lectures & objectives · isapp 2014 (belgirate) 21-30 july 2014 transport of cosmic rays in the...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
David Maurin (LPSC)
Lectures & objectivesISAPP 2014 (Belgirate)
21-30 July 2014
Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30)● What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and transport● Relevant time scales: ≠ species have ≠ phenomenology● Main modelling ingredients: key parameters and uncertainties● Tools to solve the transport equation
Charged signals: electrons/positrons, antibaryons (~1h30)● What is astroparticle physics and DM (Dark Matter) indirect detection● What are the astrophysical backgrounds + uncertainties [nuclear]● Phenomenology of DM signals + uncertainties [transport and dark matter]● Pros and Cons of DM indirect detection with charged GCRs
![Page 2: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
I. Introduction; Galactic Cosmic Rays1. Early history of CRs: discovery and disputes2. GCR journey (from source to detector)3. Timeline4. Observables and questions
II. Processes, ingredients, characteristic times1. Definitions2. Diffusion (space and momentum)3. Convection and adiabatic losses4. Energy losses (continuous)5. Catastrophic losses6. All together
III. Solving the equations: GCR phenomenology1. From microphysics to effective models2. Full set of equations (with source terms)3 (Semi-)Analytical, numerical, & MC solutions4. Stable species: degeneracy D0 /L5. Radioactive species and local ISM6. Leptons and local sources
Transport of cosmic rays (CR) in the Galaxy
GCRs-II.pdf
![Page 3: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
[galprop.stanford.edu]
Time scales: all together
0
EC
0
Escape (D)Escape (Vc)
Escape (D)tHinel
1. Dominant effects● Nuclei escape from the Galaxy● Leptons loose their energy
2. Local origin● Low energy radioactive nuclei● High energy electrons and positrons
→ Numbers depend on MW model parameters (halo size, diffusion coefficient...)→ Time scale for effects in the disc overestimated: CRs see density n
ISM <n> (h/H) n
ISM
II.6 Time scales
reacc
reacc
![Page 4: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
I. Introduction; Galactic Cosmic Rays1. Early history of CRs: discovery and disputes2. GCR journey (from source to detector)3. Timeline4. Observables and questions
II. Processes, ingredients, characteristic times1. Definitions2. Diffusion (space and momentum)3. Convection and adiabatic losses4. Energy losses (continuous)5. Catastrophic losses6. All together
III. Solving the equations: GCR phenomenology1. From microphysics to effective models2. Full set of equations (with source terms)3 (Semi-)Analytical, numerical, & MC solutions4. Stable species: degeneracy D0 /L5. Radioactive species and local ISM6. Leptons and local sources
Transport of cosmic rays (CR) in the Galaxy
GCRs-III.pdf
![Page 5: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
R☼
~ 8 kpc
(nuclear physics)(MHD)
2. Transport in the Galaxy1. Source injection● spectrum ~ R-2
● abundances● energy gains/losses● fragmentation/decay
● diffusion: R-
● convection
Charged cosmic rays in the Galaxy: reminder
Galacticwind
![Page 6: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
R☼
~ 8 kpc
(nuclear physics)(MHD)
2. Transport in the Galaxy1. Source injection● spectrum ~ R-2
● abundances● energy gains/losses● fragmentation/decay
● diffusion: R-
● convection
Charged cosmic rays in the Galaxy: reminder
Galacticwind
Do we understand the “standard” fluxes (everywhere and anytime)?● Sources (SN, pulsars, ...)● Nucleosynthesis (r and s-process for heavy nuclei)● Acceleration mechanisms (injection, B amplification, Emax)● Propagation mechanisms (turbulence, spatial dependence, isotropy)● Magneto-cosmico-gaseo properties of the Galaxy (MHD description)
![Page 7: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
R☼
~ 8 kpc
(nuclear physics)(MHD)
2. Transport in the Galaxy1. Source injection● spectrum ~ R-2
● abundances● energy gains/losses● fragmentation/decay
● diffusion: R-
● convection
Charged cosmic rays in the Galaxy: reminder
In this lecture (simpler task):
● Transport equations (all terms, all species)● Set geometry/ingredients● Solve the equations
→ Which GCR data constrain which parameters
of the model?
Galacticwind
Do we understand the “standard” fluxes (everywhere and anytime)?● Sources (SN, pulsars, ...)● Nucleosynthesis (r and s-process for heavy nuclei)● Acceleration mechanisms (injection, B amplification, Emax)● Propagation mechanisms (turbulence, spatial dependence, isotropy)● Magneto-cosmico-gaseo properties of the Galaxy (MHD description)
![Page 8: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Transport of cosmic rays (CR) in the Galaxy
1. Diffusion: from microphysics to effective models 2. Full set of equations (with source terms)3 (Semi-)Analytical, numerical, & MC solutions4. Stable species: degeneracy K0 /L5. Radioactive species and local ISM6. Leptons and local sources
III. Solving the transport equations: GCR phenomenology
![Page 9: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Diffusion coefficients from microphysics
[Adapted from R. Tautz (CRISM 2014)]
● Physics problem: motion in a turbulent field
III.1Microphysics
![Page 10: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Diffusion coefficients from microphysics
● Physics problem: motion in a turbulent field
● Ansatz: diffusion equation
III.1Microphysics
[Adapted from R. Tautz (CRISM 2014)]
![Page 11: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Diffusion coefficients from microphysics
● Physics problem: motion in a turbulent field
● Ansatz: diffusion equation
III.1Microphysics
[Adapted from R. Tautz (CRISM 2014)]
![Page 12: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Diffusion coefficients from microphysics
● Physics problem: motion in a turbulent field
● Ansatz: diffusion equation
Pitch angle =cos(v,B0)
Analytical calculation
- Mean free path
III.1Microphysics
[Adapted from R. Tautz (CRISM 2014)]
![Page 13: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Diffusion coefficients from microphysics
● Physics problem: motion in a turbulent field
● Ansatz: diffusion equation
Pitch angle =cos(v,B0)
Taylor-Green-Kubo formula
Analytical calculation
- Mean free path
- Fokker-Planck coefficient
III.1Microphysics
[Adapted from R. Tautz (CRISM 2014)]
![Page 14: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Diffusion coefficients from microphysics
● Physics problem: motion in a turbulent field
● Ansatz: diffusion equation
Unknown vx,y, unknownposition in Bx,y
Pitch angle =cos(v,B0)
Taylor-Green-Kubo formula
Analytical calculation
- Mean free path
- Fokker-Planck coefficient
- Equation of motion (Lorentz)
III.1Microphysics
[Adapted from R. Tautz (CRISM 2014)]
![Page 15: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Diffusion coefficients from microphysics
