lecture 2: time-dependent measurements with flavor and cp samples oreconstruction of b meson samples...

55
Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples o Reconstruction of B meson samples o Lifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor eigenstate decay

Upload: ferdinand-hawkins

Post on 17-Jan-2016

221 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor

and CP Samples o Reconstruction of B meson sampleso Lifetimes and B0 oscillation

measurements with flavor eigenstate decay

Page 2: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 2

z ~ 260 m

0tagB

ee

4S

K

0recB

B-Flavor Tagging

cβγz/ΔtΔ

Exclusive B Meson

Reconstruction

0

SK

/J

0 0rec fl avB B (flavor eigenstates) lifetime, mixing analyses0 0

rec CPB B (CP eigenstates) CP analysis

Experimental Technique for B Factories

(4S) produces coherent B pair: t t

Time-integrated asymmetries are zero

0

0

( )

( )

tag

rec

B B t

B B t

Page 3: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 3

Main Variables for B Reconstruction

For exclusive B reconstruction, two nearly uncorrelated* kinematic variables are used:

* *B beamE E E

2 2* *BbeamESm E p

2 2 2 2

2

2 2 2 2

ES

beamE E E

m pbeam beamB

pm

* * *( , ),B B beamE Ep B candidate (energy, 3-momentum) and beam energy in (4S) frame

Signal at E ~ 0

Signal at mES ~ mB

Resolutions

10 40 MeVE

22.6 MeV/ cESm

“Energy-substituted

mass”

* If E were zero, the variables would be fully correlated; however, E is typically at least 5 times larger than beam and so dominates E

Page 4: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 4

Example for Hadronic B Decays

mES

E

sidebands

signal region

B0  J/KS

, 3 ,0 3ESB mES Em E m

Defined outside signal region in

Si

or

Si

de

gnal

r to

Region:

estimat

deb

e b

and Re

ackgro

gion:

unds

mES [GeV/c2]

E [

MeV

]

Page 5: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 5

Continuum Background Suppression Separate 2-jet continuum from spherical BB

events via event shape variables

Ratio of second-to-zeroth order Fox-Wolfram moments (R2):

B decays

B decays

Continuum

Continuum

R2

Angle of thrust axis of “rest of the event” wrt B candidate direction

(T)

cosT

Page 6: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 6

Select intermediate mesons using either mass or mass difference:

After selection, candidates are constrained to nominal masses

Inclusive Open Charm States

D*+ D0+

D0 K-+

D0 K+-

m(K-+) [GeV/c2] m [GeV/c2]

Page 7: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 7

Inclusive Charmonium Signals/J e e /J

(2 ) /

/

S J

J

(2 ) /

/

S J

J e e

Page 8: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 8

Flavor Eigenstate Neutral B Sample

0 (*)1( , , )B D h h a 0 *0/ ( )B J K K

Ntag = 23618Purity = 84%

Ntag = 1757Purity = 96%

* 0 0 0

0

, , , ,,

S

S

D D D K K K KD K K

Charm decay modes

B decay modes

BBAABBARAR81.3 fb81.3 fbBBAABBARAR81.3 fb81.3 fb

mES [GeV/c2] mES [GeV/c2]

0( ) 28%BF D ( ) 12%BF D

0( ) 4.1%BF B

Self-TaggingModes

Page 9: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 9

Flavor Eigenstate Charged B Sample

(*)0B D (*)1/ , (2 ) , ,C CB J K S K K K

Ntag = 15915Purity = 87%

Ntag = 6245Purity = 94%

*0 0 0 0 0, , , , SD D D K K K K

Charm decay modes

B decay modes

BBAABBARAR81.3 fb81.3 fbBBAABBARAR81.3 fb81.3 fb

mES [GeV/c2] mES [GeV/c2]

0( ) 28%BF D

0( ) 1.2%BF B

Self-TaggingModes

Page 10: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 10

Golden Sample: (cc)KS CP Eigenstates

(2S)Ks

c1Ks

0/ ( )SJ K

0 0 0/ ( )SJ K

0(2 ) ( )SS K

01 ( )SC K

BBAABBARAR81.3 fb81.3 fbBBAABBARAR81.3 fb81.3 fb

Ncand = 974Purity = 97%

Candidates & purity for mES > 5.27 GeV/c2

Ncand = 150Purity = 97%

Ncand = 170Purity = 89%

Ncand = 80Purity = 95%

Page 11: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 11

Selecting candidates for B J/KL

KL detected by nuclear interactions in EMC or IFRo EMC neutral clusters with energy between 0.2 and 2.0 GeV

