lpcmun delegate handbook - rcnmun.files.wordpress.com€¦ · delegate handbook 1. overview: flow...
TRANSCRIPT
LPCMUN Li Po Chun Model United Nations Email: [email protected] Website: http://lpcmun.tk
LPCMUNDelegate Handbook
Table of Contents
Overview: Flow of Debate, Rules and Procedures
Overview
Key concepts
Attending the Committee Session
Conference Protocol
Flow of Debate, Rules and Procedures
Rules of Parliamentary Procedures
Rules Governing Speeches
Points
Rules Governing Substantive Measures
Rules Governing Voting
Flow of Debate Diagram
LPCMUN
Delegate Handbook 1
Overview:Flow of Debate, Rules and ProceduresOverviewThe debates held by LPCMUN will be governed by the rules provided in this handbook. The debate follows the
General Speaker’s List (GSL), the backbone of the debate, with occasional deviations for motions for
moderated or unmoderated caucuses. The committee session will consist primarily of a series of speeches
based on the GSL. A nation may add its name to the GSL by submitting a request to the Chair by note passing
or by raising its placard when the Chair welcomes delegates to do so. The names of the next several nations to
speak will always be posted for the convenience of the Committee. During the GSL, the parliamentary rules of
procedure are in order. If a delegation wishes to discuss a particular issue in detail, it may request a deviation
from the GSL in the form of a moderated caucus.
Delegate can motion for a moderated caucus to facilitate discussion in a less formal format. The purpose of
the moderated caucus is to facilitate substantive debate at critical junctures in the discussion. The delegate
making the motion must briefly specify a topic, a speaking time, and an overall time limit, not to exceed twenty
minutes, for the caucus. Once the motion is passed, the Chair will then temporarily depart from the GSL and call
on delegates to speak at his or her discretion for the stipulated time. A motion for a moderated caucus is in
order at any time when the floor is open, prior to closure of debate. Once raised, the motion will be voted on
immediately, with a simple majority required for passage. The Chair may rule the motion dilatory, in which case
the motion is considered out of order.
Delegates may choose to email fellow delegates in the committee to discuss solutions or certain matters after
having heard them express their particular points of view during formal debate, or to motion for a unmoderated
caucus. Ultimately, these discussions should cumulate in the creation of draft resolutions which express the
common ground found during debate.
Draft resolutions are the result of caucusing and coordinated writing efforts by the delegates. Once submitted
to the chair, a resolution may be introduced by the submitting delegation and put forward for debate by the
committee. These will be followed by the amendments, which offer specific altercations to the draft resolution,
and when the debate is closed, the committee proceeds to voting on the proposed draft resolutions.
LPCMUN
Delegate Handbook 2
Key concepts
Here is a table outlining some key concepts:
General Speaker’s List Moderated Caucus Unmoderated Caucus Draft Resolution and
Amendments
The GSL is the backbone of
the general debate. The
committee session will begin
with the first speaker. Once a
speaker finishes his/her
speech, the floor will be
opened by the Chair to
motions raised by delegates.
If no motions are presented,
debate continues according
to the GSL.
A moderated caucus can
be motioned for when the
floor is open. Delegates can
motion for a moderated
caucus, stating (1) Purpose,
(2) Duration, (3) Time per
speaker. The committee will
then vote on the motion for
the caucus.
An unmoderated caucus
can be motioned for when
the floor is open. Delegates
can motion for a moderated
caucus stating (1) Purpose,
(2) Duration. The committee
will then vote on the motion
for the caucus.
Draft Resolutions will be
the main documents in this
conference. Once a draft
resolution has been revised
after caucusing and
coordinated writing efforts, it
can be submitted to the
Chair by email. The Chair will
welcome delegates to
introduce the draft
resolution once the Chair
has approved the draft
resolution sent to the email.
GSL speeches are 1 min
long. Countries who would
like to speak can put their
names on the GSL by
sending a message to the
Chair via note-passing or by
raising their placards when
the Chair welcomes
delegates to do so.
Moderated caucus
speeches will follow the
voted purpose and the time
per speaker. The Chair will
entertain speakers one at a
time. Delegates may raise
their placards indicate their
wish to speak.
