locating central travelers’ groups in travel blogs’ social networks (accepted journal of...

Upload: kostas-zafiropoulos

Post on 29-May-2018

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    1/29

    Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social

    Networks

    Vasiliki Vrana,

    Assistant Professor, Department of Business Administration

    Technological Institute of Serres, [email protected], Terma

    Magnisias, 62124 Serres, Greece

    Kostas Zafiropoulos,

    Assistant Professor, Department of International and European

    Studies, University of Macedonia, [email protected], Egnatia 156, 54006

    Thessaloniki, Greece

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    2/29

    Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social

    Networks

    Abstract

    Purpose The paper, using Travelpod.com, aims to provide a

    methodology to locate central groups of travelers and to describe

    pattern characteristics of central travelers.

    Design/methodology/approach The paper uses snowball sampling

    to locate travelers and analyze their hyperlinks interconnections to

    identify central travelers groups. Analysis of the adjacency matrix of

    the social network of travelers using Multidimensional Scaling and

    Hierarchical Cluster Analysis to identify core travelers groups

    follows.

    Findings Seven % of travelers are considered as central travelers.

    They form core groups containing the most active and information

    providing travelers. Group membership is correlated with common

    travelers characteristics.

    Research limitations/implications Research is limited to a

    specific network of travelers, to a specific time interval, and to a

    specific sampling method. Repetition of the study in other travelers

    networks in several time instances using a full list of member

    travelers would help to generalize findings. Also other graph

    theoretic approaches, besides the statistical analysis used, could

    reveal more properties.

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    3/29

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    4/29

    reviews and recommendations are becoming the new digital form of

    word of mouth (Litvin et al., 2008; Schmallegger and Carson, 2008).

    Sigala (2009, p.221) mentioned as information is the lifeblood of

    tourism, the use and diffusion of Web 2.0 technologies have a

    substantial impact of both tourism demand and supply. Moreover,

    blogs are becoming a very important information source for interna-

    tional travelers for getting travel advice and suggestions. Blogs can

    impact on travelers evaluation of tourism products and decision

    making process. when reading others travel experiences

    through weblogs, this also creates to the reader the willingness to

    travel and visit the same destination claimed Sigala (2009, p.225).

    Xiang and Gretzel (2010) also highlighted the functions of blogs in

    creating and sharing new experiences, trustworthiness to online

    travelers and the use of blogs as marketing intelligence.

    Travel and tourism blogs take several different forms, but the

    majority of travel blogs are diaries of individuals about their trips

    (Lew, 2007). Many public travel blog sites, like travelblog.org,

    travelpod.com, blog.realtravel.com, yourtraveljournal.com,

    worldnomads.com and travelpost.com, have specialized in hosting

    these individual travel blogs (Pan et al., 2007; Schmallegger and

    Carson, 2008). Travel blogs can include comments, suggestions,

    advice, directions, maps, photos and videos, links to related websites

    hyperlinks, to external information, links to other travelers, RSS,

    trackbacks, comments, taglines, archives, permanent links and

    blogrolls (Blood, 2002; Sigala 2009). Travelers use blogs as a new

    way of sharing tour experiences with family and friends and with an

    international audience. Knowledge seeker tourists can get from blogs

    virtual experiences of trips, trend information for their destinations

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    5/29

    (Schmallegger and Carson , 2008; Sigala, 2007) and prepare their

    trips with confidence using subjective data unfiltered and free of

    marketing bias (Hepburn, 2007). Due to the unbiased information

    shared in blogs based on first-hand authentic travel experiences,

    many travelers tend to use and trust blogs information for searching

    for travel information, tips and selecting travel suppliers and

    destinations (Sigala 2009, p. 224).

    Blogging tools enable between-blog interactivity (Du and

    Wagner, 2006) thus social networks are established and relationships

    in the world of blogs are built (Efimova and de Moor, 2005; Sigala,

    2009). Finding blogs communication patterns is important since The

    discovery of information networks among websites or among site

    producers through the analysis of link counts and patterns, and

    exploration into motivations or contexts for linking, has been a key

    issue in this social science literature (Park and Jankofski 2008, p.

