list of cases of supreme court of india, · pdf fileapp. 1—list of cases of supreme...

143
239 APPENDIX 1 LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, 2011 ARBITRATION Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation 1. A.P.S. Kushwaha (SSI Unit) v. Municipal Corporation and Ors. (17.02.2011) Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Sections 11, 11(6) & 34. AIR 2011 SC 1935, 2011(2) ARBLR 452 (SC), (2011) 2 CompLJ 10 (SC), 2011(2) SCALE 627. 2. B.D. Sharma Firm v. Western Coalfields Limited (20.07.2011) Arbitration Act, 1940 Sections 30 & 33. ILR[2011]MP2312. 3. Bharat Rasiklal Ashra v. Gautam Rasiklal Ashra and Anr. (25.08.2011) Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 11. AIR 2011 SC 3562, (2011) 4 CompLJ 1 (SC), JT 2011(10) SC 1, 2011(9) SCALE 457. 4. Board of Control for Cricket in India v. World Sports Group (I) P. Ltd. (21.04.2011) Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Sections 9 & 11. 2011(5) SCALE 19. 5. Booz Allen and Hamilton Inc. v. SBI Home Finance Ltd. and Ors. (15.04.2011) Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Sections 8, 8(1), 11, 34, 34(2), 48(2). Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985. AIR 2011 SC 2507, 2011(2) ARBLR 155 (SC), JT 2011(5) SC 198, 2011(5) SCALE 147, (2011) 5 SCC 532. Specific Relief Act, 1963. Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Sections 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 97 & 99. Code of Civil Procedure Section 94 & 96; Order 8 Rule 1, Order 34 Rule 1 & Order 34 Rule 4(1) & (2). Arbitration and Conciliation Ordinance 1996. Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Sections 2(2), 11, 11(5) & 11(9). 6. Cauvery Coffee Traders, Mangalore v. Hornor Resources (Intern.) Company Ltd. (13.09.2011) Indian Partnership Act, 1932. 2011(4) ARBLR 1 (SC), (2011) 4 CompLJ 241 (SC), 2011(10) SCALE 419. 7. Deutsche Post Bank Home Finance Ltd. v. Taduri Sridhar and Anr. (29.03.2011) Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Sections 7, 8 & 11. AIR 2011 SC 1899, 2011(2) ARBLR 1 (SC), (2011) 2 CompLJ 542 (SC), JT 2011(4) SC 45, (2011) 7 MLJ 385 (SC), 2011(4) SCALE 33, (2011) 11 SCC 375

Upload: buituong

Post on 06-Mar-2018

280 views

Category:

Documents


6 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

239

APPENDIX 1

LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, 2011National L aw U niversity, Delhi

App. 1—List of C ases of Supreme C ourt of I ndia, 2011

ARBITRATION

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

1. A.P.S. Kushwaha (SSI Unit)v. Municipal Corporationand Ors. (17.02.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 11, 11(6) &34.

AIR 2011 SC 1935, 2011(2)ARBLR 452 (SC), (2011) 2CompLJ 10 (SC), 2011(2)SCALE 627.

2. B.D. Sharma Firm v.Western Coalfields Limited(20.07.2011)

Arbitration Act, 1940 Sections30 & 33.

ILR[2011]MP2312.

3. Bharat Rasiklal Ashra v.Gautam Rasiklal Ashra andAnr. (25.08.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Section 11.

AIR 2011 SC 3562, (2011) 4CompLJ 1 (SC), JT 2011(10) SC1, 2011(9) SCALE 457.

4. Board of Control for Cricketin India v. World SportsGroup (I) P. Ltd.(21.04.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 9 & 11.

2011(5) SCALE 19.

5. Booz Allen and HamiltonInc. v. SBI Home FinanceLtd. and Ors. (15.04.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 8, 8(1), 11,34, 34(2), 48(2).

Sick Industrial Companies(Special Provisions) Act, 1985.

AIR 2011 SC 2507, 2011(2)ARBLR 155 (SC), JT 2011(5) SC198, 2011(5) SCALE 147,(2011) 5 SCC 532.

Specific Relief Act, 1963.

Transfer of Property Act, 1882Sections 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90,97 & 99.

Code of Civil Procedure Section94 & 96; Order 8 Rule 1, Order34 Rule 1 & Order 34 Rule 4(1)& (2).

Arbitration and ConciliationOrdinance 1996.

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 2(2), 11,11(5) & 11(9).

6. Cauvery Coffee Traders,Mangalore v. HornorResources (Intern.) CompanyLtd. (13.09.2011)

Indian Partnership Act, 1932.

2011(4) ARBLR 1 (SC), (2011) 4CompLJ 241 (SC), 2011(10)SCALE 419.

7. Deutsche Post Bank HomeFinance Ltd. v. TaduriSridhar and Anr.(29.03.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 7, 8 & 11.

AIR 2011 SC 1899, 2011(2)ARBLR 1 (SC), (2011) 2CompLJ 542 (SC), JT 2011(4)SC 45, (2011) 7 MLJ 385 (SC),2011(4) SCALE 33, (2011) 11SCC 375

Page 2: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

240 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

8. Durga Charan Rautray v.State of Orissa and Anr.(01.11.2011)

Interest Act, 1978 ArbitrationAct, 1940 Sections 30, 33 & 39.

2011(4) ARBLR 97 (SC), JT2011(12) SC 275, 2011(2)SCALE 316

9. Fuerst Day Lawson Ltd. andOrs. Etc. v. Jindal ExportsLtd. and Ors. (08.07.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 2, 3, 4(2), 5,7, 8, 37, 37(1), 44, 45, 46, 47,49, 50, 85 & 86.

2011(3) ARBLR 82 (SC), JT2011(7) SC 469, 2011(6) MhLJ803, 2011(7) SCALE 513,(2011) 8 SCC 333.

Delhi High Court Act, 1996Section 10.

Specific Relief Act, 1963 Sections6 & 6(3).

Trade Marks Act, 1940-Sections76, 76(1) & 77.

Arbitration Act, 1940 Sections14, 15, 16, 17, 26, 29, 30, 39,39(1), 39(2), 47 & 48.

Government of India Act 1915Section 108.

Land Acquisition Act, 1894Sections 26 & 54.

Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958Sections 39& 43.

Indian Succession Act, 1925Section 299.

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988Section 140.

Government of India Act, 1935Section 223.

Arbitration Act 1899.

Arbitration (Protocol andConvention) Act 1937.

Foreign Awards (Recognitionand Enforcement) Act, 1961-Sections 3, 4(1), 6, 6(1) & 6(2).

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Sections 2, 4, 89, 104, 104(1),104(2), 104(4) & 588.

Constitution of India-Article 136& 225.

Code of Civil Procedure 1877Section 588.

10. India Industrial GrowthFund Limited v. NesanuruDoraswamy and Ors.(09.05.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 9, 11, 11(6)& 11(12).

2011(6) SCALE 446.

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996-Section 11.

11. Indian Oil Corporation Ltd.v. SPS Engineering Ltd.(03.02.2011)

Limitation Act, 1963.

AIR 2011 SC 987, 2011(1)ARBLR 373 (SC), (2011) 2CompLJ 19 (SC), 2011(4) MhLJ10 (SC), (2011) 4 MLJ 174 (SC),2011(2) SCALE 291, (2011) 3SCC 507, [2011] 2 SCR 512.

Page 3: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 241

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

12. J.G. Engineers Pvt. Ltd. v.Union of India (UOI) andAnr. (28.04.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996-Sections 28(1), 28(3),34 & 34(2).

AIR 2011 SC 2477, 2011(2)ARBLR 84 (SC), JT 2011(5) SC380, 2011(5) SCALE 46, (2011)5 SCC 758.

13. Khiviraj Motors v. TheGuanellian Society(04.07.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996-Section 11

2011(4) ARBLR 123 (SC),2011(4) PLJR 35, 2011(7)SCALE 46.

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 34 & 36.

14. Leela Hotels Ltd. v. Housingand Urban DevelopmentCorporation Ltd.(15.11.2011)

Contract Act, 1872 Sections 59& 60.

2011(12) SCALE 573

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 8, 31(7), 34,34(2) & 37(1)(A).

Indian Tolls Act, 1851.

15. MSK Projects (I) (JV) Ltd. v.State of Rajasthan and Anr.(21.07.2011)

Rajasthan Motor VehiclesTaxation (Amendment) Act,1994.

AIR 2011 SC 2979, 2011(3)ARBLR 119 (SC), 2011 5 AWC5076 SC, (2011) 3 CompLJ 481(SC), JT 2011(8) SC 37, 2011(7)SCALE 694.

Interest Act, 1978Section 3.

Contract Act, 1972 Sections 73& 74.

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Order 8 Rule 5.

Arbitration Act, 1940-Sections 8,14(2), 20, 30, 31, 31(4), 33, 34,42 & 43.

16. Milkfood Pvt. Ltd. v. GMCIce Cream (P) Ltd.(04.08.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Section 27.

2011(3) ARBLR 397 (SC),2011(59) BLJR 2403, 2011(3)KLT (SN) 111, (2011) 7 MLJ812 (SC), 2011(8) SCALE 233.

Code of Civil Procedure -Section115 & Order 7 Rule 10.

17. Oil and Natural GasCorporation Ltd. v. Off-Shore Enterprises Inc.(23.02.2011)

Arbitration Act, 1940 ContractAct, 1872.

2011(4) SCALE 45.

18. Omnia Technologies P. Ltd.v. W.M.A. Van Loosbroek(03.03.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 11(6) &11(9).

2011(1) ARBLR 520 (SC),(2011) 2 CompLJ 14 (SC),2011(3) SCALE 176, (2011) 3SCC 682.

19. P. R. Shah, Shares and StockBroker (P) Ltd. v. B.H.H.Securities (P) Ltd. and Ors.(14.10.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996-Sections 8, 34 &34(2).

2011(4) ARBLR 128 (SC), JT2011(12) SC 290, 2011(11)SCALE 668.

20. Phulchand Exports Ltd. v.OOO Patriot (12.10.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 34, 47 & 48.

JT 2011(12) SC 138, 2011(11)SCALE 475.

Registration Act, 1908 Sections17, 17(1), 17(2) & 49.

Arbitration Act, 1940 Sections14, 17, 30, 32 & 33.

21. Ramesh Kumar and An. v.Furu Ram and Anr. etc.(18.08.2011)

Indian Contract Act, 1872Section 17.

2011(3) ARBLR 477 (SC), JT2011(9) SC 505, 2011(6) MhLJ842, 2011(9) SCALE 16, (2011)8 SCC 613.

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955Section 12.

Page 4: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

242 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Stamp Act.

Indian Evidence Act, 1872Section 114.

Indian Registration Act, 1866,1871 & 1877.

22. Reva Electric Car CompanyP. Ltd. v. Green Mobil(25.11.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996-Sections 9, 11, 11(4),11(5), 11(6), 11(9) & 16(1).

2011(13) SCALE 169.

23. Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996-Sections 7, 8, 11,16(1) & 17.

SMS Tea Estates Pvt. Ltd. v.Chandmari Tea CompanyPvt. Ltd. (20.07.2011)

Transfer of Property Act, 1882Sections 106 & 107.

2011(4) ARBLR 265 (SC),(2011) 3 CompLJ 666 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 455, 2011(3) KLT(SN) 69, 2011(7) SCALE 747.

Registration Act, 1908-Sections17, 17(1) & 49.

Indian Stamp Act, 1899 Sections33, 35, 38 & 40.

Specific Relief Act, 1877.

Indian Contract Act, 1872Section 19.

24. Shipping Corporation ofIndia Ltd. v. Mare ShippingInc. (13.07.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Section 34.

2011(3) ARBLR 281 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 188, 2011(7) SCALE597, (2011) 8 SCC 39.

Contract Act Sections 73 & 74.

Maritime Arbitration Rules.

25. State of Goa v. PraveenEnterprises (04.07.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 2, 2(9), 8, 11,11(2), 11(3), 11(4), 11(5), 11(6),11(9), 21, 23, 23(3), 25, 32(2),34 & 43.

2011(3) ARBLR 209 (SC), 20114 AWC 3918 SC, 112(2011)CLT 659 (SC), JT 2011(8) SC359, (2011) 7 MLJ 775 (SC),2011(7) SCALE 131.

Arbitration Act, 1940 Section20.

Limitation Act, 1963 Section 3,3(2), 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12,13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20,21, 22, 23, 24, 43, 43(1) &43(2).

Arbitration Act, 1889. Section 4.

26. State of Orissa and Ors. v.Bhagyadhar Dash(04.07.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996-Section 11.

AIR 2011 SC 3409, 2011(3)ARBLR 139 (SC), [2011(3) JCR220 (SC) ], JT 2011(7) SC 283,2011(4) PLJR 69, 2011(7)SCALE 71, (2011) 7 SCC 406.

Arbitration Act, 1940-Section 7,11, 16 & 20.

27. State of U.P. and Ors. v.Combined ChemicalsCompany Private Limited(04.01.2011)

Sale of Goods Act, 1930 Sections5, 5(1) & 5(2).

2011(1) ARBLR 91 (SC), JT2011(1) SC 179, 2011(1) SCALE85, (2011) 2 SCC 151.

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Section 7 & 11(4).

Constitution of India Article299.

Page 5: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 243

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

28. Suresh Dhanuka v. SunitaMohapatra (02.12.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 9 & 17.

2011(3) SCALE 315.

Trade and Merchandise MarksAct, 1958.

Trade Marks Act, 1999 Sections134 & 135.

Specific Relief Act, 1963-Sections 41 & 42.

Contract Act, 1872 Section 27.

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 31, 31(1),31(5), 32, 33, 33(1), 33(4), 34,34(1), 34(2), 34(3) & 34(5).

29. The State of Maharashtraand Ors. v. Ark Builders Pvt.Ltd. (28.02.2011)

Bihar Building (Lease Rent andEviction) Control Act, 1947Section 18(1).

Bihar House Rent Control Order1942 Section 14.

AIR 2011 SC 1374, 2011(1)ARBLR 512 (SC), 2011 3 AWC2919 SC, 2011(3) BomCR 48,[2011] 101 CLA 324 (SC),(2011) 2 CompLJ 137 (SC),2011(3) CTC 777, 2011-3-LW177, 2011(2) RCR (Civil) 598,RLW 2011(3) SC 1908, 2011(3)SCALE 20, (2011) 4 SCC 616.

Limitation Act, 1963 Schedule-Article 119 Arbitration Act,1940-Sections 14 & 17.

30. Union of India (UOI) andAnr. v. Deepak Electric andTrading Company and Anr.(20.10.2011)

Code of Civil Procedure-Section79.

2011(4) ARBLR 104 (SC), 183(2011) DLT 475 (SC), 2011(2)SCALE 139.

31. Union of India (UOI) andOrs. v. Master ConstructionCo. (25.04.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 11 & 11(6).

2011(2) ARBLR 105 (SC),(2011) 2 CompLJ 520 (SC), JT2011(5) SC 244, 2011(5) MhLJ835 (SC), 2011(5) SCALE 165.

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Section 34 & 37.

32. Union of India (UOI) v. Col.L. S. N. Murthy and Anr.(23.11.2011)

Contract Act 1892 Sections 23& 70.

JT 2011(13) SC 258, 2011(13)SCALE 67.

Specific Relief Acts.

Constitution of India Articles 13,13(3), 136 & 368.

Arbitration Act, 1940-Sections 3,29 & 41.

Interest Act, 1839.

33. Union of India (UOI) v.Krafters Engineering andLeasing (P) Ltd.(12.07.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996-Sections 31(7) &37(1). Code of Civil Procedure -Section 34.

2011(3) ARBLR 153 (SC),2011(4) MPLJ 1, 2011(7)SCALE 405, (2011) 7 SCC 279.

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996-Section 2(1), 2(2),2(3), 2(4), 2(5), 2(7), 5, 9, 11(6)34, 36, 48, 49 & 59.

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Order 7 Rule 11.

34. Videocon Industries Limitedv. Union of India (UOI) andAnr. (11.05.2011)

Indian Arbitration Act, 1940-Section 9.

AIR 2011 SC 2040, 2011(2)ARBLR 180 (SC), (2011) 4CompLJ 256 (SC), JT 2011(6)SC 261, 2011(5) SCALE 678,(2011) 6 SCC 161.

35. Yograj Infrastructure Ltd. v.SSANGYONG Engineeringand Construction CompanyLtd. (15.12.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 9 & 17.

2011(13) SCALE 526.

Page 6: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

244 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

International Arbitration Act,2002.

Supreme Court Rules, 1966Order 13 Rule 3.

Companies Act, 1956Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996 Sections 2(2), 9, 17,34, 37, 37(2) & 42.

36. Yograj Infrastructure Ltd. v.Ssang Yong Engineering andConstruction Co. Ltd.(01.09.2011)

Indian Arbitration Act, 1940.

AIR 2011 SC 3517, 2011(4)ARBLR 82 (SC), JT 2011(10) SC588, 2011(9) SCALE 567,(2011) 9 SCC 735.

BANKING LAW

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Anil Sachar and Anr. v. ShreeNath Spinners P. Ltd. andOrs. etc. (17.08.2011)

Negotiable Instruments Act-Section 138.

2011(12) SCALE 655.

Negotiable Instruments Act-Section 138 & 139.

Indian Penal Code-Section 406& 420.

2. Anil Sachar and Anr. v. ShreeNath Spinners P. Ltd. andOrs. etc. (19.07.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 235(2).

(2011) 3 CompLJ 654 (SC),2011(3) Crimes 142 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 586, 2011(3) KLJ444, 2011(3) KLT (SN) 71,2011(7) SCALE 730.

Negotiable Instruments Act,1881-Section 138, 141, 141(1)& 141(2).

Banking Public FinancialInstitutions and NegotiableInstruments Laws (Amendment)Act, 1988.

Companies Act, 1956 – Sections2(24), 5, 303(1) & 303(2).

3. Harshendra Kumar D. v.Rebatilata Koley Etc.(08.02.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 397, 401 & 482.

AIR 2011 SC 1090, 2011(59)BLJR 325, [2011] 101 CLA 330(SC), [2011] 162 CompCas 247(SC), 2011 CriLJ 1626, 2011(1)Crimes 280 (SC), 2011(3) PLJR100, 2011(2) SCALE 278,(2011) 3 SCC 351, (2011) 1 SCC(Cri) 1139, [2011] 2 SCR 670.

Industrial Reconstruction Bankof India Act, 1984-Sections 2,3(1), 18, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40,41,42, 43, 44, 45, 46,47,48, 49,50 & 51.

Industrial Reconstruction Bank(Transfer of Undertaking andRepeal) Act, 1997-Sections 3, 4,4(4), 13 & 13(2).

4. Industrial Investment Bankof India Ltd. v. Jain CablesPvt. Ltd. and Ors.(05.01.2011)

Transfer of Property Act, 1882-Section 69. Companies Act.

AIR 2011 SC 658, JT 2011(1)SC 26, (2011) 1 MLJ 552 (SC),2011(1) SCALE 61, (2011) 2SCC 218, [2011] 1 SCR 82.

Tamil Nadu Protection ofInterests of Depositors (inFinancial Establishments) Act,1997-Section 3 & 4.

5. K. K. Baskaran v. State rep.by its Secretary, Tamil Naduand Ors. (04.03.2011)

Maharashtra Protection ofInterests of Depositors (inFinancial Establishments) Act,1999.

AIR 2011 SC 1485, JT 2011(3)SC 201, 2011(3) MhLJ 955,2011(3) SCALE 380, (2011) 3SCC 793.

Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934.

Page 7: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 245

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Banking Regulation Act, 1949-Section 5.

Companies Act, 1956-Section58A & 58AA.

Criminal Law (Amendment)Ordinance, 1944.

Criminal Law (Tamil NaduAmendment) Act, 1977.

Tamil Nadu Protection ofInterests of Depositors (inFinancial Establishments)(Amendment) Act, 2003-Section2.

Tamil Nadu Protection ofInterest of Depositors (inFinancial Establishments) Act,1977.

Constitution of India-Article 14,19(1) & 21.

6. Narayana Chandra Ghosh v.UCO Bank and Ors.(18.03.2011)

Securitization andReconstruction of FinancialAssets and Enforcement ofSecurity Interest Act, 2002-Sections 13(2), 17, 18 & 18(1).

AIR 2011 SC 1913, [2011] 102CLA 260 (SC), [2011] 163CompCas 278 (SC), (2011) 2CompLJ 208 (SC), JT 2011(4)SC 9, 2011(4) MhLJ 529 (SC),2011(4) SCALE 93, (2011) 4SCC 548.

COMMERCIAL LAW

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Mines and Minerals(Development and Regulation)Act, 1957-Section 4(1) & 21.

Indian Penal Code-Section 379.

1. B.R. Surendranath Singh v.Deputy Director,Department of Mines andGeology, Karnataka andOrs. (11.04.2011)

Code of Criminal ProcedureSection 482.

AIR 2011 SC 1679, 2011(4)KCCR SN 361, 2011(4) SCALE531, (2011) 5 SCC 449.

Minor Concession Rules 1960-Rule 24A & 24(A) (6).

Constitution of India-Article136.

Burmah Shell (Acquisition ofUndertakings in India) Act,1976-Section 7.

2. Bharat PetroleumCorporation Ltd. v.Chembur Service Station(02.03.2011)

Maharashtra Rent Control Act,1999-Sections 7(5), 7(15), 25, 26& 29.

112(2011) CLT 478 (SC), JT2011(3) SC 1, (2011) 3 MLJ 154(SC), 2011(4) SCALE 209,(2011) 3 SCC 710.

Essential Commodities Act,1955.

Bombay Rents Hotel andLodging House Rates (Control)Act, 1947-Sections 5(4A), 5(11),15, 15(1) & 15A.

Indian Easements Act, 1882-Section 52.

Page 8: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

246 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Transfer of Property Act-Section105 & 108.

Indian Contract Act, 1872-Section 202, 205 & 221.

Public Premises (Eviction ofUnauthorised Occupant) Act,1971.

Petroleum Act, 1934.

Public Premises (Eviction ofUnauthorised Occupants)(Amendment) Act, 1980Companies Act, 1956-Section 3.

Bombay Municipal CorporationAct-Section 314.

Constitution of India-Article 12& 14.

Maharashtra CooperativeSocieties Act, 1960.

3. AIR ports Authority of IndiaAct, 1994-Sections 3, 11, 12,12A, 12A (1), 12A (4), 22, 22A,38 & 39.

JT 2011(5) SC 221, 2011(5)SCALE 193, (2011) 5 SCC 360.

Consumer OnlineFoundation, etc. v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Ors., etc.(26.04.2011)

AIR ports Authority of India(Amendment) Act, 2003.

AIR ports Economic RegulatoryAuthority of India Act, 2008-Section 2 & 13(1).

General Clauses Act, 1897-Section 6.

Bombay Agricultural ProduceMarkets Act, 1939-Section 11.

Bombay Municipalities Act1901-Section 60.

Companies Act, 1956.

Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948-Section 46(1) & 70.

Road Transport CorporationsAct, 1950-Section 45(1).

Wealth Tax Act, 1957-Section7(1).

Constitution of India-Article265.

4. Glodyne Technoserve Ltd. v.State of M.P. and Ors.(04.04.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 32,136 & 226.

AIR 2011 SC 2574, JT 2011(4)SC 404, 2011(4) SCALE 229,(2011) 5 SCC 103.

5. Haryana State AgriculturalMarketing Board and Anr. v.Raj Pal (10.02.2011)

Haryana State AgriculturalMarketing Board (Sale ofImmovable Property) Rules,1997-Rules 4, 4(5), 5, 12(3) &12(3A).

AIR 2011 SC 1394, III (2011)CPJ 20 (SC), 2011(4) SCALE209(1).

6. Hussnain International v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (21.02.2011)

Foreign Trade (Development andRegulation) Act, 1992-Section11(2) & 15(1).

2011(265) ELT 24 (SC), JT2011(2) SC 303, 2011(2) SCALE658, [2011] 106 SCL 235 (SC) .

Page 9: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 247

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

7. Industrial Promotion andInvestment Corporation ofOrissa Limited v. TuobroFurguson Steels PrivateLimited and Ors.(05.12.2011)

State Financial Corporation Act,1951-Section 29.

2011(3) SCALE 294.

Karnataka Industrial AreaDevelopment Act, 1966-Section13, 41 & 41(2).

8. Karnataka Industrial AreasDevelopment Board andAnr. v. Prakash Dal Mill andOrs. (06.04.2011)

Karnataka Industrial AreaDevelopment Rules.

AIR 2011 SC 1570, JT 2011(4)SC 215, 2011(4) SCALE 306,(2011) 6 SCC 714.

Constitution of India-Article 12,14 & 226.

Karnataka Industrial AreaDevelopment Board Regulations,1969-Regulations 7 & 10.

State Financial CorporationsAct, 1951-Sections 3, 10, 29 &31.

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.

9. Kerala Financial Corporationv. Vincent Paul and Anr.(14.03.2011)

State Financial CorporationsRules.

AIR 2011 SC 1388, 2011(3)ALLMR (SC) 964, (2011) 2CompLJ 531 (SC), 2011(6) CTC554, JT 2011(3) SC 421, PLJR122, 2011(3) SCALE 520,(2011) 4 SCC 171.

Uttar Pradesh Krishi UtpadanMandi Adhiniyam, 1964 –Sections 2, 9, 9(1), 9(2), 17 &37.

10. Krishi Utpadan MandiSamiti, Allahabad v.Baidyanath Ayurved Bhawan(Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.(11.08.2011)

Indian Companies Act, 1956.

2011(9) SCALE 111.

Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940.

Uttar Pradesh Krishi UtpadanMandi Niyamavali, 1965-Rule70.

Karnataka Agricultural ProduceMarketing (Regulation) Act,1966.

Andhra Pradesh General SalesTax Act, 1950.

Madhya Pradesh Krishi UpajMandi Adhiniyam, 1973.

11. Larsen and Toubro Ltd. andAnr. v. Union of India (UOI)and Ors. (05.05.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 14. AIR 2011 SC 2194, JT 2011(6)SC 1, 2011(5) SCALE 335,(2011) 5 SCC 430.

12. State of Haryana and Ors. v.Malik Traders (17.08.2011)

Indian Contract Act, 1872-Section 5.

AIR 2011 SC 3574, 2011 52011(4) KLT (SN) 20, 2011(9)SCALE 1.

13. State of U.P. and Ors. v.Narender Pal Singh(11.02.2011)

Constitution of India-Article226.

2011 2 AWC 1900 SC.

Standards of Weights andMeasures Act, 1976-Section 73.

14. The State of Maharashtraand Ors. v. Raj Marketingand Anr. (26.08.2011)

Standards of Weights andMeasures (Enforcement) Act,1985-Section 65.

AIR 2011 SC 3556, 2011(9)SCALE 469.

Page 10: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

248 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Standards of Weights andMeasures (PackagedCommodities) Rules, 1977-Rule2, 6, 23 (1), 29, 33 & 39.

State Excise Act TelecomRegulatory Authority of IndiaAct, 1997-Sections 2, 18, 11(1),14, 14(1) & 18.

15. Union of India (UOI) andAnr. v. Association ofUnified Telecom ServiceProviders of India and Ors.(11.10.2011)

Indian Tolls Act, 1851-Section 2.

2011(2) SCALE 24.

Indian Telegraph Act, 1885-Sections 2, 4, 4(1) & 4(2).

Telecom Regulatory Authority ofIndia (Amendment) Act, 2000.

Constitution of India-Articles 14,19(1), 32, 136 & 226.

COMPANY LAW

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Companies Act, 1956-Section178.

Major Port Trusts Act, 1963-Sections 42(3) & 111.

1. APM Terminals B.V. v.Union of India (UOI) andAnr. (11.05.2011)

Indian Ports Act, 1908.

II (2011) BC 681, 2011(4)BomCR 10, JT 2011(6) SC 289,2011(3) KLT (SN) 17, (2011) 6MLJ 176 (SC), 2011(6) SCALE271, (2011) 6 SCC 756.

Electricity Act, 2003-Section79(1).

Constitution of India-Article 14.

Companies Act, 1956-Sections4A, 4A (1) & 4A (2).

Securitisation andReconstruction of FinancialAssets and Enforcement ofSecurity Interest Act, 2002-Section 2(1).

Industrial Finance CorporationAct, 1948-Section 3.

2. Bharat Steel Tubes Ltd. etc.v. IFCI Ltd. and Ors.(04.04.2011)

Industrial Finance Corporation(Transfer of Undertaking andRepeal) Act, 1993-Section 1, 4,4(2), 4(3), 4(5) & 5.

AIR 2011 SC 2568, 2011 5AWC 4564 SC, [2011] 102 CLA119 (SC), [2011] 163 CompCas283 (SC), (2011) 2 CompLJ 201(SC), [2011(3) JCR 53 (SC) ], JT2011(4) SC 414, 2011(3) KCCRSN 325, 2011-4-LW 845,2011(4) SCALE 294, [2011] 107SCL 199 (SC) .

Textile Undertakings (TakingOver of Management) Act,1983.

Companies Act, 1913.

3. Custodian of TextilesUndertaking, Bombay v.Hall and Anderson Ltd. andOrs. (17.01.2011)

Textile UndertakingNationalisation Act, 1995-Sec-tion 8.

JT 2011(3) SC 275, 2011(2)KCCR SN 139, 2011(1) SCALE511, (2011) 11 SCC 390, [2011]2 SCR 134.

Companies Act, 1961.

Swadeshi Cotton Mills(Acquisition and Transfer ofUndertaking) Act, 1986-Section3 & 3 (1).

Page 11: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 249

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Constitution of India-Article 39B& 39C.

4. Electronics Corporation ofIndia Ltd. v. Union of India(UOI) and Ors. (17.02.2011)

Companies Act, 1956 CentralExcise Act, 1944-Section 4(1)Central Excise Act, 1944-Section4(4) Central Excise Valuation(Determination of Price ofExcisable Goods) Rules, 2000-Rule 7.

(2011) 238 CTR (SC) 353,2011(184) ECR 193 (SC),2011(265) ELT 11 (SC), [2011]332 ITR 58 (SC), JT 2011(6) SC372, 2011(2) SCALE 494,(2011) 3 SCC 404, (2011) 1 SCC(L& S) 514, [2011] 2 SCR 971,2011 [21] STR 593, (2011) 39VST 1 (SC) .

5. Employees Provident FundCommissioner v. O.L. ofEsskay PharmaceuticalsLimited (08.11.2011)

Employees’ Provident Funds andMiscellaneous Provisions Act,1952-Section 2, 7A, 8F, 11,11(1), 11(2), 13B, 14B, 15(2), 17& 17(6).

JT 2011(13) SC 104, 2011(12)SCALE 479.

Companies Act, 1956-Section442, 528, 529, 529(1), 529(2),529(3), 529A, 529A(1),529A(2), 529A(8), 530, 530(1),531, 532, 533, 534, 535, 536,537, 538, 539, 540, 541, 542,543, 544, 545, 546, 547, 548,549, 550, 551, 552, 553, 554,555, 556, 557, 558, 559 & 560.

Employee’s State Insurance Act,1948-Section 94 PresidencyTowns Insolvency Act, 1909-Section 49.

Provincial Insolvency Act, 1920-Section 45, 46, 47, 47(2), 48, 49,50 & 61.

Companies Act, 1913-Section230.

Companies (Amendment) Act,1985.

Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.

Madhya Pradesh General SalesTax Act, 1958-Section 33C.

Recovery of Debts Due to Banksand Financial Institutions Act,1993.

Securitisation andReconstruction of FinancialAssets and Enforcement ofSecurity Interest Act, 2002-Section 2(1), 3, 13, 13(1), 13(4),13(7), 13(9), 14B & 35.

Workmen’s Compensation Act,1923-Section 14, 14A.

Estate Duty Act, 1953-Section47(1) & 74.

Mines and Minerals (Regulationand Development) Act, 1957-Section 25 & 25(2).

Page 12: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

250 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Gift Tax Act, 1958-Section 30.

State Financial CorporationsAct, 1951-Section 29 & 46B.

Debts Recovery Tribunals Act-Section 19, 19(19), 22 & 34(1).

Banking Companies Act, 1949.

Displaced Persons (DebtsAdjustment) Act, 1951.

Motor Vehicles Act, 1939-Section 68 (B).

Constitution of India-Article 37,38, 43 & 372(1).

Defence of India Act, 1962-Section 43.

Transfer of Property Act-Section69 & 69A.

Defence of India Rules, 1962-Rule 131(2).

6. K.K. Baskaran v. State rep.by its Secretary, Tamil Naduand Ors. (04.03.2011)

Tamil Nadu Protection ofInterests of Depositors (inFinancial Establishments) Act,1997-Section 3 & 4.Maharashtra Protection ofInterests of Depositors (inFinancial Establishments) Act,1999.

AIR 2011 SC 1485, 2011(2)ALLMR (SC) 957, II (2011) BC191, 2011(2) CTC 887, JT2011(3) SC 201, 2011(3) MhLJ955, 2011(3) SCALE 380,(2011) 3 SCC 793.

Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934.

Banking Regulation Act, 1949-Section 5.

Companies Act, 1956-Section58A & 58AA.

Criminal Law (Amendment)Ordinance, 1944.

Criminal Law (Tamil NaduAmendment) Act, 1977.

Tamil Nadu Protection ofInterests of Depositors (inFinancial Establishments)(Amendment) Act, 2003-Section2.

Tamil Nadu Protection ofInterest of Depositors (inFinancial Establishments) Act,1977.

Constitution of India-Article 14,19(1) & 21.

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996-Section 2(1), 7, 7(4),11 & 11(6).

7. Powertech World WideLimited v. DelvinInternational GeneralTrading LLC (14.11.2011 Companies Act, 1956.

JT 2011(13) SC 187, 2011(12)SCALE 519.

Page 13: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 251

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

8. State Bank of Travancore v.Kingston Computers (I) P.Ltd. (22.02.2011)

Delhi High Court (original side)Rules 1967.

2011(5) MhLJ 842 (SC), (2011)164 PLR 120, 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 869, 2011(3) SCALE 33,(2011) 11 SCC 524, [2011] 107SCL 377 (SC) .

Companies Act, 1956.

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996-Section 2(2), 9, 17,34, 37, 37(2) & 42.

9. Yograj Infrastructure Ltd. v.Ssang Yong Engineering andConstruction Co. Ltd.(01.09.2011)

Indian Arbitration Act, 1940.

AIR 2011 SC 3517, 2011(4)ARBLR 82 (SC), JT 2011(10) SC588, 2011-5-LW 646, 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 882, 2011(9)SCALE 567, (2011) 9 SCC 735.

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Companies Act, 1956-Section178.

Major Port Trusts Act, 1963-Section 42(3) & 111.

1. APM Terminals B.V. v.Union of India (UOI) andAnr. (11.05.2011)

Indian Ports Act, 1908.

II (2011) BC 681, 2011(4)BomCR 10 JT 2011(6) SC 2892011(3) KLT (SN) 17(2011) 6MLJ 176 (SC) 2011(6) SCALE271, (2011) 6 SCC 756.

Electricity Act, 2003-Section79(1).

Constitution of India-Article 14.

2. Afjal Imam v. State of Biharand Ors. (19.04.2011)

Bihar Municipal Act, 2007-Sections 12(1), 17, 18(2), 19(2),20,21,22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28,29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36,37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44,45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52,53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 63,100(1), 354(2), 354(3), 365, 419& 488. Patna MunicipalCorporation Act, 1951. HowrahMunicipal Corporation Act,1980-Section 6(2) & 7.

2011(59) BLJR 1155 [2011(3)JCR 14 (SC) ] JT 2011(5) SC 19,2011(3) PLJR 290, 2011(4)SCALE 815(2011) 5 SCC 729.

Calcutta Municipal CorporationAct, 1980-Section 8(2) & 9.

West Bengal MunicipalCorporation Act, 2006. MadhyaPradesh Municipal CorporationAct, 1956-Section 37, 37(3) &37(8).

Madhya Pradesh andChhattisgarh Municipalities Act,1961-Section 70.

Mizoram Municipalities Act,2007-Section 21.

Goa Municipalities Act, 1968-Sections 52, 64, 66 & 66(1).

Forest Act, 1927. Representationof the People Act, 1951.

Companies Act, 1956-Section83A (1), 446(1) & 446(2).

Page 14: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

252 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Income-tax Act. Companies Act,1913. Maharashtra Sales Tax onthe Transfer of the Right to useany Goods for any Purpose Act,1985-Section 2(10), 3 & 8A.Bombay Sales Tax Act, 1952.

Madhya Pradesh MunicipalCorporation (Amendment) Act,1998. Code of Civil Procedure-Section 23, 23 (3) & 25.

Bihar Municipal EmpoweredStanding Committee Conduct ofBusiness Rules, 2010-Rule 6, 7,10 & 14. Constitution of India-Articles 14, 109, 126, 243R,243R(2), 243S, 243S(5), 243U& 243W.

3. Amar Singh v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Ors.(11.05.2011)

Indian Telegraph Act, 1885-Sections 5, 5(2), 20, 21, 25 &26.

2011 4 AWC 3726 SC 2011(5)SCALE 606, (2011) 7 SCC 69.

Indian Penal Code-Sections120B, 201, 419, 420, 468 &471.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 161.

Code of Civil Procedure-Order19 Rules 3 & Order 19 Rules 3(1).

Supreme Court Rules, 1966-Rule5 & 13. Supreme Court Orders-Order 11.

Constitution of India-Article19(1), 21 & 32.

4. Amrik Singh Lyallpuri v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (21.04.2011)

Delhi Municipal CorporationAct, 1957-Sections 2, 2(1), 111,167(12A), 183, 343, 347(1),347(2), 347(7), 347A, 347A(3),347B, 347B(2), 347B(3), 347C,347D & 347E.

179(2011) DLT 168 (SC) JT2011(5) SC 129, 2011(4) SCALE854(2011) 6 SCC 535.

New Delhi Municipal CouncilAct, 1994-Sections 2(1), 253,253 (3), 256, 257 & 355.Constitution of India(Amendment) Act, 1973. SeaCustoms Act, 1878. CompaniesAct. Constitution of India (Sixty-ninth Amendment) Act, 1991.

Government of National CapitalTerritory of Delhi Act, 1991-Section 41 & 41(3).

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 193, 196 & 228. Codeof Criminal Procedure, 1973-Section 195.

Page 15: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 253

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Constitution of India-Articles 14,136, 239, 239AA, 371D &371D (5).

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.

5. Aruna RamachandraShanbaug v. Union of India(UOI) and Ors. (24.01.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 32. [2011(1) JCR 196 (SC) ] 2011-2-LW (Crl) 129, 2011(1) RCR(Civil) 854, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 699, 2011(1) SCALE673 [2011] 2 SCR 869.

Representation of the PeoplesAct, 1951. Constitution (Fifty-second Amendment) Act, 1985.

6. Balchandra L. Jarkiholi andOrs. v. B. S. Yeddyurappaand Ors. (13.05.2011)

Karnataka Legislative Assembly(Disqualification of Members onGround of Defection) Rules1986-Rule 6, 6(2), 6(4), 6(5),6(6), 6(7), 7, 7(2) & 7(3).

2011 6 AWC (Supp) 5810 SC JT2011(6) SC 132(2011) 7 MLJ283 (SC) 2011(3) RCR (Civil)223, 2011(6) SCALE 172(2011)7 SCC 1.

Code of Civil Procedure-Order 6Rule 15(2)(4).

Constitution of India-Articles 14,19(1), 102, 122, 136, 191,191(2), 212, 226, 227 & 356.

Right to Information Act.Constitution of India-Article309.

7. Barot VijaykumarBalakrishna and Ors. v.Modh VinaykumarDasrathlal and Ors.(05.07.2011)

Gujarat General State ServiceClass II Recruitment(Examination) Rules 2008-Rule12, 12(2), 12(3), 13, 14, 16 &19.

2011(4) ALLMR (SC) 849[2011(3) JCR 267 (SC) ] JT2011(7) SC 266, 2011(3) KLT(SN) 55(2011) 8 MLJ 91 (SC)2011(7) SCALE 12(2011) 7 SCC308 (2011) 2 SCC (L& S) 281.

8. Bhim Singh v. Union of India(UOI) and Ors. (12.01.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 32. 2011(1) SCALE 697.

9. Centre For Environment andFood Security v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Ors.(14.03.2011)

National Rural EmploymentGuarantee Act, 2005-Section 27.

2011(4) SCALE 50.

Constitution of India-Articles 14,15, 16, 25 & 341(1).

10. Centre, Public InterestLitigation and Anr. v. Unionof India (UOI) (21.01.2011)

Constitution (Scheduled Castes)Order 1950.

2011(2) SCALE 132.

Workmen’s Compensation Act,1923.

11. Delhi Jal Board v. NationalCampaign for Dignity andRights of Sewerage andAllied Workers and Ors.(12.07.2011)

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Section 2. Constitution of India(Forty-fourth Amendment) Act,1978. Constitution of India(Forty-second Amendment) Act,1976. C.P.W.D./PWD(DA)/DelhiJal Board Contractors LabourRegulations.

181(2011) DLT 77 (SC) JT2011(8) SC 232, 2011(7) SCALE489, (2011) 8 SCC 568.

Constitution of India-Articles 3,14, 19, 20, 21, 32, 38, 39, 39A,42, 141, 142, 144 & 226.

Page 16: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

254 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

12. Democratic YouthFederation of India v. Unionof India (UOI) and Ors.(13.05.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 21. 2011(11) SCALE 398.

13. Eastern Coalfields Ltd. v.Tetulia Coke Plant (P) Ltd.and Ors. (10.08.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 14. [2011(4) JCR 11 (SC) ], 2011(9)SCALE 88.

14. Environmental andConsumer Protect. Found v.Delhi Administration andOrs. (11.01.2011)

Free and Compulsory EducationAct 2009.

2011(1) SCALE 709.

15. Federation of A.P. MinorityEducational Institution v.Admission and FeeRegulatory Committee forMatters relating To FeeFixation in Pvt. UnaidedProfessional Colleges andOrs. (25. 08. 2011)

Andhra Pradesh SocietiesRegistration Act 2001. AndhraPradesh Educational Institutions(Regulation of Admission andProhibition of Capitation Fee)Act, 1983-Section 3 & 15.Constitution of India-Article19(1), 30 & 136. AndhraPradesh Engineering CommonEntrance Test for DiplomaHolders for Admission into B.F.B.Tech. & B.Pharma coursesRules, 2004-Rule 12 & 6.

2011(9) SCALE 422.

16. Friends of Victoria Memorialv. Howrah GanatantrikNagarik Samity and Ors.(12.09.2011)

Constitution of India-Article136.

2011(10) SCALE 313.

Income Tax Act, 1961-Section9(1).

Government of India Act, 1935.

17. GVK Inds. Ltd. and Anr. v.The Income Tax Officer andAnr. (01.03.2011)

Constitution of India-Articles 1,2, 14, 51, 245, 245(1), 246, 248,249, 250, 253, 260 & 368.

[2011] 162 CompCas 574 (SC)(2011) 239 CTR (SC) 113[2011] 332 ITR 130 (SC) JT2011(3) SC 356, 2011(3) KCCRSN 250, 2011(3) SCALE111(2011) 4 SCC 36 [2011] 197TAXMAN 337 (SC) (2010) 39VST 114 (SC) .

Guru Gobind Singh IndraprasthaUniversity Act, 1998-Section 6,6(2) & 27.

18. Indian Medical Associationv. Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (12.05.2011)

Delhi Professional Colleges orInstitutions (Prohibition ofCapitation Fee Regulation ofAdmission Fixation of Non-Exploitative Fee.

AIR 2011 SC 2365 JT 2011(6)SC 505, 2011(3) KLT (SN)81(2011) 7 MLJ 981 (SC)2011(6) SCALE 86(2011) 7 SCC179.

Delhi Professional Colleges orInstitutions (Prohibition ofCapitation Fee Regulation ofAdmission Fixation of Non-Exploitative other Measures toEnsure Equity.

Delhi Professional Colleges orInstitutions (Prohibition ofCapitation Fee Regulation ofAdmission Fixation of Non-Exploitative Excellence) Act.

Page 17: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 255

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Delhi Professional Colleges orInstitutions (Prohibition ofCapitation Fee Regulation ofAdmission Fixation of Non-Exploitative, 2007.

Constitution of India (NinetyThird Amendments) Act, 2005.

Persons with Disabilities (EqualOpportunities Protection ofRights and Full Participation)Act, 1995.

Constitution of India-Articles 12,14, 15, 15(1), 15(2), 15(4), 16,16(1), 16(4), 16(4A), 16(4B), 19,19(1), 19(6), 21, 29, 29(2), 30,30(1), 31B, 32, 38, 46, 142, 162,226 & 368.

Guru Gobind Singh IndraprasthaUniversity Ordinance-Ordinance30.

19. Joydeep Mukharjee v. Stateof West Bengal and Ors.(03.02.2011)

West Bengal GovernmentTownship (Extension of CivicAmenities) Act, 1975-Section 2& 4. West Bengal GovernmentTownship (Extension of CivicAmenities) (Amendment) Act,1985. Constitution of India-Article 14 & 21.

AIR 2011 SC 1169, 2011(4)ALLMR (SC) 879, 2011 GLH(2) 1600, 2011(2) KCCR SN165, 2011(2) PLJR 59, 2011(2)SCALE 172(2011) 2 SCC 706,[2011] 2 SCR 493.

West Bengal GovernmentTownship (Extension of CivicAmenities) Ordinance, 1975.

20. Justice P. D. Dinakaran v.Hon ‘ ble Judges InquiryCommittee and Ors.(05.07.2011)

Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968-Sections 3, 3 (1), 3 (2), 3 (3), 3(4), 3 (8), 3 (9), 4, 4(1), 4(2),4(3), 5, 6, 6(1), 6(2) & 6(3).Commissions of Inquiry Act,1952.

JT 2011(7) SC 425, 2011(3)KLT (SN) 65(2011) 8 MLJ 331(SC) 2011(II) OLR (SC) 445,2011(6) SCALE 797.

Passports Act, 1967.

Food and Drugs Act, 1938.

Army Act, 1950-Section 130.

Uttar Pradesh (Temporary)Control of Rent and EvictionAct, 1947.

Bengal Money Lenders Act,1940.

Judges (Inquiry) Rules, 1969-Rule 9(2).

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section 35.

Constitution of India-Articles 14,21, 32, 100, 105, 217(1), 124,124(4), 124(5), 141, 218, 316,317 & 317(1).

Page 18: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

256 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

21. Justice P. D. Dinakaran v.Judges Inquiry Committeeand Anr. (26.08.2011)

Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968-Sections 3, 3(1), 3(2), 3 (3), 3(4),3(8), 3(9), 4, 4(1), 4(2) & 5.

JT 2011(10) SC 230, 2011(9)SCALE 437.

Benami Transactions(Prohibition) Act, 1988.

Tamil Nadu Land Reforms(Fixation of Ceiling on Land)Act, 1961.

Judges (Inquiry) Rules, 1969-Rule 2, 5, 5(1), 5(3), 9 & 9(2).Constitution of India-Articles121, 124, 124(4), 124(5), 141,217, 217(1) & 224.

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.

Roerich and Devika RaniRoerich Estate (Acquisition andTransfer) Act, 1996.

22. K. T. Plantation Pvt. Ltd.and Anr. v. State ofKarnataka (09.08.2011)

Karnataka Land Reforms Act,1961-Sections 38, 63, 64, 66, 67,67(1), 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74,75, 76, 79A, 79B, 79B(1),79B(2), 79B(3), 79B(4), 80, 83,104, 107, 107(1), 107(2), 110,122A & 140.

AIR 2011 SC 3430 JT 2011(8)SC 65(2011) 7 MLJ 1185 (SC)2011(8) SCALE 583 (2011) 9SCC 1.

Land Reforms (Amendment)Act, 1973-Section 80, 83 & 107.

Delhi Laws Act, 1912. Ajmer-Merwara (Extension of Laws)Act, 1947 Part C.

States (Laws) Act, 1950. GeneralClauses Act, 1897-Section 23,109, 110, 139 & 140.

Essential Commodities Act,1955-Section 3(6).

Mines and Minerals (Regulationand Development) Act, 1957-Section 28(3).

Land Acquisition Act, 1894.

Constitution of India (24thAmendment) Act, 1971.

Constitution of India (17thAmendment) Act, 1964.

Bihar Land Reforms Act, 1950.

Land Acquisition (MadrasAmendment) Act, 1961.

Bombay Town Planning Act,1958.

Banking Companies (Acquisitionand Transfer of Undertakings)Act, 1969.

Punjab Security of Land TenuresAct, 1953.

Page 19: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 257

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

West Bengal Great Eastern Hotel(Acquisition of Undertaking)Act, 1980. Constitution of India(Amendment) Act, 1978.Constitution of India (7thAmendment) Act, 1956.Constitution of India(Amendment) Act, 1951-Article31A.

Travancore-Cochin Cochin LandTax Act. Delhi Special PoliceEstablishment Act, 1946-Section6A.

Central Educational Institutions(Reservation in Admission) Act,2006. Constitution of India(Amendment) Act, 1982-Section69A.

Constitution of India-Articles 12,14, 15, 19, 19(5), 20, 21, 31(1),31A, 31A(1), 30(1A), 31B, 31C,32, 200, 226, 24, 246, 248,254(1), 254(2) & 300A.

Bombay Land Revenue CodeRoerich and Devika RaniRoerich Estate (Acquisition andTransfer) Ordinance, 1992.

National Council for TeacherEducation Act, 1993-Section 14,15 & 16.

Constitution of India-Article 142& 226.

23. Kumari Ranjana Mishra andAnr. Vs The State of Biharand Ors. (10.03.2011)

Bihar School Examination BoardRules, 1963-Rule 7 & 7(1).

AIR 2011 SC 1383, 2011 3AWC 2283 SC 2011(59) BLJR616 JT 2011(3) SC 487, 2011(3)KCCR SN 318, 2011(2) PLJR186, 2011(3) SCALE 444(2011)4 SCC 192.

24. Md. Murtaza and Ors. v.State of Assam and Ors.(29.08.2011)

Constitution of India-Article19(1) & 19(6).

JT 2011(13) SC 145, 2011-5-LW332(2011) 8 MLJ 66 (SC)2011(4) RCR (Civil) 346,2011(9) SCALE 526.

City of Nagpur Corporation Act-Section 269.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 133.

25. Mohd. Hamid and Anr. Etc.etc. v. Badi Masjid Trust andOrs. Etc. etc. (20.07.2011)

Constitution of India-Articles 25,26, 32 & 226.

2011(3) ACR 3280 (SC) JT2011(12) SC 46, 2011(3) KLT401 (SC) 2011-4-LW 796,2011(3) RCR (Civil) 773,2011(3) RCR (Criminal) 691,2011(8) SCALE 2.

Indian Police Act, 1861-Sections17, 18, 19 & 53(1).

26. Nandini Sundar and Ors. v.State of Chhattisgarh(05.07.2011)

Chhattisgarh Police Act, 2007-Sections 1(2), 2, 9, 9(1), 9(2), 10,23, 23(1), 24, 25, 50(1) & 50(2).

JT 2011(7) SC 561, 2011(6)SCALE 839(2011) 7 SCC 547.

Indian Evidence Act.

Minor Act.

Indian Penal Code of CriminalProcedure Constitution of India-Articles 14, 21 & 355.

Page 20: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

258 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,120B, 148, 149, 302, 307, 323,324, 325 & 326.

27. Narayan Dutt and Ors. v.State of Punjab and Anr.(24.02.2011)

Crimanal Procedure Code-Sections 173, 319 & 321.Constitution of India-Articles 14,72 & 161.

