melvin hale opposition to defendant jackie vietti's motion to dismiss third amended complaint -...

8/18/2019 Melvin Hale Opposition to Defendant Jackie Vietti's Motion to Dismiss Third Amended Complaint - Emporia State U…

1/49

MO \JB ROM\BL P\I\BP LMP\XM@\ @ARX\

LMP\XM@\ AC DIOPIP

@isb Oa. 92-


2/49

8

rbtinmitb ikimost pnimotmcc car rbpartmok ri`mst i`ts iol i jitb `rmeb mo PNME. \jb rbpartmok ac

ri`mse ms i pratb`tbl i`tmvmty, iol rbtinmitmao car rbpartmok ri`mse ms mnnbkin. Lr. Jinb ms Icrmìo

Iebrmìo, i ebehbr ac i pratb`tbl `niss mo`nulbl mo tjb `niss ac pbrsaos car wjae @aokrbss

`rbitbl i rbtinmitmao ìusb ac i`tmao. Jb lml pbrsaoinny appasb uoniwcun bepnayebot pri`tm`bs,

eilb i panm`b rbpart, iol pirtm`mpitbl mo spbidmok aut ikimost pbr`bmvbl ri`mst i`tmvmtmbs it BPR

iol PNME. \jb suhsbqubot cniwbl movbstmkitmao àolu`tbl hy BPR àeebo`bl (ictbr Lr. Jinb

ebt wmtj Vravast @arlnb iol Guly Iolbrsao iol suhsbqubotny tjb BPR Vanm`b Lbpirtebot) is i

rbsunt ac Lr. Jinb mocaremok BPR Motbrme Vrbsmlbot Lr. Gi`dmb Smbttm tjit jb waunl oat innaw tjb

BPR Vanm`b Lbpirtebot (BPRVL), Kwbo Inbxiolbr, Livml @arlnb, Guly Iolbrsao ar ioyaobbnsb ta swbbp tjms eittbr „uolbr tjb ruk,― mo io beimn ta Smbttm litbl Guny 2, 8692, ictbr oa i`tmao

ar rbspaosb hy Inbxiolbr, @arlnb iol Iolbrsao. Lr. Smbttm wis car`bl mota naadmok mota Lr.

Jinb‑s ào`bros, iol sjb `nimes ta jivb àeebo`bl io motbroin movbstmkitmao ao Guny 96, 8692.

BPR‑s movbstmkitmao purparts ta jivb lbtbremobl wjbtjbr i jitb `rmeb rbpartbl hy Lr.

Jinb i`tuinny a`ùrrbl. Mt rbprbsbots aony tjb cmolmoks iol ào`nusmaos ac BPR, is appasbl ta

Jinb‑s i`àuot ac tjb `mrùestio`b s surrauolmok jms rbpart ac lms`rmemoitmao iol i jitb `rmeb.

\jms wis oat io movbstmkitmao àolu`tbl hy i obutrin pirty4 ritjbr, aob àolu`tbl hy Er. Niuhbr,

i naoktmeb ciemnmin crmbol ac tjb suspb`t. Niuhbr sbnb`tbl wjae ta motbrvmbw iol wjit bvmlbo`b

ta àosmlbr. \jbrb wbrb oa jbirmoks, puhnm` ar prmvitb, oa bvmlbo`b accbrbl, oa swaro stitbebots

iol oa appartuomty car Lr. Jinb ta rbspaol ta tjb `rmtm`mses nbvbnbl ikimost jms innbkitmaos, nbt

inaob àolu`t lmrb`t ar `rass-bxiemoitmao ac wmtobssbs. Bvmlbo`b tjit waunl jivb hbbo civarihnb

ta Lr. Jinb, su`j is tjb jiolwrmtmok apmomao ac [boly @irnsao, ms ihsbot crae Niuhbr's rbpart.

Earbavbr, tjb movbstmkitmao caùsbs earb ao Lr. Jinb iol jms wmcb‑s pbrsaoin nmvbs tjio

jms `nimes ac ri`min lms`rmemoitmao ar i jitb `rmeb. Eu`j ac tjb rbpart ào`bros `brtimo

@isb 2792-`v-6


3/49

0

ànnbikubs‑ pbrsaoin apmomaos ac Lr. Jinb, is appasbl ta wjbtjbr ar oat tjby àunl pravmlb

mocareitmao rbnitbl ta tjb innbkbl `rmeb. @aosbqubotny, tjb BPR movbstmkitmao, wjmnb purpartmok

ta eidb ahgb`t mvb cmolmoks, ms sanbny lbvatbl ta lboymok Jinb‑s innbkitmaos, usmok wjitbvbr

ebios ivimnihnb, su`j is prbss àocbrbo`bs, prbss rbnbisbs, iol àeeuomìtmaos wmtj tjb puhnm`,

stulbots, ciùnty, sticc iol inueom. Bi`j ac tjb lbcboliots i`qumbs`bl ta tjb cmolmoks ac tjb

rbpart iol molu`bl atjbrs ta la sa, lbspmtb doawmok mt àotimobl knirmok cinsbjaals iol

moi`ùri`mbs, iol lbpm`ts Jinb iol jms wmcb is jitb jaix pbrpbtritars. \jb „movbstmkitmao― wis

tjb jaix.

\jbrb ms rbisao ta suspb`t tjit tjb purpasb ac tjb movbstmkitmao wis earb ta bxaobritb

BPR iol PNME tjio ta lbtbremob mc i jitb `rmeb a`ùrrbl iol suspb`t(s) bxmstbl. Xmttkbrs wis

bxpnm`mtny bxaobritbl ta kbt tjit ebssikb i`rass. Hy @arlnb‑s awo ilemssmao, jil Lr. Jinb

smkobl tjb sbpiritmao ikrbbebot bxtbolbl ta jme ao A`tahbr 98, 8692, jb wiotbl Lr. Jinb ta

rbnbisb BPR iol mts ikbots crae inn nbkin nmihmnmty, iol ta tidb lawo tjb Eir`jAoBeparmi.àe

wbhsmtb, wjm`j accbrs appasmok vmbws ao tjms eittbr. Jil tjb purpasb ac tjb BPR movbstmkitmao

hbbo truny ta lbtbremob mc i`ts ac ri`mse iol hmis jil a`ùrrbl, tjb movbstmkitmao waunl jivb

iljbrbl ta bstihnmsjbl btjmìn iol nbkin kumlbnmobs car àolu`tmok su`j movbstmkitmaos.

EINM@B IOL HMIP

Lbcboliot Smbttm jis `jinnbokbl innbkitmaos tjit sjb pirtm`mpitbl mo lbciemok Lr. Jinb,

iol hbmok movanvbl mo i àospmri`y ta lboy jme jms àostmtutmaoin rmkjts. \jms sb`tmao wmnnbxiemob bxpnm`mt àeebots eilb hy Smbttm iol Gajosao it tjb obws àocbrbo`b tjby àolu`tbl

ao Pbptbehbr =, 8692 mo Vnueh Jinn ao tjb BPR ìepus ta iooauo`b tjb rbsunts ac Smbttm‑s

movbstmkitmao. @aotriry ta stitbebots eilb hy tjb lbcbosb, Smbttm iol Gajosao sniolbr Jinb

@isb 2792-`v-6


4/49

<

rbpbitblny tjraukjaut tjb prbss àocbrbo`b. \a pmo lawo BPR‑s pbrspb`tmvb ao jitb `rmeb, i

rbpartbr isds Smbttm iol Gajosao „Mc tjb `rmeb ac tjb IEB `jur`j eissi`rb tjit jippbobl jil

jippbobl jbrb, waunl tjit hb i jitb `rmeb1― Gajosao ioswbrs, „ [bnn mc saebaob àeemts i

eurlbr, mt‑s uonmdbny tjby‑rb kaooi try ta jivb mt `nissmcmbl is i jitb `rmeb car sbotbo`mok

purpasbs hbìus b tjbrb‑s oa earb sbrmaus sbotbo`b tjio nmcb ar pbrjips lbitj sa mt waunl gust hb

pamotnbss.― Smbttm‑s iol Gajosao‑s pasmtmao ao tjb oatmao ac „jitb `rmeb― ms tjit tjb ào`bpt ms

pamotnbss, bvbo car eissi`rbs, wjm`j ms ioatjbr wiy ac siymok tjb tbre ms ebiomoknbss. \jit

hbmok tjb ìsb, Smbttm iol Gajosao waunl nmtbrinny som`dbr iol sàcc it saebaob wja rbpartbl i

jitb `rmeb, bspb`minny saebtjmok is „ebiomoknbss― ta tjbe is i ri`min snur mo i oatbhaad, wjm`jms hismìnny wjit tjby lml. Gajosao àotmoubs h y siymok, „[rmtmok i warl ao i pmb`b ac pipbr, oa

eittbr jaw accbosmvb, ar wjit tjb warl ms, ms oat i `rmeb, mt‑s gust wrmtmok i warl ao i pmb`b ac

pipbr. ―\jbrb irb oa `mrùestio`bs uolbr wjm`j tjit emkjt hb i `rmeb. Vnimotmcc lmsikrbbs.

\jbrb obvbr wis io movbstmkitmao mota i jitb `rmeb. Smbttm iol Gajosao lao‑t‑ ipprb`mitb tjb

oatmao ac jitb `rmeb. \jb pjrisb „jitb `rmeb― ms usbl hy pnimotmcc is i hrail `nissmcmìtmao .

