mormonism beyond the gender binary
DESCRIPTION
Presented at the Mormon Transhumanist Association on 6 April 2012 in Salt Lake City, Utah. A rehearsal version is available at (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Isw2I6Z2_Lc).TRANSCRIPT
Mormonism Beyond the Gender
Binary
AUDIENCE AWARENESS
Heard the word "postgender" before today
Have a personal friend who's intersex
OUTLINE
1. Discuss the shortcomings of gender roles
2. Explain why the gender binary fails
3. Defend my view that Postgenderism will result in many genders, rather than no genders
4. Conclude as to why this is a good thing for Mormonism
BIO
-Feminist, Biologist -Wrote a book
OUTLINE
1. Discuss the shortcomings of gender roles
2. Explain why the gender binary fails
3. Defend my view that Postgenderism will result in many genders, rather than no genders
4. Conclude as to why this is a good thing for Mormonism
SHORTCOMINGS OF GENDER ROLES
Stories:
-Feminist Mormon Housewives angst (angry, hurt women and indignant singles because of motherhood emphasis and governance gap)
-Arbon: MPA faculty
SHORTCOMINGS OF GENDER ROLES
-Intersex: square peg, round hole
-Friend Steve- likes boys, effects on self-concept and esteem
"Fiercely gendered world"
OUTLINE
1. Discuss the shortcomings of gender roles
2. Explain why the gender binary fails
3. Defend my view that Postgenderism will result in many genders, rather than no genders
4. Conclude as to why this is a good thing for Mormonism
GENDER BINARY ≠ REALITY
“Everybody is either a boy or a girl- this is a pretty obvious and common sense proposition. Until you examine it closely.”
PRIESTHOOD OR RELIEF SOCIETY?
•What about when appearance doesn’t give it away?
PRIESTHOOD OR RELIEF SOCIETY?
SO, LET’S VOTE!
“GENDER IS AN ESSENTIAL
CHARACTERISTIC OF INDIVIDUAL
PREMORTAL, MORTAL, AND
ETERNAL IDENTITY AND
PURPOSE.”–FAMILY PROC
Jessica Taylor
Conclusion from uncertainty: perform both marriages, or perform neither; choosing only one couple is irrational.
Jessica Taylor
Spiritual sex of each?
Jessica Taylor
Excommunication Exaltation
Jessica Taylor
If physical appearance cannot ground the bishop’s decision, the criterion of appearance must be rejected, not just the “fringe” cases.
•“But,” you might contend, “intersex folks are such a small minority- sure there are a few questionable cases, but that doesn’t mean the whole male/female system is a failure.” The border cases reveal the underlying truth we usually don’t otherwise think of, however. Sex and gender are a photomosaic rather than a binary: for everyone.
OUTLINE
1. Discuss the shortcomings of gender roles
2. Explain why the gender binary fails
3. Defend my view that Postgenderism will result in many genders, rather than no genders
4. Conclude as to why this is a good thing for Mormonism
POSTGENDERISM= MANY GENDERS
(NOT GENDER NEUTRALITY)
This mouse has two,
and only two, parents:
two male mice.
"Assisted reproduction will make it possible for individuals of any sex to reproduce in any combinations they choose, with or without 'mothers' and 'fathers'”
POSTGENDERISM= MANY GENDERS
(NOT GENDER NEUTRALITY)
•Sexual traits may become as freely
chosen as eyesight (through wearing
contacts or undergoing lasik surgery),
or even hair color (by dying your hair).
•When humans gain the ability to
"talk" to our cells the way our
genomes presently do, a whole world
of choice opens up that is tough to
imagine presently.
POSTGENDERISM= MANY GENDERS
(NOT GENDER NEUTRALITY)
•"Greater biological fluidity and
psychological androgyny will allow
future persons to explore both
masculine and feminine aspects of
personality. Postgenderists do not call
for the end of all gender traits, or
universal androgyny, but rather that
those traits become a matter of
choice."
POSTGENDERISM= MANY GENDERS
(NOT GENDER NEUTRALITY)
•Analogy: gender vs.
literary genre
•[Male/female]
will be replaced by
[?]
•Analogy: gender vs.
literary genre
•[Fiction/non-fiction]
will be replaced by
[fantasy, historical fiction, memoir, tragedy, scripture, romance, diary, fable]
OUTLINE
1. Discuss the shortcomings of gender roles
2. Explain why the gender binary fails
3. Defend my view that Postgenderism will result in many genders, rather than no genders
4. Conclude as to why this is a good thing for Mormonism
POLYGENDERED MORMONISM>
BINARY MORMONISM
Marriage= Two Intersex
POLYGENDERED MORMONISM>
BINARY MORMONISM
Marriage= Two Intersex
POLYGENDERED MORMONISM>
BINARY MORMONISM
Governance
POLYGENDERED MORMONISM>
BINARY MORMONISM
Governance
POLYGENDERED MORMONISM>
BINARY MORMONISM
Governance
Mormonism Beyond the
Gender Binary