moisture physics 708 - university of waterloo

37
Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 1 /170 Understanding Water: Understanding Water: The Physics of Moisture Dynamics The Physics of Moisture Dynamics www.civil.uwaterloo.ca/beg BEG Building Engineering Group Dr John F Straube Department of Civil Engineering + School of Architecture University of Waterloo Waterloo, Ontario, Canada 2/24/2005 2 /170 Overview Overview Moisture and Building Science Moisture storage in porous materials Moisture transport through porous materials Material performance thresholds Modeling 2/24/2005 3 /170 Moisture Physics Moisture Physics The Basics: The Moisture Balance Wetting, Drying, Storage The Water Molecule Phases, vapour pressure Porous Media – wood, concrete drywall Moisture Storage Moisture Transport – diffusion, capillary

Upload: others

Post on 23-Mar-2022

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 1

/170

Understanding Water:Understanding Water:The Physics of Moisture DynamicsThe Physics of Moisture Dynamics

www.civil.uwaterloo.ca/beg

BEGBuilding Engineering Group

Dr John F StraubeDepartment of Civil Engineering

+School of ArchitectureUniversity of Waterloo

Waterloo, Ontario, Canada

2/24/2005 2 /170

OverviewOverview

Moisture and Building ScienceMoisture storage in porous materialsMoisture transport through porous materials Material performance thresholds

Modeling

2/24/2005 3 /170

Moisture PhysicsMoisture Physics

The Basics: The Moisture BalanceWetting, Drying, Storage

The Water MoleculePhases, vapour pressure

Porous Media – wood, concrete drywallMoisture StorageMoisture Transport – diffusion, capillary

2/24/2005 4 /170

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 2

2/24/2005 5 /170

The Water MoleculeThe Water Molecule

Asymmetrical = polar Small: one billion = one foot

0.28 nm≅ 3 Å

2/24/2005 6 /170

The Polar MoleculeThe Polar Molecule

Hydrogen end is “more” positiveOxygen end is “more” negative

O2-

H+

H+

O2-

H+

H+

+

_ +

_

2/24/2005 7 /170

Polar ImplicationsPolar Implications

Boiling point higher than predicted

Adsorptionwater vapour sticks to surfaces

Surface tensionliquid water sticks to itself and surfaces

Surfactantsinteract with water at surfaces

2/24/2005 8 /170

Moisture PhasesMoisture PhasesAs for most materialsAll four phasesoccur commonly in buildings

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 3

2/24/2005 9 /170

Moisture as a Gas (water vapor)Moisture as a Gas (water vapor)

2/24/2005 10 /170

Vapour PressureVapour PressureFor water vapour in a containerHigher temperature

= more energy= higher velocity= harder collisions with wall (higher pressure)

Greater number of molecules = more collisions with walls (higher pressure)= pressure simply another measure for moisture content

2/24/2005 11 /170

Water Vapour in AirWater Vapour in Air

Water vapour exists in all airAir has a maximum vapour holding capacity

Capacity changes dramatically with temperatureWhen the maximum holding capacity is exceeded, condensation occurs

These facts are summarized by thepsychrometric chart

2/24/2005 12 /170

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 4

2/24/2005 13 /170-10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 25.0 30.0 35.0 40.0

Temperature ( °C)

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

Vap

our

Pre

ssure

(Pa

)

100% RH75% RH50% RH25% RH

Psych Chart: Air Vapour Content vs Temperature

Saturation

50%

RH

25%RH

75%

RH

100%

RH

100%RH

TemperatureA

ir M

oist

ure

Con

tent

= va

pour

pres

sure

(Pa,

in H

g),

hum

idity

rat

io (g

/kg,

gra

ins/

pd)

-10 ºC14 º F

0 ºC32 º F

10 ºC50 º F

20 ºC68 º F

30 ºC86 º F

40 ºC104º F

2/24/2005 14 /170

Moisture as a LiquidMoisture as a Liquid

Polar molecules stick to each otherLiquid water exists in clusters

e.g., H120O60 at room temperatureClusters get smallerwith higher temp

2/24/2005 15 /170

Vibrating Liquid WaterVibrating Liquid Water

Red= Oxygen (big, M=16)Blue = Hydrogen (small, M=1)