Hy tidmok avbr twa eaotjs ta àepnbtb tjb „movbstmkitmao,― BPR saukjt ta kmvb tjb

puhnm` tjb meprbssmao tjit i nat ac tjaukjt iol lbnmhbritmao wbot mota tjb rbsunts ac tjb

movbstmkitmao. [jit jippbobl ao Pbptbehbr =, 8692 mo tjb iooauo`bebot ac tjb „movbstmkitmao―

wis i lbnmhbritb, rbjbirsbl, iol motbotmaoin i`t, gust is pnimotmcc hbnmbvbs tjit tjb wrmtmok ac tjb

ri`min snur wis i lbnmhbritb, rbjbirsbl, iol motbotmaoin i`t. [jit jippbobl ao Iprmn : tj , 8692

wis i care ac ri`min hunnymok. [jit a`ùrrbl ao Pbptbehbr =, 8692 wis sniolbraus. Lr. Jinb

wis hbmok puhnm`ny puomsjbl car rbpartmok ri`mse iol i jitb `rmeb. \jb iooauo`bebot wis insa

ìnùnitbl ta lmssmpitb suppart iol stbin eaebotue iol caùs crae tjb Eir`j ao Beparmi wjm`j

wis sbt car Pbptbehbr 92 tj .

@isb 2792-`v-6


5/49

2

Ptirtmok it ihaut 98 emoutbs mota tjb rb`arlmok ac tjb DSAB hrail`ist, Gajosao innaws

jms meikmoitmao ta ruo wmnl, lbs`rmhmok Accm`b


6/49

3

„ad― iol sjb taad i pm`turb ac mt , ac tjb warl ao tjb pikb wmtj jbr ìebri, jbr pjaob, ao jbr

pjaob. Iol sa tjb stulbot M tjmod it tjit pamot wbot hi`d ta jbr accm`b. Re M lao‑t doaw mc sjb

taad jbr oatbhaad it tjit pamot ar oat. Hut tjbo Ers. Jinb sjawbl mt ta jbr jushiol wja wis mo

ioatjbr accm`b iol siml „ tjms ms wjit tjb stulbot gust sjawbl eb,― iol tjby wbrb hatj accbolbl

hbìusb mt”s io accbosmvb warl.

„Iol crae tjbrb, mt TwisU gust hisbl ao tjmoks tjit t jby jivb put aut tjraukj apbo nbttbrs

iol atjbr bxprbssmaos, wrmttbo bxprbssmaos, i pbrsao àunl kbt tjb meprbssmao tjit tjb warl wis,

mt jippbobl mo Ers. Jinb”s accm`b , ar mt jippbobl saebwjbrb bnsb . Hut mt jippbobl mo tjit

stulbot‑s accm`b. Iol sjb hraukjt mt , mc sjb jilo‑t, mc Lbio Inbxiolbr jil hbbo tjbrb tjit liy ,

tjbrb”s i kaal `jio`b tjit obmtjbr Er. iol Ers. Jinb waunl bvbr jivb sbbo mt . Pa, mt”s dmol ac i

cnudb tjit tjby siw mt ta hbkmo wmtj .―

Yubstmao7 Pa mo tjit ìsb1

Gajosao7 „Car tjit rbisao wb lao”t jivb ioy , wb ìo”t rbisaoihny ào`nulb tjit mt wis wrmttbo

wmtj tjb motbot ta accbol tjbe .―

\jb botmrb rbàrlmok ac tjb BPR prbss àocbrbo`b ìo hb cauol ao tjb DSAB wbhsmtb

uolbr tjb tmtnb „ BPR careinny bxaobritbs bepnaybb i`ùsbl ac ri`min snur .― Mt msùrrbotny

ivimnihnb it tjb cannawmok RXN7 jttp7//dvab.àe/obwsblmt/96088-bsu-oa-ri`min-lms`rmemoitmao-

ar-jitb-`rmeb-mo-snme-lbpirtebot. \jb rbàrlmok ms it tjb hattae ac tjb pikb. \a cunny

ipprb`mitb tjb lbrmsmao iol àotbept jbipbl upao tjb Jinbs, mt ms vinuihnb ta nmstbo ta tjb

rbàrlmok. \jb DSAB irtm`nb ms itti`jbl is Bxjmhmt I , iol moàrparitbl hy rbcbrbo`b jbrbmo.

Smbttm‑s apbomok rbeirds hbkmo wmtj „Iokbnmì iol Ebnvmo Jinb cmnbl i àepnimot ac io

innbkbl jitb `rmeb wmtj tjb Beparmi Ptitb Romvbrsmty panm`b lbpirtebot. Aur ao-ìepus panm`b

@isb 2792-`v-6


7/49

;

lbpirtebot movbstmkitbl tjb innbkbl àepnimot tjit wis rbnitbl ta tjb wrmtmok ac i ri`min snur mo

tjb oatbhaad ac i kriluitb stulbot wmtjmo tjb s`jaan ac nmhriry iol mocareitmao eioikbebot.―

\jb bxjiustmvb prbss àocbrbo`b stirtbl wmtj tjb „Jinbs― iol bolbl wmtj tjb „Jinbs ,― iol tjb

ebssikb ào`bromok tjb pnimotmcc wis naul iol `nbir. Lao‑t hbn mbvb ioytjmok jb siml.

I`àrlmok ta Smbttm iol Gajosao, „\jb Jinbs TwbrbU spadbo ta, M tjmod, ao sbvbrin

a`ìsmaos. \jby wbrb motbrvmbwbl, iol tjby lml bxprbss sbvbrin mostio`bs tjit tjby innbkbl wbrb

lms`rmemoitary i`ts iol tjit tidbo intakbtjbr `rbitbs i jastmnb ward bovmraoebot.― Gajosao

àotmoubs, „Pa tjb movbstmkitar siml, ‟cmob, nbt‑s `jb`d inn tjms aut.‑ Pa tjby wbot tjraukj iol

naadbl it bi`j aob Tac tjb `nimesU, tindbl ta tjb pbapnb movanvbl, naadbl it tjb `mrùestio`bs iol

ìeb up wmtj ào`nusmaos car bvbry smoknb aob ac tjbe tjit wis i nbkmtmeitb, oao-lms`rmemoitary

hisms car wjy tjit tjmok jippbobl…iol jivmok rbil tjb movbstmkitmao rbparts iol sa ao, mt wiso‑t

bvbo i `nasb ìnn! Mt wis vbry `nbir tjit tjbrb wis oat i lms`rmemoitary motbot.― I rbpartbr mo tjb

iulmbo`b rbinmzbl tjb mepnmìtmaosac Gajosao‑s stitbebot iol isdbl tjb cannawmok qubstmao7

„[jit labs tjit siy ihaut tjb Jinbs1― \jb rbàrlmok eidbs mt lmccmùnt ta lboy tjit tjb rbsunts

wbrb lieikmok ta tjb Jinbs.

Smbttm iol Gajosao, wjbo oat lmrb`tny itti`dmok tjb Jinbs hy oieb, eilb `brtimo tjit tjby

àovbybl tjit tjby jbnl tjb Jinbs mo tjb nawbst rbkirl, iol cauol tjbmr innbkitmaos wmnlny

uocauolbl iol àotrmvbl. Smbttm iol Gajosao eilb mt ̀ nbir tjit oa aob àunl hbnmbvb aob warl

ac tjb innbkitmaos tjit tjb Jinbs wbrb eidmok. \jb Jinbs wbrb oat `rblmhnb, „mt wiso‑t bvbo i

`nasb ìnn!―Gajosao siml it aob pamot. [jit labs tjit siy ihaut tjb Jinbs1 Mt lbciebs tjbe iol

pni`bs tjbe mo i cinsb nmkjt. Smbttm iol Gajosao wbrb jmlmok hbjmol tjb strm`tbst nbkin lbcmomtmao

ac jitb `rmeb, iol bxpauolmok àotrmvbl starmbs, mo`nulmok jaw tjmoks jippbobl tjb liy ac tjb

jitb `rmeb. \jb cannawmok liy Smbttm hi`dtri`dbl iol waunl mssub i stitbebot tjit trmbl ta sactbo

@isb 2792-`v-6


8/49

:

tjit stio`b, `nimemok tjit BPR wis o‑t jmlmok hbjmol tjb nbkin lbcmomtmao ac„jitb `rmeb, ― hut

accbrbl oa bvmlbo`b ta suppart tjit eavb, iol tjbrb ms oa atjbr wiy ta `jiri`tbrmzb tjbmr pasmtmao.

Mo tjb prbss àocbrbo`b, Gajosao lb`nirbl tjit tjb accm`b wjbrb tjb innbkbl jitb `rmeb

taad pni`b wis oat i prmvitb accm`b, iol tjit mt wis ao tjb tjmrl cnaar. Gajosao siml mt jil io

„apbo laar.― Vbapnb ìeb mo iol aut ac tjit accm`b inn liy. „Mt wis typmìnny oat na`dbl car east

ac tjb liy ar bvbomok.― \jit ms cinsb. \a hbkmo wmtj, tjb accm`b wjbrb tjb mo`mlbot taad pni`b

wis Accm`b


9/49

=

tiepbrbl wmtj hut tjb uona`dbl laar iol tjb wrmtmok ao jbr oatbhaad irb tjb eimo tjmoks. (pjata

itti`jbl).― (La`. 90, pk. 88). Iokbnmì isdbl Lr. Jinb mc Lbio Inbxiolbr wis mo tjb ebbtmok

iol jb siml ybs. Pjb isdbl jme ta nbt jbr doaw tjit sjb obbls ta tind ta tjb KI wjbo sjb jis i

`jio`b iol nbt jbr doaw wjit jip pbobl. Nitbr, Lr. Jinb sbols i tbxt hi`d7 „Mo Kwbos ac`.

