mel bochner language 1966 - · pdf filemel bochner, a pioneer in the ... (1970) , counting...
TRANSCRIPT
MEL BOCHNER, A PIONEER IN THE FIELD OF CONCEPTUAL ART, was one o f the
first artists in the 1960s to introduce language into the visual field. W h i l e critics have long
been attentive to and appreciative o f Bochner's recurring themes, i nc lud ing his interest in
measurement, count ing , and shape, his explorat ion of the relationship between language
and v i s ion has remained vir tual ly undocumented . T h i s focus exhib i t ion at the A r t Institute
o f Ch i c a go brings together more than 50 works o n paper, paintings, sculptures, photo
graphs, and installations to present an overview o f his language-based investigations over
the past four decades.
MEL
BOCHNERLANGUAGE
1966-2006
T h e study o f language has played a
transformative role i n the evolut ion o f
Bochner's art. After graduating from Carnegie
Institute o f Technology i n 1962, he traveled
around M e x i c o and lived in both San
Francisco and Ch icago , where he audited
phi losophy classes at Northwestern Univers i ty
and frequently visited the A r t Institute o f
Ch icago . A t the t ime, Northwestern was one
o f the leading strongholds o f Con t inen ta l
philosophy, and its influence, c o m b i n e d
wi th his desire to produce art, led h i m to
N e w York. In Bochner's early notebooks, he
expressed "interest i n formal and semantic
reversals, in w o r d and image," as wel l as his
efforts at " t rying to make objects funct ion
as language i n anothet discourse." 1
T h e year 1966 was a watershed for Bochner.
In addi t ion to publ i sh ing art c r i t ic ism o n
the M i n i m a l i s t movement, he under took
a series o f w o r d portraits. In these works,
Bochner used the thesaurus as a reference
to flesh out an attribute o f his subject w i t h
synonyms. L i n k i n g the contextual w i t h
the visual, Bochner presented the words
i n a form that was particularly relevant to
his subject's work and persona. Portrait of
Eva Hesse, for example, takes the shape o f
one or Hesse's early sculptures o f wrapped,
painted cord la id d o w n onto prepared
Masoni te , whi le Bochner's choice o f words
alludes to the method, cond i t ion , and
effects o f her sculptural strategy. A l t h o u g h
the w o r d portraits may be traced back to
concrete poetry—poems i n the shape o f
things—exemplif ied by the French poet
G u i l l a u m e Apollinaire 's calligrammes (1918),
it was Bochner's serialization o f language that
dist inguished his works t rom those or his
predecessors. In the portraits, language is "a
passive list o f elements rather than an active
description of the indiv idual i ty of a person,
i m p l y i n g that language and experience
can never be made congruent. ' Bochner,
i n col laborat ion w i t h the artist Robert
Smi thson , also produced the first magazine
intervention, The Domain of the Great Bear.
O n e of three such pieces o n display i n the
exhib i t ion , this work uses the magazine page
as a gallery space. By presenting an article
ostensibly about the H a y d e n Planetarium in
an art magazine (but not announc ing that
it was an artwork), they created a work that
was a reproduct ion wi thout ever having been
an or iginal . Taken together, the magazine
intervention pieces represent a subversive
crit ique o f "the character o f the institutions
that collected and merchandised art, and the
language w i t h w h i c h it was interpreted." 3
W h i l e teaching i n N e w York at the School
o f V i s u a l Ar t s i n the fall o f that same year,
Bochner installed his influential Working
Drawings and Other Visible Things on Paper
Not Necessarily Meant to Be Viewed as Art,
w h i c h has been called the first Concep tua l
art exhibi t ion. ' 1 Bochner invi ted artists
whose work he admired to provide h i m
wi th materials that were not self-consciously
"works o f art." H e then photocopied the
motley col lect ion o f sketches, invoices,
and ephemera (as well as projects by other
intellectual workers inc lud ing mathematicians
and scientists) reproducing them at a un i fo rm
size and arranging them alphabetically i n a
three-ring binder. T o emphasize the fact that
these objects were reproductions, not original
artworks, Bochner made four identical copies
o f the binder, each o f w h i c h was displayed
o n a table-height pedestal. Since no chairs
were provided, v iewing the books, whi le bent
over, became a physical challenge. T h e objects
themselves were reproductions that had
no inherent aesthetic value, and by placing
them in a large, otherwise empty gallery,
the artist questioned prevail ing assumptions
about both the content and the installation
o f artworks. C o n t a i n e d w i t h i n this project
are several concepts that w o u l d cont inue to
inform Bochner's w o r k — a n emphasis o n
serial process, a concern w i t h the difference
between reading and seeing, and a heightened
attention to h o w a work can alter, and be
altered by, the space o f the gallery.
