tracking calculations grows
exponentially. However, a good representation of mixing
events and patterns (consistent with experimental evid-
ence) can be achieved when a high-quality velocity "eld
description is combined with an adequate mesh resolu-
tion and an accurate integration algorithm (as an
example see Hobbs et al., 1997; Hobbs & Muzzio,
1998a,b,c). Souvaliotis, Jana, and Ottino (1995) investi-
gated the performance of"rst-, second-, and third-order
numerical integration methods in a 2-D mixing system
from which analytical solutions for particle trajectoriescan be determined. Their "ndings suggest that for real
systems, higher-order methods are preferable. Here,
a fourth-order Runge}Kutta scheme is used (Press, Flan-
nery, Teukolsky & Vetterling, 1986). This integration
method o!ers a good compromise between accuracy and
computational expense for this particular application
case. Di!erent integration time steps were used for the
di!erent Reynolds number cases analyzed. For each case,
di!erent runs were performed with decreasing time step
lengths until a consistent output was found in terms of
size and shape of the segregated regions as portrayed by
PoincareH sections. The velocity gradients fed into theintegration subroutine were obtained from the interpo-
lated velocity "elds. The resulting particle trajectories,
x(t), were back-transformed to the stationary frame by
adding the solid-body rotation of the reference frame.
Additionally, the amount of stretching experienced by
the #uid was calculated. Since the amount of inter-
material surface area generated by the mixing process is
directly proportional to the amount of stretching experi-
enced by #uid elements present at the location (Muzzio
et al. (1991); or in more detail Muzzio et al. (1999); for an
earlier articulation of these ideas see Ottino, Ranz,
& Macosko (1981)); an estimate of overall e$ciency of
the mixing process can be obtained by determining local
rates of stretching throughout the #ow domain. Stretch-
ing is calculated by considering a #uid element represent-
ed by an in"nitesimal vector l. This vector is located at an
arbitrary position in the #ow domain and it is stretched
as it is convected by the #ow. The evolution of this vector
is described by the equation
dlR/dt"(v)2 ) l
R(2)
Stretching () is de"ned as the ratio of the magnitude of
the vector l at time t to its initial magnitude.
Stretching,""lR"/"l
"""l
R". (3)
As with Eq. (1), Eq. (2) is integrated using fourth-order
Runge}Kutta. Stretching values are calculated for many
vectors (O(10)) throughout the #ow domain in an at-
tempt to reveal regions of non-chaotic and chaotic #ow.
3. Results and discussion
3.1. Computational velocity xeld
The three-dimensional velocity "eld is determined for
the stirred tank system using CFD. Figs. 1a and 1b are
two-dimensional vector plots for Re"8.64 and 69.12.
The "gures depict one half of a vertical cross section of
the stirred tank with the shaft and impeller shown on the
left. A detailed analysis of numerical accuracy, mesh
optimization, and an experimental validation of the velo-
city "elds are presented elswere (Lamberto et al., 1999).
To better reveal the underlying structure of the #ow, only
the axial and radial velocity components are displayed in
the "gure. Secondary circulation loops within the #ow
are revealed both above and below the impeller. These
circulation regions are the primary cause of segregation
in the system and their positions depend on impeller
speed (see for example Lamberto, 1996, 1999; Yao et al.,
1998). To investigate this behavior further, particle track-
ing simulations are performed.
3.2. Particle tracking simulations and PoincareH sections
To illustrate the motion of individual #uid particles in
the #ow, four #uid particles are tracked for 2 min of
D. J. Lamberto et al. / Chemical Engineering Science 56 (2001) 4887}4899 4889
-
8/4/2019 Lamberto 2001
4/13
Fig. 2. Chaotic and regular trajectories in a stirred tank system. (a) Four particle pathlines obtained from simulation of mixing at 200 RPM
(Re"34.56) for 400 periods. Two of these particles, initially placed near the upper and lower segregated regions, trace out the surface of torii identical
in shape to those observed experimentally (blue trajectories). The other two particles, placed in the discharge stream of the impeller (one above and the
other below the impeller mid-plane), move in an apparently random manner throughout a much larger volume of the tank (red pathlines). However,
neither one crosses the mid-plane of the impeller. (b) Shape of the torus surfaces traced out by visualization experiments.
simulated mixing time at Re+35. Initially, two particles
are placed near the upper and lower segregated regions.
Particle 1 is placed at the same height xN
as the center of
the upper segregated region (xAS
) displaced radially by
1 cm: (xN
, rN
)"(xAS
, rAS#1 cm). Particle 2 is placed
similarly relative to the lower region: (xN
, rN
)"
(xAJrAJ#1 cm). The other two particles (denoted 3 and 4)are both located in the discharge stream of the impeller at
a radial position 3 cm in front of the tip of the blade.
Particle 3 is placed 1.5 mm above the mid-plane of the
impeller while particle 4 is placed 1.5 mm below the
mid-plane (xN"x
G#1.5 mm and x
N"x
G!1.5 mm).
The pathlines of these particles are shown in Fig. 2a.
