modeling sediment transport along the upper …...modeling sediment transport along the upper texas...

26
Modeling Sediment Transport Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed, Jefferson County Highway 87 roadbed, Jefferson County

Upload: others

Post on 10-Mar-2020

8 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

Modeling Sediment TransportModeling Sediment TransportAlong the Upper Texas CoastAlong the Upper Texas Coast

David B. King Jr.Jeffery P. WatersWilliam R. Curtis

Highway 87 roadbed, Jefferson CountyHighway 87 roadbed, Jefferson County

Page 2: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

Galveston District – Corps of EngineersSabine Pass to San Luis Pass

Shoreline Erosion Feasibility Study

Page 3: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

ERDC’s Role in the FeasibilityStudy

• WIS wave hindcast• ADCIRC water level and currents• Sediment Budget• SBEACH storm-induced beach changes• STWAVE / GENESIS longterm shoreline change modeling

Page 4: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

Status

• Develop numerical modeling tools to predictshoreline change

• Use these tools to evaluate design alternativesfor erosion control, storm damage reduction, andenvironmental restoration

• Final design refinement and optimization

Current

Near Future

Page 5: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

SBEACH(Storm-induced BEAch CHange)

• Numerical Model for simulating cross-shore beachchange

• Intended use is to predict short-term beach profileresponse to storms

Page 6: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

Hurricane Claudette landfallHurricane Claudette landfall

centralcentral TexasTexas coastcoast

JulyJuly 15, 200315, 2003

SBEACH Calibration

Page 7: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

Hurricane Claudette Beach Erosion

Page 8: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

Data Inputs

Pre- and Post-Storm Profiles

Waves and Water Levels

Page 9: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

Example ResultBolivar Peninsula Recession at 2.5 meters

-5

0

5

10

15

-5 0 5 10 15

Measured Recession (m)

Pred

icte

d R

eces

sion

(m)

No TubeGeo Tube

Page 10: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

GENESIS(GENEralized model for SImulating

Shoreline change)

• Numerical Model for simulating along-shore beachchange

• Intended use is to predict long-term shorelineevolution

Page 11: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

GENESIS Calibration

Data• WIS hindcast waves• WIS windfields• NOS Bathymetry• Texas BEG shorelines

and change rates

Tools• STWAVE - transforms

offshore waves to near-breaking depths

• GENESIS - predictslongshore transport ratesand long term beachevolution

Page 12: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

Shoreline Change Rates - Galveston Island

Page 13: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

Shoreline Change Rates – High Island

Page 14: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

Differences inChange Rates

• Differences in shoreline definitions

• Errors in the data and the analysisprocedure

• Natural variations in the shorelinechange rate at different times

Page 15: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

Published Transport RatesBales, J. D. and Holley, E. R.

(1989). Sand transport in Texas tidalinlet, JWPCO Eng, 115 (4), 427-443.

Hall, G. L. (1975). Sediment transportprocesses in the nearshore watersadjacent to Galveston Island and BolivarPeninsula, Ph. D. diss., Texas A&M.

Mason, C. (1981). “Hydraulics andstability of five Texas inlets,” Misc PaperCERC-81-1.

Prather, S. H. and Sorensen, R. M.(1972). “An investigation of RolloverPass, Bolivar Peninsula, Texas,”. TAMU-SG-72-202.

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.(1983). “Galveston County shoreerosion study, Feasibility report onbeach erosion

• Published reports indicate nettransport is to the southwestalong all or almost all of thestudy area.

• Net rates are generally withinthe 30,000 – 150,000 m3/yrrange to the southwest.

Page 16: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

West End of Galveston Seawall

February 2003

Page 17: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

Angle and Sign Convention

Page 18: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

Wave Angles

Page 19: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

Preliminary TransportCalculations

• Use offshore WIS wave data – 10 years of hourlydata

• Remove offshore traveling waves• Simple Snell’s Law transformation to breaking depth• Transport rate from “CERC” formula

Net longshore sediment transport rate results:High Island – 75,000 m3/yr to southwestGalveston Island – 135,000 m3/yr to northeast

Page 20: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

High Energy Wave Angles

Page 21: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

Solution Attempts• Earlier WIS hindcast 1976-1995• NOAA Buoy 42035 data (off Galveston)• Different definitions of wave angle and period• Influence of coastal currents

Nothing shifted the direction of net transport onGalveston Island to the southwest . . .

until we investigated the influence of local winds.

Page 22: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

Local Wind Effects

• Affects wave transformations (STWAVE).

• Modifies surfzone currents (GENESIS).

Including both requires modifications to bothSTWAVE and GENESIS standard procedures.

Page 23: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

Net and Gross Transport RatesGalveston Island

• Plot here

Page 24: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

Shoreline Change RateGalveston Island

Page 25: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

Calibration Results

• Local winds are important in transport rate calculations• 600-700 K gross and 0-40 K m3/yr net transport to

southwest along West Galveston Island• 500 K gross and 50-100 K m3/yr net transport to

southwest along central portion of High Island• Net transport reversals to the northeast at East Beach

on Galveston Island and near Sea Rim State Park inJefferson County

Page 26: Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper …...Modeling Sediment Transport Along the Upper Texas Coast David B. King Jr. Jeffery P. Waters William R. Curtis Highway 87 roadbed,

US Army Corpsof Engineers

Coastal and Hydraulics LaboratoryEngineer Research & Development Center

Current Activities

• Using SBEACH to look at the effects of storms on asuite of beachfill alternatives

• These data are being used by economic andenvironmental modelers to narrow the range ofoptimal alternatives