@aeb lawo.― Lr. Jinb iol Iokbnmì ebt mo Lbio Inbxiolbr‑s accm`b ta rbpart tjb mo`mlbot, iol

Iokbnmì isds tjb Lbio ta ka sbb tjb KI ihaut tjb mo`mlbot. \jb KI stitbs tjit Lbio Inbxiolbr

labs oat cannaw-up wmtj jbr uotmn ictbr tjb Jinbs ebt wmtj Vravast @arlnb mo Guob, ictbr tjb KI

jil hbbo rbnbisbl crae jbr pasmtmao it PNME mo Eiy. Lr. Jinb hbnmbvbs tjit Lr. Law ìo

àrraharitb jms rbpart ao tjms eittbr hbìusb jb sjirbl jms ào`bros wmtj jbr sjartny ictbr tjbmo`mlbot iol isdbl car jbr issmstio`b mo cannawmok-up wmtj Lbio Inbxiolbr ta cmol aut wjy tjbrb

wis oa i`tmao ao jbr pirt. [jbo yau rb- rbil Gajosao‑s prbss stitbebot mo nmkjt ac tjb ci`ts, mt

rbvbins lb`bptmao tjit ms smepny hrbitjtidmok, pirtmùnirny smo`b jms ranb ms insa @a-Lmrb`tar ac tjb

Da`j @botbr car Nbilbrsjmp iol Btjm`s.

\jb kriluitb issmstiot rbpartbl ta Iokbnmì Jinb iol wardbl wmtj jbr bvbry ward liy

iol actbo jil wbbdny sticc ebbtmoks takbtjbr wmtj tjb àeeuomìtmaos KI. Lr. Jinb usuinny

siw tjb KI sbvbrin tmebs i liy. Car i wjmnb jbr lbsd wis nmtbrinny mo Iokbnmì‑s accm`b. I pjata

ac tjb KI‑s lbsd mo Iokbnmì‑s accm`b it PNME ms itti`jbl is Bxjmhmt @ , iol ms moàrparitbl hy

rbcbrbo`b jbrbmo. Lr. Iolrbw Pemtj, tjb Issa`mit b Lbio wja jil rbspaosmhmnmtmbs car inn KI‑s,

wis tjb aob wja lb`mlbl ta eavb Iokbnmì‑s KI ta Accm`b


10/49

96

rbnitmaosjmp wmtj KI mo wjasb accm`b tjb jitb spbb`j wis cauol. Vbapnb tbnn nmbs car i rbisao. Mo

tjms ìsb, mt wis rbtinmitmao iol lms`rmemoitmao hy lbcieitmao. ]au kbt i straok sbosb ac tjms hy

smepny cannawmokGajosao‑s niokuikb, wjm`j `nbirny cannaws i einm`maus spbùnitmvb pittbro,

mosbrtmok liti is jb sbbs cmt.

[mtjaut BPR, Beparmi waunl hbàeb i kjast tawo, wjm`j eidbs car i pawbrcun

mo`botmvb ta ka inaok ta kbt inaok wmtj mt. Lr. Jinb hbìeb syehanm` ac wjy yau la o‑t ebss

wmtj BPR. Cbir ac rbtinmitmao inaob eidbs mt jirl ta tidb i prmo`mpnbl stiol. Mc bvbo aob ac tjb

lbcboliots mo tjms ìsb jil lb`mlbl ta tidb i prmo`mpnbl stiol, tjby waunl jivb eilb i jukb

lmccbrbo`b mo tjb autàeb. \jb Hni`d Ptulbot Romao (HPR) àunl jivb eilb i hmk mepi`t, hut

vm`b- prbsmlbot Lbmlri Bnmgij jbnpbl ta stbbr tjbe mo tjb ilemomstritmao‑s lmrb`tmao. Birny ao

Smbttm zbrabl mo ao wmoomok avbr Bnmgij, iol su``bblbl. \jb sieb ms trub car Diyni Kmnearb.

Kmnearb hrikkbl aonmob ihaut tjb gah Smbttm accbrbl jbr mo tjb obw lmvbrsmty pnioomok kraup.

Ptulbots wbrb aony ihnb ta pirtm`mpitb mo tjb kraup hy movmtitmao. Lbrbd [mnsao, BPR

Jaebàemok Dmok, Ptulbot Vrbsmlbot ac tjb Jaoars @annbkb, iol nbilbr ac sbvbrin stulbot

arkiomzitmaos momtminny syepitjmzbl wmtj tjb Jinbs, iol tanl tjbe tjit wjbo jb wardbl sbùrmty

car BPR it omkjt, pirt ac tjbmr pitran mo`nulbl `jb`dmok inn accm`b laars omkjtny. I`àrlmok ta

[mnsao, mc io accm`b laar wis rautmobny uona`dbl, mt waunl jivb hbbo rbpartbl hy sbùrmty.

[mnsao, hbmok i ebehbr ac tjb Jaoars @annbkb, cauol jmesbnc tjrbitbobl wmtj prbssurb iol

rbtinmitmao car sjirmok jms suppart car tjb upàemok Eir`j, iol ictbr Xmttkbrs‑ liukjtbr Inbxi

\jaeis jbnl i ebbtmok wmtj jbr Jaoars pbbrs stitmok tjit jbr eatjbr wis mooa`bot. [mnsao nitbr

eilb i jukb iooauo`bebot ta jms `mr`nb ac issa`mitbs iol mo tjb eblmi tjit Xmttkbrs wis

àepnbtbny mooa`bot, tjit sjb wis cinsbny i`ùsbl, iol tjit jb lmsivawbl ioy issa`mitmao wmtj

tjb Jinbs ‑ ìusb .

@isb 2792-`v-6


11/49

99

Pirij Ppaao (wja ms insa i ebehbr ac tjb Jaoars @annbkb àjart `nuh) iol Irmbn @aanby

it tjb BPR Hunnbtmo stulbot obwspipbr jivb usbl tjbmr pasmtmaos ta lbcieb iol mosunt tjb Jinbs,

intjaukj tjit wis oat inwiys trub car Ppaao. Pjb rbpartbl i cimrny uohmisbl stary mo A`tahbr mo

wjm`j sjb lmrb`tny bstihnmsjbl tjit jiolwrmtmok bxpbrt @irnsao rb-àocmrebl Xmttkbrs is tjb

jmkjny nmdbny iutjar ac tjb ri`min snur. \jb omob `nissmcmìtmaos mo carbosm` jiolwrmtmok

bxiemoitmao ahtimobl crae tjb chm.kav wbhsmtb7 Mlbotmcmìtmao, Jmkjny Vrahihnb Lml [rmtb,

Vrahihny Lml [rmtb, Molmìtmaos Lml [rmtb, Oa @ao`nusmao, Molmìtmaos Lml Oat [rmtb, Vrahihnb

Lml Oat [rmtb, Jmkjny Vrahihnb Lml Oat [rmtb, Bnmemoitmao. Ppaao tjbo wratb ioatjbr irtm`nb

rbkirlmok i einm`maus niwsumt tjit wis cmnbl ikimost Lr. Jinb ta tidb iwiy jms trilbeird. \jitniwsumt wis lmsemssbl ikimost tjb pbtmtmaobr. \jb ioknb ac Ppaao‑s stary wis ta lbpm`t Lr. Jinb

is nmtmkmaus. Ppaao àocmlbl tjit sjb wis car̀ bl hy tjb uomvbrsmty obwspipbr blmtar-mo-`jmbc,

Irmbn @aanby, ta wrmtb i „lms`rblmtmok stary.― \jms wis oat io blmtarmin ar apmomao pmb`b.

Puhsbqubotny, tjb rbnitmaosjmp wmtj Ppaao turobl sautj wjbo sjb bstihnmsjbl i `nasbr crmbolsjmp

wmtj jbr Jaoars ànnbikub iol Xmttkbrs‑ liukjtbr Inbxi \jaeis. Pbvbrin irtm`nbs wmtj ci nsb iol

lbcieitary eitbrmin qum`dny cannawbl mo tjb Hunnbtmo.

Lbcboliots `nime tjit Lr. Jinb cimns ta ebotmao tjb bxi`t pjrisb wjm`j ms lbcieitary.

\ jb rbsunts ac tjb „movbstmkitmao,― wjbtjbr quatbl mo wjanb ar mo pirt, irb lbcieitary. G ajosaos‑

botmrb oirritmvb mslbcieitary, is ms Smbttm‑s. Mo tjb prbss àocbrbo`b, Smbttm iol Gajosao

bepjitmìnny stitbl „ [b doaw wjit aur ci`ts irb iol wb jivb hisbl aur ào`nusmaos ao tjb ci`ts

wb jivb mo jiol. ― \jby lbciebl Lr. Jinb, cniuotbl tjbmr pawbr ta ioomjmnitb jme wmtj brrars

iol aemssmaos, iol bvbo jil i cbw niukjs inaok tjb wiy, mo`nulmok niukjmok wmtj i rbpartbr

ìnnmokjms upàemok eir`j i „juot.― [jit àunl lbcieb Jinb earb tjio lbs`rmhmok jme is i

nymok appartuomst wja pniymok tjb ri`b ìrl hbìusb ac i „cnudb1― Obmtjbr Smbttm oar Gajosao

@isb 2792-`v-6


12/49


13/49

90

Autsmlb „rbvmbwbrs― waunl cimn ta àeprbjbol tjb nmbs hbmok lmssbemoitbl mo tjb

„movbstmkitmao,― oar tjb motbot ac tjb uomvbrsmty, uonbss tjby taa wbrb smepny àepnm`mt, iol tjit ms

oat mepniusmhnb. BPR sbnb`tbl tjbe. Vnimotmcc wis obvbr àoti`tbl hy tjb rbvmbwbrs oar

mocarebl tjit tjbrb wbr b „vinmlitars.― Obmtjbr lml tjby sjirb tjbmr pnio ta jivb bxtbroin pirtmbs

movanvbl mo tjb movbstmkitmao ta tjb puhnm`. Mt wis i sb`rbt. [aunl io autsmlb rbvmbwbr doaw tjit

tjb botmrb lbs`rmptmao ac tjb pjysmìn s`bob jis hbbo cinsmcmbl1 \jby prahihny w aunlo‑t. Io

autsmlb rbvmbwbr sbnb`tbl hy BPR, nmdb tjb rbpartbrs mo tjb obws àocbrbo`b, jil ta rbny ta i krbit

bxtbot ao wjit BPR wis cbblmok tjbe, iol hisbl ao tjbmr trust, BPR taad àepnbtb ilviotikb ac

tjbmr pasmtmao ac pawbr iol iutjarmty. \jb autsmlb rbvmbwbrs lml oat ̀ aolu`t tjbmr awomolbpbolbot movbstmkitmao, iol ahtimo moput crae hatj smlbs ac tjb àotravbrsy, tjus tjby wbrb mo

oa pasmtmao ta rbi`j ioy ào`nusmao ao tjb cimrobss, tjaraukjobss ar nakm` usbl mo tjb

movbstmkitmao. \jby wbrb ebrb ruhhbr stieps car jmrb. „Mo io i`tmao car nmhbn ar sniolbr, mt

succm`bs ta innbkb kbobrinny tjit lbcieitary eittbr wis puhnmsjbl ar spadbo ào`bromok tjb

pnimotmcc , iol mc tjit innbkitmao ms oat lbombl mo tjb ioswbr, mt obbl oat hb pravbl it trmin.―

Bepjisms illbl. Diosis Xunbs ac @mvmn Vra`blurb, @jiptbr 36, Irtm`nb 8, Pb`tmao 86=, (g).