The particles placed in the discharge of the impeller (red
particles) follow pathlines that move through a large
portion of the volume of the tank; their trajectories ap-
pear random. However, one of them always remains
above the mid-plane of the impeller while the other
always remains below the impeller, revealing symptoms
of vertical segregation that have often been observed by
practitioners. The blue particles trace out the surface of
torii that are essentially identical in shape to the seg-
regated regions observed in #ow visualization experi-
ments (Fig. 2b).
PoincareH sections are used as a diagnostic tool to
reveal regular regions of the #ow and to examine details
of the #ow structure. PoincareH sections are generated in
this paper by tracking a small number of particles
(O(100)) in the #ow for a large number of periods
(O(1000)) and marking the intersection of the particle
trajectories with a vertical plane attached to impeller
(note that tracking is performed using the rotating framevelocity "eld and therefore this vertical plane, although it
is attached to the impeller, is stationary). This typically
generates a two-dimensional picture of the #ow structure
that reveals chaotic #ow regions as a `random-lookingacloud of points and regular #ow regions as collection of
closed particle paths.
Fig. 3a shows the initial position of 77 particles placed
in the #ow in a cross-shaped pattern centered at the
positions of the segregated regions (since the posi-
tions of the segregated regions depend on Reynoldsnumber, slightly di!erent initial conditions are used
for each Reynolds number). In this case (100 RPM,Re"17.28) the particles are tracked for 400 periods of
the #ow where 1 period is de"ned as 1 revolution of the
impeller. In the PoincareH section shown in Fig. 3b, two
types of behavior are apparent; a random-looking cloud
of points starting at the discharge of the impeller (sugges-
ting chaotic #ow), and two islands that contain ellipti-
cal-shaped closed loops (suggesting non-chaotic #ow).
Fig. 3c reveals the structure within the lower segregated
region.
Neither the experimental observations presented else-
where (Lamberto et al., 1996; Yao et al., 1998) nor the
qualitative analogies made in this section constitute
proof of the presence of chaos in the stirred tank. To
achieve such proof, we must consider the rate of stretch-
ing of material elements throughout the #ow; sustained
exponential stretching in a bounded domain demon-
strates that the #ow is chaotic.
3.3. Stretchingxelds, distributions, and rates
Stretching "elds are generated by tracking the stretch-
ing experienced by &10,000 #uid particles uniformly
placed on a vertical plane located at "303 (i.e. mid-plane between impeller blades). Figs. 4a}4c show the
stretching "elds relative to the initial particle position
after mixing for 200 periods at 100, 200, and
4890 D. J. Lamberto et al. / Chemical Engineering Science 56 (2001) 4887}4899
-
8/4/2019 Lamberto 2001
5/13
Fig. 3. PoincareH section of the stirred tank #ow (Re"17.28): (a) initial
positions; (b) after 400 periods (impeller rotations); (c) close-up of the
lower segregated region.
Fig. 4. Stretching "eld for +10,000 particles placed uniformly in
a vertical cross section of the tank. Stretching is plotted versus the
initial particle position and the colors represent stretching values that
increase from black to red. Particles are tracked for 200 periods at (a)
Re"17.28, (b) Re"34.56, and (c) Re"67.12. In all cases the poorly
mixed segregated regions appear as islands of low stretching sur-
rounded by a chaotic `seaa.
400 RPM (Re"17.28,34.56, and 69.12). The stretching
value is denoted by the color of the points in the plots
and increase in the usual order: black, dark blue, light
blue, green, yellow, magenta, and red. The segregated
regions are clearly evident in the "gures as two large oval
islands of low stretching values that appear above and
below the impeller. These islands are surrounded by
a `seaa of high stretching values increasing exponentially
with time and corresponding to the chaotic region of the
#ow. Even within the chaotic region, an extremely wide
distribution of stretching values is revealed by the com-
putations, indicating that laminar mixing in stirred tanks
causes a very wide distributions of micromixing inten-
sities, a characteristic of chaotic #ows (Muzzio et al.,
1991, 1999). As the Reynolds number increases, the
stretching "eld remains highly non-uniform (and as
a consequence also the intermaterial area density), al-
though it continues to span several orders of magnitude.
This observation has deep implications; for example,
transport-controlled chemical reactions will proceed at
extremely non-uniform rates in such #ows. For systems
with multiple reactions, wherein the product distribution
is often a!ected by mixing performance, such wide distri-
bution of micromixing rates would result in considerable
overproduction of waste products (Muzzio & Liu, 1996;
Zalc & Muzzio, 1999). Similar observations have been
reported for turbulent #ows by many authors; for a com-
prehensive reference see Baldyga and Bourne (1999).