    62). Further, in the study field of blogging (especially in political

    blogging), it has been proved that blogs are organized around central

    focal point blogs, where most of the informative conversation is

    taking place (Drezner and Farrell, 2004). In this sense, travelers

    blogs may also be organized around central blogs. The latest may

    serve as the most influential travelers blogs where the most read

    posts appear. Thus, it is interesting to provide the tools and

    methodology to locate such central blogs groups. The paper aims at

    providing a methodology to locate central groups of travelers and to

    locate travelers that link to them. Finding central travelers is

    interesting and useful since one can locate them and study the

    information these influential travelers provide. The paper Favorite

    travelers lists and finds connectivity patterns between these groups

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    6/29

    of travelers: patterns of central travelers and patterns of travelers

    linking to them. The paper studies travelers interconnections through

    hyperlinks by using as a case study Travelpod.com.

    2. Conversation in the blogosphereBy definition, blogs link to other sources of information usually to

    other blogs. Barger (1997) who first used the term weblog, defined

    blog as a web page where a blogger logs all the other web pages

    he finds interesting. Drezner and Farrell (2004, p. 5) defined

    weblogs as A web page with minimal to no external editing,

    providing on-line commentary, periodically updated and presented in

    reverse chronological order, with hyperlinks to other online sources.

    Blogging tools provide the appropriate enhanced features for

    managing blog interactivity and promoting the creation of social

    networks among bloggers (Du and Wagner, 2006). Sigala (2008)

    based on Ying and Davis (2007) and Lento et al. (2006) studies

    mentioned blogs create and maintain strong online communities

    through their social ties tools such as blogrolls, permalinks,

    comments and trackbacks and Williams and Jacobs (2004)

    highlighted that interactivity is the key to the success of blogs and the

    other social network systems . Interactivity between blogs can be

    implemented with blogrolls, permalinks and comments and

    trackbacks. A blogroll is a list of blogs that many bloggers

    maintain and occupies a permanent position on the blogs home page.

    The list consists of the blogs that the blogger frequently reads or

    especially admires and offers links to these blogs. Blogrolls

    provide an excellent means of situating a bloggers interests and

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    7/29

    preferences within the blogosphere. Bloggers are likely to use their

    blogrolls to link other blogs that have shared interests mentioned

    Drezner and Farell (2004, p.7) and Marlow (2004, p.3) wrote This

    form evolved early in the development of the medium both as a type

    of social acknowledgement and as a navigational tool for readers to

    find other authors with similar interests. Albrecht et al. (2007, p.

    506) referred to this form as connectedness of weblogs.

    Interactivity can be also achieved through permalinks and

    comments. Comment tools are allowing readers to express their

    opinions on a weblog entry and permalinks are allowing weblogs link

    posts with one another. In that way, bloggers and readers can express

    thoughts and discuss their opinions through an iterative cycle of

    postings and comments (Drezner and Farell, 2004 ; Guo et al., 2008;

    Mishne and Glance, 2006). Such posts themselves link directly to a

    specific post on the other blog, and are a key form of information

    exchange in the blogosphere. Drezner and Farrell (2004) highlighted

    the fact that links and page views are the currency of the

    blogosphere.

    Last, are trackbacks and pingbacks. Trackback is a citation

    notification system (Brady, 2005) which informs bloggers of traffic

    to their original entries. It enables bloggers to determine when other

    bloggers have written another entry of their own that references their

    original post (Waggener Edstrom Worldwide, 2006). If both

    weblogs are enabled with trackback functionality, a reference from a

    post on weblog A to another post on weblog B will update the post

    on B to contain a back-reference to the post on A (Marlow, 2004)

    creating in that way a symmetrical link the original post (Efimova

    and de Moor, 2005). A pingback is an automated trackback.

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    8/29

    Pingbacks support auto-discovery where the software automatically

    finds out the links in a post, and automatically tries to pingback those

    URLs, while trackbacks must be done manually by entering the

    trackback URL that the trackback should be sent to

    (http://codex.wordpress.org /Introduction_to_Blogging#Pingbacks)

    Conversation in the blogosphere is organized around some

    central focal point blogs, an elite minority of blogs that is known as

    A-list blogs (Herring et al., 2004; Herring et al., 2005). A-list

    blogs were first recorded in the political blogosphere (Drezner and

    Farell, 2004) however nowadays some blog authors manage to make

    themselves a celebrity among the community of bloggers whatever

    the type, purpose, or content of a blog is (Trammell and

    Keshelashvili, 2005). A-list blogs receive the most inbound links

    from other blogs and are the most widely read and cited. Waggener

    Edstrom Worldwide (2006) commenting on A-list blogs wrote

    almost every category has a handful of bloggers who are perceived

    to carry more weight in terms of influence than the others.

