microfinance annie
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
1
Micro Finance in Indiaoverview, challenges, and the role of
technology
By Annie Duflo Centre for Micro Finance Research
October 28, 2005
2
Outline of presentation
• What is microfinance?• Providing financial services to the poor:
challenges• Providing financial services to the poor
in India: Overview• Microfinance: Challenges ahead and
potential solutions/initiatives• The Centre for Micro Finance Research
3
Microfinance: what is it?
4
Microfinance: what is it?
What are the words that come to your mind when you hear the word microfinance?
5
Microfinance: what is it?
R4
R3
R1 / R2
Microfinance = provision of
financial services to the poor
48%
15%
37%
6
Microfinance: what is it?
• Micro-credit• Group lending• Social/charitable
activity
• Range of financial services
• Group and individual lending
• Profitable activity
What it often is What it really should be
7
Providing financial services to the poor: challenges
8
Providing financial services to the poor: challenges
• Risk management challenges due to information asymmetry problems
• Accessibility (geographic accessibility and easiness to deal with)
• No collateral, Low value and cash intensive nature of the business
• Staff training and motivation
High transaction
costs
9
Information asymmetry
Decision to take loanLoan usage loan repayment
Adverse selection
Moral hazard
10
Adverse selection: incomplete information problem (before the loan)
Don’t know Client’s type
Interest rate reflects proba of default
Safer clients drop outNeed to increase interest
rate
Providing credit can become
impossible
11
Moral hazard: hidden action problem (after loan)
Can not observe what client is doing
Bad loan usageStrategic unwillingness
To repay
12
Clients profile
• 75% population lives in rural areas: geographical access difficult
• Informal activities: need access at flexible times
• Illiteracy: difficult to deal with traditional services
• Low value of transactions• Lack of collateral
13
Staff
• Lack of trained staff• Lack of motivated staff• Difficult to incentives staff
14
Delivering financial services to the poor in India: an overview
15
Providing financial services to the poor: occupied India
Deccan, late 19th Century: peasant riots on account of coercive
alienation of land by moneylenders.
Organization of cooperative societies as alternative institutions for providing crédit by british government
16
Providing financial services to the poor:Independent India:Credit was viewed as essential part of fight
against poverty which led to following measures:
• Expansion of the institutional structure• Directed lending to disadvantaged borrowers
and sectors• Interest rates supported by subsidies• Institutional vehicles: cooperatives,
commercial banks and Regional Rural Banks [RRBs].
17
Providing financial services to the poor:Timeline• 1950 & 1969: emphasis on the promoting of
cooperatives. • 1969: nationalization of the major commercial
banks: beginning of commercial bank branch expansion in the rural and semi-urban areas.
• 1976: Regional Rural Banks (RRB), low cost institutions mandated to reach the poorest in credit-deficient areas
• During this period, intervention of the RBI (Reserve Bank of India) was essential: special credit programmes for channeling subsidized credit to the rural sector (concept of “priority sector”)
18
Financial reforms for RFIs
• Enhance the areas of commercial fredon• Increase their outreach to the poor• Stimulate additional flows to the sector. • Liberalising interest rates for cooperatives and
RRBs, • Relaxing controls on where, for what purpose
and for whom RFIs could lend, reworking the sub-heads under the priority sector,
• Introducing prudential norms• Restructuring and recapitalising of RRBs.
19
Results
• Access in terms of rural branches increased from 1,833 in 1969 to around 32,538 at present: 49% of all scheduled commercial bank branches are rural
• The population per rural branch declined from 2,01,854 in 1969 to around 16,000 at present.
• The proportion of borrowings of rural households from institutional sources increased from 7 per cent in 1951 to more than 60 per cent at present.
