lessons from armenia or why brazil’s corruption scandal is ...€¦ · president michel temer of...

3
As we know, financial markets dislike uncertainty. Last Thursday Brazil’s Supreme Court released a plea-bargain testimony accusing President Michel Temer of corruption and obstruction of justice. According to the tape recording, the President allegedly wanted to silence the former speaker of Brazil’s Lower House Eduardo Cuhna. Currently imprisoned, Eduardo Cuhna was giving testimony on the Car Wash Investigation. This has caused the biggest one day sell- off in Brazil risk assets since the US elections in November last year. To us, this news was an opportunity to carefully add risk in Brazil (please see last paragraph for more details). In our view, the news doesn’t change the fundamental and reform outlook for the country. Here is why. A testimony from Joesley Batista, one of the owners of JBS, the largest meatpacker in the world, is detailed and impactful. Joesley and I have had regular meetings during my Brazil trips for the last ten years. I was somewhat surprised to see him as the cause of a major turmoil in the country. Let’s move beyond the headlines. Financial markets can be short-sighted. There are many scenarios of Temer’s departure or non-departure at this stage. No doubt, it will be accompanied by volatility. Can this completely derail the reform agenda? I don’t think so. The reforms are needed and most likely whoever comes next will sustain the reform agenda. During my last trip to Brazil, we were surprised by the unanimous view on the need to approve the pension reform from the government and business circles. In my view, a multi-year anticorruption campaign, while being painful in the short-term, has laid a stronger foundation for the country’s development over the medium-term. This, in my opinion, is what investors should be focused on. To strike a contrast, I want to share with you what happens when corruption and the rule of law become synonymous. Have you heard of a country called Armenia? It’s one of the former CIS republics. Armenia is a beautiful country with three million people, rich cultural and architectural heritage. It has one of the highest literacy rates in the world. Two thirds of the Armenian population or 7 million people live outside the country. Most of the Armenian Diaspora communities came into being as a result of the Armenian genocide in 1915 in Western Armenia, which is now Turkey. Thankfully the list of famous Armenians is not limited to the Kardashians. They range from a French singer Charles Aznavour to American former world tennis champion Andre Agassi. This includes an American singer Cher (Cherilyn Sarkisian), international chess champion Garry Kasparov, American entertainment billionaire Kirk Kerkorian …the list goes on. Lessons from Armenia or Why Brazil’s Corruption Scandal is a Good Thing Polina Kurdyavko, Co-Head of Emerging Markets Joesley Batista and Michel Temer Armenia on the map Yerevan, the capital of Armenia

Upload: others

Post on 28-Jun-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Lessons from Armenia or Why Brazil’s Corruption Scandal is ...€¦ · President Michel Temer of corruption and obstruction of justice. ... There are many scenarios of Temer’s

As we know, financial markets dislike uncertainty. Last Thursday Brazil’s Supreme Court released a plea-bargain testimony accusing President Michel Temer of corruption and obstruction of justice. According to the tape recording, the President allegedly wanted to silence the former speaker of Brazil’s Lower House Eduardo Cuhna. Currently imprisoned, Eduardo Cuhna was giving testimony on the Car Wash Investigation. This has caused the biggest one day sell-off in Brazil risk assets since the US elections in November last year. To us, this news was an opportunity to carefully add risk in Brazil (please see last paragraph for more details). In our view, the news doesn’t change the fundamental and reform outlook for the country. Here is why.

A testimony from Joesley Batista, one of the owners of JBS, the largest meatpacker in the world, is detailed and impactful. Joesley and I have had regular meetings during my Brazil trips for the last ten years. I was somewhat surprised to see him as the cause of a major turmoil in the country.

Let’s move beyond the headlines. Financial markets can be short-sighted. There are many scenarios of Temer’s departure or non-departure at this stage. No doubt, it will be accompanied by volatility. Can this completely derail the reform agenda? I don’t think so. The reforms are needed and most likely whoever comes next will sustain the reform agenda. During my last trip to Brazil, we were surprised by the unanimous view on the need to approve the pension reform from the government and business circles.

In my view, a multi-year anticorruption campaign, while being painful in the short-term, has laid a stronger foundation for the country’s development over the medium-term. This, in my opinion, is what investors should be focused on.

To strike a contrast, I want to share with you what happens when corruption and the rule of law become synonymous. Have you heard of a country called Armenia? It’s one of the former CIS republics. Armenia is a beautiful country with three million people, rich cultural and architectural heritage. It has one of the highest literacy rates in the world. Two thirds of the Armenian population or 7 million people live outside the country. Most of the Armenian Diaspora communities came into being as a result of the Armenian genocide in 1915 in Western Armenia, which is now Turkey.