    3. The case study and MethodologyTravelPod was founded in 1997 as the world's original travel blog

    and it has been identified as one the most popular travel blog site by

    many researchers (Carson, 2007; Pan et al.,2007; Schmallegger and

    Carson, 2008; Wenger; 2007). On 18th November 2008, TravelPod

    was identified through Technorati as the 11th between the 100 top

    blogs having an Authority: 9299 and Rank: 9, and is the 1st travel

    blog in the list.

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    9/29

    TravelPod introduces itself as: TravelPod's free travel blog

    lets you chart your trips on a map, share unlimited photos and videos,

    and stay in touch while you travel. Thought TravelPod travelers can

    1.preserve travel memories by uploading photos and videos, chart

    trips with travel maps and weave photos directly into stories 2. Get

    inspired for next trip by meeting other travelers and participating in

    travel forums 3. Share experiences with family and friends, by setting

    up email import tools, send email updates and RSS feeds and email

    notifications for new entries 4. Use advanced features as update

    travel blogs from mobile phone, track visitors of blogs, show travel

    blogs on MySpace, Facebook and other sites send update

    notifications to Facebook friends and others. In TravelPod each

    traveler can maintain many blogs presented at travelers TravelPod

    page. At this page, Recent Entries, Recent Comments, Recent

    Forum Posts, Favorite travelers and Others Similar Travelers

    are also presented. Favorite travelers is a special form of a blogroll

    and is a list of travelers that travelers frequently read or especially

    admire.

    Travelpod.com provides a Top 100 travelers list, according

    to number of visits to their website. This paper considers the Top 100

    travelers list and records links from travelers to other travelers within

    TravelPod. The functionality of Travelpod.com regarding Favorite

    travelers lists serving as blogrolls, allows to record and study the

    incoming links between travelers.

    Next, by using snowball sampling, links from these travelers

    to new travelers within TravelPod are recorded. Snowball sampling

    has also been used in collecting data in political blogosphere and is

    one of the preferred methods to sample in social networks studies. By

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    10/29

    considering the Top 100 travelers as a starting point the aim is to

    maximize the probability of finding most popular and therefore

    perhaps most linked travelers. Finally, a set of 563 travelers and their

    incoming links is formed. The recording of travelers and their

    hyperlinks was done during January 2009. Regarding the recording

    of incoming links between travelers, an automated routine was used.

    So an effort was made to keep human interaction during recording to

    a minimum level.

    The adjacency matrix of the social network of travelers was

    used. In this matrix if two travelers I and J have a relation then 1 is

    placed at the cell (i,j), otherwise 0 is placed in this cell. The paper

    adopts a statistical approach for studying networks, although other

    graph theoretic approaches also exist such as finding components or

    cliques. These graph theoretic notions are used in the study of social

    networks to locate actors who interact with each other. Our statistical

    approach on the other hand, in particular scaling and clustering

    analysis, is the preferred method because the interest is to find groups

    of travelers which have these properties: 1) within these groups the

    travelers need not be interconnected but 2) rather, they need to be

    linked by nearly the same set of travelers. In this sense, clustering

    algorithms applied on the original adjacency matrix are considered

    suitable for locating these groups.

    The paper studies incoming links between travelers, using

    the Favourite travelers list which is equivalent to blogroll. In order

    to construct a network, a 563 by 563 non-symmetric binary data

    matrix is used where unity is placed in cell ij if traveler i links to

    traveler j through the favourite travelers list, else zero is placed in the

    cell. The next step involves the construction of a travelers

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    11/29

    interconnection network. It is a directed graph where travelers are

    noted as nodes and incoming links as directed arrows. The paper

    adopts a method introduced by Zafiropoulos and Vrana (2010) for

    locating core blog groups in political blogging. The original idea

    (Drezner and Farrell, 2004) is that political blogs are organized

    around central focal point blogs, where most of the informative

    conversation is taking place. Zafiropoulos and Vrana (2010)

    introduced a combination of social networking theory,

    multidimensional scaling and hierarchical cluster analysis to locate

    such groups by studying incoming links through blogrolls. By

    finding such groups, one can explore how bloggers are organized and

    easily follow how conversation proceeds. For travel blogs, the idea

    may take a different form. Travelers or travel blogs are

    interconnected through blogrolls or favourite travelers lists, and in

    this way they may form groups of blogs or travelers, which are

    considered familiar or most important (while the rest of the blogs or

    travelers are more isolated). It is important to locate such groups in

    order to see how travelers or travelers blog are organized, which

    blogs are considered familiar and which are their characteristics that

    distinguish them from the rest of the travelers.

    Multidimensional Scaling (MDS) is used in the analysis as a

    data reduction technique and also to quantify the original binary data.