Unmoderated caucus will
allow delegates to discuss
informally in relation to the
topic and to collaborate on
resolution writing.
Amendments may follow
after draft resolutions have
been discussed.
Amendments should be sent
to the Chair’s email. They will
then be debated on and
voted by the committee.
Detailed explanation of Flow of Debate, Rules and Procedures to follow in later pages.
LPCMUN
Delegate Handbook 3
Attending the committee session
Conference Protocol
Attire: Delegates should attend in formal dress.
Raising the Placard: Delegates may raise their placards to:
At any time during the committee session
1. Raise a Point of Order 2. Ask for a Right of Reply
When the floor is open
1. Add his or her delegation to the GSL when the Chair welcomes delegates to do so2. Raise a Motion for a Moderated Caucus or Unmoderated Caucus3. Raise other motions mentioned in this handbook4. Raise a Point of Parliamentary Inquiry5. Raise a Point of Personal Privilege
Note-passing: Delegates may pass notes to fellow members of the committee discreetly during com-mittee sessions.
Email: Delegates who wish to submit documents to the Chair should notify the Chair via note-passing and send relevant materials to the Chair.
Rapporteur sheet: Delegates should pay attention to the projected rapporteur sheet at all times in order to follow the debate.
LPCMUN
Delegate Handbook 4
Flow of Debate, Rules and Procedures
Rules of Parliamentary Procedures
I. SCOPE: These rules apply to all the committees in this conference.
II. LANGUAGE: English will be the official and working language of the conference. Formal
and diplomatic language is expected from delegates at all times; delegates should
address the committee in the third person.
III. GENERAL POWERS OF THE COMMITTEE STAFF: The Committee Chair will declare
the opening and closing of each meeting and may propose the adoption of any
procedural motion to which there is no significant objection. Subject to these rules, the
Chair will have complete control of the proceedings of any meeting. The Chair will direct
discussions, accord the right to speak, put questions to the committee, announce
decisions, rule on points of order, and ensure and enforce the observance of these rules.
The Chair may temporarily transfer his duties to another member of the Committee staff
or other designates of the Chair. The Chair assistant will work closely with the Chair to
record proceedings throughout the entire debate.
IV. DEBATE: Delegates should raise a motion to open the
General Speakers List.
V. MODERATED CAUCUS: The purpose of the
moderated caucus is to facilitate substantive debate at
critical junctures in the discussion. The Chair will
temporarily depart from the speakers list and call on
delegates to speak at his or her discretion for the
stipulated time. A motion for a moderated caucus is in order at any time when the floor is
open, prior to closure of debate. The delegate making the motion must briefly specify a
topic, a speaking time, and an overall time limit, not to exceed twenty minutes, for the
caucus. Once raised, the motion will be voted on immediately, with a simple majority
required for passage. The Chair may rule the motion dilatory, in which case the motion is
considered out of order.
Motion to open the GSL
Motion for a Moderated Caucus
Request to speak in a Moderated
Caucus
LPCMUN
Delegate Handbook 5
VI. UNMODERATED CAUCUS: An unmoderated caucus
temporarily suspends formal debate and allows
members to discuss ideas informally in the committee
room. A motion for an unmoderated caucus is in order at any time when the floor is
open, prior to closure of debate. The delegate making the motion must briefly explain the
purpose for the motion and specify a time limit for the caucus, not to exceed twenty
minutes. The motion will be put to a vote immediately, and a simple majority is required
for passage. The Chair may rule the motion dilatory, in which case the motion is
considered out of order.
VII. CLOSURE OF DEBATE: When the floor is open, a
delegate may move to close debate on the substantive
or procedural matter under discussion. The Chair may
rule such a motion dilatory. When closure of debate is
moved, the Chair may recognize up to two speakers against the motion. No speaker in
favor of the motion will be recognized. Closure of debate requires a 2/3 majority to pass.
If the Committee is in favor of closure, the Chair will declare the closure of debate, and
the resolution or amendment will be brought to an immediate vote. If the speakers list is
exhausted and no delegations wish to add their name to the list, debate is immediately
closed and voting procedures commence.