20
Results (cont’d)
• 31% (131.1 million) of the total deposit accounts are in rural India
• 43%(22.4 million) of total credit accounts are in rural India
• Positive impact on the poor (Rohini Pande/Burgess paper)
21
However…Success was not as high as hoped
• Defects in policy design,• Infirmities in implementation• Inability of the government of the day to desist
from resorting to measures such as loan waivers.• High defaults• The banking system - was not able to internalise
lending to the poor as a viable activity but only as a social obligation
• More and more difficult for commercial bankers to accept that lending to the poor could be a viable activity.
22
Micro Finance: apparition
• The financial sector reforms motivated policy planners to search for products and strategies for delivering financial services to the poor – microFinance - in a sustainable manner consistent with high repayment rates.
• NABARD: empirical observation that had been catalysed by NGOs that poors gather in informal groups
• Create a formal interface of these informal arrangements of the poor with the banking system.
• Bank-SHG Linkage Programme.• Recent emergence of MFIs: professionally run
institutions specialiazed in delivering credit with low cost staff and local knowledge
23
Despite all these efforts…large gaps remain
• Against rural population of 741.0 million, 500 million people un-served
• Population per branch: 22,793• Penetration of savings accounts is below 18%• As against 104% in urban and semi-urban areas• Number of villages per branch: 19• High dependence on informal sources
– 36% of rural credit from informal sources– Dependence even higher for lower income households:
78%
24
Microfinance ahead: challenges
25
Gaps in demand and supply
Demand: Rs. 450 billion/y
60% in South…to cover all parts of India
Less than 2 million Households reached
500 million un-served poor
Disbursed: 39 billion
Need employment opportunities
Need protection
against all risks
Market constraints
Insurance under-delivered
Scaling up
Increase
impact
26
Scaling up: challenges
27
Limitation of the predominant model
Bank SHG
NGO
Loan at 9%
No liabilit
y
Group formation/linka
ge
SHG-Bank linkage model
28
Financial Intermediation Model
MFI JLG GroupBank
Loan at a 9%
Loan at 20%
Scaling up existing MFIs: challenges
29
Limitations to growth of MFIs:
• Lack of adequate quantities of risk capital
• Lack of long-term finance to pay for creation of the necessary infrastructure and pre-operative expense
• Lack of well trained staff in adequate numbers at all levels
• technology
30
Lack of adequate capital: the ICICI Bank response
Searched for a model which:• Separates risk of MFI from risk inherent
in the mf portfolio• Provides a mechanisms to banks to
continuously incentivise partners• Inability of MFIs to provide risk capital in
large quantum, which limited advances from banks
31
The ICICI Bank Partnership Model
MFI JLG GroupBank
Servicing fees of 11%
Loan at 9%
Interest charged
: 20%FLDG of
10%
32
Long-term finance: the ICICI bank response
• There is an underlying business model in the MFI’s expansion: no reason why it cannot be funded by commercial debt
• ICICI Bank is offereing to its MFI partners long-term finance of a tenure of 3-5 years
33
Lack of well-trained staff: ICICI Bank response
• Initiated partnerships with training institutions (Indian Grameen Services, Care India)
• Establish a Financial Services Learning School in collaboration with MicroSave India
• Provide high level training in banking and finance to MFI practitioners in collaboration with IFMR (Institute for Financial Management Research)
34
Technology
Role of technology in microfinance:• MIS• Cash handling• Data capture and subsequent
management
35
Technology: ICICI Bank response
• Creation of rural connectivity in partnership with telecom companies and internet service providers
• Assistance to emerging MFIs to adopt scalable MIS solutions
• Support to research and development on technological devices that can reduce transaction costs– Low cost ATMs, low-cost computing devices,
mobile and internet-based transaction platforms
36
Scaling up: creation of new MFIs
Need 200 MFIs to cover all India• ICICI Bank (SIG): support to entrepreneurs to start
MFIs– KAS Foundation, Orissa
• Inputs are needed:– Organizational and staff incentive structures– Finance related issues (source of funds, capital structure)– Legal issues: regulations etc.– Business plan related issues: scale, expansion strategy etc.