● Physics problem: motion in a turbulent field
● Ansatz: diffusion equation
Unknown vx,y, unknownposition in Bx,y
Pitch angle =cos(v,B0)
Taylor-Green-Kubo formula
→ Can only be solved in ideal situations● Quasi-Linear Theory (B ≪B): QLT● 2nd order QLT: SOQLT● Non-linear guiding centre: NLGC
Analytical calculation
- Mean free path
- Fokker-Planck coefficient
- Equation of motion (Lorentz)
III.1Microphysics
[Adapted from R. Tautz (CRISM 2014)]
![Page 16: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Diffusion coefficients from microphysics
● Physics problem: motion in a turbulent field
● Ansatz: diffusion equation
Unknown vx,y, unknownposition in Bx,y
Pitch angle =cos(v,B0)
Taylor-Green-Kubo formula
→ Can only be solved in ideal situations● Quasi-Linear Theory (B ≪B): QLT● 2nd order QLT: SOQLT● Non-linear guiding centre: NLGC
Numerical simulationsAnalytical calculation
- Mean free path
- Fokker-Planck coefficient
- Equation of motion (Lorentz)
Reality: resonant wave-particle interaction with stochastic motion
III.1Microphysics
[Adapted from R. Tautz (CRISM 2014)]
![Page 17: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Diffusion coefficients from microphysics
● Physics problem: motion in a turbulent field
● Ansatz: diffusion equation
Unknown vx,y, unknownposition in Bx,y
Pitch angle =cos(v,B0)
Reality: resonant wave-particle interaction with stochastic motion... turbulence model requires:
● Energy spectrum (diff.eq. for wave!): W k-s
- Kolmogorov: s=5/3 =1/3- Kraichnan: s=3/2 =1/2
Taylor-Green-Kubo formula
→ Can only be solved in ideal situations● Quasi-Linear Theory (B ≪B): QLT● 2nd order QLT: SOQLT● Non-linear guiding centre: NLGC
Numerical simulationsAnalytical calculation
- Mean free path
- Fokker-Planck coefficient
- Equation of motion (Lorentz)
D R
= 2-s
III.1Microphysics
[Adapted from R. Tautz (CRISM 2014)]
![Page 18: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Diffusion coefficients from microphysics
● Physics problem: motion in a turbulent field
● Ansatz: diffusion equation
Unknown vx,y, unknownposition in Bx,y
Pitch angle =cos(v,B0)
Reality: resonant wave-particle interaction with stochastic motion... turbulence model requires:
● Energy spectrum (diff.eq. for wave!): W k-s
- Kolmogorov: s=5/3 =1/3- Kraichnan: s=3/2 =1/2
Taylor-Green-Kubo formula
→ Can only be solved in ideal situations● Quasi-Linear Theory (B ≪B): QLT● 2nd order QLT: SOQLT● Non-linear guiding centre: NLGC
Numerical simulationsAnalytical calculation
- Mean free path
- Fokker-Planck coefficient
- Equation of motion (Lorentz) OR
→ Turbulence is Kolmogorov for the
Sun
Direct measurement
III.1Microphysics
[Adapted from R. Tautz (CRISM 2014)]
D R
= 2-s
![Page 19: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Diffusion coefficients from microphysics
● Physics problem: motion in a turbulent field
● Ansatz: diffusion equation
Unknown vx,y, unknownposition in Bx,y
Pitch angle =cos(v,B0)
Taylor-Green-Kubo formula
→ Can only be solved in ideal situations● Quasi-Linear Theory (B ≪B): QLT● 2nd order QLT: SOQLT● Non-linear guiding centre: NLGC
Numerical simulationsAnalytical calculation
- Mean free path
- Fokker-Planck coefficient
- Equation of motion (Lorentz)
- Slab
- 2D
- Isotropic
- Others (e.g. Goldreich-Sridahr)
Composite
Reality: resonant wave-particle interaction with stochastic motion... turbulence model requires:
● Energy spectrum (diff.eq. for wave!): W k-s
● Geometry
III.1Microphysics
[Adapted from R. Tautz (CRISM 2014)]
![Page 20: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Diffusion coefficients from microphysics
● Physics problem: motion in a turbulent field
● Ansatz: diffusion equation
Unknown vx,y, unknownposition in Bx,y
Pitch angle =cos(v,B0)
Taylor-Green-Kubo formula
→ Can only be solved in ideal situations● Quasi-Linear Theory (B ≪B): QLT● 2nd order QLT: SOQLT● Non-linear guiding centre: NLGC
Numerical simulationsAnalytical calculation
- Mean free path
- Fokker-Planck coefficient
- Equation of motion (Lorentz)
Reality: resonant wave-particle interaction with stochastic motion... turbulence model requires:
● Energy spectrum (diff.eq. for wave!): W k-s
● Geometry● Dynamical behaviour
III.1Microphysics
[Adapted from R. Tautz (CRISM 2014)]
![Page 21: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Diffusion coefficients from microphysics
● Physics problem: motion in a turbulent field
● Ansatz: diffusion equation
Unknown vx,y, unknownposition in Bx,y
Pitch angle =cos(v,B0)
Taylor-Green-Kubo formula
→ Can only be solved in ideal situations● Quasi-Linear Theory (B ≪B): QLT● 2nd order QLT: SOQLT● Non-linear guiding centre: NLGC
Numerical simulationsAnalytical calculation
- Mean free path
- Fokker-Planck coefficient
- Equation of motion (Lorentz)
Reality: resonant wave-particle interaction with stochastic motion... turbulence model requires:
● Energy spectrum (diff.eq. for wave!): W k-s
● Geometry● Dynamical behaviour
III.1Microphysics
(N.B.: alsoinputs of analytical
calculations)
[Adapted from R. Tautz (CRISM 2014)]
![Page 22: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Diffusion coefficients from microphysics
● Physics problem: motion in a turbulent field
● Ansatz: diffusion equation
Unknown vx,y, unknownposition in Bx,y
Pitch angle =cos(v,B0)
Taylor-Green-Kubo formula
→ Can only be solved in ideal situations● Quasi-Linear Theory (B ≪B): QLT● 2nd order QLT: SOQLT● Non-linear guiding centre: NLGC
Numerical simulationsAnalytical calculation
- Mean free path
- Fokker-Planck coefficient
- Equation of motion (Lorentz)
Reality: resonant wave-particle interaction with stochastic motion... turbulence model requires:
● Energy spectrum (diff.eq. for wave!): W k-s
● Geometry● Dynamical behaviour
- Instabilities- Damped waved- Intermittency
Diffusion in MHD
turbulence
III.1Microphysics
[Adapted from R. Tautz (CRISM 2014)]
![Page 23: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Diffusion coefficients from microphysics
● Physics problem: motion in a turbulent field
● Ansatz: diffusion equation
Unknown vx,y, unknownposition in Bx,y
Pitch angle =cos(v,B0)
Taylor-Green-Kubo formula
→ Low resolution only (time-consuming)
→ Near future(?): full MHD treatment (CRs + gas + B)
Numerical simulationsAnalytical calculation
- Mean free path
- Fokker-Planck coefficient
- Equation of motion (Lorentz)
Reality: resonant wave-particle interaction with stochastic motion... turbulence model requires:
● Energy spectrum (diff.eq. for wave!): W k-s
● Geometry● Dynamical behaviour
- Instabilities- Damped waved- Intermittency
→ Can only be solved in ideal situations● Quasi-Linear Theory (B ≪B): QLT● 2nd order QLT: SOQLT● Non-linear guiding centre: NLGC
III.1Microphysics
[Adapted from R. Tautz (CRISM 2014)]
![Page 24: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Effective models: fit of careful with the interpretation!)