AIR 2011 SC 1216, 2011 3AWC 2953 SC 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 209, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 140, 2011(2) SCALE712(2011) 4 SCC 353 (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 243.

28. Narmada Bachao Andolan v.State of Madhya Pradesh(26.07.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 3(1). General ClausesAct, 1897-Section 21.

AIR 2011 SC 3199 JT 2011(8)SC 307, 2011(3) KLT (SN) 74,2011(8) SCALE 38.

Government of India Act, 1935-Section 49(1).

Defence of India Act, 1939-Section 2(5). Appropriation Act.Business Rules, 1961-Rule 7.

Constitution of India-Articles 21,37, 38, 39, 41, 43, 46, 47, 77,77(3), 154(1), 166, 166(1),166(2), 166(3), 300, 300A &361.

Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948.29. Narmada Bachao Andolan v.State of Madhya Pradesh andAnr. (11.05.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Sections 4, 4(1), 6, 9, 11, 11(2),16, 17, 18, 48, 50 & 54.

AIR 2011 SC 1989 JT 2011(6)SC 379, 2011(5) SCALE624(2011) 7 SCC 639.

Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980-Section 2.

Inter State Water Disputes Act,1956-Section 2.

Punjab Security of Land TenuresAct, 1953. Railways Act, 1989-Section 73.

Indian Railways ConferenceAssociation Rules-Rule 161A.

Right to Information Act.Income Tax Act.

Madhya Pradesh Pariyojana KeKaran Visthapit Vyakti(Punahsthapan) Adhiniyam,1985-Section 11(4).

Madhya Pradesh Land RevenueCode-Section 117.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 340.

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Order 11 Rule 35, Order 11Rule 36, 96 & 97. Constitutionof India-Articles 14, 21, 37, 38,39, 41, 43, 46, 47 & 300A.

Uttar Pradesh Industrial AreaDevelopment Act, 1976-Sections6(2), 8, 9, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18 &19.

30. National Council for TeacherEducation and Ors. v. ShriShyam Shiksha PrashikshanSansthan and Ors. Etc. etc.(31.01.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988.

2011(6) ADJ 13 AIR 2011 SC2112, 2011 4 AWC 3265 SC, JT2011(6) SC 223, 2011(5) SCALE505.

Page 21: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 259

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Uttar Pradesh Urban Planningand Development Act, 1973-Sections 30, 32, 40, 41, 42, 43,44, 45, 46, 47, 49, 50, 51, 53 &58.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 468, 469, 470,471 & 473.

All India Services (Death cumRetirement Benefits) Rules,1958-Rule 6.

New Okhla IndustrialDevelopment Area (Preparationand Finalization of Plan)Regulations, 1991. Constitutionof India-Article 14 & 21.

31. P. Parthasarathy v. State ofKarnataka and Ors.(24.08.2011)

Karnataka Industrial AreasDevelopment Act, 1966-Sections4, 6, 28, 28(1), 28(2), 28(3) &28(4).

2011(9) SCALE 373.

32. P. V. Indiresan v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Ors.(18.08.2011)

Central Educational Institutions(Reservation in Admission) Act,2006-Section 2 & 3.Constitution of India (Ninety-third Amendment) Act.Constitution of India (Ninety-third 2005 Haryana Service ofEngineers Class I PWD(Irrigation Branch) Rules, 1964-Rule 7. Constitution of India-Articles 15(5), 16(4) & 21A.

2011(59) BLJR 2075, 181(2011)DLT 608 (SC) JT 2011(9) SC415, 2011(9) SCALE 33 (2011)8 SCC 441.

Haj Committee Act, 1959.

Haj Committee Act, 2002.

Madras Hindu Religious andCharitable Endowments Act,1951. Income Tax Act.

Central Excise Act.

Sales Tax Act.

33. Prafull Goradia v. Union ofIndia (UOI) (28.01.2011)

Central Provinces and Berar Act.

2011(2) ALLMR (SC) 453, 20113 AWC 2376 SC (SCSuppl)2011(2) CHN 204, 2011(1)CTC 747 [2011(2) JCR 49 (SC) ]2011(2) KCCR SN 106, 2011(1)KLT 584 (SC) 2011-3-LW 44,2011(2) RCR (Civil) 232,2011(1) SCALE 761(2011) 2SCC 568 [2011] 1 SCR 579,2011(1) UC 404.

Constitution of India-Articles 14,15, 27 & 32.

34. Prakash Jha Productions andAnr. v. Union of India (UOI)and Ors. (19.08.2011)

Uttar Pradesh Cinemas(Regulation) Act, 1955-Section 6& 6(1). Cinematograph Act,1952 & 1958-Section 3 & 4.Constitution of India-Article19(1).

2011 6 AWC (Supp) 5598 SC2011 GLH (3) 172 JT 2011(10)SC 102(2011) 7 MLJ 1227 (SC)2011(9) SCALE 265(2011) 8SCC 372.

35. Pratap Chandra Mehta v.State Bar Council of M.P.and Ors. (09.08.2011)

Advocates Act, 1961-Sections 2,3, 3(2), 3(3), 3(3A), 3(4), 4, 5, 6,6(1), 7, 8, 10B, 11, 11(1), 12,14, 15, 15(1), 15(2), 15(3), 17,21, 24(1), 28, 28(1), 28(2),28(3), 35, 36, 37, 43, 43(1),43(2), 47A, 47A(1), 48, 49,49(1), 49A, 49A(4) & 54.Advocates (Amendment) Act,

JT 2011(9) SC 135, 2011(3)KLT (SN) 105, 2011(4) RCR(Civil) 183, 2011(8) SCALE 506,(2011) 9 SCC 573.

Page 22: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

260 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

1977-Section 5. Uttar PradeshMunicipalities Act, 1916-Section87A & 87A(2). Uttar PradeshPanchayati Raj Act, 1947-Section 14.

General Clauses Act, 1897.

State Bar Council of MadhyaPradesh Rules, 1962-Rule 1, 2,3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12,12(2), 14, 15, 22, 110, 118, 119,120, 121, 122, 122A, 122A(1),122B & 123.

Constitution of India-Articles 14,75(3), 156(1) & 324.

Central Electricity RegulatoryCommission (Procedure Termsand Conditions for Grant ofTrading Licence and OtherRelated Matters) Regulations,2004-Regulation 6A.

State Bar Council of MadhyaPradesh (Amendment) Rules,1975.

Right to Information Act, 2005.36. Ram Jethmalani and Ors. v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (04.07.2011)

Constitution of India-Articles 14,19, 21, 26, 26(1), 31 & 32.

2011(4) ALLMR (SC) 815 JT2011(7) SC 104, 2011(3) KLT(SN) 47, 2011(3) RCR (Civil)643, 2011(3) RCR (Criminal)480, 2011(6) SCALE 691,(2011) 8 SCC 1.

38. Ram Jethmalani and Ors. v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (23.09.2011)

Constitution of India-Articles 14,16, 32, 136, 137, 142, 142(1),145 & 145(1).

2011(4) KLT (SN) 43, 2011(10)SCALE 753.

Supreme Court Rules, 1966-Rule40.

Code of Civil Procedure-Order47 Rules 1.

39. Re: Exploi. Of Chiln. InjOrph. In St. of T. N. v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (16.08.2011)

Right to Education Act. 2011(11) SCALE 15.

40. Safai Karamchari Andolanand Ors. v. Union of India(UOI) and Ors. (12.01.2011)

Employment of ManualScavengers and Construction ofDry Latrines (Prohibition) Act,1993-Section 5.

2011(1) SCALE 708.

41. Sampurna Behura v. Unionof India (UOI) and Ors.(12.10.2011)

Juvenile Justice (Care andProtection of Children) Act,2000-Sections 4, 29, 63, 63 (2)& 63 (3). Constitution of India-Article 32.

2011(11) SCALE 512.

Page 23: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 261

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Administrative Tribunals Act,1985-Sections 6, 8, 8(1), 8(2),10, 10A & 12(2).

Administrative Tribunals(Amendment) Act, 2006-Section6(2), 8 & 10A. AdministrativeTribunals (Amendment) Rules,2006.

42. Shanker Raju v. Union ofIndia (UOI) (04.01.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 32& 141. Administrative TribunalsRules, 2006. AdministrativeTribunals (Amendment) Act,2007-Section 8.

2011(2) ALD69 (SC) 2011(1)ALLMR (SC) 957, 2011 1 AWC(Supp) 584 SC 2011(271) ELT492 (SC) [2011(3) JCR 38 (SC) ]JT 2011(1) SC 49(2011) 3 MLJ181 (SC) 2011(1) SCALE 70(2011) 2 SCC 132(2011) 1 SCC(L& S) 161 [2011] 2 SCR1(2011) 1 UPLBEC 342.

Punjab Reorganization Act,1966-Sections 2, 5, 54(3), 78,78(1), 79 & 80.

43. State of Himachal Pradesh v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (27.09.2011)

Government of India Act, 1935-Section 38, 204 & 290A.

2011(11) SCALE 144.

Inter-State Water Disputes Act.

Inter-State, 1956. Supreme CourtRules, 1966-Order 23 Rules 6.Constitution of India-Articles 1,3, 73, 73(1), 131, 143, 162,246(3), 246(4), 262, 262(2), 294& 363.

States Merger (ChiefCommissioners Provinces)Order, 1949. State of HimachalPradesh (Transfer of Assets andLiabilities) Order, 1972.

Constitution of India (7thAmendment) Act, 1956.

44. State of Orissa and Anr. v.Mamata Mohanty(09.02.2011)

Uttar Pradesh SecondaryEducation Services CommissionRules, 1983. Uttar PradeshIntermediate Education Act,1921-Section 6(2). LimitationAct, 1963-Section 3.

112(2011) CLT 46, 2011(2)KCCR SN 167, 2011(2) SCALE377(2011) 3 SCC 436(2011) 2SCC (L& S) 83 [2011] 2 SCR704.

Orissa Education (Recruitmentand Conditions of Service ofTeachers and Members of theStaff of Aided EducationalInstitutions) Rules, 1974-Rule 2,4, 5(1), 5(2), 5(3), 6 & 7.

Constitution of India – Articles14, 16 & 21A. Orissa AidedEducational InstitutionsEmployee’s Common Cadre andInter Transferability Rules,1979.

45. State of Punjab and Ors. v.Nirbhai Singh and Anr.(27.05.2011)

Punjab Panchayat Raj(Amendment) Act 2011-Section1(2).

2011(6) SCALE 544.

Supreme Court Rules, 1966.46. State of Punjab v. State ofHaryana and Ors.(23.09.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 13& 131.

2011(10) SCALE 718.

Page 24: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

262 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Indian Penal Code-Sections 376,376(2) & 376(2)(5).

47. State of Rajasthan and Ors.v. Sanyam Lodha(25.08.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 357 & 357A. RajasthanChief Minister’s Relief FundRules, 1999-Rule 4, 5, 7, 8, 10& 11.

2011 6 AWC (Supp) 5702 SC JT2011(10) SC 7, 2011(9) SCALE379.

Rajasthan Chief Minister’sFamine and Relief Fund Rules,1979. Constitution of India-Article 162.

48. State of U.P. and Ors. v.Bharat Singh and Ors.(08.03.2011)

Uttar Pradesh Higher EducationService Commission Act, 1980-Sections 3, 4, 6, 6(1), 11, 11(2),12, 12(1), 12(2), 12(3), 13,13(1), 13(3), 13(4), 13(5), 13(6),14, 15, 15(2), 31 & 32.

JT 2011(3) SC 457, 2011(3)SCALE 392(2011) 4 SCC120(2011) 1 SCC (L& S)639(2011) 2 UPLBEC 1109.

Uttar Pradesh Services(Reservation for ScheduledCastes and Scheduled Tribes andother Backward Classes) Act,1994.

Uttar Pradesh State UniversitiesAct, 1973-Sections 60A, 60B,60D & 60E.

Uttar Pradesh SecondaryEducation Services Commissionand Selection Boards Act, 1982-Section 10 & 12.

Constitution of India-Articles 14,14(1), 15, 16, 16(4) & 154.

Uttar Pradesh Higher EducationServices Commission Rules,1981-Rule 4, 4(1), 4(2), 4(4),4(5) & 4(6).

Uttar Pradesh Higher EducationServices Commission (Procedurefor Selection of Teachers)Regulations, 1983.

Uttar Pradesh Higher EducationAided Colleges Transfer ofTeachers Rules, 2005.

49. State of Uttaranchal v.Golden Forest Co. (P) Ltd.(11.04.2011)

Uttar Pradesh ReorganizationAct, 2000-Section 91.

Uttar Pradesh ZamindariAbolition and Land ReformsAct, 1950-Sections 154(1), 166,167 & 167(2).

AIR 2011 SC 1723, 2011 4AWC 4210 SC, JT 2011(6) SC619, 2011(4) SCALE 512,2011(1) UD 279.

Rajasthan Public Trust Act,1959.

50. Suraz India Trust v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Anr.(04.04.2011)

Constitution of India-Articles 32,124(2), 156(1), 224 & 368.

JT 2011(4) SC 149, 2011(4)SCALE 252.

51. Union of India (UOI) andOrs. v. J. D. Suryavanshi(05.09.2011)

Constitution of India-Article226.

AIR 2011 SC 3605, 2011(10)SCALE 689.

Page 25: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 263

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Finance Act (No. 2) 1998-Sections 87, 88, 95 & 98.

52. Union of India (UOI) andOrs. v. Nitdip TextileProcessors Pvt. Ltd. and Anr.(03.11.2011)

Central Excise Act, 1944-Sections 11A, 11AB, 11AC, 14,173B, 173C & 209A.

2011(2) SCALE 386.

Wealth Tax Act, 1957. Gift TaxAct, 1958. Income Tax Act,1961-Section 297(2).

Interest Tax Act, 1974.Expenditure Tax Act, 1987.

Customs Act, 1962. CustomsTariff Act, 1975. Central ExciseTariff Act, 1985.

Customs Tariff Act, 1985.General Clauses Act, 1897-Section 6.

Travancore Cochin AgriculturalIncome Tax Act.

Constitution of India-Article 14& 226.

Central Excise Rules, 1944-Rule173F & 173Q.

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996-Section 5.

53. Union of India (UOI) andOrs. v. Tantia ConstructionPvt. Ltd. (18.04.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 14,19(1) & 226.

2011(2) ARBLR 115 (SC) 20115 AWC 4568 SC [2011(3) JCR 8(SC) ] JT 2011(5) SC 59,2011(2) KLJ 15, 2011-3-LW691, 2011(3) RCR (Civil) 821,2011(4) SCALE 745(2011) 5SCC 697.

54. Zafruddin Khan v. AligarhMuslim University and Ors.(14.02.2011)

Aligarh Muslim University Act,1920-Section 5(9A) & 12(2).

(SCSuppl) 2011(2) CHN 178 JT2011(2) SC 152, 2011(2) SCALE635, (2011) 1 UPLBEC 633.

CONSUMER LAW/CONSUMER PROTECTION

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Government Savings Banks Act1873-Section 15.

Consumer Protection Act, 1986-Section 2(1).

1. ArulmighuDhandayudhapaniswamyThirukoil, Palani, TamilNadu, thr. Its JointCommissioner v. TheDirector General of PostOffices, Department of Postsand Ors. (13.07.2011)

Post Office Savings BankGeneral Rules, 1981-Rule 16 &17.

2011 5 AWC 4905 SC112(2011) CLT 617 (SC) III(2011) CPJ 25 (SC) JT 2011(8)SC 657, 2011(3) KLT (SN) 78,2011-4-LW 374, 2011(3) RCR(Civil) 776, 2011(7) SCALE 466.

2. C. Venkatachalam v.Ajitkumar C. Shah and Ors.(29.08.2011)

Consumer Protection Act, 1986-Section 6 & 17.

III (2011) CPJ 33 (SC) JT2011(10) SC 207(2011) 6 MLJ555 (SC) 2011(4) RCR (Civil)234, 2011(9) SCALE 479.

3. Citicorp. Maruti FinanceLtd. v. S. Vijayalaxmi(14.11.2011)

Securitisation andReconstruction of FinancialAssets and Enforcement ofSecurity Interest Act, 2002.

2011(4) RCR (Civil) 876,2011(12) SCALE 537.

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 51.

Page 26: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

264 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Consumer Protection Act, 1986-Section 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 13, 13(4),13(5), 13(6), 14(1), 24(A) &30A.

Carriage by AIR Act, 1972-Section 2, 2(1), 3, 3 (2) & 7.

4. Ethiopian AIR lines v.Ganesh Narain Saboo(09.08.2011)

Uttar Pradesh CooperativeSocieties Act.

AIR 2011 SC 3495, 2011(6)ALT 28 (SC) 2011 5 AWC(Supp) 5398 SC, IV (2011) CPJ43 (SC) JT 2011(9) SC 243,2011(4) KLT (SN) 23 (2011) 8MLJ 71 (SC) 2011(4) RCR(Civil) 93 RLW 2011(4) SC2929, 2011(8) SCALE 549,(2011) 8 SCC 539.

Uttar Pradesh Industrial DisputesAct, 1947.

Carriers Act 1865-Section 9.

Indian Carriage of Goods by SeaAct, 1925. Railways Act, 1890-Section 80.

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section 9, 84, 86, 86(1), 86(2),86(6), 87, 87(B) & Order 1 Rule8.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section193 & 228.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 195.

Consumer ProtectionRegulations, 2005-Regulation26.

Constitution of India-Article363(22).

Carriage by AIR Rule-Rules 1.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section1(2), 1(3), 2, 8, 18, 18(1), 19 &28.

Arbitration Act Special CourtAct.

5. Goel Jewellers vs.... NationalInsurance Company Ltd.(09.09.2011)

Consumer Protection Act, 1986-Section 21.

IV (2011) CPJ 1 (SC) .

6. H. K. K. Bail and Anr. v.Cyma Exports Pvt. Ltd. andAnr. (19.01.2011)

Consumer Protection Act, 1986-Section 25.

Constitution of India-Article142.

2011(1) SCALE 597.

Consumer Protection Act, 1986-Section 12.

7. Haryana UrbanDevelopment Authority v.Viresh Sangwan and Anr.(08.11.2011)

Haryana Urban DevelopmentAuthority Act, 1977.

JT 2011(13) SC 287, 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 935.

Haryana Urban Development(Disposal of Land and Buildings)Regulations, 1978-Regulations5(3) & 20.

Haryana Urban DevelopmentAuthority (Erection of Building)Regulations, 1979-Regulation10.

Page 27: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 265

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Consumer Protection Act, 1986-Section 12.

8. Haryana Urban Devt. Auth.v. Shushila Devi Sharma(02.09.2011)

Constitution of India-Article136.

IV (2011) CPJ 3 (SC) .

9. LIC of India and Anr. v.Hira Lal (23.08.2011)

Consumer Protection Act-Section12.

IV (2011) CPJ 4 (SC) .

Consumer Protection Act, 1986-Section 12, 15 & 21.

Code of Civil Procedure-Section34.

10. Mrs. Rubi (Chandra) Duttav. United India InsuranceCo. Ltd. (18.03.2011)

Indian Penal Code.

2011 ACJ 2310, 2011 3 AWC2908 SC (SCSuppl) 2011(2)CHN 82 II (2011) CPJ 19 (SC)(2011) 3 GLR 2303 (SC)[2011(3) JCR 276 (SC) ] JT2011(3) SC 586(2011) 7 MLJ818 (SC) 2011(2) PLJR 181,2011(2) RCR (Civil) 591,2011(3) SCALE 654(2011) 11SCC 269, 2011(2) UC 1426.

11. P. Vankat Naidu v. LifeInsurance Corporation ofIndia and Anr. (26.08.2011)

Consumer Protection Act, 1986-Section 27.

IV (2011) CPJ 6 (SC) .

12. Rajeev Hitendra Pathak andOrs. v. Achyut KashinathKarekar and Anr.(19.08.2011)

Consumer Protection Act, 1986-Section 12, 12(1), 12(3), 13,13(2), 13(3), 13(4), 13(5), 13(6),14, 14(1), 17, 18, 22, 22(1),22A, 22B, 22C, 22D & 30A.

2011 5 AWC (Supp) 5302 SC IV(2011) CPJ 35 (SC) JT 2011(9)SC 407, 2011-5-LW 774(2011)164 PLR 274, 2011(4) RCR(Civil) 175, 2011(9) SCALE 287.

Consumer Protection(Amendment) Act, 2002-Section17A, 17B & 22(2).

Consumer Protection(Amendment) Act, 2003-Section22A.

Consumer ProtectionRegulations 2005-Regulation26(1).

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.

13. Ranchi University v. SnehKumar (08.04.2011)

Consumer Protection Act, 1986-Section 12.

AIR 2011 SC 1824, 2011 4AWC 3275 SC 112(2011) CLT599 (SC) 2011(4) KCCR SN391, 2011(2) PLJR 112, 2011(2)RCR (Civil) 859, 2011(4)SCALE 795.

14. Ravinder Raj v. CompetentMotors Co. Pvt. Ltd. andAnr. (10.02.2011)

Sale of Goods Act 1930-Section46A (1) & 64.

AIR 2011 SC 1061, 2011(5)ALD 93 (SC) 2011 2 AWC 1895SC (SCSuppl) 2011(2) CHN 214II (2011) CPJ 1 (SC) 2011(266)ELT 157 (SC), [2011(2) JCR 63(SC) ] JT 2011(2) SC 149,2011(2) KLJ 41, 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 151, 2011(2) SCALE446(2011) 11 SCC 547 [2011] 2SCR 756, 2011(2) UC 1411.

15. Silversons v. OrientalInsurance Company Ltd. andAnr. (15.09.2011)

Consumer Protection Act-Section15.

IV (2011) CPJ 9 (SC) .

Page 28: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

266 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Consumer Protection Act, 1986-Section 23.

16. The New India AssuranceCo. Ltd. v. Priya BlueIndustries Pvt. Ltd.(09.03.2011)

Marine Insurance Act, 1963-Section 55, 57 & 60.

2011 3 AWC 2364 SC II (2011)CPJ 15 (SC) JT 2011(3) SC 452,2011(2) KCCR SN 125, 2011(2)RCR (Civil) 410, 2011(3)SCALE 502, (2011) 4 SCC 231,2011(2) UC 1422.

Consumer Protection Act, 1986-Section 3, 12, 23, 25, 27 & 29.

17. Trans Mediterranean AIRways v. Universal Exportsand Anr. (15.09.2011)

Carriage by AIR Act, 1972-Section 2, 2(1), 3, 4, 4A, 5, 6,6(A), 7, 8, 21 & 86.

[2011] 105 CLA 1 (SC) IV(2011) CPJ 13 (SC) JT 2011(10)SC 624, 2011(4) KLT (SN) 72,2011(4) RCR (Civil) 472,2011(10) SCALE 524.

Indian Carriage by AIR Act,1934-Section 4.

Contract Act, 1872.

Evidence Act.

Banking Companies Act.

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Section 51.

Bihar and Orissa CooperativeSocieties Act-Societie 48 & 151.

Limitation Act, 1963-Section 14.

Arbitration Act Carriers Act1865-Section 9.

Code of Civil Procedure-Section9, 25 & 27.

Code of Civil Procedure-Order21 Rule 37 & Order 39 Rule 2A.

Constitution of India-Articles13(3), 14, 323A & 323B.

Carriage by AIR Rules-Rules 1,1(2), 1(3), 6, 9, 10, 12, 13, 14,16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 28, 29, 29(1),29(2), 30 & 33.

AIR Cargo Tariff Rules.

18. Usha Kumari Ranawat v.The Senior DivisionalManager, LIC of India andAnr. (12.05.2011)

Consumer Protection Act, 1986-Section 17 & 21.

2011(6) SCALE 493.

19. Vinod Kumar Thareja v.Alpha Construction and Ors.(08.02.2011)

Consumer Protection Act, 1986-Section 12.

AIR 2011 SC 996, 2011(3)ALLMR (SC) 449 II (2011) CPJ3 (SC) 2011(3) RCR (Civil) 576RLW 2011(2) SC 1798, 2011(2)SCALE 630 (2011) 11 SCC 453,2011(2) UC 1416.

CONTEMPT

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Section 2, 12, 12(1) & 19.

1. Anup Bhushan Vohra v. TheRegistrar General, HighCourt of Judicature atCalcutta (16.09.2011)

Calcutta High Court Contemptof Courts Rules, 1975.

JT 2011(10) SC 606, 2011(4)KLT (SN) 60, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 275, 2011(10)SCALE 561.

Page 29: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 267

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Contempt of Court Act, 1971-Section 2, 15, 15(1), 19.

Seeds Act.

2. N. Shivanna v. AdvantaIndia Limited and Anr.(14.03.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 391.

2011 CriLJ 1916 JT 2011(3) SC415, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal)385, 2011(3) SCALE 536,(2011) 4 SCC 216(2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 192.

3. Chandra Prakash SinghChauhan v. State of U.P. andAnr. (14.06.2011)

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Section 12, 15, 15(1), 15(2), 20& 23.

2011(6) SCALE 583.

Bar Council of India Act.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 156(3) Allahabad HighCourt Rules, 1952-Rule 2, 3, 4& 5.

Advocates Act, 1961.

4. Olvin School Society v. AnilKumar Sharma and Ors.(11.10.2011)

Societies Registration Act, 1860Uttar Pradesh IntermediateEducation Act, 1921-Section7(a), 16(D).

2011(11) SCALE 427.

Delhi Education Act, 1973Constitution of Indian-Article 19& 19(1).

5. Dr. Sarita Parikh and Anr. v.Union of india (UOI) andOrs. (23.02.2011)

Suo Motu Contempt Rules. 2011(4) SCALE 565.

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Section 2.

6. H. G. Rangangoud v. StateTrading Corporation ofIndia Limited and Ors.(11.11.2011)

Mines and Minerals(Development and Regulation)Act, 1957-Section 5(1) & 17A(1A).

JT 2011(13) SC 200, 2011(4)RCR (Criminal) 862, 2011(12)SCALE 504.

Constitution of India-Article215.

7. Kalyaneshwari v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Ors.(12.05.2011)

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971. 2011(3) ALLMR (SC) 462 JT2011(7) SC 6, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 77, 2011(6) SCALE220.

8. Kanwar Singh Saini v. HighCourt of Delhi (23.09.2011)

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Section 2, 10, 11, 12, 19(1).

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Order 10 Rule 1, Order 14 Rule1(5), Order 15 Rule 1, Order 21Rule 32, Order 39 Rule 1, Order39 Rule 2 & Order 39 Rule 2A.

2011(4) KLT (SN) 32, 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 402, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 407, 2011(10)SCALE 725.

Indian Forest Act, 1927.

Coastal Area Classification andDevelopment Regulations 1991.

Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980.

Maharashtra Private Forest(Acquisition) Act, 1975-Section21.

9. Krishnadevi MalchandKamathia and Ors. v.Bombay EnvironmentalAction Group and Ors.(31.01.2011)

Environment Protection Act,1986-Section 15.

AIR 2011 SC 1140, 2011(3)ALLMR (SC) 474, 2011(3)BomCR 786(SCSuppl) 2011(3)CHN 66 JT 2011(2) SC 84,2011(2) SCALE 133 (2011) 3SCC 363.

Page 30: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

268 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

10. L.K. Trust v. EDC Ltd. andOrs. (10.05.2011)

Companies Act, 1956 StateFinance Corporation Act, 1951-Section 29 Transfer of PropertyAct, 1882-Section 54 Transfer ofProperty Act, 1882-Section 60Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Section 2, 12.

AIR 2011 SC 2060 II (2011) BC655 JT 2011(6) SC 470, 2011(3)KLT (SN) 9, 2011(4) MPLJ 9,2011(4) RCR (Civil) 600,2011(5) SCALE 531(2011) 6SCC 780.

Contempt of Courts Rules-Rule3(C).

Supreme Court Rules, 1966Supreme Court Orders-Order 47Constitution of India-Article129, 136, 141, 144.

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Section 2, 12, 14, 15 & 23.

11. Muthu Karuppan v. ParithiIlamvazhuthi and Anr.(15.04.2011)

Madras High Court Contempt ofCourt Rules, 1975-Rule 3, 4 &8. Constitution of India-Article215 & 225.

AIR 2011 SC 1645, 2011 CriLJ2680, 2011(2) Crimes 163 (SC)2011(3) CTC 520 [2011(3) JCR23 (SC) ] JT 2011(4) SC 268,2011(3) KCCR SN 329, 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 829, 2011(4)SCALE 664(2011) 5 SCC 496,(2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 709, 2011(2)UC 922.

12. National CampaignCommittee for CentralLegislation on ConstructionLabour v. Union of India(UOI) and Ors. (15.03.2011)

Building and Other ConstructionWorkers (Regulations ofEmployment and Conditions ofService) Act, 1996-Section 4, 6,7, 12, 16, 18, 22, 60.

JT 2011(3) SC 406, 2011(3)KCCR SN 313, 2011(3) SCALE558 (2011) 4 SCC 647.

Building and Other ConstructionWorkers’ Welfare Cess Act,1996-Section 3.

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971Constitution of India-Article 32.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 156(3), 200.

13. P. Mahalingam v. MonicaKumar and Anr.(16.12.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 32,136, 226, 311(2).

2011(13) SCALE 594.

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Section 12, 20.

14. Prakash Kakubhai Rangwalav. Nyayalay KaramachariAnne N.H.S. and Anr.(19.04.2011)

Constitution of India-Article215.

2011(5) SCALE 121.

15. Sanjoy Narayan Editor inChief Hindustan and Ors. v.Hon. High Court ofAllahabad thr. R. G.(30.08.2011)

Right to Information ActContempt of Courts ActConstitution of India-Article19(1) & 19(2).

JT 2011(10) SC 74, 2011(3)KLT 882 (SC) 2011(9) SCALE532.

CONTRACTS

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Board of Control for Cricketin India v. World SportsGroup (I) P. Ltd.(21.04.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996-Section 9 & 11.

2011(5) SCALE 19.

2. Chatterjee Petrochem (I) Pvt.Ltd. v. HaldiaPetrochemicals Ltd. and Ors.(30.09.2011)

Specific Relief Act, 1963. [2011] 105 CLA 27 (SC) [2011]167 CompCas 373 (SC) 2011(4)KLT (SN) 101, 2011(11) SCALE325.

Page 31: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 269

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Companies Act, 1956-Section10F, 289, 397, 397(2), 398, 399,402, 403, 406, 433 & 619B.

Depositories Act, 1996.

Companies Act, 1913.

Companies Act, 1948-Section210.

Contract Act-Section 51, 52, 53& 54.

SEBI (Depositories andParticipants) Regulations 1996.

Companies Act, 1956.3. Citadel Fine Pharmaceuticalsv. Ramaniyam Real EstatesP. Ltd. and Anr.(08.08.2011)

Tamil Nadu Urban Land(Ceiling and Regulations) Act,1978-Section 5, 6, 7, 9(5), 11(1),11(3), 12, 13, 14, l5, 15B, 16 &21.

AIR 2011 SC 3351, 2011 5AWC 4861 SC, 2011(6) CTC112 JT 2011(9) SC 265, 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 894, 2011(8)SCALE 301.

Income Tax Act, 1961-Section269UC.

Tamil Nadu Urban Land(Ceiling and Regulation) RepealAct, 1999-Section 3 & 4.

Indian Contract Act, 1872-Section 55.

Specific Relief Act, 1963-Section9.

Income Tax Rules, 1962-Rule48L.

Companies Act, 1956.

Income Tax Act, 1961-Section230A.

Income Tax Act 1981-Section230A.

4. Coromandel Indag Products(P) Ltd. v. Garuda Chit andTrading Co. P. Ltd. and Anr.(16.08.2011)

Specific Relief Act, 1963-Section16.

2011 6 AWC (Supp) 5899 SC JT2011(10) SC 34(2011) 8 MLJ112 (SC) 2011(4) RCR (Civil)677, 2011(9) SCALE 139(2011)8 SCC 601.

Urban Land Ceiling Act-Section3 & 6.

Urban Land (Ceiling andRegulation) Ordinance 1976.

Contract Act, 1872-Section 51,52, 53, 54 & 55.

Transfer of Property Act, 1882-Section 34, 55, 55(1) & 55(5).

5. Mrs. Saradamani Kandappanv. Mrs. S. Rajalakshmi andOrs. (04.07.2011)

Specific Relief Act, 1963.

AIR 2011 SC 3234, 2011(5)ALD 100 (SC) JT 2011(8) SC129 2011(3) KLT (SN) 43(2011) 6 MLJ 149 (SC) 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 130.

Rent Control Act.

Bombay Rents Hotel andLodging House Rates ControlAct, 1947-Section 5(10)(B), 7 &9(2).

Code of Civil Procedure-Order41 Rule 27.

Page 32: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

270 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Constitution of India-Article 14& 136.

6. Oil and Natural GasCorporation Ltd. v. Off-Shore Enterprises Inc.(23.02.2011)

Arbitration Act, 1940 ContractAct.

2011(4) SCALE 45.

7. Pramod Buildings andDevelopers (P) Ltd. v. ShantaChopra (09.02.2011)

Income Tax Act, 1961-Section269(UL). Constitution of India-Article 136.

AIR 2011 SC 1424, 2011(3)ALLMR (SC) 960, 2011(3)KCCR SN 302, 2011(3) RCR(Civil) 507, 2011(3) SCALE 65,(2011) 4 SCC 741.

Indian Partnership Act.8. R. L. Kalathia and Co. v.State of Gujarat(14.01.2011)

Code of Civil Procedure-Section80.

AIR 2011 SC 754, 2011(1)ALLMR (SC) 952, 2011 3 AWC2634 SC (SCSuppl) 2011(2)CHN 30, 2011(2) CTC117(2011) 1 GLR 819 (SC)[2011(1) JCR 172 (SC) ] JT2011(2) SC 68, 2011(2) KCCRSN 99, (2011) 3 MLJ 213 (SC)2011(2) RCR (Civil) 832,2011(1) SCALE 441(2011) 2SCC 400 [2011]1 SCR 391.

Specific Relief Act, 1963-Section10, 12, 12(3), 14, 20 & 20(1).

Hindu Minority andGuardianship Act, 1956-Section8(2).

9. Shanker Singh v. NarinderSingh and Ors. (15.12.2011)

Constitution of India-Article136.

2011(13) SCALE 574.

Sale of Goods Act 1930-Section45(1), 46(1), 47(1) & 49(1).

10. Suchetan Exports P. Ltd. v.Gupta Coal India Limitedand Ors. (02.08.2011)

Code of Civil Procedure-Order39 Rule 1 & Order 39 Rule 2.

[2011(4) JCR 65 (SC) ] JT2011(8) SC 542, 2011(8) SCALE165.

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996-Section 5.

11. Union of India (UOI) andOrs. v. Tantia ConstructionPvt. Ltd. (18.04.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 14,19(1) & 226.

2011(2) ARBLR 115 (SC) 20115 AWC 4568 SC [2011(3) JCR 8(SC) ] JT 2011(5) SC 59,2011(2) KLJ 15, 2011-3-LW691, 2011(3) RCR (Civil) 821,2011(4) SCALE 745(2011) 5SCC 697.

CRIMINAL LAW

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. A. Shankar v. State ofKarnataka (09.06.2011)

Supreme Court (Enlargement ofCriminal Appellate Jurisdiction)Act, 1970-Section 2. IndianPenal Code, 1860-Sections 302,307 & 324. Code of CriminalProcedure, 1973-Section 161 &313.

AIR 2011 SC 2302, 2011(3)Crimes 21 (SC) JT 2011(6) SC659, 2011(6) SCALE 478,(2011) 6 SCC 279(2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 915.

Page 33: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 271

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

2. A. Subash Babu v. State ofA.P. and Anr. (21.07.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure(Andhra Pradesh SecondAmendment) Act, 1992. HinduMarriage Act, 1955-Sections 4,5, 11 & 16. Terrorist andDisruptive Activities (Prevention)Act, 1987-Section 19. IndianPenal Code-Sections 198A(1),304B, 417, 420, 494, 495 &498A.

2011(3) ACR 3182 (SC) AIR2011 SC 3031 II (2011) DMC827 III (2011) DMC 50SC,2011(3) JCC 2189 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 483, 2011(4) PLJR1, 2011(3) RCR (Criminal) 674,2011(7) SCALE 671(2011) 7SCC 616, 2011(2) UC 1509.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 2, 154, 155(2),155(4), 156, 156(3), 173(2),198, 198(1) & 482. Constitutionof India-Articles 136, 141, 142,200, 246, 254 & 254(2).

3. A. B. Bhaskara Rao v.Inspector of Police, CBI,Visakhapatnam (23.09.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Section 7, 7(2), 12, 13,13(1) & 13(2). Hindu MarriageAct, 1955-Section 13B(1) &13B(2).

2011(4) KLT (SN) 35, 2011(4)RCR (Criminal) 290, 2011(10)SCALE 740.

Constitution of India-Article 142& 145.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 161 & 482.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section302 & 304.

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section 100. Code of CivilProcedure, 1908-Order 47 Rules6.

Prevention of Corruption Act,1947-Section 5 & 5(2).

Supreme Court Rules, 1966.

4. A. N. Santhanam v. K.Elangovan (15.02.2011)

Scheduled Castes and ScheduledTribes (Prevention of Atrocities)Act, 1989-Section 3(1). Code ofCriminal Procedure, 1973-Sections 307, 386, 389, 390,391, 392 & 401.

2011(2) JCC 720.

5. AZEEZ v. State of Kerala(28.03.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 279,304A & 337.

2011(4) SCALE 241.

6. Abdul Gani Bhat v. ChAIRman, Islamia CollegeGoverning Board And Ors.(25.01.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure -Section 340.

2011(2) SCALE 224.

7. Abdul Rehman and Ors. v.K. M. Anees-ul-Haq(14.11.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 109, 114, 147, 182,192, 193, 194, 195, 196, 199,200, 205, 206, 207, 208, 209,210, 211, 228, 340, 379, 406,419, 448, 465, 467, 471, 476 &500.

JT 2011(13) SC 271, 2011(12)SCALE 609.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 173, 195, 195(1),340 & 482.

Page 34: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

272 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Dowry Prohibition Act-Section 3& 4.

Prevention of Corruption Act,1947-Sections 1, 2, 5(2), 6, 6(1),6(2), 7, 10 & 11.

8. Abhay Singh Chautala v.C.B.I. (04.07.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act,1947-Sections 13, 13(1), 13(2),15, 15(1), 15(3) 19, 19(1) &19(2).

2011(2) ACR 2252 (SC) 2011(2)ALD (Cri) 574, 2011(3) Crimes93 (SC) 2011 GLH (3) 311 JT2011(7) SC 313, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 443, 2011(6) SCALE658 (2011) 7 SCC 141(2011) 3SCC (Cri) 1.

Delhi Special PoliceEstablishment Act-Section 5 &6.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 21,21(3), 21(7), 21(12) & 109.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 482.

9. Agricultural MarketCommittee A.P. etc. v. M. K.Exports, A.P. etc. etc.(29.04.2011)

Andhra Pradesh Agricultural(Produce and Livestock) MarketsAct, 1966-Sections 7, 7(5), 12,12(1), 12A to 12G & 23.

2011(2) Crimes 241 (SC) JT2011(5) SC 353, 2011(5) SCALE62.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 482.

Indian Evidence Act-Section113B.

10. Ajay Kumar Das v. State ofJharkhand and Anr.(06.09.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 34,304B & 498A.

AIR 2011 SC 3652, 2011(59)BLJR 2707.00, JT 2011(13) SC78, 2011(4) RCR (Criminal)231, 2011(10) SCALE 390.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 482.

11. Ajit Singh v. State of Punjab(01.09.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,299, 300, 302, 304 & 307.

JT 2011(10) SC 177, 2011(10)SCALE 127.

12. Akkamahadevi v. State ofKarnataka (09.06.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section302 & 380.

2011(6) SCALE 530.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 235 & 313.

13. Akram Khan v. State of WestBengal (05.12.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 120B, 363, 363A &364A.

2011(3) SCALE 308.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973.

Indian Evidence Act-Section 35.14. Alamelu and Anr. v. Staterepresented by Inspector ofPolice (18.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 109,366 & 376. Code of CriminalProcedure-Section 311 & 313.Constitution of India-Article 21& 136.

2011(2) ACR 1873 (SC) AIR2011 SC 715, 2011(1) ALD (Cri)711, 2011(1) JCC 239 (SC)[2011(2) JCR 1 (SC) ] JT2011(1) SC 265, 2011(2) KCCRSN 96, 2011(1) NCC 487,2011(1) RCR (Criminal) 498,2011(1) SCALE 575(2011) 2SCC 385(2011) 1 SCC (Cri) 688[2011] 2 SCR 147.

Page 35: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 273

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

15. Amar Bahadur Singh v. Stateof U.P. (25.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 376. 2011(3) ACR 2565 (SC) AIR2011 SC 1352, 2011 CriLJ 1921[2011(2) JCR 224 (SC) ] JT2011(3) SC 269, 2011(I) OLR(SC) 1023, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 893, 2011(3) SCALE353 [2011] 2 SCR 243.

16. Ameer Chand v. NirmalChand (08.04.2011)

Negotiable Instruments Act,1881-Section 138.

AIR 2011 SC 3297.

17. Amerika Rai and Ors. v.State of Bihar (23.02.2011)

Arms Act-Section 27. IndianPenal Code-Sections 34, 149,302, 307 & 324.

2011(2) ACR 1227 (SC) AIR2011 SC 1379, 2011(59) BLJR340, 2011(2) Crimes 48 (SC) JT2011(5) SC 406, 2011(3) PLJR131, 2011(2) SCALE 696,(2011) 4 SCC 677(2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 429, 2011(1) UC 612.

18. Amit Singh v. State ofMaharashtra and Anr.(08.08.2011)

Juvenile Justice (Care andProtection of Children) Act,2000.

Arms Act, 1959-Sections 2, 3, 5,7A, 15, 20, 25, 25(1B), 27 & 64.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 120B, 307, 341,379, 392, 396 & 506.

2011(3) ACR 3087 (SC) 2011(3)Crimes 200 (SC) JT 2011(8) SC634, 2011(3) KLJ 53, 2011(II)OLR (SC) 740 (2011) 164 PLR312, 2011(3) RCR (Criminal)859, 2011(8) SCALE 439,2011(3) UC 1814.

Juvenile Justice (Care andProtection of Children) Rules2007-Rule 12 & 98.

Constitution of India-Article 21& 32.

19. Amitava Banerjee @ Amit @Bappa Banerjee v. State ofWest Bengal (17.08.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 201-I,302 & 364. Code of CriminalProcedure-Section 161 & 164.

AIR 2011 SC 2913, 2011(3)Crimes 214 (SC) JT 2011(9) SC371, 2011(9) SCALE 185,2011(3) UC 1714.

20. Anil Kumar Gupta v. State ofU.P. (09.03.2011)

Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961-Section 3 & 4. Indian PenalCode-Section 498A & 304B.

2011(2) ACR 2129 (SC) 2011CriLJ 2131 II (2011) DMC 220SC, 2011(2) JCC 1226 JT2011(3) SC 529, 2011(1) NCC825, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal)292, 2011(3) SCALE 453 (2011)11 SCC 24(2011) 3 SCC (Cri)94.

Negotiable Instruments Act-Section 138 & 139. Indian PenalCode-Section 406 & 420.

21. Anil Sachar and Anr. v. ShreeNath Spinners P. Ltd. andOrs. etc. (19.07.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 235(2).

III (2011) BC 508 (2011) 3CompLJ 654 (SC) 2011(3)Crimes 142 (SC) JT 2011(8) SC586, 2011(3) KLJ 444, 2011(3)KLT (SN) 71, 2011(II) OLR (SC)693, 2011(3) RCR (Criminal)698, RLW 2011(4) SC 3442,2011(7) SCALE 730, 2011(2)UC 1484.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,114, 302, 307 & 448.

22. Anisetti Veerabhadra Raoand Anr. v. State of A.P.(25.01.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

2011(3) ACR 2567 (SC) JT2011(7) SC 50, 2011(3) SCALE4.

Page 36: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

274 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Negotiable Instruments Act,1881-Section 138 & 141.

23. Anita Malhotra v. ApparelExport Promotion Counciland Anr. (08.11.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 397 & 482.Companies Act, 1956-Sections25, 159, 160, 161, 163, 166,610 & 610(3).

2011(6) BomCR 694, 183(2011) DLT 488 (SC) 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 930, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 835, 2011(12)SCALE 471.

Evidence Act, 1872-Section 74,74(1) & 74(2).

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Section 2, 12, 12(1) & 19.

24. Anup Bhushan Vohra v. TheRegistrar General, HighCourt of Judicature atCalcutta (16.09.2011)

Calcutta High Court. Contemptof Courts Rules, 1975.

JT 2011(10) SC 606, 2011(4)KLT (SN) 60, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 275, 2011(10)SCALE 561.

25. Anwar Ali and Ors. v. Stateof U.P. (07.06.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 148,149, 302, 307 & 452.

2011(6) SCALE 545.

26. Arabindra Mukherjee v. Stateof West Bengal (02.06.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections120B, 201, 302 & 364.

2011(6) SCALE 547.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

Scheduled Castes and ScheduledTribes (Prevention of AtrocitiesAct) 1989-Section 3(1).

27. Arumugam Servai v. State ofTamil Nadu (19.04.2011)

Hindu Marriage Act.

AIR 2011 SC 1859, 2011 CriLJ2899, 2011(2) Crimes 221 (SC),2011 GLH (2) 1546, 2011(3)JCC 1985 (SC), [2011(3) JCR128 (SC) ] JT 2011(4) SC 300,2011(2) KLJ 44, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 729, 2011(4) SCALE756(2011) 6 SCC 405(2011) 2SCC (Cri) 993.

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Section 13(1), 13(2) & 19.

28. Arun Kumar Aggarwal v.State of Madhya Pradesh andOrs. (02.09.2011)

Anti Corruption Act, 1988-Sections 13, 13(1), 13(2) & 19.

AIR 2011 SC 3056 JT 2011(10)SC 167, 2011(4) RCR (Criminal)137, 2011(9) SCALE 608.

Income Tax Act, 1922-Section31.

Income Tax Act, 1961-Section153(3).

Indian Penal Code-Section 120B.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 169 & 482.

Mental Capacity Act, 2005.

Termination of Life on Requestand Assisted Suicide (ReviewProcedures) Act, 2002.

Burial and Cremation Act.

29. Aruna RamchandraShanbaug v. Union of India(UOI) and Ors. (07.03.2011)

Oregon Death with Dignity Act,1997.

AIR 2011 SC 1290, 2011(59)BLJR 561, ILR 2011(1) Kerala913 [2011(2) JCR 172 (SC) ] JT2011(3) SC 300, 2011(2) KCCRSN 123, 2011(3) KLT (SN) 26,(2011) 2 MLJ 735 (SC) 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 167, 2011(3)SCALE 298 (2011) 4 SCC 454,(2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 352, 2011(1)UC 622.

Transplantation of HumanOrgans Act, 1994-Section 2 & 3(6).

Indian Penal Code-Sections 302,304, 306 & 309.

Page 37: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 275

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 241.

Constitution of India-Articles 12,21, 32, 226 & 226(1).

Indian Evidence Act-Section 25.

Terrorist and DisruptiveActivities (Prevention) Act,1987-Section 3 (5) & 15.

30. Arup Bhuyan v. State ofAssam (03.02.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 19& 21.

2011(1) ACR 655 (SC) 2011(2)ADJ 700 AIR 2011 SC 957,2011 CriLJ 1455, 2011(1)Crimes 268 (SC) (2011) 1 GLR845 (SC) 2011(2) JCC 977,2011(1) JCC 416 (SC) [2011(2)JCR 170 (SC) ] 2011(2) KCCRSN 141, 2011(I) OLR (SC)1057, 2011(1) RCR (Criminal)882, 2011(2) SCALE 210 (2011)3 SCC 377(2011) 1 SCC (Cri)855 [2011] 2 SCR 506.

Himachal Pradesh Ceiling onLand Holdings Act, 1972.

31. Ashish Chadha v. Smt. AshaKumari and Anr.(02.12.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections120B, 218, 420, 467, 468 &471.

2011(13) SCALE 157.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 239, 240 & 303.

Constitution of India-Article22(1) & 136.

Special Marriage Act 1954.

Delhi Special PoliceEstablishment Act, 1946. IndianPenal Code-Sections 120B, 302,306 & 506.

32. Ashok Kumar Todi v.Kishwar Jahan and Ors.(01.03.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Sections 2, 154(3), 156(1), 173,173(2), 174 & 175.

2011(1) ACR 981 (SC) AIR2011 SC 1254(2011) 3 CALLT 9(SC) 2011 CriLJ 2317, I (2011)DMC 418 SC JT 2011(3) SC 50,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 145,2011(3) SCALE 94(2011) 3 SCC758 (2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 75.

Constitution of India-Article 19,21 & 226.

33. Ashok Surajlal Ulke v. Stateof Maharashtra (27.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 354& 376.

2011 CriLJ 2330, 2011(3)KCCR SN 279, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 63, 2011(2) SCALE616 [2011] 2 SCR 246.

34. Ashok Tshering Bhutia v.State of Sikkim (25.02.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Sections 13(1), 13(2), 19& 19(1). Prevention ofCorruption Act, 1947-Section5(1). Terrorist and DisruptiveActivities (Prevention) Act,1987-Section 20. IndianEvidence Act, 1872.

AIR 2011 SC 1363, 2011 CriLJ1770, 2011(2) JCC 1153,2011(1) NCC 861, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 99, 2011(2) SCALE735(2011) 4 SCC 402(2011) 2SCC (Cri) 258.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 161, 162, 313,391 & 465. Sikkim GovernmentServants Conduct Rules, 1981-Rule 19.

Code of Civil Procedure-Section391.

Page 38: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

276 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Code of Civil Procedure-Order41 Rule 27.

Constitution of India-Article 14& 21.

35. Assistant Director, Direct ofEnforcement v. Hassan AliKhan (17.03.2011)

Prevention of Money LaunderingAct, 2002.

2011(4) SCALE 53.

Antiquities and Art TreasuresAct, 1972-Section 3, 24 & 25(1).Customs Act.

Indian Penal Code-Section 120B.

36. B. Fine Art Auctioneers Pvt.Ltd. and Ors. v. C.B.I. andAnr. (25.01.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 136& 226.

2011(2) ACR 1533 (SC)2011(265) ELT 167 (SC), JT2011(6) SC 307, 2011(1) SCALE742(2011) 11 SCC 491(2011) 3SCC (Cri) 229 [2011] 1 SCR563.

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 9, 45 & 73.Identification of Prisoners Act,1920-Section 2, 4 & 5.

Arms Act-Section 27(3).

37. B.A. Umesh v. Regr. Gen.High Court of Karnataka(01.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,201, 302, 307, 347, 376, 376(2),392, 394, 449, 467 & 471.

2011(2) ACR 1478 (SC) AIR2011 SC 1000, 2011(59) BLJR267, 2011(2) JCC 924 [2011(2)JCR 265 (SC) ] JT 2011(2) SC128, 2011(1) RCR (Criminal)803, 2011(1) RCR (Criminal)804, 2011(2) SCALE 111,(2011) 3 SCC 85(2011) 1 SCC(Cri) 801.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 235(2), 313,354(3) & 366.

Contempt of Court Act, 1971-Sections 2, 15, 15(1) & 19.

Seeds Act.

38. B.N. Shivanna v. AdvantaIndia Limited and Anr.(14.03.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 391.

2011 CriLJ 1916 JT 2011(3) SC415, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal)385, 2011(3) SCALE 536,(2011) 4 SCC 216, (2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 192.

High Court of Karnataka(Contempt of Court Proceedings)Rules, 1981-Rule 7.

Contempt of Supreme CourtRules, 1975.

