misra,d.c.(2009) change management for e government 24.10.2009
DESCRIPTION
This presentation deals with change management (CM) for e-government. It highlights various models of CM and lays emphasis on CM plan for e-government which should be part of an over-all e-business plan for e-government.TRANSCRIPT
Change Management for Change Management for
E-government E-government
byby
Dr D.C.MISRADr D.C.MISRA
22
A Presentation A Presentation
byby
Dr D.C.MISRADr D.C.MISRA
eGov ConsultanteGov Consultant
New Delhi, IndiaNew Delhi, India
Tel: 91-11-22452431Tel: 91-11-22452431
E-mail: dc_misra [at] hotmail.comE-mail: dc_misra [at] hotmail.com
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
33
Importance of ChangeImportance of Change
“ …“ …..that it is not the strongest of the ..that it is not the strongest of the species that survive, species that survive,
nor the most intelligent, nor the most intelligent,
but that are most responsive to but that are most responsive to change…..”change…..”
--------- Charles Darwin --------- Charles Darwin
(No evidence that Darwin said or wrote it!)(No evidence that Darwin said or wrote it!)
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
44
What is proposed to be What is proposed to be covered?covered?
I.I. DefinitionDefinitionII.II. Dimensions of ChangeDimensions of ChangeIII.III. Types of ChangeTypes of ChangeIV.IV. Models of ChangeModels of ChangeV.V. Change in GovernmentChange in GovernmentVI.VI. Change due to E-Change due to E-
governmentgovernmentVII.VII.ConclusionConclusion
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
55
I. Definition I. Definition
What is What is ChangeChange??
A new and unfamiliar state.A new and unfamiliar state. What is What is Change ManagementChange Management ? ?
A A systematic approachsystematic approach to dealing to dealing with change. with change.
Change Management has several Change Management has several dimensionsdimensions::
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
66
II. Dimensions of ChangeII. Dimensions of Change
1.1. StateState: Present and New State: Present and New State2.2. TransitionTransition: From Present to New State: From Present to New State3.3. PlanningPlanning: For change: For change4.4. ImplementationImplementation: For change: For change5.5. TechnologyTechnology: Change for new technology: Change for new technology6.6. TrainingTraining: For change: For change 7.7. CostCost: Cost-Benefit Analysis of change: Cost-Benefit Analysis of change8.8. Monitoring and EvaluationMonitoring and Evaluation: Of change: Of change9.9. AdoptionAdoption: By organisation and individuals: By organisation and individuals10.10. Change ManagementChange Management: Managing change: Managing change
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
77
III. Types of ChangeIII. Types of Change
1.1. PlannedPlanned and and EmergentEmergent (Unplanned) (Unplanned) ChangesChanges
2.2. EpisodicEpisodic (Replacement of one (Replacement of one programme by another) and programme by another) and ContinuousContinuous (ongoing/incremental) Changes(ongoing/incremental) Changes
3.3. DevelopmentalDevelopmental (improving existing (improving existing situation-first order), situation-first order), TransitionalTransitional (new (new state-second order) and state-second order) and TransformationalTransformational (radical, second order) (Ackerman)(radical, second order) (Ackerman)
4.4. Change Change due todue to E-government E-government5.5. Change Change forfor E-government E-government
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
88
IV. Models of ChangeIV. Models of Change
1.1. 7 S Model7 S Model2.2. PESTELI ModelPESTELI Model3.3. Five WhysFive Whys4.4. Theory of Constraints Theory of Constraints 5.5. Forced Field AnalysisForced Field Analysis6.6. CEC ModelCEC Model7.7. Business Process ReengineeringBusiness Process Reengineering8.8. Beckhard and Harris ModelBeckhard and Harris Model9.9. ADKAR ModelADKAR Model10.10. Change Management IcebergChange Management Iceberg
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
99
1. 7S Model1. 7S Model
Waterman, Peters and Phillips (1980) developed it working for McKinsey
Peters and Waterman surveyed 62 successful US companies in the late 1970s using the 7S Model.