The distribution of behaviors is examined statistically
by computing the probability density function (PDF) of
the logarithm of stretching values:
HL
(log
)"1
N
dN(log
)
dlog
, (4)
where N is the total number of #uid particles and
dN(log
) is the number of particles that have values
between log
and log
#d log
. The stretching
distributions for &40,000 particles placed uniformly
throughout the entire #ow domain are estimated for 100,
200, and 400 RPM and are plotted for the same number
D. J. Lamberto et al. / Chemical Engineering Science 56 (2001) 4887}4899 4891
-
8/4/2019 Lamberto 2001
6/13
Fig. 5. Stretching distributions for+40,000 particles placed uniformly
throughout the tank after 200 periods of mixing at Re"17.28, 34.56,
and 67.12 (from left to right). The distributions resemble those obtained
in other #ows for partially chaotic conditions.
Fig. 6. Geometric mean of the stretching plotted versus time for the
bulkand segregated#ow regions. Stretching increases at an exponential
rate for the particles in the bulk #ow region while only at a linear rate in
the poorly mixed islands.
of impeller rotations (Fig. 5). The distributions broaden
with increasing Reynolds number and they all
display a large hump of low stretching values corre-
sponding to the segregated islands. They look qualitat-
ively similar to distributions computed for other #ows
with large non-chaotic islands (Muzzio et al., 1991; Liu,
Peskin, Muzzio, & Leong, 1994c; Hobbs & Muzzio,
1998).
To further analyze and quantify mixing in the system,
spreading of tracer was simulated by introducing 1000
#uid particles into the #ow. Each particle is locatedrandomly within a small circle of 1 cm radius centered
either at the discharge stream of the impeller or inside the
segregated regions. The radius of the circle was deter-
mined by screening several values and comparing
simulated dye streaks with dye streaks observed experi-
mentally; a value of 1 cm was large enough to simulate
dye injection but not so large for the particles to leave the
segregated regions.
The particles were mixed for 10 min at
100 RPM (Re+17) and their stretching values were
recorded. The geometric mean values of the stret-
ching experienced by the 1000 particles within the
bulk #ow region and the 1000 particles in the islands are
plotted versus time in Fig. 6. The stretching values
increase exponentially in the bulk #ow region but
only linearly in the segregated regions of regular
#ow. Similar trends are observed for all Reynolds
numbers studied. Since the #ow is laminar (Re+69),
the cause of the exponential growth in stretching is
the presence of chaos in the #ow. Thus, laminar stirred
tank #ows can be deemed partially chaotic and the slope
of the curve for particles outside the segregated regi-
ons is an estimate of the Lyapunov exponent,
+0.16 (Re+17).
3.4. Injection locations and impeller ewects
Tracking computations are performed to simulate
mixing of a small spherical drop of dye solution into the
bulk of the #uid. The e!ects of the initial position (`injec-
tion locationa) of the droplet on the resulting mixing
structures are examined and stretching rates are deter-
mined for a droplet that moves near the impeller. Com-
putationally, the droplet consists of 822 particles
uniformly distributed on the surface of a sphere with
a radius equal to 1 cm, `injecteda into three regions of the
#ow: (1) at the axial position of the impeller mid-plane,
1 cm in front of the tip of the impeller blade, and inter-
secting the separation plane at the impeller mid-plane; (2)at an axial position equal to twice the height of the
impeller and a radial position equal to the outer radius of
the impeller, and (3) at the center of the upper segregated
region for each Reynolds number. Simulation results for
a droplet in the lower region are analogous to results
obtained for the upper region and will not be presented
here.
Figs. 7a}c show the "nal position of the particles after
mixing for 400 periods at Re"34.56 (200 RPM). These
"gures clearly show the isolating e!ect of the islands and
the separatrix originated by the impeller mid-plane. The
particles within drop 1 cover much of the bulk #ow
region and experience exponential growth in stretching.
Note that they mostly populate the outer layers of the
segregated regions (corresponding to the portion of drop
1 that was initially inside the region). The particles dis-
perse above and below the impeller, since the initial
location of the blob straddles the impeller plane. The
particles in drop 2 experience similar stretching; however,
these particles remain con"ned to the region above the
impeller mid-plane, since their initial location is above
the separatrix. Drop 3 remains entirely within the upper
segregated region and experiences only a linear growth in
stretching as shown before (Fig. 6b).
4892 D. J. Lamberto et al. / Chemical Engineering Science 56 (2001) 4887}4899
-
8/4/2019 Lamberto 2001
7/13
Fig. 7. Particle positions after 400 periods of mixing at 200 RPM for three droplets of particles. (a) The particles of droplet 1 (initially located at the
impeller discharge) spread throughout the tank and experience relatively high stretching values, except at the edge of the segregated region where they
experience low stretching. (b) The particles of droplet 2 (originally located above the impeller mid-plane in the chaotic region) also experience high
stretching and are not only isolated from the segregated region, but also from the region of the tank below the impeller. (c) Finally, the particles of
droplet 3 (initially located in the upper segregated region) remain isolated from the chaotic region and experience low stretching.
A closer examination of the evolution of drop 2 is
presented in Fig. 8. Averages of short-time stretching
values, 12, and single-period average stretching
multipliers (Muzzio et al., 1991) are plotted in Figs. 8a
and b; multipliers are de"ned as the ratio of attime t#t to the value of at time t (here t is equal to
0.1 s). The long-time plot is given in Fig. 8c. Since the
amount of intermaterial surface between components
being mixed increases proportionally to 12, the stretch-
ing multiplier indicates the global rate of the mixing
process in the #ow (for a full discussion, see Muzzio et al.,
1999).
