mariam kamunyu ma thesis

7/23/2019 Mariam Kamunyu MA Thesis

1/68


2/68


3/68

"#$%&'() *("($#*#"&+ (),("-'"$ &.# /'$.&

&% )#*%"0&/( '" 1#"2( 3 "'$#/'(

04567889: 7; 87=? @4?@7?69;8 A@ 8B9 >9C47>969;8D @A> 8B9 *=D89> A@

E=FD G.46=; /7HB8D =;: )96AI>=87D=87A; 7; (@>7I=J K=I4?8L A@ E=FM

N;7O9>D78L A@ P>98A>7=Q

RL

*=>7=6 1=64;L4

084:9;8 "AQ STTTUVSW

P>99: 4;:9> 8B9 D4O7D7A; A@

P>A@9DDA> (LA:9?9 ,Q (8D9;4F=

(8 8B9

K=I4?8L A@ E=FM N;7O9>D78L A@ E=HAD

XY %I8A59> ZYST


4/68

ii

P?=H7=>7D6 )9I?=>=87A;

"# *=>7=6 1=64;L4 $% &'(')* $'+,-('.

/0 1&-2 " 34$'(52-4$ 6&-2 7,-89-(95: '42-9,5 -4$ " -: -6-(' %; 2&' 9+ IJ

)=89+ GK L+2%)'( ?K/H


5/68

iii

)9:7I=87A;

1&95 ('5'-(+& 7-7'( 95 $'$9+-2'$ 2% :* 7%75 M0J0 I3&%(%# 6&% 94;,3'4+'5 :* ,9;' 94 :%(' 6-*5 2&-4

&' @4%65 -4$ $%'5 5% 692& 8('-2 692 -4$ 2-+20 N4$ 2% :* :%2&'( O%(+-5 J-:34*3# 6&%5' 695$%:#

$95+97,94' -4$ $'7'4$-)9,92* -(' 34:-2+&'$0


6/68

iv

(I[;AF?9:H69;8

" 6%3,$ ,9@' 2% 2&-4@ 2&' P'42(' ;%( Q3:-4 R98&25 ;%( 2&' %77%(23492* 2% )' 7-(2 %; 2&95 ,9;'S

+&-48948 7(%8(-::'0 T7'+9-, 2&-4@5 2% I-8435 J9,,-4$'( 6&%5' $%%( 95 -,6-*5 %7'40

A92& 32:%52 8(-2923$' " -+@4%6,'$8' :* 537'(=95%( M(%;'55%( N*%$',' N25'436- 6&%5' 5&-(7

942',,'+2# +-4$%3( -4$ :'29+3,%35 6-*5 94$957'45-),* '4(9+&'$ 2&95 $955'(2-29%40


7/68

v

E7D8 A@ =55>9O7=87A;D

PRP P%4='429%4 %4 2&' R98&25 %; 2&' P&9,$

EP1 E'$'(-, P-792-, 1'((92%(* %; N)3U-

QRP Q3:-4 R98&25 P%::922''

"PPMR "42'(4-29%4-, P%='4-42 %4 P9=9, -4$ M%,929+-, R98&25

"PVTPR "42'(4-29%4-, P%='4-42 %4 V+%4%:9+# T%+9-, -4$ P3,23(-, R98&25

"W "457'+2%( W'4'(-, %; M%,9+'

IM5 I':)'(5 %; M-(,9-:'42

XME X98'(9-4 M%,9+' E%(+'

XYMO X'6 Y%(@ M%,9+' O'7-(2:'42

LO"QR L;;9+' ;%( O':%+(-29+ "45292329%45 -4$ Q3:-4 R98&25

LQPQR L;;9+' %; 2&'


8/68

vi

&=5?9 A@ -A;89;8D

"#$%&'() *("($#*#"&+ (),("-'"$ &.# /'$.& &% )#*%"0&/( '" 1#"2( 3 "'$#/'( 44444444444444 5

678958:5;< )=>78:8?5@A 444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 55

)=B5>8?5@A 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 555

(>CA@D7=B9


9/68


10/68

1

-.(P/ %"# \ '"&/%)N-&'%"

SQSR=I[H>A4;:

1&95 95 - 2-,' %; 26% +%342(9'5[ J'4*- 94 V-52 N;(9+- -4$ X98'(9- 2&' N;(9+-4 89-42 94 A'52 N;(9+-0 Z32

2&' 52%(* )'8945 ;-( ;(%: N;(9+-[ 92 )'8945 94 X'6 Y%(@ P92* 94 ?K//0 "4 T'72':)'( ?K//# N:'(9+-45

$%64'$ 2&'9( 2%%,5 -4$ 2%%@ 2% 2&' ;-:'$ A-,, T2(''2 ;94-4+9-, $952(9+2 2% 7(%2'52 94 6&-2 +-:' 2% )'

@4%64 -5 L++37* A-,, T2(''2 BLATC0 1&' ('-5%4 ;%( 2&'9( 7(%2'52 6-5./

T%+9-, -4$ '+%4%:9+ 94'D3-,92*# 8(''$# +%((3729%4 -4$ 2&' 7'(+'9='$ 34$3' 94;,3'4+' %; +%(7%(-29%45

%4 8%='(4:'42\7-(29+3,-(,* ;(%: 2&' ;94-4+9-, 5'(=9+'5 5'+2%(0 1&' LAT 5,%8-4# !" $%" &'" (()#

(';'(5 2% 94+%:' 94'D3-,92* -4$ 6'-,2& $952(9)329%4 94 2&' G

"4579('$ )* 2&' L++37* I%=':'42# 7(%2'525 '(372'$ -+(%55 2&' +%342(* 692& 2&' -(: %; 2&' 52-2'

59:9,-(,* 56948948 94 -+29%4 D3',,948 2&' 7(%2'52 -4$ -(('52948 7(%2'52'(50 I%(' 2&-4 - *'-( ,-2'(#

'42'( J'4*-0 Z'26''4 I-* -4$ `34' ?K/G J'4*-45 ;%,,%6'$ 5392 $'+(*948 2&'9( :':)'(5 %;

7-(,9-:'42>5 BIM5C ';;%(25 2% +9(+3:='42 2&' ,-6 -4$ -6-($ 2&':5',='5 &';2* 7-* 94+('-5'5 $'5792'

-,('-$* )'948 5%:' %; 2&' )'52 7-9$ IM5 94 2&' 6%(,$ -4$ 94 5792' %; 2&' &'-=* 6-8' )3($'4 2&-2

J'4*-45 5&%3,$'( 2&(%38& $957(%7%(29%4-2',* &98& 2-a'50 F9@' 94 X98'(9-# 5%:' %; 2&' 7'-+';3,

7(%2'525 6'(' $957'(5'$ )* 35' %; 6-2'( +-44%45 -4$ )'-29485 )* 2&' 7%,9+'0

1&' ;%('8%948 5'2 %; '='425 :%29=-2'$ 2&95 523$* -5 2&'* 7('5'42 )%2& 73bb,948 -4$

$95D39'2948 +%4+'(450 O95D39'2948 )'+-35' 2&'* 9,,352(-2' - +,'-( @4''SU'(@ ('-+29%4 2&-2 2&' 52-2'

-4$ 7%,9+' &-=' 2% 7(%2'52[ - $957(%7%(29%4-2' ('57%45' 6&9+& 5'':5 2% )' 945292329%4-,95'$ -4$

/&227.cc'4069@97'$9-0%(8c69@9cL++37*dA-,,dT2(''2B-++'55'$ GK I-* ?K/HC0?&227.cc'4069@97'$9-0%(8c69@9cL++37*d:%=':'42B-++'55'$ GK I-* ?K/HC0GL V::-43', e Z Vb'-:-,3 ^fL++37* X98'(9-. L4' *'-( ,-2'(# 2&' 8-945# 2&' ,%55'5>

&227.cc66607(':93:29:'5480+%:c4'65c//HghKS%++37*498'(9-S%4'S*'-(S,-2'(S2&'S8-945S2&'S,%55'50&2:, B-++'55'$ GK

I-* ?K/HC0


11/68

2

4%(:-,95'$0 1&' +%4+'(45 -(' 73bb,948 94 ,98&2 %; 2&' )3$$948 $':%+(-29+ 57-+'5 94 2&' +-5' 523$*

+%342(9'5 6&9+& -(' '=9$'4+'$ )* 2&' 8(%6948 ;(''$%:5 %; 'a7('559%4 -4$ :'$9-0 Y'2 94 52-(@

+%42(-52 2&' :-4-8':'42 %; 7(%2'525 95 -(+&-9+ -4$ (''@948 %; -32&%(92-(9-495:0

1&' 7('%++37-29%4 %; 2&95 523$* 95 2&'(';%(' 2&' 'a+&-48' %; 8(9'=-4+'5 )'26''4 - 52-2' -4$

925 +929b'45 2&(%38& $':%452(-29%450 I%(' 7('+95',*# 92 95 -)%32 2&' :%$-,92* %; 53+& 8(9'=-4+'5

6&'4 2&'* -(95' )'26''4 8%='(4:'42 -4$ $':%452(-2%(50

SQZ08=8969;8 A@ 8B9 A5?96

M(%2'525 &-=' )''4 329,95'$ )* +929b'45 2% 'a7('55 2&'9( 8(9'=-4+'5 %( -579(-29%45 594+' 29:'

9::':%(9-,0 Q%6'='(# -5 2&' T7'+9-, R-77%(2'3( %4 2&' (98&25 2% ;(''$%: %; 7'-+';3, -55':),* -4$

%; -55%+9-29%4 4%2'5# ^94 ;-( 2%% :-4* 9452-4+'5# 2&' -)9,92* 2% &%,$ 7'-+';3, -55':),9'5 &-5 )''4

$'49'$ %( ('52(9+2'$ )* -32&%(929'5 94 =9%,-29%4 %; 942'(4-29%4-, &3:-4 (98&25 4%(:5 -4$

52-4$-($50>H1&95 95 4% $9;;'('42 ;%( 2&' +%342(9'5 94 D3'529%40 O':%452(-29%45 -(' :%52,* 2%,'(-2'$

)* 2&' 52-2' -4$ '='4 2&95# %4,* 6&'4 7(%2'525 -(' 4%2 $'':'$ 94+%4='49'42 -4$ $% 4%2 (%35' 2%%

:3+& (3)),'0 1&' :-94 +%4+'(4 95 2&-2 &952%(9+-, -4$ +3(('42 2('4$5 94 )%2& +%342(9'5 5&%6 2&-2 2&'

52-2' 'a'(+95'5 - 7('53:729%4 94 ;-=%3( %; -()92(-(9,* ('52(9+2948 7(%2'52 -+29=929'50 1&'5'

('52(9+29%45 8% %='( -4$ )'*%4$ ,-6;3, ,9:92-29%40

^V='4 94 -$=-4+'$ $':%+(-+9'5# $':%452(-29%45 &-=' 4%2 )''4 7%,9+'$ 692&%32 &3:-4

(98&25 -)35'50>iL4,* ('+'42,*# E'(835%4 I955%3(9 94 2&'


12/68

3

2% (95@ +(929+95: (-2&'( 2&-4 7(-95'[ -5 2&' +%45'D3'4+'5 -22-+&'$ 2% 2&' 7%,9+948 %; $':%452(-29%45

-,:%52 -,6-*5 7('5'42 &3:-4 (98&25 +%4+'(450>l V='4 6%(5'# ^2&'9( +%42':7%(-(* 'a&9)929%4 %;

75'3$%S2%,'(-4+' 2% +9=9, 7(%2'525 95 ,-$'4 692& 7%,929+-, 34$'(+3(('425# :-49;'52948 94 2&'9(

(',989%35>g -4$ %;2'4 53)U'+29=' '4;%(+':'42 %; ('52(9+29%45 2% $':%452(-29%450 "4 2&95 ('8-($#

^:-942'4-4+' %; 73),9+ %($'(> 2(3:75 -,, %2&'( +%459$'(-29%45 -5 92 95 2&' :%52 +%::%4 U3529;9+-29%4

7(%;;'('$ ;%( 5377('559%4 %; 7(%2'5250

"4 ('92'(-29%4# - 7('53:729%4 -8-9452 $':%452(-29%45 95 7('=-,'42 94 2&' +-5' 523$*

+%342(9'5 -4$ 94$''$ 6%(,$ %='(0 1&95 7('53:729%4 7'(59525 %6948 2% 2&' +3(('42 %32S$-2'$

-((-48':'425 ;%( 2&' :-4-8':'42 %; $':%452(-29%45 94 J'4*- -4$ X98'(9-0 1&' 7%,9+948 %; 7(%2'52

94 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'5 ':)%$9'5 2&' 7(%='()9-, ;,* 94 2&' %942:'420 N++%($948,*# 2&' 4'8%29-2'$

:-4-8':'42 :%$', &-5 )''4 5948,'$ %32 ;%( +%459$'(-29%4 -5 - 7%2'429-, 2(-45;%(:-29=' ('57%45'

2% 2&' $952('55948 52-235 D3%0

SQX/9D9=>IB C49D87A;D

1%6-($5 -$$('55948 2&' ('5'-(+& 7(%),':# 2&95 523$* 5''@5 2% -456'( 2&' ;%,,%6948 ('5'-(+&

D3'529%45.

/0 "5 2&'(' - (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'm

?0 A&-2 7(%57'+25 $%'5 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& %;;'( ;%( 2&' ';;'+29='

('-,95-29%4 %; 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'm

G0 1% 6&-2 'a2'42 +-4 2&' ,'8-, ;(-:'6%(@ %; J'4*- -4$ X98'(9- -++%::%$-2' -

4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& 2% &-4$,948 $':%452(-29%45m

SQT07H;7@7I=;I9 A@ 8B9 D84:L

1&' -9: %; 2&' 523$* 95 2% '453(' 2&-2 2&'(' 95 :%(' :'-4948;3, 9:7,':'42-29%4 %; +929b'4>5 (98&25 2%

'a7('55 $955'42 )* 6-* %; $':%452(-29%450 1&' %)U'+29=' 95 ;%( 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'5 2% &-=' -

:%$', ;%( 9:7,':'42-29%4 %; - 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+&0 T3+& -4 -77(%-+& 95 )'4';9+9-,

)%2& ;%( 73),9+ -$:94952(-29%4 %; ,-6 -4$ %($'( -5 6',, -5 +929b'4 7-(29+97-29%4 -4$ 'a'(+95' %; +9=9,

,9)'(29'50

l4 i -)%='# HGG0g4 i -)%='# HGH0


13/68

4

SQWE789>=84>9 >9O79F

1&'(' 95 ('5'-(+& %4 ;(''$%: %; -55':),*# $':%452(-29%45 -4$ 2&' (98&2 2% 7(%2'520 X'8%29-2'$

:-4-8':'42 &-5 ('+'9='$ 5%:' -22'429%4 )32 4%2 4'-(,* -5 :3+& )* 6-* %; 5+&%,-(,* 6%(@5 -4$

(-(',* 94 2&' $9:'459%4 %; 92 )'948 2&' 7(9:-(* ='&9+,' 2% '4&-4+' 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-29%40 1&95

5'+29%4 ('=9'65 5%:' %; 2&' 'a952948 6%(@5 ;%( 2&'9( +%42(9)329%45 -4$ 9$'429;9'5 2&' 8-75 94 2&':

6&9+& +('-2' 2&' %77%(23492* ;%( 2&' 7('5'42 6%(@0

7"$89 94 %4' %; 2&' :%52 ('+'42 -32&%(92-29=' 6%(@5 %4 7'-+';3, 7(%2'52.h

_- +,'-( $9=9$' n'a9525o )'26''4 2&%5' 6&% 5'' 2&' 7%,9+' -5 &-=948 -$%72'$ - ;-( :%(' -88('559='

52-4+'# -@94 2% 7-(-S:9,92-(95: 6&'4 +%4;(%42'$ 692& -4$ $'-,948 692& ,-(8' 5+-,' $95%($'( -4$ 2&%5'

6&% 69,, 529,, 5'' 73),9+ %($'( 7%,9+948 -5# ,-(8',*# )* +%45'42 -4$ ^4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42> 6&'('='(

7%559),' p 692& =9%,'4+' -4$ ;%(+' - ,%48# ,%48 6-* $%64 2&' ,952 %; 7%559),' 5%,329%450

7"$8 7(%7%5'5 - ('=%,329%4-(* 6-* %; ,%%@948 -2 7(%2'525 2&-2 95 94 ,94' 692& 2&' 2&94@948 2&-2

&3:-4 (98&25 5&%3,$ 4%2 )' +-2'8%(95'$ 942% 8'4'(-29%45 -4$ 2&'(')* -++(3948 =-(*948 %),98-29%45

)-5'$ %4 2&'5' &9'(-(+&9'50 "452'-$# &' -='(5 2&-2 2&' (98&2 2% 7(%2'52 :352 )' 5''4 )* 52-2'5 -5 -

7%5929=' %),98-29%4 ('D39(948 2&' 8%='(4:'42 2% ;-+9,92-2' 7(%2'52 -4$ 4%2 :'(',* =9'6 92 -5 -

4'8-29=' (98&2 6&9+& 2&'* 5&%3,$ (';(-94 ;(%: ,9:929480 1&95 7%5929=' %),98-29%4 95 -2 2&' &'-(2 %;

4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 6&9+& +-,,5 ;%( +%%7'(-29%4 -:%48 -,, -+2%(5 94=%,='$ 94 - 7(%2'520

:6.;,&0/K "4 $%948 5%# &'

$(-65 -22'429%4 2% 2&' 4-23(' %; 2&' (98&2 2% ;(''$%: %; -55':),* 4%2948 2&-2 92 95 %4' 2&-2

94&'('42,* 94=92'5 +&-,,'48' -4$ ,9:92-29%40 "2 95 ;%( 2&95 ('-5%4 2&-2 - 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42

