learning about propaganda

162
Learning about Propaganda

Upload: balin

Post on 23-Feb-2016

19 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Learning about Propaganda. Propaganda Story Time. “The Poisonous Mushroom” A Children’s Story by Ernst Heimer. Propaganda Story Time. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Learning about Propaganda

Learning about Propaganda

PropagandaStory Time

ldquoThe Poisonous Mushroomrdquo

A Childrenrsquos Story

byErnst Heimer

PropagandaStory Time A mother and her young boy are gathering mushrooms in the German forest The boy finds some poisonous ones The mother explains that there are good mushrooms and poisonous ones and as they go home says

Look Franz human beings in this world are like the mushrooms in the forest There are good mushrooms and there are good people There are poisonous bad mushrooms and there are bad people And we have to be on our guard against bad people just as we have to be on guard against poisonous mushrooms Do you understand that

PropagandaStory Time Yes mother Franz replies I understand that in dealing with bad people trouble may arise just as when one eats a poisonous mushroom One may even dieldquo

And do you know too who these bad men are these poisonous mushrooms of mankind the mother continued

Franz slaps his chest in pride Of course I know mother They are the Jews Our teacher has often told us about themldquo

The mother praises her boy for his intelligence and goes on to explain the different kinds of poisonous Jews the Jewish pedlar the Jewish cattle-dealer the Kosher butcher the Jewish doctor the baptised Jew and so on

PropagandaStory Time However they disguise themselves or however friendly they try to be affirming a thousand times their good intentions to us one must not believe them Jews they are and Jews they remain For our Volk they are poisonldquo

Like the poisonous mushroom says Franz

Yes my child Just as a single poisonous mushrooms can kill a whole family so a solitary Jew can destroy a whole village a whole city even an entire Volkldquo

Franz has understood

Tell me mother do all non-Jews know that the Jew is as dangerous as a poisonous mushroomMother shakes her head

PropagandaStory Time

Unfortunately not my child There are millions of non-Jews who do not yet know the Jews So we have to enlighten people and warn them against the Jews Our young people too must be warned Our boys and girls must learn to know the Jew They must learn that the Jew is the most dangerous poison-mushroom in existence Just as poisonous mushrooms spring up everywhere so the Jew is found in every country in the world Just as poisonous mushrooms often lead to the most dreadful calamity so the Jew is the cause of misery and distress illness and death

PropagandaStory Time

1 What about this story is similar to other childrenrsquos stories you have read or had read to you as a child

2 What about this story is different from other childrenrsquos stories you have read or had read to you as a child

3 What is your reaction to this story

PropagandaDefinitions

Propaganda (n)mdash

1 information ideas or rumors deliberately spread widely to help or harm a person group movement institution nation etc

2 the deliberate spreading of such information rumors etc

3 the particular doctrines or principles propagated by an organization or movement

Are you familiar with any types of propaganda

What is Propagandabull Propaganda what it meansbull Propaganda is a specific type of message

presentation aimed at serving a particular purposebull It means to propagate (actively spread) a

philosophy or point of view (which may be true but often is not)

bull The most common use of the term (historically) is in political contexts in particular to refer to certain efforts sponsored by governments or political groups

bull In most countries propaganda has negative connotations but this is not universally true

Where do we see propaganda

bull Newspapers and booksbull Magazinesbull Internetbull Clothingbull Billboardsbull Bumper stickersbull TVbull Radiobull Signsbull Productsbull Cartoons (political)

What is propagandabull Propaganda is usually a pejorative

termbull Propaganda is typically a label

assigned to othersrsquo persuasion

bull ldquoPropaganda is the deliberate systematic attempt to shape perceptions manipulate cognitions and direct behavior to achieve a response that furthers the desired intent of the propagandistrdquomdashJowett amp ODonnell 1986 Propaganda and Persuasion

Propaganda Purposebull The aim of propaganda is to influence peoples opinions

actively rather than to merely communicate the facts about something

bull For example propaganda might be used to gather either support or disapproval of a certain position rather than to simply present the position

bull What separates propaganda from normal communication is in the subtle often insidious ways that the message attempts to shape opinion

bull For example propaganda is often presented in a way that attempts to deliberately evoke a strong emotion especially by suggesting non-logical (or non-intuitive)relationships between concepts

Why are they used

bull To manipulate the readers or viewers reason and emotions to persuade you to believe in something or someone buy an item or vote a certain way

Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda

bull The PBS election guide Web site ldquoBy The Peoplerdquo makes the following argument for why political advertisements should be looked at more carefully

bull ldquoThe bottom line then is that its important for citizens to look carefully at political ads Certainly the truth or falsity and regardless of lsquotruthrsquo the deceptiveness of ad content is important to examine Many newspapers and television analysis programs provide the citizen a good opportunity to learn more about the quality of the verbal content of political commercials Although a majority of Americans are not aware of this government closely controls the truth-value of national product advertising on television But because of the principle of free speech a principle protected by the US Constitution there is no control whatsoever on the content of a political commercial Basically a politician can say anything she or he wishes in a political ad The only lsquocontrolrsquo over content in a political ad is media and public response to that contentrdquo

What is a Propaganda Poster

bull A Propaganda Poster is usually created by an existing government or a political party trying to gain control of the government

bull It uses patriotism and nationalism to glorify an idea or plan

bull It is meant to convince the people to support the idea or plan

bull It focuses either on the positives and ignores the negatives or focuses on the negatives and ignores the positives

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 2: Learning about Propaganda

PropagandaStory Time

ldquoThe Poisonous Mushroomrdquo

A Childrenrsquos Story

byErnst Heimer

PropagandaStory Time A mother and her young boy are gathering mushrooms in the German forest The boy finds some poisonous ones The mother explains that there are good mushrooms and poisonous ones and as they go home says

Look Franz human beings in this world are like the mushrooms in the forest There are good mushrooms and there are good people There are poisonous bad mushrooms and there are bad people And we have to be on our guard against bad people just as we have to be on guard against poisonous mushrooms Do you understand that

PropagandaStory Time Yes mother Franz replies I understand that in dealing with bad people trouble may arise just as when one eats a poisonous mushroom One may even dieldquo

And do you know too who these bad men are these poisonous mushrooms of mankind the mother continued

Franz slaps his chest in pride Of course I know mother They are the Jews Our teacher has often told us about themldquo

The mother praises her boy for his intelligence and goes on to explain the different kinds of poisonous Jews the Jewish pedlar the Jewish cattle-dealer the Kosher butcher the Jewish doctor the baptised Jew and so on

PropagandaStory Time However they disguise themselves or however friendly they try to be affirming a thousand times their good intentions to us one must not believe them Jews they are and Jews they remain For our Volk they are poisonldquo

Like the poisonous mushroom says Franz

Yes my child Just as a single poisonous mushrooms can kill a whole family so a solitary Jew can destroy a whole village a whole city even an entire Volkldquo

Franz has understood

Tell me mother do all non-Jews know that the Jew is as dangerous as a poisonous mushroomMother shakes her head

PropagandaStory Time

Unfortunately not my child There are millions of non-Jews who do not yet know the Jews So we have to enlighten people and warn them against the Jews Our young people too must be warned Our boys and girls must learn to know the Jew They must learn that the Jew is the most dangerous poison-mushroom in existence Just as poisonous mushrooms spring up everywhere so the Jew is found in every country in the world Just as poisonous mushrooms often lead to the most dreadful calamity so the Jew is the cause of misery and distress illness and death

PropagandaStory Time

1 What about this story is similar to other childrenrsquos stories you have read or had read to you as a child

2 What about this story is different from other childrenrsquos stories you have read or had read to you as a child

3 What is your reaction to this story

PropagandaDefinitions

Propaganda (n)mdash

1 information ideas or rumors deliberately spread widely to help or harm a person group movement institution nation etc

2 the deliberate spreading of such information rumors etc

3 the particular doctrines or principles propagated by an organization or movement

Are you familiar with any types of propaganda

What is Propagandabull Propaganda what it meansbull Propaganda is a specific type of message

presentation aimed at serving a particular purposebull It means to propagate (actively spread) a

philosophy or point of view (which may be true but often is not)

bull The most common use of the term (historically) is in political contexts in particular to refer to certain efforts sponsored by governments or political groups

bull In most countries propaganda has negative connotations but this is not universally true

Where do we see propaganda

bull Newspapers and booksbull Magazinesbull Internetbull Clothingbull Billboardsbull Bumper stickersbull TVbull Radiobull Signsbull Productsbull Cartoons (political)

What is propagandabull Propaganda is usually a pejorative

termbull Propaganda is typically a label

assigned to othersrsquo persuasion

bull ldquoPropaganda is the deliberate systematic attempt to shape perceptions manipulate cognitions and direct behavior to achieve a response that furthers the desired intent of the propagandistrdquomdashJowett amp ODonnell 1986 Propaganda and Persuasion

Propaganda Purposebull The aim of propaganda is to influence peoples opinions

actively rather than to merely communicate the facts about something

bull For example propaganda might be used to gather either support or disapproval of a certain position rather than to simply present the position

bull What separates propaganda from normal communication is in the subtle often insidious ways that the message attempts to shape opinion

bull For example propaganda is often presented in a way that attempts to deliberately evoke a strong emotion especially by suggesting non-logical (or non-intuitive)relationships between concepts

Why are they used

bull To manipulate the readers or viewers reason and emotions to persuade you to believe in something or someone buy an item or vote a certain way

Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda

bull The PBS election guide Web site ldquoBy The Peoplerdquo makes the following argument for why political advertisements should be looked at more carefully

bull ldquoThe bottom line then is that its important for citizens to look carefully at political ads Certainly the truth or falsity and regardless of lsquotruthrsquo the deceptiveness of ad content is important to examine Many newspapers and television analysis programs provide the citizen a good opportunity to learn more about the quality of the verbal content of political commercials Although a majority of Americans are not aware of this government closely controls the truth-value of national product advertising on television But because of the principle of free speech a principle protected by the US Constitution there is no control whatsoever on the content of a political commercial Basically a politician can say anything she or he wishes in a political ad The only lsquocontrolrsquo over content in a political ad is media and public response to that contentrdquo

