march 2008 doc.: ieee 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...march 2008 slide 5 [email protected] doc.:...

30
March 2008 [email protected] Slide 1 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission Project: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area N Project: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area N etworks ( etworks ( WPANs WPANs ) ) Submission Title: Application requirements and proposed solutions Date Submitted: 18 March, 2008 Source: Ludwig Winkel, Siemens AG Address Siemensallee 74, Karlsruhe, 76187, Germany Voice: +49 721 595 6098, FAX: +49 721 595 893 6098, E-Mail:[email protected] Re: IEEE P802.15.SG4a Call For Applications, see 15-07-0936-00-004e-call-applications-tg4e.doc Abstract: Requirements of factory automation and proposed solution Purpose: Provide P802.15.4 application for Process automation and Factory automation Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein. Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P802.15.

Upload: others

Post on 03-Apr-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 1

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Project: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area NProject: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (etworks (WPANsWPANs))

Submission Title: Application requirements and proposed solutionsDate Submitted: 18 March, 2008Source: Ludwig Winkel, Siemens AGAddress Siemensallee 74, Karlsruhe, 76187, GermanyVoice: +49 721 595 6098, FAX: +49 721 595 893 6098, E-Mail:[email protected]: IEEE P802.15.SG4a Call For Applications, see 15-07-0936-00-004e-call-applications-tg4e.doc

Abstract: Requirements of factory automation and proposed solution

Purpose: Provide P802.15.4 application for Process automation and Factory automationNotice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P802.15.

Page 2: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 2

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

802.15.4e application

[email protected]

March 18, 2008

Orlando

Page 3: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 3

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Integration of wireless in wired infrastructure

MES,SCADA,Monitoring

Controller

Remote I/O

Networking components

Field Devices

Sensors+Actors (Factory Automation)

Manufacturing Execution System

Page 4: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 4

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Industrial Wireless LAN (IWLAN) enables industrial mobile Communication

• Industrial Mobile Communication

SecureEasy configurationAccess control (Authentification)Encryption, etc.

RobustMetal housing with high environmental protection classProtection against vibration and shockExtended Temperature range

ReliableCyclic data transmission(Deterministic, low latency)RedundancyControl of radio linkStable radio link

SafeSafety communication even on the same medium as non-safety related communication

Page 5: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 5

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe communication via PROFIsafe

Fieldbus

Security

HMI

Motion Control

wireless

HMI

Sensors

Remote IO

Proxy

Controller

Proxy

Fail safe communicationvia PROFIsafe-Profile

Up to Safety Category 4 according to EN 954-1Up to Safety Category 4 according to EN 954-1

SIL3, see IEC/EN 61508SIL3, see IEC/EN 61508

Wireless – even in safety applications!

Page 6: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 6

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

2. Use Cases – How can wireless meetcurrent customers’ requirements

Use Cases

Use Cases are• No. 1: Asset management• No. 2: Increase process information by

additional sensors for monitoring• No. 3: Wireless field device in control• No. 4: All wireless field devices in one

network

Page 7: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 7

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

MaintenanceStation

Use Case 1 Asset Management • Current situation

– Modern field devices have lots of diagnostics data

– These data are available in most cases only per costly on-site inspection

• How wireless supports customers– Wireless units allow central access to

field devices• Customers benefits

– No changes, only add-ons– Higher plant availability– Predictive instead of preventive

maintenance reduces costs– Quick Return of Invest– Wireless even in backbone buses

(also in following use cases)

DCS OSMS

RIO 4-20mA supportGateway

802.