2/24/2005 16 /170

Moisture as LiquidMoisture as Liquid

Single vapor molecule is smallLiquid cluster is largeHence, Gore-Tex & Tyvek

Vapour molecules pass through small openingsLiquid molecules repelled by hydrophobicE.g., try a pin hole in housewrap

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 5

2/24/2005 17 /170

Moisture as a SolidMoisture as a SolidCanadian moisture jokes

2/24/2005 18 /170

Ice : Moisture as SolidIce : Moisture as Solid

Ice forms a crystal and expands as it freezese.g., lower density by 9%

2/24/2005 19 /170

Surface TensionSurface Tension

Water is attracted to selfCreates a “membrane” or “surface film”

+ _ + _ + _

2/24/2005 20 /170

Surface Tension: Surface Tension: WettableWettableWater attracted to self

more than surfaceWater attracted to

surface more than self

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 6

2/24/2005 21 /170

Capillary Suction PressureCapillary Suction Pressure

Silicon dioxide (glass) – attracts waterResult - meniscus, capillary suction

2/24/2005 22 /170

Capillary PressuresCapillary Pressures

Result of surface tension = attraction to surfaces

pressure varies with pore sizee.g., height rise in a glass tube

Gravity Down

Surface tension up

2/24/2005 23 /170

Surface TensionSurface Tension

2/24/2005 24 /170

Capillary rise between platesCapillary rise between plates

Paper clip

Elasticband

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 7

2/24/2005 25 /170

Calculating capillary riseCalculating capillary rise

2/24/2005 26 /170

Capillary rise versus diameterCapillary rise versus diameter

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0.00 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 0.09 0.10

diameter [inch]

capi

llary

rise

[inc

h]

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0.000 0.001 0.002 0.003 0.004 0.005 0.006 0.007 0.008 0.009 0.010

diameter [inch]

capi

llary

rise

[inc

h]

2/24/2005 27 /170

Particle Size Particle Size vsvs Capillary SuctionCapillary Suction

1.00E+01

1.00E+02

1.00E+03

1.00E+04

1.00E+05

1.00E+06

1.00E+07

0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10Radius [mm]

Cap

illar

y Pr

essu

re (P

a)

2/24/2005 28 /170

SurfactantsSurfactants

Changes the way water molecules interact with surfaces

dramatically reduces surface tensionSoap is a surfactant

connects water to greaseone end is polarone end is non-polar (sticks to oil and grease)

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 8

2/24/2005 29 /170

Soap and WaterSoap and Water

2/24/2005 30 /170

Nature of Porous MaterialsNature of Porous Materials

Many materials interact with moisture!Many building materials are porous

woodconcrete, brick, gypsum

Nature of material is as important as nature of water

2/24/2005 31 /170

Slice through a porous materialSlice through a porous material

e.g., wood, brick, gypsum, concrete

2/24/2005 32 /170

Real MaterialsReal Materials

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 9

2/24/2005 33 /170

Clay BrickClay Brick

Mercuryporosimetry

Pressureplate

BrickSucks!0

5

10

15

20

25

30

1E-91E-81E-71E-61E-51E-4

Pore Radius (m)

Cum

ulat

ive %

of T

otal

Volu

me

Vacuum saturation

24 hr cold absorption

2/24/2005 34 /170

Simple ModelsSimple Models

Cubic packing of spherical particles

Random particles size and packing

Simple Reality

2/24/2005 35 /170

Isotropic Isotropic matlmatl’’ss: Wood Structure: Wood Structure

Equivalent to a bundle of tubesflow along grain much faster

Surface tension in Surface tension in small tubes can small tubes can feed water up feed water up 100m (300 ft) tall 100m (300 ft) tall treestrees