O f equal importance i n the development o f
Bochner's ideas was his teaching a n history
at the School o f the Vi sua l Arts , rather than
studio art. T h i s , Bochner has said, "forced
me to t h i n k about h o w visual ideas can
be discussed—the relat ionship between
Theory of Boundaries, i c - ' O . N a t i o n a l G a l l e n ' or A r t , Wash ing ton , D . C .
Theory of Syntax (ist Version), 1971. C o l l e c t i o n o f Barrv Le V a .
language and images. W h e n y o u are
s tanding i n front o f a class s h o w i n g slides
o f paint ings that is exactly what y o u are
engaged i n : t h i n k i n g through h o w images
convey i d e a s . T h e s e realizations, coup led
w i t h the artist's interest i n the early-20th-
century Aus t r i an phi losopher L u d w i g
Wittgenstein 's l inguis t ic theories about the
nature o f logical proposi t ions , added a new
d i m e n s i o n to Bochner 's cr i t ical investigation
o f language. H e was especially interested in
Wittgenstein 's no t ion that proposi t ions are
b ipo la r—tha t they must be capable o f be ing
both true and false—and his statement,
" T h e l imi t s o f m y language are the l imi t s o f
m y w o r l d . " 6
Between 1969 and 1973, B o c h n e r created
drawings, paint ings, and sculptures that use
these ideas to visual ly examine the veracity
o f some basic l inguis t ic and mathemat ica l
proposi t ions . H e r e they are powerful ly
realized as Prepositional Sculpture (1969),
Language Is Not Transparent (1970), Theory of
Boundaries (1970), Counting Alternatives (The
Wittgenstein Illustrations) (1971; exh ib i ted as
p r in ted i l lustrat ions for the 1991 pub l i ca t ion
o f On Certainty), and Axiom of Indifference
(1973). Each o f these works presents direct,
seemingly s imple statements—or, i n the case
o f The Wittgenstein Illustrations, c o u n t i n g
sequences—but reveals them to be visual ly
and conceptual ly perplexing. Language Is
Not Transparent provides perhaps the most
l u c i d example o f this. W r i t t e n i n chalk
over a section o f black paint that B o c h n e r
a l lowed to d r ip , the w o r k vacillates between
an expressionistically painted field and a co ld
declarat ion o f fact. T h e phrase "Language
Is N o t Transparent" signifies that words are
never a s imple representation o f t h o u g h t —
they are always colored by the subjective and
undisclosed ideologies o f the speaker.
For The Wittgenstein Illustrations, Bochne r
used a square matr ix that is d i v i d e d i n ha l f
diagonally, vertically, and horizontal ly .
A l o n g these Cartesian coordinates, he drew
patterns o f numbers sequentially, i n cardinal
order. In this work , c o u n t i n g acts as a
universal language, leading viewers th rough
the drawings as they read the numer ica l
sequences. However , the numbers were
d rawn freehand, and they do not always
match the geometry or trajectory a long
w h i c h they travel. Therefore, despite the
i m p l i e d cert i tude o f a geometr ic system
that w o u l d appear to be infal l ible , B o c h n e r
demonstrated i n visual terms h o w any
rat ional system can falter a n d eventual ly
break d o w n completely.