    The method reproduces the original data and map them on a fewer

    dimensions space (namely two in this analysis) while the effort is to

    keep intact the distances among the original data on the new

    reproduced data. Stress is a measure of goodness of fit between

    distances of original data and distances of the reproduced data. Better

    fit is assumed when stress is close to zero.

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    12/29

    Hierarchical Cluster Analysis (HCA) uses the quantified data

    from MDS to produce clusters of travelers with similar properties.

    Since the input is the incoming links, travelers in the same cluster are

    linked by nearly the same set of travelers. So in this way the travelers

    in a formed cluster are regarded to be of the same family have

    common characteristics - by travelers who link them. Some of the

    clusters that are produced by HCA, gather the largest number of

    incoming links. If this happens then they may serve as conversational

    focal points.

    4. FindingsMultidimensional Scaling (MS presents very good fit with

    Stress=0.0493), followed by Hierarchical Cluster Analysis (HCA)

    result to the formation of seven clusters of travelers regarding

    incoming links. These clusters of travelers are described in Table 1.

    They are called Clusters hereafter. To decide about the suitable

    number of out-clusters, the study uses a scree plot of the number of

    clusters against Wilks Lambdas.

    Only 41 out of 563 travelers, i.e. 7.3% of the 563 travelers

    are organized in seven central clusters. Cluster 1 consists of 14

    travelers who have an average number of incoming links 5.71.

    Clearly, it is the least referred cluster out of the seven clusters since

    the travelers within the cluster are referred nearly by six other

    travelers. Cluster 2 consists of ten travelers and has an average

    number of incoming links of 6.6, which slightly larger than the

    relative number of incoming links of Cluster 1. Cluster 3 consists of

    seven travelers and has an average number of incoming links 6.86.

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    13/29

    Cluster 4 consists of five travelers with an average number of

    incoming links 11.83. Cluster 5 has two travelers luchy and

    wakingdream and an average number of incoming links 14. Cluster

    6 and 7 both consist of one traveler each, themeoff in cluster 6 with

    number of incoming links 16 and whereshegoes in Cluster 7 with

    number of incoming links 30, which is the largest of all (Table 1).