Bvbry rbpartbr it tjb prbss àocbrbo`b uolbrstaal tjb mepnmìtmaos ac tjb rbsunts ac tjb Smbttm

„movbstmkitmao― is ào`bromok tjb pnimotmcc.

Ictbr jbirmok tjb rbsunts ac tjb cmolmoks, aob rbpartbl isdbl i sbirmok qubstmao, „La yau

tjmod tjb Jinbs irb kamok ta tidb i`tmao ikimost yau kuys car sniolbr ar saebtjmok nmdb tjit1―

Smbttm stitbs„\jit ms i qubstmao ta isd tjb Jinbs.― Ioatjbr rbpartbr isdbl i smemnirny

strimkjtc arwirl qubstmao7 „Pa oaw tjit tjb movbstmkitmao ms àepnbtb, oaw tjit bvbrytjmok‑s laob,

hismìnny, iol ikimo, M lao‑t ebio ta sauol is mc (moiulmhnb), hut M wmnn isd mt tjms wiy, hbìusb M

lao‑t doaw ac i hbttbr wiy ta isd mt, lml tjb Jinbs tbnn tjb wjanb trutj1― \jms qubstmao jis i

@isb 2792-`v-6


14/49

9<

hmoiry ioswbr, ybs ar oa. Smbttm wis oat is lmrb`t. Pjb mepnmbl tjit tjb Jinbs wbrb nymok hy

stitmok „M wiot ta tjmod ihaut jaw ta ioswbr tjit qubstmao.― [jit ms tjbrb ta tjmod ihaut ictbr

àolu`tmok io „motbosmvb movbstmkitmao― tjit innbkblny „boàepissbl tjb motbrvmbw ac 9= pbapnb

iol rbsuntbl mo i 026 pikb laùebot ac cmolmoks iol ào`nusmao1 ― \jbsb irb Smbttm‑s warls

sueeirmzmok tjb lbptj iol bxtbot ac tjb movbstmkitmao. Hut naad it jaw lbcieitmao iol cinsb

nmkjt ward. Smbttm mo jbr rbspaosb smtuitbl tjb Jinbs mo i cinsb nmkjt. Car bxiepnb, mc i pbrsao

isds tjbmr hbst crmbol mc tjby sjaunl litb saebaob iol tjb ioswbr ms7 „Nbt eb tjmod ihaut jaw ta

ioswbr tjit,― tjb mepnmìtmao ms ahvmaus4 tjbmr crmbol jis rbsbrvitmaos ar warsb, iol tjb ioswbr ms

prahihny oa. Smbttm iol Gajosao lalkbl tjb qubstmao car ahvmaus nbkin rbisaos.

\jb rbpartbr rbàkomzbl tjb sbrmausobss ac tjb autàeb ac tjb movbstmkitmao iol isds Lr.

Smbttm mc tjb uomvbrsmty wis ào`brobl ihaut i niwsumt movanvmok sniolbr tjit emkjt hb cmnbl

ikimost tjb uomvbrsmty. \jb qubstmao inaob supparts pnimotmcc ‑s irkuebot tjit i rbisaoihnb pbrsao

àunl àostrub tjb rbeirds eilb hy lbcboliots Smbttm iol Gajosao mo tjms obws àocbrbo`b is

lbciemok jme, hy hatj bxpnm`mt iol mepnm`mt rbcbrbo`b. Mc tjb rbsunts ac tjb movbstmkitmao irb ta hb

hbnmbvbl, Lr. Jinb iol jms wmcb cmnnbl i cinsb panm`b rbpart, wjm`j ms i `rmeb.

Gajosao rbspaolbl tjms wiy ta tjb qubstmao7 „Lml tjb Jinbs tbnn tjb wjanb trutj1―

Gajosao siml „Vbr`bptmao ms dby…\jby‑rb lamok wjitbvbr tjby‑rb lamok iol tjby eiy jivb i

lmccbrbot pbr`bptmao ihaut tjmoks tjio atjbrs.― \jb Jinbs irb oaw l brmsmvbny nuepbl mo wmtj

„atjbrs ,― tjby irb oat nmdb us. \jby irbo‑t bvbo `nasb. Paebaob moqumrbs ihaut tjb stitus ac

Lbio Inbxiolbr, Smbttm wis qum`d ta rbspaol tjit sjb àunl oat àeebot ao Inbxiolbr lub ta mt

hbmok i „pbrsaoobn― mssub. Lbio Inbxiolbr wis lbrbnm`t mo jbr luty mo oat movbstmkitmok tjb hmis

mo`mlbot wjbo mt a`ùrrbl, ybt Smbttm iol Gajosao eidb oa ebotmao ac tjit. \jb rbinmty ms tjit oa

@iuìsmios wbrb jirebl mo tjb eidmok ac Smbttm‑s prbss àocbrbo`b, gust tjb Jinbs, wja irb

@isb 2792-`v-6


15/49

92

Icrmìo Iebrmìo. \jb BPRVL cimnbl ta ànnb`t iol sbùrb bvmlbo`b iol ta cannaw-up ao tjb

jiolwrmtmok. Lr. @arlnb wis is lbrbnm`t mo jms rbspaosmhmnmtmbs ta cannaw-up ao ciùnty ào`bros

ào`bromok lms`rmemoitmao iol rbtinmitmao, iol intjaukj jb stitbl tjit jb jil cmvb mtbes ao jms nmst

ta cannaw-up ao ictbr ebbtmok wmtj Jinb ao ar ihaut Guob 06, 8692, jb lml oatjmok. Inbxiolbr

àotmoubl ta jiriss tjb Jinbs, iol isdbl Iokbnmì ta motbri`t wmtj Xmttkbrs mo i eioobr tjit

Iokbnmì cbnt wis lbebiomok, sa Iokbnmì qumt, iol sbot aut tjb Apbo Nbttbr ao Guny 8;, 8692.

\jb pamot ms tjit Smbttm eilb oa ebotmao ac pbrcareio`b prahnbes issa`mitbl wmtj @iuìsmios

lmrb`tny rbnitbl ta tjb mssubs mo tjb movbstmkitmao.

Gajosao‑s oirritmvb ihaut tjb accm`b naìtmao, jawbvbr, ms o at mepunsmvb ar pamotnbss. Jb

ms lamok jms nbvbn hbst ta lmstri`t ittbotmao iwiy crae tjb i`tuin naìtmao ac tjb mo`mlbot iol tjb

uoniwcun botry sa tjit jb ìo eidb ioyhaly i suspb`t is wbnn is stitb tjit tjb mo`mlbot wis oat

lmrb`tbl it tjb Jinbs. \jb seinnbr tjb paan ac patbotmin suspb`ts, tjb krbitbr tjb ̀ jio`b ac i

eit`j. Vnimotmcc ìooat bxpauol ao inn tjb eioy brrars mo Gajosao‑s riot, hut tjb eatmvb ms

smokunir7 ta lms`rblmt tjb Jinbs. \jb Jinbs irb ebotmaobl hy oieb mo àoguo`tmao wmtj tjb rbsunts

ac BPR‑s movbstmkitmao avbr tjmrty tmebs it tjb prbss àoc brbo`b iol ouebraus tmebs mo io

Beparmi Kizbttb iol Hunnbtmo irtm`nb. I trub àpy ac tjb Beparmi Kizbttb irtm`nb ms itti`jbl is

Bxjmhmt L , iol i trub àpy ac tjb irtm`nb crae tjb Hunnbtmo ms itti`jbl is Bxjmhmt B , iol hatj irb

moàrparitbl hy rbcbrbo`b jbrbmo.

Smbttm iol Gajosao pbllnbl tjbsb cinsbjaals ta bvbry ebbtmok tjby ittbolbl, is lml atjbrs

su`j is Gisao Hraads iol Kiry [yitt, cuo`tmaomok mo i ìnùnitbl iol ìnnaus ìepimko ta

smnbo`b tjb ci`ts prbsbotbl hy Lr. Jinb (La`. 86-9, pks. 9


16/49

93

tjb rbpart, lbspmtb doawmok tjit mt wis lbbpny cniwbl iol lbcieitary. Atjbrs mo tjb uomvbrsmty

wbrb mo cbir ac rbtinmitmao (i ci`t tjit wb ebotmaobl mo i ebbtmok ta Vanm`b @jmbc @jrms Jaavbr)

iol bvbotuinny ihiolaobl tjb Jinbs hbìusb mt lml oat ippbir tjit tjb Jinbs jil tjb pawbr ta ka

up ikimost tjb mostmtutmao. Bi`j iol bvbry lbcboliot dobw tjit Jinb wis succbrmok car rbpartmok

ri`mse, iol tjit tjb „movbstmkitmao― lbciebl jme, ybt bi`j aob wmnncunny `jasb ta suppart io

molbcbosmhnb vbrsmao ac bvbots surrauolmok wjit triospmrbl ao tjb caurtj cnaar. \jb pjrisbs tjit

„oa jitb `rmeb a`ùrrbl― iol „oa lms`rmemoitmao wis cauol ,― iol „mt wiso‑t bvbo `nasb!― wbrb

prapikitbl tjraukjaut tjb BPR ìepus iol eblmi ta lms`rblmt Lr. Jinb car lamok wjit1 Cinsbny

rbpartmok ri`mse iol i jitb `rmeb1 [jit mc Jinbs‑ rbparts ac ri`mse iol i jitb `rmeb irb i`tuinnytrub iol tjb rbsunts ac tjb movbstmkitmao irb cinsb1 \jit passmhmnmty bxmsts. Oa aob sjaunl jivb ta

bolurb wjit Lr. Jinb jis bolurbl car rbpartmok ri`mse ioywjbrb. Smbttm iol Gajosao iol inn

movanvbl wmnncunny sbt aut ta `rusj innbkitmaos ac ri`mse hy ioy iol inn ebios, mo`nulmok

rbtinmitmao iol lms`rmemoitmao wmtj oa rbkirl wjitsabvbr ta tjb ci`ts ar tjb trutj ar tjb niw. Lr.