L ikewise , Theory of Boundaries and Axiom
of Indifference l inguis t ica l ly compl ica te ou r
comprehens ion o f space. In the former
piece, B o c h n e r rubbed w i t h d ry p igment
four large squares arranged equidis tant lv
across a w a l l . In the center o f each square
he wrote the fractional statements "a t / in ,"
"over / in , " " / i n , " and "at/out," descr ib ing
the c o n d i t i o n o f the colored p igment i n
relat ionship to the bounda ry o f the ruled
square. Axiom of Indifference is a floor piece
consis t ing o f eight, 12-inch m a s k i n g tape
squares o n the f loor (four o n each side o f
a wal l ) , w i t h three pennies i n a par t icular
relat ion to each square, and an equal n u m b e r
o f sentences wr i t t en i n i nk o n the m a s k i n g
tape d o c u m e n t i n g the loca t ion o f the
pennies compared to the taped boundaries
("all are i n / a l l are out; all are not i n / a l l are
not out; some are i n ; some are out; some are
not i n ; some are not out") . B y descr ib ing the
associations o f surface and edge, in te r io r i ty
and exteriority, B o c h n e r used language
to explore the ambigu i ty o f spatial terms,
revealing the often self-contradictory
relat ionship between descr ip t ion and reality.
In true e l l ip t ica l fashion, Bochner 's most
recent Thesaurus Paintings l ook back to
his earliest mature d rawings—the w o r d
portraits. Fo r the portraits, B o c h n e r
used Roget's Thesaurus as a source because
it represented "objectified language, a
warehouse for words ." O n the occasion
o f his 1995 retrospective e x h i b i t i o n at Yale
Univers i ty A r t Gal le ry , N e w H a v e n , the
artist had a chance to reconsider these 1966
works , and realized that "there was st i l l juice
left i n the i d e a . ' s T h r o u g h o u t his career,
B o c h n e r has recycled ideas, because the
elasticity o f mean ing i n his earlier w o r k
has a l lowed concepts to be renewed by
constantly changing their visual contexts.
T h e reconsideration o f the 1966 portraits
p rompted further development o f the idea,
w h i c h d i d not come to f ru i t ion u n t i l 2002,
w h e n he discovered a new ed i t ion o f Roget's
Thesaurus. B o c h n e r was amazed by the
book's new attitude toward language and
that it n o w includes co l loqu ia l speech as
wel l as obscenity. Because students were
using the b o o k — a m o n g them his teenage
daughter—he realized that this represented a
significant shift i n society's mora l standards.
Bochne r began reading the new ed i t ion ,
a l l owing the words themselves to suggest
subjects for his work . U n l i k e the neutral
or objectified tone that the earlier portraits
emit , the Thesaurus Paintings have been
described as "dark thoughts" i n w h i c h the
"pain t ing lists the synonyms o f an intensely
fraught w o r d whose centrali ty to the
h u m a n experience has spawned a pungent
array o f vernacular expressions, vulgarities
and epithets." 9 E a c h w o r d is painted i n
a different color, i n hand lettering that
undoub ted ly reflects the influence o f his
father, a sign painter. T h e lists o f words are
arranged i n hor izonta l rows, forc ing some
o f them to wrap inconsistent ly to the next
l ine , emphas iz ing the fact that the synonyms
become increasingly obscene and bod i ly as
the pa in t ing progresses. Bochner 's use o f
co lor also diverts the text f rom its du ty to
convey meaning , interfering w i t h our abi l i ty
to read the paint ings i n the convent iona l
narrative way—lef t to right, and top to
bot tom—because some o f the colors are so
close i n value to the painting's g r o u n d that
they disappear, wh i l e others scream w i t h
intense levels o f saturation. T h e result ing
d i scon t inu i ty functions as a cr i t ique o f the
super imposed orderliness, as wel l the i m p l i e d
Counting Alternatives (The Wittgenstein Illustrations): Asterisk Branch. 1971/91.
C o l l e c t i o n o f Suzanne F. C o h e n . Bal t imore .
Axiom of Indifference. 1973. T h e M u s e u m o f M o d e r n A r t , N e w York.
objectivity, o f Roget's concept o f language.