Thankfully the list of famous Armenians is not limited to the Kardashians. They range from a French singer Charles Aznavour to American former world tennis champion Andre Agassi. This includes an American singer Cher (Cherilyn Sarkisian), international chess champion Garry Kasparov, American entertainment billionaire Kirk Kerkorian …the list goes on.

Lessons from Armenia or Why Brazil’s Corruption Scandal is a Good Thing Polina Kurdyavko, Co-Head of Emerging Markets

Joesley Batista and Michel Temer

Armenia on the map

Yerevan, the capital of Armenia

Page 2: Lessons from Armenia or Why Brazil’s Corruption Scandal is ...€¦ · President Michel Temer of corruption and obstruction of justice. ... There are many scenarios of Temer’s

Lessons from Armenia

Why are Armenian people successful everywhere except for Armenia?I am Russian, of Armenian descent. My husband and I just got back from a trip to Armenia. We are involved in various charitable activities with underprivileged children in the country. The contrast between Armenia’s macro picture and daily reality struck me.

The macroeconomic picture in Armenia looks healthy based on a research note published by Sberbank on 17 May. Strong remittances from Russia, a pick up in exports to Russia and EU, as well as dovish monetary policy should translate into a 3% GDP growth in 2017. The country has mineral resources (copper and precious metals) and fertile climate for agriculture. The government debt to GDP at 58% and the fiscal deficit at 3.5% are not in a worrying territory.

Yet human statistics are striking a different chord. Since 1991, Armenians have been abandoning the country. An average population has fallen by 500,000 citizens over this period to less than 3 million people today. The unemployment rate is over 17%. Over 30% of people live below the poverty line (same as in Venezuela!). 20% of children under five years old have health problems caused by undernourishment.

Armenia has been dealt a heavy hand with geopolitics. The frozen conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan regarding Nagorno-Karabakh, as well as ongoing blockage of Armenia by Turkey made it difficult to develop trade links. Yet this is not the only reason for the harsh living conditions.

Foreign direct investment remains very low at below 1% percent of GDP. In my view, one of the key reasons is corruption. According to Transparency International, the country ranks 113 out of 176 based on the corruption perception index. Armenia is suffering under the thumb of local oligarchs and Russian monopolies. The government doesn’t have any real opposition and legal system is weakened. There are allegations of government officials taking regular cuts from businesses. A local journalist once commented, “It is difficult to find another country in the world, where the ruling party has so many members with mafia-style nicknames”.

Yet, there is hope. Events from an anticorruption scandal in Brazil to Ukraine’s shutdown of PrivatBank owned by one of the richest oligarchs in the country set a precedent and gave hope. Hope for a government that would allow a country to unlock its potential one day.

As we know, financial markets dislike uncertainty. While Armenia appears stable to investors, Brazil is in the midst of turmoil. The Brazilian composer Tom Jobim once said: “Brazil is not for beginners”. We are going through some interesting times. Times that I believe can structurally change the country for years to come. Investors should lengthen their time horizon.

At Bluebay, we are overweight Brazilian credit in Long Only EM credit portfolios. We are currently running a long exposure on our EM credit alternative potfolio. We used last week’s price drop to add to exposure in Brazil. In some portfolios, we have taken partial profits on more liquid names. Needless to say, Brazil requires close monitoring. The team will be visiting Brazil in June. Stay tuned. One of the children’s home that we visited on the trip in the center of Yerevan (entrance,

bathroom, kitchen)

TUMO center in Armenia - state of art digital media learning center

Page 3: Lessons from Armenia or Why Brazil’s Corruption Scandal is ...€¦ · President Michel Temer of corruption and obstruction of justice. ... There are many scenarios of Temer’s