What is a Propaganda Poster

bull A Propaganda Poster is usually created by an existing government or a political party trying to gain control of the government

bull It uses patriotism and nationalism to glorify an idea or plan

bull It is meant to convince the people to support the idea or plan

bull It focuses either on the positives and ignores the negatives or focuses on the negatives and ignores the positives

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 3: Learning about Propaganda

PropagandaStory Time A mother and her young boy are gathering mushrooms in the German forest The boy finds some poisonous ones The mother explains that there are good mushrooms and poisonous ones and as they go home says

Look Franz human beings in this world are like the mushrooms in the forest There are good mushrooms and there are good people There are poisonous bad mushrooms and there are bad people And we have to be on our guard against bad people just as we have to be on guard against poisonous mushrooms Do you understand that

PropagandaStory Time Yes mother Franz replies I understand that in dealing with bad people trouble may arise just as when one eats a poisonous mushroom One may even dieldquo

And do you know too who these bad men are these poisonous mushrooms of mankind the mother continued

Franz slaps his chest in pride Of course I know mother They are the Jews Our teacher has often told us about themldquo

The mother praises her boy for his intelligence and goes on to explain the different kinds of poisonous Jews the Jewish pedlar the Jewish cattle-dealer the Kosher butcher the Jewish doctor the baptised Jew and so on

PropagandaStory Time However they disguise themselves or however friendly they try to be affirming a thousand times their good intentions to us one must not believe them Jews they are and Jews they remain For our Volk they are poisonldquo

Like the poisonous mushroom says Franz

Yes my child Just as a single poisonous mushrooms can kill a whole family so a solitary Jew can destroy a whole village a whole city even an entire Volkldquo

Franz has understood

Tell me mother do all non-Jews know that the Jew is as dangerous as a poisonous mushroomMother shakes her head

PropagandaStory Time

Unfortunately not my child There are millions of non-Jews who do not yet know the Jews So we have to enlighten people and warn them against the Jews Our young people too must be warned Our boys and girls must learn to know the Jew They must learn that the Jew is the most dangerous poison-mushroom in existence Just as poisonous mushrooms spring up everywhere so the Jew is found in every country in the world Just as poisonous mushrooms often lead to the most dreadful calamity so the Jew is the cause of misery and distress illness and death

PropagandaStory Time

1 What about this story is similar to other childrenrsquos stories you have read or had read to you as a child

2 What about this story is different from other childrenrsquos stories you have read or had read to you as a child

3 What is your reaction to this story

PropagandaDefinitions

Propaganda (n)mdash

1 information ideas or rumors deliberately spread widely to help or harm a person group movement institution nation etc

2 the deliberate spreading of such information rumors etc

3 the particular doctrines or principles propagated by an organization or movement

Are you familiar with any types of propaganda

What is Propagandabull Propaganda what it meansbull Propaganda is a specific type of message

presentation aimed at serving a particular purposebull It means to propagate (actively spread) a

philosophy or point of view (which may be true but often is not)

bull The most common use of the term (historically) is in political contexts in particular to refer to certain efforts sponsored by governments or political groups

bull In most countries propaganda has negative connotations but this is not universally true

Where do we see propaganda

bull Newspapers and booksbull Magazinesbull Internetbull Clothingbull Billboardsbull Bumper stickersbull TVbull Radiobull Signsbull Productsbull Cartoons (political)

What is propagandabull Propaganda is usually a pejorative

termbull Propaganda is typically a label

assigned to othersrsquo persuasion

bull ldquoPropaganda is the deliberate systematic attempt to shape perceptions manipulate cognitions and direct behavior to achieve a response that furthers the desired intent of the propagandistrdquomdashJowett amp ODonnell 1986 Propaganda and Persuasion

Propaganda Purposebull The aim of propaganda is to influence peoples opinions

actively rather than to merely communicate the facts about something

bull For example propaganda might be used to gather either support or disapproval of a certain position rather than to simply present the position

bull What separates propaganda from normal communication is in the subtle often insidious ways that the message attempts to shape opinion

bull For example propaganda is often presented in a way that attempts to deliberately evoke a strong emotion especially by suggesting non-logical (or non-intuitive)relationships between concepts

Why are they used

bull To manipulate the readers or viewers reason and emotions to persuade you to believe in something or someone buy an item or vote a certain way

Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda

bull The PBS election guide Web site ldquoBy The Peoplerdquo makes the following argument for why political advertisements should be looked at more carefully

bull ldquoThe bottom line then is that its important for citizens to look carefully at political ads Certainly the truth or falsity and regardless of lsquotruthrsquo the deceptiveness of ad content is important to examine Many newspapers and television analysis programs provide the citizen a good opportunity to learn more about the quality of the verbal content of political commercials Although a majority of Americans are not aware of this government closely controls the truth-value of national product advertising on television But because of the principle of free speech a principle protected by the US Constitution there is no control whatsoever on the content of a political commercial Basically a politician can say anything she or he wishes in a political ad The only lsquocontrolrsquo over content in a political ad is media and public response to that contentrdquo

What is a Propaganda Poster

bull A Propaganda Poster is usually created by an existing government or a political party trying to gain control of the government

bull It uses patriotism and nationalism to glorify an idea or plan

bull It is meant to convince the people to support the idea or plan

bull It focuses either on the positives and ignores the negatives or focuses on the negatives and ignores the positives

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 4: Learning about Propaganda

PropagandaStory Time Yes mother Franz replies I understand that in dealing with bad people trouble may arise just as when one eats a poisonous mushroom One may even dieldquo

And do you know too who these bad men are these poisonous mushrooms of mankind the mother continued

Franz slaps his chest in pride Of course I know mother They are the Jews Our teacher has often told us about themldquo

The mother praises her boy for his intelligence and goes on to explain the different kinds of poisonous Jews the Jewish pedlar the Jewish cattle-dealer the Kosher butcher the Jewish doctor the baptised Jew and so on

PropagandaStory Time However they disguise themselves or however friendly they try to be affirming a thousand times their good intentions to us one must not believe them Jews they are and Jews they remain For our Volk they are poisonldquo

Like the poisonous mushroom says Franz

Yes my child Just as a single poisonous mushrooms can kill a whole family so a solitary Jew can destroy a whole village a whole city even an entire Volkldquo

Franz has understood

Tell me mother do all non-Jews know that the Jew is as dangerous as a poisonous mushroomMother shakes her head

PropagandaStory Time

Unfortunately not my child There are millions of non-Jews who do not yet know the Jews So we have to enlighten people and warn them against the Jews Our young people too must be warned Our boys and girls must learn to know the Jew They must learn that the Jew is the most dangerous poison-mushroom in existence Just as poisonous mushrooms spring up everywhere so the Jew is found in every country in the world Just as poisonous mushrooms often lead to the most dreadful calamity so the Jew is the cause of misery and distress illness and death

PropagandaStory Time

1 What about this story is similar to other childrenrsquos stories you have read or had read to you as a child

2 What about this story is different from other childrenrsquos stories you have read or had read to you as a child

3 What is your reaction to this story

PropagandaDefinitions

Propaganda (n)mdash

1 information ideas or rumors deliberately spread widely to help or harm a person group movement institution nation etc

2 the deliberate spreading of such information rumors etc

3 the particular doctrines or principles propagated by an organization or movement

Are you familiar with any types of propaganda

What is Propagandabull Propaganda what it meansbull Propaganda is a specific type of message

presentation aimed at serving a particular purposebull It means to propagate (actively spread) a

philosophy or point of view (which may be true but often is not)

bull The most common use of the term (historically) is in political contexts in particular to refer to certain efforts sponsored by governments or political groups

bull In most countries propaganda has negative connotations but this is not universally true

Where do we see propaganda

bull Newspapers and booksbull Magazinesbull Internetbull Clothingbull Billboardsbull Bumper stickersbull TVbull Radiobull Signsbull Productsbull Cartoons (political)

What is propagandabull Propaganda is usually a pejorative

termbull Propaganda is typically a label

assigned to othersrsquo persuasion

bull ldquoPropaganda is the deliberate systematic attempt to shape perceptions manipulate cognitions and direct behavior to achieve a response that furthers the desired intent of the propagandistrdquomdashJowett amp ODonnell 1986 Propaganda and Persuasion

Propaganda Purposebull The aim of propaganda is to influence peoples opinions

actively rather than to merely communicate the facts about something

bull For example propaganda might be used to gather either support or disapproval of a certain position rather than to simply present the position

bull What separates propaganda from normal communication is in the subtle often insidious ways that the message attempts to shape opinion

bull For example propaganda is often presented in a way that attempts to deliberately evoke a strong emotion especially by suggesting non-logical (or non-intuitive)relationships between concepts

Why are they used

bull To manipulate the readers or viewers reason and emotions to persuade you to believe in something or someone buy an item or vote a certain way

Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda

bull The PBS election guide Web site ldquoBy The Peoplerdquo makes the following argument for why political advertisements should be looked at more carefully

bull ldquoThe bottom line then is that its important for citizens to look carefully at political ads Certainly the truth or falsity and regardless of lsquotruthrsquo the deceptiveness of ad content is important to examine Many newspapers and television analysis programs provide the citizen a good opportunity to learn more about the quality of the verbal content of political commercials Although a majority of Americans are not aware of this government closely controls the truth-value of national product advertising on television But because of the principle of free speech a principle protected by the US Constitution there is no control whatsoever on the content of a political commercial Basically a politician can say anything she or he wishes in a political ad The only lsquocontrolrsquo over content in a political ad is media and public response to that contentrdquo