• Veto clusters forming 0s with any other photon (E > 30 MeV)

• Remove clusters (E > 1 GeV) containing two distinct bumpso IFR neutral clusters are 2 or more RPC layers that are

unmatched to any projected charged tracko Only able to determine angle of KL wrt interaction point, not

energy

B candidates formed from mass-constrained J/ l+l- and KL candidateso Since there should be missing momentum along KL direction, cut

on difference between observed and expectedo Use cuts on J/ l+l- helicity angle (sin2h for signal) and B

candidate polar angle (sin2 wrt to z-axis)

Page 12: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 12

Final Candidate Selection Apply constraint of

known mB mass & KL direction to determine momentum pKL

Search for signal in the one remaining variable expressed as:

signalbkg

EMC

Remove

measured – expected missing pt [GeV/c]

22 2 2

/2

/

L L

L L

B K KJ

K KJ

m E m p

p p d

* * */

* * */

LK beamJ

B

E E E E

p

LKJp p

LKd

Page 13: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 13

CP Eigenstate Sample: B J/KL

BBAABBARAR81.3 fb81.3 fbBBAABBARAR81.3 fb81.3 fb

Signal

J/ Bkg

Fake J/ Bkg

0/ LJ K

Ncand = 988Purity = 55%

Estimated with MC

Estimated with sidebands

Resolution of about 10 MeV for E after mB

constraint

Page 14: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 14

Sample B0 J/ KL Event

KL

Page 15: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 15

One More Mode for CP Sample

*0 0 0 SJ/ψK K

Ncand = 147 Purity 81%

P VV: mixture of statesCP

BBAABBARAR81.3 fb81.3 fbBBAABBARAR81.3 fb81.3 fb

2

1 2 ,

| | f raction of -odd

D R

R A CP

( ) ( )(16.0 3.2 1.4 )%stat systR BABAR PRL 87, 241801 (2001)

( ) ( )(19.1 2.3 2.6 )%stat systR BELLE hep-ex/0205021

Conclude: J/ mostly CP even

Page 16: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 16

Angular Analysis at BABAR

K* modes without

0

K* modes with 0

Projections of fits for amplitudes and rescattering phases:

22 20 , , , ,A A A

Page 17: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 17

Time-Dependent Analysis Strategies

Measurements

Hig

her p

recisio

n

Factorize the analysis into building blocks Incre

asin

g co

mple

xity

a) Reconstruction of B mesons in flavor eigenstates

b) B vertex reconstruction

0/ Lif etimesB B

0 0 MixingB B c) Flavor Tagging + a + b

AsymmetriesCP d) Reconstruction of neutralB mesons in CP eigenstates + a + b + c

Analysis Ingredient

Page 18: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 18

Measurement of B0 and B+ Lifetime

3. Reconstruct inclusively the vertex of the “other” B meson (BTAG)

4. Compute the proper time difference t5. Fit the t spectra

(4s)

= 0.55

Tag B

z ~ 110 m Reco Bz ~ 65 m

+z

t z/c

K0

D-

--

K+

1. Fully reconstruct one B mesonin flavor eigenstate (BREC)

2. Reconstruct the decay vertex

Page 19: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 19

B Decay Time (ps)

perfectresolution

B-Lifetimes: Time Distributions

Production point of B meson

is known with good accuracy

Proper time difference

obtained from distance z

between the two B vertices

LEP/CDF

B Factories

B Decay Time Difference (ps)

perfectresolution

Control of the resolution function at

negative times

B Decay Time (ps)

finiteresolution

Fit the parameters of the

resolution function together with the lifetime

finiteresolution

B Decay Time Difference (ps)

Page 20: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 20

Vertex and z Reconstruction

Brec vertex

Brec daughters

z

1.Reconstruct Brec vertex from Brec daughters

Beam spot

Interaction Point

Brec direction

Btag direction

2.Reconstruct Btag direction from Brec vertex & momentum, beam spot, and (4S) momentum = pseudotrack