A sharp increase in the stretching values (see Fig. 8a),
and a maximum peak in the multiplier plot (see Fig. 8b),
occur when particles pass between the blades of the
impeller and for a brief period after discharge from the
impeller. At t&2.3 s, as the stretching rate goes through
a minimum, the curve in Fig. 8a becomes almost #at and
the average multiplier is minimum. At this time the
particles are at their maximum distance from the impel-
ler. Subsequently, particles move slowly until t&4 s
when they are again drawn toward the impeller and their
stretching rate again increases. However, since the par-
ticles are more dispersed, not all of them experience an
increase in the stretching rate at the same time and
therefore the slope is not as steep as the initial increase.
After t&5 s the particles are distributed throughout the
chaotic region of the #ow, the stretching multiplier be-
comes roughly a constant (Fig. 8b), and the long-time
plot of the logarithm of acquires a constant slope
(Fig. 8c).
4. Time-dependent RPM
A method for eliminating segregation and enhancing
mixing can be developed based on several studies which
have shown that e$cient mixing in laminar #ows can be
achieved by generating a time-dependent chaotic #ow
(Aref, 1984; Aref & Balachandar, 1986; Beigie, Leonard,
& Wiggins, 1991, 1993; Franjione, Leong, & Ottino,
1989; Leong & Ottino, 1989; Liu, Muzzio, & Peskin,
1994a,b; Muzzio et al., 1991; Ott & Antonsen, 1988;
Ottino, Leong, Rising, & Swanson, 1988; Swanson & Ot-
tino, 1990). A similar approach has been used here to
enhance mixing in the stirred tank. Since the positions of
the segregated regions have been found to depend on the
impeller rotation rate (Lamberto et al., 1996, 1999),
a #uctuation of the rotation rate should lead to wide-
spread mixing by preventing the formation of stable torii.
Then, mixing times can be signi"cantly reduced by #uc-
tuating the impeller speed between two settings (Lam-
berto et al., 1996; Yao et al., 1998).
As the rotation rate changes from settingC1 to setting
C2, some of the #uid in the well-mixed region becomes
part of the newly formed segregated region. Since the
center of the new torus is displaced, rotation within the
torus forms a swirl pattern. When the rotation rate is
D. J. Lamberto et al. / Chemical Engineering Science 56 (2001) 4887}4899 4893
-
8/4/2019 Lamberto 2001
8/13
Fig. 8. Evolution of the geometric mean stretching for droplet 2: (a) short-time average of stretching, (b) stretching multipliers, and (c) the long-time
stretching of the particles (2000 periods).
Our experimental observations derived from laser-induced #uor-
escent tracer experiments (not presented here) suggest that the duration
of transient periods is controlled by the ramp of the motor (typically 5 s)
and not by the response of the #uid (less than 30 s for the Re conditions
studied here). The contribution of these transient intervals to mixing is
di$cult to establish experimentally. An alternative is to reverse the
rotation of the impeller without changing the RPM value. In such
a condition, the segregated torii are only relocated during the transient.
Results of such experiments recently reported by Yao et al. (1998),
suggest that the role of transients is not signi"cant. Only minimum
enhancements of mixing were achieved by #ow reversals. Our own
experiments to be discussed in a future publication are consistent with
this observation.
changed back to setting C1 some of the #uid trapped
inside the segregated region at settingC2 is now released
into the well-mixed region and quickly becomes disper-
sed throughout the tank. Within the segregated region,
#uid previously found outside the segregated region
continues to swirl around #uid originally located in thechaotic region, getting better mixed. This process is con-
ceptually similar to kneading bread dough where the
dough is stretched and folded repeatedly to promote
good mixing. By using variable speed, stable segregated
regions do not form, and intermaterial area is generated
at an increased rate as observed by the striation patterns
formed in #ow visualization experiments.
In this section the e!ects of time-dependent RPM are
examined computationally. The most general approach
to computationally model the e!ect of variable RPM
protocols should consider the two constant velocity"elds
corresponding to the two velocity settings, and also the
transient between them. However, the simulation of tran-
sients in 3-D #ows is not a trivial task. In order to track
the position of#uid particles during transients, a series of
sucesive interpolations between steady velocity "elds
needs to be performed. Moreover, while the convergence
of a numerical scheme towards a steady-state #ow is
a relatively robust process amenable of experimental
validation, experimental veri"cation of numerical results
for a 3-D transient #ow is very di$cult, bringing into
question the practicality of such an approach. As a "rst
approximation, here we merely examine the e!ect of
iteration between steady-state conditions, without con-
sidering the added contribution of transients. Therefore,
time-dependent RPM is simulated by periodically alter-
nating two velocity "elds (v
(x, y, z) and v
(x, y, z)) into
Eqs. (1) and (2); each velocity "eld corresponding to
a di!erent impeller speed. The software is initialized by
reading in the node positions and velocity values for both"elds. Particles are tracked for a predetermined amount
of time using velocity "eld C1, followed by tracking
using velocity "eldC2 for the same amount of time. As
shown below, simulated and experimental results agree
quite well in spite of the simpli"cation incurred in ne-
glecting the transients. In the remainder of this paper,
mixing schemes are referred to by the "rst speed setting
(always the higher of the two) followed by the second
speed setting and the duration of each setting in seconds.