2/24/2005 36 /170

Storage MechanismsStorage Mechanisms

Basic mechanisms in materials

capillary pores (bound liquid, vapour, ice)sorption (adsorbed)

in enclosurespools and puddles (free liquid)

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 10

2/24/2005 37 /170

Adsorbed State of MoistureAdsorbed State of Moisture

Poorly understood by mostWater vapour molecules stick to surfaces

like dust on glass tabledynamic balancemolecules stick and leavedepends on energy of water vapour

Very important for porous materials with large surface areas

2/24/2005 38 /170

Adsorbed MoistureAdsorbed Moisture

2/24/2005 39 /170

Adsorption Lower RHAdsorption Lower RH

2/24/2005 40 /170

Adsorption higher RHAdsorption higher RH

More H20 sticks

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 11

2/24/2005 41 /170

Adsorption Adsorption -- higher temperaturehigher temperature

HigherEnergyLess H20 sticks

2/24/2005 42 /170

Materials Materials -- Lots of surface areaLots of surface area

0.0001

0.001

0.01

0.1

1

10

100

1000

0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10Radius [mm]

Surf

ace

Are

a pe

r cc

[m2]

Assuming spherical particles and cubic packing

Surf

ace

Are

a (m

2pe

r cc)

2/24/2005 43 /170

Adsorbed MoistureAdsorbed Moisture

One layer of molecules

0 20 60Relative Humidity

Moi

stur

e C

onte

nt

40

Low RH

2/24/2005 44 /170

Adsorbed MoistureAdsorbed Moisture

0 20 60Relative Humidity

Moi

stur

e C

onte

nt

40

Multi- layer of molecules

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 12

2/24/2005 45 /170

Adsorbed MoistureAdsorbed Moisture

0 20 60Relative Humidity

Moi

stur

e C

onte

nt40

Multi- layer of molecules

Mid RH

2/24/2005 46 /170

Adsorbed MoistureAdsorbed Moisture

0 20 60Relative Humidity

Moi

stur

e C

onte

nt

40

Multi- layer of molecules

80

High RH

2/24/2005 47 /170

CondensationCondensation

Thick layers formno longer attracted strongly to surface

Strongly attached

Loosely attached

No longer attached

C: Interconnected layers, (internal capillary condensation)

A: Single-layer of adsorbed molecules

B: Multiple layers of adsorbed molecules

D: water in pores, capillary suction

E: Supersaturated Regime

A

wcrit

wcap

wsat

Adsorbed Water: Hygroscopic Regime

B C

E

Supersaturation - all pores filled

Relative Humidity (%)

Capillary Saturation

00 2020 100100808060604040

DAbsorbed Water: Capillary Regime

Free Water: Supersaturated Regime

Moi

stur

e C

onte

nt (

w%

)

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 13

2/24/2005 49 /170

Moisture RegionsMoisture Regions

Hygroscopicdry to the touch but still moisturee.g., wood can store over 25% by weight

Capillary rangewet to touch, but no draining (sponge)e.g., brick 5 to 20% by weight

Over-saturated rangewater drains from materiale.g., crushed stone

2/24/2005 50 /170

Predicting SorptionPredicting Sorption

BET with Rounsley enhancement

XX

CC

n

1 1 111

=+ −

−−

⎣⎢

⎦⎥

φφ

φφ( )

where X is the equilibrium moisture content (M%), X1 is the moisture content in a mono-layer of adsorbate (M%),

φ is the relative humidity, C is a constant, comprising the heat of adsorption, heat of condensationand the universal gas constant (typically 20 to 50), n is the maximum number of layers that can be adsorbed (typically 4-6).

2/24/2005 51 /170

Vapor pressuresVapor pressures

Curved SurfacesKelvin’s Equation

TRr cos2

wPcapP

ln wv ⋅⋅⋅⋅⋅−

=⎟⎟⎟

⎜⎜⎜

ρθσ

where, ρ is the density of water,

Pcap is vapor pressure over the curved surface of water in a capillarypore, Pw is the water vapor pressure over a flat surface at the sametemperature, Rwv is the water vapor gas constant, and other terms are as before.