Btag Vertex

tag tracks, V0s

3.Reconstruct Btag vertex from pseudotrack plus consistent set of tag tracks

4.Convert from Δz to Δt, accounting for (small) B momentum in (4S) frame

Result: High efficiency (97%) and σ(Δz)rms ~ 180μm versus <|Δz|> ~ βγcτ = 260μm

Page 21: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 21

Conversion from z to ttagrec

rec tag,rec ,tag

rec tagwhere and are in diff erent f rames

Bz z

zzt t t m

p p

t t

Proper time difference:

* * * *rec rec tag rec rec rec rec tag

Since one is f ully reconstructed and two mesons are correlated:( ) cos ( )

B Bz c t t c t t

Boost Approximation *,rec ,tag (4 ),Neglect , take : B z z S zp p p

zp t

c

rec tag

rec tag

Do not know ( ), but can compute average event-by-event:

Bt

t t t

t t t

Improved Boost Approximation *r

*rec

ec

Since cos 0, z

tc

0.2% effect

Average B Approximation 0* * * *rec rec rec reccos ( | |)

Bz c t c t

Improves resolution by 5% in quadrature

Page 22: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 22

Actual Δt Signal Resolution Function

(Δtmeas-Δttrue)/σ(Δt)

Signal MC: Δt resolution function

Asymmetric RF:Tracks from long-lived charm in tag

vertex

~0.6 ps

Event-by-event σ(Δt) from vertex

errors

σ(Δz) [cm]

Empirical Models with parameters fit to data: Gaussian convolved with an exponential [lifetime] or Triple Gaussian [mixing, CP]

Page 23: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 23

Effect of Charm Tracks on t

D flight direction

bias

(ztag)

Charm

tracks

ztag

Prompt B

tracks

ttrue

tmeas

zrec

tmeas – ttrue < 0

t > 0

z axis

D flight direction

bias

(ztag)

Charm

tracks

ztag

Prompt B

tracks

ttrue

tmeas

zrec

tmeas – ttrue < 0

t < 0

Underlying principle: tag vertex dominates

resolution

Page 24: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 24

Gaussian-Exponential t Resolution Model

(1

( ; ) (0, )

(0, ) )

ˆ

()t

t t

R t G

G E

a f S

f S

Parameters:

ˆ , ,a f S

f = fraction in core Gaussian componentS = scale factor for estimated event-by-event errors = effective lifetime for charm bias component

Core Gaussian

Gaussian convolved with exponential

Motivated by inclusion of charm decay products in determination of Btag vertex, creating a small bias in the mean residual t distribution

Outlier component (measurement error not applicable) added explicitly to PDF used in likelihood fit with one additional free

parameter foutlier

where truet t t Event-by-event

uncertainties from vertex fits (t)

0.2 0.20.3 0.3, ,0.2 %, 0.2 %sig outlier bk outlierff

0.69 0.07,1.21 0.07,1.04 0 2ˆ . 4a

Page 25: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 25

Method for Extracting Lifetime

Global unbinned maximum likelihood technique

• Includes probability-density functions (PDFs) for signal & backgrounds

• Incorporates model for t resolution function for signal & backgroundPrimary advantages:

• Incorporates all correlations between parameters describing dataset

• Extracts maximum statistical precision for desired result

Cautions:

• Need to build reasonable model that incorporates physical correlations

• Need to thoroughly test the model with Monte Carlo simulation to verify complete understanding

Page 26: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 26

Likelihood Function for Lifetime Fits

sig,i , ˆ, ; ), ˆ( ;2

i B

i

| Δt | / τ

i t i BB

eH (Δt a) R Δt a

τ

, ,, , ,

, ,, , ,

(1 )

(1 ) (1 )

i sig i sig isig outlier sig outlier outlier i

sig i bk ibk outlier bk outlier outlier i

P p f H f O

p f H f O

Signal model:

,bk,i ,0

,0 ,0

ˆ, ; , ,

( ) (1 )2

ˆ( ; )i bk

i t i bk bk| Δt | / τ

ibk bkbk

iR Δ

H (Δt f b)e

f t fτ

t b

Background model:

Outlier model: outlier,i (0,10 ps)i GO (Δt )

Two single-sided exponentials convolved with signal Gaussian resolution function

Prompt and lifetime components convolved with separate background Gaussian resolution

function

Gaussian with zero mean and fixed 10 ps width

Probability Density Function (PDF):

Likelihood Function:

Assign probabilities for individual events to be signal (psig,i) or background (1- psig,i),

based on observed mES value and a separate global fit to the mES distribution

for the sample Sum PDFs for charged and neutral samples

for a combined fit with a total of 19 free parameters

00 0 0 0

0 , , 0 ,0, ,0

, , ,0, ,

ˆˆln ln ( , , ; , , , , , , )

ˆˆln ( , , ; , , , , , , )

i i t i sig i bk bksig outlier bk outlierBi

i i t i sig i bk bksig outlier bk outlierBi

L P t p a b ff f

P t p a b ff f

Likelihood Function

Page 27: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 29

Signal and Background Probabilities

signal: 6967 95purity 90 %

signal: 7266 94purity 93 %

Gaussian

ARGUS function

mES (GeV/c2)

wrong-charge contamination

mES (GeV/c2)

psig,i ~ 0 psig,i ~ 0.9

Background properties from

sideband events BBAABBARAR20.6 fb20.6 fbBBAABBARAR20.6 fb20.6 fb

Neutral Neutral BB Mesons Mesons

Charged Charged BB Mesons Mesons

2(1 )20 0( ; , ) 1 , where /ESx

BES ES ES ES ESA m m A m x e x m m

ARGUS background function:

Page 28: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 30

B-Lifetime Measurements

Good agreement with previous lifetime measurements

Excellent control of the time resolution function (parameterization, tails)

0

0

1.546 0.032 0.022 ps1.673 0.032 0.023 ps

/ 1.082 0.026 0.012

B

B

B B

(error PDG2000 ~ 0.03 ps, stat+syst)

BABAR PRL 87, 201803 (2001)

Proof of principle for time-dependent analysis at B Factories

background

BBAABBARAR20.7 fb20.7 fbBBAABBARAR20.7 fb20.7 fb

Page 29: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 31

B-Lifetime Measurements

Good agreement with previous lifetime measurements

Excellent control of the time resolution function (parameterization, tails)

0

0

1.554 0.030 0.019 ps1.695 0.026 0.015 ps

/ 1.091 0.023 0.014

B

B

B B

(error PDG2000 ~ 0.03 ps, stat+syst)

Belle PRL 88, 171801 (2002)

Proof of principle for time-dependent analysis at B Factories

background

BelleBelle29.1 fb29.1 fbBelleBelle

29.1 fb29.1 fb

Page 30: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 32

Measurement of B0B0 Mixing

3. Reconstruct Inclusively the vertex of the “other” B meson (Btag)

5. compute the proper time difference t

(4s)

= 0.55

Tag B

z ~ 110 m Reco Bz ~ 65 m

+z

t z/c

K0

D-

--

K+

1. Fully reconstruct one B meson in flavor eigenstate (Brec) 2. Reconstruct the decay vertex

3. Reconstruct Inclusively the vertex of the “other” B meson (Btag) 4. Determine the flavor of Btag to separate Mixed and Unmixed events

Tag B

z ~ 110 m

5. compute the proper time difference t 6. Fit the t spectra of mixed and unmixed events

Page 31: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 33

0B D

0 ,B DX D K X

0 0, sB D X D D

Methods for B Flavor Tagging

0 *,B D D K

Many different physics processes can be used

Secondary lepton

K

Kaon(s)

Soft pions from D* decays

, Fast charged tracks

Primary lepton

b c sW W

Page 32: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 34

Use charge correlations with decay products to define two physics categorieso “Lepton”o “Kaon”