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    14/29

    Cluster number and

    travelers name in

    TravelPod

    Number

    of

    incoming

    links

    Top100

    rating

    # visitors

    6/1/2009

    Travelers country of

    origin

    # of countries

    visited

    Posted photos

    5/12009

    Posted

    entries

    5/1/2009

    In travel

    blogs

    5/1/2009

    1. aaronvdb 6 Australia 10 39 107 5

    1. alinmattrtw2005 4 27 129,625 United Kingdom 44 1797 315 1

    1. barrettbingley 5 Canada 20 536 77 1

    1. bjw1981 4 Australia 13 92 50 2

    1. clintonb 5 57 84,401 Australia 33 1084 181 3

    1. kevandsian 6 9 204,195 United Kingdom 51 778 201 5

    1. marktjhung 9 25 3945 111 4

    1. matty 6 Australia 24 125 90 2

    1. mills-mcshea 7 United Kingdom 13 950 95 2

    1. moses 4 Australia 19 27 64 2

    1. racheljohn 4 40 109,711 United Kingdom 22 1119 136 2

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    15/29

    1. shanewilson 5 20 140,005 Australia 35 2222 295 2

    1. slipperycoconut 5 63 81,409 United States 16 1020 128 1

    1. zento 10 34 117,15 Argentina 14 6032 207 2

    Average 5.7 24.21 1411.86 146.93 2.43

    2. christinasworld 9 96 61,117 United States 30 680 126 3

    2. darkstar 6 Canada 14 480 160 7

    2. foolsgold 5 73 73,728 United Kingdom 39 1150 201 4

    2. gypsymichelle 4 Philippines 63 1299 225 25

    2. jeffsadventures 7 5 239,234 United States 25 3268 215 1

    2. off_road_clara 5 92 63,162 United Kingdom 20 1492 485 9

    2. radsolv 6 United States 79 510 734 31

    2. scottwoz 10 12 188000 United Kingdom 22 5558 582 3

    2. will 9 Australia 34 1994 365 4

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    16/29

    2. yellowdragon 5 Germany 23 1647 133 10

    Average 6.6 34,9 1807,8 322,6 9,7

    3. exploreamerica 6 36 9962 406 17

    3. jawad 7 10 203,191 United Kingdom 17 999 304 2

    3. lucinate 6 16 159,106 Australia 51 3798 333 2

    3. Paul 8 Thailand 20 3123 200 2

    3. siscri 8 69 75,247 Ireland 28 487 128 5

    3. twittg 6 23 133,082 United States 70 2706 355 9

    3. uncledavros 7 3 417,829 Australia 63 14158 479 3

    Average 6.8 40,71 5033,28 315 5,71

    4. eddakath 14 30 121,849 Australia 14 9746 559 3

    4. Jessica_cdn 9 Canada 24 218 164 9

    4. Iraleigh 11 15 164,485 United States 34 4373 402 3

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    17/29

    4. peacefrog 11 11 188,367 France 48 5922 650 5

    4. stevejames 12 4 266,808 United Kingdom 15 114 376 2

    4. technotrekker 14 1 674,165 Australia 47 4477 325 2

    Average 11.8 30,33 4141,66 412,66 4

    5. lucky 14 53 85,875 Canada 43 1667 122 11

    5. wakingdream 14 Canada 16 1061 82 6

    Average 14 29,5 1364 102 8,5

    6. thymeoff 16 6 226,049 Canada 24 2446 161 1

    7. whereshegoes 30 2 536,275 Canada 38 2454 737 5

    Table 1. Description of clusters of most linked travelers (visited 5 and 6/1/2009).

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    18/29

    4.1 Clusters characteristics

    This section deals with the analysis of the characteristics of travelers

    clusters. The seven clusters consist of the most linked travelers.

    According to the methodology of cluster analysis, travelers within

    each cluster are linked almost simultaneously by the travelers. So in

    this way the travelers in a formed cluster may be regarded to be of

    the same family have common characteristics - by travelers who

    link them. A question that arises is on what basis other travelers link

    to each group of central travelers? It is probable that common

    characteristics of central travelers place them in the same cluster

    according to other travelers choices (favorites). Thus it is interesting

    to investigate whether blogs within clusters share common

    properties. Several characteristics were taken into account in order to

    see whether they may be associated with placement of travelers to the

    specific clusters. They may not be all the characteristics necessary to

    drive to a solid conclusion but rather they must be considered to

    constitute an available set of data that allows making a first attempt

    to analyze clusters profiles. These are traveler s number of

    incoming links, his/her placement in the top100 TravelPod rating (in

    case he/she belongs in this list), number of visitors to his/her site (on

    6/1/2009), travelers country of origin, number of countries visited by

    him/her, number of posted photos by him/her (till 5/1/2009), number

    of posted entries (till 5/1/2009), number of his/her travel blogs

    (5/1/2009), duration of his/her membership, and whether he/she

    received TravelPod Badges (by means of recognition of his/her

    achievements or history regarding participation in TravelPod, for

    example if he/she is a founding member) (Table 1).

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    19/29

    Clusters with higher number of incoming links consist to a

    higher degree of travelers with TravelPod budges (founding members

    etc), longer period of membership and more posted entries in their

    blogs. This can be verified by correlation coefficients calculated for

    number of incoming links and the travelers characteristics (Table 2).

    In addition, placement in TravelPod top100 list is correlated though

    not significantly with number of incoming links. This means that

    there is a tendency for those travelers who are ranked high (according

    to visits to their sites) to be part of clusters with high number of

    incoming links. However, the actual number of visitors is not

    correlated with number of incoming links, so number of visits to their

    own sites, does not provide evidence of the placement of travelers in

    some cluster and therefore is not connected in this since with

    networking patterns among travelers.

    Regarding travelers country of origin, travelers mainly come

    from Australia, United Kingdom, Canada and United States. Only

    few come from Argentina, France, Germany, Ireland, Philippines,

    and Thailand. Travelers that belong to most linked clusters, those are

    Clusters 5, 6 and 7, and they all come from Canada. Regarding the

    number of countries, that the travelers have visited there is not a

    linear correlation between this number and the cluster membership

    (Table 2). Regarding number of posted photos and posted entries of

    the travelers, it is only number of entries which is significantly

    correlated with number of incoming links, and cluster membership.

    Travelers that are linked higher, also have higher communication

    flow by means of how frequently they address to visitors of the

    website by narrating their experience. On the contrary, number of

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    20/29

    blogs of the travelers is not correlated with number of incoming

    links.