-77(%-+& 2&'4 )'+%:'5 7-(29+3,-(,* +%4='49'42 -5 92 2&'4 '453('5 2&-2 2&' 52-2' 7'(;%(:5 925

7%5929=' %),98-29%4 94 ;-+9,92-2948 $':%452(-29%450

=$0>26. $95+355'5 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' 94 X98'(9- )* '=-,3-2948 73),9+ %($'( 7%,9+9480

Q95 6%(@ 5'(='5 2% 9,,3:94-2' 2&' 7(%2'52 +%42'a2 94 X98'(9-0 E%( 9452-4+' 94 $95+355948 2&' &952%(*

%; 7(%2'525# &' -='(5 2&-2 X98'(9->5 ;%(:'( :9,92-(* ('89:'5 :-* 'a7,-94 2&' +3,23(' %; :9,92-4+*

$957,-*'$ 94 7(%2'52 7%,9+948 2% $-2'0 Q' -,5% 9$'429;9'5 7('=-,'42 ('52(9+29%45 %4 2&' (98&2 2%

$':%452(-2' 94 X98'(9- 53+& -5 &95 %='(-,, $'$3+29%4 2&-2 94 ^-4-,*595 %; 2&' 7%,9+'>5 ('57%45' 2%

hO I'-$ ?'" ."4 3$4 6+ >"$-"+/3 >%6&"2&@ A,1'&2 $.8 %"1/3$&,6. ,. &'" B/0$. A,1'&2 *-& "%$ B?K/KC /h0/KIR J%4=92b C/.8$0".&$3 3,D"%&,"2 6+ $ +%"" >"6>3"@ %"3,1,6.9 2>""-'9 >%"229 $22"0D3EB?KKGC ?li0


14/68

5

$':%452(-29%45 -4$ +9=9, 7(%2'525 94 X98'(9-# - +%45952'42 7-22'(4 )'+%:'5 '=9$'420 1&95 95 2&-2 2&'

7%,9+' ('57%45' &-5 -,6-*5 )''4 -429S7'%7,'>0>//

N 8,%)-, 523$*/? %4 ('7('559%4 -4$ +(9:94-,95-29%4 %; 7(%2'52 -(%34$ 2&' 6%(,$ ;'-23('5

J'4*- -5 %4' %; 925 +-5' 523$* +%342(9'50 1&' 523$* &98&,98&25 ('52(9+29%4 2'4$'4+9'5 94 J'4*- -4$

9$'429;9'5 2&-2 2&' @'* +&-,,'48' 95 2&' 9:7%5929%4 %; $957(%7%(29%4-2' ('52(9+29%45 -4$ 'a+'559=' 35'

%; ;%(+' )* 7%,9+' 94 J'4*-0

1&' L(8-495-29%4 ;%( T'+3(92* -4$ P%S%7'(-29%4 94 V3(%7' BLTPVC L;;9+' ;%( O':%+(-29+

"45292329%45 -4$ Q3:-4 R98&25 &-5 7(%$3+'$ 6&-2 -(' -(83-),* 2&' :%52 -32&%(92-29=' 839$',94'5

%4 ;(''$%: %; 7'-+';3, -55':),*0/G1&95 94;'('4+' 95 ('-+&'$ ;(%: %)5'(=948 2&' (',9-4+' 2&-2 95

7,-+'$ %4 2&' 839$',94'5 94 %2&'( @'* 6%(@5 53+& -5 5 7%5929='

%),98-29%4 2% ;-+9,92-2' 7(%2'520 1&' LTPV 'a7('55,* +-723('5 )'52 7(-+29+' %4 -+29%45 -4$ ,-65 2&-2

6%3,$ -:%342 2% $957(%7%(29%4-2' ('52(9+29%45 6&9,' -,5% &98&,98&2948 2&' 9$'- %; ,'8929:-2'

('52(9+29%450 1&'5' 839$',94'5 -(' ':7,%*'$ 2% :-@' ;9(: $'$3+29%45 -5 2% 2&' 7(%7%(29%4-,92* %;

('52(9+29%45 2% 2&' (98&2 2% 7(%2'52 94 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'50 1&' 839$',94'5 -,5% +%((%)%(-2' 2&'

-77(%-+&'5 2-@'4 34$'( 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& 692& ('8-($5 2% 7(%+'$3(-, 9553'50

1&' W'4'=- N+-$':* %; "42'(4-29%4-, Q3:-492-(9-4 F-6 -4$ Q3:-4 R98&25 ('+'42,*

(','-5'$ - )(9';948 7-7'( %4 2&' ;-+9,92-29%4 %; 7'-+';3, 7(%2'520/H1&' )(9';948 $%+3:'425 2&' ,-2'52

2('4$5 94 7'-+';3, 7(%2'525 -4$ &',75 2% ;,'5& %32 )'52 7(-+29+'5 94 2&('' @'* -('-5. 2&' $32* 2%

;-+9,92-2' 7'-+';3, 7(%2'52# ('D39('$ -+29%4 )* ,-6 '4;%(+':'42 %;;9+9-,5 -4$ 7('='42948 2&'

'a+'559=' 35' %; ;%(+' 94 7%,9+948 7(%2'520

1&'


15/68

6

(-2&'( 2&-4 ;(352(-2'# $':%452(-29%450>/j 1&' 52(-2'89'5 7(%7%5'$ 94 2&' ('7%(2 69,, )' 5+(329495'$

;%( 7%2'429-, 5392-)9,92* 94 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'50

SQ]/9D9=>IB 698BA:A?AHL

1&95 523$* 69,, 329,95' $'5@ ('=9'6 -4$ 94 2'(:5 %; 5+%7'# 92 69,, +-5' 523$* J'4*- -4$ X98'(9-0 1&'5'

+-5' 523$9'5 -(' 5','+2'$ ;%( 2&' ('-5%4 2&-2 J'4*- -4$ X98'(9- -(' +%459$'('$ +%342(9'5 %;

94;,3'4+' 94 2&'9( 53)S('89%45# V-52 N;(9+- -4$ A'52 N;(9+- ('57'+29=',*0 N$$929%4-,,*# 7%559),'

-$=-4+':'425 94 J'4*- -4$ X98'(9- :-* 7%(2'4$ - 7%5929=' 529:3,35 ;%( +%342(9'5 94 2&'9( 53)S

('89%45 2% ':3,-2'0 1&' 592' %; 2&' ('5'-(+& 69,, )' 94 X98'(9- -4$ -5 :3+& -5 2&95 ;-+2 %;;'(5 2&'

%77%(23492*# 92 69,, ':7,%* @'* 94;%(:-425 942'(=9'65 ;%( +,-(9;9+-29%4 -4$ 2% '4(9+& 2&' 523$*0

SQVE7678=87A;D A@ D84:L

N 7(',9:94-(* ,92'(-23(' ('=9'6 ('='-,'$ 2&-2 2&'(' 95 - 5+-(+92* %; 5+&%,-(,* 6%(@5 57'+9;9+-,,* %4

4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -5 92 (',-2'5 2% 7(%2'520 A&9,' 2&95 ,-+34- %;;'(5 7(%57'+25 ;%( 2&' 7('5'42

6%(@# 92 -,5% 7('5'425 - ,9:92-29%40 N5 7"$8'D3-,,* %)5'(='$./l

"2 95 &-($ 2% +%342 2&' 43:)'( %; )%%@5 94 2&' N48,%SP%::%46'-,2& 6%(,$ $'$9+-2'$ 2% 2&' 2%79+ %;

;('' 57''+&0 1&%5' %4 2&' 2%79+ %; 7(%2'52 -4$ -55':),* 6%3,$ 7(%)-),* 4%2 329,95' 2&' ;948'(5 %; )%2&

&-4$50>

1&' 6(92'( 69,, '4$'-=%3( 2% :9298-2' 2&95 94;%(:-29%4-, 8-7 )* +%453,2948 2&' )(%-$'52 =-(9'2* %;

('5%3(+'5 53+& -5 ('7%(25# 7-7'(5 -4$ 53+& %2&'( 35';3, 5%3(+'50

SQ^%O9>O79F A@ IB=D

P&-72'( %4' 7('5'425 2&' )-+@8(%34$ 2% 2&' 523$*# 2&' 52-2':'42 %; 2&' 7(%),':# ('5'-(+&

D3'529%45# 2&' :'2&%$%,%8* 2% )' -$%72'$ -4$ 34$'(2-@'5 - ('=9'6 %; @'* -4$ +3(('42 ,92'(-23('

(','=-42 2% 2&' 523$*0

P&-72'( 26% 7('5'425 2&' +%4+'723-, ;(-:'6%(@ ;%( 2&' 6%(@0 "2 )'8945 )* 5'22948 %32 2&'

4%(:-29=' ;(-:'6%(@ %; 2&' (98&2 2% ;(''$%: %; 7'-+';3, -55':),* 2&'4 942'((%8-2948 2&' 'a952'4+'

/j4 /i -)%='# /l0/l4 h -)%='# j0


16/68

7

%; - $95294+2 (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'0 "2 +%4+,3$'5 )* ('5%,=948 6&'2&'( 2&'(' 95 - (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'

942'(4-29%4-,,* -5 6',, -5 94 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'50

P&-72'( 2&('' 2-+@,'5 2&' 2&'%('29+-, ;(-:'6%(@ %; 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+&

-4$ 34$'(2-@'5 -4 -4-,*595 %; &%6 92 6%(@5 94 7(-+29+'0 T7'+9;9+-,,*# 2&95 +&-72'( -55'55'5 2&'

7(%57'+25 2&' -77(%-+& %;;'(5 2&(%38& 'a2(-7%,-29%4 %; 925 @'* ;'-23('5 -4$ 7(94+97,'50

P&-72'( ;%3( -4-,*5'5 2&' 52-2' %; 73),9+ 7(%2'525 94 2&' +%342(9'5 34$'( ('=9'60 1&95

94+,3$'5 - )(9'; &952%(* %; 7(%2'52# (','=-42 ,'8-, ;(-:'6%(@ 2%8'2&'( 692& 2&' +3(('42 52-235 %4

:-4-8':'42 %; $':%452(-29%450 "2 -,5% -55'55'5 2&' 7(%57'+25 %; 9:7,':'42-29%4 94 )%2& +%342(9'5

%; 523$* -5 6',, -5 '42(* -='43'5 ;%( 2&' -$%729%4 %; 2&' :%$',0

P&-72'( ;9=' +%459525 %; 2&' @'* ;94$9485# ('+%::'4$-29%45 -4$ +%4+,359%40 O'$3+29%45 69,,

)' $(-64 ;(%: +-4=-55'$ -(83:'425 -4$ ('+%::'4$-29%45 7(%7%5'$ 2%6-($5 94529232948 -

4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& %; $':%452(-29%45 94 J'4*- -4$ X98'(9-0

SQU)9@7;787A; A@ 89>6D

"4 2&95 $955'(2-29%4# 2&' 2'(:5 $':%452(-29%4 -4$ 7(%2'52 69,, )' 35'$ 942'(+&-48'-),*0 1&' La;%($

$9+29%4-(* $';94'5 - $':%452(-29%4 -5 ^- 73),9+ :''2948 %( :-(+& 7(%2'52948 -8-9452 5%:'2&948 %(

'a7('55948 =9'65 %4 - 7%,929+-, 9553'>0/g T9:9,-(,* - $':%452(-29%4 95 ',5'6&'(' $';94'$ -5 ^-4

%++-59%4 6&'4 - ,-(8' 8(%37 %; 7'%7,' 7(%2'52 -)%32 5%:'2&9480 T*4%4*:5 %( (',-2'$ 6%($5 ;%( 2&95

5'45' %; $':%452(-29%4 n-('o 7(%2'520>SU

T9:9,-(,*# 2&' 2'(:5. (98&2 2% ;(''$%: %; 7'-+';3, -55':),*# ;(''$%: %; -55':),*# 7'-+';3,

-55':),* 69,, )' 35'$ 942'(+&-48'-),*.?K

N4 q-55':),*r 95 -4 942'429%4-, -4$ 2':7%(-(* 8-2&'(948 94 - 7(9=-2' %( 73),9+ 57-+' ;%( - 57'+9;9+

73(7%5'0 "2 94+,3$'5 $':%452(-29%45# 9459$' :''29485# 52(9@'5# 7(%+'559%45# (-,,9'5 %( '='4 5925S940

/gLa;%($ $9+29%4-(9'5 &227.cc6660%a;%($$9+29%4-(9'50+%:c$';94929%4c'48,95&c$':%452(-29%4 B-++'55'$ GK I-* ?K/HC0/hI-+I9,,-4 O9+29%4-(* &227.cc6660:-+:9,,-4$9+29%4-(*0+%:c2&'5-3(35c)(9295&c$':%452(-29%4 B-++'55'$ GK I-*

?K/HC0?K NcQRPc?Kc?l B?K/?C l0


17/68

8

-.(P/ &_% \ K'/0& &.'"$0 K'/0&+ '0 &.#/# ( /'$.& &%

)#*%"0&/(`

ZQS';8>A:4I87A;

"5 2&'(' - 57'+9;9+ (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'm N,2&%38& 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& 2%

$':%452(-29%45 7(%+''$5 %4 2&' 7(':95' 2&-2 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' 95 U3529+9-),'# 2&'(')*

+('-2948 -4 '4292,':'42 %4 2&' 7-(2 %; $':%452(-2%(5 -4$ - $32* %4 2&' 7-(2 %; 2&' 52-2'[ 2&95 6%(@

4'='(2&','55 +%459$'(5 2&' D3'529%4 - 7'(294'42 %4'0 1&95 5'+29%4 -22':725 2% -456'( 2&' D3'529%4 0

ZQZ#D8=5?7DB7;H 8B9 >7HB8 8A :96A;D8>=89 !"#B7D8A>LM ?9H=? ;A>6D =;: I4D8A6

ZQZQS &B9 @4;:=69;8=? >7HB8 8A @>99:A6 A@ ??-4$ ^n4o% ('52(9+29%45 :-* )' 7,-+'$ %4 2&' 'a'(+95' %; 2&95 (98&2>?G

'a+'72 94 5% ;-( -5 95 ,'8-,,* 7'(:9559),'0

1&' (98&2 %; 7'-+';3, -55':),* 95 -,5% ;%34$ 94 2&' "42'(4-29%4-, P%='4-42 %4 V+%4%:9+#

T%+9-, -4$ P3,23(-, R98&25 B"PVTPRC 6&'(' 92 95 -(29+3,-2'$ 692& ('57'+2 2% 2(-$' 349%4 (98&25 -5 -

^(98&2 2% 52(9@'>0?H1&' (98&2 -++(3'5 2% +&9,$('4 -5 2&' P%4='429%4 %4 2&' R98&25 %; 2&' P&9,$ BPRPC

-;;9(:5 2&-2# ^T2-2'5 M-(29'5 ('+%8495' 2&' (98&25 %; 2&' +&9,$_ 2% ;(''$%: %; 7'-+';3, -55':),*0>?i

1&' N;(9+-4 &3:-4 (98&25 5*52': 59:9,-(,* ('+%8495'5 2&' (98&2 ;,$2&' N;(9+-4 P&-(2'( %4 Q3:-4

?/


18/68

9

-4$ M'%7,'5> R98&25 BN;(9+-4 P&-(2'(C 6&9+& 7(%=9$'5 2&-2 ^n'o='(* 94$9=9$3-, 5&-,, &-=' 2&' (98&2 2%

-55':),' ;('',* 692& %2&'(50>?j

ZQZQZ ( :7D87;I8 >7HB8 8A :96A;D8>=89 969>H9D

^1&' ,94'-8' %; - $95294+2 (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'# 2% 7(%2'52 %( 2% -55':),' 95 :%(' :9a'$ -4$ $9;;9+3,22% 2(-+'>?ln&'(' +%:7-('$ 2% ;(''$%: %; 'a7('559%4o0 N5 ;-( -5 Z(9295& &952%(* 8%'5# ^n2o&'(' 95 4%

29:' -2 6&9+& %4' +-4 '-59,* 7,%2 2&' '42(* %; - (98&2 2% -55':),* -4$ 7(%2'52 942% ,'8-, -4$ U3$9+9-,

$95+%3(5' 94 V48,-4$0>?g 1&' '-(,9'52 :'429%4 %; - $95294+2 (98&2 2% 7(%2'52 95 %)5'(='$ 94 2&'

^U3$8:'42 %; F%($ O'44948 IR 94 B/DD$%8 ; J,&&KL(6&'(' &' 52('55'$ 2&-2 ^2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'

-4$ 2&' (98&2 2% 7(%2'52 %4 :-22'(5 %; 73),9+ +%4+'(4_ -(' (98&25 6&9+& 92 95 94 2&' 73),9+ 942'('52

2&-2 94$9=9$3-,5 5&%3,$ 7%55'550>GKF%($ O'44948 ;%34$ &952%(9+-, 5377%(2 ;%( U3$9+9-, ('+%84929%4 %;

2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'.G/

n"o4 /g/h_ 2&' P%3(2 %; P%::%4 P%34+9, %; F%4$%4 -;;9(:'$ ^2&' 34$%3)2'$ (98&2 %; V48,95& :'4 2%

-55':),' 2%8'2&'( ;%( 2&' 73(7%5' %; $',9)'(-2948 37%4 73),9+ 8(9'=-4+'50> T3+& 95 2&' (98&2 %;