Multivariable techniques used to combine PID, kinematic variables, correlations, event informationo e.g., primary lepton without PID,

soft pions from D* decays

o Multivariable analysis with neural network techniques: “NT1”, “NT2” categories

0B D 0 ,B DX D K X

0 0, sB D X D D

Flavor Tagging for Mixing Study

* 1.0[1.1] GeV/ c f or [ ]p e

No confl icting Lepton tag, 0ikaons

q

Page 33: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 35

Electron ID at BABARo Match track to EMC

clustero 0.89 < EEMC/p < 1.2

o EM shower shape requirements

o DCH dE/dx and DIRC Cherenkov angle consistent with electron hypothesis

eff e=91%, misid=0.13%

Page 34: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 36

Electron ID at Belleo Match track to ECL clustero EECL/p ratio requirement

o EM shower shape requirements, track-cluster matching

o DCH dE/dx, TOF, ACC consistent with electron hypothesis

eff e=94%, misid=0.5%

Page 35: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 37

Muon ID at BABARo # int. lengths in IFR >2.2o Difference in measured

and expected int. length <1

o Match bet’n extrapolated track and IFR hits

o Requirements on average and spread of # of IFR hits per layer

eff =75%, misid=2.5%

Page 36: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 38

Muon ID at Belleo Difference in measured

and expected rangeo Match bet’n extrapolated

track and KLM hitso Likelihood based selection

eff =90%, misid=1%

Open = Loose; Closed = Tight

Effi

cie

ncy

Pio

n f

ake r

ate

Page 37: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 39

Some Inputs to NN Tagger

Opening angle between input

track and thrust axis of recoil B

0

0

,

s

B D XD D

Sum of energy within 90o of estimated W

direction

Opening angle between input

track and missing

momentum vector

CMS momentum of input track

0B D

0B D

0B D

Page 38: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 40

Flavor Tagging Performance in Data

Tagging category

Fraction of tagged

events(%)

Wrong tag fraction w (%)

Mistag fraction

difference w (%)

Q =

(1-2w)2 (%)

Lepton 10.9 0.3 9.0 1.4 0.9 2.2 7.4 0.5

Kaon 35.8 1.0 17.6 1.0 -1.9 1.5 15.0 0.9

NT1 7.7 0.2 22.0 2.1 5.6 3.2 2.5 0.4

NT2 13.8 0.3 35.1 1.9 -5.9 2.7 1.2 0.3

ALL 68.4 0.7 26.1 1.2

The large sample of fully reconstructed events provides the precise determination of the tagging parameters required in the CP fit

Highest “efficiency” Smallest mistag fraction

BBAABBARAR29.7 fb29.7 fbBBAABBARAR29.7 fb29.7 fb

Error on sin2 and md depend on the “quality factor” Q approx. as:

1sin 2

Q

Page 39: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 41

Decay Time Difference (reco-tag) (ps)

UnMixedMixed

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8

0

0 0 0 0

0 0 0unmixed

1

mixed

cos4

B

mixing, tag tagflav

| Δt | / τ

mixi

mixing, tag tagflav

ng, dB

fl

fl v

a

a

v

"f " (B B or B B )

"f "

ef (Δt) Δm Δt

τ

(B B or B B )

0

0 0 0 0

0 0 0unmixed

1

mixed

cos4

B

mixing, tag tagflav

| Δt | / τ

mixi

mixing, tag tagflav

ng, dB

fl

fl v

a

a

v

"f " (B B or B B )

"f "

ef (Δt) Δm Δt

τ

(B B or B B )

0 0 0

0 0 0

0

0

1 cos4

1 2

unmixe

mixed

( )

d

B

mixing, tag tagflav

mixing, tag tagf

| Δt | / τ

mixin

lav fla

g, dB

flav

v

"f " (B B or B B )

"f " (B

ω R Δe

f (Δt) Δm Δt

B or B B

τt

)

0 0 0

0 0 0

0

0

1 cos4

1 2

unmixe

mixed

( )

d

B

mixing, tag tagflav

mixing, tag tagf

| Δt | / τ

mixin

lav fla

g, dB

flav

v

"f " (B B or B B )

"f " (B

ω R Δe

f (Δt) Δm Δt

B or B B

τt

)

is the flavor mistag probability is the time resolution function

ωR( t)

B-Mixing Analysis:Time Distributions

Decay Time Difference (reco-tag) (ps)

UnMixedMixed

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8

perfect flavor tagging,time resolution

realistic mistag probability,

finite time resolution

Page 40: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 42

Triple-Gaussian t Resolution Model

Core Gaussian

Tail Gaussian

Outlier Gaussian

( ; ) ( , )

