m150707: scheduling note and slides - briefing on ...*oo~mmo kji-l r drto gr@ikhaa southmra d i r ii...

30
SCHEDULING NOTE Title: INFORMATION BRIEFING ON INSPECTIONS, TESTS, ANALYSES, AND ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA (ITAAC) (Public) Purpose: To provide the Commission an update on industry and staff activities related to completing ITAAC, conducting inspections on ITAAC, and verification of ITAAC completion. Scheduled: July 7, 2015 9:00 am Duration: Approx. 2 hours and 45 minutes Location: Commissioners' Conference Room, 1 st floor OWFN Participants: Presentation External Panel 30 mins* Alan Torres, General Manager of Nuclear Construction, 15 mins.* South Carolina Electric & Gas Company Topic: Licensee perspective on the ITAAC from field-related activities, and efforts the utilities are taking for completing ITAAC Mark Rauckhorst, Vice President of Construction, Vogtle Units 3 and 4, 15 mins.* Southern Operating Co., Inc. Topic: Licensee perspective on the ITAAC from field-related activities, and efforts the utilities are taking for completing ITAAC Commission Q & A 40 mins. Break 5 mins. NRC Staff Panel 45 mins.* Michael Johnson, Deputy Executive Director for Operations Gary Holahan, Deputy Director, Office of New Reactors Michael Cheok, Director, Construction Inspection & Operational Programs, NRO James Beardsley, Branch Chief, Construction Inspection Program Branch, NRO Topic: NRC's Construction Inspection Program implementation as related to ITAAC, and lessons learned to date

Upload: others

Post on 13-Oct-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

SCHEDULING NOTE

Title: INFORMATION BRIEFING ON INSPECTIONS, TESTS,ANALYSES, AND ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA (ITAAC) (Public)

Purpose: To provide the Commission an update on industry and staff activitiesrelated to completing ITAAC, conducting inspections on ITAAC, andverification of ITAAC completion.

Scheduled: July 7, 2015

9:00 am

Duration: Approx. 2 hours and 45 minutes

Location: Commissioners' Conference Room, 1 st floor OWFN

Participants: Presentation

External Panel 30 mins*

Alan Torres, General Manager of Nuclear Construction, 15 mins.*South Carolina Electric & Gas CompanyTopic: Licensee perspective on the ITAAC from field-related activities,and efforts the utilities are taking for completing ITAAC

Mark Rauckhorst, Vice President of Construction, Vogtle Units 3 and 4, 15 mins.*Southern Operating Co., Inc.Topic: Licensee perspective on the ITAAC from field-related activities,and efforts the utilities are taking for completing ITAAC

Commission Q & A 40 mins.

Break 5 mins.

NRC Staff Panel 45 mins.*

Michael Johnson, Deputy Executive Director for OperationsGary Holahan, Deputy Director, Office of New ReactorsMichael Cheok, Director, Construction Inspection & Operational Programs,

NROJames Beardsley, Branch Chief, Construction Inspection Program Branch, NRO

Topic: NRC's Construction Inspection Program implementation as related toITAAC, and lessons learned to date

Page 2: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

William Jones, Director of the Division of Construction Projects, RIITopic: Status of Regional ITAAC inspections and related insights

Brian Anderson, Branch Chief, ITAAC and Generic Communications Branch, NRO

Topic: Verification of ITAAC closure notifications, ITAAC lessons learned.

Commission Q & A 40 mins.

Discussion - Wrap-up 5 mins.

*For presentation only and does not include time for Commission Q & A's.

Page 3: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

Vogtle 3&4 ITAAC Update

Mark Rauckhorst

Southern Nuclear Operating Company

July 7, 2015

Page 4: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

ITAAC Closure Notification (ICN) Submittal-Units 3&4 .