-55':),*0 T% -,5% 95 2&' (98&2 2% :''2 2%8'2&'(# 2% 8% 94 7(%+'559%4# 2% $':%452(-2' -4$ 2% 7(%2'52 %4

:-22'(5 %; 73),9+ +%4+'(40 N5 ,%48 -5 -,, 95 $%4' 7'-+'-),*_ 92 95 4%2 7(%&9)92'$0

"4 2&' B/DD$%8+-5'# %2&'( U3529+'5 -;;9(:'$ 2&' ;%('8%948 7%5929%4# T2-:7 F` 57%@' %; 2&' ^,9)'(2* 2%

57'-@# 2&' ,9)'(2* 2% -55':),' -4$ 2&' ,9)'(2* 2% 7(%2'52 %( +%::349+-2' 94;%(:-29%4>0G? F%($

O'44948 -,5% 4%2'$ 2&-2 2&' ^(98&2 %; 7(%2'52 95 %4' -57'+2 %; 2&' (98&2 2% ;('' 57''+&>0 GG N

53)5'D3'42 +-5' -32&%(92-29=',* -55'(25 2&' 'a952'4+' %; 2&' (98&2. ^V48,95& ,-6 37&%,$5 2% 2&' ;3,,

2&' (98&2 %; 7'%7,' 2% $':%452(-2' -4$ 2% :-@' 2&'9( =9'65 @4%64 5% ,%48 -5 -,, 95 $%4'

7'-+'-),*>0GHE%,,%6948 2&'5' ,'-$948 +-5'5# +%3(25 +-4 )' 5''4 2% )' :%(' 'a7,9+92 94 -55'(2948 -

(98&2 2% $':%452(-2'0 E%( 9452-4+' 94 2&' B,%2& +-5'# 7-(2 %; 2&' &%,$948 ('-$5 2&35. ^+%3(25 &-=' ,%48

('+%8495'$ 2&' (98&2_ 2% 7(%2'52 %4 :-22'(5 %; 73),9+ +%4+'(40>Gi

ZQZQX ';89>;=87A;=? >9IAH;787A; =;: =@@7>6=87A; A@ 8B9 >7HB8 8A A89D8

V:'(8'42 942'(4-29%4-, 4%(:5 -4$ 7(-+29+' '=9$'4+' ('+%84929%4 %; - (98&2 2% 7(%2'520 1&' R98&25# -(2 //0?lO I'-$ ?'" ."4 3$4 6+ >"$-"+/3 >%6&"2&@ A,1'&2 $.8 %"1/3$&,6. ,. &'" B/0$. A,1'&2 *-& "%$ B?K/KC H0?g-5 -)%='# H0?hB/DD$%8 ; J,&&n/hljo sZ /H? BPNC +92'$ 94 4 ?l -)%='# H0GK-5 -)%='# i0G/-5 -)%='0G?-5 -)%='0GG-5 -)%='0GHA ; M',"+ M6.2&$D3" 6+ N";6. $.8 M6%.4$33 "O >$%&" M".&%$3 P3"-&%,-,&E G"."%$&,.1 Q6$%8 n/hg?o sZ Hig# HlK0GiB,%2& $.8 *.1/ ; M',"+ M6.2&$D3" 6+ !"2& R6%F2',%" n/hglo gi P( N77 R# /HG0


19/68

10

5377%(2 2&' 349='(5-,92* %; - (98&2 2% 7'-+';3, 7(%2'520 L4' ('5%,329%4Gj'52-),95&'5 2&' :-4$-2' %; -

T7'+9-, R-77%(2'3( %4 2&' (98&25 2% ;(''$%: %; 7'-+';3, -55':),* -4$ %; -55%+9-29%4 6&9,'

-4%2&'(Gl ('4'65 2&95 :-4$-2'0 1&' T7'+9-, R-77%(2'3( %4 2&' (98&25 2% ;(''$%: %; 7'-+';3,

-55':),* &-5 )''4 9452(3:'42-, 94 2&' -(29+3,-29%4 %; - (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'0 "4 &95 ;9(52 ('7%(2 2%

2&' P%34+9,# 2&' T7'+9-, R-77%(2'3( $';94'5 2&-2# ^n-o4 q-55':),*r 95 -4 942'429%4-, -4$ 2':7%(-(*

8-2&'(948 94 - 7(9=-2' %( 73),9+ 57-+' ;%( - 57'+9;9+ 73(7%5'0 "2_ 94+,3$'5 $':%452(-29%45# 9459$'

:''29485# 52(9@'5# 7(%+'559%45# (-,,9'5_>Gg"4 - 53)5'D3'42 ('7%(2# 2&' T7'+9-, R-77%(2'3( ('92'(-2'5

2&-2 ^n2o&' -)9,92* 2% &%,$ 7'-+';3, -55':),9'5 95 - ;34$-:'42-, -4$ 942'8(-, +%:7%4'42 %; 2&'

:3,29;-+'2'$ (98&2 2% ;(''$%: %; 7'-+';3, -55':),*>0Gh "4 $%948 5%# &' &98&,98&25 2&'

:3,29$9:'459%4-, 4-23(' %; 2&' (98&2 2% ;(''$%: %; 7'-+';3, -55':),* 94 2&-2 92 '4+%:7-55'5

$95294+2 (98&25 53+& -5 7(%2'520

E3(2&'(# 94 73(53-4+' %; - $'+959%4HK)* 2&' Q3:-4 R98&25 P%34+9,# 2&' L;;9+' %; 2&'


20/68

11

(?? 08=89D B':7&-595 :94'C 6&9+& 7(%=9$'$ 94732 ;%( 2&95 ('7%(2 94$9+-2'$ 2&-2 2&' (98&2 2% 7'-+';3,

-55':),*# 6&9+& 94 5%:' +-5'5 -,5% :-@'5 (';'('4+' 2% 7'-+';3, 7(%2'52 %( $':%452(-29%4# 95

7(%2'+2'$ )* 2&' P%45292329%4# 57'+9;9+ ,'895,-29%4 %( )%2&0

1&' ;%('8%948 9,,352(-29%45 $% 4%2 +%4529232' -4 'a&-3529=' '43:'(-29%4 )32 +'(2-94,* 5'(=' 2%

9,,3:94-2' 2&' 942'(4-29%4-, -++'72-4+' %; - (98&2 2% 7'-+';3, 7(%2'520

ZQZQT &B9 $#"%&' )*+,$-@A> 8B9 >7HB8 8A :96A;D8>=89

Q-=948 942'((%8-2'$ -4$ '52-),95&'$ - $95294+2 (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'# - )(9'; 2','%,%89+-, -4-,*595 95

;922948 -4$ :-* 6',, 5'(=' 2% +%((%)%(-2' 2&' 2&'595 2&-2 2&'(' 95 - (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'0 1&95 +-,,5

;%( -4 'a-:94-29%4 %; 2&' %$,26. 8KS&%";%( 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'0

T+&%,-(,* ('=9'6 &-5 ('='-,'$ 2&-2 $':%+(-29+ 'a7('559%4 95 )* ;-( 2&' :%52 +%:7',,948 -4$

(','=-42 U3529;9+-29%4 ;%( 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'0 ^N,,%6948 +929b'45 2% '48-8' 94 73),9+ 7(%2'52 95

5''4 -5 )'948 %4' %; 2&' :-94 $95294+29%45 )'26''4 - 2%2-,92-(9-4 5%+9'2* -4$ - $':%+(-+*0> HG1&'


21/68

12

1&95 95 'D3-,,* 2&' +-5' ;%( 2&' (98&2 2% ;(''$%: %; -55':),*# 6&9+& 7(%=9$'5 2&' 4%(:-29='

;(-:'6%(@ -4$ )-595 ;%( 2&' (98&2 2% 7(%2'520 "2 &-5 )''4 5-9$ 2&-2 ^n2o&' (98&2 2% -55':),' 7'-+';3,,*

('525 -2 2&' +%(' %; ;34+29%4948 $':%+(-29+ 5*52':5# -4$ 95 +,%5',* (',-2'$ 2% %2&'( +%(4'(52%4'5 %;

$':%+(-+* -4$ 7,3(-,95:>0Hg1&95 5923-29%4 95 53++94+2,* +-723('$ )',%6.Hh

n1o&' ;(''$%: %; 7'-+';3, -55':),* 95 -55%+9-2'$ 692& 2&' (98&2 2% +&-,,'48' 2&' $%:94-42 =9'65

692&94 5%+9'2*# 2% 7('5'42 -,2'(4-29=' 9$'-5 -4$ %7949%45# 2% 7(%:%2' 2&' 942'('525 -4$ =9'65 %;

:94%(92* 8(%375 -4$ :-(894-,9b'$ 5'+29%45 %; 5%+9'2*# -4$ 2% 7(%=9$' -4 %77%(23492* ;%( 94$9=9$3-,5

2% 'a7('55 2&'9( =9'65 -4$ %7949%45 94 73),9+# ('8-($,'55 %; 2&'9( 7%6'(# 6'-,2& %( 52-2350

E94-,,*# 7(%2'52 7,-*5 - 349D3' 26%S7(%48'$ (%,' 94 ^$':%452(-2948 2% 2&' 8%='(4:'42 2&-2 92 &-5

52(-*'$ 2%% ;-( ;(%: 2&' 7-2& %; -++'72-)9,92*_ -4$ 7-(2,* $'2'((948 92 ;(%: $%948 5%0>iK

ZQX&B9 >7HB8 8A :96A;D8>=89 7; 19;L= =;: "7H9>7=

Q-=948 '52-),95&'$ 2&' $95294+2 (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'# 92 95 4'+'55-(* 2% 5923-2' 2&' 5-:' 94 2&' +-5'

523$* +%342(9'50 P929b'45 %; )%2& J'4*- -4$ X98'(9- '4U%* =-(9%35 +9=9, ,9)'(29'5 -4$ 2&'(';%('

$':%452(-29%45 6&'4 &',$ -(' 6',, 692&94 2&'9( (98&25 -5 69,, )' 'a':7,9;9'$0 1&'9( 4-29%4-,

+%45292329%45 83-(-42'' 2&' ;(''$%: %; -55':),* 6&9+& &%35'5 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'0 X98'(9->5

P%45292329%4 94 5'+29%4 HK 7(%=9$'5 2&-2# ^n'o='(* 7'(5%4 5&-,, )' '4292,'$ 2% -55':),' ;('',* -4$

-55%+9-2' 692& %2&'( 7'(5%45 %( 7%,929+-, 7-(2*0>i/X98'(9-4 +-5' ,-6 37&%,$5 2&' 59849;9+-4+' %; 2&95

(98&2.i?

N5 %)5'(='$ )* 2&' P%3(2 %; N77'-, 94 UHGHJ ; *HVHJHJ9IW 2&' (98&25 2% ;(''$%: %; -55':),* -4$

'a7('559%4 -(' 2&' )%4' %; -4* $':%+(-29+ ;%(: %; 8%='(4:'420 1&'* -(' 7-(2 %; 2&' ;%34$-29%4 %4

6&9+& $':%+(-29+ 8%='(4-4+' ('5250iH

I%(' 7('+95',*# 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' -5 -4 -57'+2 %; 2&' (98&2 2% ;(''$%: %; -55':),* &-5

('+'9='$ U3$9+9-, -77(%=-, )* 2&' X98'(9-4 +%3(25 -5 2&'* &-=' &',$ 2&-2.ii

HgLTPV L;;9+' ;%( O':%+(-29+ "45292329%45 -4$ Q3:-4 R98&25 B$.8D66F 6. 06.,&6%,.1 +%""860 6+ >"$-"+/3 $22"0D3EB?K//C i0Hh-5 -)%='# l0iK4 HG -)%='# hHl0i/P%45292329%4 %; 2&' E'$'(-, R'73),9+ %; X98'(9-# /hhh# 5'+ HK0i?LX L8)3 B/0$. %,1'&2 3$4 $.8 >%$-&,-" ,. V,1"%,$ B?K/GC GjH0iGB?KKlC /g XAFR B72 /KjjC Hil0iH-5 -)%='# Hhg SiKK0iiU.2>"-&6%XG"."%$3 6+ J63,-" ; *33 V,1"%,$ J"6>3"2 J$%&E T Y&'"%2 B?KKlC /g XAFR HjhSiKK 7-(-5 ZSP +92'$ 94 "1 T-:75%4

^1&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' 94 - $':%+(-+*. N4 '=-,3-29%4 %; 73),9+ %($'( 7%,9+948 94 X98'(9-> B?K/KC ? *+%,-$. '/0$. %,1'&2

3$4 56/%.$3 HHl0


22/68

13

nPo'(2-94,*# 94 - $':%+(-+*# 92 95 2&' (98&2 %; +929b'45 2% +%4$3+2 7'-+';3, 7(%+'559%45# (-,,9'5 %(

$':%452(-29%45 692&%32 5''@948 %( %)2-94948 7'(:9559%4 ;(%: -4*)%$*0 "2 95 - (98&2 83-(-42''$ )*

2&' /hhh P%45292329%4 -4$ -4* ,-6 2&-2 -22':725 2% +3(2-9, 2&-2 (98&2 95 43,, -4$ =%9$ -4$ %; 4%

+%45'D3'4+'0

J'4*->5 P%45292329%4 8%'5 - 52'7 ;3(2&'( )* 'a7('55,* 52-2948 2&-2# ^n'o='(* 7'(5%4 &-5 2&' (98&2#

7'-+'-),* -4$ 34-(:'$# 2% -55':),'# 2% $':%452(-2'# 2% 79+@'2# -4$ 2% 7('5'42 7'2929%45 2% 73),9+

-32&%(929'50>ijN(83-),*# 2&95 7(%=959%4 94 2&' J'4*-4 P%45292329%4 95 2&' %32+%:' %; 2&' 'a7'(9'4+'

%; 2&' 94-$'D3-+9'5 %; +%45292329%4-, 7(%=959%45 2&-2 :'(',* -;;9(: - (98&2 2% ;(''$%: %; -55':),*

;(%: 6&9+& - (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' :-* )' $'$3+'$0 1&' 'a7'(9'4+' &-5 )''4 2&-2 %;2'4 29:'5#

2%2-,92-(9-4 8%='(4:'425 ('U'+2 53+& ,9)'(-, ('-$9485 %; 2&' (98&2 2% -55':),' -5 V48,95& +%3(25 &-='

'a2(-7%,-2'$ 94 B/DD"% -4$ %2&'( +-5'5 (';'(('$ 2% -)%='0 T3+& 'a7'(9'4+' 6-5 +%::%47,-+'

$3(948 2&' -7-(2&'9$ *'-(5 94 T%32& N;(9+- -4$ %;;'('$ 59849;9+-42 ,'55%45 2&-2 -++%342 ;%( 2&'

'a7('55 -;;9(:-29%4 %; - (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' 94 2&' +%342(*>5 7%52S-7-(2&'9$ P%45292329%40 1&'

J'4*-4 P%45292329%4 )%((%6'$ $9('+2,* -4$ ='()-29: ;(%: 2&' T%32& N;(9+-4 P%45292329%40il

1&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' 95 2&'(';%(' 34'D39=%+-, 94 )%2& +-5' 523$* +%342(9'5 -,2&%38& =9-

$9;;'('42 (%32'50 "4 %4'# 92 &-5 )''4 $'$3+'$ ;(%: - +%45292329%4-, (98&2 2% ;(''$%: ;(%: -55':),*

6&9,' 94 2&' %2&'( 92 95 'a7('55,* -;;9(:'$ -5 - +%45292329%4-, (98&20

ZQT-A;I?4D7A;

1&' +&-72'( ',3+9$-2'5 - $95294+2 (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' 6&9+& 95 ('+%8495'$ )%2& 942'(4-29%4-,,* -4$

94 2&' ('57'+29=' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'50 1&' ;-+2 %; 2&' ('+%84929%4 %; 2&' (98&2 94 2&'%(*# &%6'='(#

$%'5 4%2 :'-4 2&-2 94 925 2(-U'+2%(*# 2&'(' &-5 4%2 )''4 %77%5929%40 7"$8 +-723('5 2&' 5923-29%4

53++94+2,*.ig

1&'(' 95 - +,'-( &%:%8'4'92* -)%32 2&' =-,3' -4$ 4'+'5592* %; ;(''$%: 2% 57'-@# '='4 2% 57'-@

%;;'459=',* %( )-5','55,*[ 2&' 5-:' +-44%2 )' 5-9$ -)%32 2&' (98&2 2% 7(%2'52 -4$ $':%452(-2' $'5792'

2&' -,,9'$# 5*:)9%29+ 4-23(' %; 2&' 26% (98&250 1%% %;2'4_ 92 95 -(83'$ 2&-2 2&' (98&2 2% 7(%2'52 5&%3,$

D392' 7(%7'(,* )' +%342'(=-9,'$ )* 2&' +%4='49'4+' %; %2&'(5# )3594'55 $95(3729%4 -4$ 2&'

^34('-5%4-),'> 4-23(' %; 7(%2'520 "2 95# D392' 59:7,*# 94+%4+'9=-),' 2&-2 5'459),' 7'%7,' 6%3,$ -(83'

2&-2 ;('' 57''+& 5&%3,$ )' +3(2-9,'$ )'+-35' %2&'(5 :98&2 )' ^94+%4='49'4+'$> %( ^)'+-35' " $95-8(''

692& *%3>0

ijP%45292329%4 %; J'4*-# ?K/K# -(2 Gl0ilP%45292329%4 %; 2&' R'73),9+ %; T%32& N;(9+-# /hhj# -(2 /l0ig4 ?l -)%='# l0


23/68

14

1&' ;%('8%948 D3%2' ,'4$5 =-,9$92* 2% 2&' (','=-4+' -4$ 59849;9+-4+' %; 2&' ('5'-(+& 7(%),': 2&-2 95

2&' ;%+35 %; 2&95 6%(@ 6&9+& 95 2&-2 -,, 2%% %;2'4# 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' 95 ;('',* $957'45'$ 692&

%( '='4 6%(5' +%342'( )-,-4+'$ -2 2&' -,2-( %; ^+%4='49'4+'>0

1&' %)U'+29=' 95 2% 'a7,%(' -4 -77(%-+& 2&-2 +-4 '453(' 2&-2 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' +-4 )' :%('

:'-4948;3,,* ('-,95'$0


24/68

15

-.(P/ &./## \ "#$%&'() *("($#*#"&+ P/'"-'PE#0 3

P/%0P#-&0

XQS';8>A:4I87A;

1&95 +&-72'( 942(%$3+'5 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& )* +%:7('&'459=',* ',3+9$-2948 925

'55'4+'# 7(94+97,'5 -4$ 52(-2'89'50 1&' +&-72'( -,5% -$$('55'5 2&' 9:7-+2 %; 2&95 -77(%-+& %4 2&'

&-4$,948 %; 7(%2'525# 2(-='(5948 2&' =-(9%35 $329'5 2&-2 -++(3' 2% 2&' 52-2' %4 -++%342 %; 2&95 :%$',0

"4 $%948 5%# 2&' $95+3559%4 &98&,98&25 2&' 7(%57'+25 %; - 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& 94

'4&-4+948 2&' ('-,95-29%4 %; 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'0 1&' +&-72'( 69,, +%4+,3$' )* &98&,98&2948

+&-,,'48'5 2&-2 :-* +%452(-94 2&' ('-$* -$%729%4 %; 2&' :%$',[ 6&9+& 69,, %;;'( ,'55%45 ;%( 2&' +-5'

523$* +%342(9'50

XQZ&B9 ;9HA87=89: 6=;=H969;8 6A:9?

