measurementofserumfreethyroxinebyriainvariousclinicalstatesjnm.snmjournals.org/content/21/3/233.full.pdf ·...

7
CLINICAL SCIENCES The most commonly used test in the diagnosis of thyroid function is the serum thyroxine (T4) concen tration. Since circulating T4 is almost totally bound e―@99.97%), primarily by the thyronine-bindingglobulin (TBG) but also by albumin and prealbumin (TBPA), measurement of serum total T4 concentration will be influenced by both the quantity of T4 secreted by the thyroid gland and the concentration of TBG. It is gen erally accepted that the free or unbound T4 concentra tion (FT.@) is more readily available to the tissues for metabolic action, and that the measurement of serum FT4 more accurately reflects thyroid function, since it is not altered by the concentration of the thyronine binding proteins, especially TBG. Many methods have been described for the calculation of the free T4 con centration, and all depend on measurement of the serum T4 concentration and an assessment of the percentage of the total T4 that is unbound. The triiodothyronine uptake (T3U) is the most commonly used test to deter mine the relative saturation of the TBG binding sites by T4, and it indirectly reflects the proportion of the free T4 in serum. The indirect measurement of the serum FT4 is then calculated as the product of the T4 and T3U and is reported as a free T4 index (FF1). The FTI can also be Received Jan. 30, 1979; revision accepted Sept. 12, 1979. For reprints contact: Lewis E. Braverman, MD, Dept. of Endocri nology, Univ. of Mass. Medical School, 55 Lake Ave. North, Worcester, MA 01605. calculated by the quotient of the serum T4 and TBG concentrations measured by radioimmunoassay (RIA). These indirect methods do have clinical utility but do not give a quantitative Fl'4 concentration (1—4). A direct measurement of serum FT4 can be assessed as the product of the serum T4 and the fraction of free T4 measured by equilibrium dialysis (5—7). Other methods for measuring FF4, such as Sephadex filtration (8), ultrafiltration (9), charcoal absorption (10), ion exchange or gel filtration (11), and a combination of dialysis and gas chromatography (/2) as well as RIA methods (13, 14), have also been described. Most of these are not suitable for routine laboratory use, since they are often time-consuming and technically more difficult to perform. The present report describes a rapid, reproducible, and simple RIA method for the quantitative measurement of FT4 in the sera of patients with thyroid dysfunction, in patients with the estrogen-induced increase in TBG that occurs in pregnancy, in euthyroid patients with hereditary TBG abnormalities, and in sick euthyroid patients. MATERIALS AND METHODS Fr4byRIA. TheIMMOPHASEFT41251 Radio immunoassay Test System* was used. Each kit contains the following reagents, sufficient for 60 FT4 determi nations: The T4 antibody (rabbit anti-T4), covalently bound to porous glass particles, suspended in phos Volume 21, Number 3 233 IN VITRO NUCLEAR MEDICINE Measurement ofSerumFreeThyroxinebyRIAinVariousClinicalStates LewisE.Braverman, CynthiaM.Abreau,PaulBrock,RichardKleinmann, LawrenceFournier,GeraldOdstrchel,and Hubert J. P. Schoemaker University of Massachusetts Medical School, Worcester, and Corning Medical, Medfield, Massachusetts A radloimmunoassay for quantitativelymeasuringthe serum concentrationof free thyroxineis described.Thismethoddoesnot requireequilibriumdialysis,and is rapid and reproducible.The serum values obtainedby this radioimmunoassay andby equilibriumdialysisare similarin normalsubjects,hyperthyroidand hypo thyroid patients, pregnantwomen, â€oesick euthyroid― patients, and euthyroidpa tientswith hereditaryTBG abnormalities.The methodalso providesa total serum thyroxineconcentrationinthe same assayprocedure. J NucI Med 21: 233—239,1980

Upload: others

Post on 23-Feb-2021

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: MeasurementofSerumFreeThyroxinebyRIAinVariousClinicalStatesjnm.snmjournals.org/content/21/3/233.full.pdf · 1.02.0 BRAVERMAN,ABREAU,BROCK,KLEINMANN.FOURNIER,ODSTRCHEL,SCHOEMAKER phate-bufferedsaline,pH7.4,containingbovineserum

CLINICAL SCIENCES

The most commonly used test in the diagnosis ofthyroid function is the serum thyroxine (T4) concentration. Since circulating T4 is almost totally bounde―@99.97%),primarily by the thyronine-bindingglobulin(TBG) but also by albumin and prealbumin (TBPA),measurement of serum total T4 concentration will beinfluenced by both the quantity of T4 secreted by thethyroid gland and the concentration of TBG. It is generally accepted that the free or unbound T4 concentration (FT.@) is more readily available to the tissues formetabolic action, and that the measurement of serumFT4 more accurately reflects thyroid function, since itis not altered by the concentration of the thyroninebinding proteins, especially TBG. Many methods havebeen described for the calculation of the free T4 concentration, and all depend on measurement of the serumT4 concentration and an assessment of the percentageof the total T4 that is unbound. The triiodothyronineuptake (T3U) is the most commonly used test to determine the relative saturation of the TBG binding sites byT4, and it indirectly reflects the proportion of the free T4in serum. The indirect measurement of the serum FT4is then calculated as the product of the T4 and T3U andis reported as a free T4 index (FF1). The FTI can also be

Received Jan. 30, 1979; revision accepted Sept. 12, 1979.