• Corporate partnerships: attractive track to build access to microfinance
37
Support new MFIs: The Venture Capitalist model
• VCs specifically focused on the micro-finance space: Lok Capital, Aavishkar and Bellwether.
• Bellwether– three equity commitments for start-ups– increased the size of fund from 10mn USD to 25mn
USD.
• ICICI Bank solution:– Each MFI will need to reach a minimal CRISIL or an
MCRIL operational sustainability rating – Then the entrepreneur buys out the stake of the VC
and ICICI Bank gives an option to the entrepreneur to take a long-term debt to finance this buy out.
38
Scaling-up: what form of support is needed?
• Interest rates should reflect the costs of transactions/probability of default and be sustainable
• Focus on diminishing the cost of these transactions and expand access
Equity support, Remove caps and floors, create facilitative infrastructure
to reduce transaction costs
39
Alternate channels
• Agent model– Model of LIC– Challenge: control fraud
• Internet connectivity– BSNL: if wireless system installed ate the
existing connected rural exchanges: 80-85% of villages could be connected
– Variety of devices that can work with internet kiosks: biometric low-cost ATMs
– Makes controlling fraud easier
40
Internet Kiosks
Connectivity
STD/PCO: •Enabling voice communication
Printer & Other
Accessories : Enabling job
work
Kiosk Operator:•Entrepreneur•Provides commercial services
Internet KioskInternet KioskMultimedia PC with Power
backup
41
Internet kiosks
• ITC, nLogue, Drishtee: more than 6000 internet kiosks using Wireless in Local Loop, VSAT terminals
• ICICI partnered with some of these organizations– Finance individual entrepreneurs to purchase
operating license and equipment– Break even within 1st year– Suite of financial services– 2000 kiosks
42
Internet kiosks: remaining gaps
• Providing constant connectivity expensive
• Finding motivated entrepreneurs difficult
• Break even has been delayed for various reasons (required back-end systems to service clients difficult tp find etc.)
43
ICICI Bank strategy: summary
Conventional Rural Banking
Conventional Rural Banking
Branch based
Branch based
Manpowerintensive
Manpowerintensive
Productdriven
Productdriven
Single product
Single product
Our strategy
Our strategy
Hybrid channels
Hybrid channels
Technology
intensive
Technology
intensive
Customerdriven
Customerdriven
Multiple products
Multiple products
44
Maximize impact of microfinance: challenges
45
Maximize impact
VulnerabilityNeed for
More than credit
Differences amongcustomers
Need for customized
products
Understand what programmes work the bestand for whom
46
Maximize impact
Employment scarcity
Other constraints
Finance other credit constraint segments
MFI-sectoral expertsPartnerships
Local Financial Institution: serving all credit constraint-Segments in 2-3 districts
47
Range of Microfinancial services:
• Individual lending– Information problem– No unique ID– No credit info sharing– Need technology!
• Insurance– Adverse selection, moral hazard, fraud
48
Range of Microfinancial services:
• Health insurance– Reimbursement model– Cashless model– How to identify illness? – How to avoid fraud?
• Livestock insurance– Recognize cause of death– Identify animal (role of technology)
49
Range of Microfinancial services:
• Weather insurance– Index-based: index created by assigning
weights to critical time periods– Past weather data mapped to this index to
arrive at normal treshhold index– If deviation: compensation
• Commodity price derivatives– NCDEX: offers price discovery services: offer
farmers instruments to hedge pre and post harvest risks
– Makes using commodity as collateral possible
50
Range of Microfinancial services:
• Savings and investments products– Could be offered through Money Market
Mutual Fund: MFI acts as agent
• Remittances– 10 million seasonal and circular migrants
(National Commission on Rural Labour)– Adhikar, Orissa– ICICI: remittance product through internet
kiosks
51
Key enablers needed for maximize impact and scaling up
• Credit Bureau• Unique identifier• Technology platform• Rural infrastructure• Change in regulations (interest rates
et.)• Training institutions• Research
52
CMFR: The Centre for Micro Finance
Research
53
Objectives
• Fill gaps in understanding of microfinance: – Extent and channels of impact– What programme designs work and what do
not?– What programme variants can increase impact?
