Language-based Security: Information Flow Control

18739A: Foundations of Security and Privacy

Anupam DattaFall 2009

Lecture Outline

Information Flow Control (IFC)

Security definition Non-interference [Goguen-Meseguer82]

Language-based enforcement Type system [Volpano-Smith-Irvine96] based on

prior work [Denning-Denning77]

IFC in Tax Preparation Software

Definition of Security Non-interference (idea)

Program

HI

LI

HO

LO

HI’ HO’

No information flows from high inputs to low outputs

Security levels:H: ClassifiedL: Unclassified

Exampleif x = 1 then y:=1 else y:=0

NoLHYesHL

YesLL

YesHHNIyx

Specification and Enforcement

Approach Use a typed programming language Types represent security levels

H, L,… Sub-typing captures partial order among

security levels L H

Type system captures allowed information flows Soundness theorem

Well-typed programs satisfy non-interference

Language Definition Syntax Type System Operational Semantics

Soundness Theorem Well typed programs satisfy non-interference

Syntax (I)

Syntax (II)

We will focus on the special case where type is either H or L and L H

Type System (I) Typing judgment

Type system (II)

Type System (III)

Exampleif x = 1 then y:=1 else y:=0

NoLHYesHL

YesLL

YesHHNIyx

Will justify rows 1 & 2

Example with types

Key rules used are (ASSIGN) and (IF)

Type System (IV)

Exampleif x = 1 then y:=1 else y:=0

NoLHYesHL

YesLL

YesHHNIyx

Will justify rows 3 & 4

Example with types Suppose x: L var and y: H var

1. Use (ASSIGN), (CMD-), (SUBTYPE) to infer (y:=1): L cmd and (y:=0): L cmd

2. Now use (IF) rule

x: H var and y: L var is not well-typed as expected

L H

Operational Semantics (I) is memory: a function from locations to values (l) is contents of location l Judgments

1. Evaluating expression e in memory yields value n

2. Evaluating command c in memory yields memory ’

Program executes by evaluating expressions and commands

Operational Semantics (II)

Operational Semantics (III)

Soundness Theorem

Recall Non-interference

Program

HI

LI

HO

LO

HI’ HO’

No information flows from high inputs to low outputs

Security levels:H: ClassifiedL: Unclassified

Practical Languages for IFC Jif [Liskov-Myers et al.]

Java + information flow http://www.cs.cornell.edu/jif/

Flow Caml [Pottier-Simonet] Extends OCaml language with type system for

tracing information flow http://

citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/summary?doi=10.1.1.11.2104

Web Security: A Domain for IFC

Brendan Eich, Chief Technology Officer, Mozilla Corp.Improving JavaScript's Default Security Model with Information Flow, CSF 2009 Invited talk

Thanks

Questions?

Formal definition

•System is deterministic finite state machine: takes input and transitions to next state producing output•Trace tr is a sequence of inputs and outputs (high & low)•OutputL(S,tr,c): low output of system S when input c is applied to the state corresponding to trace tr•purgeHI(tr): returns a trace with all high inputs in tr removed

Programming Language Definition Syntax and Static Semantics (or “well-formed

programs”) Syntax of types and terms Type system

Semantics (or “meaning of programs”) Operational or dynamic semantics (Defines how programs execute)

Type Safety Well-typed programs do not get stuck, i.e., they

either terminate or keep reducing following the operational semantics

Language Definition Examples Syntax, Semantics (Static, Dynamic) ML:

R. Milner, M. Tofte, R. Harper, and D. MacQueen, The Definition of Standard ML (Revised). MIT Press, 1997

Java: J. Alves-Foss (Ed.), Formal Syntax and Semantics

of Java. LNCS 1523, 1999