^n1o&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& &-5# %='( 2&' ,-52 ;'6 $'+-$'5# 7('=-9,'$ 94 :3+& %; 2&'

jK ^E%,,%6948 $')9,92-2948 +,-5&'5 )'26''4

$':%452(-2%(5 -4$ 7%,9+' 94 2&' /hjK5>#j/

:%52 6'52'(4 $':%+(-+9'5 )'8-4 2% 'a7,%(' 2&'4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+&0 ^n1o&%5' 6&% &-$ 2% $% 73),9+S%($'( 7%,9+948 +-:' 2% 2&'

+%4+,359%4 2&-2 92 6%3,$ )' :%(' 7(%$3+29='# 6&'(' 7%559),'# 2% 6%(@ 692& +(%6$5# (-2&'( 2&-4

-8-9452 2&':0>j? 1&' T7'+9-, R-77%(2'3( %4 'a2(-U3$9+9-,# 53::-(* %( -()92(-(* 'a'+329%45 &-5

,-3$'$ 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -4$ 53++94+2,* &98&,98&2'$ 925 @'* ;'-23('.jG


25/68

16

1&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 ^;%+35'5 %4 :949:95948 =9%,'4+' -4$ )-,-4+948 2&' (98&25 %; +%:7-49'5#

8%='(4:'425 -4$ 2&' 8'4'(-, 73),9+ 692& 2&%5' %; 6%(@'(5 -4$ 57'+9-, 942'('52 8(%375>jH -4$

2&'(';%(' '4-),'5 2&' 7%559)9,92* %; - 694S694 5923-29%4 ;%( -,, 7-(29'5 94=%,='$0

"4 52-(@ +%42(-52# 94 N;(9+-# -4$ -5 6',, 94 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'5# 7(%2'525 -('

7('$%:94-42,* &-4$,'$ 35948 2&' '5+-,-2'$ ;%(+' :%$', %; 7(%2'52 7%,9+948 2&-2 7('+'$'$

4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'420 ^J'* ;'-23('5 %; '5+-,-2'$ ;%(+'_ 94+,3$'. kI-559=' 35' %; ;%(+' 2% $'2'(

'='4 :94%( =9%,-29%45[ "429:9$-2948 35' %; (',-29%45 692& %(8-495'(5[ n-4$o W'4'(-,9b'$ -4$

94$95+(9:94-2' 94;%(:-29%4 8-2&'(948k0ji N2 925 6%(52# ^2&' :9,92-4+* %; 7(%2'52%(5 n95o :'2 )*

94+('-5'$ :9,92-4+* )* 2&' 7%,9+'0 N4* 5&%6 %; ;%(+' %( =9%,'4+' )* 2&' 7(%2'52%(5 n95o :'2 692&

%='(6&',:948 ;%(+' 94 ('23(40>jj

O':%452(-29%45 94 N;(9+- -4$ 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'5 )'-( 2&' +,'-( :-(@5 %; -4 '5+-,-2'$

;%(+' :%$',0 1&95 95 94 5792' %; 2&' ;-+2 2&-2 2&' (98&2 2% ;(''$%: %; 7'-+';3, -55':),* 95 ('+%8495'$

94 2&' "PPMR# N;(9+-4 P&-(2'( -4$ =9(23-,,* -,, 4-29%4-, ,-65 94+,3$948 2&%5' %; 2&' +-5' 523$*

+%342(9'50 1&' N;(9+-4 P%::9559%4 %4 Q3:-4 -4$ M'%7,'5> R98&25 BN;(9+-4 P%::9559%4C &-5

%)5'(='$ 2&-2 ^'a'(+95948 2&95 (98&2# '='4 7'-+';3,,*# 95 %;2'4 :'2 692& ('7('559%4 -4$ )(32-,92* ;(%:

2&' 52-2' -4$ 925 -77-(-2350>jl

1&95 6-5 -,5% 2&' +-5' ;%( 6'52'(4 $':%+(-+9'5 94 $'+-$'5 7-520 ^"4 ('57%45' 2% 2&' 8(%6948

=9%,'4+' -2 $':%452(-29%45_ n2&'o 4'6 $%+2(94' %; ^^4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42>> ':'(8'$ )-5'$ %4

8('-2'( +%%7'(-29%4 )'26''4 7%,9+' -4$ $':%452(-2%(5 -4$ -4 ';;%(2 2% -=%9$ =9%,'4+'0>jgW9='4 2&'

8-945 ('-,95'$ 94 +%342(9'5 6&9+& &-=' -$%72'$ 92# 92 95 29:' ;%( N;(9+- -4$ 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'5

2% :%=' 2%6-($5 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 %; $':%452(-29%450 1&' N;(9+-4 P%::9559%4 5&-('5 2&95

+%4=9+29%4 &-=948 ('+'42,* 52-2'$ 2&-2.jh

N5 N;(9+- 6924'55'5 -4 94+('-5' 94 2&' 43:)'( %; 7(%2'525# 2&' +&-,,'48'5 %; 9:7,':'42-29%4 %;

@4%64 -4$ -++'72'$ 52-4$-($5 &-5 94U'+2'$ - 4'6 3(8'4+* 942% 2&' 73),9+ %($'( 7%,9+948 $')-2'0 1&'

N;(9+-4 P%::9559%4 %4 Q3:-4 -4$ M'%7,'5> R98&25 95 +3(('42,* $'=',%7948 925 ;%+35 %4 2&' +(929+-,

jHO Z-@'( Ê(%: )-2%45 2% 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42. 1&' 2(-45;%(:-29%4 %; 7%,9+948 94$352(9-, $95732'5 94 N352(-,9-> Gh/

-=-9,-),' -2 &227.cc7%,9+9480%a;%($U%3(4-,50%(8 B-++'55'$ /K L+2%)'( ?K/HC0jiO O',,- M%(2- e Q R'92'( ?'" >63,-,.1 6+ &%$.2.$&,6.$3 >%6&"2& B?KKjC /gG +92'$ 94 Ò I+P-(2&* ^1&' M%,9+948 %;

1(-454-29%4-, M(%2'52 )* O%4-2',,- O',,- M%(2-[ N))* M'2'(5%4[ Q'()'(2 R'92'(> B?KKlC iK*-&$ =6-,6361,-$ HH/0jjNT t92-,' Ê(%: 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 2% +%::-4$ -4$ +%42(%,. Q%6 2&' X'6 Y%(@ M%,9+' O'7-(2:'42 7%,9+'5

7(%2'525> B?KKjC /i J63,-,.1 $.8 =6-,"&E@ *. U.&"%.$&,6.$3 Z6/%.$3 A"2"$%-' 6+ A"2"$%-' $.8 J63,-E ?gj0jlN;(9+-4 P%::9559%4 %4 Q3:-4 -4$ M'%7,'5> R98&25# O-495& "4529232' ;%( Q3:-4 R98&25 e N;(9+-4 M%,9+948 P9=9,9-4

L='(598&2 E%(3: ^M%,9+' -4$ &3:-4 (98&25 94 N;(9+-> B?K/HC H V"423"&&"% 6. J63,-" $.8 B/0$. A,1'&2 ,. *+%,-$ G0jg4 jj -)%='0jh4 jl -)%='0


26/68

17

-('- %; M%,9+' -4$ Q3:-4 R98&250 "4 2&95 +%42'a2# 2&' P%::9559%4 :-* )' 6',, 5'(='$ 2% +%459$'( 2&'

$'=',%7:'42 %; 925 %64 N;(9+-4 839$',94'5 %4 ;-+9,92-2948 7'-+';3, 7(%2'520

1&' N;(9+-4 P%::9559%4>5 -55'55:'42 %; - 73),9+ %($'( :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& 95 94 ,94' 692& -4$ 94

;-+2 $'5+(9)'5 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'420 1&95 95 $95+'(49),' ;(%: 2&'9( =9'6 2&-2 ^n7o%,9+948 7(%2'52

-+29%4 -4$ 57'+9;9+-,,* 7'-+';3, 7(%2'52 :352 732 $9-,%83'# +%::349+-29%4 -4$ 4'8%29-29%4 -2 2&'

+%('0 1&'5' -(' ;34$-:'42-, =-,3'5 94 -4* $':%+(-29+ -4$ +%::3492* +'42('$ 7%,9+948 7-(-$98:0>lK

XQX&B9 9@@9I8 A@ ;9HA87=89: 6=;=H969;8 A; 8B9 >7HB8 8A :96A;D8>=89

1&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& )'52%65 %),98-29%45 -4$ $329'5 %4 2&' 7-(2 %; 2&' 52-2' -4$

925 -77-(-235 94 2&' &-4$,948 %; $':%452(-29%450 T+&%,-(5# 7(-+2929%4'(5# (98&25 &%,$'(5 -4$ $32*

)'-('(5 -(' -,6-*5 +%4+'(4'$ 692& 2&' 4-23(' %; %),98-29%4 2&-2 - (98&2 9:7%5'5 -5 2&95 &-5 - $9('+2

+%((',-29%4 2% 925 ('-,95-29%40 A92& ('8-($5 2% 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'# 92 &-5 )''4 5-9$ 2&-2.l/

P%:7,*948 692& 2&' (98&2 2% 7(%2'52 94 2&' +%42'a2 %; ;(''$%: %; -55':),* '42-9,5 )%2& 2&' 4'8-29='

%),98-29%4 %; (';(-94948 ;(%: 942'(;'(948 692& 7'-+';3, 7(%2'525 -4$ 2&' 7%5929=' %),98-29%4 %;

7(%2'+2948 (98&25 &%,$'(5# 94+,3$948 &3:-4 (98&25 $';'4$'(5# 94 2&' 'a'(+95' %; 2&'9( (98&2 2% 7(%2'520

XQXQS "9H=87O9 A5?7H=87A;

"4 5% ;-( -5 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' $'(9='5 ;(%: 2&' (98&2 2% ;(''$%: %; 7'-+';3, -55':),* 6&9+&

95 - +9=9, -4$ 7%,929+-, (98&2# 92 95 2&'(';%(' -,5% +-2'8%(95'$ -5 - +9=9, -4$ 7%,929+-, (98&20 P9=9, -4$

7%,929+-, (98&25 353-,,* +%4U3(' - 4'8-29=' $32* %4 2&' 7-(2 %; 2&' 52-2' 90'0 2&' 8'4'(-, $32* 2%

(';(-940

1&95 %),98-29%4 ('D39('5 2&' 52-2' -4$ 925 -77-(-235 2% (';(-94 ;(%: 942'(;'(948 692& 2&'

'a'(+95' %; 2&' (98&2 2% 7(%2'520 1%6-($5 2&95# 2&' T7'+9-, R-77%(2'3( %4 2&' (98&25 2% ;(''$%: %;

7'-+';3, -55':),* -4$ %; -55%+9-29%4 ^+%459$'(5 -5 - )'52 7(-+29+' 2&' 7('53:729%4 94 ;-=%3( %;

&%,$948 7'-+';3, -55':),9'5# -5 52('55'$ )* 2&' LTPVcLO"QR M-4', %; Va7'(25 %4 E(''$%: %;

M'-+';3, N55':),*0>l? E(%: - 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 =9'6# 2&95 7('53:729%4 &-5 26% @'*

9:7,9+-29%450 1&' ;9(52 95 2&-2 ^n-o4*2&948 4%2 'a7('55,* ;%()9$$'4 )* ,-6 5&%3,$ )' 7('53:'$ 2% )'

7'(:9559),'# -4$ 2&%5' 695&948 2% -55':),' 5&%3,$ 4%2 )' ('D39('$ 2% %)2-94 7'(:9559%4 2% $% 5%0>lG

lK4 jl -)%='0l/

Ncj?c??i B?KKlC ?0l? NcQRPc?Kc?l B?K/?C g0lGLTPV L;;9+' ;%( O':%+(-29+ "45292329%45 -4$ Q3:-4 R98&25 G/,8"3,."2 6. +%""860 6+ >"$-"+/3 $22"0D3E B?K/KC /i0


27/68

18

1&' 5'+%4$ 95 2&-2 2&' 5-9$ 7('53:729%4 94 ;-=%3( %; 7(%2'52 ^5&%3,$ )' +,'-(,* -4$ 'a7,9+92,*

'52-),95&'$ 94 ,-60>lH

1&' T7'+9-, R-77%(2'3( ('92'(-2'5 2&-2 ^T2-2'5_ &-=' - 4'8-29=' %),98-29%4 4%2 2% 34$3,*

942'(;'(' 692& 2&' (98&2 2% 7'-+';3, -55':),*0>li Q' 7(%7%5'5 2&' ;%,,%6948 2'52 2%6-($5 ,9:92948

7(%&9)929%4 %; 7(%2'525.lj

M(%&9)929%4 5&%3,$ )' - :'-53(' %; ,-52 ('5%(2 -4$ 2&' -32&%(929'5 :-* 7(%&9)92 - 7'-+';3, -55':),*

%4,* 6&'4 - ,'55 ('52(9+29=' ('57%45' 6%3,$ 4%2 -+&9'=' 2&' ,'8929:-2' -9:B5C 73(53'$ )* 2&'

-32&%(929'50

1&' 3,29:-2' 2'52 7(%7%5'$ )* 2&' T7'+9-, R-77%(2'3( 95 2&-2 ^-4* ('52(9+29%45 9:7%5'$ :352 )'

4'+'55-(* -4$ 7(%7%(29%4-2' 2% 2&' -9: 73(53'$0>ll

XQXQZ PAD787O9 A5?7H=87A;

1(-$929%4-,,*# +9=9, -4$ 7%,929+-, (98&25 6'(' 2&%38&2 2% '48'4$'( 4'8-29=' %),98-29%45 6&9,' 5%+9%S

'+%4%:9+ (98&25 )'8'2 7%5929=' %),98-29%450 1&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& 7('$%:94-42,*

94=%@'5 - 7%5929=' %),98-29%4 %4 2&' 7-(2 %; 52-2'5 $'5792' 2&' +,-559;9+-29%4 %; 2&' (98&2 2% 7(%2'52 -5

- +9=9, -4$ 7%,929+-, (98&20 1&95 7%5929=' %),98-29%4 5&%3,$ 4%2 )' 5''4 -5 -4 -4%:-,* %( -4

944%=-29%40 1&' 2(-$929%4-, -77(%-+& 6&9+& (989$,* +,-559;9'$ &3:-4 (98&25 942% $95294+2 +,-55'5 %;

+9=9, -4$ 7%,929+-, (98&25 '48'4$'(948 %4,* 4'8-29=' %),98-29%45[ -4$ 5%+9%S'+%4%:9+ -4$ +3,23(-,

(98&25 '48'4$'(948 %4,* 7%5929=' %),98-29%45 &-5 ,%48 )''4 U'2295%4'$0 1&' /hhG t9'44- O'+,-(-29%4

%4 Q3:-4 R98&25 -$%72'$ 94 /hhG -;;9(:5 2&-2 ^n-o,, &3:-4 (98&25 n+9=9, -4$ 7%,929+-,# 5%+9%S

'+%4%:9+ -4$ +3,23(-,C -(' 349='(5-,# 94$9=959),' -4$ 942'($'7'4$'42 -4$ 942'((',-2'$0>lg

1&' @'* :-49;'52-29%4 %; 2&' 52-2'>5 7%5929=' %),98-29%4 94 2&' 7(%2'+29%4 %; (98&25 -4$ 2%

;-+9,92-2' $':%452(-29%45 95 5''4 94 ^2&' (%,' %; ,-6S'4;%(+':'42 %;;9+9-,5 n6&9+&o 8%'5 )'*%4$

('+%849b948 2&' 'a952'4+' %; ;34$-:'42-, (98&25 -4$ 94+,3$'5 7%5929=',* 5-;'83-($948 2&%5' (98&25>0lh

Z'52 7(-+29+' 94 2&95 ('8-($ 5388'525 2&-2.gK

1&95 5&%3,$ )' 'a7('55,* 52-2'$ 94 -4* (','=-42 $%:'529+ ,'895,-29%4 7'(2-94948 2% ;(''$%: %;

-55':),* -4$ 7%,9+' -4$ :9,92-(* 7%6'(50 1&95 7%5929=' %),98-29%4 ('D39('5 2&' 52-2' 2% 7(%2'+2 2&'

lH4 lG -)%='0li4 l? -)%='# //0lj4 l? -)%='# //0ll4 l? -)%='# //0lg NcPLXE0/ilc?H B/hhGC 7-(- i0lh4 lG -)%='# li0gK4 lG -)%='# Gj0