III.1Microphysics
![Page 25: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Effective models: fit of careful with the interpretation!)
● Everywhere: planetary → galaxy clusters● Typical amplitudes: ~ G – nT● Two components (comparable strength):
✔ Regular B0 (large scale)✔ Turbulent B (small scale), i.e. <B>=0
Magnetic fields
III.1Microphysics
![Page 26: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Effective models: fit of careful with the interpretation!)
● Everywhere: planetary → galaxy clusters● Typical amplitudes: ~ G – nT● Two components (comparable strength):
✔ Regular B0 (large scale)✔ Turbulent B (small scale), i.e. <B>=0 Diffusion+
confinement = geometry
Magnetic fields
III.1Microphysics
![Page 27: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Effective models: fit of careful with the interpretation!)
● Everywhere: planetary → galaxy clusters● Typical amplitudes: ~ G – nT● Two components (comparable strength):
✔ Regular B0 (large scale)✔ Turbulent B (small scale), i.e. <B>=0
Milky Way (408 MHz)http://apod.nasa.pod/ap011020.html
Diffusion+ confinement = geometry
Ekers & Sancisi, A&A 54, 973 (1977)
NGC4631 (610 MHz)Magnetic fields
III.1Microphysics
![Page 28: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Effective models: fit of careful with the interpretation!)
● Everywhere: planetary → galaxy clusters● Typical amplitudes: ~ G – nT● Two components (comparable strength):
✔ Regular B0 (large scale)✔ Turbulent B (small scale), i.e. <B>=0
Milky Way (408 MHz)http://apod.nasa.pod/ap011020.html
Diffusion+ confinement = geometry
Ekers & Sancisi, A&A 54, 973 (1977)
NGC4631 (610 MHz)
Geometry = camembert box → Diffusive halo half-height ~ L
Magnetic fields
III.1Microphysics
![Page 29: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Effective models: fit of careful with the interpretation!)
● Everywhere: planetary → galaxy clusters● Typical amplitudes: ~ G – nT● Two components (comparable strength):
✔ Regular B0 (large scale)✔ Turbulent B (small scale), i.e. <B>=0
Milky Way (408 MHz)http://apod.nasa.pod/ap011020.html
Diffusion+ confinement = geometry
Ekers & Sancisi, A&A 54, 973 (1977)
NGC4631 (610 MHz)
Diffusioncoefficients
Geometry = camembert box → Diffusive halo half-height ~ L
Magnetic fields
III.1Microphysics
![Page 30: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Effective models: fit of careful with the interpretation!)
● Everywhere: planetary → galaxy clusters● Typical amplitudes: ~ G – nT● Two components (comparable strength):
✔ Regular B0 (large scale)✔ Turbulent B (small scale), i.e. <B>=0
Milky Way (408 MHz)http://apod.nasa.pod/ap011020.html
Diffusion+ confinement = geometry
Ekers & Sancisi, A&A 54, 973 (1977)
NGC4631 (610 MHz)
Usual simplifying assumptions● Isotropic (no preferred diffusion direction)● Standard (no sub-diffusion, Levy flights...)● Spatial-independent diffusion coefficient● Wind: ⊥ to galactic plane (cst or linear)● “Minimal” reacceleration (VA mediated)
Diffusioncoefficients
Geometry = camembert box → Diffusive halo half-height ~ L
Magnetic fields
with =0
III.1Microphysics
![Page 31: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Effective models: fit of careful with the interpretation!)
● Everywhere: planetary → galaxy clusters● Typical amplitudes: ~ G – nT● Two components (comparable strength):
✔ Regular B0 (large scale)✔ Turbulent B (small scale), i.e. <B>=0
Milky Way (408 MHz)http://apod.nasa.pod/ap011020.html
Diffusion+ confinement = geometry
Ekers & Sancisi, A&A 54, 973 (1977)
NGC4631 (610 MHz)
→ D = D0 R
→ DEE (pVA)2/D
Usual simplifying assumptions● Isotropic (no preferred diffusion direction)● Standard (no sub-diffusion, Levy flights...)● Spatial-independent diffusion coefficient● Wind: ⊥ to galactic plane (cst or linear)● “Minimal” reacceleration (VA mediated)
Diffusioncoefficients
Geometry = camembert box → Diffusive halo half-height ~ L
Magnetic fields
with =0
III.1Microphysics
![Page 32: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Effective models: fit of careful with the interpretation!)
● Everywhere: planetary → galaxy clusters● Typical amplitudes: ~ G – nT● Two components (comparable strength):
✔ Regular B0 (large scale)✔ Turbulent B (small scale), i.e. <B>=0
Milky Way (408 MHz)http://apod.nasa.pod/ap011020.html
Diffusion+ confinement = geometry
Ekers & Sancisi, A&A 54, 973 (1977)
NGC4631 (610 MHz)
→ D = D0 R
→ DEE (pVA)2/D
Usual simplifying assumptions● Isotropic (no preferred diffusion direction)● Standard (no sub-diffusion, Levy flights...)● Spatial-independent diffusion coefficient● Wind: ⊥ to galactic plane (cst or linear)● “Minimal” reacceleration (VA mediated)
Diffusioncoefficients
Geometry = camembert box → Diffusive halo half-height ~ L
Magnetic fields
“Minimal” model5 free parameters
D0, , VA, L, Vc
with =0
III.1Microphysics
![Page 33: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Transport of cosmic rays (CR) in the Galaxy
III. Solving the transport equations: GCR phenomenology
1. Diffusion: from microphysics to effective models 2. Full set of equations (with source terms)3 (Semi-)Analytical, numerical, & MC solutions4. Stable species: degeneracy K0 /L5. Radioactive species and local ISM6. Leptons and local sources
![Page 34: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
III.2 All terms
Milky Way (408 MHz)http://apod.nasa.pod/ap011020.html
![Page 35: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
Milky Way (408 MHz)http://apod.nasa.pod/ap011020.html
III.2 All terms
![Page 36: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
Milky Way (408 MHz)http://apod.nasa.pod/ap011020.html
Primary source term: space-time granularity
● Spatial distribution (positions)● Age source / duration● Spectrum (for all species)
III.2 All terms
primary species=
accelerated in sources
![Page 37: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
Milky Way (408 MHz)http://apod.nasa.pod/ap011020.html
Primary source term: space-time granularity
● Spatial distribution (positions)● Age source / duration● Spectrum (for all species)
→ 1st approximation:● smooth spatial distribution● steady-state
→ Refinement: add specific sources you believe may contribute to the total
III.2 All terms
primary species=
accelerated in sources
![Page 38: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
Milky Way (408 MHz)http://apod.nasa.pod/ap011020.html
Primary source term: space-time granularity
● Spatial distribution (positions)● Age source / duration● Spectrum (for all species)
→ 1st approximation:● smooth spatial distribution● steady-state
→ Refinement: add specific sources you believe may contribute to the total[ ]
III.2 All terms
primary species=
accelerated in sources
![Page 39: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
Milky Way (408 MHz)http://apod.nasa.pod/ap011020.html
[ ]
III.2 All terms
![Page 40: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
Milky Way (408 MHz)http://apod.nasa.pod/ap011020.html
[ ]
Secondary source term: production
● ISM ~ 90% H, 10% He● CRs: Mostly p and He (for e+, pbar, dbar)● Cross-sections: data + models
III.2 All terms
Secondary species=
created in nuclear interaction of primary CR on ISM
![Page 41: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
Milky Way (408 MHz)http://apod.nasa.pod/ap011020.html
Secondary source term: production
● ISM ~ 90% H, 10% He● CRs: Mostly p and He (for e+, pbar, dbar)● Cross-sections: data + models
For nuclei:
→ models:
[ ]
● Semi-empirical (Silberberg & Tsao)● Empirical (Webber et al.)● Microscopic (Zeitlin et al.)