Lessons from Armenia

This document is issued in the United Kingdom (UK) by BlueBay Asset Management LLP (BlueBay), which is authorised and regulated by the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). BlueBay is also registered with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and is a member of the National Futures Association (NFA) as authorised by the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). This document may also be issued in the United States by BlueBay Asset Management USA LLC which is registered with the SEC and the NFA. In Japan, by BlueBay Asset Management International Limited which is registered with the Kanto Local Finance Bureau of Ministry of Finance, Japan. In Switzerland, by BlueBay Asset Management AG where the Representative and Paying Agent is BNP Paribas Securities Services, Paris, succursale de Zurich, Selnaustrasse 16, 8002 Zurich, Switzerland. The place of performance is at the registered office of the Representative. The courts of the registered office of the Swiss representative shall have jurisdiction pertaining to claims in connection with the distribution of the Shares in Switzerland. In Australia, BlueBay is exempt from the requirement to hold an Australian financial services licence under the Corporations Act in respect of financial services as it is regulated by the FCA under the laws of the UK which differ from Australian laws. In Canada, BlueBay is not registered under securities laws and is relying on the international dealer exemption under applicable provincial securities legislation, which permit BlueBay to carry out certain specified dealer activities for those Canadian residents that qualify as “a Canadian permitted client”, as such term is defined under applicable securities legislation. The registrations and memberships noted should not be interpreted as an endorsement or approval of any of the BlueBay entities identified by the respective licensing or registering authorities. Unless otherwise stated, all data has been sourced by BlueBay. To the best of BlueBay’s knowledge and belief this document is true and accurate at the date hereof. BlueBay makes no express or implied warranties or representations with respect to the information contained in this document and hereby expressly disclaim all warranties of accuracy, completeness or fitness for a particular purpose. The document is intended only for “professional clients” and “eligible counterparties” (as defined by the FCA) or in the US by “accredited investors” (as defined in the Securities Act of 1933) or “qualified purchasers” (as defined in the Investment Company Act of 1940) as applicable and should not be relied upon by any other category of customer. This document does not constitute an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to purchase any security or investment product in any jurisdiction and is for information purposes only. This document is not available for distribution in any jurisdiction where such distribution would be prohibited and is not aimed at such persons in those jurisdictions. Except where agreed explicitly in writing, BlueBay does not provide investment or other advice and nothing in this document constitutes any advice, nor should be interpreted as such. No BlueBay Fund will be offered, except pursuant and subject to the offering memorandum and subscription materials. This document is for general information only and is

not a complete description of an investment in any BlueBay Fund. If there is an inconsistency between this document and the offering materials for the BlueBay Fund, the provisions in the Offering Materials shall prevail. Past performance is not indicative of future results. The investments discussed may fluctuate in value and investors may not get back the amount invested. You should read the offering materials carefully before investing in any BlueBay fund. Gross performance figures reflect the reinvestment of all dividends and earnings, but do not reflect the deduction of fees and expenses. Net performance figures reflect the reinvestment of all dividends and earnings, and the deduction of fees and expenses. A description of the specific fee structure is contained in the fund’s prospectus. The fund return will be reduced by the deduction of the applicable fees. No part of this document may be reproduced in any manner without the prior written permission of BlueBay. In the United States, this document may be provided by RBC Global Asset Management (U.S.) Inc. (“RBC GAM-US”), an SEC registered investment adviser. In Hong Kong, this document may be provided by RBC Investment Management (Asia) Limited, which is registered with the Securities and Futures Commission. RBC Global Asset Management (RBC GAM) is the asset management division of Royal Bank of Canada (RBC) which includes BlueBay, RBC GAM-US, RBC Alternative Asset Management Inc., RBC Investment Management (Asia) Limited and RBC Global Asset Management Inc., which are separate, but affiliated corporate entities. Copyright 2017 © BlueBay, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of RBC and BlueBay may be considered to be related and/or connected to RBC and its other affiliates. ® Registered trademark of RBC. RBC GAM is a trademark of RBC. BlueBay Asset Management LLP, registered office 77 Grosvenor Street, London W1K 3JR, partnership registered in England and Wales number OC370085. All rights reserved.

FOR INSTITUTIONAL INVESTOR USE ONLY. All material presented is compiled from sources believed to be reliable and current, but accuracy cannot be guaranteed. This is not to be construed as an offer to buy or sell any financial instruments. It is not our intention to state, indicate or imply in any manner that current or past results are indicative of future profitability or expectations. The views expressed herein are those of BlueBay Asset Management LLP as of 5.23.17. Views are subject to change at any time based on market or other conditions.RBC Global Asset Management (RBC GAM) is the asset management division of Royal Bank of Canada (RBC) and comprises the following affiliates, all of which are indirect wholly owned subsidiaries of RBC: RBC Global Asset Management (U.S.) Inc. (RBC GAM-US), RBC Global Asset Management Inc., RBC Global Asset Management (UK) Limited (RBC GAM-UK), BlueBay Asset Management LLP, BlueBay Asset Management USA LLC and the asset management division of RBC Investment Management (Asia) Limited. ®/™ Trademark(s) of Royal Bank of Canada. Used under license. © 2017 RBC Global Asset Management (U.S.) Inc.

RBC Global Asset Management (U.S.) Inc.Minneapolis | Boston | Chicago

800.553.2143 | us.rbcgam.com