1180

2.15

.4

Page 8: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 8

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Use Case 2- Increase process knowledge by additional monitoring TAGs

• How wireless supports customers– Due to lower total cost of ownership

(TCO) users can add additional wireless measurement points

• Customers benefits– Higher performance …– Better product quality …– Less energy and material input …– Increased productivity …

through enhanced process knowledge via additional monitoring field devices

OS

T

P

F L

A

L

P

FT

Gateway

T

• Current Situation– Due to high installation costs only most important

field devices are installed

Page 9: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 9

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Use Case 3Wireless field devices in process control

OS

T

P

F L

A

L

P

FT

Gateway

T

• How wireless supports customers– After getting experience with wireless

field devices in monitoring applications a user may add wireless devices in control

• Customers benefits– Same wireless technology for

monitoring and control– Change from monitoring to control

results in no new invest, just add an existing/new wireless device into control strategy

• Current Situation– Customers wants to have experience with new

technology before using it in mission critical applications

Page 10: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 10

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Use Case 4All Wireless Field Devices in

One Network

• How wireless supports customers– Wireless devices can be easy

integrated in this unchanged environment

• Customers benefits– No new device types– No additional training– No additional networking components

like routers

• Current Situation– Customers have a rich set of tools,

templates, standards, experience with device out of 1+ classes (e.g. HART, PROFIBUS, FF)

Gateway

COMMUNICATION FOUNDATION

HART

Field Device Types

Digital I/O

Cyclic & acyclic Data

Page 11: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 11

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

3. Resulting technical / commercial requirements

• Two major types of Applications – Process Automation– Factory Automation

• Stability against noisy Environment• Use of Standard Radio Technologies

for monitoring and control• Simplicity• Minimize Lifecycle Costs & Easy

Integration in existing automation solutions• Secure operation with wireless

technology

Page 12: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 12

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Two major types of ApplicationsProcess Automation

Requirements from process automation• high number of devices in one wireless cell• moderate performance requirements

(latency times 500+ ms)• relative long distances • Redundant communica-

tion paths• Functional Safety

Applications

Page 13: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 13

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Two major types of ApplicationsFactory Automation

Application Application

Requirements from factory automation• smaller number of devices in one wireless cell• high performance requirements

(latency times < 10 ms)• relative short distances• Redundant communica-

tion paths• Functional Safety

Page 14: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 14

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Stability against noisy Environment

Robust Communication over the air • Coexistence with other wireless technologies, e.g.

– IEEE 802.11 (WLAN)– IEEE 802.15.1 (Bluetooth)– Future specifications

• Robust against interference sources– E.g. micro wave oven

802.11x

802.15.1EMC

802.15.4ee.g. infrastructurelaptops…

cell phonesPDAskeyboard & mouse…

Page 15: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 15

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Use of Standard Radio Technologiesfor monitoring and control

• Interoperability from an end-user’s perspective– Free choice of supplier, e.g. for field devices– Devices from different suppliers run in the same wireless

network

• Interoperability from an supplier’s perspective– More than one chip vendors for wireless components – Cheap wireless components (e.g. ASICs)– Wide-spread technology

Page 16: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 16

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Simplicity• Easy installation without special tools, e.g. for site surveys, and

without special training• Simple expandability of the network by new devices• Simple network management• Common infrastructure (unique radio technology)• Minimum number of infrastructural networking components

Page 17: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 17

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

• Easy installation without special tools, e.g. for site surveys, and without special training

• Simple expandability of the network by new devices• Simple network management• Common infrastructure (unique radio technology)• Minimum number of infrastructural networking components

Simplicity

Page 18: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 18

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Minimize Lifecycle Costs & Easy Integration in existing automation solutions

• Minimum Lifecycle Costs– Battery life time 5+ years

• Excessive and configurable usage of sleep modes• low power consumption of the radio

– Self- configuring networks– Self- Healing networks

• Easy wireless integration in existing automation solutions– Used tools– Used templates– Industry and Customer standards

should be able to be used by customers, e.g. for integration andparameterization of HART, PROFIBUS and FF devices

Page 19: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 19

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Secure operation with wireless technology

Assurance that the origin and/or the source of data are correctly identified.

Data Authenticy

Property that data has not been changed,destroyed, or lost in an accidental manner.