VIII. RECONSIDERATION: A motion to reconsider is in order
when a resolution or amendment has been adopted or
rejected, and must be made by a member who voted
with the majority on the substantive proposal. The Chair
will recognize two speakers opposing the motion after which the motion will be
immediately put to a vote. A 2/3 majority of the members present and voting is required
for reconsideration.
Rules Governing Speeches
I. GENERAL SPEAKER’S LIST: The Committee will have
a General Speakers List for the Topic Area being
discussed. A delegation may add its name to the
speakers list by raising its placard when the Chair
welcomes delegates to do so. The names of the next
several nations to speak will always be posted for the convenience of the Committee.
Motion for Unmoderated Caucus
Motion for Closure of Debate
Motion for Reconsideration
Request to add country to General
Speaker’s List
LPCMUN
Delegate Handbook 6
II. SPEECHES: No delegate may address a session without having previously obtained the
permission of the Chair. The Chair may call a speaker to order if her remarks are not
relevant to the subject under discussion, or are offensive to committee members or staff.
III. SPEAKING TIME: When any speakers list is opened, the speaking time is automatically
set to one minute. Delegates may also motion to set a new speaking time at any time
when points or motions are in order during formal debate. This motion requires a simple
majority to pass.
IV. YIELDS: A delegate granted the right to speak from a speakers list may, after speaking,
yield in one of three ways: to another delegate, to questions, or to the Chair. Yields are in
order only on substantive speeches and not during moderated caucus.
A. Yield to questions: Questioners will be selected by the Chair and limited to one
question each. Follow-up questions will be allowed only at the discretion of the Chair.
B. Yield to comments: The Chair may recognize two delegations, other than the initial
speaker, to comment for 30 seconds each on the specific content of the speech just
completed.
C. Yield to the chair: Such a yield should be made if the delegate does not wish his or her
speech to be subject to comments. The Chair will then return to the GSL.
V. RIGHT OF REPLY: A delegate whose personal or
national integrity has been impugned by another
delegate may request in writing a Right of Reply. The
Chair’s decision whether to grant the Right of Reply
cannot be appealed, and a delegate granted a Right of Reply will not address the
committee until requested to do so by the Chair.
Points
VI. POINT OF ORDER: During the discussion of any
matter, a delegate may rise to a Point of Order to indicate
an instance of improper use of parliamentary procedure.
The Point of Order will be immediately decided by the
Chair in accordance with these rules of procedure. The Chair may rule out of order those
points that are dilatory or improper; such a decision cannot be appealed. A
representative rising to a Point of Order may not speak on the substance of the matter
under discussion. A Point of Order may only interrupt a speaker when the speech itself is
not following proper parliamentary procedure.
Request for Right of Reply
Raise a Point of Order
LPCMUN
Delegate Handbook 7
VII. POINT OF PARLIAMENTARY INQUIRY: A delegate
may rise to a Point of Parliamentary Inquiry to ask the
Chair a question regarding the Rules of Procedure. A
Point of Parliamentary Inquiry can be made when the
floor is open.
VIII. POINT OF PERSONAL PRIVILEGE: If a delegate feels
there is a need to inform the Chair of a personal matter
that is hindering his/her participation, the delegate may
raise this point when the floor is open.
Rules Governing Substantive Measures
I. DRAFT RESOLUTION: Before being introduced, a draft resolution needs to have at
least 5 signatures from different delegations and the
approval of the Chair. Signing a resolution need not
indicate support of the resolution, and the signatory
has no further rights or obligations. The Chair’s
decision not to accept a resolution or amendment
may not be appealed. Introduction of draft
resolutions require a simple majority to pass unless
otherwise stated in specific Committee rules.
II. INTRODUCING RESOLUTIONS: Once a resolution
has been approved as stipulated above and has
distributed electronically, a delegate may make a
motion to introduce the resolution. This motion
requires only authorization by the Chair. More than
one resolution may be on the floor at any one time,
but at most one resolution may be passed.
III. AMENDMENTS: Delegates may amend any
Raise a Point of Parliamentary In-
quiry
Raise a Point of Personal Privilege
To submit a draft resolution
SEND EMAIL TO YOUR CHAIR
and notify your Chair via note-passing
---
After the Chair has approved the draft
resolution:
Motion for introduction of
draft resolution
LPCMUN
Delegate Handbook 8
resolution that has been introduced. An amendment
must have the approval of the Chair and the
signatures of 1/5 of the Committee. Amendments to
amendments are out of order; however, an amended
part of a resolution may be further amended. There
are no official sponsors of amendments and all
amendments, once a resolution is on the floor, must
be debated and voted upon.
