making smes survive an economic downturn – a finnish model juhapekka suutarinen adviser,...
TRANSCRIPT
Making SMEs survive an economic downturn – a Finnish model
Juhapekka Suutarinen
Adviser, Confederation of Finnish Industries EK
International seminar in Tirana, Albania
February 2-3, 2012
25.1.2012 JSu
2
Making SMEs survive an economic downturn: contents
• Background: enterprise structure in Finland• What is EK and how do we work?• Small Business Act defines EU Commission’s SME policy• Public sector toolbox for SMEs during a downturn• Special financing tools often needed when economy slumps• Economic downturn separates the wheat from the chaff
Enterprise structure in Finland
25.1.2012 JSu
44
Employees
Number and share of enterprises (2010)*
N % Cumulative %
1-4 227 022 86,5 86,6
5-9 18 077 6,9 93,4
10-49 14 514 5,5 98,9
50-249 2 321 0,9 99,8
250- 614 0,2 100,0
Total 262 548 100,0Source:Statistics Finland *excluding primary production sectors
Number and share of enterprises by size class
25.1.2012 JSu
5
Finnish enterprises by size class
Size class
Number of enterprises (excl. sectors of primary production)
1995 2000 2005 2010
1-4 156142 183833 196421 227022
5-9 14280 15644 16369 18077
10-49 9351 12728 13085 14514
50-249 1746 2200 2293 2321
250- 496 560 576 614
Total 182015 214965 228744 262548
Share of enterprise base, %
1995 2000 2005 2010
85,8 85,5 85,9 86,5
7,8 7,3 7,2 6,9
5,1 5,9 5,7 5,5
1,0 1,0 1,0 0,9
0,3 0,3 0,3 0,2
100,0 100,0 100,0 100,0
Source: Statistics Finland, Statfin –database
25.1.2012 JSu
6
Source: OECD (2009). Measuring Entrepreneurship. A Collection of Indicators. 2009 Edition
25.1.2012 JSu
7
Source: OECD (2009). Measuring Entrepreneurship. A Collection of Indicators. 2009 Edition
25.1.2012 JSu
88
Employer enterprises and self-employed persons in Finland
9
Elinkeinoelämän keskusliitto
Finlands Näringsliv
Confederation of Finnish Industries
9 EK/Eng/shs11.2004
25.1.2012 JSu
www.ek.fi/ek/en/index.php
25.1.2012 JSu
10
EK represents
• The entire private sector and companies of all sizes
• 27 branch associations
• About 16,000 member companies, of which 96% are SMEs
• Over 70% of Finland’s GDP
• Over 95% of Finland’s exports
• About 950 000 employees
Unparalleled knowledge and information of Finnish business
25.1.2012 JSu
EK members’ share of all Finnish companies 2010, %
Number of employees
Number of EK members
Companies in Finland1
EK share of all companies, %
Less than 10 6 972 245 099 2,8
10 – 49 6 230 14 514 42,9
50 – 249 2 017 2 321 86,9
At least 250 608 614 99,0
Total 15 827 262 548 6,0
1 Source: Statistics Finland, Company register
11
25.1.2012 JSu
12
Director General
Mikko Pukkinen
EK organisation
Regional officesAssistant manager Annaleena Mäkilä
SME AffairsDirector Pentti Mäkinen
EK BrusselsHead of EK BrusselsTytti Peltonen
DirectorTellervo
Kylä-Harakka-Ruonala
Infrastructure
DirectorTimo Kekkonen
InnovationEnvironment & Competences
DirectorJussi Mustonen
Economic policy
DirectorEeva-Liisa Inkeroinen
Industrial relations
DirectorJukka Ahtela
Legislation and trade policy
CommunicationDirector Leena Jaakkola
AdministrationDirector Markku Järvenpää
25.1.2012 JSu
13
EK activities
Regional Offices Regional Offices
EK BrusselsEK Brussels
• Energy• Supplies
Management• Logistics• Infrastructure• Climate • Environment • Sustainable
Development
CommunicationsCommunications
BusinessInfrastructure
• Labour and Social Law
• Business Law• Competition
and EU-law• Corporate
Security• Trade Policy
• Economy• Taxation• Business
Cycles • Employment• Financing
Welfare
• CoordinatingCollective Bargaining
• Development of Working Life
• Wage Increase andLabour MarketAnalysis
• Labour marketstatistics
Legal Affairs and Trade Policy
Economic Policy IndustrialRelations
• Education and Training
• Labour and Immigration
• Innovation Environment
• Company Growth andInternationali-sation
• Foresight• Information
Society
Innovation Environment
and Competences
SME Affairs SME Affairs
25.1.2012 JSu
14
Delegation for Entrepreneurs
General Assembly
Board
Extended Management Group
Director General
Management GroupCommittee of
Member Federations
• Business Infrastructure• Legal Affairs and
Trade Policy• Economic Policy• Industrial Relations• Innovation Environment
and Competences• SME Affairs• Regional Offices• EK Brussels • Communications
Regional Advisory Boards
Committees
Member Companies Member Federations (27)
Decision making in EK
25.1.2012 JSu
15
EK Departments
DirectorMr Jussi Mustonen
DirectorMs Tellervo