III.2 All terms
Secondary species=
created in nuclear interaction of primary CR on ISM
![Page 42: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
Milky Way (408 MHz)http://apod.nasa.pod/ap011020.html
Secondary source term: production
● ISM ~ 90% H, 10% He● CRs: Mostly p and He (for e+, pbar, dbar)● Cross-sections: data + models
For nuclei:
→ models:
[ ]
● Semi-empirical (Silberberg & Tsao)● Empirical (Webber et al.)● Microscopic (Zeitlin et al.)
III.2 All terms
Secondary species=
created in nuclear interaction of primary CR on ISM
![Page 43: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
[ ]
III.2 All terms
![Page 44: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
[ ]
Remarks
III.2 All terms
![Page 45: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
[ ]
Remarks
→ 2nd order differential equation (space and energy) + time-derivative
III.2 All terms
![Page 46: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
[ ]
Remarks
→ 2nd order differential equation (space and energy) + time-derivative
→ Linear equations: local sources or “DM” source term can be dealt with separately
III.2 All terms
![Page 47: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
[ ]
Remarks
→ 2nd order differential equation (space and energy) + time-derivative
→ Linear equations: local sources or “DM” source term can be dealt with separately
→ Set of N coupled equations
III.2 All terms
![Page 48: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
[ ]
Remarks
→ 2nd order differential equation (space and energy) + time-derivative
→ Linear equations: local sources or “DM” source term can be dealt with separately
→ Set of N coupled equations
III.2 All terms
![Page 49: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
0
The full transport equation(s)
[ ]
Remarks
→ 2nd order differential equation (space and energy) + time-derivative
→ Linear equations: local sources or “DM” source term can be dealt with separately
→ Set of N coupled equations
¦56Fe
¦12C
10Be10B
¦4He1H
p,de±
¦56Fe
¦12C
10Be10B
¦4He1H
p,de±
=
0
00
III.2 All terms
![Page 50: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
[ ]
Remarks
→ 2nd order differential equation (space and energy) + time-derivative
→ Linear equations: local sources or “DM” source term can be dealt with separately
→ Set of N coupled equations
→ Solve iteratively (or diagonalise) for nuclei
III.2 All terms
0
¦56Fe
¦12C
10Be10B
¦4He1H
p,de±
¦56Fe
¦12C
10Be10B
¦4He1H
p,de±
=
0
00
![Page 51: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
The full transport equation(s)
[ ]
Remarks
→ 2nd order differential equation (space and energy) + time-derivative
→ Linear equations: local sources or “DM” source term can be dealt with separately
→ Set of N coupled equations
→ Solve iteratively (or diagonalise) for nuclei→ Calculate p, e±, from p, He afterwards
III.2 All terms
0
¦56Fe
¦12C
10Be10B
¦4He1H
p,de±
¦56Fe
¦12C
10Be10B
¦4He1H
p,de±
=
0
00
![Page 52: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
Transport of cosmic rays (CR) in the Galaxy
III. Solving the transport equations: GCR phenomenology
1. Diffusion: from microphysics to effective models 2. Full set of equations (with source terms)3 (Semi-)Analytical, numerical, & MC solutions4. Stable species: degeneracy K0 /L5. Radioactive species and local ISM6. Leptons and local sources
![Page 53: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
Solving the transport equation
(Semi-)analytical Numerical Monte Carlo
III.3 Techniques
![Page 54: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
Solving the transport equation
(Semi-)analytical Numerical Monte Carlo
Simplify the problem:● keep dominant effects only● simplify the geometry - spherical/cylindrical/1D halo - sources/gas in thin disc (z)
Approach
III.3 Techniques
![Page 55: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
Solving the transport equation
(Semi-)analytical Numerical Monte Carlo
Simplify the problem:● keep dominant effects only● simplify the geometry - spherical/cylindrical/1D halo - sources/gas in thin disc (z)
Approach
Tools ● Green functions
III.3 Techniques
![Page 56: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
Solving the transport equation
(Semi-)analytical Numerical Monte Carlo
Simplify the problem:● keep dominant effects only● simplify the geometry - spherical/cylindrical/1D halo - sources/gas in thin disc (z)
Approach
Tools ● Green functions● Fourier/Bessel expansion● Differential equations
III.3 Techniques
![Page 57: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
Solving the transport equation
(Semi-)analytical Numerical Monte Carlo
Simplify the problem:● keep dominant effects only● simplify the geometry - spherical/cylindrical/1D halo - sources/gas in thin disc (z)
Pros andcons
Approach
● Useful to understand the physics● Fast and no instabilities
● Only solve approximate model● New solution for new problem
Tools ● Green functions● Fourier/Bessel expansion● Differential equations
III.3 Techniques
![Page 58: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
Solving the transport equation
(Semi-)analytical Numerical Monte Carlo
Simplify the problem:● keep dominant effects only● simplify the geometry - spherical/cylindrical/1D halo - sources/gas in thin disc (z)
Finite difference scheme:● discretise the equation● scheme (e.g., Crank-Nicholson)● invert tridiagonal matrix
Pros andcons
Approach
● Useful to understand the physics● Fast and no instabilities
● Only solve approximate model● New solution for new problem
Tools ● Green functions● Fourier/Bessel expansion● Differential equations
III.3 Techniques
![Page 59: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
Solving the transport equation
(Semi-)analytical Numerical Monte Carlo
Simplify the problem:● keep dominant effects only● simplify the geometry - spherical/cylindrical/1D halo - sources/gas in thin disc (z)
Finite difference scheme:● discretise the equation● scheme (e.g., Crank-Nicholson)● invert tridiagonal matrix
Pros andcons
Approach
● Useful to understand the physics● Fast and no instabilities
● Only solve approximate model● New solution for new problem
Tools ● Green functions● Fourier/Bessel expansion● Differential equations
III.3 Techniques
Crank-Nicholson scheme
Explicit schemeImplicit scheme
![Page 60: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
Solving the transport equation
(Semi-)analytical Numerical Monte Carlo
Simplify the problem:● keep dominant effects only● simplify the geometry - spherical/cylindrical/1D halo - sources/gas in thin disc (z)
Finite difference scheme:● discretise the equation● scheme (e.g., Crank-Nicholson)● invert tridiagonal matrix
Pros andcons
Approach
● Useful to understand the physics● Fast and no instabilities
● Only solve approximate model● New solution for new problem
Tools ● Green functions● Fourier/Bessel expansion● Differential equations
● Numerical solvers● Numerical recipes (Press et al.)● NAG libraries, GSL (free)
III.3 Techniques
![Page 61: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
Solving the transport equation
(Semi-)analytical Numerical Monte Carlo
Simplify the problem:● keep dominant effects only● simplify the geometry - spherical/cylindrical/1D halo - sources/gas in thin disc (z)
Finite difference scheme:● discretise the equation● scheme (e.g., Crank-Nicholson)● invert tridiagonal matrix
Pros andcons
● Very simple algebra● Any new input easily included
● Slow, huge memory for high res.● Less insight in the physics
Approach
● Useful to understand the physics● Fast and no instabilities