A b o u t the Thesaurus Paintings, Bochne r
has said, " T h e h u m o r in these paint ings
has someth ing to do w i t h the devo lu t ion o f
language, f rom the formal and proper to the
vulgar and nasty. There's a narrative i n that
d o w n w a r d spiral . O f course, that raises the
quest ion o f w h o is speaking. T h e artist? T h e
thesaurus? A voice i n your head?" 1 0
For over 40 years, M e l Bochner's art has
remained fiercely commi t t ed to unravel ing
language's relationship to experience. Perhaps
his approach to the visual representation
of language is best summarized by the text o f
one o f his 1969 Notecard àvzWmgs:
N O T H O U G H T E X I S T S W I T H O U T A
S U S T A I N I N G S U P P O R T .
1. Q u o t e d i n R i c h a r d S. F ie ld , " M e l Bochner : T h o u g h t M a d e
V i s i b l e , " in Mel Bochner: Thought Made Visible 1066-¡97}, exh.
cat. (Yale Univers i ty A r t Gal lery , 199s), pp . 15—16.
2. Ib id . , p. 23.
3. Ib id . , p. 24.
4. Ben jamin B u c h l o h , " C o n c e p t u a l A r t 1962-1969: F r o m the
Aesthetic o f A d m i n i s t r a t i o n to the C r i t i q u e o f Ins t i tu t ion ,"
October ( W i n t e r 1990), pp. 105-43, ci ted i n F ie ld (note 1),
p. 24 n. 30.
5. Q u o t e d in "In conversat ion: M e l Bochne r w i t h P h o n g B u i . "
Brooklyn Rail (May 2006) , p. 16.
6. L u d w i g Wi t tgens te in , Tracta tus Logico-Philosophicus
(Harcourt . Brace, and C o m p a n v / K . Paul , Trench, Truber, 1922).
7. Q u o t e d i n M a r k Godfrey, "Language Factory: M e l Bochne r
talks to M a r k Godf rev about words , portraits. R o g é i s
Thesaurus, color, Jorge Luis Borges, h u m o u r , nostalgia and
pol i t i ca l engagement." Frieze$~> ( N o v . / D e c . 2004), p. 103.
8. Q u o t e d i n Godf rey (note 7), p. 103.
9. Rober ta S m i t h , New York Times, June 16, 2006, p . E33.
10. Q u o t e d in Godr r ey (note 7), p. 104.
MARK PASCALE
ASSOICATE CURATOR OF PRINTS AND DRAWINGSS
Working Drawings and Other Visible Things on Paper Not Necessarily Meant to Be Viewed as Art, 1966. C o l l e c t i o n o f the artist.
M E L B O C H N E R
Born Pittsburgh, 1940
B F A from Carnegie Institute of
Technology, Pittsburgh, 1962
Lives and works in N e w York
2007
Mel Bochner: Drawing
from Four Decades, San
Diego Museum o f Ar t ;
Weatherspoon Ar t Museum,
University o f Nor th Carol ina ,
Greensboro; Bi rmingham
Museum of Ar t ; Werner H .
Kramarsky, N e w York (cat.
with essay by Ruth Fine)
2006
Thesaurus Paintings, Peter
Freeman, Inc., N e w York
2003
Mel Bochner opere recenti,
Gallería d 'Arte i l Gabbiano,
Rome
Mel Bochner: Photographs
IÇ66-1969, Carnegie Museum
o f Ar t , Pittsburgh; Harvard
University A n Museums,
Cambridge, Massachusetts (cat.
with essays bv Scon Rothkopf
and Elisabeth Sussrnan)
2002
Mel Bochner: Measurements:
Works from the 1960S/1990S,
Fonds Regional d 'Art
Contemporain de Borgogne,
Di jon (cat. with essay bv
Hubert Besacier and interview
with Claire Legrand)
2001
Mel Bochner Blue Powder
Pigment Wall Pieces, 1968-69:
Drawings and Installations,
Grant Selwyn Fine Arts,
Beverly Hi l l s
1999
Centro de Arte Hel io Oit ic ica ,
R io de Janeiro, 1999 (cat.)