For example, if a mixing cycle consists of mixing at 100
RPM for 10 s followed by mixing at 50 RPM for 10 s, it is
referred to as 100/50/10.
4894 D. J. Lamberto et al. / Chemical Engineering Science 56 (2001) 4887}4899
-
8/4/2019 Lamberto 2001
9/13
Fig. 9. Comparison of constant and time-dependent RPM mixing protocols. From left to right, the stretching distributions after 133, 267, 400, and 533periods are shown for (a) 400 RPM and (b) 200/100/30.
Fig. 10. E!ects of#uctuation frequency on the stretching distributions
for 200/100 RPM settings, for various #uctuation frequencies. All the
curves are practically identical.
4.1. PoincareH sections and stretching distributions
Mixing improvement due to variable RPM protocols
is manifested in PoincareH sections as an absence of seg-
regated structures (not shown here). It is also re#ected in
stretching distributions, which become more symmetric
as stretching values increase exponentially throughout
the entire #ow domain.Stretching distributions generated for the mixing
scheme 200/100/30 are contrasted with those generated
by constant-speed mixing at 400 RPM. Fig. 9a shows the
distributions for 400 RPM plotted for 20, 40, 60, and 80 s
of mixing. Each one has a large peak of low stretching
values, which corresponds to the segregated regions, fol-
lowed by a long high-stretching tail, which corresponds
to the bulk or chaotic region of the #ow. In contrast,
Fig. 9b shows distributions for 200/100/30 at times corre-
sponding to the exact number of periods as each of the
curves for the 400 RPM case. More desirable mixing
conditions are achieved through the use of time-depen-
dent RPM; the sharp peak of low stretching values has
almost entirely been eliminated and the distributions are
also narrower indicating that the mixing intensity is more
uniform throughout the stirred tank.
4.2. Ewects of impeller speedyuctuation frequency
Stretching distributions are used to examine the e!ects
of impeller #uctuation frequency. The impeller is #uc-
tuated between 200 and 100 RPM every 30, 15, 10, and
5 s. These frequencies were chosen based on preliminary
#ow visualization experiments. These #uctuation fre-
quencies are clearly unrealistic for the large tanks used in
most industrial operations. However, such tanks are typi-
cally operated at much lower speeds, and under such
conditions the corresponding #uctuation frequencies are
substantially lower. The stretching distributions are plot-
ted in Fig. 10, after 400 #ow periods (400 impeller revol-
utions) of mixing. Their shapes are almost identical for
each duration time, except for a small `humpa at lower
values of stretching that corresponds to a (relatively)
slow-mixing region that is created where the torii used to
be. This `humpa moves to higher values of stretching
as the #uctuation frequency increases between 2 speed
D. J. Lamberto et al. / Chemical Engineering Science 56 (2001) 4887}4899 4895
-
8/4/2019 Lamberto 2001
10/13
Fig. 11. Positions and stretching values of the particles of droplet
3 after 2 min of mixing at (a) constant 200 RPM, (b) 200/100/30, (c)
200/100/15, (d) 200/100/10, and (e) 200/100/5.
changes per minute (i.e., every 30 s) to 12 changes per
minute (i.e., every 5 s), indicating that mixing may be
Fig. 12. Stretching versus number of revolutions for the conditions
depicted in Fig. 11a}e (from bottom to top). Stretching values increase
at an exponential rate for all the time-dependent RPM mixing schemes
while they increase only linearly for constant RPM mixing.
more e!ective for schemes that #uctuate impeller speed
more rapidly (consistent with experimental observations
by Yao et al., 1998).
To further investigate the e!ects of #uctuation fre-
quency, let us again consider the mixing of a droplet of
dye solution and focus on drop 3 (see previous section),
which is located inside the upper segregated region.
Fig. 11a shows the particle positions and stretching
values after mixing for 400 periods at 200 RPM
(Re"34). Figs. 11b}e are generated by #uctuating the
impeller speed between 200 and 100 RPM every 30, 15,
10, and 5 s, respectively. The corresponding stretching
rates are plotted in Fig. 12 (the stretching rate for con-
stant speed mixing at 200 RPM is included for compari-son). The stretching values obtained for time-dependent
RPM schemes are orders of magnitude greater than the
rates for constant speed. The #uid inside the previously
segregated regions now stretches at an exponential rate
and in general the greatest increases in the rate of stretch-
ing are observed for the higher #uctuation frequencies.
This agrees with Figs. 11d and e, which show that the
particles are most widely dispersed, and therefore better
mixed with the surrounding bulk #uid, for protocols that
#uctuate impeller speed every 5 and 10 s. It should be
noted that, although the stretching rates of the particles
in the segregated regions increase exponentially, these
rates are still considerably lower than those experienced
by particles in the bulk #ow region. This di!erence is the
source of the small `humpa observed in the stretching
distribution plots in Fig. 9.