A. An approved amendment may be introduced
when the floor is open. General debate will be
suspended and two speakers lists will be
established, one for and one against the amendment. Debate will alternate between
each list.
B. A motion to close debate will be in order after the Committee has heard two speakers
for the motion and two against, or when one of the speakers lists is exhausted. The
Chair will recognize two speakers against the motion to close debate, and a 2/3
majority is required for closure of debate on the agenda.
C. When debate is closed on the amendment, the Committee will move to an immediate
vote. After the vote, debate will return to the general speakers list.
Rules Governing Voting
I. DIVISION OF THE QUESTION: After debate on a Topic
Area has been closed, a delegate may move to divide
the question on any item which is about to be voted on.
Division of the question allows for a specified set of
operative clauses to be voted on separately from the rest. Pre-ambulatory clauses may
not be removed by division of the question. This motion requires a simple majority to
pass.
A. If the motion passes, the Chair will accept proposals on how to divide the question.
Such proposals may divide the question into two or more parts. After all proposals
have been accepted, the Chair will arrange them from most the proposal that offers
the drastic change to the resolution to the one that offers the least, and each will be
voted on, in that order.
B. If any proposal passes, all other proposals are discarded and the resolution or
amendment is divided accordingly. A substantive vote must then be taken on each
To submit an amendment
SEND EMAIL TO YOUR CHAIR
and notify your Chair via note-passing
---
After the Chair has approved an
amendment:
Motion for introduction of amendment
Motion for division of question
LPCMUN
Delegate Handbook 9
divided part to determine whether or not it is included in the final draft. A simple
majority is required for inclusion of each part. After all parts have been voted on,
those that were voted to be included are recombined into the final resolution. If all
of the operative parts of the substantive proposal are rejected, the proposal will be
considered to have been rejected as a whole.
II. REORDERING RESOLUTIONS: The default order in
which resolutions are voted on is the order in which they
were introduced. After debate on a topic has been
closed, a delegate may motion to change the order in
which resolutions on the Committee floor will be voted on. Such a motion must specify a
desired order. Once such a motion has been made, the Chair will accept alternative
proposals for ordering. Proposals will be voted on in the order in which they were
received and require a simple majority to pass; once a proposal has been passed, all
others are discarded and resolutions will be voted on in that order.
III. VOTING: Once Committee is in voting procedure and all relevant motions have been
entertained, the committee will vote on all resolutions on the floor. Voting occurs on each
resolution in succession; once a resolution has been passed, no further resolutions will
be voted on. Each country will have one vote. Each delegation may vote “Yes,” “No,” or
“Abstain.” After the Chair has announced the beginning of voting, no delegate will
interrupt the voting except on a Point of Order in connection with the actual conduct of
the voting. A simple majority requires more “Yes” votes than “No” votes; abstentions are
not counted toward either total.
IV. ROLL CALL VOTING: After closure of debate on any Topic Area, any delegate may
request a roll call vote. Voting will be automatically adopted under the discretion of the
Chair.
A. In a roll call vote, the Chair will call all countries in attendance in alphabetical order
beginning with a randomly selected member.
B. In the first sequence, delegates may vote “Yes,” “No,” “Abstain,” “Pass,” “Yes with
rights,” or “No with rights.”
C. A delegate who passes during the first sequence of the roll call must vote “Yes” or
“No” during the second sequence. The same delegate may not request the right
of explanation.
Motion for reordering or resolutions
LPCMUN
Delegate Handbook 10
D. A delegate may only vote with rights if his or her vote appears to constitute a
divergence from his or her country’s policy. After all delegates have voted,
delegates who had requested the right of explanation will be granted 30 seconds each
to explain their votes.
E. The Chair will then announce the outcome of the vote.
LPCMUN
Delegate Handbook 11
Flow of DebateThis diagram outlines the flow of debate.
LPCMUN
Delegate Handbook 12