1998
Mel Bochner: Drawings
1966-197$, Lawrence Markey,
N e w York (cat. wi th essay by
Barn- Schwabsky)
1996
Me I Bochner: Thought Made
Visible 1966-19/$, Stadtische
Galerie im Lenbachhaus,
M u n i c h ; La Société des
Expositions du Palais des
Beaux-Arts, Brussels; Yale
University Ar t Gallery (cat.
with essays by Richard S.
Field, James Meyer, Yve-Alain
Bois, et al.)
1973
Mel Bochner: Axiom of
Indifference, Sonnabend
Gallery, N e w York (cat.)
1972
Mel Bochner: 7 Properties of
Between, Sonnabend Gallery
1970
Toselli Gallery, M i l a n
1966
Working Drawings and Other
Visible Things on Paper Not
Necessarily Meant to Be Viewed
as Art, School o f the Visual
Arts Gallery, New York
2004
Whitney Biennial Whi tney
Museum of American Ar t
(cat. with essay by Chrissie
Iles et al.)
1996
196-)—199s: Reconsidering the
Object of Art, Museum of
Contemporary Art Los Angeles
(cat. with essays by A n n
Goldstein, Anne Rorimer,
Lucy R. Lippard, et al.)
1991
WORDS & #s. Museum of
Contemporary Art , Wright
State University, Dayton ,
O h i o (cat.)
E X H I B I T I O N S
S E L E C T E D O N E - P E R S O N
SELECTED GROUP
EXHIBITIONS
1990
L'Art conceptuel, une
perspective. Musée d 'Art
Moderne de la V i l l e de Paris
(cat. with essay bv Benjamin
H . D . Buchloh)
1985
The Maximal Implications
of the Minimal Line, M i l t o n
and Sally Avery Center
for the Arts, Bard College,
Annandale-on-Hudson,
N e w York (cat.)
1984
Flyktpunkterf\ranishing Points,
Moderna Museet, Stockholm
(cat. wi th essay by Lucv R.
I. ippard)
1974
Line as Language: Six Artists
Draw, Princeton University
Art Museum, Princeton, N e w
Jersey (cat. wi th essay by
Rosalind Krauss)
1971
Situation Concepts, Gallery
Nachst, St. Stephen,
Innsbruck
1970
Language IV, D w a n Gallery,
N e w York
Using Walls (Indoors),
T h e Jewish Museum,
N e w York (cat.)
Artists and Photographs,
Mult iples Gal len ' , N e w York
(cat. wi th essay by Lawrence
Alloway)
1968
Language II, D w a n Gallery
1967
Monuments, Tombstones
and Trophies, Museum of
Contemporary Crafts,
N e w York
Alberro, Alexander. " M e l Bochner:
Thought Made Visible 1966-
1973." Artforum 34, no. 6
(February 1996), pp. 80-81.
Boice, Bruce. "The A x i o m of
Indifference." Arts Magazine
no. 6 (April 1973), pp. 66—68.
Bochner, M e l . Spéculations: Ecrits,
196$- 197$. Eds. Christophe
Cherix and Valérie Mavridorakis.
Trans. Thierrv Dubois . Musée
d'Art Moderne et Contemporain,
Geneva, 2003.
Borden, Lizzie. "New York Reviews:
M e l Bochner, Sonnabend
Gallen,'." Artforum 10, no. 8
(April 1972), pp. 83-85.
Cherix, Christophe, Laurent Jenny,
and James Meyer. Mel
Bochner: Working Drawings
and Other Visible Things on
Paper Not Necessarily Meant
to Be Viewed as Art. Cabinet
des Estampes du Musée d 'Art
et d 'Histoire, 1997.
Danto , Ar thur C . "Introduction."
In On Certainty, bv l .udwig
Wittgenstein. Eds. G . E . M .
Anscombe and G . H . von
Wright. Trans. Denis Paul and
G . E. M . Anscombe. A r i o n
Press, 1991.
de Bruvn , Eric . "Alfaville, or the
Utopies o f M e l Bochner."
Grey Room, no. 10 (Winter
2003), pp. 76—111.
Kal ina , Richard. "Measure for
Measure." Art in America 84,
no. 9 (Sept. 1996), pp. 88-93.