For reprints contact: Lewis E. Braverman, MD, Dept. of Endocrinology, Univ. of Mass. Medical School, 55 Lake Ave. North,Worcester, MA 01605.

calculated by the quotient of the serum T4 and TBGconcentrations measured by radioimmunoassay (RIA).These indirect methods do have clinical utility but do notgive a quantitative Fl'4 concentration (1—4).

A direct measurement of serum FT4 can be assessedas the product of the serum T4 and the fraction of freeT4 measured by equilibrium dialysis (5—7). Othermethods for measuring FF4, such as Sephadex filtration(8), ultrafiltration (9), charcoal absorption (10), ionexchange or gel filtration (11), and a combination ofdialysis and gas chromatography (/2) as well as RIAmethods (13, 14), have also been described. Most of theseare not suitable for routine laboratory use, since they areoften time-consuming and technically more difficult toperform.

The present report describes a rapid, reproducible, andsimple RIA method for the quantitative measurementof FT4 in the sera of patients with thyroid dysfunction,in patients with the estrogen-induced increase in TBGthat occurs in pregnancy, in euthyroid patients withhereditary TBG abnormalities, and in sick euthyroidpatients.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fr4byRIA.TheIMMOPHASEFT41251Radioimmunoassay Test System* was used. Each kit containsthe following reagents, sufficient for 60 FT4 determinations: The T4 antibody (rabbit anti-T4), covalentlybound to porous glass particles, suspended in phos

Volume 21, Number 3 233

IN VITRO NUCLEAR MEDICINE

Measurementof SerumFreeThyroxinebyRIAinVariousClinicalStates

LewisE.Braverman,CynthiaM.Abreau,PaulBrock,RichardKleinmann,LawrenceFournier,GeraldOdstrchel,andHubertJ. P. Schoemaker

University of Massachusetts Medical School, Worcester, and Corning Medical, Medfield, Massachusetts

A radloimmunoassayfor quantitativelymeasuringthe serum concentrationoffree thyroxineis described.Thismethoddoesnotrequireequilibriumdialysis,andis rapid and reproducible.The serumvalues obtainedby this radioimmunoassayand by equilibriumdialysisare similarin normalsubjects,hyperthyroidand hypothyroid patients, pregnantwomen, “sickeuthyroid―patients, and euthyroidpatientswith hereditaryTBG abnormalities.The methodalso providesa total serumthyroxineconcentrationin the same assayprocedure.

J NucI Med 21: 233—239,1980

Page 2: MeasurementofSerumFreeThyroxinebyRIAinVariousClinicalStatesjnm.snmjournals.org/content/21/3/233.full.pdf · 1.02.0 BRAVERMAN,ABREAU,BROCK,KLEINMANN.FOURNIER,ODSTRCHEL,SCHOEMAKER phate-bufferedsaline,pH7.4,containingbovineserum

1.0 2.0

BRAVERMAN, ABREAU, BROCK, KLEINMANN. FOURNIER, ODSTRCHEL, SCHOEMAKER

phate-buffered saline, pH 7.4, containing bovine serumalbumin and sodium azide; I- I 25-labeled T4, Tracer Acontaining red dye and Tracer B containing green dyeand thimerosal; five vials of lyophilized humanplasma-based standards containing FT4 at concentrations of 0.5, 1.0, 2.0, 4.0, and 6.0 ng/dl; and two vials oflyophilized human-plasma-based controls. The FT4standards were determined by using the equilibriumdialysis method as described by Sterling and Hegedus(5). Before use, the lyophilized reagents are reconstitutedwith distilled or deionized water. Tracer A and TracerB are reconstituted with 6 ml water, and standards andcontrols with 3 ml water. The vials are swirled and thenintermittently mixed for 10 mm.

The total T4 can also be measured, since values for 14are given for each of the FT4 standards. A total 14standard curve can be obtained by using Tracer B. In astudy by Hertl and Odstrchel (/5), it was demonstratedthat the binding of 14 to its specific immobilized antibody (IMA) obeys second-order reaction kinetics. Therate of the reaction is a function of the FT4 concentrationand the antibody concentration. The FT4. in turn, is related to total concentrations of T4 and thyronine-bindingprotein. The FT4 method was developed in conjunctionwith a basic kinetic and thermodynamic study (15).

