Mismatched understandings?

Findings from a study of vulnerability

Kate Brown

Vulnerability and young people

What it’s not about…

How to measure vulnerability, how to recognise or ‘cure’ it etc.

Instead:

Exploring ideas about vulnerability from different perspectivesKey points/questions for consideration

Why vulnerability?

Interest from work with ‘sexually exploited’ YP

Lyndsay – grew up in care, selling sex and using heroin since 12 (2004):

“some kids get left out of being seen as victims. They don’t seem vulnerable, but just because they don’t seem vulnerable, doesn’t mean they aren’t.”

Older children in need often present as ‘badly behaved’; whether in trouble with the criminal justice system, abusing drugs or alcohol, going missing, truanting, self-harming, or in other ways [….] this can mask their vulnerability, and lead professionals to ‘blame’ or judge children…

(House of Commons Education Committee, 2012: 34)

Quick outline of the study

25 interviews with ‘vulnerable’ young people (intensive support, aged 12-18)

15 interviews with professionals (commissioners, managers, ‘front line’ workers)

Sampling - Young women and young men, 12-18 years old, 7/25 BME YP, range of vulnerabilities, and half young people were ‘troublesome’

‘Peter Schmeichel’Aged 16

JadeAged 17

Relevant Findings

Official understandings of vulnerability and idea of ‘vulnerable groups’

Vulnerability and ‘difficult behaviour’ - closely linked

Young people’s perceptions of vulnerability very different to ‘official’ views

Young people’s ideas about addressing vulnerability (resilience)

The view from professionals: ‘vulnerability’ differed according to personal judgements and setting

… differences in people’s levels of acceptability (ASB worker)

A number of government initiatives have used vulnerability in a different way and that's reflected in the local authority structure and the result is a lot of debate and confusion around where boundary lines are drawn around vulnerability (Commissioner, City Council)

Discretion important, so practices are more plasticine than they seem – difficult to research?

Which young people are

‘vulnerable’?

Vulnerable group or circumstances No. of informants‘Sexually exploited’ young women* 9Parental abuse/neglect/poor parenting 7Drug and alcohol use* 6Homeless/poorly housed 6Offending behaviour/ getting ‘in trouble’* 6Parental drug/alcohol use 5Parental domestic violence 5Looked after children 4Not achieving at school 4Mental health issues 4Learning difficulties 3Gypsy and traveller young people 3Significant health problems 3Parents who offend 3Young carers 3English as second language 3Disabled young people 2Asylum seekers and refugees 2Those who run away* 2Living in poverty 2Self-harm* 2BME backgrounds 2Parents with mental health issues 2NEET* 2

Adversity packages Difficult lives, multiple disadvantage… Family problems? Or wider structures and systems:

… it would be about when I were just turning fifteen. My Mum were with a really good mate of hers, a bloke, and I got touched by him, so and he got took to thingy and that when I were younger… To t’police and then nowt come of it (Jay Jay, M, 17)

In the end I ended up running away and being homeless and they wouldn’t find me anywhere else to live because I was getting bullied this children’s home (Alicia, F, 16)

When you’ve got money, like, everything seems to be fine, there’s, like, no stress to lead to family arguments or things like that (Hayley, F, 16)

Which young people are

‘vulnerable’?

Vulnerable group or circumstances No. of informants‘Sexually exploited’ young women* 9Parental abuse/neglect/poor parenting 7Drug and alcohol use* 6Homeless/poorly housed 6Offending behaviour/ getting ‘in trouble’* 6Parental drug/alcohol use 5Parental domestic violence 5Looked after children 4Not achieving at school 4Mental health issues 4Learning difficulties 3Gypsy and traveller young people 3Significant health problems 3Parents who offend 3Young carers 3English as second language 3Disabled young people 2Asylum seekers and refugees 2Those who run away* 2Living in poverty 2Self-harm* 2BME backgrounds 2Parents with mental health issues 2NEET* 2

‘Poor behaviour’ and vulnerability Jess (15): In 2009, I was abused by my Dad and that was when I got my social worker. They tried to get me a foster home, but because I didn’t want to stay there, my behaviour got bad. That’s when I was selling sex.