Data Integrity

Assurance that information is not disclosed to unauthorized individuals, processes, or devices.

Confidentiality

The property of a device, a system or a system resource being accessible and usable upon demand by an authorized system entity, according to performance specifications for the system; i.e., a system is available if itprovides services according to the system design whenever users request them

Availability

Assurance of the identity of a device or a system resource.Authentication

The protection of devices or system resources against unauthorized access.

Authorization

DefinitionSecurity Properties

Page 20: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 20

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

4. Siemens’ proposal baseline • Meshed Networking (TDMA)• High Performance (TDMA)• Frequency Agility• IEEE 802.15.4 on 2.4 GHz Band • Coexistence with IEEE 802.11• Wireless Backbone based on IEEE 802.11 and

IEC 61784-2, CP 3/4 (PROFInet Conformance Class A wireless)• Security

Page 21: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 21

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Meshed Networking

Gateway Device

Requirements are– Reliability &

Robustness– Huge Coverage– Simplicity– Self-organizing– Self healing– Long distances

Page 22: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 22

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

High Performance is met by Star Topology

t

Sync Beacon from Gateway

Scheduled Timeslots

Contention period,optional

10 ms cycle time

Requirements are– TDMA based– fulfils the req. from

factory automation– deterministic

behavior– required for high

performance cyclic communication

– allows acyclic traffic (contention period)

Gateway Device

Page 23: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 23

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Frequency Agility to enable robustness and availability

t

Frequency

1

n

Frequency usage over time for one dedicated link

Requirements are– Robustness against

interferences– Availability of the

network

Page 24: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 24

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

IEEE 802.15.4 on 2.4 GHz Band

• Standard Technology, specified by IEEE– Cheap– Multi vendor– Low power– Scalable

• 2.4 GHz Band– High performance– Worldwide usability enabled

Requirements are– Interoperability from

an end-user’s and supplier’s perspective

– Lifetime >5 years

Page 25: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 25

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Coexistence with IEEE 802.11. ... ...

Siemens sans

siemens sans bold

siemens sans italic

siemens sans italic bold

siemens sans black

siemens black italic

-

WLAN (IWLAN) and 802.15.4 RF Spectrum

15 2520 26

IEEE 802.11

IEEE 802.15.4

Channel 1 Channel 6 Channel 11

2412 MHz 2437 MHz 2462 MHz

Primary

Channel

2425 MHz 2450 MHz 2475 MHz2480 MHz

Clear channels

Primary

Secon

dary

Secon

dary

Standard should allow to enable only selected channels (e.g. in the gaps of running WLAN)

Page 26: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 26

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Security

• AES encryption (Advanced Encryption Standard)– Open and accepted encryption technology

• Authentification and key update approach suitable for mesh networks as well– Scalable technology, applicable for simple devices (primitive

sensors) as well

• Security on Wireless should be based on available standard technologies

Page 27: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 27

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Overall Approach

Dual Mode approach• Unique hardware platform• Minor difference in FW stack

– Optimization for advanced mesh (AM) functionality

– Optimization for advanced performance (AP) functionality

Page 28: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 28

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Overall Approach

Physical Layer (PHY)

Software

Hardware

SecurityServiceProvider

Advanced Mesh (AM)

Medium Access Layer (MAC) – lower part from 802.15.4

Advanced Performance (AP)

MAC extensions for mesh

MAC – part from 802.15.4

MAC extensions for star

MAC – part from 802.15.4

Network Mgmt

Page 29: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

March 2008

[email protected] 29

doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00

Submission

Your Questions and Comments

QuestionsComments

Thank youfor yourattention

a1

Page 30: March 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 …...March 2008 Slide 5 Ludwig.Winkel@Siemens.com doc.: IEEE 802.15.4e-03-0000-00 Submission IWLAN Reaction times allow even a fail safe

Slide 29

a1 das ist eine wiederholung von oben, dann besser weglassenadbire0; 06.09.2006