    Finally, duration of membership and TravelPod budges are

    correlated with number of incoming links. The most linked travels

    have also entered TravelPod earlier and hold some budges that is

    they are founding members or moderators, etc. In this sense, it seems

    that duration of membership and TravelPod budge holding are

    synonyms. To clarify the connection of the travelers profiles with

    cluster membership, a stepwise regression analysis is performed,

    considering number of incoming links as the dependent variable and

    the rest variables as independent (Table 3). Only posted entries and

    membership duration are affecting number of incoming links (and

    consequently cluster membership). According to Beta absolute

    values they affect number of incoming links nearly equally, although

    posted entries present a higher coefficient (in absolute value). Highly

    linked travelers have more posted entries and are members of

    TravelPod for a longer time.

    Number of incoming

    links

    Placement in Top100 TravelPod rating -.351

    Number of visitors .031

    Number of countries visited -.029

    Posted photos .186

    Posted entries .408(**)

    Number of travel blogs the traveler has

    created

    -.108

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    21/29

    Member since (year) -.317(*)

    TravelPod budges (1 yes/ 0 no) .379(*)

    (**: p< 0.01, *: p< 0.05)

    Table 2. Correlation coefficients of number of incoming links with

    travelers characteristics.

    B Std. Error Beta T p

    Constant 2771.280 1108.315 2.500 .020

    Posted entries .018 .005 .559 3.340 .003

    Member since (year) -1.381 .53 -.418 -2.497 .021

    R2=0.403

    Table 3. Stepwise regression of number of incoming links by

    travelers characteristics.

    5. ConclusionsThe originality of the paper lies on the study of travelers

    interconnections using multivariate statistics on data of social

    networks to describe core travelers groups. By adopting ideas from

    political blogging, the paper proposes a methodology for locating

    linkage patterns and describes how travelers are networked, forming

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    22/29

    in this way central groups of travelers. By studying travelers,

    interconnection the paper has shown that only few travelers are really

    involved in networking, while the average interlinking is low.

    However, there exist central travelers groups, which can be located

    by using the proposed method. Other travelers within TravelPod.com

    recognize and distinguish these groups possibly because travelers

    within each group have common characteristics. Analysis provides

    evidence that cluster-group membership is correlated with common

    travelers characteristics. Also, travelers within some of the clusters-

    groups are most active in posting entries while they are members of

    Travelpod for a long time. In this sense, core groups contain the most

    active and more information providing travelers. It is more likely for

    these travelers to be reached by others who navigate through a series

    of incoming links that lead to them. In this fashion, it is probable that

    these travelers have the potential to address many visitors of the site

    and therefore it is probable that they have a bigger impact on the

    provision of information. Locating these travelers is important and

    useful for both researchers and practitioners, since one can easily

    locate them and be informed and analyze discussions of the most

    influential travelers. Having in mind that Travelpod.com is one of the

    top travel blogs sites, we might consider this case as indicative of the

    relative sites.

    Due to the unbiased information shared in blogs based on

    first-hand authentic travel experiences, many travelers tend to use

    and trust blogs information for searching travel information. Blogs

    are becoming a very important information source for international

    travelers for getting travel advice and suggestions. Blogs play an

    increasingly important role in the consumer decision making process

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    23/29

    with the faceless reviewers who add their comments to these web-

    pages rapidly becoming the travel opinion leaders of the electronic

    age. Considering the importance of blogs perhaps the most useful

    application of travel blogs for destination marketing organizations

    and tourism businesses is monitoring the attitudes of travelers.

    Identifying the characteristics of the authors and readers, and

    assessing the extent to which these characteristics match those of key

    markets is challenging. Understanding how influential specific blogs

    are among their readers is a challenge. On these grounds the paper

    strived to identify influential travelers with relevance to the impact

    they have on other travelers and regarding to their trustworthiness

    measured by the number of incoming links to them. Central

    travelers blogs are the most popular and it has been shown from the

    analysis, that they are most active in uploading posts, pictures and

    information in general. For travelers who wish to be informed,

    locating central travelers blogs means avoiding further navigation

    through other blogs in order to find information. Thus, travelers who

    wish to find information may limit their navigation for economy to

    the most linked travelers blogs.

    By locating central travelers, a researcher may understand

    what the popular characteristics or content are. On the other hand,

    knowing where and how people are commenting and sharing their

    opinions about their brands gives companies the opportunity to

    respond and influence their perceptions of them. Central travelers

    could be really valuable to companies regarding provision of

    information.

    This research is limited to the use of a specific network, it

    was performed at some specific time interval, by using a specific

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    24/29

    methodological approach. The study of other travelers networks by

    using also other graph theoretic approaches would be useful to test or

    enhance the findings.