Scott (18): I've got big scars on my arms and that where I've been attacked with knives and stuff because, I don't know, I've been in [housing estate] and I've been on my own and I’ve still looked for a fight. I don't know, I like being on the floor getting booted in the head sometimes

Vulnerable young people often not ‘weak’, deferent, ‘innocent victims’

Link between behaviour and social and economic circumstances

‘Poor behaviour’ and vulnerability

... poor behaviour and vulnerability is absolutely the hardest thing to deal with. Without question. If you’re vulnerable and you’re compliant... you know… vulnerable and awkward is a totally different ball game. (Commissioner, City Council)

Rarely recognised in policy? – YP imagined as ‘vulnerable victims’ or ‘dangerous wrong-doers’

Vulnerable when demonstrated…“Compliance”“engagement”“motivation for change”being forthcoming with details

... if someone’s lived at home and they’re just being naughty and they keep going into prison, we wouldn’t say that’s vulnerability – that’s just them they’re not abiding by the rules and they just think it’s a joke and they think it’s a game… (Manager, Housing Service)

Ideas about ‘vulnerability’ lead to exclusion of ‘most vulnerable’? How far do services “Cherry-pick the easy to engage”? (Social Care Manager) especially in times of limited resources and competition

More about performance than circumstance?

… aggression sometimes from young, 15 or 16 [year old]... big lads coming in can sort of make you look at them differently. It shouldn’t do but it can. (Manager, Education Service)

I don’t think I’ve ever heard of someone saying ‘he’s a vulnerable lad’ ever, but I’ve heard loads and loads of people say ‘oh, she’s a vulnerable girl’ and all this (Alicia)

See also Cramer (2005) and Passaro (1996) - vulnerability, gender, housing

How does gender fit?

Young people’s views of vulnerability

Kate: What about if workers said that you were vulnerable?

Charlie: I'd tell them to shut up.

Kate: Why?

Charlie: 'Cos I'm not vulnerable. They just chat a load of shit. […] I think I'm doing well for myself, and if [Social Worker] just said that I was vulnerable, then it'd make me feel like I'm doing loads of things I shouldn't be.

More about resistance

Not all resistant, and not always, past and future was different

Different views of situations, relative responses

Tensions: family loyalty, acceptable behaviour, ‘nosiness’, clashes over independence

Chris (17) “Absolutely not vulnerable at all…”

People have even more difficulties than me. This might not be such a big thing. I've seen other people have more difficulties even worser than these. Yeah it's difficult, but not difficult difficult, I’d say.

Wadren (17): … they were basically blaming my Mum so… which made me lose my temper.

Jess (15): [Social Worker] helped by putting me in care, but she didn’t really help me ‘cos I’m not allowed to go out by myself ‘cos I put myself in too much risk.

Brook (16): Basically, he [YOS Worker] wanted to know the ins and outs of a cat's arse. He wanted to know everything. Things that he didn't need to know, he just wanted to know.

Mismatched understandings

Responded to the idea of a ‘difficult life’, but most YP were resistant to vulnerability classifications

Raises questions…

How far young people’s understandings subjugated?

Legitimacy of classification systems used in practice and research? Further work needed on young people’s classifications/assessments?

Views on resilience Friends, family, informal networks – varied.

Where limited family/friends, services very significant:

Timeliness

Trust/‘being taken seriously’

Short term interventions and struggles with transition

Limitations of speaking interventions – action!

What do factors have in common?

A mixed bag of conclusions

More questions than answers…Some suggestions for further reflection: • Adversity packages • ‘Difficult’ behaviour and vulnerability• Line between family and society • Gender expectations and intervention patterns• Austerity, outcome pressures and cherry picking? • YP don’t see lives as ‘problematic’ in same way as

professionals/policy-makers • Legitimacy of services and interventions• Specialism/multi-agency working – research/practice

approach designed to suit adults? • Relationship with workers• Importance of time