The key concept of the FT4 (RIA) method is that theconcentration of thyroxine bound to the immobilizedantibody (IMA) in Tube A after a 30-mm incubation isfunctionally related to the FT4 concentration in thesample. This functional relationship is described by thefollowing equation:

f[IMA-T4] = [FT4]0k1t

Where f is a symbol for “functionof―,[FT4]0 is theconcentration of unbound thyroxine in the serum sample,k1 is the forward rate constant, and t is the reaction timein minutes. More details on the theory of the assay aredescribed by Ekins (16) and Fullarton and Lidgard (17).The derivation of the full integrated rate equation isdescribed by Schoemaker (/8). In the FT4 (RIA) assay,two reactions, A and B, are measured. In reaction A, 14antibody immobilized onto porous glass particles (IMA)binds the 14 that is not bound to the thyronine-bindingproteins throughout the incubation period. The countfrom 14 bound in reaction A (cpmA) divided by the totalcounts (TC) represents the fraction of 14 moleculesbound to IMA and is thus a function of the percentageof free 14 in the serum. In reaction B, the bound 14 isdisplaced from the proteins by thimerosal, and then bindsto the IMA. In this classical RIA, the patient's total T4concentration is calculated from the radioactive T4bound to IMA. The product of the fraction of T4 boundto I MA in the A series (cpmA/TCA) and the total T4concentration ( B series) gives a measure of the amountofT4 bound to IMA in the A series, which is a functionof the free 14 concentration. A standard curve is con

structed on linear graph paper by plotting cpmA/TCAx T4(@g/dl)as abscissaagainstFT4(ng/ml) as ordinate. A smooth curve is drawn through the points andthe FT4 in ng/mi is determined from the standard curvefor both the supplied control samples and the unknownserum samples.

All reagents should be brought to room temperaturebefore starting the assay. Before pipetting the immobilized antibody, the vial is thoroughly mixed until theglass particles are suspended. The assay procedure isdescribed in the product insert.

yr4byequilibriumdialysis.SerumT4concentrationwas measured by RIA by a solid-phase technique.* Thepercent free T4 was measured by equilibrium dialysis asdescribed by Sterling and Hegedus (5). fT4 (ng/dl) wascalculated as the product of the total T4 and fraction offree T4.

Free thyroxine index. The Ff1 was calculated by usingcommercially available reagents for measuring T4, TBG,and T3U. Serum T4 and TBG concentrations weremeasured by RIA,* and Fl! (IMMO PHASE) calculated as: T4 (jsg/dl)/TBG (@tg/ml) X 10.

Serum T4 (RIA) and T3U were measured with commercial kits,t and the Fl! (NML) calculated as: T3U/100 x T4.

Serum T3. Serum T3 concentration was measured bya solid-phase RIA method.*

Serum ‘NH.Serum TSH concentration was measuredby a commercial double-antibody method.@

In this study, FF4 (RIA) was measured in the sera of243 subjects: 89 healthy euthyroid subjects, 29 hypothyroid patients, 25 hyperthyroid patients, 3 1 pregnantwomen, 47 sick euthyroid patients, and 22 patients withhereditary TBG abnormalities. The―sick―euthyroidssuffered from a wide variety of systemic illnesses including metastatic carcinoma, renal failure, severe infection, cirrhosis, and congestive heart failure; none wasreceiving drugs known to affect thyroid function or the

DoseResponseCurve

3.0 4.0

6.0

:5p4.0

I@ 2.0

1.0@ I I I

cpm A (14 @gldl)T.C.

FIG.1. RepresentatIvestandardcurve.cpmA/TCAX (T@@g/dl)Isplotted agaInst FT4 concentration. Solid circles represent mean andbars±s.e.m.,computedfromsixconsecutIveassays.

234 THE JOURNAL OF NUCLEAR MEDICINE

Page 3: MeasurementofSerumFreeThyroxinebyRIAinVariousClinicalStatesjnm.snmjournals.org/content/21/3/233.full.pdf · 1.02.0 BRAVERMAN,ABREAU,BROCK,KLEINMANN.FOURNIER,ODSTRCHEL,SCHOEMAKER phate-bufferedsaline,pH7.4,containingbovineserum

MeanFT4Coefficientof

variation'(ng/dl)(%)

CLINICAL SCIENCESIN VITRO NUCLEAR MEDICINE

Correlation Between Equilibrium Dialysisand RIA Free-T4 Methods

1.0 2.0 3.0 4@O 5.0

IMMO PHASEFr@-T4(ngldl)

FIG.2. ComparisonofFT4(RIA)withFT4(equil.dial.).Regressiongives following relationship: FT4 (AlA) 0.68 FT4 (equil. dial.) +0.47, wIth r = 0.96. Symbols indicate various clinical states in 170patients as follows: 71 euthyroid (•);15 hypothyroid (); 23 hyperthyrold(0); 18pregnant(0); 17“sick―euthyroidswith lowT4(*); six“sick―euthyroidswithnormalT4(U);fourhereditaryTBG

@fIcIent(•);11 heredItary IowTBG (‘t@r);and five hereditary highTBG(J). Normalrangeforeachmethodisalsoindicated.

pregnant women was always within the euthyroid range,and the mean value did not differ from that observed inthe euthyroid subjects. Others have reported that themean serum FT4 (equil. dial.) in pregnancy may besignificantly lower than that observed in euthyroidsubjects (2,6,20,21 ). Serum TSH concentration was wellwithin the normal range (0—10ng/ml) in the pregnantsubjects.

