making digital platforms the drivers of the …
TRANSCRIPT
Digital platforms have emerged as
one of the most powerful catalysts
that transform the way we produce,
consume, contribute, and transcend
traditional value chains – creating a
competitive advantage for
organizations and society in general.
Today, most manual activities in
organizations are being digitized,
and the platforms that enable this
offer greater convenience to
consumers, and help micro, small,
and medium-sized enterprises get
wider access to resources – thereby
MAKING DIGITAL PLATFORMS THE DRIVERS OF THE SOUTHEAST ASIAN ECONOMY
amplifying global reach. However, as
is the case with any technology or
innovation, the platform economy
offers benefits, as well as challenges.
The question that immediately comes
to mind is, ‘Can we fully leverage
these benefits while addressing the
challenges?’ Let’s look at the
Southeast Asian (SEA) economy and
discuss how it can successfully adopt
an orchestrated approach to its
advantage.
Broadening opportunities for employment and work-life balance
Digital platforms have been known for creating new jobs such as crowd workers,
drivers of ride-hailing apps, riders of food delivery services, etc. While some of
these jobs are not new per se, the modalities of matching workers to jobs
through platforms definitely are – thanks to payment schemes and value
accumulation in platforms. The likes of Grab and Gojek are now evolving into
‘super apps’ and labor platforms, providing employment to individuals who had
no prior work experience. Another defining feature of digital platforms is the
flexibility they provide – giving the power back to the people, by offering
short-term tasks at relatively low costs (‘firm-driven’ flexibility), at the same time,
allowing workers to achieve work-life balance (‘worker-driven’ flexibility).
Digital platforms offering a plethora of opportunities in SEA
Before the pandemic, SEA had a
collective GDP growth rate of
approximately 5%, which is 2
percentage points above the global
average, making SEA one of the
world's best performing regions.
While the region has amassed
economic prowess over the last
decade, there is still significant
disparity in the economic
progression amongst the constitute
markets of this region. A majority of
these constituent markets are in a
developing stage, struggling to get
the investments needed for inclusive
growth. Nevertheless, the
emergence of digital platforms and
opportunities to leapfrog to new
ways of working are enabling
organizations and the societies alike
to reap substantial benefits.
1
Improving accessibility
Lack of access has been a traditional
barrier, and although not completely
eliminated, is starting to get
addressed as digital platforms expand
cross-border trade through
e-commerce – particularly in moving
goods across national borders. In my
view, e-commerce has transformed
trade in at least three ways –
improving cost-efficiency in the flow
of information and products across
borders, accelerating the flow of
funds through e-payment systems
with built-in validation mechanisms,
and growing the traffic of parcelized
cross-border shipments.
Digital payments and QR codes triggering growth
It’s a known fact that the emergence
of digital payments and QR codes
has favoured e-commerce, not just
across borders but in every
household. A number of studies have
posited that digital payment solutions
tend to catalyze consumer spending –
even for offline businesses. Digital
payments also enable financial
inclusion, the rise of mobile money
and fintech payment systems in
general, while fostering financial
inclusion of previously unbanked or
underbanked individuals. For example,
in Association of Southeast Asian
Nations (ASEAN) economies, close to
41% of fintech payment users in 2018
were unbanked or underbanked. The
relative importance of card and
e-money payments is significant,
and rising in emerging economies,
accounting for over 60% of the total
cashless payment volume in Southeast
Asia. As a result, mobile money
Bridging the digital gap
With rising literacy, digital platforms
are playing a crucial role in closing
the digital gap. They are filling the
gaps and providing services and
solutions – especially in places where
state mechanisms are unavailable. For
example, unbanked populations in
underserved rural areas are availing
online consultations with professional
physicians – by opening payments
accounts and storing value securely
through a mobile payments bank.
Also, in regions that are sparse in local
educational institutions – a mobile
device is being used to access the
curriculum, coursework, and lectures
from other sources.
2
transactions have increased
substantially in volume and value. We
saw this particularly in the case of
Singapore, where the government’s
distribution of cash assistance was
done via digital platforms during the
COVID-19 pandemic.
Improved access tohealth care
Health care providers are now
providing quality health services
anytime, anywhere without payment
challenges. Health care in Singapore,
and Indonesia in particular, is extending
its reach significantly by riding on the
backbone of digital platforms.
Well-designed digital health
offerings are making it easier to
deliver patient-centric health care.
Cloud-based health databases (subject
to satisfying the security, privacy and
confidentiality parameters) are
facilitating mobile solutions for
clinicians. Digital platform solutions
carry substantial promise in making the
health service delivery more efficient
and inclusive, ultimately improving the
quality of health care received.