What is a Propaganda Poster

bull A Propaganda Poster is usually created by an existing government or a political party trying to gain control of the government

bull It uses patriotism and nationalism to glorify an idea or plan

bull It is meant to convince the people to support the idea or plan

bull It focuses either on the positives and ignores the negatives or focuses on the negatives and ignores the positives

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 5: Learning about Propaganda

PropagandaStory Time However they disguise themselves or however friendly they try to be affirming a thousand times their good intentions to us one must not believe them Jews they are and Jews they remain For our Volk they are poisonldquo

Like the poisonous mushroom says Franz

Yes my child Just as a single poisonous mushrooms can kill a whole family so a solitary Jew can destroy a whole village a whole city even an entire Volkldquo

Franz has understood

Tell me mother do all non-Jews know that the Jew is as dangerous as a poisonous mushroomMother shakes her head

PropagandaStory Time

Unfortunately not my child There are millions of non-Jews who do not yet know the Jews So we have to enlighten people and warn them against the Jews Our young people too must be warned Our boys and girls must learn to know the Jew They must learn that the Jew is the most dangerous poison-mushroom in existence Just as poisonous mushrooms spring up everywhere so the Jew is found in every country in the world Just as poisonous mushrooms often lead to the most dreadful calamity so the Jew is the cause of misery and distress illness and death

PropagandaStory Time

1 What about this story is similar to other childrenrsquos stories you have read or had read to you as a child

2 What about this story is different from other childrenrsquos stories you have read or had read to you as a child

3 What is your reaction to this story

PropagandaDefinitions

Propaganda (n)mdash

1 information ideas or rumors deliberately spread widely to help or harm a person group movement institution nation etc

2 the deliberate spreading of such information rumors etc

3 the particular doctrines or principles propagated by an organization or movement

Are you familiar with any types of propaganda

What is Propagandabull Propaganda what it meansbull Propaganda is a specific type of message

presentation aimed at serving a particular purposebull It means to propagate (actively spread) a

philosophy or point of view (which may be true but often is not)

bull The most common use of the term (historically) is in political contexts in particular to refer to certain efforts sponsored by governments or political groups

bull In most countries propaganda has negative connotations but this is not universally true

Where do we see propaganda

bull Newspapers and booksbull Magazinesbull Internetbull Clothingbull Billboardsbull Bumper stickersbull TVbull Radiobull Signsbull Productsbull Cartoons (political)

What is propagandabull Propaganda is usually a pejorative

termbull Propaganda is typically a label

assigned to othersrsquo persuasion

bull ldquoPropaganda is the deliberate systematic attempt to shape perceptions manipulate cognitions and direct behavior to achieve a response that furthers the desired intent of the propagandistrdquomdashJowett amp ODonnell 1986 Propaganda and Persuasion

Propaganda Purposebull The aim of propaganda is to influence peoples opinions

actively rather than to merely communicate the facts about something

bull For example propaganda might be used to gather either support or disapproval of a certain position rather than to simply present the position

bull What separates propaganda from normal communication is in the subtle often insidious ways that the message attempts to shape opinion

bull For example propaganda is often presented in a way that attempts to deliberately evoke a strong emotion especially by suggesting non-logical (or non-intuitive)relationships between concepts

Why are they used

bull To manipulate the readers or viewers reason and emotions to persuade you to believe in something or someone buy an item or vote a certain way

Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda

bull The PBS election guide Web site ldquoBy The Peoplerdquo makes the following argument for why political advertisements should be looked at more carefully

bull ldquoThe bottom line then is that its important for citizens to look carefully at political ads Certainly the truth or falsity and regardless of lsquotruthrsquo the deceptiveness of ad content is important to examine Many newspapers and television analysis programs provide the citizen a good opportunity to learn more about the quality of the verbal content of political commercials Although a majority of Americans are not aware of this government closely controls the truth-value of national product advertising on television But because of the principle of free speech a principle protected by the US Constitution there is no control whatsoever on the content of a political commercial Basically a politician can say anything she or he wishes in a political ad The only lsquocontrolrsquo over content in a political ad is media and public response to that contentrdquo

What is a Propaganda Poster

bull A Propaganda Poster is usually created by an existing government or a political party trying to gain control of the government

bull It uses patriotism and nationalism to glorify an idea or plan

bull It is meant to convince the people to support the idea or plan

bull It focuses either on the positives and ignores the negatives or focuses on the negatives and ignores the positives

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 6: Learning about Propaganda

PropagandaStory Time

Unfortunately not my child There are millions of non-Jews who do not yet know the Jews So we have to enlighten people and warn them against the Jews Our young people too must be warned Our boys and girls must learn to know the Jew They must learn that the Jew is the most dangerous poison-mushroom in existence Just as poisonous mushrooms spring up everywhere so the Jew is found in every country in the world Just as poisonous mushrooms often lead to the most dreadful calamity so the Jew is the cause of misery and distress illness and death

PropagandaStory Time

1 What about this story is similar to other childrenrsquos stories you have read or had read to you as a child

2 What about this story is different from other childrenrsquos stories you have read or had read to you as a child

3 What is your reaction to this story

PropagandaDefinitions

Propaganda (n)mdash

1 information ideas or rumors deliberately spread widely to help or harm a person group movement institution nation etc

2 the deliberate spreading of such information rumors etc

3 the particular doctrines or principles propagated by an organization or movement

Are you familiar with any types of propaganda

What is Propagandabull Propaganda what it meansbull Propaganda is a specific type of message

presentation aimed at serving a particular purposebull It means to propagate (actively spread) a

philosophy or point of view (which may be true but often is not)

bull The most common use of the term (historically) is in political contexts in particular to refer to certain efforts sponsored by governments or political groups

bull In most countries propaganda has negative connotations but this is not universally true

Where do we see propaganda

bull Newspapers and booksbull Magazinesbull Internetbull Clothingbull Billboardsbull Bumper stickersbull TVbull Radiobull Signsbull Productsbull Cartoons (political)

What is propagandabull Propaganda is usually a pejorative

termbull Propaganda is typically a label

assigned to othersrsquo persuasion

bull ldquoPropaganda is the deliberate systematic attempt to shape perceptions manipulate cognitions and direct behavior to achieve a response that furthers the desired intent of the propagandistrdquomdashJowett amp ODonnell 1986 Propaganda and Persuasion

Propaganda Purposebull The aim of propaganda is to influence peoples opinions

actively rather than to merely communicate the facts about something

bull For example propaganda might be used to gather either support or disapproval of a certain position rather than to simply present the position

bull What separates propaganda from normal communication is in the subtle often insidious ways that the message attempts to shape opinion

bull For example propaganda is often presented in a way that attempts to deliberately evoke a strong emotion especially by suggesting non-logical (or non-intuitive)relationships between concepts

Why are they used

bull To manipulate the readers or viewers reason and emotions to persuade you to believe in something or someone buy an item or vote a certain way

Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda

bull The PBS election guide Web site ldquoBy The Peoplerdquo makes the following argument for why political advertisements should be looked at more carefully

bull ldquoThe bottom line then is that its important for citizens to look carefully at political ads Certainly the truth or falsity and regardless of lsquotruthrsquo the deceptiveness of ad content is important to examine Many newspapers and television analysis programs provide the citizen a good opportunity to learn more about the quality of the verbal content of political commercials Although a majority of Americans are not aware of this government closely controls the truth-value of national product advertising on television But because of the principle of free speech a principle protected by the US Constitution there is no control whatsoever on the content of a political commercial Basically a politician can say anything she or he wishes in a political ad The only lsquocontrolrsquo over content in a political ad is media and public response to that contentrdquo

What is a Propaganda Poster

bull A Propaganda Poster is usually created by an existing government or a political party trying to gain control of the government

bull It uses patriotism and nationalism to glorify an idea or plan

bull It is meant to convince the people to support the idea or plan

bull It focuses either on the positives and ignores the negatives or focuses on the negatives and ignores the positives

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 7: Learning about Propaganda

PropagandaStory Time

1 What about this story is similar to other childrenrsquos stories you have read or had read to you as a child

2 What about this story is different from other childrenrsquos stories you have read or had read to you as a child

3 What is your reaction to this story

PropagandaDefinitions

Propaganda (n)mdash

1 information ideas or rumors deliberately spread widely to help or harm a person group movement institution nation etc

2 the deliberate spreading of such information rumors etc

3 the particular doctrines or principles propagated by an organization or movement

Are you familiar with any types of propaganda

What is Propagandabull Propaganda what it meansbull Propaganda is a specific type of message

presentation aimed at serving a particular purposebull It means to propagate (actively spread) a

philosophy or point of view (which may be true but often is not)

bull The most common use of the term (historically) is in political contexts in particular to refer to certain efforts sponsored by governments or political groups

bull In most countries propaganda has negative connotations but this is not universally true

Where do we see propaganda

bull Newspapers and booksbull Magazinesbull Internetbull Clothingbull Billboardsbull Bumper stickersbull TVbull Radiobull Signsbull Productsbull Cartoons (political)

What is propagandabull Propaganda is usually a pejorative

termbull Propaganda is typically a label

assigned to othersrsquo persuasion

bull ldquoPropaganda is the deliberate systematic attempt to shape perceptions manipulate cognitions and direct behavior to achieve a response that furthers the desired intent of the propagandistrdquomdashJowett amp ODonnell 1986 Propaganda and Persuasion

Propaganda Purposebull The aim of propaganda is to influence peoples opinions

actively rather than to merely communicate the facts about something

bull For example propaganda might be used to gather either support or disapproval of a certain position rather than to simply present the position

bull What separates propaganda from normal communication is in the subtle often insidious ways that the message attempts to shape opinion

bull For example propaganda is often presented in a way that attempts to deliberately evoke a strong emotion especially by suggesting non-logical (or non-intuitive)relationships between concepts

Why are they used

bull To manipulate the readers or viewers reason and emotions to persuade you to believe in something or someone buy an item or vote a certain way

Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda

bull The PBS election guide Web site ldquoBy The Peoplerdquo makes the following argument for why political advertisements should be looked at more carefully

bull ldquoThe bottom line then is that its important for citizens to look carefully at political ads Certainly the truth or falsity and regardless of lsquotruthrsquo the deceptiveness of ad content is important to examine Many newspapers and television analysis programs provide the citizen a good opportunity to learn more about the quality of the verbal content of political commercials Although a majority of Americans are not aware of this government closely controls the truth-value of national product advertising on television But because of the principle of free speech a principle protected by the US Constitution there is no control whatsoever on the content of a political commercial Basically a politician can say anything she or he wishes in a political ad The only lsquocontrolrsquo over content in a political ad is media and public response to that contentrdquo

What is a Propaganda Poster

bull A Propaganda Poster is usually created by an existing government or a political party trying to gain control of the government

bull It uses patriotism and nationalism to glorify an idea or plan

bull It is meant to convince the people to support the idea or plan

bull It focuses either on the positives and ignores the negatives or focuses on the negatives and ignores the positives

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 8: Learning about Propaganda

PropagandaDefinitions

Propaganda (n)mdash

1 information ideas or rumors deliberately spread widely to help or harm a person group movement institution nation etc

2 the deliberate spreading of such information rumors etc

3 the particular doctrines or principles propagated by an organization or movement

Are you familiar with any types of propaganda

What is Propagandabull Propaganda what it meansbull Propaganda is a specific type of message

presentation aimed at serving a particular purposebull It means to propagate (actively spread) a

philosophy or point of view (which may be true but often is not)

bull The most common use of the term (historically) is in political contexts in particular to refer to certain efforts sponsored by governments or political groups

bull In most countries propaganda has negative connotations but this is not universally true

Where do we see propaganda

bull Newspapers and booksbull Magazinesbull Internetbull Clothingbull Billboardsbull Bumper stickersbull TVbull Radiobull Signsbull Productsbull Cartoons (political)

What is propagandabull Propaganda is usually a pejorative

termbull Propaganda is typically a label

assigned to othersrsquo persuasion

bull ldquoPropaganda is the deliberate systematic attempt to shape perceptions manipulate cognitions and direct behavior to achieve a response that furthers the desired intent of the propagandistrdquomdashJowett amp ODonnell 1986 Propaganda and Persuasion

Propaganda Purposebull The aim of propaganda is to influence peoples opinions

actively rather than to merely communicate the facts about something

bull For example propaganda might be used to gather either support or disapproval of a certain position rather than to simply present the position

bull What separates propaganda from normal communication is in the subtle often insidious ways that the message attempts to shape opinion

bull For example propaganda is often presented in a way that attempts to deliberately evoke a strong emotion especially by suggesting non-logical (or non-intuitive)relationships between concepts

Why are they used

bull To manipulate the readers or viewers reason and emotions to persuade you to believe in something or someone buy an item or vote a certain way

Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda

bull The PBS election guide Web site ldquoBy The Peoplerdquo makes the following argument for why political advertisements should be looked at more carefully

bull ldquoThe bottom line then is that its important for citizens to look carefully at political ads Certainly the truth or falsity and regardless of lsquotruthrsquo the deceptiveness of ad content is important to examine Many newspapers and television analysis programs provide the citizen a good opportunity to learn more about the quality of the verbal content of political commercials Although a majority of Americans are not aware of this government closely controls the truth-value of national product advertising on television But because of the principle of free speech a principle protected by the US Constitution there is no control whatsoever on the content of a political commercial Basically a politician can say anything she or he wishes in a political ad The only lsquocontrolrsquo over content in a political ad is media and public response to that contentrdquo

What is a Propaganda Poster

bull A Propaganda Poster is usually created by an existing government or a political party trying to gain control of the government

bull It uses patriotism and nationalism to glorify an idea or plan

bull It is meant to convince the people to support the idea or plan

bull It focuses either on the positives and ignores the negatives or focuses on the negatives and ignores the positives

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 9: Learning about Propaganda

What is Propagandabull Propaganda what it meansbull Propaganda is a specific type of message

presentation aimed at serving a particular purposebull It means to propagate (actively spread) a

philosophy or point of view (which may be true but often is not)

bull The most common use of the term (historically) is in political contexts in particular to refer to certain efforts sponsored by governments or political groups

bull In most countries propaganda has negative connotations but this is not universally true

Where do we see propaganda

bull Newspapers and booksbull Magazinesbull Internetbull Clothingbull Billboardsbull Bumper stickersbull TVbull Radiobull Signsbull Productsbull Cartoons (political)

What is propagandabull Propaganda is usually a pejorative

termbull Propaganda is typically a label

assigned to othersrsquo persuasion

bull ldquoPropaganda is the deliberate systematic attempt to shape perceptions manipulate cognitions and direct behavior to achieve a response that furthers the desired intent of the propagandistrdquomdashJowett amp ODonnell 1986 Propaganda and Persuasion

Propaganda Purposebull The aim of propaganda is to influence peoples opinions

actively rather than to merely communicate the facts about something

bull For example propaganda might be used to gather either support or disapproval of a certain position rather than to simply present the position

bull What separates propaganda from normal communication is in the subtle often insidious ways that the message attempts to shape opinion

bull For example propaganda is often presented in a way that attempts to deliberately evoke a strong emotion especially by suggesting non-logical (or non-intuitive)relationships between concepts

Why are they used

bull To manipulate the readers or viewers reason and emotions to persuade you to believe in something or someone buy an item or vote a certain way

Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda

bull The PBS election guide Web site ldquoBy The Peoplerdquo makes the following argument for why political advertisements should be looked at more carefully

bull ldquoThe bottom line then is that its important for citizens to look carefully at political ads Certainly the truth or falsity and regardless of lsquotruthrsquo the deceptiveness of ad content is important to examine Many newspapers and television analysis programs provide the citizen a good opportunity to learn more about the quality of the verbal content of political commercials Although a majority of Americans are not aware of this government closely controls the truth-value of national product advertising on television But because of the principle of free speech a principle protected by the US Constitution there is no control whatsoever on the content of a political commercial Basically a politician can say anything she or he wishes in a political ad The only lsquocontrolrsquo over content in a political ad is media and public response to that contentrdquo

What is a Propaganda Poster

bull A Propaganda Poster is usually created by an existing government or a political party trying to gain control of the government

bull It uses patriotism and nationalism to glorify an idea or plan

bull It is meant to convince the people to support the idea or plan

bull It focuses either on the positives and ignores the negatives or focuses on the negatives and ignores the positives

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 10: Learning about Propaganda

Where do we see propaganda

bull Newspapers and booksbull Magazinesbull Internetbull Clothingbull Billboardsbull Bumper stickersbull TVbull Radiobull Signsbull Productsbull Cartoons (political)

What is propagandabull Propaganda is usually a pejorative

termbull Propaganda is typically a label

assigned to othersrsquo persuasion

bull ldquoPropaganda is the deliberate systematic attempt to shape perceptions manipulate cognitions and direct behavior to achieve a response that furthers the desired intent of the propagandistrdquomdashJowett amp ODonnell 1986 Propaganda and Persuasion

Propaganda Purposebull The aim of propaganda is to influence peoples opinions

actively rather than to merely communicate the facts about something

bull For example propaganda might be used to gather either support or disapproval of a certain position rather than to simply present the position

bull What separates propaganda from normal communication is in the subtle often insidious ways that the message attempts to shape opinion

bull For example propaganda is often presented in a way that attempts to deliberately evoke a strong emotion especially by suggesting non-logical (or non-intuitive)relationships between concepts

Why are they used

bull To manipulate the readers or viewers reason and emotions to persuade you to believe in something or someone buy an item or vote a certain way

Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda

bull The PBS election guide Web site ldquoBy The Peoplerdquo makes the following argument for why political advertisements should be looked at more carefully

bull ldquoThe bottom line then is that its important for citizens to look carefully at political ads Certainly the truth or falsity and regardless of lsquotruthrsquo the deceptiveness of ad content is important to examine Many newspapers and television analysis programs provide the citizen a good opportunity to learn more about the quality of the verbal content of political commercials Although a majority of Americans are not aware of this government closely controls the truth-value of national product advertising on television But because of the principle of free speech a principle protected by the US Constitution there is no control whatsoever on the content of a political commercial Basically a politician can say anything she or he wishes in a political ad The only lsquocontrolrsquo over content in a political ad is media and public response to that contentrdquo

What is a Propaganda Poster

bull A Propaganda Poster is usually created by an existing government or a political party trying to gain control of the government

bull It uses patriotism and nationalism to glorify an idea or plan

bull It is meant to convince the people to support the idea or plan

bull It focuses either on the positives and ignores the negatives or focuses on the negatives and ignores the positives

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 11: Learning about Propaganda

What is propagandabull Propaganda is usually a pejorative

termbull Propaganda is typically a label

assigned to othersrsquo persuasion

bull ldquoPropaganda is the deliberate systematic attempt to shape perceptions manipulate cognitions and direct behavior to achieve a response that furthers the desired intent of the propagandistrdquomdashJowett amp ODonnell 1986 Propaganda and Persuasion

Propaganda Purposebull The aim of propaganda is to influence peoples opinions

actively rather than to merely communicate the facts about something

bull For example propaganda might be used to gather either support or disapproval of a certain position rather than to simply present the position

bull What separates propaganda from normal communication is in the subtle often insidious ways that the message attempts to shape opinion

bull For example propaganda is often presented in a way that attempts to deliberately evoke a strong emotion especially by suggesting non-logical (or non-intuitive)relationships between concepts

Why are they used

bull To manipulate the readers or viewers reason and emotions to persuade you to believe in something or someone buy an item or vote a certain way

Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda

bull The PBS election guide Web site ldquoBy The Peoplerdquo makes the following argument for why political advertisements should be looked at more carefully

bull ldquoThe bottom line then is that its important for citizens to look carefully at political ads Certainly the truth or falsity and regardless of lsquotruthrsquo the deceptiveness of ad content is important to examine Many newspapers and television analysis programs provide the citizen a good opportunity to learn more about the quality of the verbal content of political commercials Although a majority of Americans are not aware of this government closely controls the truth-value of national product advertising on television But because of the principle of free speech a principle protected by the US Constitution there is no control whatsoever on the content of a political commercial Basically a politician can say anything she or he wishes in a political ad The only lsquocontrolrsquo over content in a political ad is media and public response to that contentrdquo

What is a Propaganda Poster

bull A Propaganda Poster is usually created by an existing government or a political party trying to gain control of the government

bull It uses patriotism and nationalism to glorify an idea or plan

bull It is meant to convince the people to support the idea or plan

bull It focuses either on the positives and ignores the negatives or focuses on the negatives and ignores the positives

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 12: Learning about Propaganda

Propaganda Purposebull The aim of propaganda is to influence peoples opinions

actively rather than to merely communicate the facts about something

bull For example propaganda might be used to gather either support or disapproval of a certain position rather than to simply present the position

bull What separates propaganda from normal communication is in the subtle often insidious ways that the message attempts to shape opinion

bull For example propaganda is often presented in a way that attempts to deliberately evoke a strong emotion especially by suggesting non-logical (or non-intuitive)relationships between concepts

Why are they used

bull To manipulate the readers or viewers reason and emotions to persuade you to believe in something or someone buy an item or vote a certain way

Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda

bull The PBS election guide Web site ldquoBy The Peoplerdquo makes the following argument for why political advertisements should be looked at more carefully

bull ldquoThe bottom line then is that its important for citizens to look carefully at political ads Certainly the truth or falsity and regardless of lsquotruthrsquo the deceptiveness of ad content is important to examine Many newspapers and television analysis programs provide the citizen a good opportunity to learn more about the quality of the verbal content of political commercials Although a majority of Americans are not aware of this government closely controls the truth-value of national product advertising on television But because of the principle of free speech a principle protected by the US Constitution there is no control whatsoever on the content of a political commercial Basically a politician can say anything she or he wishes in a political ad The only lsquocontrolrsquo over content in a political ad is media and public response to that contentrdquo

What is a Propaganda Poster

bull A Propaganda Poster is usually created by an existing government or a political party trying to gain control of the government

bull It uses patriotism and nationalism to glorify an idea or plan

bull It is meant to convince the people to support the idea or plan

bull It focuses either on the positives and ignores the negatives or focuses on the negatives and ignores the positives

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 13: Learning about Propaganda

Why are they used

bull To manipulate the readers or viewers reason and emotions to persuade you to believe in something or someone buy an item or vote a certain way

Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda

bull The PBS election guide Web site ldquoBy The Peoplerdquo makes the following argument for why political advertisements should be looked at more carefully

bull ldquoThe bottom line then is that its important for citizens to look carefully at political ads Certainly the truth or falsity and regardless of lsquotruthrsquo the deceptiveness of ad content is important to examine Many newspapers and television analysis programs provide the citizen a good opportunity to learn more about the quality of the verbal content of political commercials Although a majority of Americans are not aware of this government closely controls the truth-value of national product advertising on television But because of the principle of free speech a principle protected by the US Constitution there is no control whatsoever on the content of a political commercial Basically a politician can say anything she or he wishes in a political ad The only lsquocontrolrsquo over content in a political ad is media and public response to that contentrdquo

What is a Propaganda Poster

bull A Propaganda Poster is usually created by an existing government or a political party trying to gain control of the government

bull It uses patriotism and nationalism to glorify an idea or plan

bull It is meant to convince the people to support the idea or plan

bull It focuses either on the positives and ignores the negatives or focuses on the negatives and ignores the positives

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 14: Learning about Propaganda

Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda

bull The PBS election guide Web site ldquoBy The Peoplerdquo makes the following argument for why political advertisements should be looked at more carefully

bull ldquoThe bottom line then is that its important for citizens to look carefully at political ads Certainly the truth or falsity and regardless of lsquotruthrsquo the deceptiveness of ad content is important to examine Many newspapers and television analysis programs provide the citizen a good opportunity to learn more about the quality of the verbal content of political commercials Although a majority of Americans are not aware of this government closely controls the truth-value of national product advertising on television But because of the principle of free speech a principle protected by the US Constitution there is no control whatsoever on the content of a political commercial Basically a politician can say anything she or he wishes in a political ad The only lsquocontrolrsquo over content in a political ad is media and public response to that contentrdquo

What is a Propaganda Poster

bull A Propaganda Poster is usually created by an existing government or a political party trying to gain control of the government

bull It uses patriotism and nationalism to glorify an idea or plan

bull It is meant to convince the people to support the idea or plan

bull It focuses either on the positives and ignores the negatives or focuses on the negatives and ignores the positives

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 15: Learning about Propaganda

What is a Propaganda Poster

bull A Propaganda Poster is usually created by an existing government or a political party trying to gain control of the government

bull It uses patriotism and nationalism to glorify an idea or plan

bull It is meant to convince the people to support the idea or plan

bull It focuses either on the positives and ignores the negatives or focuses on the negatives and ignores the positives

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 16: Learning about Propaganda

What are Propaganda Techniques

bull methods and approaches used to spread ideas that further a cause ndash political commercial religious or civil

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 17: Learning about Propaganda

Propaganda Includes

bull A goal for the viewerbullA techniquebull Images to capture the viewerbull Words in the form of slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 18: Learning about Propaganda

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull TechniqueAppealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 19: Learning about Propaganda

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 20: Learning about Propaganda

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 21: Learning about Propaganda

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 22: Learning about Propaganda

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 23: Learning about Propaganda

bull Goal for Viewerbull Images Symbolsbull Technique Appealbull Slogan

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 24: Learning about Propaganda

Ten Commandments of Propaganda

1) Divide and Conquera)More small groups are easier to pit against each other

2) Tell the people what they wanta)Pander to the masses

3) The bigger the lie the more people will believe ita)Make statements grandiose and loud

4) ALWAYS appeal to the lowest common denominatora) Itrsquos OK to ldquodumb it downrdquo

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 25: Learning about Propaganda

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

5)Generalize as much as possiblea) Paint in broad strokes

6) Use expert testimoniala) Have someone known or relatable

ldquopitchrdquo it

7) Refer often to the authority of your officea) Remind public of knowledge and

power

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 26: Learning about Propaganda

Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)

8) Stack the cards with informationa)Use as much supportive evidence as possible

9) A confused people are easily leda)More informed means more skeptical

10) Get the plain folks onto the bandwagona)Appeal to the common man amp he will follow

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 27: Learning about Propaganda

Features of Propagandabull There is a hidden motive which is not made obvious in all

propagandabull The methods used are generally insidious (wicked)bull Propaganda are generally costly and carried out at a

national scalebull When presenting the idea there is always a biasbull Religious national or political interests are usually sources

of propagandabull All forms of media and a lot of repetition are used to

propagate the messagebull The intention of propaganda is for the people to accept

one idea and exclude any alternative ideas

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 28: Learning about Propaganda

Guarding Against Propagandabull Always question what you see or hear no matter

where or how you see it or who says itbull Weigh ideas against everything you know and can

find outbull Always look for a hidden motivebull Ask the person why heshe thinks that it is true and

why

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 29: Learning about Propaganda

Adapted from the Propaganda Critic Web site For more detailed definitions and additional examplessee wwwpropagandacriticcomPROPAGANDA ndash the use of a variety of communication techniques that create an emotional appeal to accept a particular belief or opinion to adopt a certain behavior or to perform a particular actionThere is some disagreement about whether all persuasive communication is propagandistic or whether the propaganda label can only be applied to dishonest messagesNAME CALLING ndash links a person or idea to a negative symbol Examples commie fascist yuppieGLITTERING GENERALITIES ndash use of virtue words the opposite of name calling ie links aperson or idea to a positive symbol Examples democracy patriotism family

Propaganda Strategies

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 30: Learning about Propaganda

Sloganbull A catchword or phrase loaded with emotionbull Often sells through repetitionbull Clever and easy to rememberbull Stays with you a long timebull Often a melody you already know

ldquoTrust Sleepyrsquos For the lsquorestrsquoOf your liferdquo

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 31: Learning about Propaganda

Name-Calling The name-calling technique links a person or idea to a

negative symbol The propagandist who uses this technique hopes that the

audience will reject the person or the idea on the basis of the negative symbol instead of looking at the available evidence

The most obvious type of name calling involves bad names For example consider the following

Communist Fascist Criminal LiarTerrorist Bum

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 32: Learning about Propaganda

Name - Callingbull A way of smearing an

opponentbull Intent is to damage

opponentbull It also arouses suspicion of

opponentbull Intention is to create an

uneasy feelingbull Used by politicians and

product companies

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 33: Learning about Propaganda

Name calling

bull Attaching a negative label to a person or a thing ndashUsed to try to avoid supporting their

own opinion with facts ndashRather than explain what they believe

in they prefer to try to tear their opponent down

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 34: Learning about Propaganda

Name-Callingbull This technique links a person or idea to a

negative imagebull It is hoped that association with this negative

symbol will cause the viewer to reject it outright bull A derivative of this technique involves carefully

selecting descriptive words bull Compare the connotations word determined

and aggressive bull This is the opposite of glittering generalities

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 35: Learning about Propaganda

Name-callingbullA negative word or feeling is attached to an idea product or person bull If that word or feeling goes along with that person or idea the implication is that we shouldnrsquot be interested in it

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 36: Learning about Propaganda

More Name CallingA more subtle form of name-calling involves words or phrases that are selected because they possess a negative emotional charge

Those who oppose budget cuts may characterize fiscally conservative politicians as stingy