( , )

(

ˆ

, )

core core core

tatail

outlier

il tail

outlier outlier

R t f G

G

a

f

Gf

,

Bias

0

core

tail

outli

core c

tail

t

t

er

b

b

Widths

8 ps

core

tail tail

outlie

core t

t

r

S

S

(1 )tail outliercore fff

Parameters: ,, ,ˆ , ,core core ctail outlier taila ff S b b

f = fractions in tail and outlierS = scale factor for estimated

event-by-event errorsb = bias factor due to inclusion of

charm products in tag vertex

Event-by-event uncertainties from vertex

fits (t)

Page 41: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 43

Monte Carlo

Correlation: (t) and residual t bias

z axis

ztag

Prompt B

tracks

Charm

tracks

D flight direction

(t) smallest, t

bias zero

(ztag) D flight direction

bias

(ztag)

Charm

tracks

ztag

Prompt B

tracks

(t) largest, t bias largest

Page 42: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 44

Mistag fraction versus vertex error for kaon tags

Yet another correlation!

Tests of likelihood fit with full Monte Carlo shows bias of +0.0070.003 for md (about 40% of statistical

error!)

Mystery:

Resolved!2mistag rate scaled by tp

pt spectrum of wrong-sign kaons softer than those in correct-tag processes

2But: ( ) 1/ tt p Systematic difference in pt

leads to correlation

Page 43: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 45

Fit Results for Signal Resolution Parameters

Run 1 Run 2

Score 1.37 0.09 1.18 0.11

bcore lepton 0.06 0.13 -0.04 0.16

bcore kaon -0.22 0.08 -0.25 0.09

bcore NT1 -0.07 0.15 -0.45 0.21

bcore NT2 -0.46 0.12 -0.20 0.16

btail -5.0 4.2 -7.5 2.4

ftail 0.014 0.020

0.015 0.010

foutlier 0.008 0.004

0.000 0.014

Non-zero bias for kaons

Page 44: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 46

Additions to the Likelihood Function

1 2 1 2D w D w

12

w w w w w w

12

D D D D D D

0

0

,

,

11

2cos

co2

s1

1

dmixing,

dmixing,

tag B

tag B

f (Δt) Δm Δt

f

D D

D D(Δt) Δm Δt

1. Allow for difference in B0 vs B0 mistag rates

PDFs now depend on tag state as

well

2. Allow for prompt and non-prompt background components

Adds fractions for each tagging category, effective lifetime for non-prompt component, and “effective dilutions” for both

8 parameters

4+1+8 parameters

Page 45: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 47

Blind Analyses Analyses were done “blind” to eliminate

possible experimenters’ biaso In general, measurements of a quantity “X” are done with

likelihood fits – blinding achieved by replacing “X” with “X+R” in likelihood fits

• R is drawn from a Gaussian with a width a few times the expected error

• Random number sequence is “seeded” with a “blinding string”

• The reported statistical error is unaffected• Allows all systematic studies to be done while still blind

Page 46: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 48

md Likelihood Fit

Combined unbinned maximum likelihood fit to t spectra of mixed and unmixed events in the B flavor sample

All t parameters extracted from data Correct estimate of the error and correlations

Fit Parameters # Main Sample

md 1 Signal

Mistag fractions for B0 and B0 tags

8 Signal

Signal resolution function 2x8 * Signal

Description of background t 5+8 Sidebands

Background t resolution 2x3 * Sidebands

B lifetime from PDG 2002 0 B = 1.548 ps

Total parameters 44

* 2 running periods

Page 47: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 50

Final Tagged Mixing Sample

1097 34(96.0 0.7)%

signalNPurity

798 31(88.9 1.2)%

signalNPurity

3156 63(84.6 0.7)%

signalNPurity

1293 43(79.4 1.3)%

signalNPurity

Gaussian

ARGUS function

psig,i ~ 0 psig,i ~ 0.96

Background properties from

sideband events

Lepton KaonLepton

NT2NT1

Page 48: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 51

1(0 516 0 016 0 010 ) ps d (stat) (syst)Δm . . . BABAR PRL 88, 221802 (2002)