2/24/2005 52 /170

Kelvin: Capillary condensationKelvin: Capillary condensation

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 14

2/24/2005 53 /170

Sorption + CondensationSorption + Condensation

2/24/2005 54 /170

SorptionSorption

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%Relative Humidity

Moi

stur

e C

onte

nt (M

%) concrete

brickcement stuccosoftwood

to 140%

2/24/2005 55 /170

Sorption IsothermSorption Isotherm

0

5

10

15

20

0 20 40 60 80 100RH (%)

MC (M

%)

SprucePlywoodFibreboardRed BrickMortarConcreteStucco

2/24/2005 56 /170

HysteresisHysteresis of Sorptionof Sorption

Ink Bottle effect

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 15

2/24/2005 57 /170

Sorption Sorption vsvs TemperatureTemperature

Sorption vapor vs temperature and MC

2/24/2005 58 /170

Temperature EffectsTemperature Effects

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

0 20 40 60 80 100 120Relative Humidity (%)

Mos

iture

Con

tent

(w%

)

02749

Softwood

Temperature

Its RH not vapour pressure

ºC/ 80 º FºC/ 120 º F

ºC/ 32 º F

2/24/2005 59 /170

Sorption testSorption test

Tupperware Standard- Balanced ASTM

2/24/2005 60 /170

Significance Of RegionsSignificance Of Regions

mould, corrosiontend to begin around 80%layer is thick enough that “free” H20 is avail.

Swellingonly occurs in hygroscopic range

Freeze-thawcapillary range

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 16

2/24/2005 61 /170

SwellingSwelling

1

2/24/2005 62 /170

SwellingSwelling

2

2/24/2005 63 /170

SwellingSwelling

3

2/24/2005 64 /170

SwellingSwelling

4

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 17

2/24/2005 65 /170

Swelling Causing CurvingSwelling Causing Curving

Swelling on Bottom Side

• E.g., concrete slab curl• Deck Board cupping

Shrinkage on Top Side

2/24/2005 66 /170

Moisture SwellingMoisture Swelling

2/24/2005 67 /170

Wood Swelling and ShrinkageWood Swelling and Shrinkage

∆=3.5%

Wood acts as a bundle of tubesShrinks across grain, not alongOnly during adsorptionE.g. Drywall cracks

2/24/2005 68 /170

Colonial DoorsColonial Doors

DesignedDesigned so that frame so that frame has nearly no cross grainhas nearly no cross grainCrossCross--grain panels slidegrain panels slide

Detail Section

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 18

2/24/2005 69 /170

Wood expansionWood expansionConcrete ShrinkageConcrete Shrinkage

Stucco ShrinkageStucco Shrinkage

Frame ShrinkageFrame Shrinkage

2/24/2005 70 /170

Brick expansionBrick expansionConcrete ShrinkageConcrete Shrinkage

Adobe shrinkageAdobe shrinkageStucco Stucco spallsspalls

2/24/2005 71 /170

SolutionsSolutions

Allow movementCupping

Reduce gradientReduce thicknessReduce stiffness & restrain

Shrinkage swellingReduce range of RHReduce rate of changeReduce cross grain!

2/24/2005 72 /170

Measuring Moisture StorageMeasuring Moisture Storage

Sorption, capillary saturation, pore volumeMaterial Density (Dry)

kg/m3

Open Porosity

(%)

MC @ ≅95%RH

(M%)

wcap

(M%)

Concrete 2200 15-18 4-5 6-8 Brick 1600-2100 11-40 3-8 6-20 Cement Mortar 1800-1900 20-30 5-7 14-20 Softwood 400-600 50-80 20-30 100-200 Fibreboard 240-380 60-80 20-25 100-200 Wood chipboard 700 50-70 15-20 100-150 Expanded polystyrene