Supporters might prefer to describe them as thrifty Both words refer to the same behavior but they have very different connotations

Other examples of negatively charged words include social engineering radical cowardly

counter-culture

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 37: Learning about Propaganda

For exampleDo we want a mayor who will leave us in debt

Spending grew 100

under Mayor Moneybags

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 38: Learning about Propaganda

Propaganda Techniques2 Name Calling (negative names or adjectives)

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 39: Learning about Propaganda

Name-calling

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 40: Learning about Propaganda

Name-calling

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 41: Learning about Propaganda

Name-Calling

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 42: Learning about Propaganda

Name-Calling

The Jew The inciter of war the prolonger of war

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 43: Learning about Propaganda

Glittering GeneralitiesThe Glittering Generality is in short Name Calling in reverse

While Name Calling seeks to make us form a judgment to reject and condemn without examining the evidence the Glittering Generality device seeks to make us approve and accept without examining the evidence

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 44: Learning about Propaganda

More Glittering GeneralitiesWe believe in fight for live by virtue words about which we have deep-set ideas

Such words include civilization Christianity good proper right democracy patriotism motherhood fatherhood science medicine health and love For our purposes in propaganda analysis we call these virtue words Glittering Generalities in order to focus attention upon this dangerous characteristic that they have

They mean different things to different people they can be used in different ways

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 45: Learning about Propaganda

Glittering Generalities

bull uses important-sounding glad words ndash little or no real meaning

bull used in general statements that cannot be proved or disproved ndash Words like good honest fair and best are

examples of glad words

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 46: Learning about Propaganda

Glittering Generalitiesbull Use of words and images that generally carry a

favorable meaning to everyone including liberty democracy freedom and civilization

bull It hopes to associate a person idea or group with a positive feeling but no direct evidence

bull The largest problem with this technique is that all of these words mean different things to different people

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 47: Learning about Propaganda

Glittering Generalities in Text

bull STATEMENT ldquoWe are at a crossroads for human destiny We must chose a true leader for our cityrdquo

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience emotionally connected to the subject through use of words such as ldquodestinyrdquo and ldquoleaderrdquo

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The candidate may or may not be a good leader The text provides no evidence to suggest actual positive qualities

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 48: Learning about Propaganda

Glittering Generalities in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoChange We Can Believe Inrdquobull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by the

promise of ldquochangerdquo The idea is catchy and attractive but without substance or evidence

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 49: Learning about Propaganda

Glittering GeneralitybullA commonly admired virtue is used to inspire positive feelings for a person idea or productbullWords like truth democracy beauty timeless are examples of those general terms

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 50: Learning about Propaganda

A Little More for Glittering Generalities

When someone talks to us about democracy we immediately think of our own definite ideas about democracy the ideas we learned at home at school and in church

Our first and natural reaction is to assume that the speaker is using the word in our sense that he believes as we do on this important subject

This lowers our sales resistance and makes us far less suspicious than we ought to be when the speaker begins telling us the things the United States must do to preserve democracy

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 51: Learning about Propaganda

Glittering Generalitiesbull Glittering generalities are

words that are patriotic attractive or catchy but donrsquot really say anything honor glory love of country and freedom

bull When examined closely these words have little meaning and little relationship to what they advertise

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 52: Learning about Propaganda

For example

If you want to be brighter yoursquoll support Bill Brite

Look on the bright side

Vote for Bill Brite

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 53: Learning about Propaganda

Propaganda Techniques

3 Glittering Generality (Good adjectives names)

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 54: Learning about Propaganda

Glittering Generalities

Open the door to freedom Put a strong man at the helm Out of the swamp Forward with the powers of renewalrdquo

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 55: Learning about Propaganda

Glittering Generalities

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 56: Learning about Propaganda

The next two are ways of making false connectionsTRANSFER ndash a device by which the propagandist links the authority or prestige of something wellrespectedand revered such as church or nation to something he would have us accept Example apolitical activist closes her speech with a prayerTESTIMONIAL ndash a public figure or a celebrity promotes or endorses a product a policy or a politicalcandidate Examples an athlete appears on the Wheaties box an actor speaks at a political rally

Propaganda Strategies

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 57: Learning about Propaganda

TransferPositive feelingsdesires are connected to a productuser

Transfers positive feelings we have of something we know to something we donrsquot

bull Sex Appealbull Love Popularitybull Famebull Wealthbull Power

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 58: Learning about Propaganda

Transferbull TRANSFER is an attempt to

make the audience view a certain item in the same way as it views another item to link the two in the audiencersquos mind

bull Political logos do this frequently they link patriotic images (like flags) together with a candidate

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 59: Learning about Propaganda

Transfer

bull Attempt is made to transfer the prestige of a positive symbol to a person or an idea ndashFor example using the American flag

as a backdrop for a political event makes the implication that the event is patriotic in the best interest of the US

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 60: Learning about Propaganda

Transferbull Propagandists transfer the fame prestige or

reliability of something or someone to an issue that may or may not be related

bull Any politician who publicly says a prayer is transferring religion to their image

bull Use of a flag or patriotic leader is also commonly utilized

bull The Nazis justified treatment of the Jews by ldquoprovingrdquo their inferiority through their own science

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 61: Learning about Propaganda

Transfer in TextSTATEMENT ldquoAll across the rich green fields the

towering purple mountains Americans are discovering Smell-Free Deodorantrdquo

EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience to consume a certain product because a positive image is associated with the product

WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by its connection to a positive image

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 62: Learning about Propaganda

Transfer in Mediabull STATEMENT Santa

says ldquoCoke Timerdquobull PROPAGANDA The

audience is meant to transfer its positive feelings about Santa into positive feelings about consuming Coke though the two are in no way related

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 63: Learning about Propaganda

Transfer of EmotionsIn the Transfer device symbols are constantly used

The cross represents the Christian Church The flag represents the nation Cartoons like Uncle Sam represent a

consensus of public opinion Those symbols stir emotions At their very sight with the speed of light is aroused the whole

complex of feelings we have with respect to church or nation A cartoonist by having Uncle Sam disapprove a budget for

unemployment relief would have us feel that the whole United States disapproves relief costs

By drawing an Uncle Sam who approves the same budget the cartoonist would have us feel that the American people approve it

Thus the Transfer device is used both for and against causes and ideas

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 64: Learning about Propaganda

TransferbullSymbols quotes or images of famous people are used to convey a messagebullThe message may not necessarily be associated with them

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 65: Learning about Propaganda

Transfer

bull Projecting good or bad qualities from one person or group onto another

bull The positive or negative association will ldquorub offrdquo on the other person or groupndash Politicians posing next to the

flag with veterans or troopsndash An ad for a dietary supplement

features a researcher in a white lab coat with a clip board to make the product appear more scientific

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 66: Learning about Propaganda

For example

Joe uses symbols of America to tie his restaurant to American values for Independence Day

Celebrate the American Way this 4th of July-

Eat at Joersquos

Joersquos Barbeque

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 67: Learning about Propaganda

Transfer

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 68: Learning about Propaganda

Transfer

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 69: Learning about Propaganda

Transfer

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 70: Learning about Propaganda

Testimonial

bull When big name personalities are used to endorse a productndash Whenever you see someone famous

endorsing a product ask yourself how much that person knows about the product and what he or she stands to gain by promoting it

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 71: Learning about Propaganda

Testimonialbull A celebrity or expert who endorse a

product candidate or idea bull Think about all of the commercials

with celebrities bull The celebrity may not always be

qualified to speak on the subject

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 72: Learning about Propaganda

Testimonialbull Statement endorsing an ideaproduct by a prominent personbull Product can be inside or outside particular fieldbull Musical artistsbull Sports giantsbull Actorsactresses

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 73: Learning about Propaganda

Testimonial in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoKobe Bryant only drinks Cokerdquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to consume a certain product because a celebrity uses the product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing regarding quality established by the statement that a celebrity consumes it

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 74: Learning about Propaganda

al

Testimonials

bullIf someone famous uses this product believes this idea or supports this candidate so should webullA famous person endorses an idea a product a candidate

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 75: Learning about Propaganda

For example

If we drink milk we will all be as famous as Milly the model

Milly the Model asks ldquoGot Milkrdquo

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 76: Learning about Propaganda

Testimonial in Media

STATEMENT ldquoI choose milkrdquo

PROPAGANDA Taylor Swiftrsquos choice to drink milk is meant to make the audience members believe milk will help them be beautiful and glamorous as well

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 77: Learning about Propaganda

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 78: Learning about Propaganda

Testimonial

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 79: Learning about Propaganda

Testimonial

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 80: Learning about Propaganda

Testimonial

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 81: Learning about Propaganda

Appeal to Authority

bull Appeals to authority have important and powerful people supporting a candidate or idea

bull Similar to testimonial

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 82: Learning about Propaganda

Appeal to Authority

One People One Reich One Fuumlhrer

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 83: Learning about Propaganda

Bait and Switchbull This technique transfers the readersrsquo attention

from an exciting idea to a less exciting idea bull This technique is in some cases against the

law

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 84: Learning about Propaganda

Bait and Switch in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoImagine having more money than you

could ever spend Imagine being rich famous and attractive Dove soap is the first step

bull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the audience excited (money fame amp beauty) and then to switch to something not remotely exciting (soap)

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA While the product may or may not be high quality there is nothing about soap that will lead to money or fame

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 85: Learning about Propaganda

Bait and Switch in Media

bull IMAGE Lipstick marks pictures of girls phone numbers and deodorant

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to be lured in by images suggesting a manrsquos attractiveness to women attention at the bottom of the add is then switched to deodorant A link is suggested where none actually exists

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 86: Learning about Propaganda