Jinb rb`bmvbl tjms ebssikb naul iol `nbir. Vra sb ar oat, Lr. Jinb jis oa motbotmaos ac pissmvbny

i``bptmok wjit jb hbnmbvbs irb cuoliebotin uoiehmkuaus vmanitmaos ac jms `mvmn rmkjts.

XB\INMI\MAO

\a pravb rbtinmitmao, i pnimotmcc eust lbeaostritb tjit (9) sjb bokikbl mo i pratb`tbl

i`tmvmty doawo ta tjb lbcboliot4 (8) tjb lbcboliot taad io bepnayebot i`tmao ilvbrsb jbr4 iol

(0) tjbrb bxmsts i ìusin àoob`tmao hbtwbbo tjb pratb`tbl i`tmvmty iol tjb ilvbrsb i`tmao. Kbnbni

v. Kriy , 3


17/49

9;

rbtinmitary ritmaoinb car tidmok ilvbrsb `aolu`t ikimost tjb bepnaybb. Jbroiolbz , 3


18/49

9:

rbsanvbl i `mrùmt spnmt ao tjb lbcmomtmao ac "ilvbrsb bepnayebot i`tmao," Rotmn 8663, tjb cblbrin

àurts ac ippbins wbrb lmvmlbl avbr jaw sbvbrb io bepnaybr's ilvbrsb i`tmao eust hb ta cio

wmtjmo tjb stitutb. East hrail7 "Ioy i`tmvmty rbisaoihny nmdbny ta lbtbr" io bepnaybb crae

vmolmìtmok pratb`tbl rmkjts. (Omotj @mrùmt) Emllnb krauol7 Io bepnayebot i`tmao tjit i

rbisaoihnb bepnaybb waunl cmol "eitbrminny ilvbrsb," m.b. rbsuntmok mo tiokmhnb mogury ar jire.

(Pbvbotj @mrùmt, L.@. @mrùmt) East oirraw7 \jb bepnaybr jis tidbo io "untmeitb bepnayebot

i`tmao" (m.b. cmrmok, lbeatmao) ikimost tjb bepnaybb. (Cmctj @mrùmt, Bmkjtj @mrùmt). \jb Puprbeb

@aurt untmeitbny rbsanvbl tjb "@mrùmt Ppnmt" mo civar ac i emllnb-ac-tjb-rail "eitbrminny

ilvbrsb" stiolirl, hut lbcmobl "eitbrminmty" ahgb`tmvbny crae tjb pbrspb`tmvb ac i "rbisaoihnbbepnaybb." Lbpbolmok ao tjb @mrùmt, ìsb niw prb-litmok Hurnmoktao Oartjbro eiy oat rbeimo

kaal niw. Lr. Jinb hbnmbvbs tjit jms ̀ nimes survmvb uolbr tjb oirrawbst rbilmok, hut tjit tjb

emllnb rbilmok ms earb ippraprmitb7 „Io bepnayebot i`tmao tjit i rbisaoihnb bepnaybb waunl

cmol "eitbrminny ilvbrsb," m.b. rbsuntmok mo tiokmhnb mogury ar jire.―

BPR ilemomstritars innbkb tjit prbvbotmok Lr. Jinb crae rbkunir ciùnty i`tmvmtmbs iol

accm`bs wis oat rbtinmitary lurmok io bxtbolbl àanmok acc pbrmal tjit nistbl car avbr smx eaotjs,

lbprmvmok jme ac pracbssmaoin sbrvm`bs iol issa`mitmaos. \jb Puprbeb @aurt pasbl twa

jypatjbtmìn smtuitmaos ta mnnustritb ilvbrsb i`tmaos. Mo tjb sbàol mt illrbssbl bepnaybb

bx`nusmaos7 „I supbrvmsar's rbcusin ta movmtb io bepnaybb ta nuo`j ms oareinny trmvmin, i

oaoi`tmaoihnb pbtty snmkjt. Hut ta rbtinmitb hy bx`nulmok io bepnaybb crae i wbbdny trimomok

nuo`j tjit àotrmhutbs smkomcmìotny ta tjb bepnaybb's pracbssmaoin ilvio`bebot emkjt wbnn lbtbr

i rbisaoihnb bepnaybb crae àepnimomok ihaut lms`rmemoitmao.― Hurnmoktao Oa., 2


19/49

9=

Io bepnaybb eust untmeitbny lbeaostritb i ìusin obxus hbtwbbo jms ar jbr pratb`tbl

àolu`t iol tjb bepnaybr's rbtinmitary rbspaosb. \jb àurts ac ippbins rbàkomzb tjrbb ebtjals

ac pravmok ìusitmao7 (9) tbeparin praxmemty hbtwbbo tjb pratb`tbl i`tmvmty iol tjb ilvbrsb

i`tmao4 (8) praac tjit atjbr smemnirny smtuitbl bepnaybbs wbrb trbitbl earb civarihny4 iol (0)

lmrb`t praac ac tjb bepnaybr's rbtinmitary motbot. Gmebobz v. @mty i/Obw ]ard , 362 C. Pupp. 8l


20/49

86

Jbory v. [ybtj Vjires., Mo` ., 393 C.0l 90


21/49

89

hb rblrbssbl hy tjb rbqubstbl rbnmbc." Innbo v. [rmkjt ,


22/49

88

rbtinmitmao `nime, pravmlmok sjb ìo lbeaostritb 'i kaal cimtj, rbisaoihnb hbnmbc tjit tjb

uolbrnymok `jinnbokbl i`tmaos ac tjb bepnaybr vmanitbl tjb niw'" (quatmok Piroa v. Lauknis

Bnnmeio-Kmhhaos & Mvbs. Mo`., 9:0 C.0l 922, 92= (8l @mn'. 9===) (`mtitmao aemttbl)))).

MOGRXMBP

Lbcboliots `nime tjit Lr. Jinb jis oat hbbo mogurbl hy tjbmr àolu`t, lbspmtb doawmok

tjit Lr. Jinb jis hbbo ivamlbl iol lmspirikbl it BPR, iol sdbwbrbl ao tjb Motbrobt. Aob su`j

Motbrobt bxiepnb ms cauol ao i wbhsmtb ìnnbl lawotrbols.àe. Io A`tahbr 93, 8962 irtm`nb wis

wrmttbo mo Lawotrbols botmtnbl Hni`d Vracbssar Lbeiols Jitb @rmeb Movbstmkitmao \jbo Pubs

[jbo Jb Labso‑t Nmdb t jb Xbsunts. (La`. 90, pks. ;


23/49

80

Mo Pbptbehbr, tjb uomvbrsmty siml io movbstmkitmao ac tjb mo`mlbot iol mts ictbreitj cauol oa

bvmlbo`b ac i jitb `rmeb ar ri`min lms`rmemoitmao.

M tjmod tjit‑s i om`b wiy ac siymok tjms wis ybt ioatjbr jitb `rmeb jaix.

Jbrb‑s jaw M sbb mt7 \jb Jinbs wbrb ìepus ikmtitars tjit àostiotn y àepnimobl ihaut

ri`mse tjit lmlo‑t bxmst. \jby nmdbny stikbl i jitb `rmeb hbìusb tjby àunlo‑t pravb tjbmr `nimes

ac ri`mse ioy atjbr wiy. [jbo tjb uomvbrsmty movbstmkitbl iol cauol tjit tjb jitb `rmeb wis

hunnsjmt iol tjit tjb Jinbs wbrb prahihny hbjmol mt, Ebnvmo Jinb cmnbl i niwsumt mo io ittbept ta

sivb ci`b. \jby sjaunl hb irrbstbl car tjbct hbìusb tjby gust stanb i pikb aut ac In Pjirptao‑s

pniyhaad.

\jbsb twa ‟ ri`min gustm`bwirrmars‑ gust eilb tjmoks i nat jirlbr ao nbkmtmeitb praspb`tmvb

hni`d bepnaybbs. [jbtjbr Beparmi Ptitb wmnn ilemt mt ar oat, tjby wmnn tjmod twm`b hbcarb jmrmok

atjbr hni`d pracbssars. Mc mt àebs lawo ta twa ippnmìots, aob hni`d iol aob wjmtb, wmtj bquin

quinmcmìtmaos, tjby‑rb kamok wmtj tjb wjmtb aob. Ictbr inn ac tjb stmod iol krmbc ìusbl hy tjb

Jinbs, tjby‑l hb `rizy oat ta.―

(jttp7//lawotrbol.àe/;9supbrh/hni`d-pracbssar-lbeiols-jitb-`rmeb-movbstmkitmao-tjbo-subs-wjbo-

jb-labsot-nmdb-tjb-rbsunts).