32 95 5 > 300

Gypsum (exterior) 1000 70 10 50-100

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 19

/170

Moisture TransportMoisture Transport

2/24/2005 74 /170

Moisture TransportMoisture Transport

Moves from high concentration to lessThis does not always mean more moisture content or more vapour pressure!Each phase should be considered separately

liquidvapor (diffusion and air leakage)adsorbedice

2/24/2005 75 /170

Liquid flowLiquid flowMay be driven by:

gravitypressure differences (air or water)capillary pressures

Capillary – 0 to 10 MPa (M!)Gravity always acts, downward

About 10 000 Pa/m (1.3 psi/yd =15 psi/33 ft)Air pressure varies

wind typically < 100 Pa (0.015 psi= 2 psf) short 1000 Pa bursts (0.15 psi = 20 psf)

2/24/2005 76 /170

Capillary FlowCapillary Flow

Eg. : Crushed stone, air gapslarge pores - no suction (“wicking”)

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 20

2/24/2005 77 /170

Capillary FlowCapillary FlowExample: Sand, siding lapsSmaller pores - some wicking (inches to feet)

2/24/2005 78 /170

Head Joints Head Joints –– capillary crackcapillary crack

2/24/2005 79 /170

Water Penetration MechanismWater Penetration Mechanism

Hypothetical area of bonded mortar in head joint

Potential interfacial crack plane locations

Water drawn into crack by capillarity

Hydrostatic head: highest entrance to deepest exit

2/24/2005 80 /170

Pressure and Masonry PermeancePressure and Masonry Permeance

Application Rate:200 l/m /hr2

Suction Pressure0

123456

-125 -100 -75 -50 -25 0 25 50 75 100 125

Pressure Difference (Pa)

Pene

trat

ion

Rat

e (l/

hr/m

2 )

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 21

2/24/2005 81 /170

ImplicationsImplications

Air pressure does not substantially increase water permeance of masonryHence, pressure equalization is not that importantDrainage is the key

2/24/2005 82 /170

Capillary FlowCapillary Flow-- concrete sucksconcrete sucksExample: Clay or siltWicking (dozens - hundreds of ft)

2/24/2005 83 /170

Particle Size Particle Size vsvs Capillary SuctionCapillary Suction

1.00E+01

1.00E+02

1.00E+03

1.00E+04

1.00E+05

1.00E+06

1.00E+07

0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10Radius [mm]

Cap

illar

y Pr

essu

re (P

a)

2/24/2005 84 /170

Measuring Liquid TransportMeasuring Liquid Transport

Water uptake

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 22

2/24/2005 85 /170 2/24/2005 86 /170

Typical resultsTypical results

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

0 2 4 6 8

Square Root of Time

Weig

ht g

ain (

g sin

ce st

art)