" H o w C a n You Defend M a k i n g
Paintings Now? A Conversation
between Me l Bochner and
James Meyer." In As Painting:
Division and DispLicement.
Wexner Center for the Arts,
O h i o State University,
Columbus, 2001.
"language Faetón" M e l Bochner
talks to Mark Godfrey about
words, portraits, Roget's
Thesaurus, color, Jorge Luis
Borges, humour, nostalgia
and political engagement."
FriezeSj (Nov./Dec. 2004),
pp. 102-05.
Lubel l , FJlen. "Gallery Reviews:
M e l Bochner Sonnabend
D o w n t o w n . " Arts Magazine
47, no. 5 (March 1973), p. 77.
Pincus-Wit ten , Robert. "The
Constant as Variable."
Artforum 11, no. 4 (December
1972), pp- 28-34.
Smith, Roberta. New York Times,
June 16, 2006, p. E33.
Zelevansky, L y n n . "Beyond
Geometry: Objects, Systems,
Concepts." In Beyond
Geometry: Experiments in Form
t940s—-,os, Los Angeles
County Museum of Art , 2004,
PP- 9-33-
Weiss, Jeffrey. "Language in the
V i c i n i t y o f Art : Artists
Writ ings, i960—1975."
Artforum 42, no. 10 (Summer
2004), pp. 212—17.
Unless otherwise noted, all works
are in the collection of the artist.
* 1966
Ink on graph paper: 8 7 x 11 in .
Cause and Effect, 1966
Ink on graph paper; d.: 5 ~h i n .
The Domain of the Great Bear, 1966
Published in Art Voices, Fall 1966
Facsimile of magazine pages; 12 7=
x 9 7* in .
Ryerson and Burnham Libraries,
gift of the artist
Maximum/Minimum, 1966
Ink on two sheets of lined paper:
each 7 /> x 5 in .
Col lec t ion of M r . and M r s . Frank
Preuss, Hamburg , Germany
Minimal Art—The Movie, 1966
Ink and pencil on notebook paper;
6x3 '/• in .
Portrait of Ad Reinhardt, 1966
Ink on graph paper; 10 7« x 3 7* in .
Portrait of Dan Flavin, 1966
Ink on graph paper (cut out); 4 'A
x 8 7: in .
Portrait of Donald Judd, 1966
Ink on paper; 5 '/* x 6 7" i n .
Portrait of Eva Hesse, 1966
Ink on graph paper; d.: 4 7« i n .
Portrait of Robert Smithson, [966
Ink on graph paper; 7 7* x 6 in .
Portrait of Sol LeWitt, 1966
Ink on graph paper; 5'Ax 5 'A i n .
WORK IN THE EXHIBITION
SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY
Notecard (No thought exists... ), 1969. C o l l e c t i o n ot the artist.
Self!Portrait, 1966
Ink on graph paper; 5 V* x 5 7* in .
Private collection. N e w York
Working Drawings and Other Visible
Things on Paper Not Necessarily
Meant to Be Viewed as Art, 1966
Four identical looseleaf notebooks,
each with 100 xerox copies ot studio
notes, working drawings, and
diagrams collected and xeroxed bv
the artist
Beach Boys—100%, 1967
Published in Arts Magazine,
March 1967
Facsimile o f magazine pages; 12 7*
x 9 V"- in .
Rverson and Burnham Libraries,
gift of the artist
Four Comments Concerning:
Photograph-Blocks, 1967
Photograph mounted on board;
12 x 12 in .
Four Rows, 1967
Self-adhesive plastic on board; 14 7
x 11 74 in .
Letter Piece (for Dwan Exhibition),
1967-
Typewritten letter and envelope; 11
x 8 'I- in . , envelope: 4 7« x 9 7» i n .
Alfaville, Godard s Apocalypse, 1968
Published in Arts Magazine,
M a y 1968
Facsimile of magazine pages;
12 7«x 97'* in .
Ryerson and Burnham Libraries,
gift of the artist
Jasper's Dilemma (2), 1968
Ink and pencil on graph paper;
9 V« x 7V1 in .
Portrait of Marcel Duchamp, 1968
Ink on graph paper; 11 x 8'A i n .