Several mixing schemes employing di!erent pairs of
RPM settings have been examined for each #uctuation
frequency (every 5, 10, 15, and 30 s). Frequencies were
identi"ed corresponding to the maximum increase in
stretching for each pair of RPM settings. Results are
plotted in Fig. 13a. These results can now be compared to
determine the `most e$cienta mixing scheme. The reader
should bear in mind however, that the de"nition of
4896 D. J. Lamberto et al. / Chemical Engineering Science 56 (2001) 4887}4899
-
8/4/2019 Lamberto 2001
11/13
Fig. 13. Comparison of the optimum mixing schemes for di!erent RPM settings: 100/50/10 (dashed line), 200/100/5 (dashed}dotted line), 400/50/5
(dotted line), and 400/300/10 (continuous line). (a) Setting 200/100/5 had the highest stretching rate per revolution; (b) 400/300/10 had the highest
stretching rate per unit time; and (c) 100/50/10 gave the highest rate per unit of power requirement.
e$ciency is somewhat arbitrary and that di!erent results
can be obtained for various de"nitions. For example, one
can choose stretchingper revolution as a basis for compari-son. This is a reasonable choice because for laminar #ows
in stirred tanks, the time scale is determined by the impel-
ler speed, and the dimensionless mixing time is given by
the number of revolutions. Therefore, laminar mixing op-
erations should be scaled up using the total number of
revolution as a basis. When compared in this manner, it is
observed that the #uid experiences the highest amount of
stretching per revolution for the mixing scheme 200/100/5,
followed by 100/50/10, and 400/50/5. The lowest is the
400/300/10 scheme. The fact that the lower RPM settings
outperformed the higher may seem counter-intuitive at
"rst since the size of the segregated regions has been
shown to be larger at the lower RPM settings (Lamberto
et al., 1996; Yao et al., 1998). However, the positions of the
segregated regions have also been shown to change most
drastically with changes in speed at lower Reynolds num-
bers (lower RPM settings) and therefore, since mixing
enhancements are caused by continuously displacing the
segregated regions, the largest enhancements are obtained
at the lowest speeds.
However, in cases where an intrinsic time scale is impor-
tant (as is the case, for example, for systems where the
characteristic time of a chemical reaction determines the
necessary mixing performance) one might be interested
in the amount of stretching per unit of clock time. Such
a comparison, shown in Fig. 13b, reveals that the `mixing
e$ciencya order has changed. The mixing schemes400/50/5, 400/300/10, and 200/100/5 all generate stretch-
ing values several orders of magnitude higher than the
100/50/10 scheme on a per-minute basis because they
apply more revolutions (i.e., more #ow periods) per unit
time.
In many other applications, a useful measure of the
mixing e$ciency must consider, in addition to mixing
time, the power requirements of the system. The
power dissipation per unit volume of each scheme
is estimated as the average of the power for const-
ant speed mixing at each RPM setting, where the
power per unit volume is calculated as P"2(D : D)
where D is the rate-of-strain tensor. The ratios of stretch-
ing to P are plotted for each condition in Fig. 13c. The
scheme 100/50/10 is now the most e$cient mixing method.
5. Conclusions
Lagrangian particle tracking software has been de-
veloped to perform an in-depth analysis of laminar mix-
ing in a stirred tank. Path lines of#uid particles placed
initially near the positions of the segregated regions
trace out the surfaces of three-dimensional torii. Their
D. J. Lamberto et al. / Chemical Engineering Science 56 (2001) 4887}4899 4897
-
8/4/2019 Lamberto 2001
12/13
shapes are identical to the shapes of the poorly mixed
regions observed experimentally and the particles remain
in these regions inde"nitely. PoincareH sections of the
#ow reveal a complex internal structure of such regions.
The stretching distributions experienced by #uid
elements display a `humpa of low stretching values
and a long tail of high stretching values characteristicof a partially chaotic #ow. Further, stretching values
of #uid elements inside of the segregated regions
increase only linearly while the stretching values
experienced by #uid elements placed in the bulk
#ow increase at an exponential rate, characteristic of
a chaotic #ow.
A `globally chaotica #ow was generated through the
use of dynamic #ow perturbations. The e!ect of time-
dependent RPM on stretching values was numerically
examined for various mixing schemes; pairs of RPM
settings (consistent with the Reynolds numbers used
throughout this paper) and several frequencies of speed
changes were examined. Upon application of such
schemes, the `humpa previously observed in the stretching
distributions, corresponding to a slow-mixing region, was
reduced in size, the distributions were more symmetric,
and stretching increased at an exponential rate through-
out the #ow domain. Several speed #uctuation frequencies
were examined. In general, #uctuating impeller speed
every 5 and 10 s produced the largest increase in the
stretching rate, while increases where the speed was #uc-
tuated every 15 and 30 s produced the lowest rates. Rates
were higher for the lower RPM settings when plotted
either per revolutions or per unit of energy consumed, and
higher for the higher RPM settings when plotted as a func-tion of time. While at the laboratory scale considered in
this study energy considerations are inconsequential, at
the industrial scale, the expense of run time versus power
requirements must be carefully considered when applying
these techniques.