Slope = waterabsorptioncoefficient

2/24/2005 87 /170

Liquid transport: wettingLiquid transport: wetting

Role of pore structureRole of pore structure

Place porous material in contact with water

Small capillaries have large suction and large flow resistance

Large capillaries have less suction and little flow resistace

2/24/2005 88 /170

Liquid transport: wettingLiquid transport: wetting

Role of pore structure

Small capillaries have large suction and large flow resistance

Large capillaries have less suction and little flow resistace

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 23

2/24/2005 89 /170

Liquid transport: wettingLiquid transport: wetting

Role of pore structure

Small capillaries have large suction and large flow resistance

Large capillaries have less suction and little flow resistace

2/24/2005 90 /170

Liquid transport: wettingLiquid transport: wetting

Role of pore structure

Small capillaries have large suction and large flow resistance

Large capillaries have less suction and little flow resistace

2/24/2005 91 /170

Liquid transport: wettingLiquid transport: wetting

Role of pore structure

Small capillaries have large suction and large flow resistance

Large capillaries have less suction and little flow resistace

2/24/2005 92 /170

Liquid transport: wettingLiquid transport: wetting

Role of pore structure

Small capillaries have large suction and large flow resistance

Large capillaries have less suction and little flow resistace

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 24

2/24/2005 93 /170

Liquid transport: wettingLiquid transport: wetting

Role of pore structure

Small capillaries have large suction and large flow resistance

Large capillaries have less suction and little flow resistace

2/24/2005 94 /170

Liquid transport: redistributionLiquid transport: redistribution

Role of pore structure

Small capillaries have large suction and large flow resistance

Large capillaries have less suction and little flow resistace

2/24/2005 95 /170

Liquid transport: redistributionLiquid transport: redistribution

Role of pore structure

Small capillaries have large suction and large flow resistance

Large capillaries have less suction and little flow resistace

2/24/2005 96 /170

Liquid transport: redistributionLiquid transport: redistribution

Role of pore structure

Small capillaries have large suction and large flow resistance

Large capillaries have less suction and little flow resistace

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 25

2/24/2005 97 /170

Liquid transport: redistributionLiquid transport: redistribution

Role of pore structure

Small capillaries have large suction and large flow resistance

Large capillaries have less suction and little flow resistace

2/24/2005 98 /170

Liquid transport: redistributionLiquid transport: redistribution

Role of pore structure

Small capillaries have large suction and large flow resistance

Large capillaries have less suction and little flow resistace

2/24/2005 99 /170

HydrophobicHydrophobicExample: silicone impregnation, many (clean) plastics and polymersRepels water – no wicking!

2/24/2005 100 /170

Water RepellentsWater Repellents

Normal, capillaryactive material

water

material material

Hydrophobicallytreated material

Waterflowing in:system not inequilibrium

No water flow

E.g., silicone

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 26

2/24/2005 101 /170

Water Vapour TransportWater Vapour Transport

Vapour Diffusion (like heat conduction)

more to less vapourAir Convection (like heat convection)

more to less air pressureflow through cracks and holesvapour is along for the ride

2/24/2005 102 /170

Vapour DiffusionVapour DiffusionSlow process – through open poresSome materials allow easy diffusion

Very open porese.g. batt, gypsum, cellulose, etc

Many materials resist diffusionsmall pored materialse.g., concrete, brick, stone

Some stop, or practically stop itcrystals, or microporee.g., many plastics (poly), metals, glass

2/24/2005 103 /170

DiffusionDiffusion

Each layer reduces vapor flow

2/24/2005 104 /170

AirflowAirflow

Vapor flows with airConstant flow across layers

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 27

2/24/2005 105 /170-10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 25.0 30.0 35.0 40.0

Temperature ( °C)

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

Vap

our

Pre

ssure

(Pa

)

100% RH75% RH50% RH25% RH

Air Leakage vs Diffusion

Summer

Winter

Air LeakageCondensation

Diffusion

50%

RH

25%RH

75%

RH100%

RH

•Air barrier systems essential•Low perm vapor barrier rarely needed

-10 ºC14 º F

0 ºC32 º F

10 ºC50 º F

20 ºC68 º F

30 ºC86 º F

40 ºC104º F

2/24/2005 106 /170

VapourVapour Permeability MeasurementPermeability Measurement

e.g. ASTM E96

Procedure A Procedure B

Water= 100%RH

Specimen

23 °C /50%RH

Dessicant= 0%RH

Specimen

23 °C /50%RH

Water= 100%RH

Specimen

23 °C /50%RH

Procedure BW

2/24/2005 107 /170

The Tupperware standardThe Tupperware standard

Can conduct tests in your own kitchen with special salts and good scale

2/24/2005 108 /170

Typical saltsTypical salts

Italics are temperature insensitive

Salt RH% Salt RH

Lithium Chloride 11.3 Sodium Chloride 75.3

Potassium Acetate 22.5 Potassium Chloride 84.3

Magnesium Chloride 32.8 Barium Chloride 90

Potassium Carbonate 43.2 Potassium Nitrate 93.6

Magnesium Nitrate 52.9 Potassium Sulfate 97.3

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 28

2/24/2005 109 /170

VapourVapour Permeance Permeance vsvs RHRH

Relative Humidity (%)1000 50

δp

Test Results

““PermeancePermeance””changes with RHchanges with RHother transport other transport mechanisms as workmechanisms as work

Example of Building Paper

2/24/2005 110 /170

Adsorbed FlowAdsorbed Flow

Also called surface diffusion

Driven by RH differences!