39. B.V. Vidhyashankar v. B.Mahaveer Kumar(28.03.2011)

Negotiable Instruments Act,1881-Section 138.

2011(3) RCR (Civil) 942,2011(3) RCR (Criminal) 797.

40. Babu and Anr. v. State ofM.P. (20.05.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 302& 377.

2011(6) SCALE 425.

41. Babulal Sahu v. State ofChhattisgarh (13.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 300,302 & 304.

AIR 2011 SC 2530 [2011(3)JCR 318 (SC) ] 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 72, 2011(6) SCALE206.

Dowry Prohibition (Amendment)Act, 1986. Dowry ProhibitionAct, 1961-Section 2 & 4.

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 113B.

42. Bachni Devi and Anr. v.State of Haryana throughSecretary, Home Department(08.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section30 & 304B.

2011(1) ACR 661 (SC) AIR2011 SC 1098, 2011(59) BLJR306, 2011 CriLJ 1634, 2011(1)Crimes 289 (SC), I (2011) DMC494 SC, 2011 GLH(2) 1557,2011(1) JCC 418 (SC), JT2011(2) SC 1, 2011(2) KCCRSN 160, 2011(1) NCC 670,2011(2) PLJR 54, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 868, 2011(2) SCALE265(2011) 4 SCC 427(2011) 2

Page 39: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 277

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 161.

SCC (Cri) 280 [2011] 2 SCR627.

43. Baldev Singh and Ors. v.State of Punjab (22.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 376,376(2) & 342.

2011(2) ACR 1226 (SC), AIR2011 SC 1231, 2011 CriLJ1746, 2011(2) Crimes 52 (SC),2011(1) JCC 519 (SC), JT2011(3) SC 540, 2011(3) PLJR81, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal)127, 2011(2) SCALE 689.

Indian Penal Code-Section 34,324 & 326.

44. Baljinder Singh @ Bittu v.State of Punjab (28.09.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 357.

2011(4) Crimes 161 (SC),2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 697,2011(11) SCALE 180.

45. Bangaru Laxman v. State(through CBI) and Anr.(22.11.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Sections 5, 5(1), 5(2), 5(3)5(4), 6, 7 & 26. Criminal LawAmendment Act, 1952-Section 3& 8(2). Special Court (Trial ofOffences Relating toTransactions in Securities) ActGeneral Clauses Act, 1897-Section 3(32).

2011(13) SCALE 212.

Code of Criminal Procedure1973-Sections 164, 167, 195,306, 306(1), 306(2), 306(4),307, 308, 308 (1), 308 (2), 308(3), 308 (4), 308 (5) & 340.

Code of Criminal Procedure1898-Sections 308, 337, 338,339, 339A & 540.

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 113A & 113B.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 304, 304B, 306 &498A.

46. Bansi Lal v. State of Haryana(14.01.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 313 & 319.

AIR 2011 SC 691, 2011(1) ALD(Cri) 704, 2011(1) Crimes 211(SC), 2011 GLH (2) 969, (2011)2 GLR 969, 2011(1) JCC 480(SC) [2011(1) JCR 259 (SC) ] JT2011(5) SC 373, 2011(2) KCCRSN 98, 2011(4) PLJR 15,2011(1) RCR (Criminal) 753,RLW 2011(1) SC 357, 2011(1)SCALE 447, (2011) 11 SCC 359,(2011) 3 SCC (Cri) 188, [2011]1 SCR 724.

47. Bhagaloo Lodh and Anr. v.State of U.P. (14.06.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section34 & 302.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 313.

2011(2) ACR 2301 (SC) AIR2011 SC 2292, 2011(3) Crimes10 (SC), JT 2011(6) SC 498,2011(6) SCALE 505, 2011(2)UC 1269.

Indian Evidence Act-Section 27.48. Bhagwan Dass v. State(NCT) of Delhi (09.05.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure on162(1) & 313.

AIR 2011 SC 1863, 2011(59)BLJR 2408, 2011 CriLJ 2903,2011(2) Crimes 266 (SC) JT2011(6) SC 345, 2011(3) PLJR241, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal)920, 2011(5) SCALE 498,(2011) 6 SCC 396, 2011(2) UC1183.

Page 40: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

278 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

49. Bhaiyamiyan @ Jardar Khanand Anr. v. State of MadhyaPradesh (03.05.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section376(2).

AIR 2011 SC 2218, 2011(2) JLJ242, 2011(3) RCR (Criminal)690, 2011(6) SCALE 326,(2011) 6 SCC 394, (2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 983.

50. Bhaskar Mishra v. State ofMadhya Pradesh(08.08.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 307.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 438, 439 & 482.

AIR 2011 SC 3656, JT 2011(10)SC 301, 2011(10) SCALE 125.

Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961-Section 3 & 4.

Indian Penal Code-Section 406& 498A.

52. Bhushan Kumar Meen v.State of Punjab and Ors.(02.09.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 482.

2011(3) ACR 2696 (SC), JT2011(10) SC 107, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 144, 2011(9) SCALE617, (2011) 8 SCC 438.

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Sections 3, 5(1), 7, 9, 10,11, 13(1) & 13(2).

Prevention of Money LaunderingAct, 2002-Sections 2, 3, 4, 43,43 (1), 43 (2), 44, 45(1), 45(1A),54 & 55.

53. Binod Kumar v. State ofJharkhand and Ors.(29.03.2011)

Delhi Special PoliceEstablishment Act, 1946-Section1 & 2.

Foreign Exchange RegulationAct-Section 3 & 4.

Narcotics Drugs PsychotropicSubstances Act.

Prevention of Money-laundering(Amendment) Act 2009.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 4(2) & 156(3).

2011(2) ACR 1992 (SC),2011(59) BLJR 1181, 2011(3)JCC 1636, [2011(2) JCR 253(SC) ] JT 2011(4) SC 114,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 702,2011(4) SCALE 109, (2011) 11SCC 463, (2011) 3 SCC (Cri)217.

Indian Penal Code-Sections120B, 409, 420, 423, 424 &465.

Constitution of India-Article 136& 253.

54. Birbal B. Chouhan and Anr.etc. etc. v. State ofChhattisgarh etc. etc.(14.11.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section399 & 402.

JT 2011(13) SC 157, 2011(12)SCALE 604.

55. Birender Poddar v. State ofBihar (16.05.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 34,302 & 498A.

AIR 2011 SC 2336, 2011(59)BLJR 2067, 2011(2) Crimes 285(SC), II (2011) DMC 384 SC, JT2011(6) SC 609, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 510, RLW 2011(4)SC 3061, 2011(6) SCALE 354,(2011) 6 SCC 350, (2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 957, 2011(2) UC 1355.

Page 41: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 279

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

56. Buddhu Singh v. State ofBihar (Now Jharkhand)(28.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 302& 304.

2011(59) BLJR 1497, JT2011(6) SC 617, 2011(4) KCCRSN 396, 2011(3) PLJR 20,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 895.

57. Budhadev Karmaskar v.State of West Bengal(02.08.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 21. 2011(3) ACR 3003 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 289, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 754, 2011(8) SCALE155.

Indian Penal Code-Section 302.58. Budhadev Karmaskar vs.State of West Bengal(14.02.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 21.

2011(3) ACR 2401 (SC), 2011CriLJ 1684, 2011(2) Crimes 17(SC), [2011(2) JCR 65 (SC) ], JT2011(2) SC 115, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 897, 2011(2) SCALE435, (2011) 11 SCC 538, [2011]2 SCR 925, 2011(2) UC 1448.

59. Budhadev Karmaskar v.State of West Bengal(15.09.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 21. JT 2011(12) SC 15, 2011(10)SCALE 558.

60. Budhadev Karmaskar v.State of West Bengal(24.08.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 21. JT 2011(9) SC 361, 2011(9)SCALE 327, 2011(3) UC 1784.

61. C. Ronald and Anr. v. State,U. T. of Andaman andNicobar Islands(10.08.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure1898-Sections 164, 313, 386 &417.

2011(3) ACR 3206 (SC), JT2011(10) SC 77, 2011(9) SCALE59, 2011(3) UC 1611.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 35,304, 304A, 324, 326 & 429.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Sections 209, 216, 228, 240,323, 386, 397, 399, 401 & 482.

62. C.B.I. and Ors. v. KeshubMahindra etc. etc.(11.05.2011)

Constitution of India-Article137.

AIR 2011 SC 2037, 2011(2)Crimes 308 (SC), ILR [2011] MP1789, 2011(2) KLT 740 (SC),2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 906,2011(5) SCALE 591, (2011) 6SCC 216, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)863.

63. C.B.I. v. Blue Sky Tie-UpPvt. Ltd. and Ors.(20.05.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Section 13(1) & 13(2).

2011(6) SCALE 436.

Foreign Exchange RegulationAct, 1973-Sections 13, 18(1),18A, 19(1), 44(2), 56, 56(1) &69.

Monopolies and RestrictiveTrade Practices Act, 1969-Section 48A.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 482.

Indian Penal Code-Section 120B,409 & 477A.

Terrorist and DisruptiveActivities (Prevention) Act,1987-Section 8(3) & 14(5).

64. CBI v. Mustafa AhmadDossa (22.02.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Sections 173(8), 273, 299,299(2) & 362.

2011(2) ACR 1233 (SC), JT2011(2) SC 411, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 178, 2011(2) SCALE720, (2011) 4 SCC 418, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 272.

Page 42: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

280 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

65. CBI, Hyderabad v.Subramani Gopalakrishnanand Anr. (21.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections120B, 409, 419, 420, 467, 468,471 & 477A.

2011(2) Crimes 229 (SC),2011(3) JCC 1823, JT 2011(5)SC 121, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal)946, 2011(5) SCALE 12, (2011)5 SCC 296, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)618, 2011(2) UC 1320.

66. Delhi Special PoliceEstablishment Act, 1946-Section5(1).

2011(3) GLT (SC) 17, 2011(4)SCALE 583.

Center for PIL and Ors. v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (11.04.2011)

Prevention of Money LaunderingAct. 2002-Section 46 & 46(2).

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 2, 24, 24(4),24(5), 24(6), 24(7), 46, 46(1),46(4), 46(5), 46(6) & 46(7).

Constitution of India-Article226.

67. Chandra Bonia v. State ofAssam (30.03.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 164.

2011(3) GLT (SC) 23, JT2011(7) SC 68, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 190, 2011(6) SCALE721.

68. Chandra Prakash SinghChauhan v. State of U.P. andAnr. (14.06.2011)

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Sections 12, 15, 15(1), 15(2), 20& 23.

2011(6) SCALE 583.

Bar Council of India Act. Codeof Criminal Procedure-Section156(3). Allahabad High CourtRules, 1952-Rule 2, 3, 4 & 5.Advocates Act, 1961.

Constitution of India-Article 14,20(3) & 21.

69. Chandran @ Manichan @Maniyan v. State of Kerala(04.04.2011)

Kerala Abkari Act-Sections2(6A), 2(8), 2(9), 2(10), 2(12),2(13), 3, 6, 7, 8, 41A, 55, 57A,57A(1), 57A(2), 57A(5), 57B,58, 58A(5).

AIR 2011 SC 1594, 2011(2)Crimes 111 (SC), JT 2011(4) SC340, 2011(4) SCALE 314,(2011) 5 SCC 161.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 120B, 201, 299,300, 302, 307, 320, 324, 326 &328.

Cochin Abkari Act.

Travancore Abkari Act.

Madras Abkari Act.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 161, 164, 306,307, 319, 337, 342 & 342A.

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Sections 5, 6, 32, 101, 105, 106,113A, 114A, 114B, 132 & 133.

Prevention of Corruption Act.

Indian Oaths Act-Section 5.

Income Tax Act-Section 131.

Page 43: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 281

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

70. Chhote Lal v. State of M.P.(14.07.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 302& 376(2).

2011(3) ACR 3199 (SC),2011(8) SCALE 257, 2011(2)UC 1476.

Juvenile Justice Act, 2000-Section 23.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 109,120B, 149, 323, 372, 373, 377& 451.

71. Childline India Foundationand Anr. v. Allan JohnWaters and Ors.(18.03.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 164. Constitutionof India-Articles 15(3), 21, 21A,23, 24, 39 & 45.

2011(2) ACR 1978 (SC), 2011CriLJ 2305, 2011(2) Crimes 72(SC), 2011 GLH (1) 694, (2011)3 GLR 2397 (SC), [2011(2) JCR281 (SC) ], JT 2011(3) SC 570,2011(3) KCCR SN 317, 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 339, 2011(3)SCALE 639, (2011) 6 SCC 261,(2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 900.

Prevention of Corruption Act,1947-Section 5(1), 5(2) & 19.

72. Chittaranjan Das v. State ofOrissa (04.07.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 197 & 482.

2011(2) ACR 2247 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 504, 2011(7) SCALE461, (2011) 7 SCC 167, (2011) 3SCC (Cri) 78.

73. D. Ethiraj v. Secretary toGovt. and Ors. (11.10.2011)

Official Secrets Act, 1923-Sections 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 & 10.

2011(6) CTC 549, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 720.

Criminal Law Amendment Act,1961-Section 2 & 3. IndianPenal Code-Sections 34, 109,119, 121, 122, 123, 124, 125,126, 127, 128, 130, 302, 326 &366. Constitution of India-Article 161.

74. D.M. Nagaraja v. TheGovernment of Karnatakaand Ors. (19.09.2011)

Karnataka Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBootleggers Drug – Offenders.

2011(4) KLT (SN) 47, 2011(4)RCR (Criminal) 264, 2011(10)SCALE 592.

Karnataka Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBootleggers Drug – Gamblers.

Karnataka Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBootleggers Drug – Goondas.

Karnataka Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBootleggers Drug-ImmoralTraffic Offenders.

Karnataka Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBootleggers Drug – Slum.Maintenance of Internal SecurityAct, 1971.

Arms Act-Section 3 & 25.

Indian Penal Code 1986-Sections34, 109, 120(B), 141, 143, 144,147, 148, 149, 220, 302, 324,348, 350, 352, 353, 384, 399,402 & 506(B).

Code of Criminal Procedure.

Page 44: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

282 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBootleggers Drug OffendersForest Offenders GoondasImmoral Traffic Offenders SandOffenders Slum-Grabbers andVideo Pirates Act, 1982.

Constitution of India-Article 19,21 & 22.

75. Dandu Jaggaraju v. State ofA.P. (20.07.2011)

Indian Evidence Act-Sections 27,201, 302 & 379.

AIR 2011 SC 3387, 2011(4)RCR (Criminal) 718, 2011(9)SCALE 523.

76. Daya Nand v. State ofHaryana (07.01.2011)

Juvenile Justice Act, 1986.Juvenile Justice (Care andProtection of Children) Act,2000-Sections 2, 2(1), 7A, 15,16(2), 20, 49 & 69. JuvenileJustice (Care and Protection ofChildren) (Amendment) Act,2006. Indian Penal Code-Section376 & 511.

Juvenile Justice (Care andProtection of Children) Rules,2000-Rule 12 & 98.

AIR 2011 SC 593, 2011 CriLJ1157, 2011(1) Crimes 182 (SC),2011 GLH (1) 496, 2011(1)JCC325 (SC), [2011(1) JCR 245(SC) ], JT 2011(1) SC 106,2011(1) KLJ470, 2011(1) NCC523, 2011(1) OLR (SC) 811,2011(1) RCR (Criminal) 420,2011(1) SCALE 143, (2011) 2SCC 224, (2011) 1 SCC (Cri)666, [2011] 1 SCR 173, 2011(2)UC 1296.

Rajasthan Excise Act-Section54A.

77. Dayal Das v. State ofRajasthan (22.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 304& 328.

(2011) 11 SCC 575.

Rajasthan Excise Act-Section54A.

78. Dayal Das v. State ofRajasthan (22.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 304& 328.

2011(2) ACR 2137 (SC), AIR2011 SC 1361, 2011 CriLJ2137, JT 2011(3) SC 261,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 846,2011(3) SCALE 356, [2011] 2SCR 1136.

Indian Arms Act-Section 27.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

79. Deepak Verma v. State ofHimachal Pradesh(11.10.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 34,302 & 323.

2011(4) Crimes 213 (SC),2011(11) SCALE 406, (2011) 10SCC 129.

80. Dharmatma Singh v.Harminder Singh and Ors.(10.05.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 109, 114, 120B,148, 158, 323, 324, 326, 342,376, 376B, 376C, 376D, 420,452 & 506.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 161, 170, 173,173(2), 173(8), 190 (1) & 482.

AIR 2011 SC 2094, 2011(2)Crimes 259 (SC), JT 2011(6) SC68, 2011(3) RCR (Criminal) 38,2011(5) SCALE 552, (2011) 6SCC 102, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)834, 2011(2) UC 1170.

Code of Criminal Procedure1898-Section 173, 190 & 561A.

81. Dinesh Kumar v. Chairman,Airport Authority of Indiaand Anr. (22.11.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Sections 7, 13(1), 13(2),19(1), 19(2), 19(3) & 19(4).

2011(13) SCALE 132.

82. Dinesh Prajapati v. State ofM.P. (23.05.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 302. 2011(6) SCALE 427.

Page 45: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 283

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

83. Disha v. State of Gujarat andOrs. (20.07.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section & 173(8). IndianPenal Code, 1860-Section 120B,406 & 420.

AIR 2011 SC 3168, 2011(3)Crimes 195 (SC), 2011(3) JCC2138 (SC), JT 2011(7) SC 548,2011(3) PLJR 317, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 694, 2011(7) SCALE736, 2011(2) UC 1496.

Supreme Court (Enlargement ofCriminal Appellate Jurisdiction)Act, 1970-Section 2.

84. Durbal v. State of U.P.(25.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 147,148, 149 & 302.

2011(2) ACR 1527 (SC), AIR2011 SC 795, 2011(2) ALD (Cri)131, 2011 CriLJ 1106, 2011(1)JCC 475 (SC), 2011(2) KCCRSN 110, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 124, 2011(1) SCALE730, (2011) 2 SCC 676, (2011) 1SCC (Cri) 877, [2011] 1 SCR1062, 2011(1) UC 501.

Indian Evidence Act-Section 105.

Indian Penal Code-Section 84,302, 304, & 342.

85. Elavarasan v. State rep. byInspector of Police(05.07.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 428.

2011(2) ACR 2227 (SC),2011(3) Crimes 132 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 77, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 543, 2011(7) SCALE33, (2011) 7 SCC 110, (2011) 3SCC (Cri) 44.

86. Fahim Khan v. State of BiharNow Jharkhand(21.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 302.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 157(3) & 313.

2011(2) Crimes 225 (SC), 2011GLH (2) 227, [2011(3) JCR 101(SC) ], 2011(4) SCALE 796.

87. G. Reddeiah v. TheGovernment of AndhraPradesh and Anr.(09.09.2011)

Andhra Pradesh Forest Act,1967-Sections 20(1), 29, 29A (1)& 29(2).

JT 2011(10) SC 285, 2011(4)KLT (SN) 50, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 219, 2011(10)SCALE 224.

Andhra Pradesh Prevention ofDangerous Activities of BootLeggers Dacoits Drug OffendersGoondas Immoral TrafficOffenders and Land GrabbersAct, 1986-Section 2, 3 & 3 (1).

Maintenance of Internal SecurityAct, 1971.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section120B, 378 & 379. AndhraPradesh Sandal Wood and RedSanders Transit Rules, 1969-Rule 3. Constitution of India-Article 19 & 21.

Code of Criminal Procedure.

88. Indian Penal Code-Sections 302,380, 404 & 452.

Gajraj v. State (NCT) ofDelhi (22.09.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

2011(4) Crimes 173 (SC), 183(2011) DLT 35 (SC), 2011(10)SCALE 695.

89. Ghanshyam vs. State ofMaharashtra (28.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 420,468 & 471.

2011(1) OLR (SC) 1021.

Arms Act, 1950-Section 3, 25 &27.

90. Ghure and Ors. v. State ofRajasthan (17.06.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 120B, 395, 396, 397,398 & 412.

2011(3) ACR 2373 (SC), AIR2011 SC 2268, 2011(3) Crimes66 (SC), 2011(6) SCALE 570,(2011) 11 SCC 694.

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 27.

Page 46: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

284 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 313.

91. Glaxo Smith KlinePharmaceuticals Ltd. andAnr. v. State of MadhyaPradesh (28.07.2011)

Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940-Section 18, 25(3) & 35.

AIR 2011 SC 2998, 2011(3)RCR (Criminal) 736, 2011(8)SCALE 80.

92. Gopal Dass thru. BrotherAnand Vir v. Union of India(UOI) and Anr. (14.03.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 32. JT 2011(3) SC 412, 2011(2)KCCR SN 126, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 289, 2011(3) SCALE571, (2011) 4 SCC 300, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 214.

93. Gopal v. State of Karnataka(19.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 302. 2011 CriLJ 2894, 2011(4)KCCR SN 2781, 2011(3) KLJ15, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal)838, 2011(5) SCALE 119.

94. Gopal v. State of MadhyaPradesh (19.05.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 147,148, 149, 302, 304, 323 & 324.

AIR 2011 SC 2325, 2011(2)Crimes 292 (SC), JT 2011(6) SC613, 2011(3) RCR (Criminal)507, 2011(6) SCALE 343,(2011) 6 SCC 354

95. Gosu JAIR ami Reddy andAnr. v. State of A.P.(26.07.2011)

Explosive Substances Act-Section3 & 5.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 140,147, 148, 149, 302, 307 & 324.

Arms Act-Section 25(1).

Code of Criminal Procedure.

2011(3) ACR 3167 (SC), AIR2011 SC 3147, 2011(4) Crimes244 (SC), 2011(3) JCC 2160(SC), JT 2011(8) SC 263,2011(3) KLT (SN) 103, 2011(4)RCR (Criminal) 540, 2011(8)SCALE 58, (2011) 11 SCC 766,2011(2) UC 1531.

Constitution of India-Article136.

Crl. Law Amendment Act-Section 7(1).

Representation of the PeopleAct-Section 136.

96. Gulab Das and Ors. v. Stateof M.P. (16.11.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,294, 307, & 325.

JT 2011(13) SC 167, 2011(12)SCALE 625.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 320.

Evidence Act-Section 113B.97. Gurdeep Singh v. State ofPunjab and Ors.(25.08.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 304B& 498A.

AIR 2011 SC 3616, JT 2011(10)SC 265.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 161.

98. Gurdial Singh and Ors. v.State of Punjab (24.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,148, 149, 304, 323, 324 & 307.

AIR 2011 SC 840, 2011(2) ALD(Cri) 136, 2011 CriLJ 1110,2011(2) JCC 897, [2011(1) JCR198 (SC) ], JT 2011(5) SC 415,2011(1) RCR (Criminal) 879,2011(1) SCALE 669, (2011) 2SCC 768, (2011) 1 SCC (Cri)890, [2011] 1 SCR 556.

Page 47: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 285

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

99. Gurjinder Singh v. State ofPunjab (18.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 302. AIR 2011 SC 972, 2011 CriLJ1693, 2011(2) Crimes 29 (SC),2011(2) JCC 1119, 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 92, 2011(2)SCALE 504, (2011) 3 SCC 530,(2011) 1 SCC (Cri) 1199.

100. Gurmail Singh v. State ofPunjab (20.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,149, 300, 302, 304, 323 & 324.

JT 2011(7) SC 40, 2011(6)SCALE 322.

101. Guru Dev Singh v. State ofM.P. (10.05.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,300, 302, 307 & 323. Code ofCriminal Procedure-Section 313.

AIR 2011 SC 2088, 2011(3) JCC1829, 2011(2) JLJ 276, JT2011(6) SC 76, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 30, 2011(6) SCALE20, (2011) 5 SCC 721.

102. Hardeep Singh v. State ofMadhya Pradesh(05.12.2011)

Madhya Pradesh RecognizedExaminations Act 1937-Section3 & 4.

2011(3) SCALE 289.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,395, 420, 468 & 469.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 197. Constitutionof India-Article 21.

103. Haresh Mohandas Rajput v.State of Maharashtra(20.09.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 106.

AIR 2011 SC 3681, 2011(4)Crimes 163 (SC), JT 2011(10)SC 493, 2011(4) KLT (SN) 48,2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 257,2011(10) SCALE 629.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section302 & 376.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 313.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 304,330, 343, 380 & 457.Constitution of India-Article 21& 22(1).

104. Haricharan and Anr. v. Stateof Madhya Pradesh and Ors.(09.03.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973.

2011(2) ACR 2119 (SC),2011(2) JCC 1068, 2011(2) JLJ334, JT 2011(3) SC 493,2011(1) NCC882, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 330, 2011(3) SCALE462, (2011) 4 SCC 159, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 96.

105. Harshendra Kumar D. v.Rebatilata Koley Etc.(08.02.2011)

Negotiable Instruments Act,1881-Sections 138, 141, 141(1)& 141(2).

Banking Public FinancialInstitutions and NegotiableInstruments Laws (Amendment)Act, 1988.

Companies Act, 1956-Sections2(24), 5, 303(1) & 303(2).

2011(2) ACR 1512 (SC), AIR2011 SC 1090, 1(2010) BC 685,2011(59) BLJR 325, [2011] 101CLA 330 (SC), [2011] 162CompCas 247 (SC), 2011 CriLJ1626, 2011(1) Crimes 280 (SC),2011(1) JCC 42 (SC), 2011(2)KCCR SN 159, 2011(1) KLJ731, 2011(1) KLT 732 (SC),2011(1) NCC 542, 2011(3)PLJR 100, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 887, RLW 2011(2)SC 1724, 2011(2) SCALE 278,(2011) 3 SCC 351, (2011) 1 SCC(Cri) 1139, [2011] 106 SCL 159(SC), [2011] 2 SCR 670, 2011(1)UC 478.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 397, 401 & 482.

Page 48: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

286 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

106. Indian Penal Code-Sections120B, 417, 420, 465, 467, 468& 471.

2011(13) SCALE 536.Helios and MathesonInformation Technology Ltd.and Ors. v. Rajeev Sawhneyand Anr. (16.12.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 173, 202, 227,239, 240 & 482.

Constitution of India-Article136.

107. Himanshu @ Chintu v. Stateof NCT of Delhi(04.01.2011)

Arms Act, 1959-Section 25 &27.

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 154.

Code of Criminal Procedure -Section & 313. Indian PenalCode-Section 34 & 302.

2011(1) ACR 342 (SC), 2011 1AWC (Supp) 2.35 SC, 2011(1)Crimes 157 (SC), 2011(121)DRJ513, [2011(1) JCR 281 (SC)], JT 2011(1) SC 123, 2011(3)PLJR 253, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 405, 2011(1) SCALE30, (2011) 2 SCC 36, (2011) 1SCC (Cri) 593, [2011] 1 SCR 48,2011(1) UC 237.

Protection of Women fromDomestic Violence Act, 2005-Sections 2, 12, 28 & 32.

108. Inderjit Singh Grewal v.State of Punjab and Anr.(23.08.2011)

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 13B & 23 (2). Guardiansand Wards Act, 1890.

III (2011) DMC 7SC, 2011(3)KLJ 40, 2011(4) KLT (SN) 69,2011(4) RCR (Civil) 129,2011(9) SCALE 295, 2011(3)UC 1758.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 468 & 482.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 40, 43, 107, 120B, 191,193, 376, 406 & 498A.

Protection of Women fromDomestic Violence Rules, 2006-Rule 15(6).

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 201, 302, 342 & 364.

109. Inspector of Police, TamilNadu v. John David(20.04.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 31(2), 167, 313,378 & 386.

2011(2) ALD (Cri) 635, 2011(2)Crimes 201 (SC), 2011(3) CTC104, JT 2011(5) SC 1, 2011(4)KCCR SN 377, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 272, 2011(4) SCALE878, (2011) 5 SCC 509, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 647, 2011(2) UC 949.

110. Iqbal Moosa Patel v. State ofGujarat (12.01.2011)

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985-Sections 8,21, 29, 35, 54 & 67.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

Constitution of India-Article136.

2011(2) ACR 1897 (SC),2011(2) ALD (Cri) 148, 2011(3)CGLJ 361, 2011 CriLJ 1142,2011(1) Crimes 205 (SC), 2011GLH (2) 905, (2011) 2 GLR905, 2011(1) JCC 35 (SC),[2011(1) JCR 241 (SC) ], JT2011(1) SC 157, 2011(2) KCCRSN 116, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 473, 2011(1) SCALE318, (2011) 2 SCC 198, (2011) 1SCC (Cri) 654, [2011] 2 SCR121.

East Punjab Urban RentRestriction Act, 1949-Section 13.

111. Iqbal Singh Narang and Ors.v. Veeran Narang(30.11.2011)

Maharashtra Rent Control Act,1999.

2011(13) SCALE 137.

Page 49: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 287

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Limitation Act-Section 5.

Indian Penal Code-Sections120B, 193, 420 & 425.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 195, 195(1), 340& 482.

112. Jagat Singh v. State of H. P.(03.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,300, 302, 303, 304, 305, 306,307, 308, 309, 310, 311, 312,313, 314, 315, 316, 317, 318,319, 320, 321, 322, 323 & 324.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

2011(1) ACR 336 (SC), 2011(1)ALD 402 (SC), 2011 CriLJ 949,2011(1) Crimes 173 (SC),2011(1) JCC 296 (SC), JT2011(1) SC 111, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 393, 2011(1) SCALE25, (2011) 2 SCC 234, (2011) 1SCC (Cri) 671, [2011] 1 SCR 1,2011(1) UC 205.

113. Jagdish Rai v. State ofPunjab (11.03.2011)

Narcotics Drugs andPsychotropic Substances Act,1985-Sections 15, 18, 35 & 54.

Indian Evidence Act-Section 114.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

2011(3) ACR 2405 (SC), AIR2011 SC 1568, 2011 CriLJ2294, 2011(2) Crimes 59 (SC),(2011) 3 GLR 2025, JT 2011(3)SC 196, 2011(3) KCCR SN 304,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 291,RLW 2011(2) SC 1184, 2011(3)SCALE 507, (2011) 4 SCC 571,(2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 292, 2011(1)UC 605.

114. Jagga Singh and Anr. v. Stateof Punjab (03.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,302, 307 & 325.

2011(1) ACR 683 (SC), AIR2011 SC 960, 2011(1) ALD (Cri)689, 2011 CriLJ 1457, 2011(1)Crimes 270 (SC), 2011(1) JCC415 (SC), [2011(2) JCR 48 (SC)], JT 2011(2) SC 496, 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 755, 2011(2)SCALE 209, (2011) 3 SCC 137,(2011) 1 SCC (Cri) 845, [2011]2 SCR 483, 2011(1) UC 463.

115. Prevention of Corruption Act.Jahid Shaikh and Ors. v.State of Gujarat and Anr.(06.07.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Sections 154, 161(3), 164, 173,173(5), 207, 208, 227 & 406.

2011(3) ACR 2931 (SC), JT2011(7) SC 220, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 608, 2011(7) SCALE327, (2011) 7 SCC 762.

Supreme Court Rules, 1966.Supreme Court Orders-Order36.

Constitution of India-Article 21.

116. Jaisy @ Jayaseelan v. Staterep. by Inspector of Police(23.11.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,302, 341 & 449.

JT 2011(13) SC 330, 2011(13)SCALE 81.

117. Jakia Nasim Ahesan andAnr. v. State of Gujarat andOrs. (12.09.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 173(1), 173(2),173(8), 190, 197, 200 & 482.

2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 198,2011(10) SCALE 246, (2011) 1SCC (Cri) 1095.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 114, 120B, 153A, 186,187, 193 & 302. Constitution ofIndia-Article 226.

Page 50: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

288 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Indian Penal Code-Sections 201,302, 304B, 398A & 498A.

118. Jaladhar Mondal v. State ofWest Bengal (25.05.2011)

Constitution of India-Article136.

AIR 2011 SC 1937, [2011(4)JCR 79 (SC) ], JT 2011(6) SC118, 2011(6) SCALE 374,(2011) 6 SCC 382, (2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 976, 2011(2) UC 1331.

119. Jalpat Rai and Ors. v. Stateof Haryana (06.07.2011)

Arms Act, 1959-Section 27.Supreme Court (Enlargement ofCriminal Appellate Jurisdiction)Act, 1970-Section 2.

2011(3) ACR 2828 (SC),2011(3) Crimes 289 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 55, 2011(3) KLT(SN) 88, 2011(7) SCALE 348.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 148,149, 302, 307, 323, 454 & 506.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313 & 319.

120. Jayakumar v. State of Kerala(23.05.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,302, 397 & 457.

2011(6) SCALE 430.

121. Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 439.

2011(13) SCALE 531.Jetha Bhaya Odedara v.Ganga Maldebhai Odedaraand Anr. (16.12.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 114,120B, 143, 147, 148, 149, 279,302, 307, 323, 324, 325, 337,338, 367, 447, 504, 506(2) &507(2).

Arms Act-Sections 25(1), 25(1)A, 25(1B), 25(1) BA & 25(1)(D).

Bombay Police Act-Sections 110,117, 122C, 135, 135B & 142.Prohibition Act-Sections 65(1)E,65E, 66B, 66(1)B, 66E, 66EE &85(1).

Moter Vehicle Act-Section 177,184 & 337.

122. Joseph Salvaraj A. v. State ofGujarat and Ors.(04.07.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 405,406, 415, 420, 503, 506 &506(1).

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 437 & 482. Codeof Civil Procedure-Order 37Rule 2.

2011(3) ACR 2378 (SC), AIR2011 SC 2258, JT 2011(7) SC53, 2011(4) PLJR 31, 2011(3)RCR (Criminal) 632, 2011(6)SCALE 731, (2011) 7 SCC 59,(2011) 3 SCC (Cri) 23.

Indian Penal Code-Section 120B& 302.

123. Jugal Kishore Khetawat v.State of West Bengal(25.02.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 377, 378, 394,394(2) & 431. Constitution ofIndia-Article 21 & 136.

AIR 2011 SC 1358, 2011 CriLJ2170, 2011 GLH (3) 135,2011(3) KCCR SN 285, 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 847, 2011(3)SCALE 414, (2011) 11 SCC 502.

124. K.P. Thimmappa Gowda v.State of Karnataka(04.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 376& 417.

2011(2) ACR 1604 (SC), AIR2011 SC 2564, 2011 CriLJ2591, 2011(2) Crimes 140 (SC),JT 2011(4) SC 2, 2011(II) OLR(SC) 172, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 589, 2011(4) SCALE224.

Page 51: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 289

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Constitution of India-Articles 14,15, 16, 17, 19, 21, 25 & 46.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,323, 354, 452 & 506(2).

125. Kailas and Ors. v. State ofMaharashtra T. R. Taluka P.S. (05.01.2011)

Scheduled Cases and ScheduledTribes (Prevention of Atrocities)Act, 1989-Section 3.

2011(1) ACR 807 (SC), AIR2011 SC 598, 2011(1) Crimes138 (SC), 2011 GLH (2) 994,(2011) 2 GLR 994, 2011(1) JCC461 (SC), JT 2011(1) SC 19,2011(1) RCR (Criminal) 431,2011(1) SCALE 40, (2011) 1SCC (Cri) 401, [2011] 1 SCR 94,2011(1) UC 225.

126. Kailash Gour and Ors. v.State of Assam (15.12.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,302, 323, 324, 326 & 448.

2011(13) SCALE 549.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 161.

127. Kamleshwar Paswan v. Stateof U.T. Chandigarh(11.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 302,307 & 308.

2011(3) ACR 2404 (SC),2011(3) KCCR 252, 2011(1)OLR (SC) 800, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 60, 2011(2) SCALE289, (2011) 11 SCC 564, [2011]1 SCR 647.

128. Kanaiyalal Lalchand Sachdevand Ors. v. State ofMaharashtra and Ors.(07.02.2011)

Securitisation andReconstruction of FinancialAssets and Enforcement ofSecurity Interest Act, 2002-Sections 13,13(2), 13(3), 13(3A),13(4), 13(10), 13(12), 14, 17,17(1), 38(1) & 38(2).

Transfer of Property Act, 1882-Section 69 & 69A.

Security Interest (Enforcement)Rules 2002-Rule 4 & 8.

2011(2) ACR 1507 (SC),1(2010) BC 698, (SCSuppl)2011(2) CHN 105, [2011] 101CLA 146 (SC), [2011] 162CompCas 337 (SC), (2011) 2CompLJ 1 (SC), JT 2011(3) SC159, 2011-4-LW 332, 2011-2-LW (Crl) 194, 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 676, 2011(2) SCALE 233,(2011) 2 SCC 782, [2011] 106SCL 1 (SC), [2011] 2 SCR 602.

Constitution of India-Article 226& 227.

Securitisation andReconstruction of FinancialAssets and Enforcement ofSecurity Interest (Second)Ordinance 2002.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 147,149, 302 & 326.

129. Kanaka Rekha Naik v.Manoj Kumar Pradhan andAnr. (25.01.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 389 & 482.

2011(2) ACR 1522 (SC), AIR2011 SC 799, 2011(2) ALD (Cri)153, 2011 CriLJ 1113, 2011(2)JCC 723 (SC), JT 2011(3) SC270, 2011(2) KCCR SN 115,2011(2) KLJ 253, 2011(2) PLJR77, 2011(1) RCR (Criminal)894, 2011(1) SCALE 736,(2011) 4 SCC 596, (2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 475, [2011] 1 SCR 842,2011(1) UC 510.

130. Kanwar Singh Saini v. HighCourt of Delhi (23.09.2011)

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Sections 2, 10, 11, 12 & 19(1).

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Order 10 Rule 1, Order 14 Rule1(5), Order 15 Rule 1, Order 21Rule 32, Order 39 Rule 1, Order39 Rule 2 & Order 39 Rule 2A.

2011(4) KLT (SN) 32, 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 402, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 407, 2011(10)SCALE 725.

Page 52: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

290 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Section 7, 13(1) & 13(2).

131. Kanwarjit Singh Kakkar v.State of Punjab and Anr.(28.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 168.

Punjab Civil Services(Punishment and Appeal) RulesPunjab Civil Medical (StateService Class I) Rules 1972-Rule15.

2011(3) ACR 2663 (SC),2011(4) ADJ734, 2011(2) ALD(Cri) 651, 2011(3) CGLJ 308,2011(2) Crimes 235 (SC), 2011GLH(2) 445, 2011(3) JCC 1917(SC), JT 2011(5) SC 214,2011(2) KLT 630 (SC), 2011(3)PLJR 137, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 127, 2011(5) SCALE37.

Negotiable Instruments Act,1881-Section 138.

132. Kaushalya Devi Massand vs.Roopkishore Khore(15.03.2011)

Indian Penal Code.

AIR 2011 SC 2566, 2011(2) JLJ203, 2011(3) KCCR 282,2011(2) KLJ 9, 2011(1) NCC706, 2011(2) RCR (Civil) 390,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 298,RLW 2011(4) SC 3029, 2011(3)SCALE 574, (2011) 4 SCC 593,(2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 472.

133. Keesari Madhav Reddy v.State of A.P. (04.02.2011)

Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961-Section 3, 4 & 6.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,302, 304B & 498A.

2011(1) ACR 657 (SC), 2011CriLJ 1460, 2011(1) Crimes 262(SC), 2011(2) JCC 1111, JT2011(2) SC 6, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 299, 2011(2) SCALE184, (2011) 2 SCC 790, (2011) 1SCC (Cri) 904, 2011(1) UC 491.

135. Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 319 & 136.

Keshav Prasad Sharma v.Indian Oil Corporation andOrs. (25.01.2011)

Code of Civil Procedure-Section96 & 100.

2011(2) ACR 1532 (SC),[2011(2) JCR 185 (SC) ],2011(2) KCCR SN 140, 2011(1)RCR (Criminal) 894, 2011(2)SCALE 2, [2011] 1 SCR 838.

136. Kilakkatha Parambath Sasiand Ors. v. State of Kerala(04.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,147, 148, 149, 302, 307 & 324.

2011(1) ACR 667 (SC), AIR2011 SC 1064, JT 2011(3) SC70, 2011(3) RCR (Criminal)183, 2011(2) SCALE 213,(2011) 4 SCC 552, (2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 355, [2011] 2 SCR 540.

137. Negotiable Instruments Act,1881-Section 138.

Kolla Veera Raghav Rao v.Gorantla Venkateswara Raoand Anr. (01.02.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 221(1), 221(2) & 300(1).

Indian Penal Code-Section 420.

Constitution of India-Article20(2).

2011(2) ACR 1497 (SC), AIR2011 SC 641, 1(2010) BC 669,2011(2) BomCR 448, (2011) 2CALLT 77 (SC), 112(2011) CLT79, 2011 CriLJ 1094, 2011(1)Crimes 266 (SC), 2011(2) CTC459, [2011(2) JCR 193 (SC) ],2011(2) KCCR SN 102, 2011(1)KLJ675, 2011(1) KLT 602 (SC),2011(1) PLJR 159, 2011(1) RCR(Civil) 901, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 803, 2011(2) SCALE148, (2011) 2 SCC 703, (2011) 1SCC (Cri) 882, [2011] 106 SCL233 (SC), 2011(1) UC 449.

138. Krishan Kumar Malik v.State of Haryana(04.07.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 6.

Indian Penal Code-Section 366& 376(2).

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 53A, 161 & 164.

2011(3) ACR 2820 (SC),2011(2) ALD (Cri) 593, JT2011(7) SC 94, 2011(II) OLR(SC) 307, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 589, 2011(6) SCALE759, (2011) 7 SCC 130, (2011) 3SCC (Cri) 61.

Page 53: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 291

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

139. Kuldeep Sharma v. State ofH. P. and Anr. (04.04.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act,1947-Section 5(2).

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 120B, 201, 409, 420,465, 467, 468, 471 & 511.

AIR 2011 SC 1895, 2011 CriLJ2678, JT 2011(6) SC 492,2011(3) KCCR SN 314, 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 604, 2011(4)SCALE 256.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

Arms Act, 1959-Section 27.140. Kuldip Yadav and Ors. v.State of Bihar (11.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 141,147, 148, 149, 302, 307, 323,324 & 447.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 164, 173, 210,210(2), 210(3), 223 & 313.

AIR 2011 SC 1737, 2011(2)ALD (Cri) 112, 2011(59) BLJR929, 2011 CriLJ 2640, [2011(3)JCR 116 (SC) ], JT 2011(4) SC436, 2011(3) KCCR SN 309,2011(3) PLJR 25, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 820, 2011(4) SCALE543, (2011) 5 SCC 324, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 632.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section34 & 302.

141. Kulvinder Singh and Anr. v.State of Haryana(11.04.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 161 & 313.

AIR 2011 SC 1777, 2011(2)ALD (Cri) 102, 2011 CriLJ2633, 2011(2) Crimes 192 (SC),[2011(3) JCR 108 (SC) ], JT2011(4) SC 512, 2011(3) KCCRSN 283, 2011(4) SCALE 520,(2011) 5 SCC 258, (2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 608.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 181(4) & 482.

142. Kushal Kumar Gupta andAnr. v. Mala Gupta(07.09.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 406& 498A.

2011(3) ACR 2735 (SC), JT2011(10) SC 110, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 186, RLW 2011(4)SC 3271, 2011(10) SCALE 116.

143. Lakhan Lal v. State of Bihar(14.01.2011)

Juvenile Justice (Care andProtection of Children) Act,2000-Sections 2, 2(1), 7A, 20 &49.

Bihar Childrens Act, 1970.

Juvenile Justice Act, 1986-Section 63.

Indian Penal Code-Section 34 &302.

AIR 2011 SC 842, 2011(2) ALD(Cri) 125, 2011(59) BLJR 1763,2011 CriLJ 1116, 2011(1) JCC287, JT 2011(6) SC 315,2011(2) KCCR SN 117, 2011(1)NCC 576, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 494, 2011(1) SCALE504, (2011) 1 SCC (Cri) 676,[2011] 1 SCR 770.

Juvenile Justice (Care andProtection of Children) Rules2007-Rule 12 & 98.

Indian Penal Code-Section 494& 498A.

144. Lal Kishore Jha v. State ofJharkhand and Anr.(02.05.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 311, 397 & 401.

2011(6) SCALE 418, (2011) 6SCC 453, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)1013.

145. Laxmichand @ Balbutya v.State of Maharashtra(06.01.2011)

Supreme Court Enlargement ofCriminal Appellate JurisdictionAct-Section 2.

Indian Penal Code-Section 302& 304.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 209.

2011(1) ACR 827 (SC), 2011(1)Crimes 197 (SC), 2011(1) JCC256 (SC), [2011(1) JCR 250 (SC)], JT 2011(1) SC 79, 2011(1)NCC 330, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 24, 2011(1) SCALE120, (2011) 2 SCC 128, (2011) 1SCC (Cri) 621, [2011] 1 SCR124.

Page 54: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

292 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 107, 155(2),156(1), 161, 174, 306, 397(2) &482.

146. M. Mohan v. The Staterepresented by The DeputySuperintendent of Police(01.03.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections304B, 306, 309 & 498A.

Code of Criminal Procedure1898-Section 561A.

2011(1) ACR 965 (SC), AIR2011 SC 1238, 2011 CriLJ1900, 2011(2) JCC 1078, JT2011(3) SC 32, 2011(1) NCC714, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal)272, 2011(3) SCALE 78, (2011)3 SCC 626, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)1.

Code of Civil Procedure-Section151. Constitution of India-Article 226.

147. M. Nageshwar Rao v. Stateof Andhra Pradesh(05.01.2011)

Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 161, 174 & 313.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 302,304B, 306 & 498A.

2011(1) ACR 818 (SC), 2011 1AWC (Supp) 2.37 SC, 2011(1)Crimes 145 (SC), 2011(1) JCC432 (SC), [2011(1) JCR 233 (SC)], JT 2011(1) SC 31, 2011(1)NCC 601, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 225, RLW 2011(1)SC 554, 2011(1) SCALE 99,(2011) 2 SCC 188, (2011) 1 SCC(Cri) 646, [2011]1 SCR 608,2011(2) UC 1305.

148. M.P. State v. Pradeep KumarGupta (18.05.2011)

Madhya Pradesh MunicipalCorporation Act.

Madhya Pradesh MunicipalitiesAct, 1961-Sections 86, 86(1),86(2) & 86(4).

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Sections 7, 10, 11, 13, 15,19 & 19(1). Madhya PradeshMunicipal Service (Executive)Rules 1973-Rule 2, 17, 31 & 32.

AIR 2011 SC 2334, 2011(3)Crimes 59 (SC), 2011(2) JLJ231, JT 2011(6) SC 46, 2011(3)PLJR 60, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 506, 2011(6) SCALE337, (2011) 6 SCC 389, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 978, 2011(2) UC1341, 2011(4) UJ2163 (SC),(2011) 2 UPLBEC 45.

Arms Act.149. Mahender Singh v. State ofUttaranchal (09.08.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 302,304, 304(1), 332, 342 & 353.

JT 2011(10) SC 268, 2011(9)SCALE 520.

150. Arms Act.Mahesh and Anr. v. State ofMadhya Pradesh(13.09.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 34&302.

2011(4) Crimes 200 (SC),2011(10) SCALE 549.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

Indian Penal Code-Section 302.151. Maloth Somaraju v. State ofA.P. (17.08.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 161.

2011(3) ACR 2993 (SC),2011(3) Crimes 180 (SC), JT2011(10) SC 17, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 889, 2011(9) SCALE174, (2011) 8 SCC 635, 2011(3)UC 1744.

Uttar Pradesh Excise Act, 1910-Section 60 (2).

152. Man Singh v. State of U.P.(19.07.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

2011(3) ACR 3198 (SC),2011(8) SCALE 256, 2011(2)UC 1491.

Page 55: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 293

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

153. Mangesh v. State ofMaharashtra (05.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section302, 304 & 307.

2011(1) ACR 813 (SC), AIR2011 SC 637, 2011 CriLJ 1166,2011(1) Crimes 152 (SC),2011(1) JCC 330 (SC), JT2011(1) SC 15, 2011(2) KCCRSN 79, 2011(1) SCALE 57,(2011) 2 SCC 123, (2011) 1 SCC(Cri) 616, [2011] 1 SCR 72,2011(1) UC 250.

Terrorist and DisruptiveActivities (Prevention) Act,1987-Sections 3, 3(1), 3(2), 3(3),9, 11, 12, 15, 15(1), 15(2), 19,20A, 20A(1) & 28A.

Special Courts Act 1984.

154. Manjit Singh @ Mange v.CBI, through its S. P.(25.01.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 30.

2011(3) ACR 2503 (SC), AIR2011 SC 806, 2011(2) KCCRSN 113, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 765, 2011(1) SCALE766, (2011) 11 SCC 578, [2011]1 SCR 997.

Delhi Police SpecialEstablishment Act, 1946-Section3.

Explosives Act.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,120B, 211, 224, 273 & 302.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 2 & 313.

Constitution of India-Article 14& 21.

Terrorist and DisruptiveActivities (Prevention) Rules1987-Rule 15 & 15(5).

155. Manoj Yadav v. Pushpa @Kiran Yadav and Ors.(11.01.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 125. Criminal Procedure(Amendment) Act 2001.

2011(2) ACR 1681 (SC), AIR2011 SC 847, 2011(1) CTC 511,I (2011) DMC 209 SC, 2011(1)JCC 471 (SC), JT 2011(1) SC164, 2011(1) KLJ 30, 2011(1)RCR (Civil) 803, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 513, 2011(1) SCALE287, [2011] 1 SCR 644.

Indian Evidence Act-Sections 27,201, 302, 366 & 376.

156. Md. Mannan @ AbdulMannan v. State of Bihar(20.04.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

2011(59) BLJR 1201, 2011(2)Crimes 216 (SC), [2011(3) JCR103 (SC) ], JT 2011(5) SC 167,2011(3) PLJR 1, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 874, 2011(4) SCALE809, (2011) 5 SCC 317, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 626, 2011(2) UC1314.

157. Md. Sukur Ali v. State ofAssam (24.02.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 340. Constitution ofIndia-Article 21 & 22(1).

Rowlatt Act.

AIR 2011 SC 1222, 2011 CriLJ1690, 2011(266) ELT 32 (SC),[2011(2) JCR 301 (SC) ],2011(2) KCCR SN 168, 2011(1)KLT 881 (SC), 2011(I) OLR(SC) 1014, 2011(2) PLJR 67,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 121,2011(2) SCALE 730, (2011) 4SCC 729, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)481.

Page 56: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

294 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

158. Mehboob Batcha and Ors. v.State rep. by Supdt. of Police(29.03.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 302.

Constitution of India-Article 21& 22(1).

2011(2) Crimes 84 (SC), 2011GLH (2) 201, JT 2011(3) SC541, 2011(I) OLR (SC) 1068,2011(2) PLJR 81, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 599, 2011(4) SCALE20, (2011) 7 SCC 45, (2011) 3SCC (Cri) 70, 2011(2) UC841

159. Milind Shripad Chandurkarv. Kalim M. Khan and Anr.(03.03.2011)

Negotiable Instruments Act,1881-Sections 7, 8, 9, 118, 138,139 & 142.

Companies Act, 1956.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 313.

2011(2) ACR 1185 (SC), AIR2011 SC 1588, II (2011) BC542,2011(2) BomCR 482, [2011]102 CLA 128 (SC), 2011 CriLJ1912, 2011(3) CTC 234, JT2011(3) SC 138, 2011(1) KLJ720, 2011(2) KLT 271 (SC),2011(4) MhLJ 96 (SC), 2011(3)PLJR 42, 2011(2) RCR (Civil)687, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal)568, RLW 2011(2) SC 1135,2011(3) SCALE 285, (2011) 4SCC 275, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)208.

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 9 & 10.