    References

    Albrecht, S. Lbcke, M. and Hartig-Perschke, R. (2007), Weblog

    Campaigning in the German Bundestag Election 2005,

    Social Science Computer Review , Vol 25 No. 4, pp. 504-

    520.

    Blood, R. (2002), The Weblog Handbook: Practical Advice on

    Creating and Maintaining Your Blog. Cambridge MA:

    Perseus Publishing, U.S.

    Barger, J. (1997), FAQ: Weblog Resources available at:

    http://chnm.gmu.edu/ digitalhistory /links/ pdf/

    chapter1/1.41.pdf (accessed 1 April 2009)

    Brady, M.(2005), Blogging: personal participation in public

    knowledge building on the web Working Paper [2005, 02],

    Chimera. available at: www.essex.ac.uk/

    chimera/content/pubs/wps/cwp-2005-02-blogging-in-the-

    knowledge-society-mb.pdf (accessed 31 March 2009)

    Carson, D. (2007), The blogosphere as a market research tool for

    tourism destinations: A case study of Australias Northern

    Territory,Journal of Vacation Marketing, Vol. 14 No 2, pp.

    111-119.

    Drezner, D. and Farrell, H. (2004), The power and politics of

    blogs, Annual Meeting of the American Political Science

    Association, Washington, DC, August, 2004, available at:

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    25/29

    http://www.utsc.utoronto.ca /~farrell/ blogpaperfinal.pdf

    (accessed 31 March 2009)

    Du, H. and Wagner, C. (2006), Weblog success: Exploring the role

    of technology, International Journal of Human-Computer

    Studies, Vol 64 No 9, pp. 789-798.

    Efimova, L. and de Moore, A. (2005), Beyond personal

    webpublishing: An exploratory study of conversational

    blogging practices, In Proceedings of the Thirty-Eighth

    Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences

    (HICSS-38), 3-6 January 2005, pp. 107a 107a.

    Hepburn, C. (2007). web 2.0 for the tourism and travel industry,

    available at:

    http://www.ebusinessforum.gr/engine/index.php?op=modloa

    d&modname=

    Downloads&action=downloadsviewfile&ctn...el (accessed 7

    January 2009)

    Herring, S. C. Kouper, I. Scheidt, L. A. and Wright, E. (2004),

    Women and children last: The discursive construction of

    weblogs, In L. Gurak et al. (Eds.), Into the Blogosphere:

    Rhetoric, Community and Culture of blogs, available at:

    http://blog.lib.umn.edu/blogosphere/women_and_children.ht

    ml (accessed 13 June 2009)

    Heung, V. C. S.(2003), Internet Usage by International Travellers:

    Reasons and Barriers. International, Journal of

    Contemporary Hospitality Management, Vol. 15, No. 7,

    pp.370-378.

    Hsu, C-L., and Lin, C-C. (2008), Acceptance of blog usage: The

    roles of technology acceptance, social influence and

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    26/29

    knowledge sharing motivation, Information and

    Management, Vol 45, pp. 65-74.

    Herring, S.C. Kouper, I. Paolillo, J. Scheidt, L. A. Tyworth, M.

    Welsch, P. Wright, E and Yu, N. (2005), Conversations in

    the Blogosphere: An Analysis "From the Bottom Up" In

    Proceedings of the Thirty-Eighth Hawai'i International

    Conference on System Sciences (HICSS-38), Los Alamitos:

    IEEE Press.

    Guo, X. Vogel, D. Zhou, Z. Zhang, X. Chen, H. (2008), Chaos

    Theory as a Model for Interpreting Weblog Traffic, In

    Proceedings of the 41st Hawaii International Conference on

    System Sciences 2008.

    Kaldis, K. Boccorh, R. and Buhalis. D. (2003), Technology Enabled

    Distribution of Hotels. An Investigation of the Hotel Sector

    in Athens, Greece, in Frew, A. Hitz, M. and O'Connor, P.

    (Eds.) Information and Communication Technologies in

    Tourism , Springer Verlag , Wien, pp. 280 287.

    Lento T. Welser, H. T. Gu L. and Smith, M. (2006), The Ties that

    Blog: Relationship Between Social Ties and Continued

    participation in blogs, 3Workshop on Weblogging

    Edinburgh, available at:

    http://www.blogpulse.com/www2006-

    workshop/papers/Lento-Welser-Gu-Smith-TiesThatBlog.pdf

    (accessed 15 June 2009)

    Lew, A. (2007), Social Software in Tourism, Event Management

    and Tourism Education, 3rd

    Tourism Outlook Conference in

    conjunction with the Global Events Congress II, 16-18 July

    2007, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    27/29

    Litvin, S., Goldsmith, R and Pan, B. (2008), Electronic word-of-

    mouth in hospitality and tourism management, Tourism

    management, Vol. 29, No. 3, pp. 456-468.