Affects highly porous, especially fibrous natural materials

2/24/2005 111 /170

Adsorbed moisture flows from more MC to less MC (or from high RH to low RH)

2/24/2005 112 /170

Competing MechanismsCompeting Mechanisms

Tightly bound adsorbed molecules --no surface diffusion

Surface diffusion flow direction opposes vapour diffusion !

E.g. Cold and humid outsidewarm and dry inside

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 29

2/24/2005 113 /170

VapourVapour Permeance: StuccoPermeance: Stucco

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%Relative Humidity (%)

Perm

eanc

e (fo

r 19

mm

thic

k)

Mean

Lower

Upper

Result of Adsorbed Flow

2/24/2005 114 /170

VapourVapour Permeance: SheathingPermeance: Sheathing

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

Relative Humidity

Per

mea

nce

(ng/

Pa

s m

2) 11.1 mm OSB

12.7 mm Plywood

Dry

Cup

Wet

Cup

Result of Adsorbed Flow

Kraft Paper, Smart Retarder are similar

101

2/24/2005 115 /170

Vapour BarriersVapour Barriers

Control vapour diffusion onlyVapour barriers in Code: <1 US perm

based on Rowley 1937 no good science

Vapour retarder approx 2-5 US permMeasurement Units

Metric perms ng /(s·m2·Pa)US perm grain/(hr·in Hg· ft2)WVT grams/(sq ft/24 hours)

2/24/2005 116 /170

LowLow--permeance Materialspermeance Materials

6 mil Poly 3.5 metric (0.1 US perm)Vinyl wall paper 15 metric perm (0.3 US)Concrete 1/2 perm for 8” foundation wallDrywall with a VB paint 0.3 to 1 permBrick veneer (1/2 - 2 US perms)Extruded foam 1/2 - 1 US perms for 1.5”Plywood 0.5 to 20 US perms (dry to wet)Kraft paper 0.3 to 2 US perms (dry and wet)

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 30

2/24/2005 117 /170

SemiSemi--permeable Materialspermeable Materials

Plywood 0.5 to 20 US perms (dry to wet)Expanded foam 2.5 - 5 US perms for 1 inchSpray PUR about 2 US permsDrywall with latex paint (2-5 US perms)

2/24/2005 118 /170

HighHigh--perm Materialsperm Materials

Fibreboard over 20Plywood 0.5 to 20 (dry to wet)Icynene open cell spray foam 10 - 13Tyvek other housewraps 20 to 50 permsBuilding paper over 10 to 30

2/24/2005 119 /170

Summary Moisture TransportSummary Moisture Transport

Moisture in 3 phases moves with three mechanisms

Liquid capillary (suction)Adsorbed flow (RH)Vapour diffusion (vapor pressure)

Moisture storage in all three phases, only two important for hygroscopic

Adsorbed (RH)Liquid (capillary suction)

/170

Moisture ThresholdsMoisture Thresholds

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 31

2/24/2005 121 /170

Material Performance ThresholdsMaterial Performance Thresholds

Depends on What PerformanceCorrosionMouldDecayFreeze-thawDissolution/Dissassociation

Also, mechanical properties, insulating, etc.

2/24/2005 122 /170

Performance of What?Performance of What?

Materials - asphalt, paperLayers - building paperSub-assembly - lapped, between airspace/sheathingAssembly - drained stucco over steel studEnclosure - wall, joints, windowBuilding - 12 storey apartment bldgSite - seashore or shelteredClimate -Miami or Minneapolis

2/24/2005 123 /170 2/24/2005 124 /170

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 32

2/24/2005 125 /170

Material PerformanceMaterial Performance

How to predict performance?1. We test materials or layers. 2. Model assemblies in specific climates.