28/68

19

7-(29+97-425 %; - 7'-+';3, -55':),* ;(%: -4* 7'(5%45 %( 8(%375 B94+,3$948 $1".&2 >%6;6-$&"/%2 -4$

+%342'(S$':%452(-2%(5C 2&-2 -22':72 2% $95(372 %( 94&9)92 2&': 94 -4* 6-*0

N5 +-4 )' %)5'(='$# 2&95 %),98-29%4 4'+'55-(9,* 94;%(:5 -4 -77(%-+& 2&-2 95 $9;;'('42 ;(%: 2&'

-77(%-+& 2-@'4 94 -4 '5+-,-2'$ ;%(+' :%$', '=9$'42 94 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'5 6&'(' 7%,9+' 2('-2

2&' 7(%2'52'(5 4%2 -5 2&' 7'(5%45 $'5'(=948 %; 7(%2'+29%4# (-2&'( -5 2&' %;;'4$'(50 E(%: -4

'5+-,-2'$ ;%(+' :%$', 52-4$S7%942# ^+(%6$5 -(' )'52 34$'(52%%$ -5 9((-29%4-,# :%4%,92&9+ 34925 2&-2

-(' $-48'(%35 -4$ 7(%4' 2% =9%,'4+' n6&'('-5 2&'o 4'6 -77(%-+& ('8-($n5o 52'('%2*7'5 -55%+9-2'$

692& 2&' +,-559+-, 34$'(52-4$948 %; +(%6$ )'&-=9%3( -5 6(%48 -4$ 7%2'429-,,* $-48'(%35>g/"2 %;;'(5

2&' 94598&2 +(929+-, 2% 34$'(52-4$948 2&-2 ;%(+' B;(%: 2&' 7%,9+'C )'8'25 ;%(+' B;(%: 2&' 7(%2'52'(5C0

N9:948 2% +%(('+2 2&95 7('+%4+'9='$ )9-5# 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& ':7&-595'5

2&-2 8%='(4:'425 :352 +%:7('&'4$ 7(%2'52 -5 (-29%4-, )'&-=9%3([ $':%+(-29+ 'a7('559%4 %;

$955'42 %( $957,'-53(' )* :':)'(5 %; 2&' +929b'4(*0 I%52 :%$'(4 8%='(4:'425 -(' +%:948 2% 2&95('-,95-29%4 -4$ -(' 5''@948 2% 9:7(%=' 2&'9( 7(%2'52 7%,9+948 94;(-52(3+23('0 E%( 9452-4+'# 2&'


29/68

20

2(-94948 %; ,-6 '4;%(+':'42 %;;9+9-,5# 94+,3$948 94 &3:-4 (98&250>gH1&95 5'(='5 2% ('92'(-2' 2&' ;-+2

2&-2 2&95 $32* %4 2&' 7-(2 %; 8%='(4:'42 95 4%6 -4 -++'72'$ =9'60

XQT$47:7;H 7;I7


30/68

21

6&% ,952'$ 92 -5 %4' %; 2&' ';;'+29=' :'-53('5 -4$ )'52 7(-+29+'5 2% '453(' 2&' 7(%:%29%4 -4$

7(%2'+29%4 %; &3:-4 (98&25 94 7'-+';3, 7(%2'520gg

F'-$948 5+&%,-(5 -4$ ('5'-(+&'(5 94 7(%2'52 :-4-8':'42 &-=' ('+'42,* ('+%::'4$'$ 2&-2

^X-29%4-, ('83,-29%45 5&%3,$ -$%72 2&' ^5-;'2* 2(9-48,'> -77(%-+& 2% 7(%:%2' 2&' 4'8%29-2'$

:-4-8':'42 %; 7(%2'5250>gh1&95 ;%(:-,95-29%4 95 94 ('+%84929%4 %; 2&' 94$957'45-),' (%,' 2&-2 2&'

5-;'2* 2(9-48,' 7,-*5 2% 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ -4$ ';;'+29=' :-4-8':'42 %; $':%452(-29%450

Q%6'='(# 2&'(' :-* )' 9452-4+'5 6&'(' - H 2& 8(%37 %; 52-@'&%,$'(5 :-* 4''$ 2% )'

('7('5'42'$ 94 2&' 5-;'2* 2(9-48,'# 6&9+& :-* 9:7,9+-2' - +&-48' %; 2'(:94%,%8* 2% q5-;'2* 5D3-('r0

N +-5' 94 7%942 95 2&-2 2&'(' 95 - (':-94$'( %; 2&' 73),9+ 2&-2 95 4%2 $955'42948 )32 :-* )' 9:7-+2'$

)* 2&' 7(%2'52>5 %32+%:'50 M'(&-75 92 95 ;-9( 2% 5-* 2&-2 53+& -4 942'('52 69,, )' ('7('5'42'$ )* 2&'

52-2'# )32 -5 $'79+2'$ )* +-5'5 %; +%342'( $':%452(-29%4 94=%,=948 -429S-)%(29%4 %( 7(%S$'-2&

7'4-,2* -4$ -429S$'-2& 7'4-,2* 7(%2'52'(5[ &-(:%495-29%4 %; -,, 942'('525 692&94 %4' 5-;'2* 2(9-48,'

+-4 )' $9;;9+3,20 "(('57'+29=' %; 2&95# 2&' 7%,9+' &-=' ^- $32* 2% 7(%2'+2 -4$ ;-+9,92-2' '-+& '='42

6&'(' +%342'(S$':%452(-29%45 -(' %(8-495'$ %( %++3(# -4$ 2&' 52-2' 5&%3,$ :-@' -=-9,-),'

-$'D3-2' 7%,9+948 ('5%3(+'5 2% ;-+9,92-2' 53+& (',-2'$ 59:3,2-4'%35 -55':),9'5>0hK

XQTQZ )7=?AH49 =;: IA664;7I=87A;

O9-,%83' -4$ +%::349+-29%4 -(' 5%:' 7(94+97-, 79,,-(5 %; 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+&

-4$ -(' +%,,'+29=',* $95+355'$ &'(' %6948 2% 2&'9( 942'($'7'4$'42 4-23('0 N:%48 2&' 8%='(4:'42>5

7%5929=' %),98-29%45 95 ^2&' 4''$ 2% ;-+9,92-2' 7'-+';3, 7(%2'52 2&(%38& $9-,%83' -4$

+%::349+-29%40>h/ 1&' T7'+9-, R-77%(2'3( %4 2&' (98&25 2% ;(''$%: %; 7'-+';3, -55':),* -4$ %;

-55%+9-29%4 ^52('55'5 2&' 32:%52 9:7%(2-4+' %; 8'4394' $9-,%83'# 94+,3$948 2&(%38& 4'8%29-29%4#

)'26''4 ,-6 '4;%(+':'42 -32&%(929'5 -4$ %(8-495'(5 94 %($'( 2% '453(' 2&' 5:%%2& +%4$3+2 %; 2&'

73),9+ -55':),*>0h?

O9-,%83' 95 (','=-42 )%2& )';%(' -4$ $3(948 2&' 7(%2'520 "4 %($'( ;%( 2&' 7%,9+' 2% 7,-* 2&'9(

;-+9,92-29=' (%,'# 2&'(' 5&%3,$ )' ^8%%$ $9-,%83'# +%::349+-29%4 -4$ +%S%7'(-29%4 )'26''4 7%,9+'

-4$ 7(%2'52%(5[ 7%,9+' -4$ 2&9($ 7-(29'5[ -4$ 7(%2'52%(5 -4$ 2&%5' -8-9452 6&%: 2&'* -('

gg4 gH -)%='# g0ghW'4'=- N+-$':* %; "42'(4-29%4-, Q3:-492-(9-4 F-6 -4$ Q3:-4 R98&25 *-$8"0E D%,"+,.1 .6HI@ C$-,3,&$&,.1 >"$-"+/3

>%6&"2&2B?K/HC GK0hK4 lG -)%='# /g0h/Q W%((948'# P T2%22 e I R%59' ^O9-,%83' 7%,9+'# $'+959%4 :-@948# -4$ 2&' :-4-8':'42 %; 73),9+ %($'( $3(948 7(%2'52

+(%6$ '='425> B?K/?C hZ6/%.$3 6+ U.;"2&,1$&,;" J2E-'6361E $.8 Y++".8"% J%6+,3,.1 ///0h?4 l? -)%='# //0


31/68

22

7(%2'529480>hG" "4 ;-+2#^';;'+29=' $9-,%83' 94 )%2& $9('+29%45 6-5 :%(' ,9@',* 2% ,'-$ 2% - 7'-+';3, -4$

2(%3),' ;('' 7(%2'520>hH

V;;'+29=' +%::349+-29%4 )'26''4 2&' 7%,9+' -4$ 7(%2'52'(5 95 9:7%(2-42 94 'a+&-48948

94;%(:-29%4 2&-2 69,, '4-),' ;-+9,92-29%4 %; 2&' 7(%2'52 -4$ 7(%2'+29%4 %; 2&' 7(%2'52'(50 "4 ,94' 692& -

4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+ 7(%2'52'(5 5&%3,$ 4%2 )' 2('-2'$ -5 -4 34('-5%4-),' :%4%,92&9+

'4292*0 1&95 +-,,5 ;%( 6&-2 95 @4%64 -5 - ^4% 53(7(95'5> -77(%-+& 2% 7%,9+9480 N ;'-23(' %; 2&95

-77(%-+& 95 2&-2 ^n,o-6S'4;%(+':'42 %;;9+'(5 5&%3,$ -,,%6 29:' ;%( 7'%7,' 94 - +(%6$ 2% ('57%4$ -5

94$9=9$3-,5 2% 2&' 5923-29%4 2&'* ;-+'# 94+,3$948 -4* 6-(49485 %( $9('+29%45 89='4 2% 2&':0 hi E%(

9452-4+'# 2&' 7%,9+' 94 2&' "$-" B?K/KC h?0hl4 lG -)%='# lg0hg4 lG -)%='# lg0


32/68

23

:323-,,* -8(''-),' -++%::%$-29%4 94 -$=-4+' %; 2&' $-2' 7(%=9$'$ 94 2&' 4%29;9+-29%4 ;%( 2&'

-55':),*0>hh

XQTQT &A?9>=;I9

(98&2 2% 'a7('55 $955'42 95 +%459$'('$ :%(' 7-(-:%342 2&-4 2&' ;-529$9%35 37&%,$948

%; 2&' ,-6 ;%( :94%( 94;(-+29%450 L4' %; 2&' @'* ;'-23('5 %; 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 &-5 )''4

$'5+(9)'$ -5 ':)(-+948 k+%'(+9=' 942'(='429%4 -5 - ,-52 ('5%(2[ 2%,'(-4+' %; :94%( )('-+&'5[

n7o-(24'(5&97 -9:'$ -2 '453(948 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'[ n-4$o n9o4;%(:-29%4 8-2&'(948 ;%+35'$ %4

73495&948 %;;'45'5k0/KK1&' T7'+9-, R-77%(2'3( %4 'a2(-U3$9+9-,# 53::-(* %( -()92(-(* 'a'+329%45

+%4+3(5 692& 2&95 7(94+97,'./K/

1&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& '42-9,5 -++'72948 5%:' %; 2&' 579,,S%='( ';;'+2 %; 2&' 7(%2'52 94

('23(4 ;%( -553(-4+'5 -5 2% 2&' 7'-+';3, 4-23(' %; 2&' '='420 1&' ':7&-595 %; 2&95 -77(%-+& 95

2&'(';%(' %4 '453(948 7'-+'# (-2&'( 2&-4 '4;%(+948 ,-60 "4 2&95 7-(-$98: %; q34$'(S'4;%(+':'42r %;

2&' ,-6# ;%(+' 5&%3,$ )' 35'$ )* 2&' 7%,9+' 94 5',;S$';'4+'# (-2&'( 2&-4 2% -55'(2 2&' -32&%(92* %; 2&'

,-6 94 2&' -)52(-+20

1&' ;%('8%948 95 4%2 -4 %32,-4$95& 53):9559%4 -4$ 95 +%:7-(-),' 2% 2&' U3529;9+-29%4 ;%( +9=9,

$95%)'$9'4+' 6&9+& 95 +&9';,* $':%+(-+*0 1&95 4%29%4 &-5 )''4 9$'429;9'$ -5 &-=948 ('+'9='$

)-+@948 ;(%: 2&'


33/68

24

1&' P%3(2 &-5 -,5% 5'='(-, 29:'5 52-2'$ 2&-2 2&'(' 95 - $95294+29%4 )'26''4 =9%,-29%4 %; ,-6 6&'(' -

2&9($ 7'(5%4 95 94U3('$ -4$ %4' 6&'(' :'(',* 2&' T2-2' 95 94+%::%$'$# -4$ &-5 ('D39('$ 2&' T2-2' 2%

-$U352 925',; 2% 2&' +929b'45k +%45+9'4+' -4$ ;9(52 -:'4$:'42 942'('5250

1&' 7(94+97,' %; 2%,'(-4+' -,5% +-,,5 ;%( - 7('53:729%4 %; 7'-+';3,4'55 %; 2&' $':%452(-29%40 A&'('

2&'(' -(' 57%(-$9+ 94+9$'425# 2&' 7%,9+' -(' ('D39('$ 2% 59:7,* 9$'429;* -4$ 9; 7%559),' 5948,' %32 2&'

=9%,'42 ',':'425 692&%32 4'+'55-(9,* +-,,948 %;; 2&' 6&%,' 7(%2'520 1&95 &-5 ('+'9='$ 5377%(2 ;(%:

5+&%,-(5 94 2&' -('- 6&% &-=' 945952'$ 2&-2 2%,'(-4+' 95 %4' %; 2&' 7('=-9,948 2(-925 %; 2&' 4'8%29-2'$

:-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& -5 92 95 7(-+29+'$ 94 2&' ('7('559=' 7%,9+948 2-+29+5 -4$ (','-(4 4'6 6-*5 2% ('57%4$ 2%

7(%2'520 1&95 95 94 ;-+2 -4 94$957'45-),' -57'+2 2% 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 ^n5o94+' 7%,9+' 69,, -,6-*5

/Ki4 jj -)%='0/Kj4 /K? -)%='# ?Hl0


34/68

25

&-=' 2% :-@' %4S2&'S57%2 $'2'(:94-29%45 -)%32 &%6 2% $'-, 692& - 89='4 5923-29%4# 92 95 '57'+9-,,*

9:7%(2-42 2&-2 ('57'+2 ;%( $955'42 )' 7-(2 %; 7%,9+' +3,23('0>/Kl

1&' ('S5%+9-,95-29%4 2&-2 95 4''$'$ %4 2&' 7-(2 %; 2&' 52-2' -4$ 2&' 7%,9+' &-5 4%2 -,6-*5

&-77'4'$0 1&95 95 %6948 :%52,* 2% ('59,9'42 945292329%4-, 94+,94-29%4 2%6-($5 35' %; ;%(+' )32 -,5% -

,-+@ %; 7%,929+-, 69,, ;(%: 2&' 52-2' 2% -$%72 2&95 :%(' +929b'4 ':7%6'(948# $':%+(-29+# &3:-4

(98&25 -77(%-+& 2% 7%,9+9480 1&95 95 &-($,* 53(7(95948 -5 5+&%,-(5 %4 2&' 52-235 %; 2&' 52-2' -4$

$':%+(-+* &-=' %)5'(='$ 2&-2# ^&-,; %; 2&' q$':%+(-29b948r +%342(9'5 94 2&' 6%(,$ 2%$-* -(' 9,,9)'(-,

$':%+(-+9'50>/Kg V='4 94 :-23(' $':%+(-+9'5 53+& -5 2&' 9D46


35/68

26

1&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 :%$', 7('5'425 -4 '42(* 7%942 ;%( -32&%(929'5 2% )' :%('

94=%,='$ 94 2&' 7,-44948 %; 7(%2'52 )32 2&95 95 -4 -57'+2 2&-2 +-4 '-59,* )' -)35'$ 2% 529;,' 2&'

-32%4%:* %; 2&' 7(%2'52 -4$ 7(%2'52'(50 A-(4948 -8-9452 2&95# 2&' T7'+9-, R-77%(2'3( %4 2&' (98&25

2% ;(''$%: %; 7'-+';3, -55':),* -4$ %; -55%+9-29%4 4%2'5 2&-2 -()92(-(* ('52(9+29%45 :-* :-49;'52 94

=-(9%35 6-*50 1&' ;9(52 (',-2'5 2% - 4%29;9+-29%4 7(%+'55 2&-2 95 7'88'$ 37%4 - ;%(:-, %( 94;%(:-,

('D3'52 )* 2&' -32&%(929'5 2% 4'8%29-2' %( 7(%7%5' 2&' 29:9485 -4$ ='43' %; 2&' 7(%2'520///"4 5-*948

2&95# 2&' T7'+9-, R-77%(2'3( 95 +%8495-42 %; 2&' -()92(-(* 6-* 94 6&9+& 2&' 4%29;9+-29%4 ('D39(':'42

95 -77,9'$ 94 :%52 +%342(9'5 90'0 :9534$'(52%%$ ;%( 7'(:9559%40 Q' ;3(2&'( -='(5 2&-2 -4* 53+&

945952'4+' %( ('D39(':'42 )* -32&%(929'5 2% 4'8%29-2' 2&' 29:' -4$ 7,-+' %; 2&' 7(%2'52 95

^2-42-:%342 2% ('52(9+2948 2&' 7,-44'$ -55':),* -4$ 6%3,$ 4''$ 2% 7-55 2&' 52(9+2 2'52 %; 4'+'5592*

-4$ 7(%7%(29%4-,92*# -5 $';94'$ 94 -(29+,' ?/ %; 2&' P%='4-42 n"PPMRo_ -77,9+-),' 2% ('52(9+29%450>//?