Kylä-Harakka-Ruonala
Director Mr Jukka Ahtela
Director MsEeva-Liisa Inkeroinen
Labour and Social LawDirector of LegislationMr Lasse Laatunen
Business LawDirector of LegislationMr Hannu Rautiainen
Trade Policy andInternational
RelationsChief Policy Adviser
Mr Simo Karetie
Corporate Security
EconomicsSenior EconomistMr Penna Urrila
TaxationChief Policy AdviserMr Tero Honkavaara
Coordinating Collective Bargaining
Development ofWorking Life
Wage Increase andLabour Market
Analysis
Labour market statistics
Energy and Climate Chief Policy Adviser Mr Mikael Ohlström
Transport and Infrastructure
Chief Policy Adviser Ms Tiina Haapasalo
Natural Resources and
Supplies Management
BusinessInfrastructure
Legal Affairs and
Trade Policy
EconomicPolicy
IndustrialRelations
DirectorMr Timo Kekkonen
Innovation and Growth Director of Innovation Ms Hannele Pohjola
Education, Training and Labour
Director of Education and Training
Ms Jaana Lehto
Innovation Environment
and Competences
25.1.2012 JSu
16
Ways for EK to influence national policy and legislation
The President of the Republic
The Government
Ministries
The Parliament
Committees
Political parties
• Opinions at request• Own-initiated statements and recommendations• Participation in committees and working groups• Hearings • Background contacts
EK
Departments
Member federations
25.1.2012 JSu
17
Ways for EK to influence in the EU
Commission EuropeanParliament
Council
Ministries and Finnish EU Mission
• Opinions by EK and BUSINESSEUROPE at request• Own-initiated statements and recommendations• Participation in committees and preparatory bodies• Hearings in Finland and Brussels• Direct contacts in Brussels
BUSINESSEUROPE
Sector federations
EK
Departments
Member federations
Small Business Act defines EU Commission’s SME policy
25.1.2012 JSu
19
How Small Business Act shapes EU SME policy
• The Small Business Act for Europe (SBA; COM(2008) 394) forms a guideline for both the Commission and the Member States to pave the way for SMEs to prosper
• The SBA:˗ anchors the “Think Small First” principle in law and policy
making to strengthen SMEs’ competitiveness
˗ acknowledges the crucial role of SMEs in the wellbeing of a society
˗ stands on a set of 10 principles and offers a guide for policymakers and legislators in EU and Member States to create a level playing field for SMEs
25.1.2012 JSu
20
Principles of the SBA 1(2)
• The 10 principles are:
2) Ensure that honest entrepreneurs who have faced bankruptcy quickly get a second chance
1) Create an environment in which entrepreneurs and family businesses can thrive and entrepreneurship is rewarded
3) Design rules according to the “Think Small First” principle
4) Make public administrations responsive to SMEs’ needs
5) Adapt public policy tools to SME needs: facilitate SMEs’ participation in public procurement and better use State Aid possibilities for SMEs
25.1.2012 JSu
21
Principles of the SBA 2(2)
7) Help SMEs to benefit more from the opportunities offered by the Single Market
6) Facilitate SMEs’ access to finance and develop a legal and business environment supportive to timely payments in commercial transactions
8) Promote the upgrading of skills in SMEs and all forms of innovation
9) Enable SMEs to turn environmental challenges into opportunities
10) Encourage and support SMEs to benefit from the growth of markets
25.1.2012 JSu
22
Where we stand now
• Launched in 2008 and reviewed in 2011, the SBA is still far from being implemented
• The Commission has been faithful to most of its commitments
• Though adopted by the Member States in Dec 2008 Council, they have so far failed to deliver on several actions
• The 2011 review proposes, in connection with the economic crisis and the Europe 2020 strategy, both new actions and developed existing actions in these areas:˗ making smart regulation a reality
˗ paying special attention to SMEs’ financing needs
˗ improving market access for SMEs with a broad approach
˗ helping SMEs’ contribution to resource-efficient economy
˗ promoting entrepreneurship, job creation, and inclusive growth
Public sector toolbox for SMEs during a downturn
25.1.2012 JSu
24
The tools in the box
• Secure access to finance
• Provide special financial support to exports
• Encourage innovation
• Offer diversified possibilities to training and education
• Increase write-off possibilities for investments
• Consider other tax incentives for e.g. research & development expenditures, private venture capitalists’ investments etc.