Must know loads, microclimate

““No Wrong Material, No Wrong Material, Just Materials Used the Wrong WayJust Materials Used the Wrong Way””

2/24/2005 126 /170

Florida Pier

Structural Steel Waterloo

2/24/2005 127 /170

Steel CorrosionSteel Corrosion

Electrochemical Process - oxygen + electrolyteCan begin if RH>80%Coatings protectZinc galvanizing is sacrificialFactors

Temperature (Arhenius Law)Time of Wetness (TOW)pH of environmentSalinity

2/24/2005 128 /170

RH, T and RH, T and CorrosionCorrosion

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 33

2/24/2005 129 /170

CorrosionRate

(g/m2/day)

0 7 14pH

pH and Steel CorrosionpH and Steel Corrosion

(Base)(Acid)

2/24/2005 130 /170

CorrosionRate

(g/m2/day)

0 7 14pH

pH and Zinc CorrosionpH and Zinc Corrosion

steel

zinc

acidic basic

2/24/2005 131 /170

• Spores and toxins Spores and toxins cause cause immunoimmuno--depressiondepression

•• LBL estimates US LBL estimates US health and health and productivity losses at productivity losses at $30 to 100 billion/yr$30 to 100 billion/yr

•• ““Sick Building Sick Building SyndromeSyndrome””

2/24/2005 132 /170

Mould Growth On SurfacesMould Growth On Surfaces

SurfaceSurface Humidity > about 80%RHTemperature 5C/40F - 50C/120F

Food Source (cellulose, soap, wood, oil)pH - usually less than 8 - 10

GrowthRate

0C/32F Temperature 50C/120F

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 34

2/24/2005 133 /170

From: Klaus Sedelbauer PhD Thesis

2/24/2005 134 /170

Germination & GrowthGermination & GrowthTime for spore germination

Rate of GrowthPlots for perfect food source

From: Klaus Sedelbauer PhD ThesisBrampton stripmall

2/24/2005 135 /170

Minimum LevelsMinimum Levels

Different species = different conditionsDynamically varying mix as substrate and conditions change

From: Clarke, Bldg & Environ

2/24/2005 136 /170

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 35

2/24/2005 137 /170

Wood DecayWood Decay

Surface Humidity > 95%RH, MC>30%Temperature 5C/40F - 50C/120F

Highly species, sample, exposure dependent

GrowthRate

0C/32F Temperature 50C/120F

2/24/2005 138 /170

Waterloo, PatioWaterloo, Patio

Buffalo, NYBuffalo, NY

2/24/2005 139 /170

FreezeFreeze--thawthaw

Must be nearly saturated while freezingFactors

degree of saturationhow coldrate of freezingpores size distributionliquid diffusivity

2/24/2005 140 /170

SubfluorescenseSubfluorescense

Salts absorbed in porous mineral material while dissolved in liquid waterWater evaporates salts recrystalize

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 36

2/24/2005 141 /170 2/24/2005 142 /170

DissolutionDissolution

Water is the universal solventAvoid capillary saturatione.g.:

EIFS finish re-emulsificationGypsum becomes goopaper unglues

2/24/2005 143 /170

MicroclimateMicroclimate

Surface HumidityT= 20 CRH = 60%

0

Temperature

VapourVapourPressurePressure

40-20 20

T= 14.5 C, RH=85%

DamagePossible

2/24/2005 144 /170

MicroclimateMicroclimate

pH Acid or Alkaline

pH=10

pH=4?

Steel in Concrete

Screw in Gypsum

Dr John Straube Presentation Moisture Physics 37

2/24/2005 145 /170

ConclusionsConclusions

Moisture control is a balance of wetting and dryingWater is a unique molecule

Adsorption – swelling/shrinkingCapillary / surface tension

Separate the phases ….Vapor, liquid, adsorbed, solid

… and transport modes …Diffusion, convection, capillary, adsorbed

… when thinking about moisture