Notation
D rate-of-strain tensor
DQ
shaft diameterD
R
tank diameter
F(vH) probability density function ofv
H
H #uid level height
H@
height of impeller blade
l vector representing #uid element
N number of sample points used to determine
PDFN
Npumping coe$cient
N
impeller speed, rev/s
PDF probability distribution function
Re impeller Reynolds number (N
DG
/)
RPM impeller speed, rev/min
rG
impeller radius
v
velocity vector (vV
, vP, v
F)
vV
, vP, v
Faxial, radial, and tangential velocity compo-
nents
v velocity gradient tensor
xG
impeller mid-plane axial position
=@
width of impeller blade
Greek letters
stretching
#uid viscosity #uid density
References
Alvarez, M. M., Muzzio, F. J., Cerbelli, S., Adrover, A., &
Giona, M. (1998). Self-similar spatio-temporal structure of material
"laments in chaotic #ows. Physical Review Letters, 81(16),
3395}3398.
Aref, H. (1984). Stirring by chaotic advection. Journal of Fluid Mechan-
ics, 143, 1}21.
Aref, H., & Balachandar, S. (1986). Chaotic advection in a Stokes #ow.
Physics of Fluids, 29, 3515}3521.
Backer, M. P., Metzger, L. S., Slaber, P. L., Nevitt, K. L., & Boder,
G. B. (1988). Large-scale production of monoclonal antibodies
in suspension culture. Biotechnology and Bioengineering, 32,
993}1000.
Baldyga, J., & Bourne, J. R. (1999). Turbulent mixing and chemical
reactions (867 pp.). New York: Wiley.
Beck, C., Stiefel, H., & Stinnett, T. (1987). Cell-culture bioreactors.
Chemical Engineering, 94(2), 121}129.
Beigie, D., Leonard, A., & Wiggins, S. (1991). A global study of en-
hanced stretching and di!usion in a chaotic tangles. Physics of
Fluids, 3, 1039}1050.
Beigie, D., Leonard, A., & Wiggins, S. (1993). Statistical relaxation
under nonturbulent chaotic #ows: Non-Gaussian high-stretch tails
of "nite-time Lyapunov exponent distributions. Physical Review
Letters, 70, 275}278.
Blynsniuk, J. W., & Sefton, V. M. (1991). Production of uniform drops
of viscous liquids using a coaxial airstream. Canadian Journal of
Chemical Engineering, 69, 245}250.
Cherry, R. S., & Papoutsakis, E. T. (1998). Hydrodynamic e!ect on cell
growth in agitated microcarrier bioreactor. NASA echnical memo-
randum, 1(4069), pp. 155}157.
Croughan, M. S., Hamel, J., & Wang, D. I. C. (1987). Hydrodynamic
e!ects on animal cells Grown in microcarrier cultures. Biotechnol-
ogy and Bioengineering, XXIX, 130}141.
Croughan, M. S., Hamel, J. P., & Wang, D. I. C. (1988). E !ects ofmicrocarrier concentration in animal cell culture. Biotechnology and
Bioengineering, 32, 975}982.
Franjione, J. G., Leong, C. W., & Ottino, J. M. (1989). Symmetries
within chaos: A route to e!ective mixing. Physics of Fluids, 1,
1772}1782.
Harvey III, A. D., & Rogers, S. E. (1996). Steady and unsteady compu-
tation of impeller-stirred reactors. A.I.Ch.E. Journal, 42(10),
2701}2712.
Harvey III, A. D., Wood, S. P., & Leng, D. E. (1997). Experimental and
computational study of multiple impeller #ows. Chemical Engineer-
ing Science, 52(9), 1479}1491.
Hobbs, M. D., & Muzzio, F. J. (1998a). Kenics static mixer: A three-
dimensional chaotic #ow. Chemical Engineering Journal, 67(3),
153}166.
4898 D. J. Lamberto et al. / Chemical Engineering Science 56 (2001) 4887}4899
-
8/4/2019 Lamberto 2001
13/13
Hobbs, M. D., & Muzzio, F. J. (1998b). Reynolds number e!ects on
laminar mixing in the Kenics static mixer. Chemical Engineering
Journal, 70, 93.
Hobbs, M. D., & Muzzio, F. J. (1998c). Optimization of a static mixer
using dynamical systems techniques. Chemical Engineering Science,
53(18), 3199}3213.
Lamberto, D. J. (1997). Enhancing laminar mixing in stirred tank reactors
using dynamicyow perturbations. Ph.D. thesis dissertation. The StateUniversity of New Jersey, Rutgers.
Lamberto, D. J., Alvarez, M. M., & Muzzio, F. J. (1999). Experimental
and computational investigation of the laminar #ow structure in
a stirred tank. Chemical Engineering Science, 54, 919}942.