Study for Imagine the Enclosed Area
Blue, 1969
Ink and colored pencil on paper;
6 'A x 7 74 i n .
Language Is Not Transparent, 1969
Rubber stamp on four sheets o f
paper; each 6{/*\ 7 '/* in .
Notecards (Fragmentation...),
( The distance bettveen... ), (Theory
of Boundaries... ), (No thought
exists...), ( The surface as support... ),
(Imagine an infinitesimal...),
(Background is neither...), (If we
could imagine... ), (Language is
always...), (Relations can become... ),
(Forgetting is the only...),
(Functional breakdown...), 1969
Ink on 12 notecards; each 5 x 8 in .
Photography Cannot Record Abstract
Ideas, 1969
Silver dye-bleach print; 16 x 20 in .
Study for Prepositional Sculptures,
1969
Ink on graph paper; 11x8 '/» i n .
Prepositional Sculpture, 1969
W o o d , self-adhesive v inyl , and tape
on floor; 48 x 156 x 4 in .
Courtesy o f the artist and
Peter Freeman, Inc.
Language Is Not Transparent, 1970
Cha lk on paint on wall ; 72 x 48 in .
Los Angeles C o u n t y Museum ot
Ar t , Modern and Contemporary
Ar t C o u n c i l
Misunderstandings (A Theory of
Photography), 1970
Photo offset on 10 notecards,
manila envelope; each card 5 x 8 in .
Theory of Boundaries, 1970
Cha lk on drv pigment on wall ;
dimensions determined bv
installation
National Gallery ot Ar t ,
Washington, D . C .
7 Properties of Between, 1971
Ink on paper; 11x8'/•• in .
Theory of Syntax (1st Version), 1971
Ink on paper; 6'A x 7 7< in .
Col lec t ion o f Barrv Le Va
Translation, 1971
Ink on graph paper; 16 x 20 in .
An Ultimate Project for Sol LeWitt,
1971
Ink on paper; approx. 12 x 8 7* in .
The LeWi t t Col lec t ion , Chester.
C o n n .
Axiom of Indifference, 1973
Ink on spiral notebook paper;
11 x 14 in .
Axiom of Indifference, 1973
Ink on masking tape and pennies
on floor; each square 12 x 12 in.
The Museum of Modern Ar t , N e w
York, Commit tee on Painting and
Sculpture Funds
Left/Right/Right/Left, 1973
Ink on paper; 11 \S'l- in .
Private collection, N e w York
The Wittgenstein Illustrations, 1991
12 line photo engravings; 20 x 15 i n .
Col lec t ion o f Suzanne F. Cohen ,
Baltimore
Quotation Piece: "Nothing we do— "
1995
Two sheets o f oi l newspaper;
44 x 27 'I* i n .
Private collection. N e w York
If the Color Changes (#2), 1997
O i l on canvas; 36 x 48 in.
Courtesy o f the artist and
Peter Freeman, Inc.
If the Color Changes (#6), 1998
O i l on canvas; 36 x 48 in.
You Can Call It That If You Like,
2001
Charcoal on two sheets o f paper;
4 4 \ JO in .
Courtesy o f the artist and
Peter Freeman, Inc.
You Can Call It That If You Like
(#2), 2001
Charcoal on two sheets of paper,
44 x 30 in .
Courtesy o f the artist and
Peter Freeman, Inc.
Meaningless, 2003
O i l and acrylic on canvas;
45 x 60 in .
Nothing, 2 0 0 4
O i l on canvas; 4s x 60 in .
Col lec t ion o f Ji l l and Peter Kraus
Useless, 2005
O i l and acrvlic on canvas;
60 x 80 in .
Col lec t ion o f Betty and Edward
Harris
And/If/Or/But, 2006
Acryl ic on four canvases,
each 40 x 30 in.
Courtesy o f the artist and
Peter Freeman, Inc.
Obscene, 2006
O i l and acrylic on canvas;
60 x 80 in .
Money/Obscene, 2006
O i l on velvet; 74 x 47 in .