160. Mohan Singh v. State ofBihar (26.08.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 120B, 302, 306 &387.

AIR 2011 SC 3534, 2011(59)BLJR 3063, 2011(9) SCALE426, 2011(3) UC 1734.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Sections 214, 215, 221, 225, 313& 464.

Explosive Substance Act-Section4 & 5.

161. Mohd. Arif @ Ashfaq v. Stateof NCT of Delhi(10.08.2011)

Arms Act-Section 3, 25 & 27.

2011(3) Crimes 228 (SC), JT2011(9) SC 563, 2011(8) SCALE328.

Indian Evidence Act-Sections 24,25, 26, 27, 28, 29 & 30.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 43,120A,120B, 121,121A, 186,302, 307, 353, 420, 468, 471 &474.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 37, 43, 46(1), 129& 313.

Registration of Birth and DeathAct, 1969-Section 17.

163. Mohd. Imran Khan v. State(Govt. of NCT of Delhi)(10.10.2011)

Evidence Act, 1872-Section 114& 118.

2011(4) Crimes 205 (SC), JT2011(13) SC 159, 2011(11)SCALE 376, (2011) 10 SCC 192.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 342, 363, 366, 376& 506.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 164, 313 & 315.

Arms Act, 1959-Section 27.164. Mrinal Das and Ors. v. TheState of Tripura(05.09.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 3, 114 & 133.

2011(10) SCALE 55.

Page 57: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 295

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Criminal Law Amendment Act,1952.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 148, 149, 302, 307& 326.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 173, 306, 306(1),306(4), 307 & 308.

165. Munilal Mochi v. State ofBihar and Anr. (21.07.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act,1947-Section 5(1), 5(2) & 5(3).

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 120B, 162, 163, 165A,409, 420, 467, 468, 471, 471(A)& 477A.

AIR 2011 SC 3025, 2011(3)Crimes 124 (SC), JT 2011(7) SC545, 2011(3) RCR (Criminal)702, 2011(7) SCALE 691,2011(2) UC 1506.

166. Murugan @ Settu v. State ofTamil Nadu (06.05.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 35.

Registration of Birth and DeathsAct, 1969-Section 17.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 109, 363, 366 & 376.

AIR 2011 SC 1691, 2011(3)CGLJ 554, 2011 CriLJ 2948,2011(2) Crimes 273 (SC), JT2011(6) SC 602, 2011(4) KCCRSN 373, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 35, 2011(5) SCALE464, (2011) 6 SCC 111, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 842, 2011(2) UC1199.

Arms Act-Section 4 & 25.

Indian Evidence Act-Section 27.

167. Mustkeem @ Sirajudeen v.State of Rajasthan(13.07.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,120B, 149 & 302.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 162 & 313 Constitutionof India-Article 136.

2011(3) ACR 2925, 2011(3)Crimes 118 (SC), 2011(3) JCC2117 (SC), JT 2011(7) SC 304,2011(II) OLR (SC) 526, 2011(3)RCR (Criminal) 766, 2011(7)SCALE 481, 2011(2) UC 1462.

168. Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Sections 2, 12, 14, 15 & 23.

Muthu Karuppan v. ParithiIlamvazhuthi and Anr.(15.04.2011)

Madras High Court Contempt ofCourt Rules, 1975-Rule 3, 4 &8. Constitution of India-Article215 & 225.

AIR 2011 SC 1645, 2011 CriLJ2680, 2011(2) Crimes 163 (SC),2011(3) CTC520, [2011(3) JCR23 (SC) ], JT 2011(4) SC 268,2011(3) KCCR SN 329, 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 829, 2011(4)SCALE 664, (2011) 5 SCC 496,(2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 709, 2011(2)UC 922.

169. Nachhatar Singh and Anr. v.State of Punjab (03.02.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Sections 113A, 34, 304B, 306 &498A.

2011(2) ACR 2117 (SC), 2011CriLJ 2292, [2011(3) JCR 51(SC) ], JT 2011(7) SC 47,2011(3) KCCR SN 306, 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 259, 2011(3)SCALE 411, (2011) 11 SCC 542,[2011] 2 SCR 478.

170. Nand Kishore v. State ofMadhya Pradesh(07.07.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 34,149 & 302.

2011(3) ACR 2910 (SC), JT2011(7) SC 203, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 658, 2011(7) SCALE386.

171. Narayan Dutt and Ors. v.State of Punjab and Anr.(24.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,120B, 148, 149, 302, 307, 323,324, 325 & 326.

Crimanal Procedure Code-Section 173, 319 & 321.

AIR 2011 SC 1216, 2011 3AWC 2953 SC, 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 209, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 140, 2011(2) SCALE712, (2011) 4 SCC 353, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 243.

Page 58: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

296 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Constitution of India-Article 14,72 & 161.

172. Narinder Singh Arora v.State (Govt. of NCT ofDelhi) and Ors. (05.12.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,302, 304B & 498A.

2011(3) SCALE 352.

Arms Act, 1959-Section 25(1).173. Narmada Bai v. State ofGujarat and Ors.(08.04.2011)

Bombay Police Act, 1951 –Section 135.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,224, 225, 307, 323, 324, 341,427 & 506.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 173(2), 173(8) & 220.

AIR 2011 SC 1804, 2011 CriLJ2651, 2011(2) Crimes 142 (SC),(2011) 3 GLR 2104 (SC),[2011(3) JCR 67 (SC) ], JT2011(4) SC 279, 2011(3) KCCRSN 262, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 12, 2011(4) SCALE469, (2011) 5 SCC 79, (2011) 1SCC (Cri) 1109.

Constitution of India-Article 21,22 & 32.

175. Narwinder Singh v. State ofPunjab (05.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 302,304B, 306 & 498A.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Sections 221(1), 221(2), 222,313 & 464(1).

Indian Evidence Act-Section113B.

2011(1) ACR 350 (SC), AIR2011 SC 686, 2011(2) ALD (Cri)36, 2011(1) Crimes 200 (SC), II(2011) DMC 474 SC, 2011(1)JCC 334 (SC), JT 2011(1) SC89, 2011(2) KCCR SN 84,2011(1) NCC 623, 2011(3)PLJR 272, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 427, RLW 2011(1)SC 573, 2011(1) SCALE 114,(2011) 2 SCC 47, (2011) 1 SCC(Cri) 601, [2011] 1 SCR 110.

176. Nasib Hussain Siddi andOrs. v. State of Gujarat(28.09.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 114,325, 333, 342 & 506(2).

JT 2011(13) SC 66, 2011(4)RCR (Criminal) 698, 2011(11)SCALE 178.

177. Natha Shankar Mahajan v.State of Maharashtra(28.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 302. 2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 925,2011(5) SCALE 389.

Maharashtra Control ofOrganized Crime Act, 1999-Sections 3(1), 3(2), 3(4) & 3(5).

178. Nilesh Dinkar Paradkar v.State of Maharashtra(09.03.2011)

Arms Act, 1959-Sections 3, 5, 7,25, 30 & 36.

2011(3) JCC 1972 (SC), JT2011(3) SC 429, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 533, (2011) 4 SCC143.

Indian Evidence Act-Section 1 &3.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 115,120B, 302 & 419.

Negotiable Instruments Act,1881-Section 138.

179. Nitinbhai Saevatilal Shahand Anr. v. ManubhaiManjibhai Panchal and Anr.(01.09.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure1973-Sections 260, 262, 263,264, 313, 322, 325, 326, 326(1),326(2), 326(3), 357, 461 & 465.Code of Criminal Procedure1898-Section 350.

2011(3) ACR 2690, AIR 2011SC 3076, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 148, 2011(9) SCALE583.

Page 59: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 297

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Commission of Inquiries Act.

Arms Act-Section 325 & 327.

Bombay Police Act-Section 161 &197.

180. Noorul Huda MaqboolAhmed v. Ram Deo Tyagiand Ors. (04.07.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,107, 111, 113, 120B, 141, 143,144, 145, 147, 149, 302, 307 &442.

2011(3) ACR 2383 (SC),2011(3) Crimes 69 (SC), JT2011(7) SC 189, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 550, 2011(6)SCALE 644, (2011) 7 SCC 95,(2011) 3 SCC (Cri) 31.

Code of Criminal Procedure -Sections 47(2), 161, 169, 170,227, 228 & 319.

Civil Service Rules.

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Sections 2, 12, 12(1), 15 & 30.

181. O.P. Sharma and Ors. v.High Court of Punjab andHaryana (09.05.2011)

Advocates Act, 1961.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,393, 452 & 506.

Bar Council of India Rules.

2011(3) ACR 2650 (SC), AIR2011 SC 2101, 2011 CriLJ2952, JT 2011(6) SC 275,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 884,2011(5) SCALE 518, (2011) 6SCC 86, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)821, (2011) 2 SCC (L&S) 11.

Constitution of India-Article 142& 144.

182. Om Prakash v. State ofHaryana (07.07.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections363, 366, 368, 376 & 376(2).

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 313.

JT 2011(8) SC 69, 2011(3)KLT (SN) 54, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 616, 2011(7)SCALE 396.

183. P. Mahalingam v. MonicaKumar and Anr.(16.12.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 156(3) & 200.

2011(13) SCALE 594.

Constitution of India-Articles 32,136, 226 & 311(2).

184. P. Parasurami Reddy v. Stateof A.P. (02.08.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act-Section 7, 13(1) & 13(2).

2011(3) ACR 3096 (SC),2011(3) RCR (Criminal) 863,2011(8) SCALE 625.

Code of Criminal Procedure(Amendment) Act, 1923.

185. Padal Venkata Rama Reddy@ Ramu v. KovvuriSatyanarayana Reddy andOrs. (29.07.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,120B, 147, 148, 149, 201, 307,427 & 467.

2011(3) ACR 3156 (SC),2011(3) Crimes 161 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 646, 2011(8)SCALE 128, 2011(2) UC1546.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 155(2), 156(1) &482.

Constitution of India-Article 226.

186. Panch Ram v. State ofChhatisgarh (03.01.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act,1947-Section 5(1) & 5(2).

112 (2011) CLT 528 (SC),2011(1) Crimes 181 (SC),2011(I) OLR (SC) 688.

187. Pancho v. State of Haryana(20.10.2011)

Evidence Act-Section 3, 3 (1), 3 (2)& 30.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,302, 392 & 396.

2011(4) Crimes 226 (SC),2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 665,2011(2) SCALE 187.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313 & 366.

Page 60: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

298 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Indian Penal Code-Section 302.188. Prahalad Patel v. State ofMadhya Pradesh(02.03.2011)

Constitution of India-Article136.

2011(1) ACR 962 (SC), AIR2011 SC 961, 2011 CriLJ 1474,2011(2) Crimes 53 (SC), 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 434, 2011(3)SCALE 70, (2011) 4 SCC 262,(2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 205.

Indian Evidence Act-Section 27.189. Prahalad Singh and Ors. v.State of M.P. (19.07.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 148,149, 302 & 307.

2011(3) ACR 3278 (SC), ILR[2011] MP 2309, JT 2011(8) SC591, 2011(3) PLJR 314, 2011(3)RCR (Criminal) 757, 2011(8)SCALE 105.

Land Acquisition Act IndianPenal Code-Section 34.

190. Prakash Kadam and etc. v.Ramprasad VishwanathGupta and Anr.(13.05.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 120B,302 & 364.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 176(1A).

AIR 2011 SC 1945, 2011(2)Crimes 279 (SC), (2011) 3 GLR2237 (SC), 2011(2) KLJ 37,2011(3) PLJR 277, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 1, RLW 2011(2) SC1833, 2011(6) SCALE 236,(2011) 6 SCC 189, (2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 848, 2011(2) UC 1361.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section366 & 376(2).

191. Prem Prakash @ Lillu andAnr. v. State of Haryana(07.07.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 154 & 313.

2011(3) ACR 2917 (SC), JT2011(7) SC 213, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 762, 2011(7) SCALE379, (2011) 11 SCC 687.

Arms Act-Section 27.192. Prem Singh v. State ofHaryana (02.09.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,120B, 149 & 302.

[2011(4) JCR 156 (SC) ], JT2011(12) SC 31, 2011(10)SCALE 102193.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 161 & 313.

Oaths Act-Section 5.193. Prithipal Singh etc. v. Stateof Punjab and Anr. etc.(04.11.2011)

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985.

2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 791,2011(12) SCALE 411(1).

Protection of Human Rights Act,1993.

Evidence Act, 1872-Sections106, 114, 133 & 134.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 120B, 201, 220,302, 364 & 365.

Code of Criminal Procedure1973-Sections 161, 173(8), 197,306,313,337, 342, 377,386,397, 401, 401(4) & 464.

Constitution of India 1950-Article 21, 22 & 32.

194. Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 482.

2011(13) SCALE 522.Punjab State WarehousingCorporation Faridkot v. Sh.Durga Ji Traders and Ors.(28.11.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section406 & 409.

Warehousing Corporation Act,1962.

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.195. Pyla Mutyalamma @Satyavathi v. Pyla SuriDemudu and Anr.(09.08.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 125.

2011(4) RCR (Civil) 551,2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 446,2011(9) SCALE 403, 2011(3)UC 1793.

Page 61: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 299

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Indian Penal Code-Section 494.

Constitution of India-Article136.

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Section 13(1) & 13(2).

Sree Sankaracharya University ofSanskrit Act, 1994-Sections 23,50, 50(2) & 50(3).

196. R. Ramachandran Nair v.The Deputy SuperintendentVigilance Police and Anr.(28.03.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 114.

2011(2) Crimes 95 (SC), JT2011(4) SC 500, 2011(2) KCCRSN 144, 2011(2) KLT 135 (SC),2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 564,2011(4) SCALE 14, (2011) 4SCC 395, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)251.

Indian Penal Code-Sections120B, 409, 463, 468 & 477A.

Code of Criminal Procedure -Section 239.

197. R. Vijayan v. Baby and Anr.(11.10.2011)

Negotiable Instruments Act,1881-Sections 138, 143, 143(1),143(3), 144 & 145.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Sections 29, 29(2), 62, 262, 263,264, 265, 357, 357(1) & 357(3).

[2011] 105 CLA 205 (SC),2011(4) Crimes 237 (SC), JT2011(13) SC 300, 2011(4) KLT355 (SC), 2011(4) RCR (Civil)834, 2011(4) RCR (Criminal)743, 2011(11) SCALE 550.

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985-Section 37.

198. R.S. Mishra v. State ofOrissa and Ors.(01.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections120B, 201, 302, 304, 304(1),323 & 380.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 227, 228, 300 (2)& 401.

2011(1) ACR 643 (SC), AIR2011 SC 1103, 2011 CriLJ1654, JT 2011(2) SC 291,2011(1) RCR (Criminal) 872,2011(2) SCALE 98, (2011) 2SCC 689, (2011) 1 SCC (Cri)785, [2011] 2 SCR 338, 2011(1)UC 451.

Code of Criminal Procedure1898-Section 202 & 203.

199. Rabindra Kumar Pal @ DaraSingh v. Republic of India(21.01.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Sections 3, 8, 9, 21, 24, 25, 26,27, 28, 29, 30 & 73.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 162, 164, 164(2),164(3), 281 & 313.

Terrorist and DisruptiveActivities (Prevention) Act-Section 15(1).

2011(2) ACR 1690 (SC), AIR2011 SC 1436, 2011(1) Crimes217 (SC), JT 2011(1) SC 350,2011(2) KCCR SN 92, 2011(I)OLR (SC) 818, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 641, 2011(1) SCALE615, (2011) 2 SCC 490, (2011) 1SCC (Cri) 706, [2011] 1 SCR929.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 147,148, 149, 302, 435 & 436.

Constitution of India-Article20(3).

Foreign Exchange RegulationAct, 1973-Sections 8, 8(2), 9,9(1), 13, 18A, 18(1), 19(1), 35,40, 44(2), 50, 51, 52, 56, 56(1),57, 58, 61, 61(1), 64(2), 68,68(1), 154, 195(1) & 271(1).

Income Tax Act-Section 147,148 & 276C.

200. Radheshyam Kejriwal v.State of West Bengal andAnr. (18.02.2011)

Customs Act.

2011(2) ACR 1199 (SC), [2011]102 CLA 283 (SC), 2011 CriLJ1747, 2011(266) ELT 294 (SC),[2011] 130 ITD 509 (SC),[2011] 333 ITR 58 (SC), 2011(2)JCC943, JT 2011(2) SC 443,2011(2) KCCR SN 171, 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 756, 2011(2)SCALE 540, (2011) 3 SCC 581,(2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 721, [2011]

Page 62: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

300 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 40 to 43.

Companies Act.

108 SCL 406 (SC), 2011(2) UJ1009 (SC), (2011) 40 VST 11(SC) .

Foreign Exchange RegulationAct, 1947-Section 23D.

Sea Customs Act, 1878-Section167.

Imports and Exports (Control)Act, 1947-Section 5.

Code of Criminal Procedure1898-Section 403 & 476.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 300, 401 & 482.

Indian Penal Code-Section 120B.

Constitution of India-Article 14,20(2) & 21.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 161 & 313.

2011(9) SCALE 472.201. Raghubir Singh v. State ofRajasthan and Ors.(29.08.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 147,148, 149, 302, 304, 307, 323,324, 325 & 447. Constitution ofIndia-Article 136.

202. Raghuvansh DewanchandBhasin v. State ofMaharashtra and Anr.(09.09.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section324, 342 & 345. Constitution ofIndia-Articles 21, 22(1), 22(2),32 & 226.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 70, 71, 71(2), 78,79 & 476.

AIR 2011 SC 3393, 2011(6)CTC 228, JT 2011(10) SC 253,2011(4) KLT (SN) 21, 2011(4)RCR (Criminal) 212, 2011(10)SCALE 233.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 107 & 151.

203. Rajender Singh Pathania andOrs. v. State of N. C. T. ofDelhi and Ors. (12.08.2011)

Constitution of India-Articles 21,22, 32 & 226.

2011(3) ACR 3102 (SC), JT2011(10) SC 294, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 827, 2011(9) SCALE124, 2011(3) UC 1801.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,147, 148, 149, 307, 332 & 353.

204. Rajendra HarakchandBhandari and Ors. v. State ofMaharashtra and Anr.(08.04.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 320(9).

2011(2) ACR 1601 (SC), AIR2011 SC 1821, 2011 CriLJ2891, 2011(2) Crimes 160 (SC),JT 2011(4) SC 137, 2011(4)KCCR SN 394, 2011(3) PLJR74, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal)614, 2011(4) SCALE 450.

205. Code of Criminal Procedure(Amendment) Act, 1955.

Rajesh Kumar v. Statethrough Govt. of NCT ofDelhi (28.09.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure1973-Sections 117, 125, 138(2),145, 147, 235, 235(2), 313, 353,354(3), 360 & 465.

183 (2011) DLT78 (SC),2011(4) KLT (SN) 49, 2011(4)RCR (Criminal) 459, 2011(11)SCALE 182

Evidence Act.

Code of Criminal Procedure1898-Sections 268, 309, 367,367(5), 376(5) & 562.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section302.

Constitution of India-Article 21.

Page 63: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 301

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

206. Rajesh Singh and Ors. v.State of U.P. (28.03.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 34 &302.

2011(2) Crimes 90 (SC), 2011(2)JCC 1326 (SC), JT 2011(3) SC617, 2011(2) PLJR 145, 2011(4)SCALE 6, (2011) 11 SCC 444,(2011) 3 SCC (Cri) 210.

207. Rajinder vs. State (NCT ofDelhi) and Anr. (12.08.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 34,302 & 307.

Code of Criminal Procedure -Section 313.

2011(3) ACR 3092 (SC),2011(3) Crimes 206 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 606, 2011(9) SCALE118, 2011(3) UC 1819.

Bombay Police Act-Section135(1).

208. Rajput Jabbarsingh Malaji v.State of Gujarat(24.05.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 6.

Indian Penal Code-Section 302.

2011(2) Crimes 300 (SC),2011(3) JCC 1655, JT 2011(6)SC 120, 2011(4) RCR (Criminal)254, 2011(6) SCALE 369,(2011) 6 SCC 308, (2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 940.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 161.

Negotiable Instruments Act-Section 138.

209. Raju @ Sheikha MohamedSharif v. State ofMaharashtra and Anr.(05.01.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 357(3).

2011(1) ACR 367 (SC), 2011 1AWC (Supp) 2.39SC, (2011) 2CALLT43 (SC), 2011(1) Crimes156 (SC), 2011 GLH (2) 1025,JT 2011(1) SC 95, 2011(1) RCR(Civil) 886, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 785, RLW 2011(1)SC 541, 2011(1) SCALE 67,(2011) 11 SCC 545.

Arms Act, 1959-Section 25.210. Rakesh and Anr. v. State ofMadhya Pradesh(19.09.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section302.

2011(4) Crimes 193 (SC),2011(4) JCC 2712 (SC), JT2011(10) SC 525, 2011(4) KLT(SN) 51, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 355, 2011(10)SCALE 584.

Negotiable Instruments Act,1881-Section 138 & 141.

211. Rallis India Ltd. v. PoduruVidya Bhusan and Ors.(13.04.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 482.

Food Safety and Standards Act.

Prevention of Food AdulterationAct.

2011(3) BomCR 450, [2011]102 CLA 264 (SC), [2011] 164CompCas 54 (SC), (2011) 2CompLJ 479 (SC), 2011(2)Crimes 177 (SC), [2011(3) JCR93 (SC) ], JT 2011(4) SC 247,2011(2) KLT 376 (SC), 2011(4)RCR (Criminal) 723, 2011(4)SCALE 614, 2011(2) UC 888.

212. Ram Mehar Singh vs. Stateof N.C.T. of Delhi and Ors.(12.08.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure1973-Section 107, 145 & 151.

2011(3) ACR 3099 (SC),2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 538,2011(9) SCALE 105, 2011(3)UC 1644.

213. Ramachandran and Ors. etc.vs. State of Kerala(02.09.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 141, 143, 147, 148,149, 302, 307, 323, 324, 427 &449.

2011(3) ACR 2712, AIR 2011SC 3581, [2011(4) JCR 147 (SC)], 2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 480,2011(9) SCALE 676.

214. Ramesh v. State of Rajasthan(22.02.2011)

Indian Evidence Act-Section 27& 114.

Arms Act-Section 4, 5 & 25.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,120B, 201, 302, 379, 404, 414,457 & 460.

2011(2) Crimes 33 (SC), 2011(3)JCC 1599, [2011(2) JCR 202(SC) ], JT 2011(2) SC 331,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 732,2011(2) SCALE 669, (2011) 3SCC 685, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 54.

Page 64: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

302 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Indian Penal Code-Sections 302,363, 366, 376 & 397.

215. Rameshbhai ChandubhaiRathod v. The State ofGujarat (24.01.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Sections 235, 235(2), 354,354(3) & 433A.

Constitution of India-Article 72& 161.

2011(2) ACR 1870 (SC), AIR2011 SC 803, 2011(1) ALD (Cri)686, 2011 CriLJ 1458, 2011GLH (2) 1462, [2011(1) JCR278 (SC) ], JT 2011(2) SC 33,2011-2-LW (Crl) 187, 2011(1)RCR (Criminal) 728, 2011(1)SCALE 757, (2011) 2 SCC 764,(2011) 1 SCC (Cri) 883, [2011]1 SCR 829.

216. Rangku Dutta @ RanjanKumar Dutta v. State ofAssam (20.05.2011)

Terrorist and DisruptiveActivities (Prevention) Act,1987-Sections 3, 3(2)(1), 4, 5,19, 20A, 20A(1) & 20(A)(2).

Railways Act, 1890-Section 77.

Bombay Rent Act, 1947-Section15.

AIR 2011 SC 2321, 2011(2)Crimes 295 (SC), 2011(3) GLT(SC) 12, 2011(3) JCC 1650, JT2011(6) SC 126, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 502, 2011(6) SCALE362, (2011) 6 SCC 358, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 964, (2011) 2UPLBEC 274.

Succession Act, 1925-Section213.

Prevention of Corruption Act,1947-Section 5A.

Stamp Act 1899-Section 7.

Companies Act, 1956-Section108.

Prevention of Food AdulterationAct 1954-Section 20(1).

Wild Life Protection Act, 1972-Section 55.

Industrial Disputes Act, 1947-Section 33(2). Medical CouncilAct, 1956-Section 10A.

Indian Penal Code-Section120(B) & 302.

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section 80 & 87B.

Code of Criminal Procedure.

Indian Penal Code-Section 34 &302.

217. Ranjit Singh v. State ofPunjab (29.03.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313 & 319.

2011-2-LW (Crl) 203, 2011(4)SCALE 790, (2011) 1 SCC (Cri)580, 2009(8) SLR 13 (SC) .

218. Ranjitham v. Basavaraj andOrs. (28.11.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,109, 147, 148, 149, 300, 302,304, 323, 324 & 341.

2011(13) SCALE 221.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

219. Ravindra Pal Singh vs. AjitSingh and Anr. (17.03.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections120B, 201, 302 & 364.

JT 2011(4) SC 12, 2011(3)KCCR SN 249, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 579, 2011(3) SCALE589, (2011) 4 SCC 238, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 199, 2011(2) UC 805.

Page 65: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 303

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

220. Ravindra Pal Singh v.Santosh Kumar Jaiswal andOrs. (17.03.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections120B, 307, 333, 392, 394 &411.

2011(2) ACR 1963 (SC), 2011CriLJ 2160, 2011(2) Crimes 100(SC), JT 2011(3) SC 481,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 577,2011(3) SCALE 591, (2011) 4SCC 746, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)485.

221. Rekha v. State of T. Nadu tr.Sec. to Govt. and Anr.(05.04.2011)

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBootleggers Drug – offenders.

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBootleggers Drug-ForestOffenders.

2011(2) ACR 1592 (SC),2011(3) CTC222, JT 2011(4) SC392, 2011(2) KCCR SN 142,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 527,2011(4) SCALE 387, (2011) 5SCC 244.

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBootleggers Drug – Goondas.

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBootleggers Drug-ImmoralTraffic Offenders.

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBootleggers Drug-SandOffenders.

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBootleggers Drug-SlumGrabbers.

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBootleggers Drug-Video PiratesAct.

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBootleggers Drug – 1982.

Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940.

Indian Penal Code.

Constitution of India-Articles 19,21, 22, 22(1) & 22(3).

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBottleggers Drug – Offenders.

222. Rekha v. State of T. Nadu tr.Sec. to Govt. and Anr.(15.03.2011)

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBottleggers Drug-ForestOffenders.

2011(2) CTC 461, JT 2011(5)SC 368, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal)527, 2011(3) SCALE 577,(2011) 4 SCC 260, 2011(2) UC892.

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBottleggers Drug – Goondas.

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBottleggers Drug-ImmoralTraffic Offenders.

Page 66: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

304 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBottleggers Drug-SandOffenders.

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBottleggers Drug-Slum Grabbers.

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBottleggers Drug-Video PiratesAct.

Tamil Nadu Prevention ofDangerous Activities ofBottleggers Drug – 1982.

223. Risal Singh and Anr. v. Stateof Punjab and Anr.(09.05.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 406& 498A.

2011(2) Crimes 278 (SC) .

224. Roop Ram and Anr. v. Stateof M.P. (13.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 34 &302.

2011(II) OLR (SC) 633.

225. Roopsena Khatun v. State ofWest Bengal (28.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 302& 379.

AIR 2011 SC 2256, 2011(4)KCCR SN 375, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 894, 2011(5) SCALE386.

226. Rukia Begum v. State ofKarnataka (04.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,120B, 201, 302 & 379.

2011(2) ACR 1606 (SC), AIR2011 SC 1585, 2011(2) Crimes107 (SC), 2011(2) JCC 1178, JT2011(4) SC 418, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 745, 2011(4) SCALE259, (2011) 4 SCC 779, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 488.

227. S. Ganesan vs. RamaRaghuraman and Ors.(03.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,100, 100 (3), 120B, 300, 302,304 & 307.

2011(1) ACR 324 (SC), 2011 1AWC (Supp) 33 SC, 2011(1)Crimes 165 (SC), 2011(3) JCC1542, JT 2011(1) SC 1, 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 283, 2011(1)SCALE 12, (2011) 2 SCC 83,[2011] 1 SCR 27, 2011(1) UC211.

Explosive Substances Act-Section3, 4 & 5.

228. Sadhwi Pragyna SinghThakur v. State ofMaharashtra (23.09.2011)

Unlawful Activities (Prevention)Act, 1957-Section 16, 18 & 23.Maharashtra Control ofOrganised Crime Act, 1999-Section 21, 21(2) & 21(4).

JT 2011(12) SC 56, 2011(4)KLT 321 (SC), RLW 2011(4) SC3361, 2011(10) SCALE 771.

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act-Section 37.

Assam Maintenance of PublicOrder Act, 1953. Armed Forces(Assam and Manipur) SpecialPowers Act-Section 5.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 50A, 160 (1), 167,167(2), 344, 401 & 439.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 153,302, 307, 324 & 427.

Page 67: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 305

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Constitution of India-Article 12,22(1) & 22(2).

229. Sahebrao Mohan Berad v.State of Maharashtra(18.03.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 34,201 & 302.

2011(2) ACR 1966 (SC), 2011CriLJ 2157, 2011(2) Crimes 69(SC), 2011 GLH (2) 1778, JT2011(3) SC 477, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 608, 2011(3) SCALE615, (2011) 4 SCC 249, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 201, 2011(2) UC 868.

Arms Act-Section 27.230. Sajjan Sharma v. State ofBihar (07.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,148, 149, 302 & 379.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

AIR 2011 SC 632, 2011(59)BLJR 73, 2011 CriLJ 1169,2011(1) Crimes 187 (SC),2011(1) JCC 278 (SC), [2011(1)JCR 224 (SC) ], JT 2011(1) SC173, 2011(2) KCCR SN 80,2011(2) PLJR 34, 2011(1)SCALE 137, (2011) 2 SCC 206,[2011] 1 SCR 629.

231. Sanjay Chandra v. CBI(23.11.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Section 13 & 13(2).

2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 898,2011(13) SCALE 107.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 109,420B, 468 & 471.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Sections 87, 88, 437, 437(1),437(3), 439 & 439(1).

Constitution of India-Article 19& 21.

Right to Information Act.

Contempt of Courts Act.

232. Sanjoy Narayan Editor inChief Hindustan and Ors. v.Hon. High Court ofAllahabad thr. R. G.(30.08.2011)

Constitution of India-Article19(1) & 19(2).

JT 2011(10) SC 74, 2011(3)KLT 882 (SC), 2011(9) SCALE532.

233. Santosh Kumari v. State of Jand K and Ors. (13.09.2011)

Ranbir Penal Code-Sections 109,147, 148, 149, 195(A), 302,307, 341, 504 & 506.

AIR 2011 SC 3402, JT 2011(10)SC 271, 2011(4) RCR (Criminal)360, 2011(10) SCALE 379.

Code of Criminal Procedure1989-Sections 164, 225, 267,268, 269 & 561(A).

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 215, 226, 227,228 & 464.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,109, 114, 147, 148, 149 & 302.

Negotiable Instruments Act,1881-Section 138 & 141.

234. Sarojben Ashwinkumar Shahetc. v. State of Gujarat andAnr. (10.08.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 114& 420.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 169, 319, 319(1),319(4) & 482.

2011(3) ACR 3020 (SC), III(2011) BC543, 2011(3) Crimes189 (SC), 2011 GLH (3) 180,2011(3) RCR (Criminal) 852,2011(8) SCALE 542, 2011(3)UC 1808.

235. Sat Pal v. State of Punjab(07.04.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Section 7, 13(2) & 20.

2011(6) SCALE 486.

Page 68: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

306 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

236. Sayaji Hanmat Bankar v.State of Maharashtra(13.07.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 299,300, 302 & 304.

2011(3) ACR 2922 (SC), AIR2011 SC 3172, 2011(3) Crimes129 (SC), JT 2011(7) SC 311,2011(3) RCR (Criminal) 771,2011(7) SCALE 710, 2011(2)UC 1472.

237. Shah Nawaz v. State of U.P.and Anr. (05.08.2011)

Juvenile Justice (Care andProtection of Children) Act,2000-Sections 7A, 20, 52 & 64.

Uttar Pradesh Children Act,1951-Section 2(4).

Indian Evidence Act-Section 35.

2011(3) ACR 3013 (SC), AIR2011 SC 3107, 2011(3) Crimes171 (SC), JT 2011(8) SC 475,2011(3) KLT 926 (SC), 2011(3)RCR (Criminal) 884, 2011(8)SCALE 423, 2011(3) UC 1772.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 302, 304 & 307.

Juvenile Justice (Care andProtection of Children) Rules2007-Rule 12 & 19.

238. Shaji and Ors. v. State ofKerala (03.05.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 141,143, 147, 148, 149, 302, 342 &449.

AIR 2011 SC 1825, 2011 CriLJ2935, 2011(2) Crimes 246 (SC),2011(3) JCC 1989 (SC), JT2011(6) SC 623, 2011(4) KCCRSN 374, 2011(3) KLT (SN) 19,2011-2-LW (Crl) 180, 2011(3)RCR (Criminal) 114, 2011(5)SCALE 278, (2011) 5 SCC 423,(2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 415(1),2011(2) UC 1227.

239. Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section201, 302 & 307.

2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 750,2011(11) SCALE 206.

Sham @ Kishor BhaskarraoMatkari v. The State ofMaharashtra (30.09.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 164.

240. Sharad Kumar etc. v. CentralBureau of Investigation(20.06.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 437 & 439.

2011(6) SCALE 567.

241. Sharadbhai Jivanlal Vaniyav. State of Gujarat(17.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 114,304B, 306 & 498A.

II (2011) DMC 363 SC, 2011(3)SCALE 534.

Arms Act-Section 27. IndianEvidence Act-Section 9.

242. Sheo Shankar Singh v. Stateof Jharkhand and Anr.(15.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 120B, 201 & 302.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 162 & 354(3).

Constitution of India-Article 19& 21.

AIR 2011 SC 1403, 2011(59)BLJR 882, 2011 CriLJ 2139,2011(2) Crimes 1 (SC), [2011(2)JCR 77 (SC) ], JT 2011(2) SC367, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal)634, RLW2011(3) SC 2342,2011(2) SCALE 449, (2011) 3SCC 654, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 25.

243. Sherimon v. State of Kerala(14.11.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,120(B), 302, 324 & 392.

JT 2011(13) SC 152, 2011(12)SCALE 514.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

244. Shiji @ Pappu and Ors. vs.Radhika and Anr.(14.11.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 320, 320(2),320(9) & 482.

JT 2011(13) SC 180, 2011(12)SCALE 588.

Page 69: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 307

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,120B,320,326, 354, 379, 394,,409, 418, 420, 467, 468, 471,498A & 506.

Constitution of India-Article226.

Code of Criminal Procedure1898-Section 561A.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 161.

245. Shindo Alias Sawinder Kaurand Anr. v. State of Punjab(31.03.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,113B, 302, 304B & 498A.

JT 2011(6) SC 364, 2011(II)OLR (SC) 93, 2011(3) PLJR 64,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 878,(2011) 11 SCC 517.

246. Shiv Shankar Singh v. Stateof Bihar and Anr.(22.11.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 302, 395, 396, 398& 506.

JT 2011(13) SC 319, 2011(13)SCALE 75.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 156(3), 173, 203& 204.

247. Shivlal and Anr. v. State ofChhattisgarh (19.09.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 147, 148, 149 & 302.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 154, 157, 157(1),159, 161 & 313.

2011(4) JCC 2706 (SC), JT2011(13) SC 309, 2011(4) KLT(SN) 46, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 286, 2011(10)SCALE 577.

Madhya Pradesh PoliceRegulations-Regulation 710.

248. Sirivalla Srinivasa Rao andOrs. v. State of A.P.(14.07.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,114, 323, 354 & 376(2).

2011(3) ACR 3200 (SC), JT2011(9) SC 368, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 207, 2011(8) SCALE253, (2011) 8 SCC 113, 2011(2)UC 1480.

249. Sk. Yusuf v. State of WestBengal (14.06.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 27.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section201 & 302.

2011(2) ACR 2313 (SC), AIR2011 SC 2283, 2011(3) Crimes 1(SC), JT 2011(6) SC 640,2011(3) KLT (SN) 61, 2011(6)SCALE 511, (2011) 11 SCC 754.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 313.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Sections 154, 154(3), 156(1),156(3), 169, 173, 190, 190(1),200, 202 & 482.

250. Smt. Mona Panwar v. TheHon‘ble High Court ofJudicature at Allahabadthrough its Registrar andOrs. (02.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 376.

2011(2) ACR 1498 (SC),2011(2) ADJ 503, 2011 CriLJ1619, 2011(1) Crimes 272 (SC),2011 GLH (2) 1, 2011(2)JCC969, JT 2011(2) SC 75,2011(1) KLJ64, 2011(3) MPHT241, 2011(3) PLJR 109, 2011(1)RCR (Criminal) 856, 2011(2)SCALE 150, (2011) 3 SCC 496,(2011) 1 SCC (Cri) 1181, [2011]2 SCR 413, 2011(1) UC 465.

Special Marriage Act 1954.251. Sou. Sandhya ManojWankhade v. ManojBhimrao Wankhade andOrs. (31.01.2011)

Protection of Women fromDomestic Violence Act, 2005-Sections 2, 12, 18, 19, 20, 22, 23& 29.

Indian Penal Code-Section 498A.

2011(59) BLJR 321, 2011 CriLJ1687, 2011(2) CTC455, II(2011) DMC 811, 2011 GLH (2)1111, JT 2011(3) SC 265,2011(2) KCCR SN 166, 2011(1)KLJ 57, 2011(1) KLT 609 (SC),2011-4-LW 328, 2011-2-LW

Page 70: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

308 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 482.

(Crl) 190, 2011(1) NCC691,2011(2) PLJR 71, 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 1, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 884, 2011(2) SCALE94, (2011) 3 SCC 650, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 21, [2011] 2 SCR 261.

252. Sri Indra Das v. State ofAssam (10.02.2011)

Terrorist and DisruptiveActivities (Prevention) Act, 1987.

Terrorists and DisruptiveActivities 1989-Section 3 (5).

Unlawful Activities (Prevention)Act, 1967-Section 10.

Hindu Women’s Right toProperty Act 1937. Governmentof India Act, 1935.

2011(3) ACR 2530 (SC),2011(2) ADJ 702, 2011(59)BLJR 626, 2011 CriLJ 1646,2011(2) Crimes 20 (SC), 2011(3)GLT (SC) 3, 2011(2) JCC 1165,2011(2) KCCR SN 158, 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 64, 2011(2)SCALE 312, (2011) 3 SCC 380,(2011) 1 SCC (Cri) 1150.

Prisons Act, 1894-Section 30 (2)& 56.

Bihar Sales Tax Act, 1947.Hindu Minority andGuardianship Act, 1956-Section6.

Rajasthan Nathdwara TempleAct, 1959-Section 16.

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 40 (1).

Punjab Municipal CorporationAct, 1976-Section 123.

Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998-Section 5.

Indian Penal Code-Section 124A.

Constitution of India-Articles 14,19, 19(1), 19(2), 21, 25, 26 &31(2).

Land Acquisition (Amendment)Act, 1962.

253. State of Haryana v. Rajmaland Anr. (25.11.2011)

Punjab Prohibition of CowSlaughter Act, 1955-Section 2.

JT 2011(13) SC 333, 2011(13)SCALE 165.

Punjab Prohibition of CowSlaughter Act, 1955-Section 3, 4& 8.

Code of Criminal Procedure1898-Section 439.

254. State of Kerala and Anr. v.C.P. Rao (16.05.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Section 7, 13(1) & 13(2).

2011(2) Crimes 289 (SC),2011(2) KLT 812 (SC), 2011(3)RCR (Criminal) 688, 2011(6)SCALE 358, (2011) 6 SCC 450,(2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 1010,2011(2) UC 1345.

255. State of Kerala v. Raneef(03.01.2011)

Explosive Substances Act.Unlawful Activities (Prevention)Act, 1967-Section 43D (5).

Societies Registration Act. Codeof Criminal Procedure-Section173.

2011(1) ACR 333 (SC), AIR2011 SC 340, 2011 1 AWC(Supp) 233 SC, 2011 CriLJ 982,2011(1) Crimes 177 (SC),2011(1) JCC 293 (SC), JT2011(1) SC 10, 2011(1) KLT

Page 71: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 309

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Indian Penal Code-Section 202.

Constitution of India-Article 21.

242 (SC), 2011(2) PLJR 49,2011(1) RCR (Criminal) 381,2011(1) SCALE 8, (2011) 1 SCC784, (2011) 1 SCC (Cri) 409,[2011] 1 SCR 590, 2011(1) UC198.

256. Indian Oaths Act 1873-Section5.

State of M.P. v. Ramesh andAnr. (18.03.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 3, 6 & 118.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section120B, 302 & 376.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 161(2), 313,313(3) & 315.

2011(2) ACR 1969 (SC), 2011CriLJ 2297, 2011(2) Crimes 61(SC), 2011(3) CTC 308, 2011(3)JCC 1550, 2011(2) JLJ 125, JT2011(62) SC 4, 2011(3) KCCRSN 315, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 582, 2011(3) SCALE619, (2011) 4 SCC 786, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 493, 2011(2) UC 855.

Constitution of India-Article20(3).

Indian Penal Code-Section 302.257. State of M.P. v. VishweshwarKol (18.01.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 366.

2011(2) ACR 2113 (SC), 2011CriLJ 2172, 2011(2) JCC 1124,2011(2) JLJ 30, 2011(3) KCCRSN 291, 2011(1) NCC 780,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 256,2011(3) SCALE 141, (2011) 11SCC 472, (2011) 3 SCC (Cri)225, [2011] 1 SCR 790.

Prevention of Corruption Act.258. State of Maharashtra v.Goraksha Ambaji Adsul(07.07.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 164, 201, 302,313, 354(3), 354(5) & 366.

2011(4) Crimes 150 (SC), JT2011(7) SC 231, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 558, 2011(7) SCALE570, (2011) 7 SCC 437.

Indian Penal Code-Section 201& 302.

259. State of Maharashtra v.Ravikant Shankarappa Patiland Ors. (05.05.2011)

Arms Act-Section 25(1). IndianPenal Code-Sections 148, 149,323, 342, 366, 376, 386, 452,506(2) & 511.

AIR 2011 SC 2455, 2011(3) JCC1538, JT 2011(6) SC 351,2011(6) SCALE 208, (2011) 6SCC 416, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)998, 2011(2) UC 1217.

260. State of Punjab and Anr. v.Piara Singh Bhaniara andAnr. (07.07.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 95(1).

2011(3) RCR (Criminal) 542.

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Section 7 & 13(2).

261. State of Punjab v. CentralBureau of Investigation andOrs. (02.09.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 120B, 195, 201,202, 211, 218, 219, 221, 224,323, 342, 344, 366, 366A, 376,376A, 376B, 376C, 376D, 384,406, 420, 465, 468, 471 & 506.

2011(3) ACR 2702, AIR 2011SC 2962, 2011(4) JCC 2684(SC), JT 2011(10) SC 185,2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 152,2011(9) SCALE 620.

Immoral Traffic (Prevention)Act, 1956-Section 4 & 5.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 161, 164, 173,173(1), 173(2), 173(8) & 482.

Constitution of India-Article 32,136 & 226.

Page 72: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

310 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

262. Explosive Substances Act, 1908-Section 3 & 4.

2011(3) SCALE 394.State of Punjab v. DavinderPal Singh Bhullar and Ors.etc. (07.12.2011)

Arms Act, 1959-Section 25, 54& 69.

Terrorist and DisruptiveActivities (Prevention) Act,1987-Section 3 & 5.

Andhra Pradesh Forest Act-Section 44(IIA).

States Reorganisation Act, 1956-Section 51(3).

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 97, 164, 200, 362,397(3) & 482.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 120B, 167, 193, 212,216, 223, 224, 302, 307, 323,343, 364 & 437.

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section 151.

Constitution of India-Article 32,137 & 226.

263. State of Punjab v. JagtarSingh and Ors. (26.07.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,300, 302 & 304.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

2011(3) ACR 3286 (SC), AIR2011 SC 3028, 2011(3) Crimes153 (SC), 2011(3) JCC 2175(SC), [2011(4) JCR 69 (SC) ], JT2011(8) SC 300, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 734, 2011(8) SCALE108, 2011(2) UC 1526.

264. State of Rajasthan and Ors.v. Sanyam Lodha(25.08.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 376,376(2) & 376(2) (5). Code ofCriminal Procedure-Section 357& 357A.

2011 6 AWC (Supp) 5702 SC,JT 2011(10) SC 7, 2011(9)SCALE 379.

Rajasthan Chief Minister’s ReliefFund Rules, 1999-Rule 4, 5, 7,8, 10 & 11.

Rajasthan Chief Minister’sFamine and Relief Fund Rules,1979.

Constitution of India-Article162.

265. State of Rajasthan th. Secy.Home Dept. v. AbdulMannan (07.07.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,148, 149, 302, 304, 324, 326 &449.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 161, 313 & 379.

2011(3) ACR 3266 (SC), AIR2011 SC 3013, 2011(3) JCC1899 (SC), JT 2011(8) SC 48,2011(3) RCR (Criminal) 663,2011(7) SCALE 583, (2011) 8SCC 65.

Constitution of India-Article134(1) & 134(91).

Arms Act, 1959- Sections 3 and27.

266. State of Rajasthan v. ArjunSingh and Ors. etc.(02.09.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,147, 148, 149, 302, 307 & 452.

2011(3) ACR 2723, AIR 2011SC 3380, [2011(4) JCR 138 (SC)], JT 2011(10) SC 112, 2011(4)RCR (Criminal) 270, 2011(9)SCALE 661, (2011) 9 SCC 115.

Page 73: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 311

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 313.

267. State of Rajasthan v. ChhoteLal and Ors. (08.06.2011)

Scheduled Castes and ScheduledTribes (Prevention of Atrocities)Act-Section 3.

2011(6) SCALE 526.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,42, 201, 202, 302 & 449.

268. State of Rajasthan v. HakamSingh (15.06.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 302. 2011(6) SCALE 568.

269. State of Rajasthan v. Islamand Ors. (24.05.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 148,149, 300, 302, 304, 323 & 336.

Constitution of India-Article136.

2011(3) ACR 2941 (SC), AIR2011 SC 2317, 2011(2) Crimes303 (SC), 2011(3) JCC 1927(SC), JT 2011(6) SC 452,2011(3) RCR (Criminal) 73,2011(6) SCALE 389, (2011) 6SCC 343, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)951.

Arms Act-Section 27. 2011(13) SCALE 140.270. State of Rajasthan v. SheraRam @ Vishnu Dutta(01.12.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 84, 149, 295, 300,302, 304 & 449.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 313, 379 &134(1).

Arms Act-Section 3, 25 & 27.271. State of Rajasthan v. Talevarand Anr. (17.06.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 114.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 395, 396, 397 & 398.

2011(3) ACR 2369 (SC), AIR2011 SC 2271, 2011(3) Crimes61 (SC), JT 2011(7) SC 1,2011(4) PLJR 79, 2011(6)SCALE 575, 2011(2) UC 1249.

272. State of U.P. v. Chhoteylal(14.01.2011)

Indian Evidence Act-Section 114& 118.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 164 & 313.

Indian Penal Code-Section 90,363, 366, 368, 375 & 376.

2011(2) ACR 1885 (SC),2011(1) ADJ 738, AIR 2011 SC697, 2011(1) ALD (Cri) 691,2011(1) JCC 449 (SC), JT2011(1) SC 228, 2011(2) KCCRSN 97, 2011(1) NCC 637,2011(1) RCR (Civil) 117,2011(1) RCR (Criminal) 443,2011(1) SCALE 454, (2011) 2SCC 550, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)674, [2011] 1 SCR 406.

273. State of U.P. v. Mohd Iqramand Anr. (13.06.2011)

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 13.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 302, 376 & 511.Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 313.

Equivalent Citation: 2011(2)ACR 2306 (SC), AIR 2011 SC2296, 2011(3) Crimes 14 (SC),JT 2011(6) SC 650, 2011(3)RCR (Criminal) 711, 2011(6)SCALE 497, (2011) 8 SCC 80,2011(2) UC 1276.

274. State of U.P. v. Naresh andOrs. (08.03.2011

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 37, 307 & 379.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 82, 83 & 313.

2011(2) ACR 1190 (SC), 2011CriLJ 2162, JT 2011(3) SC 508,2011(1) NCC 805, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 364, 2011(3) SCALE425, (2011) 4 SCC 324, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 216.

Page 74: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

312 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

275. State of U.P. v. Preetam andOrs. (31.03.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 147,148, 149, 302, 307 & 323.

2011(2) Crimes 103 (SC),2011(2) JCC 1221, JT 2011(4)SC 156, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal)679, 2011(4) SCALE 145,(2011) 11 SCC 286, (2011) 3SCC (Cri) 168, 2011(2) UC 812.

276. State of U.P. v. Rajit Ram @Khurpanchi (07.06.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 354& 376.

2011(6) SCALE 477.

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 135 to 159.

277. State through C.B.I. v.Mahender Singh Dahiya(28.01.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 162.

Indian Penal Code-Section 201& 302.

2011(2) ACR 1660 (SC), AIR2011 SC 1017, 2011 CriLJ2177, 2011(1) Crimes 319 (SC),JT 2011(3) SC 109, 2011(3)KCCR SN 292, 2011(1) PLJR129, 2011(1) RCR (Criminal)706, 2011(2) SCALE 7, (2011) 3SCC 109, (2011) 1 SCC (Cri)821, [2011] 1 SCR 1104,2011(1) UC 515.

Arms Act-Section 25 & 27.

Fatal Accidents Act 1855.

278. Suba Singh and Anr. v.Davinder Kaur and Anr.(06.07.2011)

Indian Short Titles Act, 1897.

States (Laws) Act, 1951-Section1, 1A & 3.

Motor Vehicles Act.

2011 ACJ 2161, 2011(3) ACR3260 (SC), AIR 2011 SC 3163,2011(6) ALD 24, 2011(4)ALLMR (SC) 940, 2011(3) JCC1911 (SC), [2011(3) JCR 260(SC) ], JT 2011(7) SC 156,2011(3) KLT (SN) 39, 2011-4-LW610, 2011(7) SCALE 225.

Indian Penal Code-Section 34.

Motor Vehicles Act.

Indian Penal Code-Section302,304 & 307.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 357, 357(1) & 357(5).

Old Antiquated Act.Constitution of India-Article20(2).

279. Subhankar Biswas v.Sandeep Meta (07.04.2011)

Standards of Weights andMeasures Act, 1976-Section 19& 74.

Standards of Weights andMeasures (PackagedCommodities) Rules, 1977-Rule2, 4, 6, 8, 9 & 23.

2011 CriLJ 2895, 2011(267)ELT 433 (SC), JT 2011(5) SC401, 2011(3) PLJR 72, 2011(3)RCR (Criminal) 152, 2011(5)SCALE 137.

280. Subramani @ Jeeva @Kullajeeva v. S. H. O.,Odiyansalai (30.03.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 148,149, 300, 302, 304 & 324.

2011 CriLJ 2897, 2011(3) JCC1559, JT 2011(5) SC 403,2011(3) RCR (Criminal) 782,2011(5) SCALE 139.

281. Subramani and Anr. v. Staterep. by inspector of police(20.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 147,148, 149, 302 & 324.

2011(3) RCR (Criminal) 499,2011(2) SCALE 225, (2011) 11SCC 643.

282. Sudam @ Rahul KaniramJadhav v. State ofMaharashtra (04.07.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 201& 302.

2011(3) ACR 2396 (SC), JT2011(7) SC 335, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 526, 2011(7) SCALE415, (2011) 7 SCC 125, (2011) 3SCC (Cri) 56.