The serum FT4 (RIA) was normal in patients with anhereditary absence of serum TBG (n 5), an hereditarydecrease in serum TBG (n 11), or an hereditary increase in serum TBG (n = 6). The serum T4 concentration in 30 sick euthyroid patients was within the normalrange, and the mean value did not differ from the euthyroid mean. Serum T4 was below the normal range in17 sick patients as determined by the IMMO PHASEmethod. Serum free 14 (RIA) was within the normalrange in all except one sick patient (0.9 ng/dl), irrespective of whether the serum 14 was normal or low,although the serum FT4 (RIA) was significantly de

TABLE1. PRECISIONOF ThE FT4(RIA)ASSAY AT TWO FT4 CONCENTRATIONS

Intra_assayt 1.4 1.12.7 1.3

Interassayt 1.4 6.42.7 7.1

. ± Coefficient of variation 100 X s.d. of mean.

t Duplicate determinations in six consecutive assays.

t Means of duplicates in six consecutive assays.

8.0-

7.0- 0=. 0

,@:6.0_ 000I.@ 00

@ 0

I1.&0@@ I 0

.@ LNO@maI-@J

.@, Range@ 0

0 4.0 0 r=0.96E:@ @E----;--@---—---—-—E3.0 I3

‘if. Normal

2.0@@ @. i Rang.

4,@.v!I;@@ I

1.0 :f.t:: T@t

T4-binding proteins. In the study comparing the Ff4.(RIA) method with the equilibrium dialysis techniquefor measuring FT4. I 70 of the 243 subjects were evaluated: 7 1 euthyroid subjects, 15 hypothyroids, 23 hyperthyroids, 20 patients with hereditary TBG abnormalties,18 pregnant subjects, and 23 sick euthyroids. The diagnoses of hyperthyroidism or hypothyroidism were confirmed clinically and by serum T4, T3, and TSH concentrations. The euthyroid subjects were healthy volunteers participating in this and other studies. SerumFTI was measured in the 47 sick euthyroids. All assayswere carried out in duplicate.

RESULTS

Variability of the standard curve, and precision of Ff@(RIA). The standard curve in six consecutive assaysdemonstrated satisfactory assay-to-assay reproducibility(Fig. 1). Inter- and intra-assay variability (/9) was wellwithin the accepted range (Table 1).

Serum Fr4 (RIA) compared with Fl', (equilibrium dialysis) (Fig. 2). FT4 (RIA) correlated extremely well withFr4 (equil. dial.) in the 170 patientsevaluated,irrespective of thyroid function, concentration of TBG andnonthyroid illness. The regression line correlating the twomethods was highly significant (r = 0.96, P < 0.001); itsequation is FT4 (RIA) 0.68 FT4 (equil. dial.) + 0.47.Both methods confirmed the diagnosis in all patients. Asexpected, FT4 by both methods was increased in hyperthyroidism and decreased in hypothyroidism. SerumFT4 was almost always within the normal range inpregnant and systemically ill euthyroid patients and inpatients with hereditary abnormalities in serum TBGconcentration.

Serum Vf4(RIA) in various clinical states (Table 2, Fig.3). Compared with the 89 euthyroid subjects evaluatedin the present study, the serum FT4 (RIA) was elevatedin all hyperthyroid patients and decreased in all hypothyroids. The normal range in a larger group of 160 euthyroid subjects (including these 89) was somewhatbroader ( I .0—2.5ng/dl). FT4 (RIA) in the sera of the

Volume 21, Number 3 235

Page 4: MeasurementofSerumFreeThyroxinebyRIAinVariousClinicalStatesjnm.snmjournals.org/content/21/3/233.full.pdf · 1.02.0 BRAVERMAN,ABREAU,BROCK,KLEINMANN.FOURNIER,ODSTRCHEL,SCHOEMAKER phate-bufferedsaline,pH7.4,containingbovineserum

ClInical Diagnosis n T4 @g/dI)' Range FT4 (ng/dI)' Range

BRAVERMAN,ABREAU,BROCK,KLEINMANN, FOURNIER,ODSTRCHEL,SCHOEMAKER

Euthyroid

HypothyroidHyperthyroidPregnancy“Sick―Euthyroidt

(Normal14)“SickEuthyroldt

(Low T4)Hereditary

Absent TBG

HereditaryLowTBG@

HereditaryHigh 180*

89

29253130

8.0±0.32.8 ±0.3

16.9 ±0.511.8 ±0.47.5±0.4

6. 1—13.10.5—4.9

12.7—22.07.4—16.85.9—11.9

1.6±0.040.5 ±0.053.8 ±0.141.5±0.041.6 ±0.06

1.3—2.30.3—1.02.9—5.91.1—2.01.0—2.1

17 3.7 ±0.3 1.6—5.3 1.3 ±0.08 0.9—1.8

2.7 ±0.3 2.0—3.7 1.3 ±0.125 0.9—1.7

11 3.9 ±0.5 1.9—8.3 1.3 ±0.09 0.8—2.0

18.1±15116 13.3—23.2 1.4±0.11 1.2—1.9

4 Mean ± s.e.m.

t Normal and low T4 concentrations are defined as greater or less than 5.5 sg/dl, respectively, using the IMMO PHASE, T4