● Only solve approximate model● New solution for new problem
Tools ● Green functions● Fourier/Bessel expansion● Differential equations
● Numerical solvers● Numerical recipes (Press et al.)● NAG libraries, GSL (free)
III.3 Techniques
![Page 62: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
Solving the transport equation
(Semi-)analytical Numerical Monte Carlo
Simplify the problem:● keep dominant effects only● simplify the geometry - spherical/cylindrical/1D halo - sources/gas in thin disc (z)
Finite difference scheme:● discretise the equation● scheme (e.g., Crank-Nicholson)● invert tridiagonal matrix
Pros andcons
● Very simple algebra● Any new input easily included
● Slow, huge memory for high res.● Less insight in the physics
Approach
● Useful to understand the physics● Fast and no instabilities
● Only solve approximate model● New solution for new problem
Tools ● Green functions● Fourier/Bessel expansion● Differential equations
● Numerical solvers● Numerical recipes (Press et al.)● NAG libraries, GSL (free)
III.3 Techniques
Follow each particle:● N particles at t=0● evolve each of them to t+1● draw random numbers for D
![Page 63: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
Solving the transport equation
(Semi-)analytical Numerical Monte Carlo
Simplify the problem:● keep dominant effects only● simplify the geometry - spherical/cylindrical/1D halo - sources/gas in thin disc (z)
Finite difference scheme:● discretise the equation● scheme (e.g., Crank-Nicholson)● invert tridiagonal matrix
Pros andcons
● Stochastic differential equations● Markov process● MPI
● Very simple algebra● Any new input easily included
● Slow, huge memory for high res.● Less insight in the physics
Approach
● Useful to understand the physics● Fast and no instabilities
● Only solve approximate model● New solution for new problem
Tools ● Green functions● Fourier/Bessel expansion● Differential equations
● Numerical solvers● Numerical recipes (Press et al.)● NAG libraries, GSL (free)
III.3 Techniques
Follow each particle:● N particles at t=0● evolve each of them to t+1● draw random numbers for D
![Page 64: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
Solving the transport equation
(Semi-)analytical Numerical Monte Carlo
Simplify the problem:● keep dominant effects only● simplify the geometry - spherical/cylindrical/1D halo - sources/gas in thin disc (z)
Finite difference scheme:● discretise the equation● scheme (e.g., Crank-Nicholson)● invert tridiagonal matrix
Pros andcons
● Statistical properties (along path)● No grid (t step), (for/back)-ward
● Very slow, statistical errors● Massively parallel problem
● Stochastic differential equations● Markov process● MPI
● Very simple algebra● Any new input easily included
● Slow, huge memory for high res.● Less insight in the physics
Approach
● Useful to understand the physics● Fast and no instabilities
● Only solve approximate model● New solution for new problem
Tools ● Green functions● Fourier/Bessel expansion● Differential equations
● Numerical solvers● Numerical recipes (Press et al.)● NAG libraries, GSL (free)
III.3 Techniques
Follow each particle:● N particles at t=0● evolve each of them to t+1● draw random numbers for D
![Page 65: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
Solving the transport equation
III.3 Techniques
(Semi-)analytical Numerical Monte Carlo
Simplify the problem:● keep dominant effects only● simplify the geometry - spherical/cylindrical/1D halo - sources/gas in thin disc (z)
Follow each particle:● N particles at t=0● evolve each of them to t+1● draw random numbers for D
Finite difference scheme:● discretise the equation● scheme (e.g., Crank-Nicholson)● invert tridiagonal matrix
Codes and/or
references
Pros andcons
Webber (1970+)Ptuskin (1980+)Schlickeiser (1990+)USINE (2000+)
GALPROP (Strong et al. 1998)DRAGON (Evoli et al. 2008)
PICARD (Kissmann et al., 2013)
● Statistical properties (along path)● No grid (t step), (for/back)-ward
● Very slow, statistical errors● Massively parallel problem
● Stochastic differential equations● Markov process● MPI
● Very simple algebra● Any new input easily included
● Slow, huge memory for high res.● Less insight in the physics
Webber & Rockstroh (1997)Farahat et al. (2008)Kopp, Büshing et al. (2012)
Approach
● Useful to understand the physics● Fast and no instabilities
● Only solve approximate model● New solution for new problem
Tools ● Green functions● Fourier/Bessel expansion● Differential equations
● Numerical solvers● Numerical recipes (Press et al.)● NAG libraries, GSL (free)
Semi-analyticalAnalytical for spatial derivativesNumerical for energy derivatives
![Page 66: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
Transport of cosmic rays (CR) in the Galaxy
III. Solving the transport equations: GCR phenomenology
1. Diffusion: from microphysics to effective models 2. Full set of equations (with source terms)3 (Semi-)Analytical, numerical, & MC solutions4. Stable species: degeneracy D0 /L5. Radioactive species and local ISM6. Leptons and local sources
![Page 67: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
Stable nuclei: simple 1D model
III.4 Stables and B/C
![Page 68: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
Stable nuclei: simple 1D model
● Simplified 1D geometry (infinite plane)● Neglect energy losses/gains● D(E) isotropic, space-independent
III.4 Stables and B/C
![Page 69: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
Stable nuclei: simple 1D model
Solution for stable species
● Simplified 1D geometry (infinite plane)● Neglect energy losses/gains● D(E) isotropic, space-independent
● Solve in the halo● Ensure condition N(z=L)=0 ● Integrate around 0
III.4 Stables and B/C
Find solution N(0)
![Page 70: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
Stable nuclei: simple 1D model
Solution for stable species
● Simplified 1D geometry (infinite plane)● Neglect energy losses/gains● D(E) isotropic, space-independent
● Solve in the halo● Ensure condition N(z=L)=0 ● Integrate around 0
III.4 Stables and B/C
![Page 71: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
Stable nuclei: simple 1D model
Solution for stable species
● Simplified 1D geometry (infinite plane)● Neglect energy losses/gains● D(E) isotropic, space-independent
● Solve in the halo● Ensure condition N(z=L)=0 ● Integrate around 0
III.4 Stables and B/C
Valid above ~10 GeV/n
![Page 72: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
Stable nuclei: ratio of primary species
Solution for stable species
● Simplified 1D geometry (infinite plane)● Neglect energy losses/gains● D(E) isotropic, space-independent
● Solve in the halo● Ensure condition N(z=L)=0 ● Integrate around 0
III.4 Stables and B/C
![Page 73: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
Stable nuclei: ratio of primary species (LE)
Solution for stable species
● Simplified 1D geometry (infinite plane)● Neglect energy losses/gains● D(E) isotropic, space-independent
● Solve in the halo● Ensure condition N(z=L)=0 ● Integrate around 0
III.4 Stables and B/C
The heavier the nucleus, the moredestroyed it is at low energy
Putze et al., A&A 526 (2011) A101
![Page 74: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
Stable nuclei: ratio of primary species (HE)
Solution for stable species
● Simplified 1D geometry (infinite plane)● Neglect energy losses/gains● D(E) isotropic, space-independent
● Solve in the halo● Ensure condition N(z=L)=0 ● Integrate around 0
III.4 Stables and B/C
Hint at p ≠
He?