Page 75: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 313

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

283. Sudarshan Kumar v. State ofHaryana (28.07.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 306. 2011(3) ACR 3284 (SC), AIR2011 SC 3024, 2011(3) Crimes178 (SC), JT 2011(8) SC 284,2011-2-LW (Crl) 511, 2011(3)RCR (Criminal) 750, 2011(8)SCALE 115, 2011(2) UC 1529.

284. Sukhbir Singh and Anr. v.State of Punjab (27.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 120B,149 & 302.

2011(2) ACR 2006 (SC), 2011CriLJ 2336, 2011(3) KCCR SN288, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal)842, 2011(4) SCALE 491,(2011) 11 SCC 436, (2011) 3SCC (Cri) 202, 2011(2) UC1327.

Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961-Section 3 & 4.

285. Sunita Kumari Kashyap v.State of Bihar and Anr.(11.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 34,406 & 498A.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 177, 178 & 179.

2011(2) ACR 1611 (SC), AIR2011 SC 1674, 2011(59) BLJR1194, 2011 CriLJ 2667, 2011(2)Crimes 181 (SC), 2011(3) JCC1932 (SC), JT 2011(4) SC 236,2011(3) KCCR SN 264, 2011(2)PLJR 191, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 26, 2011(4) SCALE572, (2011) 11 SCC 301, (2011)3 SCC (Cri) 173, 2011(1) UD412.

286. Surendera Mishra v. State ofJharkhand (06.01.2011)

Arms Act-Section 27. IndianEvidence Act-Section 105.

Indian Penal Code-Section 84 &302.

2011(1) ACR 356 (SC), AIR2011 SC 627, 2011 CriLJ 1161,2011(1) Crimes 192 (SC),2011(1) JCC 427 (SC), [2011(1)JCR 219 (SC) ], JT 2011(1) SC83, 2011(2) KCCR SN 78,2011(2) PLJR 29, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 416, 2011(1) SCALE124, (2011) 11 SCC 495, (2011)3 SCC (Cri) 232, [2011] 1 SCR133.

Indian Evidence Act-Section 27.287. Surendra Koli v. State ofU.P. Ors. (15.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 302,364 & 376.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 164.

AIR 2011 SC 970, 2011(59)BLJR 338, 2011(2) Crimes 56(SC), JT 2011(2) SC 118,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 1,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 12,2011(2) SCALE 490, (2011) 4SCC 80, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 92,[2011] 2 SCR 939.

288. Surinder Kumar v. State ofHaryana (21.10.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section302 & 307.

JT 2011(13) SC 290, 2011(4)RCR (Criminal) 658, (2011) 10SCC 173.

289. Sushil Suri v. C.B.I. and Anr.(06.05.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Section 13(1) & 13(2).

Prevention of Corruption Act,1947-Section 5(1) & 5(2).

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 320 & 482. IndianPenal Code, 1860-Sections120A, 120A (2), 120B, 409, 420,463, 467, 468 & 471.

AIR 2011 SC 1713, (2011) 4CompLJ 9 (SC), 2011 CriLJ2939, 2011(2) Crimes 251 (SC),2011(3) PLJR 51, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 356, 2011(5) SCALE412, (2011) 5 SCC 708, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 764, [2011] 107 SCL390 (SC) .

Constitution of India-Article142.

Page 76: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

314 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

290. Swaminathan and Anr. v.State of Tamil Nadu(12.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 34,302 & 304.

AIR 2011 SC 1592, 2011 CriLJ1683, [2011(2) JCR 156 (SC) ],2011(2) SCALE 229.

291. Swapan Kumar Senapati vs.State of West Bengal(24.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 304,325 & 341.

2011 CriLJ 2631, JT 2011(3) SC548, 2011(3) KCCR SN 269,2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 840,2011(3) SCALE 569.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 154(3), 156(3) &482.

292. T.C. Thangaraj v. V.Engammal and Ors.(29.07.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 409, 420 & 471.

Constitution of India-Article 21,32 & 226.

AIR 2011 SC 3010, 2011(3)Crimes 157 (SC), [2011(4) JCR76 (SC) ], 2011(3) KLT (SN)115, 2011(3) RCR (Criminal)751, 2011(8) SCALE 120,2011(2) UC 1454.

293. T.G.N. Kumar v. State ofKerala and Ors.(14.01.2011)

Negotiable Instruments Act,1881-Section 138.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 87, 88, 205, 233,243, 273, 313, 313(1), 482 &483.

Constitution of India-Article227.

AIR 2011 SC 708, I (2010) BC612, (2011) 3 CALLT 27 (SC),(SCSuppl) 2011(2) CHN22,2011(1) Crimes 339 (SC),2011(1) CTC 627, 2011 GLH(2) 1570, ILR 2011(1) Kerala321, JT 2011(3) SC 280,2011(1) KLJ 559, 2011(1) KLT362 (SC), 2011(1) NCC 443,2011(1) OLR (SC) 754, 2011(3)PLJR 284, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 507, 2011(1) SCALE472, (2011) 2 SCC 772, [2011] 1SCR 436.

Evidence Act, 1872-Section 134.294. Takdir Samsuddin Sheikh v.State of Gujarat and Anr.(21.10.2011)

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section114 & 302.

2011(4) Crimes 232 (SC),2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 840,2011(2) SCALE 158, (2011) 10SCC 158.

295. Tapas Kumar Ghosh v. Stateof West Bengal (07.06.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,302, 304B, & 498B.

II (2011) DMC 501SC, 2011(6)SCALE 549.

Arms Act-Section 27 & 30.296. Tej Bir and Anr. v. State ofHaryana and Anr.(14.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 34,120B & 307.

JT 2011(6) SC 376, 2011(4)KCCR SN 389, 2011(5) SCALE250, (2011) 11 SCC 556.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 161, 173 & 401.

297. Thermax Ltd. and Ors. v. K.M. Johny and Ors.(27.09.2011)

Negotiable Instruments Act,1881-Section 138 & 141.Industrial Disputes Act, 1947-Section 32.

2011(4) Crimes 179 (SC),2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 409,2011(11) SCALE 128.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 91, 93, 156(3),190 (1), 200 & 482.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 34, 120B, 405, 406,415, 418, 420, 423, 424 & 467.

Dowry Prohibition Act, 1986-Section 3 & 4.

298. Thota Venkateswarlu v. Stateof A.P. tr. Princl Sec. andAnr. (02.09.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 188 & 482. Indian PenalCode-Section 498A & 506.

2011(3) ACR 2698 (SC), AIR2011 SC 2900, JT 2011(10) SC281, 2011(3) KLT 909 (SC),2011(9) SCALE 603.

Page 77: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 315

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

299. Tukaram and Ors. v. State ofMaharashtra (24.02.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,147,148, 149, 302, 304(1), 324,326, 504 & 506.

2011(2) ACR 2005 (SC), 2011CriLJ 2339, JT 2011(3) SC 550,2011(3) KCCR SN 301, 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 836, 2011(3)SCALE 531.

300. Ummu Sabeena v. State ofKerala and Ors.(17.11.2011)

Conservation of ForeignExchange and prevention ofSmuggling Activities Act, 1974-Section 3. Constitution of India-Article 22 & 22(5).

2011(13) SCALE 28.

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Section 13(1) & 13(2).

301. Union of India (UOI) andOrs. v. Ramesh Gandhi(14.11.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 120B& 420.

2011(12) SCALE 544.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 155(2), 156(1) & 482.

Constitution of India-Article 141& 226.

302. Union of India (UOI) v.Hassan Ali Khan and Anr.(30.09.2011)

Prevention of Money LaunderingAct, 2002-Sections 2, 3, 4, 24,45 & 50.

2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 427,2011(11) SCALE 302, [2011]109 SCL 615 (SC) .

Foreign Exchange ManagementAct, 1999-Section 3A & 4.

Foreign Exchange ManagementAct, 1959. Evidence Act-Section27. Narcotic Drugs andPsychotropic Substances Act,1985.

Indian Penal Code-Section 121& 121A.

Arms Act, 1959.

Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972.

Immoral Traffic (Prevention)Act, 1956. Prevention ofCorruption Act, 1988.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 167(2) & 439(2).

Terrorist and DisruptiveActivities (Prevention) Act,1987-Section 20(4). PassportAct, 1967. Antiquities and ArtTreasures Act, 1972.

Income Tax Act.

Prevention of Corruption Act,1947-Section 5(1) & 5(2).

303. V.S. Achuthanandan v. R.Balakrishna Pillai and Ors.(10.02.2011)

Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948-Section 5, 16 & 78A.

Income tax Act.

Indian Penal Code-Sections120B, 201, 161, 306, 376, 409& 430.

2011(3) ACR 2540 (SC), AIR2011 SC 1037, 2011(1) Crimes294 (SC), 2011(2) KCCR SN174, 2011(2) PLJR 152, 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 538, 2011(2)SCALE 346, (2011) 3 SCC 317,(2011) 1 SCC (Cri) 1111, [2011]2 SCR 762.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313, 321 & 377.

Page 78: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

316 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Constitution of India-Article227.

Kerala State Electricity BoardTender Regulations-Regulation25.

304. Varghese K. Joseph v. TheCustodian and Ors.(31.01.2011)

Special Courts (Trial of OffencesRelating to Transactions inSecurities) Act, 1992-Section 10.Securities (Control) RegulationAct.

2011(2) ACR 1903 (SC), AIR2011 SC 832, 2011(2) ALD (Cri)139, [2011] 162 CompCas451(SC), (2011) 2 CompLJ 213(SC), 2011(1) Crimes 254 (SC),JT 2011(2) SC 10, 2011(2)KCCR SN 109, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 862, 2011(2) SCALE48, (2011) 3 SCC 394, [2011]106 SCL11 (SC), [2011] 2 SCR269.

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 13(1) & 13B.

305. Veena v. State Govt. ofNCT, Delhi and Anr.(28.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 498A.

AIR 2011 SC 3469, II (2011)DMC 243 SC.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 340.

306. Veeran and Ors. v. State ofM.P. (13.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 147,148, 149, 299, 300, 302, 304,323 & 325.

AIR 2011 SC 1655, 2011 CriLJ2688, 2011(2) Crimes 172 (SC),[2011(3) JCR 34 (SC) ], 2011(3)KCCR SN 276, 2011(4) SCALE615, (2011) 11 SCC 367, (2011)3 SCC (Cri) 195, 2011(2) UC909.

307. Vijay Kumar v. State of U.P.and Anr. (03.08.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act,1988-Section 7, 13(1) & 13(2).

Indian Evidence Act-Section 165.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 161, 311 & 313.

Code of Civil Procedure-Section115.

2011(3) ACR 3007 (SC),2011(3) Crimes 147 (SC),2011(6) CTC 445, [2011(4) JCR71 (SC) ], 2011(3) KLT (SN)112, 2011(II) OLR (SC) 658,2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 208,2011(8) SCALE 221, (2011) 8SCC 136, 2011(2) UC 1441.

Code of Civil Procedure-Order 7Rule 11 & Order 43 Rule 1.

Code of Criminal Procedure1898-Section 540.

308. Vikas Kumar Roorkewal v.State of Uttarakhand andOrs. (11.01.2011)

Scheduled Castes and ScheduledTribes (Prevention of Atrocities)Act, 1989-Section 3 (2).Terrorist and DisruptiveActivities (Prevention) Act, 1987.

Indian Evidence Act-Section 165.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 311, 406 & 407.

2011(2) ACR 1682 (SC), AIR2011 SC 726, [2011(1) JCR 253(SC) ], JT 2011(1) SC 137,2011(2) KCCR SN 95, 2011(1)OLR (SC) 778, 2011(1) RCR(Criminal) 477, 2011(1) SCALE215, (2011) 2 SCC 178, (2011) 1SCC (Cri) 638, [2011] 1 SCR279.

Indian Penal Code-Section 120B& 302.

Constitution of India-Article 21.

Page 79: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 317

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

309. Vishnu Agarwal v. State ofU.P. and Anr. (23.02.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure1898-Section 561A.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 362 & 482.

AIR 2011 SC 1232, 2011 CriLJ1744, [2011(3) JCR 49 (SC) ],JT 2011(3) SC 538, 2011(2)KCCR SN 172, 2011-4-LW338,2011-2-LW (Crl) 200, 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 754, 2011(2)SCALE 690, 2011(1) UC 592.

310. Vishram Singh Raghubanshiv. State of U.P. (15.06.2011)

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Sections 1, 12, 15 & 19.

Bar Council of India Rules.Constitution of India-Article19(1).

2011(2) ACR 2323 (SC), AIR2011 SC 2275, [2011(3) JCR306 (SC) ], JT 2011(6) SC 629,2011(4) RCR (Civil) 555,2011(3) RCR (Criminal) 716,2011(6) SCALE 534, (2011) 7SCC 776, 2011(2) UC 1256.

311. W. Kalyani v. State tr.Inspector of Police and Anr.(01.12.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,341, 386, 497 & 498A.

2011(4) KLT 957 (SC), 2011(13)SCALE 154.

312. Waikhom Yaima Singh v.State of Manipur(18.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 302. 2011(2) ACR 2364 (SC), 2011CriLJ 2673, 2011(2) Crimes 187(SC), [2011(3) JCR 62 (SC) ], JT2011(6) SC 355, 2011(3) KCCRSN 312, 2011(2) KLJ29, 2011(3)PLJR 14, 2011(4) SCALE 718,2011(2) UC 937.

313. Wakkar and Anr. v. TheState of U.P. (03.02.2011)

Arms Act-Section 25(4). IndianEvidence Act-Section 27.

Indian Penal Code-Sections120B, 147, 148, 149, 201 &302.

2011(1) ACR 673 (SC), 2011CriLJ 1639, 2011(1) Crimes 246(SC), JT 2011(2) SC 502,2011(1) NCC 838, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 26, 2011(1) RCR(Rent) 911, 2011(2) SCALE 198,(2011) 3 SCC 306, (2011) 1 SCC(Cri) 846.

314. Waman and Ors. v. State ofMaharashtra (29.06.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 147,148, 149, 302, 323 & 447.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 161.

2011(2) ACR 2271 (SC), AIR2011 SC 3327, JT 2011(7) SC24, 2011(4) RCR (Criminal)503, 2011(6) SCALE 594,(2011) 7 SCC 295, (2011) 3 SCC(Cri) 83.

315. Indian Penal Code-Section 300,302 & 304.

Yomeshbhai PranshankarBhatt v. State of Gujarat(19.05.2011)

Code of Civil Procedure-Section100 & 313. Supreme CourtRules, 1966. Constitution ofIndia-Articles 134, 139A, 142 &145.

AIR 2011 SC 2328, (2011) 3GLR 1834, JT 2011(6) SC 591,2011(3) PLJR 66, 2011(4) RCR(Civil) 321, 2011(6) SCALE 346,(2011) 6 SCC 312, (2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 944, 2011(2) UC 1287,(2011) 2 UPLBEC 251.

316. Zahoor and Ors. v. State ofU.P. (26.04.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,302, 304 & 304(1).

AIR 2011 SC 2501, 2011(4)KCCR SN 376, 2011(2) RCR(Criminal) 897, 2011(5) SCALE384.

CUSTOM

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Customs Act, 1962-Section 101& 135.

2011(268) ELT 433 (SC) .1. Asst. Collector of Customs(P) Goa and Anr. v. ShriPascoal DIAS (28.04.2011)

Import and Export (Control)Act, 1947-Section 5.

Page 80: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

318 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Bombay Land RequisitionOrdinance 1947-Section 3.

2. Automotive TyreManufacturers Association v.The Designated Authorityand Ors. (07.01.2011)

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section3 (1) & 3 (2).

Customs Act, 1962-Sections 9A,9(C), 9A (3), 129, 129(1), 129C(1), 129C (2), 129C (5), 129C(6) & 130E.

2011(183) ECR 145 (SC),2011(263) ELT 481 (SC), JT2011(1) SC 282, 2011(2) KCCRSN 108, 2011(1) SCALE 149,(2011) 2 SCC 258, [2011] 1 SCR198.

Customs Tariff Act, 1975-Section 9A to 9C.

Electricity Act, 2003-Section 62.

3. Chandna Impex Pvt. Limitedv. Commissioner of Customs,New Delhi (06.07.2011)

Customs Act, 1962-Sections2(34), 28, 28AB, 111, 114A,124, 130 & 130E.

2011(186) ECR 153 (SC),2011(269) ELT 433 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 10, 2011(3) RCR(Civil) 843, 2011(7) SCALE 291,(2011) 7 SCC 289.

Customs Act, 1962-Sections 111,112, 125, 129B & 130A.

Customs Tariff Act, 1975.

4. Commissioner of Customs(Import) v. Stoneman MarbleIndustries and Ors.(21.01.2011)

Income Tax Act, 1961-Section256.

112(2011) CLT 143 (SC),2011(183) ECR 251 (SC),2011(264) ELT 3 (SC), 2011(1)SCALE 600, (2011) 2 SCC 758,[2011] 1 SCR 545.

5. Commissioner of Customs v.Sayed Ali and Anr.(18.02.2011)

Customs Act, 1962-Sections2(34), 4, 4(1), 5, 28, 28 (1), 30,31, 34, 47, 111, 112 & 130E.

2011(184) ECR 51 (SC),2011(265) ELT 17 (SC), JT2011(2) SC 360, 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 780, 2011(2) SCALE 515,(2011) 3 SCC 537, [2011] 2 SCR1045.

6. Commissioner of Customs,Calcutta v. G. C. Jain andAnr. (04.07.2011)

Customs Act-Section 47. AIR 2011 SC 2262, 2011(4)ALLMR (SC) 874, 2011(186)ECR 137 (SC), 2011(269) ELT307 (SC), JT 2011(7) SC 1752011(6) SCALE 743.

Customs Act, 1962-Sections 14,14(1), 14(2), 14(1A), 14(1)(A),46, 50, 50(1) & 50(1A).

Customs Tariff Act, 1975.

2011(188) ECR 107 (SC),2011(272) ELT 641 (SC), JT2011(12) SC 250, 2011(2)SCALE 64.

7. Commissioner of Customs,Vishakhapatnam v.Aggarwal Industries Ltd.(17.10.2011)

Customs Valuation(Determination of Price ofImported Goods) Rules 1988-Rules 2(1), 4, 4(1), 4(2), 9, 9(1),9(3) & 10A.

Customs Act, 1962-Section 14.

Customs Tariff Act, 1975-Section 46 & 50.

8. Commnr. Of CustomsExcise, New Delhi v. LivingMedia (India) Ltd.(17.08.2011)

Customs Valuation(Determination of Value ofImported Goods) Rules 2007-Rules 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 9(1)& 10A.

2011(188) ECR 1 (SC), JT2011(9) SC 324, 2011(9) SCALE153.

Customs Valuation Rules 1988-Rule 2(2) & 9(1).

Page 81: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 319

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Customs Act, 1962-Section 25(1)& 130E.

9. Gammon India Ltd. v.Commissioner of Customs,Mumbai (06.07.2011)

Customs Tariff Act, 1975.

2011(6) ALD 29, 2011(269)ELT 289 (SC), JT 2011(7) SC525, 2011(7) SCALE 297.

Indian Partnership Act, 1932.

Customs Act, 1962-Sections2(25), 9, 12, 15, 68, 129(B) (2)& 130E.

10. Mustan Taherbhai v.Commnr. of Central Exciseand Customs (28.02.2011)

Customs Tariff Act, 1975-Section 3.

Sea Customs Act, 1878-Section20 & 21.

2011(184) ECR 176 (SC),2011(265) ELT 161 (SC), JT2011(3) SC 143, 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 602, 2011(3) SCALE 27,(2011) 4 SCC 660.

11. Om Prakash and Anr. v.Union of India (UOI) andAnr. (30.09.2011)

Customs Act, 1962-Sections 104,104(3), 104(4), 132, 133, 135,135A & 136.

2011(187) ECR 363 (SC),2011(272) ELT 321 (SC),2011(4) KLT (SN) 100, 2011-2-LW (Crl) 497, 2011(11) SCALE310.

Central Excise Act, 1944-Sections 9, 9(1), 9A, 9A (2), 13,18, 19, 20 & 21.

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985.

Evidence Act-Section 25.

Foreign Exchange RegulationAct, 1973.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Sections 2, 2(1), 41, 41(1),41(2), 42, 46, 109, 110, 116(3),155, 173, 436, 446 & 446A.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 194,195, 274, 466, 467, 476, 477,493 & 505.

Code of Criminal Procedure1898-Section 9.

Customs Act, 1962-Section 18,27 & 130E.

12. RBF Rig Corporation,Mumbai v. TheCommissioner of Customs(Imports), Mumbai(08.02.2011)

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section11B.

2011(186) ECR 1 (SC), JT2011(2) SC 489, 2011(2) SCALE271, (2011) 3 SCC 573, [2011] 2SCR 691.

Income Tax Act, 1961.

Central Excise Rules, 1944-Rule11.

Constitution of India-Article142, 226 & 227.

13. Rajmal Lakhichand and Anr.v. Commr. Cen. Exc. andCustoms, Aurangabad(04.07.2011)

Customs Act, 1962-Sections 111,112, and 120(2), 129D, 130B,130 (3) & 130 (4).

2011(186) ECR 159 (SC),2011(269) ELT 438 (SC), JT2011(7) SC 183, 2011(6) SCALE737.

14. SBEC Sugar Limited andAnr. v. Union of India (UOI)and Ors. (07.02.2011)

Customs Act, 1962-Sections 3,15(1), 25(1), 59, 61, 61(1),61(2), 64, 65, 68, 71, 71(1), 72& 72(1).

2011(186) ECR 7 (SC), (2011) 4SCC 668, [2011] 2 SCR 585.

Central Excises Act, 1944-Section 3 (1) & 60.

Page 82: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

320 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Customs and Central ExciseDuties Draw-back Rules 1995.

15. Siddachalam Exports PrivateLtd. v. Commissioner ofCentral Excise, Delhi-III(01.04.2011)

Customs Act, 1962-Sections2(33), 2(41), 14, 14(1), 108,110, 113, 114, & 130E.

2011(185) ECR 405 (SC),2011(267) ELT 3 (SC), JT2011(5) SC 255, 2011(3) RCR(Civil) 521, (2011) 5 SCC 114.

Customs Valuation(Determination of Price ofImported Goods) Rules 1988-Rules 4, 4(2), 5, 6, 7 & 8.

DEFENCE LAW

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Hardev Singh v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Anr.(14.09.2011)

Armed Forces Tribunal Act,2007-Section 30.

2011(10) SCALE 503, (2011) 10SCC 121.

AIR Force Act, 1950-Section 73& 157.

2. Ram Narayan Tiwari v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (21.02.2011)

Army Act, 1950-Sections 57, 63,71 & 72.

(SCSuppl) 2011(2) CHN 126,[2011(129) FLR 138], [2011(2)JCR 194 (SC) ], 2011(2) KCCRSN 173, 2011(2) SCALE 639,(2011) 4 SCC 684, (2011) 1 SCC(L&S) 737, [2011] 2 SCR 1104.

Navy Act, 1957.3. S.K. Jha Commodre v. Stateof Kerala and Anr.(11.01.2011)

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 475 & 549.

2011(1) OLR (SC) 769, 2011(2)SCALE 1, [2011] 1 SCR 295.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 143,147, 148, 149, 307, 326, 427 &452.

Criminal Courts and CourtMarital (Adjustment ofJurisdiction) Rules 1978-Rule 3.

4. Shish Ram v. Union of India(UOI) and Ors. (23.11.2011)

Army Act, 1950-Section 20 &20(3).

JT 2011(13) SC 316, 2011(13)SCALE 65.

Defence Services Regulations1961-Regulation 206.

Pension Regulations 1961-Regulation 113.

Constitution of India-Article136.

5. Union of India (UOI) andOrs. v. BodupalliGopalaswami (12.09.2011)

Army Act, 1950-Sections 34, 35,36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43,44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51,52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59,60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 71 & 130.

2011(4) KLT (SN) 27, 2011(10)SCALE 275.

Army Rules 1954-Rule 16, 39,39(2), 44 & 149.

Pension Regulations 1961-Regulation 16.

Constitution of India-Article 226& 227.

Army Act, 1950-Sections 3, 52,153, 154, 164 & 191.

6. Union of India (UOI)through its SecretaryMinistry of Defence v.Rabinder Singh (29.09.2011)

Prevention of Corruption Act-Section 5(2).

[2011(131) FLR 919], 2011(4)RCR (Criminal) 522, 2011(11)SCALE 231.

Page 83: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 321

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Army Rules 1954-Rule 23,30(4), 42 & 177.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Sections 3, 24, 44, 120B, 464 &477A.

EDUCATION

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Abhyudya Sanstha v. Unionof India (UOI) and Ors.(12.05.2011)

National Council for TeacherEducation Act, 1993-Sections 2,3, 3(1), 12, 14, 15, 16, 17, 17A,18, 20, 29, 31(1), 31(2), 32,32(1) & 32(2).

AIR 2011 SC 2353, 2011(3)ALLMR (SC) 969, JT 2011(6)SC 195, 2011(6) SCALE 251,(2011) 6 SCC 145.

Land Acquisition Act-Section11A.

National Council for TeacherEducation (Recognition Normsand Procedure) Regulations2007-Regulations 4, 7, 7(9),7(10), 7(11), 8, 8(7) & 8(12).

Constitution of India-Article136.

National Council for TeacherEducation (Recognition Normsand Procedure) Regulations1995.

National Council for TeacherEducation (Recognition Normsand Procedure) Regulations2002.

National Council for TeacherEducation (Recognition Normsand Procedure) Regulations2005.

2. Central Board of SecondaryEducation and Anr. v. AdityaBandopadhyay and Ors.(09.08.2011)

Right to Information Act, 2005-Sections 2, 3, 4, 4(1), 4(2), 4(3),4(4), 5, 6, 7, 7(9), 8, 8(1), 8(3),9, 10, 11, 19(8), 22 & 24.

Official Secrets Act, 1923.

Freedom to Information Act,2002-Section 8.

2011 6 AWC (Supp) 5567 SC,[2011(4) JCR 14 (SC) ], JT2011(9) SC 212, 2011(3) KLT(SN) 117, 2011-4-LW289,(2011) 7 MLJ 1237 (SC),2011(5) MPHT1, 2011(II) OLR(SC) 746, 2011(3) RCR (Civil)914, 2011(8) SCALE 645,(2011) 8 SCC 497.

Constitution of India-Article 14,19 & 19(1).

Maharashtra Secondary andHigher Secondary Board Rules,1977-Rule 104, 104(1) &104(3).

3. Chair man, BhartiaEducation Society and Anr.v. State of Himachal Pradeshand Ors. (02.02.2011)

National Council for TeacherEducation Act, 1993-Sections14, 14(1), 14(3), 14(4), 14(5),14(6), 15, 16, 17(3) & 17(4).

2011(5) BomCR 241, (2011) 7MLJ 324 (SC), 2011(2) PLJR 94,2011(3) SCALE 48, (2011) 4SCC 527, [2011] 2 SCR 461.

Page 84: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

322 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Constitution of India-Article309.

4. Chandigarh Administrationthrough the Director PublicInstructions (Colleges),Chandigarh v. UshaKheterpal Waie and Ors.(02.09.2011)

Punjab Educational Service(College Grade) (Class I) Rules1976 Punjab Educational Service(College Grade) (Class I)(Amendment) Rules, 1983.

AIR 2011 SC 2956, JT 2011(10)SC 427, 2011(9) SCALE 591.

Chandigarh Educational Service(Group A Gazetted) GovernmentArts and Science College Rules,2000.

5. Chowdhury NavinHemabhai and Ors. v. TheState of Gujarat and Ors.(18.02.2011)

Gujarat Professional MedicalEducational Colleges orInstitutions (Regulation ofAdmission and Fixation of Fees)Act, 2007-Section 4, 12 & 20(1).

AIR 2011 SC 1209, 2011 3AWC 3035 SC, (2011) 3 GLR1929, [2011(2) JCR 102 (SC) ],2011(2) SCALE 522, (2011) 3SCC 617, [2011] 2 SCR 1071.

Indian Medical Council Act,1956.

Gujarat Professional MedicalEducational Colleges orInstitutions (Regulation ofAdmission and Payment of Fees)Rules 2008-Rule 5, 5(1), 12 &12(2).

Constitution of India-Article 142& 226.

Graduate Medical EducationRegulations 1997-Regulations 4& 5.5.

Societies Registration Act, 1860. 2011(11) SCALE 427.6. Colvin School Society v. AnilKumar Sharma and Ors.(11.10.2011)

Uttar Pradesh IntermediateEducation Act, 1921-Section 7(a)& 16(D).

Delhi Education Act, 1973.

Constitution of Indian-Article 19& 19(1).

Medical Cadre ContractAppointment Rules, 2005.

7. Dr. Archana chouhanpundhir v. State of M.P. andOrs. (24.01.2011)

Entrance Examination Rules2007-Rule 2 & 9.

AIR 2011 SC 1166, ILR [2011]MP 1119, 2011(2) JLJ80,2011(2) SCALE 180, (2011) 11SCC 486.

Entrance Examination Rules2008.

8. RTE Act Pondicherry SchoolEducation Rules 1996.

2011(6) SCALE 563.Environmental andConsumer Protect. Found v.Delhi Administration andOrs. (29.04.2011)

Constitution of India-Article21A.

9. Right of Children to Free andCompulsory Education Act2009-Section 19(2) & 25(1).

2011(6) SCALE 552.Environmental andConsumer Protect. Found. v.Delhi Administration andOrs. (29.03.2011)

Constitution of India-Article21A.

Page 85: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 323

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

10. Andhra Pradesh SocietiesRegistration Act 2001.

2011(9) SCALE 422.Federation of A.P. MinorityEducational Institution v.Admission and FeeRegulatory Committee forMatters relating To FeeFixation in Pvt. UnaidedProfessional Colleges andOrs. (25. 08. 2011)

Andhra Pradesh EducationalInstitutions (Regulation ofAdmission and Prohibition ofCapitation Fee) Act, 1983-Section 3 & 15. Constitution ofIndia-Article 19(1), 30 & 136.

Andhra Pradesh EngineeringCommon Entrance Test forDiploma Holders for Admissioninto B.F. B.Tech. & B.Pharmacourses Rules, 2004-Rule 12.

Andhra Pradesh EngineeringCommon Entrance Test forDiploma Holders for Admissioninto B.F. B.Tech. And B.Pharmacourses Rules, 2006-Rule 6.

11. Fee Regulatory Committee v.Kalol Institute ofManagement, etc.(11.10.2011)

Gujarat Professional TechnicalEducational Colleges orInstitutions (Regulation ofAdmission Fixation of Fees) Act,2007-Sections 9, 10(1), 10(3) &11(1).

2011(11) SCALE 760.

Constitution of India-Article226.

12. Govt. of A.P. and Ors. v. SriSevadas Vidyamandir HighSchool and Ors.(06.09.2011)

Andhra Pradesh EducationalInstitutions (EstablishmentRecognition Administration andControl of Schools Under PrivateManagement) Rules 1993-Rule10(17).

JT 2011(10) SC 388, 2011(10)SCALE 208.

13. Hardeep Singh v. State ofMadhya Pradesh(05.12.2011)

Madhya Pradesh RecognizedExaminations Act 1937-Section3 & 4.

2011(3) SCALE 289.

Indian Penal Code-Sections 34,395, 420, 468 & 469.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 197.

Constitution of India-Article 21.

Guru Gobind Singh IndraprasthaUniversity Act, 1998-Section 6,6(2) & 27.

14. Indian Medical Associationv. Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (12.05.2011)

Delhi Professional Colleges orInstitutions (Prohibition ofCapitation Fee Regulation ofAdmission Fixation of Non-Exploitative Fee DelhiProfessional Colleges orInstitutions (Prohibition ofCapitation Fee Regulation ofAdmission Fixation of Non-Exploitative other Measures toEnsure Equity Delhi ProfessionalColleges or Institutions(Prohibition of Capitation Fee

AIR 2011 SC 2365, JT 2011(6)SC 505, 2011(3) KLT (SN) 81,(2011) 7MLJ981 (SC), 2011(6)SCALE 86, (2011) 7 SCC 179.

Page 86: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

324 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Regulation of AdmissionFixation of Non-ExploitativeExcellence) Act.

Delhi Professional Colleges orInstitutions (Prohibition ofCapitation Fee Regulation ofAdmission Fixation of Non-Exploitative 2007.

Constitution of India (NinetyThird Amendments) Act, 2005.Persons with Disabilities (EqualOpportunities Protection ofRights and Full Participation)Act, 1995.

Constitution of India-Articles 12,14, 15, 15(1), 15(2), 15(4), 16,16(1), 16(4), 16(4A), 16(4B), 19,19(1), 19(6), 21, 29, 29(2), 30,30(1), 31B, 32, 38, 46, 142, 162,226 & 368.

Guru Gobind Singh IndraprasthaUniversity Ordinance-Ordinance30.

16. Maharashtra Universities Act,1994-Sections 8, 5(60), 14(5),115, 115(2) & 423.

Khandesh College EducationSociety, Jalgaon and Anr. v.Arjun Hari Narkhede andOrs. (05.07.2011)

Maharashtra Civil Services(Leave) Rules, 1981-Rule 50, 52,54 & 68.

AIR 2011 SC 3226, 2011(4)ALLMR (SC) 885, [2011(131)FLR 134], JT 2011(7) SC 3402011(7) SCALE 146, (2011) 7SCC 172, (2011) 2 SCC (L& S)244.

17. Mahatma Gandhi Universityand Anr. v. Jikku Paul andOrs. Etc. etc. (08.04.2011)

All India Council for TechnicalEducation Regulations-Regulation 6.1.

AIR 2011 SC 3543, [2011(3)JCR 56 (SC) ], 2011(4) SCALE578.

18. Modern Dental College andResearch Centre and Ors. v.State of Madhya Pradesh andOrs. (23.09.2011)

Madhya Pradesh Niji VyavsayikShikshan Sanstha (Pravesh KaViniyaman Avam Shulk kaNirdharan) Adhiniyam 2007.

2011(10) SCALE 716.

19. Mohd. Salman v. Committeeof Management and Ors.(08.09.2011)

Uttar Pradesh SubordinateRevenue Executive Service(Tahsildar) Rules-Rule 6(3), 12& 14.

2011(10) SCALE 251.

20 Delhi School Education Act-Sections 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 & 14.

Mrs. Satimbla Sharma andOrs. v. St. Paul’s SeniorSecondary School and Ors.(11.08.2011)

Right of Children to Free andCompulsory Education Act2009-Sections 2, 23, 23 (3), 38& 38 (2).

AIR 2011 SC 2926, 2011(6)ALLMR (SC) 5672, 2011 GLH(3) 162, JT 2011(8) SC 611,2011(3) KLT 674 (SC), 2011(9)SCALE 92, 2011(5) UJ 3460(SC) .

Constitution of India-Articles 12,14, 30(1), 36, 39 & 226.

21. P. V. Indiresan v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Ors.(18.08.2011)

Central Educational Institutions(Reservation in Admission) Act,2006-Section 2 & 3.

Constitution of India (Ninety-third Amendment) Act.

2011(59) BLJR 2075, 181(2011)DLT 608 (SC), JT 2011(9) SC415, 2011(9) SCALE 33, (2011)8 SCC 441.

Page 87: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 325

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Constitution of India (Ninety-third 2005 Haryana Service ofEngineers Class I PWD(Irrigation Branch) Rules, 1964-Rule 7.

Constitution of India-Articles15(5), 16(4) & 21A.

Dentists Act, 1948-Section 10A(4).

22. Priya Darshni Dental Collegeand Hospital v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Ors.(15.02.2011)

Medical Council of IndiaEstablishment of MedicalCollege Regulations 1999-Regulations 4, 4(1), 4(2), 6, 7,10, 11(2) & 60.

JT 2011(3) SC 553, 2011(3)KCCR 281, 2011(3) SCALE543, (2011) 4 SCC 623.

23. Pushpa Kumari and Ors. v.The State of Bihar and Ors.(11.10.2011)

National Council for TeacherEducation Act, 1993.

2011(11) SCALE 573, (2011) 10SCC 189.

24. Ranu Hazarika and Ors. v.State of Assam and Ors.(28.02.2011)

National Council for TeacherEducation Act, 1993-Sections12, 32, 32(2) & 33.

Assam Elementary Education(Provincialization) (Amendment)Rules, 2005.

2011(1) GLT (SC) 52, JT2011(2) SC 497, 2011(3) SCALE37, (2011) 4 SCC 798, (2011) 1SCC (L& S) 745.

Assam Elementary Education(Provincialization) Rules, 1977.

National Council for TeacherEducation (Determination ofMinimum Qualifications forRecruitment of Teachers inSchools) Regulations 2001.

25. Sanchit Bansal and Anr. v.The Joint Admission Board(JAB) and Ors. (11.10.2011)

Right to Information Act, 2005. 2011(11) SCALE 593.

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971.26. Sanjay Adlakha v. State ofHaryana and Ors.(01.06.2011)

Constitution of India-Article136.

2011(6) SCALE 419.

27. National Council of Teachers’Education Act, 1993-Section14(3) & 17.

2011(13) SCALE 598.

National Council of Teachers’Education Regulations 2002.

Shri Morvi SarvajanikKelavni Mandal SanchalitMSKM B. Ed. College v.National Council forTeachers Education and Ors.(16.12.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 32& 226.

Constitution of India-Article15(5).

2011(59) BLJR 1758.28. Social Justice Alliance andAnr. v. Union of India (UOI)and Ors. (01.06.2011)

Central Educational Institution(Reservation in Admission) Act,2007.

29. State of T. Nadu and Ors. v.M. Seshachalam and Ors.(14.06.2011)

Tamil Nadu Uniform System ofSchool Education Act 2010-Section 3.

2011(6) SCALE 522.

Tamil Nadu Uniform System ofSchool Education (AmendmentAct) 2011-Section 3.

Page 88: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

326 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

30. State of Tamil Nadu andOrs. v. K. Shyam Sunder andOrs. (09.08.2011)

Tamil Nadu Uniform System ofSchool Education (Amendment)Act 2011-Section 3.

AIR 2011 SC 3470, JT 2011(9)SC 166, 2011(8) SCALE 474.

Right of Children to Free andCompulsory Education Act2009-Section 29 & 34.

Tamil Nadu Uniform System ofSchool Education Act 2010-Sections 3, 3(1), 11, 12, 14 &18.

Delhi Laws Act, 1912 EmployeesState Insurance Act GeneralClauses Act, 1897-Section 6.

Karnataka State Civil Services(Regulation of Promotion Payand Pension) Act, 1973.

Constitution of India-Articles 12,13, 13(2), 14, 15, 21A, 143, 245& 246.

Tamil Nadu Uniform System ofSchool Education Ordinance2009.

31. Swami Vivekanand Collegeof Education and Ors. v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (12.10.2011)

National Council for TeacherEducation Act, 1993-Sections12, 13, 14, 14(3), 15, 15(3), 32& 32(2).

JT 2011(12) SC 125, 2011(11)SCALE 489.

National Council for TeacherEducation (Recognition Normsand Procedure) Regulations2007-Regulation 8(3), 8(4) &8(5).

National Council for TeacherEducation (Recognition Normand Procedure) Regulations2009-Regulation 8(3), 8(4) &8(5).

National Council for TeacherEducation (Recognition Normand Procedure) Regulations2005-Regulations 8, 8(3) & 8(5).

National Council for TeacherEducation (Recognition Normsand Procedure) (Amendment)Regulations 2006-Regulation 3.

National Council for TeacherEducation (Recognition Normand Procedure) Regulations2002-Regulation 8.

Constitution of India-Article 14& 19(1).

Chartered Accountants Act,1949-Section 3.

32. The Institute of CharteredAccountants of India v.Shaunak H. Satya and Ors.(02.09.2011)

Right to Information Act, 2005-Sections 2, 3, 4, 4(1), 8, 8(1),8(3), 9, 10 & 11.

JT 2011(10) SC 128, 2011(4)KLT (SN) 17, 2011-5-LW299,2011(4) RCR (Civil) 336,2011(9) SCALE 639, (2011) 8SCC 781, [2011] 109 SCL 200(SC) .

Page 89: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 327

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Chartered Accountants Act,1948.

Copyright Act, 1957-Section 51,52 & 52(1).

Constitution of India-Article 12.

Chartered AccountantsRegulations 1988-Regulations38, 39(2), 39(4) & 42.

33. The Secretary, All India Pre-Medical/Pre-DentalExamination, C.B.S.E. AndOrs. v. KhushbooShrivastava and Ors.(17.08.2011)

Constitution of India-Article226.

2011 6 AWC (Supp) 5678SC,2011(9) SCALE 63.

All India Council for TechnicalEducation Act, 1987.

34. Visveswaraya TechnologicalUniversity and Anr. v.Krishnendu Halder and Ors.(18.02.2011)

Visveswaraya TechnologicalUniversity Act, 1994-Section20(1).

AIR 2011 SC 1429, 2011 3AWC 2945 SC, JT 2011(3) SC187, 2011(3) KCCR 2326,2011(2) PLJR 199, 2011(3)SCALE 359, (2011) 4 SCC 606,[2011] 2 SCR 1007.

Professional EducationalInstitution Rules, 2006-Rule 1(3)& 3.

Constitution of India-Article 19& 254.

ELECTION/ ANTI DEFECTION LAW

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Maharashtra Scheduled CastesScheduled Tribes De-notifiedTribes (Vimukta Jatis).

1. Bharati BalkrishnaDhongade v. State ofMaharashtra and Ors.(05.12.2011)

Maharashtra Scheduled CastesScheduled Tribes De-notifiedNomadic Tribes.

2011(3) SCALE 300.

Maharashtra Scheduled CastesScheduled Tribes De-notifiedOther Backward Classes.

Maharashtra Scheduled CastesScheduled Tribes De-notifiedSpecial Backward Category(Regulation of IssuanceMaharashtra Scheduled CastesScheduled Tribes De-notifiedVerification of) Caste CertificateAct Maharashtra ScheduledCastes Scheduled Tribes De-notified 2001 Constitution ofIndia-Article 15(4), 16(4), 341,342, 366(24) & 366(25).

Constitution of India (ScheduledTribes) Order 1950.

2. Desiya Murpokku DravidaKazhagam and Anr. v. TheElection Commission ofIndia (16.03.2011)

Representation of the PeopleAct, 1951-Section 29A (1) &29A.

JT 2011(3) SC 395, 2011(3)KCCR SN 294, 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 606, 2011(3) SCALE 579,(2011) 4 SCC 224.

Page 90: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

328 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Conduct of Election Rules,1961-Rule 5 & 10.

Constitution of India-Article324.

Election Symbols (Reservationand Allotment) Order 1968.

3. Representation of the PeopleAct, 1951-Section 10 & 100(1)& 116A.

2011(1) ALLMR (SC) 249,2011(3) SCALE 283.

Gajanan Samadhan Lande v.Sanjay Shyamrao Dhotre(30.11.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 102& 102(1).

4. Kalyan Kumar Gogoi v.Ashutosh Agnihotri and Anr.(18.01.2011)

Representation of People Act,1951-Sections 25, 31, 56, 57,57(1), 58, 58(1), 80, 80(1), 80A,81, 87(2), 100, 100(1), 100(2) &116A.

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 3, 60 & 64.

AIR 2011 SC 760, 2011(4) ALD14 (SC), 2011(2) GLT (SC) 5, JT2011(1) SC 249, 2011(2) KCCR1407, 2011(1) SCALE 516,(2011) 2 SCC 532, (2011) 1 SCC(Cri) 741, [2011] 1 SCR 796.

Conduct of Election Rules,1961-Rule 3 & 15.

Representation of People Act,1951-Sections 30, 80, 81, 83, 87,97, 97(1), 100, 100 (1), 117 &118.

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section 151, Order 6 Rule 16 &Order 14 Rule 1.

5. Kalyan Singh Chouhan v. C.P. Joshi (24.01.2011)

Conduct of Election Rules,1961-Rules 42 and 63.

AIR 2011 SC 1127, 2011(2)ALT44 (SC), (SCSuppl) 2011(3)CHN173, 112(2011) CLT 228(SC), JT 2011(2) SC 97, 2011(1)RCR (Civil) 865, 2011(1)SCALE 718, (2011) 11 SCC 786,[2011] 2 SCR 216.

6. Kodikunnil Suresh @ J.Monian v. N. S. Saji Kumaretc. (12.05.2011)

Representation of the PeopleAct, 1951-Sections 4, 36, 87(2),100 (1), 116A, 116C (2) & 117.

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 3 & 35.

ILR2011(2) Kerala 515, JT2011(6) SC 83, 2011(2) KLT721 (SC), (2011) 6 MLJ 595(SC), 2011(3) RCR (Civil) 194,2011(6) SCALE 70, (2011) 6SCC 430.

Children Act, 1960-Section 2.

Kerala Registration of Marriages(Common) Rules 2008.

Constitution (Scheduled Castes)Order 1950 Hindu Law.

7. Nandiesha Reddy v. Mrs.Kavitha Mahesh(08.07.2011)

Representation of the PeopleAct, 1951-Sections 13, 14A,18(1), 33, 33(1), 33(4), 34,36(2), 36(4), 81, 81(3), 83,83(1), 86, 87, 100(1) & 101.

JT 2011(7) SC 244, 2011(3)RCR (Civil) 709, 2011(7)SCALE 363, (2011) 7 SCC 721.

Presidential and Vice PresidentialElections Act, 1952-Sections 5(B)(1) & 5C.

Code of Civil Procedure-Order 6Rule 2, Order 6 Rule 15(1), andOrder 6 Rules 16 & Order 7Rules 11.

Supreme Court Rules-Rule 7.

Supreme Court Order-Order 39.

Page 91: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 329

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

8. P.H. Paul Manoj Pandian v.Mr. P. Veldurai (13.04.2011)

Representation of People Act,1951-Sections 9A, 80, 81, 82,83, 84, 100(1) & 116A.

Madras High Court ElectionPetition Rules 1967-Rule 2.Constitution of India-Article162.

AIR 2011 SC 1660, JT 2011(4)SC 567, 2011(4) KCCR SN 359,2011(5) MhLJ805 (SC), 2011(2)RCR (Civil) 723, 2011(4)SCALE 596, (2011) 5 SCC 214.

9. Ramesh Rout v. RabindraNath Rout (09.12.2011)

Representation of the PeopleAct, 1951-Sections 5(2), 29A,30, 31, 33, 33(1), 33(4), 34, 35,36, 36(1), 36(2), 36(4), 36(5),83, 83(1), 87, 100(1), 116A &116C.

2011(3) SCALE 423.

Conduct of Elections Rules,1961-Rules 4, 5 & 10.

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Order 6 Rule 2 Rules of ElectionLaw.

Constitution of India-Article324.

Election Symbols (Reservationand Allotment) Order 1968.

10. Advocates Act, 1961-Sections15, 15(1), 15(2), 15(3), 49 &49(1).

JT 2011(12) SC 280, 2011(11)SCALE 538.

The Bar Council ofMaharashtra and Goa v.Manubhai Paragji Vashi andOrs. (13.10.2011)

Bar Council of Maharashtra andGoa Rules-Rule 6, 6(1) 31, 32 &40.

Bar Council of India Rules,1975-Rule 1 & 2.

Constitution of India-Article136.

11. University of Kerala v.Council, Principals, Colleges,Kerala and Ors.(08.12.2011)

Jawaharlal Nehru UniversityAct.

2011(13) SCALE 487.

ELECTRICITY LAW

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Bihar State Electricity Boardv. The Patna Electric SupplyCo. Ltd. and Ors.(01.09.2011)

Indian Electricity Act, 1910. [2011(4) JCR 110 (SC) ],2011(9) SCALE 581.

2. Dr. S.C. Jindal v. Uhbvnlthro. Executive Engineer andAnr. (07.01.2011)

Code of Civil Procedure-Section100.

112(2011) CLT 117 (SC), 2011ELR (SC) 1142, 2011(3) KCCRSN 296, 2011(3) RCR (Civil)694, 2011(3) SCALE 14.

3. NTPC Ltd. v. M.P. StateElectricity Board and Ors.(29.09.2011)

Electricity Act, 2003-Sections2(28), 13, 43A (2), 61, 62, 62(6),63, 76, 111 & 185. Electricity(Supply) Act, 1948-Section 43A& 43A (2).

2011 ELR (SC) 1485.

Electricity RegulatoryCommissions Act, 1998.

Page 92: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

330 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Indian Electricity Act, 1910.

Sale of Goods Act 1930-Section61.

Essential Commodities Act,1955.

Code of Civil Procedure-Section144. Central ElectricityRegulatory Commission (Termsand Conditions of Tariff)Regulations 2004-Regulation5A.

Central Electricity RegulatoryCommission (Conduct ofBusiness) Regulation 1999-Regulation 79(2).

Electricity RegulatoryCommissions Act, 1988.

4. Sagar Sugars and AlliedProducts Ltd. v. TheTransmission Corporation ofA.P. Ltd. and Ors.(13.10.2011)

Andhra Pradesh ElectricityReforms Act, 1998.

JT 2011(13) SC 215, 2011(11)SCALE 544, (2011) 10 SCC 154.

5. Electricity Supply Act, 1948-Section 49 & 49(3).

Shree Sidhbali Steels Ltd. andOrs. v. State of U.P. andOrs. (20.01.2011)

Uttar Pradesh ElectricityReforms Act, 1999-Section 7, 12& 24. Electricity RegulatoryCommission Act, 1998-Section29.

AIR 2011 SC 1175, 2011 5AWC 4986 SC, 2011 ELR (SC)1122, 2011(1) SCALE 676,(2011) 3 SCC 193.

Uttar Pradesh ReorganizationAct, 2000. Companies Act,1956. General Clauses Act,1897-Section 14 & 21.Rajasthan Sales Tax Act, 1994-Section 15.

Central Sales Tax Act-Section 8(5).

Constitution of India-Article 14,19(1) & 32.

6. Sri Chandu Khamaru v. Smt.Nayan Malik and Ors.(02.09.2011)

Electricity Act, 2003-Sections42(1), 43(1), 67, 67(1) & 67(2).

AIR 2011 SC 2897, 2011 6AWC (Supp) 5441SC, [2011(4)JCR 106 (SC) ], JT 2011(10) SC195, 2011(9) SCALE 598.

7. The Executive Engineer andAnr. v. M / S. Sri SeetaramRice Mill (20.10.2011)

Electricity RegulatoryCommissions Act, 1998. IndianElectricity Act, 1910.

2011(12) SCALE 243.

Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948.

Electricity Act, 2003-Sections126, 126(1), 126(3), 126(4),126(5), 126(6), 127, 135,135(2), 135(3), 135(4), 135(1A)& 181(2).

Delhi Development Act, 1957-Section 30 & 31A. Railways Act,1989-Section 123.

Page 93: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 331

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Terrorist and DisruptiveActivities (Prevention) Act,1987-Section 3 (1). RecoveryAct-Section 2. Orissa ElectricityReforms Act, 1995.

Andhra Pradesh ElectricityReforms Act-Section 126.

Registrar of Trade Marks andthe Tribunal under the Tradeand Merchandise Marks Act,1958.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section24.

Income Tax Act-Section 34.

Grid Corporation of Orissa Ltd.(General Conditions of Supply)Regulations 1995.

Orissa Electricity RegulatoryCommission Distribution(Condition of Supply)Regulations 2004-Regulations80, 80 (10), 82 & 106.

Constitution of India-Article 14& 226.

8. The Executive Engineer andAnr. v. Sri Seetaram RiceMill (20.10.2011)

Electricity RegulatoryCommissions Act, 1998. IndianElectricity Act, 1910.