• Schedule infrastructure and other public construction projects for downturn periods
• Contemplate offering turnaround management services to SMEs
• Provide a possibility for temporary lay-offs
25.1.2012 JSu
25
Tool by tool 1 / 2
• Scheduling construction projects– public projects keep the wheels rolling in a labour-intensive industry
– launch road, railroad, harbour, public building construction or restoration when private demand in the industry declines
• Speeding up write-offs– investments slow down when demand fades
– shorter period for writing off investments in production facilities encourages execution of strategic plans
– helps in maintaining a positive atmosphere among entrepreneurs
25.1.2012 JSu
26
Tool by tool 2 / 2
• Encouraging innovation, R & D, business angels activities...– if tax incentives have been on the government agenda downturn offers a
perfect time to launch dynamic effects
• Time for updating skills– implement effective lifelong learning measures
– modernize social security system to support upgrading of skills
– encourage cooperation between educational institutions and SMEs
• Temporary lay-offs better than redundancy– for an SME it is essential to hold on to its skilled labour force
– flexible lay-off possibilities need to be accompanied by sufficient compensations
25.1.2012 JSu
27
Special financing tools often needed when economy slumps
25.1.2012 JSu
29
Access to finance key factor in prosperity of SMEs
• Economic hardship often implies growing need of finance for SMEs, especially working capital
• Current economic crisis and new solvency regulations for banks (Basel 2 & 3) form financial challenges to enterprises– secondary sources grow in importance, if there are such
• In Finland, e.g. insurance companies, pension institutes, Finnvera (a specialized public financing company) and Tekes (the Finnish Funding Agency for Technology and Innovation) offer financing for entrepreneurs
25.1.2012 JSu
30
Scarce capital may result in undesirable outcomes
• Difficulties in finding capital could mean slow growth, or no growth– if working capital dries up the road may even lead to bankruptcy
• Common problems entrepreneurs face are– high cost of capital
– demand for securities and real collaterals
– bureaucratic procedures related to many secondary sources
• The financial system ought to be able to provide capital for enterprises at every phase of life cycle– if private sources are not available public sector should bridge the gaps
25.1.2012 JSu
31
Examples of special arrangements in Finland
• Counter-cyclical financing by Finvera– for companies with up to 1 000 employees
– “...prerequisites for profitable business once the economic situation improves”
– for working capital and investment needs
– 40 % of companies that have obtained CCF say this saved them from bankruptcy
• Export credit financing (capital goods exports)– arrangement of financing for foreign customers (one stop shop at
Finvera)
– to ensure the competitiveness of Finnish exporters
– similar models already effective in principal competitor countries
Economic downturn separates the wheat from the chaff
25.1.2012 JSu
33
Anticipation and prioritization
• Prioritization:– make sure you have a clear strategy which is up-to-date
– concentrate on the important issues
– communicate with your personnel and interest groups
• Anticipation:– build a strong balance sheet in order to cope with the challenging
periods
– be customer-oriented
– obtain customers from various trades
Success factors apply in a downturn, too
• Risk tolerance and good planning; customer orientation
25.1.2012 JSu
34
• Mastering markets (customer relations, marketing, market knowledge, communication)
• Mastering production (progressive technology, diverse selection of products)
• Mastering networks (business contacts, distribution chain, corporate image)
• Mastering strategies (strategic planning, management, international experience of the board)
25.1.2012 JSu
35
Board shows direction, management executes
• In an average SME, the board consists mainly, or totally, of members of management and/or owner family
• When pursuing growth – or when economy slumps - this is often not good enough
• According to many studies, wide knowledge and experience are invaluable assets in achieving targeted growth
• At the same time as putting up their time and effort for board work, experienced entrepreneurs or business angels are often willing to make an investment in a promising enterprise
25.1.2012 JSu
36
To make the best use of the board:
• Take care of sufficient diversity of members– age, sex, background, experience
• Keep an active contact with board members, even between board meetings
• Be ready to reward members, and cover their expenses for meetings
• Remember: the board’s main task is not to listen to performance reports but to determine the strategic direction and “spar” the management
25.1.2012 JSu
37
Thank you for your attention!
This Presentation has been produced with the financial assistance of the European Commission. The views expressed herein are those of Bosmip 4 and can therefore in no way be
taken to reflect the official opinion of the European Commission.