Lamberto, D. J., Muzzio, F. J., Swanson, P. D., & Tonkovich, A. L.
(1996). Using time-dependent RPM to enhance mixing in stirred
vessels. Chemical Engineering Science, 51, 733}741.
Leong, C. W., & Ottino, J. M. (1989). Experiments on mixing due to
chaotic advection in a cavity. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 209,
463}499.
Liu, M., Muzzio, F. J., & Peskin, R. L. (1994a). E!ects of manifolds and
corner singularities in chaotic cavity #ows. Chaos, Solitons and
Fractals, 4, 2145}2167.
Liu, M., Muzzio, F. J., & Peskin, R. L. (1994b). Quanti"cation of
mixing in aperiodic chaotic #ows. Chaos, Solitons and Fractals, 4,869}893.
Liu, M., Peskin, R. L., Muzzio, F. J., & Leong, C. W. (1994c). Structure
of the stretching in chaotic cavity #ows. A.I.Ch.E. Journal, 40,
1273}1286.
Muzzio, F. J., Alvarez, M. M., Cerbelli, S., Giona, M., & Adrover, A.
(2000). The intermaterial area density and striation thickness distri-
bution generated by time- and spatially-periodic 2D chaotic #ows.
Chemical Engineering Science, 55(8), 1497}1508.
Muzzio, F. J., & Liu, M. (1996). Chemical reactions in chaotic#ows. The
Chemical Engineering Journal, 64, 117.
Muzzio, F. J., Swanson, P. D., & Ottino, J. M. (1991). The statistics of
stretching in chaotic #ows. Physics of Fluids, 3, 822}834.
Omurtag, A. C., Stickel, V., & Chevray, R. (1996). Chaotic advection in
a bioengineering system. Proceedings of Engineering Mechanics, 1,
450}453.Ott, E., & Antonsen, T. M. (1988). Chaotic #uid convection and the
fractal nature of passive scalar gradients. Physical Review Letters, 61,
2839}2842.
Ottino, J. M., Leong, C. W., Rising, H., & Swanson, P. D. (1988).
Morphological structures produced by mixing in chaotic #ows.
Nature, 333, 419}425.
Ottino, J. M., Ranz, W. E., & Macosko, C. W. (1981). A framework of
description of mechanical mixing of#uids. A.I.Ch.E. Journal, 27(4),
565}577.
Papoutsakis, E. T. (1993). Fluid-mechanical damage of animal cells in
bioreactors. Trends in Biotechnology, 9(12), 427}437.
Press, W. H., Flannery, B. P., Teukolsky, S. A., & Vetterling, W. T.
(1986). Numerical recipes (The art of scientixc computing). Cam-
bridge: Cambridge University Press.Ranade, V. V. (1997). An e$cient computational model for simulating
#ow in stirred vessels: A case of Rushton turbine. Chemical Engin-
eering Science, 52(24), 4473}4484.
Rauline, D., Tanguy, P. A., Le BleHvec, J.-M., & Bousquet, J.
(1997). Numerical investigation of the performance of several
static mixers. The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, 76,
527,535.
Sefton, M. V., Dawson, R. M., Broughton, R. L., Blysniuk, J.,
& Sugamori, M. E. (1987). Microencapsulation of mammalian
cells in a water-insoluble polyacrylate by coextrusion and inter-
facial precipitation. Biotechnology and Bioengineering, 29(9),
1935}1943.
Souvaliotis, A., Jana, S. C., & Ottino, J. M. (1995). Potentialities
and limitations of mixing simulations. A.I.Ch.E. Journal, 41(7),
1605}1621.Swanson, D., & Ottino, J. M. (1990). A comparative computational and
experimental study of chaotic mixing of viscous #uids. Journal of
Fluid Mechanics, 213, 227}249.
Tanaka, H., Semba, H., Jitsufuchi, T., & Harada, H. (1988). The e!ect of
physical stress on plant cells in suspension cultures. Biotechnology
Letters, 10, 485}480.
Tanguy, P. A., Thibault, F., Brito-De La Fuente, E., Espinosa-
Solares, T., & Tecante, A. (1998). Mixing performance
induced by coaxial #at blade-helical ribbon impellers rotating
at di!erent speeds. Chemical Engineering Science, 52(11),
1733}1741.
de la VilleHon, J., Bertrand, F., Tanguy, P. A., Labrie, R., Bousquet, J.,
& Lebouvier, D. (1998). Numerical investigation of mixing e$ciency
of helical ribbons. A.I.Ch.E. Journal, 44(4), 972}977.
Yao, W. G., Sato, H., Takahashi, K., & Koyama, K. (1998). Mixingperformance experiments in impeller stirred tanks subjected to
unsteady rotational speeds. Chemical Engineering Science, 53(17),
3031}3040.
Zalc, J., & Muzzio, F. J. (1999). Parallel-competitive reactions in
a 2-dimensional chaotic #ow. Chemical Engineering Science,
54, 1053.
D. J. Lamberto et al. / Chemical Engineering Science 56 (2001) 4887}4899 4899