law commission report no. 192- prevention of vexatious litigation, 2005 (2)

7/26/2019 Law Commission Report No. 192- Prevention of Vexatious Litigation, 2005 (2)

1/101

LAW COMMISSION OF INDIA

192NDREPORT

ON

PREVENTION OF VEXATIOUS LITIGATION

JUNE 2005

LatestLaws.com


2/101

LatestLaws.com

Justic LAW COMMMISSION OF INDIAM! JAGANNAD"A RAO S"ASTRI #"AWANC$%i&'%( NEW DEL"I)110 001 TEL * 2++,--.5 FAX * /O112+0.+,-2++,,,.0 E)'%i3 * c$!ic4s!(ic!i(

Rsi6(c * 1 JANPAT" NEW DEL"I TEL * 2+019-5

D!O!N7!/+810582005)LC/LS Ju( . 2005

D%& S$&i #$&%6%: :i

I $%; 7&%&6i(< t$ 192(6

R=7&t 7> t$ L%C7''issi7( 7( ?P&;(ti7( 7> V@%ti7us Liti7& t%( u= t$ su:ct i(

6t%i3 i( t$is R=7&t! It $%s '%6 %( i( 6=t$ stu6B 7> t$ '%tt& %s (>7&c6i( 6i>>&(t :u&is6icti7(s!

T$ ;%3i6itB 7> t$ %>7&s%i6 M%6&%s Act 7> 19-9 %s u=$36 B t$Su=&' C7u&t 7> I(6i% i( P!"! M%3 ;s! St%t 7> A!P!* /AIR 195 SC1,2. %(6 t$ C7u&t =7i(t6 7ut t$ %6;%(t% $%;i(< suc$ % 3%! It '%B

7s&;6 t$%t t$ M%6&%s Act 7> 19-9 %(6 t$ M%$%&%s$t&% Act 7> 19.1%& %s6 u=7( %( 736 st%tut 7> E( 1,9 %(6 t$ 3% 6c3%&6 i(G&= ;s! L7%' /1,.9 +9 C$D 1,! S;&%3 i'=&7;'(ts $%; (

'%6 i( t$ 3% i( t$%t c7u(t&B t$ 3%tst =&7;isi7(s i(< sc -2 7> t$/U Su=&' C7u&t Act 19,1! U(6& t$%t Act t$ E(


3/101

LatestLaws.com

#$%': s&is 7> c%ss i( 200+ i( U 6ci66 B t$ C7u&t 7> A==%3 $%;3%i6 67( t$ =&7c6u& t7 >73376 s7 t$%t t$ st%tuts 67 (7t 7>>(6 t$

=&i(ci=3 7> ?%ccss t7 :ustic c7(t%i(6 i( A&t 7> t$ Eu&7=%(C7(;(ti7(! I( Aust&%3i% %(6 N %3%(6 %3s7 3%s 7( =&;(ti7( 7>;@%ti7us 3itit& t$ =&s7(s7 6c3%&6 %s t$ ;@%ti7us 3itii3 ci;i3 7& c&i'i(%3 =&7c6i(i3i(< suc$ c%ss i( t$ su7&6i(%t c7u&ts it$ t$3%; 7> t$ Dist&ict %(6 Sssi7(s C7u&t! T$s c7u&ts i33 @%'i( $t$&

t$ =&7c6i( t$ ;@%ti7us 3itii3s %(B suc$ c%s>7& % c7u&t it$7ut 7t%i(i(< 3%; %s &ui&6 B t$ Act t$ c%s i33 6is'iss6 %(6 c7sts i33 $%; t7 %%&66 B t$ c7u&t i( $ic$ suc$=&7c6i(i36! I( %66iti7( t$ "i %


4/101

LatestLaws.com

=&7c6i(


5/101

LatestLaws.com

C$%=t& Tit3 P% P%&3i%'(t t7 (%ct 1- t7 1.T$ V@%ti7us Liti


6/101

LatestLaws.com

C$%=t& I

INTRODUCTORK

E%&3i& R=7&ts 7> t$ L% C7''issi7(

I( t$ 1,9t$R=7&t 7> t$ L% C7''issi7( 7> I(6i% 7( ?R;isi7( 7>

C7u&t)F St&uctu& /F&u%&B 200- t$& %s % &>&(c t7 ?>&i;737us %(6

;@%ti7us 3iti t$%tR=7&t t$ C7''issi7( $%6 7cc%si7( t7 &>& t7 t$ c7(st%(t 6'%(6 >7&

i(c&%s i( c7u&t > t7 =&;(t >&i;737us 7& ;@%ti7us 3itii>tB B%&s % 3;Bi(< ?c7u&t > c%' i(t7 ;7t& t$

3;B %3s7! " =7s6 ;%&i7us usti7(s*

LatestLaws.com


7/101

LatestLaws.com

It is u(67ut63B % &i;737us %(6 ;@%ti7us %cti7(s

s$7u36 i(stitut6! #ut it is %( ;i3 >7& $ic$ t$ G7;&('(t $%s

7(3B its3> %(6 its %>ici(t &'6B !! ! ! !!

W$B 6i6 6is$7(st =3%i(ti>>s %==3B t7 t$ C7u&ts >7& t$ i(stituti7(

> %s i'=7s6 E;i6(t3B c%us t$B t$7u succss! D7s t$ i(stituti7( 7> > 6i'i(is$ t$%t c$%(c

N7t i( t$ s'%33st 6 t$ M%6&%s V@%ti7us Liti 19-9 %(6 &>&&6 t7 t$ :u6


8/101

LatestLaws.com

W &c7''(6 t$%t 7( t$ 3i(s 7> t$ %7; '(ti7(6 M%6&%s Act

VIII 7> 19-9 % C(t&%3 Act '%B (%ct6 t7 cu& ;@%ti7us 7&

>&i;737us 3iti&i;737us %(6 ;@%ti7us 3iti i(c&%s i( c7u&t > %s %3s7 st%t6 B t$ Su=&' C7u&t i(

Sc&t%&B t7 G7;t! 7> M%6&%s ;s! P!R! S&i&%'u3u * 199/1 SCC +-5 /= +51

$& it %s 7s&;6 %s >7337s*

I( t$ ti' it %s ($%(c6


9/101

LatestLaws.com

6%3 it$ =&;(ti7( 7> ?;@%ti7us 3iti>&(t >&7' t$7s 6%3i(&i;737us 3iti>&(t! As i33

s( i( $ (sui(< c$%=t& ?;@%ti7us 3iti&i;737us) it$7ut t$ (6 >7& =&sist(t

>i3i(< 7> si'i3%& c%s) ;( i> it $%s (7 '&its $%ts7;& %(6 is i(t(66 t7

$%&%ss t$ 6>(6%(t 7& is %( %us 7> t$ =&7css 7> t$ C7u&t! Fu&t$& t$&

%& s7' @isti(< =&7;isi7(s i( t$ C76 7> Ci;i3 P&7c6u& 3i O&6&

Ru3 1 O&6& . Ru3 1 sc +5A tc! $ic$ 6%3 it$ ?>&i;737us 3iti


10/101

LatestLaws.com

At3%st i( t7 St%ts M%6&%s %(6 M%$%&%s$t&% t$& %& st%tuts '%6

B t$ St%t L t$ Act

=&7;i6 >7& 6c3%&i(< % =&s7( %s % ;@%ti7us 3iti

t$ A6;7c%t G(&%3 %(6 7(c $ is s7 6c3%&6 $ c%((7t i(iti%t %(B

%cti7( 7> % ci;i3 7& c&i'i(%3 (%tu& it$7ut =&i7& 3%; 7> t$ C7u&t! T$

6c3%&%ti7( i33 =u3is$6 i( t$ St%t G%tt! T$ >7337i(< %& t$

&3;%(t i'=7&t%(t =&7;isi7(s!

Scti7( 2/1* I> 7( %( %==3ic%ti7( '%6 B t$ A6;7c%t G(&%3 t$

"ii6 t$%t %(B =&s7( $%s $%itu%33B %(6 it$7ut %(B

10

LatestLaws.com


11/101

LatestLaws.com

&%s7(%3 t& i(< $%&6 7&6& t$%t (7 =&7c6i( t$ "i t$ Dist&ict %(6 Sssi7(s Ju6&&6 t7 i( scti7( 2 su scti7( /1 s$%33

(7t %(B =&7c6i( A!P! /AIR 195 SC

11

LatestLaws.com


12/101

LatestLaws.com

1,2.! "i6%B%tu33%$ J /%s $ t$( %s =7i(t6 7ut t$%t suc$ 3 Ju6ic%tu& /C7(stituti7( Act 1925/15

1 G7 Vc! -9! /T$s 3%s $%; si(c ( &=3%c6 B sc -2 7> t$

Su=&' C7u&t Act 19,1!

I( t$ Su=&' C7u&t %( %& t$

G7;&('(t 7> I(6i% Act 19+5 %s &:ct6! It %s st%t6 t$%t t$ su:ct 7>

t$ s%i6 3 List II /Ju&is6icti7( %(6

=7&s 7> %33 C7u&t @c=t t$ F6&%3 C7u&t it$ &s=ct 7> t$ '%tt&s i(

t$is List =&7c6u& i( R(t %(6 R;(u C7u&ts %(6 (t&B 2 7> List III

/C&i'i(%3 =&7c6u& i(c3u6i(< %33 '%tt&s i(c3u66 i( t$ C76 7> C&i'i(%3

=&7c6u& %t t$ 6%t 7> =%ssi(< 7> t$is Act %(6 E(t&B - 7> List II /Ci;i3

=&7c6u& i(c3u6i(< t$ 3% 7> Li'it%ti7( %(6 %33 '%tt&s i(c3u66 i( t$

C76 7> Ci;i3 P&7c6u& %t t$ 6%t 7> =%ssi(< t$is Act 7> t$ VII Sc$6u3

t7 t$ 19+5 Act!

T$ Su=&' C7u&t %>t& u=$736i(< t$ 3 t$ "i


13/101

LatestLaws.com

&%s7(%3 c%us >i3 ;@%ti7us %cti7(s ci;i3 7& c&i'i(%3! T$ Act is

(7t i(t(66 t7 6=&i; suc$ % =&s7( 7> $is &i

%(B c3%i' >7& t$ 7==7sit =%&tB is $%&%ss6! Suc$ %( Act %s

=%ss6 i( E( t$ =&7css 7> C7u&t! I( its 7:ct t$ Act =&7'7ts =u3ic

>(6i(< it$& A&t 19 7& A&t 1-!

M%6&%s Act ,8-9 is c7(>i(6 t7 736 O36 M%6&%s P&7;i(c >7& t$ SR Act

195*

A(7t$& usti7( t$%t %&7s i( P!"! M%3 ;s! St%t 7> AP AIR 195

SC 1,2. &>&&6 t7 %7; %s $t$& t$ "i A(6$&% P&%6s$

%s &i t$ M%6&%s Act 19-9 t7 t$ citis 7>

"B6&%%6 %(6 Scu(6&%%6 $& t$ %==33%(t %s >i3i(< % (u'& 7>

c%ss! T$ Su=&' C7u&t %>t& &>&&i(< t7 scti7(s 5 %(6 119 7> t$

St%ts R)7&7& 1!11!5 i( t$ &s=cti; =%&ts 7> t$ (3B >7&'6 St%t 7> A(6$&%

P&%6s$ %s c7(>i(6 t7 t$


14/101

LatestLaws.com

>7& 1!11!5 %(6 c7u36 (7t @t(66 t7 7t$& A(6$&% P&%6s$ u(3ss t$is %s 67( B t$ 3 t$

(3B >7&'6 St%t 7> A(6$&% P&%6s$! T$ M%6&%s Act 19-9 %s

t$&>7& $36 (7t %==3ic%3 t7 t$ citis 7> "B6&%%6 %(6 Scu(6&%%6

$ic$ & 7utsi6 t$ t&&it7&i%3 3i'its 7> t$ >7&'& St%t 7> M%6&%s!