2011 ELR (SC) 1498, JT2011(12) SC 386.

Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948.

Electricity Act, 2003-Sections126, 126(1), 126(2), 126(3),126(4), 126(5), 126(6), 127,135, 135(1), 135(1A), 135(2),135(3), 135(4) & 181(2).

Delhi Development Act, 1957-Section 30 & 31A. Tamil NaduRent Act-Section 2(6A).

Railways Act, 1989-Section 123.

Terrorist and DisruptiveActivities (Prevention) Act,1987-Section 3 (1).

Recovery Act-Section 2. OrissaElectricity Reforms Act, 1995.

Andhra Pradesh ElectricityReforms Act-Section 126.

Trade and Merchandise MarksAct, 1958.

Income Tax Act-Section 34.

Indian Penal Code, 1860-Section24.

Orissa Electricity RegulatoryCommission Distribution(Condition of Supply)Regulations 2004-Regulations80, 80 (10), 82 & 106.

Page 94: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

332 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

General Conditions of SupplyRegulations 1995. Constitutionof India-Article 14 & 226.

Orissa Electricity RegulatoryCommission Distribution(Conditions of Supply) Code2004.

9. Uttar Pradesh PowerCorporation Ltd. v. N. T. P.C. Ltd. and Ors.(14.09.2011)

Companies Act, 1956. ElectricityAct, 2003. Electricity RegulatoryCommissions Act, 1998-Section3, 4 & 17. Electricity SupplyAct, 1948.

2011 ELR (SC) 1119, JT2011(13) SC 176, 2011(10)SCALE 499.

Telecom Regulatory Authority ofIndia Act, 1997.

ENERGY & POWER

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. State of Himachal Pradesh v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (27.09.2011)

Punjab Reorganisation Act,1966-Section 2, 5, 54(3), 78,78(1), 79 & 80 Government ofIndia Act, 1935-Section 38, 204& 290A Inter-State State WaterDisputes Act Inter-State 1956Supreme Court Rules, 1966-Order 23 Rule 6 Constitution ofIndia-Article 1, 3, 73, 73(1),131, 143, 162, 246(3), 246(4),262, 262(2), 294 & 363 StatesMerger (Chief CommissionersProvinces) Order 1949 State ofHimachal Pradesh (Transfer ofAssets and Liabilities) Order1972 Constitution of India (7thAmendment) Act, 1956.

2011(11) SCALE 144.

ENVIRONMENTAL LAW

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Democratic YouthFederation of India v. Unionof India (UOI) and Ors.(13.05.2011

Constitution of India-Article 21 2011(11) SCALE 398.

2. Govt. of A.P. and Ors. v.Obulapuram Minig.Company P. Ltd. and Ors.(29.07.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 21 2011(8) SCALE 127.

3. Govt. of A.P. and Ors. V.Obulapuram MinigCompany P. Ltd. and Ors.(05.08.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 21 2011(8) SCALE 535.

4. Indian Council for Enviro-Legal Action v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Ors.(18.07.2011

Water (Prevention and Controlof Pollution) Act, 1974-Section24, 25, 25(5), 26, 33, 33A, 43 &44.

JT 2011(8) SC 375, 2011(3)RCR (Civil) 779, 2011(7)SCALE 768, (2011) 8 SCC 161.

AIR (Prevention and Control ofPollution) Act 1981-Section 21& 31A.

Page 95: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 333

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Code of Civil Procedure -Section34.

Industries (Development andRegulation) Act, 1951Environment (Protection) Act-Section 3 & 5.

Comprehensive ResponseCompensation andEnvironmental Liability Act,1980.

Public Liability Insurance Act,1991.

Supreme Court Act 1981 InterestAct 1839.

Interest (Amendment) Act, 1978.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 144 & 374(3).

Indian Penal Code-Section 148,149, 304 & 326.

Supreme Court’s Rules.

Constitution of India-Article 12,14, 21, 32, 136, 141,142(1) &226.

5. K. Balakrishnan Nambiar v.State of Karnataka and Ors.(05.05.2011)

Madras Forest Act, 1882 ForestConservation Act, 1980-Section2

AIR 2011 SC 1628, JT 2011(6)SC 18, 2011(4) KCCR 2621,2011(5) SCALE 407, (2011) 5SCC 353.

6. Kalyaneshwari v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Ors.(21.01.2011)

Societies Registration Act 21 of1860.

Factories Act, 1948 EnvironmentProtection Act, 1986.

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971Constitution of India-Article 14,21, 32 & 141.

(SCSuppl) 2011(3) CHN 77,2011(3) KCCR SN 251, 2011(1)SCALE 651, (2011) 3 SCC 287,(2011) 1 SCC (L& S) 498,[2011] 1 SCR 894.

7. Lafarge Umiam Mining Pvt.Ltd. v. Union of India (UOI)and Ors. (06.07.2011)

Companies Act, 1956Environment (Protection) Act,1986-Section 3, 3(1), 3(2), 3(3).

JT 2011(7) SC 346, 2011(7)SCALE 242, (2011) 7 SCC 338.

Mines and Minerals (Regulationand Development) Act, 1957-Section 5(1) Wildlife (Protection)Act, 1972 Forest (Conservation)Act, 1980-Section 2 & 3.

Environment (Protection) Rules1986-Rule 5(3) MineralConcession Rules 1960-Rule37A Forest (Conservation)Rules, 1981-Rule 4 ForestConservation Rules 2003-Rule 6.

8. Princl. Chief Conservator ofForest and Anr. v. J. K.Johnson and Ors.(17.10.2011)

Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972-Section 9, 39, 39(1), 50, 50(1),50(2), 50(3)(A), 50(4), 51, 51(1),51(2), 53, 54, 54(1), 54(2) &58A.

JT 2011(12) SC 76, 2011(4)KLT (SN) 98, 2011(4) RCR(Criminal) 865, 2011(2) SCALE50.

Page 96: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

334 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Wild Life (Protection)Amendment Act, 2002 BombaySales Tax Act-Section 37(1)Bengal Municipal Act, 1932-Section 431 Bengal MunicipalAct, 1932-Section 432 AssamForest Regulation 1891-Section62.

Constitution of India-Article226.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 320(8) & 451.

Statement of Objects andReasons Act, 2003.

9. Research Foundn. ForScience v. Union of India(UOI) and Anr. (25.05.2011)

Gujarat Maritime Board Act1981-Section 37, 38, 39, 41 &110.

2011(6) SCALE 443.

Gujarat Maritime Board(Conditions and Procedures forGranting Permission for UtilizingShip Recycling Plots)Regulations 2006.

10. State of Madhya Pradesh andAnr. v. Medha Patkar andOrs. (02.08.2011)

Environment (Protection) Act,1986-Section 3 (2).

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 18.

2011 6 AWC (Supp) 5549 SC,JT 2011(8) SC 568, 2011(8)SCALE 170, (2011) 8 SCC 55.

Panchayats (Extension ofScheduled Areas) Act, 1996-Section 3 & 4(1).

Environment (Protection) Rules1986-Rule 5(3).

Government of Madhya PradeshBusiness Rules.

AIR (Prevention and Control ofPollution) Act 1981.

11. Sterlite Industries (I) Ltd. etc.etc. v. Union of India (UOI)and Ors. etc (11.10.2011)

Water (Prevention and Controlof Pollution) Act, 1974.

2011(11) SCALE 422.

12. Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972. 2011(5) SCALE 131.

Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980.

T.N. GodavarmanThirumulpad v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Ors.(14.03.2011) Uttar Pradesh Saw Mill Rules

1978.

13. T.N. GodavarmanThirumulpad v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Ors.(31.01.2011)

Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980. 2011(5) SCALE 126.

Page 97: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 335

EVIDENCE

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

1. Commissioner of Police,Delhi and Ors. v. JaiBhagwan (10.05.2011)

Delhi Police Act, 1978-Section21.

Delhi Police (F and A) Rules1980-Rule 16.

179(2011) DLT 578 (SC),[2011(129) FLR 1094], JT2011(6) SC 63, 2011(5) SCALE696, (2011) 6 SCC 376, (2011) 2SCC (L& S) 132.

2. Himanshu @ Chintu v. Stateof NCT of Delhi(04.01.2011)

Arms Act, 1959-Section 25 &27 Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 154 Code of CriminalProcedure -Section 161 Codeof Criminal Procedure -Section313 Indian Penal Code-Section34 Indian Penal Code-Section302.

2011(1) ACR 342 (SC), 2011 1AWC (Supp) 2.35 SC, 2011(1)Crimes 157 (SC), 2011(121) DRJ513, [2011(1) JCR 281 (SC) ], JT2011(1) SC 123, 2011(3) PLJR253, 2011(1) RCR (Criminal) 405,2011(1) SCALE 30, (2011) 2 SCC36, (2011) 1 SCC (Cri) 593,[2011]1 SCR 48

3. Aswant Singh v. GurdevSingh and Ors. (21.10.2011)

Evidence Act, 1872-Section 74Evidence Act, 1872-Section 76Evidence Act, 1872-Section 77Evidence Act, 1872-Section 78.

2011(4) RCR (Civil) 755, 2011(2)SCALE 182.

4. K. K. Velusamy v. N.Palanisamy (30.03.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 3 Indian Evidence Act,1872-Section 8 InformationTechnology Act, 2000-Section2 Code of Civil Procedure -Section 151 Code of CivilProcedure -Order 18 Rule 17Code of Civil Procedure -Order 18 Rule 17A.

2011(3) ALLMR (SC) 445, 2011 3AWC 3104 SC, 2011(3) CTC 422,JT 2011(4) SC 38, 2011(2) KCCRSN 132, 2011(2) KLJ240, 2011-3-LW 738, 2011(2) PLJR 138,2011(2) RCR (Civil) 875, 2011113 RD414, RLW 2011(3) SC2457, 2011(4) SCALE 61, (2011)11 SCC 275.

5. Narwinder Singh v. State ofPunjab (05.01.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 302Indian Penal Code-Section304B Indian Penal Code-Section 306 Indian PenalCode-Section 498A Code ofCriminal Procedure -Section221(1), 221(2), 222, 313 &464(1) Indian Evidence Act-Section 113B.

2011(1) ACR 350 (SC), AIR 2011SC 686, 2011(2) ALD (Cri) 36,2011(1) Crimes 200 (SC), II(2011) DMC 474 SC, 2011(1)JCC 334 (SC), JT 2011(1) SC 89,2011(2) KCCR SN 84, 2011(1)NCC 623, 2011(3) PLJR 272,2011(1) RCR (Criminal) 427,RLW 2011(1) SC 573, 2011(1)SCALE 114, (2011) 2 SCC 47,(2011) 1 SCC (Cri) 601, [2011] 1SCR 110.

6. Rangammal v. Kuppuswamiand Anr. (13.05.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 101.

Equivalent Citation: AIR 2011 SC2344, 2011(5) ALD 38 (SC), 20115 AWC 4692 SC, 2011(4) BomCR32, 2011(4) CTC769, [2011(4)JCR 37 (SC) ], JT 2011(6) SC 457,2011-3-LW48, 2011(II) OLR (SC)278, 2011(4) RCR (Civil) 251,2011 113 RD 744, 2011(6)SCALE 161.

7. Surendera Mishra v. State ofJharkhand (06.01.2011)

Arms Act-Section 27 IndianEvidence Act-Section 105Indian Penal Code-Section 84Indian Penal Code-Section302.

2011(1) ACR 356 (SC), AIR 2011SC 627, 2011 CriLJ 1161, 2011(1)Crimes 192 (SC), 2011(1) JCC427 (SC), [2011(1) JCR 219 (SC)], JT 2011(1) SC 83, 2011(2)KCCR SN 78, 2011(2) PLJR 29,2011(1) RCR (Criminal) 416,2011(1) SCALE 124, (2011) 11SCC 495, (2011) 3 SCC (Cri) 232,[2011] 1 SCR 133.

Page 98: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

336 National Law University, Delhi

EXCISE

Sl. No. Partiname Act/Legislation Referred Citation

1. AIR Liquide North IndiaPvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner,Central Excise, Jaipur-I(30.08.2011)

Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985. 2011(187) ECR 243 (SC), JT2011(9) SC 547, 2011(9) SCALE506.

2. Commissioner of C. Ex. v.Sunil Silk Mills (20.04.2011)

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section11AC, 11A (2) Central ExciseRules, 1944-Rule 96ZO, 96ZQ,96ZQ (1) 96ZQ (3), 96ZQ (5).

2011(267) ELT 438 (SC) .

3. Commissioner of C. Ex.,Mumbai-II v. DoreProcessors (17.03.2011)

Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985. 2011(266) ELT 417 (SC) .

4. Commissioner of C. Ex.,Mumbai-III v. Amar FabricsPvt. Ltd. (17.03.2011)

Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985. 2011(266) ELT 419 (SC) .

5. Commissioner of CentalExcise, Belapur, Mumbai v.RDC Concrete (India) P.Ltd. (09.08.2011

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section35C (1), 35C (2) Central ExciseTariff Act, 1985.

2011(187) ECR 1 (SC), JT2011(9) SC 114, 2011(8) SCALE314, [2011] 32 STT 426.

6. Commissioner of CentralExcise v. Kalvert Foods IndiaPvt. Ltd. and Ors.(09.08.2011)

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section14 Drug Rules.

2011(187) ECR 123 (SC), JT2011(9) SC 126, 2011(8) SCALE320.

7. Commissioner of CentralExcise, Chandigarh v. DoabaSteel Rolling Mills(06.07.2011)

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section3, 3A, 3A (2), 35H Hot Re-rolling Steel Mills AnnualCapacity Determination RulesHot Re-rolling 1997.

2011(186) ECR 144 (SC),2011(269) ELT 298 (SC), JT2011(10) SC 456, 2011(7)SCALE 282.

Central Excise Tariff Act, 1944.

8. Commissioner of CentralExcise, Nagpur v. GurukripaResins Pvt. Ltd.(11.07.2011)

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section2, 35L Central Excise Tariff Act,1985.

2011(270) ELT 3 (SC), JT2011(9) SC 40, 2011(7) SCALE472.

9. Commissioner, CentralExcise, Bangalore v. MeyerHealth Care Pvt. Ltd. andOrs. (07.04.2011

Trade Marks Act. 2011(185) ECR 1 (SC),2011(267) ELT 145 (SC), JT2011(6) SC 361, 2011(4) SCALE593.

Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.

Central Excise Rules, 1944-Rule9(2).

10. Commissioner of CentralExcise, Meerut-II v.Sundstrand Forms Pvt. Ltd.(30.08.2011)

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section11A, 11A(1).

2011(187) ECR 248 (SC), JT2011(10) SC 200, 2011(9)SCALE 512.

11. Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.Commissioner of CentralExcise, Noida v. KitplyIndustries Ltd. (07.09.2011)

Central Excise Tariff Rule-Rule3, 173B.

2011(187) ECR 255 (SC),2011(10) SCALE 118.

12. Commissioner of CentralExcise, Shillong v. IndiaCarbon Ltd. (19.04.2011)

Sale of Goods Act. 2011(269) ELT 6 (SC) .

Page 99: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 337

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

13. Electronics Corporation ofIndia Ltd. v. Union of India(UOI) and Ors. (17.02.2011)

Companies Act, 1956 CentralExcise Act, 1944-Section 4(1),4(4).

Central Excise Valuation(Determination of Price ofExcisable Goods) Rules, 2000-Rule 7.

(2011) 238 CTR (SC) 353,2011(184) ECR 193 (SC),2011(265) ELT 11 (SC), [2011]332 ITR 58 (SC), JT 2011(6) SC372, 2011(2) SCALE 494,(2011) 3 SCC 404, (2011) 1 SCC(L& S) 514, [2011] 2 SCR 971,2011[21] STR 593, (2011) 39VST1 (SC) .

14. Central Excise Act, 1944-Section2, 4, 11AB & 35L.

2011(274) ELT 3 (SC) .Essel Propack Ltd. v.Commissioner of CentralExcise, Mumbai-III(09.11.2011)

Central Excise Rules, 1944-Rule173Q.

15. Grasim Industries Ltd. v.Commissioner of CentralExcise, Bhopal (18.08.2011)

Central Excise and Salt Act,1944-Section 11, 11A, 11B, &12.

2011(271) ELT 164 (SC) .

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section2, 3, 11A, 11AC, 35G & 35L.

16. Grasim Industries Ltd. v.Union of India (UOI)(13.10.2011)

Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985-Section 15.

2011(188) ECR 248 (SC),2011(273) ELT 10 (SC), JT2011(12) SC 89, 2011(11)SCALE 580.

Central Excise Rules, 1944-Rule173Q & 173Q(1).

17. Central Excise Act, 1944-Section3, 3A, 11, 11A & 11A(2).

Hans Steel Rolling Mill v.Commissioner of CentralExcise (10.03.2011)

Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.

Central Excise Rules-Rule 5, 96P& 96ZP.

2011(184) ECR 173 (SC),2011(265) ELT 321 (SC), JT2011(3) SC 448, 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 675, 2011(3) SCALE 421,(2011) 3 SCC 748.

Hot-Re-rolling Steel MillsAnnual Capacity DeterminationRules, 1997.

Uttar Pradesh Excise Act, 1910-Section 28.

18. Kesar Enterprises Ltd. v.State of U.P. and Ors.(06.07.2011)

Income Tax Act, 1961-Section142(2A) Constitution of India-Article 14 & 226.

2011(4) ALLMR (SC) 897, 20114 AWC 3909 SC, JT 2011(7) SC397, 2011(7) SCALE 232.

19. Man Singh v. State of U.P.(19.07.2011)

Uttar Pradesh Excise Act, 1910-Section 60 (2).

Code of Criminal Procedure(Cr.P.C) Section 313.

2011(3) ACR 3198 (SC),2011(8) SCALE 256, 2011(2)UC 1491.

20. Medley Pharmaceuticals Ltd.v. The Commissioner ofCentral Excise and Customs,Daman (14.01.2011)

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section2, 3, 4(1), 35L Drugs andCosmetics Act, 1940-Section 3,18 & 27 Central Excise TariffAct, 1985.

Central Excise Valuation Rules,1975-Rule 4, 6, 7 & 93.

2011(186) ECR 18 (SC), JT2011(2) SC 53, 2011(2) KCCRSN 101, 2011(1) RCR (Civil)888, 2011(1) SCALE 480,(2011) 2 SCC 601, [2011] 1 SCR741.

Central Excise Valuation(Determination of Price ofExcisable Goods) Rules, 2000-Rule 6, 7, 8 & 11 Drugs andCosmetic Rules 1940-Rule65(18), 93, 95, 96 & 96(1).

Page 100: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

338 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Prevention of Food AdulterationRules Constitution of India-Article 133, 136.

Drugs Control Act.

21. Om Prakash and Anr. v.Union of India (UOI) andAnr. (30.09.2011)

Customs Act, 1962-Section 104,104(3), 104(4), 132, 133, 135,135A & 136.

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section9, 9(1), 9A, 9A(2), 13, 18, 19,20 & 21.

2011(187) ECR 363 (SC),2011(272) ELT 321 (SC),2011(4) KLT (SN) 100, 2011-2-LW (Crl) 497, 2011(11) SCALE310.

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985.

Evidence Act-Section 25 ForeignExchange Regulation Act, 1973.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 2, 2(1), 41, 41(1),41(2), 42, 46, 109, 110, 116(3),155, 173, 436, 446 & 446A.

Indian Penal Code-Section 194,195, 274, 466, 467, 476, 477,493 & 505.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1898-Section 9.

22. Ranbaxy Laboratories Ltd.v. Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (21.10.2011)

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section11B, 11B (1), 11B (2), 11BB &12A.

Central Excises and CustomsLaws (Amendment) Act, 1991.

2011(188) ECR 241 (SC),2011(273) ELT 3 (SC), JT2011(12) SC 18, 2011(2) SCALE164.

23. Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.Royal Enfield (Unit of EicherLtd.) v. Commissioner ofCentral Excise, Chennai(10.08.2011)

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section4, 4(4).

2011(187) ECR 137 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 622, 2011(8) SCALE409.

Finance Act, 2000-Section 3,112, 112(1).

24. Sangam Spinners Ltd. v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (18.03.2011)

Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.

Central Excise Rules, 1944-Rule43 to 57A, 57B, 57B (1), 57D,57(H) & 57G.

2011(184) ECR 183 (SC),2011(266) ELT 145 (SC), JT2011(4) SC 53, 2011(3) KCCRSN 255, 2011(3) SCALE 629,(2011) 11 SCC 408.

Constitution of India-Article 14.

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section57A, 57B.

25. Central Excise Act, 1944-Section5A(1).

Saraswati Sugar Mills v.Commissioner of CentralExcise, Delhi-III(02.08.2011)

Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.

Central Excise Rules, 1944-Rule57Q, 57Q(1) & 173B.

AIR 2011 SC 3286, 2011(187)ECR 10 (SC), JT 2011(8) SC547, 2011(8) SCALE 203,[2011] 32 STT 469.

26. State of Maharashtra andOrs. v. Subhash ArjundasKataria (26.08.2011)

Standards of Weights andMeasures Act, 1976-Section 2,73.

[2011(4) JCR 91 (SC) ], 2011(9)SCALE 463.

Central Excise Act-Section 4A,4A(1), 4A(2).

Page 101: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 339

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Standards of Weights andMeasures (PackagedCommodities) Rules, 1977-Rule2, 3, 6, 23(1), 29, 33, & 39.

Standards of Weights andMeasures (Enforcement) Act,1985-Section 65.

27. State of U.P. and Ors. v.Mohan Meakin BreweriesLtd. and Anr. (23.09.2011)

Uttar Pradesh Excise Act, 1910-Section 17(1), 18, 19, 28, 28A,29 & 31.

2011(187) ECR 378 (SC),2011(11) SCALE 44

Mysore Excise Act.

Punjab Excise Act 1914-Section32.

Punjab Breweries Rules 1932.

Income Tax Act, 1961-Section44AC, 206C.

Uttar Pradesh Brewery Rules,1961-Rule 31, 37, 41, 53, 636 &816.

Uttar Pradesh Bottling of ForeignLiquor Rules, 1969-Rule 6, 7,7(10) & 7(11).

Uttar Pradesh Brewery(Amendment) Rules, 1975.

Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section11A, 11A (1), 11AB, 11AC.

28. The Commissioner ofCentral Excise,Visakhapatnam v. Mehta andCo. (10.02.2011)

Central Excise Rules-Rule 9(2),52A, 173Q, 173Q(1) & 209A.

2011(184) ECR 46 (SC),2011(2) SCALE 322, (2011) 4SCC 435, [2011] 2 SCR 874.

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section35L.

29. Uniflex Cables Ltd. v.Commissioner, CentralExcise, Surat-II (24.08.2011)

Central Excise Rules, 1944-Rule173B & 173Q(1).

2011(271) ELT 161 (SC), JT2011(13) SC 233, 2011(9)SCALE 370.

30. Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. v. Ind-SwiftLaboratories Ltd.(21.02.2011)

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section11A, 11AB, 32E, 32E(1), 32F,32F(1), 32F(7), 32M.

Finance Act-Section 73 & 75.

2011(184) ECR 299 (SC),2011(265) ELT 3 (SC), JT2011(2) SC 352, 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 680, 2011(2) SCALE 589,[2011] 2 SCR 1087, (2011) 40VST1 (SC) .

CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004-Rule 3, 4 & 14.

31. Union of India (UOI) v. V.E.Commercial Vehicles Ltd.(13.07.2011)

Central Excise Act-Section11AC.

2011(270) ELT 145 (SC) .

32. Central Excises Act, 1944-Section 3.

Usha Rectifier Corpn. (I)Ltd. (Presently known asUsha (I) Ltd.) v.Commissioner of CentralExcise, New Delhi(13.01.2011)

Central Excise Rules-Rule 9 &49.

2011(184) ECR 43 (SC), JT2011(3) SC 183, 2011(1) RCR(Civil) 843, 2011(1) SCALE 416,(2011) 11 SCC 571, [2011] 1SCR 347.

Page 102: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

340 National Law University, Delhi

FAMILY LAW

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Dayanandi v. Rukma D.Suvarna and Ors.(31.10.2011)

Indian Succession Act, 1925-Section 63 Indian SuccessionAct, 1925-Section 71.

2011(4) RCR (Civil) 856,2011(2) SCALE 306.

2. Deepti Bhandari v. NitinBhandari and Anr.(14.12.2011)

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 9 Protection of Womenfrom Domestic Violence Act,2005-Section 12 Protection ofWomen from Domestic ViolenceAct, 2005-Section 21 Guardiansand Wards Act, 1890-Section 25Indian Penal Code-Section 406Indian Penal Code-Section 498ACode of Criminal Procedure -Section 482.

2011(13) SCALE 506.

3. Flg. Officer Rajiv Gakhar v.Ms. Bhavana @ Sahar Wasif(11.05.2011)

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 5 Hindu Marriage Act,1955-Section 8 Hindu MarriageAct, 1955-Section 11 HinduMarriage Act, 1955-Section 12Indian Penal Code-Section 406Indian Penal Code-Section 419Indian Penal Code-Section 420.

2011(2) ShimLC 299.

4. Flg. Officer Rajiv Gakhar v.Bhavana @ Sahar Wasif(11.05.2011)

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 5 Hindu Marriage Act,1955-Section 8 Hindu MarriageAct, 1955-Section 11 HinduMarriage Act, 1955-Section 12Indian Penal Code-Section 406Indian Penal Code-Section 419Indian Penal Code-Section 420.

AIR 2011 SC 2053, 2011(5)ALD51 (SC), 2011 4 AWC 4282SC, (SCSuppl) 2011(3) CHN 11,2011(4) CTC 783, II (2011)DMC 400 SC, (2011) 3 GLR2006, [2011(3) JCR 280 (SC) ],2011(2) KLJ 16, 2011-4-LW840, 2011(5) MhLJ 176, (2011)7 MLJ 827 (SC), 2011(4) MPLJ28, 2011(II) OLR (SC) 108,2011(3) RCR (Civil) 640,2011(5) SCALE 601, (2011) 6SCC 139.

5. Ganduri Koteshwarammaand Anr. v. Chakiri Yanadiand Anr. (12.10.2011)

Hindu Succession (Amendment)Act, 2005 Hindu Succession Act,1956-Section 6 Hindu SuccessionAct, 1956-Section 6(1) HinduSuccession Act, 1956-Section6(5) Hindu Succession Act,1956-Section 29A RegistrationAct, 1908 Code of CivilProcedure -Section 97-Order 20Rule 18.

2011(6) CTC102, JT 2011(11)SC 483, 2011-5-LW 612,2011(4) RCR (Civil) 916,2011(11) SCALE 467.

6. Gaytri Bajaj v. Jiten Bhalla(16.12.2011)

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 13B(1) Hindu MarriageAct, 1955-Section 28Guardianship and Wards Act,1890 Hindu Minority andGuardianship Act, 1956.

2011(13) SCALE 527.

Page 103: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 341

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

7. Ghisalal v. Dhapubai (Dead)by L. Rs. And Ors.(12.01.2011)

Hindu Adoptions andMaintenance Act, 1956-Section6, 7, 8, 11(1), 11(2), 12 & 16Hindu Marriage Act, 1955Hindu Minority andGuardianship Act, 1956 MadhyaPradesh Ceiling on AgriculturalHoldings Act, 1960-Section 10Code of Civil Procedure Section96-Order 41 Rule 1 Constitutionof India-Article 14, 15 & 136Hindu Succession Act, 1956.

AIR 2011 SC 644, 2011(6) ALT12 (SC), 2011 3 AWC 2521 SC,2011(4) BomCR 446, (SCSuppl)2011(2) CHN 230, 112 (2011)CLT 30, 2011(2) CTC 700,[2011(2) JCR 109 (SC) ],2011(1) JLJ 368, JT 2011(1) SC213, 2011(2) KCCR SN 89,2011(1) KLJ 59, 2011(3) MhLJ371 (SC), (2011) 3 MLJ 1100(SC), 2011 MPLJ 513 (SC),2011(1) RCR (Civil) 786, RLW2011(1) SC 623, 2011(1) SCALE325, (2011) 2 SCC 298, [2011] 1SCR 651.

8. Itesh Bhatnagar v. DeepaBhatnagar (18.04.2011)

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 13B, 13B(1) & 13B(2)Marriage Laws (Amendment)Act, 1976 Constitution of India-Article 142.

AIR 2011 SC 1637, 2011(3)ALLMR (SC) 408, 2011 4 AWC4014 SC, 2011(3) BomCR 603,(SCSuppl) 2011(3) CHN 91, II(2011) DMC 1 SC, (2011) 3GLR 2331 (SC), [2011(3) JCR 1(SC) ], JT 2011(5) SC 176,2011(2) KLJ 11, 2011-3-LW7,2011(3) PLJR 7, 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 793, RLW 2011(2) SC1471, 2011(4) SCALE 724,(2011) 5 SCC 234.

9. Marabasappa (D) by L. Rs.And Ors. v. Ningappa (D) byL. Rs. And Ors.(08.09.2011)

Hindu Succession Act, 1955-Section 14(1) Hindu SuccessionAct, 1956-Section 14.

2011(4) RCR (Civil) 370,2011(10) SCALE 214.

10. Pankaj Mahajan v. Dimple @Kajal (30.09.2011)

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 13 & 13(1).

2011 GLH (3) 513, JT 2011(13)SC 50, 2011(4) RCR (Civil) 534,2011(11) SCALE 278.

11. Parimal v. Veena @ Bharti(08.02.2011)

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 13(1) Limitation Act,1963-Section 5 Indian EvidenceAct, 1872-Section 101, 103 &114 General Clauses Act, 1897-Section 27 Code of CriminalProcedure, 1973-Section 125Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section 5, 104 & 122 Code ofCivil Procedure, 1908-Order 5Rule 20, Order 9 Rule 13, Order41 Rule 31, Order 43 Rule 2.

AIR 2011 SC 1150, 2011(2)ALLMR (SC) 462, 2011(2) ALT33 (SC), 2011 2 AWC 1910 SC,2011(4) BomCR 395, (SCSuppl)2011(2) CHN 219, 112(2011)CLT 120 (SC), 2011(2) CTC329, [2011(2) JCR 96 (SC) ],2011-5-LW 322, 2011(3) MhLj725, 2011(3) PLJR 93, 2011(2)RCR (Civil) 155, 2011(2)SCALE 302, (2011) 3 SCC 545,[2011] 2 SCR 648, 2011(1) UC413.

12. Prema v. Nanje Gowda andOrs. (10.05.2011)

Hindu Succession Act, 1956-Section 6 Hindu Succession Act,1956-Section 6A, 6B 6C & 29AHindu Succession (KarnatakaAmendment) Act 1990 HinduWomen’s Right to Property Act1937 Provincial Insolvency Act,1920-Section 28A ProvincialInsolvency (Amendment) Act,1948-Section 60 Transfer ofProperty Act-Section 76 UttarPradesh Consolidation ofHoldings Act, 1953 Code of

AIR 2011 SC 2077, JT 2011(6)SC 209, 2011(5) KarLJ84,2011(3) KCCR 1677, 2011(II)OLR (SC) 116, 2011(3) RCR(Civil) 215, 2011(6) SCALE 28,(2011) 6 SCC 462.

Page 104: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

342 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Civil Procedure -Section 97, 151,152 & 153 Code of CivilProcedure -Order 35 Rule 5(1)Constitution of India-Article 14,15, 15(1), 15(3) & 16 HinduSuccession Act, 1986-Section29A.

13. Rajinder Sharma v. ArpanaSharma (04.07.2011)

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 12 Indian Penal Code-Section 420 Code of CivilProcedure-Order 41 Rule 27.

AIR 2011 SC 3161, 2011(6)ALT21 (SC), 2011 5 AWC 5097SC, II (2011) DMC 807,[2011(4) JCR 47 (SC) ], JT2011(8) SC 594, 2011(3) RCR(Civil) 913, 2011(7) SCALE 708.

14. Ranjit Kaur v. MajorHarmohinder Singh and Ors.(02.11.2011)

Hindu Adoptions andMaintenance Act, 1956-Section18 Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 13 Code of CriminalProcedure -Section 125 Code ofCivil Procedure -Order 39 Rule 1& 2.

JT 2011(13) SC 212.

15. Revanasiddappa and Anr. v.Mallikarjun and Ors.(31.03.2011)

Hindu Marriage Act, 1956-Section 16, 16(1), 16(2) & 16(3)Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 11, 12, 16, 16(1), 16(2)& 16(3) Constitution of India-Article 37, 39 & 300A HinduLaw.

2011 3 AWC3126 SC, 112(2011) CLT 469 (SC), 2011(2)CTC 810, 2011 GLH (1) 757,[2011(2) JCR 259 (SC) ], JT2011(4) SC 90, 2011(2) KCCR1531, 2011(2) KLT 176, RLW2011(3) SC 2547, 2011(4)SCALE 189, (2011) 11 SCC 1.

16. Ruchi Majoo v. SanjeevMajoo (13.05.2011)

Guardians and Wards Act, 1890-Section 7, 8, 9, 9(1), 9(2), 9(3),10, 11 & 12 Representation ofPeople Act, 1950-Section 20Code of Criminal Procedure(Amendment) Act, 1999Divorces and Legal SeparationsAct, 1971 Prohibition of DowryAct, 1961 Code of CivilProcedure-Section 151 IndianPenal Code-Section 34, 406 &498A Code of CriminalProcedure, 1908-Section 13Code of Criminal Procedure,1908-Section 488 Constitutionof India-Article 32 & 227 Codeof Criminal Procedure(Amendment) Act, 2002.

AIR 2011 SC 1952, 2011(5)ALD 19 (SC), 2011(3) ALLMR(SC) 991, 2011 4 AWC 4295SC, 2011(4) BomCR 542,2011(3) CTC 873, II (2011)DMC 317 SC, 2011(3) JCC1617, JT 2011(6) SC 167,2011(2) KLT 788 (SC), 2011-4-LW 774, 2011(5) MhLj 316,(2011) 6 MLJ 575 (SC), 2011(3)RCR (Civil) 122, 2011(6)SCALE 290, (2011) 6 SCC 479,(2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 1033.

17. Shehammal v. Hasan KhaniRawther and Ors.(02.08.2011)

Transfer of Property Act, 1882-Section 2 & 6 Indian ContractAct, 1872-Section 23 IndianEvidence Act-Section 115Mulla’s “Principles ofMahomedan Law”-Section 54.

AIR 2011 SC 3609, 2011 5AWC 4353 SC, 4(2011) CCR790, JT 2011(8) SC 533,2011(3) KLT 504 (SC), 2011-4-LW 341, (2011) 7 MLJ 789(SC), 2011(3) RCR (Civil) 894,2011(8) SCALE 186.

18. Veena v. State Govt. ofNCT, Delhi and Anr.(28.01.2011)

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 13(1) & 13B IndianPenal Code-Section 498A Codeof Criminal Procedure -Section340

AIR 2011 SC 3469, II (2011)DMC 243SC

Page 105: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 343

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

19. Vinny Parmvir Parmar v.Parmvir Parmar(20.07.2011)

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 13B, 25 & 25(3) Code ofCriminal Procedure 1898-Section488 Constitution of India-Article136 Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 125.

2011(6) ALD 91 (SC), 2011 5AWC 5070 SC, II (2011) DMC754, JT 2011(7) SC 553,2011(3) KLT (SN) 89, 2011-4-LW 368, 2011(3) RCR (Civil)900, 2011(7) SCALE 741.

FEMA/FERA

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Radheshyam Kejriwal v.State of West Bengal andAnr. (18.02.2011)

Foreign Exchange RegulationAct, 1973-Section 8, 8(2), 9,9(1), 13, 18A, 18(1), 19(1), 35,40, 44(2), 50,51, 52, 56, 56(1),57, 58, 61, 61(1), 64(2), 68,68(1), 154, 195(1) & 271(1)Income Tax Act-Section 147,148 & 276C Customs ActIndian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 40 to 43 Companies ActForeign Exchange RegulationAct, 1947-Section 23D SeaCustoms Act, 1878-Section 167Imports and Exports (Control)Act, 1947-Section 5 Code ofCriminal Procedure 1898-Section403 & 476 Code of CriminalProcedure, 1973-Section 300,401 & 482 Indian Penal Code-Section 120B Constitution ofIndia-Article 14, 20(2) & 21.

2011(2) ACR 1199 (SC), [2011]102 CLA 283 (SC), 2011 CriLJ1747, 2011(266) ELT 294 (SC),[2011] 130 ITD 509 (SC),[2011] 333 ITR 58 (SC), 2011(2)JCC 943, JT 2011(2) SC 443,2011(2) KCCR SN 171, 2011(2)RCR (Criminal) 756, 2011(2)SCALE 540, (2011) 3 SCC 581,(2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 721, [2011]108 SCL 406 (SC), (2011) 40VST 11 (SC) .

2. Thirumalai ChemicalsLimited v. Union of India(UOI) and Ors. (11.04.2011)

Foreign Exchange ManagementAct, 1999-Section 13, 19, 19(1),19(2), 45(5), 49, 49(1), 49(3),49(4), 49(5), 49(6) & 51 ForeignExchange Regulation Act, 1973-Section 8(3), 8(4), 50, 51, 52,52(1), 52(2), 52(3) & 52(4)Limitation Act-Section 5 GeneralClauses Act, 1897-Section 6Constitution of India-Article 226& 227.

AIR 2011 SC 1725, 2011 5AWC 4585 SC, [2011] 102 CLA269 (SC), [2011] 163 CompCas380 (SC), (2011) 3 CompLJ 46(SC), 2011(268) ELT 296 (SC),JT 2011(4) SC 453, 2011(4)KCCR SN 395, 2011(3) RCR(Civil) 20, 2011(4) SCALE 642,(2011) 6 SCC 739, [2011] 108SCL 78 (SC) .

FOOD ADULTERATION

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Academy of NutritionImprovement and Ors. v.Union of India (UOI)(04.07.2011)

Prevention of Food AdulterationAct 1954-Section 2, 3, 7, 23, 23(1)& 23(1A) Prevention of FoodAdulteration Act 1954-Section 59Andhra Pradesh Panchayat Samitisand Zilla Parishads Act, 1959-Section 18 & 69 Prevention ofFood Adulteration Rules 1955-Rule 42, 43 (22), 44H & 44IPrevention of Food Adulteration(Tenth Amendment) Rules, 1997,(Fifth Amendment) Rules, 2000,(Eighth Amendment) Rules, 2005Constitution of India-Article 14,19(1), 21 & 142.

2011 6 AWC (Supp) 6010 SC,JT 2011(8) SC 16, 2011(3)KLT (SN) 45, 2011-2-LW(Crl) 477, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 784, 2011(7)SCALE 307, (2011) 8 SCC274.

Page 106: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

344 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

2. Swadesi Jagran Manch andOrs. v. State of Orissa andAnr. (04.07.2011)

Prevention of Food AdulterationRules 1955-Rule 44I.

2011-2-LW (Crl) 496, 2011(7)SCALE 326, (2011) 8SCC274(1).

3. He State of Rajasthan andOrs. v. The High Court ofJudicature for Rajasthan,Jodhpur through its RegistrarGeneral (11.10.2011)

Prevention of Food AdulterationAct 1954-Section 9 & 9(1)Prevention of Food AdulterationRules 1955-Rule 8 Prevention ofFood Adulteration (Amendment)Rules 1980 Indian Penal Code,1860-Section 21 Prevention ofFood Adulteration (FourthAmendment) Rules 1976-Rule 3.

2011(11) SCALE 576.

HUMAN RIGHTS

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Bachpan Bachao Andolan v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (18.04.2011)

Juvenile Justice (Care andProtection of Children) Act,2000-Section 31 Juvenile Justice(Care and Protection ofChildren) Act, 2000-Section31(1) & 33(3) Employment ofChildren’s Act, 1938 ChildLabour (Prohibition andRegulation) Act, 1986 MinimumWages Act, 1976 Prevention ofImmoral Traffic Act EqualRemuneration Act, 1976 EqualRemuneration Rules BondedLabour System (Abolition) Act,1976 Bonded Labour System(Abolition) Rules Factories Act,1948 Motor Transport WorkersAct, 1961 Goa Children’s Act,2003 Plantation Labour Act,1951 Mines Act, 1952 MerchantShipping Act, 1958 ApprenticesAct, 1961 Bidi and CigarWorkers (Conditions ofEmployment) Act, 1966 WestBengal Shops and EstablishmentAct, 1963 Young PersonsHarmful Publications Act, 1956Information Technology Act,2000-Section 67 Indian PenalCode-Section 41, 293, 319, 320,321, 322, 323, 324, 325, 326,327, 328, 329, 339, 340, 341,342, 343, 344, 345, 346, 350,351, 361, 362, 363, 365, 366,366A, 366B, 367, 368, 370, 371,372, 373, 375, 416, 420, 465,466, 468, 471, 503 & 506Transplantation of HumanOrgan Act, 1994 Suppression ofImmoral Trafficking Act ChildWelfare Act Juvenile Justice(Care and Protection) Act, 2002-Section 18 Right of Children toFree and Compulsory EducationAct 2009-Section 3 Immoral

AIR 2011 SC 3361, 2011 4AWC 4188 SC, 2011(59) BLJR905, JT 2011(5) SC 68, 2011(4)SCALE 769, (2011) 5 SCC 1.

Page 107: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 345

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Traffic Prevention Act, 1956-Section 2K, 7, 8, 8A, 8B, 15,17(2) & 17(3) Constitution ofIndia-Article 14, 15, 16, 17, 21,21A, 23, 24, 32 & 39 ChildrenPledging of Labour Act 1933.

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Commissioner, CentralExcise, Bangalore v. MeyerHealth Care Pvt. Ltd. andOrs. (07.04.2011)

Trade Marks Act. 2011(185) ECR 1 (SC),2011(267) ELT 145 (SC), JT2011(6) SC 361, 2011(4) SCALE593.

2. Rasiklal ManickchandDhariwal and Anr. v. M.S.S.Food Products (25.11.2011)

Madhya Pradesh Civil CourtsAct, 1958 Evidence Act TradeMarks Act, 1999-Section 2(1)Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section 10, 24, 151, 152 Code ofCivil Procedure, 1908-Order 6Rule 17-Order7 Rule 11-Order 9Rule 6, 6(1), 7 & 13-Order 11Rule 12, 14,-Order 16 Rule 1,6,-Order 18 Rule 1, 2, 2(2), 2(3),2(3A), 4, 4(1), 4(2), 5, 13 & 15 -Order 20 Rule 1-Order 26 Rules16, 16A, 17 & 18-Order 30Rule.

2011(13) SCALE 183.

3. T.V. Venugopal v. UshodayaEnterprises Ltd. and Anr.(03.03.2011)

Copyright Act, 1957-Section 45& 45(1) Trade and MerchandiseMarks Act, 1958-Section 21&46. Trade Marks Act, 1999-Section 100 & 159(4) FederalAnti Dilution Act, 1996 TradeMark Rules 1959-Rule 24(3)Limitation Act, 1963-Section 22Code of Civil Procedure -Order2 Rule 2(3).

JT 2011(3) SC 225, MIPR2011(1) 219, (2011) 2 MLJ 849(SC), 2011(45) PTC 433 (SC),2011(3) SCALE 182, (2011) 4SCC 85.

LAND ACQUISITION

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. A.P. Industrial InfrastructureCorporation Ltd. v.Chinthamaneni NarasimhaRao and Ors. (15.09.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4, 4(1), 5A, 6 & 17.Constitution of India-Article226.

AIR 2011 SC 3558, 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 831, 2011(10)SCALE 460.

2. Banda DevelopmentAuthority, Banda v. Moti LalAgarwal and Ors. (26.04.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4, 4(1), 6, 6(1), 6(2), 7,9, 9(1), 11, 11A, 14, 16, 17,17(1), 17(2), 17(3A), 17(4) &47.

JT 2011(5) SC 106, 2011(5)SCALE 173, (2011) 5 SCC 394.

Uttar Pradesh ZamindariAbolition and Land Reforms ActLimitation Act Land Acquisition(Amendment) Act 1984-Section11.

A Code of Civil Procedure -Section 80, Order 21 Rule 35,36, 95 & 96.

Page 108: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

346 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Constitution of India-Article226.

3. Bilkis and Ors. v. State ofMaharashtra and Ors. (05.04.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4(1) & 6.

2011(4) BomCR 107, 2011(5)SCALE 257.

4. Binabai Bhate v. State ofMadhya Pradesh and Ors.(04.07.2011)

Act: Madhya Pradesh NagarTatha Gram Nivesh Adhiniyam,1973-Section 14, 17, 17A,17A(2), 18, 19, 19(2), 19(3), 23& 23A.

ILR [2011] MP 2091, JT2011(7) SC 510, 2011(6) SCALE726.

5. Brij Mohan and Ors. v.Haryana UrbanDevelopment Authority andAnr. (03.01. 2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4 Land Acquisition Act,1894-Section 23(1A) LandAcquisition Act, 1894-Section23(2) Land Acquisition Act,1894-Section 28.

AIR 2011 SC 343, 2011 1, JT2011(1) SC 100, 2011(1) SCALE1, (2011) 2 SCC 29, [2011] 1SCR 12.

6. Brij Pal Bhargava and Ors.v. State of U.P. and Ors.(23.02. 2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4, 5A, 5A (2) & 6.

2011(3) ADJ 1, 2011 3 2011(2)SCALE 692, (2011) 5 SCC 413.

7. Chakas v. State of Punjaband Ors. (24.08.2011)

Land Acquisition Act-Section 4,6, 18 & 54.

JT 2011(10) SC 447, 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 211, 2011(9)SCALE 362.

8. City Improvement Trust BoardAct, 1976-Section 15(1).

2011(13) SCALE 48.Chandrashekar (D) by L. Rs.and Ors. v. Land AcquisitionOfficer and Anr.(22.11.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 18 (3).

9. Chindha Fakira Patil (D)through L. Rs. v. The SpecialLand Acquisition Officer,Jalgaon (01.11.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4, 4(1), 6, 18 & 54.Constitution of India-Article136.

2011(6) BomCR 735, 2011(2)SCALE 321.

10. Dedicated Freight CorridorCorporation of India v.Subodh Singh and Ors.(30.03. 2011)

Indian Railways Act, 1989-Section 2, 2(37A), 20A, 20A(1),20A(2), 20A(4), 20B, 20C, 20D,20D(1), 20D(2), 20E, 20E(1),20E(2), 20F, 20F(1), 20F(2),20F(3), 20F(4), 20H, 20I & 20JLand Acquisition Act, 1894Railways (Amendment) Act,2008.

2011 3 AWC3112SC, 2011(3)KCCR SN 280, 2011(4) SCALE71, (2011) 11 SCC 100.

11. Delhi Administrationthrough its Secretary v.Umrao Singh (11.10.2011)

Delhi Land Acquisition Act,1957-Section 4, 22, 22(3), 56 &56(2). Delhi DevelopmentAuthority (Disposal ofDeveloped Nazul Land) Rules,1981-Rule 4, 4(1), 4(2), 6, 6(1)& 13.

2011(11) SCALE 560.

12. Delhi AIR tech Services Pvt.Ltd. and Anr. v. State of U.P.and Anr. (18.08.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 2, 3, 4, 4(1), 5, 5A, 6,6(1), 7, 8, 9, 9(1), 10, 11, 11A,12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 17(1),17(2), 17(3), 17(3A), 17(3B),17(4), 18, 23(1A), 23(2), 24, 28,31(1), 31, 31(2), 34, 48, 48(1) &48B.

JT 2011(9) SC 440, 2011(9)SCALE 201.

Page 109: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 347

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Companies Act, 1956 DelhiMunicipal Corporation Act,1957 Rajasthan UrbanImprovement Act.

1987 Metro Rail ConstructionWorks Act, 1978.

Land Acquisition (Amendment)Act 1984.

Bangalore DevelopmentAuthority Act-Section 27 & 36General Clauses Act-Section 21Constitution of India-Article 13,13(1), 13(3), 14, 19, 19(1), 21,31, 31A, 31(2), 141, 300A,366(10), 372, 372(1) & 395.

13. Delhi DevelopmentAuthority v. S. S. Aggarwaland Ors. (02.08. 2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4, 4(1), 6, 9, 17(1), 18,25(2), 53 & 54.

AIR 2011 SC 3265, 181(2011)DLT 557 (SC), 2011(8) SCALE178.

Constitution of India-Article 14.

Contract Act-Section 23 & 28.Delhi Lands (Restrictions onTransfer) Act, 1972.

Code of Civil Procedure -Section151, Order 6 Rule 17, Order 6Rule 18.

14. Dev Sharan and Ors. v. Stateof U.P. and Ors.(07.03.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 3, 4, 4(1), 5A, 6, 17,17(1), 17(1)(A), 17(2) & 17(4)Land Acquisition (Amendment)Act, 1923-Section 3.

JT 2011(3) SC 102, 2011(4)MhLJ 545 (SC), 2011(3) SCALE369, (2011) 4 SCC 769.

Constitution of India-Article 13,19(1), 226 & 300A.

15. Devender Kumar Tyagi andOrs. v. State of U.P. andOrs. (23.08.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4, 4(1), 5A, 5A(1),5A(2), 6, 6(1), 6(2), 9(1), 11, 17,17(1), 17(2), 17(4) & 27.

JT 2011(9) SC 390, 2011(3)KLT (SN) 154, (2011) 8 MLJ385 (SC), 2011(9) SCALE 310.

Land Acquisition (Amendment)Act 1984.

National Capital RegionPlanning Board Act, 1985-Section 2, 10, 10(2), 19, 19(1),19(2), 20, 27& 29.

Uttar Pradesh Urban Planningand Development Act, 1973Constitution of India-Article 32Land Acquisition (Amendmentand Validation) Ordinances1967.

16. Devendra Singh and Ors. v.State of U.P. and Ors.(03.08.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4, 4(1), 5A, 5A(1),5A(2), 6, 6(1), 9, 17, 17(1),17(2) & 17(4).

JT 2011(8) SC 31, 2011(3),2011(4) RCR (Civil) 840, 2011114 RD 418, 2011(8) SCALE244.

Page 110: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

348 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

17. Executive Engineer,Karnataka Housing Board v.Land Acquisition Officer,Gadag and Ors.(04.01.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4(1).

AIR 2011 SC 781, 2011 2 JT2011(1) SC 539, 2011(2) KCCR1165, 2011(1) SCALE 203,(2011) 2 SCC 246, [2011] 1 SCR600.

18. Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4, 6, 11 & 17.

Fida Hussain and Ors. v.Moradabad DevelopmentAuthority and Anr.(19.07.2011)

Land Acquisition (Amendment)Act 1898.

AIR 2011 SC 3001, 2011 5 JT2011(8) SC 333, 2011(7) SCALE757.

Constitution of India-Article133, 136 & 141.

19. Goa Housing Board v.Rameshchandra GovindPawaskar and Anr.(11.10.2011)

Goa Daman and DiuAgricultural Tenancy Act, 1964-Section 18A, 18B, 18C, 18D,18E, 18H, 18J & 18K.

JT 2011(12) SC 161, 2011(11)SCALE 646.

Goa Land Use (Regulation) Act,1991-Section 2 & 3.

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 23, 23 (1A), 23 (2), 24& 28. Goa Daman and DiuTown and Country PlanningAct, 1974-Section 13, 15, 17, 18,29, 31, 35(1), 37, 41, 42, 30 &32.

20. Greater Noida Indusl. Devt.Auth. v. Devendra Kumarand Ors. (06.07. 2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 3, 4, 4(1), 5A, 6, 6(1),17, 17(1) & 17(4).

2011(6) ADJ 480, 2011(7)SCALE 439.

Uttar Pradesh Industrial AreaDevelopment Act, 1976-Section2, 3, 6, 6(2), 7 & 9.