N4%2&'( +-329%4 (',-2'5 2% 2&' 4'+'5592* %; 8'4394' $9-,%83'0 I'-4948;3, $9-,%83'# 94=%,='5

5%:' ,'=', %; 2(352 -:%48 2&' 7-(29'5 -4$ 2&'9( ('57'+29=' 942'429%45[ )32 2&' :-@9485 %; 7%,9+'S

+929b'4 (',-29%45&97 94 :%52 9; 4%2 -,, +%342(9'5 &-=' 2(-$929%4-,,* )''4 +&-(-+2'(95'$ 692& $952(352#

6%(5'4'$ )* 7-52 7%,9+' &-4$,948 %; $':%452(-29%450 ^M%,9+' %;;9+'(5 ':7,%*948 2&95 52*,' n'5+-,-2'$

;%(+'o %;2'4 '42'( 53+& 5923-29%45 n7(%2'525o 'a7'+2948 2(%3),' -4$ =9'6948 2&'9( (%,' -5 %4' %;

7(%2'+2948 2&' 8'4'(-, 7%73,-29%4 ;(%: 2&' 2(%3),':-@'(50>//G "4 +%42(-52# 2&' 4'8%29-2'$

:-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& &-5 7(%='$ 2&-2 53+& - $*4-:9+ 95 +%342'(7(%$3+29=' -5 92 $%'5 4%2

4'+'55-(9,* ('53,2 94 7'-+';3, 7(%2'525 -4$ 6&-2 95 ('-,,* 4''$'$ 95 $9-,%83'0 T+&%,-(5 &-=' &%6'='(

'a7('55'$ $95D39'2 4%2948 2&-2.//H

nOo'5792' 2&' ;-+2 2&-2 $9-,%83' 7%,9+948 95 :%29=-2'$ 2% '4&-4+' &3:-4 (98&25 -4$ $':%+(-29+ ;%(:5

%; 7(%2'52 7%,9+948# n2&-2 6(92'(o ('5'(='5 U3$8':'42 %4 2&' -77(%-+&0 Q' 4%2'5 2&' 2'459%4 )'26''4

9452(3:'42-, 7%,9+' %)U'+29='5 -4$ 2&' (&'2%(9+ %; $9-,%83'0

1&' D3%2'$ 6%(@ ;3(2&'( '+&%'5 7('=9%35,* 'a7('55'$ 5+'729+95: 692& 2&' 6(92'( :-942-94948 2&-2

&' ^95 3453(' 6&'2&'( $9-,%83' 7%,9+948 69,, ('53,2 94>//i ^8'4394',* :%(' $':%+(-29+ ;%(:5 %;

7(%2'52 7%,9+948# %( :'(',* ,'-$ 2% 4%2&948 )32 :%(' 53)2,' ;%(:5 %; +%'(+9%40>//j 1&95 *'2 -8-94

-,,3$'5 2% 2&' 7%2'429-, %; 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& 2% )' 329,95'$ 34$'( 2&' 8395' %;

/// NcQRPc?GcGh B?K/GC /j0//?4 /// -)%='0//G4 /Kl -)%='# /?H0//HI A-&,52(w:#^E%('52-,,948 =9%,'4+'. M%,9+' @4%6,'$8' %; 942'(-+29%4 692& 7%,929+-, -+29=9525> B?KKlC /? BHC 76D,3,


36/68

27

$9-,%83' 2% ('52(9+2 2&' (98&2 2% 7(%2'520 "4 ;-+2# ('5'-(+&'(5 +%((%)%(-2' 2&95 4%29%4 &-=948 ;%34$

2&-2 ^:-4* +%::-4$'(5 $952(352'$ 2&' 2-+29+ n$9-,%83'o -4$ ('5'42'$ &-=948 2% '48-8' 692&

7(%2'52'(5 6&%: &-=' 4% $'59(' 2% ('+97(%+-2'# '57'+9-,,* -5 2&' ('53,25 %; $9-,%83' -(' 4%2 -,6-*5

9::'$9-2',* -77-('420>//lR'5'-(+& $%4' 94 O'4:-(@ &-5 %)5'(='$ ^5%:' +%459$'(-),' ('5952-4+'

2% 2&' 9:7%5929%4 %; $9-,%83' 2-+29+5 94 2&' O-495& 7%,9+'0>//gT9:9,-(,* 94 N352(-,9- 2&'(' -(' ;94$9485

2&-2 ^:%$'(4 7%,9+' -32&%(929'5# 6&% :-942-94 2&' ,-2'42 +-7-+92* 2% 35' +%'(+9%4 94+,3$948 (9%2

2'+&4%,%8*# (':-94 ('5%,32' -4$ $'2'(:94'$ 2% +%42(%, :-U%( 94$352(9-, 52(9;'# )32 7(';'(-),* )*

4'8%29-29%4 -4$ 7'(53-59%40>//h

1&'(' 95 2&'(';%(' U3529;9-),' -77('&'459%4 2&-2 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& 9; 4%2

9:7,':'42'$ 8'4394',* +-4 )' 35'$ 2% +('-2' 344'+'55-(* )%22,'4'+@5 -4$ 'a+'559=' 7%,9+' +%42(%,

94 2&' 7,-44948 -4$ (344948 %; 7(%2'520 1&95 +-4 &%6'='( )' +%342'('$ )* '453(948 2&-2 2&'

4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 :%$', 95 94+%(7%(-2'$ 94 - :-44'( 2&-2 &'98&2'45 +&-4+'5 %; '4;%(+':'420

XQWQX 09?9I8 I=D9 D84:L+ a-A66=;: =;: IA;8>A?b 7; "9F 2A>[

X'6 Y%(@ T2-2' &-5 )''4 5','+2'$ -5 - +-5' 523$* ;%( 2&' ('-5%4 2&-2 92 95 -4 9,,352(-29%4 %; -4

9452-4+' 6&'(' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 6-5 94929-,,* -$%72'$ )32 7%,9+948 52(-2'89'5 4%6 5&%6

$'=9-29%4 94 7(-+29+'0 X'6 Y%(@ T2-2' &-5 -,5% )''4 $'':'$ 2% )' - ('7('5'42-29=' 5-:7,' %; 2&' /?KE3(2&'(# X'6

Y%(@ ^('7('5'42'$ - :9+(%+%5: %; 7%,9+'S7(%2'52'( -4$ 7%,9+'S73),9+ 942'(-+29%45 -2 2&' &'98&2 %;

2&' 7'(9%$ %; '5+-,-2'$ ;%(+'_ n-4$o 2&' +%::%44'55 %; 2&' ('7('559%4 %; $955'42_>0/?/1&95 +-5'

523$* ;3(2&'( :-2+&'5 2&' 9::'$9-2',* 7(9%( $95+3559%4 %; 2&' 2&('-2 %; - 4%4S8'4394'

9:7,':'42-29%4 %; 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 :%$',0

1&95 +-5' 523$* 69,, ;%+35 %4 2&' X'6 Y%(@ M%,9+' O'7-(2:'42 BXYMOC6&9+& 95 +%4+'(4'$

692& 7%,9+948 7(%2'52 94 2&' 52-2' %; X'6 Y%(@0 N5 52-2'$# X'6 Y%(@ 94929-,,* 9:7,':'42'$ 2&'

'5+-,-2'$ ;%(+' :%$',# )32 2&95 -77(%-+& 6-5 ^$95+('$92'$ 94 2&' /hlK5 -4$ ('7,-+'$ )* %4' %;

q4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42r>0/??N ,'-$948 5+&%,-( -4$ ('5'-(+&'( ('=9'6'$ 2&' &-4$,948 %; 7(%2'525 94

//l4 //H -)%='# Ghl0//g` Q-=',34$# ` ",3:# I `'45'4# Z X9',5'4# J R-5:355'4 e P T2%22 ^V='42 7%,9+948\O9-,%83' 94 2&' 7%,9+948 %; :-55 '='425

94 O'4:-(@> B?K//C H P/%6>"$. J63,-" =-,".-" $.8 A"2"$%-' Q/33"&,.+92'$ 94 Q W%((948'# P T2%22 e I R%59' ^O9-,%83'

7%,9+'# $'+959%4 :-@948# -4$ 2&' :-4-8':'42 %; 73),9+ %($'( $3(948 7(%2'52 +(%6$ '='425> B?K/?C h Z6/%.$3 6+

U.;"2&,1$&,;" J2E-'6361E $.8 Y++".8"% J%6+,3,.1 //G0//h4 jH -)%='# GhK0/?K` V-(,# TN T%3,' e `O I+P-(2&* ^M(%2'52 34$'( ;9('m Va7,-94948 2&' 7%,9+948 %; 7(%2'52> B?KKGC jg*0"%,-$. =6-,6361,-$3

A";,"4 igl0/?/-5 -)%='0/??4 jj -)%='# ?hK0


37/68

28

X'6 Y%(@ %='( 2&' +%3(5' %; 59a *'-(5 ;(%: /hhh -4$ +%4+,3$'$ 2&-2 2&' XYMO &-$ $'7-(2'$ ;(%:

2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 :%$', )* ;-9,948 2% ;%,,%6 '-+& %; 925 $%+2(94'5 -5 $':%452(-2'$ )*

2&'9( 7%,9+948./?G

1&' XYMO (';35'$ 2% :-@' -4* +%342'( %;;'(5 %; - :-(+& ,%+-29%4# $'=',%7'$ - +%42(%, :%$', )-5'$

%4 7('='42948 -,:%52 -4* $95(3729%4 %; +%::3492* -+29=929'5# +32 %;; 4'8%29-29%45 692& %(8-495'(5 -4$

;-9,'$ 2% '52-),95& -$'D3-2' +%::349+-29%4 692& %(8-495'(5 $3(948 2&' $':%452(-29%4# 35'$ -(('525

94$95+(9:94-2',*# -4$ ;94-,,* 35'$ )-2%45# 7'77'( 57(-*# -4$ &%(5' +&-(8'5 :'(',* 2% +,'-( 52(''25#

6&'4 2&'(' 6-5 4% 2&('-2 %; 94U3(* %( 7(%7'(2* $'52(3+29%40

1&' ('5'-(+&'( 8%'5 %4 2% %)5'(=' 2&-2 2&95 ^4'6 52*,' %; 7(%2'52 7%,9+948 +-4 )' +-,,'$ ^^+%::-4$

-4$ +%42(%,>> )'+-35' %; 925 -22':72 2% :9+(%S:-4-8' $':%452(-29%45 94 -4 ';;%(2 2% 7('='42

$95%($'( -4$ 2&' $95(3729%4 %; '='(*$-* ,9;'0>/?H 1&95 :%$', %; 7%,9+948 95 +&-(-+2'(95'$ )* ;9='

7(-+29+'5 )'948. ^-='(59%4 2% $95(3729%4# +%42(%,,'$ -++'55# $9=9$' -4$ +%4D3'(# 5&%+@ -4$ -6'# -4$

b'(% 2%,'(-4+'0>/?i 1&' '55'4+' %; 2&'5' 7(-+29+'5 ^95 2&'9( %(9'42-29%4 2%6-($5 &'98&2'4948 2&'

-)9,92* %; 2&' 7%,9+' 2% :9+(%S:-4-8' -,, 9:7%(2-42 -57'+25 %; 2&' $':%452(-29%4 ;(%: 2&' 8(-42948

%; 7'(:925 2% 2&' $957'(5-, %; $':%452(-2%(50>/?j

1&' 37(%-( -8-9452 2&'5' 4'6 7%,9+948 2-+29+5 &-5 ;%34$ 925 6-* 2% 2&' +%3(2 692& $'+959%45

;('D3'42,* 94 ;-=%3( %; 2&' 7(%2'52'(5 2&'(')* ';;'+29=',* $95-,,%6948 5%:' %; 2&' :'2&%$5 -77,9'$

)* 2&' 7%,9+'./?l

"4 `3,* ?KKH# - $952(9+2 +%3(2 U3$8' (3,'$ 2&-2 2&('' %; 2&%5' ;%3( 2-+29+5 n+%:7,-94'$ %;o -('

34+%45292329%4-,_ W(-42948 94U34+29=' (',9'; 2% '4U%94 7%,9+' ;(%: B/C +,%5948 52(''25 -2

$':%452(-29%4 592'5 692&%32 7(%=9$948 94;%(:-29%4 -)%32 -,2'(4-2' :'-45 %; -++'55# B?C 35948 u7'45u

2% ('52(9+2 -++'55 2% $':%452(-29%45# -4$ BGC 5'-(+&948 $':%452(-2%(5k )-85 692&%32 94$9=9$3-,9b'$

53579+9%40

1&95 +-5' 523$* 7('5'425 @'* ,'55%45 ;%( 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'5 %; J'4*- -4$ X98'(9-0 M%,9+' ^:352

-22':72 2% )-,-4+' 2&' $'59('_ 2% -=%9$ $95(3729%4 692& 2&' (98&25 %; $':%452(-2%(5 2% 'a7('55

2&'9( =9'650>/?g"2 95 ;%( 2&95 ('-5%4 2&-2 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& 95 -77%592' -5 92 (',9'5

%4 - ;(-:'6%(@ %; 7(94+97,'5 -4$ 7(-+29+'5 53+& -5 $9-,%83' -4$ :'$9-29%45 2&-2 +-4 -++%::%$-2'

/?G4 jj -)%='# ?hK0/?H4 jj -)%='# ?gG0/?i4 jj -)%='# ?h?0/?j4 jj -)%='# ?h?0/?l=&$/D"% ; V"4 R6%FX%0 KG P9=0 h/j? BT0O0X0Y0 X%=0 /h# ?KKGC &227.cc66604*+,30%(8c:+d+%:7,-942d52)d///hKG0&2:,

;%( 2&' U3$8:'42 5''=&$/D"% ?KKH AF /ihGglK -2 GG +92'$ 94 4 /Kl -)%='# hh S /KK0/?g4 jj -)%='# GK?0


38/68

29

2&95 D3'52 ;%( )-,-4+' )'+-35' 2&' ^4-23(' %; 2&-2 )-,-4+948 7%942 -4$ &%6 92 95 -+&9'='$ 95 -

+%452-42,* 5&9;2948 'D3-29%40>/?h

L4' ,'-$948 5+&%,-( &-=948 523$9'$ 2&' 4'6 7%,9+948 :'2&%$5 94 X'6 Y%(@ ('+%::'4$5

2&-2# ^n(o-2&'( 2&-4 -$%72948 7-(-:9,92-(* %( +%::-4$ -4$ +%42(%, :%$',5# 7%,9+' 5&%3,$ ('S

'a-:94' 2&' 35';3,4'55 %; 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& 2% 7(%2'52 7%,9+9480>/GK

XQ]-A;I?4D7A;

1&95 +&-72'( 347-+@5 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -5 - :%$', ;%( 2&' &-4$,948 %; 7(%2'5250 1&95

-77(%-+& 95 +%42(-52'$ 692& 2&' '5+-,-2'$ ;%(+' :%$', 6&9+& 95 2&' 7('=-9,948 7(%2'52 :-4-8':'42

-77(%-+& 94 N;(9+- -4$ 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'50 N $95+3559%4 %4 2&' %),98-29%45 '=%@'$ )* 2&' (98&2

2% $':%452(-2' ('='-,5 2&-2 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& 95 7('$%:94-42,* +%4+'(4'$

692& - 52-2'>5 7%5929=' %),98-29%45 692&%32 6&9+& ('-,95-29%4 %; 2&' (98&2 )'+%:'5 )3($'45%:'0

X'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 95 - 52(-2'8* 2&-2 ':)(-+'5 - ;(-:'6%(@ %; +'(2-94 7(94+97,'5 2&'

;%(':%52 %; 6&9+& &-=' )''4 ',3+9$-2'$0 1&95 $95+3559%4 -,5% 5'(='5 2% 9,,352(-2' 2&' 7(%57'+25 %;

-$%72948 - 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& 94 2&' &-4$,948 %; 7(%2'5250 "4 +%4+,3$948 2&95 +&-72'(#

-4 -55'55:'42 %; 2&' 7%2'429-, 792;-,,5 %; 2&' :%$', &-=' )''4 7('5'42'$0 1&' 7('=-9,948 9:7('559%4

95 2&-2 2&' :%$', 925',; &-5 &-($,* )''4 +(929+95'$ )32 9452'-$ 2&' $(-6)-+@5 $'(9=' 6&'4 7%,9+' -4$

-32&%(929'5 -22':72 2% +9(+3:='42 2&' 7(94+97,'5 2&-2 839$' 2&' 7(%7%5'$ -77(%-+&0

Q-=948 +%:7('&'459=',* -4-,*5'$ 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 :%$',# 2&' 4'a2 +&-72'( -9:5

2% -55'55 925 =9-)9,92* ;%( -$%729%4 94 J'4*- -4$ X98'(9-0 "4 $%948 5%# 2&' %),98-29%45# 7(94+97,'5 -4$

792;-,,5 34$'(5+%('$ 94 2&95 +&-72'( 69,, 7(%=9$' - ;(-:'6%(@ ;%( -4-,*5950

/?h4 jj -)%='# GK?0/GK4 jj -)%='# GK?0


39/68

30

-.(P/ K%N/ \ &%_(/)0 &.# "#$%&'() *("($#*#"& *%)#E '"

1#"2( 3 "'$#/'(+ -.(EE#"$#0 3 P/%0P#-&0

TQS';8>A:4I87A;

1&95 +&-72'( ;'-23('5 -4 -4-,*595 %; 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'5 34$'( ('=9'60 1&' $95+3559%4 69,, )'