Vasts nmdb tjb aob ihavb molmìtb pnimotmcc eiy hb pni`bl mo jires wiy hy tjb rb`dnbss iol

wiotao àolu`t ac tjb lbcboliots. \jms ìusbs pnimotmcc krbit ào`bro car jms pbrsaoin sicbty. Mo io

beimn ta Lr. Smbttm litbl Pbptbehbr 9: tj , 8692, Jinb siml „ M hbnmbvb tjit yaur nbilbrsjmp ac Beparmi

Ptitb Romvbrsmty eiy àeb ta h b doawo is tjb lirdbst liys mo tjb jmstary ac tjms mostmtutmao.― \jb

eioobr mo wjm`j sjb àolu`tbl jbr movbstmkitmao ms ìusb.

@isb 2792-`v-6


24/49

8<

\JB JIOL[XM\MOK BSMLBO@B

\jb Jinbs rbpartbl tjbmr ào`bros ihaut i jitb `rmeb ta tjb BPRVL mo tjb ictbroaao ao

Guny 9, 8692. Birny tjb obxt earomok, it ;70;ie, tjb BPRVL àoti`tbl Lr. Jinb hy pjaob iol

stitbl tjit mo tjbmr apmomao oa `rmeb jil a`ùrrbl. Lr. Jinb rbqubstbl i panm`b rbpart, hut wis

mocarebl tjit oa panm`b rbpart àunl hb ahtimobl hy tjb Jinbs hbìusb tjbrb oa carein rbpart wis

tidbo lub ta tjb mosmkomcmìo`b ac tjb mo`mlbot tjit tjb Jinbs rbpartbl, iol tjit tjbrb waunl hb oa

curtjbr i`tmao tidbo. \jb BPR Vanm`b Lbpirtebot sjut lawo ioy lmsùssmao ac i jitb `rmeb (ar

ioy `rmeb). Cannawmok tjb àovbrsitmao wmtj BPRVL, pnimotmcc ìnnbl tjb accm`b ac tjb Nyao

@auoty Ittaroby Eir` Kaaleio ta rbpart tjb mo`mlbot. Kaaleio obvbr rbturobl jms ìnn. I

trub iol àrrb`t àpy ac pnimotmcc‑s pjaob rbàrls car hatj ìnns ms itti`jbl is Bxjmhmt C , iol

moàrparitbl hy rbcbrbo`b jbrbmo.

Lbcboliots jivb lbeiolbl tjit pnimotmcc pralu`b earb jiolwrmtmok bvmlbo`b, mo`nulmok i

wrmttbo rbpart. [jbo Vnimotmcc Jinb eilb jms rbpart ac tjb jitb `rmeb ta tjb BPRVL iol BPR,

tjasb ikbo`mbs sjaunl jivb issuebl tjb rbspaosmhmnmty is i rbpartmok ikbo`y car ìrrymok tjb hinn

crae tjbrb. Ao Guny 9, 8692, tjb sieb liy tjit pnimotmcc cmnbl i panm`b rbpart, Iokbnmì Jinb sbot

io beimn ta @irnsao stitmok tjit sjb sjaunl hb jbirmok crae BPRVL rbkirlmok tjb jiolwrmtmok.

I trub iol àrrb`t àpy ac Iokbnmì‑s beimn ta @irnsao ms itti`jbl is Bxjmhmt K , iol

moàrparitbl hy rbcbrbo`b jbrbmo. Oaob ac tjb lbcboliots ìrbl tjit BPR lml oat kbt tjms eittbr

rbsanvbl lurmok tjbmr „cimr, tjaraukj, iol nakmìn― movbstmkitmao,― innawmoktjb jiolwrmtmok

mepnmìtmaos ta lioknb uotmn mt hbìeb puhnm`. I tjaraukj movbstmkitmao waunl jivb oat innawbl

tjms ta jippbo, ar innawbl tjb stulbot‑s oatbhaad wmtj tjb snur ta lmsippbir. Ac inn tjb mssubs tjit

BPR labs oat ippbir ta wiot rbsanvbl, tjb east smkomcmìot ms i lbcmomtmvb jiolwrmtmok

@isb 2792-`v-6


25/49

82

bxiemoitmao ac Xmttkbrs. BPR sjaunl jivb lbeiolbl su`j io bxiemoitmao car tjb sieb rbisao

tjit tjby ìo lbeiol cmokbrprmotmok, lruk ar inàjan tbsts.

@NIMEP IKIMOP\ LBCBOLIO\P

Lbcboliots Smbttm, @arlnb, Iolbrsao, Inbxiolbr, Gajosao, Niuhbr, Law, iol [yitt,

oiebl mo @auots MMM iol S, wbrb cunny iwirb tjit BPR jil motbotmaoinny ìusbl mrrbpirihnb jire

ta Lr. Jinb‑s rbputitmao iol motbkrmty hy tjb sjie movbstmkitmao, mo vmanitmao ac jms


26/49

83

Lbcboliots Kwbo Inbxiolbr, @jrms Jaavbr, Lr. Livml @arlnb, Guly Iolbrsao, Xiy

Niuhbr, Lr. Gi`dmb Smbttm, Lr. Dbvmo Gajosao, Lr. Kiry [yitt, Lr. Emrij Law, Gisao Hraads,

Pirij Ppaao, Irmbn @aanby, Lbrbd [mnsao, Diyni Kmnearb iol Lbmlri Bnmgij, inn doaw tjit Lr.

Jinb wis puomsjbl car spbidmok aut ikimost wjit jb pbr`bmvbl is ri`mse, iol tjb ìepus iol

puhnm` jis wmtobssbl tjb lieikb car lamok sa. Lr. Jinb labs oat obbl ioy ac tjb icarbebotmaobl

lbcboliots ta vinmlitb jms pbrsaoin cbbnmoks ihaut wjit àostmtutbs i ri`mst i`t, pirtmùnirny wjbo

inn ac tjb ilemomstritmvb cmkurbs irb @iuìsmio, iol inn ippbirbl ta ni`d bepitjy.

MOGRO@\MSB XBNMBC

Is car moguo`tmvb rbnmbc, Vnimotmcc Jinb nbivbs lms`rbtmao ta tjb @aurt is ta wjit rbeblmbs

irb nbkinny ivimnihnb. Vnimotmcc Jinb innbkbs mo mts àepnimot tjit jb ms succbrmok i lmrb`t iol

ùrrbot mogury is i rbsunt ac tjb sjie „movbstmkitmao ,― iol wmnn àotmoub ta succbr tjit mogury

uonbss tjbrb ms nbkin motbrvbotmao.

VXI]BX CAX XBNMBC

[JBXBCAXB, Vnimotmcc Ebnvmo Jinb, Vj.L. priys tjit gulkebot hb botbrbl ikimost

Lbcboliots Beparmi Ptitb Romvbrsmty, Kwbo Inbxiolbr, @jrms Jaavbr, Lr. Livml @arlnb, Guly

Iolbrsao, Xiy Niuhbr, Lr. Gi`dmb Smbttm, Lr. Dbvmo Gajosao, Lr. Kiry [yitt, Lr. Emrij Law,

Gisao Hraads, Pirij Ppaao, Irmbn @aanby, Lbrbd [mnsao, Diyni Kmnearb iol Lbmlri Bnmgij, iol

Labs 9-966 car inn rbeblmbs innawbl hy niw, àsts ac sumt, iol car su`j atjbr iol curtjbr rbnmbc is

tjb @aurt eiy arlbr. Vnimotmcc rbspb`tcunny rbqubs ts tjms @aurt ta lboy Lbcboliot Smbttm‑s

pbolmok eatmao ta lmsemss lmrb`tbl it Vnimotmcc‑s\jmrl Iebolbl @aepnimot.

@isb 2792-`v-6


27/49

8;

LI\BL7 Iprmn 82, 8693 Xbspb`tcunny suhemttbl,

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQEbnvmo Jinb, VjL, Vnimotmcc Vra PbV.A. Hax 39;3Kaalybir, IW :200:rbbcrbsjFyijaa.`ae =93-3=6-;=8;

@isb 2792-`v-6


28/49

8:

@BX\MCM@I\B AC PBXSM@B

@isb Oa. 92-


29/49

BZJMHM\ „I―

@isb 2792-`v-6


30/49

R careinny bxaobritbs bepnaybb i`ùsbl ac ri`minsnur

PBV\B BX 96\J, 86 92

[ XM\\ BO H] I G LA EB

H Beimn

BPR Motbrme Vrbs . L r. Gi`d mb S mbttmio swbrsq ubstmaosl urmok i obws à ocbrbò b [ bl obsliyihaut tjb cmolmoks i o movbs mki tmao motaioi nnbkblri`mi nmo`mlbot Vj ata h y IG La eb /DSAObws.

e pa rmiP i tbR omvbrsmtyjis p uhnm`nybxa bri tbl tj b bepnaybb i`` usbl ac nrm mok i ri` min snur tji t spi rdbl iomotbroi nmovbstmki tmaobirn mbr tj mssueebr

Motbrme Vrbsmlbot Lr Gi`dmb Smbttm iooa uo`bl j i t e avb \ ju rsl iy ta h bob t Lb h Xmkbrs , i naok meb bep nayb bi `ùsbl a c Mrmtmoktj b ri ` min s nurao i oa bh aad motjb P `ja anacNmhri ry io l Mocare i tmao E i oik bebo t hi`d mobirny I prmn.S mbttmsi ml tjb rb n s oa suhstio tmvb bvmlbo`b pral u`bl l urmok j b movbs mki tmao 6 nmodXmttkbrs ta j bmol lb o . Xmttkbrs iol a tj br P NM be pnaybbs s i ml tjby l ml oat wrmttj b warl mo qubs tmao. P j b i nsa accbrbl ta ti dbhatj i pa gyqripji ol j iolwot mok tbst ta ` nbirj br oi eb .

j t tp7//dvab . àe/obwsbltt/i 6088 bsu oa ri`mi n-l ms̀ rm emoittao ar jitb `rn eb n o snne lbpi rtebot Xbtrmbvbl crae DSAB wbhsmtb , < 80 86

@isb 2792-`v-6


31/49

Smbttm s̀ aeebots la o t oieb io yhaly hutio apbonbttbrcrae Lr Ebnvmo iol Iokb nmìJ inb tjbà upnbwjaei lb j b mommi ni nnbkit maosacri`mi nromsà au`t oiebs X mkbrs i s jb molmvmluin mo qubstmao. b J i nbssiyt jb mitt a roby Livml \ rbvmoa j i s s uhemttbls uhstio tmvbbvmlbo` b ta hi `dtj bmr ` nime.Lb timnsac tj it bvmlbo`b j iv b oathbb o rbnbisbl .