New Okhla IndustrialDevelopment Area (Preparationand Finalisation of Plan)Regulations 1991-RegulationsRegulations 4 & 5.

Uttar Pradesh General ClausesAct 1904-Section 21.

Right to Information Act, 2005Constitution of India-Article226.

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4, 11, 18, 23(1), 26, 28,31, 31(2), 34, 53 & 54.

21. Ivo Agnelo SantimanoFernandes and Ors. v.Government of Goa andAnr. (23.02.2011)

Code of Civil Procedure-Order21 Rules 1.

2011(5) SCALE 252, (2011) 11SCC 506, [2011] 2 SCR 1142.

22. J and K Housing Board andAnr. v. Kunwar SanjayKrishan Kaul and Ors.(04.11.2011)

Jammu and Kashmir LandAcquisition Act 1990-Section 2,3, 4, 4(1), 4(2), 5, 5(2), 5A,5A(1), 6, 6(2), 7, 8, 9, 9(2), 9A,11, 12, 12(2), 17, 17A, 18, 32,43 & 44.

JT 2011(13) SC 1, 2011(12)SCALE 434.

Jammu and Kashmir HousingBoard Act, 1976-Section 14, 15,17, 19 & 26(1) (2).

Page 111: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 349

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4, 4(1), 5 & 5A.

Urban Land (Ceiling andRegulation) Act, 1976.

Land Acquisition Rules-Rule 3Land Acquisition Rules-Rules63.

23. Jaipur DevelopmentAuthority and Ors. v. VijayKumar Data and Anr.(12.07.2011)

Rajasthan Land Acquisition Act,1953-Section 4, 4(1), 5A, 6, 6(1),9(1), 9(3), 11, 17, 17(1), 16, 18,26(2), 31(3), 31(4) & 48.Rajasthan Lokayukta and Up-Lokayuktas Act, 1973-Section 1,2(1) & 10.

JT 2011(8) SC 211, 2011(3)KLT (SN) 77, RLW 2011(3) SC2384, 2011(7) SCALE 633.

Urban Land Ceiling Act JaipurDevelopment Authority Act,1982-Section 83.

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section 47& 144, Order 21 Rule97 & 99.

Constitution of India-Article 1477(1), 77(2), 77(3), 136, 166,166(1), 166(2), 166(3) & 226.Rajasthan Improvement Trust(Disposal of Urban Land) Rules,1974.

Rajasthan Land AcquisitionRules 1956-Rule 31 & 36.

Punjab Town Improvement Act,1922-Section 42.

24. Jalandhar ImprovementTrust vs.Vinod Kumar andOrs. (15.07.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894Punjab Public Premises Land(Eviction and Rent Recovery)Act, 1973-Section 5 & 7.

2011(3) RCR (Civil) 832,2011(7) SCALE 613.

Displaced Persons(Compensation andRehabilitation) Act 1954Evacuee Property Act, 1950.

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4, 6, 11 & 11A.

25. Jeet Singh and Anr. v. Unionof India (UOI) and Ors.(15.09.2011)

Land Acquisition (Amendment)Act 1984.

2011 5 AWC 4928 SC, 2011(10)SCALE 516.

Contempt of Courts ActConstitution of India-Article226.

26. Land Acquisition Act-Section 4,6 & 48(1).

2011(6) SCALE 458.Jharkhand State HousingBoard and Anr. v.Akhileshwar Singh and Ors.(20.04.2011)

Bihar State Housing Board Act.

27. K.T. Plantation Pvt. Ltd. andAnr. v. State of Karnataka(09.08.2011)

Roerich and Devika RaniRoerich Estate (Acquisition andTransfer) Act, 1996.

AIR 2011 SC 3430, JT 2011(8)SC 65, (2011) 7 MLJ 1185 (SC),2011(8) SCALE 583, (2011) 9SCC 1.

Page 112: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

350 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Karnataka Land Reforms Act,1961-Section 38, 63, 64, 66, 67,68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75,76, 67(1), 79A, 79B, 79B (1),79B (2), 79B (3), 79B (4), 80, 83,104, 107, 107(1), 107(2), 110,122A & 14.

Land Reforms (Amendment)Act, 1973-Section 80, 83 & 107.

Delhi Laws Act, 1912.

Ajmer-Merwara (Extension ofLaws) Act, 1947.

Part C States (Laws) Act, 1950General Clauses Act, 1897-Section 23, 109, 110, 139 &140.

Essential Commodities Act,1955-Section 3 (6).

Mines and Minerals (Regulationand Development) Act, 1957-Section 28 (3).

Land Acquisition Act, 1894Constitution of India (24thAmendment) Act, 1971Constitution of India (17thAmendment) Act, 1964.

Bihar Land Reforms Act, 1950Land Acquisition (MadrasAmendment) Act, 1961.

Bombay Town Planning Act,1958 Banking Companies(Acquisition and Transfer ofUndertakings) Act, 1969.

Punjab Security of Land TenuresAct, 1953.

West Bengal Great Eastern Hotel(Acquisition of Undertaking)Act, 1980.

Constitution of India(Amendment) Act, 1978Constitution of India (7thAmendment) Act, 1956Constitution of India(Amendment) Act, 1951-Article31A.

Travancore-Cochin Cochin LandTax Act Delhi Special PoliceEstablishment Act, 1946-Section6A.

Central Educational Institutions(Reservation in Admission) Act,2006.

Constitution of India(Amendment) Act, 1982-Section69A.

Page 113: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 351

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Constitution of India-Article 12,14, 15, 19, 19(5), 20, 21 &31(1).

Constitution of India-Article31A Constitution of India-Article 31A (1) Constitution ofIndia-Article 30 (1A)Constitution of India-Article 31BConstitution of India-Article31C Constitution of India-Article 32 Constitution of India-Article 200 Constitution ofIndia-Article 226 Constitution ofIndia-Article 245 Constitution ofIndia-Article 246 Constitution ofIndia-Article 248 Constitution ofIndia-Article 254(1) Constitutionof India-Article 254(2)Constitution of India-Article300A Bombay Land RevenueCode Roerich and Devika RaniRoerich Estate (Acquisition andTransfer) Ordinance 1992.

28. Kailash N. Dwivedi and Ors.v. State of U.P. and Ors.(29.11.2011)

Cawnpore Urban AreaDevelopment Act 1945-Section53 & 60.

2011(13) SCALE 518.

Uttar Pradesh NagarMahapalika Adhiniyam 1959-Section 357, 363, 365, 574 &577.

Uttar Pradesh Urban Planningand Development Act, 1973-Section 17.

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4(1) & 6(1).

Uttar Pradesh MunicipalitiesAct, 1916.

Uttar Pradesh TownImprovement Act 1919.

29. Kamal Trading PrivateLimited (now known asManav Investment andTrading Company Ltd.) v.State of West Bengal andOrs. (13.12.2011)

West Bengal PremisesRequisition and Control(Temporary Provision) Act, 1947Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4, 4(1), 5A, 5A(1),5A(2), 6, 6(1), 6(3) & 17(4)Constitution of India-Article 14,19 & 300A.

2011(13) SCALE 511.

30. Kerala State Housing Boardand Ors. v. Kerala StateHousing Board, NellikodeHousing Colony AllotteesAssn. and Ors. (14.09.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 18 Land Acquisition Act,1894-Section 34.

2011(10) SCALE 437.

31. Keshavadas ShridharaoSavakar and Ors. v. AssistantCommnr. And LandAcquisition Officer and Anr.(28.01.2011)

Land Acquisition Act-Section4(1) Land Acquisition Act-Section 54 Code of CivilProcedure-Order 41 Rule 27Constitution of India-Article142.

2011 2 AWC 1973 SC, 2011114 RD6, 2011(2) SCALE 4,(2011) 11 SCC 476.

Page 114: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

352 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

32. Kolkata MetropolitanDevelopment Authority v.Gobinda Chandra Makaland Anr. (02.09.2011)

West Bengal Land (Requisitionand Acquisition) Act, 1948-Section 3 (1), 4(1), 7 & 8B LandAcquisition Act, 1894 – SectioN4, 4(1), 6, 9(3A), 9(3B), 11A &23 (1).

JT 2011(10) SC 573, 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 758, 2011(10)SCALE 41.

33. Lalrinvenga (Dead) throughL. Rs. and Anr. v. State ofMizoram and Ors.(13.09.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4(1), 6 & 6(1) MizoDistrict (Land Revenue) Act,1956-Section 2 Mizo DistrictAgricultural Land Rules 1971-Rule 6 Constitution of India-Article 226.

AIR 2011 SC 3389, 2011 6AWC (Supp) 5452 SC, 2011(4)KLT (SN) 40, 2011(10) SCALE431.

34. Land Acquisition Officer-cum-RDO, ChevellaDivision Ranga ReddyDistrict v. A. RamachandraReddy and Ors.(12.01.2011-SC)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4(1), 5A, 6, 11, 11A, 17,17(1), 17(3A) & 17(5).

AIR 2011 SC 662, 2011(4) ALD30 (SC), 2011(2) ALLMR (SC)470, 2011 2 AWC 2171 SC, JT2011(1) SC 132, 2011(2) KCCRSN 94, (2011) 4 MLJ 205 (SC),2011(2) RCR (Civil) 557, 2011112 RD 520, 2011(1) SCALE298, (2011) 2 SCC 447, [2011] 1SCR 324.

MEDICINE

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Medical Council of India v.J. Saai Prasanna and Ors.etc. etc. (09.05.2011)

Indian Medical Council Act,1956-Section 10A, 13(3),13(4A), 15 Indian, 25(1), 25(4).

2011(6) SCALE 400, (2011) 11SCC 748.a

Medical Practitioners andDentists Act Screening TestsRegulations 2002-RegulationRegulation 4.

Foreign Medical InstitutionRegulations 2001 Screening Test(Amendment) Regulations 2010.

2. Union of India (UOI) v.Glaxo India Ltd. and Anr.(30.03.2011)

Essential Commodities Act, 1955General Clauses Act-Section 6Price Fixation Order 1986Orissa Sales Tax Act Drugs(Price Control) Order 1970,1979 & 1987 Sugar (MovementControl) Order 1959 Drugs(Prices Control) Order 1989.

JT 2011(4) SC 161, 2011(4)SCALE 157, (2011) 6 SCC 668.

LABOUR & INDUSTRIAL LAW

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

1. Bhilwara Dugdh UtpadakSahakari S. Ltd. v. VinodKumar Sharma and Ors.(01.09. 2011)

Contract Labour (Regulationand Abolition) Act, 1970-Section10.

AIR 2011 SC 3546, JT 2011(10)SC 434, 2011(9) SCALE 578.

2. Bihar State Electricity Boardand Anr. v. Ram Deo PrasadSingh and Ors. (08.09.2011)

Bihar Reorganisation Act, 2000-Section 2A, 2, 33C, 62, 62(1),62(3), 89 & 89(1).

AIR 2011 SC 3423, 2011(6)CTC457, [2011(4) JCR 112(SC)], 2011(10) SCALE 177.

Electricity Supply Act, 1948Warehousing Corporations Act,1962.

Page 115: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 353

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Road Transport Act, 1950Industrial Disputes Act, 1947Industrial Establishment(Standing Orders) Act, 1946.

Code of Civil Procedure-Order 9Rule 4.

3. Centre for Environment andFood Security v. Union ofIndia (UOI) & Ors.(12.05.2011)

Mahatma Gandhi NationalRural Employment GuaranteeAct, 2005-Section 17(2), 24, 25,27 & 27(2).

JT 2011(6) SC 56, 2011(6)SCALE 212, (2011) 5 SCC 668,(2011) 2 SCC (L& S) 56.

Delhi Special PoliceEstablishment Act, 1946-Section6.

Workmen’s Compensation Act,1923 Contempt of Courts Act,1971-Section 2.

4. Delhi Jal Board v. NationalCampaign for Dignity andRights of Sewerage andAllied Workers and Ors. (12.07.2011)

Constitution of India (Forty-fourth Amendment) Act, 1978.

181 (2011) DLT 77 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 232, 2011(7) SCALE489, (2011) 8 SCC 568.

Constitution of India (Forty-second Amendment) Act, 1976C.P.W.D./PWD (DA) /Delhi JalBoard Contractors LabourRegulations Constitution ofIndia-Article 3, 14, 19, 20, 21,32 38, 39, 39A, 42, 141, 142,144 & 226.

5. Democratic YouthFederation of India v. Unionof India (UOI) and Ors.(30.09.2011)

Insecticides Act, 1968Insecticides Rules 1971-Rule 35.

2011(11) SCALE 400.

6. Devinder Singh v. MunicipalCouncil (11.04.2011)

Industrial Disputes Act, 1947-Section 2, 17B, 25, 25F & 25G.

AIR Force Act, 1950 Army Act,1950 Navy Act, 1957 FactoriesAct, 1948 Andhra Pradesh(Tilengana Area) Shops andEstablishments Act, 1951Constitution of India-Article 14,16, 226 & 227.

AIR 2011 SC 2532, JT 2011(5)SC 333, 2011(4) SCALE 631,(2011) 6 SCC 584, (2011) 2 SCC(L&S) 153.

7. Dewan Chand Builders andContractors v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Ors. (18.11.2011)

The Building and OtherConstruction Workers(Regulation of Employment andConditions of Service) Act,1996-Section 1(4), 2, 7, 10, 12,18(1), 24, 24(1) & 62.

2011(13) SCALE 12.

The Building and OtherConstruction Workers WelfareCess Act, 1996-Section 2, 3,3(1), 4, 5, 8, 9, 11 & 14.

Workmen’s Compensation Act,1923 Orissa Mining AreasDevelopment Fund Act, 1952.

Punjab Agricultural ProduceMarkets Act, 1961.

Page 116: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

354 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Building and Other ConstructionWorkers (Regulation ofEmployment and Conditions ofService) Central Rules 1998.

The Building and OtherConstruction Workers WelfareCess Rules 1998-Rule 3, Rules 4,Rules 5, Rules 7, Rules 8, Rules9, Rules 10, Rules 11, Rules 12,13 & 14.

Delhi Building and OtherConstruction Workers (RE& CS)Rules 2002 Constitution ofIndia-Article 21 & 265.

Building and Other ConstructionWorkers (Regulation ofEmployment and Conditions ofService) Ordinance 1995.

8. Gyana Pattnaik, GeneralSecretary, Tata RefractoriesSramik Sangha, DistrictJharsuguda, Orissa v. Stateimplemtn. Offr-cum-lab.Commr.Orissa and Or.(18.07.2011)

Trade Unions Act 1926 ModelElection Rules Trade UnionsRules.

2011(130) FLR 902.

9. Employee State Insurance ActFactories Act, 1948.

L.N. Gadodia and Sons andAnr. v. Regional ProvidentFund Commissioner(26.09.2011)

Employees Provident Funds andMiscellaneous Provisions Act,1952-Section 2, 2A, 6, 7A & 7D.

[2011(131) FLR 925], 2011 LLR1124, 2011(11) SCALE 22.

Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.

Central Sales Tax Act, 1956.

Income Tax Act, 1961.

Delhi Shops and EstablishmentsAct 1954-Section 2(5) & 2(9).

Societies Registration Act, 1860Mines Act, 1952 Evidence Act-Section 106.

Constitution of India-Article 43.

Madhya Pradesh IndustrialRelations Act, 1960-Section 31.

10. Man Singh v. Maruti SuzukiIndia Ltd. and Anr.(26.08.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 136& 227.

JT 2011(9) SC 558, 2011 LLR1009, 2011(9) SCALE 390.

11. Industrial Disputes Act, 1947-Section 9A.

Marathwada Gramin BankKaramchari Sanghatana andAnr. v. Management ofMarathwada Gramin Bankand Ors. (09.09.2011)

Employees Provident Fund andMiscellaneous Provisions Act,1952-Section 12 & 17(3).

AIR 2011 SC 3567, 2011 LLR1130, 2011(10) SCALE 184.

Marathwada Gramin Bank(Staff) Service Regulations 1980-Regulation 56.

Constitution of India-Article136.

Page 117: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 355

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

12. Ranbir Singh v. TheExecutive Engineer(03.01.2011)

Industrial Disputes Act, 1947-Section 25.

(2011) IILLJ 313 SC, 2011 LLR612, 2011(1) SCALE 502,[2011] 1 SCR 587.

13. Siemens Ltd. and Anr. v.Siemens Employees Unionand Anr. (12.10.2011)

Maharashtra Recognition ofTrade Unions and Prevention ofUnfair Labour Practices Act,1971-Section 5, 7, 26, 27, 28 &30(2).

JT 2011(12) SC 151, 2011(11)SCALE 502.

Industrial Disputes Act, 1947-Section 2 & 9A.

Constitution of India-Article 14& 136.

14. Sunil Kr. Ghosh and Ors. v.K. Ram Chandran and Ors.(18.11.2011)

Companies Act, 1956-Section293 Industrial Disputes Act,1947-Section 10 (2), 12(4) &12(5).

2011(13) SCALE 23.

15. Union of India (UOI) andOrs. v. Vartak Labour Union(04.03. 2011)

Constitution of India-Article 14,15, 16 & 21.

Border Road Regulations.

JT 2011(3) SC 110, 2011 LLR337, 2011(3) SCALE 246,(2011) 4 SCC 200.

LIMITATION

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Disha Constructions andOrs. v. State of Goa andAnr. (09.12.2011)

Limitation Act, 1908-Section15(2) Limitation Act, 1963-Section 2, 12, 13, 14, 15 &15(2) Code of Civil Procedure-Section 80.

2011(13) SCALE 492.

2. Khatri Hotels PrivateLimited and Anr. v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Anr.(09.09.2011)

Delhi Municipal CorporationAct, 1957-Section 477, 478 &507 Delhi Land Reforms Act,1954-Section 150, 150(3) DelhiDevelopment Act, 1957-Section22(1) Companies Act, 1956Limitation Act, 1963-Section 2,3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13,14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21,22, 23 & 24 Limitation Act,1963-Schedule-Article-58Limitation Act, 1908-Schedule-Article 120 Code of CivilProcedure-Order 2 Rule 2Constitution of India-Article136.

AIR 2011 SC 3590, JT 2011(10)SC 541, (2011) 8 MLJ 369 (SC),2011(10) SCALE 190, (2011) 9SCC 126.

3. The State of Maharashtraand Ors. v. Ark Builders Pvt.Ltd. (28.02.2011)

Arbitration and ConciliationAct, 1996-Section 31, 31(1),31(5), 32, 33, 33(1), 33 (4), 34,34(1), 34(2), 34(3) & 34(5)Bihar Building (Lease Rent andEviction) Control Act, 1947-Section 18(1) Bihar House RentControl Order 1942-Section 14.

AIR 2011 SC 1374, 2011(1)ARBLR 512 (SC), 2011 3 AWC2919 SC, 2011(3) BomCR 48,[2011] 101 CLA 324 (SC),(2011) 2 CompLJ 137 (SC),2011(3) CTC 777, 2011-3-LW177, 2011(2) RCR (Civil) 598,RLW 2011(3) SC 1908, 2011(3)SCALE 20, (2011) 4 SCC 616.

4. Union of India (UOI) andAnr. v. Deepak Electric andTrading Company and Anr.(20.10.2011)

Limitation Act, 1963-Schedule-Article 119 Arbitration Act,1940-Section 14 & 17 Code ofCivil Procedure-Section 79.

2011(4) ARBLR 104 (SC),2011(6) CTC 452, 183 (2011)DLT475 (SC), 2011(2) SCALE139.

Page 118: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

356 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

5. Union of India (UOI) andOrs. v. Kartar Kaur(24.05.2011)

Administrative Tribunals Act,1985-Section 19, 21(2), 21(3) &28 Code of Civil Procedure-Section 80 & 96.

2011(6) SCALE 439.

MEDIA & COMMUNICATION

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

1. Prakash Jha Productions andAnr. v. Union of India (UOI)and Ors. (19.08.2011)

Uttar Pradesh Cinemas(Regulation) Act, 1955-Section 6& 6(1).

Cinematograph Act, 1952 &1958-Section 3& 4. Constitutionof India-Article 19(1).

JT 2011(10) SC 102, (2011) 7MLJ 1227 (SC), 2011(9) SCALE265, (2011) 8 SCC 372.

MINES & MINERALS

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

1. Ashok Kumar Lingala v.State of Karnataka and Ors.(18.10.2011)

Karnataka (Sandur Area) InamAbolition Act, 1976-Section 10Minor Mineral (Developmentand Regulation) Act Mines andMinerals Act-Section 24AMineral Concessions Rules1960-Rule 22(3), 59 & 60.

2011(2) SCALE 121.

Mineral Concessions Rules1960-Rules 72.

2. Mines and Minerals a(Development and Regulation)Act, 1957-Section 4(1) & 21.

AIR 2011 SC 1679, 2011(4)SCALE 531, (2011) 5 SCC 449.

B.R. Surendranath Singh v.Deputy Director,Department of Mines andGeology, Karnataka andOrs. (11.04.2011) Indian Penal Code-Section 379.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 482.

Minor Concession Rules 1960-Rule 24A, 24(A) & (6).Constitution of India-Article136.

3. Govt. of A.P. and Ors. v.Obulapuram MiningCompany P. Ltd. and Ors.etc. (05. 08.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 21. 2011(8) SCALE 535.

4. State of Karnataka and Ors.v. Janthakal Enterprises andAnr. (15.04.2011)

Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980-Section 2 EnvironmentProtection Acts 1986.

2011 6 AWC (Supp) 5999 SC,[2011(3) JCR 210 (SC)], JT2011(8) SC 346, 2011(4) RCR(Civil) 297, 2011(7) SCALE 117.

5. State of Rajasthan and Anr.v. J.K. Synthetics Ltd. andAnr. (04.07.2011)

Act: Mines and Minerals(Development and Regulation)Act, 1957-Section 9, 9A, 9(2) &9(3). Code of Civil Procedure,1908-Section 144 MineralsConcession Rules 1960-Rule 27,27(1), 27(2), 27(3), 31, 45, 54(1)& 64A.

JT 2011(8) SC 346, 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 297, 2011(7)SCALE 117.

Constitution of India-Article136.

Page 119: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 357

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

6. Maharashtra Zilla Parishads andPanchayat Samitis Act, 1961-Section 144, 145, 147, 149, 151,151(1), 152 & 155.

2011(11) SCALE 113.

Bombay Gram Panchayats Act,1958-Section 127 & 127(1).

Maharashtra Land RevenueCode 1966-Section 2(19) & 64.

Sales Tax Act MineralConcession Rules 1960-Rule 27.

Mineral Concession Rules 1960-Rule 27(1).

MOTOR VEHICLE

Sl. No. Partiname Act/Legislation Referred Citation

1. A. Sridhar v. United IndiaInsurance Company Ltd. andAnr. (13.09.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 140 Motor Vehicles Act,1988-Section 166.

JT 2011(13) SC 68, (2011) 164PLR 804, 2011(10) SCALE 428.

2. Alka Ojha v. RajasthanPublic Service Commissionand Anr. (25.08.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 2(10), 2(19), 3, 4, 7,7(3), 7(5), 8, 8(1), 8(5), 8(6), 9,9(1), 9(4), 9(5), 9(6), 9(7), 10,12, 18 & 75(2).

AIR 2011 SC 3547, [2011(131)FLR 593], 2011(9) SCALE 411.

Rajasthan TransportSubordinate Service Rules, 1963-Rule 11 Constitution of India-Article 142 & 309.

Motor Vehicles Act, 1939-Section 110B Motor VehiclesAct, 1988-Section 168 (1)

3. B. Kothandapani v. TamilNadu State TransportCorporation Ltd.(12.05.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1939-Section 110B Motor VehiclesAct, 1988-Section 168 (1).

JT 2011(6) SC 257, 2011(5)MhLj 307, 2011(3) RCR (Civil)206, 2011(6) SCALE 41, (2011)6 SCC 420, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)1002.

4. C. Mohanraju v. DivisionalManager, United IndiaAssurance Co. Ltd. and Anr.(04.04.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 166.

AIR 2011 SC 1897, 2011(2)RCR (Civil) 836, 2011(4)SCALE 675.

5. Govind Yadav v. The NewIndia Insurance CompanyLimited (01. 11.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 166 Motor Vehicles Act,1939 Consumer Protection Act,1986.

JT 2011(13) SC 40, 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 817, 2011(2)SCALE 336.

6. Ibrahim v. Raju and Ors.(31.10. 2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 158 (6), 166, 166(4) &173.

JT 2011(13) SC 90, 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 863, 2011(2)SCALE 297.

Administration of Justice(Miscellaneous Provisions) Act1933-Section 6.

Motor Vehicles Act, 1939Consumer Protection Act, 1986.

7. Jawahar Singh v. Bala Jainand Ors. (09.05. 2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 MotorVehicles Rules.

AIR 2011 SC 2436, 2011(5)MhLj 336, (2011) 7 MLJ 833(SC), 2011(3) RCR (Civil) 269,2011(5) SCALE 494, (2011) 6SCC 425, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri)1006, 2011(3) TAC 12.

Page 120: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

358 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Partiname Act/Legislation Referred Citation

8. Kusum Lata and Ors. v.Satbir and Ors. (02.03.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act-Section 166. AIR 2011 SC 1234, 2011 2(2011) 3 MLJ 151 (SC), (2011)162 PLR 490, 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 379, 2011(3) SCALE 74,(2011) 3 SCC 646, (2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 18.

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 41(6), 109(3).

9. Maninderjit Singh Bitta v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (07.04.2011)

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989-Rule 50.

JT 2011(4) SC 383, 2011(2)RCR (Civil) 733, 2011(4)SCALE 435.

10. Maninderjit Singh Bitta v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (08.12.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 109(3) Motor VehiclesRules, 1989-Rule 50 Contemptof Courts Act, 1971.

2011(3) ALLMR (SC) 911.

11. Maninderjit Singh Bitta v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (13.10. 2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 41(6), 109(3), Rule 50Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Section 12 & 15.

2011(11) SCALE 634.

Constitution of India-Article129.

12. Maninderjit Singh Bitta v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (30.08. 2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988Contempt of Court Act, 1971Motor Vehicle (New HighSecurity Registration Plates)Order 2001.

2011(10) SCALE 161.

13. National InsuranceCompany Ltd. v. Kusumaand Anr. (23.08. 2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 166 & 168.

Motor Vehicles Act, 1939-Section 110B.

JT 2011(9) SC 356, 20112011(4) RCR (Civil) 180,2011(9) SCALE 305.

14. National InsuranceCompany Ltd. v. ShyamSingh and Ors. (04. 07.2011)

Indian Penal Code-Section 229& 304A.

AIR 2011 SC 3231, ILR [2011]MP 1803, 2011(6) SCALE 723,(2011) 7 SCC 65, (2011) 3 SCC(Cri) 28.

15. National InsuranceCompany Ltd. v. Sinitha andOrs. (23.11. 2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 140, 140(2), 140(3),140(4), 140(5), 141, 141(1),141(2), 141(3), 142, 143, 144,161, 161(2), 161(3), 162,162(2), 163, 163A, 163A (2),163B, 165, 166, 167, 168 &168A.

2011(13) SCALE 84.

Workmen’s Compensation Act,1923.

Indian Penal Code-Section 279,304A & 337.

16. New India Assurance Co.Ltd. v. Yadu Sambhaji Moreand Ors. (07.01.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1939-Section 110A, 133 & 134A.

2011(3) MhLJ 365 (SC), 2011MPLJ 468 (SC), (2011) 1 SCC(Cri) 700.

17. New India AssuranceCompany Ltd. v. YaduSambhaji More and Ors.(07.01.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1939-Section 2(18), 92A & 110ASupreme Court Rules, 1966-Order 15 Rule 1.

AIR 2011 SC 666, 2011(2)BomCR1, 2011(2) RCR (Civil)613, 2011(1) SCALE 130,(2011) 2 SCC 416, [2011] 1 SCR160.

Page 121: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 359

Sl. No. Partiname Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Constitution of India-Article 133& 134A.

18. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.v. Dhanbai Kanji Gadhviand Ors. (17. 01.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 163A & 166.

AIR 2011 SC 1138, JT 2011(6)SC 311, (2011) 3 MLJ 1097(SC), (2011) 11 SCC 513, [2011]1 SCR 784.

19. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.v. Vithabai and Ors. (05.07.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act. JT 2011(7) SC 89, 2011(3) RCR(Civil) 728, 2011(7) SCALE 1.

20. P.S. Somanathan and Ors. v.Dictrict Insurance Officerand Anr. (17.02.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 163A & 166.

JT 2011(2) SC 242, (2011) 4MLJ 169 (SC), 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 228, 2011(2) SCALE 473,(2011) 3 SCC 566, (2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 48.

21. Pushpa @ Leela and Ors. v.Shakuntala and Ors.(12.01.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 2(30), 50, 50(1), 50(2) &157.

Motor Vehicles Act, 1939Representation of the PeopleAct, 1951.

AIR 2011 SC 682, (2011) 3 MLJ219 (SC), 2011(1) SCALE 303,(2011) 2 SCC 240, (2011) 1 SCC(Cri) 682, [2011] 1 SCR 334.

22. Ranjana Prakash and Ors. v.Divisional Manager and Anr.(29.07.2011)

Code of Civil Procedure -Order41 Rule 33.

2011(4) RCR (Civil) 218,2011(8) SCALE 240.

23. Ravi v. Badrinarayan andOrs. (18.02.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 133, 140, 166, 173 Codeof Criminal Procedure -Section154, 161 Indian Penal Code-Section 279, 338.

(2011) 4 MLJ 315 (SC), 2011(2)SCALE 618, (2011) 4 SCC 693,(2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 751.

24. Raviraj Udupa v. UnitedIndia Insurance CompanyLtd. and Ors. (16.08.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act-Section 166. 2011 5 AWC 5119 SC, 2011(9)SCALE 348.

25. Rudra v. DivisionalManager, National InsuranceCo. Ltd. and Anr.(18.03.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 166.

AIR 2011 SC 2572, JT 2011(4)SC 225, 2011(4) SCALE 249,(2011) 11 SCC 511, (2011) 3SCC (Cri) 238.

26. Rudra v. DivisionalManager, National InsuranceCompany Ltd. and Anr.(18.03.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 166.

RLW 2011(4) SC 3291,

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 166.

27. Sanjay Batham v. MunnalalParihar and Ors.(01.11.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1939Consumer Protection Act, 1986Persons with Disabilities (EqualOpportunities Protection ofRights and Full Participation)Act, 1995-Section 2.

JT 2011(13) SC 32, 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 937, 2011(2)SCALE 328.

28. Sant Singh v. Sukhdev Singhand Ors. (04.03.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 163A, 166 & 168.

2011(2) RCR (Civil) 830,2011(4) SCALE 246, (2011) 11SCC 632.

29. Sharma Transports v. TheState of Maharashtra andOrs. (02.08. 2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 2, 2(13), 2(43), 84, 86,88, 110 & 200.

AIR 2011 SC 3279, JT 2011(8)SC 559, 2011(6) MhLj 834,(2011) 7 MLJ 805 (SC), (2011) 8SCC 647.

Page 122: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

360 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Partiname Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Central Motor Vehicles Rules,1989-Rule 93, 93(1), 93(3),93(3A), 93(4), 93(6A), 93(8),125C, 128, 128(1) & 128(9).Constitution of India-Article19(1).

30. Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 166.

Sri Kumaresh v. The Divl.Manager National InsuranceCompany Ltd. and Anr.(29.04. 2011)

Workmen Compensation Act,1923.

JT 2011(6) SC 35, (2011) 164PLR 110, 2011(2) RCR (Civil)913.

31. Sri Laxman @ LaxmanMourya v. DivisionalManager, Oritl. Ins.Company Ltd. and Anr.(08.11. 2011)

JT 2011(13) SC 205.

32. Sri Nagarajappa v. TheDivisional Manager, TheOriental Insurance Co. Ltd(11.04.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 166, 168 & 169.

AIR 2011 SC 1785, JT 2011(4)SC 211, 2011(2) RCR (Civil)720, 2011(4) SCALE 515.

33. Sri Ramachandrappa vs. TheManager, Royal SundaramAlliance Insurance CompanyLimited (09. 08. 201)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 166.

AIR 2011 SC 2951, JT 2011(8)SC 628, 2011(4) RCR (Civil)107, 2011(8) SCALE 399.

34. Sri. K. R. Madhusudhan andOrs. v. The AdministrativeOfficer and Anr.(18.02.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 166.

AIR 2011 SC 979, 2011(4)MhLJ 520 (SC), 2011(2) SCALE511, (2011) 4 SCC 689, (2011) 2SCC (Cri) 706, [2011] 2 SCR1061.

35. Syed Mehaboob v. The NewIndia Assurance Co. Ltd.(07.02. 2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 166.

2011 ACJ 1667, 2011 3 AWC2900 SC, 2011(4) SCALE 496,(2011) 11 SCC 625.

36. The State of West Bengal andOrs. v. Mani BhushanKumar (11. 10.2011)

West Bengal Motor Vehicles TaxAct, 1970-Section 16, 16(3) &16(4).

2011(11) SCALE 566, (2011) 10SCC 147.

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 66, 66(1), 87, 88, 88(1),88(7) & 207.

37. United India InsuranceCompany Ltd. v. Shila Dattaand Ors. (13. 10.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 95(2), 110D, 147,147(1), 147(2), 147(3), 149,149(1), 149(2), 149(3), 149(7),158(6), 162, 163A, 163A (1),163A(2), 163A(3), 165, 166,166(1), 166(4), 168, 168(1),168(2), 169, 170, 172, 173 &173(2).

JT 2011(12) SC 233, 2011(4)KLT 378, (2011) 164 PLR 806,2011(2) SCALE 5.

Motor Vehicles Act, 1939-Section 96, 96(2), 96(6).

38. Urmila and Ors. v. RashpalKaur and Ors. (09.08.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 166 & 173.

JT 2011(8) SC 603, 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 216, 2011(8)SCALE 406.

39. Urviben Chiragbhai Sheth vs.Vijaybhai ShambhubhaiJoranputra and Ors.(26.04.2011

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. AIR 2011 SC 2502, JT 2011(5)SC 396, (2011) 7 MLJ 823 (SC),2011(2) RCR (Civil) 871,2011(5) SCALE 225.

Page 123: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 361

Sl. No. Partiname Act/Legislation Referred Citation

40. Uttar Pradesh State RoadTransport Corporation v.Kulsum and Ors.(25.07.2011)

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988-Section 2(19), 2(30), 95(4),96(2), 103,103 (1A), 146, 147,149, 157 & 196.

JT 2011(8) SC 322, (2011) 7MLJ 375 (SC), (2011(8) SCALE28, (2011) 8 SCC 142.

Motor Vehicle Act, 1939-Section2(19).

Insurance Act, 1938.

Central Motor Vehicle Rule1989-Rule 3.

NARCOTIC/DRUGS

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

1. Ashok @ Dangra Jaiswal v.State of M.P. (05.04.2011)

Narcotics Drugs andPsychotropic Substance Act,1985-Section 8, 21.

Code of Criminal Procedure -Section 465.

AIR 2011 SC 1335, JT 2011(4)SC 34, 2011(2) RCR (Criminal)611, RLW2011(3) SC 1883,2011(4) SCALE 273, (2011) 5SCC 123.

2. Bahadur Singh v. State ofPunjab (26.04.2011)

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985-Section 18,50 & 55.

2011(2) RCR (Criminal) 944,2011(5) SCALE 550.

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985-Section 57.

3. Bhola Singh v. State ofPunjab (08.02.2011)

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act-Section 15, 25,35, 50 & 54.

2011 CriLJ 2296, JT 2011(3) SC392, 2011(3) SCALE 495,(2011) 11 SCC 653, [2011] 2SCR 642.

4. Daulat Ram and Anr. v.C.B.N. Mandsaur, M.P.(27.01.2011)

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act-Section 8, 18Narcotics Drugs andPsychotropic Substances Rule1985-Rule 13.

2011 CriLJ 2329, 2011(2)SCALE 488, [2011] 1 SCR 1092.

5. Harjit Singh v. State ofPunjab (30.03.2011)

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985-Section 2,8 & 18.

Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 313.

2011 CriLJ 2332, JT 2011(4) SC100, 2011(4) SCALE 116,(2011) 4 SCC 441, (2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 286.

Constitution of India-Article 20.

6. Iqbal Moosa Patel v. State ofGujarat (12.01.2011)

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985-Section 8,21, 29, 35, 54 & 67.

Code of Criminal Procedure -Section 313.

2011 CriLJ 1142, JT 2011(1) SC157, 2011(1) SCALE 318,(2011) 2 SCC 198, (2011) 1 SCC(Cri) 654, [2011] 2 SCR 121.

Constitution of India-Article136.

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985-Section 18& 50.

7. Jarnail Singh v. State ofPunjab (11.02.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 25.

AIR 2011 SC 964, 2011 CriLJ1738, 2011(1) RCR (Criminal)925, 2011(2) SCALE 401,(2011) 1 SCC (Cri) 1191, [2011]2 SCR 888.

Code of Criminal Procedure -Section 293 & 313 Constitutionof India-Article 136.

Page 124: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

362 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

8. Narcotics Central Bureau v.Sukh Dev Raj Sodhi(20.05.2011

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985-Section 50.

AIR 2011 SC 1939, JT 2011(6)SC 125, 2011(6) SCALE 368,(2011) 6 SCC 392, (2011) 2 SCC(Cri) 981.

9. Nikku Khan @Mohammadeen v. State ofHaryana (21.07.2011)

Narcotic Drugs andPhychotropic Substance Act,1985-Section 2, 21, 41 & 50.

AIR 2011 SC 3113, 2011(3)Crimes 127 (SC), JT 2011(8) SC53, 2011(8) SCALE 24.

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985-Section 22,50 & 50 (1).

10. Nirmal Singh Pehlwan @Nimma v. Inspector,Customs, Customs House,Punjab (21.07. 2011)

Customs Act-Section 108.

JT 2011(8) SC 581, 2011(II)OLR (SC) 689, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 831, 2011(8) SCALE430.

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 25.

Code of Criminal Procedure -Section 313.

11. Rajender Singh v. State ofHaryana (08.08.2011)

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985-Section 18,42, 42(1), 42(2), 52, 55, 57Code of Criminal Procedure -Section 313.

2011(3) Crimes 210 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 577, 2011(8) SCALE434, (2011) 8 SCC 130, 2009(2)SLR 224 (SC).

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances (Amendment) Act2001-Section 42.

12. Ram Singh v. Central Bureauof Narcotics (28.04.2011)

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985-Section 8,18, 42, 43, 51, 53 & 67.

AIR 2011 SC 2490, 2011(6)SCALE 243, (2011) 11 SCC 347,(2011) 3 SCC (Cri) 181.

Indian Evidence Act-Section 24,25, 26& 27.

Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 161, 173 & 313.

Customs Act.

13. Senior Intelligence Officer v.Jugal Kishore Samra(05.07.2011)

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985-Section 21,29, 37 & 67 Prevention ofCorruption Act, 1947-Section5(1) & 5(2) Customs Act, 1962Foreign Exchange RegulationAct, 1973 Sea Customs Act Codeof Criminal Procedure -Section161, 161(1),161(2), 438 & 438(2) Indian Penal Code-Section109, 120B, 161, 165 & 179Constitution of India-Article20(3), 21, 22, 22(1), 22(2) & 32.

2011(2) ACR 2238 (SC),2011(270) ELT 147 (SC), JT2011(7) SC 165, 2011(3) RCR(Criminal) 519, 2011(7) SCALE3.

14. State of Delhi v. Ram Avtar@ Rama (07.07.2011)

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985-Section 21,41, 41(1), 42, 42(2), 43, 50, 50(1), 50 (2) & 50 (5) Income TaxAct Code of Criminal Procedure-Section 313.

180 (2011) DLT 629 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 464, 2011(3) KLT(SN) 49, 2011(4) PLJR 60,2011(4) RCR (Criminal) 191,RLW 2011(4) SC 3500, 2011(7)SCALE 428.

15. State of Rajasthan v. TaraSingh (29.03.2011)

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act, 1985 – Section8,15 & 50.

2011(4) KCCR SN 387, (2011)11 SCC 559.

Page 125: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 363

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

16. Sunil Rai @ Paua and Ors. v.Union Territory, Chandigarh(04.07.2011)

Narcotic Drugs and PsychotropicSubstances Act Indian PenalCode-Section 34, 120B & 302Code of Criminal Procedure -Section 164 & 313 IndianEvidence Act-Section 10.

AIR 2011 SC 2545, 2011(3)Crimes 111 (SC), JT 2011(7) SC58, 2011(II) OLR (SC) 259,2011(3) RCR (Criminal) 636,2011(6) SCALE 612.

PROPERTY LAW

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Amiya Bala Dutta and Ors.v. Mukud Adhikari and Ors.(23.02.2011)

Code of Civil Procedure -Section100(1).

2011 3 AWC 2275 SC, (2011) 2CALLT 78 (SC), JT 2011(3) SC93, (2011) 11 SCC 628.

2. Arulmighu LakshmiNarayanaswamy Temple,rep. by its ChAIR man,Board of Trustees v.Nallammal (Dead) thr. L.Rs. and Ors. (15.09.2011)

Madras Inam Estates (Abolitionand Conversion into RyotwariAct) 1963-Section 2, 2(4), 2(5),2(11) & 8 Madras Estates LandAct, 1908 Tamil Nadu Estates(Abolition and Conversion intoRyotwari) Act, 1948 LandAcquisition Act Tamil NaduMinor Inams (Abolition andConversion into Ryotwari) Act,1963.

2011(10) SCALE 510.

3. Brij Mohan and Ors. v.Haryana UrbanDevelopment Authority andAnr. (03.01.2011)

Land Acquisition Act, 1894-Section 4 Land Acquisition Act,1894-Section 23(1A), 23(2) &28.

AIR 2011 SC 343, 2011 1 AWC(Supp) 579SC, (SCSuppl)2011(1) CHN211, JT 2011(1)SC 100, 2011(2) RCR (Civil)224, 2011(1) SCALE 1, (2011) 2SCC 29, [2011] 1 SCR 12.

4. Citadel Fine Pharmaceuticalsv. Ramaniyam Real EstatesP. Ltd. and Anr.(08.08.2011)

Companies Act, 1956 TamilNadu Urban Land (Ceiling andRegulations) Act, 1978-Section5, 6, 7, 9(5), 11(1), 11(3), 12,13, 14, l5, 15B, 16 & 21 IncomeTax Act, 1961-Section 269UCTamil Nadu Urban Land(Ceiling and Regulation) RepealAct, 1999-Section 3 & 4 IndianContract Act, 1872-Section 55Specific Relief Act, 1963-Section9 Income Tax Rules, 1962-Rule48L.

AIR 2011 SC 3351, 2011 5AWC 4861 SC, 2011(6) CTC112, JT 2011(9) SC 265,2011(4) RCR (Civil) 894,2011(8) SCALE 301.

5. Commissioner, CentralExcise, Bangalore v. MeyerHealth Care Pvt. Ltd. andOrs. (07.04.2011)

Trade Marks Act. 2011(185) ECR 1 (SC),2011(267) ELT 145 (SC), JT2011(6) SC 361, 2011(4) SCALE593.

6. Coromandel Indag Products(P) Ltd. v. Garuda Chit andTrading Co. P. Ltd. and Anr.(16.08.2011)

Companies Act, 1956 IncomeTax Act, 1961-Section 230AIncome Tax Act 1981-Section230A Specific Relief Act, 1963-Section 16 Urban Land CeilingAct-Section 3 & 6 Urban Land(Ceiling and Regulation)Ordinance 1976.

2011 6 AWC (Supp) 5899 SC,JT 2011(10) SC 34, (2011) 8MLJ 112 (SC), 2011(4) RCR(Civil) 677, 2011(9) SCALE 139,(2011) 8 SCC 601.

Page 126: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

364 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

7. Deb Ratan Biswas and Ors.v. Most. Anand Moyi Deviand Ors. (15.04.2011)

Indian Contract Act-Section 207Code of Civil Procedure -Section151.

AIR 2011 SC 1653, 2011(3)ALLMR (SC) 908, 2011 4 AWC4013 SC, (SCSuppl) 2011(3)CHN 108, ILR 2011(2) Kerala339, [2011(3) JCR 33 (SC) ], JT2011(4) SC 244, 2011(2) KLJ12, 2011(2) KLT 366 (SC),2011-3-LW 166, 2011(3) PLJR19, (2011) 164 PLR 135,2011(3) RCR (Civil) 681, 2011113 RD 451, RLW 2011(3) SC2282, 2011(4) SCALE 656.

8. Dr. Shehla Burney and Ors.v. Syed Ali Mossa Raza(Dead) by L. Rs. and Ors.(21.04.2011)

Limitation Act, 1963-Schedule-Article 65 Code of CivilProcedure -Section 100 Code ofCivil Procedure -Order 7 Rule 5& 7.

2011 4 AWC 3624 SC, JT2011(5) SC 137, 2011-3-LW 62,2011(5) MhLj 340, 2011(4)MPLJ 40, (2011) 164 PLR 127,2011(3) RCR (Civil) 345, 2011113 RD 456, 2011(4) SCALE838, (2011) 6 SCC 529.

9. Dunlop India Limited v. A.A. Rahna and Anr.(04.05.2011)

Kerala Buildings (Lease and RentControl) Act 1965-Section 2(1),11, 11(1), 11(2), 11(3), 11(4), 15& 18 Sick Industrial Companies(Special Provisions) Act, 1985-Section 15, 16, 17(3), 22 &22(1) Haryana Urban (Controlof Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973-Section 13(2) Bombay RentsHotel and Lodging Houses RatesControl Act, 1947-Section 13(1)Karnataka Rent Control Act-Section 50 (1).

AIR 2011 SC 2198, 2011(2)KLT 682, 2011(1) RCR (Rent)354, 2011(5) SCALE 312,(2011) 5 SCC 778.

10. Gayathri Womens WelfareAssociation v. Gowrammaand Anr. (11.01.2011)

Societies Registration Act Codeof Civil Procedure -Order 6 Rule17 Code of Civil Procedure -Order 8 Rule 1, 6A, 6B, 6C, 6D,6E, 6F, 6G & 9 Code of CivilProcedure Order 20 Rule 18.

AIR 2011 SC 785, 2011 2 AWC2161 SC, (SCSuppl) 2011(2)CHN 139, 112(2011) CLT 106(SC), JT 2011(1) SC 315,2011(1) KLJ55, 2011(3) MhLJ354 (SC), (2011) 4 MLJ 195(SC), 2011 MPLJ 477 (SC), 2011112 RD 511, RLW 2011(1) SC588, 2011(1) SCALE 379,(2011) 2 SCC 330, [2011] 2 SCR47.

11. Gian Kaur v. Raghubir Singh(03.02.2011)

Special Relief Act-Section 34. 2011 3 AWC 2266 SC, JT2011(7) SC 44, 2011(3) KCCRSN 319, 2011-3-LW175,2011(4) MhLJ 527 (SC), (2011)7 MLJ 846 (SC), 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 377, 2011(3) SCALE 241,(2011) 4 SCC 567, [2011] 2 SCR486.

12. Godavari Sugar Mills Ltd. v.The State of Maharashtraand Ors. (20.01.2011)

Maharashtra Agricultural Lands(Ceiling on Holdings) Act, 1961-Section 21, 21(4), 24, 24(1),24(2), 25, 26 & 26(3) Defence ofIndia Act, 1962 Constitution ofIndia-Article 226.

2011(3) MhLJ 387 (SC), 2011(1)SCALE 588, [2011] 2 SCR 180.

Page 127: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 365

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

13. H. Siddiqui (dead) by L. Rs.v. A. Ramalingam(04.03.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 20(2), 65 & 66 Code ofCivil Procedure, 1908-Order 41Rule 31.

AIR 2011 SC 1492, 2011(2)ALLMR (SC) 938, 2011 2 AWC1704 SC, 2011(268) ELT 436(SC), 2011 GLH (1) 586, JT2011(3) SC 522, 2011(2) KCCR1398, 2011-4-LW 805, 2011(4)MhLJ 88 (SC), 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 385, 2011(3) SCALE 290,(2011) 4 SCC 240.

14. Hafeeza Bibi and Ors. v.Shaikh Farid (dead) by L. Rs.and Ors. (05.05.2011)

Registration Act, 1908-Section17, 17(1) & 49 Transfer ofProperty Act, 1882-Section 123,129 & 138 Indian RegistrationAct 1866 Indian Registration Act1871 Indian Registration Act1877 Specific Relief Act 1877Hyderabad Stamp Act-Section55 Mohammadan Law SunniLaw Muslim Law.

AIR 2011 SC 1695, 2011(3)ALLMR (SC) 981, 2011 3 AWC3142 SC, 2011(3) CGLJ 489,2011(2) JKJ 8 [SC], JT 2011(6)SC 5, 2011(4) KCCR SN 358,2011(3) KLJ 6, 2011(2) KLT661 (SC), 2011-3-LW 700,2011(5) MhLj 24, 2011(4) MPLJ46, 2011(4) PLJR 21, 2011(2)RCR (Civil) 940, 2011 113RD796, 2011(5) SCALE 371,(2011) 5 SCC 654.

15. Hari Ram v. Jyoti Prasadand Anr. (27.01.2011)

Limitation Act, 1963-Section 3Limitation Act, 1963-Section 22Code of Criminal Procedure,1973-Section 133 Code of CivilProcedure -Order 1 Rule 8.

AIR 2011 SC 952, 2011(2)ALLMR (SC) 457, 2011 2 AWC2006 SC, (SCSuppl) 2011(2)CHN120, 2011(3) CTC 769, JT2011(3) SC 173, 2011(2) KCCRSN 154, (2010) 164 PLR 641,2011(2) RCR (Civil) 515, 2011113 RD333, RLW 2011(2) SC1694, 2011(1) SCALE 749,(2011) 2 SCC 682, [2011] 1 SCR1076, 2011(1) UC 408.

16. Humanity and Anr. v. Stateof West Bengal and Ors.(26.05.2011)

Companies Act, 1986-Section25(1) Constitution of India-Article 14 & 19(1).

AIR 2011 SC 2308, 2011(4)ALLMR (SC) 468, 2011 4 AWC4286 SC, (SCSuppl) 2011(3)CHN 1, 2011(112) CLR (SC)589, JT 2011(6) SC 334,2011(3) KLT (SN) 12, 2011(3)PLJR 261, 2011(6) SCALE 378,(2011) 6 SCC 125.

17. ITC Ltd. v. State of UttarPradesh and Ors.(05.07.2011)

Uttar Pradesh Industrial AreaDevelopment Act, 1976 UttarPradesh Urban Planning andDevelopment Act, 1973-Section6, 6(1), 6(2), 7, 9(2), 12, 12(3),14, 14(1), 14(2), 18, 19, 30, 32,40, 41, 41(1), 41(3), 43, 44, 45,46, 47, 49, 50, 51, 53 & 58Uttar Pradesh President’s Acts(Re-enactment withModifications) Act, 1974pTransfer of Property Act, 1882-Section 4 Indian Contract Act,1872-Section 20 & 21 NoidaDevelopment Area BuildingRegulations 1986 StatutoryRegulations 1996 Noida(Preparation and Finalisation ofPlan) Regulations 1991-Regulations Regulations 2 Noida

2011 5 AWC (Supp) 5208 SC,JT 2011(7) SC 602, 2011(3)KLT (SN) 57, 2011(7) SCALE183, (2011) 7 SCC 493.

Page 128: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

366 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

(Preparation and Finalisation ofPlan) Regulations 1991-Regulations 3 (1) Noida(Preparation and Finalisation ofPlan) Regulations 1991-Regulations 4, 4(1), 9 & 11Noida Building Regulations andDirections 2006-RegulationsRegulations 3.12, 33.3 & 33.4.