The following three constitute special appealsPLAIN FOLKS ndash attempt to convince the audience that a prominent person and his ideas are ldquoofthe peoplerdquo Examples a prominent politician eats at McDonaldrsquos an actress is photographed shopping forgroceriesBANDWAGON ndash makes the appeal that ldquoeveryone else is doing it and so should yourdquo Examples anad states that ldquoeveryone is rushing down to their Ford dealerrdquoFEAR ndash plays on deep-seated fears warns the audience that disaster will result if they do not followa particular course of action Example an insurance company pamphlet includes pictures of housesdestroyed floods followed up by details about home-ownersrsquo insurance

Propaganda Strategies

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 87: Learning about Propaganda

Bandwagon

bull because everyone else is doing something you should do it too or youll be left out ndash The technique embodies a keeping up with the

Joneses philosophy

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 88: Learning about Propaganda

Bandwagon

bull Hop on the bandwagon or else you donrsquot fit in Everyone is doing it so you should too

bull This technique is contrived peer pressure ndash no one wants to be left out or behind

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 89: Learning about Propaganda

Bandwagonbull persuasive technique that invites you to join the

crowdbull Everybodyrsquos doing itbull Often uses weasel words

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 90: Learning about Propaganda

BandwagonbullEverybody is doing this

bullIf you want to fit in you need to ldquojump on the bandwagonrdquo and do it toobullThe implication is that you must JOIN in to FIT in

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 91: Learning about Propaganda

Bandwagon in Media

bull STATEMENT ldquoMore people are smoking Camels than ever beforerdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The attempt is to make the audience want to join a large number of people

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 92: Learning about Propaganda

For example

If the whole world uses this VISA card you must need one too

Bank of the World Visa Card-You can use it from Tennessee to

Timbuktu-anywhere you travel in whole wide

world

Sign up today at wwwbowvisacom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 93: Learning about Propaganda

Propaganda Techniques4 Bandwagon (everyonersquos doing it)

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 94: Learning about Propaganda

Bandwagon

bull ldquoEverything and everyone for victoryrdquo

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 95: Learning about Propaganda

Bandwagon

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 96: Learning about Propaganda

Bandwagon

bull Everyone listens to the Fuhrer

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 97: Learning about Propaganda

Fear

bull During wartime this technique is used often

bull It informs people that personal danger is imminent if they do or do not do some specific action

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 98: Learning about Propaganda

FearbullOur fears are displayedbullIdeas candidates or products are shown to put our fears to rest

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 99: Learning about Propaganda

FearThis technique can be highly effective when wielded by a fascist demagogue but it is typically used in less dramatic ways Consider the following

bull A television commercial portrays a terrible automobile accident (the fear appeal) and reminds viewers to wear their seat-belts (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A pamphlet from an insurance company includes pictures of houses destroyed by floods (the fear appeal) and follows up with details about home-owners insurance (the fear-reducing behavior)

bull A letter from a pro-gun organization begins by describing a lawless America in which only criminals own guns (the fear appeal) and concludes by asking readers to oppose a ban on automatic weapons (the fear-reducing behavior)

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 100: Learning about Propaganda

For exampleIf you use Safety Ware it will people from stealing your identity-or will it

Guard against Identity theft

Use Safety Ware

wwwsafetywarecom

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 101: Learning about Propaganda

FearThe streets of our country are in turmoil The universities are filled with students rebelling and rioting Communists are seeking to destroy our country Russia is threatening us with her might and the Republic is in danger Yes - danger from within and without We need law and order Without it our nation cannot survive - Adolf Hitler 1932

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 102: Learning about Propaganda

Propaganda TechniquesFear

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 103: Learning about Propaganda

Fear

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 104: Learning about Propaganda

Fear

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 105: Learning about Propaganda

Fear

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 106: Learning about Propaganda

Loaded WORDS The loaded languagetechnique uses wordsthat cause a strongfeeling Once the reader isfeeling strongly he orshe may be more likelyto agree with the writer What are some examplesof loaded words This technique often uses interesting

and eye-catching visuals as well

>

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 107: Learning about Propaganda

Emotional Wordsbull The use of emotional

words is meant to stir the audiencersquos emotions making little or no use of facts

bull Words such as love adore hate care andor support may be used to attach the audiencersquos emotions to a product or idea

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 108: Learning about Propaganda

Emotional Words in Textbull STATEMENT ldquoIf you love your dog yoursquoll buy

him Eukanubardquobull EXPLANATION The attempt here is to get the

audience to attach the emotion of love to a product

bull WHY IT IS PROPAGANDA The true love one may feel for a dog has no actual relationship to the purchase of dog food

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 109: Learning about Propaganda

From a leaflet distributed by the North Korean army encouraging American soldiers to surrender

Emotional Words in Mediabull STATEMENT ldquoDonrsquot let

your loved ones mourn for yourdquo

bull PROPAGANDA The audience is meant to connect its positive emotions for loved ones to the idea of surrendering to the enemy in order to spare its loved ones pain

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 110: Learning about Propaganda

Emotional wordsbullWe associate those words and therefore those positive feelings with the product bullWords that leave us with positive feelings are used to describe a product person or idea

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 111: Learning about Propaganda

Loaded Words

Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla MintGet a cool and inviting brushing experience with Crest Whitening Expressions Refreshing Vanilla Mint

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 112: Learning about Propaganda

Loaded WORDS

This billboard advertisement uses the word ldquoirresistiblerdquo to appeal to our emotions

The visual is also very appealing

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 113: Learning about Propaganda

For exampleWhat feelings are inspired by the words ldquotrue loverdquo If you wear this cologne will someone fall in love with you

True Love

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 114: Learning about Propaganda

The next two are types of logical fallaciesBAD LOGIC ndash an illogical message is not necessarily propagandistic it can be just a logical mistakeit is propaganda if logic is manipulated deliberately to promote a cause Example Senator X wants toregulate the power industry All Communist governments regulate their power industries Senator X is aCommunistUNWARRANTED EXTRAPOLATION ndash making huge predictions about the future on the basisof a few small facts Example If the US approves NAFTA thousands of jobs and factories will move toMexico

Propaganda Strategies

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 115: Learning about Propaganda

What is a Logical Fallacybull Logic correct or reliable

information method or reasoningbull Fallacy ldquoargumentrdquo in which the

premise given for the conclusion does not provide the needed degree of support

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 116: Learning about Propaganda

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull Drawing a conclusion from a series of premises

bull For example Religion is good Wars are fought over religion

bull Therefore religious wars are good

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 117: Learning about Propaganda

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull In this technique two things that may or may not really be similar are portrayed as being similar

bull When examining the comparison you must ask yourself how similar the items are

bull In most false analogies there is simply not enough evidence available to support the comparison

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 118: Learning about Propaganda

Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy

bull This technique suggests that because B follows A A must cause B ndashRemember just because two events

or two sets of data are related does not necessarily mean that one caused the other to happen

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 119: Learning about Propaganda

Logical FallaciesFaulty AnalogybullFactual supporting details

are used though they do not support the conclusion It works like thisbullChristians believe in God bullMuslims believe in GodbullChristians are Muslims

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 120: Learning about Propaganda

More Logical Fallacy

bull Red herring something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter at hand a misleading clue

We admit that this measure is popular But we also urge you to note that there are so many bond issues on this ballot that the whole thing is getting ridiculous

I think there is great merit in making the requirements stricter for the graduate students I recommend that you support it too After all we are in a budget crisis and we do not want our salaries affected

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 121: Learning about Propaganda

Final Logical FallaciesFalse causality stating that even B was caused by

event A just because B happened after AExample Money makes people arrogant Not all people and not always just money

Overgeneralization forming a conclusion with too little evidence

Look for words such as ldquoall every and always Theyrsquore statements that are so general

that they oversimplify reality ignoring important details

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 122: Learning about Propaganda

For example

Does this mean that teachers need medication to keep their cool during the school day

More teachers recommend Calm-me to help them make it through the day

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 123: Learning about Propaganda

Examples of Logical Fallacybull Ad hominem appealing to onersquos prejudices emotions or

special interests rather than onersquos intellect or reason attacking an opponentrsquos character rather than answering his argument

Bill I believe that abortion is morally wrong

Dave Of course you would say that youre a priest

Bill What about the arguments I gave to support my position

Dave Those dont count Like I said youre a priest so you have to say that abortion is wrong Further you are just a lackey to the Pope so I cant believe what you say

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 124: Learning about Propaganda

EuphemismsWhen propagandists use glittering generalities and name-calling symbols they are attempting to arouse their audience with vivid emotionally suggestive words

In certain situations however the propagandist attempts to pacify the audience in order to make an unpleasant reality more palatable

This is accomplished by using words that are bland and euphemistic

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 125: Learning about Propaganda

Euphemisms

bull The use of words or statements that deter from the meaning to make it not as bad and more tasteful to the general public

bull The Nazis used the term resettlement to describe the mass murder of the Jews

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 126: Learning about Propaganda

An Example for Euphemism

Since war is particularly unpleasant military discourse is full of euphemisms

In the 1940s America changed the name of the War Department to the Department of Defense

Under the Reagan Administration the MX-Missile was renamed The Peacekeeperldquo

During war-time civilian casualties are referred to as collateral damage and the word liquidation is used as a synonym for murder

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 127: Learning about Propaganda

Euphemisms

bull Collateral Damagebull Final Solutionbull Shell Shockbull Disassembly

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 128: Learning about Propaganda

Snob Appealbull Aims to flatterbull Makes assumption insinuation that this productidea is

better than othershellipbull Thus those that use it are toobull ldquoAvant Garderdquo ahead of the times

The Ultimate driving machine

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 129: Learning about Propaganda

Plain Folksbull Opposite of Snob Appealbull Identifies productidea with a locality or countrybull Practical product for ordinary people

Like a good neighborhellip

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 130: Learning about Propaganda

Plain FolksBy using the plain-folks technique speakers attempt to convince their audience that they and their ideas are of the people