I( t$ St%t 7> &%3% % si'i3%& usti7( %&7s i( A6;7c%t G(&%3 ;s!

T!A! R%:(6&%( 19,,/1 LT %(6 i( J7s ;s! M%6$u* 199-/1 LT ,55 %(6

it %s $36 t$%t t$ M%6&%s Act 7> 19-9 %s (7t %==3ic%3 t7 t$ %&%s i( t$

St%t 7> &%3% @c=t i( &

t$ c7'=7sit St%t 7> M%6&%s >7& 1!11!5!

M%$%&%s$t&% V@%ti7us Litii(6 t7 t$

St%t 7> M%$%&%s$t&%

T$is Act 7> 19.1 is '%6 %==3ic%3 t7 >&s$ c%ss t7 >i36 %s 33

%s t7 =(6i(< %cti7(s! It is 7t$&is 7( t$ s%' 3i(s %s t$ M%6&%s Act 7>

19-9! U(6& t$is Act t$ A6;7c%t G(&%3 c%( %==3B >7& 6c3%&i(< t$

7==7sit =%&tB %s % ;@%ti7us 3itii36 7( t$ A==33%t Si6 7> t$ "i t$

Ru3s %(6 s$7u36 $%&6 B % Di;isi7( #(c$ 7> t$ C7u&t %(6 7&6& 7>

t$ C7u&t s$7u36 =u3is$6 %s =&sc&i6 i( t$ Act /=u3is$6 i( t$

G%tt %(6 ci&cu3%t6 t7 suc$ c7u&ts %s t$ "i


15/101

LatestLaws.com

Sssi7(s Ju6 M%6&%s >7& 1!11!5! As =7i(t6 $i3

6iscussi(< t$ %==3ic%i3itB 7> t$ M%6&%s Act 7> 19-9 t$ s%i6 Act %s

&st&ict6 i( its t&&it7&i%3 %==3ic%ti7( 7(3B t7 t$ >7&'& St%t 7> M%6&%s $&

t$ N7&t$ M%3%%& =%&t 7> t$ ( St%t 7> &%3% /$ic$ %s >7&'6 7(

1!11!5! It %s $36 i( A6;7c%t G(&%3 ;s! T!A! R%:(6&%(* 19,,/1 LT

+05 %(6 J7s ;s! M%6$u* 1-9-/1 LT ,55 t$%t it %s (7t %==3ic%3 t7 7t$&

=%&ts 7> t$ St%t 7> &%3%!

T$&>7& t$ &%3% L% R>7&'s C7''itt $%s (7 &c7''(66

% 3 &%3%! T$ G7;&('(t &7u7&%&6

t$ #i33 tit36 ?T$ &%3% V@%ti7us Liti 7t$& (%tu& i( %(B c7u&t 7& c7u&ts! T$

=&s7( $%s t7 7t%i( 3%; 7> t$ "i $ is i(iti%ti(< % =&7c6i( t$ "i t$ Dist&ict C7u&t &>uss t7


17/101

LatestLaws.com

C$%=t& III

L M%6&%s %(6 i( t$ St%t 7> M%$%&%s$t&% 7( t$ su:ct 7>

P&;(ti7( 7> V@%ti7us Liti &%3%!

T$ c7(stituti7(%3 ;%3i6itB 7> t$ M%6&%s Act 7> 19-9 $%s ( u=$36

B t$ Su=&' C7u&t i( P!"! M%3 ;s! St%t 7> A!P!* AIR 195 SC 1,2.!

W %& 7> t$ ;i t$%t t$& is % t& $ 7u36 (7t

%3376 t7 >i3 %(B ci;i3 7& c&i'i(%3 c%ss 7& %(B 7t$& tB= 7> c%s i( t$

"i t$ "i


18/101

LatestLaws.com

W s$%33 >i&st @%'i( t$ 3


19/101

LatestLaws.com

T$ =7siti7( u(6& t$ C7(stituti7( 7> I(6i% %>t& t$ C7(stituti7( /-2(6

A'(6'(t Act 19. /!!>! +!1!.. is %s >7337s*

List III* C7(cu&&(t List

E(t&B 2* C&i'i(%3 =&7c6u&s i(c3u6i(< %33 '%tt&s i(c3u66 i( t$

C76 7> C&i'i(%3 P&7c6u& %t t$ c7''(c'(t 7> t$ C7(stituti7(!

E(t&B 11A* A6'i(ist&%ti7( 7> :ustic c7(stituti7( %(6 7&

%33 C7u&ts @c=t t$ Su=&' C7u&t %(6 t$ "i t$is C7(stituti7(

3i'it%ti7( %(6 %&it&%ti7(!

E(t&B -* Ju&is6icti7(s %(6 =7&s 7> %33 c7u&ts @c=t t$ Su=&'

C7u&t it$ &s=ct t7 %(B 7> t$ '%tt& i( t$is List!

It is t7 (7t6 t$%t u(6& t$ -2(6A'(6'(t t$ 7&6s i( E(t&B + 7> List

II 7> VII Sc$6u3 7> t$ C7(stituti7( ?A6'i(ist&%ti7( 7> :ustic c7(stituti7(

%(6 7& %33 c7u&ts @c=t t$ Su=&' C7u&t %(6 t$ "i&&6 t7 E(t&B 11A 7> t$ C7(cu&&(t List!

O( t$ %sis 7> t$ &%s7(i(< 7> t$ Su=&' C7u&t i( P!"! M%3s

c%s $736i(< i( >%;7u& 7> t$ 3 t$ St%t L

M%6&%s u(6& E(t&B 2 7> List II E(t&is 2 %(6 - 7> List III 7> t$ G7;&('(t

7> I(6i% Act 19+5 t$ =7siti7( u(6& t$ C7(stituti7( c7's c3%&!

19

LatestLaws.com


20/101

LatestLaws.com

Ci;i3 %(6 C&i'i(%3 P&7c6u&s c7(ti(u ;( u(6& t$ C7(stituti7(

7> I(6i% i( List III 7> VII Sc$6u3 ;i! E(t&B 2 %(6 E(t&B 1+! Fu&t$& t$

&7%6 (t&B 7> ?A6'i(ist&%ti7( 7> Justic $ic$ %s i( List II $%s (

s$i>t6 i(t7 t$ List III %s E(t&B 11A B t$ -2(6 A'(6'(t! E(t&B - 7>

List III &3%ts t7 :u&is6icti7( %(6 =7& 7> C7u&ts /@c=t Su=&' C7u&t!

I( ;i 7> t$s E(t&is it is c3%& t$%t 7( t$ ;&B &%s7(i(< 7> t$ Su=&'

C7u&t i( P!"! M%3 P%&3i%'(t $%s %'=3 =7& u(6& E(t&is 2 11A 1+

%(6 - 7> List III t7 3 ;@%ti7us 3iti I(6i% Act 19+5! T$us t$& is (7

6i>>icu3tB 7( t$ usti7( 7> 3


21/101

LatestLaws.com

C$%=t& IV

Cu&s 7( V@%ti7us Liti&i;737us %==3ic%ti7(s >7& t$ =u&=7s 7> i'=%c$i(< %

:u6u&t$& %==3ic%ti7( it$7ut 3%; 7> t$

C7u&t!

21

LatestLaws.com


22/101

LatestLaws.com

I( t$%t c%s t$ >i&st 7> t$ %cti7(s &su3t6 i( % :u6(6%(ts i( 1,,+! T$ %==%3 %s %%(67(6 %(6 B

7&6& 6%t6 9t$A=&i3 1,,- t$ c7sts 7> &s=7(6(ts & 7&6&6 t7 =%i6

B t$ (@t >&i(6 7> %==33%(ts!

T$&%>t& i( N7;! 1,,5 A=&i3 1,, Ju( %(6 Ju3B 1,,. ;%&i7us

%==3ic%ti7(s & '%6 s7' t7 t$ t&i%3 c7u&t %(6 s7' t7 t$ %==33%t

c7u&t si(< t$ stti(< %si6 7> t$ :u6&s$ c%s %s st%&t6 7( 2.t$Oct! 1,,. t7 %&&st t$ 'i(uts 7>

:u67337i(< 7&6& $ic$ t76%B is (7( %s G&= ;s! L7%' 7&6&*

T$%t t$ s%i6 %==3ic%(ts 7& %(B 7> t$' (7t %3376 t7 '% %(B

>u&t$& %==3ic%ti7(s i( t$s %cti7(s 7& it$& 7> t$' t7 t$is C7u&t 7&

t7 t$ C7u&t 37 it$7ut 3%; 7> t$is C7u&t i(< >i&st 7t%i(6!

A(6 i> (7tic 7> %(B suc$ %==3ic%ti7(s s$%33


23/101

LatestLaws.com

2! I($&(t =7&s* T$ Su=&' C7u&t P&%ctic /Ui( its c7''(t%&B

u(6& O&6& 1, Ru3 19 &>&s t7 i($&(t =7& 7> C7u&ts t7 st%B 7&

6is'iss %cti7(s $ic$ %& >&i;737us 7& ;@%ti7us! It st%ts* /=%&7' t$ &u3 t$ C7u&t $%s %( i($&(t :u&is6icti7( t7 st%B 7&

6is'iss %cti7(s %(6 t7 st&i 7ut =3%6i(&i;737us 7& i( %(B %B %( %us 7> t$ =&7css 7> t$ C7u&t u(6&

$ic$ it c7u36 6%3 it$ %33 t$ c%ss i(c3u66 i( t$is Ru3 /Ric$3 ;s!

M%> >&i;737us 7& ;@%ti7us

=3%6i(> >&i;737us 7& ;@%ti7us =3%6i((c %s t$ c%s

'%B 7&

2+

LatestLaws.com


24/101

LatestLaws.com

/ it is sc%(6%37us >&i;737us 7& ;@%ti7us 7&

/c it '%B =&:u6ic '%&&%ss 7& 63%B t$ >%i& t&i%3 7> t$ %cti7(

7&

/6 it is 7t$&is %( %us 7> t$ =&7css 7> t$ C7u&t %(6

'%B 7&6& t$ %cti7(s t7 st%B6 7& 6is'iss6 7& :u6 succ6i(< i( t$ c3%i'!

T$& is c7(si6&%3 c%s 3% i( U u(6& t$is Ru3 ut s$%33

&>& t7 % > 7> t$' &3;%(t >7& t$ su:ct 7> ?>&i;737us %(6 ;@%ti7us

%cti7(s!

T$ @=&ssi7( ?>&i;737us 7& ;@%ti7us '%(s c%ss $ic$ %&

?7;i7us3B >&i;737us 7& ;@%ti7us /Att! G( 7> Duc$B 7> L%(c%st& ;s! L

N W R3B /1,92+ C$ 2.- /2..! T$ @=&ssi7( i(c3u6s =&7c6i( t$ =&7css* As$'7& ;s! #&itis$ L7c%3 C7&=* /1990/2 A33

ER 9,1 /CA!

2-

LatestLaws.com


25/101

LatestLaws.com

U St%tuts t7 =&;(t ?;@%ti7us 3iti t$ Su=&' C7u&t 7> Ju6ic%tu& /C7(s73i6%ti7(

Act 1925 /15 1 G7! V!C -9!

T$%t $%s (7 ( &=3%c6 B sc -2 7> t$ Su=&' C7u&t Act

19,1! T$ 19,1 Act is %( i'=&7;'(t 7;& t$ 1925 Act i( s;&%3

&s=cts! I( =%&ticu3%& B t$ 19,5 A'(6'(t t$ C7u&t c%( (7 =%ss %

?ci;i3 =&7c6i(&7' %( 7&6& &>usi(< 3%;! #ut t$ C7u&ts $%; s%i6 t$%t t$ 7&6& u(6&

sc! -2 is t$ 3%st 7> t$ ;%&i7us 7t$& 7=ti7(s 7=( t7 t$ C7u&t >7& suc$

%( 7&6& is =%ss6!