AlA.* Low and high TBG concentrations are defined as less than 12 jzg/mI or more than 60 @Lg/mIusing the IMMO PHASE, TBG

AlA.IITo determine 14 concentratIon more accurately, a 10 zl sample was used in the six samples with high TBGandT4concen

trations.

creased in the patients with a low serum 14 (P <0.001).

Various thyroid function tests in sick euthyroid patients (Tables 3 and 4). In some euthyroid patients withsystemic illness, serum 14 concentration and Ff1 maybe decreased or increased, FT4 (equil. dial.) elevated, andserum 13 concentration decreased, leadii?ig to falsediagnoses of hypothyroidism or hyperthyroidism. Multiple tests of thyroid function were therefore carried outin the.47 sick euthyroid patients. The percent free T4 byequilibrium dialysis was significantly increased in the

23 sick patients evaluated by this method (P < 0.001)and was above the normal range in 18. The serum T3Uwas also increased and was above the normal range in16 patients. As noted above, serum T4 was within thenormal range in 30 patients, but was decreased in 17patients as measured by the IMMO PHASE RIA. Inthese 17 patients ETI (NML) was decreased in nine andFf1 (IMMO PHASE) in seven. Serum FT4 (RIA) waswithin the normal range in all except one sick patient (0.9ng/dl), but values in patients with a low serum T4 weresignificantly decreased. Ff4 (equil. dial.) was also within

Free-T4 In Patients with Various ClInical States

4.0

IU.

2.0

U I U I I U U I IEuthyrold Hypo Hyper “Sick―“Sick―Pregnancy Hr.dltary H.r.dltary Hsosdltary

Thyroid Thyroid EuthyroidEuthyrold Abssnt Low High(Normal 14) (Low 14) 180 150 TBG

FIG.3. Tt@serumFT4(RIA)frequencydistributionfor variousgroupsof patients(n 243):89 euthyroid;29 hypothyroId;25hyperthyroid;31 pregnant;30 and 17 “sickeuthyrolds―with normaland low serumT4concentrations respectively; fIve, 11, andsixeuthyroldsubjectswithhereditary180abnormalities.

236 THE JOURNAL OF NUCLEAR MEDICINE

TABLE2. SERUMT4 AND FT (RIA) CONCENTRATIONSIN VARIOUSCLINICALSTATES

iii*ii@iii@i@

Page 5: MeasurementofSerumFreeThyroxinebyRIAinVariousClinicalStatesjnm.snmjournals.org/content/21/3/233.full.pdf · 1.02.0 BRAVERMAN,ABREAU,BROCK,KLEINMANN.FOURNIER,ODSTRCHEL,SCHOEMAKER phate-bufferedsaline,pH7.4,containingbovineserum

TABLE3. THYROIDFUNCTIONTESTSIN SICK EUTHYROIDPATIENTSWITH NORMAL@ CONCENTRATION'SERUM

T4IMMO

IMMO EquilibriumPHASE NML PHASE dialysist

T4 TBG@ T4 RT3U FT4 (AlA) FT4 FT4(j@g/dI) (jsg/ml) FTI (@g/dI) (%) FTI (ng/dl) (%) (ng/dl)T3(ng/dI)TSH(@tU/mI)Mean

7.5 16.9 3.9 7.9 39.7 3.2 1.6 0.030 2.0693.60.2s.e.m. 0.4 0.8 0.1 0.2 1.2 0.07 0.06 0.0020.08Range

5.9—11.910.1—32.22.7—5.75.9—9.8 32.7—53.32.2—4.3 0.8—2.1 0.022—0.0361.6-2.70.9—3.212—15680—2202.4—9.00—10Normal5.5—12.0 12—30 2.5—6.0 5.5—11.5 35—45 2.2—4.7 1.0—2.50.017—0.028range.