Their book In Search of Excellence (1982) became a management bestseller in 1980s
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
1010
7S Model7S Model
1. Strategy (Plan of Action)2. Structure (Organisational
Chart)3. Systems (Procedures)4. Staff (Personnel)5. Style (Management Style)6. Shared values (Guiding values)7. Skills (Capabilities)
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
1111
2. PESTEL Model2. PESTEL Model
It is a It is a checklistchecklist for understanding for understanding change:change:
P: Political factorsP: Political factors
E: Economic factorsE: Economic factors
S: Social factorsS: Social factors
T: Technological factorsT: Technological factors
E: Ecological factorsE: Ecological factors
L: Legislative factorsL: Legislative factors© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
1212
3. Five Whys3. Five Whys
Senge et al. (1994) Simple tool for analysis of a Problem Why? (My Internet connection broke down) Why? (There were repairs in nearby room) Why? (His Internet connection broke down) Why? (There was no proper maintenance) Why? (There was no supervision) Answer: Repairs must be supervised.
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
1313
4. Theory of Constraints4. Theory of Constraints Goldratt and Cox, 1993 Goldratt and Cox (1992): The Goal,
Goldratt (1994): It’s not luck, Goldratt (1997): Critical Chain, Goldratt and Cox (2004): The Goal : A Process of Ongoing Improvement
View a process as a whole. (All phases) Identify constraints that impede the flow Ease the identified constraints to improve
the flow The flow at the slowest phase will be the
speed of flow of the entire process.
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
1414
5. Forced Field Analysis5. Forced Field Analysis
Force field analysis (Lewin, 1951) Tells us whether organisational
change will occur. Based on concept of “force,” or
people’s perception of change Driving forces Restraining forces Equilibrium
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
1515
Forced Field AnalysisForced Field Analysis
Lewin’s Three Fundamental Assertions:1. Increasing the driving forces results in an
increase in the resisting forces; the current equilibrium does not change but is maintained under increased tension.
2. Reducing resisting forces is preferable because it allows movement towards the desired state, without increasing tension.
3. Group norms are an important force in resisting and shaping organisational change.
Source: Iles and Sutherland 2001
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
1616
6. The CEC Model6. The CEC Model Peter Senge, founder of the Centre for Organizational Peter Senge, founder of the Centre for Organizational
Learning, MIT's Sloan School of ManagementLearning, MIT's Sloan School of Management Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of Learning Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of Learning
OrganisationOrganisation (1990) (1990) Difference between Commitment, Enrolment and Compliance Commitment-Apathy Continuum No need to for everyone to be “fully committed” to change Analyse who needs to change and to what extent and draw straegy for change accordingly
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
1717
The CEC ModelThe CEC Model
Commitment, Enrolment and Commitment, Enrolment and ComplianceCompliance
Commitment
Enrolment
Genuine Compliance
Formal Compliance
Grudging Compliance
Non-compliance
Apathy
Figure: Commitment-Apathy Continuum
Source: Based on Iles and Sutherland 2001
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
1818
7. Business Process 7. Business Process ReengineeringReengineering
Hammer and Champy (1993) BPR: ... the fundamental rethinking and radical
redesign of business processes to achieve dramatic improvements in critical, contemporary measures of performance such as cost, quality, service and speed.
Steps in BPR: 1. Prepare the organisation2. Fundamentally rethink the way that work
gets done3. Restructure the organisation around the
new business process.4. Implement new information and
measurement systems to reinforce change.
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
1919
8. Beckhard and Harris Change 8. Beckhard and Harris Change ModelModel
Beckhard and Harris Change Model (1987) is Beckhard and Harris Change Model (1987) is a formulaa formula
It is attributed to David GleicherIt is attributed to David Gleicher It supercedes Taylor’s scientific management It supercedes Taylor’s scientific management
(Taylorism) based on “command-and-control” (Taylorism) based on “command-and-control” aproach which assumed:aproach which assumed:
Workers work, Managers thinkWorkers work, Managers think Taylorism, reflective of industrial age, has Taylorism, reflective of industrial age, has
been replaced by “human relations been replaced by “human relations movement” recognising worker involvementmovement” recognising worker involvement
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
2020
Beckhard and Harris Change Beckhard and Harris Change ModelModel
Beckhard and Harris formula states thatBeckhard and Harris formula states that
D x V x F > RD x V x F > R
where D= Dissatisfactionwhere D= Dissatisfaction
V= VisionV= Vision
F= First StepsF= First Steps
R= ResistanceR= Resistance Note that no factor on left hand side Note that no factor on left hand side
should be zero, otherwise change will also should be zero, otherwise change will also be zero.be zero.