Scti7( -2 /%s %'(66 B sc 2- 7> P&7scuti7( 7> O>>(cs Act

19,5 &%6s %s >7337s*

Scti7( -2* I> 7( %( %==3ic%ti7( '%6 B t$ Att7&(B G(&%3 u(6&

t$is scti7( t$ "ii6 t$%t %(B =&s7( $%s $%itu%33B

%(6 =&sist(t3B %(6 it$7ut &%s7(%3


26/101

LatestLaws.com

/ '%6 ;@%ti7us %==3ic%ti7(s i( %(B ci;i3 =&7c6i( t$ 7&6& s$%33 (7t c7(ti(u6 B $i' it$7ut t$

3%; 7> t$ "i7& 3%; u(6& t$is suit7& s$%33

'%6 B $i' i( %(B ci;i3 =&7c6i( t$ "i7&'%ti7( s$%33 3%i6 >7& % :ustic 7> t$ =%c B t$

=&s7( % t$ "i


27/101

LatestLaws.com

/ (7 %==3ic%ti7( >7& 3%; t7 =&>& % i33 7> i(6ict'(t s$%33 '%6

B $i' it$7ut t$ 3%; 7> t$ "ict 7> t$

t7 7t$& 7&6&s!

/2 A( 7&6& u(6& su scti7( /1 '%B =&7;i6 t$%t it s$%33 c%s t7 $%;

>>ct %t t$ (6 7> % s=ci>i6 =&i76 ut s$%33 7t$&is &'%i( i(

>7&c i(6>i(it3B!

/+ L%; >7& i(stituti7( 7& c7(ti(u%(c 7> 7& >7& t$ '%i(< %(

%==3ic%ti7( i( %(B ci;i3 =&7c6i(

%( 7&6& >7& t$ ti' i(< i( >7&c u(6& su scti7( /1 s$%33 (7t

t$ =&7scuti7(

is (7t %( %us 7> t$ c&i'i(%3 =&7css %(6 t$%t t$& %& &%s7(%3

7& t$ i(stituti7( 7> t$ =&7scuti7( B t$ %==3ic%(t!

/- N7 %==%3 s$%33 3i >&7' % 6cisi7( 7> t$ "iusi(< 3%;

&ui&6 B ;i&tu 7> t$is scti7(!

/5 A c7=B 7> %(B 7&6& u(6& su scti7( /1 s$%33 =u3is$6 i( t$

L7(67( G%tt!

W$%t is '%(t B t$ 7&6s ?$%itu%33B %(6 =&sist(t3B*

2.

LatestLaws.com


28/101

LatestLaws.com

L7&6 #i( t$ 7&6s ?$%itu%33B %(6 =&sist(t3B /=%&% 22 i(

sc! -2/1 %s >7337s*

T$ $%33'%& usu%33B is t$%t t$ =3%i(ti>> sus t$ s%' =%&tB

&=%t63B i( &3i%(c 7( ss(ti%33B t$ s%' c%us 7> %cti7( =&$%=s

it$ 'i(7& ;%&i%ti7(s %>t& it $%s ( &u36 u=7( t$&B i'=7si((6%(ts t$ u&6( 7> &;isiti(< c3%i' %>t& c3%i' t$%t t$

c3%i'%(t &3is 7( ss(ti%33B t$ s%' c%us 7> %cti7( =&$%=s it$

'i(7& ;%&i%ti7(s %>t& it $%s ( &u36 u=7( i( %cti7(s % t$B & t7 su6 %t %33 s$%33 :7i(6 i(

t$ s%' %cti7( t$%t t$ c3%i'%(t %ut7'%tic%33B c$%33(


29/101

LatestLaws.com

Eu&7=%( C7''issi7( 7( U Act*

A&t 7> t$ Eu&7=%( C7(;(ti7( t$

Su=&' C7u&t Act 19,1 is i( ;i73%ti7( 7> t$ C7(;(ti7(! I( G736& ;s!

U(it6 i( t$ U(it6 i(7&' 7> :u6ici%3 =&7c6i(


30/101

LatestLaws.com

T$ ;@%ti7us 3iti7& % &;i 7> % s(i7& Ju6

%(B c%s t$ %==3ic%(t is$6 t7 &i(

t$%t suc$ % &;i is (7t suc$ %s t7 6(B t$ ss(c 7> t$ &i

%ccss t7 c7u&t i(66 s7' >7&' 7> & % %ccss t7 c7u&t is

(css%&B i( t$ i(t&sts 7> t$ =&7=& %6'i(ist&%ti7( 7> :ustic %(6

'ust t$&>7& & &i c7u&t s&;ics B % > 3iti


31/101

LatestLaws.com

St&%s7u&< 7& '& %==3ic%ti7(s

%& 3i3B t7 &s=ct!

T$ Ju6i&st &>&&6 t7 E&t ;s! O>>ici%3 Rci;& 2001 EWCA Li; +-0

/2002 /1 WLR +2 /25t$Ju3B 200+ $& t$ C7u&t $36 t$%t sc -2 %s

c7(;(ti7( c7'=3i%(t! T$ 3%&(6 Ju6&&6 t7 t$ 7s&;%ti7(s 7>

L7&6 W773> i( E&t ;s! V(;i3 1999/+ WLR .0 t7 % si'i3%& >>ct! T$

c%ss u(6& t$ St&%su&< :u&is=&u6(c i( G736& ;s! U /A81, 1 E"RR

52-* As$i(&&6 t7 >7& t$ =&i(ci=3 t$%t %

c7u&t 'i


32/101

LatestLaws.com

/i t$%t t$ 3i'it%ti7(s %==3i6 67 (7t &st&ict 7& &6uc t$ %ccss 3>t

t7 t$ i(6i;i6u%3 i( suc$ % %B 7& t7 suc$ %( @t(t t$%t t$ ;&B

ss(c 7> t$ &i&7' i(t&>&i(< it$ t$ C7u&t 7& its st%>> %(6

/;ii 7(3B =%=& =&7c6u& /i!! (7 7&%3 $%&i( %(B Di;isi7( 7> t$ "i


33/101

LatestLaws.com

C7u(t&B C7u&t 3;3 it c7u36 67( B % 6si7& 33 st%3is$6 7( %ut$7&itB t$%t

/i T$is C7u&t 3i %(B C7u&t $%s %( i($&(t :u&is6icti7( t7

=&7tct its =&7css >&7' %us

/ii T$ c%t %us i33 (;& c37s6

/iii N7 3iti % 3iti &i (7 &%s7(%3 su


34/101

LatestLaws.com

T$is usti7( 7> &s$ %cti7(s!

I( #$%': ;s! D%;i6 F7&6stic 2000/1 WLR ,, L7&6 P$i33i=s

&>&&6 t7 t$ St&%s7u&< =&i(ci=3s i( #3&7' t$s &'6is it$7ut % 3

%cti7(s!

L7&6 P$i33i=s s%i6 t$%t $& % 3iti t$ c7u&t B '%i(< %==3ic%ti7(s %(6

i(stituti(< =&7c6i( '&it! I> it %&


35/101

LatestLaws.com

=&'itt6 t7 =&7c6 i( t$ usu%3 %B! Suc$ % =&7c6u& 7> >ici%3 Rci;& 2001 EWCA /ci; +-0* 2002/1 LR +20 /CA t$ c7u&t

$36 t$%t t$ ui;%3(t st%tut7&B =&7c6u& i( sc -2/- 7> t$ 19,1 Act %s

c7(;(ti7( c7'=3i%(t! C7'=%& t$ %==&7;%3 7> t$ Eu&7=%( C7''issi7(

7( "u'%( Ri % 3iti =&'issi7(

Suc$ &st&icti7(s i33 St&%s7u&< c7'=3i%(t L7&6 P$i33i=s $36!

/i E&t S&is 7> c%ss*

+5

LatestLaws.com


36/101

LatestLaws.com

W s$%33 (7 &>& t7 t$ E&t s&is 7> c%ss 3%6i(< t7 t$ %==3ic%(t

i(< %((6 >&7' (t&B i(t7 R7B%3 C7u&ts >7& t$& B%&s! T$ c%ss

6ci66 %t 6i>>&(t st% it$ 7& >i3i(< % ( %cti7(! T$s 7&6&s & u=$36 B t$

C7u&t 7> A==%3 7( +0t$M%&c$ 1999 /s E&t ;s! V(;i3* 1999/+ WLR

.0 /L7&6 W773> Ott7( A367us JJ! F&s$ %==3ic%ti7(s >7& 3%; &

&>us6 B Nu&7& %33 >utu& %cti7(s! /T$ 7&%3

%&


37/101

LatestLaws.com

C7u&t 7s&;6 t$%t t$ =%ti(c it$ $ic$ Nu& %==3ic%ti7(s 7> E3&t %s >%i& %(6 7=()'i(66! T$ C7u&t 7> A==%3

$%&6 %(6 &>us6 3%;!

/i; Kt %(7t$& %==3ic%ti7( >7& 3%; t7 %==%3 %s &:ct6 B t$ C7u&t

7> A==%3 i( E&t ;s! O>>ici%3 Rci;&* /2001 EWCA /Li; +05 /20t$F!

2001!

/; T$ $u'%( &i t$ Su=&' C7u&t Act

19,1 6i6 (7t ;i73%t t$ &i%i& t&i%3 u(6& A&t 7>

t$ "u'%( Rit& %( 7&6& 7> c7(si6&%3 &%&itB %s =%ss6 7( 21 S=! 2001

i( Att7&(B G(&%3 ;s! E&t* 2002/2 A33 ER .,9 B #&77 %(6 "%&&is7(

JJ u(6& i($&(t =7&s &st&%i(i(< E&t >&7' (t&i(< t$ R7B%3 C7u&ts 7>

Justic it$7ut =&'issi7(! It %s 6i&ct6 %s >7337s*

T$ C7u&ts su=&;isi(< &73 @t(66 B7(6 t$ '& &

3iti 3iti c7u&t st%>> %(6 6istu&i(< t$

7&6&3B c7(6uct 7> C7u&t =&7csss i( % c7'=3t3B 7sssi; =u&suit

7> t$i& 7( 3iti7&%&6 B 7( u('&it7&i7us

+.

LatestLaws.com


38/101

LatestLaws.com

%==3ic%ti7( %>t& %(7t$& %(6 i(sisti(< t$%t t$B s$7u36 %>>7&66

=&i7&itB 7;& 7t$& 3iti


39/101

LatestLaws.com

Act 19,1 %(6 %s %3376 %s M&! E&t $%6 st%&t6 ;@%ti7us =&7scuti7(s

t77! T$ C7u&t =%ss6 % C&i'i(%3 P&7c6i( i(6>i(it

6u&%ti7(!

/ii #$%': s&is*

Is'%i3 A6u33%$ #$%': c%ss* T$is %s %(7t$& ;@%ti7us 3iti7& =&'issi7( t7 %==%3 >7& %( @t(si7( 7> ti' it$i(

$ic$ t7 %==%3 % #$%': 3iti&&6 t7! T$ 6is=ut %s it$ & t$ =3%((i(< 6=%&t'(t &>usi(< =&'issi7( t7 %337 $i' t7 us

$is &%& B%&6 >7& c%&)%s$i(7& t$ c7u&ts >i36 it$ c7u&t > @'=ti7(

%s >7337s /=%&% 2+

M&! #$%': is (7t %37( i( '%i(< =&sist(t %==3ic%ti7(s t7 t$is

c7u&t it$ t$ (>it 7> c7u&t > @'=ti7(s! T$ c7u&t $%s (

$%(66 % &=7&t B t$ Ci;i3 A==%3s O>>ic $ic$ i6(ti>is t$

3iti


40/101

LatestLaws.com

%==3ic%ti7(s i( t$ =&i76 si(c 1 J%(u%&B 2000! A33 7> t$' $%;

( u(succss>u3 %33 7> t$s $%; ( it$ (>it 7> >s

@'=ti7(! Litiit 7> > @'=ti7(! Litiu3 1 u(6t&'i(6 %(6 %33

12 it$ (>it 7> > @'=ti7(! Litiu3 1+

u(succss>u3 7( u(6t&'i(6 %33 it$ t$ (>it 7> > @'=ti7(!