Normal serum 14 concentration is defined as greater than 5.5 zg/dl by IMMOPHASE.t

Due to the limited supply of sera, equilibrium dialysis data were obtained on only six of the 30patients.TABLE

4. THYROIDFUNCTIONTESTSIN SICK EUTHYROIDPATIENTSWITHLOW'SERUMT4CONCENTRATiONIMMO

PHASEEquilibriumIMMONML FT4dialysisPHASE

(RIA) FT@FT4T3TSHPatientT4 TBG T@ AT3U(%) FTI (ng/dl) (%)(ng/dl)(ng/dl)(p@U/mljno.(jzg/dl) (jsg/ml) FrI (j.tgldl)

CLINICAL SCIENCESIN VITRO NUCLEAR MEDICINE

15.115.43.35.955.33.31.50.0270.0411.6 1.825 183.03.323.89.44.05.059.53.01.40.0391.2133.532.414.11.74.344.71.91.00.0341.9382.944.915.43.26.450.93.31.60.0451.71943.053.017.51.73.948.61.91.60.0351.9464.364.718.72.55.638.62.20.0221.3402.975.013.53.76.244.82.81.30.0171.0182.485.113.33.85.847.32.71.30.0372.0223.494.710.64.45.749.12.81.50.1001.606.5101.62.56.41.666.81.11.00.0761.9353.2112.910.82.33.555.51.90.90.0561.101.8122.816.31.73.345.91.51.20.0361.9457.1135.310.35.15.151.82.61.80.0231.2493.8145.217.23.04.640.21.81.00.0411.1204.9152.213.11.73.748.61.81.20.0521.01502.9161.66.72.42.752.61.41.10.0400.9279.5172.316.91.43.243.41.41.30.0421.5444.0Mean3.713.03.24.549.62.21.30.0090.2090.3±

s.e.m.0.31.90.50.33.00.10.11

4 Low serum T4 concentration is defined as less than 5.5 zg/dl using 1MMO PHASE.

the normal range in all except one sick patient. SerumTBG (RIA) was below normal in seven of the 47 sickpatients, six of whom had a low serum T4 concentration.There was a positive correlation between serum TBG andT4 concentrations in these 47 sick euthyroid patients (r= 0.713, P < 0.001). Since illness is associated with

decreased peripheral outer-ring deiodination of T4 to T3,serum T3 concentration was below the normal range in33 sick patients. Serum TSH concentration was normalin the 47 euthyroid, sick patients.

DISCUSSION

Measurement of the serum FT4 concentration is anexcellent test of thyroid function, since it is not usuallyaffected by TBG abnormalities or by the decreasedouter-ring monodeiodination of T4 to T3 associated witha wide variety of acute and chronic illnesses (22—26).The FTI is an indirect assessment of the serum FT4concentration, but even though the relationship is notquantitative, the Ff1 correlates well with the FT4 con

Volume 21, Number 3 237

Page 6: MeasurementofSerumFreeThyroxinebyRIAinVariousClinicalStatesjnm.snmjournals.org/content/21/3/233.full.pdf · 1.02.0 BRAVERMAN,ABREAU,BROCK,KLEINMANN.FOURNIER,ODSTRCHEL,SCHOEMAKER phate-bufferedsaline,pH7.4,containingbovineserum

I3RAVERMAN, ABREAU, BROCK. KLEINMANN, FOURNIER. ODSTRCHEL, SCHOEMAKER

centration in most patients' sera. The FTI requires twotests, a direct measurement of TBG by RIA or the relative saturation ofTBG by 13 (T3U), and the serum 14concentration. Most FTI or FT4 methods are comparedwith the FT4 as determined by equilibrium dialysis,which quantitatively measures the free 14 concentrationin serum. The present method for measuring fl'4 by RIAalso uses two measurements that are carried out in thesame assay. This method results in values similar to thoseobtained by equilibrium dialysis in normal subjects, inpatients with hyperthyroidism and hypothyroidism andabnormalities in TBG, and in most sick euthyroid patients. This method is simple, rapid, and reproducible.In addition to an FT4 value, the two-tube test also provides values for the serum T4 concentration.

Patients who are severely ill may present a diagnosticproblem, since the serum concentrations of 13, T4, FTI,and FT4 may be abnormal, suggesting the possibility ofthyroid dysfunction. In the present study, the low serumT3 concentration in many of the systemically ill patientsconfirms the findings from many laboratories (22-26).It is evident, therefore, that in sick patients the measurement of the serum T3 concentration may result ina false diagnosis of hypothyroidism. The serum 14 concentration is usually normal in patients with systemicillness, although in some patients it may be elevated(26—30)or decreased (1,2,6,7,27,31—33). In the presentstudy, the serum 14 concentration was not elevated inany of the 47 sick patients, but was below the normalrange in 17. The ETI is usually normal in euthyroid sickpatients, although increased (26,29) or decreased(31,32) values have been reported to occur with variable

frequency. In the present study, the FTI was decreasedin nine of 47 sick patients, and elevated in none. Theserum 14 was low in these nine patients. The FT4 measured by equilibrium dialysis and RIA was normal in allexcept one of these patients with a low FF1, although themean FT4 (RIA) was significantly decreased. It is evident from the discrepancy between the FF1 and FT4 inthese nine patients that the T3U was not sufficiently elevated to result in a normal FTI. Others have reporteda similar discrepancy between the percent free 14 andthe T3U, with the result that the FT4 (equil. dial.) maybe normal and the FTI decreased in some systemicallyill patients (2,32,33). Burrows and Chopra and theircoworkers (28,34) have suggested the possibility of anondialyzable inhibitor (1gM) ofT4 binding in sick patients, detectable only by equilibrium dialysis, althoughSchussler and Welski have not found such an inhibitor(35). In view of the normal values for FT4 as determinedby RIA and equilibrium dialysis in almost all the sickpatients with a low serum T4, the FT4 (RIA) can besubstituted for the more cumbersome and less reproducible equilibrium dialysis technique.