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
2121
9. The ADKAR Model9. The ADKAR Model
AwarenessAwareness of the need to change of the need to change DesireDesire to participate and support to participate and support
the changethe change KnowledgeKnowledge of how to change (and of how to change (and
what the change looks like)what the change looks like) AbilityAbility to implement the change on to implement the change on
a day-to-day basisa day-to-day basis ReinforcementReinforcement to keep the change to keep the change
in placein place
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
2222
10. Change Management 10. Change Management IcebergIceberg
This model of Wilfried Krüger deals This model of Wilfried Krüger deals with barriers to changewith barriers to change
It is strong visualisation of change in It is strong visualisation of change in organisationsorganisations
The tip of the iceberg is seen by The tip of the iceberg is seen by change managers while the rest is change managers while the rest is ignoredignored
Change managers thus consider Cost, Change managers thus consider Cost, Quality and Time (Issue Management)Quality and Time (Issue Management)
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
2323
Change Management Change Management IcebergIceberg
Below the surface there are two more Below the surface there are two more dimensions of Change and dimensions of Change and Management:Management:
(i) Management of Perceptions and(i) Management of Perceptions and
BeliefsBeliefs
(ii) Power and Politics Management(ii) Power and Politics Management Below the surface are Below the surface are PromotersPromoters, ,
OpponentsOpponents, , Hidden OpponentsHidden Opponents and and Potential PromotersPotential Promoters
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
2424
V. Change in GovernmentV. Change in Government
Sources of Change in GovernmentSources of Change in Government Electoral ProcessElectoral Process, for example, General , for example, General
Elections every five yearsElections every five years Such change in Government means Such change in Government means
basic basic
“ “3P Changes,” namely, in Policies, 3P Changes,” namely, in Policies, Programmes and PersonnelProgrammes and Personnel
Legislative ProcessLegislative Process, for example, by , for example, by passing an act of Parliamentpassing an act of Parliament
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
2525
Change in GovernmentChange in Government Such change may create new entities like Such change may create new entities like
Department of IT, Computer Board and CIODepartment of IT, Computer Board and CIO MediaMedia, for example, by urging change in , for example, by urging change in
specific public policies and programmesspecific public policies and programmes SocietySociety, for example, by inducing changes , for example, by inducing changes
in public policies and programmes due to in public policies and programmes due to increased expectations, availability of new increased expectations, availability of new technology, etc.technology, etc.
Civil ServiceCivil Service, for example, by suggesting , for example, by suggesting changes in public policies and programmes changes in public policies and programmes while contributing to their development or while contributing to their development or implementing themimplementing them
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
2626
VI. Change due to E-VI. Change due to E-governmentgovernment
Fear of new TechnologyFear of new Technology Disrtuptive nature, break with pastDisrtuptive nature, break with past Lack of Knowledge and Skills in Computer Lack of Knowledge and Skills in Computer
hardware and softwarehardware and software Diffficulties in joining Gov with IT to make Diffficulties in joining Gov with IT to make
E-gov, or Gov+IT=E-govE-gov, or Gov+IT=E-gov Radically new methods of working and Radically new methods of working and
proceduresprocedures Absence of Training/Coaching/Ready HelpAbsence of Training/Coaching/Ready Help
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
VII ConclusionVII Conclusion
Change is very difficult to achieve in Change is very difficult to achieve in E-governmentE-government
A carefully drawn up change A carefully drawn up change management plan prepared in management plan prepared in consultation with all stakeholders consultation with all stakeholders alone can helpalone can help
The change management plan should The change management plan should be part of a larger e-business plan for be part of a larger e-business plan for e-governmente-government
2727© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009
2828
Change Management for Change Management for E-governmentE-government
With this I conclude my With this I conclude my presentation.presentation.
Thank you for your Thank you for your attention. attention.
And Have a Nice Day!And Have a Nice Day!
© Dr D.C.Misra 2009© Dr D.C.Misra 2009October 24, 2009October 24, 2009