Litiu3 2,

u(succss>u3 1, u(6t&'i(6 it$ > @'=ti7( -0 ti's! Liti @'=ti7( 7( %c$ 7cc%si7(!

P%&3i%'(t %3t&6 t$ Accss t7 Justic Act 1999 /$ic$ &3%ts t7 3&( Lt6 ;s! C%'&7(

M%cD7(%36* 2000/1 WLR 1+11 /1+19)20 7> t$ (6 >7& =&s&;i(< t$

&s7u&cs 7> t$ C7u&t (%'3B si336 Ju6>! T$ C7u&t

7s&;6* /=%&% 2

t7 D=utB M%st&s 7> t$ C7u&t $%; t7 s=(6 t7 $7u&s %c$ 6%B

7( R7337s*

-0

LatestLaws.com


41/101

LatestLaws.com

I 7u36 7&6& st%B 7( %33 $is cu&&(t %==3ic%ti7(s t7 t$is C7u&t %(6

%(B %==3ic%ti7(s $ '%B 376utu& it$ t$ c7u&t u(ti3 t$%t

>u&t$& $%&i(< t%s =3%c!

W$i3 6is'issi(< t$ t$& %==3ic%ti7(s >i36 B #$%': >7& 3%; %(6

6i&cti(< %s %7; t$ 3%&(6 Ju6u&t$& &>&&6 t7 t$& Ju67& 6ci6i(< $t$& %(B 7t$&

s7&t 7> i(:u(cti7( s$7u36 issu6 t7 c7(t&73 M&! #$%':s >utu&

%cti;itis!

/ii #$%': ;s! F7&s6ic* 200-/1 WLR ,,/CA /25t$Ju3B 200+

T$is c%s c%' >7& t$& Ju6


42/101

LatestLaws.com

S$i==i(< C7&=(! 1,91 AC 909 T%B37& ;s! L%&(c 2002/+ WLR -0 t$

C7u&t &>&&6 t7 t$ st%t'(t 7> #&77 J i( A# %(6 7t$&s ;s! J7$( WBt$

#&7t$& Lt6! 199./, M6 L!R 5. t7 t$ >>ct t$%t t$ i6(ti>ic%ti7( 7> t$

c3%sss 7> ;@%ti7us 3iti


43/101

LatestLaws.com

A(B %==3ic%ti7( s$7u36 '%6 7( =%=& %(6 i33 6%3t it$ 7(

=%=&!

/6 I> suc$ %( 7&6& %s st%t6 i( c3 /c is (7t >7u(6 >>cti; % Ju6

t$ "i is

c3%i'6 i( % 6is%s$i7( it$ % ;i t7 c7(t(6 t$%t it is (7t

c7;&6 B t$ 7&6& i( c3 /c %7;! T$is c7u36 >7& % =&i76 7>

2 B%&s!

/ I> suc$ %( ?@t(66 ci;i3 &st&%i(t 7&6& 7& % ?>cti; %(6 $ is sti33 '7;i(< %==3ic%ti7(s

$ic$ %& &:ct6 %s 6;7i6 7> '&it t$ "ii6 C7u(tB C7u&t '%B c7(si6& $t$& it is %==&7=&i%t t7

'% %(B susu(t &>us%3s 7> =&'issi7( ?>i(%3! T$&%>t&

%(B susu(t &>us%3 7> =&'issi7( 7( t$ t$

=&7c6i( '&it i33 (7t

%==3ic%3 u(3ss t$ Ju6uss =&'issi7( $i's3> 7& t$ =%ssi(< 7> %(B suc$

7&6&s %s st%t6 %7;!

/


44/101

LatestLaws.com

A>t& 3%Bi(< 67( t$ %7; A==%3 &>&&6

t7 t$ =3% 7> t$ >i; #%&&ist&s! T$ C7u&t $36 t$%t t$ %==3ic%ti7( 7> M&!

#$%': >7& %cti7( %7& %337& t$

#%&&ist&s %(6 M&! #$%':! It %s s$7ci(< t$%t M&! #$%': i(st%6 7>

t&Bi(< t7 sust%i( $is =3% %i; #%&&ist&s t$&%t(6 t7 >i3 c%ss

%7& t$s #%&&ist&s! T$ C7u&t t$us

s%i6 it %s % >it c%s >7& ?%( @t(66 ci;i3 &st&%i(t 7&6&! It u&t$&

%==3ic%ti7( 7& t% st=s i( t$ C7u&t 7> A==%3 "i


45/101

LatestLaws.com

/5 A(Bt$i(< 67( B M&! #$%': %i; #%&&ist&s

c%( i7& M%st& #7'%( u(6&

=%&% /2 7& s =&'issi7( t7 %==%3 %s =& =%&% /+ it$7ut

M%st& #7'%( %(687& P%& J %& (7t %;%i3%3 >7& s7'

&%s7( %(7t$& M%st& %(687& Ju6i36 u(6& sc -2 7> t$ Su=&' C7u&t Act

19,1B t$ Att7&(B G(&%3 %>t& M&! A3@%(6& (t 7( >i3i(< &=%t6

%==3ic%ti7(s 7( t$ s%' su:ct it$7ut (6 ;( %>t& G&= ;s! L7%'

7&6&s & =%ss6! I( =%&% -2 M%u&ic %B M%c%B JJ 7s&;6*

It c7's %s (7)su&=&is %


46/101

LatestLaws.com

ui36i(< %(6 $%s %==%&6 >7& 50 "i Justic!

T$ C7u&t 7> A==%3 t$( =%ss6 %( 7&6& u(6& sc -2 it$7ut

3i'it%ti7( 7> ti'!

/- J7$( P=i( c%s* I( "!M! Att7&(B G(&%3 ;s! J7$( P=i(* 200-

EW"C 12- /A6'( t$ 3%&(6 Ju6t& &>&&i(< t7 t$ i((u'&%3

c%ss >i36 B M&! P=i( $36 t$%t 7(3B 7( s=ci>i6 c%s %&&6 t7 i(

#$%':s c%s %& 7t$&is (7t suit%3 %t t$is st% t$ Eu&7=%( C7(;(ti7(!

V%&i7us st=s $%; t7 t%( i( U %s st%t6 B L7&6 P$i33i=s i( #$%':s

c%s %(6 it is 7(3B %s % 3%st &s7&t t$%t scti7( -2 7&6&s c%( =%ss6!

T$s c%ss %& c&t%i(3B


47/101

LatestLaws.com

C$%=t& V

Cu&s 7( ;@%ti7us 3iti % > St%ts i( USA $ic$ %& i(t(66

t7 =&;(t ;@%ti7us 3iti>&(t St%ts i( USA!

I( USA t$& %& =&7;isi7(s '%6 &ui&i(< su&tB 7& &ui&i(< =&i7&

3%; 7> C7u&t 7& >7& t%i(< %cti7( >7& c7(t'=t 7> C7u&t i> %cti7( is >i36

6is7Bi(< t$ %&3i& 7&6&s &ui&i(< 3%;!

T$ st%tuts %3s7 =&7;i6 >7& st%B =(6i(< t$ >u&(is$i(i%3B =&'itt6 t7 &'%i( =(6i(< %t 3%st t7 B%&s

it$7ut $%;i(< ( &7u/2 A>t& % 3itii(%33B 6t&'i(6 % t$ issus 7> >%ct

7& 3% 6t&'i(6 7& c7(c3u66 B t$ >i(%3 6t&'i(%ti7( %


49/101

LatestLaws.com

Scti7( +91/c 6>i(s ?scu&itB %s %( u(6&t%i(< t7 %ssu& =%B'(t $ic$

'%B &%s7(%3B i(cu&&6 B t$ 7==7sit =%&tB! Scti7( +/6 6>i(s

?=3%i(ti>> %(6 sc +91/ 6>i(s ?6>(6%(t!

Scti7( +91!1 =&'its % 6>(6%(t t7 '7; t$ C7u&t >7& %( 7&6&

&ui&i(< t$ =3%i(ti>> t7 >u&(is$ ?scu&itB 7( t$ > is %

;@%ti7us 3iti>i6%;it

%s '%B '%t&i%3 t7 t$ t$ '7ti7(! N7 6t&'i(%ti7( '%6 Bt$ C7u&t i( 6t&'i(i(< 7& &u3i(< t$ '7ti7( s$%33 7& 6'6 t7 %

6t&'i(%ti7( 7> %(B issu i( t$ 3iti t$ '&its t$&7>!

Scti7( +91!+ st%ts t$%t i> %>t& suc$ $%&i((6%(t t$ C7u&t s$%33 7&6& t$ =3%i(ti>> t7 >u&(is$ >7& t$ (>it 7> t$

'7;i(< 6>(6%(t scu&itB i( suc$ %'7u(t %(6 it$i( suc$ ti' %s t$ C7u&t

s$%33 >i@!

Scti7( +91!- st%ts t$%t i> scu&itB is (7t >u&(is$6 t$ 3iti(6%(t >7& $7s (>it t$ scu&itB

%s 7&6&6!

Scti7( +91! =&7;i6s >7& st%B 7> t$ 3iti73376!

Scti7( +91!./% s%Bs t$%t i( %66iti7( t7 %(B 7t$& &u3i(< =&7;i66 i(

t$is tit3 t$ C7u&t '%B 7( its 7( '7ti7( 7& t$ '7ti7( 7> %(B =%&tB (t&

-9

LatestLaws.com


50/101

LatestLaws.com

% =&)>i3i(< 7&6& $ic$ =&7$iits t$ ;@%ti7us 3iti&7' >i3i(< %(B (

3iti t$ St%t i( =&7=&i% =&s7( it$7ut >i&st 7t%i(i( t$ =&si6i(< Ju6 t$ C7u&t $& t$ 3itii36! Dis76i(c 7> t$ 7&6& B % ;@%ti7us 3iti c7u&t!

Scti7( +91!./ st%ts t$%t t$ =&si6i(< Ju6i36 >7& t$ =u&=7ss 7> $%&%ss'(t 7& 63%B! T$ =&si6i(< Ju6i3 %(B 3iti&7' t$ =&si6i(< Ju6i3s t$ 3iti t$ >i3i(< 7> t$%t (7tic 7t%i(s %( 7&6& >&7' t$

=&si6i(< Ju6i3i( t$ 3iti7& %(B 7&6&!

50

LatestLaws.com


51/101

LatestLaws.com

Scti7( +.1!./ st%ts t$%t t$ c3& 7> t$ C7u&t s$%33 =&7;i6 t$

Ju6ici%3 C7u(ci3 % c7=B 7> %(B =&)>i3i(< 7&6&s issu6 =u&su%(t t7 su

6i;isi7( /%! T$ Ju6ici%3 C7u(ci3 s$%33 '%i(t%i( % &c7&6 7> ;@%ti7us

3itii3i(< 7&6&s %(6 s$%33 %((u%33B 6iss'i(%t %

3ist 7> t$7s =&s7(s t7 t$ c3&s 7> t$ C7u&ts 7> ?t$is St%t!