Mixing with Hadronic Sample

BBAABBARAR29.7 fb29.7 fbBBAABBARAR29.7 fb29.7 fb

Precision measurement consistent with world average

Signal: mES>5.27

Bgnd: mES<5.27

Page 49: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 52

)

1 2 cosd

mixing

B

A ( tω Δm Δt

Mixing Asymmetry with Hadronic Sample

Unfolded raw asymmetry

t [ps]

dm/π~

21~

Folded raw asymmetry

|t| [ps]

BBAABBARAR29.7 fb29.7 fbBBAABBARAR29.7 fb29.7 fb

Page 50: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 53

Systematic Errors on md

[md]

Description of background events 0.004

Background fractions, sideband extrapolation

Background t structure and resolution

Peaking B+ background

t resolution and detector effects 0.005

Silicon detector residual misalignment

t resolution model

(t) requirement

Fit bias correction and MC statistics 0.003

Fixed lifetime from PDG2000 * 0.006

Total 0.010

* Now improved with PDG2002

Page 51: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 54

Mixing in Hadronic Modes at Belle

1(0 528 0 017 0 011 ) ps d (stat) (syst)Δm . . .

BELLEBELLE29.1 fb29.1 fbBELLEBELLE29.1 fb29.1 fb

Page 52: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 55

1. Fully reconstruct one B meson in CP eigenstate (Brec)2. Reconstruct the decay vertex

1. Fully reconstruct one B meson in CP eigenstate (Brec)2. Reconstruct the decay vertex

5. compute the proper time difference t 6. Fit the t spectra of B0 and B0 tagged events5. compute the proper time difference t 6. Fit the t spectra of B0 and B0 tagged events

Measurement of sin2

3. Reconstruct Inclusively the vertex of the “other” B meson (Btag) 4. Determine the flavor of Btag to separate B0 and B0

(4s)

= 0.56

Tag B

z ~ 110 m Reco Bz ~ 65 m

-z

t z/c

K0

KS0

-

+

+

Page 53: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 56

0 0

0 0( ) 1 2 sin2 sintag tagCP d

tag tag

N(B B ) N(B B )A t ω β Δm Δt

N(B B ) N(B B )

( ) 1 2 cosmixing d

N(unmixed) N(mixed)A t ω Δm Δt

N(unmixed) N(mixed)

Time-Dependent CP Asymmetries

Use the large statistics Bflav data sample to determine the mistag probabilities and the parameters of the time-resolution function

0 0/ SCPB J K

Time-dependence ofCP-violating asymmetry in

0 0- mixingB B Time-dependence of

(Assuming no confusion of Brec state)

Page 54: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 57

Summary Precision measurements of lifetimes and B0

oscillations have been performed at the B Factorieso Require the development of all techniques for B reconstruction,

determination of vertex separation, tagging of the recoil B state at decay, unbinned maximum likelihood fitting and validation procedures

o Results are in excellent agreement with previous results and represent some of the single most-precise measurements available

mmdd = 0.516 = 0.516 ± ± 0.016 (stat)0.016 (stat) ± ± 0.010 (syst) ps0.010 (syst) ps-1-1

BELLE preprint-02/020, hep-ex/0207022, to appear in PLB

BABAR PRL 88, 221802 (2002)

mmdd = 0.528 = 0.528 ± ± 0.017 (stat)0.017 (stat) ± ± 0.011 (syst) ps0.011 (syst) ps-1-1

Tomorrowo Apply tools to measurement of CP violation in neutral B decays

Page 55: Lecture 2: Time-Dependent Measurements with Flavor and CP Samples oReconstruction of B meson samples oLifetimes and B 0 oscillation measurements with flavor

Aug 5-7, 2002 D.MacFarlane at SSI 2002 58

Bibliography: Lecture 2

1. [lifetime] BABAR Collab., B.Aubert et al., PRL 87, 201803 (2001)2. [lifetime] Belle Collab., K.Abe et al., PRL 88, 171801 (2002)3. [mixing] BABAR Collab., B.Aubert et al., PRL 88, 221802 (2002)4. [mixing] Belle Collab, T.Tomura et al., hep-ex/0207022, to appear

in PLB5. [mixing] BABAR Collab., B.Aubert et al., hep-ex/0201020, to

appear in PRD