(collective effects, acceleration in WR winds)
Vladimiro et al., ApJ 752 (2012) 68
![Page 75: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
Stable nuclei: primary flux (HE)
Solution for stable species
● Simplified 1D geometry (infinite plane)● Neglect energy losses/gains● D(E) isotropic, space-independent
● Solve in the halo● Ensure condition N(z=L)=0 ● Integrate around 0
→
III.4 Stables and B/C
Departure from a pure power law?Concavity in the spectrum?
Adriani et al., Science 332 (2011) 69
![Page 76: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/76.jpg)
Stable nuclei: secondary/primary (HE)
Solution for stable species
● Simplified 1D geometry (infinite plane)● Neglect energy losses/gains● D(E) isotropic, space-independent
● Solve in the halo● Ensure condition N(z=L)=0 ● Integrate around 0
→
→
III.4 Stables and B/C
![Page 77: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/77.jpg)
Stable nuclei: secondary/primary +
Solution for stable species
● Simplified 1D geometry (infinite plane)● Neglect energy losses/gains● D(E) isotropic, space-independent
● Solve in the halo● Ensure condition N(z=L)=0 ● Integrate around 0
→
→
Putze et al., A&A 516 (2010) A66Putze et al., A&A 526 (2011) A101
III.4 Stables and B/C
→ Current data not at high energyenough to determine
→
→
![Page 78: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/78.jpg)
Stable nuclei: secondary/primary +
Solution for stable species
● Simplified 1D geometry (infinite plane)● Neglect energy losses/gains● D(E) isotropic, space-independent
● Solve in the halo● Ensure condition N(z=L)=0 ● Integrate around 0
→
→
Putze et al., A&A 516 (2010) A66Putze et al., A&A 526 (2011) A101
III.4 Stables and B/C
Interplay between Vc, Va, and D(E)
low energy dependence
→ Current data not at high energyenough to determine
→
→
![Page 79: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/79.jpg)
Stable nuclei: secondary/primary +
Solution for stable species
● Simplified 1D geometry (infinite plane)● Neglect energy losses/gains● D(E) isotropic, space-independent
● Solve in the halo● Ensure condition N(z=L)=0 ● Integrate around 0
→ Nuclear uncertainties > B/C data uncertainties
III.4 Stables and B/C
DM, Putze & DeromeA&A 516, 67(2010)
→ Current data not at high energyenough to determine
→
→
![Page 80: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/80.jpg)
Stable nuclei: secondary/primary and D0/L degeneracy
Solution for stable species
● Simplified 1D geometry (infinite plane)● Neglect energy losses/gains● D(E) isotropic, space-independent
● Solve in the halo● Ensure condition N(z=L)=0 ● Integrate around 0
III.4 Stables and B/C
DM et al., ApJ 555 (2001), 585
→ Current data not at high energyenough to determine
→
→
→ Strong D0/L degeneracy≠ D0 and L (but same D0/L) gives same B/C
![Page 81: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/81.jpg)
Stable nuclei: secondary/primary and D0/L degeneracy
Solution for stable species
● Simplified 1D geometry (infinite plane)● Neglect energy losses/gains● D(E) isotropic, space-independent
● Solve in the halo● Ensure condition N(z=L)=0 ● Integrate around 0
III.4 Stables and B/C
→ Current data not at high energyenough to determine
→
→
→ Strong D0/L degeneracy≠ D0 and L (but same D0/L) gives same B/C
Leaky-Box equation and grammage
N.B.: correct answer ~ 10 g/cm2
![Page 82: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/82.jpg)
Transport of cosmic rays (CR) in the Galaxy
III. Solving the transport equations: GCR phenomenology
1. Diffusion: from microphysics to effective models 2. Full set of equations (with source terms)3 (Semi-)Analytical, numerical, & MC solutions4. Stable species: degeneracy K0 /L5. Radioactive species and local ISM6. Leptons and local sources
![Page 83: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/83.jpg)
Secondary radioactive nuclei (LE)
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
![Page 84: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/84.jpg)
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
Secondary radioactive nuclei (LE)
![Page 85: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/85.jpg)
Solution for radioactive species● Only decay and diffusion● Unbounded diffusion (not sensitive to L)
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
Secondary radioactive nuclei (LE)
![Page 86: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/86.jpg)
Solution for radioactive species● Only decay and diffusion● Unbounded diffusion (not sensitive to L)
● Green function: solution for Q(r)=(r)→ only depends on the distance to the source
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
Secondary radioactive nuclei (LE)
![Page 87: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/87.jpg)
Solution for radioactive species● Only decay and diffusion● Unbounded diffusion (not sensitive to L)
● Green function: solution for Q(r)=(r)→ only depends on the distance to the source
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
Secondary radioactive nuclei (LE)
![Page 88: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/88.jpg)
Solution for radioactive species● Only decay and diffusion● Unbounded diffusion (not sensitive to L)
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
Secondary radioactive nuclei (LE)
![Page 89: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/89.jpg)
Solution for radioactive species● Only decay and diffusion● Unbounded diffusion (not sensitive to L)
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
Secondary radioactive nuclei (LE)
![Page 90: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/90.jpg)
Solution for radioactive species● Only decay and diffusion● Unbounded diffusion (not sensitive to L)
N.B.: r is the distance, and we now change to (r,z) variables
d3r=4r2dr = 2rdrdz
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
Find solution Nr(0)
Secondary radioactive nuclei (LE)
![Page 91: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/91.jpg)
● Only decay and diffusion● Unbounded diffusion (not sensitive to L)
N.B.: r is the distance, and we now change to (r,z) variables
d3r=4r2dr = 2rdrdz
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
→ Direct measure of the diffusion coefficient
Solution for radioactive species
Secondary radioactive nuclei (LE)
![Page 92: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/92.jpg)
But data are scarce...● No direct measurement of 10Be● Only ~ one energy for 10Be/Be or 10Be/9Be (also 26Al, 36Cl, 54Mn)
● Only decay and diffusion● Unbounded diffusion (not sensitive to L)
N.B.: r is the distance, and we now change to (r,z) variables
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
→ Direct measure of the diffusion coefficient→ Indirect measure of L
Solution for radioactive species
Secondary radioactive nuclei (LE)
![Page 93: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/93.jpg)
But data are scarce...● No direct measurement of 10Be● Only ~ one energy for 10Be/Be or 10Be/9Be (also 26Al, 36Cl, 54Mn)
● Only decay and diffusion● Unbounded diffusion (not sensitive to L)
N.B.: r is the distance, and we now change to (r,z) variables
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
→ Direct measure of the diffusion coefficient→ Indirect measure of L
Solution for radioactive species
Putze et al., A&A 516 (2010) A66
Secondary radioactive nuclei (LE)
![Page 94: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/94.jpg)
Secondary radioactive nuclei: the local ISM (LISM)
From how far away radioactive nuclei come?