T@%s

T$ Ci;i3 P&%ctic %(6 R'6is C76 6%3s it$ ?;@%ti7us 3itii(s 6>(6%(t c3%us /2 6>i(s ?3itii(s ?L7c%3 A6'i(ist&%ti; Ju6i(s ?'7;i((6%(t c3%us /5 6>i(s ?=3%i(ti>>!

Scti7( 11!051 &>&s t7 ?M7ti7( >7& 6t&'i(i(< =3%i(ti>> % ;@%ti7us

3iti> is % ;@%ti7us 3iti> t7 >u&(is$ scu&itB!

Scti7( 11!052/% &>&s t7 ?st%B 7> =&7c6i(< 7( >i3i(< 7> '7ti7(! It

st%ts t$%t 7( t$ >i3i(< 7> % '7ti7( u(6& sc 11!051 t$ 3iti7& t$ 10t$6%B %>t& t$ 6%t it

is 6(i6 7&

51

LatestLaws.com


52/101

LatestLaws.com

/2 i> t$ '7ti7( is 7& t$ 10t$6%B %>t& t$ 6%t

t$ '7;i(< 6>(6%(t &ci;s (7tic t$%t t$ =3%i(ti>> $%s

>u&(is$6 t$ &ui&6 scu&itB!

Scti7( 11!052/ st%ts t$%t 7( t$ >i3i(< 7> % '7ti7( u(6& sc

11!051 7( 7& %>t& t$ 6%t t$ t&i%3 st%&ts t$ 3iti7& % =&i76

t$ C7u&t 6t&'i(s!

Scti7( 11!05+ &>&s t7 t$ $%&i(< $& ;i6(c is t%( 7&%33B 7&

B %>>i6%;it! It &%6s %s >7337s*

Scti7( 11!05-* C&it&i7( >7& >i(6i(< =3%i(ti>> % ;@%ti7us 3itii;

3itii(%33B 6t&'i(6 %6;&s3B t7 t$ =3%i(ti>>

/# =&'itt6 t7 &'%i( =(6i(< %t 3%st t7 B%&s

it$7ut $%;i(< ( &7u t$

=3%i(ti>> &=%t63B &)3iti


53/101

LatestLaws.com

/A t$ ;%3i6itB 7> t$ 6t&'i(%ti7( % t$ issus 7> >%ct

7& 3% 6t&'i(6 7& c7(c3u66 B t$ >i(%3 6t&'i(%ti7( %7& >%i3u& t7 >u&(is$ scu&itB!

Scti7( 11!05. &>&s t7 6is'iss%3 7( '&its %(6 s%Bs t$%t i> t$

3iti7& ?=&7$iiti(< >i3i(< 7> ( 3iti7& =u(is$'(t >7& c7(t'=t %3s7! It

&%6s %s >7337s*

Scti7( 11!101 P&>i3i(< 7&6&* c7(t'=t*

/% A c7u&t '%B 7( its 7( '7ti7( 7& t$ '7ti7( 7> %(B =%&tB

(t& %( 7&6& =&7$iiti(< % =&s7( >&7' >i3i(i(6s %>t& (7tic

%(6 $%&i(< %s =&7;i66 B su c$%=t& # t$%t*

/1 t$ =&s7( is % ;@%ti7us 3iti


54/101

LatestLaws.com

=&'issi7( t7 t$ =&s7( u(6& sc 11!102 t7 >i3 t$

3itii36 >7& t$ =u&=7s 7> $%&%ss'(t 7&

63%B!

/T$ 37c%3 A6'i(ist&%ti; Ju6u&(is$i(< 7> scu&itB >7& t$ (>it 7> t$ 6>(6%(t %s =&7;i66

i( su C$%=t& #!

Scti7( 11!10+ &>&s t7 ?Dutis 7> C3&* 'ist%( >i3i(7& 7&6&i(< scu&itB >&7' t$ =3%i(ti>> i( %66iti7( t7 6c3%&i( t$ 3iti scu&itB 7&6&6 is (7t >u&(is$6! T$B %3s7

=&7;i6 >7& 6is'iss%3 7> c%s 7( '&its! I> t$ =3%i(ti>> $7 $%s (

6c3%&6 % ;@%ti7us 3itii3i(< % >&s$ %cti7( 6is7Bs it %(6 >i3s % c%s it$7ut

suc$ =&'issi7( $ c%( =u(is$6 >7& c7(t'=t 7> C7u&t! T$7ui6 %(6 t$ =3%i(ti>> &ui&6 t7 7t%i( =&'issi7( st%Bi(< t$

'%tt&! T$ US st%tuts %3s7 =&7;i6 &c7 %( 7&6& =%ss6 B C7u&t

i( %(7t$& St%t 6c3%&i(< % =&s7( %s % ;@%ti7us 3iti%tu&s 7> t$ 3%s &3%ti(< t7 ;@%ti7us 3iti


56/101

LatestLaws.com

C$%=t& VI

Cu&s 7( V@%ti7us Liti& t7 t$ >>7&ts '%6 i( Aust&%3i% %(6 N

%3%(6 t7 =&;(t ;@%ti7us 3iti


57/101

LatestLaws.com

=&7css 7> t$ C7u&t %(6 t$%t t$& is =&i'% >%ci 7& t$

=&7c6i( %( %==3ic%ti7( $ic$ '%B (css%&B i( % =%&ticu3%& c%s

>7& =&7c6i( % st=

7& t$ '%i(< 7> %( %==3ic%ti7( $ic$ '%B (css%&B i( % =%&ticu3%&

c%s >7& =&7c6i(7& t$ t&iu(%3

/c i( t$ c%s 7> c&i'i(%3 =&7c6i(


58/101

LatestLaws.com

?P&7c6i(i(6 %s i(c3u6i( % C7u&t i(c3u6i(< % C7u&t 7>

su''%&B :u&is6icti7( 7& % t&iu(%3!

T$( t$ 7&6s ?;@%ti7us =&7c6i(i(6 %s '%(i(< t$

>7337i( t$ =&7css 7> % C7u&t 7& % t&iu(%3

/ i(stitut6 t7 $%&%ss 7& %((7B t7 c%us 63%B 7& 6t&i'(t 7& >7&

%(B 7t$& &7(u3 =u&=7s

/c i(stitut6 7& =u&su6 it$7ut &%s7(%3 i(iti7( 67s (7t us t$ 7&6s ?$%itu%33B 7& ?=&sist(t3B 7&

?>&u(t3B 3itii(iti7( %==%&s t7

'uc$ i6& %(6 %==%&s %3s7 t7 c7;& ?>&i;737us c%ss!

Scti7( - &>&s t7 ?Rst&icti7( 7> ;@%ti7us =&7c6i(7337s*

5,

LatestLaws.com


59/101

LatestLaws.com

-/1 I> % C7u&t is s%tis>i6 t$%t

/% % =&s7( $%s i(stitut6 7& c7(6uct6 ;@%ti7us

=&7c6i(7& 7& %>t& t$ c7''(c'(t

7> t$is Act 7&

/ it is 3i3B t$%t t$ =&s7( i33 i(stitut 7& c7(6uct

;@%ti7us =&7c6i( t$ >7337i(< 7&6&s )

/c %( 7&6& st%Bi(< %(B =&7c6i( t$ =&7c6i(&7' i(stituti( t$ C7u&t

/i % =&s7( %


60/101

LatestLaws.com

/% st%Bi(< %(B =&7c6i( t$ =&7c6i(&7' i(stituti(< =&7c6i( t$ =&7c6i( t$ =&7c6i( (7 >7&c 7& >>ct i( 3%!

0

LatestLaws.com


61/101

LatestLaws.com

W $%; s( t$%t i( USA i( s7' St%t st%tuts 7( suc$ situ%ti7(s $& %

;@%ti7us 3itii3s % c%s it$7ut si(< 3%; $ c%( =u(is$6 >7&

c7(t'=t 7> C7u&t! #ut $& c7sts c%( i'=7s6!

Scti7( 6%3s it$ ?3%; t7 i(stitut =&7c6i(7& 3%; t7 i(stitut =&7c6i(>i6%;it i( su==7&t 7> t$

%==3ic%ti7(!

/2T$ C7u&t 7& t&iu(%3 t7 $ic$ t$ %==3ic%ti7( >7& 3%; is

'%6 '%B 6is'iss t$ %==3ic%ti7( ;( i> t$ %==3ic%(t 67s

(7t %==%& %t % $%&i(< 7> t$ %==3ic%ti7(!

1

LatestLaws.com


62/101

LatestLaws.com

/+T$ %>>i6%;it %cc7'=%(Bi(< t$ %==3ic%ti7( >7& 3%; is t7

3ist %33 t$ 7cc%si7(s 7( $ic$ t$ %==3ic%(t $%s '%6 %(

%==3ic%ti7( >7& 3%; u(6& suscti7( /1 %(6 t7 6isc37s %33

>%cts '%t&i%3 t7 t$ %==3ic%ti7( $t$& su==7&ti(< 7&

%6;&s t7 t$ %==3ic%ti7( t$%t %& (7( t7 t$ %==3ic%(t!

/-Nit$& t$ %==3ic%ti7( (7& t$ %>>i6%(t %& t7 s&;6 7(

%(B 7t$& =&s7( u(3ss t$ C7u&t 7& t&iu(%3 7&6&s u(6&

suscti7( / t$%t t$B %& t7 s&;6 7( %(7t$& =&s7(!

/5T$ C7u&t 7& t&iu(%3 is t7 6is'iss t$ %==3ic%ti7( >7& 3%; i>

it c7(si6&s t$%t

/% t$ %>>i6%;it 67s (7t 6isc37s ;&Bt$i(< &ui&6 B

suscti7( /+ t7 6isc37s6

/ t$ =&7c6i(>i6%;it s&;6 7(

/i t$ =&s7( %


63/101

LatestLaws.com

/. L%; is (7t t7 i6 t$%t )

/% t$ =&7c6i( ;i6(c >i6%;it >i36 i( c7((cti7( it$ %( %==3ic%ti7( >7& 3%;

'(ti7(6 i( suscti7( /+!

/10 T$ C7u&t 7& t&iu(%3 '%B 6is=7s 7> t$ %==3ic%ti7( >7&

3%; B

/% 6is'issi(< t$ %==3ic%ti7( 7&

/ 7& t$ situ%ti7(s u(6& $ic$ t$ 7&6&

u(6& sc! -/1 st%Bi(< 7& =&7$iiti(< % =&s7( c7u36 &sci(66 7&

;%&i6! It s%Bs*

Sc! .* O( t$ %==3ic%ti7( 7>

/% % =&s7( i( &s=ct 7> $7' t$& is i( >7&c %( 7&6& u(6&

sc! -/1 )

/i st%Bi(< %(B =&7c6i( t$ =&7c6i(


64/101

LatestLaws.com

/ii =&7$iiti(< t$%t =&s7( >&7' i(stituti(< =&7c6i(

t$ C7u&t 7& t&iu(%3 7&

/ % =&s7( &>&&6 t7 i( sc! -/2

t$ C7u&t 7& % Ju6 t$ C7u&t i( $ic$ t$ 7&6& %s '%6

'%B &sci(6 7& ;%&B t$ 7&6&!