J-- ICNs Projected

.- U3 ICNs Projected

U4 ICNs Projectedw0z

0-IJ

U-U-A

M4

I IS - I

213 201422015 2dl 6

I

2017 2018

oKORGAA SOUTIU,,APOWERt COMPOM

201b

*Ogi00iwrpeo "M r~aton ,weIminh aRun~~~tS 3&4 Nula eeomn

Page 5: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

ITAAC Life CyclePlan

L -PD

L ..

Execute Notify

WPI - C P - 1-t'wP Wl _-PCD~ 'QP IQNS. L ., - -

# PDP - Performance Documentation Plan

* WP - Work Package

, PCD - Principal Closure Document

o CP - Completion Package

* ICN - ITAAC Closure Notification

*OO~MMO kji-l Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRAr d R i II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4MI~ ~ ~ ~~~, %- unS3&3ulerDveomn

Page 6: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

Life Cycle StatusUnit 3&4 Ufe Cycle Projection

ITAAC Closure Notification (ICN)

Completion Packae (CP)

Principal Closure Document (PCD)

rw

1720

1720

Total

1746

1746

1746

1 7 4 6 t

5000-

873

1720

Work Package (WP)

Performance and DocumentationPlan (PDP)

4349

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

Note: a completed Projected'This number b under review to account for ITAAC with multiple PCDs."WP screened as ITAAC appicable by CBI Reld Engineer prior to field implementation"Total project estimate of WP screened by COIias ITAAC applicableProjections reflect totals until the end of project with the exception of ICN 2015, which Is yearly based.

DaltonGFOlGRAA*Og~thrp.~wA PWFi~IOI OWER SMMMMACOMPAW *ftwme "'b

I~ ~ ~ ~~. j~ un 4Ncea"eeomn

Page 7: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

Early Uncompleted ITAAC Notification(UIN) Submittal Update

* 10 CFR 52.99(c)(3), Licensee shall submit theUIN at least 225 days before fuel load

• Early UIN submittal path forward:- Construction Inspection Program Task Force

- Evaluate current processes

- Share results

POW" COMMNY

un~~~tS 3&4 Nucea Deeomn

Page 8: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

Moving Forward

* Execution of ITAAC Maintenance

o Discuss opportunities related to early UINsubmittal with NRC

* Utilize NRC inspection planning meetings tocontinue coordination with NRC

& 6, .. Wftý

@EOOIaIs~TIMRa

POWERt 3&4Y Nuclearas De elpm n

Page 9: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

.uwoOa SI a:)n n c 9a

8StVI~uP8M~ANWW3 IMdJlO- M-Vrp3UnMS VrVM*OjgU110oId44

Page 10: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

A

US.NRCUnited States Nuclear Regulatory Commission

Protecting People and the Environment

BRIEFING ONINSPECTIONS, TESTS, ANALYSES,

AND ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA(ITAAC) - RELATED ACTIVITIES

Michael JohnsonDeputy Executive Director-for Operations

July 7, 2015

Page 11: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

ITAAC PROGRAMS ANDPOLICIES

Gary Holahan, Deputy Director

Office of New Reactors

2

Page 12: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

CONSTRUCTION INSPECTIONPROGRAM UPDATE

Michael Cheok, Director

Division of Construction Inspection andOperational Programs

Office of New Reactors

3

Page 13: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

AGENDA

* NRC's Construction InspectionProgram - James Beardsley

* Regional ITAAC Inspections - WilliamJones

* ITAAC Closure - Brian Anderson

• Summary - Michael Cheok

4

Page 14: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

KEY MESSAGES

" Successful implementation of theconstruction inspection program

• Improvement of our processesthrough lessons learned

" Involvement of all stakeholders inenhancing transparency, efficiency,and predictability of our processes

5

Page 15: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

NEW NUCLEAR PLANTCONSTRUCTION INSPECTION

PROGRAM

James Beardsley, Chief

Construction Inspection Program Branch

Office of New Reactors

6

Page 16: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

CONSTRUCTION INSPECTIONPROGRAM IS BROAD, COMPREHENSIVE

" ITAAC Inspection

o Construction and Operational ProgramInspections

" Periodic Assessment of ConstructionInspection Program Results

* Vendor Inspection Program

7

Page 17: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

COORDINATION BETWEEN NRCOFFICES

* Technical Assistance Requests- Formal communication process between

construction inspectors and headquarters

* Construction Inspection ProgramInformation Management System(CIPIMS)-Planning, scheduling and reporting