\j b J i nbs si y K bo Inb xiolbr tjblbi o ac tj b P `jaa nacNmhriry i ol Mocareit mao Eioi kb eb ot pra e msbl t amovbs tmki tb tj bmr̀ nimes hut l mlo i ol ` rbitbl i j astmnbward bovmraoeb otcar tj b ` aupnb. BP R Nbkin @a uosbn

DbvmoGajos ao si ml blobsli y tjb wardmok̀ aol mtmaos ` aunl j ivb me pravbl hut tjby l mloat qui nmcyis j astmnb.

I nbxi olb r Xmttkbrs i ol Eb nvmo Jinb rbe imobepna ybl hy BPR . Iok bnmì Ji nb rbsmkobl j br pa smtmao birnmbr tj mssueebr .

Ao [ blobsliy Be par mi Ptitb i ooauo `bl pn ios 6 ` rbitb i w ard kraup k birbl tawirls castbrmok i e arbmo`nusmvb i teaspjbrb is vbmni s pniost a rbvmb tj b ` urrbot krmbvio`b pa nmm̀bs io l pra` bl urbs ta ei db surb` aep nimots i rb j iol nbl ear b q um`dny.

\jbJi nb ji vb a rkio mzbl i i r` j ao e parmi sbt ta hbkmoit 706 ie \ub liya utsmlb Vnueh Jinn \ jb Ji nb

s iy tjb y /mnnàeebo i t tj b e i r`j Mctj it j i ppb os mt wau nl hb tj bmr cmrst motbrvmb P wmtj naì n eb l mii ctbr tjbinnbkit maos ` ieb ta nmkjt.

;706 pe [blobsliy7 BPR cmols oa ri`mi nlms`rmemoitmao ar jitb `rmeb mo PNG lbpirtebot

Be parmi Ptitb R omvbrsmtyjis l btbre moblt jb rb wis o a j i tb ` rmeb a r ri` min lms` rmemoitmao mo tj b P `jaa nacNmhriry iol Mocareitmao i oikbebo canma /mok i o i nnbkitmaoacri`mi ne msà olu`t stbeemok crae io mò mlbot t jmspis t sprmk.

Mo i ob P ` aocbrbo`b i t VM ehJinn vbaob sai y Mo brmeVrbsmlbot Lr Gi`dmb S mbttms i ml tjb mo broi nrbvmb ̂ wjm`j

ni tbr mol ul bl t 9

bxtbroi nà osuntiots movanvbl motbr .bws vmtj obirny 86 w mtobssbs i rbsu nbl moi 0 26.p ikbrbpart . Mtcauol i ri`mi nsnurj il hbbo zr ttbo ao i oabhaad mo tjb P NMEkril uitb iss msi ot accm̀b i ol wisl msàvb rbl hy i o uooiebl kril stulb ot \ jb mo`mlbo wis rbpa rtbl ta Iok bnmì J i nb iois smsti ot ta PNM LbioKwbo Inbxiolbr wjb o Inb xiolbr /is oa me ebl mitbny ivi mnihnb. PR Nbkin @auosb nDbvmo Gajosao s iys tjbbvmlbo`b s kkbstso a `rmebtaa d pni`b .

7 78=

Gajosao rm tmo k i [ arl Mso i @rmeb

Jb s iys tjb kril s tulb ot ile mttbl mo motbrvmb s tjit tjby j i l oa ml bi ja ` aunl vb w rmttbotj b snur ao tjboatbhaad i ol nbct mt j brb .

7 70:

Gajosao Ioy uehbr a c Vbapnb @aunl vb ...

@isb 2792-`v-6


32/49


33/49

DSAB Obws ji s hb bo mo beimn `aoti` w mtjtjb J inbs smo`bnist [)om kj . [ jbo i sdbl car i kbobr n ` aeeb ot,j b J i nbs mommin y rbcbrrbl us t a i Ci`b ha ad bvbot pikb car tjb i r j̀ ao eparmi . \ j i t nmodi`̀usbs e parmi

Pti b 6 p rì m̀mokmostm utmaoi nri `mse i ol tjb movbs Mkitma o s mepnyswbp wjit mt ` innbl hniti ot ri `mse uolbr j bruk. \jb Ji nbs armkmoi n s iml tjby l ms`avbrbl tjb ri `ms oa b moqubstmao i l meebl mitb nỳ aepni mobl . j boisdblta ` nirmcytjbtmeb nmob, DSAB bws wisl mrb t̀bl ta io apbo nbttbr ta I nbx olbr si ymokj b ri ` min bpmtjb nis lmrb`tbl i t j be i ol I nbx ol br cimnblta movbstmkitb is s jbpra emsbl - mos bil , ` rbi mok i j astmnb vardbovmraoebo ta j b p amowjbrbIok bnm̀i J i nb rbsmkobl .

\ j b J i nbs si y tjb y Smnnm̀aeebo it tj b e ir` j \ ubsli Mctjit j ppb os , Mt wau nl hb tjb mr cmrst e tbrvmb P wmtj na ì neb lmi i ctbr tj b innbki tmaos ` iebta nmkj t.

7 : 7 ;

Cunn BPRObw s aocbrbo`b Pbp. = 8692

DSAB O b MP L mrb`tar @ju`d P iepnbs ` aot rmhutbl ta tjms rbpart

@isb 2792-`v-6


34/49

BZJMHM\ „H―

@isb 2792-`v-6


35/49

BEIMN EBPPIKBP MO EI] 8692 XBKIXLMOK BSINRI\MAO

AC IOKBNM@I JINB ”P KXILRI\B IPPMP\IO\

Crae7 Iokbnmì JinbPbot7 \ubsliy, Eiy 62, 8692 3788 VE\a7 Kwbo InbxiolbrPuhgb`t7 XB7 KI bvinuitmaos

Jm Kwbo7

Iolrbw sbot tjb care ta eb nist wbbd, sa M cmnnbl mt aut iol kivb mt ta jme it tjit tmeb.

Iokbnmì

Crae7 Kwbo InbxiolbrPbot7 \ubsliy, Eiy 62, 8692 3786 VE\a7 Iokbnmì JinbPuhgb`t7 C[7 KI bvinuitmaos

Vnbisb cmnn tjms aut car Hrboli”s ward. \jiods. Kwbo

Crae7 Iolrbw PemtjPbot7 Crmliy, Eiy 69, 8692 =79< IE\a7 Emrij Law4 Xahmo Durz4 Pirij Puttao4 Ditjmb Hu`deio4 Iokbnmì Jinb4 Kwbo InbxiolbrPuhgb`t7 KI bvinuitmaos

Jm Cands7

Itti`jbl pnbisb cmol io bvinuitmao care car bvinuitmok yaur kriluitb issmstiot. M waunl krbitnyipprb`mitb yaur issmstio`b mo àepnbtmok tjms bvinuitmao, is wb irb ùrrbotny àolu`tmokmotbrvmbws ac hatj ùrrbot iol praspb`tmvb kriluitb issmstiots is wb naad ta sticc aur KI

pasmtmaos car obxt ybir.

Eioy tjiods,

Iolrbw

Iolrbw G. E. Pemtj, Vj.L.Issa`mitb Vracbssar & Issa`mitb LbioP`jaan ac Nmhriry iol Mocareitmao EioikbebotBeparmi Ptitb Romvbrsmty@iepus Hax


36/49

BZJMHM\ „@―

@isb 2792-`v-6


37/49

@isb 2792-`v-6


38/49

BZJMHM\ „L―

@isb 2792-`v-6


39/49

bnàeb! Nakmo| Pmkoup

2=¶Cbw@nauls

Jaeb Obws

Vastbl7 \jursliy, Pbptbehbr 96, 8692 =792 ie

Hy Gbssmb [ikaobr gbs smbFbep ar mi.à e | 6 àeebots

Ictbr io motbosmvb movbstmkitmao, Beparmi Ptitb Romvbrsmtyjis lbtbremobl tjit tjbrb wis oa ri`min lms`rmemoitmao motjb P`jaan ac Nmhriry iol Mocareitmao Eioikbebotcannawmok io innbkitmao ac ri`min emsàolu`t stbeemokcrae io mo`mlbot tjit a`ùrrbl mo Iprmn ac 8692.

Motbrme BPR Vrbsmlbot Gi`dmb Smbttm iol BPR Nbkin@auosbn Dbvmo Gajosao pirtm`mpitbl mo i obwsàocbrbo`b it BPR ao [blobsliy. Lurmok tjit obwsàocbrbo`b, tjb lua ioswbrbl tjrbb mepartiot qubstmaos

tjit kumlbl tjb movbstmkitmao.

Mo arlbr ta ioswbr tjasb qubstmaos iol ̀ aepnbtb tjbmovbstmkitmao, twa bxtbroin rbvmbwbrs, wja wbrb oatoiebl, ̀ aoùrrbl wmtj tjb cmolmoks iol tjb ebtjalsusbl car tjb movbstmkitmao. \jb movbstmkitmao mo`nulbl

motbrvmbws wmtj 9= wmtobssbs iol rbsuntbl mo ippraxmeitbny 026 pikbs ac oatbs, laùebotitmao iol atjbr mocareitmao.