Scti7( , 6%3s it$ t$ usti7( %s t7 $%t 7u36 t$%t

=&7c6u& i> C7u&t8t&iu(%3 i( 7( St%t =%sss %( 7&6& %


65/101

LatestLaws.com

=&7;isi7(s 7> t$is Act /7t$& t$%( sc! . %==3B it$ %33

(css%&B '76i>ic%ti7(s t7 %(6 i( &3%ti7( t7 t$%t =&s7( %s i> %(

7&6& st%Bi(< %(B =&7c6i(&&6 t7 i( t$ 7&6& it$& %s t7 t$ $73 7& =%&t 7> t$

=&7c6i(&&6 t7 i( t$ 7&6& %s t$ c%s '%B

i( % C7u&t 7& t&iu(%3 %s t$ c%s &ui&s u(6& sc! %(6 t$

=&7;isi7(s 7> t$is Act /7t$& t$%( sc! . %==3B it$ %33

(css%&B '76i>ic%ti7(s t7 %(6 i( &3%ti7( t7 t$%t =&s7( %s i> %(

7&6& =&7$iiti(< t$%t =&s7( >&7' i(stituti(< =&7c6i(

/i % =&s7( i( &s=ct 7> $7' % 6c3%&%ti7( $%s (

'%6

/ii % =&s7( i( &s=ct 7> $7' %( 7&6& $%s ( '%6

7&

/iii % =&s7( &>&&6 t7 i( sc! -/2

t$ Su=&' C7u&t '%B i( &3%ti7( t7 t$ i(stituti7( 7>

=&7c6i( t$is St%t

/i; &sci(6 t$ 6c3%&%ti7( 7&

/; &sci(6 7& ;%&B t$ 7&6&

5

LatestLaws.com


66/101

LatestLaws.com

It %==%&s t$%t u(6& sc , 6c3%&%ti7(s 7& 7&6&s 7> t$ "i Aust&%3i% c%( &sci(66 7& '76i>i6 B

t$ St%t Su=&' C7u&t t$7u Wst&( Act 199 Liu7& Lic(s Act c$%(


67/101

LatestLaws.com

Scti7( 2/1 7> t$ Act 6>i(s ?37&c %( 7&6& 7> % 6sc&i=ti7( >i&st s=ci>i6 i(

sc .!

Scti7( 2/1 %3s7 6>i(s ?&7337i(< %==3ic%ti7(s %& (7t t7 t%( %s 37& 3%; '(ti7(6 i( ss , 9!

?Dc3%&%ti7( 7> ;@%ti7us 3iti>ici%3s is

c7;&6 B sc +! Sc +/1 =&7;i6s t$%t i> t$ Su=&' C7u&t 7& % Ju6i6 t$%t % =&s7( is ?>&u(t3B %(6 it$7ut &%s7(%3


68/101

LatestLaws.com

su''7(ss t7 % it(ss %&&%(ts 7& =&7css t7 issu6 t$ Su=&' C7u&t

7& suc$ Ju6 t$ Att7&(B G(&%3 t$ S73icit7&)G(&%3 t$

C&7( S73icit7& 7& t$ R t$ Su=&' C7u&t #&is%( tc!

Scti7( +/+ st%ts t$%t t$ Su=&' C7u&t 7& % Ju6 '%B

'% %( 7&6& u(6& sc +/1 s7 %s t7 c7(t%i( suc$ c7(6iti7(s 7&

u%3i>ic%ti7(s 7& t7 $%; suc$ 3i'it6 %==3ic%ti7( %s %==%& t7 it $i' 7& $&

t7 %==&7=&i%t %(6 '%B u=7( %==3ic%ti7( 7> %( 7>>ici%3 s=ci>i6 i( sc +

/2 7& 7> t$ =&s7( 6c3%&6 t7 % ;@%ti7us 3iti7& t$ ti' i(< su:ct!

Scti7( - 6%3s it$ &;7c%ti7( 7> %( 7&6& '%6 u(6& sc + %(6 sc 5

=&7;i6s >7& &i(st%t'(t 7> % 6c3%&%ti7( '%6 u(6& sc + it$i( % =&i76

7> 5 B%&s >&7' t$ &;7c%ti7( 7&6& 3


69/101

LatestLaws.com

Scti7( , &ui&s t$ =&s7( 6c3%&6 %s % ;@%ti7us 3iti7& i(stituti(< 7& t%i(< %(B 37&c 7& >>ct i( 3%!

Scti7( ,/2 =&7$iits i( suc$ %( ;(t t$ c7(ti(u%(c 7>

=&7c6i(7& >i3i(< %( %==3ic%ti7( >7& 3%; i( %

C7u&t 7& t&iu(%3!

Scti7( 10 =&'its t$ Ju6%ci >ici(t &%s7( %(6 t$&

is (7 %us 7> =&7css! Scu&itB >7& c7sts c7u36 %3s7 7&6&6!

9

LatestLaws.com


70/101

LatestLaws.com

Scti7( 1+ &>&s t7 t$ '76 7> s&;ic 7> 67cu'(t B 7& 7( $%3>

7> t$ ;@%ti7us 3iti t$ Act %& (7t

&ui&6 t7 %cc=t6!

Scti7( 1 6%3s it$ issu 7> (c$ %&&%(ts %(6 sc 1. it$ stti(&&6 t7 %s t$B %& (7t t$%t

i'=7&t%(t!

N %3%(6*

Scti7( ,,A 7> t$ Ju6ic%tu& Act 190, &3%ts t7 Rst&icti7( 7(

i(stituti7( 7> ;@%ti7us %cti7(s %(6 &%6s %s >7337s*

Scti7( ,,A* /1 I> 7( %( %==3ic%ti7( '%6 B t$ Att7&(B)

G(&%3 u(6& t$is scti7( t$ "ii6 t$%t %(B =&s7(

$%s =&sist(t3B %(6 it$7ut %(B &%s7(%3


71/101

LatestLaws.com

ci;i3 =&7c6i(< % t$ "i7& t$ '%i(< 7> t$ 7&6& s$%33 (7t c7(ti(u6 B $i' it$7ut

suc$ 3%;!

/2 L%; '%B %(B %s t$

C7u&t 7& Ju6it %(6 s$%33 (7t t$ =&7css 7>

t$ C7u&t %(6 t$%t t$& is =&i'% >%ci 7& t$ =&7c6i(

/+ N7 %==%3 s$%33 3i >&7' %( 7&6& usi(< 3%;!

W '%B %3s7 &>& t7 sc -.. 7> t$ "i7& &3i> 7> t$ =&7c6i(

T$ "%&%ss'(t Act 199.* /N

.1

LatestLaws.com


72/101

LatestLaws.com

Scti7( +2 7> t$is Act %&i;737us 7& ;@%ti7us 7& %& %us 7>

t$ =&7c6u& 7> t$ C7u&t!

/2I> % C7u&t is s%tis>i6 t$%t % =&s7( $%s =&sist(t3B i(stitut6

;@%ti7us =&7c6i( t$ C7u&t!

/+A C7u&t 'ust (7t '% %( 7&6& u(6& suscti7( /2

=&7$iiti(< % =&s7( >&7' c7''(ci(< =&7c6i( t$ C7u&t t7

6is'iss =&7c6i( t$ =&s(t R=7&t!

.2

LatestLaws.com


73/101

LatestLaws.com

C$%=t& VII

Cu&s 7( V@%ti7us Litiic st%tut7&B =&7;isi7(s i( t$ F6&%3 sBst'

$ic$ 6%3 it$ =&;(ti7( 7> ?;@%ti7us =&7c6i( t$ F6&%3 C7u&ts Act /R!S! 19,5 /F). &%6s %s

>7337s*

Scti7( -0* /1 I> t$ F6&%3 C7u&t 7> A==%3 7& t$ F6&%3

C7u&t is s%tis>i6 7( %==3ic%ti7( t$%t % =&s7( $%s =&sist(t3B

i(stitut6 ;@%ti7us =&7c6i(u&t$& =&7c6i( t$%t C7u&t!

/2 A( %==3ic%ti7( u(6& su scti7( /1 '%B '%6 7(3B it$ t$

c7(s(t 7> t$ Att7&(B G(&%3 7> C%(%6% $7 is (tit36 t7 $%&6

7( t$ %==3ic%ti7( %(6 7( %(B %==3ic%ti7( '%6 u(6& suscti7( /+!

/+ A =&s7( %7&

3%; t7 i(stitut 7& c7(ti(u % =&7c6i(


74/101

LatestLaws.com

i> it is s%tis>i6 t$%t t$ =&7c6i(< is (7t %( %us 7> =&7css %(6 t$%t

t$& %& &%s7(%3 7& t$ =&7c6i(

/5 A 6cisi7( 7> t$ C7u&t u(6& su scti7( /- is >i(%3 %(6 is (7t

su:ct t7 %==%3!

I( %66iti7( i( t$ C76s 7> P&7c6u& t$& %& =&7;isi7(s si'i3%& t7 O&6&

. Ru3 11 7> t$ I(6i%( C76 7> Ci;i3 P&7c6u&! F7& @%'=3 i( #&itis$

C73u'i% Ru3 19/2-/9 7> t$ #&itis$ C73u'i% Ru3s 7> C7u&t =&'it t$

C7u&t t7 st&i 7>> 7& 6i&ct %'(6'(t 7> t$ $73 7& %(B =%&t 7> %(

(67&s'(t =3%6i(7337s*

Ru3 19/2-* At %(B st% % =&7c6i( %( (67&s'(t

=3%6i((c %s t$ c%s

'%B 7&

/ it is u((css%&B sc%(6%37us >&i;737us 7& ;@%ti7us 7&

/c it '%B =&:u6ic '%&&%ss 7& 63%B t$ >%i& t&i%3 7&

$%&i(< 7> t$ =&7c6i( t$ =&7css 7> t$ C7u&t %(6

'%B


75/101

LatestLaws.com

Ru3 21!01* /1 A =%&tB '%B '7; >7& % Ju67& t$ 6t&'i(%ti7( >7& t&i%3 7> % usti7( 7> 3%

&%is6 B % =3%6i(< i( %( %cti7( $& t$ 6t&'i(%ti7(

7> t$ usti7( '%B 6is=7s 7> %33 7& =%&t 7> t$ %cti7(

sust%(ti%33B s$7&t( t$ t&i%3 7& &su3t i( % sust%(ti%3

s%;i(< 7> c7sts 7&

/ t7 st&i 7ut % =3%6i(< 7( t$ (c!

%(6 t$ Ju6


76/101

LatestLaws.com

C$%=t& VIII

Rc7''(6%ti7(s >7& P&;(ti(< V@%ti7us Liti&&6 i( C$%=t& II t7 t$ @isti(< 3%s 7(

=&;(ti7( 7> ;@%ti7us 3iti7&'& St%t 7> M%6&%s %(6 i( t$

St%t 7> M%$%&%s$t&% (%'3B t$ M%6&%s V@%ti7us Liti 19-9 %(6 t$ M%$%&%s$t&% V@%ti7us Liti 19.1! T$ tit3 7> t$ M%6&%s Act 7> 19-9 $%s (

%'(66 ;i6 T%'i3 N%6u A6%=t%ti7( 7> L%s O&6& 199 %(6 (7 (7(

%s V@%ti7us Liti 19-9! I( 7t$&

c$%=t&s $%; &>&&6 t7 t$ st%tut7&B =7siti7( %(6 c%s 3% i( 7t$&

c7u(t&is! I( t$ 1,9t$R=7&t 7( R;isi7( 7> C7u&t F St&uctu& t$ L%

C7''issi7( &c7''(66 /Rc7''(6%ti7( N7!10 >7& (%cti(< % C(t&%3

3& t7 =%&ticu3%& %s=cts 7> t$ ;%&i7us

37&'u3%t 7u& &c7''(6%ti7(s!