7-(29+3,-(,* +%4+'(4'$ 692& 73),9+ %($'( :-4-8':'42 94 )%2& +%342(9'5# 2&' ,'8-, ;(-:'6%(@

8%='(4948 53+& :-4-8':'42 -4$ &%6 2&' 7('5'42 -((-48':'425 -(' 942'(-+2948 692& 2&' (98&2 2%

7(%2'520 1&' 6%(@ 69,, -,5% 34$'(2-@' -4 -55'55:'42 %; 9:7,':'42-29%4 %; 2&' 4'8%29-2'$

:-4-8':'42 -77(%-+& 94 )%2& +%342(9'5#)* 9,,352(-2948 &%6 - 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 :%$', +-4

-$$('55 7(-+29+-, +%4+'(45 -;;'+2948 $':%452(-29%45 94 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'50 E94-,,*# 2&' 523$*

69,, 9$'429;* -4 '42(* 7%942 ;%( 2&' 94+%(7%(-29%4 %; 2&95 :%$', 94 J'4*- -4$ X98'(9-0

TQZ&B9 ?9H=? @>=69FA>[ HAO9>;7;H 8B9 6=;=H969;8 A@ :96A;D8>=87A;D 7; 8B9 I=D9 D84:LIA4;8>79D

TQZQS &B9 ?=F A; :9> 6=;=H969;8 =;:


40/68

31

:%(' 7'(5%45 94 -4* 73),9+ 7,-+'>0/GHN 73),9+ 7(%+'559%4 95 $';94'$ -5 ^-4* 7(%+'559%4 94# 2% %( ;(%:

- 73),9+ 7,-+'>0/GiM-(2 """ %; 2&' MLN 95 $'$9+-2'$ 2% 73),9+ 8-2&'(9485 -4$ 925 'a+,359=' U3(95$9+29%4

94 2&' :-4-8':'42 %; $':%452(-29%45 95 9,,352(-2'$ )* 2&' 7(%=959%4 2&-2. ^X% 7'(5%4 5&-,, &%,$ -

73),9+ :''2948 %( - 73),9+ 7(%+'559%4 'a+'72 94 -++%($-4+' 692& 2&' 7(%=959%45 %; 2&95 5'+29%40> /Gj

1&' 7(9:-(* ('D39(':'42 ;%( 7'(5%45 942'4$948 2% &%,$ $':%452(-29%45 95 4%29+' 6&9+& 95 ^-2 ,'-52

2&('' $-*5 )32 4% :%(' 2&-4 ;%3(2''4 $-*5 )';%(' 2&' 7(%7%5'$ $-2' %; 2&' 73),9+ :''2948 %(

7(%+'559%40>/Gl 1&' 4%29+' 5&%3,$ '42-9, 2&' %(8-495'(>5 +%42-+2 $'2-9,5# 2&' $-2' -4$ 29:' %; 2&'

7(%+'559%4 -5 6',, -5 2&' 7(%7%5'$ (%32'0/Gg

1&' ('83,-2948 -32&%(92* 94 J'4*- 94 :-22'(5 %; $':%452(-29%45 95 2&' J'4*- M%,9+'0 1&'

X-29%4-, M%,9+' T'(=9+' N+2 94 925 7-(2 t"" ='525 =-(9%35 ;34+29%45# 7%6'(5# %),98-29%45 -4$ (98&25 %4

7%,9+' %;;9+'(50 "2 57'+9;9+-,,* %),98-2'5 7%,9+' 2% :-942-94 %($'( %4 (%-$5 -4$ %2&'( 7,-+'5 $3(948

$':%452(-29%450 T'+29%4 iHB/C 7(%=9$'5 2&-2 ^n2o&' J'4*- M%,9+' T'(=9+' 5&-,, p B)C 7('='42

344'+'55-(* %)52(3+29%4 $3(948 -55':),9'5# :''29485 -4$ 7(%+'559%45 %4 73),9+ (%-$5 -4$

52(''25_>0/GhE(%: 2&' 7&(-5948 %; 2&95 5'+29%4# 92 95 +,'-( 2&-2 $':%452(-29%45 -(' :'(',* 2%,'(-2'$

6&'4 +%4='49'42 (-2&'( 2&-4 ;-+9,92-2'$0 L4' +-4 2&'(';%(' )'894 2% 5'' 6&* J'4*- 6-5 '-(,9'(

+-2'8%(95'$ -5 %)5'(=948 -4 '5+-,-2'$ ;%(+' :%$', %; 7(%2'52 7%,9+9480

"7H9>7=

"4 X98'(9-# 73),9+ %($'( :-4-8':'42 94 2&' +%42'a2 %; $':%452(-29%45 95 7(9:-(9,* ,'895,-2'$ 34$'(

2&' M3),9+ L($'( N+2 BMLNC0/HK 1&' MLN $';94'5 -4 -55':),* 2% :'-4 ^- :''2948 %; ;9=' %( :%('

7'(5%45>/H/-4$ - 73),9+ 7(%+'559%4 95 $';94'$ -5 ^- 7(%+'559%4 94 - 7,-+' %; 73),9+ ('5%(20>/H?1% 2&'

7%942# 2&' MLN 94 925 ='(* ;9(52 5'+29%4 '4-+25 2&' ^7%6'( 2% ('83,-2' -55':),9'5# :''29485 -4$

7(%+'559%450>/HGI%(' 57'+9;9+-,,*# 94 53)S5'+29%4 / 2&'('%;# 92 7(%=9$'5 2&-2.

E%( 2&' 73(7%5'5 %; 2&' 7(%7'( -4$ 7'-+';3, +%4$3+2 %; 73),9+ -55':),9'5# :''29485 -4$ 7(%+'559%45

-4$ 53)U'+2 2% 5'+29%4 // %; 2&95 N+2# 2&' W%='(4%( %; '-+& T2-2' 95 &'(')* ':7%6'('$ 2% $9('+2 2&'

+%4$3+2 %; -,, -55':),9'5# :''29485 -4$ 7(%+'559%45 %4 2&' 73),9+ (%-$5 %( 7,-+'5 %; 73),9+ ('5%(2 94

2&' T2-2' -4$ 7('5+(9)' 2&' (%32' )* 6&9+& -4$ 2&' 29:'5 -2 6&9+& -4* 7(%+'559%4 :-* 7-550

/GH4 /G? -)%='# 5'+ ?0/Gi4 /G? -)%='# 5'+ ?0/Gj4 /G? -)%='# 5'+ iB/C0/Gl4 /G? -)%='# 5'+ iB?C0/Gg4 /G? -)%='# 5'+ iBGC0/Gh4 /GG -)%='# 5'+ iHB/CB)C0/HKM3),9+ L($'( N+2 P&-72'( Gg? F-65 %; 2&' E'$'(-, R'73),9+ %; X98'(9-# /hhK0/H/4 /HK -)%='# 5'+ /?B/C0/H?4 /HK -)%='# 5'+ /?B/C0/HG4 /HK -)%='# 5'+ /BGC0


41/68

32

1&' ('83,-29%4 %; $':%452(-29%45 95 ='52'$ 94 52-2' 8%='(4%(5> %;;9+'50 Q%6'='( 94 7(-+29+'# 2&'

('83,-29%4 %; 73),9+ 7(%+'559%45 95 :-4-8'$ )* 2&' 7%,9+'[ - 7(-+29+' 2&-2 95 5-4+29%4'$ )* 2&' MLN

925',;0 "4 5'+29%4 /BGC %; 2&' MLN# 2&' W%='(4%( :-* -32&%(95' 2&' 9553-4+' %; ,9+'4+'5 )* 7%,9+' %;

57'+9;9'$ (-4@ 5'22948 %32 2&' +%4$929%45 %; 6&% +-4 &%,$ $':%452(-29%45 -4$ 2&' ='43' ;%( 2&'

5-:'0/HH E3(2&'(# 53)5'+29%4 BHC '4-),'5 2&' 8%='(4%( 2% $','8-2' 2&' 7%6'(5 2% ('83,-2'

$':%452(-29%45 2% 2&' P%::9559%4'( %; M%,9+' %; 2&' T2-2' %( 53+& %2&'( 57'+9;9'$ (-4@ %;;9+'(0/Hi

1&95 $32* %4 2&' 7-(2 %; 7%,9+' 95 ;3(2&'( +%((%)%(-2'$ )* 2&' M%,9+' N+2/Hj6&9+& 7(%=9$'5 2&-2./Hl

n1o&' P%::9559%4'( %; - T2-2' 5&-,, +%:7,* 692& 2&' $9('+29%45 %; 2&' W%='(4%( %; 2&' T2-2' 692&

('57'+2 2% 2&' :-942-94948 -4$ 5'+3(948 %; 73),9+ 5-;'2* -4$ 73),9+ %($'( 692&94 2&' T2-2'# %( +-35'

2&': 2% )' +%:7,9'$ 692&0

1&' M%,9+' N+2 -,5% 7(%=9$'5 ;%( 2&' -77%942:'42 %; ':'(8'4+* 57'+9-, +%452-),'5 94 ('57%45' 2%

57'+9-, +9(+3:52-4+'5 6&'(' 2&' P%::9559%4'( %; M%,9+' 95 5-295;9'$ 2&-2 ^-4 34,-6;3, -55':),* %(

(9%2 %( )('-+& %; 2&' 7'-+' &-5 2-@'4 7,-+' %( :-* ('-5%4-),* )' 'a7'+2'$ 2% 2-@' 7,-+' 94 2&-2

-('->0/Hg1&95 7(%=959%4 95 - 8%%$ 'a-:7,' %; 2&' 9,,S;%34$'$ 7('%++37-29%4 692& 73),9+ %($'( 2&-2

+&-(-+2'(95'5 7(%2'52 7%,9+9480

Q-=948 ,-9$ %32 2&' ,'8-, ;(-:'6%(@ 2&-2 8%='(45 :-4-8':'42 %; $':%452(-29%45 94

X98'(9-# 92 )'&%='5 2&95 523$* 2% &98&,98&2 2&' ,'8-, 52-235 %; 2&' MLN 94 X98'(9-0 1&' MLN 6-5 2&'

53)U'+2 %; - +%45292329%4-, +&-,,'48' ;9(52 -2 2&' Q98& P%3(2./Hh

The case was instituted by the All Nigeria Peoples Party and others against the Inspector General of Police

[IG] after the partys rally, protesting against the rigging of the 2003 elections, was disrupted by the police

because it did not obtain a police permit before embarking on the rally.

1&' -77,9+-425 6'(' 53++'55;3, 692& 2&' E'$'(-, Q98& P%3(2 94 N)3U- 43,,9;*948 2&' MLN -4$

-8(''948 2&-2 92 6-5 - +%,%49-, (',9+0 O955-295;9'$# 2&' "W ,%$8'$ -4 -77'-,/iK -2 2&' P%3(2 %;

N77'-,6&9+& ('23(4'$ - 34-49:%35 ='($9+2 37&%,$948 2&' Q98& P%3(2>5 U3$8:'420 P%::'42948 %4

2&' U3$8:'42# - +%::'42-2%( 4%2'$./i/

/HH4 /HK -)%='# 5'+ /BGC0/Hi4 /HK -)%='# 5'+ /BHC0/HjM%,9+' N+2 P&-72'( Gih F-65 %; 2&' E'$'(-, R'73),9+ %; X98'(9-# /hhK0/Hl4 /Hj -)%='# 5'+ /KB?C0/Hg4 /Hj -)%='# 5'+ i?0/Hh^M%,9+' 7'(:92 4%2 ('D39('$ ;%( (-,,9'5 p E-,-4-> &227.cc@-4:9-@-4%0),%857%20+%:c?K/HcK/c7%,9+'S7'(:92S4%2S

('D39('$S;%(S(-,,9'50&2:, B-++'55'$ /i T'72':)'( ?K/HC0/iK"0W0M0 =0 N0X0M0M0 B?KKlC /g XAFR BM20 /KjjC0/i/^N77'-, P%3(2 =%9$5 M3),9+ L($'( N+2> &227.cc498'(9-=9,,-8'5D3-('0+%:c;%(3:c:-94S5D3-('c/i//jS-77'-,S+%3(2S

=%9$5S73),9+S%($'(S-+20&2:, B-++'55'$ /i T'72':)'( ?K/HC0


42/68

33

nNo :9,'52%4' 6-5 *'52'($-* ('+%($'$ 94 X98'(9-k5 )9$ 2% '42&(%4' +%45292329%4-, $':%+(-+* -4$

83-(-42'' 2&' +929b'45k (98&2 2% +%48('8-2' -5 2&' P%3(2 %; N77'-,# N)3U- O9=959%4# *'52'($-* 52(3+@

$%64 2&' M3),9+ L($'( N+20 1&' +%3(2 $'+,-('$ 2&' 5-9$ N+2# 6&9+& :-4$-2'5 +929b'45 2% -77,* -4$

%)2-94 7%,9+' 7'(:92 %( -77(%=-, )';%(' &%,$948 (-,,9'5 %( 7'-+';3, -55':),9'5# u43,,# =%9$ -4$ %; 4%

';;'+2u0

1&' 2'4'25 %; 2&' R3,' %; F-6 7('5+(9)' 2&-2 94 2&' ,98&2 %; 2&' $'+959%4 %; 2&' +%3(2# 7-(,9-:'42

5&%3,$ :%=' 2% ('=9'6 -4$c%( ('7'-, 2&' MLN0 T94+' 2&' $'+959%4 6-5 :-$' %='( 5'='4 *'-(5 -8%#

2&' ,'895,-23(' &-5 4%2 94929-2'$ -4* ('=9'6 7(%+'55 '='4 2&%38& 2&' 7%,9+' &-=' 4%2 -77'-,'$ 2&'

$'+959%4# 6&9+& +%3,$ 9:7,* 2&'9( -++'72-4+' %; 920 1&95 -+29%4 &-5 ('53,2'$ 94 - 2(-='52* %; U3529+' -5

2&' X98'(9-4 7%,9+' +%42943' 2% (',* %4 2&' 9:7384'$ MLN 2% 2&' $'2(9:'42 %; +929b'45 '='4 6&'4 92

&-5 4%2 2-@'4 52'75 2% -77'-, 2&' (3,948 %; 2&' +%3(20

TQZQZ E9H=? ?7678=87A;D A; 8B9 >7HB8 8A :96A;D8>=89

1&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' 95 4%2 -)5%,32' 94 4-23('0 F9:92-29%45 %4 (98&25# 94+,3$948 &3:-4 (98&25

-(' 4%2 4'+'55-(9,* 9,,S;%34$'$ -4$ :-* )' 4'+'55-(* 94 - $':%+(-29+ 5%+9'2*0 A&-2 95 9:7%(2-42#

&%6'='(# 95 2&-2 2&'* -(' 9:7%5'$ -4$ 9:7,':'42'$ 94 52(9+2 +%:7,9-4+' 692& 2&' ,-6 -4$ 94 -

:-44'( 2&-2 $%'5 4%2 $';'-2 2&' ='(* '55'4+' %; 2&' (98&2 %( 2&' 579(92 %; 2&' ,-60 1&95 5'+29%4 5''@5

2% 'a-:94' 2&' 7-(-:'2'(5 ;%( 2&' ,-6;3, ,9:92-29%4 %; 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' 94 2&' +-5' 523$*

+%342(9'50

"4 X98'(9-# 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' 95 '4+%:7-55'$ 692&94 2&' ;(''$%: %; -55':),* -4$

,9@' -,, %2&'( +%45292329%4-, (98&25 95 4%2 -)5%,32'0 1% )'894 692 ^n6o&9,52 2&' X98'(9-4

nPo%45292329%4 $%'5 4%2_ 'a7('55,* 52-2' 2&-2 53+& -55':),* %( -55%+9-29%4 :352 )' 7'-+';3, %(

,-6;3,# 92 95 4'+'55-(9,* 9:7,9'$>0/i?1&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' 94 X98'(9- 95 53)U'+2 2% ,'8-, ,9:92-29%45

)* 6-* %; 5'+29%4 Hi %; 2&' P%45292329%4/iG6&9+& :-@'5 7(%=959%45 %4 ('52(9+29%4 -4$ $'(%8-29%4

;(%: ;34$-:'42-, (98&250 "2 7(%=9$'5 2&-2 2&' (98&2 2% 7'-+';3, -55':),* +-4 )' ('52(9+2'$ )* - ,-6

2&-2 95./iH

nRo'-5%4-),* U3529;9-),' 94 - $':%+(-29+ 5%+9'2* p B-C 94 2&' 942'('52 %; $';'4+'# 73),9+ 5-;'2*# 73),9+

%($'(# 73),9+ :%(-,92* %( 73),9+ &'-,2&[ %( B)C ;%( 2&' 73(7%5' %; 7(%2'+2948 2&' (98&25 -4$ ;(''$%: %;

%2&'( 7'(5%450

/i?JI I%6%' M6.2&,&/&,6.$3 3$4 ,. V,1"%,$ B?KKgC Hlh0/iGP%45292329%4 %; 2&' E'$'(-, R'73),9+ %; X98'(9-# /hhh0/iH-5 -)%='# 5'+ Hi0


43/68

34

"2 95 ;(%: 2&95 7(%=959%4 2&-2 2&' $(-;2'(5 -4$ $';'4$'(5 %; 2&' 43,,9;9'$ MLN ;%34$ =-,9$-29%4 ;%( 925

7(%=959%45 6&9+& ,9:92 2&' ;(''$%: %; 7'-+';3, -55':),* 83-(-42''$ )* 2&' P%45292329%40 E%(

9452-4+'# 2&' MLN 7(%=9$'5 2&-2./ii

N4* 7%,9+' %;;9+'( %; 2&' (-4@ %; 9457'+2%( %( -)%=' :-* 52%7 -4* -55':),*# :''2948 %( 7(%+'559%4 ;%(

6&9+& 4% ,9+'4+' &-5 )''4 9553'$ %( 6&9+& =9%,-2'5 -4* +%4$929%45 %; 2&' ,9+'4+' 9553'$_ -4$ :-*