- All ITAAC related findings will beavailable in CIPIMS to facilitate ITAACclosure notification assessment

8

Page 18: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

INITIATIVES ENHANCINGEFFECTIVENESS

* Early Identification and Resolution ofTechnical Issues

" Integrated transition working groupreport completed September 2014

Multiple actions are in process to planand execute transition

" Initial test program implementation

" Routine evaluation of cROPeffectiveness

9

Page 19: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

TIMELY AND EFFECTIVECONSTRUCTION INSPECTIONS

William Jones, Director

Division of Construction Projects

Region II

10

Page 20: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

PLANNING AND SCHEDULINGSUPPORT TIMELY INSPECTIONS

IonductI nspections ..

- CIPIMS

- Primavera

11

Page 21: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

IMPLEMENTING TIMELYCOMPREHENSIVE INSPECTIONS

* Inspections scheduled andperformed as activities available

* Inspectors are knowledgeableengineers with access to subjectmatter experts as needed

12

Page 22: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

APPROPRIATE INSPECTIONRESOURCES

13

Page 23: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

INSPECTIONS SUPPORT ITAACCLOSURE VERIFICATION

ICN SUBMITTALS AND INSPECTION

PLAN COMPLETION (CUMULATIVE)Inspections Complete -1--ICNs Submitted

100

80

60

40

20

0

2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2

YEAR

015 2016 2017 2018 2019/20

14

Page 24: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

COMPREHENSIVE INSPECTIONACTIVITIES

15

Page 25: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

ITAAC CLOSURE

Brian Anderson, ChiefITAAC and Generic Communications Branch

Office of New Reactors

16

Page 26: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

ITAAC CLOSURE VERIFICATIONPROCESS DISCIPLINED, CONSISTENT

" Guidance developed for ITAAC closureprocess- NEI 08-01, Rev. 5- RG 1.215, Rev. 2

" Status of ITAAC closure* Transparent approach for staff

verification of ITAAC closure notices- Verification evaluation forms- Status reports on NRC public website

17

Page 27: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

NRC STAFF READY FOREXPECTED ITAAC SURGE

* Workflow system implemented-Verification of ITAAC Closure Evaluation

System (VOICES)

* Online training module is complete* Process for 52.103(g) finding is being

finalized

* Continuous stakeholder engagementInsights incorporated from 23 publicmeetings since 2011

18

Page 28: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

ITAAC LESSONS LEARNED INFORMONGOING ACTIVITIES

" Lessons have been documented andshared

"Lessons Learned to Improve ITAAC,"RIS 2008-05, Rev. 1 (2010)

- New Reactor Lessons Learned Reports(2013)

• Development of standardized ITAAC- Increased efficiency

- Greater consistency

19

Page 29: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

SUMMARY

* The construction inspection programhas been fully implemented and lessonslearned are used to improve ourprocesses

* Stakeholder engagement is essential forenhancing the efficiency, predictability,and transparency of our processes

* Processes are in place and ready tosupport the inspection and verificationof ITAAC completion

20

Page 30: M150707: Scheduling Note and Slides - Briefing on ...*OO~MMO kji-l r Drto GR@IKHAA SOUTHMRA d i R II POU" COMOMIT Owwww" 4M I~ ~ %- unS3&3ulerDveomn~ ~~~, Life Cycle Status Unit 3&4

ACRONYMS

ITAAC

CIPIMS

VOICES

ICN

Inspections, Tests,Analyses, andAcceptance Criteria

Construction InspectionProgram InformationManagement System

Verification of ITAACClosure Evaluationand Status

ITAAC ClosureNotification

21