• Fill gaps in practice of microfinance: limitation to micro-credit, lack of financial capacity
54
Mission
The Centre for Micro Finance Research will aim to help improve the life of the poor by:
• Systematically researching the links between access to financial services and the participation of the poor in the larger economy
• Participating in maximizing access to financial services and its impact for poor through: – Research on micro finance and livelihood financing– Research-based policy advocacy– High level training for practitioners and institutions– Strategy building for Micro Finance Institutions
55
Strategy
ResearchInfluence practice
Advocacy
Strategybuilding
Training
56
Partnerships
CMFR
Banks/Insurance Companies
International organizations
MFIs/NGOs
Universities
Regulators/policymakers
57
CMFR: Research Areas
58
Impact of Microfinance
Access to Financial services
Impact?
Advocacy based on rigorous results
?
59
Constraints to Productivity
Impact
Health
infrastructure
entrepreneurship
Access toFinancial services
Inputs
•Build relevant partnerships•Provide useful products through credit
60
Economics of Micro-Enterprise
• Scale, Returns, Constraints of micro-enterprise
• Market linkages• Documentation of best practices
Help increase productivity of micro-enterprise
61
Experimentation on Product Design
selection monitoring Enforcement
•Individual/group liability•Self/MFI selection•Guarantors•Collaterals•Interest rate
•Repayment schedule•Communication strategies•Loan size•Interest rate
Design the most cost-effective products
•Within group monitoring•Staff supervision
62
Behavior and Psychology of Borrowers
• How do households face shocks and risk?• Do households save and how?• What drives savings and credit behavior?• Why do people default?• Why don’t households adopt the most
profitable activities?
Design the most effective communication strategies
63
MFI Policies: Impact
• How do MFIs policies affect loans and repayment behavior of clients?– Staff incentives– Combination of different products– Compulsory savings or insurance
Understand better impact of policies over time
64
Cost and profitability of SHGs/MFIs
BankTransaction
?Micro-loan9% 25%
Return?
•How to reduce transaction costs?•Compare costs of SHG-Bank linkage and MFI model•Show investors risk return performance of microloans
65
Research: other initiatives
66
Research: Panel Databases
• Construction of a panel database: repeated observations of same households– Study vulnerability, consumption patterns over
time– Have a panel database for on-going research
• Construction of a cross-sectional survey– Document access to financial services over time
67
Research: weekly seminar series
• Foregone seminars– Prof Ashok Jhunjhunwala (IIT Chennai), – Prof Vaidyanathan (Madras Institute of Development
Studies)– Prof Sendhil Mullainathan, Harvard– GN Bajpai, ex-Chairman of SEBI– Greg Fisher, MIT …..
• Forthcoming seminars: – Suresh Sundaresan, Columbia – Dr Narendra Jadhav, RBI …..
68
Research: Courses
• Economics of Micro Finance– Prof. Adel Varghese, TAMU– Economic theory of microfinance
• Evaluating Social Programmes– Professors from the Poverty Action Lab/MIT:
Esther Duflo (MIT), Abhijit Banerjee (MIT), Sendhil Mullainathan (Harvard), Michael Kremer (Harvard)
– Teach practitioners and researchers how to identify programs’ impacts without bias
69
MFI Strategy Unit at CMFR
70
Strategy Building
MFIsSectoralExperts
Pilots
Scale-up LFI
71
Training
• Building blocks of Banking and Finance Training Programs
• Meet training needs of the sector: In collaboration with MicroSave India– Development of national curriculum – Collaboration with 6 Regional Training
Institutes
72
THANK YOU!