Growth in the onlineeducation market
The global online education market
has witnessed rapid growth,
powered by the onset of disruptive
digital technologies - in turn,
providing quality education for all.
The COVID-19 pandemic has also
provided an impetus for online
learning. With digital platforms
bridging the connectivity gap, the
unprecedented and sudden closure
of educational institutions caused a
dramatic shift to online learning.
This became the primary response to
the widespread disruptions in
schooling caused by the pandemic.
3
Data possiblystifling competition
The economies of scale and scope,
data-driven network effects, and
control of data, pose high entry
barriers for aspirants, effectively
rendering the platform as a
non-neutral intermediary. So, not only
are the dominant players becoming
bigger monopolies, but their growing
presence and hold over data is also
serving as a deterrent for others to
get in.
The enduringchallenges
Notwithstanding the several benefits that digital platforms offer, it is important
to recognize that there are attendant risks that need to be managed. For one,
the ‘winner-takes-all’ dynamics, typical in platform-based economies, leads to
significant market concentration. Likewise, concerns about security, privacy, and
movement and ownership of data, must be considered when formulating
policies. This is especially relevant since the growth of the digital economy is
fueled by the generation, storage, processing and transfer of data – both within
and across borders.
Presence of dominantdigital platforms
Southeast Asia is no different when it
comes to witnessing market
concentration and the dominant
presence of digital platforms. Grab,
for instance, has been enjoying a
virtual monopoly in car-hailing, and
has also been able to leverage its
market leadership in payments, food
delivery and parcel delivery.
4
Need for enhanced governance
With the emergence of new work
streams and models facilitating the
employment of millions of people,
the platforms and the regulations
around them point to the lack of
social protection due to their
exclusion from legal coverage. The
problem is further exacerbated on
account of low and inconsistent
earnings, and complicated
administrative processes. The
COVID-19 crisis has amplified these
consequences and stirred up
discussions around minimum pay,
health insurance and other
work-related benefits.
5
Need for consistent policies
A varying degree of economic strength,
taxation policies and FDI rules can lead
to fairly fragmented outcomes for
countries in the SEA region as they look
to develop and leverage digital
platforms. Policies that have significant
gaps in designing competitive tax
environments to international
investors, and the ones concerning
local taxation while offering or
consuming services through these
platforms, need to be revisited. Lack of
a coherent approach in the region can
impact the attainment of long-term
sustainable development goals.
Regulatory challenges
Unregulated data access and
vulnerabilities in privacy and security
carry substantial risk. Despite the
existing frameworks in place to
regulate digital data collection and its
usage, there is no binding regional or
international framework that provides
a single standard for legal data
transfers among various jurisdictions
in Asia. The exponential
developments in technologies cause a
huge regulatory challenge that
requires a fresh approach. On the flip
side, as technology evolves at a speed
faster than society and governments
can keep up, the lack of information
and expertise can prompt authorities
to immediately regulate a new
business model, and this may
discourage innovation and
experimentation.
Furthermore, the lack of
universal-level obligations for digital
platform providers can lead to
non-inclusive growth. The opportunity
to have access to digital platforms is
equally important to people as having
access to clean water, electricity, etc.
– which governments classify as
‘essential services’. While the
platforms are ‘for profit’, there
currently seems to be no real
obligation on them to ensure inclusive
growth and participation.
6
In the expanding ‘contactless’ world, countries and organizations need to
continue pushing the frontiers of digital platform development, and focus on
maximizing the opportunities while addressing the inherent challenges.
Balancing profitably with inclusive growth
The guiding principle around the
development, expansion and policy
framework surrounding digital
platforms must certainly be ‘inclusive
growth balanced with profit-making’.
Leveraging opportunities,conquering challenges
Customer-centricity, which may be
regarded as a cliché in the corporate
world, is of paramount importance
here. Considering that the focus is on
the citizens, workers and SMEs that
lack access to technology and its
benefits, this needs to be at the
center of the evolving economy and
ecosystem.
Improving theregulatory system
Existing policies and processes for
data protection are often fragmented
across platforms and borders, and
national data policy and legislation is
still in its nascent stage of
development in many countries.
Policymakers need to come forth to
ensure that a level playing field exists
for incumbents and new entrants – to
strike a balance between collecting &
analyzing the personal data of
consumers, and innovating – while
also addressing the concerns related
to ownership of data. Efforts to adopt
and replicate the best practices across
regions can help broaden the access
to safe and secure digital financial
services and payment options. This
will help build a smarter, transparent
and robust regulatory system for
digital platforms – by protecting
personal data and strengthening
cybersecurity.