As reported previously (2,5—7,21,23,24,27,30,32), thepercent free 14 measured by equilibrium dialysis was

significantly increased in the sick patients, especially inthose with a low serum 14 concentration. The majorityof the sick patients in the present study had a normalserum FT4 (by RIA and equil. dial.) and might not havebeen as severely ill as the patients in these other studiesin whom the serum FT4 (equil. dial.) was also frequentlyincreased. It is possible that the FT4 (I{IA) would beelevated in some more severely ill patients with a normalserum 14 concentration, but less so than the EU4 (equil.dial.), since the former was somewhat lower than thelatter in the I 7 patients described above, who had a decreased serum 14 concentration.

Although this method for assessing the free T4 concentration is reliable, simple, and reproducible, its efficacy in patients with nonthyroid illness must be evaluated in other laboratories and in larger groups of sickpatients. On the basis of our study, it would be prematureto recommend the FT4 (RIA) as “the―screening test forthyroid function. However, it warrants further study byother investigators.

FOOTNOTES

* Corning Medical, Medfield, MA.

t Nuclear Medical Laboratories, Inc.,

I Beckman HTSH.

ACKNOWLEDG MENT

This research was supported in part by Research Grant Nos.AMI89I9 and AM07302 from the NIAMDD, Bethesda, MD.

REFERENCES

1. CLARKF,HORNDB:Assessmentof thyroidfunctionbythecombined use of the serum protein-bound iodine and resinuptake of 131I-triiodothyronine. J C/in Endocrino/ Metab 25:39-45,l965

2. ANDERSON BG: Free thyroxine in serum in relation to thyroid function. J Am Med Assoc 203: 577-582, 1968

3. STEIN RB, PRICE L: Evaluation ofadjusted total thyroxine(free thyroxine index) as a measure of thyroid function. J ClinEndocrino/Metab 34:225-228,1972

4. ROSENFELD L: “Freethyroxine index―:a reliable substitutefor “freethyroxine concentration―. Am J C/in Patho/ 61:118—121,1974

5. STERLINGK, HEGEDUSA: Measurementof freethyroxineconcentration in human serum. J C/in Invest 41: 1031-40,1962

6. INGBAR SH, BRAVERMAN LE, DAWBER NA, et al: A newmethod for measuring the free thyroid hormone in humanserum and an analysis of the factors that influence its concentration.J C/inInvest44:1679-1689,1965

7. BERNSTEIN0, OPPENHEIMERJH: Factors influencing theconcentration of free and total thyroxine in patients withnonthyroidal disease. J (‘/inEndocrino/ Metab 26: 195-20 1,I966

8. CAVALIERI RR, CASTLE iN, SF.ARLE GL: A simplifledmethodfor estimatingfreethyroxine fraction in serum.J Nuc/Med 10:565-70,1969

9. SCHUSSLER GC, PLAGER JE: Effect ofpreliminary purification of 131I-thyroxine on the determination of the free thy

238 THE JOURNAL OF NUCLEAR MEDICINE

Page 7: MeasurementofSerumFreeThyroxinebyRIAinVariousClinicalStatesjnm.snmjournals.org/content/21/3/233.full.pdf · 1.02.0 BRAVERMAN,ABREAU,BROCK,KLEINMANN.FOURNIER,ODSTRCHEL,SCHOEMAKER phate-bufferedsaline,pH7.4,containingbovineserum

CLINICAL SCIENCESIN VITRO NUCLEAR MEDICINE

roxine in serum. J C/in Endocrino/ Metab 27: 242-50,I967

10. KUMAGAI LF, JUBIZ W, JESSOPLD: A simple and rapidmethod for determining free thyroxine by charcoal absorption.C/in Res 15: 124, 1967(abst)

I 1. BURKE CW, SHAKESPEAR RA: Triiodothyronine and thyroxine in urine. II. Renal handling, and effect of urinaryprotein.J C/inEndocrino/Metab42:504-513,1976

12. PETERSENBA, GIESERW, LARSENPR,et al: Measurement of free thyroid hormonesin serum by dialysis and gaschromatography. C/in Chem 23: 1389-1396, 1977

13. EKINSRP, ELLISSM: The radioimmunoassayof the freethyroid hormones in serum. In Thyroid Research Robbins J,Braverman LE, eds.Amsterdam, Excerpta Medica, 1976, pp597-600