[is i jitb `rmeb àeemttbl ao ar ihaut Iprmn :, 86921

Gajosao siys mt ms mepartiot ta oatb tjit tjbrb ms oa stitb ar cblbrin niw car „jitb ̀ rmebs.― Xitjbr, mc i `rmeb msàeemttbl iol io molmvmluin ms ̀ aovm`tbl ac tjit ̀ rmeb, i lbpirturb crae sbotbo`b ̀ aunl hb kriotbl ta mo`rbisb tjbsbotbo`b mc tjb ̀ rmemoin i`t wis eatmvitbl hy jitb.

Ao ar ihaut Iprmn :, 8692, i kriluitb stulbot cauol i ri`min snur wrmttbo ao jbr oatbhaad. \jb oatbhaad wis mo iraae tjit wis uona`dbl iol ouebraus pbapnb jil i``bss ta.

„Mt wis oat i prmvitb accm`b,― Gajosao siml. „Mt jil io apbo laar, wis i pni`b wjbrb tjmoks wbrb starbl. Vbapnbìeb mo iol aut ac tjit accm`b inn liy naok iol mt wis typmìnny oat na`dbl car east ac tjb liy ar bvbomok. I``bss tatjb PNME accm`bs irb passmhnb crae tjb nmhriry.―

\jb kriluitb stulbot cauol tjb snur iol ittbeptbl ta sjaw tjb mtbe ta tjb PNME lbio, wja wis oat mo jbr accm`b.\jb stulbot tjbo wbot ta tjb issmstiot ta tjb lbio, Iokbnmì Jinb, iol sjawbl jbr tjb snur. Jinb taad i pm`turb ac tjb oatbhaad wmtj tjb snur ao jbr ̀ bnn pjaob iol sjawbl mt ta jbr jushiol Ebnvmo Jinb, io issmstiot pracbssar motjb lbpirtebot.

„Oahaly hradb mota io accm`b, oahaly lml ioytjmok ̀ rmemoin mo arlbr ta kbt i``bss ta tjb oatbhaad iol tjbo wrmtb

BPR prbss àocbrbo`b

Jaeb Obws Pparts Ahmtuirmbs Apmomao @aeeuomty Irbi Obws Euntmeblmi B-Vipbr Ilvbrtmsb Vni`b i @ni@nissmcmbls

Vanm`b/@aurts/Cmrb Kavbroebot Husmobss Bluìtmao Jbintjìrb Ptitb Obws

stmkitmao ̀ ao`nulbs7 oa jitb `rmeb it BPR - Beparmi Kizbttb7 Obws jttp7//www.beparmikizbttb. àe/obws/irtm`nbQ`2bh3bc=-6;8i-2ccl-h:6=-...


40/49


41/49

@aeebotbl

Aonmob VannXbl cnik wiromoks mssubl hy tjb Oitma[bitjbr Pbrvm`b oaw insa molmìtb iàuoty-wmlb huro hio ms m o bccb`t. La yikrbb wmtj tjms `jiokb mo panm`y1

Cannaw Rs Ao Ci`bhaad

\wmttbr

stulbot wja tjb oatbhaad hbnaokbl ta lmsìrlbl tjb oatbhaad it tjb bol ac tjb sbebstbr.

Paeb jivb isdbl wjy tjb Jinbs wimtbl uotmn Guny ta rbpart tjb mo`mlbot ta Smbttm iol niw bocar`bebot, wjbo tjbi`tuin mo`mlbot a`ùrrbl mo Iprmn. Gajosao iol Smbttm ilvmsbl tjit tjby ̀ aunl oat spbid car tjb Jinbs.

\jb Jinbs jivb oat spadbo wmtj naìn eblmi rbkirlmok tjb mo`mlbot ar tjb movbstmkitmao rbsunts. \jbmr ittaroby aonyjil tjb cannawmok stitbebot.

„Ey ̀ nmbots iol M wmnn insa hb ebbtmok wmtj rbprbsbotitmvbs ac BPR ta lmsùss tjb rbpart,― \rbvmoa siml.

\jb Jinbs jivb s`jblunbl i eir`j ao ̀ iepus car Pbpt. 92 ta illrbss wjit tjby siy irb ào`bros ac ri`minlms`rmemoitmao.

\mebnmob ac bvbots

Ao ar irauol Iprmn :, 8692, i kriluitb stulbot mo PNME lmsàvbrbl i ri`min snur wrmttbo mo jms ar jbr oatbhaad,wjm`j wis nbct mo tjb kriluitb stulbots” accm`b. \jb stulbot rbpartbl tjb lmsàvbry ta Iokbnmì Jinb, tjbo issmstiotta tjb lbio. \jb lmsàvbry wis tjbo rbpartbl ta PNME Lbio Kwbo Inbxiolbr. \jbrb wis oa carein cannaw up ittjit tmeb.

Guny 9 “ Iokbnmì Jinb iol jbr jushiol, Ebnvmo Jinb, issmstiot pracbssar mo PNME, ̀ aoti`tbl Beparmi PtitbRomvbrsmty Vanm`b iol Picbty, tanl io accm`br ihaut tjb Iprmn mo`mlbot iol innbkbl tjit i ̀ a-wardbr jil wrmttbo tjbwarl.

Guny 8 “ BPR panm`b ̀ aepnbtbl mts rbvmbw iol lbtbremobl tjit oa jitb ̀ rmeb jil a`ùrrbl. \jb lbpirtebot”s

movbstmkitmvb oatbs wbrb carwirlbl ta tjb Nyao @auoty Ittaroby car rbvmbw. Ebnvmo Jinb ̀ aoti`tbl Motbrme VrbsmlbotGi`dmb Smbttm ta bxprbss jms lmssitmsci`tmao wmtj tjb panm`b cmolmok. Pjb i`doawnblkbl jms beimn.

Guny 2 “ Ebnvmo Jinb sbot io beimn ta Motbrme Vrbsmlbot Gi`dmb Smbttm bxprbssmok ̀ ao`bro ihaut tjb BPR panm`bmovbstmkitmao.

Guny 3 “ Smbttm rbspaolbl ta Jinb iol boàurikbl jme ta cmnb i àepnimot is autnmobl mo tjb Romvbrsmty Vanm`yEiouin.

Guny : “ Jinb mocarebl Smbttm tjit jb lml oat motbol ta cmnb i ̀ aepnimot uolbr uomvbrsmty panm`y mo tjb meeblmitbcuturb.

Guny = “ Nyao @auoty Ittaroby Eir` Kaaleio àoùrrbl wmtj tjb BPR panm`b cmolmok tjit i jitb `rmeb jil oata`ùrrbl.

Guny 96 “ Smbttm lmrb`tbl tjit io movbstmkitmao hb ̀ aolu`tbl is autnmobl mo tjb Romvbrsmty Vanm`y Eiouin.

Guny 9< “ Xiy Niuhbr, issa`mitb lmrb`tar ac Jueio Xbsaur`bs, niuo`jbl io movbstmkitmao. \jb lmrb`tar ac JX lmloat jiolnb tjb movbstmkitmao hbìusb sjb jil hbbo movanvbl mo birnmbr lmsùssmaos wmtj tjb Jinbs.

[bbd ac Iuk. 8< “ \wa molbpbolbot àosuntiots wbrb sbùrbl ta rbvmbw Beparmi Ptitb”s movbstmkitmao pra`bssiol cmolmoks. Aob wis io ittaroby iol tjb atjbr i jueio rbnitmaos ̀ aosuntiot wja ms i carebr ebehbr ac tjbJmkjbr Nbiromok @aeemssmao Hairl ac \rustbbs.

Earb ihaut Naìn

6


42/49

BZJMHM\ „B―

@isb 2792-`v-6


43/49

Pbir`j

Pbir`j

JaebVanm`mbsIlvbrtmsmokBepnayebotVanm`b XbpartsPticc

Obws Ápmomao ´Pparts ́Jarobt Nmcb ´Smlba ´Hnaks Ćunn Mssub\jb Hunnsjmt ´

Cmnbl uolbr Hrbidmok Obws , Obws

Beei Ioob LbVrmbst , sticc wrmtbr • Pbptbehbr 96, 8692 • Nbivb i @aeebot

unnbtmo 7 Movbstmkitmao rbvbins oa bvmlbo`b ac jitb ̀ rmeb jttp7//bsuhunnbtmo.àe/86638/obws/movbstmkitmao-rbvbins-oa-bvmlb


44/49


45/49


46/49

BZJMHM\ „C―

@isb 2792-`v-6


47/49

@isb 2792-`v-6


48/49

BZJMHM\ „K―

@isb 2792-`v-6


49/49

BEIMN CXAE IOKBNM@I JINB \A [BOL] @IXNPAO OA\MC]MOK JBX \JI\ \JB

BPR VANM@B LBVIX\EBO\ EMKJ\ HB @AO\I@\MOK JBX XB7 XM\\KBXP

JIOL[XM\MOK

Crae7 Iokbnmì Jinb\a7 [boly @irnsaoPbot7 [blobsliy, Guny 9, 8692 ;76; VEPuhgb`t7 Xb7 uplitb/Naolao Nbttbr/piyebot

Lbir [boly,

M gust wiotbl ta kmvb yau io uplitb. \jb ìepus panm`b ebt wmtj eb taliyrbkirlmok tjb jiolwrmtmok mo`mlbot iol M jivb oat hbbo ihnb ta kbt tjbNaolao Nbttbr laob (M ie pnioomok ta rbqubst tjit mt hb ilemomstbrbl). Mwaunl nmdb ta piy yau car tjb rbpart. M wis japmok ta jivb tjb Naolao Nbttbrrbsunts mo`nulbl tjaukj. Pjaunl M gust piy yau oaw car tjb rbsunts tjit yaujivb tjus cir1

M ìo eidb i piyebot ta yau hy Crmliy wjbo M kbt ey piy`jb`d.

\jiods,Iokbnmì

@isb 2792-`v-6

melvin hale opposition to defendant jackie vietti's motion to dismiss third amended complaint -...

Documents