    Marlow, C. (2004). Audience, structure and authority in the weblog

    community, Communication Association Conference, May,

    2004, available at

    http://alumni.media.mit.edu/~cameron/cv/pubs/04-01.pdf

    (accessed 31 March 2009)

    Mishne, G. and Glance, N. (2006), Leave a reply: An analysis of

    weblog comments, WWW 2006 : 22-26. available at

    http://staff.science.uva.nl /~gilad/pubs/www2006-

    blogcomments.pdf (accessed 19 March 2009)

    Pan, B. MacLaurin, T. and Crotts, J. (2007), Travel Blogs and the

    Implications for Destination Marketing, Journal of Travel

    Research, Vol. 46 No.1, pp. 35-45.

    Park, H-W. and Jankowski, N. (2008), A hyperlink network analysis

    of citizen blogs in South Korean Politics, Javnost-the

    Public, Vol 15 No 2, pp. 57-74.

    Pudliner, B. A.(2007), Alternative Literature and Tourist

    Experience: Travel and Tourist Weblogs, Journal of

    Tourism and Cultural Change, Vol. 5, No 1, pp. 46-59.

    Rabanser, U. and Ricci, F. (2005), Recommender Systems: Do They

    Have a Viable Business Model in E-Tourism?, in Frew, A.

    (ed.) Information and Communication Technologies in

    Tourism in 2005, Springer Verlag , Wien, pp. 160171.

    Schmallegger, D. and Carson D. (2008), Blogs in tourism: Changing

    approaches to information exchange Journal of Vacation

    Marketing, Vol.14 No 2, pp. 99-110.

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    28/29

    Sigala, M. (2007), WEB 2.0 in the tourism industry: A new tourism

    generation and new e-business models,Ecoclub, No90, pp.

    5-8.

    Sigala M. (2008). Developing and implementing an eCRM 2.0

    strategy: usage and readiness of Greek tourism firms. In

    OConnor,P. Hpken, W. and Gretzel, U. (Eds) Information

    and Communication Technologies in Tourism 2008 Springer

    Verlag , Wien, pp. 463-474.

    Sigala, M. (2009), WEB 2.0, social marketing strategies and

    distribution channels for city destinations: enhancing the

    participatory role of travelers and exploiting their collective

    intelligence, In Gasc-Hernndez, M and Torres-Coronas,

    T. (Eds.)Information Communication Technologies and City

    Marketing: Digital Opportunities for Cities around the

    World, IDEA Publishing, pp. 220 244.

    Trammell, K.D. and Keshelashvili, A. (2005), Examining the new

    influencers: A self-presentation study of A-List blogs,

    Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly, Vol. 82

    No. 4, pp. 968 982.

    Waggener Edstrom Worldwide (2006), Blogging 101

    Understanding the Blogosphere From a Communications

    Perspective, available at

    http://www.waggeneredstromconsumer .com

    /whitePapers/downloads/blogging-101-understanding-the-

    blogosphere-from-a communications-persepective.pdf

    (accessed 2 March 2009)

  • 8/9/2019 Locating Central Travelers Groups in Travel Blogs Social Networks (accepted Journal of Enterprise Information Man

    29/29

    Wenger, A. (2007), Analysis of travel bloggers characteristics and

    their communication about Austria as a tourism destination,

    Journal of Vacation Marketing, Vol. 14 No 2, pp. 169-176.

    Williams, J. B. and Jacobs, J. (2004), Exploring the use of blogs as

    learning spaces in the higher education sector, Australasian

    Journal of Educational Technology, Vol. 20 No 2, pp. 232

    247.

    Xiang, Z. and Gretzel, U (2010), Role of social media in online

    travel information search, Tourism Management, Vol. 31,

    No 2, pp. 179-188.

    Ying, Z. and Davis, J. (2007), Web Communities in Blogspace, In

    Proceedings of the 40th HICSS 40th Annual Hawaii

    International Conference , pp. 85-85

    Zafiropoulos, K. and Vrana, V. (2010), A Hyperlink Study of Greek

    Political Blogs Communications Patterns. In Evans M.

    Cassie (Ed). Internet Issues: Blogging, the Digital Divide

    and Digital Libraries, Internet Policies and Issues Series,

    Nova Publishers, N.Y. to appear.