%($'( -4* 53+& -55':),*# :''2948 %( 7(%+'559%4 6&9+& &-5 )''4 7(%&9)92'$ %( 6&9+& &-5 )''4

7(%&9)92'$ %( 6&9+& =9%,-2'5 -4* 53+& +%4$929%45 -5 -;%('5-9$ 2% $957'(5' 9::'$9-2',*0

1&' ;%('8%948 7(%=959%4 -:%3425 2% - $957(%7%(29%4-2' ('52(9+29%4 %; 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' -4$

2&95 69,, )' ',-)%(-2'$ %4 ,-2'( 94 2&95 +&-72'(0

"4 J'4*-# 2&' P%45292329%4 7(%=9$'5 2&-2 ^n'o='(* 7'(5%4 &-5 2&' (98&2# 7'-+'-),* -4$

34-(:'$# 2% -55':),'# 2% $':%452(-2'# 2% 79+@'2# -4$ 2% 7('5'42 7'2929%45 2% 73),9+ -32&%(929'50>/ij

1&' D3-,9;9'(# 2% 2&' (98&2 95 9::'$9-2',* -77-('42. ^-5 ,%48 -5 2&' -55':),9'5 -(' 7'-+';3, -4$34-(:'$0 N+29%45 %( ,-65 -9:'$ -2 D3',,948 -(:'$ %( =9%,'42 -55':),9'5 69,, 2&'(';%(' 4%2

+%4529232' -4 94;(948':'42 %; 2&95 (98&20>/ilL4 2&95 D3-,9;9'(# 2&'


44/68

35

7-(29+97-2' 94 7'-+';3, 7(%2'525 95 2% )' +%459$'('$ 2&' (3,'# -4$ ,9:92-29%45 2&'('2% +%459$'('$ 2&'

'a+'729%40>/jK

TQX&B9 D8=89 A@ 8B9 >7HB8 8A A89D8 7; 8B9 I=D9 D84:L IA4;8>79D

1&95 5'+29%4 34$'(2-@'5 - 7(-+29+-, $95+3559%4 %; 2&' 'a7'(9'4+' %; $':%452(-29%45 94 J'4*- -4$

X98'(9-0 1&' 7('=9%35 $95+3559%4 ',3+9$-2'5 2&' ,'8-, -((-48':'425 94 7,-+' ;%( 2&' :-4-8':'42 %;

$':%452(-29%45 94 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'50 1&' 5-:' &-=' )''4 5&%64 2% )' &'-=*S&-4$'$ -4$

%='(,* ,9)'(-, 94 ,'8-, +%452(3+29%4 %4 ('52(9+29%45 %; $':%452(-29%450 1&' 52-2'# )%2& 94 J'4*- -4$

X98'(9- &-5 4% $%3)2 ,-2+&'$ %42% 2&'5' 57-+'5 94 2&'9( ,'8-, ;(-:'6%(@5 ,'-$948 2% 2&'

7('53:729%4 %; ,9:92948 $':%452(-29%450

1&' 69$' ,'8-, )'(2& -;;%($'$ 2% 2&' 52-2' 2% ('52(9+2 7(%2'52 95 4%2 346922948[ (-2&'( 92 95 )*

$'5984 -5 $'$3+9),' ;(%: 2&' +%,%49-, &952%(9'5 %; )%2& +%342(9'50 Z%2& +%342(9'5 &-$ 59:9,-(

+%,%49-, 'a7'(9'4+' -5 2&'* 5&-(' 2&' &'(92-8' %; &-=948 )''4 +%,%495'$ )* W('-2 Z(92-940 "4 +%,%49-,

29:'5# (98&25 6'(' 4%2 +',')(-2'$ -4$ 2&' +%,%495'( 6-5 4%2 -)%32 +('-2948 ,-65 2&-2 ':7%6'('$

53)U'+25 2% 'a7('55 $955'420 L4 2&' +%42(-(*# 2&' +%,%495'( 6-5 :%(' +%::922'$ 2% 2&' 5377('55948

%; $955'42 -4$ 2&' +%,%49-, &952%(* 94 )%2& +%342(9'5 95 %4' %; ('7('559=' ,-65 -4$ ('7('559='

7%,9+9480 1&95 4'8-29=' +3,23(' 2&-2 &-5 7'(5952'$ -4$ +%42943'5 2% 7'(=-$' 2&' 7%52S+%,%49-,

'a7'(9'4+'5 %; )%2& +%342(9'50 L; J'4*-# %4' 5+&%,-( 4%2'5 2&-2./j/

N+23-,,*# $3(948 2&' +%,%49-, '(- 2&' (98&2 2% -55':),* -4$ 2% -55%+9-2' 94 -4* ;%(: 6-5 52(9+2,*+%42(%,,'$0 1&' +%,%49-,9525 6'(' -;(-9$ 2&-2 2&' N;(9+-4 7'%7,' +%3,$ ';;'+29=',* %(8-495' -8-9452

+%,%49-, $%:94-29%4 9; 2&'* 6'(' -,,%6'$ 2% -55':),' -4$ -55%+9-2'0

1&' +3,23(' %; ('52(9+2948 2&' (98&2 2% -55':),* 95 - +%,%49-, ='5298' 2&-2 2&' 8%='(4:'42 -$&'('5 2%0

T3++'559=' 8%='(4:'425 &-=' ('2-94'$ 2&'5' ('7('559=' :'2&%$5 -5 &98&,98&2'$ )* - 523$*

34$'(2-@'4 94 ?KKK %4 2&' 52-2' %; $':%+(-+* 94 J'4*- $3(948 2&' 76,_`L '(-0 1&' 523$* ('7%(2

4%2'5 2&-2 ^n%o='( 2&' *'-(5# 2&' +%342(* &-5 6924'55'$ ('7'-2'$ 'a-:7,'5 %; :''29485 -4$

$':%452(-29%4 +(929+-, %; 2&' 8%='(4:'42 )'948 $957'(5'$ )* 2&' 7%,9+'# %;2'4 692& =9%,'4+'0>/jG1&95

/jK4 /ig -)%='0/j/J J9)6-4- C/.8$0".&$3 %,1'&2 $.8 +%""8602 ,. :".E$ B/hhKC +92'$ 94 PI M'2'( ^E34$-:'42-, (98&25 -4$ ;(''$%:5 94

J'4*- - ('=9'6 '55-*> B/hh/C G*+%,-$. Z6/%.$3 6+ U.&"%.$&,6.$3 $.8 M60>$%$&,;" ]$4lh0/j?O-49', 1%(%929+& N(-7 I%9 95 2&' 5'+%4$ 7('59$'42 %; J'4*- 6&% 5'(='$ -4 34)(%@'4 ?H *'-( 2'(: 94 %;;9+' ;(%: /hlg

2% ?KK?0/jGX X8>'2&'# `L L6929# TA X-5%48%# O Z''2&-:e TF Z(-+@948 ^O':%+(-+* ('7%(2 ;%( `-:&3(9*- J'4*-> B?KKKC /l

-=-9,-),' -2 &227.cc66609$'-0942c73),9+-29%45c5%$c37,%-$cJ'4*-07$; B-++'55'$ ?? T'72':)'( ?K/HC0


45/68

36

$95:-, 52-2' %; -;;-9(5 7'(59525 -5 9,,352(-2'$ )* - ('+'42 ?K/H ('7%(2 %4 2&' 52-2' %; $':%452(-29%45

94 J'4*-# 'a+'(72'$ )',%6./jH

T94+' ?K//# 2&'(' &-=' )''4 - 43:)'( %; $':%452(-29%45 94=%,=948 +,-5&'5 )'26''4 $':%452(-2%(5

-4$ 7%,9+' -4$ :9,92-(* 7'(5%44',0 1&' 7%,9+' &-=' )''4 -++35'$ %; 35948 'a+'559=' 7%6'( 2%

9429:9$-2' J'4*-45 6&% 7(%2'520 1&95 )''4 -;;9(:'$ )* =9$'%5 %; 7%,9+' -)35948 7(%2'52%(5#

7-(29+3,-(,* =3,4'(-),' 8(%375# 53+& -5 942'(4-,,* $957,-+'$ 7'(5%45 B"OM5C0

X98'(9- 95 4% $9;;'('420 1&' 8%='(4:'42 95 '=9$'42,* @''4 %4 537('55948 $955'42 )* 6-* %;

$':%452(-29%45 -4$ 2&95 2'4$'4+* 95 -,5% 2(-+'-),' 2% 925 +%,%49-, &'(92-8'0 N5 %4' 6(92'(

%)5'(='5./ji -4$ :-942'4-4+'

P('-29%4 %; 7%,9+' ;%(+'5 2&-2 -(' 7-(-S:9,92-(* 94 %(8-495-29%4 -4$ 6&9+& %7'(-2' -5 -77-(-235 %;

=9%,'4+' 35'$ )* 2&' (3,'(5 2% 5377('55 %77%5929%4 2% 5%+9-, 94U3529+'5 -4$ -429S$':%+(-29+ (3,' 95 %4'

%; 2&' ,'8-+9'5 )'D3'-2&'$ 2% X98'(9- )* Z(9295& +%,%49-, (3,'(50

L4' -++3(-2' 5377%5929%4 2&-2 'a7,-945 -$&'('4+' 2% 2&95 -()92(-(* +%,%49-, 2('4$ 95 2&-2 ^n2o&'

('7('559=' +&-(-+2'(5 %; )%2& 2&' 52-2' -4$ 7%,9+' 94 X98'(9- $'(9=' ;(%: 2&' ,'8929:-29%4 7(%),':5

6&9+& 7,-83'$ 53++'559=' 8%='(4:'425 94 2&' +%342(*0>/jjN5 ;-( )-+@ -5 2&' /hgK5# 5+&%,-(,* 6%(@5

%4 7%,9+948 94 X98'(9- 7%942 2% 2&' :-4-8':'42 %; $':%452(-29%45 -5 )'948 - 2(%3),' 57%20 N /hgg

523$* ;%34$ 2&-2 2&' 7%,9+'>5 7%%( &-4$,948 %; 7(%2'525 +%:7(95'$ %; 26% %32 %; - 2%2-, %; 59a :-94

('-5%45 ;%( 73),9+ %32(-8' -8-9452 7%,9+'./jl

nTo%:' %; 2&' ;-+2%(5 ('57%459),' ;%( 2&' 4'8-29=' 7'(+'729%4 %; 2&' X98'(9-4 7%,9+' )* :':)'(5 %;

5%+9'2*0 1&'* 94+,3$'. B/C $952%(29%4 %( 'a-88'(-29%4 )* 2&' 7%,9+' %; '=9$'4+' 94 +%3(2[ B?C 2&' 35' %;

344'+'55-(* ;%(+'[ BGC ;-23%354'55 94 $'-,948 692& 73),9+ $':%452(-29%45[ BHC 94'72923$' 94 &-4$,948

2&' 73),9+ %4 %++-59%45 %; 73),9+ 7(%+'559%45[ BiC 94+9=9,92* 2% :':)'(5 %; 2&' 73),9+# -4$ BjC

344'+'55-(* $',-* 94 -22'4$948 2% +%:7,-94250


46/68

37

+%42(%, %='( 2&' (%32' -4$ 29:' %; 7(%2'5250>/jg1&' 5-:' ('7%(2 8%'5 %4 2% 7'(+'729=',* +-723(' 2&'

('-5%4 )'&94$ 2&' 35' %; 'a+'559=' ;%(+' -4$ -()92(-(* ('83,-29%4 %; $':%452(-29%45./jh

"4 7(-+29+' 2&' T2-2' 5%:'29:'5 35'5 ;%(+' 2% )('-@ 37 -55':),9'5 '='4 6&'(' 2&'5' -('

7'-+';3,0 1&' )-595 ;%( -,,%6948 5%:' -55':),9'5 2% 8% -&'-$ 6&9,' 7('='42948 %2&'(5 -77'-(5

-()92(-(*# )32 +-4 353-,,* )' 2(-+'$ 2% 2&' 7%,929+-, 942'('525 %; 2&' 8%='(4:'42 94 7%6'(# 594+' 2&'

X98'(9- M%,9+' E%(+' p -,2&%38& %52'459),* - 5'(=9+' ;%( 2&' '429(' E'$'(-29%4 p 95 -456'(-),' 2% 2&'

M('59$'42# -4$ 2&35 :%(' ,9@',* 2% $% &95 )9$$948# '92&'( 'a7('55 %( -429+97-2'$0

E(%: 2&' ;%('8%948# 92 95 -77-('42 2&-2 2&' $95:-, 52-2' %; 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2' 95 -5 - ('53,2 %;

2&' 8-75 -4$ ,9:92-29%45 +('-2'$ )* 2&' ,-6 -5 6',, -5 945292329%4-,95-29%4 %; -4 -32&%(92-(9-4 +3,23('

2&(%38&%32 :%52 ;-+'25 %; 8%='(4:'420 1&95 52-235 D3% %4 $':%452(-29%45 +%:7',5 -4 -,2'(4-29='

-77(%-+& 2% 2&' :-4-8':'42 %; $':%452(-29%450 1&' 4'a2 5'+29%4 -++%($948,* 7(%7%5'5 &%6 2%

('5%,=' 2&' +&-,,'48'5 2% $':%452(-29%45 94 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'5 =9- 2&' 4'8%29-2'$

:-4-8':'42 -77(%-+&0

TQT_B=8 ;9HA87=89: 6=;=H969;8 89;:D @A> 9D9;8 IA;I9>;D

1&' -9: 94 2&95 5'+29%4 95 26%S;%,$0 1&' ;9(52 95 2% 942'((%8-2' 2&' 7('5'42 +%4+'(45 -)%32

$':%452(-29%45 94 2&' +-5' 523$* +%342(9'5 -4$ 2&' 5'+%4$ 95 2% 'a7,%(' 2&' 7(%57'+25 %; -4

-,2'(4-29=' ('-,92* )* :'-45 %; 2&' 4'8%29-2'$ :-4-8':'42 :%$',0 1&' +%4+'(45 2&-2 69,, )'

',3+9$-2'$ 94+,3$' 2&%5' 2&-2 -(95' ;(%: 2&' ;-9,9485 %; 2&' ,'8-, ;(-:'6%(@ 6&9,' %2&'(5 ':-4-2'

;(%: 7(-+29+' 2&-2 95 -2 =-(9-4+' 692& ,-60

TQTQS )7DA87A;=89 >9D8>7I87A;D 7; =I87I9

1&' 6(92'( +%459$'(5 $957(%7%(29%4-2' ('52(9+29%45 2% )' 2&%5' 2&-2 -2(%7&* %( +%:7,'2',* $';'-2

2&' -+23-,95-29%4 %; 2&' (98&2 2% $':%452(-2'0 1&' Q3:-4 R98&25 P%::922'' BQRPCSVY&-5 9$'429;9'$

8-75 2&-2 -;;'+2 2&' 9:7,':'42-29%4 %; ;(''$%: %; -55':),* 2% 94+,3$' ^B-C )-45 %4 $':%452(-29%45[

B)C 34U3529;9'$ ('52(9+29%45 %4 $':%452(-29%45[ n-4$o B+C 344'+'55-(* ('D39(':'425 2% %)2-94

-32&%(9b-29%45 2&-2 -;;'+2 2&' '4U%*:'42 %; ;(''$%: %; -55':),*0>SVS

&A8=? 5=;D

/jg1&' "42'(4-29%4-, P'42'( ;%( X%2S;%(SM(%;92 F-6 ^XWL F-6 I%492%(. X98'(9-> -=-9,-),' -2

&227.cc66609+4,0%(8c('5'-(+&c:%492%(c498'(9-0&2:, B-++'55'$ ?? T'72':)'( ?K/HC0/jh-5 -)%='0/lKQRP 95 2&' 2('-2* )%$* 2&-2 %='(5''5 2&' 9:7,':'42-29%4 %; 2&' "42'(4-29%4-, P%='4-42 %4 P9=9, -4$ M%,929+-, R98&250/l/

Ncj?c??i B?KKlC l0


47/68

38

"4 )%2& +%342(9'5# 2&' ,-65 $% 4%2 '4=95-8' - 2%2-, )-4 %4 $':%452(-29%45[ 2&95 &-5 &%6'='( +%:'

2% )' 2&' 7%,9+' 7(-+29+'0 "4 J'4*-# 2&' P%45292329%4 %; ?K/K 7(%=9$'5 -4 'a7('55 +%45292329%4-, (98&2

2% $':%452(-2'# *'2 2&' +3,23(' %; ),-4@'2 )-45 &-5 7'(5952'$ 94 5792' %; 2&' 4'6 +%45292329%4-,

$957'45-29%40 N;2'( 2&' 8'4'(-, ','+29%45 94 ?K/H -4$ 2&' 7('59$'429-, ','+29%4 7'2929%4 2&-2

;%,,%6'$# 2&'(' 6-5 - +%342(*69$' ),-4@'2 )-4 %4 $':%452(-29%450 1&' $-* )';%(' 2&' 7'2929%4 6-5

(','-5'$# 2&' "W ^6-(4'$ 2&-2 2&' 7%,9+' 6%3,$ 4%2 7'(:92 7%,929+-, 8-2&'(9485# (':94$948 2&'

7%73,-29%4 %; - +%342(*69$' $9('+29=' 9553'$ '-(,9'( 2&-2 :%42& 2&-2 )-44'$ -,, ;%(:5 %;

$':%452(-29%45# +',')(-29%45# 7%,929+-, (-,,9'5

mariam kamunyu ma thesis

Documents