14. JIANG NS, TUE KA: Determination of free thyroxine inserum by radioimmunoassay. C/in Chem 23: 1679-1683,1977

15. HERTL W, ODSTRCHELG: Kinetic and thermodynamicstudies of antigen antibody interactions in heterogeneous reaction phases I. Mo/ !mmuno/ I 6: 173—178, 1979

16. EKINS RP:Commercial radioimmunoassayfor freethyroxine.Lance:I:1190—1191,1979

17. FULLARTONJ, LIDGARDGP: Radioimmunoassayfor freethyroxine. Lance: 2: 51, 1979

18. SCHOEMAKERHiP: Corning Medical's IMMO PHASEFree T4 Assay. Ligand Quarterly 2: 45-48, 1979

19. RODBARDD: Statisticalquality control and routinedataprocessing for radioimmunoassays and immunoradiometricassays.CliiiChem 20:1255—1270,1974

20. ROBBINSJ, NELSONJH: Thyroxine-bindingby serumprotein in pregnancy and in the newborn. J C/in Invest 37:153—159,1958

21. STERLING K, BRENNER MA: Free thyroxine in humanserum: Simplified measurementwith the aid of magnesiumprecipitation. J C/in Invest 45: 153—I 63, I 966

22. REICHLIN5, BOLLINGERJ,NEJADI,etal:Tissuethyroidhormone concentration of rat and man determined by radioimmunoassay. Biologic significance. Mt. Sinai J Med 40:502-510,1973

23. BERMUDEZF,SURKSMl, OPPENHEIMERfl-I: High mcidenceof decreasedserum triiodothyronine concentration in

patients with nonthyroidal disease. J C/in Endocrino/ Metab41:27-40,1975

24. CHOPRAIi, CH0PRA U, SMITH SR. et al: Reciprocalchanges in serum concentrations of 3, 3', 5'-triiodothyronine(reverse T3) and 3, 3', 5'-triiodothyronine (T3) in systemicillnesses. J C/in Endocrino/ Metab 41: 1043-1049, 1975

25. BURGERA,NICODP,SUTERP.etal:Reducedactivethyroidhormone levels in acute illness. Lance: I: 653-655, 1976

26. BRrrroN KE,QUINNV. ELLISSM, etal: Is“T4toxicosis―a normal biochemical finding in elderly women? Lance: 2:141—142,1975

27. NOMURAS.PITTMANCS,CHAMBERSJB,etal:Reducedperipheral conversion ofthyroxine to triiodothyronine in patients with hepatic cirrhosis. J C/in Invest 56: 643-652,I 975

28. BURROWSAW,COOPERE,SHAKESPEARRA,etal:Lowserum L-T3 levelsin the elderly sick: protein binding, thyroidand pituitary responsivenessand reverseT3 concentrations.C/inEndocrino/7:289-300,1977

29. BIRKHAUSERM, BURERTH, BUSSETR, et al: Diagnosisof hyperthyroidism when serum thyroxine alone is raised.Lance:2:53-56,1977

30. GAVIN LA, ROSENTHAL M, CAVALIERI RR: The diagnosticdilemma of isolatedhyperthyroxinemia in acute illness.JAMA 242: 251-253, 1979

3/. HOWORTH PiN, WARD RL: The T4-free thyroxine indexasa test of thyroid function of first choice.J C/in Pathol 25:259—262,1972

32. CHOPRAIi, SOLOMONDH, HEPNERGW, etal: Misleadingly low free thyroxine index and usefulness of reverse tniodothyronine measurement in nonthyroidal illnesses. AnnInternMed 90:905-912,1979

33. SAMOLS E, CYRUS J, SUDHAKARAN EC, et al: The T4-ICUsyndrome:Low serumthyroxine levelsin critically ill patients.Proceedings 19th Annual Meeting, Southeastern Chapter,Soc.NucI. Mcd: 1978,p 7 (abst)

34. CEIOPRA Ii, CHUA TECO GN, NGUYEN AH, Ct al: In searchof an inhibitor of thyroid hormonebinding to serum proteinsin nonthyroid illnesses. J C/in Endocrino/ Metab 49: 63-69,I 979

35, SCHUSSLER GC, WELSKI E: Free thyroxine (T4); failure tofind evidenceof bindinginhibitorsor a dilution effect.Program, The Endocrine Society I 979, p 298 (abst)

Volume 21, Number 3 239

ABSNM EXAMThe American Board of Science in Nuclear Medicine willconduct its second exami nation for persons practici ng nuclearmedicine science on Monday, June 23, 1980in Detroit, MI. The examination will occurontheday preceding the SNMAnnual Meeting.

Those desiring certification by the Board who meet the education and experience requirements are encouraged toapply. Application form and further information may be obtained from the Secretary of the Board:

Thomas P. Haynie, M.D.Anderson Hospital6723 Bertner Ave.Houston, TX 77030

To be assured of consideration, applications must be postmarked no later than May 23, 1980.