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
D = 0.05 kpc2/Myr × (E/1 GeV)0.5
(10Be) ~ 1.5 Myr
Calculate d (1 GeV)
![Page 95: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/95.jpg)
Secondary radioactive nuclei: the local ISM (LISM)
Radioactive species are sensitive to small scales (~ 300 pc)→ the local gas is not homogeneous on this scale!
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
![Page 96: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/96.jpg)
NaI absorption measurements (5890 Å): 1005 sight lines
Lallement et al., A&A 411, 447 (2003)
Dense gas along the galactic plane … in the meridian plane … in the rotation plane
→ 20 SN explosions during the past 10-20 Myr (age of the local bubble)
(local bubble linked to the formation of the Gould Belt 30-60 Myr ago?)
→ 1 more SN about 1 Myr ago(The SN could be as close as ~ 40 pc from SS: contribution to the Pliocene-Pleistocen extinction?)
Maíz-Apellániz, ApJ 560, L83 (2001)Berghöfer & Breitschwerdt, A&A 390, 299 (2002)
Benítez, Maíz-Apellániz & Canelles, Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 081101 (2002)
Secondary radioactive nuclei: LISM and local bubble
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
![Page 97: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/97.jpg)
Secondary radioactive nuclei: toy model
Extra parameter: size of the underdense region→ Hole in the thin disc
● Only decay and diffusion● Unbounded diffusion (not sensitive to L)
N.B.: r is the distance, and we now change to (r,z) variables
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
Solution for radioactive species
Calculate
![Page 98: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/98.jpg)
Extra parameter: size of the underdense region→ Hole in the thin disc
● Only decay and diffusion● Unbounded diffusion (not sensitive to L)
N.B.: r is the distance, and we now change to (r,z) variables
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
Solution for radioactive species
Donato et al, A&A 381 (2002) 539
Secondary radioactive nuclei: toy model
![Page 99: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/99.jpg)
Extra parameter: size of the underdense region
● Only decay and diffusion● Unbounded diffusion (not sensitive to L)
N.B.: r is the distance, and we now change to (r,z) variables
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
Solution for radioactive species
Constraintson L
with/without underdense
region
Putze et al., A&A 516 (2010) A66
Secondary radioactive nuclei: toy model
![Page 100: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/100.jpg)
Extra parameter: size of the underdense region
● Only decay and diffusion● Unbounded diffusion (not sensitive to L)
N.B.: r is the distance, and we now change to (r,z) variables
III.5 Radioactive nuclei
Solution for radioactive species
→ CR data point towards rh~ 80 pc → extra parameter rh: prevent lifting D0/L degeneracy
→ D in the underdense region?+ Bad fit Be/B data (nuclear uncertainties?)
Secondary radioactive nuclei: toy model
![Page 101: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/101.jpg)
Transport of cosmic rays (CR) in the Galaxy
III. Solving the transport equations: GCR phenomenology
1. Diffusion: from microphysics to effective models 2. Full set of equations (with source terms)3 (Semi-)Analytical, numerical, & MC solutions4. Stable species: degeneracy K0 /L5. Radioactive species and local ISM6. Leptons and local sources
![Page 102: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/102.jpg)
Solution for primary electrons
III.6 High energy e±
General time-dependent
solution
Syrovatskii, Soviet Astronomy 3 (1959) 22
![Page 103: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/103.jpg)
Solution for primary electrons
III.6 High energy e±
But no datato support
time-dependent behaviour
General time-dependent
solution
Syrovatskii, Soviet Astronomy 3 (1959) 22
![Page 104: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/104.jpg)
Solution for primary electrons
III.6 High energy e±
Syrovatskii, Soviet Astronomy 3 (1959) 22
But no datato support
time-dependent behaviour
General time-dependent
solution
Green function solution (Ansatz: Syrovatskii variable)→ similar variable used to solve propagation of UHECRs in the expanding Universe
Berezinsky & Gazizov, ApJ 643 (2006) 8Alves Batista & Sigl (arXiv:1407.6150)
Synchrotron: B ~ 6 GIC: negligible
![Page 105: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/105.jpg)
High energy electrons : local origin
Origin of high energy electrons (TeV)
D = 0.05 kpc2/Myr × (E/1 GeV)0.5
III.6 High energy e±
Calculate dmax
(1 TeV)
![Page 106: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/106.jpg)
High energy electrons : local origin
Origin of high energy electrons (TeV)
● tIC
~ 0.3 Myr
● dmax
~ (2Dt)1/2
III.6 High energy e±
→ dmax
~ 1 kpc
![Page 107: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/107.jpg)
High energy electrons: single source?
Shen, ApJ 162 (1970) 181
III.6 High energy e±
Origin of high energy electrons (TeV)
● tIC
~ 0.3 Myr
● dmax
~ (2Dt)1/2 → dmax
~ 1 kpc
Singe source and cut-off in HE
spectrum→ very sensitive
to D
![Page 108: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/108.jpg)
High energy electrons: single source?
Shen, ApJ 162 (1970) 181
III.6 High energy e±
Origin of high energy electrons (TeV)
● tIC
~ 0.3 Myr
● dmax
~ (2Dt)1/2 → dmax
~ 1 kpc
Singe source and cut-off in HE
spectrum→ very sensitive
to D
[ = injection spectral index]
Time-dependentsolution for constant D
![Page 109: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/109.jpg)
High energy electrons: single source?