Courtesy Two Palms Press
N i c k Bar ron , Stephanie Bar ron . Sienna
B r o w n , Joseph C o c h a n d , Janet C o h e n ,
Suzanne C o h e n , C h r i s t i n e C o n n i t t -
O ' S h e a , Jav C la rke , James C u n o ,
Lisa D o r i n . Douglas D r u i c k , J o h n
Elderf ield, Jaune Fvans, Peter Freeman.
Jennv G h e i t h . Sarah Guernscv. Bettv
and E d w a r d Harr is , E r i n H o g a n ,
K a n o i K e i t h , l o i s Kel ly , Jud i th Russi
Kirshner , N icho la s K n i g h t , D a w n
Koster, Ii l l and Peter Kraus, leanne
Ladd , A l i s o n Langley, J . Patrick Lannan ,
Evie Lasrv, C h a i Lee, Barrv L e V a ,
Sol and C a r o l L e W i t t , James Mever ,
Alfred L M c D o u g a l and N a n c y Lauter
M c D o u g a l , Jud i th Neisser, Jeffrey
N i g r o , M a r k Pascale. Janet Passehl, G a i l
Pearson, M a r y M . Plauché, M r . and
M r s . Frank Preuss, Maureen Pskowski ,
Dehra Purden . Jud i th Racht . Rae Riffel ,
Susan Rossen. Su/.ie Schnepp, D o r o t h v
Schroeder. Irene Snead, I rv ing Stenn,
Jr., El izaheth Stepina, Harr ie t Stratis,
l i m Szvskowski , Jeftrev Weiss, and Jeff
W o n d e r l a n d . Special thanks to the artist.
This exh ib i t i on is m a d e poss ib le by
a g i f t f r o m J u d i t h Racht and I rv ing
S tenn , Jr., w i t h addi t ional f und ing and
suppor t p rov ided by J u d i t h Neisser.
O n g o i n g s u p p o r t fo r focus exh ib i t i ons
is p rov ided by The A l f red L. McDouga l
and Nancy Lauter M c D o u g a l Fund fo r
C o n t e m p o r a r y Ar t .
The a c c o m p a n y i n g ca ta logue and
academic s y m p o s i u m are gene rous l y
f u n d e d by the C o m m u n i t y Assoc ia tes
of the Ar t Inst i tu te of Ch icago ,
Lannan F o u n d a t i o n , and Na than and
Suzanne Cohen F o u n d a t i o n , Inc.
OPENING EVENTS AND
ARTIST TALK
T H U R S D A Y 5 O C T O B E R
E X H I B I T I O N P R E V I E W
5:30—8:00 p .m.
Gallery 138-139
C O N V E R S A T I O N W I T H
T H E A R T I S T A N D J A M E S
M E Y E R , A S S O C I A T E P R O F E S S O R
O F A R T H I S T O R Y , E M O R Y
U N I V E R S I T Y , A T L A N T A
6:00 p .m.
Fullerton H a l l
O P E N I N G R E C E P T I O N
7:00 p .m.
Jean and Steven G o l d m a n
Study Center
Department o f Prints and Drawings
SYMPOSIUM
F R I D A Y 6 O C T O B E R
Fullerton H a l l
Organized in collaboration wi th
James Meyer and Judith Russi
Kirshner, Dean, College o f
Ar t and Design, University o f
Illinois, Chicago
GALLERY TALKS
F R I D A Y 13 O C T O B E R
12:00 p .m.
Frances and Thomas Di t tmer
Cura tor o f Contemporary A r t
James Rondeau
Gal lery 100
T U E S D A Y 7 N O V E M B E R
12:00 p .m.
Assistant Curator o f
Contemporary A r t Lisa D o r i n
Gal lery 100
F R I D A Y 15 D E C E M B E R
12:00 p .m.
Associate Cura tor o f Prints and
Drawings M a r k Pascale
Gallery 100
C O V E R : Nothing, 2004 (detail).
C o l l e c t i o n o f J i l l and Peter Kraus .
B A C K C O V E R : Obscene, 2006 (detail).
C o l l e c t i o n o f the artist.
JAMES RONDAU
FRANCES AND THOMAS DITMER
CURATR OF CONTEMPORARY ART