18. Ishwar Dass Nassa and Ors.v. State of Haryana and Ors.(12.12.2011)

Haryana Housing Board Act,1971-Section 74 HaryanaHousing Board Rules HousingBoard Haryana (AllotmentManagement and Sale ofTenements) Regulations 1972-Regulation 11(4) Constitution ofIndia-Article 226.

2011(13) SCALE 452.

19. Jag pal Singh and Ors. v.State of Punjab and Ors.(28.01.2011)

Estates Abolition Act-Section 3Punjab Village Common Lands(Regulation) Act, 1961-Section 7Uttar Pradesh Consolidation ofHoldings Act 1954.

AIR 2011 SC 1123, 2011 3AWC 2379 SC, 112(2011) CLT130 (SC), (2011) 2 GLR 1304,[2011(2) JCR 52 (SC)], 2011(2)JKJ 34 [SC], 2011-3-LW 17,2011(1) RCR (Civil) 912, 2011113 RD 329, 2011(2) SCALE42, (2011) 11 SCC 396, [2011] 2SCR 250.

20. Janak Dulari Devi and Anr.v. Kapildeo Rai and Anr.(15.04.2011)

Transfer of Property Act, 1882-Section 8, 54 & 55(4) IndianEvidence Act, 1872-Section 92Constitution of India-Article136.

AIR 2011 SC 2521, 2011 5AWC 4475 SC, JT 2011(5) SC272, 2011(4) RCR (Civil) 708,2011 114 RD 27, (2011) 6 SCC555.

21. Joy deep Mukharjee v. Stateof West Bengal and Ors.(03.02.2011)

West Bengal GovernmentTownship (Extension of CivicAmenities) Act, 1975-Section 2,4 West Bengal GovernmentTownship (Extension of CivicAmenities) (Amendment) Act,1985 Constitution of India-Article 14 Constitution of India-Article 21 West BengalGovernment Township(Extension of Civic Amenities)Ordinance 1975.

AIR 2011 SC 1169, 2011(4)ALLMR (SC) 879, 2011 GLH(2) 1600, 2011(2) KCCR SN165, 2011(2) PLJR 59, 2011(2)SCALE 172, (2011) 2 SCC 706,[2011] 2 SCR 493.

22. K. Balakrishnan Nambiar v.State of Karnataka and Ors.(05.05.2011)

Madras Forest Act, 1882 ForestConservation Act, 1980-Section2.

AIR 2011 SC 1628, JT 2011(6)SC 18, 2011(4) KCCR 2621,2011(5) SCALE 407, (2011) 5SCC 353.

23. Khatri Hotels PrivateLimited and Anr. v. Union ofIndia (UOI) and Anr.(09.09.2011)

Delhi Municipal CorporationAct, 1957-Section 477, 478 &507 Delhi Land Reforms Act1954-Section 150 & 150(3)Delhi Development Act, 1957-Section 22(1) Companies Act,1956 Limitation Act, 1963-Section 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10,11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18,19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24 LimitationAct, 1963-Schedule-Article-58Limitation Act, 1908-Schedule-

AIR 2011 SC 3590, JT 2011(10)SC 541, (2011) 8 MLJ 369 (SC),2011(10) SCALE 190, (2011) 9SCC 126.

Page 129: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 367

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Article 120 Code of CivilProcedure-Order 2 Rule 2Constitution of India-Article136.

24. Krishan Lal Gera v. State ofHaryana and Ors.(04.07.2011)

Societies Registration Act, 1860. AIR 2011 SC 2970, 2011(4)PLJR 38, 2011(4) RCR (Civil)115, 2011(7) SCALE 105.

25. L. K. Trust v. EDC Ltd. andOrs. (10.05.2011)

Companies Act, 1956 StateFinance Corporation Act, 1951-Section 29 Transfer of PropertyAct, 1882-Section 54 & 60Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-Section 2 & 12 Contempt ofCourts Rules-Rule 3 (C)Supreme Court Rules, 1966Supreme Court Orders-Order 47Constitution of India-Article129, 136, 141 & 144.

AIR 2011 SC 2060, II (2011) BC655, JT 2011(6) SC 470,2011(3) KLT (SN) 9, 2011(4)MPLJ9, 2011(4) RCR (Civil)600, 2011(5) SCALE 531,(2011) 6 SCC 780.

26. Machavarapu Srinivasa Raoand Anr. v. The Vijayawada,Guntur, Tenali, MangalagiriUrban DevelopmentAuthority and Ors.(19.09.2011)

Andhra Pradesh Urban Areas(Development) Act, 1975-Section2, 3, 3 (1), 4, 5(1), 7, 7(1), 7(2),8, 9, 10, 12(1), 12(2), 12(3),12(4), 13, 16(1) & 38 (A)Andhra Pradesh SocietiesRegistration Act 2001 BangaloreDevelopment Authority Act,1976 Constitution of India-Article 14.

2011(10) SCALE 619.

27. Meghwal Samaj ShikshaSamiti v. Lakh Singh andOrs. (17.02.2011)

Constitution of India-Article 21. 2011(2) SCALE 654, (2011) 11SCC800.

28. Mrs. Saradamani Kandappanv. Mrs. S. Rajalakshmi andOrs. (04.07.2011)

Contract Act, 1872-Section 51,52, 53, 54 & 55 Transfer ofProperty Act, 1882-Section 34,55, 55(1) & 55(5) Specific ReliefAct, 1963 Rent Control ActBombay Rents Hotel andLodging House Rates ControlAct, 1947-Section 5(10) (B), 7 &9(2) Code of Civil Procedure -Order 41 Rule 27 Constitutionof India-Article 14 & 136.

AIR 2011 SC 3234, 2011(5)ALD 100 (SC), JT 2011(8) SC129, 2011(3) KLT (SN) 43,(2011) 6 MLJ 149 (SC), 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 130.

29. Nanjegowda and Anr. v.Gangamma and Ors.(25.08.2011)

Transfer of Property Act, 1882-Section 53A.

2011(6) ALD111 (SC), JT2011(9) SC 387, 2011(3) KLJ50, 2011(4) RCR (Civil) 805,2011(9) SCALE 358.

30. Noida EntrepreneursAssociation v. NOIDA andOrs. (09.05.2011)

Uttar Pradesh Industrial AreaDevelopment Act, 1976-Section6(2), 8, 9, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18 &19 Prevention of Corruption Act,1988 Uttar Pradesh UrbanPlanning and Development Act,1973-Section 30, 32, 40, 41, 42,43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 49, 50, 51,53 & 58 Code of CriminalProcedure, 1973-Section 468,469, 470, 471 & 473 All IndiaServices (Death cum RetirementBenefits) Rules, 1958-Rule 6

2011(6) ADJ 13, AIR 2011 SC2112, 2011 4 AWC 3265 SC, JT2011(6) SC 223, 2011(5) SCALE505.

Page 130: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

368 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

New Okhla IndustrialDevelopment Area (Preparationand Finalization of Plan)Regulations 1991 Constitutionof India-Article 14 & 21.

31. Pesara Pushpamala Reddy v.G. Veera Swamy and Ors.(04.03.2011)

Andhra Pradesh Land Grabbing(Prohibition) Act, 1982-Section7, 7(1), 7A, 7A(1), 7A(4), 7(4),8, 8(1), 8(6) & 9 AndhraPradesh Land Grabbing(Prohibition) (Amendment) Act,1987 Code of Civil Procedure,1908 Andhra Pradesh CivilCourts Act, 1972 Code ofCriminal Procedure, 1973Companies Act, 1956-Section442 & 446 Andhra PradeshLand Grabbing (Prohibition)Rules 1988-Rule 6, 6(1), 6(2),6(3), 7, 7(1) & 7(2).

JT 2011(3) SC 210, 2011(3)SCALE 253, (2011) 4 SCC 306.

32. Pirthi v. Mohan Singh andOrs. (02.09.2011)

Punjab Pre-emption emption ActPunjab Pre-emption 1913Benami Transactions(Prohibition) Act, 1988-Section 4Code of Civil Procedure-Order20 Rule 14 Punjab Pre-emptionemption (Haryana Amendment)Act Punjab Pre-emption 1995.

AIR 2011 SC 3070, JT 2011(10)SC 67, 2011(4) RCR (Civil) 349,2011(9) SCALE 669, (2011)9SCC 107.

33. Poonam and Ors. v. HarishKumar and Anr.(03.11.2011)

Constitution of India-Article136.

Constitution of India-Article136.

34. Pradeep Oil Corporation v.Municipal Corporation ofDelhi and Anr. (06.04.2011)

Government Grants Act 1895-Section 2 Delhi MunicipalCorporation Act, 1957-Section20(2), 114, 115, 116(3), 119,120, 120(1) & 120(2) Transferof Property Act, 1882-Section105, 106 & 108 IndianEasements Act, 1882-Section 52Explosives Act Public PremisesUnauthorized OccupantsEviction Act Constitution ofIndia-Article 285.

AIR 2011 SC 1869, JT 2011(5)SC 94, 2011(3) KCCR SN 298,2011(4) RCR (Civil) 313,2011(2) RCR (Rent) 285,2011(4) SCALE 422, (2011) 5SCC 270.

35. Pragati Mahila Mandal,Nanded v. MunicipalCouncil, Nanded and Ors.(18.02.2011)

Bombay Public Trust Act, 1950Maharashtra Municipal CouncilsNagar Panchayats and IndustrialTownships Act 1965-Section 92Maharashtra Regional andTown Planning Act, 1966-Section 44 Code of CivilProcedure, 1908-Section 141Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Order 22 Rule 4A Constitutionof India-Article 32 & 226Maharashtra Municipalities(Transfer of ImmovableProperty) Rules, 1983-Rule 21.

AIR 2011 SC 1512, 2011 3AWC 2937 SC, 2011(3) BomCR36, 2011(3) KCCR SN 300,2011-3-LW34, 2011(4) MhLJ 1(SC), (2011) 4 MLJ 352 (SC),2011(2) SCALE 530, (2011) 3SCC 464, [2011] 2 SCR 985.

Page 131: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 369

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

36. Purshottam VishandasRaheja and Anr. v. ShrichandVishandas Raheja (D)through L. Rs. and Ors.(06.05.2011)

Transfer of Property Act-Section44 Development Control Rules.

AIR 2011 SC 2151, 113(2011)DMC 694, 2011(4) KCCR SN357, 2011(5) MhLj181, 2011(3)RCR (Civil) 762, 2011(5)SCALE 391, (2011) 6 SCC 73.

37. Rakesh Sharma and Ors. v.State of M.P. and Ors.(30.08.2011)

Constitution of India-Article226.

JT 2011(10) SC 436, 2011(9)SCALE 538.

38. Ramdeo (D) by L. Rs. andOrs. v. Board of Revenue,U.P. and Ors. (10.03.2011)

Uttar Pradesh ZamindariAbolition and Land ReformsAct-Section 229B.

AIR 2011 SC 1548, 2011 3AWC 2918 SC, JT 2011(3) SC97, 2011 112 RD 625, 2011(3)SCALE 419, (2011) 3 SCC 755.

39. Ramesh Kumar and Anr. v.Furu Ram and Anr. etc.(18.08.2011)

Registration Act, 1908-Section17, 17(1), 17(2) & 49Arbitration Act, 1940-Section14, 17, 30, 32 & 33 IndianContract Act, 1872-Section 17Hindu Marriage Act, 1955-Section 12 Stamp Act IndianEvidence Act, 1872-Section 114Indian Registration Act 1866,1871 & 1877.

2011(3) ARBLR 477 (SC), JT2011(9) SC 505, 2011(6) MhLj842, 2011(9) SCALE 16, (2011)8 SCC 613.

40. Rameshwari Devi and Ors.v. Nirmala Devi and Ors.(04.07.2011)

Code of Civil Procedure -Section10 & 151 Code of CivilProcedure-Order 6 Rule 17,Order 7 Rule 1,Order 10 Rule 2,Order 14 Rule 2, 2(2) & 5,Order18 Rule 17A,Order 20 Rule 5,Order 22 Rule 3 Code ofCriminal Procedure-Section 340(3) Constitution of India-Article22.

[2011(3) JCR 242 (SC) ], JT2011(8) SC 90, 2011(3) KLT(SN) 53, (2011) 7MLJ361 (SC),2011(3) RCR (Civil) 932, 2011114 RD284, 2011(6) SCALE677, (2011) 8 SCC 249.

41. Rangammal v. Kuppuswamiand Anr. (13.05.2011)

Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 101.

AIR 2011 SC 2344, 2011(5)ALD 38 (SC), 2011 5 AWC4692 SC, 2011(4) BomCR 32,2011(4) CTC769, [2011(4) JCR37 (SC)], JT 2011(6) SC 457,2011-3-LW 48, 2011(II) OLR(SC) 278, 2011(4) RCR (Civil)251, 2011 113 RD744, 2011(6)SCALE 161.

42. Rasiklal ManickchandDhariwal and Anr. v. M.S.S.Food Products (25.11.2011)

Madhya Pradesh Civil CourtsAct, 1958 Evidence Act TradeMarks Act, 1999-Section 2(1)Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section 10, 24, 151, 152 Code ofCivil Procedure, 1908-Order 6Rule 17, Order 7 Rule 11, Order9 Rule 6, 6(1), 7, 13, Order 11Rule 12, 14, Order 16 Rule 1, 6,Order 18 Rule 1, 2, 2(2), 2(3),2(3A), 4, 4(1), 4(2), 5, 13 & 15,Order 20 Rule 1, Order 26 Rules16, 16A, 17 & 18, Order 30Rule 10.

2011(13) SCALE 183.

Page 132: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

370 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

43. Samittri Devi and Anr. v.Sampuran Singh and Anr.(21.01.2011)

Benami Transactions(Prohibition) Act, 1988-Section 4& 4(1) Indian Evidence Act-Section 16 Indian Evidence Act-Section 114 Transfer of PropertyAct, 1882-Section 106Conservation of ForeignExchange and SmugglingActivities Act, 1974 CompaniesAct, 1956-Section 53 (2).

AIR 2011 SC 773, 2011(4) ALD6 (SC), 2011 3 AWC 2368 SC,(SCSuppl) 2011(2) CHN 37, 112(2011) CLT 198 (SC), 2011(2)CTC 820, [2011(2) JCR 22(SC)], JT 2011(1) SC 430,2011(2) KCCR SN 107, 2011-3-LW 183, 2011(3) MhLj 740,2011(3) MPHT 252, 2011(3)PLJR 123, 2011(1) RCR (Civil)860, 2011 113 RD 500,RLW2011(1) SC 1030, 2011(1)SCALE 605, (2011) 3 SCC 556,[2011] 2 SCR 196.

44. Shankara Co-op HousingSociety Ltd. v. M. Prabhakarand Ors. (05.05.2011)

Displaced Persons(Compensation andRehabilitation) Act 1954-Section12, 12(1), 24, 33 & 36Administration of EvacueeProperty Act, 1950-Section 2, 4,4(1), 7, 7(1), 8, 8(1), 8 (4), 24,27, 28, 40, 46 & 48 LandAcquisition Act Recovery ofDebts Due to Banks andFinancial Institutions Act, 1993-Section 20 Code of CriminalProcedure Section 311Administration of EvacueeProperty (Central) Rules 1950-Rule 6 Administration ofEvacuee Property (Central) Rules1950-Rules 25 Constitution ofIndia-Article 136, 226 & 227Code of Civil Procedure -Section9 Hindu Law.

AIR 2011 SC 2161, 2011(4)ALLMR (SC) 407, RLW 2011(3)SC 2093, 2011(5) SCALE 423,(2011) 5 SCC 607.

45. Shehammal v. Hasan KhaniRawther and Ors.(02.08.2011)

Transfer of Property Act, 1882-Section 2 & 6 Indian ContractAct, 1872-Section 23 IndianEvidence Act-Section 115Mulla’s “Principles ofMahomedan Law”-Section 54.

AIR 2011 SC 3609, 2011 5AWC 4353 SC, 4 (2011) CCR790, JT 2011(8) SC 533,2011(3) KLT 504 (SC), 2011-4-LW 341, (2011) 7 MLJ 789(SC), 2011(3) RCR (Civil) 894,2011(8) SCALE 186.

46. Smt. Har Devi Asnani v.State of Rajasthan and Ors.(27.09.2011)

Rajasthan Stamp Act, 1998-Section 29, 35, 65 & 65(1)Securitisation andReconstruction of FinancialAssets and Enforcement ofSecurity Interest Act, 2002-Section 17 & 17(2) RegistrationAct, 1908 Indian Stamp (A.P.Amendment) Act, 1998-Section47A (1) Constitution of India-Article 14, 19, 226 & 227 StampAct 1899-Section 47A.

2011(4) KLT (SN) 55, 2011(11)SCALE 121.

47. Smt. Ramkanya Bai and Anr.v. Jagdish and Ors.(04.07.2011)

Indian Easements Act, 1882-Section 18 & 50 MadhyaPradesh Land Revenue Code1959-Section 44, 131, 131(1),131(2), 242, 242(1), (2), (3), (5)& 257 Code of Civil Procedure -Section 9.

AIR 2011 SC 3258, 2011 4AWC 3901 SC, 112(2011) CLT630 (SC), JT 2011(7) SC 515,(2011) 7MLJ797 (SC), 2011(7)SCALE 50, (2011) 7 SCC 452.

Page 133: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 371

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

48. State of Haryana and Ors. v.Praduman Singh (D) by L.Rs. (15.02.2011)

Displaced Persons(Compensation andRehabilitation) Act 1954-Section20(1).

AIR 2011 SC 1501, 2011(2)ALLMR (SC) 990, (SCSuppl)2011(2) CHN46, [2011(2) JCR71 (SC)], JT 2011(6) SC 667,2011(2) KLJ 8, 2011(3) RCR(Civil) 626, 2011(2) SCALE 624,(2011) 11 SCC 550, [2011] 2SCR 932.

49. State of Haryana v. MukeshKumar and Ors.(30.09.2011)

Limitation Act, 1980. 2011 GLH (3) 592, 2011(4)KLT (SN) 63, 2011-5-LW725,2011(11) SCALE 266.

50. State of Jharkhand and Ors.v. Pakur Jagran Manch andOrs. (12.01.2011)

Santhal Parganas Tenancy(Supplementary Provisions) Act,1949-Section 2, 2(1), 24, 25A,38, 38 (1), 38 (2), 67 & 69 Biharand Orissa General Clauses Act-Section 21 & 24 SanthalParganas Settlement Regulations1872-Regulations Regulations10, 13, 14, 24, 25, 25(2) &25(3).

AIR 2011 SC 675, [2011(2) JCR15 (SC)], JT 2011(3) SC 84,2011(1) SCALE 309, (2011) 2SCC 591, [2011] 1 SCR 687.

51. State of Rajasthan and Ors.v. Jeev Raj and Ors.(11.08.2011)

Land Revenue Act-Section 259. 2011 6 AWC (Supp) 5915 SC2011 114 RD 448, 2011(9)SCALE 99.

52. State of Uttarakhand andOrs. v. Harpal Singh Rawat(17.02.2011)

Indian Stamp Act 1899-Section2(16) Indian Stamp Act 1899-Schedule-Article 35 IndianStamp Act 1899-Section 2(16)Indian Stamp Act 1899-Schedule-Article 57 Mines andMinerals (Regulation andDevelopment) Act, 1957-Section3 Transfer of Property Act-Section 105 Uttar Pradesh Stamp(Amendment) Act, 1962.

AIR 2011 SC 1506, 2011 3AWC 2289 SC, 2011(2) CTC584, JT 2011(2) SC 481,2011(2) KCCR SN 170, 2011(4)MhLJ 532 (SC), (2011) 7 MLJ332, 2011(2) PLJR 88, 2011(2)RCR (Civil) 757, 2011 112 RD690, 2011(2) SCALE 643,(2011) 4 SCC 575, 2011(1) UD138.

53. State of Uttaranchal andAnr. v. Sunil Kumar Vaishand Ors. (16.08.2011)

Uttar Pradesh ZamindariAbolition and Land ReformsAct, 1950 Uttar Pradesh LandAcquisition (Rehabilitation ofRefugees) Act, 1948-Section 9 &129 Uttar Pradesh PublicPremises (Eviction ofUnauthorised Occupants) Act,1972-Section 4 Transfer ofProperty Act-Section 108 (Q).

2011 5 AWC (Supp) 5390 SC,JT 2011(10) SC 26, 2011(9)SCALE 131, (2011) 8 SCC 670.

54. State of Uttaranchal v.Golden Forest Co. (P) Ltd.(11.04.2011)

Uttar Pradesh ReorganizationAct, 2000-Section 91 UttarPradesh Zamindari Abolitionand Land Reforms Act, 1950-Section 154(1), 166, 167 &167(2).

AIR 2011 SC 1723, 2011 4AWC 4210 SC, JT 2011(6) SC619, 2011(4) SCALE 512,2011(1) UD 279.

55. Suraj Lamp and IndustriesPvt. Ltd. v. State of Haryanaand Anr. (11.10.2011)

Specific Relief Act, 1963-Section3 Transfer of Property Act,1882-Section 5, 40, 53A, 54 &55 Registration Act, 1908-Section 17 & 49 Indian StampAct, 1999 Powers of AttorneyAct, 1882-Section 1A & 2 IndianSuccession Act, 1925-Section 69

2011(6) ALT1 (SC), 2011(6)CTC 90, 183 (2011) DLT1 (SC),2011-5-LW289, (2011) 8 MLJ43 (SC), 2011(4) RCR (Civil)669, 2011(11) SCALE 438.

Page 134: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

372 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

& 70 Trusts Act-Section 91Indian Stamp Act 1899-Section27 Registration and OtherRelated laws (Amendment) Act2001 Contract Act.

56. T.V. Venugopal v. UshodayaEnterprises Ltd. and Anr.(03.03.2011)

Copyright Act, 1957-Section 45& 45(1) Trade and MerchandiseMarks Act, 1958-Section 21 &46 Trade Marks Act, 1999-Section 100 & 159(4) FederalAnti Dilution Act, 1996 TradeMark Rules 1959-Rule 24(3)Limitation Act, 1963-Section 22Code of Civil Procedure -Order2 Rule 2(3).

JT 2011(3) SC 225, MIPR2011(1) 219, (2011) 2 MLJ 849(SC), 2011(45) PTC 433 (SC),2011(3) SCALE 182, (2011) 4SCC 85.

57. Tamil Nadu Housing Boardv. The Service Society andAnr. (04.03.2011)

Land Acquisition Act. JT 2011(7) SC 13, 2011(3) RCR(Civil) 546, (2011) 11 SCC 13.

58. Tata Motors Ltd. v. Talathiof Village Chikhali and Ors.(04.07.2011)

Maharashtra Regional andTown Planning Act, 1966-Section 113, 113A, 113(1),13(2), 113(3A), 113(4), 114,114(1), 116, 118, 118 (1) & 159Maharasthra Land RevenueCode 1966-Section 2(11), 2(12),2(19), 2(23), 2(40), 38, 39, 115,168, 168 (1), 168 (2) & 174Pimpri Chinchwad New TownDevelopment Authority(Disposal of Land) Regulation1973-Regulations Regulations 1,5, 10 & 16.

JT 2011(7) SC 407, 2011(7)SCALE 93, (2011) 7 SCC 594.

59. Umerkhan v. Bismillabi @Babulal Shaikh and Ors.(28.07.2011)

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section 96, 100, 101 & 103.

[2011(4) JCR 61 (SC)] JT2011(12) SC 1, 2011(3) KLT(SN) 106, 2011-4-LW 623,2011(II) OLR (SC) 702, 2011(3)RCR (Civil) 872, 2011 114 RD369, 2011(8) SCALE 85.

60. Union of India (UOI) andAnr. v. Shankari Devi andAnr. (10.02.2011)

Requisitioning and Acquisitionof Immovable Property Act,1952-Section 7(1).

2011 2 AWC 1897 SC, 2011(2)SCALE 444.

61. Vimaleshwar Nagappa Shetv. Noor Ahmed Sheriff andOrs. (11.05.2011)

Partition Act 1893-Section 4Specific Relief Act, 1963-Section20 Code of Civil Procedure -Section 96(3).

2011 4 AWC 3990 SC,(SCSuppl) 2011(3) CHN184,[2011(3) JCR 314 (SC)] 2011(5)KarLJ 77, 2011-4-LW 814,(2011) 7 MLJ 402 (SC), 2011113 RD 528, 2011(5) SCALE596.

RIGHT TO INFORMATION

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Central Board of SecondaryEducation and Anr. v. AdityaBandopadhyay and Ors.(09.08.2011)

Right to Information Act, 2005-Section 2, 3, 4, 4(1), 4(2), 4(3),4(4), 5, 6, 7, 7(9), 8, 8 (1), 8 (3),9, 10, 11, 19(8), 22 & 24Official Secrets Act, 1923Freedom to Information Act,2002-Section 8 Constitution of

2011 6 AWC (Supp) 5567 SC,[2011(4) JCR 14 (SC)], JT2011(9) SC 212, 2011(3) KLT(SN) 117, 2011-4-LW 289,(2011) 7 MLJ 1237 (SC),2011(5) MPHT 1, 2011(II) OLR(SC) 746, 2011(3) RCR (Civil)

Page 135: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 373

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

India-Article 14, 19 & 19(1)Maharashtra Secondary andHigher Secondary Board Rules,1977-Rule 104, 104(1) &104(3).

914, 2011(8) SCALE 645,(2011) 8 SCC 497.

2. Chief Information Commr.and Anr. v. State of Manipurand Anr. (12.12.2011)

Right to Information Act-Section2, 3, 4(1), 6, 7, 7(1), 7(2), 7(3),7(8), 8, 9, 11, 18, 18(1), 18(3),18(4), 19, 19(1), 19(3), 19(4),19(5), 19(6), 19(8), 20, 24 &27(2) Central InformationCommission (Appeal Procedure)Rules, 2005-Rule 5 Constitutionof India-Article 19, 19(1), 19(2)& 21.

2011(13) SCALE 460.

3. Ram Jethmalani and Ors. v.Union of India (UOI) andOrs. (04.07.2011)

Right to Information Act, 2005Constitution of India-Article 14,19, 21, 26, 26(1), 31 & 32.

2011(4) ALLMR (SC) 815, JT2011(7) SC 104, 2011(3) KLT(SN) 47, 2011(3) RCR (Civil)643, 2011(3) RCR (Criminal)480, 2011(6) SCALE 691,(2011) 8 SCC 1.

4. Sanchit Bansal and Anr. v.The Joint Admission Board(JAB) and Ors. (11.10.2011)

Right to Information Act, 2005. 2011(11) SCALE 593.

5. The Institute of CharteredAccountants of India v.Shaunak H. Satya and Ors.(02.09.2011)

Chartered Accountants Act,1949-Section 3 Right toInformation Act, 2005-Section 2,3, 4, 4(1), 8, 8(1), 8(3), 9, 10 &11 Chartered Accountants Act,1948 Copyright Act, 1957-Section 51, 52, 52(1)Constitution of India-Article 12Chartered AccountantsRegulations 1988-RegulationsRegulations 38, 39(2), 39(4) &42.

JT 2011(10) SC 128, 2011(4)KLT (SN) 17, 2011-5-LW 299,2011(4) RCR (Civil) 336,2011(9) SCALE 639, (2011)8SCC 781, [2011] 109 SCL 200(SC).

SALES TAX

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Agarwal Oil RefineryCorporation, Kanpur v. TheCommissioner of Trade Tax,U.P. Lucknow (10.08.2011)

Uttar Pradesh Trade Tax Act,1948-Section 3A, 4A, 10, 10(1),10(2), 10(3), 10(4), 10(5), 11 &22 Limitation Act, 1963-Section5 Uttar Pradesh Trade TaxRules-Rule 41(7).

AIR 2011 SC 2932, 2011(187)ECR 233 (SC), JT 2011(9) SC25, 2011(8) SCALE 536, (2011)43 VST 296 (SC).

2. Aluva Sugar Agency v. Stateof Kerala (07.09.2011)

Kerala General Sales Tax Act,1963-Section 5.

2011(188) ECR 100 (SC),2011(272) ELT 649 (SC),2011(10) SCALE 167 (2011) 45VST1 (SC).

3. Assistant Commercial TaxesOfficer v. Makkad PlasticAgencies (29.03.2011)

Rajasthan Sales Tax Act, 1994-Section 29(7), 37, 84 & 86Income Tax Act-Section 154 &263 Uttar Pradesh Sales Tax(Amendment) Act, 1995-Section22 & 39(2).

2011(185) ECR 116 (SC), JT2011(4) SC 203, 2011(4) SCALE27, (2011) 4 SCC 750, (2011) 42VST 1 (SC).

Page 136: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

374 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

4. Commercial Taxes Officer v.Jalani Enterprises(17.03.2011)

Rajasthan Sales Tax Act CentralSales Tax Act.

2011(186) ECR 130 (SC),2011(266) ELT 289 (SC), JT2011(4) SC 507, 2011(3)SCALE 609, (2011) 4 SCC386, (2011) 39 VST 421 (SC).

5. Commissioner of Trade Tax,U.P. v. Varun BeveragesLimited (11.04.2011)

Uttar Pradesh Trade Tax Act-Section 4, 4A & 4A (4) Sales TaxAct-Section 4A Industries(Development and Regulation)Act, 1951-Section 11B.

2011(185) ECR 259 (SC),2011(267) ELT 147 (SC), JT2011(4) SC 466, 2011(4)SCALE 625, (2011) 11 SCC308, (2011) 40 VST 240 (SC).

6. Deepa Panels v. State ofKerala (12.07.2011)

Karnataka General Sales Tax Act-Section 5A.

2011(9) SCALE 108.

7. Hyderabad EngineeringIndustries v. State of AndhraPradesh (04.03.2011)

Central Sales Tax Act, 1956-Section 2, 3, 3(2), 6, 6A & 9Companies Act, 1956 AndhraPradesh General Sales Tax Act,1957 Sales of Goods Act-Section4(1).

2011(184) ECR 273 (SC), JT2011(3) SC 117, 2011(3)KCCR SN 284, 2011(3)SCALE 268, (2011) 4 SCC705, (2010) 39 VST 257(SC).

8. Epsico India Holdings Ltd.v. Commissioner of TradeTax, Lucknow, U.P.(05.04.2011)

Uttar Pradesh Trade Tax Act-Section 3B, 3F, 4B (6), 7, 8(1),8(1A), 8(1B) & 11.

2011(185) ECR 266 (SC), JT2011(4) SC 145, 2011(4)SCALE 269, (2011) 40 VST220 (SC).

9. Saraf Trading Corporationetc. Etc. v. State of Kerala(13.01.2011)

Kerala General Sales Tax Act,1963-Section 44, 44(1), 44(2) &44(3) Central Sales Tax Act, 1956-Section 5, 5(1) & 5(3) CentralExcise Act, 1944-Section 11BConstitution of India-Article 265& 286.

2011(183) ECR 232 (SC),2011(264) ELT 8 (SC), JT2011(3) SC 77, 2011(1)SCALE 401, (2011) 2 SCC344, [2011] 1 SCR 371, (2011)38 VST 1 (SC).

10. State of Jharkhand and Ors.Etc. v. Shivam CokeIndustries, Dhanbad, etc.(10.08.2011)

Bihar Finance Act 1981-Section 9,9(5), 45, 45(1), 45(2), 46, 46(2),46(3) & 46(4) Central Sales TaxAct, 1956-Section 3 Bihar Finance(Amendment) Act 1984-Section 10Limitation Act, 1963-Section 137Limitation Act, 1963-Schedule-Article 137 Bihar Finance(Amendment) Ordinance 1989-Section 7 & 7(4) Constitution ofIndia-Article 14.

2011(187) ECR 111 (SC),[2011(4) JCR 48 (SC) ], JT2011(8) SC 12, 2011(8)SCALE 571, (2011) 8 SCC656, (2011) 43 VST 279 (SC).

11. State of Tamil Nadu andand. v. India Cements Ltd.and Anr. (21.04.2011)

Tamil Nadu General Sales TaxAct, 1959-Section 17A TamilNadu General Sales Tax Act,1959-Section 28A Central SalesTax Act, 1956-Section 8 (5) &9(2) Central Excise Act, 1944-Section 37B Customs Act, 1962-Section 151A.

2011(185) ECR 106 (SC), JT2011(5) SC 143, 2011(4)SCALE 843, (2011) 40 VST225 (SC).

12. United Riceland Ltd. v. Stateof Haryana and Anr.(07.01.2011)

Haryana General Sales Tax Act,1973-Section 2, 6, 9, 9(1), 15,15(1), 15A, 17 & 18 HaryanaGeneral Sales Tax (Amendment)1993 Haryana General Sales Tax(Amendment) Act, 1991 CentralSales Tax Act, 1956-Section 5Haryana General Sales Tax(Second Amendment) Ordinance1990 Constitution of India-Article213(2), 286, 286(1) & 367(2).

2011(183) ECR 238 (SC), JT2011(1) SC 332, 2011(1)SCALE 180, (2011) 2 SCC423, [2011] 1 SCR 186, (2011)37 VST 599 (SC).

Page 137: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 375

SERVICE TAX

Sl. No. Partiname Act/Legislation Referred Citation

1. Idea Mobile CommunicationLtd. v. C.C.E. and C.(04.08.2011)

Finance Act, 1994-Section 65(72) & 65 (105, 67).

Kerala General Sales Tax Act,1963.

(2011) 243 CTR (SC) 1,2011(187) ECR 131 (SC), JT2011(8) SC 640, 2011(8) SCALE227.

Central Excise Act, 1944-Section35B.

Constitution of India-Article248.

Finance Act, 1994-Section 65, 75& 76.

2. P.C. Paulose, SparkwayEnterprises v. Commissionerof Central Excise andCustoms (13.01.2011)

AIR Ports Authority of IndiaAct, 1994-Section 3.

JT 2011(1) SC 465, 2011(1)SCALE 420(2011) 2 SCC 230[2011] 1 SCR 872.

3. UPSRTC v. Commissioner ofCentral Excise and ServiceTax (12.01.2011)

Finance Act, 1994-Section 65Motor Vehicles Act.

2011 (186) ECR 165 (SC),[2011] 30 STT 402.

4. Union of India (UOI) andAn. v. Association of UnifiedTelecom Service Providers ofIndia and Ors. (11.10.2011)

State Excise Act TelecomRegulatory Authority of IndiaAct, 1997-Section 18, 2, 11(1),14, 14(1) & 18.

2011(2) SCALE 24.

Indian Tolls Act, 1851-Section 2Indian Telegraph Act, 1885-Section 2, 4, 4(1) & 4(2).

Telecom Regulatory Authority ofIndia (Amendment) Act, 2000Constitution of India-Article 14,19(1), 32, 136 & 226.

TENANCY

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

1. Abdul Khader (D) by L. Rs.v. Tarabai and Ors.(02.05.2011)

Karnataka Certain InamsAbolition Act, 1977-Section 4, 5,5(1) & 5(3) Karnataka LandReforms Act, 1961-Section45,79A & 142(1).

AIR 2011 SC 2229, JT 2011(5)SC 160, 2011(5) SCALE 266,(2011) 6 SCC 199.

Hyderabad Abolition of InamsAct, 1955 Hyderabad Tenancyand Agricultural Lands Act,1950.

2. Banatwala and Company v.L.I.C. of India and Anr.(19.09.2011)

10 Maharashtra HousingMaharashtra Rent Control Act,1999-Section 1, 2, 2(1), 3, 3 (1),7(6), 8 (3), 16(1) & 29 PublicPremises (Eviction ofUnauthorized Occupants) Act,1971-Section 1(3), 2, 3, 5, 7, 9,10, 11, 13, 14 & 15 LifeInsurance Corporation Act,1956-Section 21 Transfer ofProperty Act, 1882-Section 105,108 & 108B Indian ContractAct, 1872 Bombay Rents Hotel

AIR 2011 SC 3619, 2011(4)RCR (Civil) 627, 2011(10)SCALE 652.

Page 138: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

376 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

and Lodging House Rates(Control) Act, 1947-Section 11& 24 State Bank of India Act,1955 State Bank of India(Subsidiary Banks) Act, 1959Banking Companies (Acquisitionand Transfer of Undertaking)Act, 1970-Section 3 ReserveBank of India Act, 1934-Section2 Maharashtra MunicipalCouncil Nagar Panchayats andIndustrial Townships Act 1965-Section 20& 21 MaharashtraHousing and Area DevelopmentAct, 1976-Section 8, 18 & 33Bombay Rents Hotel Rates andLodging House Rates (Control)Act, 1944 Central Provinces andBerar Regulation of Letting ofAccommodation Act, 1946Hyderabad Houses (RentEviction and Lease) Control Act1954 Public Premises (Evictionof Unauthorised Occupants)Amendment Act, 1980Companies Act, 1956-Section 3Institutes of Technology Act,1961 Major Port Trusts Act,1963 Punjab Reorganisation Act,1966-Section 79 Punjab & 80(6)Cantonments Act 1924 InterestAct, 1978 Delhi Rent ControlAct, 1958 Slum Areas(Improvement and Clearance)Act, 1956-Section 14A, 19 &19(1) Slum Areas (Improvementand Clearance) Act, 1956-Section 39 Uttar PradeshSugarcane (Regulation of Supplyand Purchase) Act, 1953Industries (Development andRegulation) Act, 1951-Section18G Tamil Nadu Public Men(Criminal Misconduct) Act,1973 Prevention of CorruptionAct, 1947-Section 5(1) & 5(2)Criminal Law Amendment Act,1952 Karnataka ContractCarriages (Acquisition) Act,1976 Motor Vehicles Act, 1988Industrial Disputes Act, 1947-Section 10, 25F, 25J(2) &33C(2) Andhra Pradesh Shopsand Establishments Act, 1966-Section 41(1) & 41(3) RajasthanShops and Establishments Act,1958-Section 28A ElectricityAct, 1910 Maharashtra Controlof Organized Crime Act, 1999Telegraph Act, 1885 UnlawfulActivities (Prevention Act), 1967Bombay Rent Act-Section 4 &4(1) Bombay Housing Board

Page 139: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 377

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Act, 1948 Bombay Public TrustsAct, 1950 Bombay IndustrialRelation Act, 1946 Constitutionof India-Article 14, 226, 227,254, 254(1) & 254(2) Code ofCivil Procedure Indian PenalCode-Section 161, 468 & 471Central Provinces and BerarLetting of Houses and RentControl Order 1949 BankingCompanies (Acquisition andTransfer of Undertaking) Act,1980-Section 3 Bombay RentRestriction Act, 1939 KarnatakaRent Control Act, 1961.

3. Bandaru Satyanarayana v.Imandi Anasuya and Ors.(11.04.2011)

Andhra Pradesh (Andhra Area)Tenancy Act, 1956-Section 16Constitution of India-Article 226& 227.

2011(6) SCALE 489.

4. Board of Trustees of the Portof Mumbai v. ByramjeeJeejeebhoy Pvt. Ltd. andAnr. (08.04.2011)

Bombay Rents Hotel andLodging House Rates ControlAct, 1947-Section 5(3) BombayRents Hotel and Lodging HouseRates Control Act, 1947-Section5(8), 13, 13(1), 14, 15, 15A,15(1), 15(2), 22 & 28 Transferof Property Act-Section 106, 108& 114A Maharashtra RentControl Act, 1999 BombayRents Hotel and Lodging HouseRates Control (Amendment) Act,1973.

AIR 2011 SC 1793, 2011(3)ALLMR (SC) 431, 2011(3)BomCR 563, (SCSuppl) 2011(3)CHN 150, JT 2011(4) SC 473,2011(4) MhLJ 556 (SC), 2011(4)SCALE 454, (2011) 5 SCC 128.

5. Cantonment Board and Anr.v. Church of North India(13.05.2011)

Cantonment Act 1924-Section116, 116A & 280 PublicPremises (Eviction ofUnauthorised Occupants) Act,1971-Section 2, 2(1), 2(2), 4, 5& 9 Rent Control Act Transferof Property Act, 1882-Section106, 106(1) & 107 PublicPremises (Eviction ofUnauthorised Occupants)(Amendment) Act, 1993Transfer of Property RulesCantonment LandAdministration Rules 1937.

AIR 2011 SC 2339, 2011 3AWC 3161 SC, 2011(4) BomCR66, JT 2011(6) SC 49, 2011(3)RCR (Civil) 426, 2011(1) RCR(Rent) 448, 2011(6) SCALE 229.

6. Dnyaneshwar RanganathBhandare and Anr. v. SadhuDadu Shettigar (Shetty) andAnr. (30.09.2011)

Bombay Rents Hotel andLodging House Rates ControlAct, 1947-Section 11 & 24(4)Constitution of India-Article136.

2011(4) KLT (SN) 56, 2011(11)SCALE 215.

7. Dunlop India Limited v.A.A. Rahna and Anr.(04.05.2011)

Kerala Buildings (Lease and RentControl) Act 1965-Section 2(1),11, 11(1), 11(2), 11(3), 11(4), 15& 18 Sick Industrial Companies(Special Provisions) Act, 1985-Section 15, 16, 17(3), 22 &22(1) Haryana Urban (Controlof Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973-Section 13(2) Bombay Rents

AIR 2011 SC 2198, 2011(2)KLT 682, 2011(1) RCR (Rent)354, 2011(5) SCALE 312,(2011) 5 SCC 778.

Page 140: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

378 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Hotel and Lodging Houses RatesControl Act, 1947-Section 13(1)Karnataka Rent Control Act-Section 50(1).

8. Harjit Singh Uppal v. AnupBansal (13.05.2011)

East Punjab Urban RentRestriction Act, 1949-Section 13,13(2), 15, 15(1) & 35A Code ofCivil Procedure, 1908-Section91, 92, 95, 97, 104, 105, 105(1)& 105(2).

2011(6) CTC 563, JT 2011(6)SC 236, (2011) 163 PLR 520,2011(3) RCR (Civil) 247,2011(1) RCR (Rent) 438,2011(6) SCALE 406, (2011) 11SCC 672.

9. Indra Vikram Singh and Ors.v. State of M.P. and Anr.(20.01.2011)

Vindhya Pradesh Abolition ofJagirs and Land Reforms Act,1952-Section 10 (2) MadhyaPradesh Swatwadharik AdhikarSampati (Vindhya Pradesh)Adhiniyam 1965-Section 3.

JT 2011(3) SC 564, 2011(3)SCALE 528, (2011) 11 SCC 531.

10. Kannachankandy Chandranand Ors. v. PeetikakandyAchuthan and Ors.(11.04.2011)

Kerala Buildings (Lease and RentControl) Act 1965-Section 11(2),11(3) & 11(4).

Uttar Pradesh Urban BuildingAct, 1972-Section 21 & 21(1).

11. Mehmood Rahmat UllahKhan and Anr. v. NiyazAhmad Khan (23.02.2011)

Uttar Pradesh Urban BuildingAct, 1972-Section 21 & 21(1).

(SCSuppl) 2011(3) CHN121,112(2011) CLT 127 (SC),2011(2) RCR (Rent) 475.

12. Mohammad Ahmad andAnr. v. Atma Ram Chauhanand Ors. (13.05.2011)

Rent Act Constitution of India-Article 226 Constitution ofIndia-Article 227.

AIR 2011 SC 1940, 2011 4AWC 3741 SC, 2011(4) BomCR74, 2011(4) CTC 218,179(2011) DLT 532, ILR2011(2) Kerala 851, JT 2011(6)SC 189, 2011(2) KLJ 39, (2011)162 PLR 711, 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 972, 2011(1) RCR (Rent)394, RLW 2011(2) SC 1809,2011(6) SCALE 265, (2011) 7SCC 755, 2011(1) UD 503.

13. Mritunjoy Sett (D) by L. Rs.v. Jadunath Basak (D) by L.Rs. (26.04.2011)

West Bengal Premises TenancyAct, 1956-Section 13 & 13(6)Transfer of Property Act-Section106 Indian Evidence Act, 1872-Section 17 & 32(2) Code of CivilProcedure, 1908-Section 100.

AIR 2011 SC 2496, (SCSuppl)2011(3) CHN110, JT 2011(5)SC 358, 2011(2) RCR (Civil)894, 2011(5) SCALE 32, (2011)11 SCC 402.

14. Secretary/General ManagerChennai Central CooperativeBank Ltd. and Anr. v. S.Kamalaveni Sundaram(04.01.2011)

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section 34.

2011(2) ALD 91 (SC), 2011 1AWC (Supp) 577 SC, 2011(3)BomCR 87, (SCSuppl) 2011(2)CHN 227, 2011(1) CTC 253, JT2011(1) SC 97, 2011(3) MhLJ38 (SC), 2011 MPLJ 299 (SC),2011(2) PLJR 19, 2011(2) RCR(Civil) 906, 2011(1) RCR (Rent)375, 2011(1) SCALE 21, (2011)1 SCC 790, [2011] 1 SCR 66.

15. Syndicate Bank v.Ramachandran Pillai andOrs. (04.01.2011)

Public Premises (Eviction ofUnauthorized Occupants) Act,1971-Section 3 Rent Control ActLand Reforms Act, 1963.

2011(1) SCALE 368.

16. The National TextileCorporation Ltd. v.Nareshkumar BadrikumarJagad and Ors. (05.09.2011)

Textile Undertakings (Takingover of Management) Act, 1983Textile Undertakings(Nationalisation) Act, 1995-

JT 2011(10) SC 414, 2011(2)RCR (Rent) 293, 2011(10)SCALE 28.

Page 141: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 379

Sl. No. Party Name Act Citation

Section 2, 3, 3(1), 3(2) & 4(6)Bombay Rents Hotel andLodging House Rates ControlAct, 1947 Maharashtra RentControl Act, 1999-Section 3(1)Food Corporation Act, 1964Punjab Municipalities Act 1911Companies Act-Section 619Companies Act-Section 620Indian Contract Act, 1872-Section 182 & 230 Code of CivilProcedure -Section 115 Code ofCivil Procedure -Order 8 Rule 2& 14 Constitution of India-Article 12, 136 & 285 Code ofCivil Procedure (Amendment)Act, 2002 Income Tax Act,1961.

17. V. Sumatiben MaganlalManani (dead) by LegalRepresentatives vs.Uttamchand KashiprasadShah and Anr. (04.07.2011)

Bombay Rent Act-Section 13(1). 2011(4) ALLMR (SC) 841, 2011GLH (2) 726, JT 2011(7) SC 79,2011(II) OLR (SC) 230, 2011(2)RCR (Rent) 276, 2011(6)SCALE 621, (2011) 7 SCC 328.

TRUST

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

1. A.P. DAIR y DevelopmentCorporation Federation vs.B.Narasimha Reddy and Ors.(02.09.2011)

Andhra Pradesh Mutually AidedCo-operative Societies(Amendment) Act, 2006 AndhraPradesh Mutually Aided Co-operative operative Societies ActAndhra Pradesh Mutually AidedCo-operative 1995.

AIR 2011 SC 3298, JT 2011(10)SC 145, 2011(9) SCALE 688.

Andhra Pradesh Co-operative1964.

Companies Act, 1956.

East Punjab Urban RentRestriction (Amendment) Act,1956.

Societies Registration Act, 1860Hindi Sahitya Sammelan ActRent Act.

Constitution of India-Article 12,14, 15(4), 16, 19 & 19(1).

Andhra Pradesh Co-operativeSocieties Rules.

2. Akhil Bhartiya UpbhoktaCongress v. State of MadhyaPradesh and Ors.(06.04.2011)

Act: Madhya Pradesh NagarTatha Gram Nivesh Adhiniyam,1973-Section 13, 14, 15, 16, 17,18, 19, 19(5), 20, 21, 22, 23A,23A(1), 23A(2), 23(1), 23(4),24(1), 24(2), 24(3), 25(1), 26,38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44,45,46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 53, 54,55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62,63A & 85.

AIR 2011 SC 1834, 2011 4 JT2011(4) SC 311, 2011(II) MPJR(SC) 1, 2011(4) SCALE355(2011) 5 SCC 29.

Page 142: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

380 National Law University, Delhi

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

Constitution of India-Article 14,21 & 39.

Madhya Pradesh Public TrustsAct, 1951-Section 2, 4, 5, 6, 8,11, 32 & 33.

Indian Trusts Act, 1882-Section3, 5 & 6.

Constitution of India (Forty-second Amendment) Act, 1976.

Madhya Pradesh Nagar TathaGram Nivesh Viksit BhoomiyoGriho Bhavano Tatha AnyaSanrachanao Ka Vyayan Niyam,1975-Rule 3, 4, 5, 5A to 27, 28,29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36,37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44,45, 46, 47 & 48.

Madhya Pradesh Nagar TathaGram Nivesh Adhiniyam, 2005.

Madhya Pradesh Government ofBusiness Rules.

Madhya Pradesh Nagar TathaGram Nivesh Regulations-Regulations 3 & 5.

Madhya Pradesh Zila YojanaSamiti Adhiniyam, 1995.

3. Allahabad High SchoolSociety, Allahabad and Anr.v. State of U.P. and Ors.(12.05.2011)

Uttar Pradesh SocietiesRegistration Act, 1860-Section3A(5), 4(1), 12D & 12D(1).

AIR 2011 SC 1969 JT 2011(6)SC 250, 2011(6) SCALE 45,(2011) 6 SCC 118.

Indian Penal Code-Section 409,420, 467, 468 & 471.

Allahabad High Schools SocietyRules, 1952-Rule 11 & 38.

Constitution of India-Article 136Anglo-Indian Education Code.

4. Divya Exports v. ShalimarVideo Company and Ors.(02.09.2011 )

Copyright Act, 1957 IndianTrusts Act, 1881-Section 73Indian Trusts Act, 1881-Section74 Code of Civil Procedure,1908-Order 41 Rule 24.

AIR 2011 SC 3063, 2011(9)SCALE 630.

5. Dr. T. Varghese George v.Kora K. George and Ors.(13.10.2011)

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section 11, 41, 53, 92, 92(1) &92(2).

JT 2011(12) SC 108, 2011(11)SCALE 617.

Tamil Nadu Recognized PrivateSchools (Regulation) Act, 1973-Section 11, 41 & 53.

Constitution of India-Article 26,29(1), 30 & 30 (1).

Religious Endowments Act,1863.

Page 143: LIST OF CASES OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA, · PDF fileApp. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 ARBITRATION ... Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 299. Motor Vehicles Act,

App. 1—List of Cases of Supreme Court of India, 2011 381

Sl. No. Party Name Act/Legislation Referred Citation

6. MIG Cricket Club v.Abhinav Sahakar EducationSociety and Ors. (05.09.2011)

Societies Registration Act, 1860Maharashtra Regional andTown Planning Act, 1966-Section 31, 31(1), 31(2), 35 &37(2).

2011(6) BomCR 546 JT2011(10) SC 394, 2011(6) MhLJ742 (SC) 2011(10) SCALE 8(2011) 9 SCC 97.

7. P. Seshadri v. S. MangatiGopal Reddy and Ors.(29.03.2011)

Tirumala TirupathiDevasthanam Act, 1932-Section96.

AIR 2011 SC 1883, 2011(4)SCALE 41, (2011) 5 SCC 484,(2011) 2 SCC (L& S) 46.

Hindu Charitable and ReligiousInstitutions Act, 1989.

Tirumala TirupathiDevasthanams EmployeesService Rules, 1989-Rule 2 &13. Constitution of India-Article226.

8. Parasamaya KolerinathaMadam, Tirunelveli v. P.Natesa Achari and Ors.(22.09. 2011)

Tamil Nadu Hindu Religiousand Charitable Endowments Act,1959-Section 6(13), 6(20) TamilNadu Hindu Religious andCharitable Endowments Act,1959-Section 64(1).

JT 2011(11) SC 411, 2011(4)KLT (SN) 45, 2011(10) SCALE703.