/1 #7t$ t$ M%6&%s %(6 M%$%&%s$t&% Acts &>&&6 t7 %7; %==3B t7

i(iti%ti7( 7> ci;i3 %s 33 %s c&i'i(%3 =&7c6i(7& c7(ti(u%ti7( 7> =(6i(< =&7c6i(7& c7(ti(ui(< =(6i(< =&7c6i( t$ ;i t$%t 7(c % =&s7( is 6c3%&6 t7 %

;@%ti7us 3iti


77/101

LatestLaws.com

ci;i3 7& c&i'i(%3 =&7c6i(7& c7(ti(ui(< %(B ci;i3 7& c&i'i(%3

=&7c6i(7& t$ =&s7( %s

6c3%&6 % ;@%ti7us 3iti 19. '%6 B t$ #7'%B

"ii36 7( t$ A==33%t si6 7> t$

#7'%B "i t$ ;i t$%t t$ %==3ic%ti7( i( t$is &i36 i(

t$ "i


78/101

LatestLaws.com

I( t$ St%ts i( USA %(7t$& 't$76 is '=37B6 /s C$%=t& V! I(

C%3i>7&(i% it is &ui&6 t7 =&7; t$%t i( t$ =&c6i(< ?s;( B%& =&i76

t$ =&s7( $%s c7''(c6 =&7scut6 7& '%i(t%i(6 =&7=&i% =&s7(% %t 3%st

>i; 3itii(%33B

6t&'i(6 %6;&s3B t7 t$ =&s7( 7& /ii u(:usti>i%3B =&'itt6 t7 &'%i(

=(6i(< %t 3%st >7& t7 B%&s it$7ut $%;i(< ( &7uI( T@%s t$ =&7;isi7( is si'i3%& ut it$ % >u&t$& c7(6iti7( t$%t suc$

3iti&i;737us 7& 6&%3 3%s 7& &u3s 7> =&7c6u&!

I( Aust&%3i% /s C$%=t& VI t$ "i t$%t t$ =&s7( ?>&u(t3B %(6 it$7ut &%s7(%3


79/101

LatestLaws.com

I( Hu(s3%(6 sc! + 7> t$ V@%ti7us Liti t$%t t$ =&s7( $%6 ?>&u(t3B %(6 it$7ut &%s7(%3 %& %s

t$ Su=&' C7u&t Act 7> 19,1 /U is c7(c&(6 it uss t$ 7&6s

?$%itu%33B %(6 =&sist(t3B %(6 it$7ut &%s7(%3 t$ V@%ti7us P&7c6i( t$ Su=&' C7u&t Act 19,1 %s >7337s*

T$ $%33'%& usu%33B is t$%t t$ =3%i(ti>> sus t$ s%' =%&tB

&=%t63B i( &3i%(c 7( ss(ti%33B t$ s%' c%us 7> %cti7( =&$%=s

it$ 'i(7& ;%&i%ti7(s %>t& it $%s ( &u36 u=7( t$&B i'=7si((6%(ts t$ u&6( 7> &;isiti(< c3%i' %>t& c3%i' t$%t t$

.9

LatestLaws.com


80/101

LatestLaws.com

c3%i'%(t &3is 7( ss(ti%33B t$ s%' c%us 7> %cti7( =&$%=s it$

'i(7& ;%&i%ti7(s %>t& it $%s ( &u36 u=7( i( %cti7(s % t$B & t7 su6 %t %33 s$%33 :7i(6 i(

t$ s%' %cti7( t$%t t$ c3%i'%(t %ut7'%tic%33B c$%33(t& c7(si6&i(< t$ '%tt& i( 6=t$ %& (7t i(c3i(6 t7 %66 t$

7&6 ?=&sist(t3B >7& t$ &%s7(s =&7=7s t7

T$ Act $ic$ %s =%ss6 B t$ M%6&%s P&7;i(ci%3 L&&6 :u&is6icti7( u=7( t$ M%6&%s "i $%itu%3 3itii3i(< ;@%ti7us

%cti7(s %(6 & %( %us 7> t$ =&7css 7> C7u&t

Fu&t$& i( Vi:%B N%&%i( Si( #i$%&* 19,- /+ SCC 1-

6%3i(< it$ sc! 2/6/i; 7> #i$%& C7(t&73 7> C&i's Act 19,1 t$ '%:7&itB

$36 t$%t t$ 7&6 ?$%itu%33B %3s7 '%(s ?=&sist(t3B! T$ C7u&t

7s&;6*

,0

LatestLaws.com


81/101

LatestLaws.com

T$ @=&ssi7( ?$%itu%33B '%(s ?&=%t63B 7& ?=&sist(t3B! It

i'=3is % t$&%6 7> c7(ti(uitB st&i( t$ s%' i(6

&>&&6 t7 i( %c$ 7> t$ s%i6 su)c3%uss 7& %( % ?$%it i(;73;s %(

3'(t 7> =&sist(c %(6 t(6(cB t7 &=%t t$ %cts 7& 7'issi7(s 7>

t$ s%' c3%ss 7& i(6 i> t$ %cts 7& 7'issi7(s i( usti7( %& (7t 7>

t$ s%' i(6 7& ;( i> t$B %& 7> t$ s%' i(6 $( t$B %&

c7''itt6 it$ % 37(< i(t&;%3 7> ti' t( t$' t$B c%((7t

t&%t6 %s $%itu%3 7(s

T$ %7; i(t&=&t%ti7( 7> t$ 7&6 ?$%itu%3 $%s ( >73376 i( %

(u'& 7> c%ss B t$ Su=&' C7u&t t$ 3%tst i(< i( Vi:%B A'% D%s

Di%& ;! #%3%&is$(% W%'%( D%(6* 2000 /- SCC 12 $& $i3

c7(si6&i(< sc! 1+/+ 7> t$ C!P! %(6 #&%& Ltti(< 7> "7uss %(6 R(t

C7(t&73 O&6& 19-, t$ 3%&(6 Ju6&u(t

&=titi7( 7> t$ s%' %cts! T$ 7&6 B ?$%it %(6 ?$%itu%33B

i'=3B >&u(t =&%ctic 7& us!

,1

LatestLaws.com


82/101

LatestLaws.com

"%itu%3 c7(st%(t cust7'%&B %66ict6 t7 % s=ci%3 $%it!

T$ C7u&t t$&%>t& 7s&;6* /=%&% 9

T$&>7& t$ @=&ssi7( ?$%itu%3 7u36 '%( &=%t63B 7&

=&sist(t3B %(6 i'=3is % t$&%6 7> c7(ti(uitB st&i(%u3t&!

T$us >i(6 t$%t t$ 7&6 ?$%itu%33B i(c3u6s % ?=&sist(t

$%;i7u&!

S7 >%& %s t$ 7&6 ?=&sist(t3B is c7(c&(6 R%'%(%t$% IB& i( $is

L% L@ic7( s%Bs*

?P&sist(t3B c7((7ts s7' 6 c7(ti(u%(c 7& &=titi7(! A

=&s7( '%B =&sist i( t$ s%' 6>%u3t 7& =&sist(t3B c7''it % s&is

7> 6>%u3ts* R A&ctic E( t$ ;i t$%t it is (7t

(css%&B t7 us 7t$ t$ 7&6s ?$%itu%33B %(6 =&sist(t3B! T$ 7&6s

$ic$ $%; ( us6 i( t$ M%6&%s %(6 M%$%&%s$t&% Acts (%'3B

?$%itu%33B %(6 it$7ut &%s7(%3 c%us %& su>>ici(t!

/- I( t$ M%$%&%s$t&% Act it %3s7 uss t$ 7&6s $%itu%33B %(6 it$7ut

&%s7(%3 &(t =&s7(! T$

,2

LatestLaws.com


83/101

LatestLaws.com

M%6&%s Act 7> 19-9 67s (7t us t$ 7&6s ?$t$& %i3 t$ %==3ic%ti7( i( t$ "i t$ V@%ti7us P&7c6i(i36 B /% t$

Att7&(B G(&%3 / P&i(ci=%3 R t$ Su=&' C7u&t 7& t$

P&i(ci=%3 R t$ Dist&ict C7u&t 7& /c it$ 3%; 7> C7u&t B %

=&s7( % t$ Ju6ic%tu& Act 190, t$

%==3ic%ti7( $%s t7 >i36 B t$ Att7&(B G(&%3!

,+

LatestLaws.com


84/101

LatestLaws.com

I( US i( C%3i>7&(i% u(6& sc! +91!1 7> t$ C76 7> Ci;i3 P&7c6u&

;( ?t$ 6>(6%(t c%( '7; t$ C7u&t ut t$%t is >7& %( 7&6& &ui&i( is % ;@%ti7us 3iti t$ Ci;i3 P&%ctic %(6 R'6is C76 is 7(

t$ s%' 3i(s %s i( C%3i>7&(i%!

I( C%(%6% u(6& sc! -0/2 7> t$ F6&%3 C7u&ts Act 19,5 t$

%==3ic%ti7( '%B '%6 7(3B it$ t$ c7(s(t 7> t$ Att7&(B G(&%3 7>

C%(%6% $7 is (tit36 t7 $%&6 7( t$ %==3ic%ti7(!

I( t$ 3i t$ %7; =&7;isi7(s t$ usti7( %&iss %s t7 $%t

&c7''(6%ti7(s $%; t7 '%6 t7 (%3 %==3ic%ti7(s t7 >i36 >7&

6c3%&i(< % =&s7( %s % ;@%ti7us 3iti t$ ;i t$%t t$

A6;7c%t G(&%3 7> t$ St%t %(6 i( t$ %s(c 7> %( 7>>ic 7> A6;7c%t

G(&%3 /%s i( D3$i "ii3 %( %==3ic%ti7(! I( %66iti7( %& %3s7 7>

t$ ;i t$%t % =&s7( % t$

Di;isi7( #(c$ 7> t$ "ii3 %( %==3ic%ti7( t7 6c3%& t$

7==7sit =%&tB %s % ;@%ti7us 3iti>ic 7> A6;7c%t G(&%3! T$ C7u&t 'ust %3s7 $%& t$

=&s7( %


85/101

LatestLaws.com

/ N@t usti7( is %s t7 $%t tB= 7> 7&6&s t$ "i


86/101

LatestLaws.com

/ $& i( %(B '%tt& i(stitut6 %(6i(< $i's3>

/c $& i( % =&7c6i(< i(stitut6 7& c7(ti(u6 B suc$ ;@%ti7us

3itit& 7t%i(i(< 3%; >&7' t$ %==&7=&i%t c7u&t t$ s%i6

3itii3 7& t% %==&7=&i%t >u&t$& =&7c6i(& t7 t$ ci&cu'st%(cs u(6& $ic$ 3%; c%(

us6! W >i(6 t$ >7337i(< =&7c6u&s i( ;%&i7us

:u&is6icti7(s!

I( t$ M%6&%s Act 19-9 it is st%t6 i( sc! + t$%t 3%; s$%33 (7t

%(B =&7c6i(< $ic$ '%B >i36 B t$ ;@%ti7us

3iti7& $ic$ t$ 3%; %==3ic%ti7( is >i36 >i(6s %

?=&i'% >%ci 7& suc$ =&7c6i(&s t7 t7 c7(6iti7(s! Sc! 2/2 st%ts

t$%t 3%; s$%33 (7t i6 t$%t t$ =&7c6i( t$ =&7css 7> t$ C7u&t %(6 / t$& is =&i'% >%ci

7& t$ =&7c6i( t$ U Su=&' C7u&t Act 19,1 uss t$ 7&6s ?u(3ss

t$ "ii6 t$%t t$ =&7c6i( t$ C7u&t i( usti7( %(6 t$%t t$& %& &%s7(%3 7& t$

=&7c6i(


87/101

LatestLaws.com

I( USA i( C%3i>7&(i% sc! +91!./ uss t$ 7&6s ?7(3B i> it %==%&s

t$%t t$ 3iti t$ "i Justic is s%tis>i6 t$%t t$ =&7c6i( t$ =&7css 7> t$ C7u&t %(6 t$%t t$& is =&i'% >%ci 7& t$

=&7c6i( t$ Act 7> 2002 st%ts t$%t t$ C7u&t

'ust s%tis>i6 t$%t t$ =&7c6i(7&

%(B &7(u3 =u&=7s 7& it$7ut &%s7(%3 t$ Act 7> 19,1 &>&s t7 =&i'% >%ci >ici(t &%s7( %(6 %3s7 t$%t t$& is (7 %us 7> =&7css 7> C7u&t!