Examples Bill Clinton ate at McDonalds and confessed a fondness for

trashy spy novels George Bush Sr hated broccoli and loved to fish Ronald Reagan was often photographed chopping wood Jimmy Carter presented himself as a humble peanut farmer

from Georgia Sarah Palin likened herself to a ldquohockey momrdquo in order to

connect with average moms across the country

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 131: Learning about Propaganda

Plain Folks

bull uses a folksy approach to convince us to support someone or something ndash These ads depict people with ordinary looks doing

ordinary activities

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 132: Learning about Propaganda

Plain Folks

bull This technique has a person or cause being associated with regular people

bull Candidates who are just like you ndash they put their pants on one leg at a time too

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 133: Learning about Propaganda

Plain-folks appeal

This idea product or person is associated with normal everyday people and activities

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 134: Learning about Propaganda

plain folks appeal

bull Based on the ldquocommon manrdquo ldquoperson on the streetrdquo or the ldquolittle guyrdquo

bull A politician calls himself a ldquopopulistrdquo or ldquoman of the peoplerdquo

ndash ldquoIn this time of change government must take the side of working familiesrdquo (George Bush address at the Republican National Convention Sept 3 2004

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 135: Learning about Propaganda

For Example We want a Jim Smith a mayor who supports the regular American worker

Vote for SmithClipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 136: Learning about Propaganda

Propaganda Techniques

5 Plain Folks Appeal ( ldquoof the peoplerdquo)

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 137: Learning about Propaganda

Plain Folks

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 138: Learning about Propaganda

Plain Folks

We are for Adolf Hitler

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 139: Learning about Propaganda

Plain Folks

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 140: Learning about Propaganda

Other Techniques Doublespeak

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 141: Learning about Propaganda

Other Techniques Big Liebull An outrageous falsehoodbull Captures attention because itrsquos so outrageousbull Somehow staggers audience into believing it

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 142: Learning about Propaganda

Other Techniques Scapegoat

bull A person carrying the blame for othersbull Retreats to prejudice rather than reasonbull Mostly used in the political arenabull Wins audience through association or sympathy

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 143: Learning about Propaganda

Other Techniques

bull Misery - Appeals to pity or sympathy to gain support

bull Fancy Words - Use of elegant or technical sounding words to persuade and camouflage the truth

bull Word Magic - Uses emotional or catchy words to create a positive feeling and makes it easier to remember the product or idea

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 144: Learning about Propaganda

Other Techniques Card Stacking

bull used to slant a message ndash Key words or unfavorable statistics may be

omitted in an ad or commercial leading to a series of half-truths

ndash Keep in mind that an advertiser is under no obligation to give the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 145: Learning about Propaganda

Other Techniques

bull Black and White - Presents an issue as having only two choices If you donrsquot like one choice you must choose the other

bull Simplicity and Repetition - Keep it simple and say it often enough so people will remember it and believe it

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 146: Learning about Propaganda

Black or White

bull used to polarize issues and negates all attempts to find a common groundndash You are either for something or against itndash This technique is also called black-and-white

thinking because only two choices are given there is no middle ground or shades of gray

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 147: Learning about Propaganda

How do we make sure that we are making informed choices

instead of allowing others to sway us in our decision-making

Clipart-Microsoft Office XP 2002

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 148: Learning about Propaganda

We make our own choices when hellipbullwe read and listen to reliable

sourcesbullwe watch for combinations of truths and liesbullwe check for hidden messagesbullwe watch for use of propaganda techniques

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 149: Learning about Propaganda

and most importantly

wwwscottishparliamentuk educationservice

WHEN WE LISTEN TO OUR OWN VOICES

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 150: Learning about Propaganda

Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda

Purpose

bull What is the message that this document communicates What is the documentrsquos purpose

bull Why is it important for this message to be delivered to this audience at this moment in time

bull How does the document communicate its message Think about its use of language color space and symbols

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 151: Learning about Propaganda

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Audience

bull Who is the audience for this document

bull What does the message suggest about the audiencersquos beliefs and values

bull How accurate are these beliefs about the audience

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 152: Learning about Propaganda

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Document Author

bull Who wrote the message

bull What are the writerrsquos motives for creating this message How might the writer personally benefit from the audiencersquos acceptance of this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 153: Learning about Propaganda

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Evidence Support and Outcomes

bull What facts and specific details does the document use Are the facts verifiable and believable

bull What emotions does the document use to communicate its message How is the audience likely to feel when they read this message

bull What ethical or moral values does the document use to communicate its message What relevant values are not supported by this message

bull What will happen if the audience accepts this message

bull What would happen if everyone in the world accepted this message

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 154: Learning about Propaganda

Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster

Overall Impression and Conclusions

bull What is the overall impression of this message Summarize the details that you have gathered in your analysis

bull How would you categorize this postermdashargument persuasion or propaganda Explain your choice

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 155: Learning about Propaganda

Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Administration

1 What are the main colored used in the poster Why2 What symbols if any are used in the poster Why3 If a symbol is used is it clear and easy to interpret memorable

and dramatic Why4 Are the messages in the poster primarily visual verbal or both5 Who do you think is the intended audience for the poster Why6 What does the government hope the audience will do7 What government purpose (s) is served by the poster8 The most effective posters use symbols that are unusual simple

and direct Is this an effective poster Why or why not

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 156: Learning about Propaganda

Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two

bull For each poster identify what propaganda strategy was used and record it on the lesson plan

bull Be sure to provide the strategy and the evidence from the poster

bull Also identify the goal for each poster

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits
Page 157: Learning about Propaganda

Creditsbull American Propaganda Posters courtesy of Northwestern

University Library (httpwwwlibrarynorthwesternedugovpubcollectionswwii-postersindexhtml)

bull German Propaganda Posters courtesy of German Propaganda Archive (httpwwwcalvineduacademiccasgpa)

bull Techniques courtesy of Bryan Ross West Hills High School

  • Learning about Propaganda
  • Propaganda Story Time
  • Propaganda Story Time (2)
  • Propaganda Story Time (3)
  • Propaganda Story Time (4)
  • Propaganda Story Time (5)
  • Propaganda Story Time (6)
  • Propaganda Definitions
  • What is Propaganda
  • Where do we see propaganda
  • What is propaganda
  • Propaganda Purpose
  • Why are they used
  • Importance of teaching students the techniques of propaganda
  • What is a Propaganda Poster
  • What are Propaganda Techniques
  • Propaganda Includes
  • Slide 18
  • Slide 19
  • Slide 20
  • Slide 21
  • Slide 22
  • Slide 23
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont)
  • Ten Commandments of Propaganda (cont) (2)
  • Features of Propaganda
  • Guarding Against Propaganda
  • Propaganda Strategies
  • Slogan
  • Name-Calling
  • Name - Calling
  • Name calling
  • Name-Calling (2)
  • Slide 35
  • More Name Calling
  • Slide 37
  • Propaganda Techniques
  • Name-calling
  • Name-calling (2)
  • Name-Calling (3)
  • Name-Calling (4)
  • Glittering Generalities
  • More Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (2)
  • Glittering Generalities in Text
  • Glittering Generalities in Media
  • Slide 49
  • A Little More for Glittering Generalities
  • Glittering Generalities (3)
  • Slide 52
  • Propaganda Techniques (2)
  • Glittering Generalities (4)
  • Glittering Generalities (5)
  • Propaganda Strategies (2)
  • Transfer Positive feelingsdesires are connected to a productu
  • Transfer
  • Transfer
  • Transfer (2)
  • Transfer in Text
  • Transfer in Media
  • Transfer of Emotions
  • Slide 64
  • Transfer (3)
  • Slide 66
  • Transfer (4)
  • Transfer (5)
  • Transfer (6)
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial
  • Testimonial (2)
  • Testimonial in Text
  • Slide 74
  • Slide 75
  • Testimonial in Media
  • Testimonial (3)
  • Testimonial (4)
  • Testimonial (5)
  • Testimonial (6)
  • Appeal to Authority
  • Appeal to Authority (2)
  • Bait and Switch
  • Bait and Switch in Text
  • Bait and Switch in Media
  • Propaganda Strategies (3)
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon
  • Bandwagon (2)
  • Slide 90
  • Bandwagon in Media
  • Slide 92
  • Propaganda Techniques (3)
  • Bandwagon (3)
  • Bandwagon (4)
  • Bandwagon (5)
  • Fear
  • Slide 98
  • Fear
  • Slide 100
  • Fear (2)
  • Slide 102
  • Fear (3)
  • Fear (4)
  • Fear (5)
  • Loaded WORDS
  • Emotional Words
  • Emotional Words in Text
  • Emotional Words in Media
  • Slide 110
  • Loaded Words
  • Loaded WORDS (2)
  • Slide 113
  • Propaganda Strategies (4)
  • What is a Logical Fallacy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy
  • Logical FallaciesFalse Analogy (2)
  • Slide 119
  • More Logical Fallacy
  • Final Logical Fallacies
  • Slide 122
  • Examples of Logical Fallacy
  • Euphemisms
  • Euphemisms (2)
  • An Example for Euphemism
  • Euphemisms (3)
  • Snob Appeal
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (2)
  • Plain Folks
  • Plain Folks (3)
  • Slide 133
  • plain folks appeal
  • Slide 135
  • Propaganda Techniques (4)
  • Plain Folks (4)
  • Plain Folks (5)
  • Plain Folks (6)
  • Other Techniques Doublespeak
  • Other Techniques Big Lie
  • Other Techniques Scapegoat
  • Other Techniques
  • Other Techniques Card Stacking
  • Other Techniques (2)
  • Black or White
  • Slide 147
  • Slide 148
  • Slide 149
  • Document Analysis for Argument Persuasion or Propaganda
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (2)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (3)
  • Document Questions when Analyzing a Propaganda Poster (4)
  • Propaganda Poster Analysis from National Archives and Record Ad
  • Examining Historical Propaganda from World War Two
  • Slide 157
  • Slide 158
  • Slide 159
  • Slide 160
  • Slide 161
  • Credits