Continued investments
The success of digital platforms
depends on continued attention and
investments in adjacent
infrastructure. This includes
enhancing mobile and broadband
services, as well as expanding internet
access and coverage – so different
segments of the population can tap
into the power of digital platforms
with greater ease and accessibility.
Towards this, the SEA region needs an
estimated $900+ billion in additional
investments to deliver affordable
mobile and broadband services.
Facilitating the movementof goods
Improving the trade and logistics
processes to address the existing
barriers to the delivery of goods is yet
another vital step towards maximizing
the opportunities in the SEA region.
Currently, the gap in logistics
performance between the ‘most’ and
‘least’ connected economies remains
wide. It’s also important to leverage
the technologies needed to make
customs clearance and border
procedures seamless.
Improving privacy anddata security
As digital platforms depend
increasingly on the creation,
processing, storage and transfer of
data during various transactions, the
upholding of data access and security
are becoming strategically important.
Harnessing data flows while
addressing concerns related to
privacy and security on these digital
platforms should be prioritized in
7
order to reap the wide range of
opportunities.
In the absence of supporting policies, economies that are unable to produce
goods competitively and market them effectively through the e-commerce
channel, may simply burden their local players with challenges related to
distribution and cross border supply chain. For this reason, interventions need to
go beyond merely supporting local players and provide a robust digital
infrastructure. It is imperative for countries to have a clear road map with respect
to the kind of enterprises they intend to nurture in the e-commerce space, and
the manner in which they will be supported.
Strengtheningcommunication linkages
Adequate trade initiatives and
agreements can streamline the
information exchange among all
parties involved in e-commerce
transactions. Furthermore, linkages
Policy reforms and Public-PrivatePartnerships lead the way
8
need to be strengthened between
various customs offices and also
between producers / sellers, postal
authorities, customs offices,
and buyers.
9
Collaboratingwith policy-makers
Technology and digital platforms
tend to evolve at a pace faster than
the ability of policymakers to
perceive the impact and frame
supporting policies. In such a
scenario, platform providers can take
the initiative of apprising the
governments and policymakers on
how the changes bear an influence on
societies and countries.
While a lot can be achieved, the
private sector is limited in its
capacity to bring about a systemic
transition. Partnerships among
stakeholders such as the
governments, the private sector and
civil society can prove to be useful in
searching for novel and
‘experiential’ regulatory models.
Such collaboration and co-creation
of regulatory models or initiatives
can unleash opportunities to
Policy alignment
Framing local policies that help build
intergovernmental mechanisms to
assist cross-border transfer of data
may be a smarter way to overcome
roadblocks than lobbying for a
general and comprehensive
international data protection
regime. This can include promoting
cooperation among enforcement
authorities, instituting mechanisms
that allow data subjects to enforce
data protection rights in all relevant
jurisdictions, and pushing for
uniform certification standards for
controllers. All these can improve
the objectivity and predictability of
data transfer standards.
leapfrog to higher levels of
sustainable development –
bypassing resource-intensive
development paths. The transition
can create new employment
opportunities, through increased
innovation and entrepreneurship on
digital platforms and beyond.
As we continue to witness the
exponential growth and strength of
the digital platform economy
worldwide, we need to sustain our
excitement and interest in the
opportunities that digital platforms
bring, and follow them as they go
about transforming the
socioeconomic development as well
as our everyday lives like never
before. I also urge organizations to
be forward-looking as they search
for novel ways to stay competitive
and take their business to the next
level – while also keeping a keen eye
on consumers tapping into and
enjoying the plentiful options these
platforms provide.
10
Authors
Olaf PietschnerCEO CapgeminiAPAC & Middle East
Gaurav ModiMD South East AsiaCapgemini
Deepak SarikaConsultantCapgemini
Vivianne TanSenior AnalystCapgemini
About Capgemini
Capgemini is a global leader in partnering with companies to transform and manage their business by harnessing the power of technology. The Group is guided everyday by its purpose of unleashing human energy through technology for an inclusive and sustainable future. It is a responsible and diverse organization of 270,000 team members in nearly 50 countries. With its strong 50 year heritage and deep industry expertise, Capgemini is trusted by its clients to address the entire breadth of their business needs, from strategy and design to operations, fuelled by the fast evolving and innovative world of cloud, data, AI, connectivity, software, digital engineering and platforms. The Group reported in 2020 global revenues of €16 billion.
Get the Future You Want | www.capgemini.com
Copyright © 2021 Capgemini. All rights reserved.