I( N %3%(6 sc! ,,A/2 7> t$ 190, Act s%Bs 3%; is t7

t$ C7u&t is s%tis>i6 t$%t t$ =&7c6i(< is (7t %( %us 7>

=&7css 7> C7u&t %(6 t$& is =&i'% >%ci


88/101

LatestLaws.com

I( C%(%6% i( t$ 19,5 Act sc! -0/- %3s7 &>&s t7 t$ =&7c6i( =&7css 7> C7u&t %(6 t$& i(< &%s7(%3 7& t$ =&7c6i( t$ %7; st%tuts =&>& t$ 7&6s i( t$

M%$%&%s$t&% St%tut 7> 19.1 $ic$ s%Bs t$%t 3%; s$%33 (7t i6 t$%t t$ =&7c6i(< is (7t %( %us 7> =&7css 7>

C7u&t %(6 t$& %& %3s7 &%s7(%3 7& t$ =&7c6i(& t7 t$ 7t$& c7(6iti7( t$%t t$ =&7c6i( =&7css 7> C7u&t!

/, A =&7;isi7( >7& '76i>ic%ti7( 7& &scissi7( 7> %( 7&6& 6c3%&i(< %

=&s7( %s ;@%ti7us 3iti t$ Wst&( Aust&%3i% Act 7> 2002 it is st%t6 t$%t $&

i( &s=ct 7> % ;@%ti7us 3iti&7' >i3i(< >&s$ c%ss @c=t it$ 3%; t$ C7u&t '%B 7( t$ %==3ic%ti7(

7> t$ s%i6 ;@%ti7us 3itiB it i> t$& is c$%( ci&cu'st%(cs u(6& its

i($&(t =7& %(6 i( t$%t c%s it $%s t7 $%& t$ =%&tB %t $7s i(st%(c t$

=&s7( %s 6c3%&6 ;@%ti7us 3iti


89/101

LatestLaws.com

/9 Husti7( %&iss %s t7 t$ c7(su(cs 7> >i3i(< % c%s 7& c7(ti(ui(< %

c%s it$7ut 7t%i(i(< 3%;!

It $%s ( 6%t6 %s t7 $%t %cti7( is t7 t%( % t$ 7&6& it$7ut

7t%i(i(< 3%; %(6 it$7ut 6isc37su& 7> t$ @ist(c 7> %( 7&6& % t$ M%$%&%s$t&% Act 19.1 is %3s7 7( i6(tic%3 t&'s!

T$& 67s (7t %==%& t7 %(B s=ci>ic =&7;isi7( i( t$ U Act 7>

19,1 ut i( USA i( C%3i>7&(i% sc! +91!. 7> t$ C76 7> Ci;i3 P&7c6u&

=&'its t$ C7u&t t7 t% %cti7( >7& c7(t'=t 7> C7u&t! I( T@%s sc! 11!101

7> t$ Ci;i3 P&%ctic %(6 R'6is C76 %3s7 =&'its t$ C7u&t t7 t%

=&7c6i(7& c7(t'=t 7> C7u&t!

I( Wst&( Aust&%3i% sc! 5 7> t$ Act 7> 2002 =&'its i'=7siti7( 7>

c7sts %(6 t$ st&ii(< 7ut 7> t$ =&7c6i(


90/101

LatestLaws.com

W %& 7> t$ ;i t$%t i( suc$ % situ%ti7( %s '(ti7(6 %7; t$

C7u&t i( $ic$ t$ =&7c6i( %( %&3i& 6i&cti7( t7 7t%i( 3%; t$ C7u&t

s$7u36 $%; =7& t7 6is'iss t$ =&7c6i(u&t$& &i %==%3! P%&tis c%( %3%Bs '7; t$

Su=&' C7u&t u(6& A&t! 1+ 7> t$ C7(stituti7( 7> I(6i%!

/11 A3'7st %33 st%tuts =&7;i6 >7& % t$ 7&6& 7> t$

C7u&t 6c3%&i(< % =&s7( %s % ;@%ti7us 3iti


91/101

LatestLaws.com

G%tt (7ti>ic%ti7( it '%B %3s7 =&'issi3 >7& t$ "i its 7&6& i( %(B 7t$& '%((& it 6's >it!

/12 As t7 @t(si7( 7> =&i76 7> 3i'it%ti7( t$ M%6&%s %(6 M%$%&%s$t&%

Acts '% (7 s=ci%3 =&7;isi7(! I> t$ "i&7'

i(iti%ti(< % =&7c6i(7& 3%; >7& t$

%==&7=&i%t C7u&t %s st%t6 %7; t$& '%B c%ss $& t$ suit '%B i(

s7' c%ss t$ I(6i%( Li'it%ti7( Act 19+ =&7;i6s t$%t ?i(

c7'=uti(< t$ =&i76 7> 3i'it%ti7( >7& %(B suit 7& %==3ic%ti7( >7& t$

@cuti7( 7> % 6c& t$ i(stituti7( 7& @cuti7( 7> $ic$ $%s ( st%B6

B i(:u(cti7( 7& 7&6& t$ ti' 7> t$ c7(ti(u%(c 7> t$ i(:u(cti7( 7& 7&6&

t$ 6%B 7( $ic$ it %s issu6 7& '%6 %(6 t$ 6%B 7( $ic$ it %s

it$6&%( s$%33 @c3u66!

Liis u(6& sc! -.0/2 7> t$ C76 7> C&i'i(%3 P&7c6u& 19.+

it is st%t6 t$%t $& t$ i(stituti7( 7> t$ =&7scuti7( i( &s=ct 7> %(

7>>(c $%s ( st%B6 B %( i(:u(cti7( 7& 7&6& t$( i( c7'=uti(< t$

=&i76 7> 3i'it%ti7( t$ =&i76 7> t$ c7(ti(u%(c 7> t$ i(:u(cti7( 7& 7&6&

t$ 6%B 7( $ic$ it %s issu6 7& '%6 %(6 t$ 6%B 7( $ic$ it %s

it$6&%( s$%33 @c3u66!

91

LatestLaws.com


92/101

LatestLaws.com

I( ;i 7> t$ %7; =&7;isi7(s %& 7> t$ ;i t$%t it is (7t

(css%&B t7 '% %(B s=ci%3 =&7;isi7( >7& @'=ti7( 7& @t(si7( 7> ti'

i( t$ =&7=7s6 Act!

/1+ C%ss i( '7& t$%( 7( St%t c%( &%is =&73's! Lt us %ssu' t$%t

t$ "i %(7t$& "i7&

%(tici=%t7&B %i3 7& is %&&st6 %(6 %(ts t7 >i3 %( %==3ic%ti7( >7& $%%s

c7&=us 7& >7& %i3! T7 &ui& % =&s7( t7 s =&i7& 3%; i( suc$ c%ss

7u36 i( 7u& ;i ;i73%ti; 7> %sic &i


93/101

LatestLaws.com

21 7> t$ C7(stituti7( 7> I(6i%! I( 7&6& t7 s t$%t suc$ c%ss %& (7t

c7;&6 B t$ 7&6 ?c&i'i(%3 =&7c6i(i(iti7(

7> ?c&i'i(%3 =&7c6i(>ct t$%t % c&i'i(%3 =&7c6i( % =&7c6i( c7'=3%i(t! Liis i( s7 >%& %s ci;i3

=&7c6i( I(6i% c%us %sic%33B 7u& i(t(ti7( is t7 st7= ;@%ti7us

ci;i3 3iti


94/101

LatestLaws.com

W =3%c 7( &c7&6 t$ ;%3u%3 %ssist%(c &(6&6 B D&! S!

Mu&%3i6$%& P%&t)ti' M'& 7> t$ L% C7''issi7(!

/Justic M! J%


95/101

LatestLaws.com

A((@u& I

T$ V@%ti7us Liti ;@%ti7us =&7c6i( t$ R=u3ic 7> I(6i% %s >7337s*)

1! S$7&t tit3 @t(t %(6 c7''(c'(t*

/1 T$is Act '%B c%336 T$ V@%ti7us Liti I(6i% @c=t t$ St%t 7> J%''u %(6

%s$'i&!

/+ It s$%33 c7' i(t7 >7&c 7( suc$ 6%t %s t$ C(t&%3 G7;&('(t '%B

B (7ti>ic%ti7( i( t$ O>>ici%3 G%tt s=ci>B!

95

LatestLaws.com


96/101

LatestLaws.com

2! Dc3%&%ti7( 7> % =&s7( %s % ;@%ti7us 3iti7& 6c3%&i(< % =&s7( %s %

;@%ti7us 3iti&(t =&s7(s t$ "i


97/101

LatestLaws.com

/- A==3ic%ti7( >i36 u(6& suscti7( /1 s$%33 $%&6 B t$ "i C7u&t (css%&B >7& ;@%ti7us 3iti t$ %==&7=&i%t C7u&t 7& Ju6&&6 t7 i(suscti7( /+!

/2 It s$%33 (7t (css%&B >7& t$ =&s7( 6c3%&6 %s % ;@%ti7us 3iti7337i(< c%ss*

/% $& suc$ =&s7( is i(stituti(< % =&7c6i(< i( t$ %==&7=&i%t

C7u&t 7& >7& t$ %==&7=&i%t Ju67& t$ =u&=7s 7> 7t%i(i(u&t$& =&7c6i(i6 t$%t t$ =&7c6i( t$ =&7css 7> t$ C7u&t %(6 t$%t t$& is =&i'% >%ci % =&7c6i(< si(i3i(< % c7'=3%i(t >7& % C&i'i(%3 C7u&t!

9,

LatestLaws.com


99/101

LatestLaws.com

-! Pu3ic%ti7( %(6 C7''u(ic%ti7( 7> O&6&*

/1 A c7=B 7> ;&B 7&6& '%6 )

u(6& suscti7( /2 7> scti7( 2 6c3%&i(< %(B =&s7( %s % ;@%ti7us

3iti>ici%3 G%tt %(6 '%B %3s7 =u3is$6 i(

suc$ 7t$& '%((& %s t$ "it$ %==&7=&i%t C7u&t t7 6is'iss6 %(6 7t$& c7(su(cs*

/1 A(B =&7c6i( scti7( +$%s ( '%6 it$7ut 7t%i(i(< t$ 3%; &ui&6 t7 7t%i(6

>&7' t$ %==&7=&i%t C7u&t 7& %==&7=&i%t Ju67&s%i6 '%B %3s7

99

LatestLaws.com


100/101

LatestLaws.com

3i%3 >7& =u(is$'(t >7& c7(t'=t 7> t$ "i scti7( +!

! Dc3%&%ti7( %(6 7&6& B '7& t$%( 7( "ii36 u(6& suscti7( /1 t$ "ii6 t$%t %(B =&s7( $%s ( 6c3%&6 %s % ;@%ti7us 3iti scti7( 2 B %(7t$& "i


101/101

LatestLaws.com

.! P7& t7 '% Ru3s*

T$ "i7& t$ =u&=7s 7> i'=3'(ti(< t$

=&7;isi7(s 7> t$is Act!

,! S%;i( t$is Act s$%33 i( %66iti7( t7 %(6 (7t i( 6&7 t$ =&7;isi7(s 7> %(B 7t$& 3% =&7;i6i(< >7& st&ii(< 7ut ;@%ti7us

=3%6i( %us 7> =&7css 7> 3% 7& $ic$ &ui&

c7(s(t s%(cti7( 7& %==&7;%3 i( %(B >7&' 7> %(B 7t$& %ut$7&itB >7&

t$ i(stituti7( 7& c7(ti(u%(c 7> %(B ci;i3 7& c&i'i(%3 =&7c6i(

101

LatestLaws.com

law commission report no. 192- prevention of vexatious litigation, 2005 (2)

Documents