Shen, ApJ 162 (1970) 181
III.6 High energy e±
Procedure (use of 50 pulsars)
Origin of high energy electrons (TeV)
● tIC
~ 0.3 Myr
● dmax
~ (2Dt)1/2 → dmax
~ 1 kpc
Singe source and cut-off in HE
spectrum→ very sensitive
to D
→ sources @ r>1kpc: continuous space-time distribution→ sources @ r<1kpc
[ = injection spectral index]
Time-dependentsolution for constant D
![Page 110: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/110.jpg)
High energy electrons: single source?
Atoyan, Aharonian &Völk, PRD 52 (1995) 3265Electrons and positrons in the galactic cosmic rays
III.6 High energy e±
Origin of high energy electrons (TeV)
→ Apply procedure of Shen (1970)→ More general solutions and analysis
![Page 111: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/111.jpg)
High energy electrons: single source?
Atoyan, Aharonian &Völk, PRD 52 (1995) 3265Electrons and positrons in the galactic cosmic rays
III.6 High energy e±
Origin of high energy electrons (TeV)
Burst-like source Injection slope =2.2Diffusion slope =0.6
→ Apply procedure of Shen (1970)→ More general solutions and analysis
![Page 112: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/112.jpg)
High energy electrons: single source?
Atoyan, Aharonian &Völk, PRD 52 (1995) 3265Electrons and positrons in the galactic cosmic rays
III.6 High energy e±
Origin of high energy electrons (TeV)
Burst-like source Injection slope =2.2Diffusion slope =0.6
Low energy e± have notreached yet the observer
→ Apply procedure of Shen (1970)→ More general solutions and analysis
![Page 113: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/113.jpg)
High energy electrons: single source?
Atoyan, Aharonian &Völk, PRD 52 (1995) 3265Electrons and positrons in the galactic cosmic rays
III.6 High energy e±
Origin of high energy electrons (TeV)
Burst-like source Injection slope =2.2Diffusion slope =0.6
Low energy e± have notreached yet the observer
Balance transport/E losses give slope ~3.1
→ Apply procedure of Shen (1970)→ More general solutions and analysis
![Page 114: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/114.jpg)
High energy electrons: single source?
Atoyan, Aharonian &Völk, PRD 52 (1995) 3265Electrons and positrons in the galactic cosmic rays
III.6 High energy e±
Origin of high energy electrons (TeV)
Burst-like source
Cut-off from energy losses
Injection slope =2.2Diffusion slope =0.6
Low energy e± have notreached yet the observer
Balance transport/E losses give slope ~3.1
→ Apply procedure of Shen (1970)→ More general solutions and analysis
![Page 115: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/115.jpg)
High energy electrons: single source?
Atoyan, Aharonian &Völk, PRD 52 (1995) 3265Electrons and positrons in the galactic cosmic rays
III.6 High energy e±
Origin of high energy electrons (TeV)
Burst-like source Continuous sources
Cut-off from energy losses
Injection slope =2.2Diffusion slope =0.6
Low energy e± have notreached yet the observer
Balance transport/E losses give slope ~3.1
→ Apply procedure of Shen (1970)→ More general solutions and analysis
![Page 116: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/116.jpg)
High energy electrons: single source?
Atoyan, Aharonian &Völk, PRD 52 (1995) 3265Electrons and positrons in the galactic cosmic rays
III.6 High energy e±
Origin of high energy electrons (TeV)
slope ~ ~ 2.2
Burst-like source Continuous sources
Cut-off from energy losses
Injection slope =2.2Diffusion slope =0.6
slope ~~ 2.8Low energy e± have notreached yet the observer
Balance transport/E losses give slope ~3.1
→ Apply procedure of Shen (1970)→ More general solutions and analysis
![Page 117: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/117.jpg)
High energy electrons: single source?
Atoyan, Aharonian &Völk, PRD 52 (1995) 3265Electrons and positrons in the galactic cosmic rays
III.6 High energy e±
Origin of high energy electrons (TeV)
slope ~ ~ 2.2
Burst-like source Continuous sources
Cut-off from energy losses
Injection slope =2.2Diffusion slope =0.6
slope ~~ 2.8Low energy e± have notreached yet the observer
Balance transport/E losses give slope ~3.1 → Main difficulty is to get the
numbers (sources, diffusion) correct
→ Apply procedure of Shen (1970)→ More general solutions and analysis
![Page 118: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/118.jpg)
HE e± spectrum from a single local source
III.6 High energy e±
Age
Propagation parameters
Distance
Source index
Delahaye et al., A&A 524
(2010) A51
![Page 119: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/119.jpg)
Catalog of known nearby SNRs (and pulsars)
III.6 High energy e±
Delahaye et al., A&A 524 (2010) A51
![Page 120: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/120.jpg)
Electron flux from SNRs (<2 kpc)
III.6 High energy e±
Delahaye et al., A&A 524 (2010) A51
![Page 121: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/121.jpg)
III.6 High energy e±
Delahaye et al., A&A 524 (2010) A51
Electron flux from SNRs (<2 kpc)
![Page 122: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/122.jpg)
III.6 High energy e±
Delahaye et al., A&A 524 (2010) A51
Electron flux from SNRs (<2 kpc)
![Page 123: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/123.jpg)
III.6 High energy e±
Delahaye et al., A&A 524 (2010) A51
Full calculation for e±: distant+local contributions
Exact flux difficult to predict because of uncertainties on● Source position/age/spectrum● Transport parameters (D value)● Energy losses (B value/geometry)
![Page 124: Lectures & objectives · ISAPP 2014 (Belgirate) 21-30 July 2014 Transport of cosmic rays in the Galaxy and in the heliosphere (~ 4h30) What is GCR (Galactic Cosmic Ray) physics and](https://reader034.vdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022052020/6034a4f637c7620bce726c17/html5/thumbnails/124.jpg)
« Standard » GCRs : summary and perspectives
Lecture II: processes, ingredients, characteristic times
→ Diffusion coefficient (microphysics) to effective models, GCR phenomenology● secondary stable nuclei: slope of the diffusion coefficient● secondary radioactive nuclei: local value of D0 (but sensitive to LISM)● high energy electrons and positrons: sensitive to local source(s)
Leptons
Nuclei
→ Homogeneous 2-zone diffusion models successfully explain most of the existing data up to the knee (~PeV)
Ongoing/future developments/improvements in the modelling● Phenomenology: space-time granularity, spatial-dependence (D and V)● Improvement on source description (radio/X/-ray observations)
● Spectra (not power-law): time-dependent, source dependent● In the source: secondary production, reacceleration
● Diffusion: use of D//, D
┴, anisotropic diffusion with more realistic B
→ self-consistent description (MHD) of B, CRs, and gas
Lecture III: solving the transport equations and phenomenology
→ Different time scales for nuclei and leptons● Diffusive escape at high energy (>10 GeV/n)● All effects compete @ GeV/n (convection, losses, reacceleration)● E losses dominate at high energy (>10 GeV)● E losses dominate below 100 MeV (ion and coulomb)